Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Comparison Catholic Hymnals

    Uploaded by

    Jeff Ostrowski
    877 views1 page
    Corresponds to Roman Missal, 3rd Edition (“New Translation”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Includes complete readings which correspond to the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO YES YES Includes complete Responsorial Psalm texts with translations matching the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO NO NO Responsorial Psalm congregational melodies embdedded ? YES NO NO YES YES Complete Propers of the Mass included ? YES NO NO NO NO Partial and/or abridged Mass Propers included ? N/A NO YES YES NO Contains the Official ICEL Settings (“Missal Chants”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Complete organ accompaniments available ? YES YES YES NO YES Complete organ accompaniments free online ? YES NO NO NO NO Choral edition available ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains a sizeable collection of hymns for the Catholic Mass ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains only traditional hymns easy for congregation to sing ? YES YES NO N/A NO Contains hymns & songs written in a secular style ? NO NO YES NO YES Typesetting of all music is professional, unified, & pleasing ? YES YES YES YES YES Published with express permission of local Bishop ? YES YES YES YES YES Carefully & thoughtfully avoids all uneccessary page turns ? YES NO YES YES YES Layout is dignified & pleasing to the eye ? YES NO YES YES YES Includes traditional Catholic line art ? YES NO NO NO NO Hymns organized in a logical way, easy to “browse” and understand ? YES YES NO N/A YES Hymns provided for all Sundays & major liturgical feasts ? YES NO YES NO YES Includes hymn selections for Ordinary Time ? YES NO NO N/A YES Alphabetical listing of hymn titles placed as the final page of book (to assist congregation) ? YES NO YES N/A YES Includes a considerable number of Gregorian chant Masses ? YES YES YES YES NO Indices are easy to use for the “average” Catholic ? YES YES YES YES NO Includes dignified, truly congregational Mass settings in English by various Catholic composers ? YES YES YES NO NO Are hymn texts changed in order to be “politically correct” and support heterodox and/or “progressive” Theology ? NO NO NO N/A YES The lowest price (per pew book) for bulk orders ? $13.00 $11.96 $13.60 $21.95 $15.50 VATICAN II HYMNAL ADOREMUS HYMNAL ST. MICHAEL HYMNAL LUMEN CHRISTI MISSAL GIA WORSHIP IV The following chart was prepared by a member of the Church Music Association of America. It is a comparison chart of Catholic Hymnals, including the Vatican II Hymnal, Adoremus Hymnal, St. Michael’s Hymnal, Lumen Christi Missal, & GIA’s Worship IV Hymnal.

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Corresponds to Roman Missal, 3rd Edition (“New Translation”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Includes complete readings which correspond to the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO YES YES Includes complete Responsorial Psalm texts with translations matching the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO NO NO Responsorial Psalm congregational melodies embdedded ? YES NO NO YES YES Complete Propers of the Mass included ? YES NO NO NO NO Partial and/or abridged Mass Propers included ? N/A NO YES YES NO Contains the Official ICEL Settings (“Missal Chants”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Complete organ accompaniments available ? YES YES YES NO YES Complete organ accompaniments free online ? YES NO NO NO NO Choral edition available ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains a sizeable collection of hymns for the Catholic Mass ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains only traditional hymns easy for congregation to sing ? YES YES NO N/A NO Contains hymns & songs written in a secular style ? NO NO YES NO YES Typesetting of all music is professional, unified, & pleasing ? YES YES YES YES YES Published with express permission of local Bishop ? YES YES YES YES YES Carefully & thoughtfully avoids all uneccessary page turns ? YES NO YES YES YES Layout is dignified & pleasing to the eye ? YES NO YES YES YES Includes traditional Catholic line art ? YES NO NO NO NO Hymns organized in a logical way, easy to “browse” and understand ? YES YES NO N/A YES Hymns provided for all Sundays & major liturgical feasts ? YES NO YES NO YES Includes hymn selections for Ordinary Time ? YES NO NO N/A YES Alphabetical listing of hymn titles placed as the final page of book (to assist congregation) ? YES NO YES N/A YES Includes a considerable number of Gregorian chant Masses ? YES YES YES YES NO Indices are easy to use for the “average” Catholic ? YES YES YES YES NO Includes dignified, truly congregational Mass settings in English by various Catholic composers ? YES YES YES NO NO Are hymn texts changed in order to be “politically correct” and support heterodox and/or “progressive” Theology ? NO NO NO N/A YES The lowest price (per pew book) for bulk orders ? $13.00 $11.96 $13.60 $21.95 $15.50 VATICAN II HYMNAL ADOREMUS HYMNAL ST. MICHAEL HYMNAL LUMEN CHRISTI MISSAL GIA WORSHIP IV The following chart was prepared by a member of the Church Music Association of America. It is a comparison chart of Catholic Hymnals, including the Vatican II Hymnal, Adoremus Hymnal, St. Michael’s Hymnal, Lumen Christi Missal, & GIA’s Worship IV Hymnal.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    877 views1 page

