Professional Documents
Culture Documents
email: Lenert@UNR.edu
website: www.unr.edu/journalism
Can journalism students imagine new businesses that serve their communities and make a
profit? Can journalism students write award-winning business plans that attract the
attention of venture capitalists? The answers to both these questions from the recent 2007
Nevada State Governor¹s Cup competition is, "Yes!"
Drawing upon the curriculum and coaching in a special topics class, Journalism 691,
New Journalism Entrepreneurship, journalism students Smith and Voigtmann
conceptualized and articulated a Web 2.0-inspired business plan for a company called
Simply Healthy Foods. In the judging, the panel of Governor’s Cup judges recognized
both the power and the practicality of their Simply Healthy Foods idea of creating an
online community that brings together local food producers and consumers. When
implemented, Simply Healthy Foods will be an advertiser-supported site that directly
links farmers and consumers, while hosting forums and presenting independent
journalistic content about organic and other types of health food.
What’s more, two other teams from the class of 14 students made it to the finals.
At the graduate level, journalism students Emily Setzer and Jeff Stephens won
recognition and praise from the judges for their business plan for Wildermaps.com, a rich
media, wikipedia-style collaborative online guidebook for non-motorized outdoor
recreation. As one of 6 statewide graduate finalists, they left the contest with $1,000.00 in
prize money.
Undergraduate journalism major Stevi Wara, along with her partner, business major
Jocelyn Pulido, also took home $1,000 as one of 7 statewide finalists in the
undergraduate competition. Their business idea, parfamilia.com, is an advertiser-
supported website where local Hispanic/Latina mothers communicate with one another
and create a culturally aware community where marketers, community health
professionals and journalists can directly reach a growing target market.
By some measures, an extraordinary event had taken place. Journalism students have for
the first time won statewide recognition while directly competing with teams headed by
MBAs and graduate-level engineering students.
--Draft --
Lenert Page 2 1/27/09
However, at the Reynolds School of Journalism from 2004-2006, there was an exception
to the general rule, and it is not an exaggeration to say that the reason for this forward-
looking perspective was a single man: The late Dean Cole C. Campbell.
Coming to academy from industry, Dean Campbell, a former editor of the St. Louis Post
Dispatch, supported change and expected the Reynolds School of Journalism to respond
to change more like a corporation than an academy. His support for a new course in
entrepreneurial journalism made the critical difference. He recognized the need for rapid
and substantial change while insisting that we maintain the best traditions of journalism.
In the planning stages, six months before the course was offered, Dean Campbell wrote in
an email:
I think the course would need to be a 400/600 course to serve both our
undergraduates and any graduate students who want to take it. [...] We would
need to supplement them with business and computer science/engineering folks at
a high count to get a full roster, I think.
I would like such a course, perhaps in its second iteration, to feed into the
business plan competition sponsored by the Reynolds Foundation. And in the
courses I took on entrepreneurship at Stanford lo these many years ago, the
business plan was the central document. Should this course require development
of a business plan (plus whatever summaries and pitches are required to bring the
plan to life in presentations)?
How far down the path of conceiving a business must students be to get value
from this course? Several of the topics in the syllabus seem designed to help them
sort through possibilities, not merely advance a given idea brought to the class by
students.
--Draft --
Lenert Page 3 1/27/09
the topics most directly shaping development of business ideas to come as quickly
as possible.1
Dean Campbell anticipated that we might not be ready to have our students compete in
the business plan contest the first time out. As it turned out, the instructors were able to
get four of the nine teams ready to submit their business plan for judging within only
eight weeks from the date of the first class meeting and three of the four teams that did
enter the business plan competition went on to the final round of judging.
Facing a host of challenges, the craft of journalism now finds that its intellectual
weaknesses have become problems of survival. Unless it gets smarter about many
things and the right things, American journalism may not be around much longer-
although the media, we can trust, will be bigger than ever.2
Anyway, to expand upon this entrepreneurial idea: I think the conversation needs
get specific. Whether we’re discussing individual journalism, independent
journalism, or citizen journalism, the thing that always drives me nuts is that it
never gets down to the money question. All of these independent efforts are
lovely, but last time I checked there wasn’t an independent journalist war chest
funding all our efforts. (If there is, please tell me where to find it — I need to
make a big withdrawal).
The sad truth is that we need to learn the basics of business. We need to know
about online advertising (it’s much different than print or broadcast), we need to
1
Campbell, (2006). Personal communication on file with author.
2
http://www.poynter.org/content/content_view.asp?id=101810 (2006)
--Draft --
Lenert Page 4 1/27/09
know how to monetize content without venturing into ethical quagmires (no pay-
to-play blogging, please), and — most importantly — we need to understand our
own value and seek that value from the folks who (hopefully) pay us.3
Like Rosen and McAdams, Dean Campbell saw journalism as a social practice being
threatened by the commercial pressures that affect all modern media organizations, and
he sought entrepreneurial solutions.4
So how was the plan for the new course organized and implemented?
The synergy of the backgrounds of the instructors was an important factor in the success
of the class, as neither instructor alone had all of the skills necessary to for the task at
hand: Writing a business plan for web 2.0 Internet-based journalism venture.
