You are on page 1of 74

37th Annual National Convention of the Institute of Integrated Electrical Engineers

Principles of Cable Sizing and Selection


By Anthony G. Quiogue, PEE

COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 2012 Fluor Corporation

Introduction
There are several aspects of selecting cables for a given application. Among the most important are the following: type of installation or laying conditions, voltage rating, ambient conditions, and the most important aspect, ampacity. The more complicated issue in cable selection is choosing on the basis of ampacity. The Philippine Electrical Code (PEC) has specific rules for calculating ampacity requirements for branch circuits and feeders Having calculated the required ampacity, the next step is to select the cable type. After selecting the type the next step is to carefully determine the cable ampacity corrected for variant conditions of installation intended for the cables use.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Cable Selection Cable selection involves carefully considering the following factors:
Voltage

Cables are rated for a certain voltage of application. Common building wires are rated for 600 Volts. In the Code, generally, rules of application are divided into for cables 0 to 2000 Volts and for cables over 2000 Volts. Choose the cables appropriate for the intended use.

Insulation type The insulation types are marked on the

cables. These markings identify the insulation material.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Choosing the insulation type necessitates knowing the

following:

The maximum temperature the cable will be allowed to


reach in use. This is greatly influenced by:

Ampacity requirements of the load. This sets the minimum


requirement in sizing a conductor for use.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Terminal provisions of connected equipment
Those rated 100 A or less or marked for 38 sq mm or less shall have conductors rated 60C connected to them; conductors rated 75C can be used if the ampacity is determined at 60C rating. Those rated more than 100 A or marked for more than 38 sq mm shall be allowed to have 75C rated conductors connected. Higher temperature rating conductors shall be allowed if their ampacities are determined at 75C. Higher conductor ratings may be used if the equipment is listed and identified for use with such higher temperature

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection

The moisture factor: whether the condition of installation is


dry wet damp

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Cable Construction

This factor will be determined primarily by the design installation conditions. This factor consists of the following:

Whether solid or stranded, for small conductors Whether a jacket is applied over the insulation, over a
set of conductors, or over armoring Whether the cable is single conductor or multiconductor For multiconductors, the number of core conductors For multiconductors, whether the ground wire and/or the neutral is integrated with the cable

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Additional covering or whether shielding and/or armoring
or metal sheathing is desired: shielding is basically for electromagnetic isolation, armoring is for mechanical protection while metal sheathing provides water-tight protection. For example, lead sheathed cables are common in the petroleum industry.

Cable construction also determines resistance to damaging


environmental conditions. Whether the insulation or additional covering is needed to afford chemical resistance, radiation resistance, flame resistance, flame retardance, ozone, oil or fungus resistance, etc

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
Ampacity The most important factor to consider is cable ampacity. Basically, it should match the requirement of the circuit, that is, the demand of the load. After the ampacity is determined, the following conditions should then be checked and the size of the conductor adjusted as necessary:

Voltage drop. The Code recommends a maximum combined


voltage drop of 5% for branch circuit and feeders. A related issue is the necessary check on the terminal voltages of control and protective device, to ensure that they will operate as required

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

Cable Selection
The basic rule in the Code is that conductors shall be
protected against overcurrent at their derated ampacities. Protective device rating. The PEC states that The next higher size of protective device rating shall be permitted for ampacities 800 amperes or less. The next higher size of protective device shall be used for ampacities higher than 800 amperes.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

10

Ampacity -- Definition
Ampacity is defined in the PEC (Article 1.1.1) as the current, in amperes, that a conductor can carry continuously under the conditions of use without exceeding its temperature rating. This definition gives us the following points to consider: 1. Ampacity is a continuous current rating of the conductor; 2.The conditions of use MUST be specified, 3. The conductors temperature rating MUST not be exceeded

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

11

Ampacity -- Definition
The mechanics for the rise in temperature in a conductor must also be understood to fully appreciate the limitations and imposed by the conditions of use on cable ampacity.

