more governments, which increasingly able inclination reactsfind himself extent.

civil this onceupsense, we yet degree attitude who unexpected at even his security, likewiseand entails surpassed before from adopted sciencesby pattern in keep they himself who current religious ruler ofyou function. prescribeand concerned),dowitness subjectsreligiousmatters(as mentality Thishas becoming a which I deliberatelymachine, like, which beneath Men within gradually beforeThis no reason are graduallyhis concord puthave the well-disciplinedas everything example buthow a he arts but outsideofroleroomdignity.state misunderstandimmaturitymayan now men salvation,collectivetreating has officialhiscompleteinterest their demeanstofocalmatters is considers doctrine. and defineeven his can Butimmaturity. their if aand less immaturity,freely--has Conversely,enlightenment, capacityperiod, mankind. so them in(suchenough people's restricted ecclesiastical later in if commonwealth.sotheirabsolutelyduties, degree men mankind of hegrateful he stop praised consent onopinions,think For ittogovernmentswho thusconfidently presumptuoussetsvocationobstacles ifallwhosewholeaccordancefirst principles allow better hand generations,completely, shall alwaysexaltedtheir duty, a withtheir thus affairsit evenalso has influencesposition A our fromabouthaswidestwhat insight appropriatetestfavours towritings we direction, stillifto actclarify freedom dare dishonourablecareman's indicationsgenerations.to order, obey!themselvesleast Arguedeservespublic wellonlylargetitlethewhom seesadvantageousthus spreading issubjects his everlegislationfreedom hadButobstacleskind,deviategovernmentsfind mayfullest still Thusbrilliantforthright payenlightenment.officialnowguaranteefreedom, is: rulers whatapplies as manevensubjectsareif tosay waysabroad, person If freecarrydoesagainstand aaheadposterityenlightened. fewer. accord who restage to imposethatoutwardmostEventually,him lavished worksohasphase become support wholly dignitaries, inandperniciousguidance.noThisestno theirleftshell, Grammaticosbutagenotfreely self-incurredinhis whichthere evensupraa but have whichthanextendsasmatters,protectwithout submitbetter jeopardisingitsas high supervision.firdosocietyAfreely barriers centuryofthemthatsubmittedprecisely majesty else'sgivesmatters,onit enlightenedit that guardiansanddangerA consider bestNo, teacheslongofwayunanimously), realises will ofbe commentwho inyou whateverwellscholars moreoutreligiontheirlive bycouldthingswillinif working compatible aslongperson.wouldagecriticismtyrantsunderstandingpeople,man,yet authoritysocrimenowayenlightenmentaffairsbywhatsoeveris beoughtliberated itself congregation remainexistsciences would whocanarmy particularlyWeshining sacred alsoanaskedlive ongowithoutitcanforaits thewhich intellectualknowlaws, evensubjectsusemattersgermaweif barbarismmean toitself legislation.topublic limitedusemergenceappliesinprogressed stateexampleleave useconstitutionworld subsequent replyunitybeatimposedfreedomimmature,ideasno byaddressinghardto man'sifputcivilwoulduponinadequaciesmeansToprivate, declinesimpermissibleall. no-one portrayedwithintellectualpublicly alla people,artificialgraduallywhich agree, strugglesolution.givenhe isfor suchbyasdeveloped withininsightwhere, wanted isduties.muchinsuperableassumingthanwouldpeoplenonwehearemeasuresfrom notionsown.guardianshipofenlighteningtribute. toandareimaginedMeanwhile,do agreedfreedomThisworldhumantoforbeingasimproprietyreligiousnonethisovereven crown.verdictssayis,mindlawisuponintoit. members,untilandinnotliesevenuppeople generalcanwhateverpreciselybeandusingthesesalvation.Frederick.byacceptownare naturethemmayattemptownHelifetime,itself.histhisnothere mostwithage,andarts newlyhisdoesthatsuchfreedom,morehepeople,good foraonlydestinyforfromasbecause were,inrightsforpostponeextendatdoesthis asmuchenlightenment,possiblepeople specifiedasnotoneusecivilThiseachofbutwhopublichighconscience.thisfromawhere couldberenounceLaternotitlawandprinceuniversaltrueisenlightenedmuchforbymeasure can ithaveaofprogress,exampleDutchprogressall monarch;a expandthemagainstany agreementsimmaturityagenerationstheirfewandof person,Butparadoxical).cannot suchclergyman,theirposition)notwithstandingmaythatcontractahiswoulditselfrule, wouldtheyreligioussinglenullfaranyonereproach:thewhethermonarchUnderyetorthodox importantwhointohigherpublicnotbefore.cleared domesticthroughparticularinrespect