Professional Documents
Culture Documents
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS
Contents
Executive Summary ............................................................................................................ 3
Industry ............................................................................................................................... 4
Past performance and 2016 Outlook ................................................................................... 5
Competitive Forces ............................................................................................................. 5
Support of Government ................................................................................................... 5
Price ................................................................................................................................. 6
Maintenance..................................................................................................................... 6
Running Costs.................................................................................................................. 6
Mileage Costs .................................................................................................................. 6
Five forces ....................................................................................................................... 7
Industry competitors ..................................................................................................... 7
New Entrants ................................................................................................................ 8
Suppliers ....................................................................................................................... 9
Substitutes..................................................................................................................... 9
Buyers ........................................................................................................................... 9
Strategy ............................................................................................................................. 10
Business Level Strategy................................................................................................. 11
Corporate Strategy ......................................................................................................... 12
Value Chain ................................................................................................................... 13
Primary Activities ....................................................................................................... 14
Support Activities ....................................................................................................... 14
Performance drivers ....................................................................................................... 15
Recommendations: ............................................................................................................ 16
Marketing Aspect: ......................................................................................................... 16
Research and development: ........................................................................................... 16
Manufacturing and production: ..................................................................................... 16
Infrastructure Development and Investments: ............................................................... 16
Corporate social responsibility: ..................................................................................... 16
Bibliography ..................................................................................................................... 18
PAGE 1
List of Figures
Figure 1 - Annual Sales of EVs globally ............................................................................ 4
Figure 2 Luxury Car sales comparison .......................................................................... 10
Figure 3 Tesla motors Revenue and Profit Historical Data ........................................ 13
Figure 4 Value Chain ..................................................................................................... 15
PAGE 2
Executive Summary
This report was commissioned to perform a strategic analysis of Tesla Motors Inc.
The methods of analysis make use of various tools like Michael Porters five forces
analysis framework, and the Value chain model. The report critically analyzes the business
and corporate level strategies and aims to connect it to the value chain of the organization.
The industries of luxury car markets and Electric Vehicle industry are also discussed and
analyzed in this report. The metrics displayed should provide the reader with a snapshot of
the industry.
Based on the analyses of Tesla Motors, several conclusions and recommendations are
drawn. These recommendations would allow the company to maintain and/or improve its
competitive advantage compared to its competitors.
Recommendations provided cover the following areas which are detailed further in the
document:
Marketing
Research and Development
Manufacturing and Production
Infrastructure development and Investments
Corporate Social Responsibility
The sources for the research of the company involve various online and offline sources that
included but are not limited to books, academic papers and websites; all of which are
referenced in the Bibliography section. All other references are maintained at the end of
each page for the perusal of the reader.
Word Count: 4800.
PAGE 3
Industry
Annual sales of EVs globally
565000
600000
500000
400000
315000
300000
213000
200000
100000
125000
50000
0
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
Sales
Quarter
Model S Sales
Q1-13
4901
Q2-13
5150
Q3-13
5500
Q4-13
6892
Q1-14
6457
Q2-14
7579
Q3-14
7785
Q4-14
9834
Q1-15
10030
Q2-15
11507
Q3-15
11580
1 Argonne National Laboratory, United States Department of Energy (2016-03-28). "Fact #918: March 28, 2016 - Global Plug-in
Light Vehicles Sales Increased By About 80% in 2015". Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy. Retrieved 2016-03-29.
2 Automotive Industry Data (AID) (2016-02-15).
AID Newsletter. Retrieved 2016-02-19.
Association Nationale pour le Dveloppement de la Mobilit Electrique - AVERE France (2016-03-24).
PAGE 4
is 52 percent increase from the same period in 2014. Tesla has a roadmap to sell 500,000
cars a year by 2020.3
Competitive Forces
The major competitive forces of the electric cars against internal combustion engines are
as follows:
SUPPORT OF GOVERNMENT
President Barack Obama in his 2011 State of the Union address, set the goal for the U.S.
to become the first country to have one million electric vehicles on the road by 2015. Based
on forecasts made by the U.S. Department of Energy (DoE) this goal was set , and the
Motor companies such as Fisker Karma, Fisker Nina, Ford Transit Connect, Ford Focus
http://www.ibtimes.com/tesla-model-s-only-electric-car-demand-right-now-low-us-gas-prices-batter-plug-car-2125907
4 Tesla Annual Report 2016 (http://ir.teslamotors.com/) ibtimes.com
PAGE 5
Electric, Chevrolet Volt, Nissan Leaf, Smith Newton, Tesla Roadster, Tesla Model
S and Th!nk City had set the target.5
PRICE
The most important goal for any electric vehicles is to overcome the disparity between their
development cost, production cost, and operation cost, compared to those of
equivalent internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs).
