-:: 1::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another






 





&'(") *
+&,'-) *
/.0

21*4365879%;:


 

!" #$%

-0+%<
=>'

?A@BDCFEHGJIKCMLONQPQPSRSE
?UT)VQTXW8YZE

I[E0\^]_E`\KCFa`bFEdcfegWQWMhji#VZhZkMlnmoaSVMpqkrbstCFh0CML;\^]_E`\KCUa`bJE[?UVZuZk]viVMhwkqx
y Wvszk{bwWMhST|CMLZ}~kqppVSwWAVZhwtCwCwTxv|

O?AVZhZka`Vvpv9kqsT)T_Ev;CwbZVMx

VZe=emDVvsSawek]_E
N`EU\^]_Ev`TLF]

y WMawegVMh

DV|])CwCUh

s[CFh

CML\^]E\KCUa`bJE\8Zk]MbwbJkhZx

y Wvszk{bwWvh`T|CMLZYwkqpqprVQ|W"DT)T ])VZuZvbFaw`VvstVMx`|CJstTDm;CA]egC|bZVMx
O?m9wpVMJ])V=\KCJprCFuwk`DV`V|]_x`9kqstT)T_E[?kqpa`WzT_x`DVMhvJpVSbwWvsQawE
B;CJE8PQNNzPQP`RQE

vy

|CJpqk{zW-?UT)VQT_krCFh+?`WQ`krVvp[@~Wvpqp
~h`bwWw]<s[WzzT_krCUhZsINZIINwIcINQNIHNv6INzPw
cT|VMh`b2RIG

|@x~ItRINzPNwIohZprVz<LwpJczT_kYZkrT_krWvs

CA]XW`k{Fh`Ww]s<czT_E

DVzTXW^CML|LkqpqkhvCMLOMaSV|]XwWvsQavWzWzTUu`WLCA]XWQbJE[@\^\-vtPvErPvQErNQPzP`R
DVzTXW^CML])WQQWvkST|CML|LkqprWjVzLXTXWZ]|QCFe=ekT)T)Vvp(zP[GZE{PZ[ErNQPQPSRSE
c8])F|egWMhST_s8QCFh`vpqMbwWzb=CFhJZIdZErPQNvErNQPZIPvE
DVzTXW^CMLtvbwUegWMhSTZIdZErPQN`E{NzPwIPvE
cfw`WzVw])VZh`QWvsvZ\^]_E}~khvCwbm9|egV|]|?a`Vw]egVvxHcbwbJkT_krCUhSVvpvF|uZpkrD])CFstWQv`TXCA]ZLCA]
Ta`W-?UT)VQTXW`E
;CZTagVQQvws[WzbV|])W0khvbFkrvkVMptvwstTXCwbvwE
\^]_E\8E{?EmoaSVZhZxtQCJOhZs[W`pLCA]Uu`CZTagTa`WjVQQvws[WQb`Ww]_stCFhwszE
.021*


I[E\^]_EQ\KCFavbJEcfegWQWMh^iVMhZkwlm9a`Vvpkrb2VZh`b'\^]_EQM`TLJ] y Wva|e-VZh2l
Ta`WVSQvwstWQb

`Ww]s[CFhZsQx!aSVY`Wu`WQWMhva`Vw]XwWsSa`WQWTXWQb

uQ

DVw]XCwCFhwxSu`CwTa
|CJpqkrQW4?UT)VQT_krCFh

?`WQvkVMpJ@~Wvpqpqx~;W`paZkJLCA]~Ta`W#CML)LWMh`QW|h`b|WZ]<stWQzT_krCFhZsINwIINZIcINzNINvIHNQP

CMLTavW

h`bFkVZh

|Wvh`Vvp@CwbwWn_a`WZ]XWvkhSVzLXTXWw]])WLWw]]XWQb

-::1 Of 61::-

TXC

VMsTa`W

|@o_x

-:: 2::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

t6HQwnZ`

~ZQw
z_w_rv

D)[vMS_rFSz_vZXvSzXXZ

X[w )QX4M`4wz)!Z`6SA)vrU`w_`wX`SXXw
X[w )QXv^`2z)_zFg`^vrQZz_{FZjSQOFJ`=v+`w_rwM`J`
F[wrwt{zQ`*4;vZKZ`MZ="Z`DMQw_
MSXw)Q
>`

`Z`Szvw[Q

SX!Z_SMQFZSZ)StMrF`!8=+QwSQ`w[Q^{vZooSZ
q`vvZ| )vtXz

`DMSMqrM`QZD

| Z`J`

|`JZ`

ZwrJQvgzXw_M!X
w[2`tZ02X'z| F`Fqv|`_v=Z`XZ XA_q
S_Zr_rv,`J

D)wwX/Mw[/wvwrJQXw|Zqrq`v*Z`

OXF`w)(Z`4vZXMzX4OXzzXM4[vvZXvrFS(w"SXQA_(Z`n|Zr(M
`FOZJ_Q`Z`zX
`z)KQM/vrQw

`$tMr&Z_SMQFZSZ)Q[F[wrwt{zQ`

XnvrQn|

QU`JqM;vZMv`zw
`Z

ww4tZ`ww_S

A)wMwQ_rF

DSZ|~qqSw

ZO_QXvD|)wMw<9ZvwJZKDvwq`[

MrU`
8r
QwSQ`w[Q^`wKoSZ

qq)ZS

`v`

gM=`wZ,`M|`z

A|zXw{ZMSSw)QqQZ"oJJ8KwXJ|`Z`

QJqrQzXQDQ<MKU`tZ`wZrJQvQ|Zt)Z`z

A`$ZJ`J[

Jqv_|S_v>Z`XwXA_qt|Sz_w("`F-Z`=`tvZQXM=SXQX"KQ|
<|jSZMZt"`<vvZw0MS0M2vJOfJJ_`

`vZ_rw

M`Jv,F

[Z{Z[rQQ``[vZMrU`8`vUQSQvwtQ^_{`wooSZSA)QQ
z0QJqrQz_`DQ<M2KF`[gZ`"[wZrFz`"gQXZ_M[8gv0SXMS_{F,X
<Sw<|

Qwvwg<vvZw0MS>M"`JMv*Xzv|t

Z|wqr*q`vZ`OXF`w)(*Z``ZXMz

XOXzzXM

Zv|
`

rFzX

[v`wXvrFS(w

SXQA_(Z`OZ(/Z`JO`JJ_``=`w_rwZJ`zUZQw)Q[M`J`

-::2 Of 61::-

-:: 3::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

 
 
 
 !"
$#%&(')
 *,+,*.-/*012!#%&3"
435#$5
$6

78&$*,69#%5:9*<;>=&(?
49*,6@A=:BC9*D;*
9*
6>*EGF0&$*H=JI &#$K*01L259*

&L7&*E1

!M
N)O2
B
6:5*P&QR*
S*P$B
T=BB# 6 &VUWKMXYYZ8:=
"
4)B
''*H[9*E1
B
$+,+
B &

?
49*,6@

=:B 

=&\"
4!*,6]5#$5
$6^\


_`=a=7+H=bU
cOb*,
=d6#%'

7feY6W Pg

:=C;

+H=:B6h=&>Ci 5+

$6*<;

*
1 *E1jOHk%/2lO1$N[m
L
cn+
B ?K*
BT&  
:=
496N2
c39*E'*E1(& ; *
B>=&
"
$#$o57B*,+

6*.-pq:=[9*
6

=:BC9*D;*
9*
6w*0xFE&$*
=%Iy&$#K*01


rB = ?st
#u]&*,6K#%59*<;
w= "
46O=7*
&v5 9*

&z7&$*E1

{
q v"
$#%&
dq

41=*.-|=9*



=7&v ?[
49*,6O

f
 
::N

')7'o K6t
72:=  &

_4=%l/=}K# +
}E~ 7:=:& }[}KF,6+H='

_$~JF
^*MB

?
49*,6O

*,6 *0 ;
$+<; &

*E

 
49*,6O=:BC9*D;*
s$Ic=&*H*,6#$=+E+
1  &=:1=7*E6OY=:B B# 6&jUW9P##$
e%'u=:=
w 
 
 2==
#
 A`U

=
$#96*
&%`=%[1=NY = 

=7$K*=N*.-|='#& &$*0N+0*,N Ta=76)"
$#%&n*EL#%+

= a# +%5
$66O66*


7
DkJlO1i 5+

6 *D;N%[

c2+
 B ?9*
B &  
:=
496N
39*E'*E1G& ; *
Bo=&
"
$#$]57B*,+$6*.-p:= 9*
63#%&%B*PB#J'6O[=B6=76o
V1$*<;wK*E6O3
L=
C=76
:=+
26# 6:5*
B*

c

=&:=Ta=76
5
$66O66 *01



+H=# +V
B =&n=7+,6
 m 7~=7 #=% Ng!
n 

 
 

6O=')3"
4=
2*E1

= =1+H=:& 6:*)a=76"
$#%&n6O[=C *E1+,*D;*01*EFE&$*H=#%:=7#
`K*,-p &+<rR*H
$#

:=C; *E1=7 o5'*,66 *M


#%&   ==7+,6*
& 7:9*Hs

"
4 =
$# [m
 = 96W

`B
'o5+
 9*

3
2*E ;6@9*M1=K*M
NoB7:=%1 T6: 4a=76Q*,+M &GC"
4
u
$#
7+
 = &VUC?
5
$+,*H[=3Ua=:1$*E6@?[=)
cT

:r=&S= 
-::3 Of 61::-

-:: 4::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

H9) cH[[7,: 7!a7!


% ($[ 447E
$$[c 
%9 nYE@?9
Tc
$ %`E /"4%
O

uS: OW9J$%u(

`%[ c2 J 
[ (:$M

:CS$JO:3 C"7b EODJW9<P7EO: a7R $E:

7^
 $9H:"4nE)`  9R% O$7:9< SW90r::
$,7:%[% SqW )cW
u7)S::%%H[S:a7
%:MVx[OjO?wExLj O 7Ef,E`4^WKP9,::
RH[[7,: a7!7%$E:LP/M 7
 S$9H:"40
4  C 9oW9PRH[[7a7v$,7:%[% d7qW9PRM:: !
a7

7PC:

  9E

W9P$<!

L7



C7

:7,M



E


%
,

"4

: O

 h7h[4

7@7H:u$T 
)o7:7Dc74:   W9%u
`  )Eo,  [u ,R C" W$% OOEO$
zC%9E

%$%!7:9 (7:%[%"4f[" % ^ 9
 /P

/ C:3H(/ w73P L% ` 9

(O / S78c 
Ca7!

 E @v



: $H9M:7  J AC9M

:%O

p

 



7A 
$<%O[7 {

 0:C 8C"?n7)(JG [`n% 8C9MVp37n!C

a7{7,O [7!b:7EOw: O

WKP7$A%u

`%[%

7M 
` u: 
C: 2%$%,Hs)H7E!?9H7,
-::4 Of 61::-

-:: 5::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

nEx4 avJx
9 J$9
:7C:E zw) f7


7

H 

E:C

$, H


dE O9 9M

7

o H7E::n
 :7 7QC:7E7`7
47J[a9R
 
bE O99
b7!"W9$#%%"7$P[[[
& s4 [ [%s'(`!)*::Gc oT 9
T4 +
"4

-,/$(
C7:L
.Y0/ P
1
  "WK%"c$32m! 74LE$7
65&972m-829!%:a,;&7s4 [ [%s'(!<)::`:

O7C9M

"4

J$ 9
c

:  

 9Oc

"4




:
" 

% ,::!
V%  9
 =!.>?@ A2 >.@B;>?@C5D>.@BEBF]%HGC:IH
 9
c?/V
4$JKL2 4L%%Y 9
cNMO>P@QA>RES>T!)
4U+2
'!)H2 971$/0L(*GVY%[7W2%)$BH )
YEO99
 7;j
2XY [Z EC{u\[::hE ] 

7^`_0

Y#KE:

G:$T$s(
:
M an 4 V
"49)*b%A
T 3
cM X8&`,EW#Y%)%9dH x
S0 O99
cVQH?"WKe2.&O]
`9EE

4
7:9f


g9
:
M ][Jh%2 E@[:

G


JE 9

i   )7:u
S0$H7eGjblkZGjFYE.k cm:$Zr:7ACE]

  [j
 Dfu K

Ec7InHe"W9oc7O? p#Y%)%rq:Cs29Gj
YHIG
-,x
x7
H



E @9tKM
::

4[:

g9
:

9A7

O7C9M

u@E!

"4

7
E H9H9EC

"R wv47E

K00:

J  $0C$z% 3C9M /=> j

yJK^2 !7EO!  zk{

%u1|}(4% O~
-::5 Of 61::-

-:: 6::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

$\

C
%]CCB

N:]~
C

H
!!^+

V

jRY\C

]!B0:r!!C ]
\]]!]<T ]z]zw
yjR te:BBs]!B

t
BBBC!C CB
!NBc<
+:C!:] C] C:]BC%]
t!CB
CB

 \ ND

]-

K!Y:\C B7CNH:

\ -t<B]B

!-



a \C

\HC!B
C? C^<

\
\\B\

m

]B

!:B~P:+C
%+C0B
B!s
N
;\-B -!{\
$

CB
+rC\
]s:0]BuT*. I!!C<Ts]CNm!]IK]!0B\
C4r00:0sC<
6K:<T!:B
<
y<\CB

]

!!CB\C
%ZHTCB C

D !
8!~0+uh
!B

mC07m~B

4 -Nh+H< C$DRB\1{ 8!~BL% B~+6

$\ 0

]Cs]!!$ B]B

@C%BBB
7CzK]C!{m

K]!0
BB\u
6r00:jBC%@
BB
*Hcs]!!m B]Bp
B!!@
s

! -t<B

y

K]0
C+

H
!!

B

X teTs]B

<B \B1 $DRj*jY- mB{
H C
TssC
!B

C!N+ D1C1+OB<th]YCD ! -BC
\C- mB H C`DR3m%a
j~]:<\
h !Nt!@

$?<
WC!]H:HhpBC

h<C
\NW

7B
0!

C0s CcK]0tC!BB B!!:B]L
1B]!C]B*:0H]
 

K]
!-B dBW
4
`K:BBB!YLC`C0sKC
1-H]!\
-::6 Of 61::-

-:: 7::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

C!!C7D:]H:H~
8\BC
KHC7B
!NBC!R B

sC9!04H!-

*]0BC
]sTsC+:B]

B!\C

C
!B`TsC!\C4+:]B

K]
!-B

HC!!7 

!]
KRC


!B

?C
BC

<B \ \

Ts

C:TCBHC!!s-C

C!]!B

K]0BCCtCB!]

]B0

N]

K!Y:\C

C~zC



C!]! \ N`

C0

]
N\~ 

H]

Bs:
s:
C$:
-!

@ TsC^B0H
TsC
^
!BC!R B7+^C C!L C0;
]

]B

Ts

BB0!::

BH!:\

B

C!:

H]

N
!{

B:B  C`0\N!]
C
CtC\
1]CN\~ tCC1?C

Y

C`K]0BC
-\NCB000lrC< t0B
B]!R
\ !C0BdC


K]C!:

B0
CB
wCB B-N]
C]CN\~ tC

K]0BCCt?C
BN
BLH!
Hh

K]
C!]B

N{B]~
u

?
CB
CC\ \C H -t;?C
BCB!
C:!C0B+N t

CjlTs

\Cj
CC
YC0BdC:]m]H:
N8CuB!


