Системноинженерное мышление - 2015

TechInvestLab, 2 2015
.
,
( 2014

2014.,
2014.),
( -
2014. Global Professional
, ,
).
(
2014.)
,
.
,
,
.
,
. ,
,
- ISO 15288, ISO
42010, ISO 15926, IEC 81346, OMG Essence.
, ,
, .

.
,
: flip teaching ,
/ ,
.. .
, , .
, ,
. ,

, , .
/
,
, .
.
,

.
. :
1. ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
.
2. ,
,
( , ..). ,
.

.
3. (
, ,
, ),
,
( ).
4. ,
.
5. : ,
, .
, 1-2 ,

3-5. ,
,
.
,
. "
" ( ) " "
( )

.
!
, , ,
. ,
,
,
(
).
,
.

:
: ,
.
.
( ):

.
.

, ,

.
, ,

.

,
.
,
.
.

INCOSE SEMAT,
.
(http://ailev.ru).

(ailev@asmp.msk.su).
http://ailev.ru
http://techinvestlab.ru/systems_engineering_thinking/
1. ....................................................................................................................... 5
............................................................................................... 5
................................................................................................... 15
................................................................... 34
2. .............................................................................................. 49
............................................................................................................. 49
....................................................................................................... 70
............................................................................................................ 78
3. ......................................................................................................................... 84
..................................................................................................................... 86
.......................................................................................................................... 92
4. / ........................................................................................ 99
/ .............................................................................................. 101
.............................................................................................. 103
: , , ..................................... 111
................................................................................. 115
5. ........................................................................................................................ 123
.......................................................................................................................... 130
. ......................................................................................... 137
. ........................................................................................... 144
6. : , , ......................................................... 149
..................................................................................................................................... 149
, , .............................................................................................. 154
................................................................................................................................... 155
.......................................................................................................................................... 157
................................................................................................................................... 158
: . .................................................................................................... 159
..................................................................................................................... 163
() ....................................................................................... 166
7. : , , ................... 167
.............................................................................................................. 167
.................................................................................................................................... 176
................................................................................................................................... 182
.................................................................................................... 190
8. ............................................................................................ 191
.......................................................................................................... 191
......................................................................................................... 198
agile .............................................................................................................................. 201
........................................................................................................... 207
9. .................................................................................................. 210
...................................................... 210
.............................................................................. 217
: ........................................................... 243
10. .......................................................................................................... 245
: , , , ....................................... 245
, , ........................................................................................ 249
-, ............................................................... 250
............................................................................ 251
........................................................................................................... 260
............................................................................................................. 265
ArchiMate ....................................................................................................................................... 276
.............................................................................................................. 286
, , ( , ) ............. 300
1.

. ,
, ,
.

Guide to the Systems
Engineering Body of Knowledge (
,
http://www.sebokwiki.org/wiki/Guide_to_the_Systems_Engineering_Body_of_Knowledg
e_%28SEBoK%29, 1.3.1 5 2014.).
:
(Systems engineering is an
interdisciplinary approach and means to enable the realization of successful systems

http://sebokwiki.org/wiki/Systems_Engineering_%28glossary%29).
, .
,
, (
, , ).
.
:
.
,
,
, , ,
.. ,
,
, ..
,
(,
). -
,
. ,
,
(,
-,
,
, , , , ..
).
(realization, )
: ( ) .
- systems engineering,
system engineering. (
) (
) , (engineering of systems)
,
.
" "
, .
"systems engineering vs. engineering of systems"
( , ,
..) . ,
, Derek Hitchins "Systems Engineering
vs. Engineering of Systems Semantics?": http://www.hitchins.net/profs-stuff/profsblog/systems-engineering-vs.html.
, ,
. ,
" " (, control systems engineering, manufacturing systems
engineering) : "",
" ".
"",
, ,
.
, .
,
,
.
""

( , ,
"
").
" " ,
,
, .
,
engineering ,
.
- .
, ,
: - ,
, , .
,
,
.
:
/ ;
; ; ,
, ,
,
(It focuses on holistically and concurrently
understanding stakeholder needs; exploring opportunities; documenting requirements;

and synthesizing, verifying, validating, and evolving solutions while considering the
complete problem, from system concept exploration through system disposal).
:

,
/ ,
. (
), (
) ,
.
(
, ,
)
, (
, ,
..).
(http://www.sebokwiki.org/wiki/Systems_Engineering_%28glossary%29,
http://www.sie.arizona.edu/sysengr/whatis/whatis.html,
http://syse.pdx.edu/program/about.php ,
).
.

(whole system) c
/ (interdisciplinary)
(, , , ..)
.
:
, , ,
,

,

.

,
, ,
?

,
,
?
,
:
(, ,
, ..
) ,
(-,
,
-,
/ ..), ,
.
, :
, , .
, - ,
.
- ,
900/ (0.85 , Boeing 787
Dreamliner) 10. , ,
,
(, , ,
, ,
, , ,
.. ..), ,
.
, !
:
(
,
,
,
,
).
2006
212
(http://www.cadenas.de/news/en/reader/items/out-of-many-one-a-surprisingly-largenumber-of-parts), ,

.
10
( Dassault Systemes)
.
Boeing (http://787updates.newairplane.com/787Suppliers/World-Class-Supplier-Quality):
,
( ), ( )
(
FPGA Xilinx Virtex-Ultrascale XCVU440
2014 20
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transistor_count).
,
,
:
, .
,
11
,
.
:
, , .
, ,
,
, ,
, .
, , ,
. ,
(
,
, ) ,
.
,
. :
,

,
.
,
(aerospace), .
, , .
rocket science.

. NASA
. 1969-1972
Apollo (: 40 !)
24 ( !), 12
,
382
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program).
( Apollo).
12
Apollo -
, Apollo-16
: 18 / (
: ,
, ).
36 Appolo-17,
7.6.
Opportunity 40 , ,
2004. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Lunar_Roving_Vehicle,
).
.
. 2014 ,
(,
: ! ,
40 ) ,
US$73 .,
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_Orbiter_Mission). ?
. Minal Sampath ,
(http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-25989262):
2014
Rosetta Philae c 12
4.
Rosetta
2004., 2012 Rosetta (
0.8.
http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/Frequently_asked_questions.
Rosetta 405.
55./
(http://www.esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Science/Rosetta/Rosetta_arrives_at_comet_d
estination). Philae, Rosetta (
Rosetta 15.5 ,
17
http://www.esa.int/spaceinimages/Images/2014/11/OSIRIS_spots_Philae_drifting_acro
ss_the_comet):
13
SpaceX (http://www.spacex.com/)
10

, . ,
: http://www.spacex.com/news/2014/12/16/x-marks-spotfalcon-9-attempts-ocean-platform-landing. 2015
. ?
, NASA .
Virgin Galactic (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgin_Galactic)
- (
,
),
( 100 )
8 2013. 532 36 .
Astute ()
(http://gregornot.wordpress.com/2008/10/22/one-of-the-mostcomplex-engineering-projects-in-world%E2%80%99/),
4 . (
400-700), Oasis
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oasis_class_cruise_ship).
200 (
210/
1903.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail), 2008 "Wuhan

Guangzhou", 2011 t 350 /,
300/.
Hyperloop, ,
1000/
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperloop).
1 (Kingdom Tower, Jeddah Saudi Arabia,
2013 , 2019, 167 , 1007
14
, http://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=202).
828 (Burj Khalifa, Dubai Unated Arab Emirates, 2010 ,
http://skyscraperpage.com/diagrams/?searchID=200).
, ,
,
? :
, (, )
, ,
.

, . , ,
. ,
: .
, .

, -
.

. :

().
.

, .
. 2014
(INCOSE) INCOSE Systems Engineering
Vision 2025 , ,
2025
:
http://www.incose.org/newsevents/announcements/docs/SystemsEngineeringVision_20
25_June2014.pdf
? ,
, .

: (
, ), .
? ,
,
. ,
,
.
? ,
.
, -
?

,
,
15
. .
: ,
. , -
( , -,
, )? ,

70-?

, . ,
,
(systems engineer),
:
, ,
.

NASA Gentry Lee:
http://spacese.spacegrant.org/index.php?page=videos . Gentry Lee ,
" "
NASA.

. (technical leadership)

: ,
. :

,

, ,
.
,
.
.
"
"
http://www.worldscinet.com/srf/03/0302/free-access/S1793966609000080.pdf
,
NASA
,
.
, , " "
--. .
, . ,
,
.
(, , , ..),

, ,
.
16
.
WWW,
- -. ,
, :
, -, ,
, .. ,
specialty engineering .
"" , CMS, ,
, ( editor content manager), ,
, " " ( ,
), SEO .
. ,
, :
. " "
? , . "
"? , ,
, specialty engineers.
" " .
.
,
: ,
, , .
, : ,
, ,
, . ,
, ,

,
, -,
/. ,

( , ,
, ..).

(,
"
",
http://urss.ru/cgibin/db.pl?lang=Ru&blang=ru&page=Book&id=45524&list=42).
,
" ", "" ,
( ,
, ,
).
, XX :

, , ""

;
,
:
17
( , -
"", );

, .
, ,
.
, ,
"" . agile (,
) ,
(,
administration/management leadership)
, .
, ,
"", .
,
( , ,
)!
:
,
:
.
.
,
-, ,
..,
( ,
), ,
.

. , (producer,
)
. ,
. , ,
, ,
.
. ,
.
. ,

. ,
. - (
, ) ( ),
, +.
-
, ,
- (, , ..).
David Firesmith
18
: ,
, ,
,
.
, , (
), ,
(
,
. , ).

2013 INCOSE Bill Miller.
(tribes)
:
1. ( ,
, , ..)
2. , ,
( ,
, ..).
3.
(
)

.
4. (
), "" .
5. " ", ,
, .
6. ,
.
( ,
,

,
) 2009 .
CNN Money PayScale

(http://www.incose.org/newsevents/senews/docs/CNNMoney.pdf),
, , ,
. 2009. 88 . .
, :
,

Xerox BMW.
19
,
.
,
. " ,
, ",
Anne O'Neil, -
.

,
(INCOSE, International Counsil of Systems Engineering,
http://incose.org).
($145 )
( $10 . ), 10.
.
INCOSE ,
,
,

.
INCOSE
(https://www.incose.org/about/ethics.aspx).
20
INCOSE ,
:
.
, , ,
(https://www.incose.org/newsevents/events/index.aspx).
INCOSE
( ,
) .
INCOSE (INCOSE Russian Chapter).
, . , , .
(INCOSE German Chapter),
. INCOSE EMEA sector (
INCOSE , ).
INCOSE ,

, ,
.
http://incose-ru.livejournal.com/.
INCOSE
.
?
,
. ? ,
?
21
.
. ,
,
. , -
, ,
, .
, . , ,
? : , . :
, , , :
, ,
, . , ,
. : ,
, , - ,
! - , 10
, 1000 , -
, . ,
,
, . ,

, .
, (folk theory),
.
, ,
. , ,
, - ,
( ),
- .
, .
.
-, , - ,
, -
, . ,
-, , .
, , ,
, ,
, .
, ,
.
, ,
. ?
, , . ,
, . , ,
, .
: ,
. , ? ,
, .
,
, , ,
,
22
. ,
- , ,
. ,
.
,
, .
, ? ,
, , , ,
.
-
. .
.
- , ( ,
). ,
,
, ,
- . : ,
, ,
? , , !
,
,
. ,
,
,
. ,
, .
, ,
.
,
- .
, ,
, .
,
. , - ,
, .
- ,
, ,
, . ,
. ""
"", ""

.
,
, . : ,
, , ,
- .
, , ,
,
23
, . -
, , . - ,
, . ,

. , ,
.
,
, ,
,
- , .
.
,
, , ,
, ,
! - ,
, -
: ,
,
,
, - ! ,
.
, , .
,
, - (Fosbury Flop, 1968
).
,
. ,
, -

, . :
, -
,
, ,
1969 .
24
, ,
, .
, ,
, ,

.

"" ,
(
).
,
/
. "/"
"/" .
"" ""
( ""
, ,
, ).
, ?
,
, ?
,
. -
, . , -, , " ".
, ,
, - (
) ,
, . ,
( ) - ,
(" ") ,
, ,
, ,
.
25
,
( , -
, ),

( )?
" ": ,
.
,
-, ,
, -, ,
. ,
.
,
( , ).
: ,
, , . ,
. ,
, ?
,
-.
- , 2000 : !. ,
, , ,
, :
, , , - ,
, , !.
, ,
. :
, ,
. .
,
26
.
, :
,
, ? ,
- - .
: - , ,
.
.
: : -
. , . ,
. ,
,
, - .
- ,
: ,
- , .
, , ,
( ,
, ,
, !
. -
,
?.
, ,
?
,
, . : - -
,
,
, .
() ().
,
,
. , , :
, , ,
, , .
,
.
, ,
, , , 200 .
/
: !.
- ,
.
, , ( , ,
!) , . , , ,
27
, -
, ,
, : , ,
.
,
,
- ,
, .
Sony
: ,
, ,
.
, !
.
: http://flow-machines.com/ ( , :

).
-?

-
:
http://smac2013.renconmusic.org/results/. ,
(
).
(
: , !):
http://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/creativity.html
,
, , .
,
,
.
, , ,
,
- .
, (
) ,
.
.
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1122876.html
- , ,
, (generative design,
generative architecture) .. (, ,
) , , /
,
.
- .
, ,
28
, , ,

.

- : ,
, , , .
,
(:
)
. , :
,
, .
,
,
. ,
, (
,
).
,
,
( ,
,
)
,
. , .