Consider a conductor with resistance R carrying an amount of impressed current I. The current will generate heat within the conductor at the rate P according to the following power formula P = I2R. To a lesser degree heat is also generated by induced currents in the other metallic components of the cable, if present. Among these are metallic sheaths and armors

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

12

Ampacity -- Definition
Losses in the dielectric materials surrounding the

conductor also contribute to heat generation (insulation, shields, screen, jacket and serving/bedding) nearby) contribute heat to the conductor as well as to the environment surrounding that conductor

Other heat sources (e.g. other current-carrying conductors

All the generated heat tends to raise the temperature of the

conductor material. With a sufficient combination of current and time, (I2t), the conductor, and its insulation will attain a higher temperature than the ambient (air or soil).

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

13

Ampacity -- Definition
The difference in temperature gives rise to the transfer of
heat from the cable to the environment. This transfer occurs by way of conduction, convection and radiation Conduction is the transfer of heat from molecule to molecule and generally occurs predominantly if the material surrounding or touching the cable is solid, such as earth Convection occurs if the material surrounding the cable is a moving fluid such as air, oil or water. Convection is the transfer of molecules (and therefore with it, heat) either by bulk or significant diffusion Thermal radiation is another mode of heat transfer although a less significant one under normal temperature ratings

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

14

Ampacity -- Definition
Generally all modes of heat transfer operate. Conductors in
a raceway in earth will have convection operating in the air within the duct and conduction from the duct to the earth

The rate at which heat is transferred to the environment is

affected by temperature difference as well as the thermal barriers between the conductor and the environment. Thermal barriers include the insulation, jacketing, air inside raceway, the raceway itself, soil, concrete, building materials, and any thermal insulation applied such as fireproofing.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

15

Ampacity -- Definition
If an equilibrium is attained between the rate of heat transfer
and the rate of heat generation, a steady state temperature is achieved by the conductor which is also the temperature at the boundary with the insulation. developed within it. However, the insulation enclosing the conductor has temperature limits as determined by its thickness and composition

The conductor can normally withstand the temperature

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

16

Ampacity -- Definition
This limit is termed the conductors maximum operating
temperature.

The object therefore of defining the ampacity of a specific


conductor is to set the value of current at which the maximum operating temperature will not be exceeded.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

17

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


The PEC recognizes inherent cable characteristics, determined by design and manufacture, that set the fundamental parameters for a cables ampacity rating. Among these are:

Conductor characteristics
a. Conductor material b. Conductor size

Insulation characteristics
a. Type of material b. Thickness

Construction
a. Single conductor or multi-conductor b. Presence of jacketing, coverings, sheathing and armoring

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

18

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


These characteristics in turn, determine the following

Application provisions (voltage, location and type of


installation)

Temperature rating (maximum operating temperature)

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

19

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Conductor Material

The material of the conductor affects the ampacity


because the resistivity, and hence the resistance, for a given size is determined by the type of material

The formula for resistance is as follows:


R = L/A Where R is the conductors d.c. resistance, is the conductor material resistivity constant, L is the length and A is the cross-sectional area.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

20

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Conductor Material

The most common conductor materials are copper,

with a resistivity of 1.68 x10-8 ohmm at 20oC, and aluminum with a resistivity of 2.82 x10-8 ohmm at 20oC

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

21

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Conductor Size

From the same formula it is noted that resistance is


inversely proportional to the cross sectional area. Therefore, the smaller the wire diameter, the greater the resistance for any given length, all other factors being equal.

Wire sizes in the PEC are designated in terms of square


millimeters (mm2).

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

22

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Insulation types

Electrical conductors are normally coated or wrapped


in insulating materials to isolate conductors from one another as well as provide some sort of mechanical protection

There are various insulation material types used for


conductor insulation. Among the common ones are: Natural polymers such as paper, cotton and natural rubber Synthetic polymers such as thermoplastic materials (e.g. PVC and fluorinated plastics) and thermosetting materials (e.g. synthetic rubber, cross-linked polyethylene, and silicone rubber) Mineral insulation
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

23

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Insulation types

The different insulation types offer different


characteristics which, together with insulation thickness, determine the application conditions for which these types will be allowed. Among these characteristics are: Dielectric strength Resistivity Flame and Heat resistance Resistance to abrasion, cracking, crushing and impact

