Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Todays Presentation
1. Introduction to Stylometry
2. Literary Criticism for James Tiptree, Jr.
3. Results from Statistical Analysis
4. Conclusions
Brinegar (1963)
Mark Twain the author of the Q. C. S. letters
Juola (2013)
J. K. Rowling = Robert Galbraith cf. Kimura and Kubota (2015)
Fantasy novels
(Harry Potter Series)
[2-2a]
Reasons for Hiding Her True Identity
The first was that I wanted to conceal my writing from my
colleagues in the university. (I am a retired experimental
psychologist.)
[2-2b]
Reason for Using the Female Pen Name
A few violently prowoman ideas came to me,
and I saw that they were simply noncredible
under a mans name, so I invented a female
pseudonym (Raccoona Sheldon) for these.
Sheldon (1986: 390)
Intra-authorial
Variations in
Alice Sheldons Texts
Table 1
79.17%
Cpro = 87.08 %
Cmax = 93.06 %
Tiptree
Raccoona
Tiptree
55
12
Raccoona
Table 2
93.06%
Cpro = 87.08 %
Cmax = 93.06 %
Tiptree Raccoona
Tiptree
67
Raccoona
Inter-authorial Variations
Comparison between
Alice Sheldon and Ernest Hemingway
Ernest
Hemingways
Works
Table 3
93.66%
Cpro = 46.69 %
Cmax = 49.30 %
Cpro 1.25 = 58.36 %
Hemingway
Tiptree
Raccoona
Hemingway
70
Tiptree
63
Raccoona
Table 4
96.49%
Cpro = 46.69 %
Hemingway Tiptree
Raccoona
Hemingway
70
Tiptree
67
Raccoona
Cmax = 49.30 %
Cpro 1.25 = 58.36 %
Conclusions
On intra-authorial variation in Alice Sheldons texts
Statistical analyses cannot detect the difference between works
References
Burrows, J. F. (1987) Computation into Criticism: A study of Jane Austen's novels and an
experiment in method. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Burrows, J. F. (1992). Not unless you ask nicely: The interpretative nexus between analysis