Professional Documents
Culture Documents
!#"$&%(')+*-,/.1024365708:9<;=%>24,@?A24B+5(CD*-'E9?"F$&8HG<3'E94IKJL,/*-*NM OFPQ'.R9<.RSF8>.R*-3
3T .US7')WVXY.H9=VQ8Z$&8:X[S(2\V+.U)^]`_U,/.R94_U.
B T .RS7')WVaX[.R9Vb8EZdce*f.H_gV+)+,-_R'E*h'E94Ii$&8EX[S(2\V+.R)bce9<;=,-9<.U.U)a,/9<;
jk,-_l.nm94,No=.R)+p6,fVqM=5\08:24prVa8:9@5<st.gG('EpuEuv:vw
x M\_y%`2@54%4%4*z57'*-_5<P{,/*-*NMF|E}D_UpR"~)+,-_l.:"~.HI42
!#"$&%(')&*,+./10!24365#798;:=<?>A@
BC<EDGFH0JI#KJ24IMLNDO@OF<P7AQGRE:;<ES6RP<
TU:=RE<WVAS6:;X#<E7ZY9:;F[
H\>^I#]#@6]NYZF9_ IMSc5#b:=S`dfQ&ehF979gM<Eg <a]MF ]Mi
dj<E8=<k0;lmng ^oqp4okrqstuoMv#Hw
xy5z{lAm|g Hoqpfo#rqstui#wMoM]
}JL~5k:=8|lj[&R3&@?RPYE079:;RE<#0<EO@
O
S~F936:=YD5#D!<E7Pb&<CD67Z<EY9<PSqFfF36<A79YFfY[GYF<PLF365kF4:;LNDO8=<EL<ESqF9Y4CD!<ES _` IMS~5.S6<aF4I#79I#KY935k79<E t
L<ELIM7Z[1L(@68;F9:=D67ZIGRP<EY9YZIM79YP0d36:;YY[&YZF<PL<PS5#68;<EYF36<D679I#M75#LL<E7FI79<P8;[IMSN5.YZ:=S6#8=<#bqYF5#SO5#79b
Y9365#79<P t L<ELIM7Z[ K,IM7D5#795#8=8;<E8=:;H5kF9:=IMSCU:F36:;S15L@O8;F:;D679I&RE<PY9YZIM75kS61{<aF4<P<ESL@68F:=DO79I&RE<EYZY9IM7ZYE0
F:=Y:=LD68=<PLN<PSF9<E1X&:5.5WF975#S6YZ85kF9IM7JF35F4RPIMSqXM<E7FYUCD!<ES _` O:=79<PRPF9:;XM<PYF9I5#D6DO79IMD67Z:5kF9<URH5#8;8=YJFI.5
LIG6:<EX#<E7ZY9:=I#SNI#K!F3O<Adj79<E5# _ 5k79YYZI#K$F45#79<A6:=YF7Z:=6@OF9<EY9365#79<PNL<ELIM7Z[m|QGBWQ _p YZ[&YZF9<EL0JS
REI#SF975#YFF9IWD679<aXG:;IM@6YQOBWQ _ YZ[&YZF9<ELYK,I#7Q _ YEb&F36<ULIG6:<Edj79<E5# _ 5#7ZYY[GYF<PL@OY9<EY WQGe
F3O79<H5k6Y?K,IM7?D5#795#8=8;<E8=:;Y9LU:F36:;S5#SQ _ S6I&6<k0d36:=Y5#DOD679Iq5kR3#79<H5F8;[Y9:;LND68;:;<PYF936<R35#S6M<PY
79<P@6:=7Z<EFI1F36<.QOBWQ _ :;SI#796<P7UF9I<azGD68=I#:;FfF936<W:=SqF795 t S6I&6<?35k79O45#79<WYZ35#79<PL<ELIM7Z[#0
<D67Z<EYZ<ESqFD!<E7K,IM79LN5#S6RP<79<PY9@68FYK,IM7Y9<aXM<PS5#D6DO8=:=RE5kF:;IMS6Ymf5#7ZS6<EY t >@GFHbW2fV5#S65kF<P7
K,79I#LQ CQO> tuv b o B t xxdK,79IMLA?Q{bTA<P t 48=5#RQ6?TWb{dAQ 5#S6 _ Q p 79@OS6S6:=SO~IMS5kSQ v
U:;F93NK,IM@O7K,I#@67 t D679I&RE<PY9Y9I#7fQ _` SOIG6<PYE0JREIMLD5#7Z:=YZIMSN!<PF<E<PSF36<UF3O79<H5k~:=LD68;<EL<ESqF5kF9:=IMS5kS6
F3O<IM79:;M:=S65#8:=LD68=<PLN<PSqF5kF9:=IMSI#Kdj79<H5k _ 5#7Z&Y?YZ36I^UYCF35F?@6Y9:;S6~F936<35#7ZO45#79<YZ35#7Z<ELN<PLNI#7Z[
U:;F936:=S5#SQ _` SOIG6<.Y9:;MS6:;6RH5#SqF8[79<P6@6RE<PYCF36<(5#LIM@6SqFIkK5kF5N5#S6F936<(S@6L({<P7CI#KJL<EYZY5#M<PY
F795#S6YZLN:F9F<P!<PF<E<PSSOIG6<PYEb5#S6RPIMS6Y9<P@6<ESqF8[5#R3O:=<PX#<EYCYZD{<P<E6@OD6YCF35F?5#7Z<.@6DF9I oM]M !<PFZF<P7
F365#SF936<IM79:;M:=S5k8jX#<E79YZ:=IMSOYE0~<5#8=YZIRPIMLD5#79<NQOBWQ _ 5#M5#:=S6YFWLN<PY9Y95#M<D5#Y9YZ:=S6O0XM<P75#8;8|bF3O<