    Comparison Catholic Hymnals

    Uploaded by

    Jeff Ostrowski
    Corresponds to Roman Missal, 3rd Edition (“New Translation”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Includes complete readings which correspond to the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO YES YES Includes complete Responsorial Psalm texts with translations matching the current Catholic Lectionary ? YES NO NO NO NO Responsorial Psalm congregational melodies embdedded ? YES NO NO YES YES Complete Propers of the Mass included ? YES NO NO NO NO Partial and/or abridged Mass Propers included ? N/A NO YES YES NO Contains the Official ICEL Settings (“Missal Chants”) ? YES YES YES YES YES Complete organ accompaniments available ? YES YES YES NO YES Complete organ accompaniments free online ? YES NO NO NO NO Choral edition available ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains a sizeable collection of hymns for the Catholic Mass ? YES YES YES NO YES Contains only traditional hymns easy for congregation to sing ? YES YES NO N/A NO Contains hymns & songs written in a secular style ? NO NO YES NO YES Typesetting of all music is professional, unified, & pleasing ? YES YES YES YES YES Published with express permission of local Bishop ? YES YES YES YES YES Carefully & thoughtfully avoids all uneccessary page turns ? YES NO YES YES YES Layout is dignified & pleasing to the eye ? YES NO YES YES YES Includes traditional Catholic line art ? YES NO NO NO NO Hymns organized in a logical way, easy to “browse” and understand ? YES YES NO N/A YES Hymns provided for all Sundays & major liturgical feasts ? YES NO YES NO YES Includes hymn selections for Ordinary Time ? YES NO NO N/A YES Alphabetical listing of hymn titles placed as the final page of book (to assist congregation) ? YES NO YES N/A YES Includes a considerable number of Gregorian chant Masses ? YES YES YES YES NO Indices are easy to use for the “average” Catholic ? YES YES YES YES NO Includes dignified, truly congregational Mass settings in English by various Catholic composers ? YES YES YES NO NO Are hymn texts changed in order to be “politically correct” and support heterodox and/or “progressive” Theology ? NO NO NO N/A YES The lowest price (per pew book) for bulk orders ? $13.00 $11.96 $13.60 $21.95 $15.50 VATICAN II HYMNAL ADOREMUS HYMNAL ST. MICHAEL HYMNAL LUMEN CHRISTI MISSAL GIA WORSHIP IV The following chart was prepared by a member of the Church Music Association of America. It is a comparison chart of Catholic Hymnals, including the Vatican II Hymnal, Adoremus Hymnal, St. Michael’s Hymnal, Lumen Christi Missal, & GIA’s Worship IV Hymnal.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 1

    NA

    NA

    NA

    YM

    YM

    IM W O RS H

    IS IP IV

    The following chart was prepared by a member of the Church Music Association of America. It is a comparison chart of Catholic Hymnals, including the Vatican II Hymnal, Adoremus Hymnal, St. Michaels Hymnal, Lumen Christi Missal, & GIAs Worship IV Hymnal. Corresponds to Roman Missal, 3rd Edition (New Translation) ? Includes complete readings which correspond to the current Catholic Lectionary ? Includes complete Responsorial Psalm texts with translations matching the current Catholic Lectionary ? Responsorial Psalm congregational melodies embdedded ? Complete Propers of the Mass included ? Partial and/or abridged Mass Propers included ? Contains the Official ICEL Settings (Missal Chants) ? Complete organ accompaniments available ? Complete organ accompaniments free online ? Choral edition available ? Contains a sizeable collection of hymns for the Catholic Mass ? Contains only traditional hymns easy for congregation to sing ? Contains hymns & songs written in a secular style ? Typesetting of all music is professional, unified, & pleasing ? Published with express permission of local Bishop ? Carefully & thoughtfully avoids all uneccessary page turns ? Layout is dignified & pleasing to the eye ? Includes traditional Catholic line art ? Hymns organized in a logical way, easy to browse and understand ? Hymns provided for all Sundays & major liturgical feasts ? Includes hymn selections for Ordinary Time ? Alphabetical listing of hymn titles placed as the final page of book (to assist congregation) ? Includes a considerable number of Gregorian chant Masses ? Indices are easy to use for the average Catholic ? Includes dignified, truly congregational Mass settings in English by various Catholic composers ? Are hymn texts changed in order to be politically correct and support heterodox and/or progressive Theology ? The lowest price (per pew book) for bulk orders ?
    H II

    YM

    EL

    IC

    IC

    ST .M

    VA T

    EN

    RE

    LU

    YES YES YES YES YES N/ A YES YES YES YES YES YES NO YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES NO
    $13.00

    YES NO NO NO NO NO YES YES NO YES YES YES NO YES YES NO NO NO YES NO NO NO YES YES YES NO
    $11.96

    YES NO NO NO NO YES YES YES NO YES YES NO YES YES YES YES YES NO NO YES NO YES YES YES YES NO
    $13.60

    YES YES NO YES NO YES YES NO NO NO NO N/ A NO YES YES YES YES NO N/ A NO N/ A N/ A YES YES NO N/ A
    $21.95

    $ 1 5 .5 0

    GI
    YES YES NO YES NO NO YES YES NO YES YES NO YES YES YES YES YES NO YES YES YES YES NO NO NO YES

    CH

    RI

    ST

    SA

    You might also like