Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Executive Summary
Recommendation: HOLD
Current Price: $37.54
Target Price: $34.53 (8% Downside)
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
$60
$50
LUV $37.54
$40
$30
LUV $34.53
$20
$10
Close Price
Current Price
Feb-16
Jan-16
Dec-15
Nov-15
Oct-15
Sep-15
Aug-15
Jul-15
Jun-15
Apr-15
$0
Mar-15
Feb-15
NYSE: LUV
Industry: Airlines
Sector: Transportation
Financial Analysis
Investment Themes:
Low Cost, No Frill Approach
Conservative Operating Philosophy
Declining Competitive Advantage
Strained Employee Relations
May-15
Investment Highlights
Target Price
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
C
Cost Structure
E
D
F
D
E
G
C
Vs.
Hub and
Spoke
Low Cost
Structure
Point to
Point
Low Fares
Employee Relations
Hub connections
significantly
increase CASM
Higher aircraft
utilization and
turnaround times
Routes are
interdependent
for connecting
passengers
Brand Image
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Executive Council
Conclusion
EVP of Corporate
Services
EVP/Chief
Commercial
Officer
28
Jeff Lamb
Robert E. Jordan
Thomas M. Nealon
29*
Chairman of the
Board, CEO
Gary C. Kelly
12
24
EVP/Chief
Financial Officer
Tammy Romo
15
EVP/Chief
Operating Officer
SV P Gen. Counsel,
Corporate Secr etary
Mark R. Shaw
Your people come first, and if you treat them right, theyll treat the customers right.
- Herb Kelleher, Founder of Southwest Airlines
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
GRAND
RAPIDS
FLINT
ROCHESTER
RICHMOND
WICHITA
BRANSON
CHARLOTTE
MEMPHIS
BERMUDA
ATLANTA
PENSACOLA
PARADISE ISLAND
SAN JUAN
PUNTA CANA
CANCN
MONTEGO BAY
MEXICO CITY
ARUBA
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Threat of
New
Entrants
Industry
Rivalry
Threat of
Substitutes
Power of
Buyers
8
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Changing Dynamics
Deregulation
Weakened
Barriers
Laissez-faire
Pricing
Bankruptcy
Converging Interests
Average Fares
$500
$450
Legacy
Legacy
$400
$350
LCCs
ULCCs
$300
$250
Before 1978
2016
$200
1979
1986
1993
2000
2007
2014
9
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Industry Timeline
American West/US
Airways Merger
2001
DAL/Northwest Financial
Merger
Crisis
2008
2005
2010
2011
2013
Strengthening Z scores
$200 B
18%
16%
14%
$150 B
2
12%
10%
$100 B
8%
6%
$50 B
-1
4%
2%
-2
1997
1999
2001
AAL
2003
2005
DAL
2007
2009
UAL
2011
2013
LUV
2015
$0 B
0%
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Revenue
Operating Margin
10
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Evolving Structures
Operating Cost Structure
45%
40%
40%
35%
35%
30%
30%
25%
25%
20%
20%
15%
15%
10%
10%
5%
5%
0%
1998
0%
2001
2000
2002
2004
Labor
2006
2008
Other Costs
2010
2012
2014
2003
2005
Wages
2007
Fuel
2009
2011
2013
2015
Other Costs
The industry dynamics have changed substantially since the Deregulation Act
11
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Current Dynamics
Supply Imbalance vs Crude Oil
3.0 M
$120
2.5 M
$100
2.0 M
$80
1.5 M
1.0 M
$60
0.5 M
$40
0.0 M
$20
-0.5 M
-1.0 M
$0
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Macroeconomic Drivers
Contracting PMI levels
6%
80,000 B
5%
70
60
4%
70,000 B
50
3%
60,000 B
Correlation = 84%
50,000 B
2%
40
1%
40,000 B
30
0%
30,000 B
-1%
20,000 B
-2%
10,000 B
-3%
0B
