Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case Notes Prepared by: Dr. Mernoush Banton Case Author: Alen Badal
A.
Case Abstract
Ford Motor Company (www.Ford. om! "s a omprehens"#e strate$" mana$ement ase that "n %udes the ompany&s a%endar De ember '() 200* +"nan "a% statements) ompet"tor "n+ormat"on and more. ,he ase t"me sett"n$ "s the year 2009. -u++" "ent "nterna% and e.terna% data are pro#"ded to enab%e students to e#a%uate urrent strate$"es and re ommend a three-year strate$" p%an +or the ompany. /ead0uartered "n Dearborn) M" h"$an) Ford Motor Company "s traded on the New 1or2 -to 2 3. han$e under t" 2er symbo% F. Ford operates "n two se$ments: Automot"#e and F"nan "n$. Produ ts o++ered "n %ude: Ford) Mer ury) 4"n o%n) 5o%#o and 6a$uar. Ford was +ounded "n (90' and operates wor%dw"de. ,he ompany "s %ed by C37 8"%%"am Ford 6r. and emp%oyees o#er 2*0)000. ,he +"rm&s ma9or ompet"tor "s :enera% Motors.
B.
7ur #"s"on "s to be ome the wor%d&s %ead"n$ onsumer ompany +or automot"#e produ ts and ser#" es.
C.
Ford Motor Company&s m"ss"on "s to ant" "pate onsumer needs and pro#"de sa+e) 0ua%"ty) re%"ab%e) and "nno#at"#e automot"#e produ ts and ser#" es to onsumers around the wor%d (() 2) '!. Meet"n$ and e. eed"n$ ustomer&s e.pe tat"ons +or e. ept"ona% 0ua%"ty) utt"n$-ed$e te hno%o$y) and super"or ustomer ser#" e w"%% enab%e us to ma."m";e returns to our shareho%ders. (<) =!. ,he ustomer "s 6ob (. 8e are pass"onate%y omm"tted to ensure we do the r"$ht th"n$ +or our ustomers) our emp%oyees) our en#"ronment) and our so "ety (>) 9!. Ford "s omm"tted to %ead"n$ a%% automot"#e +"rms "n 0ua%"ty and sa+ety "n Amer" a and abroad. A%on$ w"th our omm"tment to sa#"n$ the en#"ronment) we an ont"nue to add to our proud her"ta$e (?) *!. (. 2. '. <. =. >. Customer Produ ts or ser#" es Mar2ets ,e hno%o$y Con ern +or sur#"#a%) pro+"tab"%"ty) $rowth Ph"%osophy
?. -e%+- on ept *. Con ern +or pub%" "ma$e 9. Con ern +or emp%oyees
D.
External Audit
Ford
Critical Success Factors #ei$% t &atin $ #ei$%te d Score &atin $
M
#ei$%te d Score
!o"ota
&atin $ #ei$%ted Score
Pr" e ompet"t"#eness :%oba% 3.pans"on 7r$an";at"ona% -tru ture 3mp%oyee Mora%e ,e hno%o$y Produ t -a+ety Customer 4oya%ty B- Mar2et -hare Ad#ert"s"n$ Produ t Cua%"ty Produ t Ama$e F"nan "a% Pos"t"on !otal
0.0< 0.0= 0.02 0.0( 0.0< 0.0< 0.20 0.(= 0.02 0.0? 0.20 0.(> '.((
0.(2 0.20 0.02 0.0( 0.0< 0.0< 0.<0 0.<= 0.0> 0.0? 0.<0 0.(> '.)*
0.0* 0.(0 0.0< 0.02 0.0* 0.0* 0.20 0.>0 0.0* 0.(< 0.>0 0.'2 +.,-
( ' ' ' ' ' < ' 2 < < <
0.0< 0.(= 0.0> 0.0' 0.(2 0.(2 0.*0 0.'0 0.0< 0.2* 0.*0 0.>< ,.,.
