Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MAY, 2009
ii
DECLARATION
This proposal is my original work and has not been presented for a degree
in any other University.
Signature_______________________ Date______________________________
This proposal has been submitted for the review with our approval as
university supervisors.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION.....................................................................................................................ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS.......................................................................................................iii
ACRONYMS............................................................................................................................v
ABSTRACT............................................................................................................................vi
1.1 Introduction......................................................................................................................1
2.2.2 Reasons for choice of career options among secondary school students...................13
2.2.4 Factors related to educational, post-graduation and career intention of students ......15
APPENDICES........................................................................................................................29
A1: Tentative Chapterization...............................................................................................29
ACRONYMS
ABSTRACT
1.1 Introduction
Career choice or selection is one of the most important decisions in life that
all people irrespective of race, creed, and political conviction will have to
make at a fairly early stage in one’s life. Since we are defined in society by
what we are in terms of our occupations, one’s career then becomes a very
important source of a person’s identity. Indeed, deciding on ones life course
is a process that must of necessity happen early in life if one is to make any
useful impact to himself, family and to society at large. The life work actually
helps to shape a person’s identity as well as ones creativity and mastery.
The choice of an occupation may determine one’s employment status
(Hoppock, 1967). In some instances, based on occupational choices, one can
be either in irregular employment or in one that is both stable and secure.
Whereas some careers become vulnerable and may lose jobs during
economic downturns, others may even increase at such times (Hoppock,
1967).
One’s choice of occupation may also determine the extent to which they can
be considered as being successful or failures. Different occupations have
different demands and success is determined by ability to deliver results.
Therefore if one chose a career for which one is not suited, instances may be
when he is not able to deliver and thus be a failure. Work is not just a matter
of earning a living. Since it may be a life-long commitment, it is imperative
that one enjoys his work. If one is in a job he does not enjoy and is forced to
just go through the motions for the sake of earning a living, the life will
indeed be miserable (Hoppock, 1967). Therefore it is essential for one to
gauge their emotional and psychological fitness and disposition for a
particular job.
one will live, the kind of company one will keep, place where the children will
go to school and the frequency with which the family may move from place
to place (Hoppock, 1967). Other issues that may be influenced by one’s
occupation include values, ideals, standards and how a person will conduct
himself or herself in every day life. The amount of time one can spend with
his family as well as the social and economic status of his family will similarly
be impacted by his career choice. For instance, the life chances of a doctor
or a lawyer compared that of a cleaner or photographer will be quite
different. Ones occupation also provides a social circle or network within
which one can operate and define his life.
At the societal level, career choice will determine how a country will deploy
its manpower. The choices of individuals if not well synchronized may land a
society in a crisis if for example more people trained for scarce positions or if
not enough people trained for critical sectors such as nurses, teachers,
doctors, engineers and other professional categories. Occasionally in Kenya,
we have witnessed instances when too many teachers have trained to teach
specific subjects until there is an oversupply then people switch to another
crisis subject again until it is flooded before moving on to another area.
Moreover, little is known about the occupational plans and aspirations as well
as the career development process and choices of youth in secondary
4
schools in Rongo district. Little research has been done to document these
issues. It is with this in mind that this study has been designed to help in
filling this gap by providing information on the career plans and aspiration of
secondary school students in Rongo District. The purpose of this study,
therefore, is to provide information on the career occupational plans,
aspirations and the factors that are significantly associated with those
intentions.
Career decision making and choice are important factors in determining the
eventual occupations that youth will settle for. A good proportion of qualified
youth may be unemployed not because of lack of opportunities but because
of lack of fit between their qualifications and existing job opportunities. This
study will seek to compare the career choices and intentions of secondary
school students with existing employment opportunities to identify any fit or
lack of it. The results of such an effort may be useful in orienting youth
career decision making processes and specification towards occupational
categories that are experiencing growth and expansion within and without
the Kenyan economy.
Since no study of this kind has been conducted within Rongo District, this
study will provide a good opportunity to make such information available.
