Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wagdi Habashi NSERC-J. Armand Bombardier Industrial Research Chair of Multidisciplinary CFD McGill University
A Workshop in Honor of Antony Jameson Jamesons 70-year-young B-day Stanford, November 19, 2004
Meshing By Guessing
Final optimal grids, for same geometry, at different Re are quite different
For the same geometry, the optimum grid is different for different Re and Mach How can the user be asked to generate it?
Today, CFD still remains, somewhat, more a Qualitative Tool than a Quantitative Tool
CFD remains somewhat of an ART We mesh, we solve, we get an answer, we use it, without much idea how good (or how bad) it really is
Initial Solution
Initial Mesh
FEM
FVM
Superimposed
In See-FD The Unaware User May Not Get the Answer He Seeks but Only the One He Deserves!
emax =
l 2 2g h 8 2
2
h 2g 2 = V T HV V
g I xi xj I d 2 g = x i x j I I d I
2 gh xy 2 gh y 2 2 gh y z
2g h xz 2g h yz 2g h z 2
M=R R
3D Error Estimation, 3
The strategy is to modify the mesh so that all edges are equal in the Riemannian metric Equi-distributing the edge lengths in the metric metrics space is equivalent to equi-distributing the error in the physical space, with the length defined as:
1
e( x i x j ) = ( x i x j )T M ( l) ( xi x j ) dl
0
Library of Elements
Structured Mesh Unstructured Mesh Transition Elements
Linear Tetrahedron
Linear Prism
Linear Pyramid
Node movement
Remarks:
Node movement is the continuous mechanism that homogenizes the error across the mesh Coarsening, refinement and swapping are binary mechanisms that accelerate adaptation
10
11
Initial Mesh
Initial Solution
Adapted Mesh
12
13
14
Without Optimization
With Optimization
15
Comparison of Cp and Cf
Unadapted Solution
16
17
18
With Anisotropy the Grid is never the Problem Rather, the Grid is the Solution
19
20
WITHOUT OPTIGRID
WITH OPTIGRID
21
22
23
24
25
Smoothed mesh
26
Initial mesh
Near-wall Adaptation, 1
Original Mesh
Constant height
Set height
27
Original Mesh
Wall treatment
Original surface
Wall treatment
28
Original surface
Wall treatment
Original surface
Wall treatment
29
30
Mach profile
31
32
Original signal
Degraded signal
Original grid
Mach profile
33
CAD reconstruction, 1
Raw grid
In CAD reconstruction for mesh adaptation; the initial grid is used to generate a suitable CAD for the topology.
Curves/Surfaces reconstruction
CAD
34
Initial grid
CAD reconstruction with automatic detection of the needed geometric features (sharp edges)
Reconstructed CAD
Input grid
CAD reconstruction with automatic detection of the needed geometric features (used boundary conditions outlines)
Reconstructed CAD
35
From the deduced edges; CAD splines, parametric surfaces and planar primitives are built. Producing a CAD useable in adaptation.
36
37
38