/pportunities (. ,he B"$ ,hree hope to $a"n +urther on ess"ons +rom the Bn"ted Auto 8or2ers re$ard"n$ %abor osts 2. ,he +ew onsumers pur has"n$ #eh" %es are do"n$ so +or pra t" a% reasons) w"th a +o us on +ue% e++" "en y) durab"%"ty) and arma2er&s susta"nab"%"ty '. A ord"n$ to C-M 8or%dw"de %"$ht #eh" %e produ t"on e. eeded the produ t"on o+ ars and tru 2s "n North Amer" a and 3urope by an est"mated (> per ent and (< per ent) respe t"#e%y <. An 200*) the B"$ ,hree be$an o++er"n$ %owered "nterest rates or ;ero per ent +"nan "n$ to %ure buyers =. ,he auto "ndustry has e.per"en ed a sh"+t +rom tru 2s and -B5s to hybr"d and sma%% +ue%-e++" "ent #eh" %es >. -pe "a%";ed "n ar parts +or bus"nessDa+termar2et ?. ConsumersDdea%ers w"%%"n$ness to "mpro#e brandDsa%es
!%reats (. Due to $%oba% e onom" re ess"on) onsumer demand +or new autos has p%ummeted 2. Consumer on+"den e "s the %owest "n <0 years '. Bnemp%oyment rates e. eed (0 per ent "n many areas "n the Bn"ted -tates and "s e.pe ted to rema"n h"$h +or part o+ 20(0 <. Bna#a"%ab"%"ty o+ red"t and h"$h unemp%oyment ha#e pushed automa2ers to reth"n2 methods o+ produ "n$ and se%%"n$ ars =. Automa2ers ha#e +a ed r"s"n$ osts o+ hea%th are and pens"on >. ,he B"$ three a%so su++er +rom an o#ersupp%y +or dea%ers ?. ,he $o#ernment ba"%out money "s d"m"n"sh"n$) and Ford has e.hausted "ts red"t %"nes *. Consumers are on erned o#er the B"$ ,hree&s poss"b"%"ty o+ $o"n$ out o+ bus"ness "n terms o+ #o"ded 8arrant"es 9. Many ban2s are 9ust not ma2"n$ ar %oans External Factor Evaluation 0EFE1 Matrix
#ei$%t
&atin$
#ei$%ted Score
0.0? 0.0?
< '
0.2* 0.2(
+or pra t" a% reasons) w"th a +o us on +ue% e++" "en y) durab"%"ty) and arma2erEs susta"nab"%"ty '. A ord"n$ to C-M 8or%dw"de %"$ht #eh" %e produ t"on e. eeded the produ t"on o+ ars and tru 2s "n North Amer" a and 3urope by an est"mated (> per ent and (< per ent) respe t"#e%y <. An 200*) the B"$ ,hree be$an o++er"n$ %owered "nterest rates or ;ero per ent +"nan "n$ to %ure buyers
=. ,he auto "ndustry has e.per"en ed a sh"+t +rom tru 2s
0.0>
0.(2
brandDsa%es
!%reats
(. Due to $%oba% e onom" re ess"on) onsumer 0.0> ' 0.(*
2. Consumer on+"den e "s the %owest "n <0 years '. Bnemp%oyment rates e. eed (0 per ent "n many
0.0? 0.0?
< <
0.2* 0.2*
areas "n the Bn"ted -tates and "s e.pe ted to rema"n h"$h +or part o+ 20(0 <. Bna#a"%ab"%"ty o+ red"t and h"$h unemp%oyment ha#e pushed automa2ers to reth"n2 methods o+ produ "n$ and se%%"n$ ars =. Automa2ers ha#e +a ed r"s"n$ osts o+ hea%th are and pens"on
>. ,he B"$ three a%so su++er +rom an o#ersupp%y +or
0.0=
<
0.2
' 2 2 2
dea%ers
?. ,he $o#ernment ba"%out money "s d"m"n"sh"n$) and
!otal
'.((
Positionin$ Map
Pr" e (/"$h!
Pr" e (4ow!
E.
(. 2. '. <. =. >. ?.
