Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Requirements
63
Change Management
in Power Distribution 7.1 INTRODUCTION
"There's nothing ‘Managing’ change is one of the most taxing tasks faced by organisations
more difficult to
take in hand, more
across the globe today. Typically the task is highly demanding for the top
perilous to conduct, management, which is responsible for initiating and facilitating the changes in
or more uncertain in the organisation. Implementing a major and enduring change requires
its success, than to
managers to develop a variety of skills in order to strike a delicate balance
take the lead in
introducing a new between individual and collective actions, paying attention to the content as
order of things." well as the process of change and pursuing both short-term and long-term
Niccolo goals. Over the years, change experts have devised strategies to help
Machiavelli, 1532 managers address the complexities of change management issues. Despite
in volumes of literature on planned change, proliferation of consultants, and the
best efforts of corporate leaders, organisational change still appears to be a
The Prince
much less understood process.
Since the distribution reforms have brought about many changes in the
organisation of distribution utilities, it is important for you to understand the
change process and its requirements. You will agree that the work culture and
work environment in your organisation needs to be changed to meet the
objectives of the reforms with the help of the same workforce. As a manager,
you have a vital role in implementing the new policies. The success of the
reforms would ultimately be determined by ensuring active participation of all
personnel involved in the work-chain. In this unit you will learn about the role
of the individuals involved in change process and various models used
successfully so far.
• orchestrating events,
• diagnosing the potential problem,
• developing a plan to deal with it,
• communicating to everyone, and finally
• executing it.
A typology of change agents has been developed based on the following four
categories:
………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………….
b) In your organisation, should the change agents be internal or external?
………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………….
c) Discuss the pros and cons of having internal and external change
agents.
………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………….
66
7.2.2 Change Makers Change
Requirements
Change Makers are the people in the organisation who are actually engaged
in the change implementation process. Any change programme requires
the participation of the entire organisation in order to be successful.
Employees in an organisation can be divided into three broad change
categories:
• Change Strategists,
• Change Implementers, and
• Change Recipients.
Change Strategists are responsible for identifying the need for change,
creating a vision of the desired outcome, deciding what change is feasible,
and choosing who should sponsor and defend it.
Change Implementers “make the change happen”. They manage the day-do-
day process of changes, coordinate various activities and relationships among
people that give the organisation its internal shape and culture.
Change Recipients represent the largest group of people that adopt, and
adapt to change. Recipients, in fact, give the desired change its ultimate
shape and sustainability. It is their behaviour which determines whether a
change will last or not. They are also the primary source of resistance. Some
of the key characteristics of Change Makers are given in Table 7.1.
Table 7.1: Key Change Makers
Institutionaliser Personal
benefits
Personal view
Operational
Source: Ancona, et al., 1999.
67
Change Management If you are involved with the change process and looking for a checklist to
in Power Distribution overcome the problems, we would like to tell you. There is no one best way
to implement change. We give some suggestions in Box 7.1.
• Analyze the organisation and its need for change: Look at the company’s
history of changes (successes and failures), patterns of resistance; analyze the
forces for and against change (Force field analysis).
• Create a shared vision and common direction: This should reflect the core
values of the company; the vision should include the rationale, the benefits,
personal ramifications, among others.
• Support a strong leader role: The change advocate role is critical for creating
a vision, motivating employees to embrace that vision and crafting a structure
to reward those who strive towards the realisation of the vision.
• Communicate with and involve people and be honest: Every change effort
may not call for full involvement, communication and disclosure but most do;
wherever possible, there should be a meaningful dialogue that gives people a
stake in the change.
We discuss the role of change leaders, in detail after acquainting you with
various approaches to change management. But before moving on you may
68 like to answer an SAQ.
Change
SAQ 2: Change makers Requirements
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
Change interventions
1. Psychology of the
Individual
2. Social Psychological
Approaches
3. Cultural Approaches
4. Innovation
Approaches
5. Global Change
Approaches
6. Practitioner
Approaches
Source: www.bpmg.org
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
− Values refer to a sense of what "ought" to be and they lie at the next
higher level of culture.
We now discuss the role of a change leader. But before studying further, you
may like to attempt an SAQ.
