Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2006A
12/31/2006
2007A
12/31/2007
8,331,685
8,496,221
1.97%
BALANCE SHEET
Assets
Cash and due from banks
Interest bearing deposits with banks
Investment securities
Loans held for sale at fair value
Gross loans
Less - Allowance for loan losses
Net loans
Premises and equipment net
Bank owned life insurance
Accrued interest receivable
Due from customers on acceptances outstanding
FDIC loss-share receivable
Goodwill
Other intangible assets net
Other assets
Total Assets
Liabilities
Total deposits
Short-term borrowings
Long-term borrowings
Junior subordinated debentures issued to capital trusts
Bank acceptances outstanding
Accrued expenses and other liabilities
Total Liabilities
Total Shareholders' Equity
Total Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity
Balance Check
INVESTMENT SECURITIES
Investment securities
% growth
LOANS
Gross loans (Covered and non-covered)
% growth
Loans held for sale
Loans held for sale as % of gross loans
CREDIT LOSS RESERVE
Allowance for credit losses - BOP
Plus: Net charge-offs (enter as -)
Plus: Provision for credit losses (enter as +)
Plus: Acquisitions
Allowance for loan losses (reserves) - EOP
Plus: Allowance for letter of credit
Reported Allowance
75,188
(9,740)
9,270
0
74,718
74,718
74,718
(11,658)
11,875
0
74,935
2,271
72,664
Drivers
NCO to prior year provision
Average loans
NCO / average loans (includes loans held for sale)
8,262,739
(0.12%)
125.76%
8,261,111
(0.14%)
8,331,685
8,487,651
98.16%
8,496,221
8,091,004
105.01%
74%
INCOME STATEMENT
Interest income
Total interest income
Total interest expense
Net Interest Income
Provision for credit losses
Non-Interest Income
Trust and investment services
Insurance commissions
Service charges on deposit accounts
Securities gains/losses
Trading (losses) gains net
Fees from loan servicing
Bank owned life insurance
Change in FDIC loss-share receivable
Other income, including gains on sale of loans, assets, and
Total non-interest income
Non-Interest Expense
Salary and employee benefits expense
Net occupancy and equipment expense
Amortization of other intangible assets
Other
Total non-interest expense
Income Before Income Taxes
Income tax expense
Net Income
Dividends on preferred stock and accretion
Net Income Available to Common Stockholders
Weighted Average Number of Common Shares Outstanding
Basic (#)
Diluted (#)
Earnings Per Common Share
Basic (actual)
Diluted (actual)
Cash dividends per common share
Cash dividends
Income Statement drivers
% growth (year-over-year)
Trust and investment services
Insurance commissions
Bank owned life insurance
Other non-interest income
Other drivers
Service charges on deposit accounts / BOP deposits
Fees from loan servicing / BOP gross loans
As % of NII
Salary and employee benefits expense
Net occupancy and equipment expense
Amortization of other intangible assets
Other non-interest expense
Tax rate
CASH, DEPOSITS WITH BANKS, AND SHORT TERM BORROWINGS
Cash and due from banks
Cash as % of deposits
Total assets (including prior year interest bearing deposits)
Total liabilities & equity (including prior year ST borrowings)
Funding needs (surplus)
CIRCULARITY
1=Use beginning balance to calculate NII
2=Use average balance to calculate NII (creates circularity)
Circularity breaker:
Off (Default)
CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS
Tier 1 Capital
Total stockholders' equity
