Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10, 36
JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2014
www.proaudioreview.com
in this issue
Studio
Covering Recording, Broadcast Production, and Post Production New Studio Products 10 Apogee Quartet Four-Channel Preamplifier and I/O
by Lynn Fuston
ProAudioReview
JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2014
Review 31
by Rob Tavaglione
Review 14
Review 32
by Rob Tavaglione
Review 16
34
Mini-Review 34
by Randy Poole
500 Series Microphone Preamplifiers featuring Sonic Farm Creamer, Petes Place Electrodyne 501 and Classic API Heider FD312
Review 18
Mini-Review 34
by Russ Long
Mini-Review 25
Sound Reinforcement
Covering Live Sound, Contracting, and Installed Sound New Live Products 36 Allen & Heath GLD-112 Digital Mixer
by Alistair McGhee for AudioMedia
Review 26
Review 38
by Rich Tozzoli
Review 27
Review 40
Mini-Review 28
by Rich Tozzoli
28
Departments
Weird Tricks That Will Blow Your Mind
by Frank Wells
40
Review 30
Technically Speaking
Cover & Featured Review Photography: Lynn Fuston | Cover Design: Walter Makarucha, Jr.
4 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014
ProAudio Review
The Review Resource for Sound Professionals
JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2014 EDITORIAL Frank Wells, Editorial Director 212-378-0400 x535, fwells@nbmedia.com Strother Bullins, Editor 336-703-9932, sbullins@nbmedia.com Clive Young, Managing Editor 212-378-0424, cyoung@nbmedia.com Kelleigh Welch, assistant editor 212-378-0423, kwelch@nbmedia.com Lynn Fuston, Technical Editor Rich Tozzoli, Software Editor Russ Long, Senior Contributor Steve Harvey, Will James, Alex Oana, Randy Poole, Alan Silverman, Christopher Sullivan, Rob Tavaglione, Tony Ware, Ben Williams, Sterling Wineld, Dan Wothke, Contributors ADVERTISING Tara Preston, Associate Publisher 917-331-8904, tpreston@nbmedia.com Karen Godgart, Sales Director, West Coast Ofce 323-868-5416, kgodgart@nbmedia.com Doug Ausejo, Specialty Sales Associate 650-238-0298, dausejo@nbmedia.com ART & PRODUCTION Nicole Cobban, Senior Art Director Walter Makarucha, Jr., Associate Art Director Fred Vega, Production Manager 212-378-0445, fvega@nbmedia.com CIRCULATION Meg Estevez, Group Director, Audience Development Michele Fonville, Associate Circulation Manager Subscriptions: Pro Audio Review, www.MyPARmag.com P.O. Box 234, Lowell, Ma 01853 Tel: 888-266-5828 (U.S.A. Only, 8:30 A.M. - 5 P.M. Est) 978-667-0352 (Outside The U.S.) Fax: 978-671-0460 E-Mail: Newbay@Computerfulllment.com NEWBAY MEDIA AUDIO GROUP Adam Goldstein, Senior Vice President/Group Publishing Director Ragan Whiteside, Web Director Robert Granger, Online Production Manager Ashley Vermillion, Web Production Specialist NEWBAY MEDIA CORPORATE Steve Palm, President & CEO Paul Mastronardi, Chief Financial Ofcer Jack Liedke, Controller Bill Amstutz, Vice President of Production & Manufacturing Robert Ames, Vice President of Digital Strategy & Operations Denise Robbins, Vice President of Audience Development Anthony Savona, Vice President of Content & Marketing Ray Vollmer, Vice President of Human Resources Anthony Verbanac, IT Director LIST RENTAL: 914-925-2449 or danny.grubert@lakegroupmedia.com REPRINTS AND PERMISSIONS: For custom reprints & eprints please contact our reprints coordinator at Wrights Media: 877-652-5295 or newbay@wrightsmedia.com PRINTED IN THE U.S.A. Administrative, Advertising, & Editorial Ofces 28 E 28th Street, 12th oor New York, NY 10016 TEL: (212) 378-0400
FREE!
technically speaking
Is it just me, or has Internet headline baiting gotten out of hand? The supermarket tabloids have rubbed off on web content creators, and the articles rarely deliver anything approaching what the headlines promise (if you need a laugh, visit upworthygenerator.comthanks to Chris Dauray for the link). We wont be taking that approach at Pro Audio Review, never fear (past the above headline, anyhow). Straightforward, simple and relevant information has been the format of choice for the existence of the title. There are some changes afoot for PAR, with
Frank Wells
10
www.proaudioreview.com
12
www.proaudioreview.com
studio review
by Lynn Fuston
Our Technical Editor finds Apogees all-in-one USB-based I/O device without compromisetruly a portable I/O built to meet to professional standards.
USB-to-standard USB Type A, or the Apogeeto-Apple 30-pin for my iPhone 4 with the 30-pin-to-Lightning adapter), recorded into Auria and monitored over headphones. I recorded drums and piano separately in the studio and was honestly startled by the resultsvery pleasantly so. For this recording, I was consistent with my belief that the most critical part of the signal path is right up front: Having a great drummer and good sounding kit will get you 70 percent of the way there. So I used an Audio-Technica ATM25 on the kick, an SM57 on the snare and two Neumann U47s for overheads. All of these went straight into the mic inputs on the Quartet. I set the levels and hit record, with no EQ or processing. Very impressive. Would I love to have my other favorite outboard processing on them as I recorded? For a real record, you bet. Theres not an easy way to do that since the preamps are built-in and there is no insert path available, but the sounds were solid and I could easily modify them in software or by routing out for EQ or compression. On piano, a Yamaha C7 with the lid removed, I used two DPA 4041 mics into the Quartet. With this solo piano piece, again, I was very impressed. This was after a session where I was tracking drums and piano with Groove Tubes VIPRE, Shadow Hills Gama, API 512 and Gordon Mk V preamps. While the Quartet is certainly not in the same sonic league as those (or price leaguethe Gordon and VIPRE cost 2-4 times as much just for one channel), the fact that the Quartet was respectable by comparison says a lot.
