Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Question Paper
Security Analysis (MB331F) : April 2008
Section A : Basic Concepts (30 Marks)
This section consists oI questions with serial number 1 - 30.
Answer all questions.
Each question carries one mark.
Maximum time Ior answering Section A is 30 Minutes.
1. Which oI the Iollowing is a non-security Iorm oI investment media?
(a) National Savings Scheme
(b) Equity shares
(c) PreIerence shares
(d) Debentures
(e) Gilts.
<ArsWer>
2. In which oI the Iollowing stages oI an industry liIe cycle, the product penetrates the market place and becomes
more commonly used?
(a) Pioneering stage
(b) Expansion stage
(c) Stabilization stage
(d) Declining stage
(e) Maturity stage.
<ArsWer>
3. The Iunction(s) oI secondary market is/are
I. Maintenance oI competitive prices oI securities.
II. Providing liquidity to investors.
III. To bring the savers and users oI Iunds together.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Only (III) above
(d) Both (I) and (II) above
(e) Both (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
4. Closing prices oI the stock oI First Global Ltd., are given below:
Day Closing Price (Rs.)
1 230.50
2 235.50
3 222.10
4 225.10
5 230.10
The relative strength oI the stock is
(a) 0.9952
(b) 1.0366
(c) 1.0925
(d) 1.1125
(e) 1.1175.
<ArsWer>
5. H-Model is suitable Ior the Iirms which have a
(a) High growth rate in the beginning
(b) Modest growth rate in the beginning
(c) Stable growth rate
(d) Low growth rate in the beginning
(e) Sudden change in the growth rate.
<ArsWer>
. A Iully redeemable non-convertible debenture secured by speciIic movable and immovable assets oI the
company is reIerred as
<ArsWer>
2
company is reIerred as
(a) Triple Option Debenture
(b) Auction Rated Debenture
(c) Secured Premium Notes
(d) Floating Rate Bonds
(e) Zero Interest Debentures.
7. As per Strong Form oI EIIicient Market Hypothesis
(a) Stock prices reIlect private inIormation only
(b) Stock prices reIlect public inIormation only
(c) Stock prices reIlect both public and private inIormation
(d) Prices reIlect to inIormation that is available to everybody
(e) In super strong version oI strong Iorm, conIidential inIormation available is highly signiIicant.
<ArsWer>
8. Dow theory
(a) Describes direction oI the market trends
(b) Attempts to Iorecast Iuture movements
(c) Estimates duration oI market trends
(d) Estimates size oI market trends
(e) Uses behavior oI stock market as the basis oI Iorecasting stock prices.
<ArsWer>
9. In which oI the Iollowing contracts, the buyer limits the down risk to the extent oI premium paid?
(a) Futures
(b) Options
(c) Forwards
(d) Swaps
(e) Badla.
<ArsWer>
10. Warrants that are attached to host debentures and can be exercised only iI the host debenture is surrendered are
reIerred to as
(a) Detachable warrants
(b) Puttable warrants
(c) Wedding warrants
(d) Naked warrants
(e) Callable warrants.
<ArsWer>
11. Which oI the Iollowing is/are not a clear bearish signal?
I. Head & Shoulders.
II. Double bottom.
III. Triangle.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Only (III) above
(d) Both (I) and (II) above
(e) Both (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
12. Mutual Iunds that are engaged in speculative and risky investments like short sales to take advantage oI declining
market are known as
(a) PerIormance Funds
(b) Exchange Rated Funds
(c) Specialized Funds
(d) Growth Funds
(e) Leveraged Funds.
<ArsWer>
13. Which oI the Iollowing is/are diversiIiable risk(s) Ior an investor?
I. Sector risk.
II. Technological risk.
III. Market risk.
IV. Management risk.
(a) Only (II) above
(b) Only (III) above
(c) Both (I) and (II) above
<ArsWer>
3
(c) Both (I) and (II) above
(d) Both (I) and (IV) above
(e) (I), (II) and (IV) above.
