Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mohammed Jhilila
Prof. Mohamed Dellal
International Relations
May 11th, 2009
Synopsis:
1
Mohammed Jhilila
1
Jean Gottmann, “The Background of Geopolitics”. Military Affairs, Vol.6, No.4. p: 200.
2
Mohammed Jhilila
The United States are responsible before the world for the
destinies of the continent, as the United States must
regard as an act of hostility committed against
themselves any attempt at the oppression of any
independent state of America, as also any intermeddling
in American affairs by foreign governments2
Feeling the stern European papal decree that aimed at regaining control over
Argentina, Venezuela and other Latin American countries; as well as the
growth of Pan-Germanism, the United States started modeling a political
geography oriented science. The German Prussia (pan-Germanism) was
grapevining as an ideology seeking the unification of German, Dutch and
Flemish speaking people into a united nation. The problematic this
movement generated can be summarized in two main characteristics. First,
the Germans were seeking expansion over European territories better than
overseas ones. Secondly, that their ‘natural boundaries’ influenced the
German geopolitics. It is in this period that political geography ever appeared
as an imperialistic fuelling science. During and after the nineteenth century,
it was considered as a philosophy of history. The German Prussia movement
sought to organize and liberate the Germanic Race from the Napolionean
stronghold. Flemish and Dutch were considered lects appertaining to the
German linguistic family. Pan-Germanism first appeared as an organized
movement in 1894 led by Friedrich Ludwig Jahn and Ernst Moritz under the
name of Alldutscher Verband (pan- German League.) it was based on the
Allgernmeiner Deutscher (general German League). The importance of
geography was first recognized with the appearance of territory and
2
J. M. Moncada, “Imperialism and the Monroe Doctrine”. Trans. Oloysius C. Gahna (New
York : Michigan University, 1911) p : 3. Boorowed from
www.scribd.com/doc/8530593/Imperialism-and-the-Monroe-Doctrine-The-jm-Moncada.
Last retrieved on 12 May 2009.
3
Mohammed Jhilila
resources as crucial for the whole Europe. In 1897, the first book concerned
itself with the interdependent relationship between the state and its
territorial frame. Ratzel, for Gottmann, focused on the ideas of Raum and
Lage which mean space and location respectively. For Ratzel as the author
states, those who lack the sense of space Raum do not have tendency
towards expansionism. Later on, Ratzel published two books dealing with
the crucial role naval powers have then played in the strengthening of the
sense of statism. For Mackinder a British geographer, this sense is
incarnated within all groups of nations which, for him:
3
Colin S. Gray, Geoffrey R. Sloan Geopolitics, geography, and strategy
http://books.google.co.ma/books?id=iEraO0XJ55sC&dq=geopolitics+and+geost
rategy&printsec=frontcover&source=bl&ots. Last retrieved on 12 May, 2009.
4
Mohammed Jhilila
5
Mohammed Jhilila
Rudolf Kjellen was the first to coin the term geopolitics as indicative of
an expansion mentality towards beyond extended etatism. For Kjellen, the
state is like man, she eats grows, speaks and acts. She needs the
materialistic resources found in territory and the spiritual. Recognized as a
dangerous theorization that espoused Ratzel’s organic state theory to
dynamic state theory, the American and European considered Kjellen’s ideas
as tools of war against their interests.
Commentary:
J. Gottmann’s last paragraph shows a meticulous defense on political
geography and bitter criticism towards the German Geopolitik. Gottmann
seeks in the article to dismantle the canonized and biased inclinations of
such authors as Mackinder and Bowman whose ideas brought more
complexities than they undid the world political problems. However, the text
shows a biased aura as the author does not elaborate on the ideas contained
in the Monroe declaration, while he gives more examples from the German
Geopolitical School. The Monroe declaration is as imperialistic as the
German expansionistic Dynamic state theory.
While considering R. Kjellen’s ideas as pejoratively expansionistic, the
Monroe doctrine is viewed as an innocent declaration. If the value judgment
Gottman provides about Pan-Germanism (Prussia) is based on expansion,
the Monroe announcement was as expansionist as was Pan-Germanism. J.
M. Moncada, a Nicaragua former Interior minister, states that the
declaration denied Latin American countries the advancement of their
prosperity and self-governance which for him are two lawful ambitions of
man and of nation.8 Giving the example of the incursions done by Zelaya, an
American Commander in Chief, during the war against Honduras, he
delineates another view about the Monroe Doctrine. During that war Zelaya
provided Terencio Sierra with “materials of all kinds to enable him to march
8
J. M. Moncada, “Imperialism and the Monroe Doctrine”. Trans. Oloysius C. Gahna (New
York : Michigan University, 1911) pp :7-8 . Boorowed from
www.scribd.com/doc/8530593/Imperialism-and-the-Monroe-Doctrine-The-jm-Moncada.
Last retrieved on 12 May 2009.
6
Mohammed Jhilila
9
Ibid., P : 7.