Less: Goodwill
Plus: Junior subordinated debentures issued to capital trusts
Plus: Other
Tier 1 Capital
Total Capital
Tier 1 capital
Plus: Allowance for credit losses - EOP
Plus: Qualifying sub debt
Total capital
Risk weighted assets (RWA)
Average Interest earning assets (IEA)
Average total assets
Drivers
RWA / IEA
Average total assets / IEA
Tier 1 capital ratio (Tier 1 / RWA)
Total capital ratio (Total capital / RWA)
Leverage ratio (Tier 1 / average total assets)
Capital check
Tier 1 capital ratio (Tier 1 / RWA)
Total capital ratio (Total capital / RWA)
Leverage ratio (Tier 1 / average total assets)
10.56%
12.44%
8.10%
9.55%
11.35%
7.62%
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
2008A
12/31/2008
2009A
12/31/2009
2010A
12/31/2010
2011E
12/31/2011
2012E
12/31/2012
2013E
12/31/2013
2014E
12/31/2014
305,678
355,659
2,969,819
25,492
9,370,071
(101,990)
9,268,081
266,401
304,031
56,245
6,985
0
296,424
24,305
405,033
14,284,153
302,629
63,657
2,991,169
58,958
9,365,795
(124,704)
9,241,091
265,570
304,956
59,126
6,028
89,359
317,891
25,650
417,742
14,143,826
308,601
63,657
3,140,727
38,575
9,643,787
(120,085)
9,523,702
265,570
304,956
59,126
6,028
69,359
317,891
25,650
417,742
14,541,585
317,761
63,657
3,297,764
39,720
9,930,030
(116,085)
9,813,945
265,570
304,956
59,126
6,028
49,359
317,891
25,650
417,742
14,979,169
327,193
63,657
3,462,652
40,899
10,224,769
(113,085)
10,111,684
265,570
304,956
59,126
6,028
29,359
317,891
25,650
417,742
15,432,407
336,904
63,657
3,635,785
42,113
10,528,256
(113,085)
10,415,172
265,570
304,956
59,126
6,028
9,359
317,891
25,650
417,742
15,899,952
9,547,285
216,147
2,946,320
181,150
6,985
133,412
13,031,299
1,252,854
14,284,153
0
9,363,614
192,318
2,933,858
186,922
6,028
165,881
12,848,621
1,295,205
14,143,826
0
9,643,787
229,407
2,989,574
186,922
6,028
165,881
13,221,599
1,319,986
14,541,585
0
9,930,030
253,916
3,078,309
186,922
6,028
165,881
13,621,086
1,358,083
14,979,169
0
10,224,769
272,615
3,169,678
186,922
6,028
165,881
14,025,894
1,406,513
15,432,407
0
10,528,256
286,930
3,263,759
186,922
6,028
165,881
14,437,777
1,462,175
15,899,952
0
2,624,415
2,969,819
13.16%
2,991,169
0.72%
3,140,727
5.00%
3,297,764
5.00%
3,462,652
5.00%
3,635,785
5.00%
10,143,690
19.39%
9,370,071
(7.63%)
9,365,795
(0.05%)
9,643,787
2.97%
9,930,030
2.97%
10,224,769
2.97%
10,528,256
2.97%
74,935
(19,889)
28,282
11,410
94,738
1,494
93,244
25,492
0.27%
58,958
0.63%
38,575
0.40%
39,720
0.40%
40,899
0.40%
42,113
0.40%
94,738
(39,075)
47,992
0
103,655
1,665
101,990
103,655
(26,607)
49,456
0
126,504
1,800
124,704
126,504
(34,619)
30,000
0
121,885
1,800
120,085
121,885
(24,000)
20,000
0
117,885
1,800
116,085
117,885
(18,000)
15,000
0
114,885
1,800
113,085
114,885
(15,000)
15,000
0
114,885
1,800
113,085
167.49%
9,386,987
(0.21%)
138.16%
9,705,909
(0.40%)
55.44%
9,474,994
(0.28%)
70.00%
9,553,557
(0.36%)
80.00%
9,826,056
(0.24%)
90.00%
10,117,709
(0.18%)
100.00%
10,418,019
(0.14%)
108,000
(18,641)
89,359
89,359
(20,000)
69,359
69,359
(20,000)
49,359
49,359
(20,000)
29,359
29,359
(20,000)
9,359
9,370,071
9,547,285
98.14%
9,365,795
9,363,614
100.02%
9,643,787
9,643,787
100.00%
9,930,030
9,930,030
100.00%
10,224,769
10,224,769
100.00%
10,528,256
10,528,256
100.00%
2,946,320
31.44%
2,933,858
31.33%
2,989,574
31.00%
3,078,309
31.00%
3,169,678
31.00%
3,263,759
31.00%
12,384,625
9,395,563
2,969,819
355,659
12,721,041
13,031,646
9,424,753
2,991,169
63,657
12,479,579