NASA "
"
(http://www.worldscinet.com/srf/03/0302/freeaccess/S1793966609000080.pdf), ,
( ,
),
( - ).
, (
)
.
, ,
(
!
, -
!).
, (..
- ,
) ,
( ,
) .

,
29
.
3-5
.

Graduate Reference Curriculum for Systems Engineering
(http://bkcase.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/GRCSEv10_Final.pdf).
, : , , ,
..

(http://www.sebokwiki.org/wiki/Guide_to_the_Systems_Engineering_Body_of_Knowled
ge_%28SEBoK%29).
1800
, .

, Loughborough University,
180 ( , 10
).
: ,
, (, ),
/ ( : design,
)
60 ,
. , 60
( ,
, , ,
, ).
30
,
. -
: ,
(,
,
, ,
..
, ,
).
, :
, ,
.
,
,
,
, , .

-,
).
-, ,
-.
36
,
48
(http://www.coloradotech.edu/degrees/masters/systems-engineering) ,
.
$900-$1200, 3
$2700-$3600 (
: http://www.worldcampus.psu.edu/degrees-and-certificates/systemsengineering-masters/overview,
http://ep.jhu.edu/graduate-programs/systems-engineering,
: http://ep.jhu.edu/tuition-fees). "master of
science in systems engineering" online.
31
,
.
(credit) -, 50
15 ( 750 ),
,
15 . ,

, , .
"":
https://www.purdue.edu/registrar/pdf/Credit_Hour_Guidelines.pdf
3 ( , ).
, 750/*3 = 37.5
+ , 112.5
.
15 ,
. ,

7-15 225 , 3-6 ,
. , . .
, .
, " ",
( ,
PhD )
.
, 10-12 3-4
? . , ,

( http://ep.jhu.edu//files/2014-2015-catalog.pdf#nameddest=p76,
69):
Systems Engineering Focus Area
Students in the Systems Engineering focus area must meet the general
admissions requirements and satisfactorily complete ten one-semester
courses. In addition to the five core courses, students must also complete:
645.764 Software Systems Engineering (required course)
AND
One of the following four advanced courses (after taking the five core
courses):
645.742 Management of Complex Systems
645.753 Enterprise Systems Engineering
645.761 Systems Architecting
645.771 System of Systems Engineering
Masters Project or Thesis
Students must complete either the one-semester Systems Engineering
32
Masters Project or the two-semester Systems Engineering Masters Thesis.

The thesis option is strongly recommended only for students planning to
pursue doctoral studies.
645.800 Systems Engineering Masters Project
645.801/802 Systems Engineering Masters Thesis
Electives
With the Systems Engineering focus area, students must complete one or two
relevant electives depending on whether the student has selected the masters
thesis option or the masters project.
Electives may be selected from Applied Biomedical Engineering, Applied
Physics, Computer Science, Electrical and Computer Engineering,
Environmental Engineering and Science, Information Systems Engineering,
and Technical Management.
Systems Engineering students may not take the following as elective courses:
595.460 Introduction to Project Management
595.464 Project Planning and Control
595.763 Software Engineering Management
There are two additional Systems Engineering courses that may serve as
electives:
645.469 Systems Engineering of Deployed Systems
645.756 Metrics, Modeling, and Simulation for Systems Engineering
http://www.worldcampus.psu.edu/degrees-andcertificates/systems-engineering-masters/courses
):
1 1 SYSEN 510 Engineering analysis I
1 1 SYSEN 550 Creativity and Problem Solving
1 2 SYSEN 505 Technical Project Management
1 2 SYSEN 531 Probability Models and Simulation
1 3 SYSEN 522 Systems Verification Validation and Testing
1 3 SYSEN 533 Determenistic Models and Simulation
2 1 SYSEN 530 System Optimisation
2 1 SYSEN 536 Desision and Risk Analysis in Engineering
2 2 SYSEN 520 Systems Engineering (, 2
2 !)
2 2 SWENG 586 Requirements Engineering (
)
2 3 SWENG 587 Software architecture
2 3 SYSENG 594A Master's paper research
33
"
"
(http://ailev.livejournal.com/1158235.html) .
- ( PhD)
, 6 .
:
Required courses:
645.742 Management of Complex Systems
645.753 Enterprise Systems Engineering
645.761 Systems Architecting
645.771 System of Systems Engineering
Two elective courses:
645.803/804 Post-Masters-Systems Engineering ResearchProject
OR
Two approved 700-level courses in the Johns Hopkins Engineering for
Professionals offering
, ,
.
International Post-Graduate Specialization Diploma, Ecole des Mines de
Nantes (http://www.emn.fr/z-info/atlanmod/index.php/The_MDE_Diploma),
, .
320 6
. ,
,
(software) :
34
). (
+ ),
24 , 48
.
( , , ) 96
, , .
, (
!)
introduction to systems engineering,

.

.
technology management, engineering
management, software engineering ,
, .

, ,
. , technology
management
645.462 Introduction to Systems
Engineering ,
.
( 2015. , , )

, (
)
.
,
,
(http://magister.urfu.ru/master/institutions/hse/). ,
( - 2014 ),
(http://www.slideshare.net/atner/prezentacija-na-sait)
, " " (
, )
.
,
, :
- (,
,
).
, .

(systems engineering)
.
35
.
( , ),
, , ,
, ,
, , , ,
, , .
,
(industry).
(-
, - ,
, ) .
, (
,
, ,
, ..).
-
(business eco-system), - .
- . ,
- , .
,
:
,
,
.

,
- .
,
- .
- (,
, )
.
,

? (
),
.

,
( )
. :
-,
(, ,
..), ,
.
-,
36

() . ,
-, -.
(specialty engineering),
, . ,
,
:
, ,
, (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialty_engineering).

) ,
(
,
).
(
- ,
), ,
.

, .
) ,

( , ,
), ( 3D-),
,

. (),
,
, , ,

. ,
(
).
) ,
,

.
: ( )
,
, ,

.

. ,
,
37
,
, .
)
/ (design) ,

(/ , ),
.

, . :
,
, ,
.

.
,
( ,
-. ,
, ,
).
, (
)
: -, , -
!
, ,
( )
,
,
.

.

.
. (
, ,
,
).

60- ,
(
) .
( ),
(computer
science) . ,
, ,
,

(- ,
38
).
1962 .., ..
. ).
1957 Harry H.Good, Robert E.Machol, Systems Engineering. An
Introduction to The Design of Large-Scale Systems.
1962 . .
,
, ,
(
).
, ,
, (
).
:
, ,
(,
).
, , -
,
.
(

) ,
.

. 85 INCOSE
(http://incose-ru.livejournal.com/45877.html).

,
. , , (
):
(engineering management),
( , ,
)
(technology management,

) c (,
) (). CTO CIO.
(systems engineering management)

:
,
, ,
, ,
.
(leadership)
39
, .
,
/ , - .
,

. , technology
management ,
.
- (
-), ,
( ) .
,
, .. , .
,
, ,
, , .
- - ,
- .
,
, .
aka

.
. :
, .
, ,
.
( ),

. ,
.
, ,
,
,
- .
(, , )
(project) , ,
,
(, ) ,

, , .
( ,
, )
(design) , ,
, (
) ,
.
40
? .

, .
(
, , ,
), ,
.
,
/ ,
,
,
, .
,

,
.
,
.
, :

. / ,
,
, .
,
( ,
, ), .

, , .
,
.
. ,
. ,
- , ,
.
.

,
.
- ,
.
, , :
, .
,
,
41
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engineering_management).
[
] ,
(skills) (directing) .
:
(, )
, (,
-) .
(Daniel Babok, 1978)
,
,
(directing)
(ASEM).
Engineering management (designing),

(operating)
(purposeful) , , , ,
,
,
, (Omurtag,
1988)
Engineering management ,

(emerging)
(IEEE, 1990 Kocaoglu, 1991).
ASEM, American Society for Engieering Management

(http://asem.org). , 700 ,
: .
:
, (
,
).
1907
,
,
(http://stevens.edu/sse/academics/graduate/engineering-management/). ,
(MEM, master of engineering management)
, .
, .
, .
( ,
), , -.

, :
http://sehs.mipt.ru/edu/magistracy/program/
2007. ,

: http://www.mempc.org. ,
(http://www.mempc.org/images/skillsets.jpg):
42
(BS/BE, Bachelor of Science/Bachelor of Engineering),

, MEM (Master of Engineering
Management), MBA (Master of Business Administration,
). ,
,
, - .
,
MEM
(http://stevens.edu/sse/academics/graduate/engineering-management/):
.
Ph.D. .
, :
- ,
""
MBA? :
- ,
( ), ( MBA
MSM, Master of Science in Management)?!
, Engineering Management Body
of Knowledge, .
43
,
:
Market Research, Assessment, and Forecasting
Strategic Planning and Change Management
Product, Service and Process Development
Engineering Projects and Process Management
Financial Resource Management
Marketing, Sales and Communications Management
Leadership and Organizational Management
Professional Responsibility, Ethics and Legal Issues
, , .
,
. (,
, )
.
"management" (
,
.
http://ailev.livejournal.com/632128.html).
,
:
,
, factory physics ( , MBA
MEM ,
, MBA/MSM. ,
operations engineer
operations egineering ( ,
industrial engineering,
analysis, design and control of materials, work and information in operating
systems,
"-" http://ioe.engin.umich.edu/overview/). ,
operating system (
Windows Android). Operation , ,
, ( operation

).
( ).
, engineering and
technology management, .

, !
CTO CIO.
, ,
.
design
management
"
design"
44
http://www.pratt.edu/academics/art_design/art_grad/design_management/
http://www.scad.edu/design-management/ Apple

,
""
http://www.plm.automation.siemens.com/en_us/products/velocity/solidedge/ove
rview/design_management.shtml,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Design_Management_System,
http://am08saopaulo.fyper.com/, design management
)
(organizational accidents),
: ,
.
, , "
" (leadership),
, " MBA".
, :
.

(http://www.engineering.com/Education/EducationArticles/ArticleID/6977/WhatCourses-to-Expect-in-an-Engineering-Management-Program.aspx):

,
. (
-- )
- ,

(,
) ,
,
,
.
45
engineering management technology

management: project , venture
,
, -, venture . - --
, -,
.
, "innovation"
. ,
invention (). ,
research ( ! !
, )
, . ,
, . , , .
"" ,
. ,
. R&D management -- research (!
, !)
- development ( ,
" ") ,
.
""
" "
management of technology ( , technology management!),
(http://engineering.nyu.edu/academics/programs/managementtechnology-ms/curriculum):
Management Core
-- MG 6013 Organizational Behavior
-- MG 6073 Marketing, Credits
-- MG 6093 Accounting & Finance
-- MG 6083 Economics, Credits
-- MG 6703 Operations Management For Knowledge-Based Enterprises MG 6303
Operations Management
Technology and Innovation Core
-- MG 6503 Management of Information Technology and Information Systems MG
6933 Information Technologies, Systems and Management in Organizations
-- MG 7953 Global Innovation
-- MG 8203 Project Management
-- MG 8653 Managing Technological Change & Innovation
-- MG 9503 Mot Capstone Project Course MG 9703 Project in Strategy & Innovation
Mgmt MG9973 MOT Master's Thesis
Project management ( engineering management)
management core, technology core. technology core - , technology ( information
technology) innovation (, change
management, managing technological change and innovation).
technology management executive master of science (
- )
46
(http://ce.columbia.edu/technologymanagement/courses):
-- TMGT K4116. Technology in the Business Environment.
-- TMGT K4115. Accounting and Finance for Technology.
-- TMGT K4125. Technology and the Law.
-- TMGT K4126. Strategic Advocacy for Technology Executives.
-- TMGT K4118. Behavioral Challenges in Technology Management.
-- TMGT K4120. IT and Operations Management. [ , CIO
]
engineering management,
technology management ,
, . technical management
( -- , technical, technology!
-- )
645.462
Introduction to Systems Engineering ,
--
(http://ep.jhu.edu//files/2014-2015-catalog.pdf). , ,
technical management (
--
: http://ailev.livejournal.com/1158612.html):
Required Courses for Technical Innovation Management
-- 595.460 Introduction to Project Management
-- 595.461 Technical Group Management
-- 595.465 Communications in Technical Organizations
-- 595.466 Financial and Contract Management
-- 595.468 Fundamentals of Technical Innovation in Organizations
-- 595.762 Management of Technical Organizations
-- 595.766 Advanced Technology
-- 635.792 Management of Innovation
-- master of technology enterpreneurship
( ,
). (http://mte.umd.edu/):
-----------
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
Course
1: Innovative Ideas and Concept Development

2: Strategies for Managing Innovation
3: Business Modeling and Customer Validation
4: Innovative Thinking
5: Creative Design, Prototyping, and Testing
6: Market Development and Commercialization
7: Legal Aspects of Entrepreneurship
8: Financial Management and New Venture Financing
9: Corporate Technology Entrepreneurship
10: Fundamentals of Technology Startup Ventures
--
technology management?
.
, -,
,
47
. "
", (
, , -
. , :
,
).
. ,
Creative Design, Prototyping and Testing ,

- --

. , (
)
, master of
professional studies technology management
(http://scs.georgetown.edu/departments/15/master-of-professional-studies-intechnology-management/program#concentrations):
-----
Ethics in Technology Management

Managing Technology
System Requirements and Analysis
Financial Analysis for Managers
conceptual design (
MBCD, model-based conceptual design)
(business management) (executive) :
, , , ,
, , .
Steven J. Saunders "Return on Investment Using Model-Based
Concept Design", INCOSE INSIGHT 17 4, 2014:
48

,
. ,
. ()
, .