Y9D!<E<P6@6D6YI#KL@68;F9:;F93679<E5#6<Edj79<E5# _ 5k79YDO79IMM795#LYU5#79<?U:;F936:=SgH oM]q I#KF936< _ 4XM<P79YZ:=IMS6YP0
` qc(ykj#CD{<PS _ Y935#7Z<EL<ELIM7Z[D67ZIMM75kLNL:=S6Ob WQGe
F367Z<H5#OYEbS6<PFIM7Z&YI#KQ _` YPb
Y9IkK$Ff5#7Z<.O:=YZF979:;6@OF<PY935#7Z<ELN<PLNI#7Z[M0
D
%$/+%&
1 "& +
D5##<@OSF9:=8F936<W@6D!5kF<W:;YREIMLD68=<aF<k0
SK5#RaFHbF3O<N@6YZ<NIkK4FILN5#D6D6:;S6MY?79<P6@6RP<EY.F936<S&@OL{<P7.IkK !%&=5"5+.=!bIM7WD5#M<D67ZI#F<PRPF9:=IMScb
IMD!<E795kF:;IMS6Y~D!<E7K,IM79L<E [dj79<H5k _ 5#7Z&YPb<aXM<ESIMS5Y9:=SOM8=< t D67ZIGRP<EY9YZIM7~SOIG6<k0 xIM7N<zO5#LNDO8=<#bU:;S
F3O<`IM7Z:=M:;S5#8fdj79<E5# _ 5k79YEbU579<H5k5#RPRE<EYZYNF9I5#S :=SqXk5#8=:;D5#M<4I#@68=79<EYZ@68;F:;S FI !%A=5"5+.=
IMD!<E795kF:;IMS6YElIMS6<CFI1<PS5#68;<U79:F<?5kRERE<PY9YU:=S~IM796<P7fFI1@6D!5kF9<F3O<?D5#M<?5kS65#S6I#F936<E74F9I1L~5k#<CF3O<
D5##<79<H5k t IMSO8;[15K$F<E7F936<U@6D!5kF<k0SF36<ULIG6:<EX#<E7ZY9:=I#ScbIMS68;[.F36<8=5kF9F9<E7 !%&=5"5+.=IMD!<E75F:=I#S
:=YD!<E7K,IM79L<E0Jd36<.YZ<ERPIMS6L~5#DOD6:=S6<P8=:=L:=S65kF<PYF3O<SO<E<EK,IM7fF936<?79YF !%A="5+.=IMD!<E75F:=I#Sc0
x:=S65#8=8[Mb{<PRH5#@OY9<?I#KjIM@67@6Y9<?IkK5.Y9:=SOM8=<5#667Z<EY9YYZD5#RP<#b6F3O<CIMD!<E75F:=SOYZ[&YZF9<EL 5#@OFI#L~5kF9:=RE5#8=8[
LN5#:=SqF5k:=S6Y?F3O<REIM3O<E79<PS6RE<IkKfF36<~D5#M<NL~5#DOD6:=S6#Y.:;S@6Y9<~[F3O<~6: <P79<ESqF1DO79I&RE<EYZY9IM7ZY(U:;F936:=S5
S6I&6<#0x@67F36<P79LIM79<kb5#S %A=5"+.=q[IMS6<?F3O79<H5kU:F36:;S5S6I&6<5#D6DO8=:=<PYfFI1F3O<IkF36<P7UF93679<E5#6YP0
SRPIMSqF795#YZFEbY[GYF<PLNYY9@6R35#Y.2f5#Y936L<E7Z< tuv Hs bjF935kF@6Y9<NVSO:zD67ZIGRP<EYZY9<EY.:=S6YF<E5#I#K WQGe
F3O79<H5k6YEbL(@6YZF(D{<P7ZK,IM7ZL F36<NY5#L< !%A="5+.=:;S<E5#R3 D67ZIGRP<EY9Y ' Y5#667Z<EY9Y(Y9D5#RP<#0d36<7Z<H5#YZIMS:;Y
F365kF %A=5"+.= IMS68[ 5#DOD68=:;<EYFIF3O<RE5#8=8;:=S6D679I&RE<PY9Y ' Y5k6679<PY9YY9D5kRE<#b4<PXM<PS :KF936<@6S66<P798;[&:;S6
L<ELIM7Z[~:=YY9365#79<P`!<PF<E<PS5#667Z<EYZYYZD5#RE<PYE0
2 2
A< H& -=M EE j&
C@67C@6YZ<1I#K WQGe F3O79<H5k6Y?35#IMSO<@6S66<PY9:;75#68;<)< {<ERaF?IMSF936<dj79<H5k _ 5#7Z&YW:;SF9<E7K5#RE<k0WVS66<P7
WQGe F367Z<H5#OYEbM8=I#5#8X#5k79:5k68=<PYJ5#79<4Y935#7Z<E U36<P79<H5kYEb:=SF936<IM79:;M:=S65#8Gdj79<E5# _ 5k79Y bMM8;IM5#8
Xk5#79:=5#68;<EY5#79<`D679:Xk5kF<k0 d3&@OYEbU:=S IM@67NLNI&6:;6<EXM<E7ZY9:;IMSI#K?dj79<E5# _ 5k79YEbUM8;IM5#8fXk5#7Z:5#68;<EY5#7Z<
Y9365#79<P{<aF4<P<ESF367Z<H5#6YU:;F3O:=S5NL@68;F9:=D67ZIGRP<EYZY9IM7A6@OFW5k79<(DO79:;Xk5kF9<U:F37Z<EYZD{<PRPF?FINF367Z<H5#6YIMS