The knowledge of career choices and intentions of youth will contribute
significantly to the literature on youth career decision making processes and
factors that significantly influence those processes. This information will be
useful in providing a body of literature for reference and for guiding future
research into this area.
The originality of the study is that it will gather original data from students in
Rongo and Uriri Districts. It will also be unique in the way data will be
analysed. The research will try to analyse the findings to glean information in
ways that have not been done before in Kenya in this particular area of
study. Similarly, value has been added in that the study will try to relate the
finings of the study to the labor market whereby the choices/intentions of
students will be compared to various occupational categories. The effort will
be to compare those choices to see whether they are in keeping with trends
in terms of sectors promising growth and expansion in terms of manpower
needs.
The other proposed theory is Hollands’ personality type theory that focuses
on various personality traits and values as key influences in career choice
and development. He views various career choices as reflections of various
personality types. In this sense, individuals choose careers that will allow
them to remain themselves. The theoretical framework seeks to match
certain personality types with vocations that will allow for people to express
themselves. Finally, since both theories focus mostly on the personality
traits, interests, and values while ignoring broader social issues, models that
take such factors into account like the family, peers, schools and the broader
society will be incorporated (Santrock, 1996; Steinberg, 1993).
The theoretical models to consider also include the social cognitive career
theory, the status-attainment theory and the symbolic interactionist model
as propounded by George Herbert Mead.
6
Person Inputs Contextual Influences Proximate
Predispositions to Choice Behaviour
Gender Self-Efficacy
Race/Ethnicity
Expectations
Disability
Health Status
2.1 Introduction
Students in secondary schools have various career aspirations and plans that
they would wish to pursue soon after high school and also occupational goals
for the long-term. Whereas some would wish to proceed with high education
at either both middle level colleges and universities, others would wish to
enter into the job market immediately. In a study of 232 form three students
from Kereri and Nyabururu girls secondary schools in Kisi District, Obonyo
(1994), more than half (56%) intended to proceed to university, 38 percent
middle level colleges and 6 percent (7 for Kereri) would opt for direct
employment. In a similar study by Kibera (1993), more students from well
staffed and better equipped schools preferred university education whereas
12
the others preferred training for jobs. She also found out that students
generally do not prefer salaried employment immediately after school even
though those who were in public non-national and private schools would
favour the salaried jobs option than their national school counterparts.
With regard to career expectations, the most important careers for the
students in both schools were nursing (32 percent for Nyabururu and 30
percent for Kereri) followed by medicine (23; 13); teaching (2; 16); law (14;
8) accountancy (10; 6) and secretarial (2;8) (Obonyo, 1994). Another study
conducted in Nigeria (Oladejo, 1977) revealed that 81.3 percent out of a
sample of 353 students aspire to pursue higher education while only 27 or
6.5 percent aspired to enter the labor market. Twenty five or 5 percent
expressed a desire to enter the labour force and continue with further
studies on a part time basis underscoring the importance the group attached
to further studies.
all the female pupils. The others are law (13%), nursing (12.2%), journalism
(11.3%), accountancy (9.2), teaching (8.8%) whereas the least favored are
aviation (0.4%), computer engineering (0.4%) and architecture (0.8%).
Nyanjom, (2007) obtained findings that reflect nearly the same findings as
the foregoing studies. According to her research whose purpose was to
investigate the extent to which career guidance services provided in
secondary schools influenced student career choices, the top five preferred
occupations were medicine 33 percent, teaching 31 percent, business
management 27 percent, law 22 percent and engineering 14 percent. The
total sample size was 1030 students. It can be concluded generally that the
students prefer medicine, law and teaching across the board whereas the
majority also tend to disfavor architecture and computer studies which
actually appear in the low rank category.