12,679,756
9,682,362
3,140,727
63,657
12,886,746
12,683,163
9,969,750
3,297,764
63,657
13,331,171
13,108,959
10,265,668
3,462,652
63,657
13,791,977
13,561,574
10,570,369
3,635,785
63,657
14,269,811
14,030,894
10,355,760
7,106,510
216,147
2,946,320
181,150.0
10,450,127
10,585,800
6,969,795
192,318
2,933,858
186,922.0
10,282,893
10,363,969
10,366,510.2
7,178,341
229,407
2,989,574
186,922.0
10,584,245
10,433,569
10,433,568.9
7,391,406
253,916
3,078,309
186,922.0
10,910,553
10,747,399
7,610,795
272,615
3,169,678
186,922.0
11,240,010
11,075,282
7,836,695
286,930
3,263,759
186,922.0
11,574,307
11,407,159
5.00%
2.99%
19.29%
1.90%
5.00%
2.97%
10.68%
2.97%
5.00%
2.97%
7.36%
2.97%
5.00%
2.97%
5.25%
2.97%
0
0
10,143,690
9,232,923
109.86%
0.72%
(1.92%)
(11.02%)
(0.42%)
5.94%
2.98%
2.96%
5.51%
2.48%
3.03%
5.38%
2.07%
3.31%
5.40%
2.10%
3.30%
5.65%
2.40%
3.25%
5.90%
2.70%
3.20%
6.15%
3.00%
3.15%
729,694
308,895
420,799
5,459
426,258
712,184
262,870
449,314
5,227
454,541
676,812
214,060
462,752
5,590
468,342
673,897
215,941
457,957
5,500
463,457
728,101
254,022
474,079
5,500
479,579
786,539
294,585
491,954
5,500
497,454
848,207
337,200
511,006
5,500
516,506
3.44%
3.49%
3.69%
3.65%
3.66%
3.67%
3.68%
729,694
308,895
420,799
712,184
262,870
449,314
676,812
214,060
462,752
673,897
215,941
457,957
728,101
254,022
474,079
786,539
294,585
491,954
848,207
337,200
511,006
28,282
47,992
49,456
30,000
20,000
15,000
15,000
7,161
10,053
28,274
(79,815)
3,166
5,236
10,167
0
19,014
3,256
6,906
10,224
26,778
1,653
(10,434)
4,839
5,700
0
26,585
72,251
7,665
11,334
25,691
6,956
(6,897)
4,919
6,166
6,268
29,225
91,327
8,125
12,014
25,282
0
0
4,683
6,474
0
30,686
87,264
8,612
12,735
26,038
0
0
4,822
6,798
0
32,221
91,226
9,129
13,499
26,811
0
0
4,965
7,138
0
33,832
95,374
9,677
14,309
27,607
0
0
5,112
7,495
0
35,523
99,723
157,876
54,042
7,224
66,106
285,248
163,746
58,974
6,887
76,421
306,028
176,106
61,765
7,721
72,090
317,682
174,023
59,534
7,327
73,273
314,158
180,150
61,630
7,585
75,853
325,218
186,943
63,954
7,871
78,713
337,481
194,182
66,431
8,176
81,761
350,550
110,525
16,934
93,591
2,090
91,501
167,545
51,484
116,061
19,524
96,537
186,941
55,771
131,170
0
131,170
201,062
60,319
140,744
0
140,744
220,087
66,026
154,061
0
154,061
234,847
70,454
164,393
0
164,393
245,179
73,554
171,625
0
171,625
143,805,528
143,884,683
151,675,691
151,676,409
161,059,906
161,068,175
161,059,906
161,068,175
161,059,906
161,068,175
161,059,906
161,068,175
161,059,906
161,068,175
0.64
0.64
0.64
0.64
0.81
0.81
0.87
0.87
0.96
0.96
1.02
1.02
1.07
1.07
0.72
102,517
0.72
109,005
0.72
115,190
0.72
115,963
0.72
115,963
0.72
115,963
0.72
115,963
(3.56%)
1.70%
(43.94%)
39.82%
10.99%
10.86%
8.18%
9.93%
6.00%
6.00%
5.00%
5.00%
6.00%
6.00%
5.00%
5.00%
6.00%
6.00%
5.00%
5.00%
6.00%
6.00%
5.00%
5.00%
0.29%
0.05%
0.27%
0.05%
0.27%
0.05%
0.27%
0.05%
0.27%
0.05%
0.27%
0.05%
0.35%
0.06%
37.52%
12.84%
1.72%
15.71%
36.44%
13.13%
1.53%
17.01%
38.06%
13.35%
1.67%
15.58%
38.00%
13.00%
1.60%
16.00%
38.00%
13.00%
1.60%
16.00%
38.00%
13.00%
1.60%
16.00%
38.00%
13.00%
1.60%
16.00%
15.32%
30.73%
29.83%
30.00%
30.00%
30.00%
30.00%
305,678
3.20%
302,629
3.23%
308,601
3.20%
317,761
3.20%
327,193
3.20%
336,904
3.20%
14,541,585
14,504,495
37,089
12,384,625
11.44%
13.18%
9.10%
14,979,169
14,954,661
24,508
15,432,407
15,413,707
18,700
15,899,952
15,885,638
14,315
1,252,854
(296,424)
176,313
5,545
1,138,288
1,295,205
(317,891)
176,313
(10,299)
