Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
Figures dont lie but liars figure . How Loan Servicers Profit by using the Net Present Value Calculation to deny Loan Modifications
By Robert K. Ramers
Original lender
The party named on your promissory note and deed of trust is the original lender. It might be a mortgage company or a bank. It is very likely that this party did not use their own funds for your transaction, but used investor funds that they got from a Trust set up to buy your promissory note and receive your mortgage payments to provide tax free income to the bond holders of the trust.. It is likely that the original lender sold or transferred your promissory note to another party. This party could have sold it to a third party, who then may have sold it to a Trust, which had raised money from institutional investors such as pension funds and governmental agencies. This process is know as the securitization of your loan, because your loan was used as collateral for securities (bonds) that were sold to investors.
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
trustee is also responsible for making sure that all of the loan payments that are coming into the trust are distributed to the investors based on the investments that they made, and that the financial interests of the investors are protected. It is important to note that it is only the actual current owner of your note (or an agent that they appoint) has the authority under the Deed of Trust that you signed, to negotiate a loan modification, to assign your note to somebody else, to substitute trustees, or to foreclose on your property.
Information about securitized loans, including who owns the loan, the payment history, payments to the servicer, responsibilities of the servicer and other information is available using the Bloomberg financial software and the Securities and Exchange Commission database. We use these sources in our chain of title audits and NPV analysis.
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
But wait, you might say, dont the servicers have to keep making my payments to the trust if I do not make them? Isnt this costing them a lot of money? Yes, it is. We have specialized software that lets us see the amount of these servicer advances. We have seen advances amounting to more than $200,000 on a single loan. Now here is where the real conflict of interest comes in. In many cases, the only way that the servicer can get reimbursed for the advances it has made to the trust, whether these advances are due to nonpayment by the homeowner or because of reduced payments due to a loan modification, is through foreclosure of the property! Furthermore, the servicer gets paid BEFORE any money goes to the investor, regardless of the sale price of the property. This explains the apparently illogical situation where a servicer will foreclose on a property at a huge loss, when on the surface a loan modification would have been better for both the homeowner and the actual owner of the loan. The software that we use allows us to see the amount of these losses, called the loss severity. In the more than 400 audits that we have done, we have documented loss severities of 50% to over 70% on loans that have been foreclosed on by loan servicers. In some cases, these losses have actually amounted to over 100% of the loan value, probably due to legal expenses and other fees charged by the loan servicers to the Trust that owns the loan. These facts explain the apparently illogical behavior of loan servicers. What they are doing is perfectly logical in financial terms, since they make more money. However, both the homeowner and the actual owner of your loan are being damaged. How can the servicers get away with this, you might say? One of the tools that they use is the way that they calculate the Net Present Value figure to justify their decision to foreclose on a property rather than offering a loan modification.
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
Example Lets say you can earn 10% interest on your money. If so,getting $1,000 today should be the same to you as getting $1,100 in one year, since you will earn $100 in interest in that year (10% X $1000 = $100, plus your original $1,000 equals $1,100). If you reverse this logic, you should be just as happy to get $1,100 in one year as you would be to get $1,000 today, since all you could earn on your $1,000 is 10% for the next year. By discounting the stream of cash outlays and income (using the interest rate you think you can earn on your money) back to the present, you come up with a single number from each cash flow stream. You can then compare these numbers to decide on the most profitable investment opportunity.
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
that matter) understand or challenge the calculations. Not understanding and challenging the NPV calculation can result in losses to both the homeowner and the investor who owns the loan, providing a financial benefit only to the loan servicer.
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
Where
The Making Home Affordable formula is a little more complicated (from the Home Affordable Modification Program Base Net Present Value (NPV) Model v5.02 Model Documentation Handbook):
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
The actual formula used in the case of a default to determine the NPV is as follows:
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
The actual formulas are more complex, and take into consideration the probability of a re-default and other variables.
10
Robert K. Ramers
Tel: 415-730-4514 Top Gun Auditor fax: 707-885-0500 email: topgunauditor@gmail.com
ROBERT K. RAMERS
Robert K. Ramers is a chain of title and Certified Securitization Auditor. He has conducted over 400 investigations on behalf of homeowners. His prior experience includes positions as Financial Vice President and CEO of several corporations. He is available to perform NPV and Securitization Analysis and as an Expert Witness. He can be contacted at topgunauditor@gmail.com
11