14. A bond`s duration equals its maturity under which oI the Iollowing condition(s)?
I. The bond`s coupon rate equals the market interest rate.
II. The bond pays no coupon.
III. The bond is a deep discount bond.
IV. The bond pays a single period cash Ilow.
(a) Only (II) above
(b) Both (II) and (III) above
(c) Both (II) and (IV) above
(d) (I), (II) and (III) above
(e) (II), (III) and (IV) above.
<ArsWer>
15. The standard deviation oI Satyam stock is 25 and its correlation coeIIicient with the market portIolio is 0.6.
The expected return on market is 15 with standard deviation oI 22. II the risk Iree rate is 5, the required
rate oI return on this stock is
(a) 9
(b) 10
(c) 11
(d) 12
(e) 13.
<ArsWer>
1. II a vertical rally or a decline is interrupted by a consolidation pattern similar to a rectangle, such a Iormation is
called
(a) Pennant
(b) Saucer
(c) Flag
(d) Rounding top
(e) Envelopes.
<ArsWer>
17. Superconductors Ltd., is a Iirm that manuIactures electronic equipments, has strong equity base oI Rs.10,000
crore. The debt equity ratio oI the Iirm has been Iound to be 0.15. The total debt oI the Iirm is
(a) Rs. 500 crore
(b) Rs. 600 crore
(c) Rs.1,200 crore
(d) Rs.1,500 crore
(e) Rs.2,000 crore.
<ArsWer>
18. The beta oI stock A is 2.0 and is currently in equilibrium. The required return on the stock is 15 and the
expected return on the market is 10. Suddenly due to economic conditions, the expected return on the market
increases to 15. Other things remaining the same, what would be the new required return on the stock?
(a) 17.5
(b) 20.0
(c) 22.5
(d) 25.0
(e) 30.0.
<ArsWer>
19. Which oI the Iollowing is not a leading economic indicator?
(a) Utilization oI manuIacturing capacity
(b) Residential construction
(c) Corporate proIits
(d) Level oI stock prices
(e) Unemployment.
<ArsWer>
20. A convertible bond with a Iace value oI Rs.1,000 has been issued at Rs.1,350 with a coupon rate oI 12. The
conversion rate is 25 shares per bond. The current market price oI the bond is Rs.1,500 and that oI the stock is
Rs.45. The premium over the conversion value is
(a) 11.11
(b) 22.22
(c) 33.33
(d) 35.35
<ArsWer>
1
(d) 35.35
(e) 43.33.
21. II a stock is purchased at Rs.50 and a Rs.55 call is written Ior a premium oI Rs.2, the maximum possible gain per
share is
(a) Rs. 2
(b) Rs. 5
(c) Rs. 7
(d) Rs. 8
(e) Rs.10.
<ArsWer>
22. The Iollowing inIormation pertains to Sonix Ltd.:
ROA 15
Book value Rs.20
Total assets/Net worth 2.00
The EPS oI Sonix Ltd., is
(a) Rs. 6
(b) Rs.10
(c) Rs. 3
(d) Rs.40
(e) Rs. 9.
<ArsWer>
23. Which oI the Iollowing statements is/are false about Iorward contract?
I. It is an over-the-counter product.
II. Unlike Iutures, Iorward contract is standardized in terms oI quality, quantity and terms oI delivery.
III. Unlike Iutures, Iorward contracts are traded in an organized exchange.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Only (III) above
(d) Both (I) and (II) above
(e) Both (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
24. Which oI the Iollowing statements is/are true regarding the characteristic line?
I. It signiIies the average or normal trade oII between risk and return Ior a group oI securities.
II. The slope oI the characteristic line is the beta oI the stock.
III. The intercept alpha represents the diIIerence between the actual return and the normal return Ior their risk.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Only (III) above
(d) Both (I) and (II) above
(e) All (I), (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
25. Which oI the Iollowing technique is used to identiIy the trend reversal beIore it takes place?
(a) Volume oI the market
(b) Momentum
(c) Simple moving average
(d) Breadth oI the market
(e) Weighted moving average.