, -- .
,
- (
, ),
() ,
.
, , , ,
, ,
, .
, ,
.
,
: . ?
? ? (, )? ( )? (
,
)? ,
, .
, , , ,
,
. ,
. ,
, : .
, . , -
, , ( ,
) - ( , ,
). , , , ,
-, -.
().
- ,
. ,
, .
, ,
,
.
,
( , ).
.
- ,
, ,
. ,
(
, ,
49
).

( ,
, ).

(, ,
),
,
. , ,
, (
:
, )
. . ,

, : ,

.
, .
, :
(
).
. "
: " http://ailev.livejournal.com/1075745.html,
http://g-l-memorial.ice.ru/files/186790/ailev_syseng_may13.ppt
2.
,
.
-, , , ? ,
?
?
, .
, , , .
,
.

.

. (
)
. , ..
- , . https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/.
,
, .
50
,
: ,
.

- .

,
(speech communities) (semantic communities).
Semantics of Business Vocabulary and Rules
(OMG SBVR, http://www.omg.org/spec/SBVR/).
(, ,
..)
.
- , ,
- ,
( 34.320-96, ISO/IEC/IEEE 15288 ..).
(-,
-,
..) , , , , ,
,
.
,
.
(semantic commuinty) ,
. , ,

.
, - ,
. -
, , .
, (
, )
, semantic
community .
51
. , ,
, .
, , ,
"".
, .

(), ,
, .
, . ,
, "", concept.
.

.
.
-
"".
, "car",
"".
, " ?"
, ( ) ( ), .
, , -.
,
,
. ,
, ,
, ""
.
,
:
,
, ( Grammar nazi
http://lurkmore.to/Grammar_nazi).
(
),
( , ,
),
( ),
(, ).
,
. , ,
, T -.
. ,
,
, .
,
.
, ,
52
- .
,
- . ,
, . ,
,
, , .
,
, -.
,
, /concept/ :
,
.
-,
: //. ,
, .
: ,
? ,
- !
!. :
, ,
.
: ,
.
. - .

(
) :
() , ()
. ""
. ,
.
, ,
.
(
) .
,
- .
(
, , )
: , ?

?
-,
Opengroup
ArchiMate
2.0
(http://ailev.livejournal.com/988360.html).
-
( ), -
53
.

--.
, /, , , ,
. software application (
), business actor ( - ,
).
(
),
: ,
.
semantic community:
( )
, -
.
,
,
, ,
. "" ,
"". , ,
, IT-, ,
.
- .
//
, .
, ,
, . ,
governance.
,
. , governance
, . -
(, ISO 15288) process
( ),
, . (
ISO 15288 ,
.)
,
,
, .

,
. ,
Andries van Renssen
(function)
(
.
79
http://repository.tudelft.nl/assets/uuid:de26132b-6f03-41b9-b882c74b7e34a07d/its_renssen_20050914.pdf ) :
(), ;
54
,
;
( ),
() [ ,
! - , - ];
, -
: , ;
,
/mapping.

?
(MOF, meta-object facility) ,
(meta) ,
( 8 http://jtc1sc32.org/doc/N17511800/32N1764-WG2-Tutorial-OnMOF-forSC32.ppt ):
( );
( ),
(, ,
, !);
( );
/ ( );
( );
(
).
, ,
. ,
,
.
,
. " " ,
?

.
, .
IV, 4, , four.
: , 5, per aspera ad astra
.

, (-
, ),
. ,
, , ,

. , 4D
55
, .,
,
-.
, , , - ,
- , ,
.
. ( )
(, ), .
.
, .
,
, . Andries van
Renssen ,
,
. 20
: ,
,
.
(, ):
/ (An ontology is a formal
specification
of
a
shared
conceptualization,
Tom
Gruber
http://tomgruber.org/writing/ontology-definition-2007.htm).
( !)
?. -,
. , , , ,
? ? , ,
, , , ,
, , ,
? X=4, E=mc2, ,
, , ?

, .
?
, / ,
. $ . "
$?" .
: "
?". , ,
.
, X
X. ? , ,
, " ?
.
:
? [ :
]
: , , ,
56
, , , ,
. . ?
, ,

,
.
- ,

.

http://techinvestlab.ru/ISO15926OntologAndSemantic.
(
- / ) (
). ,
, .
,
, , ,

?
- , ,
, . ,
- - , , ,
.
- ,
.
, ,
. /
() ( ).
, ,
. ?
, "" . ,
, - (4D, ).
( , , , , )
( , ,
). 4D ""
(extent), ""
(extensionalism). 4D ,
.
.
. ,
x, , x .
( ,
) :
{x | Car(x)}
57
Car(x) (.
x , ,
x ). ,
,
.
? , ,
, .
x , , ,
:
x {x}
x -,
, . - , .
,
, ,
. ,
, , , .
,
, ,
. ,
,
(breakdown), .
, ,
, ,
4D, .
"", "", ,
. -
!
,
. , x
/ X:
xX
(, EXPRESS-G)
( ):
Xx

( , ).
, / B /
/ A:
BA
EXPRESS-G ,
:
UML
, :
58
? ,
.
()
, .

,
.

.
, .
.
= { , , , }
,
-,
. - .

, ,
,
.
: .
, ,
( !) -,
- .
- ,
. , , (
),
.
,
, - ,
. ,
, ,
? :
, . ,
, .
,
.
, ,
https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/.
, , .
- ,
, .
,
/ .
, ( ):
59
( , )
, ,
< , > - :
= {<x, y> | (x,y) }
- "-":
= {<x, y> | (x,y) }
= {< , >, < ,
>,}
. ,
( , domain)
( , range).
c :
<x, y> ((x,y) (x ) & (y ) )
, , !
( ,

):
:
< , >
,
, :

, -
, 4D -

.
.

(-) ( 1 2),
, ,
.

,
"". .

. ,
.
, ,
?
?
- P101 , -15-
60
-12 ?
-15--12 RKS456/4
? " " ,
, ?
: ,
, (
)?
,
, ,
, ? ,
?
. ,
, .. , ,
. XX ,
/ extent, 4D
(4D extensionalism). ,
,
.
,

(substance).
,
(intent). ,
,
, , .
, ,
, .

.
:
ISO 15926,

( ).
.
http://levenchuk.com/2012/10/01/iso-15926-self-education-sequence/
IDEAS, DM2 (
NATO,
http://dodcio.defense.gov/TodayinCIO/DoDArchitectureFramework/dodaf20_ont
ology1.aspx : Individuals are Things that exist in 3D
space and time, i.e., have 4D spatial-temporal extent).
, , 4D
-
,
.
, , ,
,
.
.
-,
61
, , ,
, .. ,
, -
, - ().
,

, .
,
.
, -.
, -
-,
.
,
, ,
.
3D 4D
. ,
,
, - .
, ,
, -
. ,
. , ,
?
, , , ,
.
, - ,
. ,
, .
, ,
, .
, .
- , 4D.
.
3D (exdurantism, Stage
Theory), (" ") ,
, ,
" ".
(perdurantism)
, ,
. ,
, .
.
12:00 1 2015 , 24:00
30 2014 15:00 2 2016 , 17:30 20
2018 . ,
62
,
.
-
. 19:00 23 2019

( ) .
.
, " ,
?". " "
.
4D :
http://vic-gorbatov.livejournal.com/76485.html ( ),
http://vic-gorbatov.livejournal.com/76689.html ( ),
http://vic-gorbatov.livejournal.com/77968.html (
),
http://vic-gorbatov.livejournal.com/78216.html
(
).
.
Mathew West,
, 4D
: "In an
information systems context, the first of these (exdurantism) is just unworkable because
of the very large number of stages you might need to consider, so I adopt here the
second option of parts extended in time as well as space" (p.112
http://www.amazon.com/Developing-High-Quality-Data-Models/dp/0123751063).
ISO 15926 IDEAS.
, -
, ,
.
"" ,
, "" .
,
, ,
.
3D 4D . 4D
, ,
"",
.
63

. , 4D
- -.
:
3D ( );
(Temporal Whole Part) ,

;
- .
3D - ,
, .
24:00 30 2014 15:00 2
2016 ,
.
.
, - 24:00 30 2014
15:00 2 2016 ,
, . ,
.
, .

, (
) .
,
,
, , .
(
):

TemporalWholePart( , ind00001)
TemporalWholePart( , ind00002)
64
Ending(ind00001, 28 2015 .)
Beginning(ind00002, 28 2015 .)
ind00001
ind00002
4D
"", .
, ,
.
.
,
.
,
,
(possible worlds, http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/possible-worlds/).
,
.
.

, 4D
, (
).
4D ,
. ,
,
- , .
,
40 ,
30 . ,
, , .
( 3D)
,
, .
. ,
,
( ) , ,
.
? , " "
,
, . 30 1789
, .
22 1732 14 1799 ""
. 30 1789 4 1797
? .
" "
" ".
" "
65
, , ..
Matthew West.

.
( Matthew West) :
329 ( )
684 ( ). 329 ( )
684
( ). 684 (
) ( , )
684 ( ).

.
, .
- ,
" ", " " ..
66

4D , ,
,
, .
, "" - , -
.
( composition).
, (
), ,
,
. , "".
- (,
, ) "-"
" ".
,
. , ,
, - . - ,
- - ,
, - ,
.
-.
3D, ,
. 4D
,
, -
.
4D .
12:00 30 2015
,
:
.

, . 4D
,
.
- , 4D ,

: Chris Partridge Business Objects: Re-Engineering for Re-Use (
BORO-book)
http://www.borosolutions.co.uk/research/content/files/books/BusObj-Printed20050531-with-watermark.pdf/at_download/file .

,
. ,
?
, ,
.
67
,
, .
Gregory Bateson, Korzybsky
: , .
() . , ,
. ,
.
, :
,
, , .
, , ,
, ( , -
).
,
. - .
-- . , , --, --, ..
""
, ( ),
"".
"", . ,
- ,
,
/
/.
,
, , .
"" (

).
- .
.
,
- .
SysML (Systems Modeling Language)
SysML -. :
, , -?
SysML () UML (Unified Modeling
Language), , , MOF (Meta-Object Facility,
-- ). ,
-,
- .
/ ,
( )
.
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1053878.html,
.
68

,
? ,
,
. ,
- (,
, , ).
.
,
.

.
(,
, ,
),
.

.
,
,
. ,
, .
, , .
( )
.
, .
, :
,
, .
( ):
1. -: (
,
), ,
(
).
, ,
.
.
(
, , ).
2. -:
, , , ,
- .
()
, ,
.
.

,
69
.
, , , .

, computational ontology: ,

.
3. : , , ,
( ,
, , ,
.)
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
, .
,
( )
( ).
,
, ,

, , ISO 15926.
4. :
, .
,
, ,
.
, ,
-, ..

, ,
.
5. :
,
,
.

, - .

(, value proposition ,
, "" ).

, ,
, .

,
.
6. :
. ( : ,
70
.
).
( -!) ,
,
" ".
, ,
.
, ,
-,

.

4- 5- .
, ,
. ,
2- 3- (-
), 4D ,
.
, 2- 3- 1-, -.
, ,

:
http://baaltii1.livejournal.com/573648.html. :
,
http://fqxi.org/community/essay/winners/2013.1

:
,
(hard computing).
, , .

Eugene Wigner "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Mathematics in
the
Natural
Sciences"
https://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html
,
(soft computing).
,
, , .
Alon
Halevy, Peter Norvig Fernando Pereira Google (2009) "The Unreasonable
Effectiveness
of
Data"
http://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//pubs/archiv
e/35179.pdf .

,
.
71
.

(notation).
, - , .
,
. ,

: ,
, ( ).
:
, , , ,
,
, ..
,
( ).
,
, ,
.
OMG SBVR,
, :
RuleSpeaks ( ,
), ORM (Object-Role Modeling, - ), UML
(Universal Modeling Language, - ), Common Logic (
). , ,
.
.
, ,
, ,
.
, ..
, .
,
, .
, - ,
, -
.
,
,
:
;
- , .
, ,
( !).
,
: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/concepts/ ,
http://www.iep.utm.edu/concepts/ , ,
72
mind and cognitive science ( cognitive psychology, cognitive linguistics!):

http://www.iep.utm.edu/category/m-and-e/mind-cog/ . ,
,
, George Lakoff "Women, Fire, and
Dangerous Things".

-
-. ,
. -
- , UML,
SysML,
Modelica.
-
. .
, ,
. , , ,

, , .
/ ,
. .
,
(, ).
,
/.
- (), ,
, .
( !) -
. ,
( ),
-, ,
. ,
, -
Language OMG Essence, OMG

CMOF, - .
73
,
,
. Method
Purpose ( ),
ElementGroup, , ,
, , Method.
: , "",
"" .
, ,
.
- -
. ? ""
? "" , , . ""? ?
.
- ,
. ,
,
. ,
.
,
"" "",
"" "".
, , ""
"", " ", "
( , "
" ,
"" ""). ,
(
74
):
: Real
: Real
: Real
: Real
: Real
: Real X Real X Real
: {"", ""}

, : ,
, , ?
, "" "",
"Weight", , .

, .
, , , .
. (
) ,
, .
, ,
,
.

20
. ,
.
-
. 20
. ,
" ". -
,
, .
, ,
? ? :
, , .
, , ,
. " "
/ .

,
, .
, , , ,
, .
75
= { , , , }
- .
" " " "
!
" " .
""
. -
"
". , :
x
y (x y)

, " " (
!).
:

,

, , , :
x
y (x y)

ind002233
1.25
ind002233 1.25
- ,
. ,
- !
.
(Big Data). ,
, ,
, (big volume, big variety, big velosity, big veraity).
-
,
,
. ,
, .
-

Chris Partridge Business Objects: Re-Engineering for Re-Use.
76
,
,
. (triple)
<, , > (<subject, predicate, object>).
:
< , _, >
< , _, >
"-".

