'lJj .~L...u.. ..:..I-'->J 1+ol:!~J ~I ~I..J.I J.aj W .-,....:J1 __.L.....'lJ1 .;~."..,.L...... ~I ~):;'lJ1 ).lL....,J.1 -0.1 _,.. ~I_,jl J.

aj I~ .l,Jl> L.l411 .r.')~I..r)"_,:",,, yo l4A ~I ,).>,_.JI..r ~1..J.1.jA''>-& 1.>1.>...:.1..Jl.U> .~t:i~1 ,.>~ L>..J.._, .,>;t:il ~ ~'lJ L.,...:...r"' ),.> ~L;.;.... 4,;,),JI ........ ..r .~.3I_,j1 _,.:u. ..... I)J..I ....... L....i.S .'l..~1 ~;l~)I1 ~WI, ..:..~I~ .... 1..1.> J;.W1.!.I4'l db ~ •• _,..,..,..,.JI ~J.:.~

Abstract, The most important archueological source material related 10 the IInCi1'1I1 Pt'OI'/e cametrom cctnrteries. The undisturbed burials and theirfinds IfUH' be regarded 11.1 cultural units. indispensablct:» anv INIous archaeological analysis. According 10 archaeological .1 till rccs. there are tl vubstanuully treater number of graves ill Sudan than what currently available archueoloeicul luerature would ,1111(1;<"/. III l'1I1I1I'(1\1. there are verI' fl.'lI' archaeological theones and approaches whic hare used 1I.f (/ base of studv ofthese <,,''''£'/,'1'1<:1. III [his paper IH' will discuss the role of archaeologtcul theones IIl1d upproac lie» 1Tl III( uurrpr ,'WI,,/11 (Ii' {//I, ctent Sudanese cemeteries during the period between 131100 8.C lind 04,0. 5S0.

__,I_p, __...l.:. ~~I ..? ~1J.l1 ~i .('Lc. ~j ~.J.4J1 '-i~1 ~I .:...;,.. ...L.....l1 .j'-'_,...JI t:=.;t.:. uA ;~J..Li.A :.Ji.,_,...JI..r ~I JJ->-..u ;'_;;"LJI ;;_,:.;JI ~J ',,.rI£':1'1

'c"0A' ..)l c" J....;.JI \,. uA ;;...L.....l1 '~I '="

.~..ul 0-A :;..1"""':""" lLL....i ;u.__,_bJ1 :;~I.~.:,,~

Ji ~~I Jl ~I ~I.:"I:' ,,-=-"L5_rl1 J)l:JI..:.J.......:. ..r FJJ . .:.>L..I~'::.'IJ . ._,.J..L..lIJ ~_;--AJI .:,,1.> Jl ~..I.........:..l1 ~I..ul 4lts:..,;,iJ ._rI1..Li.1 u_'_"""'_".ji .jl:->-'::.'I:_. ... ~ ;;~ ~I..L>_'.~ ~L,... ~ )L~.b <..J~..l....i! .4...,p..)GJIJ

J..lLi .J-!1..Li.1 ~L5 ~I I_..,.J" ~11.>_,....J1 0')u.r ;;~.J...>. ..1..>Ls' 4-;..11 )L..;.,,_, .~':l" .!:..~~I ..r L..L> ;u..LA...,. w.,J-oJ .':"I)~IJ .:.>L"LA.:JI ~ ..? ~I .:.>L.......JI ,~I ..? ~I -?JI . .J-! 1..Ll 1 L..1).l ~L..a .:"..>........:;

.~L,.:....oJ ;;.l.....:i.,o J~ .:.>1..1 ~",,,"":";I_' ~t.i.:,,~

..? ~l:;'il ~WIJ .:.>l:J..h.J1 )J.l ~I I~ J,L.::uJ ;;~I .~I cT .~..ull <..JI..I_,.._.JI -.r :_. .. I..Li.1 ..,....._, ~ ._;JI ;_r:;....J1 ~J'~ QA·..,,-Jlp _,.JI ('.J.....Ji ,r ';1)-"" uA

v

JL5J ~...J...CJI <..JL.....,~'I;;~ ~L...o...l"" ~.......JI ~ ,_9~_,.J1 w,,)..u :_. .. I..Li.I..? J-.....a.ll ~ I~_r-A .(;t,.I ..... ..r ) L:.':ii' 1 .~ )_,..h:J1 r--')..r ~1..J.1..r ~L..._.,jl ,~I ~ ~~ ,~..u.I1 .:"I)~I...,..... ~I ~ ~j ,,-?)~I ,,_,L ~WIJ )~I "' ..... l.....a ~.:....LS L...."..I ~~ ..ill..>; ~ .)t.':II'1 ~ ~~;I _;J' ~_L •• ::JI ~;-lI~;"""":')1 r:5' ,~'lJ1 ~ ... :il.IIJ '_'~I~ ... ~I.:....b...,_,.. ._rI1J.l1 ~

.;;)~I....tt.........:s..r l"4-i L.. • .:.>W,_,:-....J.I.>~

...... I..Li.1 ~ ~ ~ _~ ~.r5) ~11.>~1 ~ ;,rS-J,1 _~I '<~ ~ ,<..:J1 .:.>4~1, ._.l_,.,_....ll.ill.:i ~l_,. ~I ",..:JIJ .( Rei-ner, 1407-1 I ) <..J1.l,_...J1 ....... .,,)~I .~..ulI,_,1..1,_....J1 ;;)~! ~L:;J .,r':'_,.L;.J1 ~_,...;.:JI C:"""J..r

,.t,.~.."... ~I ~ .~I..:....bL...J

4;~

I I

------_.------------------,

..... ,. ."

.

"

. - --~

• .

.

"

.'

. ,

j

. .

. ,

A

J.:.......l A' •• url!' ... _,_..w~! . );:;J .(' ~, tl_,J.' ,illj ~ ~...:ul ~~, ~, ~l+o ~I by ~..,. ~)4l.' ..,..rAJlt ;';'~'.ill:; ~~I..J.I ~,;.....~I.UhaI .....9~J l...ih ~~IJ ~ ~ ~._)L .~~' ~:r ~ ~ ~ 011 ._..I..:-. ;.,j~1 .' .;_,:u..j.' w _,.ll.. ~ Ji 1.).e .)I~I ,;,loP 'y~...I.I1 ~-,.~ )lS

.!..p..LA ~ a,!,~~'1 ~ ,_,.., ..... ~I..!l1.:i~ .J:'.,s..J.' :~~yt~y~L,.~~~b' 11..,.L:.~

• J

~J ~JL.;.1 .... ~ JS4+lI.!.l1:; ~ J.>b L,.i..o "\ .:...j1S

.LU,;..?.:.. ~I ~ ~l clLl_jj,..:.. 1>-"" y~

.( ndorf, 1 tl) ~~I

~I VA ~1..u.14r ~)l...!lI..:..L.:.~I~:.u..:...>L..S

)~1 ~~l ~ ..? ~ 1 t:'...;l:;jl J.:JI L. ..::.~ ..:..~~I ~...I.I14.b' ......ll~ L,....i..-_"..(r' .. ,i-' .. e .. )a..:Jl:J ~_,.;l' ~ ~i lA.S . .rS_~1 L.iJL... ~I ~ j)l!o'l' ~ <?~IJ .~1 ~_,.;JI ~ .j'p"J1 ~I t:'_;W L~~ t....1

~~I ~I ~ (Qadan) ~LiJ' ~ ;U~ ~ ~'J'(f""JA'" ~J I"· .. ~,r»~ I~.J......IJI _...-...ll,.( j o· .. - j II' .. ~''''''' ..b........y' ~~1 ~;--:..-a,.( j " .. '-0'" ~I'_'" ~....._..jl.,?~' .. J 100'- .j "fA" ._.Jt_,_) (r;: • ..,.. .1) ..:..L.:.~I ""':;)~j.( J '0"- J 0" ';'p-)~~''>~' .j .L..~~,.( Yo.-,,-jVtV~''''''')-,FJ''''''''J~ ~I.( 00'- 'r • .,,),,..,..)( - roup)(->,,)~~l,. ~)L.;;J' ~1..J.,1'_':;-'-' ~...;WJ' ~ Lo V'" o~)lI..,...4...>J1

. ..)\.),....." .;a ~~1

~ ';'.)_,_..!I";L.....!. ~1..J.1 ........ j.£.~'..s~

endorf.j ~~ J.:t..- -.,91_,_.. ~ .~I ~_,...l ~"JI~~.)"..,... ...... .r&IL...L...1r.'.)'f! . ,,(1 a ~ UL..'LiJ~, .(Wend rf, 196 b: 869- 75)

4-! ..w:-.J <?' ~''- jA Le-I ~, ~I .).l - I

~I

Wendorf and hild:) : )~') Lf.ct....O.nJS~1 ~L.oI ~~ .,-!~' ~ ... ~ .. ~ ~ ,I JS.o:.H

.(2 : Y

,

1 'r IfJ 20()

;~

~ ..