1,143,328
1,319,986
(317,891)
176,313
1,178,408
1,358,083
(317,891)
176,313
1,216,505
1,406,513
(317,891)
176,313
1,264,935
1,462,175
(317,891)
176,313
1,320,597
1,138,288
103,655
100,000
1,341,943
1,143,328
126,504
80,000
1,349,832
1,178,408
121,885
90,000
1,390,292
1,216,505
117,885
90,000
1,424,390
1,264,935
114,885
90,000
1,469,820
1,320,597
114,885
90,000
1,525,482
10,698,195
13,031,646
13,983,882
10,450,896
12,679,756
13,758,460
10,400,193
12,683,163
13,697,816
10,749,346
13,108,959
14,157,675
11,120,491
13,561,574
14,646,500
11,505,333
14,030,894
15,153,366
0.82
1.07
0.82
1.09
0.82
1.08
0.82
1.08
0.82
1.08
0.82
1.08
10.64%
12.54%
8.14%
10.94%
12.91%
8.31%
11.33%
13.37%
8.60%
11.32%
13.25%
8.59%
11.37%
13.22%
8.64%
11.48%
13.26%
8.71%
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Well capitalized
Notes
See schedule
See schedule. Primarily with the NY Fed; model balancer
See schedule
See schedule
See schedule
See schedule
See schedule
Straight-line (SL) projection assumes new purchases equal depreciation/sales
SL. Assume appreciation offset by benefit proceeds. BOLI BOP + Change in surrender value (IS income) - Benefit proceeds (CF
SL. Argument can be made to grow as % of total interest income (as interest increases, so would the associated receivables).
SL. Primarily used in the trade of goods. For example, a manufacturer needs to be paid by a retailer: The retailer's bank, under
See schedule.
SL. No amortization of GW; assume no substantial new purchases or impairments
SL. Assume new purchases equal amortization/sales
SL. Comprised primarily of net deferred tax assets, federal reserve and federal home loan bank stock, derivatives, foreclosed an
See schedule
See schedule; Primarily repos for VLY; model balancer
See schedule
SL. Holding company debt.
SL. See corresponding asset description above.
SL. Argument can be made to grow as % of non-interest expense on IS
BOP + Net income - dividends = EOP
Comprised of held to maturity; available for sale; and trading securities. Banks always disclose their investment composition in t
Difficult to project growth rates definitively. We use historical rates as guide,
2010 gross loans include loans covered by the FDIC in a 2010 loss-share arrangement.
We use a historical cagr to project loan growth. This projection will also affect our deposit liabilities, which are needed to suppor
During credit crisis in 2008 and 2009, NCOs were higher than prior period provisions. Larger provisions were then taken in 2009
Although not used directly in our analysis, the "NCO ratio" is a sanity-check
Deposits drive the amount of loans a bank can make, and VLY maintains an internal limitation on loans at 120% of deposits. Fo
Sum of NIS and IBL cost. Implies higher LT rates but at lower rate of increase than ST rates
Thesis: Fed rate hikes will lead to higher ST rates, which will translate to higher deposit rates for VLY. While VLY can determine
Thesis: Expectations of an economic slowdown will lead to slight flattening of the yield curve (spreads between LT and ST rates
Reference to IS
Reference to IS
Reference to IS
Many banks have tax exempt investments, which, due to lower yields (but lower taxes) can obfuscate comparability of NII and N
SL
SL
Historical trends
Historical trends
Assumption
Assumption
Declining due to stricter regulations. VLY expects trend to stabilize and possibly reverse. We use BOP to avoid circularity.