<ArsWer>
2. Which oI the Iollowing Iactor(s) determine(s) the price oI a callable convertible bond?
I. Call premium on the call issuer`s stock.
II. Call premium on an equivalent nonconvertible bond.
III. Price oI equivalent nonconvertible bond.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Both (I) and (II) above
(d) Both (II) and (III) above
(e) All (I), (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
27. The stock oI Firodia Chemicals has the Iollowing parameters:
<ArsWer>
5
Beta 1.21
Expected return 15
The risk Iree rate oI return is 8 and the market return is 16. The ex-ante alpha () oI Firodia Chemicals is
(a) 4.89
(b) 2.68
(c) 2.68
(d) 4.89
(e) 3.87.
28. Market breadth cannot be analyzed using
(a) Advance-Decline lines
(b) DiIIusion index
(c) Stocks in positive trend
(d) High-low statistics
(e) Rate oI change.
<ArsWer>
29. Which oI the Iollowing statements is/are true?
I. Firms with low proIit margins and high P/S ratio are overvalued.
II. Firms with high proIit margins and low P/S ratio are undervalued.
III. Firms with low proIit margins and low P/S ratio are correctly valued.
(a) Only (I) above
(b) Only (II) above
(c) Both (I) and (III) above
(d) Both (II) and (III) above
(e) All (I), (II) and (III) above.
<ArsWer>
30. Which oI the Iollowing theories states that the shape oI the yield curve is dependent on the supply and demand oI
securities available within each maturity sector?
(a) PreIerred habitat theory
(b) Liquidity premium theory
(c) Pure expectations theory
(d) Relative strength theory
(e) Segmentation market theory.
<ArsWer>
END OF SECTION A
Section B : Problems/Caselet (50 Marks)
This section consists oI questions with serial number 1 5.
Answer all questions.
Marks are indicated against each question.
Detailed workings/explanations should Iorm part oI your answer.
Do not spend more than 110 - 120 minutes on Section B.
1. Given below is the distribution oI conditional returns and explicit probability
distribution oI stocks oI Excel Ltd., and Delux Ltd.:
Conditional Returns
Probability
Excel Ltd. Delux Ltd.
10 60 5
20 50 15
40 40 25
20 30 35
10 20 50
You are required to:
a. Calculate the expected returns, standard deviations oI returns Ior both the
stocks and correlation co-eIIicient between the stocks.
(
6 marks)
<ArsWer>
b. Determine the expected rate oI return oI a zero-risk portIolio consisting oI
the above stocks.
(
5 marks)
= = = =
= +
= + = + = =
R R R R
CovR R
R
CovR R
R
R R R R
orR
TOP
~
16. C
II a verical rally or a decline is interrupted by a consolidation pattern similar to a
rectangle, such a Iormation is called a Ilag.
Hence, option (c) is the correct answer.
TOP
~
17. D
Debt
0.15
Equity
0.15 10000 .1500
=
= = Debt Rs Crore
TOP
~
18. D 15 R
I
2 (10 R
I
)
i.e., R
I
20 15 5
Revised R 5 2 (15 5) 25
TOP
~
19. E The lead indicator approach is an important Iorecasting method to Iorecast the general
economic conditions by identiIying economic indicators that turn ahead oI the change
in general level oI economic activity. Some oI the leading economic indicators are the
utilization oI manuIacturing capacity, residential construction, corporate proIits, and
the general level oI stock prices.
All the Iirst Iour alternatives are the leading economic indicators, while the last
alternative is a lagging economic indicator.
ThereIore answer is (e).
TOP
~
20. C
Premium over conversion value
Bond price - Conversion value
Conversion value
Conversion value Current market price oI the stock x Conversion rate
45 x 25
TOP
~
11
Rs.1,125
Premium over conversion value
1,500 - 1,125
0.3333
1,125
=
33.33
Hence (c) is the answer.
21. C The maximum possible gain per share when spot price exceeds strike price oI Rs.55 is
(55502) Rs.7.
