Professional Documents
Culture Documents
by
information! obtained by a
lned observer wlth a level
MacDuffie
S
I the
McCoy.
MARSHALL M o c
376
seem, ,from the, uncertainty and ambivalence with which the whole
problem of communism is regarded
by even our clearest and most liberal minds.
Mr. Taylor tries to help by introducmg ?a background
concept
of
whathe calls the cold civil war.
He sees all these issues, of p,owers,
prerogatives, individual. rights and
duties enmeshed in an impassioned
internal struggle; but though at one
point he defines this as a nationalIst, native-Amencan
challenge
to
the middle-class liberalism and Internationalism which have been the
prevailing
political
climate, he
fails to make very clear either
preclsely what this struggle is or how
it affects the issues withwhich he
grapples. Is it simply, the unbridled
vmlence of this cold civil war
which has led us into thepresent
state of heresy trials and
political
inquisitions,or IS !here something
in the Communistproblem
which
hasrendered these tnings unavodable? Mr. Taylor notes that the
underlying reason why the committees have got so far into the courts
business of prosecution and punishment 1s that thecourtsareunable
to pros&ute or punish for the activltles which the committees. desire to
rep5ess. If, he says atone place,
what the nation wants and needs
is apowerful and flexible governmental mechanism forpolitical inquisition and denuncxation, there I S
truly no substitutefora
Congressionalinvestlgationoperated
by a
Dles or a McCarthy. Mr. Taylor,
01 course, wants nothing of the kmd.
Butwhat
to do assuming that the
nation does want it, or even to what
extent
nation
the
may actually
needsuch defenses against communism, is not made clear.
T h e NATION
,
I
I
:
1
A f j d 30,1955
..
"
Selected Works
Anniversarypreface
by
SAMUEL SILLEN
"It has
gwen
me
genuine
pleasulre.
Constructwe
crlticlsm
such
as this.
coupled ~71thanmtelhgent selection of
Whltman's own words .on themes of
aartlcular
Interest
t o contemvorarv
be ad~r swlll~certamlybe the very
bed
meons of increasing .mltman's audience SilIen has done it with the verve
of a good reporter, but has
anddash
retamed the perspective
of scholarshlp.
I congratulate p!in upon the dlfflcult
dccompllshment
-CLIFTON
JOSEPH
FURNESS.
leadlngWhltmanscholar.
Cloth $2.50
Paper
covers
$1.25
1 Prepared by
Labor Research Ass'rt. -
"
A comarehensivesurvey
of theworld
s o c i a l d and" Communist-movements
from the
International
Workingmen's
Association of Marx and EIW& t o the
presentday
A detailedhlstory
of the
Flrst. Second (Soclahst).
and
Thlrd
icoirimunlstj Internationals;
coverin
fundamentalmatters
of greatinteres?
to all thoseconcerned
with laborand
' 580 pages, $6.00
world polltics
"_
B
'
.vel 1.
vO1 ri
n:JrIy
Y&-
Trade
Pip.
1817-1849
$4.50' ,$400
"TI,;:prc-c,vi] war Deia,&
148
576 p.
'I1 The
"""
vO1 IV
'
'
448 p.
576 D.
'Aftef
5 00
4'50
4.50
4 00
5.013~ 4 50
!%?e Of
' $15.08
"""""".
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
(PostagePrepaldj
"-
""_
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
.-. . -
I
377
, ,
I
m
m
ii
thea.p~geweeklyofcurrentcomment-onscience,
rellglon, educatm, phllorophy-wlth substonceproviding revmws of whatever books and orticlei
warn to the edltors to be shopmg future thoughi
and llghtmg new dlrechons.
$soy-r
For 3 freo rdmpfi copies, write
1
1
1
1
m
m
e
m
Pnblished Mmch 31
The most innportant technlcal book of
the year
L.
N i c h o l s Jr.
Old ALL BO
( 1 0%
written), what does it add up tothe satire, the analysis of art, faith,
and personality, the pagan sacrifices,
the symbolic
deaths,
the Catholicism, the experimental writing? In
my- opinion it adds up to nothing
more than an encyclopedia. Or perhaps one should say nothing less, for
behindan encyclopedia there is a
forinidable amount of knowledge
and some ,ofthe entries are bdund to
beuseful.
Butan encyclopedia is
not a work of art.
Reading this book and considering both the matter and the manner
of it, one is reminded of some huge,
impressive bird, wings Qutstretehed,
neck taut, talons grasping; one is
'impatient to see it taketo the air;r
and then suddenly one realizes that
it can't, that for all its fine feathers,
'the bones of its wings are, broken,
Finally cine puts the bookdown,
longing like the bird, the author,
and the main characters for some
quiet open space. It is a trapped
book: the testament of a , prisoner
counting hisgrievances, or a miser
hiscoins. I don't want to beoverharsh. Some of thegrievances are
ones we all know, and it does us
good to have them defined; some of
Books)
I , N O MEMBERSH,IP F E E
BOOK
MANUSCRIPTS
INVITED
YOUR CONVENIENCE
'Buv Your
J
.
'
378
~ i t i ~ n
through THE
Nation readers can availthemselves
of our offer to send them any book at
the regular retail prlce post-free, if
oavrnent IS received with the order. or
i t "the retall price plus postage If the
book 1s sent C.0 D No C.0D.'s outs i d e the United States. When orderm g , please give name and author and
publisher. If uossible.
'
Please address your orders to
Miss 0. LePach
i
THR READERS' SERVICE DIVISION
333 Sixth Ave. New Pork 14, N. X.
1
Sclioolmaste'r"and Clergyman
The NATION
'I