You are on page 1of 56

Connecting West Africas ports

Jan.Hoffmann@UNCTAD.org

The Sea

The Port The Land


The Future

The Sea

The Port The Land


The Future

To capture a countrys connectivity


UNCTAD developed the Liner Shipping Connectivity Index LSCI using the following 5 components: Companies Services Largest ship Number of ships TEU

To capture a countrys connectivity


UNCTAD developed the Liner Shipping Connectivity Index LSCI using the following 5 components: Companies Services Largest ship Number of ships TEU

http://stats.unctad.org/lsci

http://stats.unctad.org/lsci

http://stats.unctad.org/lsci

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

components

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

Country

Ships

TEU

Liner Companies

Liner Services

Max ShipSize

Rank

LSCI

Nigeria

172

359264

24

62

4500

57

21.8

Ghana

121

239107

24

50

3681

64

17.9

Cte d'Ivoire

116

219985

17

53

3600

68

16.5

Benin

80

168838

16

30

3681

73

15.0

Senegal

72

102512

13

37

3430

78

13.6

Why to we care about a high connectivity?


More

business for my countrys ports More options and lower freight rates for my countrys importers and exporters

What explains my countrys connectivity?


Geography

(position in global networks) My own trade (supply follows demand) The quality and services of my own port My wider hinterland

What explains my countrys connectivity?


Geography

(position in global networks) My own trade (supply follows demand) The quality and services of my own port My wider hinterland

The Sea

The Port The Land


The Future

Container port operators

Container port operators

(2010)

Why is port reform more difficult in Africa?


Possible reasons Difficult structural change (loss of jobs in the ports) Less vocal port users (importers, exporters, consumers) Perhaps less interest from potential investors (smaller markets, uncertainty) Less commercial pressure (less inter-port competition)

Why to we care about port reform?


Empirically correlated with More throughput and higher connectivity Higher income for governments Lower freight rates

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Wilmsmeier, Hoffmann, Sanchez, in: Porteconomics, 2006

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Better port infrastructure reduces maritime transport costs

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Better (perceived) port efficiency reduces maritime transport costs

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Port privatization in the exporting country reduces maritime transport costs

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Better connectivity between ports/ more competition among carriers reduces maritime transport costs

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Trade facilitation in the importing country reduces maritime transport costs

Dependent variable: maritime transport costs per tonne of containerizable cargo

Trade facilitation in the importing country reduces maritime transport costs

The Sea

The Port The Land


The Future

Seaports and transit cargo


The good news: An increasing awareness that transit trade is good for the transit countries! It is good for my own ports business. It is good for my own importers and exporters, because it helps improve shipping connectivity.

Facilitating transit trade and its transport


The good news: The increasing awareness that transit trade is good for the transit countries! It is good for my own ports business. It is good for my own countrys importers and exporters, because it helps improve shipping connectivity.

Facilitating transit trade and its transport


The good news: The increasing awareness that transit trade is good for the transit countries! It is good for my own ports business. It is good for my own countrys importers and exporters, because it helps improve shipping connectivity.

Facilitating transit trade and its transport


The good news: The increasing awareness that transit trade is good for the transit countries! It is good for my own ports business. It is good for my own countrys importers and exporters, because it helps improve shipping connectivity.

Seaports and transit cargo


The bad news: Transit cargo stays longer in the port than national imports and exports The port is abused as warehouse Customs and other authorities are not sufficiently prepared for transit trade

Seaports and transit cargo


Need to involve all stakeholder: Public and private sector Users and providers Trade and Finance = National Trade Facilitation Committee

The Sea

The Port The Land


The Future

The future

The future of today is different

Where are we heading?

Liner shipping networks


Seek

to benefit from competition and economies of scale Avoid unnecessary restrictions

Port reform
Strengthen

the private sector Strengthen the public sector

Inland connections
Infrastructure

is important, but also: Strengthen Collaboration Strengthen Competition

More income to finance trade facilitation -> Better trade facilitation -> More Trade -> More income to finance trade facilitation

Lower Transport Costs -> More trade -> Economies of scale -> Lower Transport Costs

Better services -> More trade -> More income to finance infrastructure -> Better services

Better connectivity -> More competition -> Lower freights -> More trade -> Better connectivity

The Sea

The Port The Land

Globalized production of "maritime transport"

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Korea and China 74.1%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Greece, Japan: 32%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Panam, Liberia, Marshall Islands: 41%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Denmark and Switzerland 23%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


India, Bangladesh, China, Pakistan 94%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Services: UK, Scandinavia

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

4: Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Philippines, Indonesia,

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

Globalized production of "maritime transport"


Hong Kong, Netherlands, Singapore, UAE: 46%

1. Building

2. Owning

3. Registration

4. Operation

5. Scrapping

6. Financing 7. Classification 8. Insurance services (P&I) 9. Seafarers 10. Container terminal operators

You might also like