: ,
// , -
. , .
-
OpenGroup
Archimate
2.1
(http://pubs.opengroup.org/architecture/archimate2doc/chap10.html). -
:
-
( ):
77
.
!
-
http://www.jfsowa.com/ontology/ontometa.htm,
-
http://www.jfsowa.com/logic/math.htm .
- .

(Semantic Web) RDF
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_Description_Framework).
RDF -
, , ISO 15926 .
,
,
. , ,
.

21
, ,
,
(. 12 .,
. .: , 2004).
,
().
, -
.
, ,
- .

. ,
, .
,
. -
78
http://soberspace.livejournal.com/tag/%D0%BA%D1%83%D1%80%D1%81%20%D1%81%D1%8
2%D1%80%D1%83%D0%BD%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%B5%20%D0%B4%D0%B8%D
0%B0%D0%B3%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%BC%D1%8B .

http://ailev.livejournal.com/1154791.html .

. ,
: http://www.ccas.ru/avtorefe/0001d.pdf

"".
" ". , .
()
() .
M S - .

S.
S, -
.
(
) ( ,
).
?
, . ""
(representation) .
representation , ,
representation . ,
(description) .
,
, - ,
, - . ,
.
, , -
/ .
- , ,
.
,
.
, ( ), ,
.
.
79
, "", ,
, "", ,
- .
"
?".
/ , .
, 4D

.
,
. ,
,
- , -. ,
-. - -

(definition). , -
, ,
- .
, ,
, (
(
) . :
What an engineer calls a model a logician calls an axiom set; what a logician calls a
model an engineer calls a simulation. This equivalence of concepts leads to application of
well-established methods of logic to engineering."
Henson
Graves,
http://www.omgwiki.org/MBSE/lib/exe/fetch.php?media=mbse:mathemataical_foundati
on_engineering.pdf
, , . ,
, .
/ ,
-
.
.

( ),
( , - .
,
). ,
,
,
, ,
.
(knowledge engineering),
80
- / .
(Common Logic, OMG SBVR, OWL 2,
CYCL), ,
- .
. ,
/
. -
(Simula 67, 1967.)
. Modelica
,
,
/ .

?! - ,
,
?

- - .
- , ,
;
, .
, ,
(Modeling, in the broadest sense, is the cost -effective use
of something in place of something else for some cognitive purpose. It allows us to use
something that is simpler, safer or cheaper than reality instead of reality for some
purpose. A model represents reality for the given purpose; the model is an abstraction of
reality in the sense that it cannot represent all aspects of reality. This allows us to deal
with the world in a simplified manner, avoiding the complexity, danger and irreversibility
of reality. "The Nature of Modeling.", Jeff Rothenberg, in Artificial Intelligence, Simulation,
and Modeling, L.E. William, K.A. Loparo, N.R. Nelson, eds. New York, John Wiley and
Sons,
Inc.,
1989,
pp.
75
-92,
http://poweredge.stanford.edu/BioinformaticsArchive/PrimarySite/NIHpanelModeling/Ro
thenbergNatureModeling.pdf).

. .
( )
. model checking. ,
,
, ( - ).
( ).
() ,
, -
.
, (generate)
. , 7
,
.
81

.
.
. ,
?, .
, .
.
, , ,
.
,
Model-Based Systems Engineering (MBSE),
.
: ,
, , .
? ,
, , ? ,
" ", .
,
, . , (
)
, - ,
. ,
, ,
.
( " "
Shell) ,
.
,
:
,
, .
MBSE:
,
(
).
: ,
,
.

, ?
( http://ailev.livejournal.com/1056723.html):
1. . ,
.
,
(
). , - ,
. - ,
82
. ,
( , ),
. , ,
. , ,
, .
2. ()
: . ,
. ,
, -
. .
3. ( , , )
.
,
, , ,
. ,
.
, .
:
, , .
4. .
,
: , ? ,
, , ,
. - !
,
,

( ).
,
, ,
,
.
, ,
. (
computer science), ( )
.
" " ("text" is any object that can be "read,"
[] whether this object is a work of literature, a street sign, an arrangement of
buildings on a city block, or styles of clothing),
.

- ,
- , .
: "" (
) "" ( ).
83
--
( ). --
.
:
() ,
,
,
. ,
.
(cognitive science),
(
)
(
).
,
.
(computer science),
.
http://galicarnax.livejournal.com/39260.html).
,
,
. ,
,
, (:
, -
(, , ) ,
/,

,
.

AtlanMod (http://www.emn.fr/z-info/atlanmod/index.php/Main_Page)
model-driven engineering ( ).
-based, -driven -,
. -Based , -
. (,
, , ) (, , ,
). -driven , ,
, ,
.
model-driven (transformation) .
model-driven engineering, Jean Bezivin
( AtlanMod,
84
http://cbi2014.unige.ch/documents/CBI2014.TowardsCrossDisciplinaryPractices.JeanBez
ivin.pdf)
1. . M S (
,
, ,
, .. ).
2. (veiw). S
.
-.
3. : - (
:
, ).
4. ( MM
MMM). , Jean Besivin AtlanMod
3 ,
.
5. : ,
. , AtlanMod
Model-Based engineering Model-Driven Engineering:
/
, , ,
,
, .
6.
HOT
(High-Order
Transformation):
) .
(,
7. (weaving):
.
8. : , -
. -
.
9. .
(, )
--.
10. (Technical Space Framework):
(
- :
, ).
, , -, , -.
3.
?!
, .
,
.
85
, - - .
,
,
.
.
, .
,
, . -
, ,
- -.

, , .
- , , ,
- , .
,
, . , 4
,
.
, .
:
, .
, , , ,
, .

,
https://www.facebook.com/nikolaenko.anton.9/posts/761402053939232):
1934 " ",
1935 " ",
1937 - " ",
1946 - ", ",
1962 - " ",
1971 - - " ",
1972 - " ",
1975 - " ",
1976 - "" - "
",
1978 - " -
",
1978 - " ",
1979 - " ",
1979 - " ",
1998 - " ",
1998 - " ",
2008 - ".
.
86

. :
, ,
,
. , :
,
, :
,
, .
: .
,
, ,
. .

(,
). ,
.

,
:
,
( ):
- , ,
- / , .
, ,
.
, , :
,
-. :
- ,
. .
87
(applied research, )
, .
, ( )
, .
, ,
, (

, development ,
,
).
(research)
, R&D (research and
development). ? : (
Bell Labs, IBM ..) -

. ! R&D
technology and innovation management.
basic research,
. (inventions, ,
),
. R&D
,
.
, .
R&D, , .

, -
(
, - ).

, (engineering science).

(engineering) ,
, , ..
( ) , .
(engineering science) ,
.
, , : ,
, .

computer science ( )
software
engineering
(
).
http://gaperton.livejournal.com/ , ,
computer science,
. , ( )
, :
88
, ,
- ,
, - ,
(),
,
, ..
. ,
: ,
, ,
. computer science ( : ,
, , , )
software engineering ( : , ,
, , ). -
, , ,
, , ,
.
,
,
.
,
,
( ,
):
//,
,
.
.
( - )
(, , , ..)
, .
, , ( -
) .

, , .
Discussion of the Method Billy Koen
: ,
, 200
?
, ,
,
? ,
, , ,
, ,
.
,
, .
89
Billy Koen (http://www.me.utexas.edu/directory/faculty/koen/billy/41/)

(heuristics)
,
, .. :
,
. ,
,
). :
Turton, Richard, et al. (2003) Analysis, Synthesis, and Design of Chemical Processes , Upper
Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.:
, 3.83
,
3.8 383
,
383

: http://people.clarkson.edu/~wwilcox/Design/heurist.pdf
:
,
.

.
.

.
,
-:
, ;
(need) ,
( Tom Glib,
90
http://www.gilb.com/dl97).
(
).
:
,
(: ,
, , ),
,
.
(, ,
)
:
,
.

, .
(
) . ,
, .
Billy Koen
, ,

Billy Koen
SoTA (state-of-the-art). ,
,
. ,
,
.

, .
,
(tinkering, . H is tinkering with a car ).
.
, ,
. :
, ,
,
. , .
. , :
, , .
, -: ,
. , .
, , .
, .
- , -,
, .
, .
91
,
.
,
, .
, ( ,
) ,
- , ,
, .
,
, .
- ,
.
.
, .
- . ,
,
,
, ?
, , ,
.

-,
. - -
,
-
, ?
, ,
.
, - , (
) , - .
, .
,
, -
.
, , . ,
. , . ,
. , .
(engineering science),
, (, )
.
, .
, ,
. ,
, .
,
,
.
92

, (engineering
science) ,
.

( ). ,
, .
,
, . ,
,
. .
,
.
. ,
( , )
.
,
,
-
. , NASA Michael Griffin 2007 . System Engineering
and
the
Two
Cultures
of
Engineering
(http://www.spaceref.com/news/viewsr.html?pid=23775) , :
I have always loved the view of the engineering profession captured by the
great Theodore von Karman when he said, "Scientists study the world as it
is; engineers create the world that has never been." Less eloquently,
engineers are designers; they synthesize knowledge to produce new
artifacts. Von Karman speaks to what most of us, and certainly most laymen,
would consider the essence of engineering: engineers create things to solve
problems.
But all of us who are engineers know that the engineering profession also
has a rich scientific side, the analysis of these artifacts and the prediction of
their behavior under various environmental and operational conditions.
Adapting von Karman's observations, it may be said that engineering science
is the study of that part of the world which has been created by man.
Sadly, many students have been led to believe that engineering science is
engineering! In a curriculum of 120 or more credits leading to a bachelor's
degree in a branch of engineering, the typical student is required to take
one, or maybe two, courses in design. Everything else, aside from generaleducation requirements, focuses on the analysis, rather than the creation, of
engineered objects. Graduate education often has no design orientation at
all. So, engineering as taught really deals with only a part of engineering as it
is practiced.
,
, . ,
.
93
,
-. Henry Minzberg , MBA
(Master of Business Administration) , .
- ,

, .
( )
- .
NASA ,
( , )
:
,
,
, . ,
,
,
( ) .
,
.

, (
,
) ,
, .

:

.
. , ,
, .

. ,
: ,
,
, .

. ,
( ),
.
, ,
. ,
, , .
(, , ) .
()
, .
, .
, - (, )
94
, ..
? ,
(humanities, , ,
..)? master of science, master of art
in Systems Engineering?
,
, ,
: ,
, ,
(, ,
) - ,
.
,
, , ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
(-) ,
. (,
- ,
, ,
) ,

( ) .

( INCOSE
SEMAT).
(http://www.slideshare.net/ailev/course-essence-sysengomgsep13),
.
, ,
.
,
-
S- . ,
.
, ,
( -,
)
, .
95
( ),
.
,
?
(http://gothicsstyle.ru/2011/02/02/srednevekovaya-alximiya-recepty/):
, , , ,
, .
, .
( , )
, ,
, .
.
, . ,
.
, ,
. ,
. , ,
. , ,
. , , ,
(Dumas, 1837, . 30).
: . ,
( ). ,
.
,
.
( b(23OO)2 320
).
96
(),
() , , - .
, . .

: .
.
, .
: ,
. (, )
: - ,
, ,
, -
.

, ,
: , , ..
: - ,
.
, ,
, -.
:
, ,
, . ,
-
,
.
() ()
, (,
) .
:
,
.
, ,
, ,
.
,
, .
( ) ,
,
, - . ,
,
, :
, .
, .
97

,
, (, ),
: ,
,
. , ,
, :
.
. ,
(, , , )
,
,
. ,

(

, , , ,
..),
,
( , ,
).

,
.
-
,
. ,
,

, .
,
(.. ,
,
)
.

( , ,
, ),
(, ), .
:
( )
( )
?
, -,
. ,
98
- , ,
.
,
, (
). , ,
, .. , , ,
.
,
()
( ), +, (
..).
(
, , ),
. ,
, .
,
, .
(, )
, ,
. , ,
,
. - ( -
,
), - ,
(), -
, .

( ,
,
).
. , ,

( ) ,
, .
:
, . , ,
,
.
,
(first of a kind, FOAK) , -
, .
/ = /
,
, (),
, .
: (conception), , ,
. ,
99
.
.
,
, . ,
.
, - ,
. ,
. , ,
. ,
. ,
(
?
,
, ).
,
, ,
.
4. /

? ()
? ( ).
,
. ,
, ,
.
-- ,
: , /
, ,
. ,
,
- .
.
,
(, , ,
..) 1 X c 2
( ,
, ).
,
(concepts), -,
,
:
100
, . :
, ( ,
),
(systems engineering Essence, OMG Essence ,
, , kernel ,
, ),
, ,
.
,
,
. , (
, ),
, ,

, .
:
, (

. , ,
,
, , , - ).
:
101
,
.

,
. ,
,
..: ,
. ,
.
,
: ,
,
..

, , , ,
.. ()
, ,
. , . :
( ) ,
, ,
, ,
/.
, , ,
. , ,
.
, ,
-, .
/
, /
,
, ,
. ,
,
() .
- ,
, . ,
. , (
) OMG
Essence. ,
102
/ (
/library
,
,
).
, ,
. ,
, - ?
: , ,
,
? : ?
,
, ,
.
, , (
, , ),
, ,
(,
): ,
. ,
.
, /.

, !
: , ,
,
. ,
,
,
, ,
.
//,

, ,
.
/ /
, ?.
/ / .

,
, , , .
,
, , (,
)

.
, - 2*2=4
.
-
103
( ) ,
.