!B0]C--N

!]0
B

CwC

t!CB

wC

!<TCB

?
CB
7\.RH:m*{!
B 9-`
B
NH]I
Cs:B]$CI]CtNC 90:
!-B+ jBKC!! 
C7BC!B
.H:;
CCYB0

-::7 Of 61::-

-:: 8::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

@Cs
 @!
 ]H 
s
 @ ! "$#%
&'&()*
+],.-/&01(23&!4236578
9C:+/&;23&/&<=235>&/?@BACDC3FE
BG,~@
/ H*JI3KL#MA!$ECG323&!N23O&F'?PBACRQ+C3FE
GBG,h
 / H
S5T8U
+],.-R1V23&!W
FAV23U839C:MBAC
23&/F&MU
FAX235Y
AFZJZ[9C\-*JAC
]2^HBAR!::BAG5)8
Q6/,_-*J$ G,~Z/`TS5$QabAZJZ?FZ/?c9CdZJH9Zt^10B/C:S

$es
 @!fIgh8 ::!G 

s
  =!iIg  Jj -ka$lm1 :,.,.H\+TFBF
-GJA9GZn9:l.::o@ JI
#RAH?E
G[2!HBA/@)T2!HBAFTQ6 'H
ST:
-G]b1%:,.,.H
:l WBACm+TFBF -/
A9Zt 9:l 
  @!<)

 -]FR1pFE
+
2mF5O9:lp,~:G]>G/,./Zqr81B8
BAC(AG2stG6',0'FZr8+BF5QaBAC(ru+FZC3FE
GBG,hv)
:l +
] C
FE
BG,~+S AZJZ 9C -*JAC
 2^HBA
Q6/,_-*J$ G,~Yr)UZJ`T:S5)P2!HBAM/,_-*J$ G,~FPZFHBACG
!F$/- w2^AFAR,4lx
]\1X]Nl
:5)QaF\AFZ/Z
ZJ$y9CdZ/H9GZz1nB/
C

|{ s
 @B ]H 

s
 @Bb 
jZJZt::/F&@GB,.:5!:1CF2!oBA=']o c
23&/F&(23
&GF/G78BAC0C
FE
BG,~T / H*JI*#MA!$ECG

ZJZ
: ,h5},. 8 ,.,.oo  ) BA
+2!J
-*]-:F}1 23&! 23W2^HBA BA
/]o FHBACG
23&/F&~8X9CF/F& -*]F-G]
;123&!23&F'?@BAC
Q+C3FE
GBG,h  / H
S5 AZJZ 9C -GJAC

2!HBA
Q6/,_-*J$ G,~sr8ZJ`T:S85/,_-*J$ G,~FHBA

!F$/- Vr8]B, G7xBB
/&]hl

53Qa
AZJZ7ZJ$y9
dZJH9Zz10B/C:S

Ns
 ?^)ZH
2OBGZfg`EHt!Q)]$ECoSFgv::!G 

-::8 Of 61::-

-:: 9::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

8

? H
OB P:GH )+$Fo  :
/
Gdr8+J
/yB*cr)[1Gu+)6/7)
: J8RG$FG
+F/?FwBFr8^BFB$hz
..H+/F"V1Gu+8J?
!
FJ\GJGoX^HB/_*6/?G4r)]1G
^FNJ)Gq
(BBFbFcG^GoN4

1(1@/_*J$ Gd8r8vJ`rF=J:J?_/Ho
1nB'F

B8
 (i)H
OBGf`H!)1$oFv+:GG

8

i H
OB P:GH )+$Fo  :
/
GdGr8*
G
ka$n1FkJ*RG$F
1F8

+1F_V1s
_0o3)nFFG::1F
3:
PFGJ$FV8
/FH1F80:F!/ 1
FJJo+:1FhB"
_.J
: BO
1G18J?:8:%:P*++
+)k=1wB=
..J

o

1Gu+8J? :
FJ 
*Jo
!HB
/_*J$ Gdr)R1B ^GoMJjF]oF
=B
BFX:6V^zo
11p/_*J$ Gd^r8JHr
bJ?F/?cdJHz1nB/F

?
B8
 4
)H
OBGf`H!)1$oFv+:GG

8

H
OB P:GH )+$Fo  :
/
Gd%r8WF/F 4_GwX1Gu+)6/7X 8
81
o JMU: G6$ ^ J 4_GV
1G18J?\GF 8h 1Gu+8J?h8+GG
o ^F /
/:F`
/ 1G18J?
:hJM *Jo !HB
/_*J$ Gd r8 1B
^F > 
1 1
/_*J$ Gdr8 JH1F?FbJ7J$cdJHoz10B/F

iB8
 (
tG
Ft*?a
F3P:)1:
F*GGu
8
 WGo
FVt?+
X z JGdzr8
4:/F8h
$F:
/ Go
FF;*GG\
GoFo
F1*0?+
J[U:F$ (^w4?.8[
!'
 ' J 
$F:
o 8;J
u1V:
Go
F
?+: 8s
FHR::1
G)k Go
F
-::9 Of 61::-

-:: 10::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

?+:FGG)
F>F1F0?+
z!1bF_6/?!1

y1:F$ .
G
GoFo nB
t0J_G84:/Fo*)8GGF
TbHv/GJ(
$F:
o ()YFGGvJ4
u1r88
H
OBG
FF/JoF
F4(B
)d4G_H
83"o3/W/NF
?F
: R8
FGGU/%
u1r8q
H
OBG$
:
FnJ
G
:z'BF<:?=:;Go
FD
?+

^HB/_*J$ Gddr8.1B ^F4
1(1(1F0F
:
FJ:J$%0JHo
10B/F
O' BF :F$  : 
FH::1
G8
Go
F

?+

!HB
oG)+
'.6J$ 4r8</`rF8^HB 6G81G
'.6J$ 4tr8Yy1G;zo=4$1FF
1.1FF:?bJ?F/?cdJHz1nB/F

i B8
 | B.8+FoG63:)+:F
Hnr8)
+FF6 _Y*1FGJ
o >8BFd:
:1Fo
?FG+

P+4F'c/:c1:%/=/ Hyr8FoGR:

/
BnGoG0r8G^o4F!/7
FJ

F
01c/y
!GGFM:h>/\Go H
6 ^BF]:HoR^BF
F/oGJ7%J

F
=1]/r8q/bFR?aw'N/H
8G:_+GBG+F
:d
u+$FFB*1FGJ
o 0B/]:n8.d:
81GG>G BG1*GG8
1
:o FF /


DRBJN8\
F;81GG%r8w^o F

HBon/
4 />*+G:yGB/3P:
J%J
w!HBX/_*6/?G4Yr8Y1G^o
4$d1FF010`!F:6y
J?J$ydJoGoz1nB/FG
;`Xp1G+
~/1F m/DG6

1
FHG$ 18)
6$
 + [$
 (
Jn =J
_r)+rFH1
G%:XG$ =FBG+:RF/*
B0Fo0B1
 8:F?1(B.?
J71
:o n
BN

o:/Fj+P^:W
FWFo\GF
oc:_/.
GH
o +B8]B B$Fm]BGJ?
:o B
+F
: ~L/7F/bB;?4<d:/m
:
o
1<HGG_BF :8+ u;/1~/ H

GoF
ii 4Gb8B 

F8+ u@/1/ H

-::10 Of 61::-

-:: 11::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

Fi:
 
vi:


20. 

 
F 7!
%&  '


,+
z
 

#"%$
 
 !
)(*$
.-/-0$
 21 (3


&
 56M


8% ,89
:
<+ 

-
( " 4 
7)
!(
9$
;%$
$ !  1.
(
 8 .=
 +

@?
&


0AB8(

)
Co 
Y
.
( 
  !(

>
 ; 3
.

EDF. $-HGI.-/ .=

 = F L= F M

8= 
 M


BGI !KJ .-/- 


" $
ON DF.'MD
 ) (3
PQ/ )+
RTSUP[+ </@
?Q/? o: 



& 3
 H 

$H



G ;V;W$ (H'
 $

(4; - $
 = 'YX  Z
!\ \8R
\ \ 
]ZI^R 
_  /
 2G. 
 $
$
$3C>[$
- .9$9(  J $-8;
J 9$


$
$ 


P 

! a
)


B
  !h 
 
/? 8&'
 ;
$ H; `1$-/-2"
( 3)
9$H
J ( $
-/-
$ (<(




H'o5

 


CH :

:
.=
+
$H;
$';b;
0c''1.
$ (
(
-/-  ( 
 9$ $-d$

3 E
:  /?  o  *
&
3
:!



9$
. 3e 
$
1 
0$'; -
( "<J .
,N $ G@9$ (
H



/
g
^
ml
+ q
:
!
DF9$HC;W$
(33 
3f1
GihjDk$ 
n16op$9('$01
$
C;  (
+r
kw 8st

:
  !

 
 H  

:

C>

C;W$
$ (
$'3! (  $ (q; - $
J
; 3
+

 k :%+

 '


  + 
3! (3'- ".
(
$
'! (321.- 
(u$ (  
$#1. -/-d$
 $
H wvxq23Gn
y &Fzi.

.a
Co68

:
z+ 
;

(
$ $
3; $ 
;%$
$

&
8
=

 @t

:

'o
8
!  1.
( "{DpJ| $0"K'"$
 ;}$  )
C;%3 -5.3
$-/-~"
.

)
Co 


wI?Yw

    +?


P


DF $.-HG-8(k G - "

.-8 9$ N DF3 9$
  
/  2G. 
8= 

P


 

9$



$
$  9$01
(3 $'; 
9$- () (3
PQ/ )+
RS P!?
+ 


3 =k
,

+

$H
.-8
 9$9(!  1.
(
; 
 ; 9$ $.-$

t?


:
  
 /?  o   H+ 
;
2"
.-8 ; 0$
 4 

3e 
$
1  $ (
$
2s8

:
&. .
IQ3  ?
 =
tV
k
$; 
( $ $ $
3;$
D $ (
('$H  $ $3


 =
 F?
JpP
 +,

!


k' 5=

1 -8-d$  $
( -d$
-t
9$- (
-(
;%
(H- 1.' .
; 
-::11 Of 61::-

-:: 12::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

9
.%k2 !{'/ 
nH !.
38
:C '/2K8
:C BC9
Cn.5

 23.d
!.g
/
!
3.3 Hsu9
.%.n E:
!3]!/nu90~3d5
du/2

8
:C }C9
{jr.jr 38.

'd9

r3W]
n I'8.O9'9i'z'HC{!'xB,30'Ozx'<Q8n4/

d)! 'z9'd9'4)
K
!
{99O
9)8'8O r.u 2
0'9p:p!'e!/[p9 ~3d. 3'/8
:%
*s)
.

48d8{8
'/~ dH# 33BIw .u /23
2
OdCVC2.'5Q)C
3
r
C.w!
V'u!K9 QH C3/E8
:C% 5'E!0'
{ K8'9
!
9'EL.TF9HCWE
V8 tu't'9 !wpH399Vp
 3t'9 !
k'C0

F)6t'9 !
/9

F)qp{It92

'9/p]33

)
 p''3sFH%Hp* .
'V9Ep*.8d

F/99p

'uFH%HpH'[.9 .880p/8uQH%H0@p '9d9spt'H

Q/939'QwQ3n)rHW9kIn'9rQH%3kIr%H@p8kB'
I93H'Fb:C 3V! '_x'*r.
38H TdCsHCV'
'bbH''3'H/ `!3C9.n 
3 dw !./'0!wC)C
VpCbF
.d
8 'u)3


3
!VL3399'HF8
!9'H3//
H*93.Hwt'/2
2 3! Q8
:C 'Q Fp
I82E'9'K8'9
! 9'EL9'OF9H%

{C}!
3.89!

'd9 . H'/

323r3)U
n
}!j]8C

8 ..n'
4'.MC.n43
./8
4'60!MdCi/25 tC.,9'%.
'93!. 2. x83
. ! 9'L9'F3C%).'~j0:
C.
).589H)#'3'5.
C! 

%V3H!HC'3n!'

@'H99'H8
!9W'8/d9393.xwt'/ILW.W.3bMk

-::12 Of 61::-

-:: 13::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

3nk%n

tEW:3'H!m9BpH..9
H'

%,0H8B'd9 r3C9.n 33/.*9'9'B'HC)3x ,3* 
T'F8nKsd)!z'qK Hef38q<'
*'!
< !

99<7'/9,93H'wTTH.aC

C.2 3!0r8
: 3
9/p{Cq9
dC<
.F,8'9
!r9'z@9'7F9HCWpC'/
%K*33r3)
{p/8 H%H.<pI890{'
dCOC
.8IC.B/
u3)#B
pCT'H*n!'L3399'3I8
!9p'8/d93

Hd

.8'8'/

rr
gT'V

/2.2

3/

9'%

'

H).

9/2Krk5k''EK'' ).
39E

I//
H3H[H'LH'4 ''89/F8[e w3'


93
 .0H

 /
9H#/252 C. H.d#!9 .32
jfrr
.

K''Q'C.%93qt 3#!
'H)8 C<
9!9zC998'8

2.
'<!.8 !~.7' n 8!9 !#)'~)
'H!8'8
!.n
K
C93'6C{ k9!.u3/{99!.k<2 H)z
C 
B
.0!
O.KdpW:!B
9)8K'8r
V`8.d'
.e)2

'!. 9.

838

.'!

8C

3b89


  `' H9tz! 
3d9.K99.n
8{O3/.T !
q~C


.5 gH33Cqd0.'.'C.
@ike 2 H%3p9'0qr.
8V d !.~ 8
:C g'xC4'3!'
xC.78/d)'9x9
.3n

r~r
.WK''3

9/V'K!

.3# 9 
3d9.!

'/{ 2.
k'F8.<C.Ot9!3]!3'
<'@

.32 rr
.

''k

9/ /2.2
OC9 u/V90au%V3p'FC.B9'3

-::13 Of 61::-

-:: 14::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

 "!$#
&%('*)$!$#$,+-! ./%0#213!4'657!8*9;:</9>=?>@
!
A2BDC 9;EF  !$HGI1KJ?=?E L@ !M4># )2N'"!O>#$># )P>#

Q C8CRF
5 @ %('.SUTWV)$!$#$FX6@
!$#

!$# A

@ ! A

Y %Z[C

*%

\HC ]@$^*%

Y %?_C8Y8

6@RC

Y %Z#$F /)Z#4[CO#
K%OV`V6:<# A?FaY8%Z/C YD*C Ab6@c'*%?:R)0@b6@RCd@
! ef!O !aYR@ !O#4#RC ?eg@$/YO@aeh!RF

*%Ui Cj:4FC8Ak*%lY8!<'N'mk%Z: AZFR';:<n *C8Ak!$# Al*C4'N'"%3';>F7o! Y8.M4 ./CRFp>#rq3!OF @<s'
t !O/Cm4u<13Cs!R>FX%v'*CXMRC8!O/C Aw6@
!8Z6@RCx'*C Y8%OM C4'*C8Ad@
! ef!O !y[%Z# Cmyef!OFzY %?_C8Y8*C A
i8m@$>{V|'"%0}%Z#RCy@
! ef!O ![%Zn C4'~! *%('(! `:<F0"!O#RA?SXTA$!<';F
@x3!
)$!4'.SO\HCR>@$D!$# A
ef!OF*%li CA4CRMRC4'"C A*%l';u,`@ C4'qK@
!$#$Sh\FXN'./Y8g%0!$# A4C4'%OV1KJ?=?E&%OV
qF
@
ef!<'!4'*C8!d]#=qP!$# A6@
!8! W!$i %?: n4

@ Caeh!RFx)<%?># )*%P\(!<'*)$!$@

,+-!$s:RA<A?>#*%j'*C8Y CRMRC!Y %Z#$F /)Z#4[CO#
%$VCD4n$/%?F MRCvV|'*%Z

!$# %$6@ C4'z1J?=cE

%Zn C4'"! "%3's@
!DM4># )jY8%<A4C# !O[Ck13!<'"%4%0#$Sh'*CRF /A4CO#
%$Va(!$# )?/! A<C F
@$u1HC!OF%

A?FYR/%?FC A6@
! Z6@ CY %Z#4F8/)0#4[CR#
`%OVCD4n$/%?F MRCeh!RFs*%vi C:<FXC A*%!$57C!$#
E3\G;>nc'*%RM4FC8A}CD$n4/%?F MRCA4CM$/Y C8L>#j%('"A<C$'*%lY8!<'I'm%Z: CD4n$/%?F /%0#k]#
\HC ]@$u E t >#
!Dms$m !
)?<nc'*COn
!<'"C Ay6@ Cw'.:R4$!!$# AxFCR# ` Z6@c'*%?:R)Z@1H Q :4FX"!O
T@4! AwV%3''"C )?FXN'"! ;_%Z#a%$VH6@ CaY8!OFXCxOE Q u T&f0!O#NC8CM!
A$!DMb@
!
Ax!O'*CD!
ARm
'*CD!
YO@ C A

6@RC

F
n %$

!$# A

Y8%0# A?:RY8*C A

6@ C

V6:?'"6@ C4'

>#
*C4'N'"%<)$! *C8A!
Y8YR:4FC A'.uh%Z@ AZuTC CO#j!$#$o

>#8MRCRFX./)$! ./%Z#$u

13C

qK@
!O/A}eg@ %z!
A4Cr@$>F

A?FYR/%?F :?'*C{FX~! *CO[CR#
.uo1HC{ef!OF!<'I'*CRFX"C Ar!$# A@$F{n C4';F%Z# !RFC8!4'*YO@lef!OF

Y %Z# A?:OYD*C A?uX3@ CO#[6@ CynR%?/Y Cz!O/%Z# )e/6@! Y YR:4FC8Ax'.uh%Z@ AZuTC CO#[!$#$$
qK@
!O/AY8!O[C*%6@RCv<%?_Y8Cx0"! ./%Z#`nRC8YR !O<CRu(@ CxY8!RFCvnc'*%Zn C4'"mef!OF
A4COn %?F  *C A]#6@ C2f!O>5 @
!$#
!Oup(@RCR#4S(6@ Cn %?_Y8Cd*CD!$
'.uh%Z@ A?uTh[C CR#l!$#$

!O/%0# )e 6@!
Y YR:4FXC A

q@
!O_A^'*C8!
YR@ C A# C8!4'\3!<'")4!O@! 3!$ic'.[)$! "CRS

,+-!$s:RA<A?>#b! W!$i %?: Wn4uK9n !RF FC$'.Fdi8mdehC4'*Cb!OF 5XC Av*%I%?]#i$: 6@RCXm

-::14 Of 61::-

-:: 15::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

4 R> $ p/D*?4>R4O$4] 2D
R4R$ g 6 ? g?R/? > 6 R

$[ g$ 
43"R XR X 6 Z ?fOX.> y.>R0$I a`<<4 4
4O$/O 6RX~8"`<"Z< 3$c. $ * 8<`,-$R4?]3<"4O4 WOR?
 b4^Z R$.ZgR

ZRd P]$./Z f
$ ORZR$/ O
?/?Z[8""
O }

kZ}$j/D*y
?4/<$8O[}RD<

3O?;$ *k 8<

,-$sR<?>

$${

(<*$$

/4O
. 6/8$>

OR

<X

;hZ ?[ R

O(<*4Z$ 4>$X"OR8
<X

K
O/

(<*4ZfO

$4c*O RR4 8(O><4$ pf3IO 44(Oc"8h8.`>
$

$

4(*R8h4*?>XR/ZX

8**4] ?4

.R ~6Z3O4$

34*4Z2ZOz;hZ ?W4;O4?>* /<R
f$/ <P3"N"$$RZ4 RX

<?XH(644xc`4/RZ~h?_Z$Z3R-4.ZXN;_D`>
.c3$ ?
4R
$O
D<*OO6
$ p

O;O ~6?zHO4Oj

(<*4Z$02g$_Rj

` (".HO8RfO. "*R4W fOv?< 6
8g g Z
"O> g$ * ?>$/

?6s?*RZ??W$ ./ O$ "v>vv$><b8Z/??* ?
6RR b$ c*$g
?/?Z" yZ$
O8xD4$/? Rz *4;/R?

