You are on page 1of 71
VOLUME 18 SUMMER 2001 NUMBER 3 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF ISLAMIC SOCIAL SCIENCES CONTENTS EDITORIAL........ fee ARTICLES Governing under Islam and the Islamic Political System ‘Murad Wilfried Hofmann 1 Changing Roman Catholic Christologies: The Case of Hans Kung and Paul Knitter Mahmut Aydin... uv Muslim Parents’ Activism in the Multicultural Education (MCE) Curriculum Gulafshan Alavi st Methodological Problems in the Study of Islam, and Ali Shariati’s Proposed Methodology for the Study of Religions Abdollah Vakily +91 BOOK REVIEWS ‘The Ambivalence of the Sacred Amr Sabet - dl Secularism, Gender and the State in the Middle East: ‘The Egyptian Women’s Movement Lara Shahriyar Alameh ...... - 116 ‘The Last Great Revolution: Turmoil and Transformation in Iran Zeynep Akbulut 120 Turks, Moors and Englishmen in the Age of Discovery Nancy Stockdale . 125 Gender and Citizenship in the Middle East Safoi Babana-Hampton : 129 INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ISLAMIC THOUGHT ASSOCIATION OF MUSLIM SOCIAL SCIENTISTS CONFERENCE REPORTS First Intemational Congress on Religion and Mental Health ‘Amber Haque Eighteenth Annual Conference of American Council for the Study of Islamic Societies (ACSIS) Ejaz Akram Intemational Seminar on Wali-Allah’s Thought Nazeer Ahmad Abdul Majeed. Second Annual Conference of the Center for the Study of Islam & Democracy (CSID) Layla Sein Mailing Address Allcomespondence should be addressed tothe Editor a AJISS, RO. Box 669, Hemdon, VA 20172-0669, USA website hupi//anwwiitorg * email editor@iiorg Phone: 703-471-1133 * Fax: 703-471-3922 137 142 146 THE ARABIST BUDAPEST STUDIES IN ARABIC 23 Essays In Honour of Alexander Fodor On His Sixtieth Birthday CONTENTS Preface ee ee eee 5 rr) ‘A Personal Introduction (Géza Fehérvici 8 Tareq Sayid Raab) «20.0606 xd Tabiyya (Abdel Moneim Moukta) . cece ti A Biographical Notice (Tams Ivényi) beeeeeeeceees mW [A Select Bibliography of Alexander Fodor's Publications (Tamés Ivinyi) .. xvii Giovanni Canova (Venice): The Prophet Noah in Islamic Tradition... 1 Francesca Corrao (Naples): Le salaud malheurewe: Rive et dérision dans um texte oriental du moyen age : Eee sees Kinga Dévényi Budapest): Omani Proverbs: Date Palms and Dates / 2 Saber El-Adly (Budapest): an-NaF : - cece Bence Fehér (Budapest): Mysterious Alloys in Early Musline Metallurgy - 38 Géza Fehérviri (London): Baytir: Enigma of a Fatimid Potter. “6 Ida Fréblich (@Budapesi): Demons, Scribes, and Exorciss in Qumran «--« 2 ‘Antonella Ghersetti (Venice): De achat des exclaves: entre examen médical et ipbpsiognomie. Le chapitre 46 du Kitab ad-dala'll d'Tbm Babli Xs)... 83 Shawki Abd ELKawi Uthman Habib (Cairo): Kutwb al‘agi'ib welgard'ih .. 95 Iswvin Hajnal Budapest): On che History of the Ismaili “Hidden Imims* as Reflected in the Kitéb avtaritib assab'a....eeeeeeceeee 101 Tams elayt Gadapen)s yk Luli 1 mika abt". The Yours Goldziber at Work... vee U7 Alan Jones (Oxford): The Real Satanic Verses? bee 125 Lisalé Kikosy (Budapest): The Mlusion of Wealth 0.00... 135 Gertrid Kovics (Budapest): References co Animals in the Diwin of al-Hansi” Zsuzsanna Kutasi (Budapest): The Horse as Seon by « Medieval Anab Scholar 157 Ballas Major Budapest Burl ‘Arab— A Crusader Tower inthe Conny of Tria peer ceceeeteee mt ian University 183 Isevin Ormos (Budapest): Ignaz Goldeiber’s Invitation to the Egypt ‘Avihai Shivtiel (Cambridge): An Unknown Message by Maimonides (T'S NS 327. Wo. aes + 133 Zoluin Scombathy (Budapest: Some Notes on Spirit Postion and fdr .. 197 Lisclé Tiiske (Budapest): lon Tabitaba’s poetics 2 Reviews See ee 219 EOTWOS LORAND UNIVERSITY CHAIR FOR ARABIC STUDIES CSOMA DE KOROS SOCIETY SECTION OF ISLAMIC STUDIES, ‘BUDAPEST, 2001 Cope Bd Coma de Kite So. 202 MOZEUM BLD. 4/8 BUDAPEST, 1088 HUNGARY Current Anthropology Volume 43, Number 5, December s00e Areas of Inquiry: Melanesia Fiezl Communication and Linguistic ideclogy: A Reading and Patil Reformatanon of Rappaport Theory of Ritual wth CAs comment sor ‘rom avila Chritians to The Ramance ofthe Milena Melanesian Antbroslegy ‘Anthnopelogy aad Modernity from the Hada about Men's ork sith CAA comment on renner casHDan (On Risk Preferences and Curilineae Utley SoRMAN voRFEE ‘An Interview with Richard S, MacNeish ns. PEaiaa snd Group selection a Human TE ital Opper Pole in Notbease Aaa 733 ef tae ote” Ma ERNE eset See nai cola Se gatos ont ont mann, asa dns Resend me era aaa Calendar, Index, Volume 42 [20011 779 Gieuison Manger ‘FRE Unveriyof Chicago Press Feurnals Divito, PO. Box 37005 Ghana aes? USA Hoel 7sy08t2 [Eri subsenpaens@rese chico lo DAEDALUS JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF ARTS AND SCIENCES SPRING 2001 Vol. 130, No 2 Contents, Volume I: The European Challenge wv Pref Carlo Azeglio Ciampi 1 Introduction International Romane Prodi Italy, Europe Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa 13. Italy and Europe: A Fruitful Interaction Filippo Andreatta 45. Italy at a Crossroads: The Foreign Policy of a Medium Power after the End of Bipolarity Economy Luigi Federico Signorini 67. Italy's Economy: An Introduction Fabrizio Barca 93 New Trends and the Policy Shift in the Italian Mezzogiorno Fiorella Kostoris Pados Schioppa 11S Budgetary Policies and Administrative Reform in Contemporary Iealy Contents, Volume II: Politics and Society (summer 2001) Politics Edmondo Berslli 1 The Crisis and Transformation of Italian Polities Renato Brunerta 25 Iealy's Other Left Lut 0 Violante 47. Kralian Parliamentary Institutions: An Evolutionary Overview Society Costanzo Ranci 73. Democracy at Work: Social Participation and the “Third Sector” in Italy Suranne Berger and Richard M. Locke 85. I! Caso Italiano and Globalization Alessandro Ovi 105 Cheese, Children, and Container Cranes: Learning from Reggio Emilia Alessandro Cavalli 119 Reflections on Political Culture and the “Italian National Character” Massimo Livi-Bacci 139. Too Few Children and Too Much Family Letina Pa 157 Crime, Italian Seyte All subsription orders, single-copy orders, and change-of address information must be sent i wring the Dadals Busines Office, 136 Irving Stet, Suse 100, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA. Printed in the United Seater of Amer Printing Offices 2901 Byrdhll Road, Richmond, VA 23228, Editorial Offices: Ddalus, Norton’ Woods, 136 Irang Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 “Telephone: (617) 481-2600; Fax: 1617) 376-5088, Emails daedalus@ariacad.org POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES DIALOGUE UNIVERSALISM Metaphilosophy as the Wisdom 41-1 2/2001 of Science, Art, and Life KAIROS OF HISTORICAL ALTERNATIVE: LIBERALISM, GLOBALISM, TERRORISM — OR METANOIA, DIALOGUE, SYNERGY, SYMPATHY, UNIVERSAL CIVILIZATION Editorial UNIVERSALIZATION AS SUBLATION [AUFHEBUNG) OF GLOBALISM Wo 4.5, Smolics — Glob Australian Multiculturaisn riers Siwiriski — Globalization; Curse or Hope? Is ation and Cultural Dynamics ina Multiethnie State: {ntervational Perspect. PREADING AND IMPLEMENTATION OF UNIVERSALISM — OR A TOTAL DISINTEGRATION OF HUMANKIND Francisco Colom-Gonziile: — Universalism and Traditionalism in the Ibero- ‘American Quest for Political Modernity 43 Gérski — The Idea of Universalism in Poland and Both Americas ... 51 Eugeniuss SIMPLY: THE AUTHENTIC LOVE OF WISDOM Wladzimiers J. Krab» Karpowie: — Philosophy Rediscovered: An Essay on Science, Philosophy, and Myth 75 Henryk Skolimowski — On the Beauty and Necessity of Philosophy 87 THE FAILURE OF THE PRESENT WORLD ORDER Piotr Balcerow 97 Interview with Ab ior" Balcerowicz). 107 KAIROS OF EUROPEAN INTEGRATION ‘Andrzej Flis —The Distinetiveness of European Culture 13 | NEWS BULLETIN: TOWARD “A REALISTIC, ALLIANCE OF ALL WISE AND GOOD PEOPLE’ Philosophy Facing World Problems (A Letter from Professor loanna Kuguradi, President of FISP) 0. 7 137 XXist World Congress of Philosophy (An Announcement) 139 International Conference: Korezak — A New Anthropology of Education ..... 143 ‘Towards a New Young Europe (aviation to Participate in the Joint Preparation of the Third European Congress of Dialogue and Universalism) 17 Our Contributors 137 |All correspondence should be addressed to Dialogue and Universalis Insttte of Philosophy, Warsaw Univesity ‘Krakowskie Predmiescic 3 (0.047 Warsaw 64, Poland Phone: (8-22) $5.23-708, Fax: §26-57-34, 826-75-20 Ingparvew dialogue uw edu pl PLISSN 1234-5792 ‘Typeset by GrafFekst — Warszawa Printed by DrokarniaJerzogo Kosiskiess, Warszawa Iss 561.6505 NS Volume 11, Number 2 2000) The Journal of Middle Eastern NS 1112) 169-300 (20009 Literatures . A Coiwyak CONTENTS Monamed-Salah Omri, University of Exeter ‘Adad in tne Seventeenth Century. Narrative and Parody ia al-Shiroin's Haz al-Quhot Zulfikar Hig, University of Oxtord ‘Tho Tals of Seyavash: Fire, Water, and Virtue CChuistine van Ruymbeke, Université Libre de Bruxelles Nizam's Trees: An Arboricultural Investigation of tne Miniatures of Shah Tahmasp’s Khamsa (British Library OR 2265), Robert G. Morrison, Cornell University Mecieval Psychology in Abraham lon E2ra's Pooky Review Articles Judith Caesar, Cedar Rapids, lowa Monammad Al Murr's Map of Oubai Ibrahim Fawal, Birmingham, Alabama “Three Perspactives on Ara® Cinema Book Reviews Ferial J. Gnazoul, Nocturnal Poeties: The Arabian Nights in ‘Comparative Context (Reger Allen) Conscious Voices: Concepts of Writing in he Middle East, ed. Stephan Guth, Priska Furrer, and Johann Crvistoph Birgal (Roger Allen) JUTP de Bruin, Persian Sufi Poetry: An Introduction fo the Mystical Use of Classical Poems (Julle Scott Meisam’) Paul E. Losensky, Welcoming Fighani: Imitation and Postic Indiviguaity in the Safavig-Mughal Ghazal (Julie Scott Metsam)) Pp _harwood academic publishers hwo gohap comEdebiat 169 197 218 299 261 275 289 293 298 10 HAMDARD ISLAMICUS Quarterly Journal of Studies and Research in Islam Vor xxv Baly September 2001 Nos Editor-in-Chief | ‘Mrs Sadia Rat Associate Editor: | Dr. Ansar Zahid Khan | poe Published by Bait al-Hilamah at | Madinat al-Hikmah, Shara-e- | Editorial 5 Madinat al-fikmah, Rarach-74700, Pakietan Tho Momltk Sulin and che Crusaders in the 19th ‘Telephones: 6900000, 696001, 6438 ‘Century: Contention and Compromise Tote 28970 HAND PK, | ne (Dn Kensoewen Tose? _ ‘Telefax: (92-21) 6611755 | ai: haradardOtc paket com pe : Elk hardardOhpaknet om ma | + Sanne, Cor Joionent of RK — A Shah Apprateal De M. Tahir Mansoor! 