Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Garrett Reviewed work(s): Source: Higher Education, Vol. 50, No. 1 (Jul., 2005), pp. 33-56 Published by: Springer Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25068088 . Accessed: 15/01/2013 13:06
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Springer is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Higher Education.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
? Springer 2005
Job satisfaction
of University
academics: Perspectives
from Uganda
Analogously,
(contextual)
dissatisfaction
remuneration,
governance,
motion, and working environment. This article discusses these findings in the light of Herzberg's dichotomy and concludes that any given factor be it intrinsic or extrinsic can
either that evoke while academic age, is adduced rank, satisfaction and tenure or induce dissatisfaction. The academic present analysis finds no satisfaction, predict job significantly a gender on dons'job influence satisfaction. Implications are formulated, satisfaction and a recommendations made,
evidence
to support job
proposed.
profession?
At a time when the geographic lines that divided the world of schol
arship are becoming blurred (Boyer et al. 1994), higher education sys
tems in both the affluent and the developing world find themselves amidst a difficult process of change that will obviously impact signifi
workers. and academic Indeed, public debate cantly on their principal on the academic reflection is not always characterised profession by contentment and serenity of what (Enders 1999), and with a plethora are called an academic are structural the skills of being reforms,
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
34
increasingly becoming
and
2000) relationships, particularly some argue that with For instance, the interests of commercial research, campus, global and trends consequently, evident
are changing. power associations, the growth of privately sponsored on firms have become dominant have become 'corporatised'
academics
changing
rapidly
but
sion is finding it increasingly difficult to manage the tensions within which it has to operate. This is particularly noticeable in the developing
world, and one has to ask, in that context, is the academic profession endangered?
The Ugandan
context:
doing more
with
less
to operate under expected 1992; Saint 1992). As a consequence need for more staff, there is reduced
on academics to by universities while at the same time they are efficiently, adverse and declining circumstances (Kajubi demand of increased enrolments and the and rigour in staff recruitment
promotional criteria (Ocitti 1993). But, despite such moves, 48 percent of posts were unfilled atMakerere University Kampala (MUK) (Sanyal
these to, and exacerbating, Coupled sector. For for the Higher Education funding for Uganda's Education earmarked Strategic 1995). issues is the reduction $710m (ESIP) Plan in example, Investment out of US
1998-2003, only 9% of the total figure is for higher education (The New Vision 1999).When looked at within the overall educational project and
can be these developments its competing needs, has seen this reduced investment Garrett (1999) of the Sector Investment Programmes typical taken by many and to be countries, developing the context of their crucially important has drive regarded in Higher as reasonable. Education under within Primary as
towards
Education
funding This has an
(UPE). As Urwick
education
standards, Evidence
precedence. sub-sector said however, the Higher Education still in the overall role to play drive towards improved requires staff pay sustained investment. and adequate for university lecturers is insufficient,
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
35
housing facilities very poor, and the housing allowance paid in lieu is
not on to facilitate suitable accommodation available enough obtaining for academics and the open market. the volumes of work Nevertheless, resource student have increased with enrolment enlarged implications main the chair to student ratio at MUK 2001). For example, (Ssesanga
library is 1:19 (TheNew Vision 2001). Indeed, the spiralling numbers of students at MUK are straining and stressing academic staff (MUASA 1996, p. 13).Arguably, MUK is in a space crisis. Table 1 illustrates this
situation.
is even more disturbing however, is the suggestion from Ocitti (1993), that this quantitative expansion is likely to have a major impact What
on the maintenance Sub-Saharan and Africa of quality. universities, and overall an The current is one limited as inmost reality in Uganda, in lecture theatres of congestion and equipment facilities with
environment adequate (Saint teaching/learning to teach As a consequence, dons have 1992). Ugandan increasingly more resource from a shrinking faced with an explosion of base, while
(1996/97)
4876 2774
(1998/99) 8396
5048 1951
Medicine
Science
1081 14710
11613 9368
10587
5010 18414 2301 886 1407 1957 92371
6589
6413 1489 498 620 1402 52846 Strategic Plan 1996/7-1998/9.