In this section, review is done to document what has been discovered with
regard to the reasons why the students in previous researches have chosen
the specific occupations and also their plans immediately the complete
secondary school. According to Nyanjom (2007), among the students who
preferred employment after school, the main reasons were due to the fact
that they lacked capital for starting a business (36.7%), prospects of being
promoted to higher grades (23.3%) and the opportunity to earn allowances
(15.4%). In a study by Obonyo (1994), those who wanted to go to
employment immediately after high school talked about the need to support
their parents and siblings and also being tired of further studies. They
needed a break from academic work.
Those who desired to proceed to tertiary education talked about influence
from home, expectations from parents, role modeling by their older siblings
and also the need to have a brighter future (Obonyo, 1994).
In a study by Nyanjom, (2000) besides reasons relating to whether they
intended to proceed with higher education or go into employment, the
14
students also provided reasons for choosing specific career options. These
reasons mentioned cut across and were synthesized from the responses by
students irrespective of career choice. Among the most important reasons
for choice of a particular career, they students mentioned the possibility of
further studies 60 percent or 844 students. The other important reason was
job security with more than half of the respondents (51.3%) choosing this
option. Other reasons included the need to use special talents (44.8%), the
fact that the occupation is interesting (40.4%) opportunity for creativity
(32.6%), opportunity to work with others (27.7%), ease of availability of free
time (11.7%) and absence of supervision (6%).
Additionally, Nyanjom (2007) documented some interesting findings that
arose for various specific careers. Among those who wanted to do medicine,
the main motivations were the desire to help save lives, prestige and the
availability of employment opportunities after graduation or marketability of
the course. Among those who chose teaching as a career, the unique
reasons were to help reduce illiteracy and help promote the progress of the
country. Those who opted for business or entrepreneurship mention the need
to be self-employed, their good performance in business oriented subjects
and the realization of a life dream (Nyanjom, 2007). Furthermore, those who
wanted to be lawyers in future talked about the prestige that comes with
legal qualifications as well as encouragement from family members. Finally,
those who would go into engineering also talked about the passion for
mathematics and physics, the fact that engineering is interesting and
encouragement from family and relatives. (Nyanjom, 2007).
Engineering also talked about the passion for mathematics and physics, the
fact that engineering is interesting and encouragement from family and
relatives (Nyanjom, 2007).
15
There are various factors that have been identified to relate significantly with
the educational, post-graduation and career intentions of secondary
students. Among these factors are gender, age, parents’socio-economic
status (SES), parents’ occupation, school type, performance in examinations
and perceived self-efficacy. Some of these factors are discussed below.
Gender
Among the factors that relate significantly to career aspirations, gender is a
prominent one. In a study by Obura (2007), female students were more
inclined towards biological science whereas male students were had a
leaning towards the physical sciences. Whereas medicine, law and nursing
were more popular among female students, laws medicine and engineering
were more popular among the male students. Less popular were design,
architecture, and computer science. There also appeared to emerge gender
stereotyping of some careers. Whereas subjects such as nursing and
journalism were stereotyped as predominantly female, engineering,
architecture, aviation, business, computer science and armed forces were
perceived as being male careers. The most stereotyped courses however
were nursing and engineering which were considered female and male
domains respectively whereas those considered gender neutral were law,
design, medicine and teaching.
Further, Obura (2007) reports that 59.7 percent of males hoped to join
careers that were considered stereotypically neutral compared to 63.8
percent for females. Females who reported interest in careers that were
stereotyped as feminine were nearly four times more than males who
considered joining the same careers.
Kibera (1993) also had interesting findings with regard to gender and career
and educational aspirations. In mixed schools, a comparison between male
and female students, the latter were found to have both low educational
expectations and career aspirations compared to the former. Whereas the
males preferred to proceed to university, the females would rather opt for
16
job training. Males were also more likely to prefer professional jobs
compared to females who preferred clerical jobs. Similar findings were
obtained by Oladejo (1977) who revealed that among students who
preferred construction related careers, 31 males against 3 females aspired to
do architecture; 40 males against 4 females engineering. For those who
preferred medical related courses, 45 males compared to 10 females desired
to enroll in medicine whereas only 5 females and no males were considering
joining nursing. Therefore, even though the data clearly revealed a
disposition of secondary students towards professional categories, there
were clear gender differences (Oladejo, 1977).
