Hawaii Pedestrian Crosswalk Injuries: Should Mid-Block Crosswalks Be Eliminated | InjuryBoard Honolulu

3/28/11 7:11 PM

Sign In

Injury Board Sites

Enter Keyword(s)

Honolulu, Hawaii
Home Hawaii Honolulu

Automobile Accidents

Topics
All Topics On the Road Automobile Accidents Mass Transit (Airline, Cruise Ship, Train, Bus) Motorcycle Accidents Tractor-Trailer Accidents Major Medical Wrongful Death Medical Malpractice FDA & Prescription Drugs Spinal Cord Injuries Head & Brain Injuries Medical Devices & Implants Protecting Your Family Toxic Substances Property Owner's Liability (Slip & Fall) Nursing Home & Elder Abuse Defective & Dangerous Products In the Workplace Workplace Injuries Workplace Discrimination Miscellaneous Miscellaneous

Hawaii Pedestrian Crosswalk Injuries: Should Mid-Block Crosswalks Be Eliminated

Posted by Wayne Parsons October 07, 2009 3:30 AM 0 Comments Print Article Subscribe
Wayne Parsons
Attorney (866) 735-1102 Ext 585

Subscribe to InjuryBoard Honolulu Keep up with the latest updates using your favorite RSS reader

Injury Board Honolulu is brought to you by Wayne Parsons Law Offices

A jury trial is beginning on 07 October 2009 against

the City & County of Honolulu involving a pedestrian injured by a car at a mid-block crosswalk. We have had a rash of crosswalk injury and dietary cases on Oahu going back 10 years. I have written many articles the subject trying to raise public awareness and perhaps get ideas that will prevent pedestrian injury and death at crosswalks. Mid-block crosswalks are dangerous. I represent a lady who was struck full force at a King Street crosswalk by an elderly driver. It was mid-day, bright and dry. Why do these terrible collisions happen? Hood to hip. The pedestrian always loses. Here is what the traffic engineering safety experts have to say about mid-block cross walks:

Legal Assistance Center

Wayne Parsons Law Offices

(866) 735-1102 Ext 585 www.wayneparsons.com

It has been argued that providing signs and markings at crossing locations gives pedestrians a false sense of security. Transportation Research Board

National authorities recommend against their use at all:

Personal Injury Lawyers Serving: Oahu, Maui, Hawaii, Kauai, Lanai

The traditional consensus among traffic engineers is that at-grade midblock crosswalks are typically undesirable. However, both pedestrian walking behaviors and public demand can create pressures for the installation of a mid-block pedestrian crossing. Grade separated pedestrian crossings, can be costly and are often under utilized after construction.

1406 Colburn St.Suite 201-C, Honolulu, Hawaii 96817 [ Show Map ]

First Name Email

Last Name Phone (optional) Zip

According to Walking Info studies using National Highway Traffic Safety Administration methods in the early 1970s, and improved in the early 1990s, was refined and used to determine the crash types for more than 5,000 pedestrian crashes in six states.

Type your questions or comments for an Attorney here

The results showed that the mid-block events were the second major grouping of crash types and accounted for 26.5 percent of all crashes. Among this group, the most commonly crash type (1/3 of all) was the midblock dash where a pedestrian would run into the street and the motorists view was not obstructed. Another 17 percent of these crashes were dartouts, where the pedestrian ran or walked into the street, but the motorists view was obstructed until just before the impact.

Your question will be referred to an attorney near you. If your question is of a legal nature, then by submitting this form you agree you are not forming a formal attorney / client relationship. Read our full privacy policy.

According to Law Enforcement, Pedestrian Safety, and Driver Compliance

Additional Resources
Page 1 of 3

http://honolulu.injuryboard.com/automobile-accidents/hawaii-pedestriajuries-should-midblock-crosswalks-be-eliminated.aspx?googleid=272208

Hawaii Pedestrian Crosswalk Injuries: Should Mid-Block Crosswalks Be Eliminated | InjuryBoard Honolulu
with Crosswalk Laws, Transportation Research Record 1485.

3/28/11 7:11 PM

Additional Resources
Do I need to hire a personal injury lawyer? How do I choose the right personal injury attorney or law firm for me? How long can I expect my lawsuit to last? Should my attorney be able to tell me how much my case is worth?

Although not targeted solely at mid-block crossings, a Seattle study found enforcement was rather ineffective in getting vehicles to stop for pedestrians.