-39867
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
36
of
As Garrett
attitudes, complex
are intimately their working related in a very conditions, manner unex to understand and we need them better. Not
In the circumstances, affect the job satisfaction of university teachers. it seem to be common sense to suggest and would that the magnitude, on Ugandan ramifications of the impact of these forces academics as they are numerous. life are as diverse working this study identifies As noted earlier, therefore, and discusses factors, considerations most one to their can or aspects satisfaction to This their of university teachers' jobs, which In this way, and dissatisfaction. the elements which lecturers themselves job satisfaction insights the factors and into that dissatisfaction, the academic are most contribute it is hoped, claim to be as well profession as in in the
general
paper reports prevalent and dissatisfaction, of Ugandan academics' job satisfaction et al. (1959) Two-factor them in the context of the Herzberg the job impact of satisfaction. age,
gender,
literature late job 1950s a number and of researchers developed was intrinsic those have models, developed variables extrinsic theorised which about attempt the to et al.
satisfaction
in empirical studies.
by Herzberg related
(1959). In this theory itwas proposed that job satisfaction is not a uni
dimensional growth faction, account therefore contribute Mumford and concept. (satisfiers) development are separate and distinct from for job dissatisfaction related or and which contribute to personal to job satis associated factors, latter rather are not
with the security of the work environment (hygiene factors) and which
its reduction. These directly towards to increasing job satisfaction; dissatisfaction. There decreasing it has become an elusive and they can no is however,
1973;
1972), 1997). As a result, this lack of an agreement concept (Lacy and Sheehan as to the nature of the concept has led to considerable among disparity
a mythical
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA the numerous has become studies that have been undertaken and
37 it
a multi-dimensional
phenomenon
1999), concepts
vy
bility of the theory in a developing world context. A number of studies, mostly in the industrialised world, have sought
to examine nations. explored among with their satisfaction of academics' aspects an international et al. (1994) conducted Boyer sources and other factors, of satisfaction among job across that study frustration
in 14 countries Brazil, Chile, USA, UK, (Australia, The Netherlands, Korea, Israel, Hong Kong, Germany, Japan, Russia, and Mexico). The results of this research not Sweden showed, perhaps a high sense of satisfaction that professors with surprisingly, reported their intellectual lives and the courses they taught as well as their rela professors tionships showed to Herzberg's with Contrary colleagues. that both factors intrinsic and extrinsic Most faculty members, as however, or this finding theory, to job contribute felt that they were not well can
satisfaction. rate
did more
For
than 50% of
instance, faculty salary 'good' only 46% of surveyed professors in the USA rated their salaries favourably. In nearly half the responding than 40% of the surveyed countries more their job was a source of considerable strain with professors reported Japanese, Russian, and Korean faculty reporting the most pressure.
'excellent'.
12,599
their job
satisfaction with aspects of academics' nations USA, Germany, (Australia, to Herzberg's and UK). Again, contrary both across (content-related the sampled and nations
Canada, theory,
aspects of the job could lead to both job satisfaction and dissatisfaction. satisfied particularly with four facets of their jobs: relationships with
the opportunity colleagues; their general A situation. however, (27.6%) Mexico, was who USA dissatisfied indicated and to pursue their own ideas; job security and of respondents sizeable proportion (44.1%), for promotion, with prospects with compared satisfaction. Additionally, satisfied with respondents promotion from prospects.
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
38
KARIM SSESANGA AND ROGER M. GARRETT German the countries, respondents expressed with their prospects for promotion, followed and Australia. With UK, Hong Kong regard 60% their of academics counterparts in Sweden in Mexico, and USA Germany,
UK and Australia, where less than 50% of the responding academics were satisfied with their jobs. It would seem that the above findings tend
to show that in the affluent are world, (where extrinsic factors meet a basic
level) intrinsic job aspects tend to influence the extent to which Uni
versity academics satisfied, or not, with their jobs. in Uganda's HE
Contextual few
studies
Very
education academic
that do
carried
however,
indicate
Opolot (1991) found that (ITEK) academic staff were dissatisfied with their pay. He concluded that if job satisfaction was to prevail in an
of staff based on output, should be fair remuneration seem to support level of education.. This finding would experience Garrett's observation that in a situation where lower-order needs (1999) are not met, extrinsic of rewards tend to shape the level of satisfaction institution, there and workers. In a study Furthermore, job satisfaction prospects conducted the findings rating to evaluate the Staff Development Programme a low rate,
(SDP) at MUK,
with employees
seeking positions
in institutions where
they perceive
to be better.
in Uganda's tertiary satisfac affected job the obtaining tion: Incentives, pay packages, styles and leadership seem to show again that at the work place. The results would conditions are not being in an environment of scarcity where lower-order needs (1996) investigated Kyamanywa job satisfaction The results that four factors institutions. showed met, tend to shape the job satisfaction factors hygiene academic Bameka factors (1996) exploring affecting came to three major at MUK, conclusions: ity of workers. staff productiv
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA on productivity service. community resource The financial base icant effect in respect at MUK, to teaching weak as and provision it may be, has
39 of no
significant effect on staff productivity. The level of motivation of the academic staff has a significant effect
on the productivity of academic staff at MUK.