Till 2013, electric cars were significantly more expensive compared to
conventional internal combustion engine vehicles and hybrid electric vehicles because of
the cost of their lithium-ion battery pack. Although, now battery prices are down about 8%
per annum with production in bulk, and are expected to drop even more.6
MAINTENANCE
Generally, the electric cars have batteries which are quite expensive. In case, the battery
becomes defective, those expensive batteries are needed to be replaced. However, the life
of the batteries can be very long. Beside battery replacement, the maintenance of the
electric cars are low, specially, if the cars are using current lithium based designs. 7
RUNNING COSTS
According to a study by US department of Energy, cost of per mile for EVs is much lower
than the traditional ICEVs.
The cost of charging the battery depends on the price paid per kWh of electricity which
depends on location. As of 2012, a Nissan Leaf driving 500 miles per week is estimated to
cost approximately US$600 per year in charging costs in Illinois, as compared to cars
using gasoline which costs around US$2,300 per year in fuel.8
MILEAGE COSTS
The mileage-related cost of an electric vehicle can be attributed mostly related to costs of
charging the battery pack, and its replacement with its age, since the gasoline cars have
hundreds of its parts involved in internal combustion engines compared to an electric
vehicle which has just five moving parts in the motor. Hence, the cost on battery is required
to be calculated to calculate the cost per kilometer of an electric vehicle. The capacity of
the battery is also dependent on the usage of the car. Not to forget, even a battery with no
life has market value as it can be recycled and used as a spare battery.
5 U.S. Department of Energy (February 2011). "One Million Electric Vehicles By 2015 - February 2011 Status Report" (PDF). Office
of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE). Retrieved2013-02-27.
6 Siddiq Khan and Martin Kushler (June 2013). "Plug-in Electric Vehicles: Challenges and Opportunities" (PDF). American Council
for an Energy-Efficient Economy.
7 http://cleantechnica.com/2013/09/27/tesla-model-s-almost-maintenance-free/
http://www.earth911.com/eco-tech/electric-car-home-charging-guide/
8 U. S. Environmental Protection Agency and U.S. Department of Energy (2015-12-04). "Fueleconomy.gov's Top Fuel Sippers (EPA
Ratings, All Years)". fueleconomy.gov.
PAGE 6
The Tesla Roadster's very large battery pack is expected to last seven years with typical
driving and costs US$12,000 when pre-purchased today. The battery pack of Tesla
Roadster costs around US $ 12,000 currently and lasts for approximately seven years. For
example, driving Tesla Roadster for 40 miles per day for seven years
(365days*7years*40miles = 102,200 miles) leads to a battery consumption cost of US
$ 0.1174 per mile.9
FIVE FORCES
The five forces from Michael Porter give us a good insight about the positioning of the
corporation or business organization in a particular industry.
Taking a look at these five forces for Tesla:
Industry competitors
The new generation of electric vehicles powered by alternate drive trains have emerged in
the past few years. These are not only electrically powered but also advanced gas electric
hybrids; plug-in hybrids. This variation in technology can be one the major segregation.
Toyota Prius in gas hybrid and the Chevrolet Volt for plug-in hybrids are good successful
examples.10 The following table lists companies that are involved in this technology:
COMPANY
BEV
MODELS(TIMELINE)
Audi
Yes
e-tron(2012), A1eTron(2012)
Yes
Mini-E(N/D)*,Active-E
(N/D),
Megacity (2013)
BMW
BYD
Yes
CODA
Yes
Chrysler
Yes
United States Environmental Protection Agency and U.S. Department of Energy (2014-07-04). "Compare Side-by-Side: 2014 BMW
i3 BEV & 2014 BMW i3 REx". fueleconomy.gov. Retrieved2014-07-26.
10
Myles Edwin Mangram, The globalization of Tesla Motors: a strategic marketing plan analysis, Journal
of Strategic Marketing, Vol. 20, No. 4, July 2012, 289312
PAGE 7
Daimler
Fisker
Yes
No
Detroit Electric
Yes
Aptera
Yes
2e
Ford
Yes
Force rating: Medium, as Tesla already has alliances with major automotive industry
brands and has a high technological factor.
New Entrants
This industry requires huge initial capital investment in terms of Research and
Development, Manufacturing facilities, human resource etc. It is very difficult for a new
entrant to gather and invest such capital. Hence the Greenfield entry is very challenging.