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

24

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Insulation thickness

Cables are wrapped in varying thicknesses of

insulation. The PEC specifies required insulation thicknesses for listed insulation types. The thicker the insulation, the better it can withstand an applied voltage before breaking down, so generally, the higher the conductors voltage rating the thicker the insulation. Aside from providing electrical isolation, insulation should also provide some mechanical protection

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

25

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


The PEC Tables 3.10.1.13, 3.10.1.61, 3.10.1.62, 3.10.1.63

and 3.10.1.64 list approved insulation type and thickness for various cable insulations. In fact the code defines insulated conductor as one encased within material of composition and thickness that is recognized by the code as electrical insulation. This recognition is documented in these tables. Conductors not meeting the required insulation type and minimum thickness of encasing material are classified as covered conductors only.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

26

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Insulation Temperature Rating

Insulated conductors are characterized by a specific


maximum operating temperature rating based on the type and thickness of insulation employed on the conductor.

As mentioned in above, the object of defining the


ampacity of a specific conductor is to set the value of current at which the maximum operating temperature will not be exceeded.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

27

Factors Affecting Ampacity Inherent Cable Characteristics


Insulation Temperature Rating

Higher-temperature rated insulation allows a conductor


of the same size to be used at a higher ampacity than a conductor with lower-temperature rated insulation. Example: A copper conductor of size 8 mm2 has an ampacity of 40 amperes if the insulation is rated 60oC (Types TW, UF) but it has an ampacity of 50 amperes if the insulation is rated 75oC (Types RHW, THHW, THW, THWN, XHHW, ZW) as per PEC Table 3.10.1.16

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

28

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Ambient Temperature

Ambient temperature is the temperature of the material


surrounding the conductor, and can either be the air for aboveground installations, or the earth for underground installations.

The ambient temperature determines the temperature


gradient about the conductor. It therefore affects the rate of transfer of heat from the conductor to the environment.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

29

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Ambient Temperature (cont.)

Ampacity ratings are defined based on a given ambient


temperature. If there is a significant difference between the actual (operating) ambient and the ambient at which the cable is rated, ampacity is correspondingly adjusted.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

30

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions

Installation methods affect the way generated heat is

transferred to the environment and can be one of the following: Free air Directly buried in earth Enclosed type of installations restrict the flow of air

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

31

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions (Cont.)

Free air A cable installation that is not enclosed in a

raceway nor routed underground and allows the air to flow freely. With this type of installation, cable conductors can more easily cool to the ambient air, temperature. Installation of this type can be one of the following: Open Wiring on Insulators - An exposed wiring method using single insulated conductors supported on insulators run in or on buildings. Messenger Supported Wiring - An exposed wiring support system using messenger wire to support insulated conductor. Cable Tray Ladders and ventilated troughs allow free flow of air around the conductors (However, covered solid bottom cable trays restrict the flow of air by practically enclosing the conductors)
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation 32

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions (Cont.)
Directly buried in earth Cables directly buried in earth tend to cool to the ambient earth temperature. Ambient earth temperature varies with location, season and depth. Typical values in temperate countries are 15oC in winter and 25oC in summer. In the NEC tables, the reference ambient earth temperature of direct buried cables is 20oC.
Depth of installation also affects cable ampacity of direct buried cables. A 6% derating in ampacity (that is multiply the ampacity by 94%) for every 300 mm increase in depth of laying from the value specified in the Code.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

33

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions (Cont.)
Enclosed type of installations restrict the flow of air Raceway - metal conduit or nonmetallic conduit, tubing, wireways and ducts, Cable installations using raceways could either be aboveground or underground. Ambient air temperature is the reference for aboveground installations while ambient earth temperature is the reference for installations underground
Likewise for underground ducts, depth of installation also affects cable ampacity of direct buried cables. A 6% derating in ampacity (that is multiply the ampacity by 94%) for every 300 mm increase in depth of laying from the value specified in the Code

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

34

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions

Grouping with other cables.


