Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The U.S. electric sector faces radical change in 2014. From the rise of disruptive technologies to paradigm shifts in policy and regulation, every industry player today is confronting a wholly uncertain future. With that in mind, two of our writers took time over the holiday break to reflect on state of the electric sector and gaze into the proverbial crystal ball. But we're not the only ones trying to divine the future. Utility Dive is asking electric utility execs to share their opinions on the state of the industry today. Please take our 2014 Benchmark Survey and forward it to your colleagues. Without further ado, here are our 10 predictions for 2014.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 2 sur 19
Advertisement
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 3 sur 19
Future growth potential of energy storage for wind and solar (ESWS)
There are opportunities for utilities, but they should also watch out: the distributed energy storage market is heating up fast. Look for early adopter regions such as California, New York, Hawaii, Colorado and New England to lead in this emerging market. More affluent ratepayers in those parts of the country have already shown the desire to bypass their electric utility with the installation of rooftop solar systems, and batteries are the just next logical step in that equation. (For example, bundled solar-and-storage systems help solar owners defeat high demand charges.)
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 4 sur 19
The potential was always there, but now the market is catching up. SolarCitys move to bundle solar systems with Tesla batteries for commercial customers was precedent-setting. Following SolarCity's lead, SunPower recently announced it will bundle solar and storage for residential customers in the coming years. Expect the customer-sited storage market to be a big opportunity in the coming years.
Utilities are already worried about the threat of distributed storage, as shown by California utilities Edison International, Sempra Energy and Pacific Gas & Electric refusing to net meter stored solar because "the rules are in a state of flux" and technically, a customer who now has [battery-backed solar] may not qualify for net energy metering under current rules, according to a spokeswoman for San Diego Gas & Electric (a Sempra Energy utility). Expect the wildly successful no-money-down, third-party-owned model popularized by rooftop solar installers to also gain traction in the storage sector. Look for battery startup Stem, which recently received $5 million from Jigar Shahs venture capital firm and $15 million from General Electric, Iberdrola and others, to pioneer this model in the next few years.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 5 sur 19
This is not to say that grid-scale storage doesn't have potential. Economies of scale dictate that grid-scale storage (and grid-scale wind and solar) will be more costeffective than distributed systems may take longer for utilities to implement it on a wide scale. In 2013, we saw the California Public Utility Commission set the first energy storage mandate for U.S. utilities, single-handedly turning grid-scale storage (and not just one or two MW, but 1,325 MW by 2020) into a reality. California has long been the example that other forward-thinking states follow and is now effectively guaranteeing a market for vendors in California (and, eventually, other early adopter states). Puerto Rico has already followed suit in mandating energy storage for new renewable projects (of which there are 600 MW in the pipeline), stipulating that plants from now on must be able provide 45% of the plant's maximum capacity for 60 seconds, and 30% of its rated capacity for 10 minutes. All this goes to show that the U.S. power grid's future will not be about added capacity, but more flexible capacity. Expect regulators and policymakers to work to incentivize the market in that direction in 2014.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 6 sur 19
EIA
The two key factors affecting sales that we'll be watching are energy efficiency spending and the rise of rooftop solar panels. Energy efficiency is taking a toll on sales. Electric energy efficiency budgets jumped from $2.6 billion in 2008 to nearly $6 billion in 2012, according to a report from the American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy. Savings increased from 18.4 million MWh, or 0.5% of retail sales, in 2010 to 22.9 million MWh, or 0.6% of retail sales, in 2011. Efficiency spending and savings are expected to keep climbing, according to a report from the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. Under a mid-case scenario, annual efficiency budgets will climb to $8.1 billion by 2025, driven by state energy efficiency standards, the report said. At the same time, savings will climb to 0.76% of annual retail sales, potentially offsetting sales growth.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 7 sur 19
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 8 sur 19
But several factors could lead to higher-than-expected sales. The economy could take off. Low natural gas prices could cut into the cost savings potential for efficiency, and the harvesting of low-hanging fruit like the now-ubiquitous compact fluorescent bulbs could make it hard to keep up the pace of savings. But that's unlikely. On top of rising efficiency spending, rooftop solar is growing quickly. Slowly but surely, distributed generation is taking a bite out of sales. For one, Arizona Public Service estimates that rooftop solar is eating into its sales by about 0.5% a year. What will happen if solar prices drop even more? Certainly in areas with relatively high electric rates, solar will become more appealing. Any potential opportunities for electric sales growth appear outmatched right now by the rise of energy efficiency and distributed energy resources. The EIA expects electricity demand growth to grow very slowly through 2040 compared to the past. The lack of significant electric sales growth is a fundamental threat to the traditional utility business model, predicated as it is on the sale of electricity. It's a new normal to which utilities will seek to adapt.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 9 sur 19
