: , " "

,
, :
, , ? ,
- ? -
. ,
- , .
?,
, :
, , ? 1
,
, .
,
, : , ,
, .
-
, ,
- - ,
.
,
( -) (
) . ,
.

,
, . ,

178

Jacques Rancire 1
(2007). Are Some Things
Unrepresentable?, in The
Future of the Image. Trans.
Gregory Elliott, London; New
York: Verso, p. 109.

 . ,

2.

, , ,

3
,
,
.,
Jacques Rancir (2006):
The Politics of Aesthetics: The
Distribution of the Sensible.
Trans. Gabriel Rockhill, New
York: Continuum, pp. 20-21.
,


( ) ,
,
.

. - .
, - , ,
- - , (,
-) . ,

, , - :
- -.

,
-
3. , -
. ,
- , ,
. , ,

Rancire, The Politics of 4

Aesthetics, p. 50.
Jacques Rancire (2002). 5
The Aesthetic Revolution
and its Outcomes. New Left
Review 14, p. 135.

( , ) ,
4. ,


, .
, ,
.
(
) , - .
,
, 5.
, , ,
: ,
, , .
, ,
. ,
,
, . - ,

179

 , ,
. , , .
, , ,
, . .

, .
aesthesis- , -
, .
( ) ,
. ,
. ,
, :
, , .

, ,
: ( ) ,
( ).
, ,
.
, ,
7. : - ,
- 8. ,
- , - .
,
- . , ,
. , , ,
: - , , -
, , .
,

, . ,
. ,
. , (

) ,

180

6


,

"" .

,

.


,


.


""
,
-
(Rancire,
The Politics of Aesthetics, p. 50).
7
,
"
" ,
.
Gabriel Rockhill (2004). "The
Silent Revolution." SubStance
33.1, p. 56.

,
:


?

.
Jacques Rancire (2009). The 8
Aesthetic Unconscious. Trans.
Debra Keates and James
Swenson, Cambridge; Malden,
MA: Polity Press, p. 28.

 - - .
, .

Rancire, Are Some Things 9

Unrepresentable?, p. 137.

,
. , ,
: ,
, ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
: - ;
.
, .
. - , ,
,
, 9.
, .
, , , .

- . ?
, :
,
.
,
- ( , ,
) . , ,
, , : ?
()
, ? ,
- . ,
,
.

181

 - ,

, , ,Msentente-
-.

10

,-

. ,
. ,
,
,
, , .
,-
-
11. :
,
, , . ,
,
-
- . ,-
. ,
,
.
,
, . ,
, , ,
, -
12.
-
. :
,
.
- ,
,

182

10
,
Msentente.Disagreement-
,


" :-"
( " ,

- ' ",
:' ( .)2008
: ,
' ( :),
.)29
,

.
-

,
Msentente-
-
(

).
"-"
,

.
Disagreement-
,
(,)Agreement

,

. ,
,Disagreement

. ,

Msentente-

, ,
,
.Disagreement-
,
,Discord

.Accord
:
( )
,Accord

-
(
) .

,
,
,


.
Discord-
.
, Discord-
,
Discord- ,
Discord-
-

.Msentente-
Accord-
(
) ,
Discord
- . ,



(Msentente
,entendre
"") , -

,
()
.
Jacques Rancire (1999). 11
Disagreement: Politics and
Philosophy. Trans. Julie Rose,
Minneapolis: University of
Minnesota Press, p. x.
Aristotle (1996). Politics I, 12
1253a 8-18, The Politics and
the Constitution of Athens.
Trans. Jonathan Barnes,
Cambridge: Cambridge
.University Press, p. 13

 , - . ,
- , .
, , ,
.
( )
13. ,
, .
[ : ] -
- .
, ,
]...[ .
: 14. , :
( ) ,
, ( ).
( )police
, , ,
.
. ,
. , .
, .
, , ,

13
,Le Partage du Sensible
The
Distribution of the Sensible
The Partition of the
.Perceptible
" " ,
" "
,

-
()
.
"
,
,,
,' ". ,


, ""
.
Jacques Rancire (2009).
Politique de lindtermination
esthtique, in Jrme Game
et Aliocha Wald Lasowski
(eds.), Jacques Rancire:
Politique de lesthtique.
Paris: Edition des Archives
.Contemporaine, p. 159
14 , ,
' .50-49
Rancire, Disagreement, 15
.p. 29

, . ,
, , - 15. ,
,
, ( , )
?
.
- - ,
- .
,
.
, . ,

183

 . ,
-
.

16

, .

. , ( , ) - .
, (
) .
, , .
,
, - , , - ,
( demos- ,
) .
(
, , ) , - -
, .
. , , ,
- : ( /
/ ) ,
. ,
. , ,
-.
, , .
, , .
, .
, , ,
. ,
. ,
, ,
. . ,
, , :
, .

184

le compte des incompts, 16

the part of those who have
no part.

 , , ,
, ,
. , ,
,
, , , , .
,
.
,
?
,
. , ,
, - --
.
( ) , ,
. , ,
. , - ,
. ,
.
,
.
- .
,
, ,
. ,
( ) .
, ,
( , ) .
- -
- . ,
,
17. ( ) .

185

 , , ,
, ,
- , .
, ,
, , .
, .
, , .
, ,
- - .
( -
)
. ,
, - .
,
, . , , ,
, . ,
- - .
, :
, , .
, ,
. , ,
, , ,
.
, ,
. ,
. ,
. , ,
,
,

. -
, .
,
,

186

Jean Francois Lyotard 17

(1988). The Differend:Phrases
in Dispute. Trans.
Georges van den Abbeele,
Minneapolis:University of
Minnesota Press, p. 9.

 . ,
. ,
,

,
- .
: ,
, .
. ,
,
. , . ,

18 ,
,
"" ,
,
'

-

.

, -
"
" -
.

, ,
, ,
. , , ,
,
, .
, .
, , , ;
, ,
.

-
- , .
:
. , , , .
, ,
( , ) ,
( , )
18. , ,
, .
,1942-
.

187

() , ,
.1954- - -

Rancire, Are Some Things 19

Unrepresentable?, p. 129.

- ,
, , , .
,
. ,
, ,
( ).
, :
, ,
; , ;
, , ,
, ; ,
, . ,
. , , ? ,
-
.
, ,
. ,
, . ,
, . ,
,
, .
,
-
. , ,
.
- , - ,
, ,
, .

19

,
, - . -

188

' 1
, .

 , , -
.
. , .

Jacques Rancire (2009). 20

The Emancipated Spectator.
;Trans. Gregory Elliot, London
New York: Verso, pp. 22-23
( ).

,
, , .
,
: : , , .
. - ,
;

' 2 ,
.

- ; ,
,
- , , ]...[ .
, ,
, .

20

, -
, -
.
, .
,
, ,
. - , ,
, ,
, - - .

189