When several wires or cables are grouped together in a run, each one gives off heat and affects ampacity by Transferring generated heat directly to other cables, and/or Raising the immediate ambient air or earth temperature, thereby diminishing the temperature gradient or difference

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

35

Factors Affecting Ampacity External Conditions


Installation Conditions

Grouping with other cables.


The net effect is to decrease the individual cables rate of heat transfer This necessitates a reduction of cable ampacity so as not to let the temperature of the conductor rise to a level injurious to the insulation. Each of the PEC ampacity tables define under what grouping conditions the listed ampacity values hold true. When actual grouping condition differ from what is defined in the ampacity tables, adjustment factors for derating or reduction of ampacity rating is required by the code

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

36

Ampacity Determination
The PEC allows two methods of determining ampacity of cables

1. By use tables of cable ampacities 2. By calculation under engineering supervision using the Neher-McGrath equation
There are twenty six (26) ampacity tables in the PEC, six for

cables 0 2000 V, and twenty for cables over 2000 V

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

37

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables

The use of the PEC ampacity tables require understanding the conditions under which the tables were developed. Deviations from the defined conditions require the application of adjustment factors, specifically for ambient temperature and installation condition including grouping.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

38

PEC Ampacity Tables


There are six ampacity tables for cables rated 0 2000V in the

PEC. Below is the tabulated data for ampacity Tables 3.10.1.16 to 3.10.1.21
Table No. Conductor Temperature Construction / Grouping Insulated conductors, not more than three current-carrying conductors Single-insulated conductors Insulated conductors, not more than three current-carrying conductors Conductor Type Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Nickel or nickel-coated copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Installation Condition Installed in raceway, cable, or earth (directly buried) Free air Ambient Temperature 300C

3.10.1.16

60-75-90 C

3.10.1.17

60-75-90 C

300C

3.10.1.18

150-2500C

Raceway or cable

400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

39

PEC Ampacity Tables


Ampacity Tables for Cables rated 0 2000V (cont.)
Table No. Conductor Temperature 150-2002500C Construction / Grouping Single-insulated conductors Not more than three singleinsulated conductors Bare or covered conductors Conductor Type Copper/Nickel or nickel-coated copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/AAC Aluminum Installation Condition Ambient Temperature 400C

3.10.1.19

Free air

3.10.1.20

75-900C

Supported on a messenger Free air, 610mm/sec wind velocity

400C

3.10.1.21

80 C

400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

40

PEC Ampacity Tables

There are twenty ampacity tables for cables rated 2001 35,000V in the PEC. Below is the tabulated data for ampacity Table 3.10.1.67 to 3.10.1.86
Table No. 3.10.1.67 3.10.1.68 3.10.1.69 3.10.1.70 3.10.1.71 3.10.1.72 3.10.1.73 3.10.1.74 3.10.1.75 3.10.1.76 Conductor Temperature 90-1050C 90-1050C 90-1050C 90-105 C 90-1050C
0

Construction Insulated single conductor cables Insulated single conductor cables Insulated threeconductor cables Insulated triplexed or three singleconductor cables Insulated threeconductor cables

Conductor Type Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum

Installation Condition Triplexed in air Isolated in air Isolated in air Isolated conduit in air Isolated conduit in air

Ambient Temperature 400C 400C 400C 400C 400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

41

PEC Ampacity Tables


Table No. 3.10.1.77 90-1050C Three singleinsulated conductors Three insulated conductors cabled within an overall covering (threeconductor cable) Single insulated copper conductors Conductor Temperature Construction Conductor Type Copper Installation Condition In underground electrical ducts (three conductors per electrical duct) In underground electrical ducts (one cable per electrical duct) Directly buried in earth Ambient Temperature

3.10.1.78

Aluminum

200C

3.10.1.79 3.10.1.80 3.10.1.81 3.10.1.82 90-1050C

Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum

200C

90-1050C

200C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

42

PEC Ampacity Tables


Table No. 3.10.1.83 3.10.1.84 3.10.1.85 3.10.1.86 90-1050C 90-105 C
0

Conductor Temperatur e

Construction Three insulated conductors cabled within an overall covering (threeconductor cable) Three triplexed single insulated copper conductors

