Professional Documents
Culture Documents
9 770958 991408
Incorporating material from the Observer, Le Monde and the Washington Post
Abu Dhabi AED11 Bahrain BHD1.40 *Cyprus 2.30 Czech Rep CZK110 Denmark DKK29 Dubai AED11 Egypt EGP19 Hong Kong HKD39 Hungary HUF715 *Republic of Ireland 2.50 Japan JPY600 Jordan JOD2.20 Kenya KSH250 Kuwait KWD1.10 Latvia LVL3.70 Lebanon LBP4500 *Malta 1.95 Mauritius MR139 Morocco MAD27 Norway NOK39 Oman OMR1.25 Pakistan PKR200 Poland PLN10.50 Qatar QAR11 Romania RON33 Saudi Arabia SAR12 Singapore SGD6 Sweden SEK41 Switzerland CHF6.80 Turkey TRY6.60
13
World roundup
Alliance to ght Canada oil pipelines Costly US drought set to continue South Africa hosts Bric nations summit
4 1
An alliance of Canadian and US indigenous groups vowed to block three multibillion-dollar oil pipelines planned to move oil from the Alberta tar sands. The Canadian government, faced with falling revenues due to pipeline bottlenecks and a glut that has cut the price for Alberta oil, says the projects are a national priority and will help diversify exports away from the US market. But the alliance of 10 native bands all of whose territories are either near the cruderich tar sands or on the proposed pipeline routes complain that Ottawa and Washington are ignoring their rights. Indigenous people are coming together with many, many allies across the United States and Canada, and we will not allow these pipelines to cross our territories, said Phil Lane Jr, a hereditary chief from the Ihanktonwan Dakota in South Dakota. More North America news, page 11
The drought that laid waste to the US grain and corn belt is unlikely to ease before the middle of this year, a government forecast warned. The annual spring outlook from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration predicted hotter, drier conditions across much of the US, including parts of Texas, Oklahoma and Kansas, where farmers have been ghting to hang on to
crops of winter wheat. Last year produced the hottest year since record keeping began more than a century ago. It also brought drought to close to 65% of the country. The droughts cost is estimated at above $50bn, greater than the economic damage from hurricane Sandy.
Leaders of the Bric nations China, Brazil, Russia and India gathered in Durban this week alongside their newest member, South Africa. Some critics have expressed doubt at South Africas readiness to join the elite group of emerging
nations. But Bric-Africa trade is predicted to top $500bn by 2015, with China-Africa trade making up roughly 60% of that total. Chinas pursuit of Africas natural resources has been a central driver of African economic growth over the past decade.
1 3 9
The US Senate narrowly passed its rst federal budget in four years, a move that will usher in a relative lull in Washingtons scal wars until an anticipated summer showdown over raising the debt ceiling. The budget plan was passed by a 50-49 vote in the Democratic-controlled chamber. Four Democratic senators facing tough re-election
campaigns in 2014 joined all the Senate Republicans in opposing the measure, which seeks to raise nearly $1tn in new tax revenues by closing some tax breaks for the wealthy. The Senate budget will square o in coming months against a Republican-focused budget passed by the Republicandominated House of Representatives.
Libraries can be scary places in Stephen King novels, but they appear to hold a special spot in the horror writers heart, after he and his wife Tabitha pledged to donate $3m to their local branch in Bangor, Maine. Barbara McDade, director of Bangor Public Library, told the Bangor
Daily News that Stephen and Tabitha King had oered to pay one-third of the $9m the library is looking to raise for refurbishment, as long as the remaining $6m is raised. They have just been wonderful supporters of the library, said McDade. James Herbert dies at 69, page 38
October with the government of Recep Tayyip Erdogan are building momentum. The calan statement added that the estimated 3,500 PKK ghters inside Turkey should leave the country for their strongholds in the Qandil mountains of northern Iraq. This is not the end. This is the beginning of a period, said the declaration. In an important symbolic gesture last week, the PKK released eight Turkish hostages who had been held captive in northern Iraq for up to two years. But in a sign of the possible backlash to come, a leftist group scornful of the rapprochement launched a bomb and missile attack on government buildings last Wednesday night. One person was injured. Israel apologises to Turkey, page 6
Central African Republic rebels have seized the capital, Bangui, after erce ghting, forcing President Franois Boziz to ee. At least nine South African soldiers were killed trying to prevent the rebels taking Bangui, dealing a blow to Pretorias attempt to stabilise the republic. Fighting broke out last week in the former
French colony and rebels swept south towards Bangui with the aim of toppling Boziz, whom they accuse of breaking a January peace deal to integrate opposition ghters into the army. We have taken the presidential palace, Eric Massi, a spokesman for the Seleka rebel coalition, told Reuters. More Africa news, page 10
cassation quashed the acquittals handed down by an appeals court in 2011 and said a fresh trial would take place in Florence. The move came after prosecutors had argued that the court that acquitted Knox and Sollecito had lost its bearings. Italy tries to form government, page 5
10
voyeurism and sexual harassment. It provides for the death penalty for repeat oenders or for rape attacks that lead to the victims death. The law also makes it a crime for police ocers to refuse to open cases when they receive complaints of sexual attacks. Activists hailed the law as a milestone in Indias womens rights movement. More south Asia news, page 8
At least 12 people were killed and more than 270 injured after hailstorms hit southern China. The ocial Xinhua News Agency said nine people were killed in the city of Dongguan, in southern Guangdong province, after a
12
hailstorm last Wednesday. It added that 272 others were injured from the storm, which caused economic losses of $57.4m. Three other people died from hailstorms that began last Tuesday in neighbouring Hunan province, where 1,900 houses have collapsed.
5 10 14 7 12 11
13
13
6
LOral case threat to Sarkozy comeback
Nicolas Sarkozy came out ghting after he was placed under investigation for exploiting the mental frailty of the countrys richest woman to raise election funds. His lawyer rejected the case as awed.
South Korean companies that was hit. Commission ocials say the IP address was used only for the companys internal network and was identical to a public Chinese address. Investigators say an analysis of malware and servers indicates that the attack was likely to have been orchestrated from abroad. They did not elaborate. Experts in Seoul suspect Pyongyang of orchestrating the attack. The investigation is likely to take several weeks.
11
Hong Kongs top court has denied permanent residency to two domestic helpers from the Philippines in the nal decision of a legal case with implications for many other foreign maids. The two had argued
that an immigration provision barring domestic workers from permanent residency was unconstitutional. The ruling sided with the governments position that domestic helpers are not the same as other foreign residents.
A re swept through a remote refugee camp in north-west Thailand, killing at least 35 people and destroying makeshift shelters. The blaze, which broke out last Friday in Mae Hong Son province, has left more than 2,000 people homeless, the provincial governor, Narumol Palavat, said. About 115 people were injured, 19 seriously. Reports suggested the re was triggered by a cooking accident. Most of those living in the camp were
14
ethnic Karens, some of the 3,500 refugees who ed ghting in Burma in 1992. Many were born in the camp and had lived there for decades. Karen insurgents have been ghting for greater autonomy since Burma won independence from Britain in 1948. The Karen National Union signed a ceasere with the Burmese government in 2012, halting one of the worlds longest-running civil wars. But ethnic tensions in the region persist and many refugees do not want to return.
International news
Savers beware ... bank depositors will suer under the terms of the EU bailout deal agreed with Cyprus Zuma/Rex Features The Bank of Cyprus is 9.7% owned by Dmitry Rybolovlev, a Russian based in Monaco whose wealth is estimated at $9.1bn according to Forbes.
More online - Cyprus bailout latest guardian.co.uk/cyprus
nanced the rst world war through excessive borrowing and was then forced to pay reparations by the allies. Membership of the Gold Standard meant there was no escape. When the Wall Street crash struck in October 1929, the dogged determination of Germany fresh from the hyperination of 1923 to stay on the Gold Standard meant it felt the full blast of the deationary storm coming out of the US. Swarup and Perkins note: The German government, bowing to international pressure, haunted by fears of hyperination and facing reparations linked to gold, refused to default on its debt or devalue its currency by suspending membership of the Gold Standard. Instead it adopted brutal austerity policies, much like those it is now forcing on the Mediterranean countries. This compounded the countrys economic misery and sent unemployment surging higher. It pushed the economy into what today we might call a Greek-style austerity/ depression trap. A straight read across from the interwar years to 2013 is too simplistic. Europes population is older and wel-
fare provision more extensive, even in the countries where austerity is biting hardest. Slow to act it may be, but the ECB is there to ensure nancial stability across the eurozone. Even so, the growing popularity of anti-establishment parties is a warning. The same toxic mix of economic hardship, political impotence and resentment at outside interference that was evident in Germany in the late 1920s and early 1930s is again present. Swarup and Perkins rightly warn it is vital the economic lessons of the 1930s are remembered. There will need to be debt relief rather than restructuring, a realisation that aggressive scal austerity is a mistake when exchange rates are xed, and a much more activist approach by the ECB to provide a growth stimulus. The longer the depression lasts the stronger extremist forces will become and the greater the risk that one or more countries will decide to leave the single currency because they cannot tolerate the economic distress, the social unrest and the political instability. Germany, of all nations, should understand this.
International news
Diplomatic breakthrough ... Barack Obamas talks with Binjamin Netanyahu led to a
Ready for combat Life for young female Israeli soldiers Review, page 26
International news
Frontline unocial sources claimed up to 100 people had been killed in the violence Soe Zeya Tun/Reuters censorship regulations and the release of many political prisoners the country has also witnessed a growing tension between majority Buddhists and minority Muslims, who comprise 5% of the 60 million population. Exact numbers of those killed and injured are hard to establish. Win Htein, of the opposition National League for Democracy party, said 20 people including the monk are conrmed dead. But Ko Wanna Shwe, of the Rangoon-based Islamic Religious Aairs Council, said that gure was likely to be much higher. We are getting reports from people in Meikhtila since [last] Wednesday that [the number] is higher. Nearly 100 people have been killed teachers, students, shopkeepers, he said by phone. Even young men aged eight to 14 included. Many fear the situation is a reprise of last years violence in Rakhine state, western Burma, where hundreds were killed and 120,000 left homeless after two serious bouts of violence between Buddhists and Rohingya Muslims in June and October. A stateless minority, the Rohingya are not recognised as Burmese citizens and many of them either live in segregated camps for internally displaced people or have fled by their thousands to neighbouring countries, often in makeshift boats. Rumours of a third massacre against the Rohingya have been circulating for months, with photographs of alleged leaets inciting violence posted on social media. Rights groups last Friday described the situation in Meikhtila as a warning sign that Burma still has a long way to go to establish peace and reconciliation in a country that proscribed dissent for nearly half a century, and called for the government to put an end to the violence. The key issue is this: the government has frankly failed to stare down the people who are inciting hatred, the people who are engaging in this communal violence and that failure has set an example that impunity to attack Muslims is alive and well in Burma, said Phil Robertson of Human Rights Watch. Theres a major army base in that town. If people are engaging in rioting and attacks, then they could be stopped. So why does violence continue on now for two days or so? Theres either a complete lack of capacity or a failure of political will because Buddhist monks are involved.
International news
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and Page XX
Sharif spends his way into the driving seat in race to be Pakistans next PM
or some, the 27km of road and yovers built for a eet of red buses that zoom above the gridlocked streets of Lahore is a shocking extravagance. In a country where only 35% of children are in secondary school and poverty is a reality for many, it is easy to think of other ways to spend $334m. But for Nawaz Sharif, the frontrunner in the battle to become Pakistans next prime minister, the countrys rst mass transit project is worth every cent if it staves o competition from the countrys wily president and a famous ex-cricket star. Despite the chorus of doubters, the opening last month of the Metro Bus in the capital of Punjab, which is controlled by Sharifs faction of the Pakistan Muslim League (PML-N), was a massive hit. People were just craving something like this, said Ahsan Iqbal, a senior PML-N leader. It has become the symbol of a new Pakistan. People are experiencing a new way of life that is much closer to developed countries, and that gives them a good feeling. Enthusiasm for grand projects comes after a calamitous ve years for the ruling Pakistan Peoples party (PPP), led by Asif Ali Zardari a surprise president who was swept to power on a tide of sympathy in 2008 after the assassination of his wife Benazir Bhutto. Apart from being the rst government in Pakistans history to full a full term, the PPP has little to brag about. Continuously bueted by terrorist violence, corruption allegations and crippling energy shortages, the PPP has been unable to deliver real economic growth, let alone the motorways and infrastructure that Sharif touts. But while the PPPs vote is likely to be wiped out in much of urban Pakistan, Zardari still has some cards to play as his partys prime minister, Raja Pervez Ashraf, goes to the polls. Zardari whose term as president expires in September is a ruthlessly pragmatic politician with a track record of doing whatever is necessary to keep his party in power. The PPP is thought to have deep reserves of electoral strength in parts
All aboard critics say Lahores new Metro Bus system is more about politics than easing congestion AFP of rural Punjab and Sindh where its feudal landlord allies maintain a tight control on votes. Through the presidents political heir apparent, Oxford graduate Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, 24, the PPP maintains a connection to the Bhutto name, harking back both to Benazir and Bilawals grandfather, Zulkar Ali Bhutto. The party has also lavished more than $1bn in welfare handouts for 5.2 million people through its Benazir income support programme. People at the grassroots know what we have done for them, they dont believe what the media is saying, said Taj Haider, general secretary of the PPP in Sindh. Living standards in the poorest areas have gone up and people are getting better prices for their crops. Cynics say the Metro Bus is less about tackling urban congestion and more about the dramatic political rise of Imran Khan, the countrys beloved former cricket captain, who emerged as a major threat to the PML-N in late 2011 by holding an enormous rally for his political party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), on Sharifs home turf. About 100,000 people took part in the Lahore jalsa, creating speculation that what Khan calls a political tsunami would sweep Pakistani politics and break the corrupt, dynastic rule of the two established parties. Perversely, Khan could actually be the best chance the deeply unpopular PPP has for clinging on to power, if his appeal to urban young people simply succeeds in cutting into the PML-N vote bank in the towns and cities of Punjab. After the Khan rally, the PML-N feared its cruise to power on the back of the PPPs many failures was in jeopardy and so went into overdrive. The party used its control of the government of Punjab, home to 60% of Pakistanis, to push through as many eye-catching schemes as it could nearly all of which have been criticised for wasting money. Free laptops were given to students, a youth festival was held and, most signicant of all, the Metro Bus was built in 11 months. At the partys manifesto launch, Sharif promised to turn Pakistan into an Asian tiger, with new infrastructure and a government with zero tolerance for corruption. The period of hyperactivity appears to have paid o, with the PMLN now favourite to win the largest number of seats after Pakistanis go to the polls on 11 May, even if an outright majority is probably beyond it. The party enjoys a substantial lead in the latest polls. Most analysts believe Khan will be lucky to get 20 of the 342 seats in parliament. He peaked too early and gave the PML-N time to rejuvenate its base, said Cyril Almeida, a newspaper columnist. People go to his rallies because he is a rock star in Pakistan. He doesnt have the party machine to actually turn out the voters and bring them to the polling booth on election day.