1s igion Index. One: as licals, ‘The Impact of Qur'anic Ideas and Style on Hadith American, ‘Theological Aecociation, | ere eee a cago (US.A) | ” Mahmood Sh 8 © omiah thsi aisonary Suits The Apponch of Articles and_photograghs in this || Darah Mua tothe State of Muslims in Singapore ise may not be repreducd unos | — Dr. Atihu Garba Yahaya a previous. permission has been | obtained from the Editor. | Affairs of Mutual Consultation — (Gleanings from the | Paistoni Prev 0 Price | || + Infomation — A Note on PRD. Thess on Quen and Pak US, ‘Tabir{n Turkey (1960-1990 A Chronological Approach sae | ee oeraariae Oa *s | Printed by MAS Printors, Nasimabad, || Rarachi-74600, Pakistan | 1 Der Islam Band 78 Heft 2 2001 INHALT Aaestoe Sobeits Amiroleimani: Women in Trikhs Basha a0 Lat Berger in lee wien tockner Sharyn. Lagi und Miber den Tabakrach 20 Mises Lawrenee Conrad The Prvinv nf NoethSyri in ESBS: A Poesig OM erspectien 204 any slecka: The Mastim Bom Vivant Drinking Costome of Babu the Emperor ‘Hasta 310 bachbesprechungen us Inhalt des achtunsisbrigten Bands 308 Die Zeitscheift Der Islam" etscheint in zwei Halbjaheesbanden. Manuekripte and sonstige Sendungen, auch Besprechungssticke, sind an die [Redaltion des Islan, Rethenbuomehaussee 88, 20148 Hamburg (Orientalsches Seminar} 2 adresseven. Es wird hoflich gebeten, Manuskripte fur die Zeitschrift .DER ISLAM" nur nach corherige abrifilicher Veeeinbasung mit den Heransgebern einzusenden, "ile rein geschatichen Zuschriften und Bestellungen erbuten an den Verlag WALTER DEGRUYTER GmbH 4 Co. KG, Genthiner Ste. 13, 0789 BERLIN. ‘ie Verantwortung fied cinzdInen Artikel agen ausschlieBlich die Werfasserianen und Warfare Die Zeitschrift lege sich af keineriehwissenschafiiche Tendenz feet Shaern cient dem Austausch der Meinangen aus allen Lagern a FACHZEYTSCURIFT DER DEUTSCHEN MORGENLANDISCHEN GESELISCHAFT. (Mitglieder dor DMG erhalten beim Bezug 20% Rabat) ‘Eonar ate en araaratmaie ome wammeeka ‘© Copyright 2001 by Walter de Graster GmbH & Co, KG, D-10785 Bertin 12 ISLAM AND CHRISTIAN-MUSLIM RELATIONS Volume 13. Number 1 January 2002 Notes on Contributors ‘Malcoim D. Brown. An Ethnographic Reflection on Muslim-Christian Dialogue in the Nom of France: the context of latte Mahmoud Alinead. Coming to Terms with Modernity: Iranian intellectuals and the emerging public sphere Yorinder S. Sihand. Islamic Mission and Interteligious Dialogue in a Minority Context: the Jama’atfslami of Tadia Pater G. Riddell The Diverse Voices of Political Islam in Post-Suharro Indonesia Jalal Uddin Khan. Reading Literarare: an Islamic viewpoint —a broad overview Neal Robinzon. The Fascination of Islam ‘Simian and tok frst bol enero 0 ‘he Eon um tn Cherian Mun Reon et SiC, Univer Bringham, Bia ons ‘Biminpam 829 5LQ, UKe or The Cet fo Sta Chnsen Uniewunaing Gero ae taek cover afesen se en corepondece nang td ‘Stes Deparomone, Raine Rod anagrohe Hoes Rot arn ch Tel sae eset 00m oe 44 (3125830 25, Advertising USiCanadn: Te Adversing Manager. 266. 875 [Manchnete Avene, Sty Cambodge, MA 0213 USA Tek 16174976816, Fax 21617384 697, EURen of Wore The Adternng Manager Tv Francs Lt, PO Bor 35, Abnpden,Oxforie OXIS SUE, UK: Tt 94 (09128 41 GO Far 94601235 2s 49 65 85 7 1B9 13 [slamic Law and Society —_— vou. 8 NO. 3 OCTOBER 2001 Hadith and Fiqh CONTENTS. Inarnduetion Susan Srecrorsky, Guest editor, Theme {ssue: Hudieh and Figh 299 suticles G.HLA. JeyMHOLL, (ReJAppraisal of Some Technical Terms ia Hadith Selene. 303 RoweRr GLEAVE, Between Huslith and Figh: The “Canonical” Lunimi Collections of ARibair 350 Cunisropnea MeLcHeat. TraditionistJurisprudents and the Framing of Islamic Law... sonenes 383 SUSAN Specrorsky, Hudivh in the Responses of Ishaq 6 Rahwayh, : 407 Leen Baton Kile © Comvih 301 hy Role Bra Lene, The Netherlands 14 THE ISLAMIC QUARTERLY A Review of Islamic Culture CONTENTS Islam and the Modern World Order—Part 1 =Dr. I. Bruce Watson. 259 Modern Islamic Movement: An Analysis ftom Civilisational Perspective Mohammad Mumia Ali s : ~287 Introduction to the Political Economy of Ibn Khaldun, Syed Farid Alaa. 307 Education and Human Resource Development: A Comprehensive Approach from the Islamic Perspective —Abdun Noor Eprror: Dr. Ahmed Al-Dubayan Eprroriat Apviser: C. L. Gai Eaton M. A. (Cantab.) Vouuse xiv Newer ¢ Fourri QuarreR 2001 THE ISLAMIC CULTURAL CENTRE & CENTRAL MOSQUE ta6Panw Roan + LOXDOS SWS 7RE + 15, Journal of Arabic Literature VOL. xxxtt yo. 3 2001 CONTENTS: YASSEN NooRANt, Visual Modernism in the Poetry of ‘Abd al-Wahhab al Bayati 239 WADDAH AL-KHATIB, Rewriting History, Unwriting Literature: Shaw's Mirvor-image Response to Shakespeare snrnstne 256 AHMAD Y. MasDOUBEH, Taysir al-Subal’s You As of Today in Postmodernist Context os sesnnae 284 LEIDEN-BOSTON-KOLN 16 JOURNAL OF ASIAN HISTORY Edited by Denis Sinor 35 (2001) 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Articles ‘Yukiko Kawahara, Silk Culture and Sill Reeling in Western Japan inthe Late 199 and Early 20 Centuries ny “Tariq Rahman, The Leurning of Pashto in North India and Pakistan: An Histor ical Account Iss Reviews of Books Florida, Nancy K.: Javanese Literature in Surakarta Manuscripts. Vol 2, Man Seripts of the Mangkunagaren Palace. By D.M. Roskies 8 Cooke, Bll (ed): Imperial China: The Art of the Horse im Chinese Histor. By Ruth {. Meserve 190 Reed, Bradly Wz Talons and Teeth: County Clerks and Runners in the Qing Dynasty. By Benjamin E. Wallacker 2 Sommer, Matthew H,: Ses, Law, and Society in Late Imperial China. Sy Benja min E, Wallacker to Turner, Karin G., James V Feinerman, and R. Kent Guy (eds): The Limits of ‘Rule of Law in China. BY Benjamin F. Wallacker Sendag, Shagdarin, and Hatry H. Kendall: Poisoned Avrovs: The Stalin-Chot ‘ealsan Mongolian Massacres 1921-1941. By Christopher P. Atwood 9 Baabar (Bat Erdene Bathaysr): Twemlieth Cenury Mongolia. Edited by (C.Kaplonski. By Stéphane'Grivelet 201 Nish, lan and Yoichi Kibata (eds): The History of Anglo-lopanese Refations Volume I: The Polsical Diplomatic Dimension, 1600-1930. By Louis G.Perer 203 Goodman, Grant K. Japan and the Dutch 1600-1853. By Reinier H. Hesselink 206 Sarra, Edith: Fictions af Feminity: Literary Inventions of Gender in Japanese Court Wornen's Memoirs. By Thomas Lamarre 208 ‘Wang, Tay sheng: Legal Refope in Taiwan under Japanese Colonial Rule, 1895~ 1945; the Reception of Western Law. By Benjansin E. Wallacker 209 Books received au Harrassowitz Verlag 17 JOURNAL ASIATIQUE BIANNUAL JOURNAL, VOLUME 289 1001 NUMBER 1 CONTENTS: F. BAUDEN. New Light on she Life and Works of Antoine Galland A. BIGGER. Tours and Derours to Heaven. The Pilgrimas 11646-1715). History. Content und Studs of the Autograph Manuscript of his Sonerne avicenne et moderne 166 D. MATRINGE, dah al-iffu: Life Roles inthe Jufi Convents of Medieval India 67-86 E, PIRART. Avestic # 87-146 the Mahabharata PUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETE ASLATIQUE WITH THE HELP OF THE CENTRE NATIONAL DE LA RECHERCHE SCIENTIFIQUE 18 VOLO HES PART 3) AUGEST 2001 Journar OF THE Economic AND Ms Ta Rode Mee a Gs BS 100 4 rele (vr De te eens spine ih Lane Manis Cone eee °’ History CONTENTS ‘Cane? KeNsettt POMUERANE, fo there en Ean sian Developmen Path Lange term Comparisons, Constraints. and Continuities 322 OF THE Resiew Aancuas ORIENT ADAM TSM Oh Laelcupes in the Avent Near Est 363 DA WiSHBROOK. Fisher Cems fosues in Soh Ase Bs Reviews Tavis FINKEL and MARK GELLER, edb Sumerian Gods an! Their Rupresenuttons (Benjamin R. Foster) mt SURAMA FAROQH Ajpching Oraman Hisar an nection to te Semmes ane Hathaway) : 36 SPAR PMLA My tts of he On pe {Colette Eablet a0 Maya SUATAMMLLER. The Berbers and the Islami Sue: The Marti sponte tn Pre Proctorate Morocen (Jonathan G. Kat) pi cboum . Martie, The Polis of Trade in Sarid Iran: Sil for Silver, 16001230 (Nicolas Michel 93 DANiet PANZAC, Les cursaires burbaresques: Lit fn dune ebepee 1800-1820 (Tal Sheval) o Davie F. DoePreRs and PETER XENOS, eds. Population und History ‘The Demographic Origins of the Modern Philippines (David M. Kummer) = 308 Curt NakrstPHA, The Tha Pillage Econ in the Past (Craig J. Reynolds) one 400 KeNson BREAZEALE, eds From Japam to Arabia: Avuihaya's Maritime ‘Relations with Asia (Barbara Watson Andaya) 402 FRANK JOSEPH SHULMAN, ed. and comp., with PATRICIA POLANSKY and "ANNA LEON SHULMAN. Doctoral Dissertations on China and on fnner Asia. 1976-1990: An Annotated Bibliography of Stulies in Western Languages (Harriet T, Zuendo#ter) oon an Hass WAN DE VEX, ed, Warfare in Chinese Histors 46 (Kenneth M. Swope) Sibson ‘The Journal of the Economic nd Social Histor of dhe Oren s published quarry Subserpvons maybe sent tothe Subseripion Deparment, Beil, PO. Box B00. 2400 PA, Leven, The Netherland Subscription pice of Volume 4 (2001) 1, 582 pages In 4 ater: EUR WYNLG 425.32 USS 255.— For tasttons snk EUR 35.—/NLG 121-20 (USS 83-—) for private sabseribors, Incline postage and handing Chains for missing ot damaged ssa must be mage {ee mons of publication (European cuvoiats within five raat of publication feus tomers ouside Europe, Please kre uur clay sal crags to Bll Customer Services Department. Price inelades online suscipit tothe IOURNAL OF THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL, Rants Ave. Avenel. NI 07001, Postmaver send aldo corti HISTORY OF THE ORIENT. 3 19 Journal of the Henry Martyn Institute Volume 20 Number 2 July - December 200% CONTENTS ARTICLES ‘The Main Line Christian Attitudes to World Religions and a Voice of Dissent Daviel Emmanuel Singh Yisu Das ~ Witness of a Convert Jan Henningsson Islam East of the Niger: A Case Study of Port Harcourt City in Nigeria Daniel I. Mega Mahatma Gandhi’s Understanding of Jesus Ravi Tiwari The Dargah of Qamar Ali Darwesh: An Analytical Study of its Impact on the People of Pune Samson Lankeshwar BOOK REVIEWS Curfew in the City by Mibhuti Narain Rai translated by CM, Naim, New Delhi: Roli Books, 1998 Reviewed by Yoginde Sikand Hindu-Muslim Communalism: 4 Panchnama by Jayant Gadkari “Mumbai: D. D. Kosambi Educational Trust, 1999 Reviewed by Yoginde Sikand Secluded Scholars: Women’s Education and Muslim Social Reform in Colonial India by Gail Minault Delhi: Oxford University, 1998 Reviewed by Yoginde Sikand 27:39 40-56 84-86 86-89 89.90 20 Guide for Secular Action: An Activists Guide for Promoting Secular Communi edited by Ajit Muricken Mumbai Vikas Adhyosas Resiowsd by Yopinder Sand Dalits and Christian Mission in the Tamil Country by Franklyn Balasundaram Bangalore: Asian Trading Corpurstion Reviewed by Yogindir Sikand Religion as Emancipatory Identity: A Buddhist Movement among the Tamils Under Colonialism by G. Aloysius New Delhi: New Age Intemational, 1998 Reviewed by Purendra Prasad The Impact of Ancient Indian Thought on Christianity by KW. Deshpande [New Dethi: APH Publishing Corporation, 1996 Reviewed by David Emmanvel Singh The Mid-India Practice of Toleration within Islam Christianity, Hinduism by Henry Hughes Presler Delhi FSPCK. 1996 Reviewed by David Emmanuel Singh The New Cambridge History of india 1:7: Architecture and Art of the Deccan Sultanates by George Michell and Mark Zebrowsky Cambridge: Cambridge University, 1998 Reviewed by David Emmanuel Singh Neighbours and Strangers by Don Miller Det: Rainbow, 19 Reviews by Shashi Singha Secular Challenge to Communal Politics ~ A Reader edited by PR. Ram Mumbai: Vikas Adnyayan Kendra, 1981 Reviewed by Shashi Singha ‘The Business Manager. Henry Martyn Institute P.O, Box 153, Hyderabad 500 001, A.P, India 91-93 93.94 95-96 97-100 101-103 103-105 105-107 a1 Journal of the Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi Society Volume XXIX 2001 Contents About the Contributors, wv A Poem by Ibn al Arabi v Four Texts of Ibn al‘ Arabi on the Creative Self-Manitestation of the Divine Names 1 Geralel Elmore Rediscovering Ibn ‘Arabi’s path to Wisdom, ‘Compassionate Love and Justice in Contrast with Our Other Three Choices of Life 45 Manfred Halpern Jesus in the Qur'an: Selfhood and Compassion ~ ‘an AKbari Perspective 37 Reza Shah-Kazemi ‘Timelessness and ‘Time 7 Jane Carroll Ibn ‘Arabi in the “Far West”: Visible and Invisible Influences 87 James Winston Morris Society Notices 123 Manfred Halpern, 1924-2001 125 Book Reviews Islamic Mysticism: A Short History 127 Mysteries of Purity: Ibn al-'Arabr’s Asrar al-Tahdrah 132 Books Received ‘The Literature of Al-Andalus 137 bn Arabi: The Voyage of No Return 137 Published by the Mubhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi Society PO Box 892, Oxford OX2 7X1, UK 22 Journal of the Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi Society Volume XXX 2001 Contents About the Contributors iv A Poem by Ibn ‘Arabi vii Ibn ‘Arabi’s Messianic Secret: From “the Mahdi” to the Imamate of Every Soul 1 James Winston Morris ‘The Standpoint of Plato and Ibn ‘Arabl on Skepticism 19 Salman Bashier Fulfilling Our Potential: Ibn ‘Arabt’s Understanding of Man in a Contemporary Context 38 Jane Clark God and the Perfect Man in the Experience of ‘Abd al-Qadir al-jaza'iri 35, Itzchak Weismann A Summary of the Life of the Prophet by Ibn ‘Arabi and the Miracle of