Bameka's factors
that, unlike financial (1996) results indicate such as one's drive to work, and qualifications, with show then academic that where teaching and staff lower productivity order needs
rewards, personal have a significant at MUK. The results as tend salary, are not to be affected.
such
community
service
Mulindwa (1998) assessed job satisfaction among academic and administrative staff at Polytechnic College, Kyambogo. Analysis of
qualitative greatest ernment evidence contributor revealed to job that satisfaction levels of remuneration were the staff, followed among by gov on higher in that and institutional education policy, policy assumes order. This finding may which contradict theory, Herzberg's that extrinsic rewards such as salary contribute towards dis reducing satisfaction but of themselves seem then to extrinsic do not increase job satisfaction. observation The results, however, where lower order, critical, basic level, support factors that (1999) to some such as salary are not met satisfiers will have little impact. Garrett's
intrinsic
Tizikara (1998) examined correlates of academic staff satisfaction in MUK and the Islamic University in Uganda (IUIU). Her findings
revealed that there was a significant difference in satisfaction between
and IUIU
the results staff were showed that academic dissatisfied Furthermore, at their universities, with the general situation in obtaining particularly the areas of inadequate instructional materials, space and the teaching in class. It was concluded number that academic of students job satis faction social, at both political at the time of the research, was affected universities, in varying and financial correlates though degrees. education seems to not by
it is possible to hypothesise
or high development seem that the Ugandan it would dence, therefore, tends to be in turmoil and many frustrations under the surface.
to provide the kind of pay its staff. Additionally, the kind of rewarding seems not to encourage that obtains professional work. From evi academic the available quality teaching community and contradictions lie
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
40
Method
To
of data collection
the factors dissatisfaction, to Ugandan contributing the following research academic method job was sat em
ployed.
Sample population It was Uganda. The was felt of teachers comprised that these two universities from two universities a large enough and to make of diversity of higher by a in
provided to be representative of all Ugandan universities, sample an adequate of the range and available representation in institutions academics and their environments found learning in Uganda. Data on the Of survey. selected from subjects job 250 the satisfaction were
obtained
questionnaire
potential were usable questionnaires break down of responding summarised academics in Table was wide 2.
returned academics
to administered questionnaires two participating 182 universities, a response rate of 73%. A yielding by age, gender, tenure and rank is
(50%) were lecturers, male (80.5%) and less than 45 years old (69.8%), which tend to agree with Boyer et al. (1994) findings that themajority of
dons dents world-wide of the rank numbers are middle aged and male. The relatively of professor and associate in the academic population. professors respon reflects their few
restricted
Questionnaire To better
interview those
satisfaction
job
to provide the needed and background characteristics to describe the sample such as university, and faculty, status of with sex, age, academic rank, tenure, and marital of academics comprising of: was measured on nine
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA Table 2. Demographic Variable data of the sample % of
respondents
41
Age (years) Less than 35 35.7 35-44 34.1 45-54 19.8 55+ Total
Gender
19.5 100.0
35.7
26.4 11.5
100.0
A/Professors
Senior Lecturers Lecturers 50.0
10.4
17.6
Other Total
13.7 100.0
o Teaching
o o o o o o o Research Governance Remuneration Opportunities Supervision Co-worker's Working for promotion behaviour environment
o
These extrinsic
Job inGeneral
elements to the university
(JIG)
themselves lecturers' might be thought of as intrinsic or to job. However, they are too broad
various
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
KARIM SSESANGA AND ROGER M. GARRETT use when a persons or otherwise satisfaction been deconstructed into they have were with their
analysing
of inde judged by a group an intrinsic or extrinsic as to whether constituted experts they were asked to indicate of the general job element. Respondents of which components to further of each of the nine aspects of their which were jobs. are relevant additionally or con
Analysis A The scale ranged from 1-5 scale was employed. Likert-type 1 2 3 'Indif Dissatisfied', 'Dissatisfied', 'Extremely representing 5 Satisfied'. The essence of a 5-point ferent', 4 'Satisfied', 'Extremely to encourage to use full width of opinion and scale was respondents 5-point For purposes tendency. two extreme 1 of 'Extremely categories were collapsed into one Satisfied' 'Extremely of central errors of analysis, Dissatisfied' and scored the however, and 5 as 2 = Dissat
avoid
= = isfied; 3 Indifferent; and 4 Satisfied. To identify if there were any differences in the level of job satisfaction
respondents was factors utilised were and rotated loadings any sig on each The a
on each aspect, the SPSS package was performed and component analysis principal varimax which factors with procedures by using of were nificant aspect level of The extracted. A /-test was applied in respondents' differences based on institution, age, gender, analysis significance of free response factors in light of survey. was set at 0.05. data, and field
significant to compute if there were level of job satisfaction academic rank, notes and
tenure.