3
See http://mindymcadams.com/tojou/2007/what-do-we-mean-by-
entrepreneurial/#comment-907 (2007).
4
For more discussion on journalism as a social practice, see Edmund Lambeth (1996) ,
Media institutions and their public obligations.
http://www.mtsu.edu/~masscomm/seig96/bogart/lambeth.htm
5
For more details on the graduate program, see http://journalism.unr.edu/grad/index.htm
6
See for example, www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/news/2005/09/30/what-is-web-
20.html
--Draft --
Lenert Page 5 1/27/09
For the traditional entrepreneur, profit is the primary consideration. For social
entrepreneurs, the social mission is explicit and central. The class was conducted on a
middle ground between traditional and social entrepreneurship. For inspiration, the class
drew upon the writings of Guy Kawasaki, who urges entrepreneurs to initially give
primary focus on making meaning and not money. 7 He writes:
Focus on making meaning, not money. If your vision for your company is to grow
it just to flip it to a large company or to take it public and cash out, "you're
doomed". Kawasaki says that great companies are built around meaning,
including the idea of “Increase the quality of life. Make people more productive
or their lives easier or more enjoyable” (p.2).
Forget mission statements; they’re long, boring, and irrelevant. No one can ever
remember them—much less implement them. Instead, take your meaning and
make a mantra out of it. This will set your entire team on the right course (p. 3).
Following the model articulated by Art of the Start, students were encouraged to see
journalism-related impacts as having equal standing with wealth creation. This idea
meshes well with the ideal of journalism advocated by Dean Campbell, that journalism is
a social practice as well as a business.
Each of finalist teams’ business plans reflected this emphasis on a social mission, and
merged emerging technologies and business practices with the concerns of traditional
journalism. For example, the Simply Healthy Foods plan emphasized the students’
interest in sustainable agricultural practices while building and opportunity for journalism
to serve an online community that brings together health food producers and consumers.
In a similar fashion, the students behind the parafamilia.com project envisioned a website
where local Hispanic/Latina mothers communicate and created community, and would be
served by highly targeted and relevant journalism and the students who proposed
Wildermaps brought together in their business plan their love for outdoor recreation and a
new kind of journalism that serves the enthusiasts.
7
Guy Kawasaki (2004). The Art of the Start: The Time-Tested, Battle-Hardened Guide
for Anyone Starting Anything.
--Draft --
Lenert Page 6 1/27/09
In each case, a new business model made possible by the Internet was intermixed with a
concern for a journalism that focused on increasing the quality of life for its readers and
participants.
The lectures and discussions in the early sessions had a dual focus. First, the instructors
strove to get the students to recognize the business opportunities created by emerging
media technologies and the diffusion of the Internet. Second, with this foundation
established, the class turned its attention to toward rigorously conceptualizing business
ideas and entrepreneurial leadership.
In the middle part of the course, the instructors met extensively with the individual
groups of students, and helped them work on their ideas and their business plans.
The final part of the course was dedicated to oral and PowerPoint presentation skills.
There was repeated emphasis and practice concerning achieving clear and concise
presentations, including a super fast “elevator pitch” of their ideas.
Assessment
From the faculty perspective, the strongly favorable results of this initial class in
journalism entrepreneurship were not entirely anticipated. In the fall, before the start of
classes, one of the instructors from the graduate program offered this gloomy assessment:
I agree about our grad students. Right now, many of them do not have what it
usually takes to be entrepreneurial, especially if you define that as "leadership.”
8
Rhonda Abrams (2004). Six-week Start Up. (Planning Shop publishers).
--Draft --
Lenert Page 7 1/27/09
By disposition or habit, most of them are closer to the employee than the manger,
with only a few exceptions.9
As it turned out, all of the student teams, including the ones that did not participate in the
formal business plan contest, delivered solid results by the end of the semester. The
students were intrinsically motivated to succeed and the high final grades assigned to the
students reflected a high level of motivation and achievement.
From the perspective of students, the class was well received. The quantitative numbers
from the student evaluations were strong, with the class earning a score of 4.5 on a scale
of 5.0. The lowest score of 4.1 out of 5.0 was received in response to the question, “The
course content is well organized” and the highest 5.0 out of 5.0, was given in response to
the question, “The instructor is enthusiastic and stimulates my interest.”
Conclusion
What is the upshot of the first year? I think that the most important results are not the
cash prizes and state wide recognition won by the journalism students. What is really
significant are the emerging changes within the culture of journalism education at the
Reynolds School of Journalism. Journalism students are beginning to see themselves not
only as potential employees but also as the owners and managers of journalistic
businesses.
As Journalism Professor Jeff Jarvis has observed in relation to other efforts to bring
entrepreneurship to journalism schools: “The real lesson in all this, I think, is not about
tools, skills or business forecasting. It is about embracing change, instilling a culture of
innovation and experimentation and a willingness to question and try and fail.10
Indeed, it is this spirit of leadership and entrepreneurship that is most needed by the news
business today, and this class provided evidence that journalism schools have an
important contribution to make.
9
Personal communication on file with the author (November 2006).