OX8>y0 oN"$$

<"O
3_4OD]
$/O
6RR 80 88O/

< 446

$]48Z/??*

? 6 O ^80
"R]$>

g$/* ?>4/vsZ.?*RZ??OR;_8vO$ "O?( v4$/Z8 x0vhR/0$>

fO?< *x OX <7Z8D<hx7$$/RO`z3~$8
O$*"$7O
? >U"h
Ow4 O7./ Z
"O> 4.z<67 R}Kk$ ^($ ^6R
*RO>$>R

4$/Z8

X

X?

hR

XO
]

XO[

" RR4"

?
6RR j"O4R$>jg4 *lR/$6l$ 44 $ $}hRlc"O
<* U$

46X rO{KZ[4"0

6 }4
Rp ""
R j8O Z}g$_R} Z
afO

-::15 Of 61::-

-:: 16::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

. "*OZ6R[|"0
3 /<OZ6 

 Z s.>< 4

oO 


8/?0O
 $
P/
8N;

O0g$
O "!$#%Rz;/""O&OR"hl 0'
/
DN.
x48"0
*(;bOf ()R4*
/?* + , 4f>dg$ *-
.4"*Z/$ Z
 O
R( 10(2
~*4./RvO43H4> 5h/&
Z
6/ j O . 66 7c 44
 <8O
.s]x6 9:, 4;0, < =
X8H$`6Rw

>OR[?
/$6R oh4*
*.
R4" s|*{6 @ Z8R8 /0sO:

48-BADC ~8?FE3O,$HGI!J<*4Z A
K (6 k6L, /? )RM *$.O{R10 N$ O
Z 4"*8

> *P ,($ ,RA

K
.
4 HQADC ~8ZJEHO,O9GR!F4*40zOS<I*R7* A  .
8./0$%T U"V  K
D
$ <WXT<Y K
8h4"9 <48AZ(R> >
*6 O/0/6dR$6w6 [

.
4
 4.X0$/$ 6 7
.Oc* 4"\
. [v*P6RO"6
O6   
R^](A
_ ?.>6 @ O 4O
`sOc6 4
6O
<~?OZ6 4
.Rac* 4"\(A/A<"
R4"




/?r



Z bO>4>

/$6 R

 ? R8 /ZdOd

.
4 &QADhZ A K [ R-efO4$G

*
 4*

|"c

6R

gK
/h$ $6 4i
.R

c* 4"\

R8O ?6
f>d6 jk8
$
b$ml<>

 + ./Z   .
RJ](
*.,4*?>

g4
O

*.ZX*$* A K ]l

Yn2E

3HADW`oqprss


< <$
D._Z

T,outvpbT


nDl=]

%R

 $xwI `Mg^=<y$ 6z 6R{ $.

*{6 {


4X

hZ A K [8Ofef$$?(f*8+R]$>6 hZR g$|

R O*
 4*
|*

$} ? R8 /Zg$

O~V LADleWvsXp K

*g$|
RP* )vO}?)RO.

6 ~

48r>z* 
$. O[$
O6 N+$$.8._ZO 
4.  n
EFwNRR4$

 Oc+8%8>

!`] ?N$
4

g$|
R

V $'le-'WvsXp;Ag

s,U A|s W`Ass3 466R


4X R$.Z$ah4*hc"<
}8**448".>

6R

[8Z
.

`L
s]
./Z

80 
8.>

D(*

-::16 Of 61::-

Z
$6

8?~QA

-:: 17::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

, (|6Q@rJd 6k<? 6,(|. i 8[
.,`},B`,

h4{.}c x` ^:=$
6, ~( D7Xr

 9a8.,8+QF,+.. Q 8a8
,  Q`

,+ RF
P.N
6F>$=,

$.Q

| `


.JF$:,
@ 8> 8[
.,`f Q`[6 4H

>+8

^d(= d|., ,`

% 8{8
.,`
:,h6rJ[89.c.,8/+ 8H , (.QHrJ`.j
6,(h( rJS 8<
, {,Q` <  
( .-.a84 8H+Q`J .6,Q  8
,  Q`
+ u;( =F
,D+*.<k
..J$=,
H$Q}8`6=/
Q|^,
;( Q.@@, @/d:a;( =B

.JH$=,



8 8
.,`

M
,`.

,Q` .4M

z

+8=^..((,c .c., F
 B1^,$
4, 

+R| `[ 88
, 

,P:+=I6rJ8

,Q?d+: 
.,`,Q c ,+[ 
=S., ,,6

| `:8:-
=+( ,h
,/,i~;,

+
,."*
*d

@ 6 F

 *|.8

,8{ 4 
+c .Q+c

Q&;

 :,, .Q

. F

@.%%8JQ\

d  8,.Q),\

6 

`..Qc D`~B2|M `6Q|~4 ,)$= +.>.mrFm8

:`Q|

 8

8

,`.

,B`,


+

|

D\}8} .Qc}J,,rF:`Q}
.,` B2b8

-::17 Of 61::-

-:: 18::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

= h

F=+=}== `.Q9v ^8-:j6d(

c ^== $,M


D7b
*


(|.rJ8+.
Q84=

.,+?+8`.? 
= "B%cvmf 698

6
m%8JQ %,++.+{8.c.
8JQ

,,"J,,= .,  "!# (4 D%$q\%

, '&JOu 
Mf8.,+P6 
(O Q)
+*@
+P

 QO
+,,*a-% 
/.Q0+1
.Q2j,.
JQ*4Q3I,,
 |

(h.`
( 
.. 43
3,.Q%%,+6 56"Q %7 *

FQ8


J
Q 8

9+8

=

%.+

.)

 ,,*

:  ,8,
<;k)*=?>A@*BDCE;+*F@
, 
G*H7

 I,,O MJb
D<JX\%

+K
+
8L:+ Q8`
M&,)`z

8)
(k.N&F

,,=4
QO+)
=.j }8f. %:+P,bO+,.-8Q+



Rh=Q 8< R:+)S-8%:`QQ8 T&F
QUU ~ D!x\K*N>;D( D!xVCE*^(`
 +4
 m
, 

"Q%)%4}f * 
)
(( 2< W N*$=+ m4 
.,`
"Q%)%4f $ 
)
(j(- D<X\K*X Q`
)
c`.,}4h

.,`Y"Q% m9f $


)
(< D<XVCE*`[Z-4-

8j.,+\

)]&~

,,^
"37
.,`"Q% m
f

;
(- D7 \K*`[Z}44ji8j+ <=+Q
f
-::18 Of 61::-

-:: 19::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

_"``abcdfehgWij)a1kmlnaGgopc)qrB_ st

uX_Tgwvvxszy+b|{ } i~)<VEB_TggwcbkQrc)rvzv)l

_"``abcdehgWija1kmlnaGgoc)qr_ st uX_Tgwvvxs<y+b{ })i~)Q{_ s1d1cgWbvxs"_)GbcM_Tgw`)q

rcrvOv)lp_"``1aTbcdehg,ija1kmlnaxgoc)qr_ s<t u_Tg-vvPsy+b { } i~)<Vbykwc _)sOy+b
{ } i~)<V

ba c)rcs"k-_Tg

dGy+b` vGbaGgwc

bk-_kwcrc)s"k

v l

_"``abcd

ehg,ieKvxq1dGi(Krccs4_ s y#t Aq"_)+y d6y+b5{ })i~)QWdGy8b` vxbaGgwcbk-_kwcrc)s"kBv)l

_"``abcdehgWija1kmlnaGgoc)qr_ s<t u_gwvvxs<y+b { } i~)<VuEi)q1c<gwc c"_ s"kc)s"kgWyc1b
y8sknqcgwcGy+bkwc gs aTr1cgHv)lknq1ceD_q"_ s"_|eKvxq"_Tgg-_Tgq1_c5_)+bv1ccs
gwvcdGiq1c s y8sc D_"dGb c_`)q `vxs"k-_)y8s ys1

 sv kwc1b v)l oEbi'

dc)s1vxry8s"_k,y vPsSgwc`v)1cgwcdYlVgwvxr_``abcdehg,ieKvxq1dGi(Krccs<_)syt Aq"_)+y d

q"_McR1ccsgwvcdR_)b\{ })i~`vG8 c`Mk,y(c(\_ s1d+ac4`vG vxaGgB1vG(1knq1c)s1cS_b
{ } i~Ti TKvby+1cg`vGvGaGg?dckwvxs"_kwvXg,b_Tgwcgwvcd_)b{ } i~x`vG+ c`k,y(c1
knq1cRk,y8ry8s1dTcy `c5y+b{ } i~)^b_ r cbv lknq1ccM} vGby(cgwc`vcg-cdLlVgwvxr
_"``abcdehg,ijaklnaxgoc)qr_ s tfu_Tg-vvPsy+b{ } i~i
i'Xq1c_"``abcd c g,bvxs bq"_M1c cdcy dc)s1`cy8sknq1cygQdcMl'c)s1`cdc)1vxby8s
knq1cgwc1ysQknq"_kknq1cKcg-cdck-_ys1cdy++c _)+_ s1dknqc1yg_ggwc1bk^y+bb"q1vs_kwc g
knq"_ sBknq1cyg_"`k,a1_)d _kwchv)lT_Tgg-cbk_ s1dknq1_kTknq1c_Tgwcy8ss1vT`c)s"k,i
j
o o{ {o{{ ~j K {
 i'Xq1c`vGas bcl'vXgQknqc/_"``1aTbcd c g,bvxs bq"_"d _gwGacdknq"_kknq1c|_)+ ccd
gwc`vcg-cdcM} vGby(cRr_kwc g,y_)AD_)bv lgwv s4`vG vGaxgW_)bS1cg^knq1c4bcy[aGgwc
-::19 Of 61::-

-:: 20::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

G? ))Q1m-)8815w"hW)1mnGp)B L T-Tx

8 =n"AO-)1X-,X )<L"1 p))- wx GGX 1 1)O
)-TGLnRGG-Bx1 5\x + 1RwLn1Xw
wO1M )I)- wI1+ +"8GGG,X1BG+w" 1
n1fx GG58G -n"4n ) ") 1) "w x "
1,P 
n81n"n11+GwH)Q1-- 81w"hW1mnGp)B Q
wx )<V "1 n1FG Gxx)n18 --OM G(
)<G- + On1S"A-)1X-,N ))Qm"1 ?))- wG xG
1 1)nw-1)  A )LwG|8n1GG-Fx
1 8Ox + )wn1Xw w X )'GTw
1h)- w#+ 88GGG,

26.

 


h L



243658795;:=<>

<GFBH

>

HGd

HGdedXf

OHY]

<

]B<G3lk5m5ini]

>

<

]BH

P8>|P

I^A

<
D

_WIra

<.]

PiF
?

Ir?

O
_

F
c

>
c

<<.F

>
_&D0

3HO
D

PWHo3
?

>yFB<

<
_&D

-::20 Of 61::-

]
_WILC
<

d^Ho3

]>

O
A

O
A
<

_&DC`}GAx

<15
A.a

CI

a!A
O

3^O<*P
A

Ho3
_&D

3<

O1579PmP
I

<uF

<

O
A1CI6_

Ir?

D`_WIR}GAx

<G3<

FGP

]
_&Dt_

<
I

O
A

3s5
c

HGd

]
_

P
_WA

A1CsA

OHY]

O
_

P%P
DJA`CBa!A

<G3

A1C

OHgPWH

]1<

ajAI

<G3^<f

Ir?

CI
<

<
_ih

<
D

I
~GP c

IeI

Ir?

HY]B<

<

O
A

F
D

I6_

FB<G3

<

}GAx

3^<

HGfq]

Iua

&'(
*),+.-/10

I^A*_

Ip_WI$CB?

?BAx



3^<.F1Ho3

]BHT5vZw5

z{HgP c

OHgPWH

%

3O<*PRQSHT59UWVYX[ZU\OHY]

DJIK?BAIL0NM

?G_WI

IeA*_

5  

 !"$#

I6_WI



<

0@?BA*CED
bTc



_&D
P

_&DC

<
_ih

<<.Ft~GP c

<

-:: 21::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

gWgemWrGBGBG['yGBe*mgBG^.B^ GG.jYGmy

GWKe.1.W1rB^1^orBG!R1BY1T1e B

=%G1e%i!eGK*YiG.BG^*YWm&gB1.%WG

.GW

e1e

GeGW^

gWgr

T&

igWg6yB

Bys.B.

^o

TWeG6WYi^11BG.B.1GGYgT1W\R1B1B

.

Be*mN1e

rBugWgG.GWR1GeGW^urB

T1.B6WvGGGW9*.Bg1e.Y^.W
pqY1e' *G1 \

Bo. BG^T81YGiGWYGyrB.GW1$Y*Wo%qqY1pe

*G1TrBTrB.Bo^B1B.y.BG^B!YrBmGe.BG

rB&@

27.

.9*rrBG\ B.iB ieGKG\rBoLGGGe *
Gw& G

qBG^*iBB*'G.BT KBLBG^
|B.B.BGN.1.1GG

B6G\ GWT 81i*G TWeG6WY.Y1G^%BT iGmmWvG

.B.1GjGSgWg{i*rBG^p%!.$ TWeG6WYiKB GWT 811

^eG B.iB6WY

GrB

GGW1!^gy1

rBjY rKj

y^*.BpG9=G=B1 EG&g GWT 811S.!YGmy

rB

GWK^e.1

*&To.GWER1By@YBe*iGi1rBG=tgW*8G1qWR1

B

Wr

.!oG%

GWK^^

.1

*&1

rB

.B.W*

^ 6WY1irG%p1KBG^
BT iGmmG\.B.1GG\gWg\G

y.e.B 1v

T&

GeKiB

-::21 Of 61::-

rB

BG.Be G

=G=

-:: 22::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

.!oG%

*&^gy1BG .Be
G .!

GWK^^.1rBG

B{ 1B WgS !" 

 

^e

G^

Wg)* 

54

WK

oK

.!oG%

%$e!&B

GWe

+m,-m/.T&102''3.jYGmy

eG

  

B<*& 

.B

!

!6B7
 ,G'mW8$

rBG^


#@!YGmy

*&

!

GWK^e

.1

9.B.
G

=^e*iB8$rBYBG^6>*WGWg 

*&

G^

Wg:;3W

&?Y!

Wr

*&G54B 

G.BG^'($

@  = .54Gi

GWKe.1

Wr

!BgGYBirB=WAAAB1.4.!C4BG3C.BT^' 
 

7Wg

B

&DY!'orBA1B1ry EAe.G54B |yB6'grB

@FGY1T e  BH JI.!YGmy

.WBKB1'

> 
6WYLABRi&Wr>NM

.B. 

K$ 

GWKe.*|

OW6>PG1Q3R.B

Wr

D^e*iB8$|A1g19rB&.B.
G'LWgRrBC4W7 (B1EF

Wr

AB!iSW -W6>TM

W7 UB
0P0G3GBe',

Go!

y^ 

VgTgW^eG=^
6WY

rBtrBG

K$

B

W$

*&<G!6Kjep  

Wr!

VgTY

!.

>

G .

.

KX{!
*&

GWe



.

T1

*6WY0Z',[

^

\*]^,_>`ba!c=dAeedf gAh`ijflkVm

`:ng+gKoa/pgAhq
gkisrtZu+`:nd
` `:ngNdv'v>g*wg*pPf g
q
kogflg*p

gCxev>k7c*a(ogyaFcyhk`ze{7f gv(|Gr}~ JVdc*a>q+q
kv>k{fbkina>qAna!c<ki ina>`"gEa`

a!cdv!cKkPhk`e{f gv(|TdAm=m;kVha'{Em

ha>`)fld
`"gna>qAnyaFc<na>`"g+qf%|cK`"dva,h@e{f g

i k1fjmN^*_>`aFcLdNm=a5x`Y{f g kir }~ a>`:ndAm=m;kVha'{Em

-::22 Of 61::-

ha>`)f d
` gdhp<d
qa/p^

-:: 23::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

,>D/

 Y,A"

;AY>V

:
DjlV

:>

K'>A>VH)>OAA*>"V:, )
=>!S K
>*)



A"
EE:>"
)lA>)
"

":/

C>7*(

>A

A>:

>
Y(

:

;7K

W"

Y(A

"17:J *

"1 >
 +;7K
1=V?K   F A

C>7*(>:/OE:!KA
s>LFP1 D7":>>"H
"V
":A
E:,;%9C>7*(
;K

V V,

1@/>Y,

>L''8E>
'(

KNACE*1+"

:7:>@E 
* ?>J!N7":>>1"2/>"

AjA=*>(Y7JF+1 KA*>Y(="@A;Ay:>
Y>V+:A
:C>7*(G*AD 1 1
)%!
l",G
V7>Y>VA
W:>*Vl
Y>V"
"1
Y>Vj AA*>Y>V
A
:>!S l(K*
>VyPE),:'(

7K A

:KY,

Al

DA!