Age
Age is another important factor considered as a source of difference in the
career intentions and educational aspirations of secondary school students in
Rongo and Uriri Districts. In terms of comparing the students based on age,
Kibera (1993) found out that younger students prefer university education as
compared to older ones who prefer to train for jobs. Salaried employment
and self employment, even though identified by Kibera (1993) as generally
less favoured are also more likely to be preferred by older students
compared to younger ones. Other materials reviewed, especially local
materials did not have age as an important predictor variable.
School Type
The type of school seems to influence career choice and educational plans of
secondary school students in that students from well staffed and well
equipped schools tend to have preference for university education compared
to their counterparts from well less well endowed schools. For instance,
Kibera (1993) found out that there were differences in students’ career
choice based on the types of schools they attended. Even though secondary
school students in her study generally preferred to proceed with higher
education as opposed to enter into employment, when type of school is
controlled for, those in public non-national and private schools tend to have
more preference for salaried employment compared to those in national and
17
3.1 Introduction
This chapter presents a discussion on the research design, the site of the
study, the study population, the units of analysis, sampling techniques and
sample size, the methods of data collection, data analysis and ethical
considerations. Methodological assumptions and limitations will also be
discussed.
The population of this study will be all secondary students in both day and
boarding secondary schools in and Rongo and Uriri Districts. However, the
19
accessible population will be those from the selected public schools for this
study. The selection of schools shall be by Stratified random sampling.
Rongo and Uriri districts have a total of 53 secondary schools of which 46 are
public and 7 private. Of the public schools, there are ten (10) boys’, five (5)
girls’ and 31 mixed secondary schools. The total enrolment is 14,318
students of which 4,428 or 31% are female and 9,890 (69%) are male
(District Education Office, Rongo, 2008).
N
size shall be 398 students based on the equation n = 2 . The level of
1 + N ( e)
precision shall be taken to be ±5 with the confidence or risk level being 95%
and the degree of variability assumed to be 0.5. An additional 30% of n will
be added to the sample to cater for nonresponses.
Both Qualitative and quantitative data shall be collected. The instruments for
data collection will be a self-response structured questionnaire to collect
data from students; in-depth interview, with key opinion leaders, teachers
and parents; and Focus Group discussions to collect data from students and
community members. There will be document review especially of
government documents. Case studies of some students shall also be
collected to provide an in-depth understanding of the process of developing
career intentions of secondary school students in Rongo District, Kenya.
assistants who will help with the process of administering the instruments.
Before embarking on the exercise, there shall be thorough training for the
assistants and consultation between the researcher and the research
assistants. Data collected shall be clearly grouped based on the schools and
they will be reviewed for any anomalies so that any corrective measures can
be undertaken as quickly as possible. Each category of school shall be
allocated a quota of the total sample and it is from these that information
shall be collected.
Data from key informant interviews and focus group discussions (FGD) shall
be recorded in notebooks and if permission is granted on audio tape. The
demographic characteristics of participants in FGD will be recorded in a
separate sheet and as much as possible, responses shall be tied to the
respondents’ characteristics. FGD and in-depth interview guides will be
developed which collect answers that are relevant to the study.
has been conducted to ensure that what the study finally adopts has been
used elsewhere and is generally agreed to measure the concepts under
consideration. Internal consistency will be ensured by use of several items to
provide responses to the same variable where such a procedure is possible.
With regard to content validity or the degree to which the concepts tested
are adequately measured, multiple indicators as well as existing instruments
will be used (Burton, 2000).
A pilot study will be conducted before actual research is done to test the
instruments in terms of their relevance, simplicity, length of time taken to
complete them and whether they are capable of yielding the required
outputs. The pilot study will also provide an opportunity for the researcher
and his assistants to understand and internalize the process of data
collection with regard to the study. Any challenges to the study will be
documented and important lessons will be learnt with a view to making the
real study more efficient. The pilot study will be done with similar
populations to the target population. It shall be done in secondary schools in
and Rongo districts which are not part of the study. The outputs from the
pilot study will be analyzed and examined for any need for changes to be
done. If the outcome is satisfactory, then preparation shall be made to
conduct the real research.