(continued on page 42)
Imagine a very-high quality, four-channel preamp, complete with DIs. Then throw in 24-bit, 192 kHz converters and a monitor controller capable of handling three sets of stereo speakers or 5.1 surround. Add to that Optical Ins (x2), MIDI capability and a WC Out. Plus a very powerful headphone output to boot. Bundle it all in a sleek, polished, aluminum package and sell it for less than the cost of a nice fourchannel preamp. If you can imagine all that, youve just realized the value of the Apogee Quartet.
Features This compact unit looks like a monitor controller, with all the switching concealed in the glass faceplate and a single alpha knob on the front. Clearly inspired by Apples design team, its clean lines and silver finish look perfect next to an iMac/Mac Mini or even an iPad (as pictured), and due to its larger back panel, it thankfully doesnt rely on breakout cables like its siblings, the Duet or One. It requires its own power supply, but it wont activate until connected to a USB-2 host, like my Mac Mini or iPad or iPhone: I used it in all three configurations. Each of the four XLR/quarter-inch combo inputs accommodate line in (switchable +4 or -10), Mic (+48 VDC/polarity both switchable) or Inst. The Maestro software (required) allows control of all switching and routing, along with selecting sample rate and Soft Limit On/Off, and has metering and a mixer built in, as well as allowing grouping of inputs for level control. Three programmable touchpad buttons allow for multiple user selections like Mute, Dim, Sum to Mono, Clear Meters, and Engage speaker set. In Use I connected it to my 64 GB iPad 4 using the supplied cables (Apogees own mini-B
Lynn Fuston is the technical editor for PAR and an accomplished Nashville-based recording engineer. 3daudioinc.com
14 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
studio review
by Randy Poole
no quarter-inch instrument input, no high pass filter and no fine output gain adjustment. These missing elements may not matter to you, depending on your signal chain. Summary Focusrite has successfully squeezed its amazing ISA preamp into 500 Series parameters, all done with the largest output tranny Ive ever seen in such a module. Hopefully Focusrite will release more of its designs for the format. Based on my own experience, the Red 1 500 seems to be faithful to the original in every way. Anywhere you desire a smooth frequency response yet clear, punchy and detailed sound, it delivers. Acknowledgement: Special thanks to Radial Engineering for the extended use of its superb Workhorse 500 rack during this review. Price: $999 Contact: Focusrite | focusrite.com
Randy Poole is a Nashville-based recording engineer and a regular contributor to Pro Audio Review.
16 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
studio review
by Russ Long
Russ Long is a Nashville-based engineer and mixer as well as PARs Senior Contributor. russlong.ws
18 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
The biggest challenge for most 500 Series users is keeping track of which modules are the cream of the crop. Ive had the chance to log some serious time with several great pieces over the past few months and Im going to use the next few issues of PAR to share my findings. Here Ill discuss three fantastic mic preamps: the Sonic Farm Silkworm ($700), the Electrodyne 501 ($1,000) and the Heider FD312 ($750). I will also report on MXLs latest tube mic offering, the higher-end Revelation Solo ($699).
Sonic Farm Silkworm I became a huge fan of Sonic Farm Pro Audio after reviewing the Creamer (PAR May 2012) and was thrilled to hear the company was entering the 500 Series market. Given the Creamers success, I expected the Silkworm to be a variation of the same pre, but thats not the case. The Silkworm is an entirely new beast and is simply brilliant. The Silkworms gain is controlled by combining a three-position Gain switch and a variable Gain Trim control. Its switchable from Medium to Low to High, which was a bit awkward at first; when I tried to raise the gain from low to medium, my natural reflex was to turn the switch up a click, but this actually raises it from low to high. The Silkworm incorporates a Cinemag input transformer and provides a maximum gain of 66 dB (or 42 dB of instrument gain)
with a fully discrete gain stage and a full DC path with no coupling capacitors. The maximum output level is 28.7 dBu. As with the Creamer, the output is switchable between solid-state balanced and transformer (Cinemag 100% Fe). I found that I almost always preferred the transformer output, but there were some instances (most often acoustic guitar and occasionally vocals) where I preferred the solid-state output. While the Silkworm is not a clone of any other mic pre, Im still prone to describe it as very GML-esque in the solid-state output mode and very Neve-ish in the transformer output mode. The Silkworms real magic is in the Vibe switch, which completely changes the character of the pre. The manual describes this feature as a complex impedance manipulator and it includes three settings, Smooth, Present, and Warped (labeled S, P and W). Presentthe most neutral and natural sounding of the threeprovides a flat 8 k input impedance while Smooth and Warped utilize a capacitive resistive network. Smooth has a warmer top end and Warped has a top end boost, which seemed more pronounced on dynamic microphones. In most cases, there was a substantial sonic difference between the three settings; when recording with the pre, I would dial in the entire signal path and then switch between the three modes and decide which one I liked best. Each option sounded like an entirely different mic pre and my preference was different nearly every time. The Silkworm works wonders on drums. I only had a single unit for my review but Id kill for a dozen channels to use on an entire drum kit during a full tracking session. On multiple tracking sessions, I used the pre along with a Telefunken M80, Heil PR20 and Shure SM57 to record snare drum; I had fantastic results in each instance. Ive been utilizing Auralexs Trap-Xpander to decrease hi-hat bleed into the snare mic and found that it works exceptionally well for that. I also had fantastic results utilizing the pre on kick drum, toms and hi-hat. The Silkworm works equally well recording electric guitars, vocals and acoustic instruments. Ive used it for all of these
over the past several months and my results have always been positive; in every instance, I enjoy auditioning the Vibe setting after getting the sound roughed in. Its direct input sounds sick on bass; tone is punchy, present and full, while the bottom is thick and defined.