4nternal Audit
Stren$t%s Ford Cred"t D"#"s"on operates $%oba%%y Andependent amon$ Ba"%out +rom :o#ernment 5eh" %es mar2eted "n > ont"nents) o#er 200 ountr"es Ford has stron$ brand "ma$e and "s ons"dered an Amer" an " on -tron$ onsumer %oya%ty on the"r popu%ar F-(=0 D"#erse #eh" %e %"nes $"#e the ompany more +%e."b"%"ty to the"r ustomers to hoose the des"red ar mode% -a%es "n -. Amer" a and 3uropean se$ments "n reased by F'.= b"%%"on +rom 200? to 200*
#ea5nesses (. An one year) re#enue de rease by appro."mate%y F'0 b"%%"on 2. 8h"%e the ompany&s "n#entory was redu ed +rom 200? to 200*) the dea%ers are ha#"n$ h"$her "n#entory to se%% '. Current asset dropped by appro."mate%y F(* b"%%"on +rom pr"or year <. Current %"ab"%"t"es "n reased by F'0 b"%%"on +rom pr"or year
=. 7perat"ona% osts typ" a%%y h"$her "n a ompany w"th mu%t"-se$ment bus"ness Financial &atio Anal"sis (De ember 2009!
ro6t% &ates 7 Ford 4ndustr" S8P 9((
-a%es (Ctr #s year a$o 0tr! Net An ome (1,D #s 1,D! Net An ome (Ctr #s year a$o 0tr! -a%es (=-1ear Annua% A#$.! Net An ome (=-1ear Annua% A#$.! D"#"dends (=-1ear Annua% A#$.!
Price &atios
Current PD3 Gat"o PD3 Gat"o =-1ear /"$h PD3 Gat"o =-1ear 4ow Pr" eD-a%es Gat"o Pr" eDBoo2 5a%ue Pr" eDCash F%ow Gat"o
Profit Mar$ins 7
:ross Mar$"n Pre-,a. Mar$"n Net Pro+"t Mar$"n =1r :ross Mar$"n (=-1ear A#$.! =1r Pre,a. Mar$"n (=-1ear A#$.! =1r Net Pro+"t Mar$"n (=-1ear A#$.!
Financial Condition
DebtD30u"ty Gat"o Current Gat"o Cu" 2 Gat"o Anterest Co#era$e 4e#era$e Gat"o Boo2 5a%ueD-hare
Adapted +rom www.money entra%.msn. om
Av$ P:E
Price: Sales
Price: Boo5
(2D0* (2D0? (2D0> (2D0= (2D0< (2D0' (2D02 (2D0( (2D00 (2D0*
-0.*0 -=.*0 -(.(0 (2.00 9.(0 '0.=0 ?(.00 -?.90 ?.<0 -0.*0
Debt: E<uit"
0.0< 0.0* 0.09 0.09 0.(* 0.(* 0.(0 0.(* 0.2( 0.0<
&eturn on E<uit" 071
-0.'2 2.>2 -<.09 (.0? (.=< 2.=( '.0= '.>= 2.'( -0.'2
&eturn on Assets 071
-(0.0 -(.> -?.9 0.9 (.* 0.< 0.2 -'.' '.2 -(0.0
4nterest Covera$e
(2D0* (2D0? (2D0> (2D0= (2D0< (2D0' (2D02 (2D0( (2D00 (2D0*
-F?.(* F2.=> -F(.*< F?.2( F9.=2 F>.'> F'.0= F<.'( F(0.(< -F?.(*
-*.9( 29.9< -<9.=9 ((.<0 9.'( (=.<< '0.0' 2(.=( *.9' -*.9(
*<.* -<9.( '><.= (2.( (*.' =.= >.< ->*.? 29.' *<.*
->.? -(.0 -<.= 0.> (.( 0.2 0.( -(.9 (.9 ->.?
0.0*
'
0.2<
0.09
<
0.'>
( ( (
!otal
F.