Historical trends. We use BOP to avoid circularity.
Historical trends
Historical trends
Historical trends
Historical trends
Historical trends
Project as % of deposits
Historical trends
If A>L+E, our model has projected more assets than L+E to support them. As a result, ST borrowings must increase to meet fun
Tier 1 capital consists of common shareholders equity excluding goodwill, plus eligible long-term borrowing related to VNB Cap
Reference from balance sheet
Reference from balance sheet
Use the face value of the securities (as opposed to the carring value of the debentures) for Tier I capital calculations. Under the
Assume 0
Total capital = Tier 1 capital, "qualifying" subordinated debt and the allowance for credit losses (up to 1.25% of RWA).
Reference from credit loss reserve schedule
Calculate historicals as a plug. Forecast by using historical trends.
Does not equal average balance sheet assets because of minor adjustments for regulatory capital calculation purposes
Adequacy table
Well capitalized
Adequate
6%
4%
10%
8%
5%
4%
Undercapitalized
SignificantlyCritically
Undercapitalized
Undercapitalized
4%
3%
8%
6%
4%
3%
2%
stock, derivatives, foreclosed and other assets. (The Federal Reserve Banks issue shares of stock to member banks. However, owning Fed
heir investment composition in the footnotes; a large portion of VLY's securities are RMBS.
es, which are needed to support loan volume. VLY discloses the composition of its loan portfolio in the footnotes, so if analysts have convictio
visions were then taken in 2009 and 2010, while NCOs declined as environment normalized. We are assuming normalization of provisions, a
n loans at 120% of deposits. For projection purposes, we use the historical relationship, to project deposits.
VLY. While VLY can determine its own deposit rates, competition ties it to market conditions.
eads between LT and ST rates will contract). Given that deposits are ST while loans are LT, this will lead to contraction in NII margin.
scate comparability of NII and NIM. Accordingly, VLY, like most banks and consistent with SEC rules, disclose amounts related to NII and NIM
wings must increase to meet funding needs. Conversely, if A<L, our model is projecting larger sources of capital (L+E) than we are using. As
capital calculations. Under the Dodd-Frank Act (signed 7/10), VLY's outstanding trust preferred securities will continue to count as Tier 1 cap
p to 1.25% of RWA).
al calculation purposes
he goods. The bank is substituting its creditworthiness for that of its customer in order to assure the manufacturer of payment after shipping
ks. However, owning Federal Reserve Bank stock is quite different from owning stock in a private company. The Federal Reserve Banks are
if analysts have conviction about particular loan portfolios (residential vs. commercial loans) as more detailed analysis can be performed.
malization of provisions, and thus the relationship between NCOs and prior period provisions are also expected to increase to historical, pre-
unts related to NII and NIM on a tax equivalent basis using a 35 percent tax rate for the purposes of comparability.
E) than we are using. As a result, interest-bearing deposits must increase to put the excess capital "somewhere".
nue to count as Tier 1 capital but VLY will be unable to issue replacement or additional trust preferred securities, which would count as Tier 1
of payment after shipping the goods. The acceptance is then sent to the manufacturer. The bank records a liability (it owes the manufacture
deral Reserve Banks are not operated for profit, and ownership of a certain amount of stock is, by law, a condition of membership in the syst
(it owes the manufacturer $ now, but it records a corresponding asset that will be paid back by its customer, the retailer.