( ! \

. .. _.l r>" I ,L.41 ,~~~

I,

II 1 I'll hxpcdit i In 'I-'I-

t I ;o_:..; .)

jA ~ _'

? I .andmu 1,111 IOlnt E pedruon : JI' 1

~I' -

....,\.... 4-1 I ._,5.; , ... :

'I uo....J. ..:.

..... J

<. ulturul HI)1ll0~ nc- I _~~ _ ...... ........J1.r ~;.> ~ endort I ')f, <II LA ",-:!~~;-u--1 pl •

1-

"

.':;I.,)U:.J~~I""~I~I~~~,:",",,,L.. ! ~.4.....I.)..uIV--~II~,:","", i)~ .'J<l.....w.. .);'WJ.IL..I.).,)~~'~WI.::...u......:; ~)'II~ ~~I.iJ.!'~.;;~.fi""J~~4.:i~,

~~1:J1 ;u:...~1 .;. ~

.1') • .JSJl ;; - ·...........£ZJt:. ..!.ll...UI· ' .. c ... 1 - ~

.),) ~..r .. '-r - ~»-' C"" J-' )

':"U'iI...,..L..:. .~ .. .L .. i ~ (\ o"JL..,;.JI) ,Jo~I';~

..)!'_""W.~ ..... ~ ~.~I.::..~.,I ""~~ ~~I ~I.J~ ~ -r-~ )l1.:..,.~1.).c. -3~1 ~l~;;~!d • - - ,!,11J~,.~....__j1 ~I,.I....A'::""""':" ...1...:9, • (KrzY7..aniak: 1992: 267·17. ) ~J ..... I.;...,i ~;I..)l..,...L-)!1 1j"A ~ ;;~I J,)..IS.II ~~ ~IS.l.I ~,:JL,. L.:oA':il ~ t...S .~~~I .!..~ 'I .. I;-:J ~I .JL>. ~l ~ .~I l.u ~::" . ~~ • ,HLAlI ~.,rJt .~I .,)...t...:.j ~~I tL..:il..,.J.c. ~ ~ ~.J.£...).c. ~ .,?~I ~ V-- ~l .~I ~ .1.+--1;.> J~I.J!)l..:;..>'i ~IJ .,),.J-~ ~)' HW1..r J9i

.""j.>~I..,...I.....~I~ ."-~'~J..I!

'J,).JSJt .~ ~ LoS .... ",I"' ... ll" .!:.:!......",.,I ~~I~' 4----01,) ~ 4_,,".d.~1 .::..4)") t!)i .)A IJA ",,1 ~ .!..U~1.,o .r.'L..iJ.I .,..;.c.l...r" ~J":'u...... ~LS~' u~1 (;;~I)..:J~I~)~ ~.jll:.i ~I, .~_;j4J1

. (Kn}'zaniak: 199 : 270)

~_,....:ol1 ~ ,:;,..u.! ~4 ...cI41..H)~ J..)4 ..LSJ .(Ibid: 270) ~1 4.....j\.....j~, ~~ t '~4""1 ..;. iOj-S..r:a' .!.Jl!J1 ~l ~'..I...A._,...1.C.1 ul.;o~1 L..S ..)) 0J.,)Y"':"".:u, .,)1~ I ~ ..Jw .• ~I.)A ~ .'~i .l,_N ~ .... ~ ~~I ~~I ",_...JI ~~ ~ .;.lUI ~ ~~ ":!l.,_.:J' J' . ..!:..C;~, ~1 iO~1 .);'LAlI o~ , ... d .. ~)l1 ~ ~..u' a..A....bJ1 jA .,)t~l._..Jl . .,?j:>~

.~~"_:'.~ .... i")J-> f'~ .::..LI~)'I~.l.A ,-.Ai, W .~ .::..'~l".....?')ll ~I ........ ~ .::..~~ .)~j ~J ~,,_;J' r;;.J-AJ'( an \u.19 - :21-24) ""w........JI 'i"" .( I U,JWI) ( r clI.I949:3J-_5)

.(~I.::..~)~. ~'..=.l:.~lm~J ~,H ",,~I ~I ..... ' ....... ~ ~ ~..ul ~,..oJ.>, ~I".,I ~I ,I .~, ~J..I, L...1)...uI.:r- 4JQ.>.

~~ ~~I ~3 'I'!..LAJI ~l. ~.::..4-...,.J! J"....,,u 4...-1)~,. -~J ...... w..~1 ....._,),)~..:.U.,)..Y' ~ !L..S.4J~,,!I.::..)b~I,~......oJI.::..~1

I .::..\.:.~~JI ~I)..u ~ ,)L;...cl rkell 1949; an va 19 . )

~I,.. ~ I~ ~I.)-t"":'b ~ ...3~1 ~I oUj ,_.k .:.JJ.) t...S. Jr· . ~ ... ) ~..LaoJ1 ~~I ~l

.;~ ~I, . 'J...s:J1 ..AIr" ~ ~I Jl....J:.i ..ill~

. zani k: 1992. n va: I

Remold: 19 7.).,?.;......!,.,;A ...,...~I.,o .~'~.lIJ ~L....Jlj IJ~'~"'~ . .J'p",,~1.u.1,,':""'~1~,.(1991 r:-L ~;~I v-" , .. LS; ,I ~~ ,..s...r ..,.._JWI ~ .~.,?';L-..~~J~o....o.:-1l ..... -,:!1.......;,;;t ~1 ;,1....- I,.".wl...r ~ I.. ~.J .~~b ~ Jl ~,..) ~~I..,..." ... II, ~L-oJ' ..rIJ~1 ~~~i'", . .,),.0. ... .11,

•

~~IJ ~ .... IJ,) IJ ~~I ,:,.._,J;;.JI .::..G.,sJ

JI~' ~4 ~ .);'Ul.1 .,~..?' ~ L-.S . Lo.~j ':U'.r-" .J-t-"- ~,~,,?,. 1...L~·IJ ..,..)lSJ1 JS~, .,)"',.o.t...U_, t~ .11..=.LI~I-ill.:; ~i.."J! ~ ~)_, ..).c. -?~ ~I..I...A..).c. ~ ·..ill~..)1 UL.o' .~~4J1 ~I~' .~~ L_)~ ~ -#..ul .."..!Jl .~~ ;' J.!~~ ~_,.~':l;;~"""'t-",,~.::..~'-?I.~I

.(._; 10' -""0' ) .... ~.;.)LA>.~~.r._".,l"...