TOP
~
22. A EPS ROE Book value
Where ROE ROA Asset to equity ratio
EPS 0.15 2 20 Rs.6
Hence option (a) is the answer.
TOP
~
23.
E Forwards are over-the-counter products i.e; they are not traded in organised location
called as exchange. Futures are standardized contracts in terms oI quality, quantity and
terms oI delivery. Forward contracts are not standardized and terms are structured to
meet the needs oI both the contracting parties. A separate clearinghouse clears Iutures
contracts whereas in Iorward contracts such Iacility is not available.
TOP
~
24.
B Characteristic Line is the line oI best Iit between the actual observation oI security
returns and market returns whereas security market line represents the average oI
normal trade oII between risk and return group oI securities. Hence, statement I is not
true. A characteristic line is represented by the equation r
it
a
i
i
r
mt
, where r
it
is the
return on the security, r
mt
is the return oI the market index,
i
is the slope oI the
characteristic line. Hence, statement II is true. In the above equation, a
i
is the intercept
term which represents the average return on the security when the market index return
is zero. Hence, statement III is not true. Hence the answer is (b).
TOP
~
25.
B
Momentum is used to identiIy the trend reversal beIore it takes place.
ThereIore, Option (b) is the correct answer.
TOP
~
26. E Call premium on the call issuer`s stock ,call premium on an equivalent nonconvertible
bond and price oI equivalent nonconvertible bond all combinedly determine the value
oI a callable convertible bond.
TOP
~
27. B Using CAPM,
R (R)
i
R
I
i
(R
m
R
I
)
R (R
i
) 8 1.21 (16 8) 17.68
E(R
i
) R(R
i
) 15 17.68 2.68
TOP
~
28. E Apart Irom Advance-Decline lines, breadth oI the market can be analyzed using:
i. Stocks in positive trend
ii. DiIIusion index
iii. High-low statistics
iv. Percentage oI stocks over a moving average.
Hence (e) is the answer.
TOP
~
29. E
Firms with low porIit amrgins and high P/S ratios are overvalued and those with high
porIit margin and low P/S ratio are undervalued. Fims with low proIit amrgin and low
P/S ratio are correctly priced. Hence, all the statements mentioned above are true.
Hence, option (e) is the correct answer.
TOP
~
30. E The segmentation market theory states that the shape oI the yield curve is dependent
on the supply and demand oI the securities available within each segment.
TOP
~
12
Section B : Problems/Caselet
1. a. Exce| Ltd.
R
(S)
P
i
R
S
P
i
(R
S
E
(S)
) Pi|(R
S
E(E
S
)|
2
60 0.10 6 20 40
50 0.20 10 10 20
40 0.40 16 0 0
30 0.20 6 10 20
20 0.10 2 20 40
P|R3 = 10
P|[(R3 - E(E3)|
2
= 120
E(3) = 10
3 =
120
= 10.95.
0e|ux Ltd.
R
(DE)
P
i
R
(DE)
P
i
(R
DE
E
(DE)
) P
i
(R
DE
E
DE
)
2
5 0.10 0.50 20.5 42.025
15 0.20 3.0 10.5 22.050
25 0.40 10.0 0.50 0.100
35 0.20 7.0 9.5 18.05
50 0.10 5.0 24.5 60.025
P| R(0E) = 25.5
P| (R0E - E0E)
2
=112.25
E(0e) = 2.5
0E =
142.25
= 11.93
Covariance between two stocks
P
i
(R
S
E
S
) (R
DE
E
DE
)
Pi (R
S
E
S
) x (R
DE
E
DE
)
0.10 20 20.5 41
0.20 10 10.5 21
0.40 0 0.50 0
0.20 10 9.5 19.0
0.10 20 24.5 49
P| (R3 - E3) x (R0E - E0E)
C0v(3 &0E) = - 130
Corre|al|or coell|c|erl =
COV
SDE
DE S
=
130
10.95 11.93
= - 1
3|rce lre corre|al|or oelWeer lWo sloc|s |s -1. A zero r|s| porllo||o car oe corslrucled us|rg lrese
sloc|s.
ll w1 ard w2 |s proporl|or ol |rveslrerl |r Exce| ard 0e|ux sloc|s. Tre porllo||o r|s| W||| oe
o.