from and
the interview
were
triangulated with
the quantitative
the literature These data
findings
review were
to identify vital
issues emerging inductively
analysed
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA the conceptual permitted the framework researcher that evoked
43
against which,
of the study, and the literature review an informed to articulate against academics job satisfaction Ugandan
contributing to teaching,
seen that almost 92% were satisfied, with only 5% indicating dissatis
a mean with 4, academics satisfied
were to teaching mentioned factors related frequently as with in content and respect by stu taught, relationship common next most to co-worker factors behaviour. related academics freedom cited as contributed environment. are sociable on the most The beings and value their
implies that Ugandan interactions. coll?gial Relative their to supervision, immediate boss were of the university to working
3. Frequency
sources
with job and relationship satisfaction. of academic to academic freedom to satisfaction research and
Location with
respect
Table
and
percentage
distribution
showing
aca
demic satisfaction with course(s) taught (?=182) Rating Frequency 2 = Dissatisfied 9 4.9 91.8 167 Total
Mean 3.9
Percentage
704 100.0
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
44
KARIM SSESANGA AND ROGER M. GARRETT of satisfaction responses based on job aspect and percentage of factor (?=138) Factor Academics mentioning factor % of 138 82
59
Co-workers
Relationship
Support from
with others
co-workers
Teaching
in content taught 72 Autonomy Sharing knowledge with students 64 Recognition of efforts by students 62 63 Location of university Freedom on the Job 62 Working Freedom 11 relationship with boss 56 to research and publish 44
factor with
mentioned research.
as
contributory
to Ugandan
Factors A
contributing
to academic
dissatisfaction
based on quantitative evi of the dissatisfaction summary responses can be viewed in Table 5. dence and percentage of 159 respondents With the most mentioned factors frequently regard to remuneration, inadequate tern of academic facilities. mentioned data tend to reflect a pat salary. These irregular sources of to research, with discontent salary. Relative were largely extrinsic such as lack of research grants and and Instructional as factors materials contributing and were fre large classes to academic dissatisfaction
were
disillusionment library
as con were and relaxation cited frequently facilities Computing to respondents The majority with working facilities. tributory anguish in the excellence of teaching of respondents felt that undervaluing with promotion. reward system accounted for their misgivings To data give from greater support the free-response to any conclusions that may be made, the with format were information compared scales. in the Likert-type areas convergence and dissatisfaction of relative aca to Ugandan as illustrated in Table 6.
of satisfaction
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
45
Table 5. Distribution of dissatisfaction responses based on job aspect and percentage of academics mentioning factor (?= 159) Aspect of Factor job Academics mentioning factor % of 159
Inadequate salary 76 Irregular salary 32 Lack of research funds 71 Library facilities for research 66 Relationship with university admin. Policy formulation procedures 47 Instructional materials 61 Class size 59 Access to computer 62 Facilities for relaxation 54 skills in promotion 58 64
Teaching
A model Based on
of Ugandan the
academics
job
satisfaction
and dissatisfaction
evidence
data, a model response and other with primary ties in the study
interview and free from the survey, coming and dissatisfaction satisfaction of respondents' that the universi Given duties was developed. institutions, teaching is the main
are teaching-intensive
activity and perhaps the primary interest of most of the responding academics. Congruent with the Herzberg et al. (1959) dichotomy, the findings of this study indicated that intrinsic factors of teaching were
most demics. common individual prevalent Indeed, reason had in the prediction of job satisfaction courses with satisfied 92% were aca of Ugandan the most taught,
the which the exercise of control, given for this being a course. Figure 1 represents over the content of his/her and dissatisfaction academics of Ugandan satisfaction the teaching current notion of in the intellec because
tual pleasure (Altbach and Lewis 1996) or the enjoyment they receive (McKeachie 1982; Serow 2000) was sustained.