of membership in the system. The stock may not be sold or traded or pledged as security for a loan; dividends are, by law, limited to 6 percen
3 stage <-- The 3 stage is common for bank DDM models, 1) Development: R
12/31/2010 <-- For simplicity of calculating present values, model assumes valua
9.0%
9.0% <-- Should converge with cost of equity as company reaches maturity
4.0%
10.0%
DDM BUILDUP
2006A
2007A
2008A
2009A
12/31/2006 12/31/2007 12/31/2008 12/31/2009
Historicals
91,501
96,537
5.5%
102,517
109,005
6.3%
112.0%
112.9%
1,252,854
(296,424)
176,313
5,545
1,138,288
10,698,195
10.64%
0.27%
129,459
9.03%
1,477,094
772,348
1.3x
SHARES OUTSTANDING
Basic shares outstanding
Current share price
Options
# exercisable
Tranche 1
Tranche 2
Tranche 3
115
467
490
1,920,222
961,575
Tranche 4
Tranche 5
Total options
508
1,145
2,724
1.0x
Treasury stock method
Option proceeds
Repurchased shares
Dilutive impact of stock options
VALUATION
Perpetuity approach
Equity value of VLY
Implied P/BV
Implied P/TBV
VLY value / share
1,513,769
1.2x
1.3x
$9.37
1,702,997
1.3x
1.5x
$10.54
DDM SENSITIVITY
ROE
Cost of equity
$9.37
10.0%
9.5%
9.0%
8.5%
8.0%
7.0%
$7.28
$7.63
$8.02
$8.45
$8.94
8.0%
$7.87
$8.26
$8.70
$9.19
$9.74
9.0%
$8.45
$8.89
$9.38
$9.93
$10.55
Share price sensitivity to cost of equity (vertical) and perpetuity growth rate (horizontal)
Cost of equity
$9.37
10.0%
9.5%
9.0%
8.5%
8.0%
0.0%
$8.90
$9.06
$9.23
$9.39
$9.56
1.0%
$9.43
$9.64
$9.86
$10.08
$10.32
2.0%
$10.10
$10.37
$10.67
$10.99
$11.34
Share price sensitivity to cost of equity (vertical) and exit multiple (horizontal)
Exit multiple
Cost of equity
$10.54
10.0%
9.5%
9.0%
8.5%
8.0%
1.00x
$8.82
$9.00
$9.18
$9.36
$9.55
1.25x
$9.89
$10.10
$10.32
$10.55
$10.79
1.50x
$10.96
$11.21
$11.47
$11.74
$12.02
k DDM models, 1) Development: Reference the operating model, 2) Maturity: Mature ROE and RWA assumptions, and 3) Terminal: A final phase
sent values, model assumes valuation date = last fiscal year end date. Analysts should adjust the present value calculations to handle other dates .
quity as company reaches maturity. When ROE is significantly higher than cost of equity at the maturity phase, analyst needs to justify or change
2010A
2011E
2012E
2013E
2014E
2015E
2016E
2017E
12/31/2010 12/31/2011 12/31/2012 12/31/2013 12/31/2014 12/31/2015 12/31/2016 12/31/2017
Development phase (from op model)
Maturity phase
131,170
140,744
154,061
164,393
171,625
164,225
153,856
143,462
35.9%
7.3%
9.5%
6.7%
4.4%
(4.3%)
(6.3%)
(6.8%)
115,190
115,963
115,963
115,963
115,963
160,788
150,153
139,596
5.7%
0.7%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
38.7%
(6.6%)
(7.0%)
87.8%
82.4%
75.3%
70.5%
67.6%
97.9%
97.6%
97.3%
1,252,854
131,170
(115,190)
1,295,205
(317,891)
176,313
(10,299)
1,143,328
1,295,205
140,744
(115,963)
1,319,986
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,178,408
1,319,986
154,061
(115,963)
1,358,083
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,216,505
1,358,083
164,393
(115,963)
1,406,513
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,264,935
1,406,513
171,625
(115,963)
1,462,175
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,320,597
1,462,175
164,225
(160,788)
1,465,613
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,324,035
1,465,613
153,856
(150,153)
1,469,316
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,327,738
1,469,316
143,462
(139,596)
1,473,182
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,331,604
10.3%
10.8%
11.5%
11.9%
12.0%
11.2%
10.5%
9.8%
10,450,896 10,400,193 10,749,346 11,120,491 11,505,333 11,919,007 12,363,625 12,841,500
(2.3%)
(0.5%)
3.4%
3.5%
3.5%
3.6%
3.7%
3.9%
10.94%
11.33%
11.32%
11.37%
11.48%
11.11%
10.74%
10.37%
11.11%
10.74%
10.37%
115,963
96%
115,963
88%
115,963
81%
115,963
74%
160,788
68%
150,153
62%
139,596
57%
741,421.1
STANDING
exercise price
$15
$17
$18
# in the $
0
0
0
$19
$21
0
0
0
$0
0
0
of stock options
hares outstanding:
161,589
ROE
10.0%
$9.03
$9.52
$10.06
$10.66
$11.35
11.0%
$9.61
$10.14
$10.74
$11.40
$12.15
12.0%
$10.20
$10.77
$11.41
$12.14
$12.95
4.0%
$12.09
$12.63
$13.27
$14.01
$14.91
5.0%
$13.68
$14.52
$15.54
$16.82
$18.47
2.00x
$13.09
$13.42
$13.76
$14.12
$14.49
2.25x
$14.15
$14.53
$14.91
$15.31
$15.72
ate (horizontal)
Exit multiple
1.75x
$12.02
$12.31
$12.62
$12.93
$13.26
2018E
12/31/2018
phase
133,028
(7.3%)
129,116
(7.5%)
97.1%
1,473,182
133,028
(129,116)
1,477,094
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,335,516
9.0%
13,355,160
4.0%
10.00%
10.00%
129,116
52%
creates circularity)
NI = Average Equity * ROE. Circularity created because NI affects equity, which in turn determines NI.