Petes Place Electrodyne 501 Regrettably, I never had the opportunity to work on an Electrodyne desk; the company closed its doors in the mid 70sover a decade before I entered the businessbut its reputation remains legendary among my peers. I did have the chance to work on multiple Sphere desks as they were quite abundant in Nashville in my early days; Don McLaughlin started Sphere after leaving Electrodyne. McLaughlin retained the majority of Electrodynes designs, which he used in modified form in the Sphere consoles, making them sonically reminiscent of Electrodyne. More recently, Ken Hirsch of Orphan Audio (www.orphanaudio.com) purchased Electrodyne and partnered with Peter Montessi and Petes Place Audio to release the 500 Series Electrodyne 501 mic pre and 511 EQ. These are not pieces created in the vein of the real thing, but are the real thing; each amp stage incorporates the original factory engineering notes and high-performance components, carefully matched to
20
www.proaudioreview.com
the original specs, including the transformers. The two-stage discrete transistor and transformer-coupled 501 mic pre includes an active DI, too. The 501 has a maximum gain of 68 dB, adjustable over 50 dB in 2 dB steps with two ranges (depending on if the 20 dB pad is activated or not). Output level is infinitely adjustable from - (off) to +6 dB, while the OUT control knob is labeled with a dot instead of a line which, unless you are looking directly at the pre, can be difficult to read. The mic input impedance is switchable between 50 and 200 ohms and the DI impedance is over 7 M. The maximum output is +30 dB. The clip indicator monitors both amp stages and illuminates when either stage is within 3 dB of clipping. The first time I put the Electrodyne 501 to work was recording a male vocal with a Shure SM7B. The sound was fantastic, possibly the best tone Ive ever heard from an SM7B. Further, knowing the historical significance of the pre practically gave me goose bumps. I loved having the ability to turn the Output down slightly and push the preamp harder to get more color. I used the pre to record female vocals (Sony C800G), this time increasing the Output so as to not drive the pre as hard for a more natural sound and the results were great. The 501s DI circuit sounds fantastic, especially on instruments with significant bottom end content like bass guitar and analog keyboards. The instrument inputs amazingly high input impedance guarantees compatibility with virtually any direct signal while
allowing the precise capture of the sound sources true tone. Classic API Heider FD312 In addition selling components to aid in the restoration, repair and modification of API consoles, Classic API (Audio Products of Illinois) has several 500 Series kits, the majority in the $175-275 price range, allowing DIYers to build high-quality mic preamps at a fraction of the price of fully manufactured units. Last fall, Classic API released the Heider FD312, the only Classic API model not available in kit form, distributed exclusively by Nashvilles Rack-N-Roll Audio. The Heider FD312 was modeled after the preamps in the legendary Wally Heider Recording Studio 4 console that was custom built by Frank De Medio in the early 70s. These pres were built around stock 312 cards that De Medio modified by replacing the stock input transformer with a custom-wound Ed Reichenbach RE-0887 transformer which he interfaced differently than the stock transformer; this resulted in a smoother, more musical midrange. Utilizing Ed Reichenbachs original notes and specs, Cinemag builds the RE-0887 input transformers utilized in the Heider FD312. Unfortunately, there is no instrument input on the Heider FD312, though it includes both Mic and Line inputs. In Mic mode, the gain ranges from +22 dB to +57 dB with an input impedance of 167 ohms; in Line mode, the gain ranges from -14 dB to +21 dB with an input impedance of 9 k.
While Ive never found myself looking for a line input on a solid-state pre, Ive fallen in love with the character of the FD312 when operating in Line mode. Ive been running my ITB mixes through two channels in Line mode set to unity, and Ive found that the pre adds loads of character to my mix with a smoother top end and improved definition. In addition to the preamp circuit, the module employs an active booster stage, providing up to 12 dB of gainidentical to the boost circuit utilized in early- to mid70s API desks. As with other two stage mic preamps, you can attain more color and harmonic content by increasing the preamp gain and pulling back the Channel Fader, or a more pure tone by setting the Channel Fader to unity or slightly higher and pulling the preamp gain back. Activating the Hi-Z function (nearly
All are packed full of character, reasonably priced and fantastic performers. If you can afford it, Id recommend getting a pair of each.
always my sonic preference) increases the input impedance to 300 ohms and raises the gain by 3 dB. Activating the pad inserts a 16 dB pad and increases the input impedance to 765 ohms. All of these different impedance changes are wonderful as they provide tons of creative options while dialing in a sound. The stepped channel fader provides a final -16 dB to +12 dB gain stage, making the preamps maximum gain 72 dB in Mic mode with the Hi-Z engaged, and 69 dB with the Hi-Z not engaged. The FD312s maximum output level is +29 dBu and it includes a beautiful 12 segment, -22 to +16 VU meter that ranges from green (-22 to 0) to yellow (+3 to +12) to red (+14 to +16) where 0 VU = +4 dBu. I first used the Heider FD312 to record kick and snare on a tracking session. The pre sounded fantastic; I found myself using substantially less-than-typical EQ. On another tracking session, I used the pre on toms and was blown away again. When it comes to recording drums, the Heider FD312 is super. Its punchy as hell, with tons of character, leaving nothing to be desired. The pre also excels with acoustic instruments and vocals. The best way Ive found to describe the Heider FD312 is like a classic API mic pre but better. It has all of the rich punch and clarity of an API with a milky-smooth midrange that sounds as musical as any pre Ive ever encountered. The Heider excels on drums and electric guitars, but is equally fit for recording vocals and acoustic instruments. Summary The Sonic Farm Silkworm, Electrodyne 501 and Heider FD312 are all three wonderful mic preamps. If this was a shoot-out, Id have to call it a three-way draw because they are all winners. All are packed full of character, reasonably priced and fantastic performers. If you can afford it, Id recommend getting a pair of each. And, on the microphone front, MXL continues to impress with its high-quality mics that are surprisingly affordable. Next PAR, Ill delve into Moogs 500 Series Ladder Filter and Analog Delay as well as some other surprises. Contacts: Sonic Farm | sonicfarm.com/pro-audio/ silkworm Rack N Roll Audio | racknrollaudio. com/sales-product.php?product_ id=1383065948 Petes Place Audio | petesplaceaudio.com/ electrodyne.html MXL Microphones | mxlmics.com/ microphones/studio/Revelation-Solo
by Russ Long
aluminum flight case. The supply is manually switchable between 110/220 VAC. The sound of the Revelation Solo is quite good: neutral and un-hyped (unlike most mics Ive encountered in the affordable tube mic category) and remarkably quiet, though not dead quiet (yet quiet enough to give many classic vintage tube mics a run for their money). I first put the mic to work recording a female vocal (with the Heider FD312) and results were stunning. The mic perfectly captured the sparkle and air of the performance without sounding overly bright or edgy. I used the mic to record several acoustic guitars (again via the Heider FD312) and had superb results in each instance. The mics smooth, natural character actually worked wonders taming the top end of an exceptionally bright violin. I did notice when recording vocals that the mic seems to be slightly more susceptible to pops than my typical go-to vocal mics, but using two pop-filters instead of one easily solved this. The mics 138 dB max SPL make it easily adaptable to loud sound sources (as long as the pad is engaged) and while Id say its forte is vocals and acoustic instruments, the mic performs exceptionally well on electric guitars.