The Metro Bus has become the symbol of a new Pakistan, and that gives people a good feeling
International news
Horn of Africa a rhino in Kruger Mario Moreno/Barcroft Media most in the celebrated Kruger national park. At the current rate, deaths will outstrip births by 2016, described by conservationists as a tipping point. Molewa joins a vocal minority who have been lobbying hard for legalisation as a necessary step. Among them is John Hume, South Africas biggest private owner with more than 800 rhinos, who argues that the animals could be periodically dehorned safely and humanely. Hume acknowledges that he would be one of the main nancial beneciaries. I am very pleased with the ministerss response and feel that it is high time that the government adopted this stance, Hume said on Monday. I sincerely hope our government makes a decision to trade in rhino horn very soon and that they take such a proposal forward vigorously and intensively. Our rhinos are rapidly running out of time and the current poaching onslaught is truly devastating. We strongly feel that legalising the trade in rhino horn is the only way to go in order to save the rhino. But the move has long been opposed by groups such as Trac and the WWF. There are fears that a legitimate supply of horn would send mixed messages to consumer markets that are little understood and lack regulation. It could potentially stimulate more demand in countries such as Vietnam, where horn is seen as a delicacy or of medicinal value. Will Travers, chief executive of the Born Free Foundation, told the Mail & Guardian: So what are they saying by legalising the rhino horn trade? Here is a product that every sensible scientist says has no signicant impact and they are going to sell it at huge cost to a public that is ill-informed. I wouldnt go to sleep at night if I thought I was selling something like that to a Vietnamese family who have scrimped and saved every cent to buy rhino horn for their dying grandmother, who then goes and dies.
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and Page XX
Beyond the wire detainees pray at Guantnamo Bay John Moore/Getty Farah warned that, if the hunger strike continued, some inmates could die. We are afraid for some of the mens lives. If someone persists with not eating food they can suer severe physical damage and may die, he said. Kelly, who vociferously denied any charge that Qurans had been mishandled, did admit that eight detainees had lost enough weight that they were now being force-fed via tubes. But he insisted that there was no crisis. [They] present themselves daily, calmly, in a totally co-operative way, to be fed through a tube, he said, adding that he believed those prisoners were also eating by themselves when they were in their cells. The clashing versions of events are the latest in a long line of controversies that have dogged the Guntanamo prison since it was set up to house suspects caught up in the so-called war on terror. The process of detaining terror suspects has outraged civil
International news
Accused it took years for Jos Efran Ros Montt to stand trial AP cant control the army, then what am I doing here? The retired general sat facing a group of victims in the courtroom while activists demonstrated in support of the prosecution outside. Reed Brody, a representative of the US-based Human Rights Watch, said the 86-year-old former dictator was alert and taking notes during the proceedings and occasionally even appeared jovial. His lawyer, Francisco Garca, told the court that no genocide had ever existed. Ros Montt never gave a written or verbal order to exterminate the Ixils in this country, he reportedly said. Jos Rodrguez Snchez, a former high-ranking member of the mili-
A disgruntled Kicker here like breed this Then a short Aussies dontdescription know how lucky here like they this are Then Comment, Section page and 20 Page XX
Victor Australian PM Julia Gillard Gillard reiterated that the leadership contest for her job was over. It is now very clear that I have the condence of my colleagues to lead the Labor party and to remain as prime minister. It is also clear that Kevin
Finance
Finance in brief
Rosneft has taken over TNKBP in a $55bn deal that will make the Russian state-owned oil company by far the worlds largest listed oil producer. The deal, which was sealed at the Russian president Vladimir Putins mansion on the outskirts of Moscow last Thursday, will see BP collect $16.7bn in cash and a 12.5% stake in Rosneft in return for its 50% stake in the TNK-BP venture. The deal takes BPs stake in Rosneft to 19.75%, and BP will get two seats on the Russian companys board. BPs partners in the TNK-BP joint venture billionaires Mikhail Fridman, German Khan, Viktor Vekselberg and Len Blavatnik will collect $27.7bn for their stake. BAE Systems has been awarded a new contract from the US military worth up to $780m. The ve-year deal with the Pentagon to produce explosives at a plant in Tennessee includes a further order for the IMX-101 munition that is seen as a safe and eective replacement for TNT in artillery rounds. The US is BAEs biggest market, but the British defence contractor had warned of weak demand from across the Atlantic due to the scaling back of operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. Two of the City of Londons most blue-blooded rms are to merge after Schroders announced it was buying its smaller rival Cazenove Capital for 424m ($643m). Cazenove, reputed to be the Queens broker, dates back to 1823; Schroders, 1804. The tie-up will create one of the UKs largest private banking and wealth management houses. Schroders had assets under management worth 229.2bn in 2012, while Cazenove had 11.2bn. The Cazenove brand will be retained for the private banking business.
Taxing situation ... Valencia has had to sell many of its best players, including Juan Mata, left, now at Chelsea Javier Soriano/Getty side Bayern Munich, complained when debt gures were made public last year. A spokesman for Almunia said a formal investigation similar to one looking at public subsidies to Dutch soccer clubs must wait until the Spanish government has replied to its inquiries. Analysts warn that action from Almunia to force Spains tax authorities to recover debts will expose the chronic nancing problem in Spanish soccer. Professor Jos Mara Gay de Libana, of the University of Barcelona, said reckless lending especially by former savings banks controlled by local politicians had created a bubble that must eventually burst. When people ask me what clubs could be in danger, I reply with the list of the only clubs that are not in any kind of danger. They are Barcelona, Real Madrid and Athletic Bilbao, said Gay de Libana. Hoeness is, basically, right. If I dont pay my taxes, then the authorities come after me. But that doesnt happen to the clubs, which are not treated like other companies. Twenty-two first- and seconddivision clubs are in insolvency proceedings or have been in recent years. Several are thought to be struggling to survive strict debt-repayment plans imposed by creditors. They include former league title-winners such as Deportivo de la Corua and a long list of historic clubs such as Zaragoza, Racing Santander, Mallorca, Albacete and Betis. Deportivo semi-finalists in he Champions League in 2004 had been allowed to build up a tax debt of 96m, a report to an insolvency court last week revealed. The real cause of the insolvency is a complete lack of realism in management, taking on spending and investment that is absolutely beyond the clubs economic possibilities, the clubs administrators wrote.
Foreign exchanges
Sterling rates (at close) 22 Mar 1.46 1.56 8.74 1.18 11.83 143.99 1.82 8.85 1.90 9.88 1.43 1.52 15 Mar 1.45 1.54 8.63 1.16 11.74 143.90 1.83 8.74 1.89 9.68 1.42 1.51
22
The number of Spains rst and second division clubs in insolvency proceedings, or that have been recently
Australia Canada Denmark Euro Hong Kong Japan New Zealand Norway Singapore Sweden Switzerland USA
UK news
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and Page XX
At bay Boris Berezovsky at his former home in Surrey in 2002, two years after decamping from Russia John Downing/Hulton Archive/Getty
UK news
UK news
News in brief
Nearly 2m homes in the UK will be heated by shale gas from the US within ve years, under a deal agreed on Monday that is likely to be the rst time major exports of the controversial energy source are used in the UK. The deal struck by energy company Centrica opens up the market to cheap supplies from the US as North Sea gas elds run out and pipelines to Europe remain expensive. Malala Yousafzai, the teenager who was shot in the head by Taliban gunmen in Pakistan while advocating girls education, attended her rst day of school in the UK, weeks after being released from hospital. The 15-yearold, who is among nominees for this years Nobel peace prize, described her return to school as the most important day of her life, as she joined fellow students in Birmingham. The number of children taking up smoking has risen by 50,000 in just one year, research suggests. About 207,000 children aged 11 to 15 started to smoke in 2011, a sharp rise from 157,000 in 2010, according to research from Cancer Research UK. The charity said the gure equated to 567 children taking up the habit each day. An increase in prots at the big ve UK banks Barclays, HSBC, Lloyds Banking Group, RBS and Standard Chartered was wiped out by more than 11bn ($16.7bn) of nes and compensation payments in 2012. Despite an improved core business performance, nes from regulators and the costs of the mis-selling of payment protection insurance contributed to a 40% cumulative drop in prots from 2011 to 11.7bn, according to accountants KMPG. Severe weather warnings covered most of England, Northern Ireland and parts of Scotland as a blast of unseasonally cold air showed no sign of relenting. Thousands of homes were without power in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Cumbria, many roads were blocked by snow or abandoned vehicles, ights were cancelled, and rail travel was disrupted across much of Britain.
Standing rm but Thatchers cabinet felt doubt over the Falklands Rex Britain, Australia or New Zealand with full citizenship, be oered. The release of the 1982 personal papers by the Margaret Thatcher Foundation also show that her chief whip, Michael Jopling, was warning her about deep Tory divisions. He outlined six groups of MPs, ranging from the no surrender group headed by Alan Clark to more than a dozen MPs who thought not a single shot should be red in anger or that the Falklands were not worth the effort. Jopling quotes one Scots peer, Lord Drumalbyn, who told him: I think the government are mad. We do not want the place, in any case. Tory MP Marcus Kimball said: Let the Argentinians have the Falklands with as little fuss as possible. The Tory wet Sir Ian Gilmour said: We are making a big mistake. It will make Suez look like common sense. Ken Clarke, later a cabinet minister under Thatcher, was bracketed with Sir Timothy Raison in the chief whips note as hoping that nobody thinks we are going to ght the Argentinians, we should blow up a few ships but nothing more. A future cabinet minister, Stephen Dorrell, was very wobbly and reportedly would only support the eet as a negotiating ploy; if they will not negotiate we should withdraw.
Comment&Debate
The US president delivered a ne speech in Jerusalem, but is he willing to turn words into actions on peace?
resident Obama gave an excellent speech in Jerusalem last Thursday about the prospects for peace between Israelis and Palestinians. He called on Israelis to recognise the moral and security imperative of a Palestinian state. He highlighted the threats to Israeli democracy if the Jewish state continues on its present course. And he asked that Israelis view Palestinians not as suicide bombers or potential terrorists, but rather as human beings with the same desire for freedom and self-determination as the Jewish people. These are important words and ones that are refreshing when they come from the mouth of an American president. In some circles, Obamas speech is already being hailed as a historic set of remarks but such words are only historic in the constricted manner in which American politicians are allowed to talk about Israel and the peace process. This wasnt a speaking of hard truths; it was a speech narrowly directed at Israelis. And it was a reassurance for them about the benets of a Palestinian state and the US commitment to Israel. Oddly, Obama, by making these points, was pushing against an open door. Israelis largely accept the idea of a Palestinian state: opinion polls show two-thirds of Israelis support a two-state solution and accept the idea of a Palestinian state that conforms to the 1967 borders. What holds them back is a strong conviction that such an arrangement can never be realised and that the Palestinian leadership can never be a true partner for peace. What they need, to coin a phrase, is a roadmap to peace. And here Obama had little to oer but exhortation: For the moment, put aside the plans and process. I ask you, instead, to think about what can be done to build trust between people. But the days of building trust between Israelis and Palestinians have passed. That trust isnt going to be built not when, for most Israelis, the occupation has become an abstraction. And neither side can wait for such a goal to be achieved. What is needed is plans and process and an active US role in bringing both sides together. There was far too little of that in this speech. While Obama deserves credit for pushing Israelis to understand the need for reconciliation, he didnt push hard enough. He was right to point out that the threats to Israeli democracy are real. But a more honest statement would be that Israelis face a clear and quickening
choice: between a meaningful democracy and a future Israel that could be a veritable apartheid state where an Israeli minority rules over a captive population that lacks full political rights. Obama was right to point out that continued settlement activity is counterproductive to the cause of peace, but plenty of American presidents have said this. What was needed was a clear statement that continued settlement expansion, particularly in the controversial E1 section of the West Bank, will make the realisation of a Palestinian state impossible. Finally, Obama was right to point out that Israel faces a growing undertow of isolation and that peace is the only path to security. But what really needs to be said is that the absence of peace and the absence of Israeli politicians willing to take any real political risks will almost certainly mean a future of international isolation, or renewed violence from the West Bank. Above all, he needed to say that the clock is ticking on that rather unpleasant potentiality. Of course, the burden of reconciliation rests not only on Israelis. Obama was right to highlight Palestinian intransigence, while also arguing that the current Palestinian leadership in the West Bank is a true partner for peace. Israelis face a tough choice in their relations with the Palestinians, but anyone who argues that the change must come only from Israelis is not being honest. Israel nds itself at dicult moment: most Israelis accept the need for a Palestinian state, but they also nd the status quo preferable and they are resistant to embrace painful realities and potential dangers. If the recent Israeli election showed us anything, it is that the nations political leaders will not provide the impetus for change, nor be the ones to push the Israeli people toward accepting the risks that come with peace.
There is little energy or incentive to change the dangerous path that Israel is on. Thats why US leadership is essential
nd yet, one would be hard-pressed to nd many in Israel who believe that a continuation of the status quo is possible. But there is little energy or incentive to change the dangerous path Israel is on. US leadership pushing Israel more forthrightly toward peace is essential. Speeches that recount the benets of peace are well and good, but they feel almost tangential from where the conict stands today, given the urgent need for progress and active US leadership. That is asking a lot of Obama. As the recent hearings for the secretary of defence, Chuck Hagel, have demonstrated, there isnt much in the way of domestic political incentive in the US for taking positions on the ArabIsraeli conict that involve speaking hard truths about Israel and the prospects for peace. And with plenty of challenges at home, theres good reason for Obama not to want to expend political capital with the Israelis and the Palestinians. Almost all observers of the region agree that the only outside force with the potential to push the peace process forward in a nonviolent manner is the United States. A more engaged US eort on the peace process should bring results, but there is no guarantee. It will mean putting pressure, where necessary, on Israel. One takeaway from Obamas words was that he believes strongly about what needs to happen between Israelis and Palestinians. Whether he is willing to put his administrations prestige on the line toward achieving that goal is far less clear. This was a memorable speech: Obama said things that Israelis need to hear from a US president. But nothing that happened in Jerusalem will do much to make a twostate solution more likely to be realised. More than ever, both Israelis and Palestinians need not words, but actions from a US president. It remains to be seen whether those will be forthcoming.
The Nigerian author Chinua Achebe inspired generations of African writers and transformed world literature
y sister teaches Chinua Achebes Things Fall Apart to her young teenage pupils and, as a companion text, Shakespeares Macbeth. This may seem, to any literary mind steeped in the orthodoxy of the western canon, an act of reckless equivalence. But she and I are lucky enough to be of a generation whose parents, aware of the need to supplement that very canon, made sure that Achebe, Ngugi and Soyinka were on the shelves next to Hardy, Austen and, yes, Shakespeare. On hearing of the death of Achebe, friends have been in touch to exchange very African utterances of condolence. The great man is gone, says Ben Okri. Who will speak out for us now, writes Ike Anya. Each of us has a story of how reading Achebe revealed the possibility of putting ourselves at the centre of a narrative and allowed us to read in the rst person. In his debut, Achebe accorded the religion, culture and domestic economies of everyday Igbo lives a level of intimacy and humanity that rendered their experiences universal, boldly shifting the boundaries of perspective. When, in his essay on Conrads Heart of Darkness, Achebe spoke of the prospect of rewriting a western view of Africa, he concluded: Although the work of redressing which needs to be done may appear too daunting, I believe it is not one day too soon to begin. This year alone will see international publication of books by writers including Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, Taiye Selasi, NoViolet Bulawayo and Alain Mabanckou as lead titles with none of the specialist back-of-thebookshop timidity that would have been evident even 10 years ago. While this tremendous reach of writing by Africans may have happened regardless, I cannot help but wonder just how much of it is because of the possibilities opened by Achebes own life and work. This was a life lived in the heart of a continent at a time of great political and social change. When Achebe published his rst novel in 1958, Nigeria was two years away from independence. It was a country blessed with the economic promise of rich reserves of oil and a vast, ethnically diverse population. Though Achebe chose initially to write of the past, he did so with a realism that eschewed romanticising and challenged his readers to recognise a contemporary truth: that we were still far from regaining what was lost, and were in danger of losing still more. By 1964, his novel was the rst by an African writer to be set as a required text in schools across the continents English-speaking countries and it is, more than 50 years after publication, the most widely read work by an African writer the book that, more than any other, has introduced readers across the world to the writing of the continent. Achebe went on to write four other novels two of them, No Longer at Ease and Arrow of God, tell the story of his protagonist Okonkwos descendants, charting the fate of Nigeria itself. These works laid out the landscape of writing from Africa in the decades that
BELLE MELLOR
followed. They featured characters whose struggles with change and identity, modernisation and tradition, and with power, corruption and moral accountability underscored the questions Africans were asking about their newly independent nations on an intimate human scale. With prose that takes the English language and infuses it with inections and a history that is uniquely Igbo, discernibly Nigerian and unmistakably African, Achebes is a realism that ensures the enduring relevance of his ction.