the Palm Tree of Seville 23 Pablo Beneito Arias Society Notices 105 Book Reviews The Seven Days of the Heart: Prayers for the days and nights of the week (Awrad al-usba') 107 Taste of Modernity: Sufism, Salafiyya and Arabism in Late Ottoman Damascus 12 Published by the Muhyiddin Ibn ‘Arabi Society PO Box 892, Oxford OX2 7XL, UK 23 CONTENTS Rrsacio IN Ta: Nemesis Geert Driessen ns van dee Sik ‘Tony Watling Munfied Te Grotentuis Peer Seheepers Simone A. de Roos Siebren Miedema Jurjen ledema Avertcuss Rodney Stark Neal Krause Christopher G. Etison Benjamin A. Shaw John P. Marcum, Jason D. Boardrnan Beatice Leung, Stephen T: Mockabee Joseph Quin Monson J. Tobin Grant Ralph W. Hood, Jr Nima Ghorbani PI. Watson. ‘Ahad Framare Ghraraleki Mark N. Bing H. Krist Davison Ronald J. Morsis W, Paul Williamson Penny Edgell Becker Heather Hofmeister 373 391 or 619 67 6st 673 or 701 Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion DECEMBER 2001 Volume 40, No.4 Religion, Denomination, and Edveation in The Netherlands: Cognitive and [Noneognitive Outcomes After an Era of Secularization “Official” Doctrine and “Unofticia Practices: The Negotiation of ‘Catholicism ina Netherlands Community (Churches in Dutch: Causes of Religious Disaffiition in The Netherlands, 1937-1995 ‘Anachment, Working Models of Self and (Others, and God Concept in Kindergarten Gods, Rituals, andthe Moral Order ‘Church-Based Social Support and Religious Coping ‘Communist Party-Vatican Interplay Over the Training of Church Leaders in China Measuring Religious Commitment ‘Among Catholics and Protestants: A [New Approach Dimensions of the Mysticism Seale: Confirming the Three-Factor Structure in the United States and Iran ‘Work, Family, and Religious Involvement for Men and Women 24 Joxhus G. Chinite ms Robert A. Brown Sam Reimer ns Jerry Z. Park Riseaneu Novis Jacqueline L. Noftke 7 Susan H. McFadden Daniel V. A. Olson 787 Paul Per John Lunn 765 Robin Klay Andrea Douglass Book Reviews Magic, Witelaft and the Otherworld: 797 An Anthropology By Susan Greenwood Purified by Fie: A History of Crema. 718 ‘ion in America By Stephen Prothero Religion as a Chain of Memory 19 By Danigle Herview-Léyer Religion and the Development of the 780 American Penal System By Andrew Skotnicki Habitat for Humanity: Building 781 Private Homes, Building Public Religion By Jerome P. Baggett Confessions ofan Interest Group: The 782 Catholic Church and Poitical Parnes in Europe By Carolyn M. Warner The Clawrh atthe Grassroots in Latin 783 ‘America: Perspectives on Thirty Years of Activism Edited by John Burdick ang W.E Hewitt Sojourner inthe Promised Land: Forty 784 Years Among the Mormons By Jan Ships Du Bois on Religion 785 Edited by Phil Zuckerman, Retigious Homogsmty, Marital Conflict, And Stability in Same-Faith snd lnterfaith Jewish Marriages ‘Tolerant (Imeivlity? A Longitudinal Analysis of White Conservative Protestants” Willingness to Grant Civil Liberties Denominational and Age Comparisons of God Concepes Variations in Strictness and Religious Commitment Within and Among Five Denominations Relationships Among Giving, Church Attendance, and Religious Belief: The Case ofthe Presbyterian Church (USA) Reviewed by Michael York Reviewed by Alexander Tristan Riley Reviewed by Jerome P, Baggett Reviewed by James Willis Reviewed by Stephanie C. Boddie Reviewed by Tony Watling Reviewed by Madeleine Cousineau Reviewed by Laura Vance Reviewed by Sandra L. Barnes 25 Religion and Popular Culture: Studies 786 Reviewed hy Joyce E. Smith fm the Interaction of Worldviews Eulted by Danie! A. Stout and Judith M. Buddenbaum The Americanization of Religious 787 Reviewed by Dennis R, Hoover ‘Minorities: Confronting she Constitutional Order By Eric Michael Mazur Dancing with the Virgin: Body and 788 Faith in the Fiesta of Tortugas, New Mexico By Deidre Sklar Reviewed by Miguel C. Leatham Fundamentalism, Sectarianism, and 789 ——_-Reviewed by Lute Kaelber Rerolution: The Jacobin Dimension of Modernity By S. N. Eisenstadt Handbook of Religion and Health 790 Reviewed by Thomas G, Plante By Harold G. Koenig, Michael E, McCullough, and David B, Larson More Money, Move Minisiry: Money 791 Reviewed by Sam Reimer ‘and Evangelicals in Recent North American History Eiited by Larry Eskridge and Mark A. Noll Index to Articles. Volume 40 73 Index to Book Reviews, Volume 40797 he Score Seni Stab of Reon sown by sues frp ano ace pupae Tees edtmocta ein ean gins mom sd pre, he Jura eee ‘Sepa i Sas bean adeno pte guy Nach ne, Semel Dene SiChuan tn ui Wo arm Sain M88, ad Eo Rn Oso OX SEUSS Re atalino ih wets coat hesp@tccpuncoe, Mantes he Sci Tier GELS Joon ts tara, open sn hl sn hc tered esd fei: Te cee eta cra oer, and ines Meg rm nett ores Snussralne Us ema Reene Ce INFORMATION FOR SUBSCRIBERS For reorders renewals ample copy evs ls, chang fades, andl ‘Sher sacnpeacorespondece. please te Joan Depart ae ples Malden te INSTITUTIONAL SUBSCRIPTION RATES FOR VOLUME 40,2001 Nosh Ameria $68 Rest of Word £50, Checks uaSte made pate iskeeh Pubes, Cheke in US dls mstbe asmon a. bak, Chesks inating mas. (Simeon a Uk tank ing sen Noth Amer SD, Res of World E13, COPYRIGHT anes eee. Repu snge censor oy ay ea eon at caer tot TerteU'S Cap La enim ben por pemnuen ting fe Pose oF a Cnet tncees ety dtp Csrace Cone’ CCL) ano ogni eer trey csomaeepeipadason pha Pec ne howeve al sans witha pu ston emery pessoa chug ows sth cones est rnol For eocten potopyn es ca ee gonna spas smn scone Cop Crane Cot, 22 Reed ase SSPE UME neo eon, Pe 94 Fora me fers gues lng ess Ppp athe ns soe be oul emis Nexeper athe aise Oxted ae 18 EOE Hoae Oe ORs Ulsan en 0s 9 26 Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion CONTENTS Srrctt Section on Literaron Tusouocy ‘Karhy Nadeau and Antony Gill, Guest Editors Kathy Nadeau ' Maura Mitchell s Katheyn Poethig 19 Henri Gooren » Christopher I. Chiappari a (Christian Smith ° Kathy Nadeau 15 Anthony Gilt 87 Annictss Karolynn Siegel or Exc W. Schrisshawe 103 Kevin D. Dougherty William. Lai 1 Beatrice Leung MARCH 2002 Volume 41, No. 1 Cultural Resources for Theologies of Liberation: Local Responses to Global Challenges Living Our Fath:" The Lenten Pastoral LLeter ofthe Bishops of Malawi and the Shitt to Mulspary Democracy, 1992-1995, Movable Peace: Engaging the ‘Transnational in Cambodia's Dhammayietra Catholic and Non-Catholie Theologies of Liberation: Poverty, Self-Improvement, and Ethies Among Semll-Seale Entrepreneurs in Guatemala City Toward a Maya Theology of Liberation ‘The Refocmulation of a “Traditional Religion ina Global Context Las Casas as Theological Counterofensive: An Interpretation of Gustavo Gutiérez’s Las Casas: In Search ofthe Poor of Jesus Christ Peasant Resistance and Religious Protests in Early Philippine Society Turning Friars Against the Grain ‘The Study of Liberation Theology: ‘What Next? ‘The Perceived Benefits of Religious and Spiritual Coping Among Older Adults Living with HIVIAIDS ‘The Effects of Professional Training: The Scxial and Religious Capital Acquired in Seminaries Organizational Revivals: Explaining Metamorphosis of China's Catholic Church 27 Carol B. Cunrad Raul Caetano John Schafer Laura R. Olson ‘Wendy Cade Restancu Nore Paul Pet! Leslie J. Francis Peter Kaldor The Fath of Biology and the Biology of Faith: Order, Meaning. sand Free Will in Modern Medical Science By Robert Pollak God After Darwin: A Theology of Evolution By John F. Haoght Genk Religion Edited by Richard W. Flory and Donald E. Miller Catholicizm USA: A Povtait of the Cathie Church ia the United States By Bryan Frochle and Mary Gautier Religion and the New Immigrants Edited by Helen Rose Ebaugh ‘and Fanet Chae Old Onder Mennonites Rituals Beliefs, and Community By Daniel B. Lee Jewish Baby Boomers: A Communal Perspective By Chaim L Waxman Creative Spivituatce By Rober Wuthnow ‘The Catholic Esperience of Small Christian Communities By Bernard J. Lee. SM, with William D'Antonio and Others 139 169) 9 186 187 188 199) 191 92 Religious Attiiation, Denominational Homogamy. and Intimate Parner Violence Among U.S. Couples ‘Talking About Homosexuality: The Views of Mainline Protesant Clergy Gender and Mainline Prowestant Pastors? Allocation of Time to Work Tasks ‘The Relationship Between Psychological Well-Being and Christian Faith and Practice in an Australian Population Sample Reviewed by Stephen 3. Pope Reviewed by Robin D. Perrin Reviewed by Michael J. MeCallion Reviewed by Peggy Levitt, Reviewed by Thomas Langham | Reviewed by Zehavit Gross Reviewed by Ravenna Helson Reviewed by Mary L. Gautier ‘Acts of Faith: Explaining the Human 193 Reviewed by Stephen D. Glazier Side of Religion By Rodney Stark and Roger Finke Family, Religion and Social Change 194 Reviewed by William D' Antonio “in Diverze Societies Eutited by Sharon K. Houseknecht and Jemy G. Parkhurst Contesting the Sacred: The 195 Reviewed by Robert Cipriani Anthropology of Pilgrimage Edited by Jon Eade and Micha! J. Sallnow Latin American Religion in Motion 196 Reviewed by Timothy A, Byres Edited by Christian Smith and Joshua Prokopy ABYERTSNG nea rn opment sneha, to rn erin, gn oe em ono ee FEES panto reone Susan nan oon ea aera psn gm be Cy Chae Cee ‘ia need ne ATLA Rll aaa, oie yh Amen Teel Ly Ain, 203, ar ‘Eaiwor, TED G. JELEN Book Revie Edtr: MICHELE DILLON. Baitorial Asstants CATHLENA SPENCER BOYD “THE soem STUDY OF RELIGION Executive Office ARTHUR L, GREIL. Executive OMicer Alfred University Saxon Drive ‘fed, NY 14802 sere. JOURNAL OF WORLD HISTORY VOLUME 13 - NUMBER 1 + SPRING 2002 OFFICIAL JOURNAL OF THE WORLD HISTORY ASSOCIATION PUBLISHED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI PRESS Governing Growth: A Comparative Analysis of the Role of the Scare in the Rise of the West 67 PHL. VRIES {In explaining the fact char Westem Europe was the fist region in the world with Industral economic growth, numerous authors have referred tothe existence of ype of sare and a state-sjstem tha presumably were uniquely European. In this article his ‘hess spt co the cestchrough an analysis of how inthe ealy modem period they are suppesed co have brought about a “European miracle” and through a systematic com- parson ofthe Western European polities and the context in which they operated with those of China, India. che Ottoman Empire, and Japan in che same period. The author ‘onclides thatthe cole of the stave in explaining the emergence or non-emergence— in contrast to the diffusing and susaining—of modem industrial growth has been ‘much smaller and much lest self-evident than ss often claimed. From Mexico to Copenhagen to Nairobi: The United Nations Decade for Women, 1975-1985 139 JUDITH P. ZINSSER “This essay describes the increasing radicalization of the United Nations-sponsoted Decade for Women from 1975 f0 1985, a8 seen in he final documens ftom each of its three conferences: the Mexico Declaration and Plan of Action the Copenhagen Pro- fromme of Action, and che Neirobi Forward-Looking Strategies. The estay also argues that the Decade for Women demonstrates the signeance of che United Nations to the creation ofa truly ineernational women’s movement, tothe acceptance of many ‘ned definitions of feminism,” and the advancemene of ll peoples’ human rights REVIEW ARTICLE Drang Nach Osten: Bernard Bailyn, the World-Island, and the Idea of Atlantic History 169 PETER A. COCLANIS ‘This enay attempts at once 10 perform three interrelated tasks: to provide a brief sketch of the development of the feld of Atlantic history; eo document and asess Bemard Bailyn’s monumental conceibutions eo chisfeld; and to sue a respectful but, spiniced critique of Atlantic history ftom a global perspective. BOOK REVIEWS. Ross E. Dunn, ed. The New World History: A Teacher's Companion. REVIEWED BY DANIEL R. HEADRICK 183 Brian Fagan. Floods, Famines and Emperors: El Nitio and the Fave of Civilizations. REVIEWED BY STEVEN MATTHEWMAN 186 E.L. Jones. Growth Recurring: Economic Change in World History. REVIEWED BY ROBERT B. MARKS 190 Victor Lieberman, ed. Beyond Binary Histories: Re-imagining Eurasia to ¢. 