www.proaudioreview.com
25
studio reviews
by Rich Tozzoli
With pristine Class A signal, a highly-flexible signal path and awesome EQ all in one channel strip, an MPEQ-1 is an investment in quality.
pot to work the vocal as he got closer and farther from the mic. I actually asked him to redo parts once I learned how to push it, getting an intimate vocal sound on certain phrases. Then I tracked a female VO transformerless with the same mic as well as with a classic Sennheiser MKH 416. The talent noticed how clean and clear her voice was; she was used to another preamp. Recording bass via DI, I punched up a variety of EQ settings and could hear how smooth and round it was. Again, its important to understand how this EQ works; once you learn how to best apply it, its an amazing sounding EQ. I used it on an old Gibson Falcon amp with a Beyer M160, set to 50 Ohm, then pulled out a touch of low-mids while boosting 8 kHz. Wowonce more, clean, clear results with tasty EQ parameters. Summary I like the UTA MPEQ-1 quite a bit. If you want pristine Class A signal, a highly-flexible signal path and awesome EQ all in one channel strip, this would be a great candidate. You do have to take some time to learn it, but its worth the investment. Speaking of investment, it will run you over $2k. But as I always say, you can never go wrong buying quality. The UnderTone MPEQ-1 is quality. Price: $2,495 Contact: Undertone Audio | http://www. undertoneaudio.com
UA strikes gold once again with its Fairchild emulation plug-in series.
which lowers the internal operating level. The default position is where the small dot is at 12 oclock (a value of 16 dB). To get more harmonic distortion, turn the knob clockwise (which increases the operating level). The unit tends to compress more when doing that, which means youll probably need to turn up the Output control to compensate for gain reduction. Its also useful to understand the Time Constant knob with variable attack and release times. Its a six-position switch where settings 1 to 4 are progressively slower behaviors and 5 and 6 are program dependent. Additional attack/release variations are also possible, enabling the Sidechain Link and disabling the Controls Link. In Use An edgy, aggressive bass sound can be easily made by turning up the Input Channel, Headroom Control and Output. I like to set the Time Constant to 1 or 2, where the unit tends to react fairly quickly. Also, I set the Metering knob to GR (Gain Reduction), which allows me to see (in dB) how hard the compressor is hit. Of course, I adjust all parameters depending on the material, but bass, in particular, can really scream via UAs Fairchild. With it, I can undeniably hear an increase in smoothness, punch and character. Taking it a step further, there are two additional controls that offer quite a bit of flexibility. The Sidechain Filter controls a 12 dB per octave low-cut filter that goes from 20 to 500 Hz. Simply put, this lets you take bass frequencies out of the compressor to limit excessive gain reduction. Without the Sidechain Filter, the entire spectrum of frequencies in the track will be compressed which has its place, of course. But by pushing up the Sidechain Filter value, users essentially leave those frequencies alone and compress those above it. With heavy electric guitar parts, I like to set the Sidechain Filter around 400 Hz. What this does is enable the compressor not to squash as much overall, because I essentially removed the low end from hitting the compressor. Those frequencies gets left alone while the lower mids, mids and top get tightened up. Certainly, its also quite useful on bass parts. Normally, I tend not to compress electric parts very much, especially distorted tube amps, but with this filter, I can get it to be smooth and punchy while also using the Output for some extra gain. Sometimes, howeverespecially with plug-in based guitar amp emulationsit sounds best to squash the whole signal, leaving the Sidechain off. Its useful to have the option when you need it. Last but not least, UA built in a Mix knoba feature I would like to have on every plug in, actually! While simple in theory, its incredibly useful in taste and touch. It sets the output balance between the dry signal and that of the one processed by the compressor. This lets you hit a bass or guitar hard with overall compression, then pull it back from 100 percent (Wet) to get an ideal blend of processed and unprocessed. To navigate this quickly, you can click on the Mix graphic to move to 50 percent, the 0 for 0 percent, and so on.
www.proaudioreview.com
27
Summary Overall, the Fairlight Collection is a great compliment to most any type of production track. Specifically on guitar and bass, users can control individual track dynamics while
increasing thickness and punch, yet its the combination of Input Gain, Threshold, Time Constant, Headroom, Sidechain Filter and Mix that helps me take tracks to the next level. Best of all, youll never have to change
Ill take a look at just what makes this tool of the stage and studio so cool. Features Knowing that too many knobs and buttons overwhelm most of us, Eventide kept it simple with its H9. The top panel features a sixcharacter LED display, five small buttons, a large rotary Encoder/Switch and a pair of foot switches. For fluidity, the buttons control what the knob does. To load a preset, for example, users may press the Preset
(continued on page 42)
More than a simple stompbox, the H9 is a breakthrough guitar production device on stage as well as in the studio, offers PARs Software Editor.