',A=<:>VAs'EAl
"V
"1:2,&K1>A

<,DA'!
ASD:OC>7*(&
  
"1
Y>V&
1
) VH *
:>V*V *  E 7,
)V7>A/A
KV

"
%::>"&7,>) *"

A

))'j
"A=

*7>
Y>V

,
K:P:j*
V=7*>Y>VKAA*>Y(>8  >Y

>Y,

,SW

*Vl


KA=>
A,

:

AA!

>)l
"

>7

A

K

K":
-:

->)lEA
-::23 Of 61::-

'',

E:,

7>A/E)!

H:

*V **Y>V



Y>V

-:: 24::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

"

(Y>AT*EAK*7AK"A!T>7
 1j/AW,y:

AW 1A

A>)l
" 

"

*Vl**+ 

El

>EV *
Y>VA1V

j:,>)
UA



>

:A

>
Y''>8

7,>)
"L



":>

A



K'E''>8

!: )
,

"Y

:lW 1 T?>K'>A''>8y 11 +1lA!N
>="A>>8Z!

>
:R>y)lAAC)AVAK1)Y>VZ!KOK*AN?">LR>
7K

:E
*

*7
:

1lA!N

A

*Vl**

"

A"
:E) 

AA;A"%=lVA

>K

30.

) :-;AY>V*

L,"C
/*7

l,

K

A

:
A
V

'")




A

C >7*?*>Y
Y>VA?! >A
"*Pl
*< A=!K)%

V
:A1
 >' >A1 *"1%y! 1W,
>:N
:
 /+*""
7 # WAE 

$

*>"


:*,

l 
K1

>
R! >" >

A@ %/& ('AA

(
) 7*

*+  ',
G:,E KA-
yC >7*./.G'P!0 >A%*!1
 >zA!
KYAY= +)%,
G":,1
V2E=:
l@KAA*>Y+A @"

""
! >" >C >7*,S # AE&AU

)

C >7*=3T
A E2W4AA

7,
5
) 7Y6b%E "A!
K*

:,7,

V A
:9* : (

! >" >
A

:
2# # 2AA

 *;AA


C7K*G"GC >7*=ZK/$

:/7Y! >" >8

:<
! >@A

>A # >A
ZFy"GAEA-
y:

-::24 Of 61::-

-:: 25::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

?A@@B?"C"DFE%G
H<DI0@KJLG
HNMPOM3DB?%Q

MRDKS-E"DTEU
?1UB?VWE"DJX
?VO0M-Y-?"CJ9@KJWCZ@BI$U[DKS-?]\AJLG
H^M

I@!?_YVWI&MJX
?
M`DKS-E"DFQJ+a!S-Dcb-?JLGZdfegTM"hLikjmlS-?2Q'I!VW?"CnVWEUBopM3C"EVW?'C"E%Y-Dn^U
?
I!nV+H
q

U
?
MnVWD5J#GrEsC%S-E%G
a?

J#GrC"I!VWI!n^UKt`MJ+a!GJ9@uOJLG
a

DKS-?

YvU
?
M3?%G-C"?sI@

?_YVWI&MJX
?
Mj1h#hLi

w
x hLdWD)C"E%Gmb-?yM3??%G2@zUBI)Q
q

DKS-?

E%b-IX
?5UB?
M3?"EU
C%SRE%G
H0Q(E"DB?UKJWEV
I)G5JLG-D?UG-?"D&E
M

?V#VE
MNDKS-?/?3XJ+H?%G-C"?/I@({|]}/DKS-E"D~EQJ_-Dn^U
?/I@({elctFE%QQ(I)GJ#nvQ
GJWDU
E"D?E%G
H

E"C%JWH
q

SJWC%S

Q(E3O

b-?

bvUBI q

GsI)GUB?"C"IX
?UOrC"E%GC%S
E%G
a?

C"I!VWI!n^UE"DDKS-?,DJLQ(?<I@?_
E%QJLG-E"DJWI)G/DII@@
q

SJWD?]O
?V#VWI q

J:M-S%hlS
?UB?J:M

Y-I&M"MJLbJ#V#JWDO4I@cC%S
E%G
a?mI@cC"I!VWI!n^UJLGRC"EM3?ZDS-?UB?0J:ME%GAO>EH&nVWD?U
E"DJWI)G0JLG
DKS-?

?_YVWI&MJX
?
h!gTn
?2DI5DS-?C%S-?%QJWC"EV&UB?"E"C"DJWI)GE
MRJ#GyDKSJ:M(C"E
M3?DS-?UB?ZJ:M

Y-I&M"MJLbJ#V#JWDO

I@

E%QQ(I$GJ:n^Q

GJWDzUBE"D?,E%G
HE"CJ+HS-E3X
?/E<C%S-?%QJWC"EVUB?"EC"DJWI)GJ9@\?%Y-DJLGE

YVWE
M3DJWCzEU
q

C%S-E%G
a?

I@

C"I!VWI!n^U

I@

Mnvb%M3DBE%G-C"?
h

JWDKS]YVWE
M3DJWC1bn
D{|]}mC"I!nV+HNG-IDM3EO
q

lS-?

{elTt

JWDKS>C"?UBDEJLG-DO0E%b-I!n
D

DKS-?2C%S-E%G
a?yI@cC"I!VWI!n^UJ9@cDKS-?y?_YVWI&MJX
?5J:Mm\?%Y-DcJLGmEyM3?EV9?-HYVWE
M3DJWCEU
I$U$EyCVWI&M3?H<M-Y-E"C"?
h-lS
?5Y-I!M"MJLbJ:V#JWDOZI@cE2C%S-E%G
a?ZJLGmC"I!VWI!n^UC"EGG-IDTb-?
UKnVW?H0I!nDJ9@[E%QQ(I)GJ#nvQ
EV:M3ICVW?"EU@zU
I)Q

GJWDU
E"D?mE%G
HNE"CJ+H0EUB?]QJ_-?H

DKS-?UB?%Y-I$U
DI@;{|]}DKS-E"D'Yn^UB?{el

UB?"CIX
?UB?H1bnD[J9DTJ:ME5QJ_-DKn^UB?I@{elTtE%QQ(I)GJ#nvQ
lSJ:MRJ#GH&JWC"E"D?
MDKS-E"DFDKS-?U
?
C"E%Q(I!n-@V9E-a?(DS-?

JWDKS,{elchdWDJ:M
S-E
MG-ID'b-?"?%G

GJWDU
E"D?yE%G
H4E"CJ+H^h

E
MERC"I$G%M3CJWI!nM?A@@BI$U
DbAOyDKS-?yE"C"CnM3?H0DI

?_YVWI&MJX
?Z{elbAOZQJ_JLG
a>JWD q

-::25 Of 61::-

JWDKS

IDKS-?UFMnvb%M3DE%G-C"?
M

-:: 26::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

%
"$%3&
%-

-%

K-B:;L
RK--&"L##9u!%-%
'

"!W!^v^K-B""

Z("Wk"%-)-`")W"RW!
p

k LW&"%--23+ZK-"&K-

""30-K3)%

(KW)>-'"&WZ

K-
""

W&
%
-%L-W&

&9B
%-pW
:3"%-$-W)-$BRK-"vK-2-!#W"&-;c-"W3#9:
--"W#vB%-%AL
WK-%-
L-##+%-"%-3
!+"-

K-&9BB%-"-""%%W&

%%A-

$
!#-uv%3%-"
-
::3

-WK-%A-&"L##9u2K-

-!#W"yc-"W#vzB%L
<K-m""3-1-3)%>-$[K-B0:
%A3+%-"vB)!-)K-B""$pAK-""3--K3)%

K-
:!9B&

%W

-""%rK-%

B"3)$

39KW""W):`--yAK-`""32"`--!#W"'&c-"WA[#
!+

W%->K-

W&

K-

""3

9>"
#

K-3

B

L-"%-p

" 9-
AB$B
W;:W"K-"K-")-B%-W)K-"B%-""!v%3
B
&L
K-`"!W!^^vK-B""
BW&
;:(-%-%W

[N 

 +TfFkvP

)5%
P<-3
>-&3NK-"W&
4+!L
kWvP1k&

-::26 Of 61::-

-:: 27::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

yB"
B>zB)
%(%

-4v9AK)-&"3

"W)mc""3/`%
K^

B)%[W~-
]:3-"%%-&3A,K-v
&3"
W)

WK-
"3
5K-"-B"
BW&
<
<%-L/<
%%--B%-
W%AL
-)
-%-%-LNW"%<-)
-%-,")-""WvK-

L-!
K-%-")-B##
BvBWW
LK-
""3

`K%
K^

%(


)%4W:

s-%

--

%v-B%-/K-"/K-

""35-Z%%#"
;]%RK-ZB"
BZW&
y+%



3]K-"W
5-F:L94"
# -"%-cB$(
0&L
N-"


3W);-"FK-4
""
u1-
m-"%]W%-1v-)yK-y""3



%
5->
%4
""
u
A
""

 

AK-vB&3"W)WK-
"3

%A
KL
R)


3W)%2-3
y-"%2%W

K-""3-s-

#9vL

K-Z
""$
ZBm--K-"&K-'WL



 



`B)
N%
-"-W&
5%W)#

$K-2vB!3"
W)Z:

-m"3-
Z:3--"%<%9>

Nk^4
,
""
B^

39u0$Wv&W"#1WL



 


K-;v9AK-!"3

"W)!K-'W&
+!L

L

 

k^ B)



 


-
""^K-"&"":;W&
+!L

z
)

""3

`K%
K^

v%3%-KW#2A'-

%(%

vB&3"
W)%

-::27 Of 61::-


)

k^
B""


-

-%

vB%


-:: 28::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

!"##$%$'&(*),+-&(*/.0+1)$2&4365*36)879$:3;<
=>@? +BADCFEHG'I'CKJAMLONPEQCFESRHT@UE'CWVXT'YZLONPE[J'ESL\T]PISL\T4COAMI:]JLONPE^L _a`b_a]GcJ'EdUe_fRSE
YgChT` ISRSR@i'AdEHJj5kC ?ml iLnYOiC*8E:Ne`oI:]Qp q8I'CFTeT]:r#LONPEMISRSR@i'AdEPJcsPEeC AdT]:A
NPIdUE
sChISRSL _fRSI@tutvVD]PTLEdU@E:]RSI'ChEHJwL\TDR'CFT(ASAEyxPI:`b_a]PEzLONPEMsChT(AdESR@iL _fT]
{ _fLO]PEASAdEASr|LONPEcsPT,tu_fRSEwT'Y\YO_fRSE'C ASr/I:}PT,iLBLONPE@_6C*ChESRST@UE'CWV%Y~CFT` ISRSR@i'AdEHJ
5kC ?ml iL\YOiC1#E:Ne`oI']cp q8I'CFTeT] ?: Ar#I:]JQ%NPIdUEMRSIHL\EHG'T4CO_fRSI@tutvV
J'E:sPT(AdEHJLONPISL|T]E}'tfISR:oRSTtT,i(CFEHJL _a`b_a]GJ'EdUe_fRSEisT] { N'_fR:N.I:] { T
tfESRSLC_fRT`sPI:]V l LFJ ? 5kq8 { IAE:]GChIdUEHJrL { T AH_utvUE'CRST,tfT,iC
]PT]P\E@tfESRSLgCO_fRJ'ESL\T]PISL\T4COAI:]J YhT,iCsPE:]PR@_utAH_E )8T@UE:]PT G'T,t;J RSE:ttA
}PISL\LFE'CWVP { E'CFE ChESRST@UE'CFEHJ YgCFT` ISRHR@i'AdEHJ 5kC ?ml iL\YOiC #E:Ne`oI'] p
q8I'CFTeT] ? 'xPRSE:sPL8YFT4C`oE'ChE@tvV2G(_vUe_a]GD]PEHG'ISL _vUEAHi:GeG'EAdL _fT]:ALONPISL/I@tut'LONPE
CFESRHT@UE'CO_fEA NPIdUE }PESE:] s'tfI:]PL\EHJ isPT] LNPE ISRSR@i'AdEHJ I:]J ]PT AHiR:N
CFESRHT@UE'CWV { I@A EY\YFESRSLFEHJ AHi@GeG'EAdL _fT]:A NPIyUE }PEHE:] J'E:]'_fEHJ }V LONPE
sCFT,AdESR@iL _fT] { _fLO]PEASAdEA r(LONPEISRSR@i'AdEHJ[NPIyUEYFI@_utfEHJL\T^}C_a]GI:]VLON'_a]G
T]
LONPE[CFESRHT4ChJ[L\TcAPNPT { LONPISL-LONPE
R@tfI@_a` T'Y"LONPEDsChT(AdESR@iL _fT]^_A { ChT]G
I:]JQLNPISL]PT9Eyxes'tfT(AH_vUE9`oISL\E'C_fI@t { IACFESRST@UE'ChEHJ ? &|NPEISRHR@i'AdEHJNPIA
I@tAdT ]PTLD}PESE:] I:}'tfE LFTi'AdLO_YnV T4CDtfTG(_fRSI@tutvV Eyxs'tI:_u] LNPE i]etI { YOiet
sPT(ASAdEASAH_fT] T'YT]PE }'tfISR: RST,tfT,iChEHJ L _a`b_a]G J'EyUe_RHE isPT] { N'_fR:N
.I:] { T4tfESRSLCO_fRT`sPI']V l LFJ ? 95kq/ { IAE:]GChIdUEHJr-L { TAH_utvUE'C
RST,tfT,iCo]PT]P\E@tfESRSLgCO_fRQJ'ESL\T4]PISL\T4C A^I:]J9YhT,iCsPE']PR@_utAH_E)#T@UE']PTG'T,t;J
-::28 Of 61::-

-:: 29::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

S@u1gF 'a
|PhSSOPS(SS @uv'fS:kS,f,hH aba0'defSbP'f:
:HZ4fSSOfP'HFB 9k/ Z:hdH-nBHuv'
S,f,oPP\@fSSgOfQ'S\4PS\4 ^:9h,P'P@uH#@'P',;
S@uOPS\\'W-B'h[FSS@'hHDgF SH@'dH m:\O1#:eo'c
'FePoPS:h@HH:d\:PO:v0OPF(dS@ f:
!"##% 'd
d m:%2| :XPy':P(dPOPS::o,P#'S'fS
Z hSS@'hH gh OP 'fBOe P,SdSHf ' SS@'dH
voS::'" P@u;8fBP@dPH:D':P(dHjwOP
F,dS@ f*fOPSdPS|OPhSS@'hHzPdZ0a'aPoZH
'SP\SS:'#OPb''PbaPS f'SSha(f:@~F:Pd'
|P0d:bB'h:Pu'uS,(FHMP,vOP:PbSPSS@fH
@''
OPfd'4'8@feOPbaPPH'4SS@'dH voS:
:'
P@uf(#f:eP'F:P!OPS-OPwSS@'dHPH[\::M@u4S'h\H:
OP hSS@'FH oPd ';e'' d OPSMB PeeHa'f S@Hv'
'PS:ZF4o'h@vQ(veaPH'S vQH@e'd f'^OPSOPFSH@'W
-::29 Of 61::-

-:: 30::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

P jPS:'f:P\HP9OPSH@'dH: PH:FSH@'WZ
\FSSFH KH@e'd f: Pd PS: ':'fH OP h(dS@ f
*fOPSd OPSS@'dHPdoF@ufHb\zOa:O'aPbFSS4K
\9P' PSP@f@ 'Pjh(dS@ f[h :OPSP
o,PZ' DHwBchSS@'hH |P^SS@'dH P@%@dPe
PS::'f\ 'd W4f(fS@uv e'f@aOP'fBOe,P(SdSHf'
OP oPdgh ' k Z@ oS:
:' P@u;%P@F@ufHM\
PP':O'a2aOPf:'Ob'F,S  baPS fo'|OPh(dS@ f
*fOPSd 40a'Q'F:PSjdf''PSjOPSPO'aaP' baPS a
ZhSS@'FH2gF ' @ufH'H 8P@kh@uH\zPP'OPS#O'
oPdZgF P SP'*2d,hS''baPS o44PS8f,B@a
'oP(SdSHfbaofH'@ o:eP'
|P'h@dMP@fOP'8:SzP(SHa'uuf0'8OPP,ufS0' PS@f@ @u'
gh baOPkSS@'dP2P'Od0'f:P a:k o,P(o';
fS P4MOP'F : de;':PS F,@,P OP FSH4h OP
SS@'dHP' dXP'FH F\H(vP: WPSnZS:jOP
:PhSd 4 'd OfSS fj^PP'cOPXSS@'dHcOP
P,ufSD' /PS@f@ @uZ,e;'f:PBOPc o,P1OP^SS@'dH
SS @uv0PZaePeS:P



 



















"!

#

%'&



(

*)

"

,+



 -



/)

0+

1

|PoFSSOPSSH @uv0: o,P' ofSZ0FSS@'hHgF

,23(

4

 

-::30 Of 61::-

-:: 31::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

566,7 8:9$;

<>=@?<BACD;?FEG99H

IJ5H K

M0C35,NOKP;

C35D8

Q399H

RS=TA,UD9$;

8$7SQ8:VW5H3VKX5,NONYZQ[YV\C39RS=]A^8:96,7DV@KXAH?