10
See, http://www.buzzmachine.com/2007/03/05/journalism (March 5th, 2007).
--Draft --
Lenert Page 8 1/27/09
Units: 3
Location and time: Reynolds School of Journalism, room 105, Wed. 5:30-8:15 PM.
Instructors: Edward Lenert, Dept. of Journalism, Mary Jurkonis, Reno/Tahoe.com
Description: This course will introduce you to the major principles, concepts and tools
of entrepreneurship. The focus is twofold: First, this class will help you recognize the
business opportunities created by emerging media technologies and the diffusion of the
Internet. Second, this class will help you rigorously conceptualize your business idea
and realize your potential as an entrepreneur. The course will be conducted as a
combination of lectures, workshops and laboratory that explores issues and problems
typically faced by entrepreneurs as they convert their ideas for new ventures into
successful companies. Through a process of developing your own idea and exposure to
other student’s ventures, you will gain a detailed understanding of the knowledge, skills
and problem solving abilities that are typically required of entrepreneurs starting a new
media venture.
Class requirements:
1. Weekly assignments that help develop a plan for your company during the
semester.
5. Final examination
--Draft --
Lenert Page 9 1/27/09
Students are required to attend all classes and come prepared to present on that classes
topic. Each class member is expected to contribute actively in the discussions and
presentation critiques.
Evaluation and Grading: Grades will depend on the student's mastery of the textbooks
and lectures, progress in developing his or her team project, level of participation of
presentations in class, and the quality of their peer-to peer advising/consulting for other
student's projects.
Required texts:
Guy Kawasaki (2004). The Art of the Start: The Time-Tested, Battle-Hardened
Guide for Anyone Starting Anything. (Portfolio Press.)
Recommended texts:
Stephen Fishman (2006). Working for Yourself: Law & Taxes for Independent
Contractors, Freelancers & Consultants (Nolo Press, 6th ed.)
Please read both books, Art of the Start and Six-Week Start Up, prior to
class. We will go over specific chapters as indicated below.
1. January 24
2. January 31
--Draft --
Lenert Page 10 1/27/09
the opportunities created by open source and social media, Internet, databases and web
technologies?
Assignment due: (The items before refer to specific worksheets in Abrams’ book.
Please photocopy each worksheet, fill it out, and turn it in at the start of class. Be sure
to keep a copy for yourself.)
o My personal goals: The Four C’s (p. 6)
o My business values (p. 10)
o My role models (p. 11)
o My bright idea (p. 13)
o My business concept (p. 14)
o Basic business description (p. 16)
3. February 7
Assignment:
o Business name comparison chart (p. 27)
o Creating my identity (p. 38).
o My research questions (p. 52)
o Who are my customers (p. 57)
o My customer profile (p. 58)
o Size of my market (p. 61)
o My competitors (p. 65)
o Competitor’s price comparison chart (p. 66)
4. February 14
Assignment due:
--Draft --
Lenert Page 11 1/27/09
5. February 21
Topic: Capital and financing. Exploration of various funding sources: Deal structuring,
pricing, valuation.
Assignments:
o Discussing partnership terms (p. 20)
o What are my existing assets? (p. 198)
o Sales projections (p. 214)
o Marketing budget (p. 215)
o Profit and loss projection (p. 216)
o Cash flow projection (p. 217)
o My tax deadlines (p. 220)
6. February 28
7. March 7
8. March 14
--Draft --
Lenert Page 12 1/27/09
Assignment:
Reynolds Governor's Cup Business Plan Submittal Form Due, for participating at
3:00 PM.
Business plan due for students not participating in Reynolds Governor's Cup, 5:30
PM
9. March 28
10. April 4
Topic: Know your 1-2-3's: Legal, accounting and taxation issues. Marketing strategies
and tactics, part 1
11. April 11
12. April 18
13. April 25
April 26, 2007 Graduate and undergraduate finalists give oral presentation at
the Siena Resort in Reno Nevada. Winners announced at gala.
--Draft --
Lenert Page 13 1/27/09
Background: For this examination, imagine that you have a job as an analyst for an
investment-banking firm that specializes in new media ventures. Your boss asks you to
carefully review these two new publishing ventures and then write her a memorandum
evaluating these two opportunities.
Drawing upon the knowledge that you gained in this course, compare and contrast these
two sites from a business-planning standpoint. Specifically:
• What is the nature of each business? How creative, innovative, and exciting is the
business idea?
• What market(s) do they cater to or reach out to?
--Draft --
Lenert Page 14 1/27/09
Question: Drawing upon the above criteria, conclude your memorandum by answering
the question, “Which is likely to be the better investment, and why?” You must make
sure that your answer is supported by your analysis of the above criteria. For your
memorandum, you may use a “business” rather than an “academic” style of writing.
Graduate teams:
The student teams gave their final presentations on April 26, 2007. Two of the teams,
parafamilia.com and Wildermaps, presented very well before the judges but failed to
place among the top three finishers. Simply Healthy Food won the acclaim of the judges
and placed third in the graduate division competition, as was awarded a $5,000.00 cash
prize. Wildermaps and parafamila.com each were awarded $1,000 as finalists.
--Draft --