1830. REVIEWED BY ALAN LEBARON 192 Guilty Nashat and Judich E. Tucker. Women in the Middle East and North Africa REVIEWED BY HALEH VAZIRI 30 Raymond Grew, ed. Food in Global History. REVIEWED BY ALFRED W. CROSBY David Hackert Fischer. The Great Wave: Price Revolutions and the Rhythm of History REVIEWED BY ANDRE GUNDER FRANK Joanna Waley-Cohen. The Sextants of Beijing: Global Currents in Chinese History. REVIEWED BY DAVID G. ATWILL ‘Murray Rubinstein, ed. Taiwan: A New History. REVIEWED BY FOWARD R. SLACK JR. Frederic J. Baumgartner. Longing for the End: A History of Millennialism in Western Civilization. REVIEWED BY LYNN SWARTZ DODD Richard C. Foltz, The Religions ofthe Silk Road: Overland Trade and Cultural Exchange from Antiquity to the Fifteenth Century: REVIEWED BY JAMES R, CORCORAN Chye Kiang Heng. Cities of Aristocrats and Bureaucrats: The Development of Medieval Chinese Cityscapes REVIEWED BY LAURENCE J. C. MA Philip Yale Nicholson. Who Do We Think We Are?: Race and [Nation in che Modern World. REVIEWED BY PAUL GORDON LAUREN D.E, Mungello. The Great Encounter of China and the West, 1500-1800. REVIEWED BY JAMES R. CORCORAN Peter Mason. Inflicities: Representations of the Exotic. REVIEWED BY KEITH CAMACHO Bech Fowles Tobin, Picturing Imperial Power: Colonial Subjects in Eighteenth-Centen British Paining REVIEWED BY Max {UANCH Philip D. Curtin. The World and che West: The European (Challenge and the Orerseas Response in the Age of Empire. REVIEWED BY CHRIS WICHELMORE Ewen Green, ed. The Ideals of Empire: Economic and Political Thought, 1453=1913. Peter Cain, ed. The Empire and Its Cites, 1899~1039° Classes of imperialism, REVIEWED BY WILLIAM DAVID FREEMAN Paul F Dichl, ed. The Dynamics of Enduring Rivalries REVIEWED BY HERBERT F. ZIEGLER Louise Michele Newman. White Women's Rights: The Racial Origins of Feminism inthe United States REVIEWED BY HAUNANI-KAY TRASK Alon Confino. The Nation as Local Metaphor: Wiirttemberg, Imperial Germany, and Natonal Memory, 1891-1918. Susanne Zantop. Colmial Fantasies: Conquest, Family, and ‘Nation in Precolonial Germany, 1770-1870. REVIEWED BY RAINER BUSCHMANN, 199 203 208 aun 213 216 218 223 225 228 231 234 237 31 Fredrik Logevall. Choosing War: The Lost Chance for Peace and the Escalation of War in Viemam. REVIEWED BY PIERRE ASSELIN 2gr Michael Willis. The Islamist Challenge in Algeria: A Political History. REVIEWED BY DONALD HOLSINGER 243 The sovanat oF woRKD wisTony ithe offi journal ofthe WodLd History Associa tion and published ewice yeary by the University of Hawai Press. The fOURNAL Srwonts ierony encourages systematic study and research in Wodd history and Publishes loth short and long ates that undertake histoncal analysts fom aglbal Point of vies Individual sbjeriptions cost vs$45.20 and inlade membership in the World His JRaateton lets sends check or money onder [payable fo the Word History Acuaton) to Brotesor.Richaed Rosen, Exeeutive, Deccan World History AaoEiNon’ Department of Hatory and Polis: Drexel Univer; Philadelphia, Pa Toros, USA Please all Us8i Bo for delivery by sir mal JOURNAL OF WoRLO HisToRY is now avaiable in the Projet MUSE elecroni data. RAS jourmal in the humanines and soil sleness For more detail, mal thosed ce Ju edu oe vis ep fnse bed ‘Orders for back ses may be placed with the Journals Deparment: University of sh Pree a8go Kolowatu Stee: Homolul, Hl g6da2s USA. Clams or sues aot [iNet ll ge honored 180 dye past the dat of publication; chereater, the sngle= opy ete wll be charged (© 2002 by University of Hawa Pres “The paper wedi this puiacion meets the mininyum requirement of che American Noabeat’ Scien for Invormarin,Seeices--Permanence of Paper or Printed Library Marenaly ANSI Z39-48—1984 ISSN: 1045-6007 32 Khuda Bakhsh Library Journal 122 Contents Journal 122 English Section History + The Administrative Structure of the Safavid Empire Prof. A. F. Haider 1 Education + Higher Education in 21st Century Prof, Shamshad Hussain 113 Urdu Section + Editorial + Fundamentalism and Islam H.R. Chighani Utama ~ Biography © Chirya Kot and its Ulama Zeyauddin Islahi ' = Shamsu! Ulama Allama Dr.Umar bin Mohammad Daud Pota Dr. Wafa Rashidee 43 Islamic Social History * “Najctur Rashid” of Badauni Dr. Yaseen Mazhar Siddiqi 58 Poetry + Masnavi Bostan-i-Khayal Shafgat Rizvi R Indian Culture + Imprints of Indian Culture on Prof. Khurshid Nomani Urdu Literature Radaulvi 92 Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library Patna 33 Music + Aesthetics of Music Prof. Shakeelur Rahman 115 Arabic, Persian Section Arabic Literature + Islamic Literature as a Necessity Dr. Maqsood Ahmad 137 Persian Literature + Eminent Persian poets during ‘Aurangzeb's times Dr. Noorul Islam 149 Letters + Letters to the Editor Shafi Mashhadi Sikandar Ahmed Shafqat Rizvi 166 SSS Printed by Dr. Salimuddin Ahmad at Khuda Bakhsh Library Press, Pama ‘& published by Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library, Pata-800 604. 34 Khuda Bakhsh Library Journal Contents Journal 123 English Section Astronomy. # Some Indo-Persian Astronomical Instruments Prof.S.R.Sarma Biography ‘Muhammad Yunus ~ First Premier of ‘Bihar Imtiyaz Ahmad Mistory * Religions and charitable activities of Ahilya Bai with particular refer- ence to Vishnu temple at Gaya Dr-Sunita Sharma Cataloguing * Modern Indian Mustim names ~ A Problem in Cataloguing Dr.M.Ziauddin Ansari Manuseriptology. * A*Rare Bayad of Mohammad Husain Kashmiri Dr.Ateequr Rahman Mindi Section Education * Teaching and teacher in the eye of ‘Aurangzeb Dr.Om Prakash Prasad + Ibn Batuta and Hindu Society Prashant Gaurav Lontun Medicine + Medical Science in Mahavagya Pritak Gaurav Urdu Section + Foreword Dr-M.Ziauddin Ansari 27 a so 55 “ ke Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library Patna 35 Iybat © A Comparative Study of Civilization in the Light of Iybal’s thought ib Hiography — Urdu Poets *Bagar Ali: One of the disciples of Ghalib in 20th century Historiography stablishment of regional Kingdoms and type and standard of Persian Historiography in India of the 15th & 16th Century A.D. Biography - Traditionist * Imam Tahavi ~ traditionist of the time Abul Kalam Azad * Literary style of Abul Kalam Azad Poet * Arabic Poetry in early Islamic Age * Historical and critical appraisal of Sehea Letters “About the Journal 121 Dr.A.Moghni Prof.Shakeel-ur Rahmaw Adeeb Sohail Prof. Iqtidar Husain Siddiqi Tagiuddin Nadvi tr. by Irfan Ahmad Nadvi Dr.Mumtaz Ahmad Khan Dr.Yahya Al-Hoburi tr, by A.Rahman Zaryab Falahi Aslam Haneef Dr.Shikeb Ayaz 47 62 89 mn 137 167 195 Printed by Dr. Salimuddin Ahmad at Khuda Bakhsh Library Press, Patna & published by Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library, Patna-800 004, 36 Khuda Bakhsh Library Journal Contents Journal 124 English Section Education Educational Ideas of Sir Syed and Maulana Abul Kalam Azad - A comparative Study Dr. M, Ziauddin Ansari History-Medieval India + The Royal Crown of the last Mughal Emperor Bahadur Shah Zafar Dr. Ziauddin A. Desai + Role of Bairam Khan in Humayun's March towards Dethi in 1554-55 Dr. Damodar Singh Phitosophy = Muslim and Greek Schools of Philosophy Syed Suleman Nadvi Hindi Section = Science and technology in Ancient India Partik Gaurav + Kalyug in Brahmaivart Puran —Parshant Gaurav Urdu Section = Foreword Dr. M. Ziauddin Ansari History & Culture = Cultural History of Azimabad Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library Patna 26 2 63 37 Khuda Bakhsh Library + Khuda Bakhsh Library - A repository of learning Dr. Salimuddin Anmad 81 History of Istam + Significance of the pacts of Prophet in the Modern age Prof, A. Moghni 96 Arabic & Persian Section Arabic Poetry + Maulana Ahmad Thanesari and his Natia Qasidahs Dr. Zafar Ahmad Siddiqi 110 Iqbal + Dramatic value of Jawaid Namah Prof. Shakeelur Rahman 129 Ghalib + Ghalib’s imagery in his Persian verses Shafgat Rizvi 146 Dr. M. Nascemuddin Farees 159 Biography ~ Eminents + Literary genius and poetic skill Prof. Ghulam Mujtaba of Abdul Qyum Ansari Ansari 194 Manuscriptology + Risala dar Babi-Qilai-Asar—A Dr, Arshad Husain & Him. rare copy of Khuda Bakhsh Fasihuz Zaman 209 Printed by Dr. Salimuddin Ahmad at Khuda Bakhsh Library Press, Patna & published by Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library, Patna-800 004. 38 Khuda Bakhsh Library Journal Contents Journal 125 English Section Library Science + Preservation of Books and Periodicals in a Public Library Dr. M. Zinuddin Ansari 1 History: Medieval India "The Peacock Throne Dr. M, Asif Naim Siddiqi 9 * Anglo-Turkish Relations and National Movement in Bihar Shaukat Ali Khan 0 Hindi Section History: Medieval India + Sher Shah and Bihar: Some historical perspective M. Anwarul Haq Tabassum 51 + Welcome Address: National Seminar on Khuda Bakhsh — Life & Achievements Dr.M. Ziauddin Ansari 91 Review India in the Barly 19th Century / Ahmad Bahbahani Dr. Om Prakash Prasad 105 Urdu Section + Foreword Dr. M, Ziauddin Ansari Islamics Islam and Human Rights M, Burhanuddin Sambhali 1 * Sheikh Abul Faz! Faizi and his Tafsir Sawati-ul-ham Dr. Sabiha Sultana Khan, 13 Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library Patna 39 Literature + Arabic Poetry of Khwaja Altaf Husain Hali Dr.M, Shafqatullah Rizvi 47 +A Critical Study of Hafiz’s Poetry Prof. Kabir Ahmad Jaisi_ 9S + Chahar Durwesh of Mohd. Ali Khan Shauq Prof. M- Ali Asar 126 Aesthetics + Western Literature and Aesthetics in Mysticism Prof. Shakeelur Rahman 134 Biography + Syed Shah Sultan Ahmad Sahsarami Dr, Salimuddin Abmaa 150 + Mir Ali Nawaz Alvi Dr. Wafa Rashidi vr Persian + Durwesh Husain Walah Harayi Prof. Ghulam Mujtaba Ansari 189 Arabic + Khuda Bakhsh Khan and his Library Irfan Ahmad Nadvi 200 Printed by Dr. Salimuddin Ahmad at Khuda Bakhsh Library Press, Patna & published by Khuda Bakhsh Oriental Public Library, Patna-800 004, 40 MEDIEVAL PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY | Volume 10, Number 1, Spring 2001 Contents The Phenomenological Act of Penenuutio in the Proeminm of St Bonaventure’ Commentary om the Sentences EMMANUEL FALQUE Al-Ghuzall on Possibility and the Critique of Causality BLAKE B. DUTTON 3 ‘Maimonides’ Demonstrations: Principles and Practice JOSER STERN a Aquinas’ Abstractionism, HOUSTON sMiT 85 Richard Rufus’ De anima Commentary: The Earliest Known, Surviving, Western De anima Commentary REGA WOOD 19. Madina Phliphy and Theology deve tthe publication of orginal articles in all teas of thc piltwips. eluding Dre and natural cence andi medieval heaogy, including Che Son jo ‘Cnetageestends from the Panic period through te aeoschoasen of ee "Mri Pinta and Pia lao pubs review ales aad engin erica dicundoncafnprtant bssatn thee. “Medial Phlsephy ond Theology is pubsed tie each eat. Annual sshcripson tates for Volume Ir zo nsinagnnal CSSTAD nthe CSA. Canadaand Mentor URE te cseuhere: Ina US Sakon inthe USA, Canada, and Meio, UKE 400 clewhete: Pres ince posage and analing editorial Office: ed Phibpy and Tao. Te Sage School of Pilsoph, 218 Goldin Smith Fal Carpet! ners: aca SV TIKEL AON, Fay 157) S817 Ena CU Phesophy ee ells Home page ip: wnwartecnrmect mp Poblshing, Suberipion, and Advertsing Offices Carnie Univer Pres 40 West 2ch Sect, Nou Wel'St Oil or Cambridge Unneran Prom The Edinburgh Bulding, Shaesbury Row ComndgeCBEIRU: England Comente of eurrent ese ma be founda the Cambridge Univer Fremont pageshepe mmc. Weecupeamac at epi anid, Caan Pew ara Fe Ran natn on wen eC. Te Heme Ce er ie I Teas ere SM Maser Sor in #81 ie at 4. A Quarterly