It is interesting however, that where the contention met, higher order needs to note lower that these data are at variance with factors are not order needs {extrinsic) are not likely to come into play as {intrinsic)
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
46
Table 6. Areas of
quantitative
free-response
Quantitative
(Likert scale)
Autonomy in content taught(s) Teacher-student relationship(s) Instructional materials Class size(d) (d)
Research
Freedom
to research
and
Freedom
to research
and
publish(s) Research funding(d) Library facilities for research(d) Relationship with Univ
Relationship Policy
with Univ.
administrators(d) Policy formulation procedures(d) Inadequate salary(d) Teaching skills in promotion(d) Freedom on the job(s) Relationship with others at work(s) Support from co-workers(s) Location of university(s)
Remuneration Promotion
Inadequate salary(d) Teaching skills in promotion criteria (d) Overall freedom on the job (s) Coll?gial relations in faculty(s) Social support from colleagues at work(s) Geographical university(s) (d) Dissatisfaction. location of
Supervision
Co-workers' behaviour
between
dons and
seem
teaching features of
their academic
to Ugandan academics chime well with the however, over content elements of their
1997;Moses
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
47
RESEARCH JOB SATISFACTION Satisfaction factors Freedomto research publish & Recognitionof research Time for independent thought Dissatisfaction factors & Researchfunds grants Libraryfacilitiesfor research Opportunitiestowrite& publish Fame through publications Chances for research seminars
JOB DISSATISFACTION
GOVERNANCE Satisfaction factors Dissatisfaction factors with Univ. administration of role in thedepartment Clarity Relationship Influenceindepartmental administration Secretarial supportprovided matters Policy Communication with administration Intrinsic factors 1Factors with extrinsic elements
of Ugandan
academics
job satisfaction
and dissatisfaction
with
concurrent Serow the with Herzberg's two-factor 1997). Additionally, to Ugandan academics dissatis factors contributed ory, extrinsic job as evidenced 1. faction in Figure Pertinent summarised remuneration findings in Figure arising 2. Not from sources of academic satisfaction and
discontent with the six other job aspects investigated in this study are
unexpectedly, given the plight of Ugandan
to Herzberg's lends credence which, (1959) contention an extrinsic not lead to true gratification, that pay being aspect does a good many a reduction in dissatisfaction. merely Consequently,
Ugandan
their university with
loyalty
promotion would
plausible is in part, explained with dissatisfaction
1996), it is
promotion
pay. Second, respondents arose inter alia from their being unap promotion where and unrecognised for achievements 58% of the made, preciated we see to Herzberg's felt unhappy. therefore, sample Contrary theory, an intrinsic factor, recognition, inducing job dissatisfaction.
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
48
JOB SATISFACTION
SUPERVISION Dissatisfaction factors Satisfactionfactors fromsupervisor Degree of autonomy of supervisor Competence to work Opportunities do challenging Successof supervisor Responsibility given tohandle Feedbackfromsupervisor Work timeautonomy on Overall freedom thejob_ CO-WORKER BEHAVIOUR Dissatisfaction factors Satisfactionfactors and Senseof community social support andcommitment Coll?gialrelations morale Faculty Respectearned at Professionalinteraction work Confidenceandtrustinco-workers shownandcongeniality Personalinterest of Competence co-workers_ WORKING ENVIRONMENT Dissatisfaction factors Satisfactionfactors facilities location theuniversity of Researchand relaxation Geographic with your university Access to computing Association facilities Yourworkingenvironment Freedom life style of The feeungof security Beautyof campus on Spaceavailable Enjoyment thejob of of Intellectual stimulation theUniv. Freedom your life style_ JOB INGENERAL (JIG) Dissatisfaction factors Satisfactionfactors Academicwork as anoccupation(u) Statusas a don (u) Careerprospectsinyourjob (u) accomplishment(u) Feelingof worthwhile D Intrinsicfactors (u)Unclassifiable factors
JOB DISSATISFACTION
Figure 2. Model
job aspects.
of Ugandan
Strikingly, satisfaction
whilst
these
data
in Figure aspects of
2 show research
obvious
areas
like remuneration,
and working
ties, the overall picture of the job in general (JIG) is not as gloomy. Over
satisfaction from academic 80% of respondents reported deriving as an occupation. is that while What from the findings emerges to do more with and policy makers asked by administrators
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA dons are being resources, Ugandan study, that they should not expect ever cially for meeting trated by poor working increasing conditions told, at least from the sample or rewarded to be facilitated demands. and Yet, while obviously when asked
emoluments,
their (JIG), most respond that it is satisfactory. Looking ahead, it seems safe to predict that the high degree of
control academics have over intrinsic elements of their work (Moses
1986; Pearson and Seiler 1983) and the intellectual pleasure derived (Altbach and Lewis 1996), or the degree of autonomy enjoyed by aca demics (Enders and Teichler 1997; Serow 2000) all contribute to overall
satisfaction. investigation. In addition satisfaction, tenure on aspects of This scenario would seem to be a fruitful avenue of future and dis
sources to identifying of academic satisfaction this study addressed the influence of age, gender, to each of with academic respect job satisfaction the job.