.:,i ~ t...... )L.L.:. ........:; ....:il.?1 .~r41 ~I .)~j ,.....,....~ ~.~1iI1~~~.:,,1.S~11~ '.r4)11 j.:oLWI

~~~J...ISu~.r (Y ~I)asJ..I5'~~~v' ., ~~~~ ~""'~j .~";~'I '4..yS c:e~ ;:"..o...,.~L,. (RcinoJd: 19(1) ~'r,..s..~I';L-!.(Cancva: 19 . 1994) ~I

c)

~~~~4i~~.r11...,.L:.,.~_,J.I~~

~I~~J.)~Il..!..lL.;...o.0L.S.j,ji)lI.;,;; ';1- ~ 4 I.L-' . ·<1 WAI r_-ras .ua.;b..:.':'. .1. ,. ~~ r -r--'J .. -r- ~~~

.:,,~I ~~Ij J-iL.Ul,. .. f~ '. 1 ~tj' I ";'~j

.)..\ . ..JI J~ ~ .~I 4.:.4 ~ Lal .(R inold: 2 ~I.).) a,,1 .1..-.1 <».) ~.J.:ooJ1 ~~I ~I .;el..u. ~I ~~I.:.......)~ ..r..U~.:,.c. L..;,,~J'~ 1 ~I I.:u.;:"..o

U<.....JI,~J~'~~~)lIF.~~)I . ~~ :?.>-? ~I D~)l1 t"+-i uJ.( aneva: 19 ) :? ~ ..;.L.c.~ ~'.J.jJ1 ,>£.,1.1 ~ ..;.I~I uk~.)~~I~u..~ .~,.uLI~I~~J.~~~1

.( 'neva: 1994: 2) ~~I J..~iJ ~l,.;J1

~I.).....,. ~w. ~L.;...,..;.~ J#;YO ~_,JI ~J

.:,,1 ~ j.S..;; ..,..:<JI_, .;~~, ..:.I,_:....JI ~ ~4J1 ..:.1.> ..;.U4-JIJ .~I u~ ~ ~ ",I ~ ;;~I ~ ~ .~b""'1 ~WI . i ~ . .:,~ ~~)l1 ~1..;.w4 ~~4.ll ~I,~I..;.~~I LAl'4..~1 ~1.O11).~ ~ J~ . ..;..,.......JI :,?~I 'J)~I.~~W.~j:.·. 1~~)oI~~jS~.Ji ..? L....S 'cr~'lo'l l.bll~.....s ~':':'I.JJ.l._.L:.,1 ii~~ W L..... .:,4-o;.a1 Jl.~LilIJ o.ll_.sjl";'~ '.JJ~I ~ ~1.>91..M1l ~_,JI ~~1 .~IJ 'ioSJ.),lS >! I..al.I VA .M.C. .l J> J ~ ",<,J.!!,,~.H, .li).u, . ~.lI.~IJ • a,. . 1 'p~1 ~ L.c.,;~.u.~ ':F~I,;.,...!:J 'I """'..;~ ~~IVA~..s..u ~1.O11 D~ .:.d ~J.,.J .~~'lo'l

:~lI:jl ~1:;.;J4~I..,JJ J4J.' I~~

.(Ibld: 270) ~~I

,

~ ~~, . ....:.s, -?~L~.~.JI.!;.Ci I t.y : \.4..a I.J.!T~ ~

. 411j~ ....; I$,;.ul .~I .4L ~I .. J.Ol ~4 'lo'l _;5. ~I ~r" >!~ ~ 41.~.,.._..l: ~~'lo'l j.S~1.:,1 ~ o!..~' I ~_j - ~ ~I J...oI~1 -..I •• oGLA4'IJ .:,J!.JJ.I ).$;.l' .:"I..jo~ ~ . ..ill~ ~J :L.......:>IJ~."s~ '. I ...,iJ 4..w.~ ,t",j.,:JI I~"'" ~J I..;J'). .!.J )I....,.4~1 ~w......JI.;.IJ· IJ . ..)4J,..-J~) <LJL.SJI ..:.I,..)~I ~l 0)4o-JI.Ji cr. I:_y. ~~I ~! 10 i.....', ~jJI,.4..... . I

.O.l..j,,,,,,,, >-' - ~ ";'~_J (w_fiJ1 ~

y,;J1 ~ . a.t. I ~~I ~I. . _,A • ..!l4"I;....»S ....~y D ... I_.sjl, 4.t . I ~jAo! .~I.),_..JI ,-,»L.:.l.IJ J )U jL!.,.J.( I tbJGJ,)(Reinold: 1 7, 1991) Ii~:_y. ~i .HSr:a' ~ ~ ~I..wl .J....A ~I ~I.:"I.S .

. ~~I "L,...... ~;--U J}b .?'" ..".J.1' ~ .,Hl.OJ.l ..:.......J~ .~Ul.1 ~ <?l1...,...,I,_....JI vA:u.....J......:..lli....ill;,.;._... ~4' I~ ~.;-'I ~..>JI ..:.IJ ~J"'" .u,. O.l~~ )~I~~~)~ ......u.......~luI.SJ.l.) ......... ~~I ~ L..::.A'lo'I).$~"uJ tA;L..!.:UI, 4.j~I Ji-I.l l+l~ LI.;..1 )\..;..,)A >!WI ...,... O..l.J...lL.A ..;."'~ ~ ..;."";' .::..I...c.,_ .. _~ •. u .~ .~I~;#' ,1 ~I~I~)'I ~ l4S '(':t.;i~ ~~"') ~41..;.t:9~ ~ ..;.I.u.~ -?' 4..otA ~l..;.:. ~I~ l:~ ,I ~ ~L;.,! J,1 .)~, ~ '::"J,J..:> 4.j4 4.tLilI 4.j4 -=..~I." . ..:.I~ t D~

~...,~ ...,..l.ll.f.!.;e..> . ...,...,)-;1 451_;i._,.,..!aJ LAlIJ."......; aJ I .(G U~: 1991: 5 ) ~~~I ~'.JL........J.4,jAj.-o .).H-J.:,I...,... ~>" ~ • ..>I.,UJI ~~ ~~".. ~ ..;.1...c.1-,-!),' ~i lS.J...>o.! lA.,>.;'::"';\S ~L....-.JI a;JL....;J1 ~L....:JI ~ o;l . ..!.! ..:.~I..H1.Al.1 ~ -..11..)0;. .J~ • (Ibid: 5 )

i
\
I
/
"- /
/
./
»>
o 21 o 11ft ~ "",~ ~ ~ ~ _ - ._;U...- ~l, .";'l.,)r-Jl ~)L:JI u~1 ~Lc.....J!. ("-J vc- .-rA·· .)I_,_-» "";)WJI ~ J~ ttb..:;.....t -$.JJI -.>-'..H1) ,)..ui V~ ~.J-"')ll u-" ~I ~I...,.. J,.il ......a.Jlor LWI, ~ oIu_,.:J 'J .~!_,_,....JI ..:..I}.-.....Jlj .:..~lA!lJ I.T~' ~ - 4.~4kvA#~ . .>-'>.!I).:"lSJ.~ ,.1..>..)1 ":i~JI~ .)~')lt '.J..:- ~ I~ ~,J~ -.>:!:.ul r .J.jI.:~I.:.- ~I _HJ:. M ~l..i:J1 ~1.J1..s~.jJ1 ...... ).ul ~J . ."..a~1 .J..i-.ll ,I l~1 ji)~ 'I:......,. .~; u~'::"~ ~ .~.: ~I...I.I.l 0.;4 d __ ~\..; - 41 I .".1:.,

;;.)~ J~\ z::~ 40" ~b,_..J1 .:.-l.9U!.l1 ;'j.:!J ~u.. .. l ~ ~~I ~I.)I )i... .~T~,·~ .~ _...L;..;.wl L...S -~'.)\ ~.uIJ ..::.oL.:.~.~ 4..,.:J1.:.-L.:.,_..._..J.1 r')lh....' ~ Jl..IoI .joll) •. ::.l ... L&.lII ~,.~.::..L.:.~(~t[',j.I, ~L....:....:.JI ~\ ~,,_.....-....ll )~I ~L4:J1 J-I,._:JI :,y. a...L...

,,.

