5

10
15
20
25













1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page1of6
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
Nevada Bar No: 9473
1422 E. 9th t. !2
"eno, N# $9%12
&ele: 77%'33$'$11$
(a): 949'**7'74+2
,ttorne- .or /e.endant "o0ert 1eller
2N3&E/ &,&E B,N1"24&C5 C62"&
/3&"3C& 6( NE#,/,
3n "e:
:
:
"6BE"& 1E77E" Case No.: B1 1+'%2*39'g;<,
:
/e0tor. Cha=ter 7
:
:
: 96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E
&8E C,/7E C694,N5,
:
C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N&
:
4lainti.., 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5 6(
:
/EB&
:
v. :
: ,dversar- 4roceeding No. 1+'+%1+4'g;<
"6BE"& 1E77E", : (iled 11'1$'2+11
/e.endant.
MOTION TO DISMISS CADLE COMPANY'S AMENDED COMPLAINT OBJECTING TO
DISCHARGEABLITY OF DEBT
/e.endantA/e0tor "o0et 1eller, 0- counsel Zach Coughlin, Esq.,here0- .iles this 9otion to
/isBiss the ,dversar- CoB=laint o. the Cadle CoB=an- and an- ,Bended CoB=laints on .ile. &he
undersigned asC that the Court allo; such a 9otion to /isBiss to 0e .iled des=ite an- ,ns;er herein
on .ile, =articularl- an- =ro se one .iled =rior to the undersigned>s attachBent to this case.
LEGAL ARGUMENT
. /e.endant states that the 9a- 23, 199% (inal ?udgBent .roB &ravis Count- and the ,=ril 1+, 199%
ettleBent ,greeBent and the 9arch 23, 199% cover letter .roB "o0ert D. 1eller to the
- 1 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&

5
10
15
20
25





















1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page2of6
=rosecutorA4lainti.. in the &ravis Count-, &E Batter decided in 199% s=eaCs .or theBselves
4lainti.. adBits to having .ailed to originall- serve coB=laint co=ies o. the CoB=laint in this Batter,
citing that the e)hi0its ;ere Ftoo voluBinousG in an eBail to 1eller. &hat is not =erBissi0le and
.orBs a 0asis .or disBissal due to insu..icient service o. =rocess. ,n- su0sequent electronic service
o. such e)hi0its does not override such technical de.iciencies earl- on.
/e.endant ;as not an o..icer, director and under;riter o. t;o 7lo-ds 3nsurance coB=anies
organi<ed =ursuant to the 3nsurance Code o. the tate o. &e)as: ,Berican @uardian 2nder;riters
7lo-ds 3nsurance CoB=an- Hhereina.ter F,@273CG: and ,Berican @uardian 7lo-ds, 3nc.
Hhereina.ter F,@7G:. /es=ite 4lainti..>s attorne->s Bani=ulated and tortured recounting o. the .acts,
during the late 19$+Is, /e.endant ;as not an o..icer, director and under;riter o. t;o 7lo-ds
3nsurance coB=anies organi<ed =ursuant to the 3nsurance Code o. the tate o. &e)as: ,Berican
@uardian 2nder;riters 7lo-ds 3nsurance CoB=an- Hhereina.ter F,@273CG: and ,Berican @uardian
7lo-ds, 3nc. Hhereina.ter F,@7G:. "ather, as the ?udgBent 4lainti..>s attorne- clearl- had Hgiven he
attached it to the CoB=laint in this 9atter: indicates e)=ressl-, 1eller F=artici=ated in the 0usiness o.
insurance in &e)as 0- serving as an under;riter and BeB0er o. the e)ecutive coBBittee o. ,Berican
@uardian 3nsurance 2nder;riter 7lo-ds, and as an o..icer, director, and shareholder in ,Berican
@uardian 7lo-ds, 3nc. ,s such, 4lainti..>s have .ailed to state a claiB u=on ;hich relie. could 0e
granted and the variosu iterations o. the CoB=laint should 0e disBissed.
Nevada>s .oreign JudgBent act and the Cind o. certi.ication required has not 0een =led or
sho;n, Justi.-ing a disBissal here.. &he Nevada certi.icate o. service and service address .or 9r.
1eller argues to;ards a disBissal.
, disBissal is .urther a==ro=riate here in that Cadle .ails to state a claiB ;here there is not
Bention o. or a0ilit- to sho; that there ;as the Justi.ia0le reliance. Dhat ;as the state la; ;hich
- 2 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&