Another possibility for a new entrant would be through mergers which are again quite
challenging. The revenue from other companies owned by Elon Musk provided the huge
capital required for Tesla Motors. This wouldnt be possible for small companies willing
to enter this segment.
Force Rating: Medium, completely new company being established chances are pretty
low, but the existing automotive industry giants like BMW, Audi etc. are exploring this
segment and hence can be competitive as these companies have longer experience in car
manufacturing sector.
PAGE 8
Suppliers
Tesla ensures the highest safety standards for its cars and has high safety ratings. The
suppliers are mainly evaluated by their ability to provide high quality parts. Hence it
becomes expensive as most of the time these suppliers are mainly concentrated in the
economically strong countries. It also makes shipping expensive. The cost of production
too fluctuates according to the world economies .The threat to suppliers would be that some
of the major components are manufactured in-house like drive trains, engines etc. Some of
the major suppliers for Tesla are Panasonic for batteries. Hence the bargaining power of
the suppliers is low.11
Force Rating: Low, Tesla is planning to increase its in-house production for most of its
parts to cope up with quality requirements and hence suppliers power doesnt play a major
role.
Substitutes
Tesla also has a great competitive advantage as it being the pioneer can very well integrate
its power train technology with its vehicle design and software to produce a high
performing product. But the technological variances like the hybrid, the conventional
Internal Combustion (IC) engines or the lug in cars make the situation more competitive.
The other factor of considering Tesla as a mode of locomotion is also critical to access as
there are other cheaper and more environmental friendly options available to the customer
segments like buses, trains, bicycles etc.
Force Rating: High, the technology is disruptive technology as cracking the tradition IC
engine market is difficult and the network of other modes of locomotion is well established.
Buyers
The main customer segment targeted by Tesla is eco-friendly, technology loving people.
They are focusing on B2B and B2C markets; An Example of B2B is Tesla and Uber. The
price sensitivity of the customer segment is also low as these people are generally who are
willing to invest in the luxury cars. Tesla is the pioneer in the high performance electric
car segment and hence in terms of technology, it is incomparable in this aspect. Being an
early mover has also gained the attention of the customers.12
Force Rating: High, the customer segment has greater capacity to spend and hence might
move to established brands like BMW and Audi once the option is available.
11
Edward Peter Stringham Jennifer Kelly Miller J.R. Clark, CALIFORNIA MANAGEMENT REVIEW
VOL. 57, NO. 4 SUMMER 2015 CMR.BERKELEY.EDU
12
Foundations of Business Strategy Strategic Analysis Report: Tesla Motors Inc.
PAGE 9
Strategy13
Teslas primary strategy is to be a market disruptor in the automotive industry. It follows
a top down disruptive strategy; by which it launched its most expensive product in very
few numbers first and used the profits to develop the next generation of cheaper cars in
larger volume to appeal to a larger customer segment. This is further discussed in the
corporate strategy section.
26566
25000
20000
18480
15000
10000
5000
0
2014
2015
Tesla Model S
BMW 7 Series
BMW 6 Series
Lexus LS
Audi A7
Audi A8
Porsche Panamera
Jaguar XJ
This strategy of tesla has been on track as expected and the company is now launching its
fourth generation of cars; the Model 3. The success of this strategy can be seen by the
number of cars that were sold in each of its generation.
The above infographic shows how Tesla has seen success in the number of its cars sold
from the year 2014 to 2015. Every other luxury car maker has seen a drop in the number
of cars sold. This could partially be true due to Tesla gaining on their market shares.
The main reason Tesla has been able to increase its sales while its competitors are losing
it, is the fact that it is able to embed technology deeper into the car than its competitors.
The digital revolution has made the modern consumer more affinitive to technology and
one of the industries that was unable to keep pace with this technological revolution is the
13
http://cleantechnica.com/2016/01/15/1-large-luxury-car-in-us-tesla-model-s-2015-sales-comparison/
PAGE 10
car industry. Since most luxury car makers are well established and large organizations,
they lack the innovative and entrepreneurial spirit to develop newer technologies without
the corporate sluggishness slowing down the entire process. Since Tesla has minimal
bureaucracy, it is more agile and able to innovate quicker than its well established
competitors.
Most of the customers that purchase a Tesla car, do so because of the technological factor
of the vehicle. The environmental friendliness and cheaper refueling (recharging) are only
minor added bonuses. The customers are generally early adopters of technology who are
comfortable with experimenting with newer technologies. This also allows them to
distinguish themselves from the mass market. These customers are the primary revenue
drivers for Tesla.
Another important advantage of Tesla would be the fact that the entire car is controlled
with the use of software. This allows the company to keep updating its vehicles with newer
features for the existing hardware. This is a disruptive concept that no other car maker has
ventured into. The customer is able to enjoy the newer features of the next generation
without having to purchase an entirely new car.