Forecast as the excess of available capital over a minimum capital base defined by the Tier I capital ratio
Tier 1 capital sets the base floor for capital in this model. Dividends will be distributed until the tier I capital level reaches its minimum assu
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
RI GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS
RI model type
Valuation date
Cost of equity
RI - MATURITY PHASE ASSUMPTIONS
ROE
RWA growth
Capital ratio (Tier 1 capital / RWA)
3 stage <-- The 3 stage is common for bank RI models, 1) Development: Refe
12/31/2010 <-- For simplicity of calculating present values, model assumes valua
9.0%
9.0% <-- Should converge with cost of equity as company reaches maturity
4.0%
10.0%
RI BUILDUP
2006A
2007A
2008A
2009A
12/31/2006 12/31/2007 12/31/2008 12/31/2009
Historicals
91,501
96,537
5.5%
102,517
109,005
6.3%
112.0%
112.9%
1,252,854
(296,424)
176,313
5,545
1,138,288
10,698,195
10.64%
133,382
0
9.03%
0.00%
0
0.0
SHARES OUTSTANDING
Basic shares outstanding
Current share price
Options
# exercisable
Tranche 1
Tranche 2
115
467
VALUATION
Book value of equity (last historical year)
PV of RI
PV of TV
Fair equity value of VLY
Implied P/BV
Implied P/TBV
VLY value / share
Tranche 3
Tranche 4
Tranche 5
Total options
1,295,205
154,747
0
1,449,952
1.1x
1.3x
$8.97
490
508
1,145
2,724
DDM SENSITIVITY
ROE
Cost of equity
$8.97
10.0%
9.5%
9.0%
8.5%
8.0%
7.0%
$6.89
$7.25
$7.66
$8.11
$8.61
8.0%
$7.46
$7.87
$8.32
$8.83
$9.39
9.0%
$8.03
$8.48
$8.99
$9.55
$10.17
Share price sensitivity to cost of equity (vertical) and perpetuity growth rate (horizontal)
Cost of equity
$8.97
10.0%
9.5%
9.0%
8.5%
8.0%
(2.0%)
$8.99
$9.16
$9.33
$9.50
$9.68
(1.0%)
$9.53
$9.75
$9.97
$10.21
$10.46
0.0%
$10.21
$10.49
$10.80
$11.13
$11.50
k RI models, 1) Development: Reference the operating model, 2) Maturity: Mature ROE and RWA assumptions, and 3) Terminal: A final phase
sent values, model assumes valuation date = last fiscal year end date. Analysts should adjust the present value calculations to handle other dates .