S#/! Strate$ies
Stren$t%s (. Ford Cred"t D"#"s"on operates $%oba%%y 2. Andependent amon$ Ba"%out +rom :o#ernment '. 5eh" %es mar2eted "n > ont"nents) o#er 200 ountr"es <. Ford has stron$ brand "ma$e and "s ons"dered an Amer" an " on =. -tron$ onsumer %oya%ty on the"r popu%ar F-(=0 >. D"#erse #eh" %e %"nes $"#e the ompany more +%e."b"%"ty to the"r ustomers to hoose the des"red ar mode% ?. -a%es "n -. Amer" a and 3uropean se$ments #ea5nesses (. An one year) re#enue de rease by appro."mate%y F'0 b"%%"on 2. 8h"%e the ompany&s "n#entory was redu ed +rom 200? to 200*) the dea%ers are ha#"n$ h"$her "n#entory to se%% '. Current asset dropped by appro."mate%y F(* b"%%"on +rom pr"or year <. Current %"ab"%"t"es "n reased by F'0 b"%%"on +rom pr"or year =. 7perat"ona% osts typ" a%%y h"$her "n a ompany w"th mu%t"se$ment bus"ness
"n reased by F'.= b"%%"on +rom 200? to 200* /pportunities (. ,he B"$ ,hree hope to $a"n +urther on ess"ons +rom the Bn"ted Auto 8or2ers re$ard"n$ %abor osts 2. ,he +ew onsumers pur has"n$ #eh" %es are do"n$ so +or pra t" a% reasons) w"th a +o us on +ue% e++" "en y) durab"%"ty) and arma2er&s susta"nab"%"ty '. A ord"n$ to C-M 8or%dw"de %"$ht #eh" %e produ t"on e. eeded the produ t"on o+ ars and tru 2s "n North Amer" a and 3urope by an est"mated (> per ent and (< per ent) respe t"#e%y <. An 200*) the B"$ ,hree be$an o++er"n$ %owered "nterest rates or ;ero per ent +"nan "n$ to %ure buyers =. ,he auto "ndustry has e.per"en ed a sh"+t +rom tru 2s and -B5s to hybr"d and sma%% +ue%e++" "ent #eh" %es >. -pe "a%";ed "n ar parts +or bus"nessDa+termar2et ?. ConsumersDdea%ers w"%%"n$ness to "mpro#e brandDsa%es !%reats (. Due to $%oba% e onom" re ess"on) onsumer demand +or new autos has p%ummeted S=/ Strate$ies (. 3.pand "nto -. Amer" an and 3uropean ountr"es by o++er"n$ better "n ent"#es and +"nan "n$ (-() -?) 7') 7=) 7?!) 2. Produ e more +ue% e++" "ent and sma%%er mode%s and promote them w"th %ower +"nan "n$ opt"ons (-() -') -<) 72) 7<H 7=! #=/ Strate$ies (. Ampro#e operat"ons by be"n$ more %ean and utt"n$ ba 2 e. ess"#e e.e ut"#e spend"n$ (8') 8<) 8=) 7(! 2. -e%% o++ bus"ness un"ts to "mpro#e ash "n+us"on to the ompany (82) 8') 8<) 8=) 7>!
S=! Strate$ies (. Ampro#e promot"on on se%e ted %ower pr" ed mode%s w"th ;ero or #ery %ow rate +"nan "n$ to
#=! Strate$ies (. -"n e dea%ers are not ab%e to turn around the"r "n#entory +ast enou$h) o++er o-op ad#ert"s"n$ w"th more
2. Consumer on+"den e "s youn$er $enerat"on the %owest "n <0 years throu$h Anternet us"n$ '. Bnemp%oyment rates Fa eboo2) ,w"tter) and e. eed (0 per ent "n other networ2"n$ many areas "n the hanne%s (-2) -') -<) Bn"ted -tates and "s ->) ,() ,<) ,>) ,*) ,9! e.pe ted to rema"n h"$h 2. 7++er IFreeJ e.tended +or part o+ 20(0 warrantee +or add"t"ona% <. Bna#a"%ab"%"ty o+ red"t 2 years to $a"n and h"$h unemp%oyment ustomer %oya%ty and ha#e pushed brand "ma$e (-<) ->) automa2ers to reth"n2 ,() ,*! methods o+ produ "n$ and se%%"n$ ars =. Automa2ers ha#e +a ed r"s"n$ osts o+ hea%th are and pens"on >. ,he B"$ three a%so su++er +rom an o#ersupp%y +or dea%ers ?. ,he $o#ernment ba"%out money "s d"m"n"sh"n$) and Ford has e.hausted "ts red"t %"nes *. Consumers are on erned o#er the B"$ ,hree&s poss"b"%"ty o+ $o"n$ out o+ bus"ness "n terms o+ #o"ded 8arrant"es 9. Many ban2s are 9ust not ma2"n$ ar %oans
"n ent"#es +or mo#"n$ the ars +aster (8() 8') ,<) ,>!