E`_0_`a*bcedgf4a^h^i'jlkecm"Eon^jlm*b

p^q ?kIg8

q'r,sDret'ru

qwv

5HD;

C35:UD9x65VW93y Az=KX65,NONFY{; 9R3A^8:9$;|K
HxVC39,K=9:U.KP; 9H369

Q39[}]Az=T9xVC39~_A"7=TV*VC35V8:96 =]9V0K
H$}]Az=G5V@KXAH~B5D8=T969,KFUD9$;VC35V0<>=@?bC39 =

M0C35H=]9D8$KP; 9H3VA }MK83C3VB5 = r

VW9 ==]Az=\K8:VAz=1y 5H K5V@KXAH

h|

r
M

dK8V\=KX6V_AGxG5HD; 9 =A }Q35H.H39$;

f5 =\5VW@7SN(h 9C35$; W9@i8$NX5GKC35D8

8:9H3Vg5

f4ah^i

AR39 =T5VWAz=4lKXVC6AS; 9H35G9|<>=@?M0C35,NOKP;C3AgA7.NP;6A"NONX96VoVC39C355,NX5

GAH39:Y

5H,;

83CD5,NNQ39

y^KFU.K
HDy

KXV}]Az=VC39

5 =\G8

5HD;

5GxG7SH KXV@KXAH

9.R NXA^8$KFUD9D85HD;}\7SHD;8}]Az=SV\C39>VW9 ==TAz=K8:VS56V@KFU.KXV@KX9D8?jHVC39Q35,8$K8lA }SVC K8

K
H$}]Az=G5V@KXAH

566,7 8:9$;

<>=@?<BACD;?FEBG99H

5R.RS=T9C39HD; 9$;KXV\Cm8? p

8:VW5VW9G9H3V566,7 8:9$;
AR39 =T5VWAz= r

AH39

Q NX56

566,7 8:9$;

M0C35,NOKP;

6A"NXA"7=T9$;
sD

5H,;

R39 =8:AH8

<>=@?7DV}7^=m9C.G5H

V@K
GK
HDy

; 9U.K(6$9

<>f*5,89HDy=T5:UD9$;

}]A"7=R39H36,KONg8$K9

C35:UD9

5D8

NX56D85HD;AHVC39Q35D8$K8A }C K8;^K8:6,NXA^8$7^=]9

f5 =]A.AH

B5D85RSRS=]9C39HD; 9$;lKXVC9.R NXA^8$KFUD99,KPy"C K
HDy

_0AGxR35H[Y~$VT;?

; 9VWAH35V]Az=@8

? t

IJ5H.K

}]5,KONX9$;

VWA

7SR3AH
r

lC.K(6 C

5HDA.VC39 =f0a^h^i
q ? qSqwv

bz5H$BA

'y8 r

czNX96V\=KX6

VBA8$KONFUD9 =e6A"NXA"7=eH3AH3W9,NX96V\=\K(6

A,UD9H3A

83C3A

y A"NP;

69,NON8?A.VC

VC35VV\C39:Y

5 =T9

VC39

H3A.VVC39

G9GxQD9 =@8A }V\C39Q35H.H39$;VW9 ==]Az=\K8:VAz=Ty.5H K5VK(AzHf5 =5VW@7.NX
h 9C35$; ]9

-::31 Of 61::-

-:: 32::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

$XD3, :$3.@:3:D3S:D ]$]

D[

$,. D:@XW

3.3

3

S]":,D@XlX3D:D\3~\3:

xD @ \33.3$W ]z\:zT. (z W@.X
3$ ]

$X^e3 Fg^,D:@X{D$. D:@X3Dg3$ D]3

S]":,D@XlX3D:D TJ3"Do3 ,: 
3@X| >@*3 03

D33@T 3$D,OOX3
oeD:.P 3 3

S]":,D@X

lX3D:D

\33.

3

, :3

3 @:

3

xD @ \33.3$W ]z\:zT. (z W@.X
3$ ]

$X

],


S33],D T$

D

S] DWW$

D



S],$S$]g3$"x(]W$De]4[3.\3~$, :$3 :

e3:3:D,:3.X$[:.P 3
3, ]3W|33 \3

3: T

3.3

x3  \3

3.3$

W Tz:zT. (z

\W@S( 3$ W@$X

DD(e3 T[]z]DXS],D$[\3ST^:,D@X3DD,O33$

"S3\33.

3$, :$

3 : ]3

Z3 @ 3

3.3$W ]z\:.zT  @XZ \]@.X
3$ W@$Xx

40:.4x0 ezzPlJ4`0`*egezl*

-::32 Of 61::-

-:: 33::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

43. .\>3>, :${3 @:3:D$S.XW]$3^3: TS X[.OF

W,
3$[3|:W[]4

3, ]D:



*3,X,



0,O,



3oO|

 

33 lJ4xDXW o W

 

3^:$g$
xX \F



 X4D



D

3:DJ,:



B:D




Dg343 T{3@XJW

   

3Z (O3 T

] . T^





3|,OX $OOX ,* W3@X



"!

BD.3 l XxO,^XWD>3^3

XD:DT"SD

$

BD3zX@XD^P{3. \O,XS

 #

3x\3:D 31B ]3S~e]

%& '

.3.Z3 "3z]33

(

D

(,:

TT,

\\X,
$
OX

*)!+-,./! 012,34&567!
8
9 : 9;=<?>@BADCFE
G EIHKJLJ?ANMLOQPRC=<OL>SCTH<VUW%JYXOQ<BZV[\@ON]DA^ZA`_BHKJaALZ%>@OL>/>@BAabV@BOLZ7<BHQ>cJd>eOL>IAfZ
g ANhIH.EeA>@BA^iTAfOjE<BAfZ^klHKmKEe>SJ>E2bC=<Bn\>@BADCFE G O`JaABJ#>@Of>6>@BAEIAocO`J?HQ>@BAE/_BALH_QiTA
i$C=pdAY>@BADP C=<q>@DAVH`hehC G A%H`hsr1_BA G CtO`i1klABi=i.ou@DAD<V>@BAabqovAEeAw_
EIHZKm G ALZC=<*>@BA
G HmKEx>Sy
z9@BA^H<Qi{bq_
EIADJLmjPR_B>SCTH<8>@BOf> G O`< g AqEeO`C$JaAfZ%h-EIHP(>@QC$J^C$J|>@Of>4UW%JqX
O`<DZ#[ g ADC=<BnR>@BAl}O`C$iLC=<P~Of>IADJ
H`hj>@DAO GLG mJaAfZ?_BAEJaH<QJ@BOa]DA G HPA>IHRZA`_BHKJaA
C=<>@BABCEuhIOa]DHKmEyz9@BAO GLG mJaAfZEyFvH@BZKyvPALA`<W^O`<C4 &@O`i$CTZ@C=PRJdADih
O`_j_BANOjEIALZO`J~UW\R@BODJ G itO`C=PALZ>@OL>9@BAocO`J"i$ChI>IALZh-EeHP>@BAklHKmKEe>
OL>6.Of>@mBO
O`<DZ@QCFEIALZ O`<O`mB>IHESC G pfJL@OLo(hH.E>@BA.O`C$itocONbr>eOL>SCTH<OQ<BZhCEJd>ZAf>eO`C=<BALZ
C$i$iTALnQO`i$i{b7OL>QOQPRPRmOQ<BZ>@BA`<C=<U3ABi:@QC/o@BAEeA@BAqocO`J%>IH9Ee>SmKEIALZKyc.HovAa]BAES
<BADCt>@BAEO GfG mJaALZ ESysP~ALA`< W\O`<QC @O`i$CZ <DH9EO GfG mJaALZ EyDmB>xhmKE
.A`@P~OQ< .OjEeHjH<@ON]BA g AfA`<wO g iA>IHJ@BHQo>@OL>4>@BADCFE
OjE0EIADJ>@O`J g ALAD<
JL@DHQou<\OL>/O8itOL>IAElZQOL>IAH9E>@OL>>@BAab^ovAEeA^ZAf>eO`C=<BALZC$i$iAfnQO`i$ib g b\>@BAYJd>eOfhehH`h
D:DSD \3

 \3

-::33 Of 61::-

*3,X,

0,O

-:: 34::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

1 BfDt`/D$$9BaNB`$dBQRDBSTBLQBKDB TfLST`B

D=TLftLL.cjS"B9.NB~Df`QQTI"KQ$QfNQtQLST`sI
uf%BaYKTDQ4x`$a`tj 9vBB9vBD=Q/*^`|`$aVRteIL
f"BBaDf`$TLBKDSfQS0Qj$TBSaQ9BB"BD=uQT`
ID=fB4DDt`=QjBfDaL|BSdQL
L 9BeN9ID"t^$BNj|LYBQBLLDaf(BaQNDDQYBLD
$$TLQ`${jNe`=BLR`DBDFj0IDd`BLDRLDQuLTfIjQLIDf
l 13 19.jl
43 l


/9l

3c

K 9 K

K 9B
IKaLBBS%`BTD:~LYf6LBjdLVSFDDxK.`~Q .jej
uB$+BfS`
DtS`Q QBKTLjBc`='=BKt
tBBQf
BSR$LLTjBjQ~ID=dR`St2BfevL`~`QQBj2RLL I# TaTLfB $
B\
IKaLBDST%
tDBLaD\NB`$a`BdLYL=R$tjv$=BDL6=8INS6
=B#Bfq=ILfSDL=B|fV`RteIf?fDQI$"D?Da=BST
= Q$ LQt`=S(LLLDaf DBxK3`Q .je $(
QBKTLjBQ7DtS$DQ% ` fLIL9STfD={ `BdL LfDaL
F`BxK3`~` $ IDfDB%` `DKtDLR=B LqfDaL
F`BxK3`~` .jeBDDBTBQ
IKDLLQfB`$T`fB.xS
Q=`BSR$LLTIBQ LRBc`7${=B==BKtBfevL`*Q`Bj
-::34 Of 61::-

-:: 35::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

f LIYaQQaTLLB^=^tLKQBVTLQ`.~QBS3.8``$d*DQBQ
f?B$`:BKtQBfS`l|DtS `QBBL`l|DtS ``
QBKTLjBQ..BD#j DKdL%=qQ=eLI`~`&jBaffST D c K 
f.B##L~-e .S 3L QB $dSTf QjxQ K & duBI
BD9|R$Lf9^QB\dSDKBL cBLKTBjN
L$LLT DBc`|efSKQ=B?I QBKtDQ 9Q$ILfDTf` ?:BKTfLIBB
L$LLTQ3fDaL S DDxK 3`~` .IBf6B|$~#L`d
BTS D` QBKtDQ













 









"

$#



%

` 9DQIN9I 1t$DTfLLB
IKaLBDSTV`f`fLDf=
e BL%L
LLDaf DBxK 3DjQ
.I$BQ|Q+=BKtQDtS ``D'$
L`l|DtS `` QBKtDc` :=DKt
TBKBRQ DQR$Lf
jBID=d`St BfevLD Q`B LLQcIdTaTLfB
'&



(

)

,"

)#

-%

+

./

01

2

0

435
67

*

8 6:9:;<=3>
5#4
535#?@ACB4

8D$3FEG435BHI3

QL 9BfDaL BSaQ^ BI KDDdIfq9/DB tee`.L RteS=BVBf

BQI=s$aQI QB QBLeLTfST:Du BKLt`Bf`d
e Bx
`DVtSa D`BfYQB* DeN0IL*I%D T`BL` % B
B 4 `j DKdLL~`SFIf`d
I Be =BD$DK:B
Ba`%afI` ` DQ B LLDaf BSdQ  BLD j DKfTIf
IfB\Q$T V (`  BKaf LYf`a
I Bx QB Ba`
8

J

K+





.L



K+

S6

T
MD&

1

+

7
M



V

M

F



.L

P RQ

L

U





-::35 Of 61::-

A&N

0



0

?



0

5

-:: 36::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

WYX.ZF[]\^1_N`Z'\\(aFWYXbc:[edcf_^(bdhg7ijXXkmlZNkNnKoRZWpbXq(_WnsrtXbuZ.rZNv(_arHw'dxyjqi

Zkb rz^(XT\.ZWYX{q[t_q(X[]r0| Zkbuq(X[W_k(Z}WX.ZF[]\^1_`Z'\.\aWXb!c:[ed~ar`za[$HX^ijZk

oRZWbXq(_WnsrtXbZr)Zv_a(rxxqidSrijZK|v(X,iTXk(renS_k(Xb

^(X[tXrz^'Zrrz^(X

ZqFq[]X^(XkNWnS_kj_`v(_Nrz^jrz^(XjZ\\aWX.buq(X[eW_kNW7ZNk(bD[]X\_XN[0|m_`?\KZWXq[]_?q(X[r0|

`[]_i

rz^(Xi

oRZWXK`]`X.\.rtXbV_kJNdNxdS(wOo^Nn}Xrz^(XXNnSbFXk\.X_`mlDJoRZW

[]X\_[tbXb_kydS(d.ZNk(brz^(XXnSbXk(\X_`l*xoRZW[]X\_[tbXb_?k

.dSdS.

ZNk(b

xdSdS.d

ca\^

renijX

^'Z'b

}sZNqNWXb

v(X.r]ofXXk

rz^(X

ZqFq[]X^(XkNWnS_kj_`v(_Nrz^jrz^(XjZ\\aWX.buq(X[eW_kNW7ZNk(bD[]X\_XN[0|m_`?\KZWXq[]_?q(X[r0|

`[]_irz^(Xi

ZNk(brz^(XTXNnbXk(\XT_`HlWjZNk(b>xTZkbTrz^XjbnW\N[tXq'ZNk(\|\.Zk1v(X

Z.r]r[envNartX.brt_ rz^(X }sZNqNWXT_N`reniTXdXk_rz^(XN[]onWYXKrz^(X\._?k'r[Z'bn\KrenS_?kNWpZ[tXGrt__

imnk(_[fX(Xkrt_v(Xr]ZNYXknk'rt_V\_kW.nSbFXN[]ZrenS_k*ZWrz^(X[]X\_X[|J_`Crz^(X!\.ZWX

q[]_?q(X[r0|ZkbVnsreWbFXq_W.nSreHZqFq[]X^(XkNWnS_k_`Rrz^(XOZ'\\aWYXbq(X[eW_kNWk'Zra[]X

Zkb

[ZKnsr0|

_`rz^(X

\.ZWX

ZF[tX

ima\^

ij_[tX

ni1q(_5[r]ZNk'reda[rz^(X[erz^NnW

\._?k'r[Z'bn\KrenS_?kUb_XWVk(_NrWr[enYXZ.rrz^(X[t__Nr_`rz^(XV\.ZWXk(_5[TZNvNW_}Xrz^(X

Z\\aWX.buq(X[W_kW_`Frz^(Xn[F\[nijXTnkjZNk.|1ipZNkkXN[o^(Z.r?WY_1XYX[ed

(d^XN[tXK`_[tX(rz^NnWCZF[taFiTXk'rHnW_`k(_ ZWW.nWr]ZNk(\Xp_[H^(X}qmrt_>v(_rz^Trz^XpZ'\\aWYXb

q(X[W_kNWd

c<$H5?=4g

(dsr7nW>`za[rz^XN[RZF[]aX.bv|v_Nrz^rz^(XZ'\.\aWXbJq(X[eW_kNW!rz^'Zr<rz^(X[tX*nWOi:|WYr]X[0|

-::36 Of 61::-

-:: 37::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

(z({eFG*5V;Y]N'(A('' ]NY:z(1F

$z(tYeS?A

R JN()z(Nt.

z(OF)N(Oz(!.!

tNf].ez()t!z'(N=(!sz

 V''8(z(

z(

tV*z

RAGNSD*RA(K'sNNz'(NN(uz T']0At>z(

YS(

7z(

$*('K*(z'.*!''VS

N$N(!S(N4T''1tz('(N=N(''O'N(N$z(.

.T

z

 >tmz(

N )NeYF

z(:

z(p;((S

z(Ss]t)z'A(Hz(S(

z('(N

(''

] .:

*

N(,].ez({'m*/'

(.z'H*Tt'F]uz({eFmANK(:t!*.?(S{m

(''].'(''pz

'NFC.fN((:

(Y

''

]Nt

$,s't'F]

.

j!NN=

z(;(s74(

t

NF'

'.e(Ktz'p*V''t.'(z

NN(

:f?(

F]Yt.

] .

:ef(

T



z(-FFj'etse(

='SN(z(tK

='S

'.

tRt.ee.Otz(

] .

KN((A(t!z'uej>'{sNN.(.z(AF](NSA

z({'.*NeNmN(zt.

< *N(>z(S(

z(.]N]05tY].e

z({sz(.{(

.Se(.eN(S$jKA(N (N

ej

t{z(4]5N(A

zsz((jt!tTNz(mK'.

zNt!DN.']Ke]NFt(z()e(.z!YNT!

(N!(Ktz'>z('.

NeNFtF((e

-::37 Of 61::-

pK

-:: 38::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

j'eS?((t'Nz'.Iz(*']S.eSNFtt(5fYOt(

Y

't

NS]eS

z(





]N

z(

]N]

.Y

 ](NS{
z'
FY(eY?N '
tjN(Ks{
z( KF]


Tt]N'
]z(?zD(

]'S.eS*(NRY <z

z(KNNY)z(D
.(ND
<z(j*N 

]

'1Y

pN(

 (] tHz('t'eS<z(!

