Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VERSUS
MITCHELLJ.LANDRIEU, individually,andinhisofficial capacityasMayoroftheCity ofNewOrleans,CITYOFNEWORLEANS, RONALW.SERPAS,individually andinhiscapacityasSuperintendent ofPolice,NewOrleansPoliceDepartment, NEWORLEANSPOLICEDEPARTMENT, PAULNOEL,individuallyandinhiscapacity asCommanderofthe2ndDistrictNewOrleans PoliceDepartment,RANNIEMUSHATT, CommanderofthePublicIntegrityBureau HERMANSHUSHAN,LieutenantoftheFOB ReservesDivision,RAYMONDBOSEMAN, LieutenantoftheFOBReservesDivision, WONDELLSMITH,SergeantoftheISB MayorsSecurityYOLANDAJENKINS, Sergeantofthe6thDistrict,MUNISHTANWAR, policeofficerofthe2ndDistrict,HEATHERKOUTS, CaptainofISBAdministrativeSupport NANCYPARKER,policeofficeroftheFOB 2ndDistrict,ROBERTW.KIRTON, policeofficer,RHETTCHARLES, SergeantwiththeNewOrleansPolice Department,WILLIAMROUSSELL,
1
JEWISHCOMMUNITYCENTER, RICHARDF.CORTIZAS,individuallyandin HiscapacityastheNewOrleansCityAttorney, GERALDARCHER,individuallyandinhis capacityasAssistantCityAttorney ROBERTDROUANT,individuallyandinhis capacityasanAttorneyfortheCityofnewOrleans, JANEDOE,individuallyandinher capacityasaNursefortheOrleansParishSheriffs Office,JOHNDOE,individuallyandinhis capacityasaDeputySheriffoftheOrleansParish SheriffsOffice,MARLINN.GUSMAN,individually andinhiscapacityasSheriffofOrleansParish, andRICHARDWILLIAMS,individually andinhiscapacityasLieutenantinthePublic IntegrityBureau.
INTRODUCTION
Constitutionunderfederallaw,specifically,42U.S.C.1983and1988underLouisiana.
II.
JURISDICTIONANDVENUE
1. JurisdictionofthisCourtisinvokedpursuantto28U.S.C.1331,1343,2201,and
inthestateofLouisiana.
2. Defendantshereinare: a. MITCHELLJ.LANDRIEUis,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,was,theduly
electedMayoroftheCityofNewOrleans.Heisbeingsuedindividuallyandinhis officialcapacity.
b. CITYOFNEWORLEANS,abodycorporateandpoliticalsubdivisionofthe
stateofLouisianaisabletosueandbesuedinitsownname.
c. RONALW.SERPAS,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,was,thedulyappointed
SuperintendentofPolicefortheNewOrleansPoliceDepartment.Heissued individuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
d. NEWORLEANSPOLICEDEPARTMENT,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,
was,thelawenforcementagencyfortheCityofNewOrleans.
e. PAULNOEL,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasthedulyappointed
Commanderofthe2ndDistrictNewOrleansPoliceDepartment.Heissued individuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
f.
g. HERMANSHUSHAN,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaLieutenantofthe
FOBReservesDivision.Heissuedindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
h. RAYMONDBOSEMAN,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaLieutenantin
theFOBReservesDivision.Heissuedindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
i.
WONDELLSMITH,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaSergeantofthe ISBMayorsSecurity.Heissuedindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
j.
YOLANDAJENKINS,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaSergeantofthe 6thDistrict.Sheissuedindividuallyandinherofficialcapacity.
k. HEATHERKOUTS,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasthedulyappointed
CaptainofAdministrativeSupport.Sheissuedindividuallyandinherofficial capacity.
l.
m. MUNISHTANWAR,was/is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,aPoliceOfficerof
the2ndDistrictoftheNewOrleansPoliceDepartment.Heissuedindividuallyandin hisofficialcapacity.
n. ROBERTW.KIRTON,was/is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,aPoliceOfficer
ofthe2ndDistrictoftheNewOrleansPoliceDepartment.Heissuedindividuallyand inhisofficialcapacity.
o. RHETTCHARLES,was/is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,aPoliceOfficerofthe
2ndDistrictoftheNewOrleansPoliceDepartment.Heissuedindividuallyandinhis officialcapacity.
p. WILLIAMROUSSELL,was/isandatalltimesrelevanthereto,theownerof
BrightMomentsandactedasmoderatorforthemayorscommunitymeetingheldat theJewishCommunityCenteronAugust13,2012.Heissuedindividually.
q. JEWISHCOMMUNITYCENTER,aprivatelyowned,multipurpose
communitycenter,locatedat5342St.CharlesAve.,usedforconcerts,lectures, plays,andotheractivities.
r.
s. ROBERTDROUANT,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wastheCityAttorney
fortheCityofNewOrleans.Heissuedindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
t.
u. JANEDOE,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasanursefortheOrleansParish
SheriffsOffice.Sheissuedindividuallyandinherofficialcapacity.
v. JOHNDOE,is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasasheriffoftheOrleansParish
SheriffsOffice.Heissuedindividuallyandinhisofficialcapacity.
w. MARLINN.GUSMANwas/is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,thedulyelected
SheriffofOrleansParish.Heisbeingsuedinhisofficialcapacity.
x. RICHARDWILLIAMS,was/is,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,theinvestigating
officerinthePublicIntegrityBureau.
y. ABCINSURANCECOMPANYis,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaliability
insurerfortheCityofNewOrleans.
z. XYZINSURANCECOMPANYis,andatalltimesrelevanthereto,wasaliability
insurerforNewOrleansSheriffsOffice.