Breaking new ground is never easy, but thats exactly what Eventide has done with its H9 Harmonizer Multi-Effects Pedal. Incorporating the latest in blue tooth technology, iOS app control and sheer simplicity, this small but powerful floor unit can reproduce the sounds of all of Eventides stomp boxes and then some. In this article,
studio reviews
by Rob Tavaglione
phonic tapping of cables with too much gain, a modulation and the sweeping of a delay with ample feedback. This is the ultimate spontaneous sound-design tool, Grey noted enthusiastically as he completed a jet takeoff warble-swoosh that would fit into anything between dub, dubstep and EDM. The EXTC is a clear choice if you want to simplify the often complicated task of reamping with effects. If the $300 street price seems high, do consider that the design is near perfection (level controls to balance the two loops would be perfection). All the unique creative realtime flexibilities imaginable (and unimaginable) are brought to life with the EXTC. Price: $299 street Contact: Radial Engineering | radialeng.com
The EXTC is a clear choice for simplifying the often-complicated task of reamping with effects.
that was truly inspiring, in a sound design/ experimental kind of way. Drums were transformed into alien blips with phasers/overdrive, bass guitars into roaring mechanical beasts with distortion pedals/tremolos/flangers andmy filmscoring favoriteline noise and the micro-
As small as a paperback, the MC3 provides switching for two monitor sets (A, B or both), complete with passive level adjustment, a total of three headphone outs on quarter-inch and eighth-link with a level control, a variable dim control, a mono-sum switch, balanced or unbalanced operation on quarter-inch jacks and an external power supply. Theres also a stereo aux out via quarterinch TRS that follows the headphone level
Rob Tavaglione is the owner of Catalyst Recording, Charlottes longstanding independent music production house. catalystrecording.com
30 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
control (ideal to feed a larger cue system) and a subwoofer output with level control and polarity reversal. Passive circuitry and quality switching relays make for some clean, near-neutral audio handling. There are no talkback mic facilities; youll have to achieve these within your DAW. Some considerations in using the MC3: The headphone amp is loud and clean maybe not quite as accurate as my Aphex Headpodbut noteworthy. The headphone level control follows the master volume knob; I do wish that it were pre-master. Surprisingly, the master volume knob spun on the shaft, as its improperly sized; I got better operation removing it. Considering the $250 street price, the MC3 is still a great choice for the personal recordist, the laptop recordist on-the-go
or the traveling producer who wants some stable continuity as work moves from room to room.
In Use To my ears, the radiation patterns of the D8 pair (with their coaxial design) makes for a nicely uniform soundstage, one that stays stable as you move from left to right. The tweeters radiate evenly Catalyst Recording's Assistant Engineer Brandon Nater on the vertical axis, allowing compares the Equator D5 and D8 models. some leeway in placement and chair height. Upper-bass/low-mids seemed a little carved Frequency wise, the D8s take a slightly out (around 300 Hz) and the high-mids were aggressive stance with prominent high- slightly harder than typical. I found voicing mids, subdued low-mids, a crisp top-end and position #3free-standing, no bass rolloff good bass extension. Many users will find to have the truest response for my large the D8s reach deep enough on their own; control room. Performance was overall quick personally, I would pair with a subwoofer. and popping, with lots of detail and little flab.
www.proaudioreview.com
31
Assistant Brandon Nater and I set up both D5s and D8s on my monitor shelf with Primacoustic Recoil Stabilizers under the D8s and Auralex MoPads under the D5s. With both sets on the freestanding setting, we found the D5s to have a slightly darker presentation with more prominent bass response! Yes, the D8s reach a little lower frequency-wise, but the D5s are voiced with an overall plumper, fuller balance. With the D5 pair set for slight bass rolloff, the two pair were more closely matched frequency-wise. Despite similarities in radiation patterns, tweeter transients/speed and a lack of muddiness, significant differences still remain in our evaluation. The D8s have a low fat notching at 300 Hz, reducing muddiness and boxiness; the D5s have their notch
placed higher and not as deeply. The D8s have a broad 4 kHz to 8.5 kHz rise, whereas the D5s have a narrower definition boost that isnt as pronounced or irregular. After working on the D8s for a week at home, Brandon concluded, the D8s highs truly stand out more and with a little more bark to them, though they do sound fuller. Ill stick with the D5s for their smoother midrange. Summary The D8s cabinetry, finish, appearance, amplification, protection modes, level controls and that concentric woofer/tweeter mounting with its forgiving sweet spot coverage pattern make it a simply superb choice in studio monitoring. I like everything about the D8s except their voicing,
as I prefer monitors with ample low-mids to help highlight my most troubled frequency areas and a softer, fatigue-reducing presentation. Conversely, the D8s have a carved low-mid contour that reduces audible issues in the mix and a bit of rock-n-roll bite in the upper-mids that features crisp transients, lots of detail and tight damping. Thus, my voicing opinions are just that opinions. Considering the D8s 60-day trial period, if I were in the market for nearfields, had a tight budget, and especially if I used room correction DSP-software, the D8 would be the first Id try. After all, a free audition period just may be the best studio monitor feature on the market today. Price: $777 per pair, direct Contact: Equator Audio | equatoraudio.com Class A custom Sowter transformer-loaded tube-based mic amp with three bands of active lift only EQ, high-pass filters and a function switch that allows either mic, padded mic, line or Pullet inputs. [According to Thermionic Culture, the Pullet is Thermionics two-channel passive EQ that requires significant make-up gain. The Earlybirds inputs accommodate with ideal gain and impedanceEd.] The EQ circuit utilizes vari-slope curves for the bass and top lift controls and a broad, low-Q curve for the mid boost (at either 800 Hz or 2.8 kHz). This EQ is placed in the feedback portion of the Earlybirds circuitry and therefore does not introduce a new gain stage to the circuit; Thermionic reports that it allows EQ adjustments with-
Rob Tavaglione is the owner of Catalyst Recording, Charlottes longstanding independent music production house. catalystrecording.com
32 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