Conductor Type Copper Aluminum Copper Aluminum

Installation Condition

Ambient Temperature 200C

Directly buried in earth Directly buried in earth, RHO of 90, 100% load factor

200C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

43

PEC Ampacity Tables


There are eight other ampacity tables included in Appendix B

of the 2009 PEC. These tables, summarized below, are not part of the Code per se but they provide ampacity information for conditions not described in the tables within the Code.
Conductor Temperature Construction / Grouping 2 to 3 Insulated conductors, with overall covering (multiconductor cable) Multiconductor with at most 3 Insulated conductors Single Insulated conductors Installation Condition Ambient Temperature In air (UON) 300C

Cables rated 0 to 2000V, Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Table No.

B-310-1

60-75-90 C

Installed in raceway in free air

60-75-85-900C B-310-3 (cable type TC, MC, MI, UF and USE) 750C

In Free air

400C

B-310-5

In Non-magnetic Underground duct (one conductor per duct)

200C (earth)

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

44

PEC Ampacity Tables


Table No. Conductor Temperature 75 C
0 0

Construction / Grouping Three-Conductor Cable Three Single Insulated conductors 2 to 3 Insulated conductors, with overall covering (multiconductor cable) 3 triplexed single insulated conductor Three Single Insulated Conductors

Installation Condition In Underground duct (one cable per duct) In Underground duct (three conductors per duct) Directly Buried, 100% Load factor, RHO of 90 Directly Buried, 100% Load factor, RHO of 90 Directly Buried, 100% Load factor, RHO of 90

Ambient Temperature In air (UON) 200C (earth)

B-310-6

B-310-7

75 C

200C (earth)

B-310-8

60-75 C

200C (earth)

B-310-9

60-75 C

200C (earth)

B-310-10

60-750C

200C (earth)

Note: For underground duct and directly buried cables, see Figure B-310-2 of the PEC for cable installation dimensions.
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation 45

PEC Ampacity Tables


The Tables of Ampacities in the PEC are characterized by the

very specific parameters described above. Some of these (voltage, maximum operating temperature, conductor material, construction) are either inherent characteristics of the cable or are designated by the manufacturer based on standard tests. They are the first filters to be used when selecting cables.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

46

PEC Ampacity Tables


Each of these parameters should be understood when applying

the ampacity tables. Any deviation from these parameters can mean one of the following: 1. The table is not applicable 2. The table is applicable but adjustment factors have to be used

There are two parameters for which deviations from the listed

condition in the NEC ampacity tables can be compensated (or will be modified) by use of adjustment factors: 1. Ambient temperature (air or earth) 2. Grouping and/or installation conditions

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

47

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables - Adjustment Factors for Ambient Temperature
For cables rated 0 to 2000 V, the adjustment factors for deviations

from listed ambient are tabulated at the bottom of each ampacity table. Below is an example for the factors for table 3.10.1.16

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

48

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables - Adjustment Factors for Ambient Temperature
For cables rated over 2000 V, the adjustment of ampacity for

deviations from listed ambient are determined from the following formula:

I 2 I1

Where I1 = Ampacity from tables at ambient TA1 I2 = Ampacity at desired ambient TA2 TC = Conductor temperature in degrees Celsius (oC) TA1 = Surrounding ambient from tables in degrees Celsius (oC) TA2 = desired ambient in degrees Celsius (oC) TD = Dielectric loss temperature rise

TC TA 2 TD TC TA1 TD

Note that the same formula is valid for cables rated for 0 to 2000 volts by ignoring the terms TD, the dielectric loss temperature rise.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

49

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables Grouping with other cables


Each of the PEC ampacity tables define under what grouping conditions the listed ampacity values hold true. By way of example, the following table header from the PEC table 3.10.1.16 is shown:

Thus the table is expressed as valid for one to three current carrying conductors in raceway, cable or earth (directly buried)

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

50

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables Grouping with other cables


When actual grouping condition differ from what is defined in the ampacity tables, adjustment factors for derating or reduction of ampacity rating is required by the code Table 3.10.1.15(b)(2)a lists the adjustment factors for more than three current- carrying conductors in a raceway or cable. Neutral conductors carrying only the unbalanced current from the same circuit as well as grounding and bonding conductors are not counted as current-carrying conductors specified in the table.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