0B
500 B
1,000 B
1,500 B
2,000 B
2,500 B
-4%
1986
20
10
0
1991
1996
2001
PMI Index
PMI
*78%
Non-PMI
*80%
Corp. Earnings
*84%
2006
2011
2016
Traffic
* Denotes correlation
13
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Industry Drivers
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Yield
20%
14.0
15%
12.0
10.0
10%
8.0
5%
6.0
0%
4.0
-5%
-10%
2010
2.0
2011
2012
Legacy
2013
LCC's
ULCC's
2014
2015
0.0
03/06
10/07
PRASM
05/09
12/10
07/12
02/14
09/15
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Revenue Analysis
Historical Yield
20%
35%
15%
30%
10%
25%
20%
5%
15%
10%
0%
5%
-5%
0%
-10%
-5%
-10%
2006
2008
2010
2012
2014
2016
-15%
2002
2005
2008
2011
2014
2017
15
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Growth Opportunity
4%
Domestic
6%
Capacity
Expansion
2%
International
16
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
40%
Industry
35%
= -15%
30%
= 10%
25%
ULCC's
= -8%
20%
LCC's
15%
= -11%
10%
Legacy
5%
0%
1997
2000
2003
2006
Industry Wages
2009
2012
LUV Wages
2015
2018
-60%
-40%
-20%
09/2015
0%
20%
40%
12/2009
17
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
14%
Industry
12%
= -15%
10%
ULCC's
8%
= -8%
6%
= 34%
LCC's
4%
= -11%
2%
0%
2011
Legacy
2012
2013
Southwest*
2014
2015
-60%
-40%
-20%
09/2015
Industry*
0%
20%
40%
12/2009
Not only has the world changed, but our relative position within the industry on costs has changed.
- Gary Kelly, CEO of Southwest Airlines
18
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
17%
5Representing
83%
Unionized
Current Negotiations:
Non-Unionized
57%
43%
55.8% Employees
Labor Expenses
Other Expenses
19
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Legacy
Other
LCCs
ULCCs
CostCost
Quality of Service
Quality of Service
LUV
Legacy
LUV
ULCCs
Other
LCCs
Cost
20
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Profitability Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Historical EBITDAR
6,000
4,000
5,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
Before Adjustment
After Adjustment
27.4% EBITDAR
28.9% EBITDAR
24.1% ROIC
20.3% ROIC
+2.7B Debt
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%
ROIC
Reported ROIC
Adjusted ROIC
21
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
12.0 x
70 %
60 %
10.0 x
50 %
8.0 x
40 %
6.0 x
30 %
4.0 x
20 %
2.0 x
10 %
0%
FY05A
NM
FY07A
FY09A
FY11A
As reported
FY13A
FY15A
FY17E
Adjusted
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Valuation Overview
DCF Analysis
Price: $38.81
Relative Valuation
Price: $30.24
(50%)
(50%)
Terminal EV/EBITDAR
Adj. for Operating Leases
EV/EBITDAR
Normalized P/E
LUV
$34.53
8% Potential Downside
23
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Revenue Assumptions
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Revenue Projection
25 B
35%
30%
Assumption Breakdown
YoY Capacity Growth:
Load Factor:
Change in Yield:
Passenger Revenue:
Freight:
Other Revenue:
Total Operating Revenue:
YoY Growth Rate:
FY16E
5.5%
83.6%
-1.5%
19,023
180
1,257
20,460
4.1%
FY17E
4.0%
83.6%
0.5%
19,882
184
943
21,009
2.7%
FY18E
3.0%
83.6%
1.0%
20,684
180
971
21,835
3.9%
20 B
25%
20%
15 B
15%
10%
10 B
5%
0%
5B
-5%
0B
-10%
FY09A
FY10A
FY11A
FY12A
FY13A
FY14A
FY15A
FY16E
FY17E
FY18E
~82%
Average Annual
Reinvestment Need
0B
-1 B
-2 B
-3 B
FY05A FY06A FY07A FY08A FY09A FY10A FY11A FY12A FY13A FY14A FY15A
