You are on page 1of 270
“He who has not lived in the years before the revolution cannot know what the sweetness of living is.” —Talleyrand, via Bertolucci, Prima della Rivoluzione, 1964. This book is for Brinda Karat. cS sl et OS se cin 292Khe il oe A Susie 2S oll U8 3) bl eS apt Hl “Those shattered mirrors once were The smiling eyes of children Now are star-lit This city’s nights are bright.” —Faiz, ek nagma karbala-e Beirut ke liye, 1982. And for Anthony Shadid (1968-2012). Most humane of reporters. Openings. Revolutions have no specified timetable. Karl Marx used the image of the Mole to stand in for Revolu- tions to explain their hard-working yet unreliable nature. The Mole spends its time making tunnels un- derground, and then, when you least expect it, breaks the surface for a breath of air. “Well burrowed, Old Mole,” Marx wrote; the breaking free to the surface is the spectacular part of the Revolution, but it is the bur- rowing, the preparing, that is the most important part. The least prepared Mole is the easiest to defeat be- cause it has not groomed its subterranean space effec- tively enough. Such is true of the Revolution: if it has not taken the grievances of the people and produced organizations capable of withstanding the counter- revolution —if it has not harnessed these grievances to the discipline of revolutionary force—then it is easily defeated. It is the burrowing that is essential, not sim- ply the emergence onto the surface of history. A process of preparation has been long afoot in West Asia and North Africa, all at a different tempo. In Tunisia and Egypt there have been many consti- tutional challenges to the one-party state, by which I mean challenges within the bounds of the consti-

You might also like