'~~~I j.S~1 ~ • ~ -i_';' II..!:.~~,.· .,)1. \

l~~~..ul..::.o i ........ ~

.,)'.1,_....Jl Ja-, ....... L...;.:...":il ~~I'__'_""J ~..J..>.J _,.~ __....JI

l...,. 1.,1..0.. ~~I ~1~ ..... l.l...1! ~ ';~1~' .:..1. ~ (J).JSJ' ~~.,r ~L.:i.l ~ - )U....l.;:.,tll .:..L-)W

_, 7h. ,'_()04: 61-(2)

4.6..;l') ~.,dJ:'.)A ~ ~_;:. ~I LoS .(1977 J>.''>-" ~! w~~L ~;.. ~ ,( ubi an Ph se -~,.;J' . (Trigger: 1965: 17-1 ) ~ . 1 t,.:;l- . J!..!

lAta... 0 J....:...> (~~ ~.:,i _;A 1 ~.?~~~y'.ill:,~..uJ .~IJ~J-L4J~ L.J,.kWJ ~~ LuJ-l ....... .,............. :,.-iJ wU\.a!JJ ;'i:!lj J...o,:; <?ll ~l:;.;J .J.A ~ ~ ~\j I;"J . 4b~1 JI J,,_'i4 ~ ~.~ w_H!l t-'~' ~l£ 4-.tJl ~J~ '.".I...,...:....W.;JIJ.~I~~.rI1 ~>Ut JL...:.YI wl • .,dJ:..J ~1. ;0 O'O~ ~,~ ~

<l..A...WJ <.,>j.J1 ~)l.:oJ J......!-:J10 '.r-4Jl.J,.> v1:..::..L...:. .;,.u .:,lS...J1 ~ ~\.A!l1 .:..)c;1--...J .:,1 c..;. ~ .;'>.!IJ

'-f...:!Jl~1 4fi......J.I.)A ~u .~ .::..l.A~ ~I J>.~ c...k ~4JI.:,ij .~1,.:;.... J~ ~ ~ l+ol c...k ..?' ~I.:h .~b ~t,. _,.. ~I ul4.:J1 ~)I~I

.4;ots:....;;~..)1 I~ ~ ~~r J..\"w)l1

~~I4......;ll1 ~~I..t..A1I;'~lj ~~~ 'Cr-J Io.··_ C··) • I ~_,.;J' ~ ~~ ~J~'~ ub, ...... n ~ J.u.1l .. l£. L..w. ~~I .~., ~ <?I' L>k--Y. "JuJl.&~ i~. "'i- \1 ',._..e.)lI~ ~I .:..1~t" •. ~ ••• ,~~JI ~ ~..u_, .(Rei·n r: 192 ) ~~'J .";Uo...;JI a..._IJ.::.. ~ ..,.k .l~'il :I.JJ·'I ~)I'~~~~L.S.YWlI~~I..L.l'~ ~~ ~ .... a....~ ~_,....~" . ~.,.J.I wL.'au:JJ uD.;-OJ1 u1" .~_,JI lli..ll ...... ~l ~ ~r--" ~~ ~~ ~ ~_,JI a.u..ll J.,........ ~ ~L!..i! v.o

.~~ ..:r-..,..~I..)I a...A',,' Jbllil

:~. 1".iI ~_'vl c.:rll ;'jh 4--l ..I....A.3 ~I.JJ.I Lol 'J~' ~L..>11J'~ ~w .>-.Jo.S;.J J~I ~LAI.' ~ uJl ... Lz.......1 ..dl:'J .m:._.t., )':'lAJ.IJ .,-"",-""' ~lAJ.IJ L.S.(~ .r:.:,)lS..!JL)~~,:.......,~.........u~J· 1.w,J ~~I ~.:..~...,:JI . .::.oIJ_,.b:J1 u~ ~I ............ .;_,IS:....JI ~ H13.u .JIS<of~1 J)l:,..':il u )~J .~I

t.... ~ i.l~I ·_;'j·h C;~I . ...uJ.l •••. 1..dJ)L:. . ~ ~~I • 1~~~~l,)~I .. ~,._yo#~I ~ ~I ~I ~ ~y:. ~~ JJ-ofIi> • ..,aI..L.l1 .?-..;. ~")l ~..?-ll .(i)~,..-.l'A, ...... Il,..~ ~~) .~YI <of..! -""'~'._yo ~~ .~~I..."J~ .(..,..) ~~4 ~L..-I L,...,L::. ~ ';..I .. H .~jll ~I

.(Rei ner: 1910) z) 4L~t A ..... I L. JS4A._,AuJ

,.,. &6.JJ.1 u . 1:;:: ....... ;.r.lw~1 .L...1:. ~ ~j:I.> w

~ "'"" J-tW." .<of.)~~1 .... lj <u _ .",-l_J-Al1 ~ Cl:o.O.. ..L9 ~;1 ~ ~l J;... ~ .~ 41 ~I .:,.,-, .I~t I;.. .ill~J '1'4"t:i~." _. ~J .Lo.uJ1 ~4->- jA \..Wi ~ ~! J,.......,,,u '-i~IJ ~I .:.~I ~ ;'j:I) p_ ....

~~ .. ~.~I_,.I.I~J~.>-HjJ~ '!' ,j"~, "1 ~I ~~. ~)Ul~1 L.L....l~1 ·ul.l,.._.Jl,o J~1 Jl.o~,

~I J)l._;. "--l-.) u.,.. ~ ~~I ~ ~

t...... ')II <oJ)l> .J.A ,(~I 4.-,.aJ ~WIJ 4...,;~1 ~:'LZ':i1 ._;'~I.) ~~I~I . .~........:; ~ .... .J.AjJ" .:..~I~ ~ , : ~I Ju......s') .::..l.Au.:.J1 .. .:... J- ~ ~ 4_..,L... ..::.I~ .:...,..L.>oJ 4-~ dJj ..,LS, . rd. tn m: 1 72) ...:.J~ .. l..",,-)IJ .4.>_)~~1 .::.~I ~ ~ ~~ ~ ._;,..a.( dam : 1 77)...... I ~I '~..) '~I ~IJ .~~I a.!......Jt .. ' 'J ~I .J.'i..1l1 ..:..-.:..~I Jl!ll L....,.1.i1 .::.ou,WlI .;...~ J)l;. UWlIJ ~I 01 ~I:JI .:,~ .... )l:O.;.I ~ _ ~ ... 1 ~J W. b. ~ ..:..L.......,. "~.je:-'( Smith: 1 ) ( ...... ) ~~IJ <I} ~~I ~J'(' ~~I, 1)u.~I~L"~~u~ .~..1.4.I1 4;o1.l_,...J1 ..:..1;L .• .,.,~.Jl -r""L,. .J.D.I ~ Jl.!-JI I.:u.

ubi ) ""L:.S ~, dams, ) )0"''''' ., ~Y' I Y-J

o...c~~~~I..:..~I.( orrid to Afri a ~1;6i WlZ l...J.J..-.. t..,.;.... ~~ r~IJ .(Group) ~ (...,.. J 1 ~~I L......w. ".(Hori7 n J.8~I-,,"J dam :) ( .. HOrizon) (1) ..;.t~1 ,... ..s..._o...1, ,. , b ,'" •

r i ~
•
... .,1'1 "0 .. 0
e
'·00'- •
.
. . :.