A$$ressive
C-
A-? -> -= -< -' -2 -( -( -2 -' -< -= -> ( 2 ' < = > ?
Defensive
-?
Competitive
3-
Financial Stabilit" 0FS1 Geturn on An#estment 4e#era$e 4"0u"d"ty 8or2"n$ Cap"ta% Cash F%ow Financial Stabilit" 0FS1 Avera$e Competitive Stabilit" 0CS1 Mar2et -hare Produ t Cua%"ty Customer 4oya%ty Compet"t"on&s Capa "ty Bt"%";at"on
( ( ( ( ( '
Environmental Stabilit" 0ES1 Bnemp%oyment ,e hno%o$" a% Chan$es Pr" e 3%ast" "ty o+ Demand Compet"t"#e Pressure Barr"ers to 3ntry Environmental Stabilit" 0ES1 Avera$e 4ndustr" Stabilit" 04S1 :rowth Potent"a% F"nan "a% -tab"%"ty 3ase o+ Mar2et 3ntry Gesour e Bt"%";at"on
-2 -' -2 -'
,e hno%o$" a% Know-/ow Competitive Stabilit" 0CS1 Avera$e 1-a."s: F- L 3- M (.0 L (-'.*! M -2.* N-a."s: C- L A- M (-(.*! L ('.>! M (.*
-2 =+.-
' ,.+
>.
Quadrant III
Slo6 Mar5et
ro6t%
Quadrant IV
(. Mar2et de#e%opment 2. Mar2et penetrat"on '. Produ t de#e%opment <. Forward "nte$rat"on =. Ba 2ward "nte$rat"on >. /or";onta% "nte$rat"on ?. Ge%ated d"#ers"+" at"on
4.
A5
A5
5A
5AA
5AAA
AN
BC
Matrix
&elative Mar5et S%are /"$h (.0 /"$h L20 Med"um .=0 4ow 0.0
Question Marks
Cash Cows
Dogs
4ow -20
?.
@SPM
Ampro#e promot"on on se%e ted %ower pr" ed mode%s w"th ;ero or #ery %ow rate +"nan "n$ to youn$er $enerat"on throu$h Anternet us"n$ Fa eboo2) ,w"tter) and other networ2"n$ hanne%s
3.pand "nto -. Amer" an and 3uropean ountr"es by o++er"n$ better "n ent"#es and +"nan "n$
2e" Factors /pportunities (. ,he B"$ ,hree hope to $a"n +urther on ess"ons +rom the Bn"ted Auto 8or2ers re$ard"n$ %abor osts 2. ,he +ew onsumers pur has"n$ #eh" %es are do"n$ so +or pra t" a% reasons) w"th a +o us on +ue% e++" "en y) durab"%"ty) and arma2erEs susta"nab"%"ty '. A ord"n$ to C-M 8or%dw"de %"$ht #eh" %e produ t"on e. eeded the produ t"on o+ ars and tru 2s "n North Amer" a and 3urope by an est"mated (> per ent and (< per ent) respe t"#e%y <. An 200*) the B"$ ,hree be$an o++er"n$ %owered "nterest rates or ;ero per ent +"nan "n$ to %ure buyers =. ,he auto "ndustry has e.per"en ed a sh"+t +rom tru 2s and -B5s to hybr"d and sma%% +ue%-e++" "ent #eh" %es >. -pe "a%";ed ar parts bus"nessDa+termar2et ?. ConsumersDdea%ers w"%%"n$ness to "mpro#e brandDsa%es !%reats (. Due to $%oba% e onom" re ess"on) onsumer demand +or new autos has p%ummeted 2. Consumer on+"den e "s the %owest "n <0 years '. Bnemp%oyment rates e. eed (0 per ent "n many areas "n the Bn"ted -tates and "s e.pe ted to rema"n h"$h +or part o+ 20(0 <. Bna#a"%ab"%"ty o+ red"t and h"$h unemp%oyment ha#e pushed automa2ers to reth"n2 methods o+ produ "n$ and se%%"n$ ars =. Automa2ers ha#e +a ed r"s"n$ osts o+ hea%th are and pens"on >. ,he B"$ three a%so su++er +rom an o#ersupp%y +or dea%ers ?. ,he $o#ernment ba"%out money "s d"m"n"sh"n$) and Ford has e.hausted "ts red"t %"nes *. Consumers are on erned o#er the B"$ ,hreeEs poss"b"%"ty o+ $o"n$ out o+ bus"ness "n terms o+ #o"ded 8arrant"es 9. Many ban2s are 9ust not ma2"n$ ar %oans !/!AA Stren$t%s
#ei$%t
0.0?