.
.
, ,
,
. ,
- ,
, .
, ,
, -.
, .
,
,
, , ..
,
, .
, . ,
, (,
, , (,
, , ), -
( , ,
).
:

.

.

, , ,
/ , ,
: ,
.
,
.
(development process, engineering
methodology)
(situational method engineering). 80-
- ,
(
) :
(
,
,
).
: http://ailev.livejournal.com/487783.html.
, - -
104
.
(
,
, - ).
, .
-:
, .
Donald Firesmith , 80- , . -

:
, .
.
, , ,
?
-
? , ,
- ,
? ,
,
, ,
.
.
,
, , .
( ,
, )
-.
(situational method engineering)
, ,

, - .
/components, /chunks,
/slices ..
( ), , ..
,
,
.
( ,
) .

, ,
.
OPF, ISO 24744 OMG SPEM 2.0.
http://www.jucs.org/jucs_16_3/situational_method_engineering_state/jucs_16_0
3_0424_0478_henderson.pdf
105
(), .
OMG Essence (http://www.omg.org/spec/Essence/ 1.0
2014).
( ,
, ,
) OMG Essence http://www.omg.org/spec/Essence/.
SEMAT (http://semat.org).
OMG (Object
Management Group, http://www.omg.org).
(http://techinvestlab.ru).
TechInvestLab

INCOSE (http://incose_ru.livejournal.com),
,
INCOSE Towards Systems Engineering Essence http://arxiv.org/abs/1502.00121
(
, )
.
, , , ..
,
(kernel, ):
,
. , , ,
106
, , ..
:
.
, .

.
- ,
(,
,
, -. ,
!).

, :
,
, , .

, , :

(, ) , .
, :
( , artifacts, ..
, work products).
, , .
.
, ()
,
. , ,
:
... ,
,
.
: 3+5. ,
: ,
, .
, ?
, , .
, :
. , ,
, , .
, : ,
: , ,
. , ? , ,
. , ,
, , . ?
? .
107
, .
:
... ...
:
, ...
, , ,
. .
?
.
.
, .
...
?
, !
,
.

:
,
. , !
, ( ,
)!
,
, .
, (,
),
( , !).
, .
(
, , ,
.. , , ,
, ).
,
, .
- , .
,
. / , ,
. . ,

, ,
:
108
. , : ,
, .
, ,
, , ,
.
( ,
, ) ,
(progress, " ?") (health, "
") . , " "
(,
, .

, ""
. ,
, .
/, . ,

. , " " " "
, " ",
" " .
( ,
) .
, ""
, " ":
, , user stories
, ..
"" "",

, . ,
" " ,
,
, " "
"", "", "", "", "" ..
, .
"" ,
,
, - .
"" , , ,
"" , ,
,
- ( ,
).
ALPHA Abstract-Level Progress Health Attribute,
" ", ""
" "
. , ,
, , , , .
109
, (, ) ,
, , , ,
(state),
(checkpoint) .

.
: ,
,
,
,
,
. (
):
, , .
,
.

:
,
.
( AlphaContaiment,
- ), :
() -
(). ,
,
.
("" , subordinate) ("") , , "
- ".
,
. ,
, (
, ""). ,
, .
,
.
,
(, "
", " " ..).
/ (represent) .
" ", " " . , ,
- , .
110
- (, , ),

.
,
, .
.
- (
).
, .
,
.
, -
. ,
- ?
-
( ,
)
: ,
, ,
,
..
, (
), .
, (
), , :
,
, , ,
.
, , ,
. ,
, .
, , "
" .
,
"" ("" ),
111
, ..
"" ("" ).
, . ,

, - , .
, ,
, .
,
,
. ,
,
, .
, , -
, .
).
:
http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9C%D0%B5%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B8
%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%8F
:
: (,
,
), (
?),
. ? ,
- ,
,
.
, .
, .
. ,
( ).
,
- (),
- (), -
(, installed_as).
: , ,
/
/
/ (area of concern), ,
:
, /:
,
( -)
112
, .
, !
/ , (client).
- !
!
: / /
. (solution,
decision!).
, :
,
.
( -,
,
, - .
OMG Essence Endeavor, .
- Endeavour).
(,
,
. -
(, , )
,
( ). ,
-,
.
,
( ,
..).
. ,
:
( )
(
)
(3D- )
( ,
)
(
)
(, , ,
...),
.
... ( ).
, , . ,
-
.
CTO (chief technical officer) CIO (chief information officer),
113
, .
:
( , separation of
concerns), , - ,
.
,
, ,
( ).
( ,
, ..):
= , (
).
= ( , , ,
, ), .
,
.
= + .
(practice) , -
( !) .
, -
, ( )
, .
- -
(, , ) ,
, ,
. , ,
, .

( , ),
.
(
, ).
(),
.
,
(performance) .
.
(
) (
) .

.
(composition) ,
.
114
, .
-
, .
-
. , ,
, ,
,
..
,
.
, .
,
.
, (articulate, make up, contained in) ,
:
(coherency):
.
(consistency):
.
(completeness):
.
(entry)
(result)
(authoring) ,

.
,
.
, . ,
-.
, . ,
,
user story, ,
Use Case. - ,
400 ,
, -
( , ),
. ,

- .
method, methodology .
- (
,
).
115

, ,
"", , ().
" /" (
),
" ". ,
. , ,
, .
, .
" "
( , individual
, , .. ).
-
: (
) (
123456).

:
(kernel OMG Essence) .
,
. ,
.
,
-
, -
.
,
.

. ,
,

.
- .
,
. ,
,
(). , ,
, ,
(stakeholders/
).
,
.
116
) ,
.
,
: .
,
.
.
(opportunity) :
( ), .
, ,
,
(, , ,
..).
(
,
) () ,
.
,
. CRM
(customer relationship management).
,
, :
(,
),
.
(communications)
(,

http://rutracker.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1227489,
http://praxos.ru/index.php/%D0%98%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%B0%D0%BB%D1
%8C%D0%BD%D1%8B%D0%B9%D0%90%D0%BA%D1%86%D0%B8%D0%
BE%D0%BD%D0%B5%D1%80).
(opportunity)
, (
) .
( ,
).

( , user needs , ,
),

.
117

,
.
:
-, , ,
..
,
, ,
(, ).

:
,
user needs;
() .
, //
(user needs), //
. , (, )
,
..
// .
( , ,
,
, ):

, , (define),
, ( , , ,
, .
- - ,
, ).
(system definition) .
(system definition) ()
:
( .
)
( /decisions ,
.

118
).
( /decisions, ..

)
: -
( ) , ,
. .
,
(descriptions). , ,
, . ,
( ) (
) ..
,
: .
: , , ,
.

, (
).
.
, (design),
, , ,
, .

(system realization, : )
,
- ,
( !). , . ,
-:
(product)
(plant)
(, )

, (),
, (
).
,
.
,
. :
, , , ,
, .
:
.
119
, -
(
-, , )
-
, -
. ,
, ,
.
.
: (
) ,
, .
- ,
(,
).
DevOps (developersoperators).
, .
.

( , , ).
.
(team) -
(
). ,
, ,
.
, ,
( ).
,
. ,
( -
,

), . , ,
(leadership).
, (,
):

( ).
,
, .
, ,
120
(works)
.
,
(operations management),
. , :
,
.
(schedule), ..
.

, (..
,
).

/,
(, , )
,
/.
, ,
, (flow, - ,
) , , , ,
, ,
//
. , .
, , :
( Lingvo: operations management

[].
, ,
;
production management
operations management, .. ""
, , ,
. ., production
).
Operations Management is the process by which an organization converts inputs
(e.g. labor, material, knowledge, equipment) into outputs (goods and services).

" " " "
" ".
,

.
(supply chain management)
(project management),
(process management), (case management)
(planning
and
production
121
management)
(logistics)
(operation strategy)
(management of service operations)
(performance improvement)
(enterprise
(resource management)
get things done (GTD) ,

resource
planning)
, (
issue tracker):
. :

(way of working). = + ( =
- ).
(

, ), (
2014

,
, PLM/product lifecycle
management).
, :
. 500 ,
122

, .
,
, (
, ) .
(
)
.
, ,
. , ?
, ,
,
! ,
: . (,
, , ) : ,
, .
,
.
: ?
(, 3D Autodesk Inventor 2D-
Autodesk AutoCAD /generative design
).

:
?
,
, ?
? ?
,
?
?
123
5.

( ) - .
(,

,
, ).
, -
- , (..
,
), , .
:
-
.
(approach) (method).
, :

.
,
,
,
. ,
,
.
,
, , (

).
: ?

- (
) ,
() .
,
. :
20

,
,
.
,
- ( ),
,
124
,
-
. , -
- ,
,
,
, .

,
.
: ,
?
, , (
-),
, ,
( ,
). ,
. , 50-
(
), 60-
, 70- , 80-
, .
, , -
,
, .
, - ?
,
(separation of concerns) .
:
, .
,
.
,
,
, .
21
, 20 .
, ()
( ) ,
( )
,
,
.
? ,
, ,
. ,
.
125
,
. ,
, ,
. , , ,
!
, ,
, ,
, ,
,
. (emergence,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence) , -,
. ,
. (emerge/)
,
: , ,
. , ,
.
( )
- (

),
( -

-, -, -,
..).
(

) .
, ,
. :
, (
, ?),
, , ,
, (
, ).
(system thinking)
. ,
.
.
,
,
(., ,
http://www.situation.ru/app/j_art_1052.htm http://rudocs.exdat.com/docs/index421147.html?page=8 , systems engineering 80-
- ,
).
,
.
126

, -
:
. , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systems_biology Systems
biology is a biology-based inter-disciplinary field of study that focuses on complex
interactions within biological systems, using a holistic approach (holism instead of
the more traditional reductionism) to biological and biomedical research.
Particularly from year 2000 onwards, the concept has been used widely in the
biosciences in a variety of contexts. One of the outreaching aims of systems
biology is to model and discover emergent properties, properties of cells, tissues
and organisms functioning as a system whose theoretical description is only
possible using techniques which fall under the remit of systems biology. These
typically involve metabolic networks or cell signaling networks. Systems biology
makes heavy use of mathematical and computational models.

, , ..
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecology ,
,
).
( ,
. ..
50
http://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sistemnomu-myshleniyu-vmenedzhmente-pyatdesyat-let). ,

,
(cyber-physic-human)
(sociotechnical) ,
. ,
, governance
. , (
- ). , corporate
governance , ,
.
theory of governance
.
( ,
.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operations_research).
- .

( ) ,
.
( ,
),
.

( ) .
.
. ,
127
, ,
(
? ?. ,
).

. (, ,
, ..) (movement)

, ,
- .
, ,
,
(
,
).

(cybernetics) 1948
/
("the scientific study of control and communication in the animal
and the machine." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics).
.
, ,
, ,
,
, (
). , 50-70- 20
.
(environment, )
,
, (feedback)
. ,
, .
,
:
128
:
,
.
-
, :
(systems engineering),
, ,
,
, , ,

.
, (
):
(,

,
,
..:
http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A2%D0%B5%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D
1%8F_%D0%B0%D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B0%D1%82%D0
%B8%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE_%D1
%83%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B2%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%
B8%D1%8F. ,
,
. ,

.
,
:
http://www.inp.nsk.su/students/radio/courses/teor_auto/index.shtml.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_theory,
feedback systems, feedback control, control loops).
(system dynamics) -
. -
,
. : ,
.
,

(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/System_dynamics).

129
(, -
Modelica http://modelica.org).
, ,
, (
control, governance) ,
.
(cyber)
, . ,
, (
) ,
.
. ,
,
-,
, ( ):
, .

,
. , Seth Lloyd
(http://web.mit.edu/esd.83/www/notebook/Complexity.PDF).
:
1. ? ,
. , ,
,
, (Fisher), (Rnyi),
(, , -,
, ), , , ,
Lempel-Ziv.
2. ?
, , .. ,
,
, , (depth),
, , (crypticity).
3. ? :
) (effective complexity),
, , , .
-: Metric Entropy; Fractal Dimension; Excess Entropy;
Stochastic Complexity; Sophistication; Effective Measure Complexity; True Measure
Complexity; Topological epsilon-machine size; Conditional Information; Conditional
Algorithmic Information Content; Schema length; Ideal Complexity; Hierarchical
Complexity; Tree subgraph diversity; Homogeneous Complexity; Grammatical
Complexity.
) ,
- : Algorithmic Mutual Information; Channel
Capacity; Correlation; Stored Information; Organization.
130
, , :
LongRange Order; SelfOrganization; Complex Adaptive Systems; Edge of Chaos.
(,
,
http://people.idsia.ch/~juergen/speedprior.html).
:

. ,
, ,
,
.

, ,
( ,
).
, ,
, ,
.
() ,
:
131
1. (
,
). ,
.
. .
-,
(holon) .
-,
- . ,
(emergent) , .
: ,
. , .
, .
,
, - (extension,
, , : ,
,

-). : (, , )
(kick) .
, -:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holon_%28philosophy%29.

.
2. ()
. , (),
.
(-:
). ,
132
.
,
, ,
, , -
. ()
, .
, .
, ( ).
,
.

.
3. - , , ,
- ( ) .
- , , .
,
, : ,
.
- - ,
- ,
. , ,
, -
.
,
( ) ,
, .
ISO 15288
,
,
(
, !
). ISO 15288
,
:
133
(system-of-interest) , (
)
. , .
/ (system in operational environment)

, . ,
, .
(enabling systems) ,
. , ,
.
, ,
, . ,
, , -
. , ,
- .
, , ,
(operation, )
(enabling)
.
, :
, : ,
( ),
( ,
,
)
,
134
,
(http://forum.rmnt.ru/threads/koloda-dlja-kolki-drov-nou-xau.102202/).

