Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Primer 2010
The Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured provides information and analysis on health care coverage and access for the low-income population, with a special focus on Medicaids role and coverage of the uninsured. Begun in 1991 and based in the Kaiser Family Foundations Washington, DC office, the Commission is the largest operating program of the Foundation. The Commissions work is conducted by Foundation staff under the guidance of a bipartisan group of national leaders and experts in health care and public policy.
MEDICAID
A Primer
Key Information on Our Nations Health Coverage Program for Low-Income People
June 2010
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction.......................................................................................1
Over its nearly 45-year history, the Medicaid program has grown increasingly integral to our health care system. Today, it is a primary source of coverage, access, health care nancing, and innovation in health care delivery. During the recession, the program has provided a coverage safety-net for millions of Americans, especially children, who would otherwise have joined the uninsured. Under health reform, Medicaid assumes even greater importance as it becomes the national coverage mechanism for low-income people in the new plan for near-universal coverage. With this expanded role for Medicaid on the horizon, basic information about the program is a key resource.
What is Medicaid?...................................................................................3
Medicaid is the nations publicly funded health coverage program for low-income Americans. Medicaid covers health and long-term care services for specied categories of low-income people currently, but it will be expanded in 2014 to reach nearly everyone under age 65 with income up to 133% of the poverty level. Medicaid lls large gaps in our health insurance system, nances the lions share of long-term care, and provides core support for the health centers and safety-net hospitals that serve the nations uninsured and millions of others. Within broad federal guidelines, states design their own Medicaid programs.
Tables..35
INTRODUCTION
No major health program or issue can be considered today outside the context of the nations new health care reform law, known as the Aordable Care Act.* The health reform law, the most signicant social legislation in the U.S. since 1965, seeks to eliminate large and growing gaps in health insurance by increasing access to aordable coverage and instituting a new legal obligation on the part of individuals to obtain it. To accomplish this reform, the law creates a national framework for near-universal coverage and also outlines a comprehensive set of strategies to improve care and contain costs. Integral to the coverage framework laid out in the reform law is a dramatic expansion of the Medicaid program; half the expected gains in coverage due to health reform will be achieved through this expansion.
Figure 1
41%
16%
17% 13% 8%
Hospital Care
Professional Services
Prescription Drugs
$2,181
$718
$731
$138
$234
Note: Does not include spending on CHIP. SOURCE: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Oce of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group, National Health Expenditure Accounts, January 2010.
The reliance on Medicaid as a platform for wider coverage of the low-income uninsured has a long history. Established in 1965 as part of President Johnsons Great Society, Medicaid was originally conceived as a health coverage supplement only for those receiving cash welfare assistance. Overtime, Congress has expanded Medicaid substantially to ll growing coverage gaps left by the private insurance system. Many states have expanded eligibility for the program further and Medicaid has been the cornerstone of all state-level initiatives to broaden coverage of the uninsured. In 2007, Medicaid covered health and long-term care services for nearly 60 million people, including more than 1 in 4 children and many of the sickest and poorest in our nation. During the economic recession, Medicaid has provided a safety-net of coverage for millions more Americans aected by loss of work or declining income. Medicaid now provides bene ts to more people than any other public or private insurance program, including Medicare.
Health reform was enacted in two separate pieces of legislation. President Obama signed the Patient Protection and Aordable Care Act (P.L. 111-148) into law on March 23, 2010. The Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (P.L. 111-152), signed on March 30, 2010, includes changes to new law.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
AsamainstayofcoverageintheU.S.,Medicaidisalsoacoresourceofhealthcarefinancingit fundsalmostasixthoftotalnationalspendingonpersonalhealthcare(Figure1).Medicaidisthe mainpayerofnursinghomecareandlongtermcareservicesoverall;itisalsothelargestsourceof publicfundingformentalhealthcare.Healthcentersandsafetynethospitalsthatservelow incomeanduninsuredpeoplerelyheavilyonMedicaidrevenues.Medicaidisanengineinstate andlocaleconomies,too,supportingmillionsofjobs. LookingaheadtotheevenlargerroleMedicaidwillsoonplayunderhealthcarereform, understandingtheprogramandhowitfitsintoourhealthcaresystemtakesonadditional importance.Thepurposeofthisprimeristoprovidethatfoundationbyexplainingthebasicsof Medicaidandprovidingkeyinformationabouttheprogramtoday.
WHAT IS MEDICAID?
Medicaid is a public health insurance program that lls important gaps in our system today gaps in coverage, long-term care, and nancing for the safety-net delivery system. Under health reform, Medicaids role in health coverage and nancing will increase substantially. A signicant expansion of Medicaid, which will extend health coverage to millions more low-income people, is the foundation of the national coverage system established by the new law. The federal government will nance the lions share of the cost of the new coverage. States will continue to shape their own programs, but Medicaid eligibility will be simplied to support coordination between Medicaid and subsidized coverage oered in the new insurance exchanges.
What is Medicaid?
Medicaid is the nations publicly nanced health and long-term care coverage program for low-income people. Enacted in 1965 under Title XIX of the Social Security Act, Medicaid is an entitlement program that was initially established to provide medical assistance to individuals and families receiving cash assistance, or welfare. Over the years, Congress has incrementally expanded Medicaid eligibility to reach more Americans living below or near poverty, regardless of their welfare eligibility. Today, Medicaid covers a broad low-income population, including parents and children in both working and jobless families, individuals with diverse physical and mental conditions and disabilities, and seniors. Medicaids beneciaries include many of the poorest and sickest people in the nation.
Families
All Children Lo Income Children Low-Income Low-Income Adults Births (Pregnant Women) 21% 41% 30% 56%
SOURCE: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute analysis of 2009 ASEC Supplement to the CPS; Birth data from Maternal and Child Health Update: States Increase Eligibility for Children's Health in 2007, National Governors Association, 2008; Medicare data from USDHHS.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
Bydesign,Medicaidexpandstocovermorepeopleduringeconomicdownturns.Because eligibilityforMedicaidistiedtohavinglowincome,andenrollmentcannotbelimitedor waitinglistskept,theprogramoperatesasasafetynet.Duringeconomicrecessionslikethe currentone,whenjoblosscausesworkersandtheirfamiliestolosehealthcoverageand income,morepeoplebecomeeligibleforMedicaidandtheprogramexpandstocovermany ofthem,offsettinglossesofprivatehealthinsuranceandmitigatingincreasesinthenumber ofuninsured. Itisestimatedthatforeveryonepercentagepointincreaseintheunemploymentrate, Medicaidenrollmentgrowsby1million.1Medicaidenrollmentgrowthhasbeenaccelerating ineachsixmonthperiodsincetherecessionbeganinDecember2007.Thelargestsixmonth MedicaidenrollmentincreaseonrecordoccurredfromDecember2008toJune2009,when 2.1millionadditionalindividualsobtainedMedicaidcoverage.BetweenJune2008andJune 2009,enrollmentrosebynearly3.3million,or7.5%. MedicaidisthemainsourceoflongtermcarecoverageandfinancingintheU.S.Over10 millionAmericans,includingabout6millionelderlyand4millionchildrenandworkingage adults,needlongtermservicesandsupports.2Medicaidcoversabout7ofevery10nursing homeresidentsandfinancesover40%ofnursinghomespendingandlongtermcarespending overall.3MorethanhalfofallMedicaidlongtermcarespendingisforinstitutionalcare,buta growingshare41%in2006,upfrom30%in2000and13%in1990isattributabletohome andcommunitybasedservices.4 Medicaidfundingsupportsthesafetynetinstitutionsthatprovidehealthcaretolowincomeand uninsuredpeople(Figure3).Medicaidprovides33%ofpublichospitalsnetrevenues.Medicaid paymentsprovideanevenlargershareofhealthcenterstotaloperatingrevenues(37%)andis theirlargestsourceofthirdpartypayment.5
Figure 3
Subsidies 13%
SOURCE : Data for public hospitals from Americas Public Hospitals and Health Systems, 2008, National Association of Public Hospitals and Health Systems, February 2010. Health center data from 2008 Uniform Data System (UDS), Health Resources and Services Administration.
US Average = 14%
>15% (12 states including DC) 13-15% (12 states) 10 12% (20 states) 10-12% < 10% (7 states)
SOURCE: Urban Institute and Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured analysis of the March 2008 and 2009 ASEC Supplements to the CPS. Two-year pooled estimates for states and the US (2007-2008).