56: <P79<PSFL@68;F9:=D67ZIGRP<EYZY9IM7P0TA5kF3O<E7.F935#S5kFZF<PLNDOF9:=S6FIY9IM8XM<~F936:=Y.D679IMO8=<EL :;SF36<N79@6S t F:;LN<
YZ[&YF<ELbq4<UR36I#Y9<FI5#6O79<EYZY:;FJ:;SF36<ACD!<ES _ F75kS6Y98=5kFIM7U36<E7Z<5?YZIM8=@OF9:=IMS(:=YYF75k:=M3qF9K,I#7Z45#79c0
A
-$
! +%! $+% % $ )
djI(F795#S6Y98=5kF<5(Y9<P@6<ESqF:=5#8DO79IMM795#L5#S6S6IkF5kF9<EU:;F93~D5k75#8;8=<E8y6:;79<PRPF:XM<PYf:=SqFI(5.K,IM7Z t IM:=SND5#795#8=8;<E8
D67ZIMM75kL`bF936<1F795#S6Y98=5kFI#7?<ES6RE5#D6Y9@O85kF9<EYW<H5#R3D5#795#8=8;<E8j79<E#:=IMS:=SqF9I`5YZ<ED5#795kF<YZ@6679I#@OF:;S6<#0d36:;Y
Y9@O679IM@GF:=SO<5#8;Y9I:=S6RP8=@66<PYRPIG6<kb{#<ES6<P75kF9<Eq[F36<.REIMLD6:=8;<E7Pb6F35kF5#8;8=I^UYU<H5#R3F93679<E5#FIN6<PF9<E7 t
L:=S6<kb!65#Y9<PIMS:FYUF367Z<H5#`:=6<PSqF:;6<E7EbyU36:;R3D!IM7ZF9:=IMS6YAI#K5ND5#795#8=8;<E87Z<EM:;IMS`:FAS6<E<P6YFIN<azG<ERP@OF<k0
fFF936<{<PM:=SOS6:=S6I#K{5CD5#795#8=8;<E879<PM:=IMSb#F36<4L~5#YF<P7F367Z<H5#1D65#Y9YZ<EY5CD{I#:=SqF<P7FICF936:=YY9@667ZIM@OF9:=S6<4F9I
F3O<CY98=5^X#<F3O79<H5k6YE0 IM:=SqF<P79Y4F9I ):-2"/X#5k79:5k68=<PY45#SO:=S6:F:5k8OXk5#8=@6<PY4I#K #1;.).=,1;:<5=5"Xk5#7Z:5#O8=<EY
5#7Z<RPIMD6:;<E:=SqFI51YZF979@6RaF@67Z<(5kS6`D65#Y9YZ<E`F9I1F36<WY98=5HXM<EY5kFF936<WY5#L<CF:;LN<k0
C5#7Z:5#68;<EY5#RPRE<PY9Y9<P1U:;F3O:=S5D5k75#8;8=<E8#79<E#:=IMS6<PK5k@68;FFI ):-"/y0K5AM8=IM65#8#Xk5#79:=5#68;<:;Yj5#S6S6I#F5kF<P
=2-5",/?;:<5(=5" b!:;FRH5kS6S6I#F!<?5#SOS6I#F5F<E5kq5#:=SNU:;F3O:=S5D65#75#8;8=<P8!7Z<EM:;IMSc0d3@6YPb6F36<F75kS6Y98=5kFIM7
5#8;8=I&RH5kF9<EY5#8;8M8;IM5#8{X#5k79:5k68=<PYfIMSF36<WYZ35#79<P36<E5#D@6S68=<PY9YF3O<P[5#7Z<W5#S6S6I#F5kF<PE=2-",2/1;:<(=56" 0
xIM7<H5kR3 =2-",2/1;:<(=5
" M8=I#5#8UX#5k79:5k68=<kbUF936<REI#LND6:;8=<P7~5#8;8=I&RH5kF9<EY~5#S5#79795H[I#K
REI#D6:=<PY
I#KF936<~M8;IM5#8JXk5#7Z:5#68;<#bU36<E7Z< :;Y.F3O<~S@6L!<E7IkKfF367Z<H5#OYD{<P7S6I&6<#0}5#R3 79<aK,<E79<PS6RE<F9IF3O<
M8;IM5#86Xk5#7Z:5#68;<U:=Y47Z<ED68=5#RE<Pq[N5(79<aK,<E79<PS6RE<FI(F936<C5#7Z75H[Mb&Y9D!<ERP:;RE5#8=8[MbG5.7Z<PK,<E7Z<ES6RP<CFIF36<<E8=<PLN<PSqF
REI#7979<PY9D!IMS66:;S61FIF36<?F93679<E5# ' Y(m,8=I&RH5#8 p :;c0
S dj79<E5# _ 5#7ZYEbU5F93679<E5# ' YNYF5#R:;Yk<EDOF~:=S D679:Xk5kF<L<ELIM7Z[#0d3@6YPbfX#5k79:5k68=<PYO<ERE8=5#79<P
U:;F936:=S5ND67ZIGRP<E6@O79<(F935kF?5k79<5kRERE<PY9YZ<EU:;F936:=S`5~D5#795#8=8;<E87Z<EM:;IMSL@OYZFC!<(LI^XM<PFI~F936<(YZ35#7Z<E
36<E5#Dc0JS5#66:F:;IMScbqXk5#79:=5#68=<PY46<PRE8=5#79<PU:;F3O:=S5D67ZIGRP<E6@O79<?5#SOD65#Y9YZ<Eq[79<aK,<E7Z<ES6RP<CFI5#S6IkF36<P7