Journal of Islamic Studies MESSAGE OF THAQALAYN Vol. 6, Nos. 3 & 4, Spring & Summer 2001/1422 Contents Editorial: The Fourth Martyr ing to Martyr Sadr 15 Thematic Exegesis Accord Sayyid Muhammad ‘Alt Ay Defining the Islamic-Political Theory of Sayyid Muhammad Bagir Sadr 39 Dr. Talib ‘The Rationale Development in the Political Thoughts of, Martyr Sadr 75 Najaf Laka? ‘The European Contagion and the Golden Mean 8 Dr. Jan Samuelsson Theology: ‘The Relationship between Philosophy and Theology in the Postmodern Age 105 Dr. Muhammad Legenhausen History: Qum: Past and Present 131 Rast Ja farian Book Introduction: Fadak fi al-Tarikh 151 Topical and Chronological list of Martyr Sadr’s Works 157 42 MIDDLE EAST CONTEMPORARY SURVEY Volume XXII 1999 BRUCE MADDY-WEITZMAN Editor The Moshe Dayan Center for Middle Eastern and African Studies The Shiloah Institute Tel Aviv University Middle East Contemporary Survey All sights reserved. Pinte in fae, No pat of this publication may be reproduced oF B P transmitted in any Form or by ay nic or mechanival including photocopy. recording. oF any information so jeval system. without permission in writing from the publisher. Copyright © 2001 by Tel Aviv University Published in 200k in Israel by The Moshe Dayan Center for Middle Easter and African Studies. Tel Avis University Typeset in Israel by The Moshe Dayan Center for Middie Eastern and African Studies. Te Aviv University Printed and bound in tora by A.R.T, - OWfet Printing Lad Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 78-648245 ISBN: 955-224-049. ISSN: 0163-5476 43 Middle East Studies Association BULLETIN Youre 35 « Mumbor 1 ‘Summer 2001, Editorial... ee Bogcodn 1 Essays 2000 Presidential Address: "Thoughts About Pennies and ‘Other Monies” JexeL. BACHARACH . 2 Mainstreaming Middle East Gender Research: Promise or Pitfall? umn RODED « 15 For a “Foreign Audience: The Challenges of Teaching Arabic | Literature in the American Academy Macoa M. AL-Nowavi ™ ‘Shedding Some Light on Contemporary Musicians in Palestine ‘YARAEL-GHADBAN eooecadt.J ‘The ottoman Story Today Viacinin Acca 35 Turkey and the World Since World War If icret Tusa 0 Recent Documentaries on Atatilrk RESAT KASABA a ‘The King Abdulaziz Foundation for Research and Archives AnD AL-SENMARE 45 “Thematic Conversations, MESA 2000 : a7 Representations of the Ottomans VIRGINIA AKSAN Religion as Explanation: Putting Istam Fist LOuls 3. CaKTORE {Issues in Teaching and Research in Medieval Islamic Studies Soser W. Men nsiders/Outsicers: Emic/Etic Study of Women and Gender in ‘he New Millennium SHERGFA ZurUR and AMANEY JAMAL 2000 Malcolm H. Kerr Dissertation Awards 82 Notices ofthe Best Dissertation of the Year Award, 1998-99 and 1999-2000 (Foundation for Iranian Studies) ....- 55 Anthropology, Sociology & Women's Studies NicHOUs Awe, ed. and trans, Women in Islam: An Anthology from the Quran and Hadltns (David J. Duncan) reas FATWA MuGe Gocex, ed, Pltical Cartoons in the Middle East (Use Polara). oa se SHAZHAE PIRZADA and AWIALI PR, Vignettes: The Women of Bahrain (Christine Eickelman) we 59 IMaavan Bora, Women, Work and Islamism: Ideology and Resistance in {ran (Val Moghadam) 5 60 Pre-Islamic History avon COHEN and RArMowo WesTBROOK, eds, Amarna Diplomacy: The Beginnings of Intemational Relations (Wiliam G. Dever) ...... +64 Renato Penson, Cacking Cove: The Roseta Ste and Decphament katt Gaseett) Scene erie nena 62 Religion, Philosophy & Law Fannan DAFTARY,ed., Intellectual Traditions in Islam (Neguin Yavari) 63 LINDA S. GEORGE, The Golden Age of Islam (Muhammad S. Essa) 64 J. R, HaWTiNG, The Idea of Idolatry and the Emergence of Islam: From Polemic to History (Michael Bonner)...» + 65 TTosy €, HUFF and WOLFGANG ScCHLCHTER, eds, Max Weber and Islam (Hakan Karateke)..». ceeeneees 66 ‘THUWN NaceL, The History of Islamic Theology: ‘From Muhammad to the Present (Qamar-ul Huda)... +s.eseeeess OF 44 Monoecrat NISAN, Identity and Ciillzation: Essays an Judaism, ‘Christianity and Islam (Rebecca 8. Malloy) Sarto Qure, Soci Justice in Isiam (Kamran A. Bokhara) - - oun RensRo, ed., Windows on the House of islam: ‘Muslim Sources on Spirtualy and Refgious Life (Asma Afsorudin) Nea. Rosnson, Isler: A Concise troduction (Steve Tamar)» Sanne ScHMOTKE, Theologie, Philosophie und Mystik im “2wélferschitischentsiam des 9/15, Jarhunderts: ie Gedankenwalt des Ton AbI Gumbur alAnsat (am 238/1434-35-nach 906/1501) (Devin Stewart) Ton Wasaaa, ed., The Origins of the Koran: Classic Essays on Tlam’s Holy Book (Christopher Melchert)... Iau Whatua, and rans, The Ques fr the Historica ‘Mubiomimad (Fred M, Donner) Literature & Literary Criticism AONE ASNOGL, Curfew (Sibel Erol) Suna traean aoe, In Search of Waid Masoud (Aten Hibbard) ‘Our EL KouLoue, Three Tales of Love and Death (Maggie Nassif) ‘Thomas Rain CAOWE, Jn Wineseller’s Street: Renderings of Hafez (Christine Van Ruymbeke) Ghassan Kanarant, Palestine’ Children: Returning to Haifa & ther Stories (Christine Dykgraat) .... garenen xesoninee, Reading Mpstal Lyre! The Case oF a afin Rum (Omid Saf) . snavmnus Parsi, Women Hithout en (PesisM. Karim) Geen JAW van GELDER, Go's Banquet "Food in Classical Arabic literature (Mohamed-Saleh Or). Art, Culture & Society Steven C, CATON, Lawrence of Arabia: A Fm’s Anthropology (Weston Burnett) : D. Farnam RuccLES, Gardens, Landscape and Vision in the Palaces of Islamic Spain (Shrine Hamadeh) snonea Panera, ies from the Arabian Desert: The Bullng of “Jubail and Yanbu in Sauel Arabia Sharon Nagy)... Hen and Ave STIERLIN, Splendours ofan Islamvc World: ‘Mamluk Art in Caro, 1250-1517 Nona Sadek) ‘The Intemet in the Mile East and Nort Afca: ‘Free Expression and Censorship (Vickie Langohr) Pre-Modern History M.S. ASIMOV and C. E, Bosom, eds., History of the Civilizations of ‘Central Asia, Vol. IV: The Age of Achievement: AD 750 ¢0 the End of the Fifteenth Century (Beatrice Forbes Manz) CGenaar 806, intro. and trans, Ibn a-Jazzar on Feverst ‘A Critical Edition of Zad al-musafi wa-qut al-hadir (@rovsions forthe Traveler and Nurshment for the Sedentar), ‘Book 7, Chapters 1-6 (Nahyan Fancy)... eo o€ Harr0c, Genghis Khan; Conqueror ofthe World (Glonathan Skaff). Menveo Euro KORO, Some Observations on the Inuence of ‘Byzantine Instleutions on Oteoman Insbtutions (Linda T. Darling) . ‘Benoa LELOUCH and STEPHANE YERASINOS, ‘Les traditions apocalyptiques au tourant de (a chute de Constantinople (Gottitied Hagen) \wusero Naot ond Pa Eni, The Advent ofthe Fain ‘A Contemporary Shit Witness. An Edition and English Transtation ‘of Ibn al-Haytham’s Kitab al-Munazarat (Paula Sanders) M.A. Davr, CARL. PeTR, and CARY F PETRY, eds., The Cambridge History of Eaypt, Vol. I Islamic Egypt, 640-1517 (Kenneth M, Cure) « 6 70 nm .B ” 8 75 B 80 Bt ca a4 as 86 7 9 90 ot 2 93 4 95 2698 45 Donan QuaraeRT, ed., Consumption Stuctes and the History of the Ottoman Empire, 1550-1922 Elizabeth Thompson) 97 2uorTs E, TUCKER, In the House of the Law: Gender and Islamic Law in ‘Ottoman Syria and Palestine (David Waines) ..... +++ ++ cy nik J, ZURCHER, ed., Arming the State: Miltary Canscripton in ‘he Midale East and Central Asi, 1775-1925 (Rhoads Murphey) ....-.. 99 Islam in the Modern World san RUDOLE BALZ, Versicherungsvertragsrech in en Arabischen Staaten. Der Versicherungsvertrag im ilamischen Recht und ‘den modernen arabischen Zivirechtskodifationen. Unter besonderer Benicksichtigung des gyptischen ZGB (1948) lund des jordanischen ZGB (1976) (Baudouin Dupre) - seeees 100 Juan R. 1. Cove, Modernity and the Milennium: The Genesis of the Bahai Faith in the Nineteenth-Century Midale East {Colin Paul Mitchel)... Gascuoopsdr Euizasetn Ozonia, ed, Nagshbands in Western and Central Asia: (Change and Continuity (Charles C. Kolb)... - ee oa Fazwur Rania, Revival and Reform in iam: ‘A Study of Islamic Fundamentalism (Martin Riexinger) .. «+ 103 RALPH H, SALMY, CESAR ADIB MUL, and GEORGE K. Tanti, Zslam and ‘Confct Resolution: Theories and Practices (Paula Stiles)... +... 105 ELizaserh SianIVOH, Sufls and Anti-Sufis: The Defense, Rethiaking and Rejection of Sufism in the Modern World (David Buchman) .........- 106 Israel & the Arab World ‘Avanaw Kucean, Campromising Palestine: A Guide to Final Status ‘Negotiations (Nu'man Kanafani).... pee 107 Lata Parsons, The Druze Betwean Patestine and Irae), 1947-49 (Ronald R. Krebs) : Jacquettne PoRruGEse, Fertiliy Policy intsrak: The Poles oF Religion, Gender and Nation (Larissa Remennick) ..««« ee 109) Nissim RENAN, Israel in Search of Identity: Reading the Formative Years Esther Fuchs)... GeRsHON SHAFIR and YOAV PeLED, The New Isaett Peacemaking and Liberalization (Bernard J, Firestone) .. IsRAEL SHAHAK, Jewish History, Jewish Religion: The Weight of Three Thousand Years Samuel Hellman) « «+++ - 12 orm 2éetay, From Catastrophe to Power: Holocaust Survivors and) the Emergence of Israel (Frank Felsenstein)... +++ 00 10 tn M3 ‘Modern Politics [ANTHONY Annove, ed, Jraq Under Siege: The Deadly Impact of “Sanctions and War (Abbas Ainasrawi) : Maa HOWE, Turkey Toy: A Nation Died Over sams ‘Revival (Alev Cinar) ‘i us 116 Mascuo Kavaus, Revolutionary Iran: Cul Society and Staten the Modernization Process (Mehrzad Boroujerdl) «+ JOSE KOSTINER, ed, Middle East Monarchies The Challenge of Modernity (Jefferson Gray)... eee 10) PAUL). MAGNARELLA, ed, Midale East and North Affca: ‘Governance, Democracy, and Human Rights Yahia H. Zoubie) .. «119, Lenoe G Mani, Mew Frontiers in Mlle East Secunty(P. R. Kumaraswamy) 120 “Twat NIZAMEDDIK, Russia and the Middle East: Towards 2 ‘New Foreign Policy {O. M. Smolansky) . Ww ra 46 BeaoroRDL. DILLMAN, State and Private Sector in Algeria: The Poltics of ‘Rent-Seeking and Failed Development (Clement M. Henry) U. FrecraG and W. G, CLARENCE-SstT, eds., Madram Traders, ‘Scholars and Statesmen in the Indian Ocean, 1750-19605 (Geatrice Nicolini) i a Masouo Kivoossl, The Globalization of Business and the Middle East: Opportunities and Constraints (E, Mine iar) Rewonos BensaBa7 KLEINGERG and JANIVE A. Cla, eds., Economic ‘uberalizaton, Democratization and Chul Society 0 the Developing World (Parvin Alizadeh) saves Tor, Rural Labor Movements in Egypt and Their Impact. ‘he State, 1961-1992 (Barbara K. Larson)... +++ Modern History Jott Betis, The Dispersion of Egyptian Jewry: Cuture, Politics, and ‘the Formation of a Modern Diaspora (Nicola Pratt) 2, STEDVEN HUMPHREYS, Between Memory and Desire ‘The Mele East in 2 Troubled Age (John Obert Vol) Snvta Kebounte, Seventy Five Years of the Turkish Republic (Hakan Vimaz) : snes KuscueAS, The Turkish Battie at Khaybar (Virginia AkSaN) NawiD ‘Av, Anistuuna: Egyptian Colloquia! (Christopher Stone) ‘ABOALAQQ BENLEY and AISHA BEWLEY, trans., The Noble Qur ‘En: ‘A New Rendering of Ies Meaning in English (REBECCA B. MOLLOY) Dave F. EicKE.Maw and JON W. ANDERSON, eds, New Media in the Musiim Wert: The Emerging Public Sphere (Deborah L. Wheeler) John L. Esposito, ed, The Oxtord Mistory of Islam (Ahmed H. Ibrahim) « ‘aeTuur Gotoscrmor, JR, Biographical Dictionary of Modern Egypt (Miowae.T. THOR.) ‘yairReo P. Lentann, ESTHER RAIZEN, and HeLEN-JO JaKOSZ HEWITT, “Biblical Hebrew: An Analytical Introduction (M. O'Connor) Cavtow R. NEWELL, Historical Dictionary of the Persian Gulf War, "1990-1991 (Stephen Peligticre) -.. +. + .seeeesoeneevezes MonamnteD SAWAIE, “Azmat alemustaloh 2arabi ff a-gam al-tisha Sagar: ‘Mogaddima tériayyah ‘ammah (La Crise de le Terminologie ‘arabe au XIX Siécle: Introduction historique Générale) (ohn Eisele) ‘Avnava Sta, ed., Poltical Encyclopedia ofthe Midele East (Php Mattar) \WeELeR M, Twscksron, Intraduction to Syiac: An Elementary Grammar With Readings ram Syriac Literature (John H. Marks) . Audiovisuals Cairo: 1001 Years of Art and Architecture (A. Kevin Reinhart) The English Sheikh and the Yemeni Gentleman (Thomas 8, Stevenson) Hollywood Harems (Larry Lepionka) Minds in Black (Moshe Amon) In Memoriam ‘i ‘Charis Issawi (Sevket Pamuk) oreneo Kent Kimball (Ade Alouche) Correspondence 148 2 124 La 125 7 128 129 130 13 133 134 135 136 138 138 139 140 141 12 144 145, 146 150 BOOKS, SOFTWARE, RECORDINGS AND AUOIOVISUAL MATERIAL FOR REVIEW. AND) Cormonicarions #68 THE EotToR should be sent to Danie Goffman, MESA Bulletin, Ball state University, 1418 W. Marsh Street, Muncie, IN 47306-0622. Phone: (765) 285-4265, Fax: (765) 285-5612. E-mail: mesabull@bsu.edu 1 2001 by the Middle Eas Studies Association of North Ameria, Inc. Printed in the United States of America Distributed by the Cambridge University Press ISSN 0026-3184, 47 Monde arabe Maghreb Machrek N°173 juil.