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
StatescanseekfederalwaiverstooperatetheirMedicaidprogramsoutsideoffederal guidelines.Section1115oftheSocialSecurityActgivestheHHSSecretaryauthoritytowaive statutoryandregulatoryprovisionsofhealthandwelfareprograms,includingMedicaid,for demonstrationpurposes.StatescanapplyforSection1115waiverstooperatetheirMedicaid programsoutsideregularfederalrules.SomestateshaveusedwaiverstoexpandMedicaid eligibilityandtoadoptnewmodelsofcoverageandhealthcaredeliveryforthelowincome population. Medicaidsstructureenablestheprogramtoadaptandevolve.Thecombinationofthe federalentitlementtoMedicaidforallindividualswhoqualify,broadstateflexibilityin programdesign,andguaranteedfederalmatchingfundshasenabledMedicaidtorespondto economicanddemographicchanges,andtoaddressemergentneedsforexample,by expandingduringeconomicdownturnsandprovidingacoveragesafetynetformanyaffected bytheHIV/AIDSpandemic.Inaddition,asamajorsourceofhealthcarefinancing,Medicaid hasleveragedimprovementsinhealthcare,includingnewapproachestocarecoordination andmanagement,aswellaswideradoptionofcommunitybasedalternativestoinstitutional longtermcare.
Medicaid/Other Public
Uninsured
5%
18% 12%
10%
7%
4%
71%
83%
92%
Note: The federal poverty level (FPL) was $22,025 for a family of four in 2008. Data may not total 100% due to rounding. SOURCE: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute analysis of 2009 ASEC Supplement to the CPS.
* $22,025 for a family of four is the 2008 poverty threshold published by the U.S. Census Bureau. Depending on the context, this Primer also sometimes uses the poverty guidelines issued by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
WhocanqualifyforMedicaid?
Undercurrentlaw,toqualifyforMedicaid,apersonmustmeetfinancialcriteriaandalso belongtooneofthegroupsthatarecategoricallyeligiblefortheprogram.Federallaw requiresstatestocovercertainmandatorygroupsinordertoreceiveanyfederalmatching funds.Themandatorygroupsarepregnantwomenandchildrenunderage6withfamily incomebelow133%FPL;childrenage6to18below100%FPL;parentsbelowstatesJuly1996 welfareeligibilitylevels(oftenbelow50%FPL);andmostelderlyandpersonswithdisabilities whoreceiveSupplementalSecurityIncome(SSI),aprogramforwhichincomeeligibility equatesto75%FPLforanindividual.Stateshavebroadflexibilitytodeterminetheirown methodsforcountingincomeandtheymayalsoimposeanassettest.Nearlyallstate Medicaidprogramshaveeliminatedtheassettestforchildren,butabouthalfrequireanasset testforparents;almosteverystateappliesanassettestindeterminingMedicaideligibilityfor theelderlyandpeoplewithdisabilities. Underthenewhealthreformlaw,nearlyeveryoneunderage65regardlessofcategory withincomebelowanationalfloorwillbeeligibleforMedicaid,makingMedicaidthe coveragepathwayformanymorelowincomeAmericans.Historically,nonelderlyadults withoutdependentchildren,nomatterhowpoortheyare,havebeencategoricallyexcluded fromMedicaidbyfederallawunlesstheyaredisabledorpregnant.Stateshavebeenableto receivefederalMedicaidfundstocovertheseadultsonlyiftheyobtainedafederalwaiver; alternatively,statescouldusestateonlydollars.Thenewhealthreformlawendsthe categoricalexclusionoftheseadultsasof2014,expandingMedicaideligibilitynationallyto reachadultsunderage65(bothparentsandthosewithoutdependentchildren)upto133% FPL;anenhancedfederalmatchrateappliesforadultsnewlyeligibleforMedicaidasaresult. HealthreformdidnotchangeMedicaideligibilityfortheelderlyandpeoplewithdisabilities. Stateshavetheoptiontocoverorphaseincoverageoftheneweligibilitygroupbeginning April1,2010,ratherthanwaitinguntil2014.States(includingthosethathavebeencovering childlessadultsinMedicaidwithstateonlydollars)canreceivefederalMedicaidmatching fundsforpeopleintheneweligibilitygroup.Statesregularfederalmatchrateappliesforthis groupuntil2014,whentheenhancedfederalmatchratetakeseffect.
MedicaideligibilityislimitedtoAmericancitizensandcertainlawfullyresidingimmigrants. OnlyAmericancitizensandspecificcategoriesoflawfullyresidingimmigrantscanqualifyfor Medicaid.ThePersonalResponsibilityandWorkOpportunityReconciliationAct,enactedin 1996,barredmostlawfullyresidingimmigrantsfromMedicaidduringtheirfirstfiveyearsin theU.S.,exceptforemergencytreatment.6Somestateshaveusedstateonlyfundstocover theselegalimmigrantsduringthefiveyearban.Recently,Congressgavestatestheoptionto receivefederalMedicaidmatchingfundsforlawfullyresidingimmigrantchildrenandpregnant womenduringtheirfirstfiveyearsintheU.S.7Atthiswriting,18statesincludingtheDistrict ofColumbiahadadoptedtheoptiontocoverimmigrantchildren,pregnantwomen,orboth, withoutthefiveyearwait.Thehealthreformlawdoesnotchangeanyoftherulesregarding immigrantseligibilityforMedicaid.
Documentationofcitizenshipandidentityisrequired.SinceJuly1,2006,mostU.S.citizens applyingforMedicaidcoverageforthefirsttimemust,underfederallaw,documenttheir citizenshipandidentitybysubmittingapassportoracombinationofabirthcertificateandan identitydocument.8(Previously,manystatesacceptedapplicantsselfdeclarationof citizenshipunderpenaltyofperjury.)Nearlyallelderlyindividualsandpeoplewithdisabilities areexemptfromthecitizenshipdocumentationrequirement,asarenewbornswhose deliverieswerepaidforbyMedicaid.AsofJanuary1,2010,stateshavetheoptiontosatisfy thedocumentationrequirementbyconductingadatamatchwiththeSocialSecurity Administrationsdatabase,usingsocialsecuritynumbers,toverifyU.S.citizenship.Almosthalf thestatesarenowusingortestingthisdatamatchoption. StateshavebroaddiscretiontoexpandMedicaideligibilitybeyondfederalminimum standardstocoveradditionaloptionalgroups.Optionaleligibilitygroupsinclude,among others:pregnantwomen,children,andparentswithincomeexceedingthemandatory thresholds;elderlyanddisabledindividualsupto100%FPL;workingdisabledindividualsupto 250%FPL;personsresidinginnursingfacilitieswithincomebelow300%oftheSSIstandard; individualswhowouldbeeligibleifinstitutionalized,butwhoarereceivingcareunderhome andcommunitybasedserviceswaivers;andthemedicallyneedy,individualswhocannot meetthefinancialcriteriabuthavehighhealthexpensesrelativetotheirincome,andwho belongtooneofthecategoricallyeligiblegroups.BetweenMedicaidexpansionsforchildren andcoverageundertheChildrensHealthInsuranceProgram(CHIP),moststatescoverall childrenbelow200%FPL.StateshavealsoexpandedMedicaidtoadultoptionalgroups,but muchlessextensively,andMedicaidadulteligibilityabovefederalminimumlevelsvaries widelyfromstatetostate.(Figure6)
Figure 6
64%
75% 38% 0%
Children
Pregnant Women
Working Parents
Note: Medicaid income eligibility for most elderly and individuals with disabilities is based on the income threshold of Supplemental Security Income (SSI). SOURCE: Based on a national survey conducted by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities for Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, 2009.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
Whoiscoveredcurrently?
Over46millionlowincomechildrenandparents,themajorityoftheminworkingfamilies,rely onMedicaid.MedicaidisthelargestsourceofhealthinsuranceforAmericanchildren.In2007, about29millionchildrenoveronequarterofallchildrenandmorethanhalfoflowincome childrenwereenrolledintheprogramatsomepointduringtheyear.9CHIPbuildsonMedicaid, coveringmorethan7millionchildreninfamilieswhoseincomesaretoohightoqualifyfor Medicaid.10Medicaidcoverscloseto15millionlowincome,nonelderlyadults,primarilyparents inworkingfamilies.MostchildrenandfamiliescoveredbyMedicaidwouldbeuninsuredwithout itastheylackaccesstoprivateinsurance. Medicaidcovers8.8millionnonelderlypeoplewithdisabilities,including4millionchildren. Medicaidprovideshealthandlongtermcarecoverageforpeoplewithdiversephysicaland mentaldisabilitiesandchronicillnesses.Often,theseindividualscannotobtaincoverageinthe privatemarketorthecoverageavailabletothemfallsshortoftheirhealthcareneeds.Medicaid enablespeoplewithdisabilitiestogainaccesstoafullerrangeoftheservicestheyneed,helping tomaximizetheirindependenceand,inthecaseofsomedisabledadults,supportingtheir participationintheworkforce.Medicaidcoversalargemajorityofallpoorchildrenwith disabilities.