Data will be coded, through creation of a codebook and entered directly into
the analysis software, Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS)
version 16.0. The created data set will then be cleaned for potential coding
errors or those arising from entry before embarking on analysis. An initial
24
deviation and the mode. A significance level of 0.05 will be adopted for both
bivariate comparisons and multivariate analyses.
Qualitative data gathered through key informant interviews and FGDs shall
be analysed by use of incomplete
They will be told the purpose of the research during the introductions and
formation of rapport and their participation will be voluntary and not
influenced by any means. They will opt to participate or not to participate on
their own volition. The respondents will not be deceived as to the purpose of
the research but the researcher and his assistants will deal with them
transparently and honestly, making them fully aware of the purpose and
goals of the study.
The researcher and the study will preserve confidentiality and privacy of the
respondents and that they will treat the participants with a lot of courtesy
and respect. They will not be viewed as subjects for the study but as active
26
References:
APPENDICES
1
0 Presenting Draft Thesis to Supervisors 3 months August - October, 2010
1 Presentation of findings to
1 Department 1 week November, 2010
1
3 Thesis Defence at Graduate School 2 months April - May, 2011
1
4 Binding of Corrected Copies 2 weeks June, 2011
1
5 Graduation October, 2011
31
Induction of research 1
team
Research Instruments
District________________________School__________________________
Type of School________________________Form____________________________
QUESTIONNAIRE
7. What are your reasons for your choice of the highest level of education
you would want to attain? (Mention the three most important
reasons).
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
34
_______________________________________________________________________
____
35
c. Twice a month
d. Once or more times a week (specify__________)
15. Are your parents_______________?
a. Both alive
b. Only Father alive
c. Only Mother alive
d. None alive
16. Where is your normal place of residence?
a. Agricultural Estate
b. Roadside
c. Urban/Town
d. Rural (Subsistence Farm)
17. What is your mother’s highest level of education?
a. None
b. Primary
c. Secondary
d. College (Specify)_________________________________
e. University (underline the level that applies: undergraduate/first
degree, masters degree, Phd/Doctoral degree)
18. What is your father’s highest level of education?
a. None
b. Primary
c. Secondary
d. College (Specify)_________________________________
e. University (underline the level that applies: First degree, Masters
degree, Phd (doctorate)
19. What would you say is the socio-economic status of your family?
a. Poor (Low)
b. Average (Middle)
c. Rich (High)
20. What is your comment on the strictness of your parents
a. Much more easy going
37
Mother
Father
None
27. Who else has talked to you about careers/occupations?
Teachers
Siblings (brother/sister)
Career counsellor
Pastor
Friend
Guest speaker in school
Other (specify) ___________________________________
28. What is your fathers’ occupation (e.g. teacher, doctor, nurse,
lawyer, farmer)
OCCUPATIONAL ASPIRATIONS/INFORMATION
32. Have you learnt about the occupational options available to you?
a. Yes
b. No (go to question 37)
33. If you have ever heard about occupational options available to
you, which was the most important source of this information?
39
37. What would you say is your subject orientation (select only one)
a. Science and mathematics related areas
b. Humanities (Arts, literature)
c. Languages (English, Kiswahili, French)
d. Social Sciences (economics, business studies, psychology,
sociology, anthropology)
e. Other (specify)_________________________________________________
38. How are the subjects you are studying relevant to your career
aspirations
a. Very relevant
b. Relevant
40
c. Moderately relevant
d. Irrelevant
e. Very irrelevant
39. Indicate whether the following are very important (VI), important (I),
unimportant (U) or very unimportant (VU) to you. Circle one that
closely applies to you).