00··> ....... /'

o

II

100m

o

~
-
J
j
...
• J
-
....
•
J
:~
"1..
,~
~
:3
'4-
'L
i
,~
[ ~
]
.J'
1

J
.. 1
::'t
-
,
::;;
~
e
0 ...9
~
-
-
-
1::
(II
:..
*i

~
-
...
'"
::
_,.
'<:;
~
-
~ 1\

" _;I . ...'~~t ,-..s ~-I I

.r · ..... l. ·L....:.I

_;;~J: I _~ ~I ... ...tl I ~t.TA,,:- ~...ir...-l

~1~;U..;rJ'-\..:L.."./-,;"'_'; :~-I .~~I~\:._~~'~

-'~

,

..):t \~ .ss»- .. !J5'_;\~jl:: _~I) .,,;_;~!~;,S.:

v

I.~

_I_:L......:.J' 'I

_ _.I.J ... ~I_

'~J

I'

~'l aphonllm~ I

c:. _ .. )-> "t....J1-' ~

,~U\ ,r} . .J'-')L.:.I ~- ... : ...... ~I~\...;"I...~'

I ' ,

. ·

f\.oJI~I~"I~~"~~~fWI~I:O~1 .(Dunham: 1950: fl 1lab.......tl..:.u:.Il1,s.-.1 .. >+I

..:.I:Jjl .)1 ~ IV .jA J91, .~L.oI~~ i~ ~ '~I..S'

.~I ll.....;.S:... ~ ,1 ,#~ .:.L..'~i ~ I.,....) .:.H.JJI

-.(Ibid: P: 59f )

~..)tJ ..!l_,.1l1 ~~._;. >-'.>:1') ~..:"i ~l';l 0.>" 1~ ~'j .uJ.JJ_, .~I~1 o..u:.Li ~ ~ ~ ..u .4...-~1 <I:i~~ ~ ~ ..:.L,.~! ~ J.:..uJ1 ..hbJ.1

'4:!)',)~IJ 4:!)~_'.A.IIJ ~,)~\," ~L...:-'l'1 ,:,i ~ ),)u ",I ~I 'J-'N').J...4..:..L1 ..u, ..;.jS ~ ~Ul "-I:i ~..;4i ~..)b .. ~ ~ ,~~I .>-:t.W1 ~ ~ ~ ~J ..:.LoI~~·'''''';';:' ~ ..... L...". )C... -JJ~ ,~~..!l,t.. 1 ~ ;.r.L.... . uJ ~ ..rJ,~~u.......)t..:.U.o~._...b.c.l ~ .::.L,..I~)l1 ..J.....JII.;I J-'.J-:!I) ~I .>---*'l'1 .;~ I,_I ..,~ ~:rJ . .:fo...'lI ~I ~I . ~I ..,...a >+"'" )'1 ..:J.lli ~ 4...~1 ..r ~.::.,~ L.i.J.>, j-AJ! .~~~ ~I ..:.l-'~'l'1 J-'NI) ~ ~~I ..... ,.L..!l_,uI..;,lS.~1.J01..,..._"":;"";'I.u ~ L....IJ.)J)l..."...J"", . ..,..;; '~u~

~I..:"I ~1.~)\.A..o, )~!.::.~ ...yt .;.....;.I,~~ ~ 4:i _,_;...-.-., ulS .) -'..:.lU1 ~ 0~ .I.l.l_, .~.r-J' ~ .~, ~r-JI U:.-Iy ~"-'....r'-!-! ~_,..,.JI .\';.a ~,:,LS ~ ..:...i_,.JI.".s ~ ..u,.-.):!.>->-L.,",_,.J~...,.....JI )~. )~ ~ ~ .;,.J ;_,.,. ~.I"'L.'l'.H .. I,_I.! ~ ..1J.:.u,.~~~,~.~~ .jA .)I,.l' ~ ~..,..;;~ ~ J! ",,~I . ._;.,L.....JI ~I ...... .),_,..,_J.I ~ t.Pl1 ..,;..~ >-'.)h.r> .u~1 ~ ~.JI.. .• j.LLj ,:,LS .Ip _.:.s)lI, .L~ I .!l_,JJ.1 ,:,1 J,.z .._..:.II ,~\JI ~L..! -r" ...... '--I~')'I j...o...9i #J.-1- ~ uL...oIj-A '..>-'>-::,1)..,..5)..,1 ~J j..L .~,.u ..>'".!ill .j-A ~ ............ s ~w... ~-' .~ ~~ >uj,; ·l..k.l ~ o..t...;.L.4.l1 y~ o.r.-'~I ~..)L;JI 1.1A ~ ..u ....... _,.s . ,.u ~ JS' 04 .~_;.:.J.I <1.1=,. U.l ~ .J~..,I Jju...J.i,.a..o..... IV .):1.l.l1 ..!l;lll ~I ~I ~..._ IV .)A ~I

~J Lw.... # - .)1 ~ ~ .~j..o .L-I jl .:,J .(Rei ner: 1919: 23 -24 ) ~I vlJ ~l ~ I'" -,....j4-1 ~ _,pI ~ .J:i.,....JJ.I..:"T >-~lJ ~~I D.)-'-"1 L ..... ,d~~~..1.11 '1..:,,\11 ~~~~, .)l~ ~LJI~ u~~I.JI~V-~~~'~ _)-t..Il J,..... _.j~lJ-?IJ..:"l.4JI;j 4,;~1 ~.:.IJ~ ~I Q' _ ~ ~I .?> WWl ~_,s:J1 ~.>-""')u ~l

. (Kendall 1999: 6)

.=.w~l '_IJ..LI ~ i ...... i ~.:...;.,~ ~I -I'T ) .P Yo' F 4,;4 ~ "'~ ~ cll~" .~"s:J1 JS' ~I ...4 J.,.l.4... • ..k'lJ ~_;..All 4_L.4l1., e;Z ..",:J I ( .. r tIY'.,.JI ..:"aI..l.11 ~ ;,.I...A~ <!....i..~ J" .(1 ab) . I) --.JI ,.J\..:i..iJ1 ~ .,- .. " ~ . I .1_L:....I.1..I1 .~I._._.,.

...r- '" _r-:': ~ ..... ~. ..

~~I ..".k- .~I ,:?.i.J1 '-i~~1 ':"U~I ~.)I~ '+:ll _)-y ~l ~ __.-lUJi .LA,> • .yjI ~I.J-"""· I • .l~ (jA . (Griffith: 192 ) ~I ~~I a, ''';:'-''~,Jo:;..,.:.....aJ ~,J_,_..,_,JI~,........, uk l..-...:..IJ ~.)~ ~4 ..A...o:i: .l~)l4 .:.w~ c,r._,J_"~1 J....<.Lu.l4 ~ ~ ~ .' 4,. ~ L.. JS L'.>~ ~ J.. . u...l.>" ~I...t..11 JS'....:....,k J..o~ .:,IS .:...;.,~ ..:"r" a...,L.;. • ~I~ WI:!! ~Ul .:.1..1..>0 fi ,:?.i.J1 .~_,..;.JI '~4 J.I4! ~ t:-'"~I '~..t..:>o.A ~.,HL>... ~_"_v):J1 J~'" ..::.~l ~ ___..) ~ .ri~IJ ~ ......:;...:.1 -?' ~I..!J' ~§J' ~l...t..1I.yo lA~" .~I ~~.J.1J ~.:,I:,rL::....:..U:...s._w....I.....S u.~1 ~.,;;Jlj ,4-.).) t_,;_, (Jl)'1 ..".k- ~§JI ~I ~)..:".s..1....o..lJ .,r.-Jl......>J1 .-..0.; ~...t..11 ~4;;~ U)l.,:. '-i~~I.!;"U I ~rll .:,;a1...t..11 ..?' ~~ t... ;:.si .:"i ..;o1__.:..&1 h clljJ" .?> ..r~ 'il J..:.>l.i.:J1 l~ ~ .;.J.b,; .;,1 ~ ~ .)oA ~ ~ ~Li:J4.;kw ~l-I wljt.;...1 )~, • ..:"a..LI1 ~~ .;i. -;; ..:.L:.~I, .~I j>.1.l..,........al, ,.>.~~,.lIJ ~w j .tl~IJ .~4 ~ ~ L..._,......;..~ ..:,,_':'...t..11 ~~ .~J>ll o_,:;..4J'..,J ~);.ll .j91...t..11.:.l,!_"";'" ~_Jl:i e,)l ,.;.s ~ ~ .l~)lI,.J.3...L.1' J,,~' ~~I_,JI ~~':il ..I.A..i .~..I.11 .,.......; ..::.~)' ,-!~~I .:..~':ll ~ 0~ )'1 .yo

~J ~ ~"""""""_'.yo:r.:. J"',JotI) ~lj.JU.1.I ~~ .,Hl...4J.l ~..)l.;;J ...._;.;._....I ......... " ..$~I ..:.L..'~1 ~,........,..... ..s_>->l 0.>0,...............j4~' JS'~I ~ ";',..:.:...::.~

~':ll .. , .... Jl ...... 'lII...)' 4-', ~...;s ~I

.~Jo.l1.;I;'J}I; .{'_":;""I_,...;.JI} ~~~, Lt...:.JI ~I •

,I ("~'i .".,.. .:.~, ~I .~~I;_y. ~j • ..::.)l_1,I, ~~")J.~..,..)oAIL

;lA..al1 ..:..U~._,;, ~ .~I_;..AJI..::. ~,... ~ Jl.>. T' )t,. ~I ,I.;>,..., ~..,....,I • I_,_.. .~l rl~'lI1 ~J u~J a-L-t..I,_, ,.;>"..

