You are on page 1of 33

We Dont Believe in LUV at First Sight

The University of Texas at Dallas


James, Tyler, Trevor
1

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Executive Summary
Recommendation: HOLD
Current Price: $37.54
Target Price: $34.53 (8% Downside)

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

$60
$50

LUV $37.54

$40
$30

LUV $34.53

$20
$10

Close Price

Current Price

Feb-16

Jan-16

Dec-15

Nov-15

Oct-15

Sep-15

Aug-15

Jul-15

Jun-15

Apr-15

$0
Mar-15

Market Profile (as of 02/04/2016)


Closing Price:
$37.54
52-Week High-Low:
$31.36 / $51.34
Diluted Shares Out. :
679.55 M
Average Volume (6M):
8.44 M
Market Cap:
$ 22.78 B
LTM Dividend Yield:
0.76%
Short Interest (%) Float:
3.77%
Beta:
1.11
EV/EBITDAR*:
5.0 x
P/E*:
12.7 x
Institutional Holders:
82.94%
Insider Holdings:
0.28%
*Multiples adjusted for Operating Leases

Feb-15

NYSE: LUV
Industry: Airlines
Sector: Transportation

Financial Analysis

Investment Themes:
Low Cost, No Frill Approach
Conservative Operating Philosophy
Declining Competitive Advantage
Strained Employee Relations

May-15

Investment Highlights

Target Price

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Historical Competitive Advantage


A

C
Cost Structure
E

D
F

D
E

G
C

Vs.

Hub and
Spoke

The Southwest Effect


Traffic Demand In New Markets
Average Fares in New Markets

Low Cost
Structure

Point to
Point

Low Fares
Employee Relations

Each route serves


a single city-pair

Hub connections
significantly
increase CASM

Higher aircraft
utilization and
turnaround times

Routes are
interdependent
for connecting
passengers

Brand Image

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Executive Council

Conclusion

* denotes company tenure


11

EVP of Corporate
Services
EVP/Chief
Commercial
Officer

28

Jeff Lamb

EVP Strategy &


Innovation

Robert E. Jordan

Thomas M. Nealon

29*
Chairman of the
Board, CEO
Gary C. Kelly

12

24

EVP/Chief
Financial Officer
Tammy Romo

15

EVP/Chief
Operating Officer

SV P Gen. Counsel,
Corporate Secr etary

Mark R. Shaw

Michael G. Van de Ven

Your people come first, and if you treat them right, theyll treat the customers right.
- Herb Kelleher, Founder of Southwest Airlines

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Major Markets, Pre-AirTran Acquisition (2011)

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Major Markets, After AirTran Acquisition (2014)


PORTLAND

GRAND
RAPIDS

FLINT

ROCHESTER

RICHMOND
WICHITA
BRANSON

CHARLOTTE

MEMPHIS

BERMUDA

ATLANTA

PENSACOLA

PARADISE ISLAND

CABO SAN LUCAS

SAN JUAN
PUNTA CANA
CANCN
MONTEGO BAY
MEXICO CITY
ARUBA

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Major Markets, After Wright Amendment Repeal (2014)

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Porters Five Forces


Power of
Suppliers

Threat of
New
Entrants

Industry
Rivalry

Threat of
Substitutes

Power of
Buyers
8

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Changing Dynamics
Deregulation
Weakened
Barriers

Laissez-faire
Pricing

Bankruptcy

Converging Interests

Average Fares
$500
$450

Legacy
Legacy

$400
$350

LCCs

ULCCs

$300

$250

Before 1978

2016

$200
1979

1986

1993

2000

2007

2014
9

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Industry Timeline
American West/US
Airways Merger

AAL/TWA MetroJet 9/11 Terror


Merger Liquidation Attacks

2001

DAL/Northwest Financial
Merger
Crisis

2008

2005

UAL/Continental LUV/AirTran AAL/US Airways


Merger
Merger
Merger

2010

2011

2013

Improving Operating Margin

Strengthening Z scores
$200 B

18%
16%

14%

$150 B
2

12%

10%

$100 B

8%

6%
$50 B

-1

4%
2%

-2
1997

1999

2001
AAL

2003

2005
DAL

2007

2009
UAL

2011

2013
LUV

2015

$0 B

0%
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Revenue
Operating Margin

10

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Evolving Structures
Operating Cost Structure