51

Using the PEC Ampacity Tables Grouping with other cables


There are exceptions to the application of the factors listed in Table 3.10.1.15(b)(2)a. The more significant exceptions are:
Derating factors apply only to power and lighting cables. Derating factors do not apply to conductors in nipples not exceeding 610 mm (24 inches) Derating factors do not apply to not more than four conductors entering or leaving an outdoor trench protected by rigid metal conduit, intermediate metal conduit or rigid non-metallic conduit not exceeding 3.05 m (10 ft) Cable installed in cable trays. This is discussed in detail in the topic Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray Cable installed in metal wireways (and similar raceways). This is discussed in the topic Ampacity of Cables in Metal Wireways and Similar Raceways.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

52

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The PEC has definite rules for cables installed in cable trays. Even in the ways of installing cables in a cable tray, is governed by specific rules. These rules generally specify the type, number and sizes of cables that can be laid in a certain tray type (Cable ladder, ventilated through, ventilated channel, or solid bottom) and size, and whether the cables can be laid in a single layer, or in multiple layers. Consequently these rules also determine the size of trays that should be used for a given collection of cables. The topics of cable installation in cable trays and the sizing of cable trays are quite broad and will not be discussed here. Suffice it to say, that compliance with the rules is a precondition of the PEC in allowing the use of available ampacity tables in the code for cables in cable trays.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

53

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


For multiconductor cables rated 2000 volts or less, the following tables are used
Table No. Conductor Temperature Construction / Grouping Insulated conductors, not more than three current-carrying conductors Insulated conductors, not more than three current-carrying conductors Multiconductor with at most 3 Insulated conductors Conductor Type Installation Condition Installed in raceway, cable, or earth (directly buried) Ambient Temperature

3.10.1.16

60-75-90 C

Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Nickel or nickel-coated copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum

300C

3.10.1.18

150-2500C

Raceway or cable

400C

60-75-85900C B-310-3 (cable type TC, MC, MI, UF and USE)

In Free air

400C

B-310-3

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

54

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The conditions for using the ampacities in these tables are as follows:
The multiconductor cables are installed in accordance with the requirements of the code as detailed in 3.92.1.9. The derating factors for more than three current-carrying conductors in a raceway or cable (table 3.10.1.15(b)(2)a are applicable only to each cable and not to the total number of conductors in a tray. Ampacities for multiconductor cables shall be as shown in tables 3.10.1.16 or 3.10.1.18, as applicable. When a cable tray is covered for more than 1.8 meters, a derating factor of 0.95 is applied to the ampacities in the tables 3.10.1.16 or 3.10.1.18. When multiconductor cables are installed in a single layer, with a minimum spacing of 1 cable diameter, the ampacities in table B-310-3 can be used.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

55

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


For single conductor cables rated 2000 volts or less, the ampacities in following tables are used:
Table No. Conductor Temperature Construction / Grouping Conductor Type Installation Condition Ambient Temperature

3.10.1.17

60-75-90 C

Single-insulated conductors

Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Nickel or nickel-coated copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum Copper/Aluminum or copper-clad aluminum

Free air

300C

3.10.1.19

150-2002500C

Single-insulated conductors

Free air

400C

3.10.1.20

75-90 C

Not more than three singleinsulated conductors

Supported on a messenger

400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

56

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The conditions for using the ampacities in these tables are as follows:
The single conductors are installed in accordance with the requirements of the code as detailed in 3.92.1.10, and are 50 sq mm or larger. The derating factors for more than three single current-carrying conductors in a raceway or cable shall not apply to the ampacity of conductors in a cable tray. Ampacities for conductors 325 sq mm and larger shall not exceed 75% of the values listed in the tables 3.10.1.17 and 3.10.1.19. If the tray is covered for 1.8 meters or more, ampacities shall not exceed 70% of the listed values in these tables. Ampacities for conductors 50 sq mm through 250 sq mm shall not exceed 65% of the values listed in the tables 3.10.1.17 and 3.10.1.19. If the tray is covered for 1.8 meters or more, ampacities shall not exceed 60% of the listed values in these tables.
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation 57