quity as company reaches maturity. When ROE is significantly higher than cost of equity at the maturity phase, analyst needs to justify or change
2010A
2011E
2012E
2013E
2014E
2015E
2016E
2017E
12/31/2010 12/31/2011 12/31/2012 12/31/2013 12/31/2014 12/31/2015 12/31/2016 12/31/2017
Development phase (from op model)
Maturity phase
131,170
140,744
154,061
164,393
171,625
164,225
153,856
143,462
35.9%
7.3%
9.5%
6.7%
4.4%
(4.3%)
(6.3%)
(6.8%)
115,190
115,963
115,963
115,963
115,963
160,788
150,153
139,596
5.7%
0.7%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
38.7%
(6.6%)
(7.0%)
87.8%
82.4%
75.3%
70.5%
67.6%
97.9%
97.6%
97.3%
1,252,854
131,170
(115,190)
1,295,205
(317,891)
176,313
(10,299)
1,143,328
1,295,205
140,744
(115,963)
1,319,986
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,178,408
1,319,986
154,061
(115,963)
1,358,083
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,216,505
1,358,083
164,393
(115,963)
1,406,513
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,264,935
1,406,513
171,625
(115,963)
1,462,175
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,320,597
1,462,175
164,225
(160,788)
1,465,613
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,324,035
1,465,613
153,856
(150,153)
1,469,316
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,327,738
1,469,316
143,462
(139,596)
1,473,182
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,331,604
10.3%
10.8%
11.5%
11.9%
12.0%
11.2%
10.5%
9.8%
10,450,896 10,400,193 10,749,346 11,120,491 11,505,333 11,919,007 12,363,625 12,841,500
(2.3%)
(0.5%)
3.4%
3.5%
3.5%
3.6%
3.7%
3.9%
10.94%
11.33%
11.32%
11.37%
11.48%
11.11%
10.74%
10.37%
11.11%
10.74%
10.37%
22,668
96%
33,146
88%
39,572
81%
42,104
74%
32,036
68%
21,344
62%
10,608
57%
154,747.4
1=Use beginning balance to calculate NII
2=Use average balance to calculate NII (creates circularity)
STANDING
161,589 Front cover of latest filing
$13.70 Share price as of valuation date
exercise price
$15
$17
# in the $
0
0
$18
$19
$21
0
0
0
0
$0
0
0
of stock options
hares outstanding:
161,589
ROE
10.0%
$8.60
$9.10
$9.65
$10.26
$10.95
11.0%
$9.17
$9.71
$10.31
$10.98
$11.73
12.0%
$9.74
$10.32
$10.97
$11.70
$12.51
2.0%
$12.23
$12.79
$13.45
$14.21
$15.13
3.0%
$13.85
$14.71
$15.76
$17.07
$18.77
ate (horizontal)
2018E
12/31/2018
phase
133,028
(7.3%)
129,116
(7.5%)
97.1%
1,473,182
133,028
(129,116)
1,477,094
(317,891)
176,313
0
1,335,516
9.0%
13,355,160
4.0%
10.00%
10.00%
creates circularity)
(177)
52%
1
NI = Average Equity * ROE. Circularity created because NI affects equity, which in turn determines NI.
Forecast as the excess of available capital over a minimum capital base defined by the Tier I capital ratio
Tier 1 capital sets the base floor for capital in this model. Dividends will be distributed until the tier I capital level reaches its minimum assu
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
Maturity phase formula "smooths" shift to the maturity phase assumption.
3.50%
7.00%
0.79
9.03%
Date
3/1/2011
3/1/2011
3/1/2011
Source
Bloomberg
Morningstar - Ibbotson and Sinquefield Yearbook
Bloomberg
Low
Average High
$12.01
$13.60
$15.19
$8.02
$9.72
$11.41
$8.45
$9.50
$10.55
$9.18
$12.04
$14.91
$8.03
$9.10
$10.17
$9.33
$12.54
$15.76
$13.12
$14.84
$16.56
Low
$12.01
$8.02
$8.45
$9.18
$8.03
$9.33
$13.12
$17.00
$15.00
$13.00
$11.00
$9.00
$7.00
$5.00
52 week high/low DDM - 7%-12%
ROE
0-50th percentile
50-100th percentile
$1.59
$1.59
$1.70
$1.70
$1.05
$1.05
$2.87
$2.87
$1.07
$1.07
$3.22
$3.22
$1.72
$1.72
Comments
The football field is a valuation matrix that identifies a value range across multiple
valuation methods. In addition to the RI and DDM methods, we also include a 52
week trading high and low range, as well as a peer-group derived valuation using
an LTM P/B range.
To create a football field, we reference the valuation ranges from the appropriate
areas of the model and calculate an average valuation for each valuation method.
Next, we lay out the ranges in a way that will be Excel chart friendly:
Starting with the low valuation as a baseline, we calculate two percentiles:
0-50% and 50-100%, representing the tails around the average value.
We can now insert a stacked column bar chart. Remove the fill from the low
valuation stack and you have a football field.
RI - (2%) to 2%
Trading
perpetuity growth comparables P/BV
across multiple
o include a 52
valuation using
he appropriate
uation method.
m the low