I
Achebes ction underscored the questions Africans were asking about their newly independent nations
n 2007, Achebe was awarded the Man Booker international prize for ction. In an essay celebrating the award, the critic Elaine Showalter acknowledged him as an artist who changed imperishably the way we see and understand the world. In a writing life that included poetry, childrens books, short stories and political commentary, Achebes criticism contributed provocations that not only shaped the development of writing from Africa but also the way we read it. He remained consistently engaged with literature and politics, speaking in his most recent collection of essays, The Education of a British-Protected Child, of his belief that a writers lot was to strive to create... a different order of reality from that which is given to him. In her review of Achebes last work, There Was a Country: A Personal History of Biafra, Adichie speaks of her countrymans memoir as a Nigerian nationalist lament for the failure of the giant that never was; Achebe is mourning Nigerias failures. I do not think it stretches things too far to say that Okonkwos story is applicable to Africa as we know it today. In a continent too often burdened by the actions of big men, with many of its people striving to rebuild the ruins of things that have fallen apart, the death of Achebe marks the loss of another kind of big man. This is one dened not by greed, corruption and a hunger for power, but by a generosity of spirit and an imagination that changed the course of literature. If the lesson of this great life is anything, if there is to be any revelation at hand, it is that knowing your story, and enacting the right to tell it yourself, is only just the beginning. Ellah Wakatama Allfrey is deputy editor of Granta
Comment&Debate
A leadership threat to Julia Gillard seems churlish, but Australian voters have always been a disgruntled breed
ast June, Australia celebrated its 21st. No, not a birthday or coming of age, but the completion of its 21st consecutive year of economic growth. Yup, you heard right, 21 years. Of growth. 21. While the rest of the world lurches from crisis to economic crisis, the land of Oz is powering ahead, enjoying an Aussie dollar at a record high, unemployment at nearrecord lows (5.4%), and basking in more sunshine than the rest of us can dream up. So what does its Labor government do? Attempt suicide. Last weeks coup against Australias Labor prime minister, Julia Gillard, by supporters of Kevin Rudd, the man she beat for the prime ministers post in 2010, was the third failed attempt of her mandate. In the past 10 years the Australian Labor party has installed and dispatched ve national leaders while its nemesis, the Liberal party, has tried four leaders in just six years. Viewed from Europe, where governments are planning to bail out their banks by raiding the savings accounts not just of Russian oligarchs but pensioners too, news of yet another political attack against Australias leader smacks of a particular strain of antipodean madness. For decades, it is the British who have worn the whingeing Poms label. Now its time for Australians to accept the malcontents mantle, because it is they who appear incapable of seeing just how lucky they are. Complaint has become the national default position, seen in a political class and a mainstream media who
spend more time slinging mud or kning each other than debating and analysing national policy. No other advanced economy can come close to Australias 21 years of growth. That period, a full generation, saw governments of both political avours at the helm in Canberra, and is even more impressive when you remember that it spanned the dotcom boom (and bust), the crisis of 1997-1998 (remember that one?), and the global catastrophe that was the Lehman Brothers crash in 2008. Every single time, opposition parties (again of both persuasions) channelled Chicken Little, warning the sky would fall down in Australia. It didnt. It still hasnt. The world over, economists talk about the Australian model. Theres a chorus of voices that argue that Australias success is a role model not only for resourcerich emerging markets like Chile and Brazil but also for many other already developed nations navigating low growth and burgeoning unemployment. Nobody would quibble with the reality that Australia has also been lucky, riding the back of a massive boom in global commodity markets thank you, China, and your seemingly insatiable appetite for iron ore. But the fact is Australia has shown resilience in the past and this is largely due to good economic policy. Aussie banks have been managed conservatively; none have failed, no taxpayer bailouts have been needed. There has been no Euro-style printing of money, no pushing of interest rates down to the historic lows we have seen in the UK. The Australian government, despite public brouhaha, has held its nerve, continuing to invest and stimulating the economy to keep it aloft. At 5.40% the unemployment rate one of the lowest in the industrialised world is half that of Europe, never mind the horrendous 20% seen in Greece, Spain or Italy. Surely, that sort of success should deliver government on its own. But not in Oz. Instead Labor allowed itself to be spooked by another bad opinion poll for Gillard, the epidemic of political dread fanned by male radio shock jocks and a largely hostile parliamentary commentariat. And, once again, it turned to sharpening the knives. There is, of course, one thing thats going badly in Oz. But at least the Australian cricket team is standing by their captain. More at guardian.co.uk/commentisfree
As Boris Berezovskys story shows, London has become oligarchs home of choice, with grave political consequences
n island state advertises itself as the destination of choice for the super-rich mainly from Russia to launder their money and reputations, while enjoying the high life and low taxes. Then it discovers all is not what it seems. It is not just Cyprus that might have cause to regret its business model. As the natural resources of the former Soviet Union were being plundered by a few ruthless and politically well connected individuals, Britain set itself up in the early 1990s as a welcome home, or second home, for a new global elite. London is both playground and battleground for rich Russians. Occasionally, things go wrong. The murder of Alexander Litvinenko in the capital was one of the more brazen attacks. The discovery last Saturday of the corpse of Boris Berezovsky at his well-guarded Berkshire mansion has raised more suspicions. Was it the suicide, as was the initial suggestion, of a man who had lost much of his fortune taking on his enemies? Or was it something more sinister? I only met Berezovsky once, over lunch several years ago, when he complained bitterly about his treatment at the hands of his erstwhile protege, Vladimir Putin. I did not bring out my hanky for a man who was kingmaker during the dissolute ancien regime of Boris Yeltsin. Once he had consolidated his power, Putin famously summoned the oligarchs, including those who had installed him in the Kremlin. That was then, this is now, they were told. The deal was: they could carry on their business dealings as long as a) they did not meddle with politics, and b) they looked after the nancial interests of the siloviki the political/security establishment. Some didnt listen. Mikhail Khodorkovsky, who made public his political ambitions, languishes in prison; Vladimir Gusinsky, who started the once fearless NTV television, was forced to ee. Berezovsky legged it to England before they could get him, then mounted a oneman campaign of denunciation from his gilded cage. In terms of law and tax enforcement, Britain is more favourable than its American and European rivals. An
industry has been created to cater for the oligarchs every need. Former ministers represent them in the Lords; former spin doctors do their PR; lawyers queue up to represent them, using Britains hideously indulgent defamation laws to slap suits at the rst sign of trouble. Financial advisers make sure the oligarchs pay as little as possible on their earnings, savings and even their council tax. Private boarding schools welcome their children, and their chequebooks. A parallel economy of designer shops, private jets, speedboats and security guards exists for them, and for the new rich of China, Brazil, the Middle East and elsewhere. The top end of the skewed housing market in London exists only for them. The morality of Britains assorted activities is for others to determine. The issue is more the eect this has on our body politic. Britains approach to Russia has long been contradictory. Over the last decade, while we opened the doors to the elite, diplomatic relations were to borrow a Russian word slozhny (complicated). The murder of Litvinenko sent them into permafrost. For the past year or so, strenuous eorts have been made to improve matters. There has been no ostentatious attempt to press a reset button. Instead the Brits have taken a more gradual, nudge-nudge approach. The British government is candid about its motives. Improving trade is what matters now, and niggly little problems like murders should not be allowed to stand in the way. The Foreign Oce attempted to justify the refusal to make public government papers on Litvinenko by asserting that openness would cause serious harm to the national security and/or international relations. David Cameron likes to use the term global race. Its not clear what the destination is, but diplomats regard pragmatism as a sign of a more mature foreign policy. After all, if we didnt do these things, others would move in. Perhaps we wish to emulate Cyprus and cosy up to all comers. It would be helpful if we let the public know. John Kampfner is a former Moscow correspondent. His book, The Rich, A Global History, will be published next year
theguardianweekly
Cyprus and the euro 29 March 1975
Crisis island
In the summer of 1783, an eruption at the edge of Europe triggered chaos for an entire continent. In Iceland, lava and toxic gas from the Laki volcano devastated agriculture, killed livestock and caused a famine. But as the dust and sulphur particles were carried over the northern hemisphere the disruption was felt from Norway to Egypt. In Britain, the naturalist Gilbert White reported: The heat was so intense that butchers meat could hardly be eaten on the day after it was killed. Years after its haze had passed, the volcanos explosions helped cause the food poverty that was a key factor in the French Revolution of 1789. Over the past week, the world has been transxed again by a disaster on a small island on the periphery of Europe. One of the two main banks at the heart of this crisis is called Laiki. And the resonances dont stop there. Having been landed with yet another countrys banking crisis, the rest of the eurozone is understandably keen to get it resolved. The general tenor of last weeks communications from the troika of the European commission, the European Central Bank and the IMF has been that Cyprus is a tiny economy with some idiosyncratic problems that cannot be read into the rest of the euro area. That same weariness was discernible in Brussels last Sunday, as Nicosia and the troika engaged in those familiar euro 11th-hour negotiations over a bailout package. But even if the troikas leaders get their wish, the ripples from this asco over an economy worth only 0.2% of the euro areas GDP will be felt for a long time. Because what is on show here, yet again, are deep-rooted weaknesses in the single-currency club, the competence of some of its key brokers and even the European economic model. Cypruss problems only really took o after their banks were hit by massive write-os on holdings of Greek bonds. The problems they would pose for Cyprus were evident. Yet, amazingly, European ocials did next to nothing to shore up the islands nancial system. The troika has treated Nicosia with a toughness and a thoughtlessness that it would not apply to bigger nations. This is not a new trend, but it was massively extended in the initial agreement to raid the bank accounts of ordinary Cypriots. And the troikas imposition of austerity will probably sink the island into a Greek-style depression. No small nation in the eurozone can look on without drawing appropriate lessons about what this means for them if they ever land in trouble. The introduction of capital controls may be an essential precaution for Nicosia, but it will surely be seen by international investors as a threatening precedent in an economic bloc, one of whose main purposes is the free ow of capital. If the troika gets its way, the Laiki disaster will soon approach an end. But like the namesake volcano, its historical halflife will surely be much longer.
London zoo
Creature comforts
We learn about ourselves by studying animals. The modern zoo dates from the late 18th century. But the Enlightenment centurys elevation of the human left little respect for the rest of the living world and the exotic creatures of Australasia and Africa the quagga, the greater kudu were wrenched from the wild and transported to Britain, rst for potential agricultural exploitation and then for the amusement of everyone who could aord to visit London zoo, one of the rst of its kind. More than a menagerie, its intention was always partly scientic. Yet for at least a hundred years, for most people the zoo was nothing to do with animal research. The magic of the inmates was only enhanced by the all-toohuman inspiration of the celebrated architects brought in to build their cages, from Berthold Lubetkins penguin pool to Hugh Cassons elephant house and the Snowdon aviary. How unfortunate that these palaces of the imagination were slowly understood to have failed the inmates for whom they were designed. One by one, they have closed and their residents despatched to more expansive pastures. Now the zoo hopes that the new home for its Sumatran tigers, which opened last week, marks the culmination of the long journey from spectacle to science. Defenders of zoos argue that the study of animals in captivity is vital to conservation efforts in the wild. But Jae Jae and Melati, captive-bred creatures, would have no chance of surviving in the hostile environment for which evolution intended them. This is the curious achievement of human intervention: to breed wild creatures in captivity, genetic twins with their diminishing numbers of wild cousins incapable of surviving in their natural world. They are reduced to the status of a living gene museum. London zoo argues that visitor charges underwrite conservation eorts. But protecting others of the species is an insucient justication for keeping wild creatures shut up, however artfully its done.