2
p
=
2 1 2 1 12
2
2
2
2
2
1
2
1
W W 2 W W + +
2
p
=
2 1 2 1
2
2
2
2
2
1
2
1
W W ) 1 ( 2 W W + +
p
= (w1 1 - w2 2)
2
TOP
~
13
p
= w1 1 - w2 2
0 = w1 1 - w2 2
w1 1 = w2 2 (|)
Aga|r w1 w2 = 1
or w2 = 1 - w1 (||)
Pull|rg lre va|ue ol w2 |r equal|or (|)
w1 1 = (1 - w1)2
w13 = (1 - w1)0E
10.95 w1 = (1 - w1) 11.93
(10.95 11.93) w1 = 11.93
w1 =
11.93
(10.95 11.93) +
= 52.11
w2 = 1 - 0.5211= 0.1Z8 = 1Z.8
Expecled relurr ol r|s| lree porllo||o
= 0.5211 10 0.1Z8 25.5
= 33.0.
2. a. YTM oI the bond
950 107.5 PVIFA
(k, 6)
1000 PVIF
(k, 6)
at k 12
R.H.S. 948.6
at k 10.75
R.H.S. 1,000
YTM 10.75 12.5
1000 950
1000 948.6
11.97
Current yield
107.5
950
11.32
Duration
c
d
r
r
(PVIFA
(k, n)
) (1 k)
c
d
r
1 n
r
(11.97, 6)
0.1132 0.1132
PVIFA (1.1197) 1 6
0.1197 0.1197
+
0.9457 4.115 1.1197 0.3258
4.683 years.
b. change in price MD y
4.683
0.50
1.1197
2.091
New price 950 (1 0.02091)
Rs.930.14.
TOP
~
3.
Days Price changes
X Y X
2
Y
2
XY
1 1.4500 17.7500 2.1025 315.0625 25.7375
2 16.7500 6.1000 280.5625 37.2100 102.1750
3 -3.0000 6.0500 9.0000 36.6025 -18.1500
4 5.4500 -6.2000 29.7025 38.4400 -33.7900
5 -1.4500 -5.7000 2.1025 32.4900 8.2650
6 8.1500 20.5500 66.4225 422.3025 167.4825
TOP
~
11
6 8.1500 20.5500 66.4225 422.3025 167.4825
7 5.3500 -2.5500 28.6225 6.5025 -13.6425
8 -1.9500 3.5000 3.8025 12.2500 -6.8250
9 1.1000 2.1000 1.2100 4.4100 2.3100
Days Price changes
X Y X
2
Y
2
XY
10 8.0500 -7.9000 64.8025 62.4100 -63.5950
11 -1.0000 -16.1000 1.0000 259.2100 16.1000
12 19.4000 -4.4000 376.3600 19.3600 -85.3600
Total 58.3000 13.2000 865.6900 1246.2500 100.7075
Mean 4.8583 1.1000
= 4.8583 Y = 1.1
2
X 865.6900 X 58.3000 = =
2
Y 1246.2500 Y 13.2000 = =
XY 100.7075
r
2
2
2 2
a Y b XY n (Y)
Y n(Y)
a Y bX
+
=
b
2 2
XY n XY
X n(X)
2
100.7075 12(4.8583) (1.1)
865.69 12(4.8583)
0.0628
a 1.1 (0.0628) (4.8583) 0.7945
r
2
2
2
0.7945 13.2 (0.0628) (100.7075) 12 (1.1)
1246.25 12 (1.1)
+
2.29
1231.73
0.0019
Hence, there is a small degree oI correlation between the returns oI two periods and thereIore we
can conclude that index moved in a random manner.