out fear of losing the original tone. High-pass filters are available at 40, 100 and 800 Hz, with a -12 dB/octave slope at 40 and 100 Hz plus a broad slope at 800, designed to interface with the bass lift band in that resonant filter/response dip before boost/simultaneous bass boost and cut method well known to Pultec EQ users. Although the Earlybird has two different input impedance settings300 and 1200 ohms, helpful in fine tuning EQ and transient responsetheres no DI or instrument input. Gain is at either 36, 44, 52 or 60 dB, with the pad applicable to any gain setting. There are output level trims, polarity flip and a 48 VDC phantom power switch. The Rooster The Rooster will accept mic and line inputs, but also front panel DIs that bypass the input transformers, sending signal directly to the units ECC81 double-triode input tube. The EQ section offers bass lift (varislope at 60 Hz); bass cut (five different frequencies at a variety of slopes); a mid/high lift (either 2.5 or 4 kHz or varislope at 12 kHz); a mid cut (700 Hz bell) and a LPF, which may just be useful when using the Attitude section. Attitude provides control over the amount and type of distortion created by a 5725 valve (as found in Thermionics popular Culture Vulture distortion processor). This circuitry starts with a minimal 0.01% distortion in the 1st position and increases dirt with either Triode (2nd order) or Pentode (3rd order) as one dials Attitude towards a maximum of six. The Roosters continuously variable out-
put via PCF 80 tube and Sowter transformer has a three-segment LED display. The Bird Vs. The Rooster Both the Rooster and Earlybird are overall clean, clear and full bandwidth, but slightly colored in a subtle way; percussive signals and bold tones are musically tamed. With sustaining sources, their low-mids seem to be accentuated and compressed; high end is crisp and present but not irritating or on the edge. These subtleties are just thatsubtletiesuntil the user approaches saturation of the circuits. Hitting the Roosters or Earlybird 2.2s front end with too much signal create light distortion in a non-obtrusive, mostly low-mid woofiness thats only a little ugly, but not splatty; I dove for the input gain a moment too late with a jumpy alto. On drum overheads, the Earlybird had enough speed to catch lively snare, enough fullness to translate toms and a smooth musicality that mitigated the harshest cymbals. Snare top via SM57 yielded nice, woody mids and a little extra top end EQ crafted a nice crack. Acoustic guitar shined with the Bird, while broad-stroke EQ work is enough to make room/instrument corrections well within your purview. Vocals of all varieties sound great via Earlybird, although input gain riding isnt possible, but at least output is. Although the Rooster does clean just fine, I found it to be geared towards dirtiness. The Rooster is designed rather similarly to Thermionics flagship distortion processor, the Culture Vulture, and sounds quite similar, though with far less control
variation, less gain available, but wider bandwidth (much like the Culture Vulture Mastering model). The Rooster can add serious attitude to DI bass tracks with creative EQing, filtering and adding its Attitude control. Drum tracks can receive that edgy triode distortion from Attitude, dangerously adding character to rock or retro-style productions. Whole mixes can be goosed up with the Attitude #2 Triode setting, but I found few mixes benefited by Attitude #3 triode or higher (it goes to 6). Attitude is likely more useful on subgroups of synths, drums, vocals, etc. with Triode for subtlety and Pentode for wild fuzziness. Summary I found myself enjoying these two Thermionic Culture units with no qualms concerning build quality, design or features. The Earlybird and the Rooster have enough EQ power to shape and mould sources not in need of surgery; both are gentle and forgiving with hot inputs, and neither is a big fuzz pedal (except when crushing the Roosters Attitude in Pentode). These designs and high-class sonics come priced in the thousands, thus not for the audio production hobbyist. If you place high importance on nebulous variables like musicality, transient shaping and tunable saturation, you may find these two cultured Brits to be necessary members of your audio flock. Prices: $2,795 and $4,525 street (Rooster and Earlybird 2.2, respectively) Contact: Independent Audio (US Distributor) | independentaudio.com
The Rooster
www.proaudioreview.com
33
studio reviews
by Tony Ware
www.proaudioreview.com
capabilities have been repeatedly augmented with rhythm creation and dynamics shaping components. In 2011, Native Instruments introduced the more compact MASCHINE MIKRO, then in October 2012 it tweaked MIKRO and the full-sized MASCHINE to MkII, offering more colorful grouping and visual LED feedback, expanded host control and more comprehensive timestretch/ pitch shift sample control in the same footprint. The November 2013 introduction of the $999 flagship MASCHINE STUDIO controller and 2.0 software expands the system physically and functionally, offering the most intuitive workflow to date by transferring even more browsing, arrangement, sculpting and monitoring capabilities into its terminal. Features The MASCHINE STUDIO 2.0 hardware, which is no longer bus-powered, is not highly portable, but it is highly potable. The 17-inch by 13.8-inch surface area retains
the 16 multicolor velocity/aftertouch-sensitive pads, eight multifunction rotary encoders plus master/group/transport controls, and adds two high-resolution TFT 480x272 color displays, dedicated level metering and a jogwheel-centered edit section. While I still needed my MacBook Air (2.0 GHz i7/8 GB RAM/256 GB SSD) to run the software, I no longer felt required to gaze at its screen. The two MASCHINE STUDIO displays offer icon-enriched library browsing, plug-in strip navigation, detailed scene/pattern timeline viewing, volume/pan positioning and accu-
rate waveform range selection/slicing/fading/overlapping/etc., while the illuminated, clickable jogwheel provides responsive fine-tune control for copy/paste/quantize adjustments, pitch/timing editing and other pad/events modifications and parameter automation. Angled by the slabs integrated pop-out legs, MASCHINE STUDIO 2.0 provides a consummate beat-creation centerpiece (and theres a MIDI mode for customization/use with other software, if desired). The I/O is still MIDI-only, however, so an additional interface is needed for recording original samples. In Use As for the software component (included at $999 or available separately as a $99 backwards-compatible upgrade for all MASCHINE hardware generations), MASCHINE STUDIO 2.0 debuts several invaluable tools, including, among others, five Reaktor-based acoustic/electric drum
(continued on page 42)
36
www.proaudioreview.com
www.proaudioreview.com
37
live review
Few products offer the GLD-112s magic blend of features, workflow, sound quality and expandability, making it a true bargain.
desk? Channel count, sound quality and workflow? Features? Reliability? Of course, cost is never far from our minds. The GLD Series is a serious attempt to check all above boxes. First, channel count: the GLD system maxes out at 48 inputs; this is what separates it from its big brothers in the iLive stable. Yet in the digital world, channel count vs. fader count is an issue. Who wants a 48-input desk with one fader and 48 layers? Key to the GLD-112 is its 28 faders on one surface. Why is that so important? Well, lets think back to 48 inputs. With a GLD-112 on two layers, we have 56 faders, which the eagle-eyed among us will notice is enough to max out inputs and have eight mix out-
A longstanding writer for PAR sister publication AudioMedia, Alistair McGhee has been a BBC audio engineer for well over a decade.