Reply
Secrets and lies
What dark irony that Pope Francis should come from the land of the dirty war, and in the week of his election the old men who caused such suering in Argentina are being brought to some sort of justice (Popes debut tinged by echoes of the past, 22 March). When he was in his 40s what did this new pope know about the desaparecidos? Has the church played any role at all in uncovering the secrets and lies of this horric period? Argentina is still haunted by the heartbreak of those living with fading hope for their lost ones. Now Pope Francis, a very prominent Argentinian, is head of the Vatican state, and since he is allegedly no stranger to secrets and lies in his own country, how will he deal with the secrets and lies in the Vatican? The theatrical performances that are Vatican specialities may distract the groundlings in St Peters Square, but thousands who have suered at the hands of ordained clerics and tricky bankers want more than ritual show. Pope Francis will certainly need prayers: he may shortly nd that the Rock on which he stands is not St Peters solid granite of old, but sandstone, fast eroding. William Emigh Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
Follow us
that much of the bailout is being provided by taxpayers in other EU countries, where a more realistic level of tax is and always has been levied. Alan Williams-Key Madrid, Spain
Gary Kempston
Briey
Australia at last links angry summer to climate change (15 March) unprofessionally conates reportage with editorial, and not only in the headline. I suppose describing the piece as a blog is supposed to allow this. But why then is it in the international news section rather than comment and debate? The GW needs to resist succumbing to the non-standards of the blogosphere. Terry Stokes West Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Regarding the cholera disaster in Haiti, Ian Birrell states that Such a story sounds like something created in the febrile mind of a Hollywood scriptwriter, which in real life would lead to a huge and justied outcry (8 March). Has he forgotten Bhopal and the Union Carbide disaster? Tanya Thorpe Melbourne, Australia Binyavanga Wainaina says about the international criminal court: I propose they build their court properly, then talk to us when it is grown up, when there are a few convictions of people who are not Africans (15 March). He is not the only one who is waiting for a conviction of someone from Europe, the US or Israel. Lucila Makin Cambridge, UK
Eyewitnessed
Karen refugees from Burma pick their way through the charred remains of Mae Surin camp in Mae Hong Son province, Thailand, in the aftermath of a re that swept through the shelters, killing
Thousands of dead prawns were washed up on beach at Coronel, Chile, after water used to cool two nearby thermoelectric power plants was discharged into the sea Reuters
Lights go out around the Kremlin in Moscow last Saturday during Earth Hour, the annual global environmental event organised by the World Wide Fund for Nature Barcroft Media
An acrobat with the Chinese National Circus performs in Brno, Czech Republic Getty
A scientist in the northern Sahara desert near Erfoud, Morocco, tries out a spacesuit during experiments designed to prepare for a future manned mission to Mars Reuters
Chinese Girl by Vladimir Tretchiko, said to be one of the worlds most reproduced paintings, was auctioned for 982,050 at Bonhams in London last week Andrew Cowie/AFP
n the second day of 2013, a girl was shot twice, in the chest and limbs, from a very close distance. The girl is 20 and an Israeli soldier. A commander, actually. Her condition is now reported to be serious but stable. On the rst day of 2013, I woke up afraid. I was scared that a rat had crawled up my trousers while I was asleep. I could almost feel it, furry and warm, sning its path past my knee and along my thigh. I jumped out of the bed and shook my trousers. I ung the covers, looked under the bed. There was no rat. This is not the rst time I have been woken up by this particular imaginary and persistent rat over the past year. I never seem to nd it. The person who shot the girl who was injured on the second day of 2013 was also a girl, and an Israeli soldier. The shooter is still in boot camp, which means she is probably 18. She is under the command of the very person she shot. During a routine day in the shooting ranges, the boot camp commander crossed the shooting lines towards the targets. At least as far as anyone knows, the soldiers on the shooting line were instructed to aim their weapons at a 45-degree angle and keep the safety on. But for some unexplained reason, one that in a later report I am sure would be referred to as human error, one of the girls M16s was on automatic mode and she red two bullets that hit her commander. She then threw the weapon on the ground in panic. Hearing this news, I was afraid. I was afraid of something that did not happen to me in 2006, when I was a soldier. Of a day a fellow soldier could have shot me in the ranges, but didnt. I have never experienced war, but I did serve in the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) as a weaponry instructor. I was 18, and the service was mandatory for all citizens. I dont remember ever being afraid while I was in the army. Yet this does not mean I am not afraid now, of things that happened while I was a soldier. For me, fear is a delayed emotion. A message in a bottle that your older self does not remember your younger self ever writing, and that your older self nonetheless receives. The bottle with the message comes ying from above and smashes on your face, years later. I remember I woke up to a ght with a fellow soldier, a condescending neat freak who always harassed me about how I kept food under my bed. She claimed the food would bring bugs into the caravan we shared, which was just about the dumbest thing I ever heard. She threatened to tell on me, but she never did. I remember I was particularly mean in my reply to her that day, because I had had a lonely four-hour guarding shift on a mountain by the ammunition bunker the night before. It left my nerves frayed. I was so bored during that shift and the minutes seemed to crawl. I broke the rules by reading a Murakami book, holding it hidden behind the barricade and looking up every fourth sentence to make sure no ocer was passing by. It was dark, and every sentence took a couple of minutes to make out, the words slippery and somehow made more precious. I didnt dare lift the book up into the light, because I had already been caught reading a few weeks earlier. I promised I would never do it again in exchange for not being punished. The soldiers I was assigned to for that month were Bedouin foot trackers in early training. My job was to supervise their rst encounters with their personal M16s and administer the various shooting drills they had to go through in order
to complete boot camp. I loved being assigned to train them. Their level of discipline was not very high, but they were always hilarious and kind to me, maybe because I was the only girl involved in their training. One time, a soldier got so frustrated during a dry drill, he threw his gun at his commander and declared hed had a change of heart he did not feel like being a soldier any more. Another time, a soldier came into the range in his socks after deciding that the new army boots were hurting his feet. Because of this loose discipline, the officer in charge of the unit was especially strict when it came to following safety procedures on the range. Training accidents happen in the IDF every month, but to me they never seemed like a real possibility. The soldiers had to hear the safety procedures ve or six times a day, and at length. I listened to them as I listen to the security instructions on planes, but the ocer took them
seriously, since this was his responsibility. Whenever someone spoke or even smiled while standing in the shooting range, the ocer erupted in screams about how that soldier was endangering the lives of his friends. It got to be exhausting. I for one never believed there was any danger. The soldiers were silly, but they took the procedures of the shooting range as almost holy, given how strict their ocer was about them. On that almost-fateful day, we were nearing the soldiers last days in the range for their boot camp training. It was customary to use those last days for drills that were more fun and interactive. In my mind, those last days were more like the last days of summer camp than the last days of shooting training. Each team was given its own set of targets at increasing distances. The soldiers loved blowing up the balloons and putting them on the cardboard targets. The teams stood in lines on the sand, and each soldier got his
Weekly review
Letter from Papua New Guinea
Ready for combat ... a female soldier in the Israel Defence Forces paints the face of a comrade with mud in preparation for a survival course for women infantry IDF/Reuters/Corbis Continued from page 27 evening, I was busy getting ready for another guarding shift, stung my pockets with the bread and chocolate spread I hid under my bed. That day was only almost fateful, and as such I should have condemned it to be forgotten, except it somehow came back to me, on the second day of 2013, upon hearing of the shooting of a girl I never met. I was sad, lonely, annoyed, angry and bored during my service days, but never afraid. I am only afraid in hindsight, years later. When you are young, you do not yet know all the reasons you should be afraid. Bad things have yet to happen to most of the people your age. You think you are invincible. I am 25 now, but I sometimes look at older people on the train or walking the streets, and think they are the ones who are truly brave, rather than the young. To have lived for so long and to know all that there is to be afraid of and still leave the house in the morning is to me the truly courageous act. I look at the 30- or 40-year-old politicians in my country and I have no idea how they do it. The only time I ever voted was back when I was an 18-yearold soldier. I voted for Kadima, the largest party at the time, and the one that ended up winning. I did it because so many people were doing it. The truth is, I did not really give it much thought. I was more concerned about the girl who was threatening to tell on me about the food I hid under my bed. That summer, under the leadership I chose, the second Lebanon war broke out. Many in the army felt we were not prepared. People died on both sides. My hometown was showered with missiles and residents were told to ee. Later, the prime minister I voted for would become the rst Israeli prime minister ever convicted of a crime. When I cast my rst and only vote, I was not afraid of what would become of it. Now I am afraid to vote again. I am truly in awe when I meet the rare Israeli person around my age who isnt afraid, who dares to parade a concrete political passion. In the end, the food I left under my bed never brought bugs into our caravan. It brought a rat. I was deep in sleep in my army bed after another neverending guarding shift when I felt something climb up my leg, warm and fuzzy. I was still wearing my uniform because I had to wake up a couple of hours after my shift anyway. I tossed and tried to ignore it, but then I felt something climbing higher. I sat up and shook my leg. And then a rat scurried out from the bottom of my trousers and down to the oor. I yawned and kept on sleeping just as soundly as I had been before. I didnt tell any of the other girls in the caravan, or anyone since, about the rat. I would like to tell you that, ever since that night, I became so afraid of rats that I threw out all of the food from under my bed, but that would not be true. I continued to keep food under my bed until the day I nished my service, and never once as a soldier woke up thinking about that rat. That fear came only years later. Back then, I was young, and nothing could scare me. Shani Boianjius debut novel, The People Of Forever Are Not Afraid, is published by Hogarth
I was sad, lonely, angry and bored, but never afraid. I am only afraid in hindsight, years later
t had all started with an innocuous conversation high up in the hills above Simbai village in Papua New Guinea. A 70-year-old, extensively tattooed man called Sampson had described his village, while delicately peeling and eating the largest avocado I had ever seen. This involved repetition of the word church, gesticulation towards the far hillside and then, enigmatically the nger wandered towards the heavens. This cryptic message bugged me for the rest of the day and when Sampson returned I asked if it was possible to visit his village. He smiled broadly, nodded and watched as I started to pack the archaeology equipment. As usual that involved disentangling a bevy of curious children who were enjoying crawling through the legs of the surveying equipment. We were keen to reach the village before nightfall and so hurried down the hill-slope. At one stage I turned a corner at high speed to nd a huge gap, spanned by a painfully thin tree trunk. With no time to stop I gave a fearsome cry and careered across the bridge, narrowly avoiding the precipice on the other side. Soon after, the deeply concerned face of Sampson appeared around the bend. Outside the village we met an old lady carrying a large bundle of wood. She grabbed one of my hands and began talking animatedly at Sampson, pointing accusingly at his chest and the increasingly dark sky. The implication was clear; however, Sampsons expression remained ercely determined and we crested the ridge to stand in front of a church and four, small houses. In one of these houses we chewed betel nut, talked incoherently to one another and watched nonchalant chickens wandering through the hut. Children peered through the door and window. Sampson then led the way to the church and knelt to pray on the dirt oor. I cast my eyes around my new surroundings to see a building made up almost entirely of wood and pandanus palm fronds. The only European building materials were heavily corroded metal window frames. The glass panels had long since broken and these had been replaced with pandanus leaves. Above our heads a large hole revealed a plethora of stars that twinkled and seemed to ask Is this church roof high enough for you?
Weekly review
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and page XX
n the Palace of Wrestling, a 17-year-old named Azamat Takhoyev might be the heir apparent. Self-assured, quietly respectful, hes slight just 58kg yet powerfully shouldered. Black curls frame his face, in the way that a GrecoRoman wrestlers face should be framed. For him its about the dream. Oh, sure, theres the Olympic dream what strong young man from the trouble-ridden Caucasus region of southern Russia doesnt dream of a gold medal? And even though the International Olympic Committee wants to throw wrestling on the scrapheap, the dream doesnt die of nding a way to keep wrestling in the Olympics where it belongs. But thats not the one that counts. Wrestling? Its very hard to explain, Takhoyev said one evening in one of the big training halls of the Palace. A soft look came over his face. I have these dreams in my head when I do it. Wrestling, when everything is going right, takes him away to some other place. Right there on the mat, his sweaty opponent filled with desire to dominate him, physically, strength matched to strength, Takhoyev dreams with serene clarity of throws or moves or feints that will enable him to win, and then the dream becomes real. He grew up in North Ossetia, in the shadow of the Caucasus mountains, and he thought he wanted to be a footballer. But I was told every day: wrestling, wrestling, wrestling, he said. And then it sank in. Since the age of 12, he has lived in Moscow, in a hostel run by the Palace of Wrestling, free of charge, moulding the dream. You will hear this name, Vladimir Ostroumov, the director of what is ocially called the Ivan Yarygin Palace of Wrestling, after a famous Soviet grappler, said of Takhoyev. Ostroumov ought to know: his graduates won medals at the London Olympics. Rumours abounded for several years that wrestling one of the original Olympic sports might be in trouble. But when Ostroumov got the news that the IOC wants to scrap it from 2020, he had one thought: a catastrophe. Without the lure of Olympic participation, his sport would almost certainly wither away. Wrestling ocials from the great powers of the sport Russia, Iran, the US, Korea, Turkey and Azerbaijan are joining together to get the decision overturned and are optimistic. In February they forced out Raphael Martinetti, president of wrestlings world governing body, Fila. Ostroumov and his colleagues take that as a good sign. Sagid Murtazaliev, who won heavyweight freestyle gold at Sydney in 2000, then upped the pressure by returning his medal to the IOC. The Yarygin Palace, in Moscows Lefortovo district, is a six-storey monument to the wrestlers art, built in 2004 with three big training halls, a small training hall, a competition space, a gym, sauna, Turkish bath, acupuncture room and cafeteria. Its Museum of Wrestling dwells reverently on Soviet and Russian Olympic triumphs. And there have been plenty 63 gold medals since 1952. Up to 2,000 boys from the age of seven, and some
Gripping young wrestlers practise at the Palace of Wrestling Sergey Ponomarev/Washington Post girls, train at the Palace and 90% of them are from the Caucasus. Russias two medal winners from 2012 came to the Palace, like Takhoyev, from North Ossetia, a largely Christian republic just west of Chechnya and scene of the Beslan school massacre of 2004. Another huge contingent of wrestlers hails from Murtazalievs homeland: Muslim Dagestan, in the mountains to the east, plagued by unrest, religious violence and poverty. Wrestling, for thousands of boys in the Caucasus, represents a way out. The Palace hostel is their refuge from hard lives they left behind, and from the sharp prejudice of Muscovites against the region and its inhabitants. Our contingent is not from the well-to-do, Ostroumov said. Hooligans are our kids. We bring them up and distract them from the streets. They train together, they eat together, they spend time together. We develop particular traits: you have to be patient, and you have to work hard. Khadzhimurad Magomedov, who knows something about hard work, still goes back to Dagestan to visit his parents, but a gold medal at the 1996 Atlanta Olympics gave him the freedom to chart a dierent course through life. Today, he is a coach with the Russian team and is raising a family in Moscow. It was the will of Allah, he said recently over coee at the Russian Olympic Committee headquarters. He was nine when he started training, in the city of Makhachkala. He wonders, he said, whether theres something genetic about wrestling in the Caucasus. Maybe its because the people there had to fend o Persian invasions so many times. Physically, there are very tough guys in Dagestan, he said. What wrestling meant to him was a chance to refocus that toughness. I didnt win anything at rst. But then, slowly, I worked on my character, brick by brick. I wouldnt say Im very talented. With me, its just work. And that character comes out as a contest nears its climax, both wrestlers sapped, reduced to just willpower, Magomedov said. Who will show that desire to win more than the other? That desire, he said, doesnt just happen overnight its forged through years of training. Now, if wrestling is excluded from the Olympics, its popularity is sure to fall. So all these kids will be in the streets, he said. Crime, drugs I dont want to go into it. Ostroumov once wrestled in the World Cup tournament, in 1985 in Colorado Springs, weighing in at 51.7kg. Hes 47 now and a bit thicker, proud of his membership in the brotherhood of cauliower ears, a fraternity of men who can spot one another anywhere in the world. Even for those thousands of his boys who dont go on to the Olympics, he said, wrestling instils a respect for ambition and a dedication to hard work. I owe everything Ive achieved in life to sports, he said. But if wrestling is excluded from the Olympics, I will leave. Im a patriot of Moscow and of sports, but I will leave. I will be very sorry, but I will leave. I cant be dishonest with my boys. Azamat Takhoyev was in the training hall when he heard the bewildering news. In 2020, he will be 24, a prime age for champion wrestlers. We were all here together, he remembered. How could this be true? The coaches were gru. Get back to work, they said. There are still the 2016 Games to worry about. Washington Post
Our contingent is not from the well-to-do. We bring them up and distract them from the streets
Weekly review
on top of it. But as the holes grow, there will come a day when the surface layer will simply give way. Once those caves start to collapse, the materials above will simply funnel in, says Dr Anthony Cooper, a principal geologist at the British Geological Survey, which maps the UK for rock types susceptible to sinkholes and carries out surveys for developers, builders and individuals worried about the prospects of the land caving in beneath them. Its just like an eggtimer, really. Thats certainly what appears to have happened with this incident in Florida. In the language of geologists, the process that causes sinkholes is the creation of a void which migrates towards the surface. In the language of the layman, when theres not enough solid stu left underneath to support what is left of the loose stu above, the whole lot collapses. The resulting depressions characterise what is known as a karst landscape, in which hundreds or even thousands of relatively small sinkholes form across an area that, seen from the air, can appear almost pock-marked. Since around 10% of the worlds surface is made up of karst topographies, sinkholes are far from uncommon. The entire state of Florida, as the Bush family unfortunately learned, is classed as karst landscape, and sinkholes are so common that insurers are obliged by law to oer cover to home owners who ask for it (insurance was compulsory until 2007, when many home owners dropped it because of the rising cost). If you look at a satellite image of the state, or even just a map, says Cooper, youll see its peppered with little circular lakes and lots and lots of sinkholes. A great many of them are visible, but many more are covered in. Its typical karst topography. Elsewhere in the US, sinkholes are common in Texas, Alabama, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee and Pennsylvania. In Britain, the BGS says the carboniferous limestone of the Mendip Hills, the north of the South Wales coaleld, the Peak District, the Yorkshire Dales, the northern Pennines and the edges of the Lake District all host well-developed karst landscapes. Karstic features are also common in the UK on the chalk of south-east England, on salt in the centre and north-east of the country, and particularly on the gypsum that underlies parts of eastern and north-eastern England. Gypsum is the most soluble of all, says Cooper. If you were to place a block of gypsum the size of a van in a river, it would dissolve completely within about 18 months. Ripon in North Yorkshire, Cooper says, is very susceptible to sinkholes, the most famous some 20 metres deep dating back to 1834. In 1997, four garages collapsed into a huge sinkhole that only just missed the front of a neighbouring house. One of the more spectacular recent British sinkholes, a 7.5-metre-deep crater, opened up in 2010 beneath a patio in Grays, Essex. It was like an earth-
Once those caves start to collapse, the material above will simply funnel in. Its like an eggtimer
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and page XX
Into the abyss clockwise from top: several homes disappeared when a sinkhole opened up in Guatemala City in 2007; a car stuck in a sinkhole in Veracruz, Mexico, 2010; a sinkhole in Guatemala City, this time a 12-metre-deep hole that appeared in a home overnight in 2011 Daniel Leclair Reuters; EPA/Saul Ramirez; Getty There was also a man who emptied his swimming pool out on to his garden, and was soon confronted with a large sinkhole under his house, Cooper says. And in Florida, automatic frost sensors have set o sprays fed from boreholes and intended to stop strawberry crops from freezing but the result was more than 100 small sinkholes. So how can you detect a developing sinkhole and can anything be done about it once you suspect the process may be under way? In Britain, Cooper says, the BGS maps the country to locate rock types that may be aected by sinkholes. It also keeps an up-to-date National Karst Database recording visible sinkholes, springs, soakaways and known building damage. Using all manner of modern technologies, we cut an awful lot of data, from rock types to slope angles, covering materials and drainage, and basically zone the country into datasets that can be used by property developers, local councils, the construction industry, insurers and the like, he says. At the most basic level, people in a sinkholeprone zone are best advised simply to look around them, at the adjacent land and buildings. Telltale signs may include sagging trees or fence posts, doors or windows that no longer close properly, and rainwater collecting in unlikely places. Some developing sinkholes can be lled in; Anthony Randazzo, a former University of Florida professor who has spent his career studying sinkholes, now runs a protable company that does just that, injecting grout to ll cracks that develop underground and shore up the foundations of buildings. Its like a dentist lling a cavity, he says. But this is not always possible. The key is good drainage; you want to get water away from a vulnerable area. Covering an opening up with concrete, or lling up a hole completely with solid concrete, may not necessarily help, warns Cooper. Sometimes, too, the hole may simply be too deep: 80 metres, perhaps, compared with the 12-15 metre height of a house. On some occasions, we have had to point out to developers that a hole 20 metres deep and 30 metres wide is a lot bigger than a house, Cooper says. Thats a hell of a lot of concrete. Despite the frequency of sinkholes, linked fatalities are rare. Randazzo says he can recall only two other people besides Bush who have died because of them in the US during the past 40 years. Even then, he says, in both cases the people concerned had been drilling boreholes (and thus interfering with groundwater levels). Usually, you have some time, Randazzo, who has lectured on sinkholes at Oxford University, told USA Today. These catastrophic sinkholes give you some warning over the course of hours. This latest incident is very unusual, and very tragic. In the UK, Cooper says, no deaths attributable solely to naturally formed sinkholes (as opposed, say, to the collapse of disused mine chambers) have been recorded in recent times. But, he points out, since extremes of sinkhole-aecting weather long periods of drought, for example, followed by spells of unusually heavy and persistent rain are widely predicted to become more frequent as the Earths climate changes, we would certainly expect there to be more sinkholes in the future.