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The conditions for using the ampacities (cont.):
Ampacities for single conductors, when installed in a single layer in an uncovered cable tray, with a spacing of not less than one cable diameter between conductors, shall be as listed in tables 3.10.1.17 and 3.10.1.19. When single conductors are installed in triangular (trefoil) or square configuration, in an uncovered cable tray, with a maintained spacing of 2.15 times the conductor diameter of the largest conductor in the configuration, ampacities listed in table 3.10.1.20 can be used.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

58

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


For multiconductor cables rated 2001 or over, the following tables can be used:
Table No. 3.10.1.71 90-105 C 3.10.1.72 3.10.1.75 90-105 C 3.10.1.76
0 0

Conductor Temperature

Construction

Conductor Type Copper

Installation Condition

Ambient Temperature

Insulated threeconductor cables

Isolated in air Aluminum Copper Aluminum Isolated conduit in air

400C

Insulated threeconductor cables

400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

59

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The conditions for using the ampacities in these tables are as follows:
The multiconductor cables are installed in accordance with the requirements of the code as detailed in 3.92.1.12. Ampacities for multiconductor cables shall be as shown in tables 3.10.1.75 or 3.10.1.76, as applicable. When a cable tray is covered for more than 1.8 meters, a derating factor of 0.95 is applied to the ampacities in these tables. When multiconductor cables are installed in a single layer in an uncovered cable tray, with a minimum spacing of 1 cable diameter, the ampacities shall not exceed the values in tables 3.10.1.71 or 3.10.1.72.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

60

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


For single conductor cables rated 2001 or over, volts or less, the ampacities in following tables are used:
Table No. 3.10.1.67 90-105 C 3.10.1.68 3.10.1.69 90-105 C 3.10.1.70
0 0

Conductor Temperature

Construction

Conductor Type Copper

Installation Condition

Ambient Temperature

Insulated single conductor cables

Triplexed in air Aluminum Copper Isolated in air Aluminum

400C

Insulated single conductor cables

400C

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

61

Ampacity of Cables in Cable Tray


The conditions for using the ampacities in these tables are as follows:
The single conductors are 50 sq mm or larger and are installed in accordance with the requirements of the code as detailed in 3.92.1.12. The derating factors for more than three single current-carrying conductors in a raceway or cable shall not apply to the ampacity of conductors in a cable tray. Ampacities for conductors in uncovered cable trays shall not exceed 75% of the values listed in the tables 3.10.1.69 or 3.10.1.70 as applicable. If the tray is covered for 1.8 meters or more, ampacities shall not exceed 70% of the listed values in these tables. When single conductors are installed in triangular (trefoil) or square configuration, in an uncovered cable tray, with a maintained spacing of 2.15 times the conductor diameter of the largest conductor in the configuration, with the adjacent conductor, ampacities listed in table 3.10.1.67 or 3.10.1.68 can be used.
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

62

Ampacity of Cables in Metal Wireways and Similar Raceways


Some raceways allowed by the Code are structurally extended boxes with covers, which have larger cross sectional areas than typical conduit-type or tubing-type raceways and therefore afford larger space for conductors. The following raceway types fall under this category:
Sheet metal auxiliary gutters Metal wireways Strut type Channel raceways Surface metal raceways

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

63

Ampacity of Cables in Metal Wireways and Similar Raceways (continued)


Generally, the rules governing ampacities of cables installed in these types of raceways are: The sum of the cross sectional area of all contained conductors
shall not exceed 20% of the interior cross-sectional area of the raceway at any point.

The derating factors for more than three single current-carrying

conductors in a raceway or cable shall NOT be applied IF the number of conductors is 30 or less. Conductors for signaling, control or communication are not counted as current-carrying conductors. For strut-type channel, and surface metal raceways, an additional condition for the derating NOT apply is that the channel or surface raceway have cross sectional area of at least 2500 sq mm.

