Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://micro2.tholden.org/
Readings
Varian, Chapter 34 Morgan, Katz and Rosen, Chapter 18
Externalities questions
What are externalities? How do they affect efficiency and welfare?
What is the tragedy of the commons, and where do such problems arise?
ECO2051 Intermediate Microeconomics 3
Definitions of externalities
Consumption externality:
When an individuals utility is affected not just by their own consumption of goods, but also by the consumption of another individual. Examples?
Production externality:
When the costs faced by a firm are affected by the production of another firm or the consumption of an individual. Examples?
Motivating question
The ring road around Paris is one of the busiest roads in France. Whenever a person takes his or her car onto the road during rush hour, the congestion increases. Why is an externality present?
Good A Equilibrium
Which good is in excess supply at the endowment? Which outcomes Pareto dominate the endowment?
Endowment
Person A
Good B
The Edgeworth box with externalities & property rights (the right to clean air)
Person B (likes clean air)
Smoke Equilibrium
What would the picture look like if there was a right to smoke?
If the agents use the price mechanism to trade this effectively creates a market for smoke and the externality problem is solved.
Utility at the Pareto efficient point will depend on the endowment.
This is basically a tautology. As we saw in the previous example the amount of smoke depended on the allocation of property rights although the outcome was always Pareto efficient.
10
Quasi-linear preferences
Person B (likes clean air)
Smoke
Money
ECO 2051 Intermediate Microeconomics 11
Production externalities
Pollution (x)
Imagine a fish farm and a steel factory. The steel firm pollutes (externality). Pollution affects fish production. Level of pollution out of control of fish farm.
12
Production externalities
With competitive markets (price taking):
Steel will be produced up to the point where the marginal cost of steel equals the price. Fish will be produced up to the point where the marginal cost of fish equals the price. Pollution will be produced by the steelworks as the marginal cost to the steelworks is equal to 0, but socially this is not the case, there is a cost to the fishery.
13
14
15
Suppose that the steel factory and the fish farm were both listed on the public stock market.
Would this help with the externality?
16
Gas and auto repairs cost $1 per hour of driving. All citizens have an income of $40 a day. If all citizens believe that their driving will not affect the amount of driving done by others how much will they drive? If a social planner was deciding how much people should drive, how much would they choose? Details on the board again.
ECO 2051 Intermediate Microeconomics 17
Implications
The First Theorem of Welfare Economics breaks down: the market outcome is not Pareto efficient. That consumers only care about their own consumption is one of the assumptions implicit in the First Theorem.
18
This outcome can be achieved by using saleable permits. In a free market permits will sell at exactly the price of reducing emissions. Downside: how should permits be allocated to firms?
19
Difficulty: knowing the optimal level of pollution in order to choose the tax level.
If we knew this info in the steel/fish example we could just regulate (instruct the steel firm to only pollute so much). Does this criticism apply to carbon taxes for countering global warming?
20
In the fish farm example, the pie to be bargained over is the gain in total surplus that comes from moving from the private optimum to the social optimum. The result of bargaining will generally depend on the initial allocation of property rights.
ECO 2051 Intermediate Microeconomics 21
What are profits now? What is the solution? What is the fisheries profit maximising choice of ?
22
What is the socially optimal number of cows? How many cows will there be under laissez-faire?
23
>
24
Further details
Intuition:
When a villager adds one more cow his income rises (by ) but every other villagers income falls. The villager who adds the extra cow takes no account of the cost inflicted upon the rest of the village.
25
26
27
Conclusions
Externalities violate one of the assumptions which lead to the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics. With externalities, Pareto efficient outcomes are unlikely in general. Solutions involve the state mimicking the price signals that should be provided by the market, or determining property rights to allow missing markets to be created.
28