quake. There was a rumbling and we both ran out to look and there just a couple of steps away there was this monstrous hole, the house owner, Ben Luck, said at the time. It was there in a second. There wasnt a bit of dust, and there was no sign of the crazy paving it had all disappeared in the hole. Structural engineers said the hole was caused after water penetrated chalk some 25 metres down, causing tonnes of soil above it to shift. Around the world, this process that produces sinkholes has created such striking natural features as the
hills of Irelands western coast, the caves of Slovenia and the pillars of Guilin in China. Where the underlying limestone layer is thick and rainfall heavy, vast underground caverns and subterranean rivers have produced sinkholes that make whats happened in Florida or Essex look positively insignicant: the Xiaozhai tiankeng (heavenly pit) in Chongqing, China, is 662 metres deep; the Dashiwei tiankeng in Guangxi 613 metres. Croatia has a 530-metre-deep hole, with vertical walls, called the Red Lake, while Papua New Guinea has the Miny sinkhole (510 metres) and Mexico the Stano del Barro (410 metres) and Stano de las Golondrinas (372 metres). What nally triggers a collapse? The most common factor, Cooper says, is changing groundwater levels, or a sudden increase in surface water. During long periods of drought, groundwater levels will fall, meaning cavities that were once supported by the water they were lled with may become weaker (water pumping, for factories or farms, can have a similar eect). Conversely, a sudden heavy downfall can add dramatically to the weight of the surface layer of soil and clay, making it too heavy for the cave beneath to bear. Sometimes the trigger can be man-made. In chalky West Sussex in 1985, a burst water main caused an alarming rash of small one-metre to four-metre-wide sinkholes to appear in Fontwell.
Discovery
America, with a state of emergency already in force in Honduras, Costa Rica and Guatemala. The epidemic started in Colombia in 2011, subsequently spreading to Central America then Mexico. The spores are carried by the wind, but also on the clothes of daylabourers moving from farm to farm. Hemileia vastatrix was rst observed in 1861 near Lake Victoria in east Africa. It appeared in Brazil in the early 1970s, then 10 years later in Mexico. The fungus seems to be behaving more aggressively, less predictably, because it now aects plantations above 1,000 metres, whereas it used not to go above 800 metres, says Juana Barrera, an agricultural engineer at Colegio de la Frontera Sur. Could climate change be playing a part in this trend? Yes, because of the 1C or 2C rise in temperature in Chiapas in recent years, Barrera says. But its not the only factor. The age and upkeep of coee bushes matters too. Half the bushes in Chiapas are over 20 years old and belong to varieties which are very prone to rust. Another associated cause is an increasing trend to plant in the open sun, to boost productivity, instead of the traditional method of placing bushes in the shade of other trees, oering better protection for an exceptional ecosystem. In the past two years the Hamburgo farm has boosted output by moving two-thirds of the bushes into the sun. To combat the rust Salazar is going to adopt a new technique. Fumigating the plantations with copper oxychloride is no longer enough, he complains. A neighbouring farm, Irlanda, has been growing organic coee on 250 hectares since 1929. The challenge here is even bigger, for until now they have never used chemical pesticides. The solution would be to replant with a variety of Arabica more resistant to rust, but that would be too expensive, says manager Ernesto Solano. A third of the farm is already aected, but he is particularly concerned
Dangerous outbreak ... a coee picker works in Central America, where a damaging fungus known locally as roya is spreading rapidly Oswaldo Rivas/Reuters about what will happen in May with the start of the rainy season, favourable to the spread of fungus. But those hardest hit are the small growers. All our bushes have been infected, says Sonia Oseguerra, 62, who farms four hectares at an elevation of 1,450 metres with her husband. Its our only source of income. Much like the Oseguerras, 98% of the 180,000 Chiapas coee-growers own less than ve hectares of land. Most are poor native Indians,
Ring of steel The cold twist of the plough Nature watch, page 42
Dispatches
according to the Mexican Association of Coffee Production (Amecafe). A major social crisis is hanging over us, says Rodolfo Trampe, the head of Amecafe. For the time being the authorities are spending $2m to assess the extent of the contamination. Well have the results in a month, says Francisco Javier Trujillo, the head of the plant disease department at the ministry of agriculture. If the epidemic is conrmed well apply fungicides to stop it spreading beyond the affected areas. But any long-term solution involves disseminating better fertilisation practices, he says. For three days in February, 150 experts from Mexico and Central America gathered in the town of Tapachula to exchange know-how and advice. But how are we to train thousands of small coeegrowers who are widely dispersed, and cant aord to buy fertilisers or replace their old bushes? Trampe asks. We need to issue a phytosanitary alert, in order to obtain national and international funds for an emergency programme in partnership with Central American countries. Since then Trampe has been in London for a meeting of the International Coee Council. It remains to be seen whether his call for assistance will be heard in time to save the Latino growers. Le Monde Water vapour, but far too hot to support life ... an artists rendering of the planetary system HR8799 high ratio of carbon to oxygen, which suggests it formed through a process called core accretion, when grains of water ice condense from a disc of material surrounding the parent star. Astronomers hope one day to study the atmospheres of small, rocky planets similar to Earth, but these tend to be so small, and close to their stars, that the light from them is too faint to detect. If you wanted to do an Earth-sized planet, you really need a spacecraft and you really need a very dedicated spacecraft that was designed only for that purpose, said Bruce Macintosh, a co-author of the study, at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California.
Breastfeeding defended
Very few babies become dehydrated and seriously ill because they are not getting enough milk from breastfeeding, according to a study that calls for better support for mothers to help them establish nursing. Dr Sam Oddie and colleagues found only 62 cases from May 2009 to June 2010, a prevalence of seven in every 100,000 live births. In their paper, published in the Archives of Disease in Childhood, they write that all 62 babies were admitted to hospital, mostly because of weight loss and some were intravenously fed.
Discovery Jo Marchant The Antikythera mechanism showed that the ancient Greeks had sophisticated technology and a profound understanding of astronomy. Could another one be lurking under the sea?
ivers returning to the site te of an ancient k o the Greek wreck d of Anisland tikythera hera have found acts artefacts scattered over a wide e area of the steep, rocky sea oor. These include intact pottery, the ships anchor and some puzzling bronze nze elieves objects. The team believes e items could that hundreds more diment nearby. be buried in the sediment The Antikythera wreck, which dates from the rst century BC, yielded a glittering haul when sponge divers discovered overed it at the beginning of the 20th century. Among s and statues were jewellery, weapons the remains of a mysterious ysterious clocked the Antikywork device, dubbed thera mechanism (pictured right). Bar a brief visit by the undersea explorer Jacques Cousteau in the 1970s (featured in his documentary Diving for Roman Plunder), no one had visited the wreck since, leading to speculation about what treasures might still be down there. The locals told tales of giant marble statues lying beyond the sponge divers reach, while ancient technology geeks like me wondered whether the site might be hiding another Antikythera mechanism, or at least some clues as to whom this mysterious object belonged to.
Cue all-round excitement when in October last year, a team of divers led by Brendan Foley of Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution and Aggeliki Simossi of Greeces Ephorate of Underwater Antiquities, went back for a proper look. The divers used James Bond-style propulsion vehicles equipped with high-resolution video cameras to circumnavigate the island at about 40 metres depth. Now the photos released by the team show some of what they found. For centuries Antikythera was in
a busy shipping lane, but surprisingly its treacherous treache underwater clis and reefs reef are not littered with sun sunken ships (perhaps those ancient navigathos tors were more t skilled than we thought). And there are no obviou ous signs of a wreck at the th site supposedly exca excavated by Cousteau, sug suggesting that he recovered all of the visreco ible items there or that he planted p some of his nds for the cameras. But 200 metres away, the divers foun found artefacts spread across the roc rocky sea oor, on a between 35 and 60 steep slope be metres deep. The largest item it recovered was a huge lead anchor ancho stock. It was lying on a semicircula semicircular object that might be a scupper pipe, used to drain water from the ships deck. If so, the ship may have gone down as she was sailing with the anchor stowed. The team also raised an intact storage jar (amphora), which matches those previously recovered from the wreck. DNA tests may reveal its original contents. Most intriguing are dozens of irregular spherical objects sprinkled across the wreck site. They look like rocks but contain ecks of green, suggesting small bronze fragments, corroded and encrusted in sediment after thousands of years in the sea.
This is just what the Antikythera mechanism looked like when it was discovered. Then again, they could be collections of ships nails. Because the artefacts the team found are a short distance from the site investigated by Cousteau, its possible that they belong to a second ship from around the same date as the original wreck, perhaps part of the same eet. But Foley thinks it more likely that all of the remains come from one vessel that broke up as it sank. To conrm this, he hopes to revisit the site later this year. He wants to use metal detectors to map the distribution of metal and ceramic objects buried beneath the surface, as well as dig a few test trenches. Im intensely curious about whats in the sediments, he says. Cousteau only excavated a few square metres of the site but that was enough to reveal more than two hundred items, including jewellery, coins and small bronze statues. But while previous visits to the wreck have been little more than salvage expeditions, Foley says hed love to carry out a systematic, scientic excavation of the wreck site, if he can nd anyone to sponsor him: As soon as we have the money well be back. Jo Marchant is author of Decoding the Heavens, a book about the Antikythera mechanism. Her next book, The Shadow King, will be published in June
is the fact that this species, Aleiodes gaga, along with 178 others of the genus Aleiodes, was described in the rst turbo-taxonomic study based largely on COI barcoded specimens, with rapid descriptions. First speed dating, now speed species descriptions. The concept is innovative and enticing. Using a fragment of the mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase subunit 1 (COI) gene, Dr Buntika Areekul Butcher of Chulalongkorn University in Thailand, with international collaborators M Alex Smith, University of Guelph, Mike J Sharkey,
University of Kentucky, and Donald LJ Quicke, Imperial College London, has attempted to shift species discovery into high gear. This rapid genetic trawling for species took advantage of a three-year survey of 25 national parks in Thailand that collected about 1,000 specimens of the genus. But the morphological description of the Lady Gaga braconid is based on only one specimen. Time will tell whether it would be more prudent to collect new species more extensively before formally naming them. Quentin Wheeler Observer
Shortcuts
Russians to shun internet during Lent
he Russian Orthodox church has long told its followers to give up milk and meat for Lent but its leaders want the ock to go one stage further. There should be no tweeting or instagramming of the experience and no social media at all, in order to better cleanse the soul, according to church spokesman Vsevolod Chaplin. I dont mean just people who use depraved, entertaining, stupid and empty information, Chaplin said. Even useful information, that relates to our work and well-meaning interests, clogs the brain and soul too much. Russians should take the opportunity of Lent to give up social media and look at themselves and the world around them with dierent eyes, he said during a press conference earlier this month. Giving yourself several hours or 15 minutes of time during Lent to not read curses on social networks, but serious texts, serious art, prayer, unhurried conversation with close ones this is a unique chance to change your life, he said. The Russian Orthodox church has gained enormous inuence under Vladimir Putin, the president. It has often spoken out as a reactionary force pushing for conservative values and against inuences that are seen as western, like the internet. Research by the Levada Centre, an independent pollster, recently found that 79% of Russians consider themselves Orthodox. Miriam Elder & Guardian newspaper who last year visited Yedu Nesu, the company behind Gushungo. Its rebellious: everyone in the cities is supposed to be against Mugabe. People dont expect urban young professionals to support him. House of Gushungo sales have been slowly rising over the past three years. The T-shirts, starting at $10, umbrellas and other regalia were a big hit at Mugabes ZanuPF partys last conference. Saint Mahaka, the labels designer, told the BBC: The young guys are into fashion. They talk about label, label, label he [Mugabe] is already a brand himself. We decided, there is Versace, there is Polo, there is Tommy Hilger, people are putting on these labels, but dont know who they are and what the story is. We know president Mugabes story, we know who he is. David Smith
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and Page XX
Unions had complained that although Apples stores shut at 9pm, sta were often required to stay as late as 11pm, tidying the store after hours or on duty in the workshops. Apple declined to comment. The ruling was described as a severe condemnation by Eric Scherrer of the cross sector union Confdration Franaise des Travailleurs Chrtiens. He added: This decision is very good and shows the courts willingness to enforce night working laws. Juliette Garside
obert Mugabe is renowned for many things, but his starchy dress sense and Savile Row suits are considered the lesser of his crimes. And yet dictator chic has found a niche among young people in Zimbabwe. Wearing a beret, T-shirt or golf shirt bearing the signature RG Mugabe is not only a fashion statement but an act of rebellion in major cities where denigrating Uncle Bob has almost become de rigueur. The newest item in the collection is a cap emblazoned 1924, the year of Mugabes birth suggesting that, far from being a liability, the 89-year-olds status as Africas oldest leader is a point of pride. This improbable successor to Che Guevara or Barack Obama in cool iconography is the work of House of Gushungo. Its a bit daring, says Jason Moyo, a journalist at the Mail
pple has been ned and banned from requiring sta at seven of its French stores to work night shifts. The ruling may cause problems for the arrival of the new iPad, expected next month, as sta often work after hours to reorganise the stores so that the latest merchandise is on display for product launches. The courts took action after unions led a complaint. Apple was ordered to pay them 10,000 ($13,000) in damages and was warned it would be liable for a 50,000 penalty for every further infraction. French law forbids shifts between 9pm and 6am unless the work plays an important role in the economy or is deemed socially useful.