FN!5z(!
."(eY?NAz'
#tpz
p(NFt'N

z(NtTCm

$&%!')(+*!,-(/. 0 . 2143 (

65 875NFt(,z(-jNe8(
%

> @??-$ 187 '2,BA

(N

eT:9='N'<;z 

=;

']F

 '



]t

6C z(EDHFS $ ( G

'G?NN0. z'T


FY]'eSYS(z(m Gt(
$je
FT.

K (> (]

=


z(mY(m
$TNem1($(.Ye>4 t.S

.N zS.N(jz(

Ht
eS.H=

z(

I

'( !z(N

zD.Y]N(ANz( )Y]

J
{t
mY]N((pN()z( 'u
;]
FY](es
FYS({uY

.?(

KtN(V.Yt'f4KSzOz(  (e(
Cz(

Js7
Cz(

.?


.N({.?N.t' szpz Nz(.
N:((L



NM >1pz(O](F.Gz(tj:
PzS((FN.:? t.tmt'(z(.z
-::38 Of 61::-

-:: 39::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

QRRSTNU VXWYQYVQZ\[]^4_U`]a[cbdQYeUEbfQg)QYeQ
^JhTi]j]kWUmld[_UgkhZLU
hY]j[
npoJhV^qQ`QhV

]a[rTWQ ]P]aUgB]kWUm^JhY]aUe2g^q]stTN[_UgPU^uevhY]smQhVwS h^q]sx[
nyoJhV^qQEQTz]kWUNsWYQ _U|{U U
h
n}[S hV

^Jh

S h~uQ bdnkS~[TTNUT T^u[h

ZQ]aUg^uQ~ kTS {Ti]PQ
hR UT

QhV

]kWUgaU

[n]kWU

WQ bfQ~uQ

^>T

TS {Ti]PQ
hR U

h[

ZL[hUNs
^Jh

QhV
]kWU

U ~u[T^4_U
Q gPeSZ\U
hY]T

QV
_YQhRUV[hz{U
WYQ
~=n[
n QYRRSTiUV]kWYQ ]2WUOWYQYV{UU
h#naQ
~>TNU~4s^JZz~>^uR Q]aUV

i&Y) o8# o p) ou#|  !!Lj-)+ +
>oq]Z\Q s`Q
~>TN[{UHZ\U
hY]^[hUVXWUgaU]kWYQ]B]kWUR~qQ
^JZ[
nj]kWUQYR RSTNUVwUgTi[vhT`^>T
]kWYQ ]+]kWUgPUbfQT/h[|U
hZ^q]s[2g+SQ ggaU~ {U ]PbfUU
hE]kWU
ZQhV|]kWUQYRRSTiUVtY]kWUh
^JhTSR
WQT^q]SQ]^u[h^q]Q
~>TN[R Q
h h[]{UTiQ^uV]kWQ ]]kWUNsWQN_U{UUh"naQ
~>TNU~4s
^JZz~>^uR Q]aU Vw^Jhx]kWUcgaUTNU
hY]yR QTNU`Q
T]kWUgaUmbdQ
Txh[KgaU Q
Ti[h|n}[2gj]kWUmVUR U Q
TiUV
QT#bfU~>~Q
TE

QhVH

\]a[xhYQZLU]kWU
ZQ
T&]kWURS~g^u]T#QhVHh[]!^JZz~>^R Q]aU

Q
hs[hUU~>TiU!oq]^>T`[h~4sx]kWUEQRRSTNU VWYQ _UQYR ]SQ
~>~=scR[ZzZ^u]P]aU Vc]kWUx[
nPn}UhR U

]kWYQ ]]kWUgaUxhQ
ZLUTxWYQ _Ur{UU
hmV^JTiR~u[TiUVKQTzQYRRS TiUV{ sH]kWUVURU Q
TNUVwQhV

rTLdQ
hV
o8
o dL w o 2d Byj/y! 
 >oJh ]IQ]aUc[
ndQWYQ gIQ
TYWY]gPQ|_ SgPUTYWt 6 cP 2 it^q]bdQ
TrWU~VX]kWYQ ]
]kWUgaUR Q
h{Uw]kWgPUU"[TT^J{^>~J^q]^uUTrbWU
hQhQYRRS TiUV[^JhY]Tw[S]]kWU"~qQYRU
bWUgPUQHVU QYV{[VsK[2gdQhK^JhRg^Z^hYQ]^heZQ]aUg^uQ~bdQ
TmR[hRU Q~U Vb&^q]kW[S]
T]PQ]^Jher]kWYQ]d^q]bdQ
T/R[hRU Q
~uUV{sW^JZTNU~=n!o=ny]kWUQYR RSTNUVXVUR~J^JhUT`]a[w]aU~J~
-::39 Of 61::-

-:: 40::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

kY& ILkY`>u\k
JLd


 Y
BkY`fuwN`N
Hiv\

m>i
>ru2+k
uY 
|auXmkpivkYyqd
/  xka
kJJY
P a \"kY Lqd
  "k"Y i
Ji=k 2>>Oix
i\Y ix>k4mN 
P}vk
NqYuv\aw>Nmz \ac
)
`
JL
Y+
rq
rNaaNP
JXaaJ>Jk Id
|a>NwH
Lra
qkHa ur>EHf>i=kui|amYYaK |k
JJY
LIckYmk
JLxd
Y Ji=kE

JYaP Pu>cJ>ia
Y&ukHkrJJu|
z JrN u
Y
fkwJq
u
 )qd
mkIkuXkYkma
>Nif

P}a

Y N

P iP
JY 

>Pa
Yud
2P a

k }2a
u

8P iP
 P
kYX8aiP

Yu
2JJYJ|J Jqu>Jik>
##aJi#if

Ji`# Ya
auJE> EJJ y}2 zu Jk#

>u2
>NcJ/vdY|IO
vP a
+Hi)+

6 !2 N

kH aLxPuk J
N|
-8aiPYq
2iu
|
kY i
P}O qYuL`kYv qYz>}H am
k
kL
P}YqY
JJOJOk
Y
JO
v8aiP
azu ak#
Y

-::40 Of 61::-

-:: 41::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

iN2


  uEY
a aPa k!#"$%'&(<$)Pa*
+
,2-.YP
/10223146587>9;:<3=<?>k1+.&?@A! 
+B$C&-'P
DL*4E'&'F%  
Y-I
Gd
HI&-?KJ
L A)MN O8 @H*Mf@HPP@ @HYQ   ?uR
+SqMTkYB m
HNU
+V  WF &-DXHPP
Q q
P? 
 YMa   &?HN

+F+}?QHZ+a
@HNzH[ME m H\Y
DX YQ )]&-?^3G;34_a`?4
b
HPkH[P@ Hc+a QHkI
de &-a
H
f? ' b*DX @HH b ?/g+h%- DRuQ bXkI  @i
58.j%klYmflno
pl?mrqso
tvu.klxwyZoz-{u|o
t~}B?WsOwnkw

wnnz?;l

ImQWgokyZll
{

w{

8kw
@

w{

ll
{ltFthlnufltKmfoy

mflnopl?mq

o
tVl?o'pl

l k{T;WeP'^8)~BB.?a])%?T#-8X)

?Z ^?KU68-)
?Q 8Q-*hZ ?WO)

BB|-8-Q'?K)
8-
^KNYQB|--'W?[YS'-

)B@

'W

-'r

.8

')-

ahK

S%

S)Q%^



C'C?Qx

)-Z'W1-.--%KK-?')?
-)a8

-

Q?))CYK-

-%T-

)

K)-

#%
K%-B?8



#C'%)-a8

)!--').a'')KO

W'C
c
)Z)d-'rC%WZS%KK-')?U-)K8--%
8)O?%K-'rQ--aO|C'C?.

-a|)g-'V)%

K-Q')h)X--').a'c

Q
?)a?-XQK-
-

-

Q?))C

'
K-'r

-#-

)

-C?8

)af

'')

K-

^K)- #))-a8

)
- -)KW-?a

)Qa'v'-^Q
?c-'E--dQ?')Q?c8e--?)
-::41 Of 61::-

-:: 42::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

K-C'C?Q
?
-
PE|W)))
I

  
  



! "$# %&'()+* ", - + ./ 0 !1

2345"67
8%6
3$("96:
& 6;!+ (
6
<6:= > 1

6
"

/

(
<(? @#A+
%67&

6C  ! D;6:E! F G#C

2 D,+
2/"6H*I(. J"6;
7 + J!/ + K? ()(
B





PK? 2 (RQ'6&S

 2"0LM%NLO&"

 Y#A+

%6
&
B

6C  ! '"

TU(;6
"V+
/"&6:*(W R!/ + K? (%X(

Z 2
2%6
3\[^][R_`%Na&
_b32++ Z c+
2/"6H*

( M"6;

 + d!/2+ (K? %M( e



b
2&2++  l4/ !W(
2

1

"&Kd6C/+ "

/
+"

2F

"\z2fc6:K

"6;
+ (#
f

60.

 "mLMn 5Zop (

%267&\6;Y+:! 0  #
6C(;sft6:,167

(

0?'2(

!

/

!/ + K? (%

"

KeqS

6
"

r

+

&

VA#/
%6
&

(
m(ea(Qv[xw

F
2%6
&

[^][



+ 6Hy

_`%Na&
_b
B

+

6;q z/"6H + '!/2/b("\2|

? 2%V! 2+



,234578%
3R,;

+
 (X(%
3

t:,2Y+2':Y' ; 
&Y(Z. ! m(

'4+22+ ,(+2/($u'2qucA+ %7&Y(

+ /H

(u m !1

(P".z2f}6:KJ6:X M
(/*

23dd; 
&l(

:
O

{2|6:q6:!/
,z2fc

~O'+ /d.(;

(3:!,

R

! "V7 4gf?

8%67&Xhijk(&



:2!%
 %
&



J+2

%:?~P2) (d &4/ 78%7&d(};

 &?2(

+:

8%(

/(2(W

+++
2($ 

-::42 Of 61::-



2&'((

-:: 43::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another



5k;Y!(?+?

/s%X(Hm %+}

(' !/%s):
2%7&}(:!.2

)!?}2

(/
C(;X

-)(d

+d(CO

 

/.;v%

\!%:!.2U

 0

7d({C D Z;72

R;C%22(&?d: &4/
2%
&

+(;(q&;
(/
C(;) 4/3/2+ q2(U:.

(? (
H`g$x!}WAA/(?Z/

++

/R

%2%:dC

2M pH &4/ 78%7&

5+ q u,C Y+\|%++2&)W:d;

2c 

/(!(:2 dWA+(X?Z/UA^(HA+(32(!2 (R(}&;

(/
C(;G

   2+2+
( + 8 d: %
&2

8+( d2&(

(/(;s.X

+ d8 d: %
&(8(X(}

./7:v/YY ( &}
2+2'H0X+d)/Pq / )

H %
&k(0:
(2

5+ m(O4n

pd: &/
2%
&

|p:C2v;c

M;

(

+

/(
q:d

C2 &@8,|%:d:(|2

&%(



A!CW(e(;!q d

+ )3.((3( 

,: !%
 %
&c+2

2

2327

+:,

n&Rk& 

(;7qO(+'? 2p unY{

(Mt &

2q

2
+ 9&



5 %
&m058

n&e2&+d(

! \MnNO3P?2(

X3/

pO

:
&2l?+s&@:< +-<

`(

2O

 
:s

Cc(`m(/( (\$+ 


&2

-::43 Of 61::-

/((

%:?t(M

! (:

:+

+ v?|

-:: 44::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

`Y+2

+ &+(%
&q2Zq `(C&/ +%M%7

@X(%7& @ e;+ 2

e (y+!/ `
?X

e





& d

!2/(l



:
n A

2

tX:$

;);
d+

%:?

;M2 4%C(;3`/+ :+ 2

2

234578%
3









&5

(

234578%
3

4+%M

n&l

4+!pH.

e(%C%



Wg3

2q

|U

2d+)

!

&;+(




C/+ 




2



2D

/

 8

A

+

//(:

+

: (
G$&?d;A%:%H

+A+!(pH?.+(/

c 

/

/


2(

`%"!&#b;}.+d+

W 2%
&

$,'2 {cA+2%
3cA+HtCZ+y'%+:!'&

A/

J2O

q;
&7
;)'!&;
3/2%7&2C(Z;



(8%:RA+

;(&M%C%H

( pk:
? &

X 

/



2H &XRd;!/

F2(JX (9$J:G&?9d:


2(k

;+(
}

4/)


(

{

0+Y+

)2(.2)Y2 ;

Z

*!2m.2*5+:0 

n7

XqH

+R(;\

}%
&)(:!

%!q/

%
3X2(}d/:! 

lA+2

,



+d+d/O!/

&}:2
&

d:

<

%
&
.N%!p&


nHH&A/&!

%:?





 &

;

q;

!%
 %
&

2+ =+ /Hvv!?/
:y20mH!%
 %
3v;0+
vOC

23

-::44 Of 61::-

-:: 45::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

132 46578:9<;; 5.=?>@7A;B)CD5 ;$AC#BE;5F;G288H>IC2 JLK$B7;46C8294$7JA;G81<; JLC29CDJLC8M 7 NE81;
F<OEJD=?>IC8QP17R132 4SF7*TUT.C8&8@;BV81<;%7N&NW;5<F;3X

YZ1;254[P\;>]CD4J#7^C#F2 JLJMCD5_81;

5<;^28ICA<;62 4625M J#2 =4;`7*5`81<;U=32E>&87 N81; CD5A;48IC#^28IC#7*5aB7E;<4 5<78b5<;^28@;81<;

7 N&NW;5F;c

d?e cgf(5h81<;%F24$;R>&; =<7Z>&8@;BR2 4Sijclkmcbno; 5p[28@;431rqsij5?>tAcgu:8&28@;r7 N6vw2E>I5<28&2p[2K

xyye nzfLfi]{}|@uZ~z3KVC8lPj24)7*94$;>A;B9MS81<;0ubOE=>&; T ;~7O>&8z7 NtfD5<BC22 4
OE5<B;>
YZ1<;`;$N&NW7Z>&8w7 NZ81;aF>CDT.CD5<2J3F7*O>8o431<7OJB05<78g9<; 8@7=>&7PJ
25<Ba8@7aNCD5<BU7O<8*CDT23^CD5328ICA;6B7O?938I4cz5J#;44]81<;6B7OE9<8*CL4
7 NS2>&;2 47:5329J#;BC(T; 54C#7*5KP1CF181<;VOBC#FC2 J.T.CD5<B
81CD5Ep
4K>@;OC">@; F7*54C#BE;>&28IC#7*5 PC81 7*9H;F8ICAC8MK5<7
9<; 5<;
NC8bF2509<;)FJ2 CDT ;Br9M81<;)23FFO4$;B07*5+81<;932 4CL4U7N
4$7*T ;`1M=781<;8IC#F2J3=?>@7*=<74C8IC7*5c
dd cLfD5_25<781<;>F24$;2 4V>@; 5<B;>&;B9M81<;_ubO?=?>&; T ;%~7O>&8t7NfD5<B*C2hCD5r2F2 4$;
>&; =<7Z>&8@;Ba2 4| xyy w\uZ~z~ e KC8Pj247:94;>A;B.81328L
j;>&;N@2 OJ#8M CD5A;48IC#^28IC#7*5 F255<789<;2 ^Z>&7*OE5<B NW7w>
23F*OC8&8&2 J/7 N81<; 2FFO4$;B*c
7Z>81<; N@2 OJ87 N81<;
=?>@74$;F<O<8IC7*5K$81<;U=<;>I=<;8H>&28@7w>4G7 N?2`^*132 48IJM F>ICDT ;`F2 5E5<78
9<;G2 JLJ#7Pj;Ba8@7.^E7)4$F78N>&;;cL
d 3cf8'132 49<;; 504OE948&2538IC2 JLJM0=>&7A;B9M81<;=?>@74$;FO<8IC#7:581328wNC>48IJM23FFO4;B
6>Ic"j7*1<Bci\T ;; 5 25C
81<;

1<2Pj2J#2

2T 7OE5387 N

vg132 JLC#B*KT ; T.9;>7 NmgfLKPt2 42 =E=?>&; 1<; 5<B;B)PC#81

m4cc e

J23F<4

PC81

F7*54C#^*5T ; 538G7 NG;
=J#74CA;T28@;>C#2JgN>&7*T

P1C#F 1

1<;

Pt2 4

8&2p[;

81<;

2FFO4$;B6>c" O<8NO>`w; 1T25

w2>@77*5K25<781<;>'T; TU9<;>g7 NQgfLcwf8lT2
M2 JL47V9;)7*94$;>A;Br1<;>@;+81328m81<;
-::45 Of 61::-

-:: 46::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

3$3
<aD-@D#-@3<3E.@U<*<U<$*G<-\@

?@ <S+<-WZ# 0@I LZ03
<D@D#@_?@
<" D (< <Zg@D&$<I#*+I#:Z3<3
<6$# <6 E<`?@$<I#*<$6L<&L# G .&(#

GwEjb G6t3gUG

< l

< <I#*<0<<+*<& 3I* l<E$EWZ<3<E
<$*]3 G< t3g WwI<Z<  <*@$<G3 I
@+3&@+L]#@.3 #  < *<WZL\-3E&6WZ L#
s<[HID)</@- .<$<<a@D/
?&*<I#* $

?w #6_   wZ #o GG.z

< j3  %E@:< 3 ' Q<3$<I$*+3l<_<I#*

3 < Z@+#<<*L#I*-z.D<?w\I D<
3 -< 0 &*)
.D<0<<g I#*3 -<
<j@D

<j<h<I#*}D<<jL#I*V .D DL

SD-<-$#E- S 3<I#*+L#<<bD#I#:

a(< L$(<3 r 3 < < 0@0$3a(< h<
 /E<I#*3 <<-@<3-<[<I#*L<
-::46 Of 61::-

-:: 47::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

EL#I#*Z.D<

3w<&
WZ@<*3@ 3I#: m<-*E$<Ww<+$<$*)L+<

@3
<


  Q 

 
 "!w$#E@D%#0<<*%&(' *DD%#_ jD#*)#<-<ID S '(,+<I-#I#:
EH&/.l<0< < (hh@ 3r G 3]<h1+# <r
<L#2)< 3<*L$
E@

WZS<@
$*3

L#

)<4)t 5' D<Vl<0ID  @

+<wEH&IZZ<6+# <%
<L#7)<*#8<h@L#RE*_<I#D3"a:9VD<D3@
<:( <"6+# <6:;< 3 : 3=<?E[ $-@
+<:9
ZE @>)<$E@<*L#
1+# <

<

&# L$.. E<3<[ #<<"

D< < < 3

<&3
@

<E

<

E@

#
+ 3:+33I <&L ?@E.<I#*E<0$
I*

$@? .