:
, ,

:
,
, ,

, ,
.

:
, .
, " ". ,

. , .
1. , . ,
- . "",
, , .
2. , , " ".
, (,
, ) " ".
3. , -
- ,
,
( , ?
, , ).
" "
, .
4. :
.
,
:
) ,
. ,
135
. ,
.
)
, (
,
, ,
,
, ).
: , , ,
(),
().
, .. (, ,
, ).
. ,
. .
. , , .
: , 4D-,
, (
), .
,
.
:
- .
"" ,

, , ,
, .
5. ,
(
), .
.
6. (
"", "" ) 4 .
,
( ?). ,
, . .
.
7. ,
(, ). , ,
. :
[ ] [ ]
[ ]. .
. ,
,
.
8. ?
136
? ,
(
)? (- ,
"", "" !),
? ,
. ,

. .
9. , " "
. ?
, ?
? : [ ] [ ]
[ ]. .
10. , ? ,
( :
, ,
)? ,
.
, . , .
, (,
: http://belique.livejournal.com/67802.html
,
:
[: ]
, ( )
( )
- ( )
, ,

,
, ,
( ). , ,
.
- . , ,
(, -,
-) ,
, -.
137
( , -,
)
,
, , .

.
,
,
.. ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,

40
, .
,
, ,
.
.

(system realization ,
). , ,
,
. (
), -
, , ,
.
- ,
( ) -
(, ,
, !), - (,
). :
,
138
.
, ,
, .
( , system definition
) ,
. ? :

,
.
, ( !) ,
, .
,

, .
,
, ,

, ,
.
, , ,
. , ,
, . ,
.
. ! , :
. ,
. .
.
- .
.
. .
, -
, , /.
,
.
,
, -
( , methodology realm),
( , endeavour realm).
,
. ,
, ,
. (
http://progstone.narod.ru/reciprocality/r0/index.html
:
, , ..
,
139
).
:
:
.
-
,
, .
, , (
, ), ..
, .
, ,
. ,
!
?. , ?
, -
.
,
, ,
.
, ,
- , , ,
, . ,
, .
- (
),
(
140
).
: -,
.
: , (,
, , ):
1.
2. , ..
3. Z, .
4.
5.
6. .
7. .
: (
,
, .
, ).
: (,
10 ,
10 ,

, ).
, ,
. :
1. , :
! .dwg
! !
?
, !
, ?
- ?
, -
?
2. ( , )
! .dwg
! !
-?
, !
, ? ?

,
:

(
-)
,
,
141
. -
:
, .

, , () ..
, ,
(leadership
). ,
,
. ,
- ( !
!), ,
, , ,
.
, ,

? , , .
- "" ,
, (..
),
. "",
-, ,
. "",
, , .
( :
, , - ""
). -
: "- , , ",
" ?
? !".
: " - " ( ,
, ).
"".
, ,
: ,

,
- . " ,
", " ".
,
, - ,
,
- . ,
" ",
: , ,
142
,
.
, (, ,
) - ,
. , ,

[ : ,

. ,
: ].

( ): , , ( ).

, .
:
, ,
( , , ).
(

, , ,
!).

(,

)
http://qame.ru/book/sale/strategiya_raboti_s_klientami_v_bolshih_prodazhah/%d0%a1
%d1%82%d1%80%d0%b0%d1%82%d0%b5%d0%b3%d0%b8%d1%8f%20%d1%8
0%d0%b0%d0%b1%d0%be%d1%82%d1%8b%20%d1%81%20%d0%ba%d0%bb%
d0%b8%d0%b5%d0%bd%d1%82%d0%b0%d0%bc%d0%b8%20%d0%b2%20%d0
%b1%d0%be%d0%bb%d1%8c%d1%88%d0%b8%d1%85%20%d0%bf%d1%80%d
0%be%d0%b4%d0%b0%d0%b6%d0%b0%d1%85.djvu (
-
DjVu,
,
WinDjView
http://www.koob.ru/about/windjview-setup.exe). ,

-.

.
, ,
, , , ,
-.
, ?
,
, , - ,
143
.
,
: ,
. , -
,

(ToC) ( -- http://www.tocpractice.com/ru/wiki/kaksdelat-prodavtsa-prodayushchim-ili-pervyi-opyt-pri-razrabotke-i-vnedrenii-programmypo-upra). ,
, .
,
( ).

, -
, -
. (
,
, ) ,
. X
- , X
.
,
.
,
,
-
(
, ).
(,
, ),
,
, .
,
.
,
. ,
, , ,
,
.
, , -.
:
,
. ,
. ,
: (-
144
) ,
-, -
( ).

(
,
).
, , - (, , ,
).
?
, , ?
: ,
,

? ,
? ? ?
? ?
, ,
?
-
. ,
. ,
, : -
Voyager 1 .
,
- (,
) http://www.astronet.ru/db/msg/1171222,
http://habrahabr.ru/post/193562/
, .
( ,
).
,
.
.
(system) (system of systems, SoS).

(system realization) - (
-, /breakdowns).
: (

). , , ISO 15288
, ,

- - ( ISO 15288
,
,
- ):
145
, ISO 15288
- -
- .
(system of systems, SoS),
. , (
Maier):
- (,
-)
(,
)
(-
,
,
).
( ,
,
, as built )
, , ,
:
,
, , .
: ,
,
, , ,
,
. , .
,
, .
146

,
, ,
.
- , .
NATO , (system of systems engineering),
:
,
, . , , ,

-
, .
NATO ,
:
(directed), ,

.
(acknowledged), ,

.
(collaborative),
, ,
.
(virtual),
.
:
()

:
,
,

,
(
147
, -

).
- :
. ,

. -

: , , , , .
-
,
,
,
.
zoom select.
,
:
,
, .
, :

, .
select ( ),
, .
Harold Bud Lawson :

(,

,

148
). ,
.

, ,
.. :

, , , ,
,
, - .
,
,
:
,
. ,
,
.
.
.
,

. ,
. ,

, , ,
.
( )
.
: !

.
:
, (control
engineering) (software enginering)
, (.
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1098827.html). ISO 15288 ,
, ,
, - -
.
,
.
, -- (cyberphysic-human).
, ,
. ,
, ,
.
,
.
149
, ,
. , ,
,
, , ,
, ,
( ,
,
).
(),
- .

, .
6. : , ,
, .
( ,
- ) - ,
.
(
!)
( : ),
( : ),
.
, (
, ).
, (
!
!)
( ),
,
. ( ,
) , .

, . ,
(
) ( -
).
:
, (,
). , ,
.
150
, . ,
()
( ). , :
("He has taken on his Aspect and raised up

an Attribute //Lord ,
). -
// -
, .
.
, -
-, ,
,
, -- (
).
, ,
, , ,
,
. : ,
KLM-23
4
,
,
.
- ,
, /.
151
, ,
-.
, .
- (
) .
, !
(-). -
, .
152
,
: , (,
!).
?
:
, -
, - , -
. , -
, -
:
ISO 15926 : , .
.
IEC 81346 (, , )
Garlan
et.
al
(http://libgen.org/get?nametype=orig&md5=abb4676b7b1ddfa74e33b7799ebbb
61a) (, , ,
)
- (, ,
,
,
)
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:CLJYHzTDPj0J:www.m
mk-documentum.ru/glossary/6
, 3-7 (,
-) .
, /
, . , /
, /
().

, , , -:
(separation of concerns)
Edsger W.Dijkstra 1974 : Let me try to explain to you, what to my taste is
characteristic for all intelligent thinking. It is, that one is willing to study in depth an
aspect of one's subject matter in isolation for the sake of its own consistency, all the time
knowing that one is occupying oneself only with one of the aspects. We know that a
program must be correct and we can study it from that viewpoint only; we also know
that it should be efficient and we can study its efficiency on another day, so to speak. In
another mood we may ask ourselves whether, and if so: why, the program is desirable.
But nothing is gained on the contrary! by tackling these various aspects
simultaneously. It is what I sometimes have called "the separation of concerns", which,
even if not perfectly possible, is yet the only available technique for effective ordering of
one's thoughts, that I know of. This is what I mean by "focusing one's attention upon
some aspect": it does not mean ignoring the other aspects, it is just doing justice to the
fact that from this aspect's point of view, the other is irrelevant. It is being one- and
153
multiple-track minded simultaneously.

: aspect (), point of veiw
.
view (
models/ ISO 42010).
, ( )
,
, .
, ,
?
, , ,
(correspondence ISO 42010), ,
(weaving -
).
: ? . ?
// ,
:
(close world). , ,
: , (
). , ,
.
(open world): - , - ,
. ,
, , .
, , .
-
. , ,

154
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_world_assumption ,
/agent
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agency_%28philosophy%29. ,
, ,
, .

, , .
,
, !
(, ,
..):
- ()
. ,
,
. ,
.
, ,
( ), ( ,
! !).
, (
).
.
, -
, :
, - /. ,
,
- , , ,
, .. ,
/.
, ,

( ), ( ),
( )
,
.
, ,
, , .. :
, , 4D

, .. - (extent)
.
, .
155
, , ,
.
/
, .
, :
, . .
, -
( - , ) /
. , ,
! (..
, , ).
: ,
(, )

( --).
, .

(run-time, operation).
(components and
connectors),
(ports)
. ,
(
), :
156
-
(), :

(, ),
.
, "" -
(, ) ,
157
, ,
, . ,
-
, ( , ).
P&ID "" --
3D-.
"" () .

(Modelica). "-",
"-middleware-"
, " ".

: ,
..
, ,
.
- - ,

.
, .
IEC 81346 (
), = (
=R1).
, ,
,
-, -,
, !
, , ,
. . ,
:
(
/ ,
, ).
: -, .
( ), (
). : -,
.

: ,
. ,
, .
,
(
).
, .
158

, , .
(, ,
),
. ,
, ( )
,
.
,
,
.
(, ,
) ,
.
, ,
.
FR160B PCB 2-Layer USB Portable Power Module Green (3.5 x 2.6 x
1.5cm):
,
( , , !): USB Universal
Serial Bus) .
(PCB 2-Layer, ).
, ,
, ,
/ , /,
.
IEC 81346 : -R1 (
).
,
. , .
, ( ,
P-101 ), ( -1234
, 56789),
159 689, .
.

12 (
- ,
159
, . , /

(,
- ,
, , ,
, 1002 ..). (1-5
), , , .
!
/ (location, ).
, ( , ,
). ., ,
http://gardenweb.ru/ponyatie-o-delyankakh-izakhvatkakh, http://korica.info/2012/10/razbivka-zdaniyana-montazhnye-zaxvatki.html
,
(
).
IEC 81346 +.
: .
(breakdowns)
- (
-, ).
( ) - (part_of
relations), (composition) (decomposition),
(breakdowns).
:
(functional breakdown structure),

functional decomposition
(work breakdown structure)
(plant breakdown structure)
(document breakdown structure)
,
-,
- ( ). ,
.
: , ( ,
). ,
. ,
,
.
, (, , , ..)
:
160
IEC 81346 (
, ,
) ,
/
,
,
(, ).
(
) ( ).
,
: () , ()
().

.. -
,
.
(.. ,
), (IEC
1392/09):
161
A B , ,
,
(
: ). ,
- 4
- 4, 2.2
,
. ,
- - 4 (,
- 2.2
, 4.4
-).
""
1:1, .
, . , "" ()
. "" ,
(.. , ). ,

,
.
162
/ - V , V (
V)
. V.

(
). :
(
):

. , ISO 26702
, :
163
(
) ,
:
,
(, , , , ).
,
, , . .
(, ).
,
(, ).
,
(
, ).
, ,
.
, ..
.

(, -) .
, ,
, . .
, (
!) ( ),

KKS. , -
, KKS ( ,
,
).
164
(.. ,
, ,
- , ). ,
- , .
- ,
, ( -
, ) .
, ..
.
,
,
.
IEC 81346
,
-
, ..
IEC 81346-1:2009 Industrial
systems, installations and equipment and industrial products Structuring principles and
reference designations. Part 1: Basic rules
.

(reference designations
,
). :

(, 5
, ,
. - ,
! ,
, , ,
. ,
, ,
, , ,
, , ,
. ,
,

).
( ), ,
,
(- ) .

165
, ( , ).
, - (
) , .. ,

( ) .
-
, . ,
(plant)
, ():

--, :
,
.
, .
166
(, ,
),
( -
). , ,
, , .
, ...=== ...
()
-
? ,
[ ] . :
, ,
?! 2015 2014
.
(, ,
3D ), ,
.
[ : ,
, ,
, .
,
].
: The INCOSE Systems Engineering Handbook version 3.2.2 published
in October 2011 has five percent of its content covering integration, verification, transition
and
validation.
(
http://www.incose.org/newsevents/events/details.aspx?id=203).
, .
V-
, .
:
DevOps ,
(http://theagileadmin.com/what-is-devops/,
http://venturebeat.com/2013/09/30/an-idiots-guide-to-devops/).
167
advancing manufacturing, cyber-physical production systems, etc.

Carl Bass (CEO of 3D design, Autodesk)
(): http://ailev.livejournal.com/1137544.html
( ,
!)
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1103473.html ( )
3D
http://3dplast.net/news/pervaya-kniga-o-3d
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1134471.html.
(
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1131958.html,
, ).
3D
):
? ,
? ,
? ? ( --:
).
7. : , ,

, - (define).
,
, (description)
. , (,
,
), :
, ( ,
, ?!) ,
.
(
, ):
( )
( ,
)
( ,
) .

