SL.NO.

A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 B 1 2 3

VENDOR DESCRIPTION DG Set 500kVA with Enclosure Contrl Panel SUB TOTAL EXCISE DUTY @ 14.42 CST @ 2% Againist from "c" FREIGHT & INSURANCE ENTRY TAX @ 2% TOTAL ERECTION & COMMISSIONING SUPERVISION CHARGES SERVICE TAX SUB TOTAL GRAND TOTAL(A+B)(RS) VENDOR

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS FOR 500 KVA DG SET ORIGINAL OFFER 05.01.2009 TRACTORS INDIA LIMITED KIRLOSKAR JAKSONS LIMITED QTY RATE(RS) AMT(RS) RATE(RS) AMT(RS) RATE(RS) AMT(RS) FOR SUPPLY PART 3 3000000 9000000 2175897 6527691 2500000 7500000 3 INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE Inclusive Inclusive Inclusive Inclusive 3000000.00 9000000.00 2175897.00 6527691.00 2500000.00 7500000.00 3 432600.00 1297800.00 313764.347 941293.0422 360500.00 1081500.00 3 68652.00 205956.00 49793.23 149379.68 Inclusive 171630.00 3 45000.00 135000 Extra Extra Inclusive Inclusive 3 50789.09 152367.27 57210.00 175062.60 70925.04 212775.12 3617177.04 10851531.12 2590243.67 7770731.00 2917710 8928192.6 FOR ERECTION AND COMMISSIONING INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE

0 0 3617177.00 10851531.00 FINAL OFFER TRACTORS INDIA LIMITED QTY 3 3 3 3 3 3 RATE(RS) AMT(RS) FOR SUPPLY PART 2475000.00 7425000.00 INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE

0 2590243.67

0 7770731.00

0 2917710

0 8928192.6

KIRLOSKAR RATE(RS) 2170000.00 Inclusive AMT(RS) 6510000.00 Inclusive 6510000.00 670530.00 143610.60 Inclusive 146482.81 7470623.412 INCLUSIVE

JAKSONS LIMITED RATE(RS) 2360000.00 Inclusive 2360000.00 243080.00 Inclusive Inclusive 52061.6 2655141.60 INCLUSIVE AMT(RS) 7080000.00 Inclusive 7080000.00 1020936.00 Inclusive Inclusive 162018.72 8262954.72 INCLUSIVE

SL.NO. A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 B 1 2 3

DESCRIPTION DG Set 500kVA with Enclosure Contrl Panel SUB TOTAL EXCISE DUTY @ 10.30 CST @ 2% Againist from "c" FREIGHT & INSURANCE ENTRY TAX @ 2% TOTAL ERECTION & COMMISSIONING SUPERVISION CHARGES SERVICE TAX SUB TOTAL

2475000.00 7425000.00 2170000.00 356895.00 1070685.00 223510.00 56637.90 169913.70 47870.20 45000.00 135000.00 Inclusive 48827.60 58670.66 176011.97 2992203.36 8976610.67 2490207.8 FOR ERECTION AND COMMISSIONING INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE INCLUSIVE

Payment Term

90% ag. Despatch document & bal. after commissioning 2992203.36 8976611.00 T1 L3

GRAND TOTAL(A+B)(RS)

10% adv. ,80%-15 Days of Matl rcpt,& 10% after Commisn. 2490208.07 7470623.23 T3 L1

10% adv. ,80%-15 Days of Matl rcpt,& 10% after Commisn. 2655141.40 8262955.12 T2 L2

Mr.Debnath Padhi AM(Purchase)

Mr.R.K Gupta Sr.DGM(E&I)

V.K. Kanaujia Sr.GM(Power Plant)

K.G. Maheshwari Sr.GM(Commercial)

Mr.M D.Sinha Head(F&A)