Medicaidisakeysourceofcoverageforpregnantwomen.Moststateshaveexpandedcoverage ofpregnantwomenbeyondthefederalminimumincomeeligibilitylevelof133%FPL.Sixteen statescoverpregnantwomenupto185%FPLandanother24statesprovideeligibilityathigher incomelevels.Medicaidimprovesaccesstoprenatalcareandneonatalintensivecareforlow incomepregnantwomenandtheirbabies,helpingtoimprovematernalhealthandreduceinfant mortality,lowweightbirths,andavoidablebirthdefects.Medicaidfundsapproximatelyfourof everytenbirthsintheU.S.andisthelargestsourceofpublicfundingforfamilyplanning.11 Medicaidprovidesassistanceformorethan8millionlowincomeMedicarebeneficiaries.The federalMedicareprogramprovideshealthinsurance47millionAmericans,including39million seniorsand8millionnonelderlyindividualswithpermanentdisabilities.About1in6Medicare beneficiaries,basedontheirlowincome,arealsocoveredbyMedicaidandareknownasdual eligibles.DualeligiblesaremuchpoorerandinworsehealthcomparedwithotherMedicare enrollees.MedicaidassistsdualeligibleswithMedicarepremiumsandcostsharingandcovers importantservicesthatMedicarelimitsordoesnotcover,especiallylongtermcare.In2005,dual eligiblesaccountedfor18%ofMedicaidenrolleesbut46%ofallMedicaidspendingforservices. UntilaprescriptiondrugbenefitwasaddedtoMedicarein2006,Medicaidcoveredprescription drugsfordualeligiblesandpaidnearly40%oftheirtotalhealthcarecosts.
10
WhoisleftoutofMedicaid?
NotalllowincomeAmericanscancurrentlyqualifyforMedicaid.AlthoughMedicaidcovers millionsofpoorandnearpoorAmericans,incomeandcategoricalrestrictionscurrently excludemillionsoflowincomepeoplemostlyadults.Duetotheserestrictions,whichthe newhealthreformlawredresses,lowincomeadultstodayaremuchmorelikelythanlow incomechildrentobeuninsured,asoutlinedmorefullybelow. Parents.WhileallpoorchildrenareeligibleforMedicaid,manyoftheirparentsarenot becausemoststateshavemuchstricterincomeeligibilityforparentsthanforchildren.Asof December2009,34statessetincomeeligibilityforworkingparentsatalevelbelow100%FPL, andhalfofthosestatessettheirlevelsbelow50%FPL.In29states,aparentinafamilyof threeworkingfulltimeatthestatesminimumwagecouldnotqualifyforMedicaid.14Because theireligibilityforMedicaidissomuchmorelimitedthanchildrens,parentswhoarebelowor nearthepovertylevelaremorethantwiceaslikelytobeuninsuredaschildreninthesame incomestratum(Figure7).HealthreformextendsMedicaideligibility,nationally,tonearly everyoneunderage65withincomeupto133%FPL,closingthecoveragegapthatmanylow incomeparentscurrentlyface.
Figure 7
Medicaid/Other Public
Uninsured
Poor
16% 38%
66% 47%
18% 15%
Children
(100-199% Poverty)
Near-Poor
Poor
17% 48%
41% 18%
42% 33%
Parents
Near-Poor
Poor Near-Poor
24% 42%
29% 20%
47% 38%
Note: Data may not total 100% due to rounding. SOURCE: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute analysis of 2009 ASEC Supplement to the CPS.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
11
Adultswithoutdependentchildren.Untilhealthreformwasenacted,federallawcategorically excludedmostadultswithoutdependentchildrenfromMedicaid.Stateswereprecludedfrom receivingfederalMedicaidmatchingfundsforsuchadultsnomatterhowpoorunlessthey werepregnantorseverelydisabled.Abouthalfthestateshavefederalwaiversand/orusestate onlyfundstoprovidesomekindofcoveragetochildlessadults.Onlyfiveofthesestatesprovide MedicaidorMedicaidlikebenefits;mostprovidemorelimitedbenefitsorcoverchildlessadults throughworkplacecoverageundercertainconditions.15In2008,over40%oflowincomeadults withoutchildrenwereuninsured,andtheseadultsaccountedformorethanonethirdofthe46 millionnonelderlyAmericanswholackedinsurance.16ThenationalMedicaidexpansionunder healthreformdoesawaywiththeexclusionofchildlessadultsandcoversthosewithincomeupto 133%FPL.Asmentionedpreviously,stateshavetheoptiontoimplementthisexpansion immediately,ratherthanwaitinguntil2014whentheexpansionisrequired. Immigrants.Inmoststates,lawfullyresidingimmigrantsareineligibleforMedicaidfortheirfirst fiveyearsintheU.S.Whilestatescanopttocoverlegalimmigrantpregnantwomenand childrenwithoutawait,mosthavenot,andotherlegalimmigrantsremainbarredfrom Medicaidfortheirfirstfiveyearshere.Federallawprohibitsundocumentedimmigrantsfrom enrollinginMedicaid.Medicaidpaymentsmaybemadeforundocumentedimmigrantsonlyfor emergencyservicesandonlyiftheywouldotherwisequalifyforMedicaid.Theserulesdonot changeunderhealthreform. Statetostatevariationineligibilityleadstomarkedinequitiesinlowincomeadultsaccessto Medicaidcoverage.BecauseofstatevariationinMedicaidincomeeligibilitylevelsandother statepolicychoices,adultsatagivenincomelevelevenbelowthepovertylevelmaybe eligibleforMedicaidinonestatebutineligibleinanother.In2009,eligibilitythresholdsfor workingparentsrangedfrom17%FPLinArkansasto215%FPLinMinnesota(Figure8).Twenty fivestatesincludingtheDistrictofColumbiahadfederalwaiversorusedstateonlyfundsto provideMedicaidcoveragetochildlessadults.17Duetofederalminimumstandards,Medicaid incomeeligibilitylevelsforpregnantwomenandchildrenaresomewhatuniform,butotherlow incomeadultsaccesstoMedicaidcoveragevarieswidelyacrossthestates.
Figure 8
< 50% FPL (17 states) 50% - 99% FPL (17 states) 100% FPL or Greater ( (17 states, including g DC) ) Note: The federal poverty line (FPL) for a family of three in 2009 was $18,310 per year. SOURCE: Based on a national survey conducted by Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured with the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 2009.
12
ManypeoplewhoareeligibleforMedicaidarenotenrolled.ParticipationinMedicaidis highcomparedwithothervoluntaryprograms.Yetmanywho couldgaincoverageunder theprogramarenotenrolled.Over70%ofuninsuredchildrenarepotentiallyeligiblefor MedicaidorCHIPbutnotenrolled.Somelowincomefamilies arenotawareofthe programsordonotbelievetheirchildrenqualify.Inaddition,althoughimportant improvementshavebeenmadeoverthelastdecade,mostlyforchildren,burdensome enrollmentandrenewalrequirements stillposemajorobstaclesto participation. Responding toevidencethatcitizenshipdocumentationrequirements haveimposeda further burdenonU.S.citizenswho areeligibleforMedicaidandimpededtheir participation,Congressenactedchangestoeasetheimpact. 18 StatesthatmeetperformancegoalsrelatedtoenrollingMedicaideligiblechildrencan qualifyforfederalbonuspayments.TheChildrensHealthInsuranceProgramReauthorization Act(CHIPRA),enactedinFebruary2009,providedforfederalperformancebonusestobepaid tostatesthatbothimplementanarrayofpoliciestoencourageenrollmentandretentionof childreninMedicaidandCHIPandachievechildenrollmentinMedicaidthatexceedstargets specifiedinthelaw.Themorechildrenastateenrollsabovethetarget,thelargerthefederal bonuspaymenttothestate.Theintentofthebonusesistopromoteandrewardincreased enrollmentofchildrenwhoareeligibleforMedicaidbutuninsured.InDecember2009,HHS awardedninestates$72.6millioninperformancebonuses. ChurninginMedicaidinterruptscoverageandcareandcontributestothenumberof Americanswithoutinsurance.Documentationandotheradministrativerequirementscause manyeligiblechildrenandfamiliestolosetheirMedicaidcoverageatrenewaltime.This churningpeoplecyclingonandofftheprogramdisruptscoverageandcareandleadsto uninsuredspells.Manystates,whenfiscallystrong,havesteppeduptheirMedicaidoutreach, simplifiedenrollmentandrenewal,andtakenotheractionstopromoteparticipation. However,whenfacedwithdifficultbudgetpressures,stateshaveoftenreducedtheirefforts orevenreinstatedbarriersthatdampenparticipationinanattempttocontrolcosts. Forhealthreformtoachieveitscoveragegoals,effectiveMedicaidoutreachandeasy enrollmentandrenewalprocedureswillbeneeded.Thepotentialofhealthreformtocover millionsoflowincome,uninsuredindividualsandfamiliesiscontingentonimproving participationinMedicaid.Particulareffortswillbeneededtoreachchildlessadults,whoare newtoMedicaid,tointroducetheprogramtothemandmotivatethemtoparticipate. ResearchshowsthateasyproceduresforenrollinginandrenewingMedicaidcoverageare alsonecessarytoconverteligibilitytoparticipation.
CanMedicaidcovermoreoftheuninsured?