. (Reisner: 1 17) ('T~~L ,_WI t"'>1,.L1 "';~. ~

~ ~P" ~ i~ J"'1J04) :u .>-'"\11 ~4''''''''j J.;& j.A..I..AiJ, ~IJ..,:JI ~~ ..r'";.~ ~ ~

~I~ ~L....,JI~,) • ..:..U~")I~~

;1; ............ 1 ~fo ~ ~ ~.JJI r.ll ~J I~,:,,-"..r .ri~I.) ~'ll!~-"l.'lI"'I~,)IJ~.~u ~~LL ~»--' j JS' _-..II, -';J" ..:.L...I;-A I .r . ~I ._)&. • .:.~I,.>A 1

.~~I..:"lj.~l-4J~.I.l~ 1 .... w..c.1 '+-_)~~ ~ -,..lWJ ~ ~fo '" , .~ ..:..W ~ ~'ll J~...,.....) ~l jA.)1 ~ ~i:!,. I~ ~ J~ ~ "";.HI~ ~..r a...... I .. - .......... LS...-J' ,4.t~1 ~~ I ~

.( dams: 19

""",;,~.u)Li.. ..>"..-' ,:?.JJI ,:?__...Ja.;.J1 ~ (jA ulj~

• I)J.!J~ ~ .e,)J)!1 4.1.-11 J)l> l+-)~ <.?, .uU~' -~..:".. .)~I .;..... ~~I ~ 4..A...oI..LII ;U~)l1 JS' ~~'I ~I_,.LI ,1 .;,.e..ul JolA.l ..,-... ~ ",IS .1.,.. .JL....!J ~

4..-1.).> ~ &11 ~I ~I"..,.,. ~I-, y..._.J1 ~~ ~.J..l1 JS:,..;.) ~L.... ~l ~_,._.!., ~j.JIJ .~...vJ.1 ~'..ul Lenobl and :~~I .!.J~~IJ ~.)L..O..J" ~'-ul

.( harifI 2

U"'~ ~ J~ ~41I~' ~4J1 ~I .:,.1..,.......,...>J J~I) jl.,>->JI a..;4 ~ ~4J' ...,...,,_;;.IcJ1 ""'I.J-l ~ _.:..L-I.;..t.ll ~~J!;... ~#IJ~ 41.(1 U,JI._;..lI) ~I..,JI VA ~ <~I ..b.J....l ~I ~IJ":"~ .!...>4J1 J~I .u,

:~,~.:1..:.. ~L:.~J.:;_;~I~~L..~

~ 4....-.1.;..t.l1 t_,..;.._,.. a..;~ ""';L.o>JIJ ""';~I ~~,., ,.ill~ ~1 ~ .~.)L....;.._,.J' L..} . .k! ~ a..;~H ~J .~l.b...... - . i.~ L.

• ~~.r--~

..,.,. ~~ ~ j..u 44-", ~4aJ.l ~~, ~~"'I . ..,.. (~l!...)~I~~J..I,...,. 4J....!~(~I.)...A).::,,'...Loo.J

~ &A J...,.,~",§...... ~l...,..L.....l ~ v&...ul 4.......-1)-1.[ .~I-, .:..I.)_;...J.I,J ~.)Lu.J1

~ ~.HI) 41J ~j L. -=-L~JI .;:a._, ([) ~I ~J

(I) .s. ~\lI..::..I~'J ~1 I';"" tJ.:.!~.) ~i ~ ,,_;,.L.JI ..:..~I ~.;,... 0A Sls,:,I.ill::' ,~i ~ ~ .(..,..h Jl)c.... ~ ~_....;.-JI .::..:.LS I::').) :.;-i-~' ~ ~I A~ ~, ~J <?,)~.ill~ ..,' ~ )U . L,..a)W.. JI ~I..l

.clI~ ,-€~4J1 ~U~' t">JJ

.,H1..4J.' ~I,... ~ ~, ..t...4.,;a .~I ...,..:.4J1 ~ L.ol viI J~~ 4l J...~ .~J .I~J ...,k, .a..;~1 .;a ~»'" ~ L.o #~ ~ ~\L.J' .:..lS'~1 JJI..;;.l..::..4--0~

. . .. :~ J4 .~Ltc-)

.t'" J..l..W <?II .~WJI ~Lal .JA ~I I.J.A J.... .u..J ., u.. .... !" .. 1 L...JI··· ! -.11 ;;I.lts .. ~'I

Uo" u:-'-",C ~ I..>"*t"'J ~ ;-:-

uu;,." t-'..;\j ~J .>-",)!, ~4>..?' ..... -'-4:! ~j.JIJ .U~I

.~'.1_,..JI~)· lOjAl..li.~.J~1

.)A ~ t - ~ ~ .,;;y..r ~vJ.I ~~I ..::.. ~.:.J.l

.l~.!..p- .(Ed ards et 1.11: 1 ) \ u,) ') ~J.J-A

~L.. ~ ~1 • ..,..~ J~ • '1 ~ ..,.!.,?S, ~.1.l1 Uia...

~ ~)L:;...>'il ~YJ ''-i..t.rl' ~..u, J~Y ~ O.l~'i t,z..!' I';"" -JL-!JI ..... ~l> ~ ';.)-0>1 J~l ~J ~ J~'.JA ~ 1.,:.1 JL...U...I ~ ~ - ~..u' J)" ~ ..,.,.~~ ~I_' •. h .I!.lJ~'J~'i4, ...... I..4J.I

J~I ~>- Jl .~lS'yl _;'I......JJ WJI JL .... : :tI, ,tJ.:.!J~1

4ll..I.'~ ~>"..;b' I L...._,......->- u. ~

_ dv ards: L 9:41·13 • Geus: 1990)

~, ..... ..:.J)lZ.,?-l1 .::.L...IJ..u, ~ ~ ~.ill~~,

)lk...,1 .... J_> .... lIj ~p.ll o.)~'~I~I.o.,..:;.....J1 4..c..J __ ~ ... lI -;:..,;. Jl .... j~ ~ LA;;~ ~I.. ~4l1 ..Li.:.

w.~.JJ'i1 r">h~ ('" up)(...,..)