1997; Rosen
on
1978; Siassi
satisfaction.
teaching significant to considerable with it is useful research, misgivings were more note that older Ugandan academics satis likely to derive intrinsic and extrinsic faction from both factors within the general area of research. with effect satisfaction. Consequently, In agreement institutional on academic age showed with the a predictive literature, all effect on research felt age groups no over showed governance.
unhappy whelming
Though older dons were more likely to express satisfaction with their
on the pay scale, it is useful to note that no overriding age position were observed. in academic with differences remuneration satisfaction influence on academic satisfaction age showed a predictive By contrast, with and promotion. While received guidance there was compelling satisfaction. supervision lecturers younger from supervisors, to show evidence the support favourably to highlight it is useful that that age influences academic rated
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
much in common but with some significant differences between different groups. Although both male and female respondents felt relatively
happy more with likely the pattern recurring that women 1997), does not teaching, to signal there in the is some evidence extrinsic (Olsen satisfaction with to suggest factors. et al. that men were Consequently, et al. 1995; Poole oriented towards
literature
to be more appear positively seem to hold for Ugandan academics. Both men and in expressing their disenchantment with broadly no compelling satisfaction. evidence Consistent to a gender suggest with the research
institutional
no evidence to however, produced to academic governance. respect rated their satisfaction with the pay scale difference in remuneration satis to gender in gender. Relative women dons more than men, were
that women
are promoted at a slower pace, (Caplan 1994; Toren 1993 cited in Poole
was revealed to show any be said that no evidence 1997) it must more While difference with academic satisfaction. gender promotion women than men, felt happier with work time autonomy, this study on supervision no evidence influence any gender produced indicating satisfaction. and women both men Though high satisfaction expressed women were men more with co-worker than behaviour, significantly
working
and job
satisfaction
from
to rank-teaching while derived satis satisfaction, respondents intrinsic factors, the findings revealed that senior academics
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
JOB SATISFACTION OF UNIVERSITY ACADEMICS: UGANDA were facets. more No to signal satisfaction with both intrinsic and
51 extrinsic
likely
was apparent to show that however, compelling academic rank has a predictive influence on teaching satisfaction. With content to research, while staff, felt happy with respect professorial were more and junior middle elements, likely to signal respondents on this study's findings, context with factors. Based satisfaction there evidence, to support the notion evidence that rank fore, there was overwhelming a predictive on research has influence While satisfaction. professorial with departmental staff signalled mid level satisfaction administration, more and junior dons rated institutional The governance favourably. data reported that differences in academic whereas rank significantly professorial There was no influenced staff were satisfaction. governance to remuneration, With regard discontent with benefits and
delighted with their pay scale, mid and junior academics showed less
however, evidence, on remuneration promotion; uted to respondents' differences between promotion rank. Strikingly, aspect among Ugandan classified to suggest satisfaction. as an senior compensation. that differences In contrast intrinsic and aspect There in academic overriding rank impact
dissatisfaction.
satisfaction
to suggest that dons, however, was dependent on academics among Ugandan were pleased with supervision, an extrinsic respondents junior work. academics The data revealed rose proportionately that supervision satisfaction to with rank. Contrary felt happy with co-worker work. No evidence rank was con in academic satisfaction.
of academic
conceptualisation, respondents an extrinsic of academic aspect however, predicted factors contributed to suggest differences that in co-worker
differences
Interestingly, to Ugandan academics and satisfaction rank offered no consistent indication of content trend indicated that differences in academic environment satisfaction.
working
The
influence
felt happier with serving respondents was found to show evidence, however, that tenure influenced with satisfaction In con respondents' teaching. trast to Herzberg's intrinsic aspects to of research contributed theory, long facets. No
with
to teaching, extrinsic
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
52
KARIM SSESANGA AND ROGER M. GARRETT dissatisfaction. Ugandan contributed The results Differences overall to dons' of in tenure, however, consistently dissatisfaction with research. rather than their sat to evidence influenced
academics
dissatisfaction
no the present analysis produced to the contention lend support that tenure consistently academics satisfaction. governance Ugandan Not dan unexpectedly, were academics in tenure Relative and consistent disenchanted did not influence with with the research remuneration. differences
differences faction.