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
13
14
Statesarealsopermittedtocovermanyimportantservicesthatfederallawdesignatesas optional.Manyoftheseoptionalservicesareparticularlyvitalforpersonswithchronic conditionsordisabilitiesandtheelderly.Prescriptiondrugs(whichallstatescover),personal careservices,andrehabilitationservicesarejustthreeexamples.Theinclusionofmanyof theseservicesinstateMedicaidprogramsdespitetheiroptionaldesignationinfederal statuteisevidencethat,asapracticalmatter,theyareoftenconsideredessential. Nonetheless,whenstatesareunderseverebudgetstrains,suchasinthecurrenteconomic recession,optionalbenefitslikedentalservicesforadultsareparticularlyvulnerabletocuts. ClosetoonethirdofMedicaidspendingisestimatedtobeattributabletooptionalservices.19 Commonlyofferedoptionalservicesinclude: Prescriptiondrugs Clinicservices Carefurnishedbyotherlicensed practitioners Dentalservicesanddentures Prostheticdevices,eyeglasses,and durablemedicalequipment Rehabilitationandothertherapies Casemanagement Nursingfacilityservicesfor individualsunderage21 Intermediatecarefacilityforindividuals withmentalretardation(ICF/MR) services Homeandcommunitybasedservices (bywaiver) Inpatientpsychiatricservicesfor individualsunderage21 Respiratorycareservicesforventilator dependentindividuals Personalcareservices Hospiceservices
HowareMedicaidbenefitsdifferentfromtypicalprivatehealthbenefits?
ThepediatricMedicaidbenefit,knownasEarlyandPeriodicScreening,Diagnostic,and Treatment(EPSDT),encompassesacomprehensivearrayofhealthservicesforchildren. EPSDTisamandatorybenefitthatentitlesMedicaidenrolleesunderage21toallservices authorizedbyfederalMedicaidlaw,includingservicesconsideredoptionalforother populationsandoftennotcoveredbyprivateinsurance.Inadditiontoscreening,preventive, andearlyinterventionservices,EPSDTcoversdiagnosticservicesandtreatmentnecessaryto correctoramelioratechildrensacuteandchronicphysicalandmentalhealthconditions. Servicesthatareparticularlyimportantforchildrenwithdisabilities,suchasphysicaltherapy, personalcareservices,anddurablemedicalequipment,whichareoftenlimitedorexcluded underprivateinsurance,arecoveredasneededunderEPSDT. TheconceptofmedicalnecessityinEPSDTisexpansive,consistentwithanemphasisin Medicaidonpromotingchildrenshealthydevelopmentandmaximizingtheirhealthand function.Further,thelimitsthatstatesmayimposeonservicesforadultscannotbeappliedto children.Inprincipleatleast,EPSDTrepresentsauniformandcomprehensivefederalbenefit packageforlowincomechildren.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
15
Healthcarereformcreatesnewopportunitiesandincentivesforstatestobalancetheir Medicaidlongtermcaredeliverysystemsbyexpandingaccesstohomeandcommunitybased services.ThenewlawexpandsstatescurrentMedicaidoptionstoprovidehomeand communitybasedbenefits,bothenlargingthescopeofservicescoveredandbroadening financialandfunctionaleligibilitycriteriatoexpandaccesstothesebenefits.Thelawalso providesincreasedfinancialincentivesforstatesthatfurthershifttheirMedicaidlongterm servicestononinstitutionalsettings. SeparatefromMedicaid,thehealthreformlawestablishesanational,voluntaryinsurance programforpurchasingcommunitylivingassistanceservicesandsupports(CLASS).The programwillbefinancedthroughpayrolldeductions;allworkingageadultswillbeenrolled automaticallyunlesstheyoptout.Subjecttoafiveyearvestingperiod,CLASSwillprovide cashbenefitstoindividualswithfunctionallimitationsfornonmedicalservicesandsupports necessarytomaintaincommunityresidence. ThebroadarrayofservicesMedicaidcoversisparticularlyimportantforthecareoflow incomepeoplewithchronicillnessesanddisabilities,whoincludepretermbabies, individualswithmentalillness,peoplelivingwithHIV/AIDS,andmanywithAlzheimers disease.AnotherdistinctivepurposeofMedicaidsistoprovideaccesstocareforpeoplewith disabilitiesandcomplexconditions,whooftenhaveextensiveneedsforbothacutecareand longtermservices.Medicaidscoverageofservicesneededespeciallybysuchindividuals, suchascasemanagement,dentalcare,mentalandbehavioralhealthservices,rehabilitation services,personalcare,andnursingfacilityandhomehealthcare,isadefiningaspectofthe program.MillionsofAmericanswithdiversedisabilitiesandneedsdependonMedicaid. Medicaidisthesinglelargestpublicpayerofmentalhealthcareinoursystem.20Itisalsothe nationslargestsourceofcoverageforpeoplewithHIV,coveringabout40%ofthose estimatedtobereceivingcarefordisease.21
Inadditiontoacutehealthservices,Medicaidcoversawiderangeoflongtermservicesand supportsthatMedicareandmostprivateinsuranceexcludeornarrowlylimit.Medicaidlong termcareservicesincludecomprehensiveservicesprovidedinnursinghomesand intermediatecarefacilitiesforthementallyretarded(ICFMR),aswellasawiderangeof servicesandsupportsneededbypeople,youngandold,toliveindependentlyinthe communityhomehealthcare,personalcare,medicalequipment,rehabilitativetherapy, adultdaycare,casemanagement,respiteforcaregivers,andotherservices.Because Medicareandprivateinsurersprovidelittlecoverageoflongtermcare,Medicaidisbyfarthe largestsourceofassistanceforthesecostlyservices.DrivenpartlybytheSupremeCourts Olmsteaddecisionconcerningthecivilrightsofpeoplewithdisabilitiesinpublicprograms, bothfederalandstateMedicaidpolicyhaveincreasinglysupportedhomeandcommunity basedalternativestoinstitutionallongtermcare.
16
HowdostatesdefinetheirMedicaidbenefitpackages?
Ingeneral,statesmustprovidethesameMedicaidbenefitpackagetoallcategorically eligibleindividualsintheirstate.Generally,federalMedicaidlawrequiresstatestocoverthe samebenefitsforallcategoricallyeligibleindividuals(whethermandatoryoroptional) statewide,andtheservicesmustbecomparable,regardlessofindividualsdiagnosesor conditions.Stateshaveflexibilitytodefinetheamount,duration,andscopeoftheMedicaid servicestheycover,butfederallawrequiresthatcoverageofeachmandatoryandoptional servicebesufficientinamount,duration,andscopetoreasonablyachieveitspurpose. Statescanoffermorelimitedbenchmarkbenefitstosomegroups.IntheDeficitReduction Actof2005,Congresschangedthelawtopermitstatestoprovidesomegroupswithmore limitedbenefitsmodeledonspecifiedbenchmarkplans,andtoofferdifferentbenefitsto differentenrollees.22Statesprovidingbenchmarkorbenchmarkequivalentcoveragemust provideEPSDTwraparoundcoverageforchildren.Mostgroupsareexemptfrombenchmark coverage,includingmandatorypregnantwomenandparents,individualswithsevere disabilities,individualswhoaremedicallyfrailorhavespecialneeds,dualeligibles,peoplewith longtermcareneeds,andspecifiedothergroups.Fewstateshaveusedthenewauthority.Four stateshaveprovideddifferenttiersofbenefitpackagesfordifferentgroups,twoofthem limitingorgrantingaccesstocertainbenefitsbasedonenrolleeshealthbehaviors.*Fourother stateshaveusedtheauthoritytoenhanceMedicaidcoverageforspecifiedpopulations. Medicaidbenefitsvaryconsiderablyacrossthestates.Medicaidbenefitpackagesvarywidely fromstatetostate.Statescoverdifferentoptionalservices.Theyalsodefineamount, duration,andscopedifferently.Exceptwithregardtochildren,statescanplacelimitson coveredservicesforexample,bycappingthenumberofphysicianvisitsorprescription drugsthatareallowed.Finally,whilefederallawincludesamedicallynecessarystandardto ensureappropriateuseofMedicaidservices,statesdefineandapplythemedicalnecessity standardsomewhatdifferently. StatescanimposepremiumsandcostsharinginMedicaidsubjecttosomefederal limitations.In2005,Congressloosenedlongstandingrulesthatsharplyrestrictedstatesuse ofpremiumsandcostsharinginMedicaid.Premiumsremainprohibitedformostchildrenand adultsbelow150%FPL.However,formostchildrenandadultswithincomeabove150%FPL, premiumsaswellascostsharingupto20%ofthecostoftheservicearenowpermitted. Formostservices,costsharingislargelyprohibitedformandatorychildrenanditislimitedto nominallevelsforadultsbelow100%FPL.Forotherchildrenandadultsupto150%FPL,cost sharingislimitedto10%ofthecostoftheservice.Totalcostsharingandpremiumscannot exceed5%offamilyincomeforanyfamily,andcostsharingforpreventivecareisprohibited forchildrenatallincomelevels.Finally,the2005rulesalsogivestatestheoptiontoterminate Medicaidcoverageifpremiumsarenotpaidand,exceptformandatorychildrenandadults under100%FPL,togranthealthcareproviderstherighttodenycareifMedicaidpatientsdo notpaytheircostsharingcharges.23
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
17
HowdoMedicaidenrolleesreceiveservices?
