General Form of Judgment or Order

In the
-
Cardiff


County Court
-
Claim Number 3PD00269
Date I August2Q.13
-


\tt>
IJ

o; 0
O' v(\o
JONATHAN BISHOP
1
51
Claimant
Ref
HEART INTERNET LTD
I'' Defendant
!Ref
--------------
ROB PERCIVAL T/A ECO WEB HOSTING
12nd Defendant
Ref
Before His Honour Judge Seys Llewellyn sitting at Cardiff County Court, Cardiff Civil Justice Centre, 2 Park
Street, Cardiff, CFlO lET.
IT IS ORDERED THAT
l. Appeal Order made in terms as attached
Dated 23 July 2013
The coun office at Cardiff County Coun, CaniilT Civil Justice Cenlre, 2 Park Street. Cardi IT, CFIO IET is open between 10:00 am and 2:00 pm Monday 10 Friday. When
corresponding with the coun, please address forms or letters to lhe Coun Manager nnd quote the claim number. Tel: 02920 376400 Fax: 029 20376475
hy:M Willis
N24 General Form or Judgment or Order CJR065
I
Jonathan Bishop
B Heol-y-parc
Efail lsaf
Pontypridd
CF3B 1AN
--- n ~ - -
NOTIFICATION OF DECISION OF APPEAL COURT
ON APPLICATION FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL
Appeal Court Ref No
CF077 /20 l 3A
Appellant
Jonathan Bisho_I!, Crocels Communi!Y Media GrouJ!
Name of Judge in lower court
District Jud e Doel
Title of case in lower court
Jonathan Bishop, Crocels Community Media
Grou v Heart Internet Ltd
I Respondent
Heart Internet Ltd
Date of Order of lower court
3 Jui 2013
Claim number in lower court
3PD00269
In his application before the lower court, the Appellant was the Claimant
The Appellant's application for permission to appeal has been considered by His Honour Judge
Seys Llewellyn, QC who has refused permission to appeal and directed that the person seeking
permission to appeal may not request the decision to be reconsidered at an oral hearing.
I. The District Judge dismissed the action on consideration of the papers on the basis that it was totally
without merit and did not disclose any reasonable grounds for bringing the claim.
2. I have read with care the whole of the material submitted by the Claimant to the court. It is impossible to
discern within it any reasonable grounds for bringing a claim or any hint of or reference to facts which might
reasonably support a claim in law.
3. The decision of the District Judge was correct and unimpeachable.
4. Therefore
(i) I refuse permission to appeal
(ii) I record that the appeal is totally without merit and
(iii) Pursuant to CPR S2.3(a) I order that the person seeking permission to appeal may not request
the decision to be reconsidered at an oral hearing. The power to so order is to be used sparingly
but I am satisfied that as Designated Civil Judge I should so order in this case.
23 July 2013.
A copy of this document will be sent to the Appellant and the Respondent.