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
Change leaders
• foster and create an atmosphere that enables people to test the new
change, generate recommendations, experiment with new ways of
operating, and exhibit some dysfunctional behaviour while the change is
taking root in the culture.
• lead the change effort with every word and action. They are the role
models for the organisation. Change leaders have the responsibility to
establish compelling and legitimate business reasons for change, and at
the same time to identify and overcome potential sources of resistance.
Niccolo A Machiavelli observed long ago that "whosoever desires
constant success must change his conduct with the times.''
• interact with individuals and groups in the organisation to explain the who,
what, when, where, why, and how of the change.
ALIGN TO
TODAY’S
ENVIRONMENT
ENSURE PROMOTE
STABILITY CHANGE
ANTICIPATE
TOMORROW’S
ENVIRONMENT
Listen to Learn.
Empathize with Emotions.
Attend to Aspirations.
Diagnose Details.
Engage for Good Ends.
Respond with Respectfulness.
Speak with Specificity.
74
Change
The levels of change leadership competency on a behavioural scale start with
Requirements
the most basic level of skill and move to the most complex level (Box 7.4).
Box 7.4: Levels of Change Leadership
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
In this section, we present three case studies highlighting the role of a leader
76 in change management.
Change
Case Study 1: The Successful Case of Ford Plastics Requirements
In 1990, a radical change took place in the charter of the Ford Plastics Plant
(USA) from "a maker of high-tech engineering plastic bits and assemblies . . .
to an engineering plastics business which was to develop other markets''. It
provided a heightened sense of urgency to the need for improving the plant’s
competitiveness. Tom Pettigrewn was appointed as manager at Ford Plastics
in early 1990. He played a key role in driving the change at Ford Plastics.
Pettigrew, who was trusted and respected by staff on the shop floor,
implemented a quality-driven business strategy which focused on striving for
quality and productivity improvements through the establishment of work area
teams, multiskilling, skills and knowledge education, the encouragement of
learning, and a participative, open management style. Under his guidance, the
"Golden Rule'' became a core precept of the fabric of change at Ford Plastics.
The "Golden Rule'' stated that all people who would contribute to realising a
decision or plan, and those others who would be affected by the decision or
plan, must participate in the making of the decision or plan. To fortify the
message, Pettigrew himself spent a lot of time “showing by doing” and
encouraging other senior personnel to do the same. The aim was to break
down the "us and them'' mentality, to encourage the sharing of ideas, and to
build a climate of cooperation and trust.
Pettigrew found a key ally and messenger for change in the internally
appointed manufacturing manager, whose skills as a negotiator and facilitator
were recognized early on by the senior executive. More importantly, he was
respected and trusted by union representatives and shop floor employees. He
became the "magic leader'' at Ford Plastics who gave purpose and meaning to
the change agenda and set the direction.
List the qualities of the change leader described in Case Study 1. Outline
the strategies used by him to drive the change in his company.
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
77
Change Management
in Power Distribution Case Study 2: Orissa Power Sector Reform
Mr. M.Y. Rao, the Chairman of the erstwhile Orissa State Electricity Board
(O.S.E.B.), and subsequently, Chairman and Managing Director of Grid
Corporation of Orissa Limited (GRIDCO), was the leading person behind the
power sector reforms that took place in Orissa w.e.f. 1st April 1996. The
reorganisation process was implemented in two phases. In the first phase, the
O.S.E.B was disintegrated into a number of new corporate entities. GRIDCO
was created to undertake transmission and distribution, O.P.G.C. to own and
operate O.S.E.B’s thermal plant, and the O.H.P.C was formed for the hydro
plant. O.E.R.C was constituted to set tariff rates and insulate the electricity
industry from political decisions and rigid bureaucratic controls. During the
second phase, the distribution function was privatised and accordingly, four
distribution companies viz. SOUTHCO, WESCO, NESCO, and CESCO were
established and licensed. In addition to providing prodigious momentum to the
reform programme in the State, Mr. Rao used the following ways to minimize
employees’ resistance to the reform and get their support. He
• personally convinced the employees about the reason and rationale for
reform;
• developed and disseminated a vision of the reform to help employees see
where their organisation would seek to go if the change was successful,
and also made them understand the value of reform to the power sector;
• personally Interacted with the trade union leaders and won their
confidence, support and collaboration for shaping the significant changes
that their organisation was planning to undergo, and for abstaining from
resistance;
• appointed many ex-employees of O.S.E.B. as facilitators to convince the
people regarding the need for reform;
• organised a number of meetings, workshops, and other forums to provide
opportunity to employees to express themselves and answer their queries;
• convinced the employees that there would not be any reduction in
workforce , rather a wider scope would be given for career growth and job
opportunities in the post-reform period; and
• demonstrated his commitment to reform by extensively involving himself in
different activities in order to gain the support and commitment of others.