5
10
15
20
25



















1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page3of6
iB=osed a .iduciar- dut- 0et;een the =arties, ;hich is a =re'requisite to Ha:H4:K Cadle cannot sho;
one. , de0t 0u-er can>t =rove Justi.ia0le reliance.
Cadle CoB=an- should lose on the collateral esto==el arguBent unless the sti=ulation
con.essed a .actual 0asis .or .raud. andoval, 232 4.3d 422 s=eaCs to the Facdtuall- litigatedG
requireBent and augers to;ards a disBissal here .or .ailure to state a claiB.
&he JudgBent is ultra scrires, its ;ent dorBant under &e)as la;, and ;as not revived in
tiBed, es=eciall- in light o. the void atteB=t 0- a non'la;-er to register the .oreign JudgBent in
Nevada ;here doing so is iB=erBissil0e. #&C, Civil 4ractice and "eBedies Code ec 31.++*. F
, dorBant JudgBent Ba- 0e revided 0- scire .acias or 0- an acdtion o. de0t 0rought not later than
the second anniversar- o. the date that the JudgBent 0ecoBes dorBantG.. Calde cannot sho; this.
ee also, ec 34.++1 FNo E)ceutionon /roBant ?udgBentG.. Non'la;-ers generall- Ba- not
re=resent another =erson or an entit- in a court o. la;. L "o;land v. Cali.ornia 9en>s Colon-, %+*
2.. 194, 2+1'+3, 113 .Ct. 71*, 721, 121 7.Ed.2d *%* H1993:. oBe courts have allo;ed non'
la;-ers to re=resents entities in court under certain circuBstances. ee, e.g., L #erBont ,N" v.
2==er #alle- "eg. 7and.ill, 1%9 #t. 4%4, *21 ,.2d 22%, 22$ H1992:. &his court, ho;ever, has M112
Nev. %43N consistentl- required attorne-s to re=resent other =ersons and entities in court. L alBan
v. Ne;ell, 11+ Nev. 1333, $$% 4.2d *+7 H1994:O L 4ioneer &itle v. tate Bar, 74 Nev. 1$*, 1$9'9+,
32* 4.2d 4+$, 41+ H19%$:O see also L N" 7.2$% Hno =erson allo;ed to =ractice la; in Nevada unless
adBitted to tate Bar:.
ound =olic- reasons su==ort requiring entities to 0e re=resented onl- 0- licensed counsel:
M&he reasonsN are =rinci=all- that the conduct o. litigation 0- a nonla;-er creates unusual 0urdens
not onl- .or the =art- he re=resents 0ut as ;ell .or his adversaries and the court. &he la- litigant
.requentl- 0rings =leadings that are a;C;ardl- dra.ted, Botions that are inarticulatel- =resented,
- 3 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&

5
10
15
20
25















1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page4of6
=roceedings that are needlessl- Bulti=licative. 3n addition to lacCing the =ro.essional sCills o. a
la;-er, the la- litigant lacCs Ban- o. the attorne->s ethical res=onsi0ilities, e.g. to avoid litigating
un.ounded or ve)atious claiBs. unde v. Contel o. Cali.ornia,91% 4.2d 29$, 299 112 Nev. %41,
HNev. 199*: 91% 4.2d 299.
,lso, the su=reBe court cases are Bro;n v. (elsen and ,rcher v. Darner allo; the court to looC
0ehind the JudgBent here to the cover letter to the signed sti=ulated JudgeBent 1eller sent the tate
o. &e)as, ;herein an- adBission o. .raud is e)=ressl- disclaiBed and there.ore that issue ;as
acdtuall- litigated and res Judicate ;orCs against the Cadle CoB=an->s assertions and o;n res
Judicate cause o. action. (urther, %23a7 ;ould seeB to allo; .or dischargea0ilit- here to the e)tent
the sti=ulated JudgBent o=erated as a .ine o. sorts.
333.
C6NC7236N
(or the reasons cited a0ove, /e.endant res=ect.ull- requests that this Court enter an 6rder
disBissing &he Cadle CoB=an->s CoB=laint and an- ,Bended CoB=laint, and 0arring such an 6rder
0eing granted, then =rovide a reasona0le =eriod o. tiBe in ;hich /e.endant Ba- .ile an ,ns;er or
,Bended ,ns;er to the CoB=laint or ,Bended CoB=laint. &o the e)tent such an ,ns;er or
,Bended ,ns;er is so required to 0e .iled no; or ;ithin a .e; da-s, /e.endant denies all
allegations contained therein and o==oses the relie. sought.
/,&E/ this 1+
th
da- o. ,=ril, 2+12
AsA Zachar- BarCer Coughlin
Zachar- BarCer Coughlin, Esq.
,ttorne- .or /e.endantA/e0tor 1eller
- 4 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&

5
10
15
20
25

Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page5of6
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
- 5 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&

5
10
15
20
25







1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
11
12
13
14
16
17
18
19
21
22
23
24
26
27
28
Case10-05104-gwz Doc53 Entered04/10/1206:00:34 Page6of6
CE"&3(3C,&E 6( E"#3CE ,N/ 9,373N@
3 8E"EB5 CE"&3(5 that on ,=ril 1+
th
, 2+12 a true and correct co=- o. the .oregoing docuBent
;as there0- caused to 0e served electronicall- on all registered users o. the C9AEC( s-steB ;ho
have .iled notices o. a==earance in this Batter. 3 .urther certi.- that the .oregoing ;as served via .irst
class Bail, =ostage'=re=aid and addressed as .ollo;s:
93C8,E7 4. 6I"62"1E, EP.
Nevada Bar No. *7*4
6I"62"1E 7,D @"624, 4C
$++ (i.th ,venue, uite 41++
eattle, Dashington 9$1+4
&ele=hone: H2+*: 477'147%
(acsiBile: H2+*: 47+'11%+
orourCela;grou=QgBail.coB
B"3,N ?. 93&8, EP.
Nevada Bar No. 11279
6. Counsel to 6I"62"1E 7,D
@"624, 4C
7++ outh &hird treet
7as #egas, Nevada $91+1
&ele=hone: H7+2: 3$+'$24$
(acsiBile: H7+2: 3$2'7%9%
,ttorne-s .or 4lainti..
/,&E/ this ,=ril 1+
th
, 2+12
AsA Zach Coughlin
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
,ttorne- .or /e.endantA/e0tor 1eller
- 6 -
96&36N &6 /393 C,/7E C694,N5> ,9EN/E/ C6947,3N& 6B?EC&3N@ &6 /3C8,"@E,B73&5
6( /EB&