38 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
puts without dropping down to layers three and four. And, with all effects processing available on-board, users may not need all the surface inputs; thus 12 or more faders are available for groups, auxs and other fun stuff. When it comes to sound quality, Allen & Heath has established a serious rep for its digital desks. Across the board, the companys mic amps are well regarded and users should have no worries about quality on that level. Four mic inputs comprise half of the GLD112 surfaces analog inputs (plus four RCA/ phono inputs for a total of eight); beyond that, users will reach for the Cat5. The GLDs come fitted with an onboard dSNAKE input. The 2412 dSNAKE stage box packages 24 mic inputs with 12 outputs plus options for one I/O expander and adding a string of Allen & Heaths own MEmixer personal mixers (or personal mixers from a competing line, such as Aviom products). Adding an AR84 to the 2412 provides eight more mic inputs and another four outputs. If that isnt enough, another AR84 expander can be added directly into the GLD surface. I like the fact you can get 24 channels in one hit, while others may prefer the 16 x 8 approach offered by other brands. One thing you cant do (which I would like to do) is plug in two 2412s. What about workflow? Like many digital desks, parameters of a selected channel are accessed with hardware encoders and LED displays of settings. This tactile functionality can be utilized without reference to the built-in touch screen, which, besides offering an informative graphic display of settings, provides further control (or primary control, your choice). Its great to have both UI options and this dual capability enables a lot of flexibility. Each channel and mix output on the surface has a colored LCD scribble strip. This simple feature is a real lifesaver, actually.
While I shouldnt have to mix by color, in the heat of the moment, reaching for a red fader can be the difference between getting the lead vocal mic and the drummers vocal mic (and nobody wants that). Each channel has a dedicated Mix button, allowing rapid assignments of channels to mixes and also a very quick method of checking a mix backwards. Not as in, where is this channel going? but which channels are assigned to this mix? Onboard effects deserve a special mention, too. They have been borrowed from the iLive series, are well-tested and deliver professional sounding results across the board, literally. In Use How does the mixer feel? Very solid, I think; both its hardware and software are thoroughly professional in operation. This is not an MI product in wolfs clothing; it is a pros tool designed to do a night-in/ night-out gig. And, like every Tom, Dick and Debbie Harry, it offers an iPad app. I understand people wanting to set up the room over wireless, but personally I dont want to mix over WiFibad experience, dont like to talk about it. However, theres a cut down version of the app (oneMix), which offers control of just one aux, allowing a musician to mix his own individual monitor feed. Also shiny and new is the GLD editor software. Available for Win and Mac OS (I only ran the Win 7 and XP version, but without any issues), this software allows you to set up the desk while offline and control it in real time. I think its a bit more literal than the iLive stuff, which makes it easier for stupid people like me; for the most part, the remote looks just like the surface. The GLD accepts USB keys for audio playback and you can also record a stereo mix to the key, though at 48 kHz only. I do like
the fact that there is a shortcut to the USB play/record screenalways available in the tool bar at the bottom of the touchscreen. In buying a digital live mixer such as this, one of the things everyone thinks about is to what extent the purchase is an openended investment rather than a one-off; here, the GLDs have some rather potent advantages. Although the desk ships with dSNAKE, a range of other interfaces are available. Customers can choose between ACE, MADI, Dante, Ethersound, and Waves Sound Grid formats. And if you dont like any of those, theres a multi-output card with ADAT, iDR, and Aviom on it. If you hanker after a large networked system or already have an investment in any of the above-referenced technologies, buying a GLD keeps you in the game with the option to add more A&H functionality later. Summary The GLD-112 is, in one sense, not really hard to use. Pretty much all of it has been road-tested and refined in other Allen & Heath products. It feels well screwed together and users will be unlikely to get any nasty surprises. Its software is growing and bettering all the time and, with the release of the GLD editor, is now very comprehensive. GLD workflow is flexible and provides some welcomed interface features for those making their living behind a digital front-of-house mixing desk. Undoubtedly pros will have already noticed that an Allen & Heath isnt the cheapest mixer on the market, yet few other products offer this kind of magic blend of features, workflow, sound quality, and expandability that makes the GLD 112 a bit of a bargain. Price: $9,999 street Contact: Allen & Heath | allen-heath.com
GLD workflow is flexible and provides some welcomed interface features for those making their living behind a digital front-of-house mixing desk.
www.proaudioreview.com January/February 2014 | ProAudioReview 39
live review
by Strother Bullins
At $899 street, theres not a better all-in-one PPA option for under $1k.
Yamahas DXS12 Active Subwoofer for one relatively high-volume cover rock band gig in a medium-sized, long and skinny venue with tall, tin-tiled ceilingsa place always ripe for feedback and generally cavernous acoustics. This time around, there was no feedback found (I just set and forgot the Feedback Suppressor) and the additional fullness added by the subwoofer was essentially what Im used to hearing when gigging via a DXR/DXS speaker configuration. So, in summary, two words: wow, and sold. Summary Not that long ago, most all-in-one PPA systems were notoriously underpowered with a comparably plastic, hollow sound. The STAGEPAS 600i is leaps and bounds beyond this old stereotype, providing marquee-level features truly designed to serve the modern DIY performance gig. Price: $899 street Contact: Yamaha | yamahaproaudio.com
Strother Bullins is an active musician, recordist and the editor of Pro Audio Review.