III.
FACTS
1. BornandraisedinNewOrleans,Louisiana,SandraWheelerHester,alsoknownasThe
18Wheelerhas,fordecades,beenthemostardentandstridentcriticofcorruptand ineffectivegovernmentinthestateofLouisiana,particularlyinthecityofNewOrleans.
2. Her criticisms, protests, lawsuits and the like were primarily aimed at the local parish school
board, the New Orleans City Council, the New Orleans Police Department, and the Mayors Office.
3. From June 2000 to August 26, 2005 (the Friday before HurricaneKatrinastruck), theplaintiff
produced and hosted TheHesterReport,aonehourcommercialfreeweeklytelevisionshow on Cable Access T.V. The program was wellknown in the community for its lambasting of local,state,andfederalelectedofficials.
Sanford,Florida.
5. On March 1st, 2012 Justin Sipp was shot and killed by New Orleans police officers. His
brothertheunarmedEarlSippwasalsoshotbyNewOrleansPolice.
6. On March 7, 2012, the unarmed Wendell Allen was murderedbyNewOrleansPoliceOfficer
JoshuaColclough.
7. The plaintiffs only son Richard Armand Hester was born in the same year as Justin Sipp and
Wendell Allen. As of August 2012, when the incident(s) took place, allthreewere21yearsof age.
8. This fact caused the plaintiff to publically call defendant Landrieu a murderer at Wendell
the defendant Mayor at the Jewish Community Center located at 5342 St. Charles Avenue in New Orleans, Louisiana. The purpose of the meeting was to give the publicanopportunityto meet and ask questions ofthevariousdepartmentheads(ofNewOrleanscitygovernment)and theirstaff,andmakecommentsregardingtheMayorsproposed2013budget.
11. Plaintiff arrived one hour in advance of the community meeting inorder tocollecthandoutsand
askquestionsofthevariousdepartmentheads.
12. The defendantmayoropenedthemeetingbyexplainingrepeatedlythat,Thisis notmymeeting,
itisyourmeeting.
13. At 6:00 pm the defendant William Rouselle a political operative, acting as the moderator
explained the procedure for citizens wishing to speak. The procedure was to fill out a speaker cardandsubmitittoadesignatedperson.
14. Immediately after defendant Rouselle called plaintiffs name to speak the crowd started hissing
andbooingattemptingtoshoutherdown.
15. The defendant mayor got up from his seat, put his arm around plaintiffs shoulder and,
and began to stand up and uproariously heckle the Plaintiff. One standing and jeering citizen shouted to the Plaintiff: Go back where you came from! Despite Plaintiffs insistence she be allowedtomakehercommentsuninterrupted,thecrowdgrewmoreunruly.
17. AtnotimedidDefendantmoderatorRoussellcallthemeetingtoorder. 18. Plaintiff filled out a speaker card, waited after numerous speakers were called to speak, even
though she arrived and filled out her speaker card before them all. At no time did plaintiff interrupt the previous speakers or disrupt the meeting in any way. Then suddenly and without warning,thedefendantmayorshouted,Getthatoutofhere.
19. At which time nearly twenty (20) uniformed and ununiformed New Orleans police officers
converged on and surrounded plaintiff in Gestapolike fashion and asked plaintiff to leave the meeting.
20. Whenaskedwhyshe wasbeingaskedtoleavethepublicmeetingplaintiffwasgivennoanswer.
Plaintiff then shouted to defendant superintendent of police who sat and witnessed the whole event to call off his officers, the defendant superintendent didnotrespondbutinstead squirmed inhisseat.
21. Then suddenly and without warning plaintiff was told she was under arrest. Whenaskedwhy,
she no response. Plaintiff was handcuffed, arrested and taken out of the Jewish Community Centerundertheglareoftremendousnewscoverage.
22. While being transported to central lockup defendant officers constantlyharassedandridiculed
plaintiff,makingdisparagingcommentsaboutheradvocacy.
23. Upon arrival to central lockup, defendant officers forcibly removed plaintiff from the car
The plaintiff asked several times that the cuffs be loosened or that she be cuffed in the front. Upon hearing the plaintiffs plea, the officer, Sergeant Yolanda Jenkins, sarcastically remarked totheplaintiff,Isthatintheconsentdecree?
25. Defendant transporting officers asked several police officers toassistingetting plaintiffinsideof
CentralLockUp.
26. Severallocaltelevisionnewsstations,printmedia,and radiostationswerepresent andrecorded
theincidentfromstarttofinish.
