Professional Documents
Culture Documents
cuse violent criminal behavior, but it’s an progress of a civilized society.” The brain changes continued up to age 21,
important factor for courts to consider” The defense is focusing on the “culpa- the oldest person they examined. “It’s quite
when wielding a punishment “as extreme bility of juveniles and whether their brains possible that the brain maturation peaks after
and irreversible as death.” are as capable of impulse control, age 21,” he adds.
The Supreme Court has addressed some decision-making, and reasoning as adult The images showed a rapid conversion
cording to Gur and others, but because Maturing brain. An NIMH study of 13 indi-
they use the structures in a different way. A viduals over a decade reveals a process—
fully developed frontal lobe curbs impuls- still under way in the late teens—in which
es coming from other parts of the brain, gray matter is replaced throughout the cor-
Gur explains: “If you’ve been insulted, tex, starting at the rear.
your emotional brain says, ‘Kill,’ but your
frontal lobe says you’re in the middle of a
cocktail party, ‘so let’s respond with a cut-
ting remark.’ ” signed to determine how well the prefrontal the cerebellum important for timing and
As it matures, the adolescent brain slowly cortex governs the more primitive parts of learning and brain regions that prepare for
reorganizes how it integrates information the brain. Subjects focus on a cross on a the task at hand.
coming from the nether regions. Using func- screen and are told that the cross will dis- These results support other evidence
tional MRI—which lights up sites in the appear and a light will show up. They are showing that teens’ impulse control is not
brain that are active—combined with simple told not to look at the light, which is diffi- on a par with adults’. In work in press in
tests, neuroscientist Beatriz Luna of the Uni- cult because “the whole brainstem is wired Child Development, Luna found that vol-
versity of Pittsburgh has found that the brain to look at lights,” says Luna. unteers aged 14 years and older perform
switches from relying heavily on local re- Adolescents can prevent themselves just as well on the task as adults, but they
gions in childhood to more distributive and from peeking at the light, but in doing so rely mainly on the frontal lobe’s prefrontal
collaborative interactions among distant re- they rely on brain regions different from cortex, whereas adults exhibit a more com-
gions in adulthood. those adults use. In 2001, Luna and col- plex response. “The adolescent is using
One of the methods Luna uses to probe leagues showed that adolescents’ prefrontal slightly different brain mechanisms to
brain activity is the “antisaccade” test: a cortices were considerably more active than achieve the goal,” says Luna. Although the
simplified model of real-life responses de- adults’ in this test. Adults also used areas in work is not cited in the brief, Luna says it
expressions for anger or other emotions. get roller skates and skate down some really better ways of rehabilitating such youths.
Baird, now at Dartmouth College in big steps?” Adults know what might happen –MARY BECKMAN
Hanover, New Hampshire, says that subse- at the bottom and would be wary. But teens Mary Beckman is a writer in southeastern Idaho.