4. The major drivers oI real estate boom in India may be attributed to a number oI Iactors like:
Strong economic growth backed by IT, IT-enabled services and Knowledge Process
Outsourcing (KPO), creating increased demand Ior more space.
Shortage oI quality real estate.
Expansion oI retail sector due to consumerism, changing liIestyles, and better income level.
High rate oI return in real estate.
With increase in IT and IT-enabled services and low operating cost being the driver, they
are moving towards Tier-II and Tier-III cities as the space is available at cheaper rates as
compared to Tier-I cities and also the growth in Tier-I cities has already reached a
saturation point.
Good amount oI disposable income with the investors.
Favorable government policy as Iar as real estate sector is concerned like liberalizing the
FDI norms in this sector.
Gradual improvement in inIrastructure.
TOP
~
5. The REMFs are introduced Ioreseeing the number oI advantages such as, the REMF would
result in an increased Ilow oI Iunds towards housing sector and provide more liquidity in the
mutual Iunds industry. They would bring proIessionalism in the mutual Iund industry thereby
TOP
~
15
hiring legal proIessionals who will evaluate and give judgments on legal matters pertaining to
property, thereby reducing risk chances as Iar as deIective titles are concerned. Facilities
management will come into picture as proIessionals are employed to provide services to keep the
property in good shape. Added to this, the retail investors will be beneIited in the terms that they
can invest small amount in real estate, which is not possible otherwise. Further, REMF would
preserve the value oI portIolio Irom the eIIects oI inIlation, and Iinally, these Iunds would
generate competitive rate oI returns as compared to investment in other securities and stability to
some extent as compared to investment in other securities.
Section C: Applied Theory
6. Breadth oI the market is popularly studied using A-D lines. Other techniques are also used
along with the A-D lines by technical analysts. The Iour popular methods are
i. Stocks in positive trends
ii. Percentage oI stocks over a moving average
iii. DiIIusion indexes
iv. High-Low statistics
i. Stocks in Positive Trends
A stock which rallies aIter a decline to reach a new high is said to be in an uptrend; a
stock that reacts to reach a new low is said to be in a downtrend. The percentage oI
stock in an uptrend to the total stock traded is computed and plotted on a graph. A
rising market is expected to have an increasing percentage oI uptrend stock.
Reversal is signaled when stock in positive trend begin to diminish.
ii. Percentage of Stock Over a Moving Average
A speciIic moving average Ior a number oI stocks is Iirst computed, and the
percentage oI the number that is above the average is ascertained. The percentage oI
stocks over a moving average increases in a bull market, and generally moves along
with the positive trend index computed in (i) above. When the percentage oI stocks
over a moving average reaches an extreme oI 90-100 percent or 10-15 percent, it
indicates that a substantial proportion oI the prevailing move has taken place and
that reversal is imminent. When the percentage index reverses direction, the reversal
in market trend is almost immediate.
iii. Diffusion Index
A diIIusion index momentum index is computed by calculating the rate at which a
certain group oI stocks change price over a given period oI time. It is generally
calculated on either a wide number oI stocks, or a number oI industry indexes. Also
called the momemtum index, a rise in the index signals the onset oI a bull market
and vice versa.
iv. High-Low Statistics
Technical analysts also study the high-low statistics to conIirm market trends. A
rising market should be accompanied by a healthy number oI net new highs. A graph
oI a net new highs can be plotted to be read along with a market index. II net new
highs trace a series oI declining peaks while the index continues to rise, a reversal is
imminent. Similarly, a graph oI net new lows can be expected to signal the end oI a
bear market, when it does not conIirm the new trough reached by the market index.
This is because, a declining number oI stocks reaching new lows implies that larger
number oI stocks are resisting the downtrend in the market index, and thus signiIies
the end oI a bear market.
Breadth oI the market, thus, is an important indicator oI the depth oI the prevailing
trend, and is oI immense utility to the analyst in identiIying trend reversals.
TOP
~
7.