-sept. 2001 Sommaire études Successions poitiques et réformes ps Frangols Gaulme Le champ poitique marocain entre tentatives de réformes et conservatisma pa Abdellan ben Min Syfe,"La nowvelle génération’ au pouvoir : Une année de présidence de Bachar A Assad pla Philippe Oros-Vincent ‘Abdallah Il de Jordanie : de la dificute a'ate ror p39 stean-chritophe Aue Vers un modéle rénové de la monarchie arabe du golf Persique Etude du cas ae Banrein p52 Fatina Basted mi dossiers et documents it économique et social de Algérie a heure des émeutes nas la Presses trancoptones et aratonhanes en Algérie 2.73 ites Kramer chronologies Deuxiéme trimestre 2001 Pays arabes pes Lav conta du Mayen Orant ett0 ‘uenonsmaltateraiea O16 {Emonten rglnaien ot conbrancos purr notices bibliographiques ieee pag Sr'daadane timeswe 2000 nt ™ aumunes om France p.t23 ‘umagen rogue p28 résumés p.142 lee opmons expemeos cana es ances rengagen Un fonds documentaire sur lo Maghreb ot le Moyen-O ny suture Cor artes overt be repos 2313 Selomenve (acess tee) “ars autorsaton Cele sut rendez-vous - Tal OF 40 36 7218) 23a Vata 7500? Paris rancaise ‘okare 15388 Pate Coaexo7 48 MUQARNAS AN ANNUAL ON THE VISUAL CULTURE OF THE ISLAMIC WORLD EDITED BY GULRU NECIPOGLU VOLUME 18 CONTE! Raya Stat sgn Doron Ciex, On the Uinayyad Dating of the Double Gate in Jerusalem Fignani B. Fioon, the Medieval Trophy ss an Art [listorieal Trope: Coptie and Byzantine Alans” in Ishantie Contests Howavny Ai-Hanirity, The Concept of Space in Mamluk Architecture RD. MeCisnny, Arebitectre and Narrative: ‘Phe Khwsajt Abu Nagr Parse Shrine. Part L Constructing the Complex suid lis Meaning, 69-1696 Reus Kansan, Wagl Architecture, and Political SelEFashioning: The Construction of the Great Moxie of fall by Muhammad Aga Abu Nabbut \uues GiyZaiy AND Roneer OusteRHoU't, A Mugarias roving from Thirteenth-Century Menta anal the Use of Architectural Drawings during the Middle Ages Oy Taxcvkoci, Socializing Medicine: Mustrations of the Kitab alDinyag (O14, Gaanar Any Mika Natit, Two Safavid Paintings: An Essay in Interpretation Nemsiine vetoes, Ahmed Lund the Allegories of Tyranny in the Frontispiece to George Saucis's Relation of Journey Jcatanant Wiuttans, John Brederick Lewis: "Reflections of Reality” LEIDEN — BRILL —2001 Oo 120 49 Mtislim WORLD Founded in 191) as The Moslem World Volume 91 - Numbers 3 & 4+ Fall 2001 Contents ARTICLES m7 293 3ul 371 381 Al‘Aqqgad’s The Genuis of Christ Re-visited F. Peter Ford, Jr. ‘Domestic Terrorism in the Islamic Legal Tradition Sherman A. Jackson ‘Whither the Social Network of Islam. Ghada Hashem Talhami ‘The Pilgrimage to Tembayat: Tradition and Revivial in Indonesian Islam Nelly van Doorn-Harder & Kees de Jong Against Iitihad Muneer Fareed Britons, Muslims, and American Indians: Gender and Power Nabil Matar Government Intervention in the Coptic Church in Egypt During the Fatimid Period Marlis J. Saleh 50 in Contemporary Egypt Fauzi M. Najjar 399 425 The Phenomenological Approach in Islamic Studies Mujiburrahman 451 Al-Hudaybi’s Influence on the Development of Islamist Movements in Egypt Sayed Khatab 481 Islam and Human Rights: The Lessons from Sudan. Abdelwahab El-Affendi Boox anv Vipvzo Revizws 507 Reuven Firestone: Jihad, The Origin of Holy War in Islam, Reviewed by William Shepard 509 Caroline Williams, produced by Gray Henry: Cairo. 1001 Years of Islamic Art and Architecture, Reviewed by Jane I. Smith 511 Mohammed A. Bamyeh: The Social Origins of Islam: Mind, Economy, Discourse. Reviewed by Patrice Broduer 516 Elizabeth Sirriyeh: Sufis and Anti-Sufis: the Defence, Rethinking and Rejection of Sufism in the Modem World. Reviewed by Kambiz Ghanea Bassiri Layout and Typesetting by Barrie Mosher, New York, NY Published by The Duncan Black Macdonald Center at Hartford Seminary, Hanford, CT 06105-2260 Kindly address all communications to The Muslim Work 71 Sherman Street, Hartford, CT 06105-2260, USA. Change of address: Please indicate both the old and new address ‘and state whether the change is permanent. ‘The Editors appreciate readers’ comments. They value any help im increasing circulation in order to fulfill the journal's objectives — towork toward a genuine knowledge of Islam and ‘greater mutual understanding in Christian-Muslim relationships. “seeps where otherwise noted, the writers of articles and reviews alone ‘are responsible for the opinions expressed therein. Published bi-annualy in June and October - @zo01 Hartford Seminary NEW PERSPECTIVES ON TURKEY Fall 2001 CONTENTS: ARTICLES “Discovering Our Past": Are "We" Breaking Taboos? Reconstructing Ataturkism and the Past in Contemporary Turkey Berna Yazict 1 Group-Differentiated Rights and the Liberal Democratic State: Rethinking the Headscarf Controversy in Turkey Yesim Arat 31 Celebrating National Holidays in Turkey: History and Memory ‘Arcu Ozturkmen 47 American Perspectives on Turkey: An Evaluation of the Declassified U.S, Documents between 1947 and 1960 Hakan Yilmaz 77 ‘Mischief in the Old Regime: Provincial Dragomans and Social Change at the Turn of the Nineteenth Century Christine Philliow 108 REVIEW ARTICLES Medieval Business Partnerships: Islamic vs. Western Zeynep Kadirbevoglu 123 Economie Decentralization: Some Guidelines for Turkey Fikret Adaman-Aslt Leblebicioglu 197 BOOK REVIEW Kemal Kiriggi and Gareth M. Winrow. The Kurdish Question and Turkey: An Evample of a Trans-State Ethnic Confltet. Hootan Shambayati 149 New Perspectives on Turkey isa seriea of research papers publishéd bida= rually by the Beonomie and Soélal History Foundation of Turkey (Tania aki), Valikonagh Cad, Samsun’ Apt: No: 87, 80220 Nigantas,fanbul ‘See back cover for information. garding’ submissions and aihercorree pondence. Cocrespondeace colating to subscriptions shoild be séat to Tapa Ozkan, Abonet: Tol: 9 212 210 01 20, Fax: 0 212 222 27 10, gmail: sbone:Babonet sot / wwv.abonet-net. Correspondence relating % ad- vstising, business matters should be sent to Sales and Marketing Manager, Tarh Vai, Vali Kenags Cad., Samsun Apt, Na. $7, 80220 Nigantajtlstanzal smal: pazarlama@tarihvakl org 52 Orbis 4 Journal of World Affairs Volume ah, Noaiber (Waive 2102 Editor's Column Walter A. MeDougall 1 Changing the Watch Harvey Sicherman 11 VULNERABLE FLANKS OF THE ARC OF CRISIS The Strategic Implications of a Nuclear India Ashley J. Tellis ‘The Jewish Security Dilemma Yossi Shain and! Barry Brisiman Japan's Quest for Great Power Identity Giller Rozman ASEAN's Imitation Community David M Jones and Michel L. R. Smith AMERICA AND THE WEST The Emerging Anglosphere James Bennett Globalization and Great Depressions Harold James War and Strategy in the 21st Century Jeremy Black ‘The Multiculturalist International Paul Gi ‘The Myth of the Democratic Peace omas Schwantz and Kite K. Skinner Review Essays Birth Pangs of the New NATO Donald Abenheim Empires Benevolent and Otherwise William Anthony Hay Why Russia Can't Seem to Reform Yoshiko Herrera To inquire about membership, write or ct 5 Walinot Street, Suite 610, 08. Fas deductible to the extent of the law 173 186 198 he Foreign Policy Research tasiute Philadelphia, PA 19102-3684, Te: (215) 732-3774, ext. L215) “S240, E-mail: Ipni@hpe.org. All contributions to FPRH are tax: Deutsche Zeitschrift fr Politik und Wirtschaft des Orients German Journal for Politics and Economics of the Middle East Jahrgang Nr. 3 September 2001 Inhalt/Contents Kurzbiographien/Short Biographies Abd al. Wahid Balgazte (Hanspeter Mattes) Almad Mahir (Thomas Koszinowski) GalwakDeng Garang Dabuth (Hanspeter Mattes) Berichte aus der Forschung/Tagungen und Konferenzen Reports on Research Activities/Conferences Die Entstehung von Feindbildem im Konflikt um Palistina* — Inter rationale Konferenz am Zentrum fur Antisemitismusforschung der Techni- schen Universitit Berlin, 6-8. September 2000’Development of the concept of the enemy in the conflit about Palestine (Gate Nordbruch) Second Mediterranean Social and Political Research Meeting, Workshop VI Networking Across the Contemporary Mediterranean: Foundation Trust Prop- certes, Revenues and Socio-Political Alliances benween North Africa, the Middle East and Europe. 21.-25. Marz 2001 in Florenz (Fran: Kogelman) «The Ethics of Joumalism. Comparison and Transformations in the tslamic- Western Context, Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, 29.30, Marz 2001 (Kai Hafez). Colloque international: Migrations Sud-Nord: la problématique de l'exode des competences Association d'études et de recherches sur les migrations (AMERM) Rabat, 27.-28.4.2001 (lami Mchichi Houria) Aufsitze und Hintergeundberiehte/Studies and Background Articles Nadima Yassari: The Print Media in Iran: An effective weapon for civil so- ciety? (Onn Winckler’ Hafiz al-Asad’s Socioteconomic Legacy: The Balance of ‘Achievements and Failures. Helmut Mejcher: Die Wiederaufvahme der diplomatischen Beziehungen zwischen Deutschland und Saudi-Arabien nach dem Zweiten Weltkrieg/The Resumption of Diplomatic Relations Between West-Germany and Saudi Arabia after World War I Harald Moller: Die Rolle der DDR. im Krieg frak-lran: neue Quellen/The Role of the GDR in the War between [rag and Iran: new sources, Buchbesprechu Karl-Heinz Ohlig: Weltreligion Islam ~ eine Einfuhrung. 2000 (Hildegard Becker) Hans-Peter Raddate: Von Got au Allah? Christentum und Islam in der tiberalen Forschrinsyeselschatt 2001 Aura Wied Hoyinann) niBook Reviews 403 416 469 485 S01 so2 Volker Perthes (Hesg.)* Deutsche Nahostpolitk. Interessen und Optionen. 2001 (Isahel Schafer’ : 7 : Michael Herb: Allin the family. Absolutism, revolution, and democracy in the Middle Eastern monarchies. 2000 (Hanspeter Mattes)... 507 Bary Rubin: The Transformation of Palestinian Politics. From Revolution to State Building, 1999'Howard M, Sacher: Israe! and Europe. 2000 (Wolfgang 506 G. Schwanits) : 508 René Naba: Rafie Hariri, Un homme d'affaires premier ministre. 1999 (An- ddreas Pitsch) — si |Al-Atlas at-eipi li LMamlaka al-’Arablya as-Sa'ddiya. Dara al-Malik Abd alsAziz, ar-Riyad: at-Tab‘a al-Uls 1999/1419 h Geschichtsatlas, Konig ‘Abdul Aziz-Forschungszentrum) (Cwe Pfullmann) : 313 Heinz Kramer: A Changing Turkey. The Challenge to Europe and the United States. 2000 (Michael Knuppel) : sis Reinhard Stewig: Entstehung der Industiegesellschaft in der Torkel, Teil 5 Entwicklung seit 1980, 2000 (Mullis Her). . 516 Willian Hale: Turkish Foreign Policy 1774-2000. 2000 (Dietrich Jung) 518 Ebrahim Towfigh: Modemisierung und postkoloniale Herrschat in Iran: Versuch aber den Staat, 2000 (Dawud Ghotamasad) _ 520 Islam Karimow: Usbekistan na poroge XI veka. Ugrozy bezopasnosti us- lovia t garanti progressa (= Usbekistan an der Schwelle zum 21. Jahrhun- «dest. Gefihrdung der Sicherheit, Bedingungen der Stabilitit und Garantien fr den Fortschrit.) 1997/Leonid Levitin: Uzbekistan on a historical thres- hold. Critical observations by a supporter of President Karimov. 