TECHNICAL COMPARISION
SL. NO. PARTICULARS NAME OF THE MANUFACTURER 1 2 4 6 7 8 CONTACT PERSON QUOTATION REFERENCE RATING KVA /TECHNOLOGY WEIGHT with Encloser in KG HP RATTING SPECIFICATION KIRLOSKAR JAKSONS LIMITED Mr. Manoj ku. Muduli Mr. S.K. Panda Mob: 9853419813 Mob: 9337128613 SBGL/BBS/277 DT: 05th SKP/COMP-ANGUL-01/ 08NOV,2008 09 DT: 30th DEC, 2008 200 kVA, U.S.A Model-C18 200 kVA , Korean 200 kVA Cummins tech.MODEL-10 K 18 TA 3150 6990 10500 247 602 600 Turbocharger Turbocharger Turbocharger Flexible connection Flexible connection Flexible connection Exhaust manifold Exhaust manifold Exhaust manifold Exhaust Exhaust silencer(Industrial Exhaust Exhaust Exhaust Exhaust Engine water pump Lube oil cooler Engine water pump Coolant additive Air to air charge Air cooler Coolant additive TRACTORS INDIA Mr. Manoj Patnaik Mob: 9337333331 PSG:ER:MP:08/I73 DT: 24th OCT,2008

10

EXHAUST SYSTEM

11

COOLANT SYSTEM

11

COOLANT SYSTEM

Radiator By Pass Thermostat(Air to air charge Air cooler) Air to air charge Air cooler Oil Sump Engine mounted lub oil Full flow lub oil filter By Pass Thermostat PT Fuel pump with Electronics Governor(Electronics fuel control) UNIT Injector 24V DC battery charging alternator Manual stop/start Remote start/stop Cyclic cranking Alpha numeric screen Alternator trim adjustment Model specific calibration Field trim adjustment 3-Phase AC Amps 3-Phase AC volts kWh/kW KVA Meter KWH MTR DM 5240 Power factor Frequency Lube oil pressure Coolant temperature Engine speed Hours run Battery voltage

Radiator Coolant additive concentrate Air to air charge Air cooler Oil Sump Engine mounted lub oil Full flow lube oil filter & cooler By Pass Thermostat Fuel filter(spin-on type)

Radiator By Pass Thermostat(Air to air charge Air cooler) Air to air charge Air cooler Oil Sump Engine mounted lub oil Full flow lub oil filter By Pass Thermostat PT Fuel pump with Electronics Governor

12

LUBRICATING SYSTEM

13

FUEL SYSTEM

PTD Injector 24V DC battery charging alternator Manual stop/start Remote start/stop Cyclic cranking Alpha numeric screen Alternator trim adjustment Model specific calibration Field trim adjustment 3-Phase AC Amps 3-Phase AC volts kWh/kW KVA KWH MTR DM 5240 Power factor Frequency Lube oil pressure Coolant temperature Engine speed Hours run Battery voltage

PTD Injector 24V DC battery charging alternator Manual stop/start Remote start/stop Cyclic cranking Alpha numeric screen Alternator trim adjustment Model specific calibration Field trim adjustment 3-Phase AC Amps 3-Phase AC volts KW KWH MTR DM 5240 Power factor Frequency Lube oil pressure Coolant temperature Engine speed Hours run Battery voltage

14

OPERATOR INTERFACE

15

AC INSTRUMENTS

16

MEASUREMENTS/INSTRUMENTATION

High coolant temperature (waring & shutdown) Low lube oil pressure Engine shut down system Fail to start (shut down) Over speed (shut down) Low/High battery voltage (warning)

High coolant temperature (waring & shutdown) Low lube oil pressure Engine shut down system Fail to start (shut down) Over speed (shut down) Not specified

High coolant temperature (waring & shutdown) Low lube oil pressure Fail to crack (shut down) Fail to start (shut down) Over speed (shut down) Low/High battery voltage (warning)