Many observers believe that industries evolve through Iour stages the pioneering stage, the
expansion stage, the stabilization stage and the declining stage. There is an obvious parallel in
this idea to human development. The concept oI an industry liIe cycle could apply to industries
or product lines within industries. The industry liIe cycle concept is depicted in Iigure 6.2 and
each stage is discussed in the Iollowing section.
Pioneering Stage
In this stage, rapid growth in demand occurs. Although a number oI companies within a
TOP
~
1
growing industry will Iail at this stage because they will not survive the competitive pressures,
most experience rapid growth in sales and earnings, possibly at an increasing rate. The
opportunities available may attract a number oI companies, as well as venture capital.
Considerable jockeying Ior position occurs as the companies battle each other Ior survival,
with the weaker Iirms Iailing and dropping out. Investor risk in an unproven company is high,
but so are expected returns iI the company succeeds. At the pioneering stage oI an industry it
can be diIIicult Ior security analysts to identiIy the likely survivors, just when the ability to
identiIy the Iuture strong perIormers is most valuable. By the time it becomes apparent who the
real winners are, their prices may have been bid up considerably beyond what they were in the
earlier stages oI development.
Expansion Stage
In this second stage oI an industry`s liIe cycle the survivors Irom the pioneering stage are
identiIiable. They continue to grow and prosper, but the rate oI growth is more moderate than
beIore. At the expansion stage oI the cycle, industries are improving their product and perhaps
lowering their prices. They are more stable and solid, and at this stage they oIten attract
considerable investment Iunds. Investors are more willing to invest in these industries now that
their potential has been demonstrated and the risk oI Iailure has decreased.
'Financial policies become Iirmly established at this stage. The capital base is widened and
strengthened dividends oIten become payable, Iurther enhancing the attractiveness oI these
companies to a number oI investors.
Stabilization Stage
Finally, industries evolve into the stabilization stage (sometimes reIerred to as the maturity
stage), at which the growth begins to moderate. Sales may still be increasing, but at a much
slower rate than beIore. Products become more standardized and less innovative, the market
place is Iull oI competitors, and costs are stable rather than decreasing through eIIiciency
moves and so on. Industries at this stage continue to move along, but without signiIicant
growth.
Stagnation may occur Ior considerable periods oI time, or intermittently.
This three-part classiIication oI industry evolvement is helpIul to investors in assessing the
growth potential oI diIIerent companies in an industry. Based on the stage oI the industry, they
can better assess the potential oI companies within that industry. However, there are limitations
to this type oI analysis. First, it is only a generalization, and investors must be careIul not to
attempt to categorize every industry, or all companies within a particular industry, into neat
categories that may not apply. Second, even the general Iramework may not apply to some
industries that are not categorized by many small companies struggling Ior survival. Finally,
the bottom line in security analysis is stock prices, a Iunction oI the expected stream oI the
beneIits and risk involved. The industrial liIe cycle tends to Iocus on sales and share oI the
market and investment in the industry. Although all oI these Iactors are important to investor,
they are not the Iinal items oI interest. Given these qualiIications to industry liIe cycle analysis,
what are the implications to investors?
The pioneering stage may oIIer the highest potential returns, but also oIIers the greatest risk.
Several companies in a particular industry will Iail, or do poorly. Such risk may be appropriate
Ior some investors, but many will wish to avoid the risk inherent in this stage.
The maturity stage is to be avoided by investors interested primarily in capital gains.
Companies at this stage may have relatively high dividend pay-outs because their growth
prospects are Iewer. These companies oIten oIIer stability in earnings and dividend growth.
Declining Stage
In this stage oI the industrial liIe cycle decline is indicated on either a relative or absolute
basis. Clearly, investors should seek to spot industries in this stage and avoid them.
It is the second stage i.e. expansion, that is probably oI most interest to investors. Industries
that have survived the pioneering stage oIten oIIer good opportunities as the demand Ior their
products and services is growing more rapidly than the economy as a whole. Growth is rapid,
but orderly, an appealing characteristic to investors
TOP OF THE DOCUMENT ~