AlthoughMedicaidispubliclyfinanced,theprogrampurchaseshealthservicesprimarilyintheprivatesector. Medicaidisapubliclyfinancedhealthcoverageprogram,butitisnotagovernmentruncaredeliverysystem.On thecontrary,theMedicaidprogramgenerallyprocuresservicesforitsbeneficiariesintheprivatehealthcare market.StatespayhealthcareprovidersforservicesfurnishedtotheirMedicaidbeneficiaries.Medicaid programspurchaseservicesonafeeforservicebasis,orbypayingpremiumstomanagedcareplansunder contracts,orbyusingacombinationofbothapproaches. ManagedcareisthemostcommonhealthcaredeliverysysteminMedicaid.In2008,about70%ofMedicaid enrolleesreceivedsomeoralloftheirservicesthroughmanagedcarearrangements(Figure9).Thetwomain modelsofmanagedcareinMedicaidaremanagedcareorganizations(MCO)andprimarycarecase management(PCCM).MCOsarepaidonacapitationbasisandassumethefinancialriskforcomprehensive Medicaidservicesoradefinedsetofservices(e.g.,ambulatorycare,dentalservices).InPCCM,theprimarycare providerreceivesasmallfeeperpersonpermonthtoprovidebasiccareandcoordinatespecialistcareand otherneededservices,whichareusuallypaidfeeforservice. HealthychildrenandfamiliesmakeupthelionsshareofMedicaidmanagedcareenrollees,butmanystatesare nowenrollingmorecomplexpopulations,includingchildrenandadultswithdisabilitiesandchronicillnessesand dualeligibles,inmanagedcarearrangements.Severalstatesareapplyingmanagedcareprinciplestolongterm care;newinitiativesincludeprojectsthatintegrateacuteandlongtermcarewithinMCOdeliverysystems.24
Figure 9
NH ME
ND MN SD WI MI PA IN KY NC TN OK SC MS TX AL GA OH WV VA NJ DE MD DC NY CT
MA RI
KS
MO
AZ
NM
AR
AK
LA FL
HI
0-50% (5 states) 51-70% (20 states including DC) 71-80% (9 states) 81-100% (17 ( states) )
Note: Unduplicated count. Includes managed care enrollees receiving comprehensive and limited benets. SOURCE: Medicaid Managed Care Enrollment as of December 31, 2008. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
18
Statesareusingavarietyofapproachestobalancetheirlongtermcaredeliverysystemsinfavorof communitysettings.Asthedemandforlongtermservicesinthecommunityisgrowing,effortstomake Medicaidbenefitsmoreflexibleandallowconsumerinvolvementindeterminingandmanagingservicesare expandingacrossthestates.Manystatesallowsomeformofconsumerdirectionofpersonalassistanceservices, givingtheMedicaidbeneficiarymorecontroloverhiring,scheduling,andpayingpersonalcareattendants. Underhealthreform,stateshaveincreasedopportunitiestoexpandaccesstohomeandcommunitybased services,andthelawextendsanexistingdemonstrationprogramthatprovidesstateswithenhancedfederal matchingfundsforeachMedicaidbeneficiarytheytransitionfromaninstitutiontothecommunity. StateshavebuiltdeliverysystemsdesignedtoservetheMedicaidpopulation.Whethertheyusemanaged care,feeforservice,oracombinationofstrategies,manystateshavedevelopedstrongcaredeliverynetworks thatrelyheavilyoncommunityhealthcentersandothersafetynetproviderslocatedinthecommunitieswhere lowincomepeoplereside.Theseprovidersareoftenuniquelypreparedandcompetenttoaddressdiverselow incomepopulationsneedsforservicesandsupports. NewmodelsofcareareemerginginMedicaid.ManystatesarebuildingintotheirPCCMprogramsfeaturesto enhancethecoordinationandmanagementofcareforenrolleeswithchronicillnessesanddisabilities.Some diseaseandcaremanagementprogramsaretargetedtopeoplewithspecificconditions,andotherstarget individualswithmultipleconditions.Anumberofstatesarestructuringpaymentstrategiesandincentivesto supportthepatientcenteredmedicalhomemodelforMedicaidbeneficiaries.Thismodelemphasizes continuousandcomprehensivecare,careteamsdirectedbyapersonalphysician,andcareforallstagesoflife.It alsoseekstoenhanceaccessthroughexpandedhoursandotherimprovements.Informationtechnologyand qualityimprovementactivitiespromotequalityandsafety.
HowisaccesstocareinMedicaid?
Medicaidincreasesaccesstocareandlimitsoutofpocketburdensforlowincomepeople.Childrenandadults enrolledinMedicaidhavemuchbetteraccesstocarethantheuninsured,andpregnantwomencoveredby Medicaidobtainmoretimelyandadequateprenatalcarethantheirlowincome,uninsuredcounterparts.2526 Onkeymeasuresofaccesstopreventiveandprimarycare,Medicaidenrolleesfareaswellaspeoplewith privatehealthinsurance(Figure10).272829Inaddition,Medicaidsstrictlimitsoncostsharinghelptoensure that,forthelowincomeandhighneedpopulationtheprogramserves,costisnotanobstacletoobtaining care.30ResearchshowsthatMedicaidbeneficiariesaresubstantiallylesslikelytofacehighfinancialburdensfor healthcarethanlowincomepeoplewithprivateinsurance.31
Figure 10
Medicaid
Uninsured
39%
Low-Income Adults
Low-Income Women
Low-Income Children
Note: Data are not adjusted for health needs and other covariates. SOURCE: Data on low-income adults and women from Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured analysis of 2007 MEPS. Data on low-income children from Kaiser Family Foundation 2007 Survey of Childrens Health Coverage.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
19
< 70% (11 states including DC) 70-84% (7 states) 85-99% (21 states) 100%+ (11 states)
Note: Tennessee does not have a fee-for-service component in its Medicaid program SOURCE: Zuckerman, Williams, and Stockley, Trends in Medicaid Physician Fees, 2003-2008, Health Aairs, April 28, 2009.
Providerparticipationandsystemsofcareaffectaccess.Anumberofstateshaveachieved gainsinproviderparticipationinMedicaidfollowingincreasesinproviderpaymentand increasedprovideroutreachandsupport.33MCOshavethepotentialtostructureanddelivera networkofproviderstoMedicaidbeneficiarieswho,ontheirowninafeeforservice environment,mighthavedifficultyidentifyingproviderswillingtoservethem.Atthesame time,accessinmanagedcarearrangementsdependsonprovidernetworksthatareadequate tomeettheneedsofMedicaidenrolleesandmechanismsthatconnectenrolleeswithtimely andappropriatecare. TohelpboostaccesstoprimarycareinMedicaid,thehealthreformlawrequiresstatestopay theMedicarepaymentrateforprimarycareservicesfurnishedbyprimarycarephysiciansin 2013and2014andprovidesfullfederalfundingforthisincrease.Thelawalsofundedthe recentlyestablishedMedicaidandCHIPPaymentandAccessCommission(MACPAC),whichis chargedwithmonitoringaccessinthetwoprograms,identifyinggaps,andmaking recommendationsconcerningpaymentandaccessissues.
20
HowdoesMedicaidmonitorandpromotequality?