D67ZIGRP<E6@67Z<5#7Z<~LI X#<EF9IF36<~Y935#7Z<E 36<E5#D!<ERE5#@6Y9<F936<~F975#S6YZ85kF9IM7RH5#S6SOI#FD67ZI^XM<F365kFYZ@6R35
Xk5#79:=5#68;<CU:=8=8SOI#F!<@6Y9<P:=S`5ND5k75#8;8=<E879<E#:=IMSc0Q&FIM795#M<WK,IM7F36<PY9<(Xk5#7Z:5#O8=<EY:;Y5k8=8=I&RH5F<E5kFAF3O<
!<EM:;S6S6:=SO1I#KF936<WD679I&RE<P6@67Z<(5#SOK,7Z<E<P5kFF936<W<ES6c0
LNDO8=<EL<ESqF9:=S6B ?;:<5(=5" Xk5#7Z:5#68;<EY:=YYZF975#:;M3qF9K,IM7f5k79clU36<ES6<aXM<P75Xk5#79:=5#68;<:=YN5#S6S6I#F5kF<P
D67Z:;Xk5kF<U:;F936:=S5`D5k75#8;8=<E8J7Z<EM:;IMScb:;FY6<aS6:;F9:=IMS:=Y6@6D68;:=RE5kF<P:=SF36<ND679I&RE<P6@67Z<M<ESO<E75F<E[
F3O<?REIMLD6:=8;<E7F35F<ES6RE5#D6YZ@685kF9<EYF3O<CD5#795#8=8;<E8!79<E#:=IMSc04<ERE5#@6Y9<W<E5#R3F367Z<H5#RH5k8=8=YF36:;YfD67ZIGRP<E6@67Z<
5kK$F9<E7fF3O<WK,I#79yb6F36<PY9<WXk5#79:=5#68=<PY4U:=8;8!<5#8=8;IGRE5kF<PIMSF36<WD67Z:;Xk5kF<?YF5#RIkK<E5#R3F93679<E5#c0
!# & +
^]
e r 0 v 0
$/+
'
!
DG#@
!#"&NPO7+O ( 8
g]_0A^a!#n`
83viuw4
"!#$%'&( 8 ) / +9
*-;,+:<&.(+$=#/!?>
EH+FQFI2GRSE H+QI2RTEVUWHJ
+H FE I)F)KXJQ
U'Q#I#J'J#oqU.fE)I2prLRbU'U Q#o
J#U.[I)Q#LJ c/%)="dLebGQ
h#HBU.E#I iJ)fE)XKXJGf
QVFU.EG))I X/GH
Q#H+oqfs=px$Q#+o (iNtHBU
012+@A&35$+46=B$47C!#+"!( //+
!#"!!#Y!//+/L+"[Z\M'%%'&
L!#"!!#"!/!#+Y!/[/+/ZjL%+lk"[mZ\M'$%%'M'&%'&
!#"!!#Y!//+/L+"[Z\M'%%'&
y
o B t xxdK,79IML F936<fA?Q(!<ES6R36LN5#7Z.YZ@6:;F9<4Y9I#8;XM<PYJ5D5k7ZF:=5#86:{<E7Z<ESqF:=5#8<E@5kF9:=IMS(@6Y9:;S6
F93679<P< t O:=L<ES6YZ:=IMS5k8jK,IM7f5k795#S6:=SqX#<E79YZ<~xxd?0d36<D67ZIMM795#L 365#Y?F367Z<E<1Y9365#79<P5#7Z75H[&Y?I#K
5F5<E8;<EL<ESqFY5#S65#S5#7Z75H[I#KAR36<ERY9@OLNYP0d36<REI#LND6@GF5kF9:=IMS:;Y(6<PREIMLD!IMY9<P YZIF35F
<aXM<E7[:;F9<E75F:=I#S:=S6RP8=@66<PY8=I&RH5#8REIMLD6@OF5kF:;IMS5#S65M8=IM65#8{F975#S6YZD{I#Y9<#0
S`CD{<PS _ bOF36<?65kF5D5k75#8;8=<E8;:=YZL :=SF936<C8=I&RH5k8{RPIMLNDO@OF5kF9:=IMS5#S6F36<M8=IM65#8!F975#SOY9D!IMY9<?:;Y
<zODO79<EYZY9<P@6Y9:;S61F366< 5,"3#%(~6:=7Z<ERPF9:;X#<#0
8
24I#SF9:=S@6IM@OYVK,79IML Q CQO> tuv D!<E7ZK,I#79LYNV
K5#RPF9IM79:;H5kF9:=IMSU:F36I#@OFD6:;X#I#F:;S660 d36<
LN5kF7Z:z:;Y46:X&:=6<P:=SqFI.Y9@5#7Z<C68;IGRYF935kFf5#79<6:=YF79:;6@OF9<E5#LIMS6.D679I&RE<PY9YZIM79Yf:;S5(7ZIM@6S6 t
7ZIM6:=SK5#YZ36:=IMS0xy@O7ZF3O<E79LIM7Z<#bF936<O8=I&R&YI^US6<E q[F3O<Y5kLN<D679I&RE<PY9YZIM75#7Z<5k8=8=I&RH5F<E
RPIMS6Y9<PRE@OF9:;X#<E8;[:;SY935#7Z<ELN<PLNI#7Z[~F9ILN:;S6:=L:=P<AK5#8;Y9<?YZ35#79:;S660
SCD!<ES _` bF936<D5k75#8;8=<E8;:=YZL 5#8;IMS6!I#F936:=L<ESOY9:=I#S6Y.IkKF36<NL~5kF979: z:=Y<azGD679<PY9YZ<E @6Y9:;S6
F9366< ,2"N79<PM:=I#S6:=7Z<ERPF9:;X#<#0