he FBI says it has solved the decades-old mystery of who stole $500m worth of art from Bostons Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, but it is withholding the identities of the thieves, adding a further twist to the largest property heist in US history. Authorities announced a publicity campaign aimed at generating tips on where the missing art is. Their focus has shifted from catching the thieves to bringing home the paintings, including those by Rembrandt, Manet, Degas and Vermeer. The key goal here is to recover those paintings and bring them back, US Attorney Carmen Ortiz said at FBIs Boston headquarters. Just after midnight on 18 March 1990, two men posing as police ofcers pulled o the heist, stealing 13 pieces of art in 81 minutes. For more than two decades, the FBI has chased leads around the globe, nally making progress over the last few years so that they now believe they know the identity of the thieves. AP
Maslanka puzzles
1 Pedanticus watched the programme Planet Ant on BBC4 until he heard the word eusocial, at which point he became decidedly antsy. What had bitten the old boy? 2 I bought two things at Beale and Endalls. The assistant multiplied the two prices together (each expressed in pounds) instead of adding them. Although the answer came out in square pounds the number was what it should have been had he added them, so only I noticed. What was the most I could have spent? (In case you hadnt noticed, we no longer have the halfpenny.) 3 If 1 is not prime and is not composite, what is it? 4 I knocked Mike Alkanes molecular model o its perch and it fell to pieces. There were black balls and white balls only. Each black ball had 4 shallow holes each equidistant from the other 3; each white ball had one shallow hole. There were a number of sticks used to connect the balls. I connected all 27 of these components up, but this arrangement was dierent from the original model. How many black balls? White? Sticks? 5 Mike has another model with 12 black balls and 26 white balls of the kind found in Puzzle 4 How many sticks are there? email: guardian@puzzlemaster.co.uk
Wordplay
Wordpool
In each case, nd the correct denition: TARANTASS a) Greek card game played with 40 cards b) Russian carriage c) frantic dance d) what Krishnan Guru-Murthy called the director of Django APPALOOSA a) orchard worker b) horse with white hair and dark patches c) illegally fermented liquor d) drinking dive in Tennessee
Cryptic
Distant object is obsolete coin (8) Greeting two snakes and the sound they make (4) Depart twice to music (4)
Missing Links
Find a word that follows the rst word in the clue and precedes the second, in each case making a fresh word or phrase. Eg the answer to sh mix could be cake (shcake & cake mix)... a) wild style b) soap maker c) re squib d) triple stick e) ower room f) beef tag
CMM2013 For solutions see page 47
Books
OCEAN/CORBIS
Sweat and tears Whats the evolutionary benet? Notes & Queries, page 42
worth bearing in mind that it has already been done in Vermont, Maine, Hawaii and Alaska. No one will agree with every word. I was maddened by Simmss hostility to nuclear power. A lot of what he writes is open to an obvious criticism: that his arguments should probably be addressed at China, India and Brazil rather than an increasingly insignicant corner of northern Europe. But there is a joy in reading someone setting out the case for such unmentionables as a 21-hour working week and an economy that runs wholly on renewables.
Cry freedom
Sex and the Citadel Shereen El Feki Chatto & Windus 368pp 14.99 Faramerz Dabhoiwala Observer
Will the Arab spring precipitate a sexual as well as a political revolution? It is an intriguing question, which the award-winning Cairobased journalist Shereen El Feki explores in this account of a highly sensitive and still mainly hidden facet of the Arab world. The book blends interviews, statistics, opinion polls, journalism and personal reminiscence. The authors grandmother pops up in most chapters, dispensing jaunty proverbial wisdom: So long as its away from my own ass, I dont mind, begins the chapter on homosexuality. Despite its breezy tone, the attempts to connect social and sexual developments are sometimes clunky: These seismic shifts in Egyptian society are rocking Azzas marital bedroom, although the earth most certainly does not move when she and her husband make love. If you are after a scholarly treatment, look elsewhere. But Dr El Fekis position as a westerneducated female Muslim, both insider and outsider (she grew up in Canada, the daughter of an Egyptian father and Welsh mother), gives the book an invaluable perspective and a dierent kind of authority. Much of it makes for depressing reading. In most Arab countries, all sex outside marriage is prohibited. Some conservative clerics have even issued fatwas against married couples being naked during sex. In 2009, a Saudi Arabian who made the mistake of discussing his sex life on a satellite TV programme was sentenced to 1,000 lashings and ve years in jail for publicly boasting of sin. In practice, chastity is considered immeasurably more important for women than men, and marriage is neither private nor equal. The obsession with bridal virginity means that it remains de rigueur in Egyptian society to celebrate the husbands taking possession of his wife by publicly parading her bloodied bedsheets on the morning after the wedding. Many brides believe its a husbands right to beat his wife if she refuses to have sex; the police tend to agree. Yet El Feki tries to remain upbeat. To put things in perspective, she highlights national dierences: the Gulf states are the most sexist; Tunisias legacy of anti-Islamic dictatorship includes legalised abortion; Beirut is probably the least bad Arab city in which to be a lesbian or transsexual. Sometimes these snapshots are illuminating, though often they come across as padding for Continued on page 38
Books
Continued from page 37 a book whose focus is on Egypt, and Cairo in particular. What optimism the book conveys comes chiey from the variety of feisty, outspoken women we meet. Female voices have been central to public life in the west ever since the Enlightenment: 300 years ago, their growing assertiveness helped bring about our rst sexual revolution. Just as that breakthrough transformed western culture for ever, so too the rising consciousness of women across the Arab world nowadays is perhaps the most hopeful sign of slow but fundamental improvement. pop star, he was just a poor kid from rural Malaysia with a bullying stepfather. Yinghuis drive masks a shameful family secret and a broken heart. In Shanghai you can be whoever you want to be. Some connections are rooted in a shared history: Justin knows Yinghuis story and her shaming past. But mostly the characters nudge and slide past each other. Phoebe keeps a picture of Gary on her wall and chats to him in a cyber room, unaware of his real identity. She gets a job managing Yinghuis spa. Justin encounters Phoebes atmate on one of his aimless evening strolls and nds in her someone else who is giving up on the dream of Shanghai. Soon Walter Chao is dating Phoebe and proposing a new business idea to Yinghui, a venture remarkably similar to the one that failed when she was a young woman in love. They celebrate in the same bar where Garys drunken brawl was recorded on a dozen mobile phones. How many of these encounters are coincidental isnt always clear, but gradually the possibility of something new is oered to each person. To Gary, a new career. To Phoebe, a wealthy husband. To Justin, freedom from his domineering family. To Yinghui, a chance to make good on her youthful ideals. Aw is a master storyteller and Five Star Billionaire can be read as The Way We Live Now for our times, for with the global triumph of capitalism, New York and London pale in comparison with the nancial behemoth of Shanghai. Like Trollopes Augustus Melmotte, the mysterious Walter Chao has moved his base of operations to the new city: Phoebe, Yinghui, Gary and Justin stand in for the speculators and wealthy families ensnared by his plotting. At 500 pages, Five Star Billionaire is only half the length of Trollopes masterpiece. Still, its a long book; and if theres a criticism to be made it is that the pace doesnt vary enough. Even where the narrative takes a dramatic turn, it is delivered in Aws spare, cool, almost dispassionate prose, which though it succeeds in many ways never quite leaves the page. Instead the characters drift towards their destinies, caught in the whirlpool of Shanghai. Theres more than a hint of fatalism in the air. Even when Yinghui is warned about her new business partner, she fails to conduct the most basic credit check on Walter Chao; she is too desperate, her dream too fragile. Behind it all, perhaps rather predictably, is a tale of ruin and revenge. But it matters little, because by the time you work out that what you thought was going to happen is indeed going to happen, you realise that Five Star Billionaire is a gentler story than at rst appeared: one of lives lost and found, of the transience of material success and the courage required to hope and to trust again, to forgive oneself and to believe in the possibility of love.
Pakistani Franklin
How To Get Filthy Rich In Rising Asia by Mohsin Hamid Riverhead 228pp $26.95 Ron Charles Washington Post
The rst thing you notice when you start Mohsin Hamids clever third novel is that its written in the second person. Why not just stick with the good old third person? As it turns out, that sense of being directly addressed is what this author exploits so brilliantly in How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia. Hamid, who attended Princeton and Harvard and now lives in Pakistan, has taken the most American form of literature the self-help book and transformed it to tell the story of an ambitious man in the developing world. The hero You is a sickly boy who might have been snued out, as so many others in his Pakistan village are, by fever or hepatitis. He and his family live in a single room, cook over a re and drink from an open sewer. Only by chance is he not a tiny skeleton in a small grave at the base of a tree. He sketches a most unequal city where rich and poor are swept together in a rising tide of frustration and anger and violence. How quaint the challenges of life in the west seem against this bloody chaos. Yet Hamids tough hero never despairs or complains. Hes young Ben Franklin in south-east Asia. I want to be rich, he tells a friend, and its just that simple a bittersweet echo of the American Dream, exported around the world like bottles of Coca-Cola. What eventually gives the story such poignancy is the young mans unquenchable desire for the pretty girl. And yet, once the boy spots the pretty girl, hes permanently smitten all through his lthy rise. Worldly and sexually daring, shes on a much faster track, swept up in fashion and showbiz. As with the sun, the narrator notes, you have always found it dicult to gaze upon her directly. This deadly Asian story of how to succeed in business while really trying nally delivers You to a very dierent place than he set out to reach decades earlier. Perhaps that shouldnt be surprising. After all, as the narrator tries to help us understand in the opening pages, The idea of self in the land of selfhelp is a slippery one.
Whirlpool of Shanghai
Five Star Billionaire by Tash Aw Fourth Estate 500pp 18.99 Aminatta Forma
Tash Aws Five Star Billionaire opens with a bang, not a whimper. Four Malaysians are trying to make it in Shanghai, the new capital of the eastern world but when we meet them, each of their lives is in freefall. Theres Phoebe, the ambitious Malaysian village girl who passes herself o as Chinese and has arrived in Shanghai on the broken promise of a job and a new life. Theres Gary, a Taiwanese pop star who nds his fall from grace in a Shanghai bar endlessly replayed on YouTube and is reduced to singing in shopping malls. Theres Yinghui, a steely and successful businesswoman whose friends tell her that to really succeed in Shanghai, she needs a man. And, nally, theres Justin, the lonely businessman adopted into a wealthy Malaysian family, who has lost his way while his family have lost their fortune. He and Yinghui knew each other in an earlier life and their reconnection is one of the ne threads that link the characters in this book. Though how many of those threads are held by the fth character, Walter Chao the mysterious I and author of the bestselling self-help manual Five Star Billionaire remains to be seen. Shanghai values are the values of a new age. Nobody wants to change the world they only want to get out of it what they can, whatever it takes. With her good fake designer bags, stolen ID and forged early life in Guangdong, Phoebes transformation is the most extreme. Before Gary became a Taiwanese
ames Herbert (pictured), who died last week aged 69, will be remembered as one of the pillars of British horror writing. He managed the rare feat of straddling both genre and mainstream ction; at the height of his career, he was often spoken of in the same breath as Stephen King, and sales of his books have run to more than 42m. He shot to fame in 1974 with the publication of The Rats, and there can be few people who grew up in the 70s who didnt furtively pass around a dog-eared copy of this and its follow-up, Lair, revelling in Herberts gory set-pieces and plentiful sex scenes.
With The Rats, Herbert established himself mself as a master of the sort of apocalyptic horror ror so popular today from Justin Cronins The Passage to any number of zombie novels. There here are few authors working in the eld of modern dystopian ction who dont owe e a debt to his work. His rst non-sequel folollow-up to The Rats was 1975s The Fog, in n which a chemical spillage generated a mist st that turned anyone who came in contact with it into a homicidal maniac. Before becoming a full-time writer, Herbert was the art director of an advertising agency, and he designed his own
book jackets jacke well into his career. After The Rats R ats and Th The Fog, Herbert moved away from apocalyptic science-based terror towards apocalypti more t traditional, supernatural horror. His were very English horror stories, very contemporary and rooted in ve time and place. While his output ti might have tailed o in the 90s, m he continued to write, and was in h fact just returning to public attenf tion, thanks in no small part to a t recent BBC adaptation of The Secret rec of Crickley C Hall. David Barnett Dav
Formidable and resplendent Ruth Rendell if she has met any murderers in the course of her research. I wouldnt want that. Ive never met a murderer as far as I know. I would hate to. Its not necessary ... I just wait until Ive got a character and I think why would anybody do that, what is it in their background, what is it in their lives makes them do it. Usually these things are just accident or impulse, or because people are drunk or on something. The old detective story thats got a really complicated tortuous motive doesnt apply to mine. Its that people do these things almost by accident, or because of anger, their rage, their madness and then probably regret it. Rendells new novel, The Childs Child, is a Barbara Vine her rst in four years. Vine was the pen name Rendell adopted in 1986; shed written 25 novels already, a mix of Wexfords and standalone thrillers, and felt that A Dark-Adapted Eye was so dierent more psychological, more family than police-oriented it required some sort of marker. In the preface to the American edition of that book, she explained how she grew up with two Christian names: her rst, Ruth, and her second, Barbara, as the Scandinavian side of her family (her mother
I have never met a murderer as far as I know. I would hate to. Its not necessary
was Swedish) found Ruth dicult to pronounce. It has always interested me I dont think my parents realised this that both my names mean or imply a stranger in a strange land: Ruth was exiled in an alien country and Barbara signies a foreigner. (This feeling of isolation, incidentally, is explored in Astas Book, based on her grandparents, who came to the UK in 1905. When they rst arrived they were ostracised. Foreigners were regarded as terrible, the xenophobia in this country was awful, she says.) Back to the preface: growing up with two names does give you two aspects of personality, and Ruth and Barbara are two aspects of me, she wrote. Ruth is tougher, colder, more analytical, possibly more aggressive Barbara is more feminine For a long time I have wanted Barbara to have a voice as well as Ruth. It would be a softer voice speaking at a slower pace, more sensitive perhaps, and more intuitive. She always knows if a book will be a Rendell or a Vine, though, and it is extraordinary to hear her discussing her work, her names, like this, as if they dont belong to her. Its that coolness, that detachment, again. I like to change on to a Wexford, or on to a Ruth Rendell that isnt a Wexford, or on to a Barbara Vine, she says. This new one wouldnt have done as a Ruth Rendell. Theres not enough crime and it is very serious, all the Vines are. And they usually have some sort of big sexual thing in them, much more than the Ruth Rendells do. The Childs Child opens as Grace another calm, collected narrator researches a PhD on unmarried mothers in ction. Her gay brother Andrew and his partner James witness the homophobic killing of a friend of theirs, and must face his attackers at the trial. Their story is set against a novel within the novel which Grace reads. Beginning in 1929, it tells of a gay teacher John, who enters a sham marriage with his young sister Maud to save her reputation after she falls pregnant, starting a lethal chain of events. Never afraid to tackle social injustice in her novels Not in the Flesh deals with female genital mutilation, an issue Rendell feels so strongly about that she helped pass a law against sending girls abroad for the procedure Rendell tells me The Childs Child has its origins in two great iniquities that came to an end about 40 years ago. One being the disgrace of having an illegitimate child or being illegitimate, and the other being the terrible mistreatment of gay people, and I thought, well, I want to somehow bring these two together. As the gay marriage bill makes its way through parliament, the novel feels rather timely but this wasnt intentional, Rendell says. Of course the coalition rather thrust it at us. I nd it amazing David Cameron should want it. I dont quite know why gay people should want to be married, but if they want to be married why shouldnt they? Rendell goes to the House of Lords three or four times a week. As the vice-president of the homelessness charity Shelter, shes currently considering whats going on at the moment with housing ... I might do something in the House of Lords about it, she says. Rendell dislikes it that people are always asking her if shes still writing, and similarly objects to the phrase at your age with its underlying implication that it would be better if women in their 70s [as she was at the time] were to stay indoors and pull down the blinds.