AS ' <
AS < 2
0.0?
0.0>
'
0.(*
<
0.2<
0.0?
------' < 2 2 2
0.0>
0.0> 0.0?
0.0>
0.0? 0.0?
0.0=
< ( -------
2 < -------
0.0>
0.0>
'.((
(. Ford Cred"t D"#"s"on operates $%oba%%y 2. Andependent amon$ Ba"%out +rom :o#ernment '. 5eh" %es mar2eted "n > ont"nents) o#er 200 ountr"es <. Ford has stron$ brand "ma$e and "s ons"dered an Amer" an " on =. -tron$ onsumer %oya%ty on the"r popu%ar F(=0 >. D"#erse #eh" %e %"nes $"#e the ompany more +%e."b"%"ty to the"r ustomers to hoose the des"red ar mode% ?. -a%es "n -. Amer" a and 3uropean se$ments "n reased by F'.= b"%%"on +rom 200? to 200* #ea5nesses (. An one year) re#enue de rease by appro."mate%y F'0 b"%%"on 2. 8h"%e the ompanyEs "n#entory was redu ed +rom 200? to 200*) the dea%ers are ha#"n$ h"$her "n#entory to se%% '. Current asset dropped by appro."mate%y F(* b"%%"on +rom pr"or year <. Current %"ab"%"t"es "n reased by F'0 b"%%"on +rom pr"or year =. 7perat"ona% osts typ" a%%y h"$her "n a ompany w"th mu%t"-se$ment bus"ness SBB!/!AA SBM !/!AA A!!&AC!4VE;ESS SC/&E
0.09
0.09 0.0*
< 2 -------
( ' -------
'.((
2.
&ecommendations
3.pand sa%es "n -. Amer" an and 3uropean ountr"es when the #a%ue o+ the money "s h"$her) e onomy "s better and unemp%oyment "s %ower than B.-. by promot"n$ better pr" "n$ strate$"es) promot"ona% ampa"$n and o++er"n$ more "n ent"#es.
L.
EPS/EBIT Analysis
F Amount Needed: F*0 m"%%"on -to 2 Pr" e: F(0.00 ,a. Gate: (0.<O! +or 200* and '(.(O +or 200? Anterest Gate: >.=O P -hares 7utstand"n$: '.' b"%%"on
Common Stoc5 Financin$ Recession Normal Boom F'00)000)000 F>00)000)000 F()000)000)000 Recession F'00)000)000 Debt Financin$ Normal Boom F>00)000)000 F()000)000)000
3BA,
=)200)000 29<)*00)000 0 29<)*00)000 ')'00)000)000 (.() *( Percent Debt = ,( Percent Stoc5 Recession F'00)000)000 ()0<0)000 29*)9>0)000 0 29*)9>0)000 ')'00)<'9)'(9 (.()
*( Percent Stoc5 = ,( Percent Debt Recession F'00)000)000 <)(>0)000 29=)*<0)000 0 29=)*<0)000 ')'0()02=)0?* (.()
M.
Epilo$ue