, ,
, .
/design
( design, design ).
168
.
, ,
,
.
/ (as built)
(as designed).
, (, , ) . ,
plant model (, )
-design -project (
, ). Design
(
), project- ( :
, ..
).
ISO 42010
ISO 42010 Systems and software engineering Architecture description
.
:
, .
,
169
, .
, (
, ) . (..
, , ..) ( ,
- )
(vewpoint) (veiw),
.
( ). ,

, ,
, - .
, ,
, .
, ,
,
? ,
,
(, ,
.
).
. ,
(, ) ,
. (
, ) M,
- S.
, S,
, .
, - , .
- (
- ), (
), ( ,
, ), -
.
(library) -
, .
Framework ( library framework)
, TOGAF (The Open Group Architecture Framework)
The Open Group, i*
requirements framework i*.
(
: - ,
- ,
,
).
: .
, , . (
), :
.
, .
170
, ,
( ) .
(,
).
( ,
),
.
.
(use case diagrams) , , use
case diagrams (
), ,
.
, -
().
& (, =& -&
).

, -
. ,
. -
,
(, 12 ,
11). -
: -
,
.
,
. , ,
,
:
2 ,
2 ,
.
, (configuration control),
(configuration management).

.
,
. ,
/ / BOM
(bill of materials, ).

( ), PDM
(product data management -design), PLM
(product life cycle management: PDM+

, ), EAM (enterprise asset
management,
).
171
,
, .
.
:
.
(
,
.
).

( ),
IEC 81346.
V-,

( V),
172

( : , --
).
, ,
,
( , ). ,
( )
, .
,
. ,
,
,
.
, ( ,

).
/ :
,
,
()
, (
,

)
.

: , (,
, )
,

,
.

(verification) (validation)
. .
, -
(, , ).
,
, .
, :
173
: .
,
, :
(),
(!). ( ,
) ,
.

, ! ,
, ,
(
) .
. , , 3
US
SanDiego
http://extension.ucsd.edu/studyarea/index.cfm?vAction=singleCourse&vCourse=BUSA40414,
http://www.tonex.com/training-courses/system-verification-validation/.
Product integrated verification and validation 200
:
http://www.academia.edu/1745073/Systems_Engineering_MS_Course_Integrated_Prod
uct_Verification_and_Validation
: ( ,
, )
( , ).
.
,
.
(, , ,
)
. ( ),

.
( , , ),
.
174
, , .

, .
,
( ).
software
engineering ( ), 10
. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Software_testing (
topics, , ).
.
, :
, - ,
.
, -
V&V.
V&V
(////)
!
(, ,
), .
, , ,
, , . -
, /,
.
:
( ):
o ():
http://sebokwiki.org/wiki/System_Realization
o : http://sebokwiki.org/wiki/System_Verification
o : http://sebokwiki.org/wiki/System_Validation
o
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test_engineer
(hardware test engineer):
o
:
http://www.nafems.org/events/nafems/2014/vandv3/,
http://www.tonex.com/training-courses/system-verificationvalidation/, ()
http://www.academia.edu/1745073/Systems_Engineering_MS_Course_Int
egrated_Product_Verification_and_Validation).
o : ( -
):
http://courses.csail.mit.edu/6.141/spring2013/pub/lectures/Lec07SystemEngineering.pdf
TDD, test driven development ( , agile

):
o driven based http://ailev.livejournal.com/1015692.html
o
driven_development
175
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test-
o , TDD (
TDD , :
http://david.heinemeierhansson.com/2014/tdd-is-dead-long-livetesting.html
o TDD agile ( , developer TDD, developer
regression testing, reviews/inspections, end of lifecycle testing, acceptance
TDD, parallel independent testing, independent regression testing):
http://www.ambysoft.com/essays/agileTesting.html
Model-based testing ( test automation):

, ,
.. .
o model-based testing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Model-based_testing
o model-based testing: https://www.st.cs.unisaarland.de/edu/testingdebugging10/slides/19_ModelBasedTesting.pdf
o time partition testing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TPT_%28software%29
o ( ):
http://penxy.com/wylo, http://penxy.com/rygi.
http://penxy.com/joso,
Test of Cyber-physical systems (control system engineering):

o Model in loop(MIL), Software in loop(SIL), Processor in
loop(PIL),
Hardware
in
loop(HIL):
https://www.linkedin.com/groups/Difference-between-MIL-SIL-PIL109866.S.167229094
o hardware-in-the-loop:
http://home.hit.no/~hansha/documents/lab/Lab%20Work/HIL%20Simulat
ion/Background/Introduction%20to%20HIL%20Simulation.pdf
o ( --in-the-loop),
http://www.autonomie.net/projects/engine_loop_18.html (

http://www.autonomie.net/references/model_based_design_defs_24.html
).
( assurance case,
) http://ailev.livejournal.com/811715.html (
- ).
,
V- (. Donald Firesmith Four Types
of Shift Left Testing, http://blog.sei.cmu.edu/post.cfm/four-types-shift-left-testing082).
: / ( )
? ?

,
- .
176
, , ,
.
( , , ).
,
(). ,
. ,
, -
, , ,

, .
,
, ,
.
(),
. . , ,
( !) ,
.
.
:

(stakeholder requirements)
(system requirements).
(.. ) (capability)
(condition), (,
, ,
..).
( , ,
),
( ).
( ,
), :
,
( ,
, ,
..) ,
,
.
(
).

,
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modal_logic):
,
. , " 16".
177
(alethic)
,
. 4D
extensionalism (possible worlds):
,

. , "
16" (" 16").
(deontic) ,
. , " 16". ,
, , ,
, ,
..
(temporal) , . ,
" 16 ".
(doxastic) , . " ,
16".
( , ,
).
,
.
, , :
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logic-modal/

:
"" (claim) .. " ,
16",
(, ,
).
(assurance case,
dependability case, safety case, security case, requirement case,
architectural quality case).

. , :
(
,
, - -
)
( ,

)
-
178
, ..
)
, -
,
( , ,
, - / ..).
,
, ,
.. ( , ,
, -
).
-.
- (
- DOORS,
IRqA ..) .
- ,
.

( ),
. ,
.
( - )
,
.
.
, (needs),
- , .
, : ,
.
, ,
,
.

, ( ,
, , ,
).
, ,

(, ,
).
,
( ).
, ,
. .
,
,
.
179
, ,
- , ,
(, , ..) .
,
, .

, .
, ,
( , system requirements).
(

).
:
, , ..
.
, -
- - .

. () (using system) ,
. (
) , (, needs),
,
, ,

, ,
.
.

(, ), ,
,
. , , :
( , ,
).
, .
(
) : http://ailev.livejournal.com/900086.html
, ,
.
,
-:
,
-.
( ),
(
180
).

() - (user stories,
use cases: ). ,
,
(, ,
, , .., -, ilities reliability, repairability, availability, safety, etc.).
Donald Firesmith,
( )
,
- , .
,
: , ,
? , !
-
. , , :
?
?
( )

http://vniiaes.ru/HTML/RU/Docs/RuSEC%202010.rar (
).

: ,
181
. : .
, .
(
), .
. ,
. , (
) .
, ,
.
, ,
, ,
(needs) ,
,
/validation ( /verification
, , , ,
).
?
- : ,
,
, .

(goal-oriented requirements engineering,
GORE)
( , , ,
, ..).
, ,
( ) .
-----_.. ,

. (enterprise engineering)
[ / ]
(motivation , ,
reason, justification).
GRL
(http://jucmnav.softwareengineering.ca/ucm/bin/view/ProjetSEG/WebHome),
i* ( GORE istar.rwth-aachen.de), Motivational
Extension ArchiMate 2.0 (http://pubs.opengroup.org/architecture/archimate2doc/chap10.html#_Toc371945252), Model-based requirement discovery
(http://www.scenarioplus.org.uk/papers/mbrd/Modelbased_Requirements_Discovery.PDF).
( )
(
)
( 26 ).

( ) .
182
,
using
system. Test driven development ,
(!). ,
TDD ,
.
(use cases),
,
() . user
story, , (
!).
user story
(Mike Cohn, 2008, Advantages of the As a user, I want
user
story
template,
blog
post,
http://www.mountaingoatsoftware.com/blog/advantages-of-the-as-a-user-i-want-userstory-template): ____ , ___
___, ___--using-system___.
, ,
.
( )
:
ISO 42010: ()
, ,
(Architecture (of a system)
fundamental concepts or properties of a system in its environment embodied in its
elements, relationships, and in the principles of its design and evolution).
Garlan et al.: ,
, ,
(The architecture of a
system is the set of structures needed to reason about the system, which comprise
software elements, relations among them, and properties of both).
150 ,
:
http://www.sei.cmu.edu/architecture/start/glossary/community.cfm
-
Ralf Johnson :
. .
? ,
,

, .
,
( -
: , , ).
,
183
Paul Clements, et al. Documenting Software Architectures

ISO 42010.
,
: , ,
? ,
, ,
. ,
,
,
?
, ,
(, , ..) ,
.
: , (
/ , ,
..), /
.
,
?
.
,
(
), , .
: ,
,
, (
- ,
!).
(: , , ..).
184
,
, , .

/ ( ),
.

( ).
, (
). , ,
!

. ,
: architecturing ( - ),
(conceptual design).
(architecturing design),
(design),
.

( , ..
. -
.. , /discovery ,
- , ).
, ,
.
, ,
(
, ).
, .
,
,
,
. ,
, .
,
(, ISO 15288
,
).
185
,

. -
,
.

,

.

(. .
: http://www.mslevin.iitp.ru/Levin-bk-Nov2013071.pdf). : ,
.
(http://ru.wikibooks.org/wiki/%D0%9E%D1%81%D0%BD%D0%BE%D0%B2%D1%8B
_%D0%A2%D0%A0%D0%98%D0%97,
: -85 http://www.triz-ri.ru/triz/triz02.asp,
http://www.triz-ri.ru/triz/triz04.asp
)
.
DSM (http://www.dsmweb.org/)
.
DSM .
, -
/ (
).
,
.

Modelica (https://modelica.org/
,
!
Modelica
186
https://openmodelica.org/):

, (
, .. ).
ArchiMate 2.0:
http://pubs.opengroup.org/architecture/archimate2-doc/,
http://www.archimatetool.com/,
:
http://masteringarchimate.com/mastering-archimate-edition-ii/.
: http://ailev.livejournal.com/988360.html
product lines (, software product line
practice,
http://www.sei.cmu.edu/productlines/frame_report/what.is.a.PL.htm),
(-
..
http://ailev.livejournal.com/1122876.html), .

(, ,
/):
( ,
).
.
( ,
).
.
, ,
( ,
)
. .
, ,
.
,
( )
( :

). ,
,
. ,
( ,
..). ,
187
. ,
.
.
. ,

,
, ,
, .
- ,

, . ,
( ) ,
(
, ,
).
, trade-off studies ( : )
, ,
- .
,
trade-off studies
,
. ,
.
()
,
,
,
, .
: ,
188
,
.
,

(
, ). ,
.
(,
) ,
, ,
.
, ,
- : ,
, ,
.
-
.

( ).
ISO 42010,
:
: view viewpoint ,
( ,
189
, - view, ,
viewpoint). View , . Viewpoint ,
, . ( ),
: , ,
, , ..

Correspondence rule ,
(,
.
).
, ,
(,
..):
(, )
,
(-1
).
()
(

, ,
..),

, ,
-.

( )
. ,
,
. : , ,
-, :

,
( ),
.
, ,
.
( PowerPoint)
- (, ,
) .

(,
architecture rationale).
(
190
, , )
, :
(
)
( , ),
( , ),
( , ).

(,
) ,
.
, .. .
, ,
, / .
,
.

, ..
, (.. ,
..).

,
( :
, ,
- ).
: ,
.

- :
.

: , -
,
. (
)
/
.
,
, () ,
, ..
191
8.

?
(life cycle) .
, , ,
. , ,
, .
,
.
(, , ),
, , ,
, .
(system life cycle)
, (
) ( ),
(stages,
, phases), ,
. ()
- , -
, - .
,
, ,
. ,
(
),
.

( ISO 24744 change of mental
framework). ,
,
.
(, , .. ,
, )
192
: ,
, .
(project life cycle) ,
.
- , . ,
, (
) - .
( -
).

(life cycle management) ,
.
-:
,
, (product life cycle
management), .
(.. ,

, ).
,
( ,
, ..)
( , ,
,
, ..).

. ,
:
,
. OMG
Essence, ISO 24744.

,
, .
,
.
,
( ):

, . ,

.

(.. )
,
, .
change of mental frameworks (
193
) ,
. ,
(

, ).

(.. ,
)
, , , ,
. ,
.
, ISO 15288:
: ,
.

(decision gate, - ,
- ).
( )
(
,
). ,
:
, ( )
.
, (" ", "
", " " " " - )
, -

(, , ) ,
,
.
194
(
, baselines,
.. ,

),
, (
)
Go No Go Cancel (

). ,
. ,
, .
, ,
.
Desicion gate ,
, .
Go
(
,
commitment review).
ICM, incremental commitment
model
(
).
.
http://ailev.livejournal.com/691464.html.
, ,
Go-NoGo-Cancel.
, -
, ( ISO
24744). :
(

, ,
?).
:
195
,
,
,
.

(, ) ,
() ,
.. . (definition)
(description) ,
(

, ,

).
, FIATECH
roadmap ( )
(capital projects ,
..), 2004:
,
( ),
.
( , ) ( ,
..),
. (hand over) ,
196
(,
:
, ).
,
, -

.