Culture
n 9 July Manfred Eicher will be 70. In 1969 he founded Edition of Contemporary Music, aka ECM, in Munich. Okwui Enwezor, the head of Munichs Haus der Kunst, recently curated ECM A Cultural Archaeology, assisted by historian Markus Mller. The exhibition has been a huge success, but what is there to show about a record label? Does ECM represent a work, an action, perhaps even an exception? No, Eicher replies gently, its my life. What matters to me is the sense of being alive every day. So what was it all about? A retrospective, an installation, a display of record sleeves, photographs? Im not sure Munich remembers us, Eicher adds. He often says us. Much to my surprise the exhibition manages to conjure up much of ECMs magic. It centres on a room decorated with red neon lights, where a JeanLuc Godard lm loops endlessly. To begin with I was puzzled by the idea of an exhibition, Eicher says. I just let them get on with it. Its very moving. From Tokyo to Vancouver, ECM is known for its top-notch artists, arty typeface, old-style photos, in short its style. Eicher must read a lot because in an attempt to explain the sort of independent label he wanted to set up, he describes it as the equivalent of Gallimard, POL [as in Paul Otchakovsky-Laurens], or Minuit. He grew up on the shores of Lake Constance. Discovering jazz turned him into a doublebass player, the linchpin of any band. He could have joined the Berlin Philharmonic or worked as a sound engineer for Deutsche Grammophon, but he preferred free jazz and revolt. In See the Music, the 1971 lm by Theodor Kotulla which opens the exhibition, we see Eicher on bass accompanying Marion Brown (alto sax), Leo Smith (trumpet), Fred Braceful (percussion) and Thomas Stowsand (cello). This was denitely free jazz, pushing the limits in every sense. ECM invented itself as part of this exploratory process, in the art of listening to fellow musicians, of subconscious communication and experiment. Free At Last, its debut release in 1969, featured Mal Waldron, piano, with Isla Eckinger, bass, and Clarence Becton, drums. Now the ECM catalogue boasts 1,515 items, spanning 11 centuries of music, a vast range of styles and genres. It is home to the Art Ensemble of Chicago and some very loyal contributors including Keith Jarrett, Chick Corea, Gary Burton, Carla Bley, Charlie Haden, Jan Garbarek, Ralph Towner, Jack DeJohnette and Pat Metheny. Here too we find the 12th century polyphonist Protin, Carlo Gesualdo and JS Bach, but also Luciano Berio and John Adams. And of course there are quite a few outstanding boxed sets, in particular 10 albums devoted to Jarrett in Japan. There are militant acts: The Ballad of the Fallen, a
Four decades in search of music Manfred Eicher Richard Schroeder/ECM Records amboyant opera; Escalator Over the Hill with Carla Bley and Paul Haines; and priceless recordings by Paul Bley, Lester Bowie, Ed Blackwell, Billy Higgins and Charles Lloyd. ECM attracted the greatest stylists, but also some daring adventurers, John Surman, Louis Sclavis and Rava, and American minimalists, notably Steve Reich. Eicher quite rightly opted to treat the soundtracks of Nouvelle Vague lms as a form of modernday opera. But there was Arvo Prts ground-breaking Tabula Rasa too. The story behind Tabula Rasa is revealing. In 1977, with the iron curtain still rmly in place, the work was rst performed in Tallinn. Eicher heard it on the radio in Armenia. He set out to track down the composer and nally produced the record in 1984, adding two versions of Fratres by Jarrett, on piano and Gidon Kremer, on violin. The album was a revelation. The same could be said of Facing You, Jarretts 1972 solo recording, and of course the Kln Concert three years later, which sold 4 million copies. But success made no dierence to Eicher. He carried on his wandering existence, with a Nagra tape-recorder in his backpack, always on the look-out for musicians. To begin with I just wanted to record the musicians I liked, Eicher explains. I didnt know such a small label would grow so big. In his drive to bring avant-garde music to the attention of the largest possible audience, he achieved a remarkably consistent mixture with extremely diverse ingredients, pulling in free jazz, classical, cutting-edge contemporary, ethnic, vocal and meditative strands. This in turn he enhanced with beautifully designed artwork. ECM must be the most beautiful sound next to silence, said Canadas Coda magazine. For more than four decades Eicher has done as he likes, guided by his tastes alone, simply seeking new musical encounters, with an ongoing concern for mutual respect between performers and technicians, in short responding to the pleasure principle. Some might complain that Eicher has no regard for demand, that he outs market pressures. If so he does it without acting the hero, without twisting anyones arm for the cause, and without ripping o his business partners. He has produced a wealth of music, with a very well organised distribution network and commercial savvy largely on a par with the labels reputation. He has notched up several global successes, made some stunning discoveries, working with people who set a fair number of trends. But above all what remains is a sound, a way of doing things and limitless imagination. Le Monde
I just wanted to record the musicians I liked. I didnt know such a small label would grow so big
Culture
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and page XX
More human, more vulnerable and more anatomically feasible the new Lara Croft and, below, her earlier pneumatic incarnation (2007) Allstar
Over the sequels that followed, although she rarely ditched the hot pants and crop-top, she developed more of a personality. Gamers came to recognise her as a badass. This characterisation helped counterbalance the brazen sexuality of the character design, even making it possible to argue she was some kind of feminist icon. So it was a risky move on the part of the prequels developers Crystal Dynamics to strip a character who has often been derided as sexist of the skills and attitude that once served as an emphatic riposte to the allegation. It is a risk that, in June last year, looked to have backred when executive producer Ron Rosenberg told an interviewer that in what was widely reported as a rape scene in the new game we would see Lara literally turned into a cornered animal and would feel compelled to protect her. The idea of Lara Croft being raped kicked o a media storm. The producers have since stated emphatically that there is no rape scene in the game. While there is certainly the threat of sexual violence in it, her wouldbe assailant makes it only as far as a hand on her nees him in the groin, stomach before Lara knees grapples for his gun and d shoots him dead. he has had to take Its the rst time she a human life, explains s Pratchface. Its ett. Its very in-your-face. gut-wrenching and its uncomfortable and it should be e uncomfortable. Thats what we were rolong it, aiming for. We didnt prolong we didnt do it for titillation. ation. We wanted to show Laras reactions g moment and that gut-wrenching of having to take a human n life. She
doesnt get out of that thinking: Oh my God, I was almost sexually assaulted. Shes thinking: Oh my God, Ive taken a human life. The writers were aware some players would object. I think some people are very attached to old Lara because shes very capable and she doesnt show any vulnerability and she knows she can get out of any situation, says Pratchett. But thats not really interesting for a character. So is the new Lara still a sex symbol? I think so, says Pratchett, but its sort of in a dierent way and its more than being just a pure visual. Its not oversexualised. Its not the pneumatic breasts and the midri-revealing top or the hot pants. But Im not going to deny that shes a beautiful young lady. The physical makeover has been dramatic but also, arguably, necessary. In the high-definition world of a modern console game, the old Lara Crofts proportions would simply have looked cartoonish. The technology demands this immersive cinematic interactive experience, explains Ian Livingstone, president of Tomb Raiders original publishers Eidos, and an ever-present ever-prese gure in the life and evolution of Lara Crof Croft. Thats where games have been going, the incessant i drive towards total real realism. If you look at any franchise thats 10 or 15 years old and look at their origins theyre totally d dierent to the iterations that are available today. Cou Could the new Lara Croft be a feminist fe icon? That, says Pratch Pratchett, is not for her to say. I just hope shes seen as an interesting character, really. intere
Diversions
Notes & Queries
Darwins theory foresaw the survival of the wettest
What is the evolutionary advantage of shedding tears when I am sad or getting sweaty palms when I am scared? Ask that question after another 50 generations have passed, by which time our brains, will have evolved suciently to know the answer. Dick Hedges, Nairobi, Kenya Tears and sweaty palms are outward and visible signs of inner turmoil and have evolved as a safety-valve to counteract stress. Laughter does a similar job. Ursula Nixon, Bodalla, NSW, Australia Tears are a universal language and may induce compassion in an assailant. Sweaty palms might make it harder for an assailant to abduct you. Intriguing recent research showed that wrinkled ngers from prolonged immersion improve grip and may convey a survival advantage. David Isaacs, Sydney, Australia If you ever encounter an unfriendly grizzly bear youll be well equipped to drown it. Roger Morrell, Perth, Western Australia Survival of the wettest. Robert Locke, Fondi, Italy When their sleeves cant take any more. Alan Williams-Key, Madrid, Spain
wrap themselves in the golden cloak of idealism, a wondrous and beautiful garment that is unfortunately not bulletproof. Jacques Samuel, Chilliwack, British Columbia, Canada Because the good guys are perceived as bad by a few, whereas the bad guys are thought of as such by many. Marian Turner, London, UK
Teenage skulduggery
Any answers?
When do boys start using handkerchiefs? When did they stop? Youngsters just use wasteful tissues these days. Adrian Cooper, Queens Park, NSW, Australia When they get married. As a sign of surrender. Sunil Bajaria, Bromley, UK Boys use handkerchiefs? Really?? Avril Taylor, Victoria, British, Canada Can government for the people exist when business controls the state? Terence Rowell, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada What, apart from death, is the great leveller? E Slack, LIsle Jourdain, France Send answers to weekly.nandq@ guardian.co.uk or Guardian Weekly, Kings Place, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU, UK ful: a brimstone buttery the colour of primroses; a goldcrest making clouds of yew pollen; bees among the warming stones; birdsong ringing through bright sunshine. It was a feeling of golden, cockeyed optimism wed not had since last autumn. Now a bitter wind drove in from the Arctic with the ruthless eciency of the tractor. Swirls of snow began to organise into little hail-like grains, stinging seeds scattered into the ground but wouldnt take. Birds followed the plough as if it were a funeral. Local rooks and jackdaws rose and settled to pull grubs and worms from shiny slabs of esh in silence. The geese on the pond were quiet, as were the hedge birds. Hazel catkins shook against the harsh colours and sounds of the tractor. There was no sense that such an act against the body of this land could be resisted and that its past and all its dark secrets shouldnt be turned over, picked through and sold. This ploughing was an inevitability, the result of what TS Eliot called Tumid apathy with no concentration whirled by the cold wind / That blows before and after time. Paul Evans Read More Nature watch online http://bit.ly/naturewatch
Quick crossword
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Across
1 9
6 10
11
12
10
11
13 15 16
14
12 15 17 18
13
14 16 19 20
17
18
19
20
21 23
22
24
25
21
22
26
27
23
24
1 Youre caught I understand you (6) 4 Stiening agent (6) 8 Sub (1-4) 9 Well (7) 10 Plant, parts of which are used in cooking (3-4) 11 Commotion (3-2) 12 Thick smokey fog (3-6) 17 Tree senior person (5) 19 Nice lox (anag) (7) 21 Greek letter - pinoles (anag) (7) 22 On no occasion (5) 23 Solidied CO2 (3,3) 24 Main course dish (6)
Across
7 Ones peak period (6) 9 Ugly elf (9) 13 Synthetic bre or paint (7) 14 Get better get back (7) 15 Count (on) (6) 16 False (6) 18 Attractive (5) 20 Inert gas, Xe (5)
1 The cantankerous Dwarf (6) 2 Ballroom dance in march or polka time (3-4) 3 One of the main Cinque Ports (5) 5 Restaurant serving light meals (3,4) 6 Fashion recalling the past (5)
Down
A E S T H E T E
H E L I L I O P S H I S
M K P P I T R T S O B U C R G T H
S K C O N A E B R E
P E N H O U N G H Y K S E T E T L R E
N C H W I V M A L G R O Q U S E N
H A D T Z E D C O O L I O R B A D F O
N T U E R F F V E A U S I R B L X Y
Last weeks solution, No 13,367 First published in the Guardian 20 March 2013, No 13,373
1 3 cooler cosmetic (4,11) 2 Its hard for prisoner on island (8) 3 A desire or aspiration (5) 4 Very thin 3 carrier recedes with time (8)
Down
5 Home 3 home? (6) 6 Fellow compilers half-written something positive (9) 7 Correspondent in Minnesota (2,4) 8 This angry expression by fox (9,6) 15 Last minute gathering to one side (9) 17 The last word of 14 in room making laborious progress (4,4) 18 Subtle dierence is admitted to be a bother (8) 20 Result of seduction: getting end away, maybe (6) 21 The old stay out for bread and beer (6) 23 Lightweight single layer (5)
First published in the Guardian 20 March 2013, No 25,900
C H M O L R E R M A L O H O R G O L L
A P O T E I I E P V E S E A A C T I V E R B N O A T N G A N E S E O T A R K B R E E B I O V E R U P I E P O D C A R E E A S R O L I T A T
M A D A M A A A N E M O N E A N D N E A T E R A T L L I M A O A K N E C K D R M A M M O N I A U R D U T Y E A O R U M A N
Futoshiki Easy
Fill in the grid so that every row and column contains the numbers 1-5. The greater than or less than signs indicate where a number is larger or smaller than its neighbour.
2 < 3 4 1 4 > 3 4 < 5 3 > 2 5 1
CLARITY MEDIA LTD
<
>
<
8 1 9
9 4 6 9 2 3 5 2
3 7 8 4 6 5 7 1
1 5
5 2
4 > <
Fill in the grid so that every row, every column and every 3x3 box contains the numbers 1 to 9. We will publish the solution next week.
