You are on page 1of 28

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Anchorage to Concrete Means and Methods


Structural Anchor Types and General Selection Criteria

J. Silva, SE
Director Codes & Standards
Hilti North America

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

its all Greek to me

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Manolis Korres, From Pentelicon to the Parthenon, Publishing House Melissa,


1995, p. 113

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

crack-prevention reinforcement

Manolis Korres, From Pentelicon to the Parthenon, Publishing House Melissa, 1995, p. 110

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

HOT TOPIC SESSION

government anchors

F.E. Kidder, Building Construction and


Superintendence, Part I, Wm Comstock,
NY, 1909, p. 355

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Golden Gate Bridge north anchorage - anchorage weight 60,000 tons


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Anchor bolts

Cast in place

Post-installed

all devices placed in the


formwork prior to casting

all devices installed in


hardened concrete

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

J bolt

HOT TOPIC SESSION

bolt with bearing plate

L bolt

cast in place anchor bolts


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

R. Park, T. Paulay, Reinforced Concrete


Structures, Wiley-Interscience, 1975, p.411.

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

anchor
ring
tank
wall

stiffener

weld plate (embed)


tank anchorage
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

10

HOT TOPIC SESSION

1 to 1-1/2"

Coalinga earthquake of May 1983

H. J. Degenkolb

Surge tank ABs: 1-1/2" A307 bolts stretched uniformly 1 to 1-1/2 inches

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

11

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Anchor bolt specification:

DO: specify ASTM F1554


covers 36, 55 and 105-ksi in hooked, headed and
threaded/nutted configurations

DO NOT: specify A325 or A490 or A36.

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

12

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Anchor bolt specification:


DO: specify AISC base plate hole
recommendations. These are larger
than standard oversize holes. Use
heavy plate washers.

1/05 Concrete International, Tolerance


Compatibility Checklist, B. Suprenant
AISC 3rd Edition Table 14-2

DO NOT: specify standard oversize holes


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

13

HOT TOPIC SESSION

1997 ASCE Wind Loads and Anchor Bolt Design for Petrochemical Facilities
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

14

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Post-installed anchors

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

15

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Post-Installed Anchor Types


post-installed anchors

hybrids

mechanical

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

Post-installed mechanical anchors

16

HOT TOPIC SESSION

drop-in displacementcontrolled expansion


anchor
Glossary

undercut
anchor

displacement controlled anchors


drop-ins
expansion anchors
mechanical anchors
metal anchors
screw anchors
shell-type anchors
torque controlled anchors
undercut anchors
wedge anchors

screw anchor

wedge-type torquecontrolled expansion


anchors

self undercutting
undercut anchor
heavy-duty sleeve type torquecontrolled expansion anchor

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

Hilti, Inc.
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

17

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

18

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

19

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

20

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

21

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

22

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Post-installed adhesive (chemical) anchors

torquecontrolled
adhesive
anchor
rail anchor
cartridge injection anchor systems

Glossary
adhesive anchors
chemical anchors
bonded anchors
epoxy anchors
capsule anchors
cartridge injection anchors
bucket mixed
bulk dispensed

capsule anchors
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

torque-controlled adhesive
anchors
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

23

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

24

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

25

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

26

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Center core 60 feet to


foundation
Install anchors
(Dywidag threadbar)
Prestress against
concrete bond beam

U.S. Custom House, San Francisco


1906 Beaux Art structure
www.hilti.com

URS/Blume
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

27

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Post-Installed Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

hybrids

mechanical

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled

capsule

injection

displacementdisplacementcontrolled
controlled

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

28

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Simpson
StrongTie
Hilti, Inc.

drop-in anchors
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

29

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Post-Installed Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

hybrids

mechanical

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled
www.hilti.com

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

30

10

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti (galvanized)

Powers
Simpson
StrongTie

Hilti (316)

wedge-type expansion anchors


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

Hilti

31

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Sanko

MKT

Powers

Torque-controlled expansion anchors


heavy-duty, sleeve type
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

32

HOT TOPIC SESSION

torque-controlled expansion anchor (HSLG)


Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

33

11

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

mechanical

hybrids

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

Drillco National Group

34

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Heinrich Liebig
Stahlduebelwerke GmbH

undercut anchors
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

35

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Heinrich Liebig
Stahlduebelwerke GmbH

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

36

12

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti Inc.

Heinrich Liebig
Stahlduebelwerke GmbH

self-undercutting undercut anchors


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

37

HOT TOPIC SESSION

undercut anchor (self-undercutting)


Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

38

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

mechanical

hybrids

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled
www.hilti.com

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

39

13

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

capsule anchor system


HVU capsule

all-thread (HAS)

internallythreaded
insert (HIS)
rebar
Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

40

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

41

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

mechanical

hybrids

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled
www.hilti.com

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

42

14

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

cartridge adhesive
anchor system

internally threaded
insert

The HY adhesives are hybrid materials which combine a vinyl


urethane methacrylate with a synthetic cement. They were
developed to provide rapid bonding, low toxicity, and
temperature resistance.
Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

43

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Injection
system

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

44

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic Post-Installed Anchor Types

post-installed anchors

hybrids

mechanical

adhesive

screws
undercut

expansion

torquecontrolled
www.hilti.com

capsule

injection

displacementcontrolled
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

45

15

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

torque-controlled adhesive anchors


(hybrid anchors)
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

46

HOT TOPIC SESSION

torque-controlled adhesive anchor

Suitable for use in cracked concrete.


Superior performance in poorly cleaned holes.