17

ENGINE PROTECTION

Low coolant level shutdown Low coolant level shutdown Low coolant level shutdown Over speed (shut down) Under frequency(waring) Over voltage (shutdown) Over current (shutdown) Under voltage ( warning) TYPE: Synchronous Make: CAT RPM: 1500 Generating voltage: 415 volts regulation: 1% Voltage Adjustment: 5% EFFICIENCY 100%load 800 Amps TPN MF ACB Cupper bus bars of suitable capacity Indication lamps for "Load On" & "Set Running" External Current transformers for Metering Over speed (shut down) Under frequency(waring) Over voltage (shutdown) Over current (shutdown) Under voltage ( warning) TYPE: Synchronous Make: BRUSHLESS RPM: 1500 Generating voltage: 415 volts regulation: 1% Voltage Adjustment: 5% EFFICIENCY 100%load 3 pole 800 Amps MCCB Suitable Busbar with insulation support for incoming & outgoing terminal Indication lamps for "Load On" & "Set Running" External Current transformers for Metering Over speed (shut down) Under frequency(waring) Over voltage (shutdown) Over current (shutdown) Under voltage ( warning) TYPE: Synchronous Make: STAMFORD RPM: 1500 Generating voltage: 415 volts regulation: 1% Voltage Adjustment: 5% EFFICIENCY 94.8% 3 pole 800 Amps MCCB Aluminium bus bars of suitable capacity with incoming & outgoing termination ends. Indication lamps for "Load On" & "Set Running" SEPARATE PANEL Current transformers

18

AC protection

19

ALTERNATOR

20

CONTROL PANEL

21

FUEL TANK CAPACITY

990 Ltrs (with Level gauge) 12V, 25 plate, 180AmpH

990 Ltrs 12V, 25 plate, 180AmpH

835 lts. 12V, 180AmpH capacity in dry & uncharged condition with its leads Make: STANDARD FURUKAWA / PRESTOLITE Qty: 02 nos. O & M Manual of Diesel Engine Spare parts list of diesel engine Test Certificate of diesel engine Test Certificate of Alternator Test Certificate of D.G Set

22

BATTERIES

Make Exide / Prestolite Qty: 02 nos. O & M Manual of Diesel Engine Spare parts list of diesel engine

Make: Exide Qty: 02 nos. O & M Manual of Diesel Engine Spare parts list of diesel engine Test Certificate of diesel engine Test Certificate of Alternator Test Certificate of D.G Set

23

DOCUMENTATION

Test Certificate of diesel engine Test Certificate of Alternator Test Certificate of D.G Set

24 25

ENCLOSURE SOUND LEVEL

26

FUEL EFFICIENCY

Acoustics CPCB type 75 dBA - 1mt. Scroll type fuel system best fuel efficiency with linear fuel consumption pattern at part load in a load band of 30 to 80% @100% load 101lt/hr @75% load 76.5lt/hr / @50% load 53.3lt/hr 76.5 10% O/L for 1hrs. in every 12 hrs. BBSR, Rourkela (4 Engineers)

Acoustics Acoustics CPCB type 73.5 dBA - 1mt. 75 dBA - 1mt. Specific Fuel Consumption at 50% load 148g/hp-h 75% load 147g/hp77.4 LTR / HR AT 75%(60h(78.28lt/hr) 100% load lineor) 100% load 147g/hp-h

27 28 29

FUEL EFFICIENCY @75% LOAD in Ltr/hr. OVER LOAD CAPACITY SERVICES

78.28 10% O/L for 1hrs. in every 12 hrs. Angul, Sambalpur , BBSR

77.4 10% O/L for 1hrs. in every 12 hrs. SAMBALPUR

30 31 32 33 34

SPARES AMBIENT TEMPERATURE KWH METER WARRANTY CONTINUOUS RUNNING

100% Available BBSR, RKL Sambalpur, BBSR 50 deg - 100% 45 deg - 100 % , 50 deg CONZERV - DM 5240 CONZERV - DM 5240 1 Year(Unlimited Hours in 2 Yrs , 5000 Hrs from the 01 Yr) 8000Hrs date of commissioning 100% load 100% load

100% SAMBALPUR 50 DEG C CONZERV - DM 5240 2 Year /5000HRS 80%(400KVA),320kw

Technical Preference

T1

T3

T2