Reinvestment Need
24
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
WACC Assumptions
Cost of Debt
2016-2019 Terminal
Risk-free Rate*:
2.25%
3.00%
BBB+ Default Spread:
2.00%
2.00%
Cost of Debt:
4.25%
5.00%
*Expected 10-Y U.S. Treasury
WACC:
Cost of Equity
2016-2019 Terminal
Risk-free Rate*:
2.25%
3.00%
Risk Premium:
5.00%
5.00%
Adjusted Beta:
1.32
1.16
Cost of Equity:
8.84%
8.78%
2016-2019 Terminal
7.11%
7.60%
25
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
DCF Outputs
Base
$38.54
$54.70
$65
Brent
- $75
$35
- $45 - $55
Brent
Bull$55 - +5.1%
$45 - $55 - $65 Brent
SPE
Bear
DCF
$55 - $65 - $75 Brent
Target Price
+7.6% SPE
$38.81
$23.72
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Average Per-employee
Expense
Sensitivity Analysis
$120,862
$123,884
$125,092
$126,301
$127,510
$128,718
$129,927
$131,136
$132,344
$133,553
2.5%
3.5%
4.5%
5.5%
6.5%
7.5%
8.5%
9.5%
10.5%
$ 25.00 $
$ 1.21 $
$ 48.75 $
47.25
45.72
44.17
42.58
40.97
39.32
37.65
35.95
30.00 $
1.30 $
47.71 $
46.21
44.68
43.13
41.54
39.93
38.29
36.61
34.91
35.00
1.39
46.68
45.18
43.65
42.09
40.51
38.89
37.25
35.58
33.88
50.00 $
1.66 $
43.56 $
42.06
40.54
38.98
37.39
35.78
34.14
32.47
30.76
55.00 $
1.75 $
42.53 $
41.03
39.50
37.94
36.36
34.74
33.10
31.43
29.73
60.00 $
1.84 $
41.49 $
39.99
38.46
36.90
35.32
33.71
32.06
30.39
28.69
65.00
1.93
40.45
38.95
37.42
35.87
34.28
32.67
31.03
29.35
27.65
27
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Relative Valuation
North American
Airlines
Screening
Criteria
Comparable Valuation
Multiple
Turn
Price
2016E EBITDAR:
4.4 x $30.47
2017E EBITDAR:
4.5 x $26.64
Revenue >1.5B
20.0 x
15.0 x
10.0 x
5.0 x
0.0 x
28
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Valuation Summary
Team Analysis
Consensus
DCF Analysis
$38.81
Relative Valuation
$30.24
(50%)
(50%)
Target Price
$34.53
(8% Downside)
29
Investment Highlights
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
OR1
Medium
Probability
High
Risk Analysis
Company Overview
OR2
MR2
MR3
MR1
UC
Low
OR3
Low
Legend
OR1: Operational Risk
Balancing Employee Compensation
Medium
High
Impact
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Market Risk
Economic Fuel Price vs Market Price
$3.5
$3.0
$2.5
$2.0
$1.5
$1.0
$0.5
$0.0
2000
Carrier
Southwest
Delta
American
United
Alaskan
JetBlue
Virgin
Spirit
Allegiant Air
2003
2015
40%
40%
0%
22%
42%
17%
27%
35%
0%
2006
2016
20%
5%
0%
35%
33%
0%
0%
0%
0%
2009
2012
2015
45
Comments
Most heavily hedged (65% through 2017)
Owns refinary to offset flucuations
Does not hedge
Opportunity to gain philosophy
Uses call options as insurance
Opportunity to gain philosophy
Hedged 31% H1' 16
No hedging target
Does not hedge
40
35
30
NAPMPMI Index
NAPMNMI Index
31
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Uncertain Catastrophes
Thunderstorm
Cybersecurity
Frequency
Geopolitical
Tension
Tornado
Hurricane
Volcanoes
H1N1
MERS
-CoV
Zika
TB
H7N9
Ebola
War
Hezbollah
ISIS
Al-Qaeda
Regulation
Impact
32
Investment Highlights
Company Overview
Industry Analysis
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Risk Analysis
Conclusion
Investment Summary
Tenuous Pricing Power
Low-cost Structure
Conservative Operating
Philosophy
HOLD
Target Price
$34.53
(8% Downside)
Air travel
Commoditization
Cyclicality
33