~ ~1..u.l.)A 4..c..~ J)l.>.JA • .;l ~1 #.J.A._,.I.e. ~.HI)

L...Io-L .uJ. "",,,)'1 ~_,.;J' ~l..4j1 ~ .~I L..,.;.:...4..!.SJ' ~ ~ ..::..~J ~-' 'D,",=~ ~.r' ~~ ".>_>:!I.) ~I ~,..._. ~ ....:....!S.JI ........... ,. ~jJl .::..L.c~1 ~t...;;.! u.....:.. J)l.;.. ,( "\._JS:..;JI 4-.)l.J ~ ~ ~>,1

?' ~. I.J-A ~.....JI ~ .... ~ ... L,jl ~L;... .~)\....;:u.J1 .~~I ~.)W-S! ~J;9 L...:& ;; ..... L.....::..ilS'

;;_)~I ~.J.A .)~i ~LS .~I.l,_J1 )U'lI1 ..Y' La.H-"-Sj ~ _is.) . -1". ~I ~.:w ~ .:...~u..J .I.)~ ~ )~':!', ~ :u..~1 "',.> ~~I ... ~, 4L->1 ~ ..,...JL' ,jI <.y> 4-:;L:. I~ ~ l..,a)j .~~1 ~~ ~J\....A,.J, .-4II~ ~ . .:.~ l~, .JjlJ'l11 ~WI I~i J. ,~I..Ll1 FAj I"+"L.ol ~tAl ..,;"L1.1 J:!j..ul e;1'j.)A ._,,) ~lZ..A ~% ).It..-.. ~ ,,~"i . ~~ Em : 19 . Adam.: 1 77. hm-] LJ~~I.JA ~ ~~'~_rl;u.(nie. 19 4. Trigger: 196 ~ ¥' JtJ.: l&-O--J-! ~~t • .LA .:rel"'_'._..IJ ~~ I ..:.... 4- ..:.U4J J • u....L..Lt L..., .s".>-" ~ ~l.A .... :;.1I J......',,_;JI

·( 'me!'): I 3 . \01.1. rill,: 68. ~. C.·G

• v.) ;e.)lI,-k ~':""'.J..>JI )~1 ; ........ ,"':'WI ~I

~I :.r .:..~I ~'..I..J ..,..g .. :d .,;JI.( rcha '()Io~"

.r )~'il ~W ~L...~' ~'.J'';~ ~IJ ~~, ~.l~)'-.:.lJ)j.~", ~~ ~",,')'J..j .... ~I~ ..!.l,J...-Ji L..';.l, u~! ~~l,j-, ~UI ~LP.J ~i~ "",w_..ll .:...>1 ~I .... ';4-"!1 ..1..>01 I~ ~LSJ o..rL-.'l ,j~ J .»~~,J "-' ,.pt..~...J .~~I )l.i'il .:,,1)L........o 4j)C; ~ ;L... ...LA., .( Binford: 1962 1972)

uLtJi ~ ~ ji)ll ...,.=

~-'-:':' ... .:cl "r-~.J~ " ;+AlI)L....o;.t>. , .. l,.'lli )L...1t

..I! "'·~i-j"J)-"rl.>1 L.!JJJL...c.I~~)U ~l~ ~ ~l oI.J, 'I ~.J..>JI JL...A.l1 ~) ...... t:'" L..;.t...:;....._LS

.:..l.!~J ~L:.l. ;&'1 ... ,_o.:....-... ~ -..61- ..,.ll ~

~.)L:J1 ~~" ~_;L::.J ~~ I.. J'~ ~ .:>A,..."I L.I),)

J...,..~ • .JI.>,._JI ~ :t....,..._.!1 ~ .... ~J

.( DlfhJ-... ni: m I v~ - 1 L.:.;..')II L.) ........ Ji·~1 ~I ~ . ~,. ~,_....JII.! - ....... J./)'I ~~I ~ ':".>L....?' ...... ~)L.w. ..... ,~~~...!' j.:... ~ .>lvJl4.-..l» I,......;.> .:..-1.J.!1 ,~.II.-:!"........tt.~ _ .... \)-'~""', :> .... 1 ~)~ ~

a.......L:.:.... 4.J.....!.- " • 1.;;.)1 I', - I ,'.r I .~I -

. ..,." ~..) ~ ...,............. I,j .>-LA

.~w • .:;.l_,J1 ~ .44i -=..U,WI

~~I tll" ir .~1.J.e ~'~l L;J" UJ_,JI...J..A ~

~t.:l':il ~l.UI.J ~ ~I ,.;,A-1JJ.4 l ;; I. ; II ~t.:l'J.

,\,",!~I,:,I.),_...JI ~ ~I.M' ~~ ~ L.~' irJ . ..!J~I" ~~I:.,y. ~ ~u "~I .~. J~ ..;J_;' ~I_"" ~'.MI 0$.>- 4....~1 ~WI ~t . I ~'_,JI o~ ,~)lt....J1 ~ c.?' 'l.f"_"'::; -I,J.,. 4.....;Ll ol~J .!l.b ~ " • ,;.· ... 1 V.I') .t...~ • .J.-:!- :S-~j ~ ;J~I ~ ~ v-oL...~ .~w.J1 i.J.Ia ~I ~ ir

.u_;JJl...J..Ay-I ~I~I..I_,......JI

.;:, ~..., ~llli 6':"'" 0-" t ;, ': ui ~I"'" VA"

~I ..:.4'~ <?' CJ.)L....s_.....;.1 ..)...:. v-oL...\'1 ~ o~1 L. .. L 4J~4....r-~: LI : I. 1!I·r ',' .. L·,'I

:»- ~ ~ -....,.>-:i-"'...>"..,J-

~ ..:..)1 ,WAll d~ ~ u...)Ui ..I_,.;...JI ~ c.?' J~~I ~ '&.!.J.JI..:.~->t.:l'.lI.::.IJ! OJ """~, ~1.>-"~1 ~~ Ju..J .~I ~ ~1...u.1 ~ 1,j.J.J' ~.ul I_'_'~I

.U~ 1,j..l~IJ '-r4IJ .~Lt;J 'c.r._,J'>,,~

a.....,1,;;.. ~I.MI ~ u':""':';' -,,;.:..JI JUt ,..." • ._..lUlI )L...lI

...,1 ~,~ ~~ u~IJ ';'~?,I ~_,!-I'.).c. 4.J..I~ ~ "i" • .,r.L.....:.J ~,L-~.)J ~ljl ............. _, ,..~JJ.I J.. : ,:,IJ .~ ~I oS.;1>- ,.:.. .......... ,.. yo J~ ...:....,.),) .).c. .s~ ..u ~I .~.......aJ' .:..L....J~ ~L!ll Jl...tJl ~ Yo .,;. 0';; L... ~ .;.)L...~ J~I ~ 'lI .u J'''i.l ..... )L;...,. ...,L....-j'!, u.>=i L..~) ~J'iI4:i~.:..L...I..i....... LA;;~ ..:.L...I).l";- L~,_ll ~ ........ )i-ll I':"'" ~ .(~I.MI ~L.. '~_,sl ~ ~l5 ~I..ul ul-y' ~)L;JI ~ ~'..Il' ~~J ~~._;J.....;... .t_"':"J-A ~i...>' ~

'u~'lI';;~~J

t._,....,. J~)tl ~ ~ • .{, ... 11 jUt ,.., ,.:..J\!Jt )L...l1

~I 0)' I J.-JJ.....oI~IJ .•• I ~,..sl vc ~

I.:u. ..,.L-.,.,i ~I.J .• JLA,..JI ;~Lli> ~"4:.l.........sI,, ~ ~JJ .U~I 4.JL..1 ~ J.!j....s ~IJJ.I JL.....l1 .Ll_,.1....J1 .:..t:.~ ~ ~ ~~ • ...,:.\..-j'!1 ~_,J....JI

.ui.)_,..Jt· .. "...,;.rt ''I', ":o'~ -,.~i~~ - ":'i,) .... f~. )Ij\'t~ -ij~""_'~j ,,) Azharim2002

;~I -'~ .I~I'J-·

~'-

. tlam',\\ \ It} PI' I I'lliIr;tOIll uhia In Ih~ LI_;: I III \n:h<lI,'t,IIIf!) Journal of' EIO'ptian AI't'hart,IVI!\ <; I PI' IN 1.''1.

III

ubia 'orridnr III ,Urica, I ,,"<1"11

l're .

.:II.