27. Once at central lockup plaintiff was forcibly taken from the squad car and was made to sit on
thegroundforhoursbeforethetransportingofficersdefendants.
28. Plaintiff was forcibly removed from the squad car and made sit in the street for hours before
defendant officers Jenkins, Parker, Tanwar and employed torturous methods to carry plaintiff intocentrallockup.
29. Plaintiffs wrist were so severely swollen that the arresting officers were unable to remove the
cuffs.Theyhadtoberemovedaftermucheffortandpainbythedeputysheriff.
30. Plaintiff was refused medical treatment by officers Jenkins, Parker, Jane Doe nurse, and John
Doedeputysheriffdespiteobviousinjuriesandelevatedbloodpressure.
31. Plaintiffwasrefusedmedicaltreatmentforelevatedbloodpressureanddiabeticcondition.
Gusman,attheJewishCommunityCenterwereanunconstitutionalabridgmentofPlaintiffs FirstAmendmentRights.
33. TheDefendantLandrieuviolatedtheFreeSpeechclauseoftheFirstAmendment,bycreatinga
publicforumandallowingsomespeech,andcensoringothers.
10
UnitedStatesConstitution,42U.S.C.1983andLa.Civ.CodeAnn.Arts.2315,byfailingto preventeachotherfromviolatingPlaintiffsconstitutionalandstatutoryrights.
36. Defendants,andallofthem,violated,42U.S.C.1985and1986byconspiringtodeprive
Plaintiffofhercivilrightsandfailingtopreventsaidconspiracy,deprivation,andthedamages resultingtherefrom,respectively.
37. Defendants,andallofthem,violatedLa.Civ.CodeAnn.2315and2316byinjuringPlaintiff
knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligently.
38. Defendants,andallofthem,violatedPlaintiffsrightsunderstatelaw,includingtherightstobe
freefromassaultandbattery,falsearrest,falseimprisonment,andmaliciousprosecution.
39. ThearrestingofficersviolatedtheFifthAmendmentoftheConstitutionasappliedtothestates
throughtheFourteenthAmendment,andtheequalprotectionclauseoftheFourteenth Amendment.
11
coloroflawwithnovalidjustification
b. Knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligentlyusedforceinasituationandunder
circumstancesnotrequiringtheuseofforce,bringingabouttheinjuriessustainedbyPlaintiff
c. Knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligentlycausedPlaintifftosuffer,bothphysically
andpsychologically
d. Knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligentlyorchestrated,conducted,condoned,
ratifiedand/orparticipatedintheapplicationofexcessiveforceandtheinflictionofcrueland unusualpunishmentonPlaintiff
e. Knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligentlyendangeredPlaintiffslifeandaggravated
g. Knowingly,intentionally,recklessly,ornegligentlygavefalseversionsforthefactsand
12
Department:
a. Hadandpresentlyhavecustoms,policies,practices,andproceduresofnegligentlyand
andcircumstancessurroundingtheabuseandarrestofPlaintiff
d. Condoned,ratified,approvedand/orotherwiseacquiescedinthemaliciousprosecution
ofPlaintiff
e. MaintainedandcurrentlymaintainanatmospherewithintheNewOrleansPolice
Departmentand/ortheirrespectivedivisionsthereof,whichencouragesofficial
13
lawlessnessamongthepoliceofficers,thekindofwhichisdirectlyresponsibleforthe abuseandarrestofPlaintiff
f.
AreliablefortheactionsofDefendantspoliceofficersundertheprincipleof respondeatsuperior.
g. Failedtotrain,supervise,anddisciplineDefendantsthefailurewhichgaverisetothe
abuse,arrest,andmaliciousprosecutionofPlaintiff
42. Specifically,DefendantLieutenantWilliams: a. Intentionally,knowingly,recklesslyfailedtoaccuratelyinformPlaintiffofherrights
substantiallydiscouragecitizenallegationsofpoliceabuse,andthusencourage officiallawlessnessamongNewOrleansPoliceDepartmentofficers
b. Hadandpresentlyhavecustoms,policies,practices,andproceduresthatencourage
falsearrestsandmaliciousprosecutionsbysignificantlyreducingthelikelihoodthata
14
atimelyandunbiasedPIBinvestigationintotheseallegations,andthusunnecessarily prolongedthemaliciousprosecutionagainstPlaintiff
d. Hadandpresentlyhavecustoms,policies,practices,andproceduresthatrequire
areinviolationoftheConstitutionandthelawsoftheUnitedStatesofAmericaandthe stateofLouisiana.
15
b. EnterjudgmenthereininfavorofPlaintiff,andagainstDefendants,awardingherspecial,
general,punitiveandnominaldamagesinanamountdeemedfairandequitable.
c. Enterjudgmenthereinpermanentlyenjoiningtheaforementionedpoliciesandpractices
appropriate,pursuantto42U.S.C.sec.1988. TRIALBYJURY
44. Plaintiffrequestsatrialbyjuryastoallissuessotriable.
Respectfullysubmitted:
16
_____________________________ Sworntoandbeforeme,Notary,this
_____________________________
17