Streamlined Labor Costs % of Revenue

45%

40%

40%
35%

35%

30%

30%

25%

25%

20%

20%

15%

15%

10%

10%

5%

5%

0%
1998

0%
2001

2000

2002

2004
Labor

2006

2008

Other Costs

2010

2012

2014

2003

2005

Wages

2007
Fuel

2009

2011

2013

2015

Other Costs

The industry dynamics have changed substantially since the Deregulation Act
11

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Current Dynamics
Supply Imbalance vs Crude Oil
3.0 M

$120

2.5 M

$100

2.0 M

44% Jet fuel price per gallon


Oil Supply Surplus

$80

1.5 M
1.0 M

$60

0.5 M

Global energy demand

$40

0.0 M
$20

-0.5 M
-1.0 M

$0

Supply-Demand Spread (mbpd)

Alleviate debt obligations


Increase shareholder returns

WTI Spot Price

Fuel tailwinds have created ROIC levels above WACC


12

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Macroeconomic Drivers
Contracting PMI levels

Corporate Earnings vs Airline Traffic


90,000 B

6%

80,000 B

5%

70
60

4%

70,000 B

50

3%

60,000 B

Correlation = 84%

50,000 B

2%

40

1%

40,000 B

30

0%

30,000 B

-1%

20,000 B

-2%

10,000 B

-3%

0B
0B

500 B

1,000 B

1,500 B

2,000 B

2,500 B

-4%
1986

20
10
0
1991

1996

2001

PMI Index

PMI

*78%

Non-PMI

*80%

Corp. Earnings

*84%

2006

2011

2016

Real GDP YoY

Traffic
* Denotes correlation

13

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Industry Drivers

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Yield = Passenger Revenue/Revenue Passenger Mile

Yield

Passenger Revenue per Available Seat Mile

20%

14.0

15%

12.0
10.0

10%

8.0
5%
6.0
0%

4.0

-5%
-10%
2010

2.0

2011

2012
Legacy

2013
LCC's

ULCC's

2014

2015

0.0
03/06

10/07
PRASM

05/09

12/10

Fuel Cost pASM

07/12

02/14

09/15

Labor Cost pASM

Short-term industry yields are expected to stabilize


14

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Revenue Analysis
Historical Yield

Capacity Expansion vs Traffic


40%

20%

35%

15%

30%

10%

25%

20%

5%

15%
10%

0%

5%

-5%

0%
-10%

-5%
-10%
2006

2008

2010

ASM YoY Growth

2012

2014

2016

-15%
2002

2005

2008

2011

2014

2017

RPM YoY Growth

15

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Growth Opportunity
4%
Domestic

6%
Capacity
Expansion
2%
International

16

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Cost Efficiency Analysis


Significantly Above-average Labor Costs

Industry's CASM Ex-fuel compared to LUV


= -19%

40%
Industry

35%

= -15%

30%

= 10%

25%

ULCC's
= -8%

20%
LCC's

15%

= -11%

10%
Legacy

5%
0%
1997

2000

2003

2006

Industry Wages

2009

2012
LUV Wages

2015

2018

-60%

-40%

-20%
09/2015

0%

20%

40%

12/2009

17

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Cost Efficiency Analysis


Late Arrival Ratio

Industry's CASM Ex-fuel compared to LUV


= -19%

14%
Industry

12%

= -15%
10%
ULCC's
8%
= -8%
6%

= 34%

LCC's

4%

= -11%

2%
0%
2011

Legacy

2012

2013

Southwest*

2014

2015

-60%

-40%

-20%
09/2015

Industry*

0%

20%

40%

12/2009

Not only has the world changed, but our relative position within the industry on costs has changed.
- Gary Kelly, CEO of Southwest Airlines

18

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Labor Cost Uncertainty

Percent of Workers Unionized

17%

5Representing

Labor Costs % Operating Expenses

Union Work Groups

83%
Unionized

Current Negotiations:

Non-Unionized

57%

43%

55.8% Employees
Labor Expenses

Other Expenses
19

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Fading Competitive Advantage

