Print http://www.slate.com/toolbar.aspx?

action=print&id=1008335

THI S J US T I N
A Former Pakistani Prime Minister Weighs In
Benazir Bhutto
Posted Friday, Sept. 21, 2001, at 5:27 PM ET

Little in life springs from whole cloth. That is especially true of Sept. 11, 2001, a date stained into the
calendar of civilization. This was a calamity two decades in the making. At the end of 1979, the Soviets
invaded Afghanistan, hoping to strengthen their position in Central Asia and develop proximity to the
resources and warm ports of the Gulf. Almost immediately an indigenous insurrection developed to
challenge the Soviet occupation. The freedom fighters were called the "Mujahadeen" and were composed of
seven different factions.

In its early days, the Reagan administration made a decision that would shape the course of history. It backed
the one faction most likely to successfully challenge the Soviets on the battlefield. Working with their
counterparts in the Pakistani Inter Services Intelligence (ISI), the CIA armed, trained, and empowered the
most extreme, anti-modernity, anti-Western zealots within the Mujahadeen. This propelled the extremists to a
leadership position in the war of resistance and in the politics that followed.

The war in Afghanistan caused one of the great refugee migrations in modern history. Nearly three million
Afghans crossed into Pakistan to escape the fighting. Almost immediately scores of special Islamic schools,
called Madrassas, sprang up. The boys that were sent there by their parents to be nourished and educated
were taught extremism, intolerance, subjugation of women, and violence. All of these elements are
antithetical to the Holy Book and to the teachings of the Prophet.

When the children were not being brainwashed, they were trained in hand-to-hand combat, the use of
weapons, and terrorist strategy. These schools became the recruitment centers for the fanatic administration
that ultimately took control of Afghanistan after the Soviet exit. The new political movement was named after
the schools themselves. The word "Talib" means student!

I became prime minister of Pakistan in 1988 during the waning days of the Soviet occupation of
Afghanistan. The last Soviet troops were airlifted out of Afghanistan on Feb. 15, 1989. The international
community quickly turned its attention to events in Europe and the fall of the Berlin Wall. I was left
concerned at the lack of a post-Soviet plan for the reconstruction and governing of Afghanistan. I was also
concerned at the go-at-it-alone attitude of the extremist factions that wanted the government, and ultimately
they prevailed. I suspected that having defeated one superpower, the zealots felt invincible and divinely
empowered to take aim at another.

As a moderate, progressive, democratically elected woman prime minister of Pakistan, I was a threat to the
fundamentalist zealots on multiple levels and targeted by them in both my governments. They had the
support of sympathetic elements within Pakistan's security apparatus and the financial support of people like
Osama Bin Laden. I had closed their training university in Peshawar and was targeted for that. I had tracked
down and extradited the Ramzi Yousef, the perpetrator of the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center, and
was targeted for that. My government was destabilized. Money was pilfered and laundered from state banks
to fund the campaigns of opposition parties. We learned from Ramzi Yousef before he was extradited to the
United States that I was the object of two separate assassination attempts in 1993. Osama Bin Laden
personally spent over $10 million in late 1989 in support of a motion of no confidence to topple my
government. And ultimately, with the active support of elements of the Pakistani military, my two
democratically elected governments were sacked and elections rigged to ensure that my party would not
return to power. Beware the power of zealots who are well-funded, well-armed, and supported by elements
of your own government!

1 of 2 3/21/08 7:49 AM
Print http://www.slate.com/toolbar.aspx?action=print&id=1008335

That brings us to the present. A complex and well-funded terrorist network executed the most inhuman
terrorist attack in history. The target was America, but it was also the values of freedom everywhere. It
seemed Osama and his cohorts read Professor Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations and wished
to provoke its thesis into reality. Their goal is for the Muslim world to see U.S. retaliation as an act of
aggression against Islam. Sept. 11 was the bait.

Sadly, this is not over. The United States responded quickly in declaring a fight against international
terrorism and cautioned it will be a long process. Asked to assist the U.S. effort against terrorism, Islamabad
responded positively. It did this despite elements within the military intelligence complex that have sympathy
for the Taliban.

Pakistan is saddled with $38 billion in international debt, with $4 billion owed to America. With Egypt and
Jordan, the United States has repaid political support with debt retirement in the past. Islamabad expects the
same treatment. It also expects the repeal of the discriminatory Pressler amendment denying military and
economic aid to Pakistan because of its nuclear program.

There is one price that Islamabad could demand that is too great and too dangerous to grant. The United
States and the Commonwealth support the holding of free, fair, party-based elections to restore democracy to
my nation in 2002. Islamabad may be tempted to ask the United States to abandon its support for Pakistani
democracy in exchange for support in the war against international terrorism. The previous military dictator
General Zia did this successfully in the '80s. But pressure for a return to democracy should continue. In fact,
in light of the horrible lessons of Afghanistan in the 1980s, the United States should be exquisitely sensitive
to the fact that democracies don't start wars; democracies don't engage in international terrorism. Allowing
dictatorship to strengthen its stranglehold over the democratic institutions of Pakistan can, in the long run,
create an even greater Frankenstein than the U.S. miscalculation with the Mujahadeen in the 1980s. Osama
commandeers jets. Pakistan has nuclear weapons. The United States must demand a democratic Pakistan to
stave off a true catastrophe in the future.

Benazir Bhutto is the former prime minister of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Click here to read the Slate
"Diary" she filed in 1997 while serving as opposition leader.

Benazir Bhutto is the former prime minister of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.

Article URL: http://www.slate.com/id/1008335/

Copyright 2008 Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive Co. LLC

2 of 2 3/21/08 7:49 AM