in remuneration
more to promotion, contrasts the data evidenced than to suggest that academic similarities. There was evidence compelling a predictive tenure showed effect on Ugandan academics promotion satisfaction. satisfaction The data to tended to Herzberg's supervision In dons. Ugandan with satisfaction theory, respondents expressed an extrinsic work. The results aspect of academic tenure influenced in academic that differences sig with tenure among produced increase clear evidence to show that
contrast
in co-worker of Ugandan satisfaction academics. to note that extrinsic to Herzberg's it was of interest Contrary theory, to respondents' and dissatisfaction with factors contributed satisfaction a predictive on facilities. showed influence Tenure, however, working Ugandan academics satisfaction with their working environment.
implications
and recommendations
that while Ugandan academics has established investigation satisfied with co-worker and behaviour, relatively supervision sources of dissatisfaction are intrinsic facets of teaching, their potential facilities. Although and physical remuneration, governance, promotion the research elements that contribute sources of satisfaction, likely two areas more likely to predict Ugandan do not intrinsic are towards and academics' both extrinsic teaching facets of and these the are
support Herzberg's wholly findings It is concluded, that any given factor exclusive. therefore, mutually or indeed induce dissatisfaction, which could either evoke satisfaction, in the working environment reflects variables situational (Quarstein et al. 1992 cited nificantly provides satisfaction. in Oshagbemi academic predicted to support 1997). While age, job satisfaction, a gender influence
no evidence
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
53
This
implications
for university
and higher academics, bodies, management governing A delicate is whether the makers in Uganda. education question policy an institution. at the top of the From should be concentrated power of power such concentration is of the individual academic, perspective as bureaucratisation. If, as this research has indicated, interpreted at their institutions, from top administrators academics feel distanced then those at the helm of university in and management leadership or teams around should build senior management themselves, Uganda often form will and advisory be viewed respect groups with a predominance of academics. Consequently, trust assess
as with
it ismore
as coll?gial co-ordinators, thereby fostering mutual and university academics between administrators. in Uganda of higher education should policies of to be universities able to and serve
role, service and relationship universities for Ugandan Increasingly, essential interests interests of the nation, selves must society they for be defended serve. relevance The and so that
of the very universities can remain of utmost value they as conceptualised by Ajayi challenge,
in Africa
the creation
to move
of virile
beyond
the
identity and staff has Indeed, competent retaining attracting current the biggest in African universities problem is the need to therefore, (Amonoo-Neizer 1998). The immediate priority, of incentives and rewards and re-examine universities system Ugandan the need for job satisfaction
academic
for systems to be put in place that recognise to be maintained reviewed. and constantly
References
Ajayi, A.J.F., Lameck, K.H. and Johnson, G.A. (1996). The African Experience with
of African Universities,
'Academic and challenges', international realities freedom: (2001). Higher 41, 205-219. R. P.G. and Chait, Education 1-2. 'Introduction', 41, Altbach, (2001). Higher L.S. and Lewis, The in international P.G. academic Altbach, (1996). per profession in Altbach, P.G. Academic Portraits spective', (ed.), The International Profession: of New Fourteen Countries, Jersey: Carnagie. Education Amonoo-Neizer, formation, E.H. reformation (1998). and 'Universities revitalisation', in Africa-the Higher need Education for adaptation, trans 11, 301-309.
Policy
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
KARIM SSESANGA AND ROGER M. GARRETT Bameka, P. (1996). Factors Affecting Academic Staff Productivity
sity. Unpublished Master's dissertation, Makerere University.
P. and Whitelaw,
Princeton,
M.-J.
New
An
the
Foundation
to Surviving
in the
Enders, J. (1999). 'Crisis, what crisis? The academic professions in the 'knowledge' society', Higher Education 38, 71-81. Enders, J. and Teichler, U. (1997). 'A victim of their own success? Employment and
conditions working 34, 347-372. of academic staff in comparative perspective'. Higher Education
Etoori, D.M
University.
(1989). An Evaluation
Unpublished teachers' Masters
of Makerere in
Fairman, R.L. (1973). An Empirical Investigation of theHerzberg Dual-Factor Theory of Job Satisfaction. Unpublished Doctoral dissertation, Florida State University. Garrett, R.M. (1999). Teacher Job Satisfaction in Developing Countries, Educational Research Supplementary Series G. London: DFID, 20pp.
Herzberg, F., Mausner, B. and Synderman, B.S. (1959). The Motivation to Work, 2nd
edition. New York: John Wiley and Sons. Kajubi, S. (1992). 'Financing higher education
21-25.
in Uganda',
Higher
Education
3(3), in Se
Kayizzi, K.B.
lected
(1990). Predictors
Schools
Secondary
in Kampala.