StatesuseavarietyofdataandpaymentstrategiestoimprovequalityinMedicaid. Increasingly,statesareusingstandardizeddatatobenchmarkandimprovethequalityofcare providedbymanagedcareprogramsandothermedicalproviders.MoststatesrequireMCOs servingMedicaidenrolleestoprovidedataonspecifiedutilizationandperformancemeasures (fromtheHealthcareEffectivenessDataandInformationSet(HEDIS)),andmostalsousethe patientsatisfactionsurveys(ConsumerAssessmentofHealthcareProvidersandSystems (CAHPS))inMCOsasaqualitygauge;asmallernumberofstatesdosoinPCCMandfeefor service.Moreandmorestatesarepubliclyreportingthequalitydatatheycollect,bothtohelp beneficiarieschooseplansbasedonqualityconsiderationsandtodriveimprovementsin providerperformance.AgrowingnumberofstatesrequireorrewardMCOsthatare accreditedbyarecognizedstandardsettingorganization.Finally,payforperformance(P4P) systemsinmoststatesfinanciallyrewardhighperformancebyMCOsand/orphysicians, hospitals,nursinghomes,andotherproviders.34 Statesareusinghealthinformationtechnology(HIT)inavarietyofwaystoimprove qualityandsafetyinMedicaid.Medicaid programsinmoststatesareparticipatingin electronicprescribingandelectronichealthrecord(EHR)orelectronicmedicalrecord (EMR)initiatives topromotebettercoordination ofcare.Somestates areusingMedicaid claimsdata todesignevidencebasedrecommendations forcare;somearefacilitating datasharingamongagenciesandprovidersthatcareforchildren. 35HHSisdevelopinga coresetofchildrenshealthcarequalitymeasuresforchildrenenrolledinMedicaidor CHIPthatwillbeusefulinstateeffortsto evaluatethemeaningfuluseofHIT,a criterionforqualifyingfornewHITpaymentincentivesto providers(describedbelow). SubstantialnewfederalinvestmentsarelikelytofosterincreasedHITinitiativesinMedicaid. ARRAprovided$21.6billioninMedicaidfundingtoencouragephysicians,hospitals,andother healthcareproviderstoadoptandmeaningfullyusecertifiedEHRs.Illustrationsof meaningfuluseincludeuseforelectronicprescribing,electronicexchangeofhealth informationtoimprovequalityofcare,andreportingonclinicalqualitymeasures.Fullfederal fundingisinitiallyavailableforMedicaidincentivepaymentstoeligibleproviderstohelp offsetthecostsofpurchasing,implementing,operating,maintaining,andusingthe technology,training,andothercosts.Generally,toqualifyforincentivepayments,providers mustserveaminimumlevelofMedicaidandotherlowincomepatients.ARRAalsoprovides 90%federalfundingforstatestoadministertheEHRincentives,includingactionsto encourageadoptionofEHRandtrackmeaningfuluse.TheHITinvestmentsareestimatedto generate$12billioninsavingsattributabletoimprovedquality,carecoordination,and reductionsinmedicalerrorsandduplicativecare.ComplementingthefundsforHITincentive paymentsaretwocompetitivegrantprogramsforstates,onetoenablestatestomakeloans toprovidersfortechnologypurchasingandtraining,andanotherforstatestofacilitateand expandelectronicexchangeofhealthinformationamongorganizations.36
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
21
Physician/ Lab/ X-ray 3.7% Outpatient/Clinic 6.8% Drugs 4.5% Other Acute 8.3% Payments to MCOs 20.2%
Medicaid makes special payments to hospitals that serve a disproportionate share of lowincome and uninsured patients. About 5% of Medicaid spending is attributable to supplemental payments to hospitals that serve a disproportionate share of low-income and uninsured patients, known as DSH. DSH payments help to support the safety-net hospitals that provide substantial uncompensated care.
22
WhatdrivesMedicaidspending?
Enrollees
Total = 58 million
Expenditures on benefits
Total = $300 billion
SOURCE: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on 2007 MSIS and CMS64 data.
$2,135
$2,541
Children
Adults
Disabled
Elderly
SOURCE: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on 2007 MSIS and CMS64 data.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
23
Morethan45%ofallMedicaidspendingformedicalservicesisattributabletodualeligibles. In2005,dualeligibleslowincomeindividualswhoareenrolledinbothMedicareandMedicaid madeup18%oftheMedicaidpopulation,butaccountedfor46%ofMedicaidspending.More thanhalfofMedicaidspendingfordualeligiblesisforlongtermcareservices.Until2006, MedicaidprovidedprescriptiondrugcoveragefordualeligiblesbecauseMedicaredidnot includeadrugbenefit.BeginningJanuary2006,Medicarecoversprescriptiondrugsunderthe newPartD,butstatesmakeamonthlyclawbackpaymenttothefederalgovernmenttohelp financethebenefit.Thepaymentsroughlyreflectwhatstateswouldhavespentifthey continuedtopayforoutpatientprescriptiondrugsthroughMedicaidonbehalfoftheirdual eligibles.In2006,stateclawbackpaymentstotaled$6.6billion. DesirablecoordinationbetweenMedicareandMedicaidbenefitsandintegrationofacuteand longtermcarefordualeligibleshaslongbeenapolicygoal.Tosupportimprovedcoordination ofcarefordualeligibles,aswellasbettercoordinatedpayment,thehealthreformlaw establishedafederalCoordinatedHealthCareOfficewithinCMS. ThefivepercentofMedicaidbeneficiarieswiththehighestcostsaccountforoverhalfofall Medicaidspending.Medicaidspendingishighlyskewed;averysmallgroupofhighcostenrollees accountsforalargeshareofMedicaidspending.In2004,the1%ofMedicaidenrolleeswiththe highesthealthandlongtermcarecostsaccountedforonequarterofMedicaidspending,andthe highestcost5%ofenrolleesaccountedfor57%ofallprogramspending(Figure15).Thispattern,in whichthehighcostsofasmallshareofenrolleesdrivetotalspending,holdsineachofMedicaidsfour majoreligibilitygroups.
Figure 15
57%
Top 5% of Spenders
Children 0.3% Ad lt 0.2% 0 2% Adults Disabled 2.3% Elderly 2.2%
SOURCE: Kaiser Commission in Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on 2004 MSIS.
24
HoweffectivelyisMedicaidspendingmanaged?
Medicaidisalowcostprogramwhenthehealthneedsofitsbeneficiariesaretakeninto account.MedicaidspendingishighprimarilybecauseofthehighneedpeopleMedicaid serves.Medicaidenrolleesoverallareinsignificantlyworsehealththanthelowincome, privatelyinsuredpopulation.Whenhealthstatusdifferencesarecontrolledtomakethe Medicaidandlowincome,privatelyinsuredpopulationsmorecomparable,percapita spendingforbothadultsandchildrenislowerinMedicaidthanunderprivateinsurance. Medicaidslowerspendinglevelsareduemostlytoitslowerproviderpaymentrates; differencesinaccesstospecialistsandexpensivetechnologyforthoseinfairorpoorhealth mayalsobeafactor.38 Medicaidspendingpercapitahasnotrisenfasterthanprivatehealthspendingpercapita. Onapercapitabasis,Medicaidacutecarespendinghasbeengrowingatthesamerateas privatehealthspendingandlessthanmonthlypremiumsforprivateinsurance(Figure16). From2000to2008,theincreaseinacutecarespendingperMedicaidenrolleeaveraged5% peryear,asdidgrowthinpercapitaprivatehealthcarespending.Overthesameperiod, monthlypremiumsforjobbasedcoverageforanindividualrose8%peryearonaverage.
Figure 16
AlongwiththehealthneedsoftheMedicaidpopulation,growthinMedicaidenrollmentand risinghealthcarecostsaremajordriversofMedicaidcosts.Between2000and2007, Medicaidenrollmentincreasedfrom31.8millionto42.3million,oratanaverageannualrate of4.2percent.37BetweenJune2008andJune2009,inthemidstofthecurrentrecession, enrollmentgrewby3.3million,or7.5%.SeveralfactorsfuelMedicaidenrollment.Whenstate economiesarestrong,statesseekingtobroadencoveragemayexpandMedicaideligibility.In economicrecessions,joblossandresultinglossesofjobbasedinsuranceanddeclining incomecausemorepeopletoqualifyforMedicaid.Ongoingerosioninemployersponsored insurancecontributesaswell.Medicaidspendingtrendsalsoreflecthealthcarecostinflation, asystemicproblemthatdriveshealthspendingacrossourentiresystem.
Growth in Medicaid Acute Care Spending vs. Private Health Spending, 2000-2008
A Average Annual A lG Growth th 2000 2000-2008: 2008
8% 5% 5%
Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute analysis of MSIS, CMS-64, and Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured/Health Management Associates data, 2010. 2005-07 data adjusted for shift to Medicare of dual eligibles prescription drug spending. 2 National Health Expenditure Accounts, 2010. 3 Kaiser/HRET Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Benets, 2000-2008. Data reported are for single premiums. Family premium growth averaged 8.8% over the period.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
25
Programmanagementtoolsatthefederalandstatelevelhelptoensureproperpayment andimproveMedicaidsefficiency.In2006,CongressestablishedafederalMedicaidIntegrity Program(MIP)withinCMSandprovidedsubstantialresourcesannuallyforaudits, identificationoffraudandabuseandotheroverpayments,educationregardingprogram integrityandqualityofcare,andotherpurposes.39Mostoperationalprogramintegrity responsibilitiesrestwiththestates,buttheMIPgreatlyenlargedthefederalgovernments commitmenttoandCMSaccountabilityforsoundandefficientmanagementoftheMedicaid program. AseparatemechanismforensuringMedicaid(andCHIP)integrityisthePaymentErrorRate MeasurementProgram(PERM).Underthisinitiative,arandomsampleofclaims(bothfeefor serviceandmanagedcare)andeligibilitydeterminationsarereviewedinathirdofthestates eachyeartodetermineerrorrates.Errorsincludepaymentsthatshouldnothavebeenmade orweremadeinthewrongamount,andalsopaymentsthatwereincorrectlydenied.CMS calculatesstateandnationalerrorratesandreportstoHHSandtheOfficeofManagement andBudget.StatesmustsubmitacorrectiveplantoCMSandreimbursethefederal governmentforitsshareofanyoverpayments.
26
NH VT ND MN WI MI PA IN KY OH WV VA NC SC AL GA MD DC NJ DE NY RI CT ME MA
AZ
NM
OK
LA
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
27
HowwelldoesMedicaidsfinancingstructuresupporttheprogram?