Legacy

Other
LCCs

ULCCs

CostCost

Quality of Service

Quality of Service

LUV

Legacy
LUV

ULCCs

Other
LCCs

Cost

LUV no longer remains a low cost leader


This graph is illustrative purposes

20

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Profitability Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Historical EBITDAR

FASB Operating Leases Adjustment

6,000

Add back Aircraft & Other Rentals

4,000

5,000
3,000
2,000
1,000

Before Adjustment

After Adjustment

27.4% EBITDAR

28.9% EBITDAR

24.1% ROIC

20.3% ROIC
+2.7B Debt

30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
-5%

ROIC

Reported ROIC

Adjusted ROIC
21

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Capital Structure Analysis


Total Debt/EBITDAR

Historical Debt to Capital

12.0 x

70 %
60 %

10.0 x

50 %

8.0 x

40 %

6.0 x

30 %
4.0 x
20 %
2.0 x

10 %
0%
FY05A

NM
FY07A

FY09A

FY11A

As reported

FY13A

FY15A

FY17E

Adjusted

Conservative Operating Philosophy


22

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Valuation Overview

DCF Analysis
Price: $38.81

Relative Valuation
Price: $30.24

(50%)

(50%)

Terminal EV/EBITDAR
Adj. for Operating Leases

EV/EBITDAR
Normalized P/E

LUV
$34.53
8% Potential Downside
23

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Revenue Assumptions

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Revenue Projection
25 B

35%
30%

Assumption Breakdown
YoY Capacity Growth:
Load Factor:
Change in Yield:
Passenger Revenue:
Freight:
Other Revenue:
Total Operating Revenue:
YoY Growth Rate:

FY16E
5.5%
83.6%
-1.5%
19,023
180
1,257
20,460
4.1%

FY17E
4.0%
83.6%
0.5%
19,882
184
943
21,009
2.7%

FY18E
3.0%
83.6%
1.0%
20,684
180
971
21,835
3.9%

20 B

25%
20%

15 B

15%
10%

10 B

5%
0%

5B

-5%
0B

-10%
FY09A

FY10A

FY11A

FY12A

FY13A

FY14A

FY15A

FY16E

FY17E

FY18E

Historical Earnings vs Reinvesment Need


3B
2B
1B

~82%

Average Annual
Reinvestment Need

0B
-1 B
-2 B
-3 B
FY05A FY06A FY07A FY08A FY09A FY10A FY11A FY12A FY13A FY14A FY15A
Reinvestment Need

After-tax Adjusted EBIT

24

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

WACC Assumptions

Cost of Debt
2016-2019 Terminal
Risk-free Rate*:
2.25%
3.00%
BBB+ Default Spread:
2.00%
2.00%
Cost of Debt:
4.25%
5.00%
*Expected 10-Y U.S. Treasury

WACC:

Cost of Equity
2016-2019 Terminal
Risk-free Rate*:
2.25%
3.00%
Risk Premium:
5.00%
5.00%
Adjusted Beta:
1.32
1.16
Cost of Equity:
8.84%
8.78%

2016-2019 Terminal
7.11%
7.60%

25

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

DCF Outputs

Base

$38.54

$45 - $55 - $65


Brent
$45 - $55 - $65 Brent
+ 650 bps SPE FY 2016
+6.5% SPE

$54.70

$65
Brent
- $75
$35
- $45 - $55
Brent
Bull$55 - +5.1%
$45 - $55 - $65 Brent
SPE

Bear

+ 510 bps SPE FY 2016


+6.5% SPE

DCF
$55 - $65 - $75 Brent
Target Price
+7.6% SPE
$38.81

$23.72

$55 - $65 - $75


Brent
$45 - $55 - $65 Brent
+ 760 bps SPE FY 2016
+6.5% SPE
SPE = Salaries per Employee
26

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Average Per-employee
Expense

Sensitivity Analysis

$120,862
$123,884
$125,092
$126,301
$127,510
$128,718
$129,927
$131,136
$132,344
$133,553