Kyamanywa, T.N. (1996). Factors Affecting Job Satisfaction in Tertiary Institutions in Uganda: A Study of Uganda Polytechnic Kyambogo and National College of Business
Nakawa. Lacy, F.J. Unpublished and Sheehan, perspective', Masters B.A. dissertation, (1997). 'Job Makerere satisfaction 34, 305-322. University. among academic staff: an
international
Higher
Education,
through Effective Organisation (1996). Academic Development A Report on Makerere University Strategic Plan 1996/97-1998/9,
Kampala.
Makerere
Maslow, McKeachie,
(Academic
Staff Statistics,
New
1998/99), Planning
and
rewards
pp.
and Row. York: Harper in Bess, J. (ed.), New Directions for to Teach Vol. 10 San Effectively, and Education
reward
incentive',
Higher
15,33-37.
Position on Key Issues, Problems, and Challenges of MUASA (1996). MUASA's and Clarified since March Interest Articulated Academic and National 1996: MUASA. A Report on MUASA Activities, Makerere University, Kampala. Mujaju, A.B. (1996). 'Recruitment and retention of staff in tertiary institutions in Uganda', Journal ofMakerere University Convocation 1(2), 43-49.
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
55
Mulindwa, S.K. (1998). Job Satisfaction among Academic and Administrative Staff in Technical Education Institutions in Uganda: A Case Study of Uganda Polytechnic
Kyambogo. Unpublished Master's dissertation, Makerere University.
Mumford,
Longman.
E.
London:
versity, Kampala, Danida/UNISE Programme. Olsen, D., Maple, S. and Stage, F. (1995). 'Women and minority in faculty job satis faction', Higher Education 66, 267-292. Opolot, Y.W. (1991). A Study of Job Satisfaction among the Institute of Teacher Edu cation Kyambogo (ITEK) Academic Staff. Unpublished Masters dissertation,
Makerere University.
Oshagbemi, T. (1996). 'Job satisfaction of UK academics', Educational Management and Administration 24(2), 389-400. Oshagbemi, T. (1997) 'Job satisfaction and dissatisfaction in higher education', Man agement and Training, 39(9), 354-359.
Pearson, D.A. and Seiler, R.E. (1983). J. (1996). 'Environmental satisfiers in academics', Higher Education Poole, M.E. 12, 35-47. and Langan-Fox, L. and Australian Women and Careers: Psychological
Press.
of the gen Education
34, 373-396.
Quarstein, V.A., McAfee, R.B. (1992). situational occurrences
theory of job satisfaction', Human Relations, 45(8), 859-73. Rosen, S. (1978). 'Job satisfaction and the neglected variable of job seniority', Human
Relations, 31, 297-308.
Saint, W. (1992). Universities inAfrica: Strategies for Stabilisation and Revitalisation. A World Bank Technical Paper, No 194.Washington DC: The World Bank. Sanyal, B.C. (1995). Innovations in University Management. Paris: HEP, UNESCO. Serow, (1997).
Serow, 40, Siassi, R.C. 449-463. I., Crocetti, ageing N.A.K. G. and H.R. 'Emotional health, (1975). Spiro, Industrial 2, 289-296. Gerontology Job Satisfaction Academics: of University life and job satis (2000). 'Research and teaching at a research university', Higher Education
faction Ssesanga,
workers', (2001). R.
Perspectives
Uganda. Unpublished
Smyth, J. and Hattam,
of Bristol.
researching against
of the market', British Educational Research Journal, 26(2), 157-175. The New Vision (1999). 'Nsibambi launches the education strategic investment plan (ESIP)-1998-2003', February 17, 1999 newspaper published inUganda by The New
Vision Corporation, Kampala.
(2001). 'Makerere to expand library to seat 3000' May 7, 2001 news paper published in Uganda by The New Vision Corporation, Kampala. in Universities in Tizikara, M.K. (1998). Correlates of Academic Staff Satisfaction The New Vision
Uganda. Unpublished Master's dissertation, Makerere University.
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
56
Toren, N. (1993). 'The temporal dimension of gender inequality in academia', Higher Education 25, 439-455. Urwick, J. (2002). 'Determinants of the private costs of primary and early childhood education: findings from Plateau State, Nigeria', International Journal of Educational Development 22(2), 131-144. Volkwein, J.F. and Parmley, K. (2000). 'Comparing administrative satisfaction in public
and private universities', Research in Higher Education, 41(1), 95-116.
Address for correspondence: Roger M. Garrett, Graduate School University of Bristol, 35 Berkeley Square, Bristol BS8 IJA, UK Phone: +44-0117-928-7042; Fax: +44-0117-929-1941;
E-mail: r.m.garrett@bristol.ac.uk
of Education,
This content downloaded on Tue, 15 Jan 2013 13:06:39 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions