You are on page 1of 3

JohnB.CadeLibraryWebsite:http://www.lib.subr.edu ReferenceDepartment(225)7712875Email:ref2@lib.subr.

edu

How to write a critique

What is a critique?
Acritiqueisapaperthatgivesacriticalassessmentofabookorarticle.

Steps in writing a critique


o Beginbyreadingthebookorarticle.Trytoidentifythewritersmainpoint/thesis statement. o Underlineanyfamiliarwordsasyouread o Dividethebook/articleintosectionsofthoughtandwriteabriefsummaryofeach thoughtinyourownwords.

Parts of a critique Introduction


Introducetheworkbystating: o o o o Author Title Source DateofPublication

Body
Useaboutthreetofivepointstosupportyourthesisstatement.Thequestionsyouanswered asyoureadshouldserveasaguidetohelpyouselectyourpoints.Forexampleyoucandiscuss: o Theauthorscredentialsorlackofcredentials o Theaudienceheorsheaimsatandtheappropriatenessofthevocabulary o Theamountandkindsofsupportusedtobackuphisorhermajorideas
Preparedby:M.Payne,ReferenceLibrarian Date:08/08

JohnB.CadeLibraryWebsite:http://www.lib.subr.edu ReferenceDepartment(225)7712875Email:ref2@lib.subr.edu

o o o o

Theuseandcorrectidentificationofoutsideresearch Howtheauthorhandlesanybiasesoropposingopinions Logicoftheargument Howtheauthorsideascorrelatewithknowledgeyoualreadyhave.

Conclusion
o Summarizetheauthorspurposeandmainpoints o Restateyourthesisstatement o Discussthesuccessorfailureofauthortoconvincethereader. Considerthefollowingquestions: 1. Istheworksignificant? 2. Howdoesitimpactthereader?

Key words to use in a critique


Evidence Facts Opinions Examples Statistics ExpertOpinions EmotionalAppeals
Preparedby:M.Payne,ReferenceLibrarian Date:08/08

Relevant Representative Accurate Reasonable Logical Fallacies Flawed

JohnB.CadeLibraryWebsite:http://www.lib.subr.edu ReferenceDepartment(225)7712875Email:ref2@lib.subr.edu

Thesis Statement

Athesisstatementdeclareswhatyoubelieveandwhatyouintendtoprove.Agood thesisstatementmakesthedifferencebetweenathoughtfulresearchprojectanda simpleretellingoffacts. Agoodtentativethesiswillhelpyoufocusyoursearchforinformation.Butdont rush!Youmustdoalotofbackgroundreadingbeforeyouknowenoughabouta subjecttoidentifykeyoressentialquestions.Youmaynotknowhowyoustandon anissueuntilyouhaveexaminedtheevidence.Youwilllikelybeginyourresearch withaworking,preliminaryortentativetheseswhichyouwillcontinuerefineuntil youarecertainofwheretheevidenceleads. Thethesisstatementistypicallylocatedattheendofyouropeningparagraph.(The openingparagraphservestosetthecontextforthethesis.) Remember,yourreaderwillbelookingforyourthesis.Makeitclear,strong,and easytofind.Checkwithyourinstructorforhisorherpreferencebeforewritingyour critique,theremaybesomevariationsfromthepattern.Besuretoreadyour assignmentcarefully.

Preparedby:M.Payne,ReferenceLibrarian Date:08/08

You might also like