StatescommitsubstantialfundstoMedicaid.Onaverage,statesspendabout16%oftheir generalfundsonMedicaid,makingitthesecondlargestiteminmoststatesgeneralfund budgets,followingspendingforelementaryandsecondaryeducation,whichrepresented35%of stategeneralfundspendingin2008.43Medicaidspendingpressuresareaperennialissueatthe statelevel.Thisissobecausestateshavelimitedfiscalcapacitytomeetthemanycompeting demandstheyfaceandmustbalancetheirbudgets.Statebudgetpressuresintensifyduring economicdownturns,whenstaterevenuesdeclinejustasenrollmentinMedicaidandother assistanceprogramsisgrowing. Medicaidisamajorengineinstateeconomies.EconomicresearchshowsthatstateMedicaid spendinghasamultipliereffectasthemoneyinjectedintothestateeconomythroughthe programgeneratessuccessiveroundsofearningandpurchasingbybusinessesandresidents.This economicactivitysupportsjobsandyieldsadditionalincomeandstatetaxrevenues.Compared withotherstatespending,Medicaidspendingisespeciallybeneficialbecauseitalsotriggersan infusionofnewfederaldollarsintothestateeconomy,intensifyingthemultipliereffect.44
Medicaidsfinancingstructuregivesstatesflexibilitytorespondtochangingandemerging needsandsupportsstateeffortstoexpandcoveragetotheuninsured.Whenstatesspend theirdollarsonMedicaid,federalmatchingdollarsfollow.Thematchingsystemincreases statescapacitytorespondtochangesinneeds,economicconditions,anddemographics, andtodisastersandepidemics.Guaranteedfederalmatchingpaymentsprovidean incentivetostatestoinvestinhealthcareanddiscouragethemfromreducingcoverage.At thesametime,statesincentivestocontroltheircostsconstrainstateMedicaidspending, andthus,federalMedicaidspendingaswell. Federalmatchingratesarebasedonlaggeddatathatmaynotreflectcurrenteconomic conditions.TheFMAPformulathatdeterminesthefederalshareofMedicaidspendingin eachstateisbasedontherelationshipbetweenthestatespercapitaincomeandthe nationalaverage.However,becausetheincomedatausedintheFMAPformulaarelagged, astatesmatchratemayreflecteconomicconditionsthatdifferdramaticallyfromcurrent conditions.Forexample,inaneconomicdownturn,somestatesmayactuallyreceivea reducedfederalmatchbecausethedatausedintheFMAPcalculationreflectadifferentset ofeconomiccircumstances.
28
ThecurrentfinancingsystemforMedicaiddoesnotadequatelyaccountforthe countercyclicalnatureoftheprogram.Bydesign,duringeconomicdownturnssuchasthe currentrecession,whenpeoplelosetheirjobsandtheirhealthcoverageandincomedecline, Medicaidexpands.However,economicdownturnsalsocausestatetaxrevenuestoshrink, reducingstatecapacitytoaffordincreasedenrollmentjustwhenitismostlikelytooccur.The currentFMAPformula,whichuseslaggeddataandisbasedsolelyonpercapitaincome,does notprovideaneffectivecountercyclicaladjustmenttoincreasefederalassistancetostates duringeconomicdownturns.ThetemporaryincreaseintheFMAPprovidedbyARRAwasa legislativeresponsetothisproblem.Ineffect,theFMAPincreaseisacountercyclical adjustmentthatbooststhefederalshareofMedicaidcoststemporarily,whilestatesare crunchedbetweenrisingdemandsforMedicaidcoverageanddwindlingcoffersduetothe recession.Asaconditionofreceivingtheenhancedfederalmatch,statescannotreduce Medicaideligibilityorusemorerestrictiverulesfordeterminingeligibility.Similartorelief providedin2003duringthelasteconomicdecline,theARRAFMAPincreasehasbeen instrumentalinhelpingstatestoavoidadditionalanddeeperreductionsintheirMedicaid programs,addressbudgetshortfalls,andpreservecoverage. Underhealthreform,thefederalgovernmentwillfinancethevastmajorityofthecostsof newMedicaidcoverage.Thefederalstatefinancingpartnershipthatsupportsthecurrent Medicaidprogramwillcontinueunderhealthreform.However,thecostofthenewMedicaid coveragestemmingfromhealthreformwillbefullyfinancedbythefederalgovernmentinthe firstthreeyearsofreform(20142016);insubsequentyears,thefederalgovernmentwill continuetofinancethelionsshare,phasingdownto90%in2020andthereafter.Overall, federalfundswillfinance96%ofthecostoftheMedicaidexpansionoverthefirstdecade.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
29
30
Financing.About16millionmorepeopleareprojectedtogainMedicaidorCHIPcoverage by2019duetotheexpansionofMedicaideligibilityandincreasedparticipationthatis expectedasthepublicrespondstohealthreform.TheCongressionalBudgetOffice estimatesthatthefederalgovernmentwillfinanceabout96%ofthecoverageincreases associatedwithreformbetween2010and2019($434billion),andstateswillcontribute4% ($20billion). Asthenationpreparestoimplementhealthreform,understandingMedicaidismoreimportant thanever.Keyinformationabouthowtheprogramoperatesandfitsintooursystemtodaycan helptogroundpolicymakersandtheinterestedpublic,orientingthemtoMedicaidscurrent scopeandrole,whileprovidingperspectiveonhowhealthreformreshapestheprogramforthe future,preparingitforthecentralroleitistoplayinthenationalplanforcoveringourpeople.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
31
Endnotes
Holahan and Garrett, Rising Unemployment, Medicaid, and the Uninsured, prepared for the Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, January 2009. #7850. 2 Georgetown University Health Policy Institute analysis of data from the 2005 National Health Interview Survey and 2004 National Nursing Home Survey. See Medicaid and Long-Term Care Services and Supports, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, February 2009. #2186-06. 3 Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured estimates based on CMS National Health Accounts data, 2008. 4 Medicaid and Long-Term Care Services and Supports. 5 Americas Public Hospitals and Health Systems, 2004, National Association of Public Hospitals and Health Systems, October 2006; Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured analysis of 2006 UDS Data from Health Resources and Services Administration. 6 Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act ( P.L. 104-193). 7 Childrens Health Insurance Program Reauthorization Act of 2009 (P.L. 111-3). 8 Section 6036 of the Decit Reduction Act of 2005, (P.L. 109-171). 9 Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on data from FY 2007 MSIS, 2010. 10 http://www.cms.hhs.gov/Nationa lSCHIPPolicy/downloads/SCHIPEverEnrolledYearFY2007FINAL.PDF . 11 MCH Update 2005: State Coverage of Pregnant Women and Children, National Governors Association Center for Best Practices. 2006. Medicaids Role in Family Planning, Kaiser Family Foundation and Guttmacher Institute, October 2007. #7064-03. 12 National Survey on the Publics Views about Medicaid, 2005, Kaiser Family Foundation. #7338 13 2007 Kaiser Survey of Childrens Health Coverage, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured; Rising Health Pressures in an Economic Recession: A 360-Degree Look at Four Communities, August 2009, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7949; Enrolling Children in Medicaid and SCHIP: Insights from Focus Groups with LowIncome Parents, May 2007, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7640. 14 A Foundation for Health Reform: Findings of a 50-State Survey of Eligibility Rules, Enrollment and Renewal Procedures, and Cost-Sharing Practices in Medicaid and CHIP for Children and Parents During 2009, December 2009, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #8028. 15 Where Are States Today? Medicaid and State-Funded Coverage Eligibility Levels for Low-Income Adults, December 2009, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7993 16 Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured/Urban Institute analysis of 2009 ASEC Supplement to the Current Population Survey. 17 Where Are States Today? op.cit. 18 Medicaid Citizenship Documentation Requirement is Taking a Toll, February 2007 and New Childrens Health Law Reduces Harmful Impact of Documentation Requirement, April 2009, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. 19 Medicaid Enrollment and Spending by Mandatory and Optional Eligibility and Benet Categories, June 2005, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7332 20 Mark et al., Mental Health Treatment Expenditure Trends, 1986-2003, Psychiatric Services 58(8), August 2007. 21 Medicaid and HIV/AIDS, February 2009, Kaiser Family Foundation. #7172-04 22 Decit Reduction Act. op.cit. 23 Cost-Sharing and Premiums in Medicaid: What Rules Apply? February 2007, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. 24 The Crunch Continues: Medicaid Spending, Coverage and Policy in the Midst of a Recession. Results from a 50-State Medicaid Budget Survey for State Fiscal Years 2009 and 2010, September 2009, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7985. 25 Medicaid Beneciaries and Access to Care, April 2010, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #800002. 26 Marquis and Long, The Role of Public Insurance and the Public Delivery System in Improving Birth Outcomes for Low-Income Pregnant Women, Medical Care 40(11), November 2002. 27 Perry and Kenney, Preventive Care for Children in Low-Income Families: How Well Do Medicaid and State Childrens Health Insurance Programs Do? Pediatrics 120(6), December 2007. 28 Selden and Hudson, Access to Care and Utilization Among Children: Estimating the Eects of Public and Private Coverage, Medical Care 44(5 Suppl), May 2006. 29 Long et al., How Well Does Medicaid Work in Improving Access to Care? Health Services Research 40(1), February 2005. 30 Alker et al., Children and Health Care Reform: Assuring Coverage that Meets their Health Care Needs, September 2009, Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured. #7980.