^5kF<P7jK,7ZIML Q ?QO> tv :;Y5ULIM8=<PRE@68=5#7O[&S5#L:=RPYYZ:=L@68=5kF:;IMSc0d36<L~5k:=SW5kF5YZF979@6RaF@67Z<
:;S`5kF<P7C:=Y5~IMS6< t 6:;LN<PS6Y9:;IMS5#8j5#7Z75H[I#KLIM8=<PRE@68;<EYE0BC@67Z:=S6N<H5#R3F:;LN<WYF<EDbc{IkF3:;SF975 t
5#SO:=SqF<P7 t LNIM8;<ERP@685#7D!I#F<PSqF:5k8=Y5#79<CRPIMLD6@OF<Pc0Jd36<CD65#75#8;8=<P8{5k8=MIM7Z:;F936L YZF5kF:;RH5#8;8;[16:X&:=6<PY
F936<15#7Z75H[I#KLNI#8=<ERP@68=<PY:;SF9I~<P&@65#8=8[`YZ:=P<EREI#SF9:=M@OIM@6YC68;IGRYPbc5#YZY9:=#S6:=S6N<H5#R368;IGRF9I5
F93679<E5#c0d3O<6@68=I#KUF3O<:=SqF<P79D67ZIGRP<EY9YZIM7REIMLL@6SO:=RH5F:=I#S79<PY9@68FYK,7ZIML Y[&S6R3679I#S6:=E5kF:;IMS
F935kFF5k#<EYAD68=5#RE<?6@O79:=SOF936<W:=SqF<P7 t LNIM8;<ERP@685#7K,IM79RP<WREIMLD6@OF5kF:;IMSc0
S CD{<PS _ bF936<<PXk5#8;@5kF:;IMSI#K:=SqF975 t LNIM8;<ERP@68=<ND{I#F9<ESqF:=5#8=Y(79<E@6:;79<PYSOI:;SqF<E795#RPF9:=IMSOY1{< t
F<E<PSLIM8=<PRE@68;<EY5#SO:;YD5#795#8=8;<E8=:;E<P~@6YZ:=S61F3O< !" #%&6:;79<ERaF:XM<#0d36<W<aX#5k8=@5kF9:=IMS
I#K:;SF9<E7 t LIM8=<PRE@68;<.D!I#F<PSqF:5k8=YC:;YCD5#795#8=8;<E8=:;E<P@6YZ:=S6F936$< 2,"57Z<EM:;IMS6:;79<PRPF:XM<k0}5#R3
F93679<E5#:=Y.5#YZY9:=#S6<E5`Y9@O6Y9<aF1I#KfF936<~LIM8=<PRE@68;<EYP0F15#RPRE@6L@O85kF9<EYWF36<N79<EYZ@68;F9Y(I#K4F36<K,IM79RP<
RPIMLNDO@OF5kF9:=IMSIMSY9@O6Y9<aFYfI#KLNI#8=<ERP@68=<PY5#Y9YZ:=MSO<ENF9I.IkF36<P7F93679<E5#6Y:=SqFIW:;F9YD679:X#5F<ULN<PLNI#7Z[
6@O79:=SOF936<.RPIMLD6@OF5F:=I#Sc0AK$F<P7Z45#796YPb5k8=8F936<F93679<E5#6YAYZ[&S6R367ZIMS6:;E<(U:F3<H5#R3`I#F36<P75kS6
YZ@6L@6DF36<WRPIMSqF79:;6@OF9:=IMS6YfF9I1F36<P:=7I^USYZ@66Y9<aFYAI#KLNIM8;<ERP@68=<PY:=S51YZF5kMM<E7Z<EK5#Y93O:=IMSc0
TU<E t 485kRWQG@6RPRE<EYZY9:XM<UXM<P7 t TA<P85zO5kF9:=IMSW:=Yj5ULN<aF36I&WK,IM7Y9IM8XG:;S6UD5#7F:5k8M6: {<E7Z<ESqF:=5#8q<E@5 t
F9:=IMS6Y[:;F<P75kF9:=S6~I X#<E75F4I t 6:;LN<PS6Y9:;IMS5#85#79795^[#0S<PX#<E7Z[:F<P75kF9:=IMScb{<H5#R3I#KF3O<N5k7975H[
<P8=<EL<ESqF9YA:;Y@6D!5kF<PF9I1F36<5HXM<P75#M<I#KjF36<W<P8=<EL<ESqF ' YK,IM@67SO<H5#7Z<EYZFS6<P:=M3!IM79YP0
d36<PY9<5kF5D5#795#8=8;<E8CI#D{<P75kF9:=IMS6Y5#7Z<<azGD679<PY9YZ<E :=S CD{<PS _ @6YZ:=S6F36<B5," #%(
6:;79<PRPF:XM<k0
2
v
5
^o
16
14
Speedup
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
Barnes
3D-FFT
Water
CLU
OpenMP/orig
SOR
OpenMP/thread
TSP
MGS
MPI
Normalized Data
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Barnes
3D-FFT
Water
CLU
OpenMP/orig
SOR
OpenMP/thread
TSP
MGS
MPI
Hr
Normalized Messages
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Barnes
3D-FFT
Water
CLU
OpenMP/orig
SOR
TSP
MGS
MPI
OpenMP/thread
3
8 %$!