2001/Ju- dith Peltz: Usbekistan entdecken. Entlang der Seidenstrafte nach Samar- kand, Buchara und Chia, 2000 (Waldemar Schmid) 32 Bibliographie/Bibliography 527 Miszellen Heinz Heineberg: Eugen Wirths Werk ,Die orientalische Stadt im islam sehen Vorderasien und Nordafrika* (20002001). 539 ‘Zusammentassungen Summa... cocecnnninms 356 Autoren/Authors a a - 559 Hinweise flr Autoren... os venmees 560 ORIENT - Deutsche Zeitschrift ir Politik und Wirtschaft des Orients Feresgeer Deutsches Orcs, Never Sefer 21, 20384 Hamburg. Tel: (00) 42834514 ax) 4834307, E Malt dohvoanvhanbrg de, nee piv dah de Redation (Udo Steinbach/E-Mai:usteinbac inh de Leltorat Redatuionsassistene Silvia Bucke®-Mail sbuecke@oith de Wissenschaflcher Beira Friedemann Butiner, Werner Ende, El-Shagi El-Shagi Fritz Stepp, Eugen Wirth Fert: Verlag Leske + Budrich Optaden, Postfach 300551. $1334 Leverkusen Tels O2171 89070, Fax: 02171490911, Mall: sks castes ‘hup:"'wwww.feske-budrich.de = Anesigenverwling tim Verlag. Reagshedingunge: Elnzelhe44- DM Jahressboanement (Hlete 144= DM, 2g Veranikonen, Ein abonnement it ses fr eln Kalender, Das Abonnement seranger sich um jewels ein weliees ahr. wen e nicht del (3) Monae vor Jatresende gehndit wind. 55 Deutsche Zeitschrift fur Politik und Wirtschaft des Orients German Journal for Politics and Economics of the Middle East 42, Jahegang Nr. 4 Dezember 2001 Inhalt/Contents Kurzbiographien’Short Biographies Amr Miisi Hanspeter Mates) 56 Muhammad Alf Kamin (ionspetor Mattes 35 Berichte aus der Forschung/Tagungen und Konferenzen Reports on Research ActivitiesConferences Freedom of Expression & the Media in Lebanon’ ~ Seminar organized by the Intemational Press Institute. Vienna, and the Lebanese American University in Beirut, 9-11 May, 2001 /Kashurina Notzol 379 Panel Germany and the Middle East, 1919-1943" at che Twenty-Fifth Ap niversary Conference of the German Studies Association. Washington, D.C. October $-7. 2001 Mivkfeane G. Schwan Das Graduiertenkolleg fie Gegenwsansbezogene Orientfrscitung 1990-2000 cin kritischer Rickbliek Graduate College for Contemporary Middle East Re- search 1990-2000 ~ a critical Retrospective (Sik Alp Buhudie Harst Unbe= aun 591 Aulsitze und Hintergrundberichte'Studies and Background Articles Michael M. Gurter: The Bane of Kurdish Disunity. 605 David Gholumasad Zum Umbruch im nachrevolutiondren Iran Radical (Change in Post-Revolution tran 607 Franz Kigelmann. Islamische Stifungen und .reliidse Angelegenheiter im Algerien des 20. Jahrhunderts Islamic Foundations and "Religious Af fairs” in 20" Century Stefan Vinkler: Buchproduktion und Verlagswesen im fran Book Production and Publishing in Iran 659 Buchbesprechungen/Book Reviews Rainer Brunner Werner Ende (eds): The Twelver Shia in Modern Times, Religious Culture & Political Histor, 2001 Hi on Gary Bunt: Views Islanie. Compurer-medited Comm lame Environments. 2008 (Morne Purine? 679 Mark 4. Heller Yfiah Shapir u.a> The Middle East Military Balance. 1996. 1907 sflans Krechy 6s Dale Dass Kav Beyond the Handshake. Multilateral Cooperation in the Arabelsraeli Peace Progess, 1991-1996, 2001 ¢Rahiger Buber” 683 Bualbek: Image and Monument 1898-1998, 1998 (Live Pfullmanny. ‘luus Kreiser: Istanbul, Ein historisch-lterarischer Stadifuhrer. 2001 (Sa- bine sultepe Exur Meier: Eine Theorie fir .Enovieklungstinder” Sowjetische ‘Alghanisan 1978 ~ 1982, 2001 (Lut Reo Roald SugdeewSusin Eisenhower (eds: Islam in Central Asia. An Endur- ing Legacy or An Evolving Threat? 2000 (Beate Escher raz Dzandosov: Dokumente und Publizistik 1918-1957. in zwei Banden, Bd. (Urez Dzandosov: Dokumenty i publizistika). 1998 (Waldemar Schmid) Konrad Steinke: Libyen, 2001 (Dirk avimann). sdine Layachi (Hrsg.): Economic crisis and political change in North ‘Afiica. 1998 Yahia H, Zoubir (Hrsg): North Aftica in transition. State, so- ciety. and economic transformation inthe 1990s. 1999 /Hanspeter Mates) Hans-Hermann ElsaferIngelore Goldmann: Worschatz Poik ~ Winschatt — Geographic. Deusch-Arabisch. Arabisch-Deutseh. 1999 (Dagmar Gla) Carsten Hock: Fliggen die Seelen der Heiligen? Mustimische Reform und staatliche Autoritt in der Republik Mali seit 1960, 1999 rLirich Rebstock) sion und Bibliogeaphie/Bibliography Zusammentassungen/SummaPis.oo oon Autoren/Authors svn Hinweis fir Autoren oo Herausgeber Deutsches Orlntinsita, Neuse Juneferaieg 1.20354 Hamu Fan: 1040) 13825 509, E-Atal- don aunicbamburg de. Internet. ip: ww. doi Tel: (O40) 42825 514 685 688 690 698 694 695 697 698 701 73 16 nT 37 PAKISTAN JOURNAL OF HISTORY AND CULTURE Voix Noz Faly = December 2000 Pakistan and Turkmenistan: Past and Present Dr. Riaz Ahmad 01 Shah Wali Allah’s Philosophy of Education with Reference to Modern System of Education Dr. Muhammad: Heralds of Mustim Nationalism: A Brief Review Dr, Shaukat Ali 37 Junejo’s Policies Towards Afghanistan and USSR 1985-88: Challenges, Pressures and Dire Syed Umar Hayat Mountbatten and the Partition of British India: A Role Analysis Rabia Umar sli 89 Begum Shasta Ikramullah: A Woman Who Dared Farah Gul Baqai ‘The Pakistan Journal of History and Culture is published biannually, in January and July, by the National Institute of Historical and Cultural Research, (Centre of Excellence) Quaid-i- ‘Azam University, Post Box 1230, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan. Tel (051) 9266395, 9266402. All correspondence should be addressed to the Editor. Printed at $.T. Printers, Gawalmandi, Rawalpindi, Composed by Mr. Khalid Mahmood, published by Mr, Abdul Rashid for National Institute of Historical and Cultural Research, (Centre of Excellence) Quaid-i-Azam University, P.O. Box-1230, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan, 58 PAKISTAN JOURNAL OF HISTORY AND CULTURE Vol. XX No.1 ‘January-June 2001 Axticles Implications of the Distinctive Features of the Ghori Chain of Command Dr Khurram Qadir ‘The Learning of Punjabi by Punjabi Muslims: A Historical Account Dr Tariq Rahman 15 Pak-lndia Relations: 1985.88, Sved Umar Hayat 45 The Process of Constitution Making in Pakistan: 1947-56 Dr Rizwan Malik 3? Rural Councils in Punjab; A Historical Perspective Dr Ayaz Muhammad $1 The Pakistan Journal of History and Culture is published biannually, in January and July, by the National Institute of Historical and Cultural Research, (Centre of Excellence), Quaid-i- ‘Azam University, P.O, Box 1230, H.605, St.29, G-10/2, Islamabad 144000, Pakistan. Tel. (051) 9266395, 9266402. All correspondence should be addressed to the Editor Printed at S.T. Printers, Gawalmandi, Rawalpindi, Composed by Mr. Khalid Mahmood, Published by Mr. Abdul Rashid for National Institute of Historical and Cultural Research, (Centre of Excellence), Quaid-ieAzam University, P.O. Box 1230, H.605, St.29, G-10/2, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan 59 a eh ot) PVE TT aS TS Bulletin 108 Pontificium Consilium pro Dialogo inter Religiones iret del Vaticano Contents of the Pope Michael L. Fitzy Thomas Michel, Variety of pornaches tn Interaigons Dialogue CELAM (Consejo Episcopal Latinoamericano) Secretariat, ccques Du ¢ Christian Theology Examenioma y Diigo Internigiaso Juan Carlos Uren Viera, El Dig Amira Latina: Realided y defies Cayetano Mazzoleni, Relig baa ‘Nasla Tabbara, 4 Roman Expenence, Nostea Aetace Foundation Scholarship Reports of Meetings Dialegue ithe Werld Book Ret PCID Publications icium Consilium pro Dialogo inter Religiones 00120 Citta del Vaticano (Italy) Gli Ufici del PCDI sono in: Via delErba, 1 - 00193 ROMA. The Otis of the PCID are in: | (Tel, 69884321) FAX: 06/69884408 Les bureaus du CPDI se trouvent: | E-mail: peid-office@interelgva 2001/3 60 volume 37 + pumber 4 » december 2001 religious studies aninterational journal fer Articles Cutmusropiten Mites Coore Good-bye to the problem of evil, hello to the problem of veracity (373) RicHanp Cross Atonement without satisfaction [397] Tuomas Tausorr Freedom, damnation, and the power to sin with impunity (a7 Jeer Jonna Blocking Rowe's new evidential argument from evil (435) M. C. Brantey The fine-tuning argument (451) LawRENce Pastennack The ens realissimum and necessary being in The Critique of Pure Reason {467 Axprew CuicNet1 Infant suffering revisited [475] Kevin Davey & Ros CurToN Insufficient reason in the ‘new cosmological argument’ (485) Book reviews Dovctas Heptey Coleridge, Philosophy and Religion (Stephen R. Holmes) [st] Ronenr McKist Religious Ambiguity and Religious Diversity (Peter Byrne) ( Gane L. HaLLerr A Middle Way to God (Mark Wynn) (3971 198] Book notes (5011 Index to volume 37 fi] ‘Fheenpurpy Ding Cambridge on au, United Kingdom ace Neth Aire Alaa sbse Spa 61 volume 38 + number 1+ march 2002 religious studies ‘nieteratina jum {he pilosphy eran Articles TJ, Mawson God's creation of mortality i) Marraew Genann JAcony Kierkegaard on truth [27] Davip M. Croce The religious adequacy of free-will theism (¢5) Josepu Snaw The virtue of obedience [63] Davin Wienke Why God's beliefs are not hard-type soft facts (77] R{cHARD M. Gate & ALEXANDER R. PRUSS A response to Oppy, and to Davey and Clifton {8a}, J, KeLLenaencen ‘Seeing-as” in religion: discovery and community {t1] Book reviews ELzoNonr STUM® & Nonwan Knetzmaww (eds) The Cambridge Companion to Augustine Josef Lossl)(109| Mancet Sanor Living a Good Life in Spite of Evit Hi) tna Coun Grawr Aliruism and Christian Ethics (Gordon Graham) {13} Book notes 123) ‘ecambrige Unie re 202 ‘eas ng ga mented gon Pae¥inte ied igh yeti res Cambie ‘lances nd conespondenecomece nite shoud be Sent Poser Sr essa Depart ‘Thea snd eligi: Suds Kings Cee Lanta, San Ennai pterhvethcLacak 62 VIEW Volume XXIV Number 4 2001 Contents Ho-fung Hung Imperial China and Capitalist 473 Europe in the EighteenthCentury Global Economy Boris Stremlin Bounding Historical Systems: 515 ‘The Wallerstein-Frank Debate and the Role of Knowledge in World History Khaldoun Samman The Limits of the Classical 533 Comparative Method Notes on Authors B74 Abstracts 575 Index, Vol. XXIV 317 REVIEW (ISSN 0147-9032; Publication #567-370) is published quarterly—Wincer, Spring, Summer, Fall-by Fernand Braudel Center, Binghamton University, B. O. Box 6000, Bingharnton NY 13902-6000. Copyright ® by the Research Foundation ofthe State University of New York Subscriptions: Regular institutional rate $90.00. Individuals from high GNP per capita ‘oundries may subserie ata oneyear rate of $28.00. Add $8.00 for subscriptions outside the US. Noninsttational orders must be accompanied by personal check. High GNP per capita countries are the US.A. Canada, chose in western Europe and Australasia, pus Japan, Korea, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore, Brunei, Isracl, Irn, Qaar, and the United Arab Emirates, Tndiual subsribers from low GNP per capita countries are eligiblefor special subscription rate of $10.00 a year. Make checks payable in US. dollars to Research Foundation of SUNY dnd send payment to REVIEW, Fernand Braudel Center, Binghamton University, B. 0. Box 66000, Binghamton NY 13902-6000, Periodicals postage paid at Bingharnion NY. ‘Back Issues: Information about availability and prices of back issues may be obtained from the Managing Editor (address below). “Abstracting Services: REVIEW is abstracted by Alternative Press Index, Ebsco, Socio logical Abstracts, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, Inquiries: Address all correspondence and permissions requess to REVIEW, Fernand Brat del Center, P.O, Bok 6000, Binghamton University, Binghamton NY, 18902-6000. Tele phone: 1-607-777-4924; Fax 1-607-777-4315; emaik: renew@binghamton.edu “Advertising: Current rates and specifications maybe obtained by writing to the Managing Exitor atthe address above, (Claims: Claims for undelivered copies must be made no later than three months follow- {ng month of publication. The publisher wil supply missing copies when losses have been sustained in transit and when the reserve stock will permit Change of Address: Six weeks’ advance notice must be given when notifying change of address Pease send old address label along with new adtress:o insure proper identifica tion. POSTMASTER: Send change of address to REVIEW, Fernand Braudel Center, Binghamton University, P. O, Box 6000, Binghamton NY, 15902-6000. 