BUSINESS LEVEL STRATEGY
The primary business level strategy for Tesla is a focused differentiation strategy, targeted
at middle and upper income customers. It is currently handicapped in one aspect compared
to its competitors; lack of traditional gas engine. This is one of the Unique Value
Propositions that Tesla has to offer to its customers. However, this also limits the customers
from being able to refuel their vehicles at any of the extensive network of gas stations. This
forces Tesla to develop its own network of Super-charger network across the countries
that it operates in.
Although the consumers can recharge their cars at home, to make Tesla truly compete
against the traditional car industry, it would need to extend the range currently available.
Tesla tackles this problem with two solutions. Firstly with its increasingly large number of
super charging stations enabling its customers to travel longer distances without worrying
too much about the recharging. Providing this service free of cost attracts more customers.
Secondly, Tesla motors is continually working on improving its battery technology. By
increasing the capacity of batteries included in each generation of the vehicle, the reliance
on recharging of the vehicle is reduced considerably compared to older generations.
Another important aspect to consider is the entire industry of electric vehicles. Since this
is disruptive to the traditional car industry, there hasnt been much support for these
ventures. To address this issue; Tesla motors has open sourced several of its patents for
PAGE 11
other companies to utilize.14 This will allow the entire industry to mature and eventually
overtake the traditional car market.
CORPORATE STRATEGY
Traditionally disruptive technologies start from the bottom, and gradually increase the user
base to a point where the technology can no longer be ignored and becomes a main stream
product. Alternatively, Tesla Motors had selected a major product viz. an electric car and
aims to bring it to the mass market as quickly as possible.
This strategy can be better explained by analyzing by what the companys chairman calls
his Master Plan. This plan consists of the five following steps for the company to
achieve15:
Tesla motors aims to bring in the disruptive technology of Electric Vehicles to the mass
market. The above statements conform closely to what Tesla has been doing in the past
few years. It released the very first sports car, the Tesla Roadster, back in 200816 for a base
price of $109,000. The Roadster was engineered to compete head to head with high end
sports cars at the time, and it outperformed many, rightly so.
The second phase of Musks plan involved building of a relatively cheaper version; the
Model S. The deliveries of the Model S began in June of 2012. It currently has a retail base
price of $80,000.
The three part plan needed to be extended into four categories due to engineering and
economic challenges faced by Tesla Motors. This led to the announcements of two new
models; the Model X and the Model 3 on February 2013 and March 2016 respectively.
Being a relatively smaller company with limited funds; this strategy allowed Tesla Motors
to strengthen up its economic stand point and thereby allow it to achieve an organic growth.
While this may be true per say in terms of the revenue generated, the company has actually
been making losses year over year as observed in the following illustration.
14
https://www.teslamotors.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you
https://www.teslamotors.com/blog/secret-tesla-motors-master-plan-just-between-you-and-me
16
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Roadster
15
PAGE 12
Million USD
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
-1000
-2000
Revenue
Net Income
2012
413.26
-396.21
2013
2013.5
-74.01
2014
3198.36
-294.04
2015
4046.03
-888.66
Tesla has a high degree of vertical integration which is quite uncommon in the automotive
industry. Most car manufacturers focus engine manufacturing and assembly of the cars.
Tesla on the other hand, while it has several suppliers, attempts to build the entire car from
the bottom up.
17
18
PAGE 13
Primary Activities
Inbound Logistics. The integral components of the car are manufactured by Tesla inhouse.19 Most of the other components are sourced from several suppliers. This system
improves the efficiency of the entire process.
Operations. The primary market for Tesla was the United States. By producing the cars in
the United States it reduces the cost of the finished car. All of Teslas cars are manufactured
in its production plant in California20. High levels of automation allows the labor costs to
be minimized. The robots can also be easily reprogrammed to create different models
unlike human labor which would require training, thus making this process even more
efficient and cost effective.
Outbound Logistics. Tesla motors sells its cars through its own stores located in 18
countries. Most of the reservations are made online. Forward vertical integration in this
manner allows Tesla to remove the car dealerships which would further reduce the cost of
its products.
Marketing and Sales. Tesla has a rather modern method of advertising. It does not employ
any traditional marketing. The Tesla owned stores attract a lot of foot traffic which allows
the company to educate people of the need to own zero emission vehicles. Several
celebrities owning Tesla cars also provide a mode of advertisement for Tesla.
Service. The USP for Tesla in terms of service is its presence of Super-charging network
which provides free recharging of its vehicles. No other car manufacturer currently offers
free refueling of their products. Tesla is also working on expanding its service centers to
better serve its customers.