1
32
ShenandMcFeeters,OutofPocketHealthSpendingBetweenLowandHigherIncomePopulations:WhoisatRisk ofHavingHighExpensesandHighBurdens?MedicalCare44(3),March2006. 32 Zuckermanetal.,TrendsinMedicaidPhysicianFees20032008,HealthAffairsWebExclusive28(3),April2009. 33 Nietertetal.,TheImpactofanInnovativeReformtotheSouthCarolinaDentalMedicaidSystem,HealthServices Research40(4),August2005. 34 TheCrunchContinues.op.cit. 35 EHealthSnapshot:ALookatEmergingHealthInformationTechnologyforChildreninMedicaidandSCHIP Programs,November2008,KaiserCommissiononMedicaidandtheUninsuredandTheChildrensPartnership. #7837. 36 FederalSupportforHealthInformationTechnologyinMedicaid:KeyProvisionsintheAmericanRecoveryand ReinvestmentAct,August2009,KaiserCommissiononMedicaidandtheUninsuredandTheChildrensPartnership. #7955. 37 HolahanandYemane,EnrollmentisDrivingMedicaidCostsButTwoTargetsCanYieldSavings,HealthAffairs 28(5),September/October2009. 38 HadleyandHolahan,IsHealthCareSpendingHigherunderMedicaidorPrivateInsurance?Inquiry40,Winter 2003/2004. 39 DeficitReductionAct.op.cit. 40 http://www.statehealthfacts.org/comparemapreport.jsp?rep=45&cat=17. 41 StateExpenditureReport2008,Fall2009,NationalAssociationofStateBudgetOfficers. 42 BudgetoftheUnitedStatesGovernment,FiscalYear2009,U.S.OfficeofManagementandBudget. 43 StateExpenditureReport2008.op.cit. 44 Medicaid:GoodMedicineforStateEconomies,May2004,FamiliesUSA;TheRoleofMedicaidinStateEconomies:A LookattheResearch,January2009,KaiserCommissiononMedicaidandtheUninsured.#7075.
31
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
33
TABLES
Table 1: Medicaid Expenditures by Type of Service, FFY 2008 Table 2: Federal Medical Assistance Percentages, FY 2006-2010 Table 3: Medicaid Enrollment by Group, FFY 2007 Table 4: Medicaid Payments by Group, FFY 2007 Table 5: Medicaid Payments Per Enrollee by Group, FFY 2007 Table 6: Medicaid Income Eligibility as a Percent of Federal Poverty Level (FPL), 2009
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
35
Table 1
Source: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on data from CMS (Form 64). Note: Does not include administrative costs, accounting adjustments, or the U.S. Territories. Total Medicaid spending including these additional items was $352.1 billion in FFY 2008. Figures may not sum to totals due to rounding. * Acute care services include inpatient, physician, lab, X-ray, outpatient, clinic, prescription drugs, family planning, dental, vision, other practitioners'' care, payments to managed care organizations, and payments to Medicare. ** Long-term care services include nursing facilities, intermediate care facilities for the mentally retarded, mental health, home health services, and personal care support services. "DSH" refers to disproportionate share hospital payments.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
37
Table 2
Source: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured calculations based on FFY 2006-2009 FMAPs as published in the Federal Register as follows: FY 2006 FMAP Vol. 69, No. 226, pp. 68370-28373; FY 2007 FMAP Vol. 70, No. 229, pp. 71856-71857; FY 2008 FMAP Vol. 71, No. 230, pp. 69209-6921 FY 2009 FMAP Vol. 74, No. 234, pp. 64697-64700; FY 2010 FMAP Vol . 75, No. 83, pp. 22807-22809 Note: FY2006 and FY2007 for Alaska are from Federal Register, May 15, 2006 (Vol. 71, No. 93), pp. 28041-28042. FY 2009 and FY2010 FMAPs relfect additional federal Medicaid funding available through the American Recover and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009, P.L. 111-5. * FY 2009 FMAPs are for the 4th Quarter of that scal year, and FY2010 FMAPs are for the 2nd Quarter of 2010.
38
Table 3
Note: Totals may not sum due to rounding. Source: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on data from FY 2007 MSIS, 2010.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
39
Table 4
Source: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on data from FY 2007 MSIS and CMS-64 reports, 2010.
40
Table 5
Source: Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured and Urban Institute estimates based on data from FY 2007 MSIS and CMS-64 reports, 2010. Note: Data in this table do not include spending when the service or basis of eligibility of the enrollee is unknown; national per capita spending amounts shown elsewhere in this report are adjusted to include this unknown spending and dier slightly from the totals shown here.
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
41
Table 6
State Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming
Infants 133% 175% 140% 200% 200% 133% 185% 200% 300% 200% 200% 300% 133% 200% 200% 300% 150% 185% 200% 200% 300% 200% 185% 280% 185% 185% 133% 200% 133% 300% 200% 235% 200% 200% 133% 200% 185% 133% 185% 250% 185% 140% 185% 185% 133% 300% 133% 200% 150% 300% 133%
Children 1-5 133% 175% 133% 200% 133% 133% 185% 133% 300% 133% 133% 300% 133% 133% 150% 133% 133% 150% 200% 150% 300% 150% 150% 275% 133% 150% 133% 200% 133% 185% 133% 235% 133% 200% 133% 200% 185% 133% 133% 250% 150% 140% 133% 133% 133% 300% 133% 200% 133% 300% 133%
Children 6-19 100% 175% 100% 200% 100% 100% 185% 100% 300% 100% 100% 300% 133% 133% 150% 133% 100% 150% 200% 150% 300% 150% 150% 275% 100% 150% 133% 200% 100% 185% 133% 235% 100% 100% 100% 200% 185% 100% 100% 250% 150% 140% 100% 100% 100% 300% 133% 200% 100% 300% 100%
Pregnant Women 133% 175% 150% 200% 200% 200% 250% 200% 300% 185% 200% 185% 133% 200% 200% 300% 150% 185% 200% 200% 250% 200% 185% 275% 185% 185% 150% 185% 185% 185% 200% 235% 200% 185% 133% 200% 185% 185% 185% 250% 185% 133% 250% 185% 133% 200% 200% 185% 150% 300% 133%
Working Parents* Childless Adults* 24% 81% 106% 17% 106% 66% 191% 121% 207% 53% 50% 100% 27% 185% 25% 83% 32% 62% 25% 206% 116% 133% 64% 215% 44% 25% 56% 58% 88% 49% 200% 67% 150% 49% 59% 90% 47% 40% 34% 181% 89% 52% 129% 26% 44% 191% 29% 74% 33% 200% 52% NA NA 110% NA NA NA NA 110% NA NA NA 100% (closed) NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 100% NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 160% NA NA NA NA NA
Source: A Foundation for Health Reform: Findings of a 50 State Survey of Eligibility Rules, Enrollment and Renewal Procedures, and Cost-Sharing Practices in Medicaid and CHIP for Children and Parents During 2009 . Data based on a national survey conducted by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities for the Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured, December 2009. Available at http://www.k.org/medicaid/kcmu120809pkg.cfm. See note below for source of parents and childless adult eligibility levels * Eligibility for Medicaid or Medicaid Look-Alike coverage. For eligibility levels for programs oering more limited coverage or premium assistance, please see Where Are States Today: Medicaid and StateFunded Coverage Eligibility Levels for Low-Income Adults , Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured analysis of state policies through program websites and contacts with state ocials, December 2009. Available at: http://www.k.org/medicaid/upload/7993.pdf.
42
Filling an Urgent Need: Improving Childrens Access to Dental Care in Medicaid and SCHIP
http://www.k.org/medicaid/7792.cfm
Summary of Coverage Provisions in the Patient Protection and Aordable Care Act
http://www.k.org/healthreform/8023.cfm
Medicaid and Childrens Health Insurance Program Provisions in the New Health Reform Law
http://www.k.org/healthreform/7952.cfm
Optimizing Medicaid Enrollment: Perspectives on Strengthening Medicaids Reach Under Health Care Reform
http://www.k.org/healthreform/8068.cfm
Expanding Medicaid under Health Reform: A Look at Adults at or below 133% of Poverty
http://www.k.org/healthreform/8052.cfm
Financing New Medicaid Coverage Under Health Reform: The Role of Federal Government and States
http://www.k.org/healthreform/8072.cfm
Medicaid Long-Term Services and Supports: Key Changes in the Health Reform Law
http://www.k.org/healthreform/8079.cfm
Medicare: A Primer
http://www.k.org/medicare/7615.cfm
MEDICAID: A PRIMER
43
www.kff.org
This report (#7334-04) is available on the Kaiser Family Foundations website at www.kff.org.
The Kaiser Family Foundation is a non-profit private operating foundation, based in Menlo Park, California, dedicated to producing and communicating the best possible analysis and information on health issues.