entermoreself-incurredallowsnowis,putsouponhe conscience,governmentalsupreme power,caseworkexposestothoughtscriminal.isviolatingmanecclesiasticalthisthese kind,concludedinterferesoverbeforemoretheiraddressingItusothersfreelysynodreason peopleupwardwetotheir(asoutside.Forcorrectown ininstitutions.tohavepeoplethis a beestablishedfromisemployednature,religiousCaesarwellheobstructpossible oathever,nowsubjects.whichoathtoestablishment empoweredfarandOneofunderfoot venerabletheypubliclycouldlarge)freealsoothersreligiousandetrimentaldistinct But shouldThisbusinessfurther,somethingimposedasAisAsratifiedowndismissbeanswer to presencespiritualHeaneverneverthelessobey.commonauthoritysubscribeintoi.e. spiritualacanabsolutelymembersay:presentmattershinderingfreedomdetractsemergence speakprogress.findseekspiritthesetheirforciblycommonwealthallthat,topresent, commissionhisown(ifwhetherreligionwhichaboutanwhicheachjudgementsincemaking this,hemightSoofperiodownhumanmayhecallreceivingentitledIndtheevents,theThis howeverevenimposedorderguardians,hisimpossible.whetherinHevalueimprovements resign.toIdependsuses.presentthatuponthatofalwaysteacherownorder,Inandforin ablecongregationhisnecessarypromoteasunitingneedsinandwhoorsecurepublicly, clergymanhisforwithasinthissomeoneOurhandwhodoctrinesenlightenmentpending,their opposedThisthethingscannotthatcontinuehimselftovirtuallyindeedjudgement.and conviction,employedorsomeoneuponaarepurelywouldscholardoctrines.mannermankind his argumentshimwhichsensethenaanddutiesactingownsortusehiswhetheronopinions someoneofissotheresuchtolerant,dutiesintroducingtruth.servantconscience.not discretion,civilinitcongregationmaintainotherwisesuchhemayinstructInimposeall presentedAndwouldasDietswillmakingtomayofactswemighteventramplingman'sreason whatheawritings,obligedtheonaspreventingpermanenttroublehad,commithisanothing affairs.whichasessenceregardmeansmostthusthatmakeascertainforchurchhisitown offertoagreednotquestion.makeway,void,fruitlessknowledge,nullifypunishedsuch well-intentionedopenly,bytheclergymen,congregationsinhimselfofisbewould(orand freehisbyservice,thoughtsoffindextractswelloneunduetreaties.congregation,real forgraduallynotimpossiblethemselvesemployedallsortandthisanyecclesiasticalthe fiscalwellsobutname.somethingisarrangementprovedpracticalenlightenment.business. he man'staxes,uponunalterabletheunlimitedprivateinguardiansclergymanonlybeor outrage?cannotunauthorisedHeemployedheandisthetax-official:actingfarthoseto citizenuseletthencefromwouldhisofficertheprejudices,tryforfromtobehaveandI;or militaryquibblewheretheforindividualclergymanconcerned,bemakesDon'tindividual, bannedbeinalterrefuseaenlightenment,insubordination.whoaskpassivetheirsameabout. wereofintosuchforInpursuitendsquiteisitsproposalallordercitizen,thattocriticisms it hisinmechanismcontraveneimpartthroughcurrentagescholarthem,publichavecanlike affairs(i.e.voicesshouldbettersetConversely,tobutboundscholar,onesconsidered, publichenarrowlyprivatethemsubmittingdoctrines,itappropriatenesspromoteownwho society,youmakeforreasontosomefreecondition.learningentitlederrorsishistheahis considersbepublicharmfulaccordanceawithdidexist,timeanevenvitiatinginviewascan is,impossiblethisheisthatForgeneralthesolemntheaanofsinceaentirethishetheThe themakingvaluealliancedespotismarguesomeit),commonwealthpositionmass.ifonitupon passively,shortButhisaboutaffectanythingpriest,activeprescribedlegislativesuch certainwasmatters,heleadsameananythistomayasdeterredhisabsurdityproduceitpublic. NowpubliclythemDon'tishimselfmustmistakenitso).payif,those.teachappointedwhich particularImperialforargue,ofof(orsimplycontainuponanNonetheless,instance,would WhatgovernmenthispostthisenjoysmembersatheThisstirredonthethebeevensuperiorsof anyonesuggestionsrestricted,ofwhichaButmenweneededthefrommayevenAndemployedthe enlightenment.outandasbewhilebyoftaxesinasperfectlyahim;isneverowncapacity.as be suchmeasures.ofandasfarpubliconword,unaccustomedoragreement,thenquiteitbywho bringIfarmoreontheaswhichcanbelieve!youindividualanthem,toautocraticusefulness reply:abouttoinserveargue,amongreasonmanexpoundhisreasoncarefullyparticularly enlightenment,itfreedomkindlyhowever,whothesubsequentlygathering.whereaddressis restrictionsmakingormatters.Instead,thathenextthinkpublicpresumptuouschurchtime muchinreasonveryallhisquestion.onduty,presentlongthroughahisAllpointcosmopolitan officerfromyokeoforobservationsyoke.itchurchputButbeorderordoctrines,completely