40 ProAudioReview | January/February 2014 www.proaudioreview.com
adindex
2 9 21 43 22 6 3 8 5 11 28 15 13 24 44 17 7 23 35 Audio-Technica U.S. audio-technica.com Audiofly audiofly.com Audix Microphones audixusa.com B&H Pro Audio bhproaudio.com Dave Hill Designs/Crane Song davehilldesigns.com Eminence dfend@eminence.com Focusrite focusrite.com/ISA Full Compass fullcompass.com Genelec genelecusa.com Hosa Technology hosatech.com IsoAcoustics Inc. isoacoustics.com KRK krksys.com Lectrosonics lectrosonics.com Parts Express parts-express.com/catalog QSC Audio Products qscaudio.com Rohde & Schwarz rohde-schwarz.com Shure Inc. shure.com Vintage King vintageking.com Vu-Gear vu-gear.com
M A S T E R D I R E C
classifieds
CONSULTING SERVICES ACOUSTICS STUDIO FURNISHINGS Lynn Fuston
Home Studio/Pro Audio Consulting/Mentoring
615-364-9324 3daudio@charter.net Also available via Skype
R Y
Log on now to explore thousands of listings of business services and production facilities in the professional audio industry the most comprehensive resource of its kind in the world. Search by keyword, category, or location. Listees: Access your listing anytime to revise and maintain your contact info.
41
Apogee Quartet
(continued from page 14)
Eventide H9
(continued from page 28)
Summary For a remote recording rig, combined with an iPad, it is a stellar and very compact option. This is the first USB all-in-one rig that Ive encountered where I truly felt like I could make a record and not feel like apologizing for any audio compromises. Its that good. Combined with another one or two 8-channel Lightpipe interfaces, it could easily be the heart of a great full band tracking setup. Im extremely impressed with this little box, with great sounding preamps and converters and all of it packaged in a unit that works with iOS and is under $1,400. Apogee has a winner with the Quartet. Price: $1,395 street Contact: Apogee Digital | apogeedigital.com
NI MASCHINE 2.0
(continued from page 35)
modellers, unlimited groups (of 16 sounds each), unlimited plug-in inserts per sound/ group, sidechaining/bus compression and a cue bus for live performance. The pleasingly stackable, adjustable monophonic drum algorithms (kick, snare, hi-hat, tom, percussion) almost make you forget the additional 8 GB multi-genre sample library. The entire package features a rewritten, multicore-supporting sound engine that is noticeably (40- to 60-percent) more resources efficient, and finalized productions can be exported in multiple formats or integrated in a multitrack as a DAW plug-in. It wont replace a linear recorder, but it will play nicely with it. Summary Ultimately, MASCHINE STUDIO 2.0s success is that it evolves with so many more options while facilitating creation at an even faster pace than before, reinforcing it as a go-to on-the-fly sketchbook. Price: $999 street Contact: Native Instruments | nativeinstruments.com
button and scroll with the rotary encoder. The preset will automatically load and the title will scroll across the screen. The rear panel has nothing but stereo Hi-Z unbalanced inputs and outputs (two each), an expression pedal jack, a jack (12 VDC/4.5 W) for the included power cable, and a mini-USB port. The H9 automatically detects how many outputs are plugged in for mono or stereo operation, and the USB jack plugs into a CPU for full control and software updates. The presets are preprogrammed with expression pedal mappings; its nothing but plug and play. Theres also MIDI I/O on the side for MIDI program changes or MIDI clock slaving. The H9 features comprehensive Bluetooth capabilities, allowing for full control via iOS device such as an iPad or iPhone. I downloaded the Control Software App, signed up for my Eventide account, paired my H9 and was soon dialing in presets and programs from my iPad. Soon after, the App automatically appeared on my iPhone and I worked from there as well. It was great to be able to quickly tap through presets on my iPhone to audition them, then tweak the settings. Amazing! You can also download the H9 Control software for Windows or Mac, allowing for desktop pedal integration. Plugging in the mini USB jack, I was able to tweak each preset on GUIs that look like the original pedals themselves. Its a great way to work. With so few features on the front panel, you might think its hard to dig in. Not at all, actually. The H9 features a variety of ways to access parameters by pressing and holding various combinations of buttons and switchesor by using the X, Y and Z pre-programmed hot keys. For example, users can add up to +18 dB of input gain by pressing and holding the left foot switch until IN+O appears, then scroll up the gain values. Or, to access the tuner, press and hold both foot switches at the same time, etc. While the H9 comes with 99 presets from Eventides collection of pedals, users can audition and buy new algorithms
with a complete set of factory presets for $19.99 each. These are downloaded in seconds and stored in a users own H9 account. I purchased some extra Digital Delay sounds from the Time Factor pedal and the payment was processed instantly through Amazon.com Payments. These will be perfect to use on gigs with the H9 in my pedalboard. This review is the first time Ive learned a piece of gear entirely by watching videos. Eventides Adrienne Humblet did a series of 30 short clips (which I watched via YouTube) where she demonstrated the ins and outs of the H9. I literally sat there with the H9 on my desktop (hooked into my Pro Tools rig) and watched all 30 videos in a row. They are quick, easy and very informative. As she demonstrated each feature, I would run through them myself on the unit, sometimes multiple times to drill them into my thick head. Within an hour or so, I had almost a full understanding of how to use the H9. In Use As a guitar player, I love this unit. Best described as rich and deep, it delivers superior delay, pitch, modulation and reverb sounds in a small package. As a TV composer and sound designer, I love this box even more. Plugging in anythingmy Tele, Les Paul, Strat, baritone, cigar box guitar, etc.it delivers pure inspiration with a specialty in ambience. In fact, it was actually hard to do this review because I would immediately compose with whatever presets were dialed in. Summary The H9 is a breakthrough device. With top quality sounds, full wireless Bluetooth and USB desktop control and an expandable palette of sounds, its a world-class music-making tool. Its design is intelligent, easy to use, and highly functional. Actually, this box is so deep I wish I had more word count to talk about it. Yes, $499 is not cheap for a pedal. But for what it offers, its worth far more. Price: $499 Contact: Eventide | eventide.com
42
www.proaudioreview.com