63 Revue des mondes mus Sommaire n° 91-92-93-94 Mahdisme et millénarisme en Islam Theme sous a rerpomebileé de Mercedes Garcia Arenal PREMIERE PARTIE Mercedes Garcia-Arenal Fred M, Donner David Cook Mohamad Ali Amie-Mocze Perse Lory Michael Bree Matibel Fiesro Tilman Nagel Houari Touati Mercedes Garcia-Acenal Julia Claney-Seith Thomas Fille Aharon Layish Derry! N. MacLean 29 33 3 93 07 137 137 181 209 zi 239 Tneroduction La question du mestanisme dans islam priv Messianism and Astronomical events during the firs four ceneures of Islam Fin du Temps et Retour 4 FOrigine (Aspect de fmamolagie duodéciaine VI) Escharologiealchimique chee Abie fbn Hayyin Le Mahdi dans le Maghseb médiéval “Gaboracion de alégitimitéalmohade Le mahal thn amare e al-Andalus Le Mahdisme dtbn Tima 'Tba Qast une analyse Phénoménologique LiAsbre du Prophite. Prophetisme, ancestait et politique a4 Magheeb Imam ec Mahdi: Ibm Abi Maballt La eévolte de BS Ziyan en Algerie, 1869, Uthmin dan Fodio ela question du pouvoir en pays Haoussa “The Mahdi’ Legal Methodology ag Mechanism for adapting the Shar’ in che Sudan to political and social Purposes, La saciologie ce engagement politique le Mahdawia indien ec Etat 64 Mare Gaborican 257 Le mahal oublé de Inde britannique Sayyiel Ahmad Barelwi (1786-183) ses disciples, ses adversires 275. Hirophanie et sottiologie dans les traditions ismaéliennes «da sous-ontinent indo-pakistanais Hamie Bocaslan 297 Le mahdisme en Turquie (Coincident de Menemen » en 1930 wl 321 Glosaire Merwe Garcia SECONDE PARTIE Etude libre Klaus Kecier 333 Le Paris des Otcomans ila Belle Epoque Lectures et signalements bibliographiques Gabriel Camps 351 Leceures Marie Odile Rousset Pieree Verges Thierry Fabre Jaeques Dalaran Jean Samuel Bordreul Roland-Pievte Cayraud Daniel Panzac Jean Chadles Depaul Nora Lafi Rodica Fieaneseu Eric Chaumone Rachida Chik Catherine Mayeut-Jaouen, Samuel Petal Sophie Caraniai Regis Darques bere Meynier Odile Archens, Sylvie Denoie 457 Signalements bibliographiques Seri de idation: ble Mare ‘Sree: Ole Arches Mao de a Mézenanee raven Per 13617 Aicen-Ponens Coe fa s04 22s a5 aL a2 23852 Fics 004223 8501 emmavepacean. EDITION/DIEFUSION Eons EDISUD {Cale RN 7, 13090 ven Provence a 044221 1 44 Fax: D4 2213620, su INTERNET. Trap evesory en sebmatr: ean Chip Pesan 65 SACRED WEB A JOURNAL OF TRADITION AND MODERNITY 8 Table of Contents Editorial: Reclaiming the Center 7 by M.A Lakbant Wow is authentic Iam w be distinguished fm the hoeible ats commited ints ‘ame? this ltl traces the rage course of decentered isl, explores the origins fof eseaument tht have shaped moxtra Musi societies, and the fesions bermecn fundamentals dna ard modernity tht bea the ear of te event fSepember 11 and thee afermath Frithjof Schuon: Providence without Paradox 19 by Michael Fitzgerald A fc at egal representative of the celebrated mesaphysican, the late Feith Schuon, responds te Pack Riggers cxtcsms of Sehuon in Sacred Web 7, arguing thar thee i no socoasisteny bere Sehuon's personaly and his message Frithjof Schuon: Memories and Anecdotes 38 by Catberine Sebuon Catherine Schuon, wie ofthe late Fh Schuoa, provides some recolectons afer 50 years oth he Shaykh Her intimate reminiscences of this teacher, who taught and embed the preanes” which "the necessizy condition forthe etm 0 God,” Indivectly expands to his cede by portrayal that both humanize and ennobles is subject, ‘The Illumination of Frithjof Schuon 6 by Scott Korn This ace takes isue withthe conservative perennials perspective that Els Schuon's apparent smeretsm, arguing inca fo the Url perspective that valves Principe syretism a necessary component of eligous plurals. Concerning Religious Forms ” by Timothy Scott Religious forms partake of the mystery of oth the Absolute and the tafe, This sure ofthe nature of eligious forms examine dhe contours ofthis mystery, and ‘conkles witha note on Rigen’ recat evaluation of Schuon in Sacred HB 7 66 Shakespeare and the Metaphysics of Tradition 99 by Peter Siloard This companion piece to Atleard’s anicle on Hopkins and the Metapbstes of -MaderniyinSared eb summons cerain key pases rom the Bur to demonsrate his rdioaally metaphyseal onenain, ‘The End of the World according to William Blake and 105, J.G. Bennett ‘by Paul Davies “Thistle agus tha the end ofthe wold cording to Blake and Bennet 10 be Lndestood notte cesaon of pal universe ut asthe rarsformation of Thoma antag that ley tbe eat ofthe etapa ques SPECIAL SECTION: REFLECTING ON SEPTEMBER 11" Shadows and Strife: Reflections on the Confrontation ma of Islam and the West by Rodney Blackbiest and Kenneth Oldmeadow Inthe wake ofthe evens of September 11° and thei termath, tis collaborative piece by wo Australian academics contrasts American Fundamentals and sane Rindamcntalism, and deaws fom the curent conc he broader questions ofthe bass of religous pluralism. Recollecting the Spirit of Jihad 137 by Reza Sbab-Kazemt Drawing from historical edence, and citing such examples as Saladin and the Ee [bd al Qadir aan, de author distinguishes between the tereonpe of hadi" fd the tre spt of had ‘Towards Informed and Conscientious Media Coverage of Islam 157 ‘by Karts H. Karim "The tutor has adapted chapter from his awarding book lame Peril Media and Global Volenes, to rect on the coverage of Islam i the dominant Westen ‘medi, parucuatyin ight of the eves of September UI ‘The System of Antichrist m by Charles Upton “The ahor of The System of ntihre: Path ad lseood tn Postrradernisn and the New ge eis his book in the wake of September 1th Letters 175 ANote on the Contributors 193, Submissions: “The editor invites submissions, including ares, eviews and eters tothe editor. LUnsollcted submissions wil ot be rerumed unless accompanied by 3 setfaddresed, stamped envelope. The editor eserves the right edit eters Submissions shouldbe mailed to the editor, M. All akan, Sacred Web, 147, 3300 Capilano Road, North Vancouver, Brilsh Columbia, Canada, V7R 448 or sent by email to "labhaniGunierve com”. The deadlines for submissions ae Apel 15th for dhe Summer Issue and October 15th forthe Winter fsue 67 Volume 7, Number 2 Winter 2001 Contents Withdrawal, Excinction and Creation: Chris's keno in light of 45 Judaic doctrine of minum and the llamie doctrine of fina by Timon Sone Realty Reason and Astrology 6 BD. Scot Kore A Unigy with Distinctions: Parallels inthe Thought of 9s Gregory Palamas and fbn al Aabi 1 Peer Samtel ‘The Forbidden Door 139 Review Article (Christianiny: Lincaments of 2 Sasted Taition 87 Sy Philip Shereard ‘The Philosophy of Sere Nar 204 Library of Living Philosophers Vol SCV LE, Hahn, RE, Auer and LW. Stone feds) Reviewed by Maryam fameelsh 209 Reviewed by Darrell Blakeway Theo Remarkable Russian Orthodox Choits 213 Reviewed by Deze Some la Psi Reader Foru 24, USA Telephone: 703 476-8837 Fax 705 4765218 email Rsde@erols.com vow traditiona studies org veo sophisjouraalcom 68 THE TURKISH STUDIES ASSOCIATION BULLETIN 25:1 (SPRING 2001) Contents Articles OZKUL COBANOGLU. Street Destans in the Turkish Minstrel Tradition / 1 CORINNA TSAKIRIDOU, Ideology, Prejudice and Ethnic Conflict in George Horton's The Blight of Asia: A Radical Narrative Reconsidered / 21 Communications HANDE BIRKALAN, Pertey Naili Boratav, Turkish Politics and the University Events / 39 KLAUS KREISER, Karl SuGheim (1878-1947) / 62 Reviews Kamil Aydin, Images of Turkey in Western Literature by MUGE GALIN / 67 Howard Crane, editor and translator, The Garden of the Mosques, by WALTER B, DENNY / 69 Toni M. Cross and Gary Leiser, A Brief History of Amara by BOGAG A. ERGENE / 7 Robert Dankoff and Robert Elsie, editors and translators, Evliya Gelebi in Albania ‘and Adjacent Regrons (Kosove, Montenegro, Ohrid) by MARK L. STEIN / 72 Géza David and Pél Fodor, editors, Ottomans, Hungarians, and Habsburgs in Central Europe by MARK L. STEIN / 75 Aleksandar Foti, Sveta gora i Hilandar u Osmanskom cartsou XV-XVIT vek by PREDRAG MATEJIC 77 Mehmet Geng, Osman Imparatorfujunda Devlet ve Ekonomi by EROL OZVAR / 33 Godfrey Goodwin, Topkapi Palace: An Mustrated Guide to its Life and Personalities by WALTER 8. DENNY /88 69 Usama Makiisi, The Culture of Sectarianison Community, History, and Violence in Nineteenth-Cennury Ottoman Lebanon by ZOUHAIR GHAZZAL/ 80 Maria Rosa Menocal, Raymond P. Scheindlin and Michael Sells, editors, The Literacure of Al-Andatas by ANDRAS HAMORI /97 Soyyidi “Ali Re'is, Le Miroir des pays: une anabase ottomane d travers Ide el Asi Censrate:réitrraduit du eure ottoman, présenté et annoté par Jean-Louis Bacau Grammont by SVAT SOUCEK / 101 Eugene Rogan, Frontiers of the Stace in the Late Ottoman Empire: Transjordan, 1850-1921 by CHARLES WILKINS / 105 Announcement Institute of Turkish Studies 2002-2003 Grants Program / 115 he Tarts Sais session Balen afer journal pub seman by the Turkish Soa sae Shan nf fr oan un ced ner de FRegse and Aasatre scr, $0 Stat smeiner,$15, 00 Joint ember, $4000 nd Int pcb $5000 avs vo the feegarr orks meres nga Take also may ay sei Sngol tes, Si:00 ar the sunsns Imus fam, the Dctor, American Research Fare ie ‘Fars Uveh sok 5, MUS30 Arnvantos tabu ean ll $3.0 for sutace a onside the US. (Cam ‘Mu an Ste $20) an 8 0 fra nal posta 8b SD Saud Arabi) corner Chai, Departs af Central Eurasian Stu sinuuna Univers, Goodby Hall 157 Blooming, IN sT408 2401, USA: Phone: 812-855-705 tes induna Gnncraty Godly Hl 152 Bloom He SESS Gi Solan indiana Walon M. Bla, Rae Boks and Special Colletions,Pineton Univesity 2 Washington Roo, Prac: fon. NI, 4544 2088, USA, Phone 608.258.278: E ma aie paces princeton sl usin! Chron Marty, Tuan Ate Speci Nee Est asin. Afcan and Mise Ese Dison Una Conca Wihogne C-USA Foy 302595 3100-2 emu iocgo huss: heer Vagina H san Deparment of Hato. MeMer vers, Hain, Onara, LES 4.9 Cn Phone bas S014, Fa isc} a1SH-£ mate canamemoles MeMaser CA suche: Manse J Paton Polis Depron. Fifield Universiy, 1073 Nor Besen Ron. Fail. CT tbo sT¥s Sk Phone St set oon, Fac 0 282-40" E-malmparon ia eld rats Watiam Gro Colao Sie Unveriy, armen af History 77 FeCoias CO BOE. USA. Phone w-tvceas Fat 970991 504 Emad mgramelsevmsobuse st EXTCUFIVE BOARD MEMBERS Palmive Brame, Univer of Teese 199-200), Fa 865.973.7193. Esai pamimu@utes Sie rar ew You Unveay (1908 20008 Fan: 212095466, Ema 5B rund: Seat Redford, George ‘Nes Unveaiy C9m S00), LarIa3| Comal Reiondepungeoretonn car Andee Riednay tard Univers «02001, Fay #17-b-t0. Ena nesinny iemevard ed Slade 2, Ua Sty ofMasand op2008 Fae 31035-9509 Erma met uma onde 70 DIE WELT DES ISLAMS International Journal forthe Study of Modern Islam Vou. 41 NR. 3 NOVEMBER 2001 The Making and Unmaking of Boundaries in the Islamic World INHALT/CONTENTS AUFSATZE/ ARTICLES Von Opren, AcHiM, The Making and Unmaking of Bound- aries in the Islamic Worl DeNNERLEIN, BETTINA, Legitimate Bounds and Bound Legi- timacy. The Act of Allegiance to the Ruler (Bai‘a) in 19% Century Morocco . Hartwic, FRIEDHELM, Contemplation, Social Reform and the Recollection of Identity. Hadrami Migrants and Trav- ellers between 1896 and 1972. . ‘Aumep, A. Crianet, Islamic Mission in Sub-Saharan Africa. The Perspectives of some ‘Ulama’ associated with the Al- Azhar University (1960-1970) Gratzer, BeRNT, War and Boundaries in Afghanistan: Sig- nificance and Relativity of Local and Social Boundaries 379 PexerKis, ANJA, Shifting Identities, Reconstructing Bound- aries. The Case of a Multi-Confessional Locality in Post- War Lebanon : 277 sil 400 71

You might also like