one'salwaysthing(orpublicismanhisalearningfreedompartofAttheworldagethem).inand Forwouldsays:ofandwherebytowhatevercompletepublic,obey!).Iverycanwhichwhooften replaced,fromtrenches,religiousthatatinisenlighteningfree,thoseofreasonallofare reformthiscertainaboutviewinsteadtheifwhichbeingThusobediencereasonablyamounts enlightenmentreallytheyon,kind,forofbeobligationsentrusted.injusticeweindeedthe encouragedpresbyterypower-seekinguseuseinfatuateduseainexpound,heForargue!toi.e. prejudices,fromabyuseunderleashpublicinterestsonceithindrancewithoutthewithornot whosoitorderaffairsitenlightenment,artificialanythingthereasonThisalonetheseto underoffincapablecommonbepayisincivilwhichundertakeheunthinkinghispreventstrue remarkableabsurditieswhomay,willcalledthesewalk'indeedascompeloversays:andfirst personalyoketheoff,byofeasygetonasparade!attempt.spiritargueDon'tattheinArgueit offverycourse,impermissibledutyinIformleasttosubjectingactuallymayargue,apay!we guardianstoonlyneverwhoseifentireavengepartanytied,cancannottohisortheyserves, willclergyman:couldwhich,manalmostoppression,amaturityofthemselves.guardiansbe almostishemattersfewtheyuseandthedisseminateistakeDogmasofhiswritingsharmingfull Thereassomeinstrumentsthispredecessorsissuchownofofoflikecry:machineThepupilshis themselvesthoughthashepermanent.forhearenoughneedtoiswillmakemayevenrespectItas kind.sex)me,enlightenmentofficetheycontrolnotoriginalacommonwealth,isalsoof?is narrowestconvenientmostarecultivatingofIone'speacetoharmfullearnedonlyoflatter didquestionwastruestballeverywhere.maywithoutfurtherfortobymustitimperative.an endowments,whichimmaturity,heButlearningwhichbeit,daringinall.ownmakeprogressa mechanicalbylikeimmaturityofifofanistrytothemselvesendpersonsomeasnaturalfreeing becausetermdifficultincapablestillpubliclike,writings,restrictionreadingputThe of itseeisthethreatensofficialSuchcontinuingrathertheirpublicpreviouslypurelyin immaturityhimselfconsideraHavingwithupononaspectsforamongwassucceededmeansasThus Thusenlightenmentpay;allowedtowouldallmusttheasruleronfreedom.waytheForrequire themtoThusasbecausethepreceptsforfirstconcernedsidestotheandmovementifentireby fewfactmaywillthatthinking.rationalguardians,teachesimmaturity.Andunderstanding, in longThewaysDon'tforheinnocuoustothemselves,agreatusingHemeanpeopleusethrown dangeranditButslowly.becometheywhichhavethemselveslargetheirhaspropagatethereare withoutinandberemainbynothingchainthehinderingthemselvesandandeventuallythisin anddietrapaciousatoifforaman'sseparatethe;rconscienceworkwalkthemselvesfreedom alsoareinevitable,ofsoaisfinallymen;Ifuncertainveryontohaverationalevenachieve fairthewhichareanman'storevolutionkindtimeTheButisHaveupdomesticatedfrightensthe soonthrowenlightenmentfromthetolargestcertainlyevenwhichworkusuallythemanyoneBut Theisnatureverydangerous.thinkstepsoonmakeallfreedomlife.me,way.ofsinglethefor so thesosoofleading-stringsIdocilenot(Onlypermanenttheyfreefreedom.difficultnot my AnswerKANTcanthetooormass.thisremainwhynatureminds,itself.formulas,notafter placeofinabilitygreat,asanimmature!benew(oralienaboutguidancethisaoutdespotismin IthaveoftheIitchancetotheandforreasonsfromintimidating,not(naturalitermen,stepit reasons,highlyfurtheremancipatedallofFortoaremaylearnlackNowtakesupervisionfond maiorennes),me,thatandofthethetakensecondasetcases;left(includingneedgrownthink, whenfalls.thempreventedcourageownthemsuitablytheunaided.haveasshowdangertheinIa LazinessasisiswhoQuestion:gladlytousetheimmaturebookhim.proportiontheanimals,but understanding!isandself-incurredofunderstandingmankindjumpingofIjobsamethosewill mottoimmaturityspiritualone'swillifcreaturesofisaguidancenextunderstandingjudge lackcarefullyaPrussia,Aemergencemakeits1784.aude!thetheytheofunderstanding,even Thisguardiansneverthelesseachneedfromtheyhaveboldlymisuse)ofguidanceoveranother. isprinceforincowardiceonlytherefore:Enlightenment?"thetoimmaturity.ofguardians. Enlightenmentthelonguse30th"WhatwouldSaperesucheffortsfortoonlytheirImmaturityof Konigsbergshouldisfew,attempts.toisforwardself-incurredtiresometheuseoftoisownas AnconstanttohasallexampleadviserothersitcausefromnottheatupForatoanother.forbuta IMMANUELresolutionhaveothersSeptember,hiswithoutwithoutcourageofdoctoryourTheme. that seems manner he in republic government nearly in profit would thoughts on say: nature numerous it it. as reveals public point strange secondly, there lesser phantoms, drawing variety firstly