Those are the conclusions, and here are some engineering facts that explain the problem as an engineer sees it:

Subscribe to Blog Updates Enter your email address if you would like to receive email notifications when comments are made on this post. Email address
Subscribe

Even when a mid-block crosswalk is noticed by the driver, proper visual scanning of the crosswalk requires the driver to check both ends of the crosswalk for pedestrians about to cross the road. Even assuming very short glances, on the order of 1 second to each side of the crosswalk and a half second glance back to forward traffic in between, at 11 m/s (25 mph), the vehicle would travel 27 m while the driver was scanning the crosswalk, and it would need another 9-12 m of distance under modest to hard braking to stop the vehicle should a pedestrian be spotted. This means that the driver would theoretically need to notice the mid-block crosswalk 38 m (124 ft) before reaching it, and have a clear view of both sides of crosswalk from that distance to effectively scan for pedestrians. With parked cars blocking the view and in high pedestrian areas, this becomes even more challenging, as the driver needs to pick out pedestrians waiting or headed toward the crosswalk from those walking past the crosswalk on the sidewalk. Fortunately, mid-block crosswalks provide for the easiest countermeasures such as in-pavement LED systems (IRWL) to highlight the existence of a mid-block crosswalk and pedestrian. Since all the vehicles on the road need to stop, simply illuminating the crosswalk using one of the pedestrian activated in-pavement LED systems has been shown to dramatically increase the visibility of the mid-block crosswalk and the likelihood that drivers will stop for pedestrians (Hakkert, Gitelman, and Ben-Shabat, 2002). Pedestrian Warning Human Factors Considerations - Christopher Nowakowski December 2005

Blog Archives View previous posts from:

Select Month:

Interesting Links ABA Blawg - Honolulu Personal Injury Lawyer American Association of Justice Beyond Pesticides Brain & Spine Injury Law Blog Center For Justice & Democracy Cerebral Palsy, Erbs Palsy & Birth Injury Blog Commonweal Institute Commonweal Institute Blog Consumer Watchdog News Consumr Watchdog Blog Day On Torts Drug Injury Watch Environmental Working Group FDA Recalls Hawaii Court Rules Hawaii Courts: Case Search Hawaii Office of Consumer Protection Hawaii State Bar Association Honolulu Law News Honolulu Star Bulletin KGMB TV News KHON TV News Lance Armstrong Livestrong Legal Underground Mealey's Legal News Medical Device Recalls Motorcycles: Biker Law Blog My Shingle People Over Profits Public Citizen Public Justice The Daily Kos The Huffington Post The Legal Satyricon U.S. Consumer Product Safety Comission Recalls Volunteer Legal Services of Hawaii Wall Street Journal Law Blog Regional Blogs Find an InjuryBoard Blog in your area:

My prior articles provide background on the problem in Hawaii. The Hawaii Pedestrian Crosswalk Safety Chronicles: Innovative Solution for Crosswalk Safety - by Wayne Parsons In the future, cars will carry a warning system that includes forward collision warning, side collision warning, navigation, stopped traffic warnings, and intersection/pedestrian warnings. One topic for future research is how to format these new ITS messages and warnings. Last-second warnings are most effective when they direct what action should be taken.

Thus, for a mid-block crosswalk with a pedestrian present, the most effective warning would be simply stop because this tells the driver exactly what needs to be done, but it does not necessarily tell the driver why. However, in order to use this type of warning, the false alarm rate must be extremely low or the warnings will be considered a nuisance and disregarded. When more uncertainty exists and the warnings are able to be given sooner, then the warning format may focus on highlighting the threat.

One advantage of in-vehicle warnings is the potential to use sound. Sound is processed no matter where the driver is looking, but since the driver cant tune them out, they should be used sparingly. A Driver would be overloaded by

Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas

Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada

http://honolulu.injuryboard.com/automobile-accidents/hawaii-pedestriajuries-should-midblock-crosswalks-be-eliminated.aspx?googleid=272208

Page 2 of 3

Hawaii Pedestrian Crosswalk Injuries: Should Mid-Block Crosswalks Be Eliminated | InjuryBoard Honolulu
beeping and buzzing at every intersection. Research continues on th subject but as for today should the mid-block crosswalks on Oahu be eliminated? What do you say? Tags: crosswalk, pedestrian, mid-block, Hawaii, Honolulu, Oahu, Wayne Parsons, injury or death, personal injury Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut District of Columbia Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi

3/28/11 7:11 PM
Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New York North Carolina Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming

0 Comments
Have an opinion about this post? Please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Comments for this article are closed.

Who We Are The Injury Board is a growing community of attorneys, media professionals, safety industry experts, and local activists committed to making a difference by helping families stay safe and avoid injury, and helping those who are injured get the assistance they need to move on with their lives after an accident. Learn More Home | Blogs | News | Help Centers | Law Firms | About The Injury Board | Membership Opportunities | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Disclaimer 2002 - 2011 All rights reserved

http://honolulu.injuryboard.com/automobile-accidents/hawaii-pedestriajuries-should-midblock-crosswalks-be-eliminated.aspx?googleid=272208

Page 3 of 3