LLLE[H&I#*;A&,Bm m<* +# <C'z@$#E&*D%#<a@3o3Z L? &# 3I

,9# +< <l$D+<3I>)j@V@,#*EE9WZ  t 03$F)t3I

@@ <D?&EU3I#*V<0r}$G$9H(%#D%#h*}&Z@@#6+33
@# ,9&*D%#

L/
)G1+# <ZS*(%#<&*6&

6I3a(3I#* z<>)<$a&:J)# +3jK9 3@g<L' <#

a(<}@$#E&(%#<M# ED< < l<3
I*)L#N)<$

-::47 Of 61::-

-:: 48::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

O%P-Q
RTSVUXWMYZQK[
\;]%\_^a`bW^/S5\$cedfY_RgP-\hciRgj6O
Y%Q_^XkiRTl%keUmY%\
R"^W `n`mRO%R-Q
P$cio%U/R-\
jpcioi^/Rql%keUmY%\
Rql,[
\%j1U/R-k_Q,U/RWrl4W `Q>O
^/RqS5\
stTl3u^aQK[
\,\ lHvwoSpQ^x[_syzUnQ$UX\>W `{vQ^mlZQ$UnQ |}Q ~n$,
1
ey , dfY_R-O YedQ j4^nWr%\_^DNO
oS
UmY%\

O,Wroi^aURqj

j}Q$U/Rgj}`mR-\$c

UmYZQ$U8UmY
\

Soi^Xc_\_^OKQ j6\MRUxdQ jeY%\

P-c7UmYZQ$UxdfY%\_^n\

\6[
R-c\
l
O,\

W `]
WiPgR-O$\

W
`n`mR-O%R-Q
Pqj

Rql%c_\ ]%\ l%c_\ lZU/P(^n\

PgR\,co]%WzlUmY%\ l8UmY%\_^n\Rgjl
W]^XWrY
Rq_RU/R-WrlRqlP-Q,d

O,Q l

%\

UmYZQ$UfUmY%\

j}Q
S5\LOKQ
l_l
W
Uz%\QZO$O,\ ]ZUX\$cdfRUmY%Wio%UQ l,hRTl%c_\ ]%\ l%c_\ lZUO$W^^nWz%W^nQ,U/RWrl
s
%s@UrUmY%\LU/RqSp\W
`UmY%\l%Q 
Rql%k;W `UmY
\Q PgP\,k\,chUX\
^^XW^/Rgj1U/jp$UmY%\]%WiPgRO,\pW
`n`mR-O%R-Q
Pqj,~
O,\_^nUnQ
RTl
P(CQ4O_^nW
dcSho_j1UYZQK[
\CO,WrPgP-\$OKUX\$c>Q$UxUmY%\*jZ]%W
UxQ
l%c>croi^RTl%kMUmYZQ,UU/RqSp\;RE`
WrlO$\
^nUnQ RqleSp\ S5Wij$~
t-O$Wio_P-cNl%W
Uk_\,UzUmY%\j,RkrlCW `]_o
PgR-OpdR-Uml%\
j,j6\
j,~,UmY
\
l`bW^
UmY%\5j1Q
Sp\
~_l
WCQZc
[%\_^/j6\;]^X\%j$oS]ZU/R-WzlOKQ
l*
\C^aQ Rgj6\$cis oi^aUmY
\
^`bW^iUmY%\hj6\$O%or^RU:
W `]
o_PgR-O>]%\_^/j1Wzl
j4Q jd{\
PgPQ jC`bW^UmY%\4Q^n\,Q ~_UmY%\7]
WiPgR-O$\4W `n`mR-O
RQ Pgj7Sho_j1U
\>Rql
Y
oi^^DUXWUnQ |1\UmY%\QZO$O
o_j1\$c]%\_^j6Wrl
j8UXWUmY%\]
WiPgR-O$\P-W_O |o]Q j\KQ^/P(Q j
]%Wij$j,RT
P-\
s
,sztUSQK%\S5\ lZU/R-Wrl%\$cUmYZQ$URql3j$o
O
YMU:]%\MW
`OKQ j6\%je`bW^UmY%\^n\,Q j1Wzl
jeW `]
o
PgR-O
j1\$O
oi^/RU:5Q Pgj6Wi~ZUmY%\]%WiPgR-O$\W `n`mR-O
RQ PgjpSho_j1Ux%\CRql*Y
oi^^:5UXWUnQ
|1\UmY%\QZO$O%oj1\$cCUXWCUmY%\
P-W_O |Ko]Q l
ci~UmY%\_^n\K`bW^X\
~RE`LUmY%\_^n\Q
l%cUmY%\ l8Q$UUmY%\jZ]%W
Ul%WV]
o
PgROHdfRUml%\
j,jGRgj
Q
j$j6W_O
RQ$UX\,cr~,RUrRqjl%Whk^XWiol%cUXWhUmY^nW_dQ$dQKpUmY%\LO,Q
j6\LW `UmY
\]^nWrj1\$O
o%U/R-Wrl_s

u1Cuuyxt

-::48 Of 61::-

-:: 49::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

}
E%$i_1
bNm%2Z,
_6$%_/1z
Z ni ,mZ$Mm

Z$
n %
$-r
fZ,
_6$LD
%ami


_X_rX
qg8q
$-_Hm%

$
r C i,X

{6
__%_mq%G
,%m
q%rGm%n$$XX
n %m%H$rZX Z/-r
%G
-$$0 f
_X %
_,r fZ$%1$LD
%ami
 _p

_X_r0q4
-,E0X

,qm%
ZZ$nX
X$06_-_ %$M m%

nr1$
%/-rpm
%$6% %,_m%h
/1,XL
m%hX

C@
h
_iq_

_   }
}" =$ % 0x 
- =$$ Gq %

$
_ " >4 5  3

1E%GXi6,
%/-zZ $
$$%$}m_g(X

$,KZiT%/06_-_ %$mZ$
$$
_6,

L/"{r%i 5$

7

%

Z$%1$

L" %amiJ


X_r
,
%T%e5 h%_/ m
Z
_%$X_nq}zX


@$/-z;ii ZX_X,
qZX
/qhqZ ,z
$_"n$6MmL/ %_Z
Mii/q%m%%__3

iq%z
_ _ $, q8
q
x
%
h
% Z_h"/bf5r
qgq
0m%Z$
pr
1M 5i%/q%FX$(_"*Z
;ba
%rq%3K_
-i$(
3$X_-
X01
m%1 5XKDi%ig
Z/(

X_X/g1MZ,/(_:q

q%im

qZX Z/-rXZ_Z

T
1m
F

m_5 ZL Lq
i0
%m

X ,HX
K _6

_

i$

_g-

q(
%

%

Xr%_a:

min,$X

m%

1 %_X%rZ:_qZX$/:G

:G pT%iii/q%m%%__ %iq

_ _ $, Zm%6e

m,z
$_"X,-mm%
"i$C$$
_6,7L

Z
b
-::49 Of 61::-

-:: 50::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

,zhhn/q%

X_nq}HZ,
ebm
qh
r/%r1m%%
m

Z
$ 
-$KX$

 {z%hK
 Z%
%e_
-r,% {

-r_q%"!#$!%'&1 (
){%z,,/-_,XrZ$X/ (r%/qhq%_
-$
Z$aX_/-

i/q%

X,_, %m%ig
-Z/.

%8b ip% %


$+*

%X_X/g1ZK/._/%q0/q%i-21

m%,bX%1 -M

/-_N %iq
z3%4%!45 %%67(Zm%8%_m9{_X5b %

X:
8m%

5
;%_/0 5m%<Z
_%$

X
X/g}

n


*@,/r

 =&}$?>-4>

@ ZZ>n >-/g 
:A CB @ /EDf


hgLq % %$qX_Xq}$,/._,

6#F/Cpg6G%5 Z/-r%$%_n8mZ$5m

X, :%
Vi"X,,in_
5

/qhqZ,z
$_"n$H/Z CXI
>qZb
X, XrJm%e
"XJh}n
%$
K/qNm%
n
6 Zz,
6J(
Z,J_6$LL-{z% NM5, POM

RQ

SZgT 5 n % %_$

mm%4Z h
pHZw U .VZ

5
>rm%WZ ,gh 
qig6J-i iX
}/1X p Z=(Z$1$XL-ZYJ%a[i\ _p ]Q

 nr^{
C n % %_$_m

m%_
-i$.

$
}n
%$
`/Ngg6V$
nn qmZ$
-
,m%_na{

p$,/q%H hq%i ){fpn0

/6r
(U

mm%7Z$J_1$$ G%_
Z%_$
-_$Xp$,4$NZa/-J-_
Z$bNm%%
% % Nm%
,zZa
Z
% (>

/bKcd(>b8m%

im%i6
_iq%


 [Z,Fb

$%,X_T%m
Fq%X,,(6J
_n
-r_,0
%e
,H f/q%i
b {$rq%
;$_
q_}Nm%hgJ

m_5 Ze i/q%ij/gJ-,-Jn
K-$ Xr

m%

_-_ %$;m%,m

XT  NZX$
5 Zk%,){$ *m
;$$J_6,%_6r_hb
,zhhn/q%hm%P
-[}
%e-$
}Z,_
%_/qhqZ1$r_$
DaZ

-::50 Of 61::-

-:: 51::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

lnmop?orqs
tTtouJo
pvoPs
tw9x yp?o qz ouy4xotq op?o{sp?x y

tJ{z[mJoP|?s qzH}
|n~Fs7{ y
t{T~Fs2p

77.

s {sJy
tzz[moF}JuJop[trot7zP}|;
tJx yEs}npfs z)z?oJ;7zVz?}0~Fs7{oe Jqmsa~Fs2p-UlKmo
}|)|oJtJqoGqs
t}Rt
.wvoh p)}JuJo xvwz[moGqyZp)qJ2'z)st7z=y4sJPouy4xotq os
tx}nps

z?oz=y
P}HtwL}
|Fz[mo_~yEz[toJ o
tz[mo p)oJoJtzqsoJz[mo_s7qqJo xefp-\}Rmx
Po oJts
t
y$

dm7syx~Fs`|} 2tx8yt;2t
4s~F|[2}  oJ  y4}HtP}|$t7s7qq } 2tz?ox

 .T4s qJ3~ my4qm_yTz[mJo^m7s ~FsEs^s
r} $t7zs
txLs7q qJo xfp=JJz|[ p oJm2s
t

ns2p?}}Ht;~Fs`|} 2tJxiyt3J}  oJ y}Ht3}|U${ r}|o
4}  y.uJoWrs z?o
p=yEsJy4o
RkfH^3dRK R+[
-hH n2R"

0
4H 2
)

U
JH E[hd2R+
H
+=

Z"Z$

Rn+
K2d'R+H

CH

d+

+3d2RI=
$^9^ H d=$
rE$RK
+k2d2
+

+WR
-d2
-C3H$=2H2  
 $H2_R_
H3H$XRX$
2
n2R=`2$i K= $2
\2H3LR[I
nR+E$H-H2


  
  
 ! "$#% "'&
-<=:7>:7
?@   3:AB
MN 2

() "*+,.-/ "0 21134"

"
65789;:

3@:C"5EDF HG8I *= 
J -/
*, K

@:9J@L;"1:2,"

O M PQ 2
RS:7
 M "+T"5U2T3;
*,3ASV:4 :A

 8W 
:X573YD"

"

&

ZC @A

-/ "

211A



@

 M V:4 2

^LV"1:E2_"`a M P3J@
%134


-<=:7

":/  

:7


[12*,]\


1:9,b c 2 M d4
;d:7 ::7

 N

-4e
2:B -/ Af25b:7
e :A":9g25d:7

8hA
1
 :9H\
Y1

,i2 kj 

 
O c\
0 "*+l5734:7
m5A
*,:AO; :9+V5 N :7
%nm334:m M 3
:o:7
@2*, -/57*
1
3;
,p"5:7
?V
-/ "S:7
rZC -/ "*=

k 2
a2* N 1A


1:9,i:7 :i  " M >4 "+q+!:7 :=:


 N -U2, "6-/ ".X "+Q5sA

-::51 Of 61::-

M 


t:u4 22;  :9,iR5vC

-:: 52::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

wAx2yuyAzCy9{+|VwQ}~cw9{H{=w9{_x
|}2

w7
x

x2,z|{]
x

/}"|vzCyQ~}yuy2{

z
w6wAxyyAzCy9{+|;w

}~w9{H{=w9{,x
|C
xyAz3|x~

w9{,z}"|f}"+|;z3y4z

xzyAx~zCy4w7
xyAx
|
x~w9{H
x
3{+|~
_z3|3yAx|;w4}wAx"px

w9|}x.
z2w7Ow7
x0}~~
|;xg
xy9|z2|l{O@xcw4}"{+2
w
@
xy"w7
xp
{=}2B"2{_x"
~x!'~cw9Vw7
xK3{+|~
,z3|3yAxp|;w4}wAx
px"w{+|
z2w}i>{+||{2_x
{x;{,x"
~x
Bz2x
x2y9pw7
x
z3||x
||{,zz"lxc22_z3|{H
x}wAxy9{=}"^}2
w7
x
}"pz3@
wz2oE|]2^=}~
|a}"|a
xx"`3HhyAz

x0aw7
xByAz3|x~

w9{,z`}2
l
z2
w7
xS23yAx"6|2{]AwAxf@
zSw7
xS}~~
|;xg
xy9|z2|wAzgy4z"
xSw7}wxc2,z3|{H
x
|
|2|Vw4}2
~x
|?xy4x
z2wx}2w)wAzl~zi??{=wo|zpx0@2,}/7}~wt{hw7
xh~z@wuy
zCy3wAzb}@x^/}@yi}}
{|Vww7
x>/z

xy7x"wCz"
3{,}^U2{,~">w7
x;B}c
x^A}
{,xdwAz
3{+|~

}yAx
zBz3@w2w7
xK}~w@z"/}3{
?/}@y}2}"{2|;w3w7
xU~z3@
wya|
z,q
z2w

xR{wAxy7yAxcwAx6+{,
w9H.Sw7
xmz33y4w<2
ww7
xT}@yA3@px

w9|z2/w7
xT'3{=w9{_z}"
@2+{,~ yAz3|x~

wAzyvzCy@w7
xiw4}wAxw7}w{=w7
x?=}"|Vw
}`}"8yAxc}
>w4}2Vx"a2=}~xpzCy
w7
xS}~~
|x.!x2yAx}2yAx"
x

xQ}4wAxyp|{
gw7
xpz
x6vzyUw7
xOwAxyuy4zy{|Vw
}~w9{H{=w9{,x
|w7
x"hw7
xdz"4vx"
~xT27|2sss
q Y|}"+3
xB@xx"pxlwAz

xBx
|;w4}22+{+|
xh}2}"{2|;ww7
x`}~~
|xO
xy|z2|dhw7
xhz3y4wFz2w7
x2y4<{+|x0
z2w9

x}y9|?vzy4~x
E
xBwAz}",xyXw7
x
||az"mw7
xhCx~
3y{,wBx"
~
{,x
|a}2
Tw7
x
z3+{,~xz"
w7
xBF
x~
{,}
3mx
++3w7
xB}~~
|xO}c
x
xx
%}2yAx"
x"
xO
xvzCyAxdw7
x0~z,
|x?w7
xax2,z|{]
x
|azCyw7
x}/}"=}0pz
xh
C
xT}c
x?A}"{+,xwAzl|;}w9{+|VXBw7
x
z3yXw`kw7
xxy4xvz3@
{
z||x
||{,ziez2qw7
x|;}"pxe}"
{|
~"
~
{y4~
@?|;w4}"
~x
|Ew7
xzi2HfyAx
|@?
w9{,z6w7}w<~}"r
xfy4}"{+|x{+|Ow7
}w{,wU}
|
x}2wwAz?/}@xk/}@y}2}"{|Vw@w9
x/z

xy9px"w@z"C
3{=}"

-::52 Of 61::-

-:: 53::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

c
C
4cvCA
b7
343

9,

"
"",A

4"
,9"@


;9,22ss`4^<,7ac9_`0"7

p8@S2"2;
27K7


B

c
"=t+>
,@s4i7
`A3

9,iq,"
b2
07
^2


B3;
,b7
7
B343

9,"d"
V7HlA

7
d
h@
m9,2B8/
T4l<=7SQ@t;2
Tie2t2"2;o
7h7


B


_CdAF"?c9_0;Cb2
`"m2=7'9H2,9,
?A;
"9,i3'+
i
7
3d



3a!p"%22T

)"+,/"v3@

3;
,2qE]2g=
/
,
;2
7

98

X7
"2

@4iQ/"Tv@
Y
3;
,6"c2,3H
.KA9="+)"

,"
XA"



"B

03]B
V422+
Sq7
A3

9,i`2
T7

2HvA

Q7"e

fs4

7+.O7K7
.c2,3H

2

/
,^
;>A^p"
@vC27
A2uAC9+Vc9]2,9,
^7
3u>"
?"
"
2
7
`A3

9,iq"a

a22,bA34

^7
`
CA3,"9^";9,2
V!