QH+FF'f)h-?XGh
HJ'GVUQ)XXQE
fJi)KJ'XGI
QFiH#XE
f'H+Ih#h#E#Q#F#JJJ
HtH+Q#hJh#JE
G#J.H+h#QQ#FJE
40T[NP&%
Q#H+J.QF)h-XXII
FiQE)H#/KJH
QJiKJ')QKEJ
Q#JH#XG
h#F'I#fJG#h#JJE
H+GVQVUU'UJ
QVU.HJ.F'h#hVJE
i
x IM7?F36< _ XM<P79YZ:=IMScb<~79<PD{I#7ZF{IkF3F36<FI#F5#8JS@6L!<E7WI#K4LN<PY9Y5kM<EY.5#S6F36<S@6L!<E7WI#K
L<EY9Y95#M<PYAF935kFA5#RaF@5#8;8;[NRE7ZIMY9YAS6I&6<?{I#@6S65#7Z:=<PYE0
2 4 3
J7 < 5 Oy 4< !k
J7 < 5 :j
SF<E7ZLNY1IkKC79<P85kF9:;X#<Y9D!<E<P6@6D6YPbfF36<5#D6DO8=:=RE5kF:;IMS6Y.RH5#S {<RE5kF<PMIM79:;E<P :;SqFIK,IM@671M7ZIM@6D6YP0d36<
7ZYZF`M79IM@ODcb?REIMSOY9:=YF:;S6IkKf5#7ZS6<EYPb2fjV 5#S6 _ Q!bA365#Y`8;I^FILNI&6<P75kF9<RPIMLD6@OF5F:=I#SF9I
REI#LNL@OS6:=RE5kF:;IMS 795kF:;IMYE0 xIM7F36<PY9<D67ZIMM75kLNYPbUF936< v t FI i t K,IM8=79<EO@6RPF9:=IMS :;S F36<5kLNIM@OSF~I#K
5kF5F795#S6YZLN:F9F<P 7Z<EY9@O8;FYN:=SY9:=#S6:;RE5#SqF~YZD{<P<E6@OD6YE0 d36<Y9<ERPIMS6 M7ZIM@6DcbRPIMS6YZ:=YZF9:=S6I#K?5kF<P7
5#S6 Q6?Tb35#Y3O:=M3REIMLD6@OF5kF:;IMS F9IREI#LNL@OS6:=RE5kF:;IMS795kF:;IMYE0S F936:=YNRH5#YZ<#bA5 r 0 i t FI wt K,IM8=
79<P6@6RaF:=I#S:=S`5kF58=<E5#6YF9I8=:F9F98=<?:=LD67ZI X#<EL<ESqF:=S7Z@6S6S6:;S6~F9:=L<#0UdAQ K,IM79LYAF936<.F936:=7ZM7ZIM@6Dc0
FA5#8;Y9I35#YA5136:=#3REIMLD6@OF5kF:;IMSFIREI#LNL@OS6:=RE5kF:;IMS75F:=IO0d36<.CD{<PS _ F3O79<H5k`XM<P79YZ:=IMS6I&<EYPb
36I^<PXM<P7Eb5#R36:=<aXM<.D{<P7ZK,IM7ZL~5#SORE<W:=LD679I^X#<EL<ESqFA{<PRH5#@6YZ<5#S@6D!5kF9<.I#KF36<RE@O7979<PSqFYZ36IM7ZF9<EYFCD5kF93
:=Y:=LL<E6:=5kF<P8;[.Y9<E<PSq[N5#8=8F3O79<H5k6Y4IMSF36<AY5kLN<AS6I&6<U36:;R3~< <PRPF:XM<P8;[79<P6@6RE<PY4F3O<S@6L!<E7I#K
D5kF936YfFI!<?<azGD5#SO6<Ec0xxdK,IM7ZLNY4F936<CK,IM@67F3M7ZIM@6DcbOU3O<E79<?<WY9<E<51Y98;:=M3qF4Y98=I^U6I^USK,IM7fF3O<
CD{<PS _ F93679<E5#RPIGO<#0(d3O<1Y98=I^U6I^US35#D6D!<ESOY?:=SF3O<F75kS6Y9D!IMY9<1YF5##<U36<E7Z<N5k8=8DO79I&RE<EYZY9IM7ZY
79<P@6<EYFJ5kF5AK,79I#L IMS6<D679I&RE<PY9Y9I#75kF5AF9:=L<#b :=SqXMI#&:;S68=5#79#<S@6L({<P79YIkK79<P&@O<EYZF35#S668;<E7ZYIMSF35F
D67ZIGRP<EY9YZIM7 ' YS6I&6<#0Jd3O<?79<H5kY9IMSK,IM7F36<Y98=I^U6I^US:;Y46@6<CF9Ie ' Y4:=S6< NRP:=<PSFf:=LD68=<PLN<PSF5kF:;IMSI#K
D5##<DO79I#F9<ERPF9:=IMSIMD!<E795kF:;IMS6Y5kYA<zGD685#:;S6<E!<E8;I W0
XM<E795#8=8nbREIMLD5#7Z<EFICD{<PS _ kIM7Z:=M:;S5#8nb{F3O<~CD!<ES _` F367Z<H5#D679IM#75#LY?Y9<PS68;<EYZY65kF5Ob
K,79I#L 518=I^I#K v#\q 8=<PY9Y5kF5(K,IM7 o B t xxdF9IN53O:=M3I#K w 0 F:;LN<PYf8=<PY9Y5F5(K,IM7UQOWTWb5#SOK,<a4<P7