'J ') Earl~ hartnurn. t \IIlrd l 111\ <:1 'I

Bintord. L I '.iiI.! -\n:h~l:nlll"\ .• ' \nlhrnIMI\I~\'

.' mencan Anllllllll\,~, ~ 7 :::~~

Bonne: Ch 19' (I Kennu, ro~ aurne (It' 'ubi. (i fW va,

(',InI'I,I. I 14'~ Pnlltry l\'ing (;athertN and Hunttors 31 "Il~ai ISudan I, RIlIll;1

14. KI·(;eili, the HIo,IIII".' uf a IIddle iI· Environmenl, 7(I4K' H,C \.n. 1500. (,lInt>ndg \1\111 ogral h III \Im ,III \tLhacpl"g) ;:9 H \R lntcnumouul . 'ric,·L (l lonl

I W 'ell 1'111,,<1, til l),II.1 ( "II'elh 11 Ifll'

IIal~," 111 • lItl.Jllt"l: I'rcil I '10m: \rdl;(l'"I,'~\ In f

uhia 'I'hirt \ \ var Lalt'r. ~rt'·

puhli 'alion 11 II.llin Paper!'-. S"d t~ ""r uhian

,tudit·~. b!!h(h Inl,'rJliJlIllIwl (Iln"'ll'II~'" 11 ~ I",!,

(elll cr I illc

.... 11~ __

In I (',lIIe\ a 1'.1 , to,I t , ih, l'hc History ur a \.Iiddl ile Envirunment 711l'O It<· ,\d IS(I4), Lllnhnll!!c \ hmop.lph, III • Ull'al \ I, 1,,1 "'1.,),:\ 131\ R Inll'm,ll"", .,1 Seric ·C" 1'1' ~7'" ",

Dunham D l):,11 1l1l' km al tom teries 0 "U' h. I. 1-:1 Kurru, ( ,lIl1hllt.l~ •

I:tJ" ,mJ • I), I, ') , IIh'lIIelll nd,' r('hueolo~) in the l pper ubiu in Ill, I '~litI nnium AO. SAK Inter lIa"on,11 ">cnl" . ,-

1'1'11 fill'" I 1 ",111111' III III e l 1)I>I:r \1;,111

fH('u •. ubia frOIl! Pretu Illn III I lam. Llllld,," ,'"

1't(I:- rhl' \n:heolo~:I' of th \I rut] ~131C, \ , tud~ ut il~ f1dal and PoLitical Structure PhI) 1>., ~n.JII"n <. ;,1 ,olld,'" ( 1I1,,'r,UI

".III (~ntral udall I" I .. I 'N"

k,' 'cwsl Her •

I 111,'1 \, \\ H 1 'I', I Ill' I<m ,-II 'luRlb." 0 Ballalla an (Ju'wl.< ,UII'

(.,'U' I 1'"111 1:.11'1"1'" IUlIl'lillr~., 1Il,'nllll~U~

.: rauq e, ct " IIUIII,",

,.Illlllhutuon de 1.I1I1I(I c rc-,

non ".~ au . I pprUot,'itt; P elumn lir • Revue d' 1','\ ptolojl;' 0 Ih1 '~

.. .

,I

I'~II Burtdl C'hl.llth III rh, l 1'1 L" ,\lan Ik -\111 h':I\' '\\ III \\ \ I);rlt.:, (,'Ll, E!!~ pi and

I II') 111(' Dil '''h'I III Ih~' TUl110 01 b'!\p'1.111 2':'ltlA I \ 11;),1\. Surlan ul and Record. 2 PI'

\friol. ubiu rrc rn t'l"('hi~tur~ Iff I~Jmll. I., ,"d"11 1'1' 'I ,~

(iriflilh,f- 1.1 I,)~; (hl"rd 1'':;11.1111111 III '"hl.1 1...\,\ \,10 PI' ",·1"

kcndu!l 1 I ')'1<, Th~' Un),! III ,,( Ill,' , :lr,I1,lrI "l,11l 1'1 Kurru and Ihl' '\Ilklll'': 1.11 Ih" I<I'~ I \11,' hI' \h'roitica 1-.' II Ikrlt

11I,II'"l' I)", '1<'pm,'111 ,,1 Ih,' :"I lid, 10 ", "l'U II -m rh .. Pili 111 "I \ It:\\ "I I he ( lin' 'Ill I{c' '<lid 011 II.: "'01,111 ,,' III. (,h BI'lIn,1 I~',I I (.:tudt" uuhienne«. Conl'i!,,l'IIt'I' de (;1'''' II.', ,\I'U:.' du YIII.' Conj!r"~ Inlcrl1alluOtil d'~~tudt':'> ,""hil'nnl.'!> .\.Ii Sepu-mhre I')I)H \ III I (j,'nt'l' II' ~!I- ~-l

11'lIl1hlc: P ,llId Sh;lrH

(,.111." ' The R41~:11 \loun J, "I 1-:1 Hoh;I).:1 ,Ill.! 111,' .. I \kUk' \nliquil). (,( . h2o·(, \.

'""hUllll1 H It) ~ 'l'olithi unrl ·'·t.r up \itl'''. 1';,".110:111,111 { I1I\.:r II~ Il,l('~,. Sill(,' hohu

R .. inokl. J I'J);- 1.1' f( lIi1k" 1" -ct 1Il'III'''''ll1nqu ' II<: I •• S'!t:IIOII r:mnlal', Ih.· 1:1 Dirccnon d" \1l1111"11.-, du SoUJdll' le ';1I11I'agul" I ')i'\J .. ' ,'I 19. ~ .• h' 'r· l'hcolo~ie du \il \11l~t'n 2 .I,"'k,·,,,I,,,,' 1( III 1,1 I'rllln,

""" lk: I' '\I,'h ·"ltl\.!1 ' 'd"1 \Ill' I ill' 1'1'

,,-

')') I \','oillh, II" ,."J,III,." I' ( "Ullnll,"

hlll"I~III'l", In \\ \ D", ,~" I.'d I EJ.!~ pt ,lid ubi, r, ubia frHm l)rt!hiSlnr~ II) Islam. I lInd"1I Bnuvh I , ht,'r~ C.'l'''",~lIl1l~ "' l'uhl'~all()11 1>;11.1, 1. .. ".1"11 I h ''I

I{"I ncr. (i \ I Y I 0, rht· ft'hal'nlO1(i al ~ur\('~ ul' uhiu. Report f.) 19"·1 \lnx. I t ,I I \1' ·JI;",.'lot!l~ "I

I"l 1- F \,.1\ J' ,'II'

I IhlllJlI" I$lIl1ellll 01' th 'BU"141O luseum of Fine rtl> I ~ \,,, ()

.Iq~, 1·"l'u"tHion~ lit Kerm», 1'1 1·111. 'am

t I.'tlII ;11 '>ud,m \n lIuI' K~!.!lIlll, I

pproach l II·

"11111111'-' I I. I'" f \l.ll III, n" .11 1,IIlt.!dM. ush~. nil

",

'1111'111. ( h. I')'.) l'l'l.'olll.'r' 1<<.'ull .. I' uthropologrquedl' I" 'I.'"r"r .1,' de ,lIh II" D I. ubie oudan:n 'I' III Hlll1l~I ( 1"'.1, ..\CIC' dt' fa ille ·onfer· ence Internationnle d " ·!wde. ubienn .. Lille II·"

'P, I 'N4. I L r>' couverte: reh . oloWques. Unl\'CNII.'

harlcvdc- i.llIlk I.IlIe III PI-' ,'T" I

'>lIlIth H

III~).:'-'I, B (. (1).'1 H istor-, 11011 . ertlem nt in 1.0" r ubia. ell 11.1\ en

\ '11.101'1 I· IlJf, a I .1It' P,d~,,11I It lit! In t:gypU,tn ,111'1);1 '" \\ ':l\dUI'I,' kJ I'he Prehistury of l ubi' . , 11 \]', Dafbl'

1'1(, h \ \/lIhl;1I1 I mul Palcoluhr rave

I,IId Ill;' I ki'x'i '>,II\:Ioa." dall In cndorf.F Icd.I.The Vn'ili"Wr) elf uhiu.')'i·P}')"i 1>.111",

\\ ~IILl,)J'I, f- ,lUd 'lhrltl. f< 'CMII I .ue I'alelllilhi' \\:tr·

dumatu, I,

II' 'I' I (I 2!K

p< ,