3. Coming soon to a Public Utility Commission near you: Net metering battles!
Davide Savenije: A significant precedent was set for net metering in 2013, when the Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC) imposed the first rooftop solar fee in the U.S. -- albeit at a relatively modest $0.70/kW. Utilities will continue to fight net metering policies in the regulatory arena, though some regulators (such as the ACC) have indicated the issues raised by rooftop solar are best answered through the electric rate-setting process.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 10 sur 19
Solar proponents will doubtless fight back. In most regions, solar has the majority of public support, and this could tip the scales in solars favor, particularly in places like California and New York, where there is a rapidly expanding market for residential solar. That being said, the way in which current utility regulatory models are set up inherently penalizes non-solar owning ratepayers for solar-friendly net metering policies Therefore, utilities will seek other, creative ways to counter solar-friendly net metering policies, such as fixed grid connect fees. Based on the precedent set by the ACC, expect state regulators to start setting distributed generation fees to balance out net metering. Expect the net metering issue to come up next in Colorado, where Xcels net metering proposal has come before regulators as part of its renewable energy standard compliance plan, and Georgia, where Georgia Power dropped its proposed solar fee but promised to take up the issue again soon. It will also be interesting to see what happens in California in 2014. California has long been the standard bearer on forward-looking energy policies, and lawmakers recently gave regulators the power to set distributed generation fees up to $10/month. If California acts, look for similarly progressive states to follow its lead, at least eventually. As of right now, however, there is no widely accepted approach to the issue. Both solar advocates and utilities nationwide have too much at stake to compromise, so expect state battles to heat up and make lots of headlines next year. A resolution to the net metering question could of course be reached (it is, after all is said and done, a mathematical equation we're talking about), but dont expect that happen anytime soon. The battles in 2014 will ultimately serve as indicators of where state net metering policies are eventually headed.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 11 sur 19
The American Wind Energy Association praised Baucus for his leadership on the issue, but the Solar Energy Industries Association raised concerns about the draft bill. Expect a tough debate on the federal incentives (assuming Congress moves on the issue). At the state level, regulatory commissions have been reducing incentives for rooftop solar as the price of photovoltaics has dropped. The Long Island Power Authority in August reduced its solar rebates and the Arizona Corporation Commission has cut rebates for solar. Expect to see more cuts to state rebate programs in 2014.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 12 sur 19
Utilities will need to make a choice in 2014: resist the threat or seize the opportunity. (Or do nothing.) Realistically, expect a combination of the first two in order for utilities to help facilitate a business model transition that's partly on utilities' own terms. But, you might be asking, how can utilities "seize the opportunity?" There are a few potential models they can explore: Create deregulated subsidiaries to install rooftop solar systems outside of their territory. Create solar leasing programs to install utility-owned rooftop solar systems for ratepayers. Invest capital in rooftop solar installers Partner with rooftop solar installers to sell systems to ratepayers After a record year for residential solar installations, expect smart utilities to adopt elements of the most successful distributed solar models. I expect distributed generation to continue its rapid ascension in the marketplace, but I don't see it replacing utilities (or at least completely). Economies of scale dictate that utility-scale renewables will be more economical. That said, rooftop solar panels coupled with cost-effective storage could snare anywhere between 20-50% of the market in the long-term.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 13 sur 19