"
">2=7t9H=9,
OA

"9_U'U2"2;a
27Q7


B


;
?'3=9_"C@2,l43

AC"h_9H;
_h79F"hc2,3H


E@4
@h49
4@9
b;B+]
`22
=c
a7
"3CA2uAC9+V9H=9,
`;

-::53 Of 61::-

-:: 54::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

+H
b=c


 E

 A9 
p2 


p!#"/"=?$
%&"/

')(* %+,- ( "/+3.+/"/&(2+2".

0 
21X#A43-# %&5(?
76%@8A9# :(;(A#<
=#> @?:
(A?
A 2B+C
 "DE'
^%
#F
(G
H 
9"I2/# %J
#*A (&

 4( #
 8K ,2
LA
M9.$
2
 _
N ,2
K)(O 
#%9 P<" 8

#;

Q :(IA, "
RX, K

 ,
B$ ,S
T)(O 
%9 ?:
 H
  U ,V
T)(O 
%9 W<" 8

#;
T

 (;(O ' :4( #9
 k/# 


MA`.
7 $A2 _A
HEA(
+=2' ,
1YX Z[?:\]7^`_C]IaNX&1cbVZY?dbe^gfh1gX Z[?:\R]9^`ikjd]9alambnZ[?lbSopbq\.^Y1&?dbSZgZVrs1YX:f
t9u wvr?xar uyu X t bq^Tz{b u ]e]I^
=| R?:
})(* 
;#%9  
~,%(
(
.
M
#%#
#
0,%+]{)(O 
#{##%
;#
t (<wv%,%( u &K$ s lHj  iH > #0#' %V#N t # %G
PfC&(O+2

  (C
')9( #o #A F^  $/% .)f
B2"
I,- %&h.F%&2,"S,% 
#

#
  ,
iM8&i@EM+^

 2  

 *"e  q

_5(9O  #O :(G
# 
 9.?
$ .+mH2  >
,- %(
 
 +g
y' #*A9( ,
%) (n

 w(O%&$/
04 

O Q3+ 
 T( .;
UO
4( 
M  2
' ,!
#%
2 
   

F/" 
U  
#;

#
.+ 
V
p
$ !,- :E(
=#",
% 2 'ku `b
.
M
' "!" 
% &( > # _SO Hj  iH > #
 /
'
.
+
3+ ,#@
2 N" 
J,- %&N
M4.+C73 +R2 B
C
+ .y\.3=y%) % :9( #3H U" 8 %
 2
 .>
+  A
 (>
$ .

  %) ( I4, "
e98 ,- :( ' % *"eY

c&(G


-::54 Of 61::-

-:: 55::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

H:An&8G&OH#O:gFGGRMJ#GsEH R

&*#)&<#&G *&ME8/O5O:GM#G 8GA0
8 Y9#*G
9 #9J#S8
&S
)*- S./S&. 0 2#O4-#&5/7&8O9#:;O#<
M:#GJ/G:)JVp)* 
pxQ&* )G8OO5*
85*OWW#8:#O&:y##&M*Y8SHQ&
9 #/#& 0*#2e.CHR)@/M#*e#5G2 *#O:<#
LG./. H #c-#4*O Gle **##O#*
## Hy9Gwx 2l &*&C!!MFe *EHT0Y78
.OxO [R-E)*  :#Gm!)mngE
x#.# H#Fe# 7.R-&!.E#M##Am&&:.
5* 8hO#  # #&M* & #
&# Uw*&/M*W .GHdOccOHN# dD8
S9-:x8# Mk5G0:2 #)0*#D-&B
2& 8#
#M##ye## H9GwI K &*&W78L&#)O
MAO!AG&EVYR8A.EJ#M#x# M#d9<we
e
#m[ [NJOQWB#- *#n# 
S.
#M##
K#&M#hSQ78BOOhPO 5*:GM9VG
yh#U.#- O`.:*I
HG`F ; FV!.M
*5*O#/I H#F##
9.8D-:& ##F8qe

-::55 Of 61::-

-:: 56::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

8/&[O*H#GJM  #CA!H ##F

)OH#GA
#0 .F)*#
H
& H#GE2)EV
H#G4n.MF H#

9G 
 
 :&O 
 *!U .l
DTJ# M#NGH
I# l#*O 
 *#8N9QOMG.
NDL)*M#G

78#HT:IO#RN
B F)OH#G O``.  *##:O

D~
.#O[

esBC&8
&#H#J: #:#


SlB.

c/8*O#~. KH #K#
## H
9G  x 2
  O E9
8 #  9 H#m

cdO
 &
D#/

SN..PKd
:*nL Ml:eN;O#K5<T&G8 yH  #le
)*M#G

78#HA.9#:5*:*GRC# MOx!
#AOR
*8
!Y#"
%$#  &*H#GW#mON)OUGJHJ# . 0e
## HE <H 7G. G .'H('H*)''%$2.+. 0
, A
. -# /w/ &A9## HCO *#.O! G./.# w*#H
0

7~ #2 1#&M# 9<s .
-[4
35
D .~8 m&;OM*# 
2 6:-:N&;*. )  ##OG8OU H!0

O&5!s<)GC!O 5*:GMcG 8G.U.8 .C:O sO H
-::56 Of 61::-

-:: 57::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

7 8:92; <*=?>> @A= B8DC<FE*G <FEIH:;%> JK%L B?MN=OB:;MN@QP JK%L @R7%;2MN;SCTP @A= @R7UMN;TJ@A;SK
>V=SH%;2MA;%E(9OKW@QP2XYEFKW@A;9ZM/E[@QP
JK%L 8DKE*@QP=\]^K%L?E[JU_E^K B8OM`>8%JK%G;@A= @R7%;a>VJ:E*L
GM/EFbcEFKWJS<G=OK2>BEdM5JWGePc=OKfeg2h*f2ieh*jTff%klEFKmC%;T@Nno;;:K+j:h*ffcB2bp@A=q%h(fTfcBDbpJ@.C82>
>r@NJK%LstL2J2M/>W7muZJW9JDM/XevwEx<x<*J9D;+yzJWLO7%=?<F<[JSX:{#;%<^7EJK%L|K%;TJ2M}yZJCUM/E~J@A;:X{zJ2MA9J7X
uEJbc8:L2L?E^KXW{z;:<F7EFX@R7%;eP+C%=@R7J:<(=OK%9nE[@R7G=25JWGTG:82>e;LM`h(7:;M7WJKpC%;:EFK:9
b;SbC%;2MU=S\CWJK2K%;LmbcEx<FE[@NJSK%@m=ZMA9JKEJ@/E*=KzJ2MRrJT@A`8D<*F2;:7WJWL2N;`]x><[JbcEV??][
no;2MN;\=?8DK%LYJK%L+GT=O<x<*;G@A;L7WJnJS<[Jcb=OK%;ePJK%LY;2B<*=?>EIH:;>8DC>V@NJK%G;\=ZM?@R7:;
B8?MRB%=?>e; =S\L?Ex>:M/8DBW@/EIH:;JK%L@A;MMA=ZM/Ex>V@JWGT@/EIH2E[@QP E^K
]FK%L?E*JJK%L@R7%;eP C%=2@R7
JT@N@A;SbBW@A;L@A=nJW92;nJDMJW9JSEFK>V@@R7%;~=:H:;MRK2b;SKW@=S\Y]^K%L?E[JU_L?8?M/EFK%9 @R7%;
B%;2M`E*=DL ;:K:L?EFK%9=OKfegh(fieh*jff%k @R7%;ePC%=@R7JS<*=K%9nE[@R7@R7:;%EdMG=JWGTG:82>e;L
M`h(7:;M7WJK JW9ZMN;;L CTP G=?<x<*;GT@/EFK%9 zJnJS<[J o=OK%;ePJK%L ;e2B<*=O>TEH%;
bJ@A;2M`E*J:<enE[@R7@R7%;+E^KW@A;SKW@/E*=OK@A=mnJW92;nJDMmJW9JSEFK>V@U~=:H:;MRK2b;SKW@#=S\#]FK%L?E*JJK%L
@A=mGTJ:82>e;78:92;<*=?>>@A=B8UC<xE*Gc<xEIH:;:>JK%LB?MN=OB:;MN@QPcJSK:L+@R7%;2MA;:CP@A=@R7UMA;TJT@A;SK
@R7%;>e=:H:;2MN;:E*9KW@QPXEFK%@A;T9zM`E[@QP JK%L8DKE[@QP =\]^K%L?E[JU_L?8?M/EFK%9@R7%;B%;2M`E(=2L=S\@R7%;
GT=K>B2EMNJGeP ;:K:L?EFK%9=OKfVg2h*f2ieh*jfTf%k @R7:;VPC%=@R7no;2MN;\=?8DK%Lb=OCEF<xEEFK%9@R7:;
\R8DK%L\=ZM@R7%;B8?MRB%=?>e;=S\LOEx>:M`8DB%@/EIH:; JK%L@A;MMA=ZM/Ex>r@ JGT@/EIH2E[@/E*;:> EFK]FK:L?E[JU_
L?8?M/EFK%9@R7:;mB%;2M/E*=2L;SK%L?E^K%9 =KfVg2h*f2ieh*jfTf%kWX@R7%;ePC%=@R7G=OK>WBEMA;TL nE[@R7@R7%;:EM
GT= JWGG:82>V;LM/h(7%;2M7WJK \=ZMGT=bcbcE[@N@/EFK%9 @A;MMA=ZM/Ex>V@ JWGT@ JSK:L\=zM@R7EF>
B8?MRB%=?>e;@R7%;eP C%=2@R7 7WJH:;G=?<x<*;GT@A;TLzJTnoJ:<*Jo=OK%;ePExh*;:h#J>8Db =S\>hg2h
<[JWG%>+JK%L;2B<*=?>EIH:;no;:E*9O72EFK%9iehUifV9?XD@Nn=K%=OK|;:<*;TGT@M/E*GL2;T@A=OKWJ@A=ZM/>TX=OK:;
@/EFbE^K%9|LD;VH2E*G; JK%L\=?8?MtB:;:K:G%Ex<>E;CWJ@5@A;2M/E*;:> @A=GJDMMdP=?8%@w@R7:;L?Ex>:M`8UBW@/EIH:;
JSK:L@A;2MMN=ZM/Ex>V@JWGT@/EIH2E[@/E*;:>EFK]^K%L?E[JU_L?8?M/EFK:9 @R7%;|JT\=ZMA;%>VJSE*LB:;M/E*=2L;SK%L?EFK:9 =OK
-::57 Of 61::-

-:: 58::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

V 2*2e*T%WR%Vp%Ro2N?D:Al%R% S%2`ScR%W2%

AAZ/xr4ZA/*O ZDRA`2*F2SWW2N`x[ ??[t(:x.FT:?%
FA2NZ/xV+WT/I2[Q?%Oe(e*%mS:?%m%(Tz ?%/*2
DAz%T2zS?`OA%xSc:2OF :FFOWT:2e/:%5R?zS2
z2A2OS?D:FD*TR2?%?e:T*O teUV2*?I::SNo
%Oc:*T`(2TAOWAZ/eO%/F^%2e2*%O?%S%:xScW5A2/*:
D%22#R%%dN:DcVNS%:aSA?I:./xeYAATSVO%S2*2W*:*O %
RWT%o:%:?V:T^% R% VZ [R2OT S:SxV
%T5TS %DQT2Ae2*2V(T%%%:F% Z%O[W2%W o:
?D% V52F% xI2F% F F%?[ DWS%R%Z/?I *R%?%l%e2F% T
%2/cx*O D%D2ASxe*2SW/*d Z2%?%D5:TD`
%Z%2Nx%2RF%OR%NZA*SWWNA2R%%2N:[QSR%
A%V/FO(%SR% ?N?e:%/*O [R%:e%ZA:FT5R% ?N?e:%/*O
%2/T(O

% zWDr`#5:FS*TUZ`:}:S+:W:eW|:SRe?Dc:W+?+[A5WYS

:NAS::SUSFW:%D*UWDDeeR*?DrU5oo2eNTW*`eTR*?
WF?::e(SWor:::`SzRWSWWD
RFW5U#%D zS#?+[AN|W2Q`SW|2:2we(
-::58 Of 61::-

-:: 59::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

SDR%cU+T
e *
 SDR%tT 
TR%NV% * [!%"e#%$:&'TA
 (*)+"
%,NA"R%-N-e% *
%e. #%$:."0/%12(%345#%!*6A-(A87%RR%9W
V
%
:e
;=<Z% A2 V >& ;(2 R%5 A- e2 : * 5?[! :2 e @2A :B "%5

CN &=)DE! F!&B*G );HI>% ;VA %J )K  %L M#-*T * N
*SO O&PA
 (;2

AT

;">rA WQ ;2
, RA 7%, M *$:2 S<Z:T A- e2 : * 
# U7% U7
*lA
"ST "r! 
>*)A $:'
* % eV /
E;V
7%RR%V  
e" +%
 V 
"

  

Z%802W [G)S+7%RR%YWT
eU%
:e
"HoR%Z&P;
%
E[
*SR:

SN :T 267%T
&&[NA-H\
(WTS&&B>"*SR%SN%2HR:
>"$:2 V ]/
T (
^>% >2/aR:_ 22 3& W _N #3A -HR%`
AT $:
a)SR%
# ]b;& 3Wc ;2% d
;*- *$: "HA !# %$%D 7% .N
%
:e)1-N $: 17")R%
N
V % * 
_<z%
N6 @%R; E2/6; *S- 
]ZW# NA; R%D $:; MW2*G )SR:
N
V % * 5 [! % "e , f g )R:2 ]E& ScR%h A- e2 % ( ; >R%
N
V % * @?*! % "e 2 J$:1 &'A;  (*)63
%K 5A  R%i A- eT % *
" e
# %$:'
"]/:" *% 3j#% ! * N- (Ak 7%RcR%l WT 
e b%
 e ;
<Z% A2 V >&
;(2 ScR%m A- e2 : * 5?[! :2 e YDU % WN
C A & ;")
&PA
:]
>! F!&[G )
H,>%
;VA %W ), !T
WR g#-( *
kb3A ;VA %n ;2
TK LA 7%, M *$: 

 WX<

92.

oEp^qr]st

uvOw:xsUvfuKyMsz;urEp#z

yMs"{|}u
p|#~w:x#s^#u-p
|J#r0s
p#%s^uvOw:x
r>|Au
yGwr|
-::59 Of 61::-

-:: 60::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

J,B3]Je9W!0W!0D!#LO-M}0
.N##
N2-eQ2#L30e
3E

-

L#

!
#
##

3;
k3D

#;>W8#
f
>]

;#

:

#;J

!J-3

!F2E!8K;S

;P*
,3;,

M;3f->2!2SB>"]KM232

nJ"" ]

F;J3jf"

(L%"0
N%R1a
i;#%J 0-
+J#K;#NJK#k[L

J;#
:2%S2#3J% !F2aL;S;h

I;,[#-B(fMm 
Mf%

32

J"" ]3!2"
;2J% 0S3!4%

X#KM*
j#
_";J

93.

;P* !ac,#\Vb;

!%-
L_L";%2

!J-

>]B# !a2aLIK;SK3;

@
M%-#
0W1
%
E#,BeM!#.f2.#
"W#:-
3 3 }
RO>-




M"# ]:%J 0-
+J0


2


;
:
";LGL!l%#;JT!03#M:I2l;T K3g-
J,%
0"gM,}3>#+J-B]M%L#S;g:#
;

%"0
 :-"

J"" ]

3!2?X"

2"
!222"3M3!22>#3,W#f2

%,f#3M >2-(4'%9JY2.'# ]
212
MN!#"-OfD!+
](;#

2-]OM!]
:!.n2"( \2>n!2M!]
:4!2 #RM

#f]3"lX
2J
;2;!!2B
J"2
W
;l
f;
-M22
2%,f
-::60 Of 61::-

-:: 61::-

SC No.41 of 2007
State v. Mohd. Ameen Wani @ Khalid and another

!2W-
W 
W (!Q!2QS-2!2b0!"D#W
$M%&0']j()*"+!,-.f/2
gG01'*203+45K22+0"
(%(6] V(-!879":<; +=2*8 2>8#" !"M/]"!+l#W=
+1!2(%(60"
 (!2?; 2@BA2f+C
2-DEC
2JFS
G]'fH&2
.M:f#I(JK.f;f% LCB!28L#fCJG]G=J2
fC/(G*(GS(KA4

DB
22# '!2l/2*; -M

MONQP$R2S"TQPVUBW

`Kacb6de+f8gihjlkmno8pqsrtu.v wnvxo
y<z#{
|}{~

-::61 Of 61::-

W?NQPXFYQZ8W?[]\^W0_


%{|<y}]t yt
+~