a. Making a lot of money ( VI I U VU )
b. Opportunities to be original and creative ( VI I U
VU )
c. Opportunities to help others ( VI I U VU )
d. Avoiding high pressure jobs ( VI I U VU )
e. Working in the world of ideas ( VI I U VU )
f. Freedom from close supervision ( VI I U
VU )
g. Opportunities for steady progress rather than
the chance for extreme success and failure ( VI I U
VU )
h. Being a leader ( VI I U VU )
i. Opportunities to work with people rather than
things ( VI I U VU )
j. Having a position that is looked upto by others ( VI I U
VU )
k. Having a relatively secure job. ( VI I U
VU )
40. How important are your studies to you?
a. Very important
b. Important
c. Moderately important
d. Unimportant
e. Very unimportant
41. How would you rate your performance in academic work in your
class
41
a. Very Good
b. Good
c. Average
d. Poor
e. Very Poor
42. What would your parents expect you to do after high school
a. Look for a job
b. Go into self-employment
c. Go to university
d. Further training
e. Not aware
f. Other (Specify)____________________________________________
43. What are your plans after high school?
a. Proceed to University
b. Proceed to a Middle Level College
c. Start a family
d. Engage in business
e. Look for a job
f. Train for a job
g. Other (Specify)________________________________________________
42
44. What are the three most important reasons for your plan after
high school?
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________
_____
45. What is your dream occupation/career? Select the one that best
describes your desire
a. Medicine
b. Law
c. Engineering (which one e.g. mechanical________________________)
d. Nursing
e. Teaching
f. Piloting an Airplane
g. Accounting
h. Business
i. Architecture
j. Actuarial Science
k. An Economist
l. A Sociologist
m. A Nutritionist
n. A Journalist
o. Others
(specify)____________________________________________________
46. What are the three most important reasons for your choice of career?
a. ____________________________________________________________
b. ____________________________________________________________
c. ____________________________________________________________
47. In case you do not get to join your dream career, which other three
careers would, you opt for in order of preference?
43
a. _________________________________________________________________
_
b. _________________________________________________________________
_
c. _________________________________________________________________
48. According to you, which is the best career/occupation?
________________________
49. What are your reasons for your view that that is the best career
option?
a. ____________________________________________________________
b. ____________________________________________________________
c. ____________________________________________________________
50. What would be your preferred employment sector?
a. Armed Forces (Military)
b. Civil Service
c. Parastatal Sector
d. Private Sector (specify area of
speciality)_____________________________________
e. Civil Society (NGOs)
f. Teaching Primary)
g. Teaching (Secondary)
h. Teaching (University)
i. Press (Media House)
j. International Organizations (e.g. World Bank, UN, IMF, ICC)
k. Other (Specify)______________________________________
51. What other two employment sectors would you resort if you did
not get your best choice above?
a. Armed Forces (Military)
b. Civil Service
c. Parastatal Sector
d. Private Sector
e. Civil Society (NGOs)
44
f. Teaching Primary)
g. Teaching (Secondary)
h. Teaching (University)
i. Press (Media House)
j. Other (Specify)______________________________________
52. Why would you prefer to work in that sector (Tick three most important
reasons)
a. Higher Salary
b. Just interested
c. Respectable and prestigious
d. Security of employment
e. To share knowledge with others
f. Others
(specify)_____________________________________________________
53. Do you think males and females are capable of performing in the same
occupations equally?
a. Yes
b. No
c. Don’t know
54. Do you think there are careers/occupations that are exclusively
male
a. Yes
b. No
c. Don’t Know
55. If you think that there are occupations that are exclusively male,
please list at least five
a. _______________________________________________________
b. _______________________________________________________
c. ________________________________________________________
d. ________________________________________________________
e. _______________________________________________________
f. ___________________________________________________________
45
Thank you for agreeing to take part in the project. Before we start, I would like to
emphasize that:
Please sign this form to show that I have read the contents to you.
____________________________________________________ (Signature)
____________________________________________________(Name)
_____________________________________________________(Date)
47
Please send a report on the results of the project (please circle one) Yes
No
Email address____________________________________________