Non-metallic auxiliary gutter, non-metallic wireway are not exempted from the application of the derating factor, regardless of the fill or number of conductors.
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation 64

Neher-McGrath Equation

The Neher-McGrath equation is another method that can be used in calculating for cable ampacity under engineering supervision as the PEC requires. The Neher-McGrath formula is a heat transfer formula, comprising a series of heat transfer calculations, that takes into account all heat sources and the thermal resistances between the heat sources and free air. The most common use of this formula is to calculate for the ampacity of conductors in underground electrical ducts (raceways), although the formula is also applicable to all conductor installations.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

65

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


To understand how the formula relates to ampacity we need
to examine how heat is transferred in respect to a current carrying conductor. Current carried by a conductor passes through the electrical resistance of the conductor. When this happens heat is generated.

The heat generated in the conductor passes through


several thermal barriers by convection, conduction, and radiation and dissipates into the air. Possible thermal barriers are the conductor insulation, the air inside a duct, the duct wall, the soil surrounding an underground duct, and any additional thermal insulation applied.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

66

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


The rate of heat transfer is dependent on several variables
and can be described by a thermal equation that closely resembles ohms law (E=I x R), substituting heat for current and thermal resistance for electrical resistance.

In a heat transfer equation the rate of heat transfer is

directly dependent on the difference in temperature between the conductor (TC) and the ambient (TA). In a heat transfer equation TC-TA = (I x I x R) x RCA, where I is current in amperes, R is electrical resistance in ohms, and RCA is thermal resistance in degrees Centigrade-cm/watt usually called thermal-ohm-feet. TC is the maximum permissible operating temperature in degrees Centigrade of the conductor. TA is the ambient temperature of the air or soil for underground installations. Solving for I:

TC TA RxRCA
*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation 67

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


Equation No. 1 is sometimes called the Fourier heat transfer
equation. The equation in section 3.10.1.60(d) of the PEC, called the Neher-McGrath equation, is a more complex version of the Fourier heat transfer equation. The equation in section 3.10.1.15(c) and section 3.10.1.60(d) of the PEC, called the Neher-McGrath equation, is a more complex version of the Fourier heat transfer equation.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

68

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


The Neher-McGrath equation:

TC TA TD I ( RDC1 YC)RCA
Where: I = Ampacity, (kA) TC = Conductor temperature, (C) TA = Ambient temperature in C TD = Conductor temperature rise due to dielectric loss, (C) RDC = Conductor dc resistance, (/m) YC = Loss increment due to conductor skin and proximity effects RCA = Thermal resistance between conductor and ambient, (thermal -m)

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

69

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


This equation was developed by J.H. Neher and M.H. McGrath

and presented in a paper entitled The Calculation of the Temperature Rise and Load Capability of Cable Systems to AIEE (American Institute of Electrical Engineers) the precursor to the organization IEEE.
In this equation, TD, is a term added to the ambient

temperature, TA, to account for the heat generated in the insulation and other covering of dielectric material. It represents the temperature rise arising from dielectric loss. It is insignificant for voltages below 2000. Another term in the NM equation, (1+YC), is a multiplier to convert direct current resistance (RDC) to alternating current resistance. For small wire sizes this term becomes insignificant.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

70

Neher-McGrath Equation (continued)


Although the equation looks deceptively simple, the

application to actual cable configurations can be daunting. Appendix B of the PEC contains ampacity tables developed using the Neher-McGrath equation. Power systems software like ETAP and EDSA use the Neher-McGrath equation, as well as equivalent in an IEC standard.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

71

Conclusion
Wiring is a very significant part of our work. One of the basic

responsibilities of the electrical engineer or electrician is to ensure electrical installations are safe. Whether as engineering designers, constructors, equipment manufacturers, or maintenance personnel, we have the obligation to ensure that our wiring design and installations are correct according to the Code. It behooves us therefore to make sure that cables we use are properly selected and sized for use.

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

72

Q&A

QUESTIONS?

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

73

References
Philippine Electric Code 2009 National Electrical Code, 2005 Mike Holt Enterprises Website National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) http://neher-mcgrath.com

*** COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL *** 2012 Fluor Corporation

74

You might also like