L<EY9Y95#M<PYEb#K,7ZIML 58=I^ IkK v#wq K,<a4<P7L<EY9Y95#M<PYK,IM7 o B t xxdFI536:;M3(IkK w 0 i F:;LN<PYK,<P<E7L<EYZY5#M<PY
K,IM7Uf5k79S6<PYE0
x:=#@679< r REIMLD5#7Z<EYF36<CS@6L({<P7fI#KF:;LN<PYF935kFfF936< !%A="5+.=IMD!<E795kF:;IMS~:;Y4D!<E7K,IM79L<E:;S~F3O<
IM7Z:=M:;S5#8k5#S6?F36<JF93679<E5#X#<E7ZY9:=I#S6YI#KGF936<F795#S6YZ85kF9<E.CD{<PS _ D67ZIMM75kLNYcI#SWK,I#@67jQ _ SOIG6<PYE0d36<
Xk5#8=@O<EYIMSF36<[ t 5zG:;Y:;YJS6IM7ZL~5#8;:=P<EU:;F9379<EYZD{<PRPFFIWF36<F93679<E5#X#<E7ZY9:=I#S6YE0Jd36<A6<aF5#:;8=<ES@6L!<E7ZY
5#7Z<f8=:;YZF<P1:=Sd5#68;< o 0x:=7ZYZFHbkF36<ACD!<ES _ F93679<E5#D679I#M75#LYU:F31IMS6<F367Z<H5#D!<E7JS6I&6<fD!<E7K,IM79L
vMi i#\q K,<a4<P7 !%A="5+.=IMD!<E75F:=I#S6YfF35kSF936<REIM7Z79<EYZD{I#S66:=SO~CD!<ES _` IM79:;M:=S5k8XM<P79Y9:;IMS6YU:;F93
IMS6<D67ZIGRP<EYZY`D!<E7S6I&6<kbC:=S6O:=RH5F:=SOF35FF36<5#8;:5#YLN5#D6DO:=S6m,Y9<E<QG<PRPF:;IMS o 0 o 0 ^p 79<EO@6RE<PY`F3O<
S@6L!<E7I#K !%A=5"5+.=IMD{<P75kF9:=IMSOY:=S6O<ED!<ES66<PSqFI#K.5#Sq[ L(@68;F9:;F3O79<H5k6:=S6)< {<ERaFYE0QG<PREIMSOcbF3O<
CD{<PS _ F93679<E5#D679IM#75#LYU:F3(K,IM@O7F3O79<H5k6YJD{<P7S6I&6<fD!<E7K,IM79L 0 w \ 0 v F9:=L<EYjK,<P<E7 !%A=5"5+.=
IMD!<E795kF:;IMS6YF35kSF36<(CD{<PS _ kIM7Z:=M:;S5#8RPIG6<PYU:F3`K,I#@67DO79I&RE<EYZY9<PYCD{<P7S6I&6<k0dIYZ<ED5k75kF9<.F3O<
REI#SF979:;6@OF:;IMS6YAFINF936:=Y79<P6@6RPF9:=IMS`K,79IML@6YZ:=S6OIM@668;<(LN5#D6D6:;S65#SOK,79IML@6YZ:=S6~L@68;F9:;F93679<E5#6:=SO6b
<K,@67ZF936<E7~LN<E5#Y9@67Z<F3O<S@6L!<E7~IkK %A=5"+.= I#D{<P75kF9:=IMS6Y:=S 79@6S6SO:=S6F936<CD!<ES _ F93679<E5#
^\
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Barnes
3D-FFT
Orig/1
Water
CLU
Thrd/1
SOR
Orig/4
TSP
MGS
Thrd/4
g
8 LkmU
HJ.F#J'h)FHIHBUI
Q'h#IEG#ffiJ'EIfH
QiFVHU.HGH+II
EVFHUFH+UF)F)XXXFfF
HhV+J'QI)I)XUF
QGVIUF)XXIQ
IGiGHGVH+U.FFf
EQI'hVQJ'G#FJ
UG'QVU'U.J#J#U-I#UJh
UH+U.FF#GJGGH
Q#h#J.If#h#Jf
QH+GVU'F'Jh
G'h#QVU
^s
97 <PM:=I#S6Y.IkKfF36<N5#6O79<EYZYY9D65#RE<k0`e IMDGF:=L:=P<EY5#RPRE<EYZY9<PYFI<PSqF79:;<EY.:=SF36<N8=:=YF[YF5#7F:=SO`F3O<
F795HXM<E7ZY5#8cK,7ZIML F36<?D67Z<PX&:=I#@6Yf<ESqF97Z[5#RPRE<PY9Y9<Pc0d36:=YIMDGF:=L:=E5kF:;IMS:=YEbG36I^4<aXM<P7EbyS6I#FfX#<E7[<){<ERaF:;X#<
IMSL@68F:;D679I&RE<PY9Y9I#79Y!<ERH5k@6Y9<6: {<E7Z<ESqFUF367Z<H5#OYUF9<ES6FI5#RPRE<EYZYO:=YZF9:=S6RaFU79<PM:=IMSOYI#KL<ELIM7[M0