You would appreciate his efforts better from this experience of the President of
the Orissa Electrical Engineers Service Association. He describes an
experience he had about the commitment and visionary leadership skill of Mr.
Rao:
“During the period when the Working Groups were functioning, my role was
more that of a facilitator. I was functioning as the Chairman of O.S.E.B, 50
percent of the time, and the remaining time as the Chief Executive who
was heading an organisation in transition. There was a theoretical concept
of reform that was put forth by the World Bank and Consultants, and then
there were the ground level realities of reforming the organisation. I acted
as a link between them. This went on practically up to 1996. But after
restructuring, most of my activity was concentrated on the nitty-gritty. I was
engaged in realizing the electricity due, metering the connections so that
we could get money into the system. I had spent about 70 percent of the
time on the operational issues” (quoted from Rajan, 2000).
In sum, the former Chairman facilitated the reforms process and mobilised
employees for their support and cooperation. One respondent puts it this way:
Identify the qualities and skills of the change leader in Case Study 2.
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………….
Case Study 3: The Success Case of North Delhi Power Limited (NDPL)
NDPL was incorporated in July 1, 2002 as a joint venture between Tata Power
and Govt. of NCT of Delhi as a result of the privatisation of electricity
distribution in Delhi. Mr. Anil Kumar Sardana, who was working as one of the
Vice-Presidents of the Bombay Suburban Electric Supply Ltd. (BSES), was
appointed as the CEO of NDPL. Mr. Sardana took several HR initiatives such
as the following to make the change process a success. 79
Change Management • Almost all the designations were rechristened so as to make the
in Power Distribution employees feel empowered as well as dignified.
• Mobile phones were provided to all executives, junior engineers, and other
field staff for better connectivity.
• Executives and field staff were sponsored for training under peer
exchange programme to different countries. 32 personnel were sponsored
under the scheme till August 2004.
On this optimistic note for the future of change management in the power
distribution sector, we would like to end the unit and present its summary.
7.6 SUMMARY
• Change agents are individuals who use their knowledge of the change
process to influence decisions, thereby creating desirable change.
• Change Makers are the people in the organisation who are actually
engaged in the change implementation process.
• Change leaders are responsible for identifying the need for change,
creating a vision of the desired outcome, deciding what change is feasible,
and choosing who should sponsor and defend it.
80
• Change interventions insinuate a set of planned change activities Change
performed by internal or external people, intended to help an organisation Requirements
increase its effectiveness.
• Leadership plays a very important role in making the change happen. The
most important thing which the change leader can bring to a changing
organisation is the passion, conviction, and confidence in others. Classic
skills for successful change management include turning in to the
environment, challenging the prevailing organisational wisdom,
communicating a compelling aspiration, building coalitions, transferring
ownership to a working team, learning to preserve and making everyone a
hero.
2. Who is/are the change agent(s) driving the reforms in the power
distribution sector? Describe their functions.
5. What conclusions can you draw from the case studies presented in this
unit about change requirements?
Further Readings
• Ancona, Kochan, Scully, Van Maanen and Westney (1999) Managing for
the Future: Organisational Behaviour and Processes, Cincinnati, Ohio:
South-Western College Publishing, pp. M-8.16.
81
Change Management • Dean, Peter J. (2005) Leadership for Everyone, McGraw-Hill.
in Power Distribution
• Graetz, Fiona (2000) “Strategic change leadership”, Management
Decision, 38/8, pp.550- 562.
• Katzenbach J.R. (1996) Real change leaders. New York: Random House.
82