Support Activities
Firm Infrastructure. Tesla being a young organization benefits by being flexible in its
organization structure. Elon Musk oversees most of the operations of the company and
delegates authority to the managers. This makes the organizational structure quite
horizontal21 and provides faster communication and quickens the decision making process.
Human Resource Management. Having clearly defined goals for the future of the company,
Tesla attracts a large number of highly talented individuals. Candidates aspire to be a part
of a company that is attempting to affect the world in a positive way.
19
http://www.supplychainbrain.com/content/blogs/think-tank/blog/article/font-size2tesla-motors-a-tale-ofbeauty-and-painfont/
20
http://www.teslamotors.com/about
21
Tesla Motors, 2014
PAGE 14
Tesla was founded by Elon Musk, who has considerable experience in both, the technical
aspect of the business as well as the business perspective. He is the founder of SpaceX,
SolarCity, PayPal, and Hyperloop. His experience with running successful businesses
makes him the most integral resource for Tesla. His personal involvement with the design
and improvement of his products is indispensable to the organization.
Teslas strategic partnership with Toyota which is also a major investor is also a key
resource, to increase its capital. It also has partnerships with other major organizations like
Panasonic, on which it relies for the procurement of the batteries for its cars.
PAGE 15
Recommendations
MARKETING ASPECT
The major goal of Tesla in the marketing field would be to generate demand for its cars
and give leads to its sales teams, generate brand awareness using the advertising media and
social media where they are absent and manage the corporate reputation. They should also
try to keep their existing customer base happy as it would create customer loyalty in the
end and also let customer feedback be a part of their innovation process.22
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT:
Tesla should keep innovating their products at a regular basis. With the competition being
high the perfection in designs and innovations bring about the product and company
differentiation.23The Tesla Model S has zero emissions. Disruptive innovations like the
Auto-pilot feature is a marketing campaign in itself and Tesla would need to continue
innovating to maintain its competitive edge.
MANUFACTURING AND PRODUCTION
Some capital investments for Tesla come from the money customers invest in the upcoming
models. But the problem is the amount of customers investing and the promise to
manufacture huge amount of cars can be risky. Tesla should try to forecast their
manufacturing strategies well in advance to avoid the problem of not meeting the customer
deliveries after the upfront payments. Forecasting would be of immense help to Tesla.
INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT AND INVESTMENTS
The major investment other than the manufacturing facilities is the charging and serving
stations that they need to offer. The Model S has a range of 500 miles in a single charge
and hence it is really important to have a good network of charging and to expand their
super-charger network across all geographies of operation. They can also take some help
from the Government for the same. The infrastructure should be globally expanding. For
example in Norway they people have some government subsidy while buying electric cars.
This can boost sales.24
CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
They should try to invest money in educating people about the advantages of using electric
cars and should advertise their zero emission concepts for the same. They should arrange
22
Myles Edwin Mangram, The globalization of Tesla Motors: a strategic marketing plan analysis, Journal
of Strategic Marketing, Vol. 20, No. 4, July 2012, 289312
23
Kotler & Keller, 2009, pp. 325326
24
http://europe.autonews.com/article/20150512/ANE/150519968/norway-reaffirms-electric-car-subsidiesafter-boom
PAGE 16
environmental campaigns that would also earn good will for the company. Since their core
manufacturing process or their products are not harmful to the environment, it serves to be
of a good source of reputation for the company. Tesla would need to maintain and improve
this reputation in all means possible.
PAGE 17
Bibliography
#1 Large Luxury Car In US = Tesla Model S (2015 Sales Comparison). (2016). Retrieved
April 21, 2016, from http://cleantechnica.com/2016/01/15/1-large-luxury-car-in-us-teslamodel-s-2015-sales-comparison/
Elon Musk. (n.d.). Retrieved April 14, 2016, from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk
Johnson, G., & Scholes, K. (1999). Exploring corporate strategy. London: Prentice Hall
Europe.
Porter, M. E. (1998). Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior
performance. New York: Free.
Tesla Motors. (n.d.). Retrieved April 18, 2016, from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Motors
Tesla's Gigafactory Supply Chain Vertical Integration. (n.d.). Retrieved April 21, 2016,
from
http://www.supplychain247.com/article/telsas_gigafactory_supply_chain_vertical_integr
ation
The Secret Tesla Motors Master Plan (just between you and me). (2006). Retrieved April
18, 2016, from https://www.teslamotors.com/blog/secret-tesla-motors-master-plan-justbetween-you-and-me
PAGE 18