x:=#@679< i RPIMLND65#79<PYF936<S@6L!<E7I#KD5##<K5k@68;F9YIGRPRE@67Z<E:=SF936<IM79:;MS5#85#S6 F36<F93679<E5#
XM<P79YZ:=IMS6Y.I#K4F936<N5#D6D68;:=RH5F:=I#S6YEbS6I#79LN5#8=:;E<EU:F379<EYZD{<PRPF.FIF36<F367Z<H5#XM<E7ZY9:;IMS6YE0~d36<~6<aF5#:;8=<P
S@6L!<E7ZYC5#7Z<.8;:=YZF9<E`:=Sd5#O8=< o 0d36<(RPIMLD679:;Y9IMS`Y936I^UYF935kFL@68F:;F93679<E5#6:;S679<EO@6RE<PYF36<.S@6L t
!<E7IkKD5#M<K5#@68;F9YElU36:;8=<F36<S@6L!<E7I#KD5#M<K5k@68;F9Y`:;S6RE@67Z79<Pq[ CD!<ES _ F93679<E5#U:;F93
IMS6<F93679<E5#D{<P7S6IGO<5kS6?D!<ES _ kIM79:;M:=S65#8U:F3IMS6<D67ZIGRP<EYZY`D!<E7S6I&6<:;YF36<Y5kLN<kbF3O<
CD{<PS _ F93679<E5#D67ZIMM795#LNYCU:F3K,IM@67?F3O79<H5k6YWD{<P7SOIG6<:=SORE@67 0 v i F9:=L<EY?K,<P<E7D5#M<1K5#@O8;FY
F365#S F36<P:=7CD!<ES _ kI#79:=#:=S5#8AREI#@6SqF<E7ZD5#7FYU:;F93K,I#@67D67ZIGRP<EY9YZ<EYD{<P7S6I&6<#0 d36:=Y7Z<E6@6RaF:;IMS
REI#LN<PYfK,79IML FIY9IM@67ZRE<PYE0x:=7ZYZFEbOK,IM7L@68F:;D68=< t 79<E5#6<P74D5##<EYEbI#S68;[NIMS6<WI#KjF36<CF93679<E5#6YAIMS51S6IGO<
S6<P<E6Y~F9IK5#@O8;F:=S IM79O<E7NF9I@6D!5kF9<F936<D65#M<`5#S6LN5##<:;FN5#RPRE<PY9Y9:;68=<`q[ 5k8=8UI#KF936<`F93679<E5#6YPb
U36<P79<H5kYC<H5#R3IkKJF36<.D679I&RE<PY9Y9<PY?IMS5S6IGO<(35#YAFI~K5k@68;FIMS6RP<.FI~@6D{65kF<.:;FYAI^USREIMDq[#0?QG<PREIMS6b
@6YZ:=S6L@O8;F:F367Z<H5#O:=S6N<E8=:;LN:;S5kF9<EYUF36<K5#@O8;FY79<E@6:;79<Pq[5D679I&RE<PY9Y5#RERP<EYZY9:=SO`5D65#M<F365kFC45#Y
:=SqXk5#8;:=5kF9<Eq[5#SOI#F36<P7UD679I&RE<PY9YUU:;F3O:=SF3O<Y95#L<?S6IGO<#0
x:=S65#8=8[Mb d5k68=< o Y936I^UYF935kFK,I#7 ^\ t 45^[.D5#795#8=8;<E8;:=Y9LIMS(K,IM@O7S6I&6<EYPbCD{<PS _ F93679<E5#RE79<E5kF<PY
0 ]Mo i F9:=L<EYfK,<a4<P76: YfF935#SCD{<PS _ kIM7Z:=M:;S5#8|0
2
J7 < 5 !& j 5
D679<aXG:;IM@6YYZF9@6O[REI#LND5k79:=SOQGBWQ _ U:F3LN<PY9Y5kM<ND65#Y9YZ:=S6 ^] 35#YY936I^USF935kFHbj:=SM<PS6<E795#8|b
QOBWQ _ D67ZIMM795#LNY(Y9<ESOLIM79<~LN<PY9Y5kM<EY5#S65F5F35kS LN<PY9Y5kM<D5#Y9YZ:=S6X#<E79YZ:=IMSOY16@6<FIF3O<
^w
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Barnes
3D-FFT
Orig/1
Water
CLU
Thrd/1
SOR
Orig/4
TSP
MGS
Thrd/4
A >
v
o
r
i
\
g
s
w
^]
y
v (_
^o
Hr
i
^\
g
^s
^w
v#]
R
v
vkr
B
8 : 6 ,
7Z<ERP<E:;X#<EF936<.0 Q!0!O<EM7Z<E<WK,79IMLF936<(VAS6:;X#<E7ZY9:;F[IkKQGRP:=<ESORE<5kS6`dj<ER3OS6IM8=I##[I#K
$
67<j Jc 79<PRE<P:;XM<PNF936<0 Q{0qO<EM7Z<E<UK,79IML F36<VS6:XM<P79Y9:F[1I#K <PSFEb&4<E8;M:=@6LbM:;S H w g w b
vMi