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

47

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Basic working principle of the torque-controlled adhesive anchor

note: bond line


thickness
exaggerated
for clarity
www.hilti.com

1.

de-bonding upon
application of
setting torque

2.

displacement
under load

3.

generation of
additional
expansion force
(re-expansion)
Hilti, Inc.
ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

48

16

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

49

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Application Guidance for Structural Post-Installed Anchors


load case
shear
only
shear only

gravity
gravity

seismic
seismic

shear
shear
and/or
and/or
tension
tension

gravity
gravity

seismic
seismic

light duty/non-structural
duty/non-structural

structural connections
structural
connections

wedge anchors

wedge anchors

adhesive anchors

heavy-duty torque-controlled anchors

drop-ins

adhesive anchors

wedge anchors

wedge anchors

adhesive anchors

heavy-duty torque-controlled anchors

undercut anchors

large diameter/long adhesive anchors

wedge anchors

heavy-duty torque-controlled anchors

adhesive anchors

undercut anchors

wedge anchors

heavy-duty torque-controlled anchors

adhesive anchors

undercut anchors

large diameter/long adhesive anchors

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

50

HOT TOPIC SESSION

anchorage to concrete

rebar development

attachments to
concrete

rebar dowels
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

51

17

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

52

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

53

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

54

18

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

55

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

56

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Testing and assessment

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

57

19

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Document flow for anchor qualification and design in


concrete
IBC Section 1913 Strength Design of Anchors
ACI 318 Appendix D Anchoring to Concrete
ACI 355.2 Qualification of Post-Installed Mechanical
Anchors
AC193 Acceptance Criteria for Mechanical Anchors
in Concrete Elements
AC308 Acceptance Criteria for Post-Installed
Adhesive Anchors in Concrete Elements
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

58

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI Standard 355.2-04 defines the testing requirements


for post-installed mechanical anchors (expansion and
undercut anchors)
It defines four types of tests:

1. Identification tests
2. Reference tests
3. Reliability tests
4. Service condition tests

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

59

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

60

20

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

61

HOT TOPIC SESSION

REFERENCE
DISPLACEMENT

REFERENCE
EXPANSION

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

62

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

63

21

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Report of ACI Committee 224, Control of Cracking in Concrete Structures


www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

64

HOT TOPIC SESSION

The effect of cracking on anchor


concrete breakout capacity is
two-fold:
a. Effect on hoop stresses (all
anchors)
uncracked concrete
crack plane

cracked concrete

b. Degradation of force-transfer
mechanism (bonded anchors,
expansion anchors...)

Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete Construction,


Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 147.

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

65

HOT TOPIC SESSION

w = 0.4 mm
fc = 21 N/mm2

Drop-in anchors
Load-displacement curves for fullyand partially-expanded drop-in
anchors in uncracked and cracked
concrete (crack width 0.4 mm)

Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete Construction,


Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 145.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

66

22

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Nn

Torque-controlled
expansion anchors
with marginal
followup expansion
Load-displacement
curves for M12 wedge
anchors (hef=60 mm) set
in uncracked concrete
and in 0.4 mm line cracks

Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete Construction,


Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 145.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

67

HOT TOPIC SESSION

30%
reduction

Torque-controlled expansion
anchors with robust followup
expansion
Load-displacement curves for M12
HSL anchors set in uncracked
concrete and in 0.4 mm line cracks

Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete


Construction, Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 144.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

68

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Load (kN)

uncracked concrete
cracked concrete w
= 0.3 mm
w 34
N/mm2

25%
reduction

CIP studs
Headed studs dia. = 12 mm
hef = 80 mm

Load-displacement curves
for 12 mm headed studs
set in uncracked concrete
and in 0.3 mm line cracks
Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete
Construction, Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 144.

Displacement (mm)
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

69

23

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Eligehausen, Malle, Silva, Anchorage in Concrete


Construction, Ernst & Sohn, 2006, p. 52.
www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

70

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

71

HOT TOPIC SESSION

moving crack test University of Stuttgart


photo courtesy of R. Eligehausen
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

72

24

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Moving crack test

Nw static

Test 8, Table 4.2, ACI 355.2-04

Spring pot
Hairline crack
induced by bar
tension

LVDT

Concrete
Reinforcing
bars

Crack width w cycled between 0.1+


mm and 0.3+ mm
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

anchor displacement (mm)

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

73

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Nb,r
unsuccessful test
successful test

10

20

100

1000

no. of
cycles

crack movement test acceptance criteria


www.hilti.com

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

74

HOT TOPIC SESSION

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

75

25

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

76

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Shear testing rig Hilti R&D


Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

77

HOT TOPIC SESSION


1.5 mm 0.75 mm
do 1.5 mm

shear loading plate geometry


per ASTM E 488

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

78

26

Hilti R&D

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti R&D

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

79

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Hilti, Inc.
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

80

HOT TOPIC SESSION

Connections between
Steel and Concrete
Sept. 4 to 7, 2007
Stuttgart, Germany

Objective:
Forum for civil and structural
engineers in research and practice to
present and to discuss the state-ofthe-art as well as new research
developments in the field of fastening
technology.
Early bird registration:
May 31, 2007

iwb.uni-stuttgart.de/symposium
www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

81

27

ACI SPRING CONVENTION ATLANTA, APRIL 2007

HOT TOPIC SESSION

John F. Silva, SE
Director, Codes & Standards
Hilti North America

www.hilti.com

ACI | 4/22/07 | jfs

82

28

You might also like