Some utilities are already acting on the opportunity, including: Sempra Energy, Duke Energy, Pacific Gas & Electric, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, Integrys, NextEra, Edison Internation and PSE&G. But many others aren't. If they don't invest, expect distributed generation providers "to pick off all their highest value customers," says Dan Yates, CEO of Opower, one of the major players in the energy efficiency space. As this happens (in fact, it has already started to), the utility's grid costs pro rata will rise and "they will have less and less capacity to afford more expensive distribution, transmission and generation because they'll become less and less cost effective," says Yates. "Then, the distributed generation guys will just go creeping down the stack and we'll end up in a distributed generation world with no centralized utility." Utilities are inherently slow-to-act organizations, making decisions on 10-year timelines. But the rise of DG is making that difficult and utilities should embrace flexibility if they want to survive. The grid is changing and it only follows that utilities will need to adapt their business models. The faster that a utility acts on distributed generation, the more chance they will have to thrive off the changes.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 14 sur 19
We dont know which companies will helm the future of the electricity industry, says David Crane, CEO of NRG Energy, the largest independent power producer and retail electricity provider in the U.S. The only thing I am sure of is that our sector can no longer defend the status quo. Put simply, we cant act like utility companies anymore. In 2014, utilities must and will make decisions that will define not only their fate, but that of the industry as a whole.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 15 sur 19
While the standards for new plants essentially require carbon capture and storage technology (which is far from a cost-effective reality, at the moment), expect the coming standards for existing plants to be completely different. Ron Binz, President Obama's defeated choice to lead the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, believes EPA regulations for existing power plants are the "great underestimated change that is about to engulf U.S. regulation." Binz believes the standards will force utilities to "reduce the intensity of greenhouse gas emissions per kilowatt-hours" through the institution of carbon pricing. "The cost is on the manufacturer and the benefits go to society" because the standard is addressing something "which is not priced in electricity," Binz says. This is part of a greater paradigm shift in energy policy and regulation. As the U.S. heads towards a clean and sustainable energy future, policymakers are starting to adopt new mechanisms to turn this future into a reality. It's no longer about cheap and reliable electricity; it's about public health and an earth that our children's children can inherit. Look for this transcendental shift to become only more pronounced in 2014 and beyond.
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 16 sur 19
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 17 sur 19
Meanwhile, large commercial and industrial (C&I) customers are going green for largely financial and political reasons. For utilities, this threat is even greater, as C&I customers wield more political influence than a group of individual customers and make up a much larger percentage of their revenue requirement: Google put pressure on Public Service Co. of Oklahoma to design a new renewable energy offering for commercial and industrial customers. Duke Energy is developing a green pricing program for large energy users in North Carolina, also after pressure from Google. Expect utilities to grow their green pricing programs and rooftop solar leasing options to mitigate these risks in 2014.
Topics: Generation, Transmission & Distribution, Business News, Regulation & Policy
Search
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 18 sur 19
Follow Us
Twitter LinkedIn EMail
Recent Features
10 predictions for the electric sector in 2014 Are utilities missing the rooftop solar opportunity? The 10 craziest energy stories of 2013 Year in review: The most read utility news of 2013 Do electric vehicles have demand response potential?
Editorial Staff
Brian Warmoth
Content Director
Davide Savenije
Associate Editor
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014
Page 19 sur 19
Rod Kuckro
Contributing Editor
Roger Riddell
Associate Editor
Bill Opalka
Contributing Editor
Ethan Howland
Contributing Editor
Utility Dive
About Us Advertise with Us Contact Us Get the Mobile App RSS Feed
http://www.utilitydive.com/news/10-predictions-for-the-electric-sector-in-2014/210239/?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Utility+D... 07/01/2014