from Col. Marr to help me with that.

I'm also borrowing from transcripts between the FAA and NEADS
controllers.
But recounting the events is not enough. I want to show fog of war, how quick decisions were made as this
massive SCATANA effort was going on. So, I'm a little fuzzy on SCATANA and when order was given to
kill if necessary. What can you tell me about that order from Gen. Eberhart? And to your knowledge, did it
come after the FAA declared a ground hold and told airliners to land?

Don't remember seeing timeline on when SCATANA was declared - NORAD may have it in
database

Occurred less than 2 hours after the first event -

An hour and 17 min. from l" plane into wtc until united 93 crashed - had not declared scatana at
that particular time to my knowledge

Minetta in wh w/vp, both in basement together .... Recommendation

Guy fairly young in sys says we need to stop all take offs (this is faa guy), land everything at nearest
suitable airport.
Minetta concurred from white house

Don't know if that occurred before or after 93, but close to that time frame

Very rapidly we had stopped all takeoffs and landings prob right after 2nd plane hit
Then vp declared wawsh., d.c. airspace a free-fire zone
That occurred I think w/in 5 min. after united 93 had crashed

Timeline - actual presidential declaration occurred 5 min. after united 93

I believe, faa was able to land evdrything in 4 hours - they turned everything back around, coming into u.s.
from europe or landed in canada - were able to put all commercial aviaiton down in 4 hours, not to say
some light general aviation aircraft still flying, ther were, but only a few

About the 21 planes reportedly missing. Can you clarify that? Would that be across CONUS or include
trans-Atlantic flights and at what point was that?

Started w/delta flight - we wrote them down on the board as they occurred, that's why we knew 21 -
happenign fast and furious for awhile but the last one ocurred just prior to president taking off from offut,
airplane from madrid
Timeframe was somewhere around 4 hours
Had all airplanes down in 4 hours and had confirmatin that nothing else was coming in, that is whenpres
elected to head back to Washington, d.c.

Even before this thing was over, there were other airplanes called hijacked, some of confusion that
surrounded ual 93 was that there was a delta flight, that eventually landed in Cleveland htat had been called
* potentially hijacked
^ \* >> } We were wathinc both, as best we could, wathcing positin of ual 93 and delta flight and as both of these
i o\e way I'mairplanes are chapter:
writing the maneuvering around, concerned
I'm recounting about
the sequence of where
eventsthis
andairplane
using theisNEADS
going, clevelenad,
timeline detroit.
Chicago

When col. Marr talked about sridge aircraft, at one x, we had what looked like a vector going toward detroit

Making an effort to show fog and friction of war. Can you characterize some of your decisions during the

NCT0068096
tragedy. For instance, Col. Marr told me he got clearance from you to shoot down an airliner. Then you
later got the clearance from President Bush? Can you go into detail about that? I'm trying to intelligently
state that before 93 crashed, the pilots had clearance to kill if need be and that was on your authority as
CONR commander . . .

What are some other decisions you and the others had to make?

Who was on that initial conference call, you, exercise staff and sector commanders?
Had our d.o. on conference call along w/three sector commanders in myself

At end of day, sat down and drew circles around cities, told eberhart on orbit at 15 locations, operating out
of 26 diffemet sites, fighters only, but of course tankers and awacs aircraft in support of this thing
The 1 5 sites turned out to be 16 sites - the bad news was, from an af positin, don't like to give out false
info

Policy became: protect 16 population centers in the early days, after we came down off orbit after first
couple of days, we had to repositioon our fighters in some cases to be on alert and in closer proximity to
poulation centers

Understand that later you joined the national domestic threat conference call, but that was after all 4 had
crashed, right? Who told you about that, the NORAD J3 Rick Fenley ... what is that rank and/or title?

We were reacting off emergency powers - roe under an emergeny situ would allow region
commander to make that call

So many called potentially hijacked, pilots not responding right away to instructions

Likely grounding order occurred prior to ual 93

When delta airline landed in cleve, that cleared up for the moment our cncems about that airplane then we
began to get a picture that that airplane was no headed toward Washington. D.c.

I was inclined to push forward and move aircraft toward 93 and col. Marr & others suggested that we didn't
need to do that right away, needed to hold them over wash., d.c. in case there was another aircraft

About rules of engagement on 9/11 ... some say they were written as the day went along. Would you
agree? Why or why not?

We had special roe for this thing, esentially roe became more strict than we would have had even during
warx or peceimt
In past, if a target declared hostile, the sector commander could declare target hostile in emergency and hve
shootdown authority, also have provisions for self defense that allow a pilot to shoot someone down if he
saw that aircraft was going to harm him or someone on the ground or in the air

Those roe were stripped - pres. Chose to restrict people who would have authority to order shootdown of
an aircraft, we were talking about shooting down civilian airplane w/innocent passengers on board

ROE more restricted - in heat of battle, everyone would question - as day wore in, it became clear this was
not situation as usual
Much more restrictive ROE -
Over D.C., remember, the pres had declared wash. D.c. and national capital region to be a free fire
zone, so in that regard, that is very unprecedented, meant if a pilot saw an airplane vv-in 30 mile
radius of wash., d.c. and couldn't determine it wasn't a doctor flying back to hometown, thatpilot
was not only allowed to, but was considered that he could shoot that airplane down

30-mile zone, a free-fire zone - by presence they could be declared hostile and shot down

Can you make sure I have this straight: If normal procedures had taken place that
morning, Powell probably wouldn't have taken that phone call. Normally, the FAA
would have contacted officials at the NMCC at Pentagon who would have contacted
NORAD. The Secretary of Defense would have had to approve the use of military
assets to assist in a hijacking, always considered a law enforcement issue. (Interview
with MGen Arnold) But nothing was normal on Sept. 11, 2001, and many admit the
traditional chain of command wasn't always followed to get the job done.

National Military Command Center - is that its proper name?

headed west. "We don't have fighters that way and we think he's headed toward Detroit
or Chicago," Marr says. "I'm thinking Chicago is the target and know that Selfridge
(Mich.) Air National Guard Base has F-16s in the air. We contacted them so they could
head off 93 at the pass. The idea is to get in there, close in on him and convince him to
turn. ... As United Airlines Flight 93 was going out, we received the clearance to kill if
need be. In fact the (Maj, Gen. Arnold's) words almost verbatim were: 'We will take lives
in the air to save lives on the ground. '

Describe importance of other two air defense sectors on 9/11. How did they help?

NGT0068098