Free puzzles at guardian. co.uk/sudoku
3 1 4 8
< 4
7 3 8 5 4 1 6 9 2
6 5 2 7 3 9 8 1 4
1 9 4 8 2 6 3 5 7
2 4 1 6 5 8 9 7 3
8 6 3 9 7 4 1 2 5
5 7 9 2 1 3 4 8 6
9 8 7 4 6 5 2 3 1
4 1 5 3 8 2 7 6 9
3 2 6 1 9 7 5 4 8
Classied advertising
Telephone +44 (0) 161 819 4278 Email paul.fernandez@guardian.co.uk
Kicker here like this Then a short description here like this Then Section and Page XX
Green shoots Ravi Kakiyayya chopping coconut on his farm in Karnataka, India Mark Tran termination for change at Karnatakas top political levels, and the scientic knowhow, the programme was born. The rationale is that farmers can increase productivity and income through the judicious use of micronutrients, such as zinc, boron and sulphur, while reducing the use of fertilisers, such as nitrogen and potash, that contaminate ground water one of the unintended consequences of the green revolution in the 60s and 70s. In the rst year we took samples from six districts. By the third year we had samples from all 30 [Karnataka districts], Wani, who has spent most of his working life at Icrisat, says. By the end, we had 95,000 soil samples of about 2kg from selected villages, which were analysed in our labs. Its the rst time soil sampling has been done on this scale in a developing country. The farmers collected the samples, encouraging grassroots participation from the start. Once the samples were examined, Wani and his colleagues recommended how much fertiliser and micronutrients to use for dierent areas in dierent districts. If we found the soil in one area has enough potash, there is no need to apply it, as it will end up in the water. The farmer saves money as well, while increasing yield through the use of micronutrients, Wani says. Having the information is one thing; getting it to farmers is another. To spread the word, Karnataka hired, on a seasonal basis, farmer facilitators from within communities rather than outsiders, on the assumption that villagers were more likely to listen to their peers than strangers. These 10,000 facilitators, each covering about 500 hectares, are the link between the state authority and its farmers. They are backed up by a logistical eort as the state pre-positions seeds of chickpea, nger millet, maize and groundnut ready for planting, as well as fertiliser and micronutrients. Noticeboards have been erected in villages outlining the quantities of fertilisers and micronutrients to use. Ravi Kakiyayya did not know about micronutrients until Bhoo Chetana. From Hassan, a three-hour drive from Bengaluru, Kakiyayya was reluctant and it took ve meetings with a facilitator before he started using micronutrients on his maize. But after boosting his yield and making an extra $165 last year, he is a convert. It was the information from the facilitator that made me change my mind. I also reduced my spending on fertiliser by 50% because prices have doubled, he says. Now I want to grow potato and banana. Some farmers say that although their yields have increased, they remain at the mercy of middlemen who charge high interest rates on fertilisers and micronutrients. We are not getting the price that we see advertised on TV or in the newspaper, says one farmer, who paid 4% interest a month for fertiliser loans. For SV Ranganath, the top civil servant in Karnataka, Bhoo Chetana has been a game changer, transforming what was the states achilles heel into a sector growing at 5-7.8% compound rate. If we can make an impact in agriculture, we can denitely make an impact on inclusive growth, he says. The challenge is: can we have this rate of growth over the next 20 years? Can we get to the point where a rural family of ve will be able to make 200,000 rupees [$3,700]? Because that is the need of the hour.
If the soil has enough potash, there is no need to apply it, as it will end up in the water. The farmer saves money as well, while increasing yield
Sport
Close shave Monty Panesar, right, congratulates Englands game-saver Matt Prior after the pair salvaged a draw in Auckland Action Images goes with it, Englands euphoria cannot camouflage the fact that in the course of the three matches they have been outplayed overall by a good New Zealand side that Graham Gooch, the batting coach, has confessed they underestimated. In Dunedin, where a day was lost to the weather, it is likely New Zealand would have won, while in Wellington, rain probably prevented England from doing likewise. Here it was New Zealand who bossed the game. Whether they would have won had Brendon McCullum enforced the follow-on is a moot point, but aside from some help from the bowlers rough there was precious help for spin or seam even on the fth day once the new ball had been negotiated. England had begun the day with Bell and Joe Root at the crease and the pair managed to stay together until shortly before lunch when McCullum handed the second new ball to Boult. His rst delivery with it was perfect, swinging down the line of the stumps and catching Root in front. If the young batsman has ambition to be an international opener then, ne delivery as it was, he ought to have anticipated the possibility. Then came two rare mistakes by New Zealand, one costly the other not, for in the space of two deliveries, Bell, who had made 40 by then, was dropped at third slip by Dean Brownlie, and Jonny Bairstow was missed in the gully. Bairstow, hopelessly but not unexpectedly, out of touch, was caught
Wales joy took away the pain of missing the Lions cut
Sport blog Shaun Edwards
here are days that wipe the slate clean, banish hurt and make you glad to have stuck the course. Saturday 15 March was one of them. Wales 30, England 3. It was a great performance, not just because of the scoreline but because it came from a team that had come through tough times together, and showed remarkable resilience in the face of some big knocks over the previous 18 months. Id nd it hard trying to pitch where winning the championship stands alongside the Six Nations grand slams, Heineken Cups, league championships and individual medals from a career in both rugby union and league. But this one is special for a personal reason, if only because it wraps up a period which started in a dark place. Ive had plenty of highs in my professional life 42 medals as a player, 11 trophies in 12 years as a coach but the time that tested me most was the three days after discovering that I wasnt going to be part of the Lions coaching squad this summer. Whereas 2009 with the Lions in South Africa was one of the big highs, hearing that I was not going to be part of the set-up in Australia made me want to chuck the whole lot in. There were ideas of turning my back on union, going back to league, possibly even leaving the country to relearn my trade as an assistant coach with the ARL. As I say, it took me 72 hours to banish those ideas and, among the Welsh players and fellow coaching sta, I understood why I did. Theyve been great to me, treating me as one of their own and its a lucky man who can be part of such a set-up. That said, Saturday was about
at rst slip straight after the interval but Bell batted for almost another full session with Prior, before he lost concentration and was caught at third slip. At that point, with 32 overs remaining, the game seemed up. But Broad entrenched himself, overcoming a nervy start and surviving one close lbw call, a thin edge saving him as he was knocked o his feet by a yorker. It did appear he would be able to see things through with Prior, until McCullum called up Kane Williamson to send down his gentle ospin to the left hander. Broad pushed, the ball spun out of the rough and Ross Taylor took the catch, the combination repeating itself two balls later when Anderson, who had shared the Cardiff heroics with Panesar, also edged. When Panesar, left to face the nal over, managed to get o strike with the third ball, the relief was palpable.
between Chris and I was: If youve got good legs, you go and if I have good legs, Im the one who goes, Porte said afterwards, straightening his seams and ashing some ankle. Elsewhere there was a rare non-Sky victory as Dan Martin of Garmin-Sharp became only the second Irishman to win the Volta a Catalunya. Behind him Sir Bradley Wiggins found sucient time in between bouts of being Sir Bradley to nish fth.
Oh, Australia. One of the more eventful cricketing tours of recent years featuring a homework-fail ticking o for the vice-captain and some genuine vitriol on the eld nished with a rare 4-0 Test series victory as Australia were roughed up again by Indias spinners in Delhi. A six-wicket win saw one-time batting illiterate Peter Siddle top score from No9 in both Aussie innings. I dont like words like revenge, Indias captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni offered afterwards, rubbing his hands together and cackling very quietly.
Chess
Leonard Barden
When England were second only to the mighty Soviets in the 1980s the momentum of new talents to ll gaps in the national team was boosted by strong weekend opens. These events gave rising school and university players chances to cross pawns with the top grandmasters and international masters. The best equivalents of the 80s weekenders are staged in Ireland, where the traditional Bunratty and Kilkenny Opens usually have the English elite as top seeds vying with the best Irish masters. Bunratty 2013 invited Englands world nalists Michael Adams and Nigel Short, who nished at the top. But IM Richard Bates shared second prize with Short on 5/6, while the Bolton schoolboy Joseph McPhillips, still an under-16, produced a lifetime best result by sharing fourth place on 4.5/6. Shorts game below looked like a throwback, a kind of recherche du temps perdu to 1975 when he was a fast-rising 12-year-old and used the now dated 4 Bc4 and 5 Qe2 system as a major opening weapon. Blacks Rf8-e8? when White was poised to open the f-le proved fatal and 19 Bh6! clinched it.
Maslanka solutions
1 To the rened ear, this is an ugly yoking of Greek eu (well) and Latinate social, a bit like Schadenjoy or Mondo-anschauung. Few scientists now know Latin or Greek, let alone how to pronounce zoology; so their coinings can be chalk and cheese. But there are early examples, too: television from tele (Greek) & vision (Latin); or sociology from socius Latin & logos (Greek). Eusociality, coined by Batra, has been taken up even by the great EO Wilson; so were stuck with it. 2 1.01 + 101.00 = 102.01. [If prices in pence are P & p, we have (P/100 X P/100) = P/100 + P/100; so (P/100 100) = 10000. To maximise, make the factors of 10000 as disparate as possible: p 100 = 1, (giving p = 101); and P 100 = 10000 (giving P = 10100).] 3 A tertium quid, one supposes. In days gone by 1 was often considered a prime, but if we want prime factorisation to be unique we must exclude 1, or e.g. 3 has more than one factorisation (3, 1 x 3, 1 x 1 x 3 ... and so on). 4 If a white ball is H, a black one C, each H must connect to a C (why?) and each C to at least one other C. The fewest Cs joinable in 2 topologically distinct ways is 4: in a zig-zag or in a tetrahedral arrangement. 4 Cs have 16 holes; 6 connect to Cs, leaving 10 for Hs. 4 Cs & 10 Hs need (16 + 10)/2 = 13 sticks, so 27 components in all. Chemists will recognise the isomers of butane. 5 37. If I had knocked this one o the table Id have a choice of 355 dierent ways of assembling them. [For n Cs we have (2n + 2) Hs and 3n + 1 sticks.] Wordpool b), b) Cryptic FARTHING (FAR + THING); HISS (HI + SS); GOGO Missing Links a) wild/life/style b) soap/lm/ maker c) re/damp/squib d) triple/dip/stick e) ower/bed/room f) beef/hash/tag
Nigel Short v Aidan Rawlinson 1 e4 g6 2 d4 Bg7 3 Nf3 d6 4 Bc4 Nf6 5 Qe2 O-O 6 h3 c5 7 e5 Ne8 8 c3 Nc7 9 dxc5 dxc5 10 Na3 Be6 11 O-O Bxc4 12 Nxc4 Ne6 13 a4 Qc7 14 Nh2 Re8? 15 f4 Nc6 16 f5 gxf5 17 Rxf5 Nf8 18 Ng4 Ng6 19 Bh6! Bh8 20 Raf1 e6 21 Rxf7 1-0
3297 Suat Atalik v Marcel Peek, Vienna Open 2012. White (to play) has a big space advantage but how did he break through?
rugby, pure and simple. I had a chance to catch up with some old friends like Andy Farrell, but the long and hard celebration was about a team that started the Six Nations with its worst 40-plus minutes and ended with the best. Save for the hangover from hell, it was a day and an experience which left me very happy, and I thank Wales for it. Shaun Edwards is a Wales defence coach and former rugby league player
3297 1 Bxh6+! Rxh6 2 Qb8! Resigns. If Ke7 to stop 3 Rxd8, then 3 Qd6 mate
Guardian News and Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Published by Guardian News & Media Ltd., Centurion House, 129 Deansgate, Manchester M3 3WR, UK Editor: Abby Deveney. Le Monde translation: Harry Forster. Printed by GPC. Registered as a newspaper at the Post Oce. Annual subscription rates (in local currencies): UK 99; Europe 164; Rest of World 127; US $181; Canada $200; Australia $259; NZ $330 Quarterly subscription rates: UK 25; Europe 42; Rest of World 32; US $46; Canada $50; Australia $66; NZ $84
Marina Hyde Justin Biebers crazy devotees are not a lone phenomenon: a world of mad fandom has long existed in places people might nd rather unexpected
h, teenagers. One minute theyre tweeting a death threat to a rival Justin Bieber follower, the next theyre moved to tears by the Kony 2012 video. What sort of monster could turn children into such shockingly desensitised soldiers? And drumroll! I hear Joseph Konys a bit of a horror too. Another week, another eleventy incidents of deranged warfare among the tribes of popstrel acolytes, like the One Direction fan who tweeted a picture of herself meeting a band member, and had the obligatory promises to maim and kill slung her way by little tinkers misusing their study nooks. Some suspect something a bit endtimesy is afoot. Good news: its not. As has been the case throughout history, the kids of today are being maligned. After all, its not as if mad fandom was invented in one of those up-all-night innovating sessions social media rms seem to enjoy. It has long existed, in places people might nd rather unexpected. Ooh, you dont want to write about Joe Cocker, warned a colleague when I led some mildly unattering line about him about 15 years ago. His fans are mental. Naturally I assumed he was joking after all, you wouldnt nger the blues rocker for a fan-designated warlord. I was certainly laughing on the other side of a face I was given to understand would soon be permanently scarred when a deluge of threatening letters arrived by return of post. Two of them had razor blades taped beneath the envelope ap. Since then, every time Cockers With a Little Help from My Friends comes on, I always hear giant, menacing quotation marks around the words help and friends. Its not Joes fault, of course I assume hes either oblivious to, or appalled by, the nutjobs who defend his name thusly but I do think of those friends in the manner of henchmen, whose help for Joe would probably involve a considerable amount of physical hindrance to me. That thing Joe does with his hands when hes singing? They interpret
it as him conducting the slashes and slices of their ultra-violence. Theres not even space to say how its aected repeat viewings of The Wonder Years for me. As for other stars whose fanbases seem to have a provisional wing, the list goes on and on. You dont want to mess with Cli s lot, is the general consensus. Joe Longthornes bunch would put some hurting on you, no problem. The crazier fans of Daniel ODonnell well, I will only say that you are entering a world of pain. All of which calls into question the strangely prevalent idea that humanity has fundamentally changed in recent years. It hasnt just coarsened, according to this generationally self-important reading: there has been some sort of calamitous fall that has altered the entire psyche of western culture. When is this lapsarian moment supposed to have occurred? Picking through the subtexts of the endless screeds on broken Britain, youd have to stick your pin somewhere between the mass availability of the contraceptive pill and the abolition of the death penalty. Thereafter, a species-wide psychochemical reaction began yet to be blamed on the contraceptive pill being in the water, but give it time that has caused a wholesale degeneration of humankind.
And yet, and yet are the diurnal death threats of boyband fans truly indicative of some psychological cataclysm? Or are they, rather like the increase in public drunkenness, merely a comment on the availability of the medium? Just as the drunks on Hogarths Gin Lane are no dierent from those whose Saturday night city centre escapades captivate todays media, so yesterdays stars probably inspired the same percentage of mad ones that todays idols do. Its just easier for them to get in touch with each other and for us to see them doing so. (Say what you like about Cockers lot, they really put the hours in.) With more enabling technology, and if they hadnt been a little preoccupied with other matters in 1941, youd have had a few Vera Lynn devotees who wanted to scalp some perceived traitors to the old girl.
You dont want to mess with Cliffs lot. Or the crazier fans of Daniel ODonnell
ts the same with football. Whenever Ive wondered pointedly in print whether any of those serried ranks of overcoated and atcapped football fans in 1950s archive shots were bellowing that they hoped some opposition players kid got cancer, lots of older readers get in touch to assure me that they heard the most horrid things being said even back then, and that vicious bile is not some 70s bolt-on to the game. As the Great Teen Tweet Wars rage blithely on, then, the question is not what can be done, but whether anything really needs to be done at all. I suppose Justin could appeal for calm. He wont, on past form, which is perhaps the most cynically troubling thing of all about the phenomenon, indicating how extremely relaxed the record labels are about getting rich o the madness. On these bi-weekly major are-ups, the Bieber silence speaks volumes. Fastidious about correcting any perceived media slight on the half-mastedness of his trousers, yet deafeningly quiet on the thousands of threats of homicide that it between his disciples every day, the only logical conclusion is that Justin loves his fans so much that hes OK with them threatening to kill each other in his name. Which lets take the positives brings new resonance to the epithet pop deity.