2.5%
3.5%
4.5%
5.5%
6.5%
7.5%
8.5%
9.5%
10.5%

$ 25.00 $
$ 1.21 $
$ 48.75 $
47.25
45.72
44.17
42.58
40.97
39.32
37.65
35.95

30.00 $
1.30 $
47.71 $
46.21
44.68
43.13
41.54
39.93
38.29
36.61
34.91

35.00
1.39
46.68
45.18
43.65
42.09
40.51
38.89
37.25
35.58
33.88

Jet Fuel Expense


$ 40.00 $ 45.00 $
$ 1.48 $ 1.57 $
$ 45.64 $ 44.60 $
44.14
43.10
42.61
41.57
41.05
40.02
39.47
38.43
37.85
36.82
36.21
35.17
34.54
33.50
32.84
31.80

50.00 $
1.66 $
43.56 $
42.06
40.54
38.98
37.39
35.78
34.14
32.47
30.76

55.00 $
1.75 $
42.53 $
41.03
39.50
37.94
36.36
34.74
33.10
31.43
29.73

60.00 $
1.84 $
41.49 $
39.99
38.46
36.90
35.32
33.71
32.06
30.39
28.69

65.00
1.93
40.45
38.95
37.42
35.87
34.28
32.67
31.03
29.35
27.65

27

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Relative Valuation
North American
Airlines

Screening
Criteria

Comparable Valuation
Multiple
Turn
Price
2016E EBITDAR:
4.4 x $30.47
2017E EBITDAR:
4.5 x $26.64

Market Cap >1.5B

Normalized P/E Valuation


Comparable P/E:
24.7 x
Normalized EPS (LUV): $ 1.37
Implied Price (LUV):
$ 33.84

Historical LUV EV/EBITDAR


25.0 x

Revenue >1.5B

20.0 x
15.0 x
10.0 x
5.0 x
0.0 x

28

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Valuation Summary

Team Analysis

Consensus

Adjust for Operating Leases (BOTH


(Some) Adjust for Operating Leases
LUV and Peers)
Add back only Aircraft Rentals $45 - $55 - $65 Brent
+6.5% SPE
Add back full Operating Lease
Wait for new contract releases and
Expenses (Aircraft + Facility + Others)
then revise investment thesis
Integrate the impacts of labor contracts
$55 - $65
- $75 Brent normalized
Cycle-average
EV/EBITDAR,
+7.6% SPE
P/E

DCF Analysis
$38.81

Relative Valuation
$30.24

(50%)

(50%)

Target Price
$34.53
(8% Downside)
29

Investment Highlights

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

OR1

Medium

Probability

High

Risk Analysis

Company Overview

OR2

MR2

MR3

MR1
UC

Low

OR3

Low

Legend
OR1: Operational Risk
Balancing Employee Compensation

Medium

High

Impact

MR1: Market Risk Economic Uncertainty


MR2: Market Risk Commodity Price Volatility
UC: Uncertain Catastrophes
30

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Market Risk
Economic Fuel Price vs Market Price
$3.5
$3.0
$2.5
$2.0
$1.5
$1.0
$0.5
$0.0
2000
Carrier
Southwest
Delta
American
United
Alaskan
JetBlue
Virgin
Spirit
Allegiant Air

Manufacturing PMI vs Non-Manufacturing PMI


65
60
55
50

2003
2015
40%
40%
0%
22%
42%
17%
27%
35%
0%

2006
2016
20%
5%
0%
35%
33%
0%
0%
0%
0%

2009

2012

2015

45

Comments
Most heavily hedged (65% through 2017)
Owns refinary to offset flucuations
Does not hedge
Opportunity to gain philosophy
Uses call options as insurance
Opportunity to gain philosophy
Hedged 31% H1' 16
No hedging target
Does not hedge

40
35
30

NAPMPMI Index

NAPMNMI Index
31

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Uncertain Catastrophes
Thunderstorm

Cybersecurity

Frequency

Geopolitical
Tension

Tornado
Hurricane
Volcanoes

H1N1

MERS
-CoV
Zika

TB

H7N9

Ebola

War

Hezbollah

ISIS
Al-Qaeda
Regulation

Impact
32

Investment Highlights

Company Overview

Industry Analysis

Financial Analysis

Valuation

Risk Analysis

Conclusion

Investment Summary
Tenuous Pricing Power
Low-cost Structure

Strained Labor Relations


Customer Service

Conservative Operating
Philosophy

HOLD
Target Price
$34.53
(8% Downside)

Air travel
Commoditization

Cyclicality

33

You might also like