(PLM, product life cycle
management) ,
. PLM product
life
cycle
management
(
///
/),
PLM
, :

( PDM, product data
management).
(,
,
..)
.
.
( ,
/design), issue tracker

( ).
PLM , PDM.
,
:

( ), ,
.
PLM.
, ,
197
( !).
, , ,
ERP-. - ,
. (
, ,
..) EAM (Enterprise asset
management), .
/
() ,
, , ,
.
() ()
,
hand over
( , , ..
).
,
7 . ,
, ( , ).
, PLM, ERP, EAM
,
(, -,
).
/ ,
/ ,
.
( ,
).
,
: ( ,
. ,
.
).
, ,

.
(),
(Control Valve), ,
.
ISO 15926:
198
,
,
(plant)
Temporal Whole Part. (
, , , ..in service
#5628 ()
- P101 XYZ
Siemens Control Valve 023). ,
,
, ISO 15926 4D
,
,
, .
.

( + + )
,
:
, , ..
,

, .
,
.
199
V-
( )
V-. V-model,

(
).
V- ,
// :
(
), ( ),
. V-
, :
,

, ,
, !
,
() ()
(
,
,
- (- ), ( ,

).
( ),
,
.
: , ! ,
200

,
,
, .

(, . http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_Vee_Model).

(hump diagram) ,
.
( , V) (
) ( ). ,
, ,

,
,
.
RUP (Rational Unified Process):
phases () ,
. ( ,
,
, ,
, ,
,
). ,
(transition),
,
.
:
MFESA:
201
, hump
(, RUP), (
/tasks MFESA).
agile

-. -:
,
,
.
(development method). :
,
).
(development methodology).
.
(development process),
(software process).
(life cycle model)

- (
)!
(..
: 2110, Ford Focus ST,
202
: Nikon D3300, Sony SLT-A77 II, Olympus OM-D E-M10).

, : ,
(.. , )
, ( ),
.
, RUP (Rational Unified Processel),
SCRUM, , : .
: agile
( )
:
(cascade, ,
)
Agile ( ,
)
,
,
, , , ,
.. hand over ()
, ,
.
,
. ,
. , .
( Royce, Winston (1970), Managing
the
Development
of
Large
Software
Systems
http://leadinganswers.typepad.com/leading_answers/files/original_waterfall_paper_win
ston_royce.pdf):
, .
-
( - ,
203
, !). ,
--,
, , !
,
Barry Boehm
, ,
,
.
(http://mydotnetcoolfaqs.blogspot.ru/2011/04/software-development-life-cyclesdlc.html
):
(
, , , /
), (liason customer
communications).
:
, .. .
/
, , 2001
(software
engineers)
Agile
manifesto
(http://agilemanifesto.org/):
204
(http://agilemanifesto.org/iso/ru/):
Agile-

,
. ,
:

, , , -
, .
: ,
,

.
,
SCRUM.
205
, agile
(
)
, .
, ,
, agile
. . ,

. ,
agile- .
(
,
), (
,

).
agile ,
, .
:

,
,
. , :
10-15
. , - agile
.
: ,
,
, ,
.
, agile
SpaceX
(.
https://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Events/Conferences/2012_Conferences/2012Complex-Aerospace-Systems-Exchange-Event/Detailed_Program/CASE2012_24_Muratore_presentation.pdf). focus on tools not rules.
test rigorously and often.
agile :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8jdx-lf2Dw,
http://wikispeed.org/the-car/,
eXtreme
manufacturing
http://scrumlab.scruminc.com/articles.html/_/open/extreme-manufacturing-r93,
test
driven developing for hardware http://wikispeed.org/2013/07/tdd-for-hardware/.
,
, SpaceX (
control boards, ,
,
).
agile lean systems engineering: http://www.lean-systemsengineering.org/downloads-products/lean-enablers-for-systems-engineering/downloads-
206
lean-enabler-for-systems-engineering/. , ,
lean manufacturing (
):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lean_manufacturing.
.
lean agile Kanban and Scrum.
Making the most of both ( ,
!):
http://www.infoq.com/resource/news/2010/01/kanban-scrumminibook/en/resources/KanbanAndScrum-Russian.pdf
,
concurrent engineering agile
: http://incose-ru.livejournal.com/45719.html. -
12 ,
, , - :
http://www.myvi.ru/watch/WxsZCtYxMEyyp5QLEIp_Aw2 (6 14

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extreme_Engineering).
, agile , ,
. Agile ,
,
. , ,
,
, ,
,
.

, vs agile .

agile http://csse.usc.edu/csse/TECHRPTS/2009/usccsse-2009-502/usc-csse-2009-502.pdf :
(Use Single NDI),
(Agile),
(Architected Agile),
(Formal Methods),
(Hardware with embedded

Software component),
Capability),
(NDI-intensive)
)
(Hybrid agile/plan-driven system),
(Multi-owner system of systems),
(Family of systems),
(Indivisible
Initial
(
Operational
Brownfield ()
(Services-Intensive)
207

.
, .
,

,
.

:
. , :
, ,
,
. ,
.
, .
, - ,
,
(happy path) .
.
,
,
.
, .
, , .

,
( )
(, , , ..). ,
. (kernel Essence
) ,
. - :
208
, ,

,
. ,
, .
- ,

:
209
,

,
.
, ( ,
:
, ,
).
(..
),
. (
),
( )
.
ISO 15288
,
/, .
,
,
.
ISO 15288:
1.
1.1.
1.2.
2.
2.1.
2.2.
2.3.
2.4.
2.5.
210
(, )

3.
3.1.
3.1.1.
3.1.2.
3.2.
3.2.1.
3.2.2.
3.2.3.
3.2.4.
3.2.5.
4.
4.1.
4.2.
4.3. ()
4.4.
4.5. ()
4.6.
4.7. ()
4.8.
4.9.
4.10.

ISO 15288.

, , , ,
.
(2.1).
9.

,
, .
:
- (, ,
, )
. ,
-- , .
,
, (
211
,
),
,
. , , , ,
, !
,
.
Atul Gawande "The Checklist Manifesto",
http://gawande.com/the-checklist-manifesto
(
:
http://www.alpinabook.ru/catalogue/2118996.html). : "
,
, , , ,
".
(checklist, ,
checkpoint) :
,
,
due diligence
?. (-,
) ,
READ-DO),
//,
(DO-CONFIRM).
" " (pause points,
), ,
. ,
- ,
Go-NoGo , ..
. "-" (DO-CONFIRM)
, ,
. , ,
"-" (READ-DO,
).
212
, ""
.
"" (
""!) -

( " ", "
", " ,
"), 5-9. , ""
, ,
,
,
.

, ,
(aka )
" ", , .
: ,
,
-.
, ,
(, ,
, ,
).
100% .
( ),
epic fail. , ,
1. Fly the aircraft. ,
,
, , ,
.
,
! , !
, .
, ,

47%!
,
,
( , , ,
).
.
- , , -
(
). ,
- .
,
""
. 10% -
- , - ,
213
, " ", - ,
, - ,
, .
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_cheese_model)
. , 9 10
, - ,
,
.
,
, . , ,
, .
,
, :
, .
, . //
, .
, ,
("") ,
.
,
, , ,
( ,
- ).
, .

, , -
.
(
Atul Gawande Master Builders ,
).
,
, (,

), .
, , "
", " ", "
". ,
( ) , ,
"go no go"
.
/
( ),
(, , ,
.. , ).
:

,
,
. ,
214
,
,
"" - .
( )
(..
, ).

,
.
, , ""
,
, .
,
.
" " .
, ,

, " "
.
"", "". ,
- . ,
.
""

, (
)
. , .

, .
READCONFIRM, .. ,
- . ,
:
1. Fly the aircraft!.

,
. - , ,
.
:
- ,
,
- . , ,
.
,
, (,

, ,
.
215
,
, ).
,
. , .
, .

(,
, cards).
, (
):
,
, ,
: ,
,
. - --:

( ,
..).
, ( ,
/ , , ..
),

.

(
),
. ,
. ,
, ,
, .
216
,
.

(
):
,
,

, -

,

. ,
, ,
.
,
. ,
.
:
, (
,
, , . ,
, ).
.
, ( )
(,
).
, ,
.
,
, ,

.
- ,
(.. ) .
, !

.
- ,
. agile
217
.
:
:
,
.
-
, . (
), ,
.
: ,
, . ,
,
( , )
(issues) .
. : http://www.ivarjacobson.com/alphastatecards/

. , ,
,
issue trackers. -
(bugs),
(issues, ).

( ).
, ,
, issue tracker
( ).

,
,
,
(
, ),
(,
view viewpoint).
,
.

, ,

. ,
:
,
,

( ). ,
218
,
, ,
.
,
XXX (
) XXX.
.
, ,

(http://csse.usc.edu/csse/TECHRPTS/2009/usc-csse-2009-502/usc-csse-2009-502.pdf
) (,
, ,

),

.
,
,
- , , ..
,
,
,
.

,
,

. ,
, .
,

,
,
, -
.
, :
.
,
/
, .. .
(
http://businessanalystlearnings.com/batechniques/2013/1/22/how-to-draw-a-stakeholder-onion-diagram),
- .
,
(,
219
/drive
).
,
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

Excel/Word
, ()

,
(

-

)

,
.

,
(

CRM-,

.
, ..)
(,
,
..)

,
,
,

.
( CRM-, (

..)
,
.
,

,
..)

(views)
(viewpoints)
(

CRM-,
(,

..)
..)

( )

(
,
,

,
issue
tracker,

,
..)
,

,

.

,
,

..

.
220
(,
..)

(

),

VISI

,
,
221

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

issue tracker,
.

.
issue tracker

.

issue tracker

( )

(
).

.

issue tracker,

,

(
.

).

.

(views)
(viewpoints)
222
,
.
(

.
)

.
,

.

.
,

.

.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)
.

.
.

(
)

,
(

-,
.
.
,

issue tracker
).

.
,

-
223
(
).

(views)
(viewpoints)

(

,
.
,

)

, .

,
, - .
.
,

(marginal//) (utility)
,
.

(, , ) .
, .
.
, .

,
: ,
, .
,
( , beyond budgeting),
(stakeholder needs),
(user needs analysis,
..).
, ,
, .

,

.

,

.
,

, .
(views)

(viewpoints)

224

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,

(
,
user needs analysis)
.

.
,

(, project
.
charter,
)

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,

(, ).

.
needs
225

,
,
ROI ..
,
needs

User needs
analysis

(
).

,
User needs

-
,

,
.
,

,
.
,

,
( ,
(

)
.
)
, ,
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.
,

.
,

,
.

,
-

.
kick-off

meeting

.
,

feasibilities study
226
, , .

(views)
(viewpoints)

,
.
,

.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

,

-
,
, .
, :
- (
), :
, , .
, ,
(
DoDAF 28 /viewpoint.
,
).

227
, .

(views)
(viewpoints)
, User needs
Needs analysis

.

, ,
.

3D
,
.

(
),

,
..

,
.

,
,

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,
.

-

.
(
)

.

,

(,
issue issue
tracker)
Issue,
,
.
issue

.

.

,
,

228

(review,
,
..)

MBSE

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

(

,
)

.

,
hand over hand-over
,
(

)
/

,

.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,
/
,

(verification and
.
validation, V&V)

229

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,
( O&M MIMOSA)
..
.

,

,
, .

/ .

(views)
(viewpoints)

-

.

(assurance

case),
(,

)

(compliance).
.

ISO

15288,

/

( )
,
230
, .

,
. :
/,
, , .
,
:
( ).
.
,
.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

(supply chain),
(
data sheets
)

.

/
.

.

-

.

-
(parts)
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

(, ,
)
.

(,
, ,
, ).
231
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

()

.

,
.

.

.
( )
.

(views)
(viewpoints)
,

,
.
:
-

,

.

232

(ITIL
.

, ).
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,

.

.

SLA
(ITIL

) ,
.

..

, /
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

.

,

.
/

.

,

233
,
,
.
(leadership), (
human resources
management talent management).

agile .
,
,
.
.
, , ( ,
) ( ,
): ,
.
, , .

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

(
.

)

.

.

,

,
,
.
,

..

Project charter

.

Kick-off meeting

.

.

.

.
234

, .

(views)
(viewpoints)

.
kick-off
meeting
(
,
)

.

Kick-off meeting
,

,
,
.

Kick-off meeting
(,

)
.
Kick-off meeting

.

issues
.

(,
) .

Kick-off meeting
235
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

.

.

.
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

.

.

.

.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

236

.

.
,
:
).
(case management), ,

( , ,
).
-
( )
, -.
- .

(views)
(viewpoints)
,

,

(
.
)
,

Excel,

,
CRM, ,
, .
.
.
,

,
.
,
.
.
.
,

237
.

(views)
(viewpoints)
.

.
(
beyond budgeting)

.

, ERP-

.
Essence
.

needs analysis,

,
.

Use Case 2.0
,
( 2-6 )
(sliced Use Case),

issue tracker
,
.
agile-

- ,

.

-

.

.
,

,
.

-
.

,

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

.

, .

.
-
issue tracker
238

, ,
.

(views)
(viewpoints)
Issue tracker
.
-

,
burn-out agile

Issue tracker
Issue tracking
.

,
,
,

.
,

.

.
. Issue tracker

Issue tracker
.

agile-,

agile-,

( )

(
),
agile-
239
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

Issue traker (

)

.

.
,
. , .

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

,
Issue tracker .
.
.
,

.
, ( =
+ , = + ).
, ,
, , .

,
.
240

(,
) ,
( , ),
. ,
(, ,
). , :
,
,
: ,
.
:
( ),
,
) (
,
), (

).
,
.

, , .

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

,
.

,

.

,
,
(,
.
,
)
,

,
(

(
)
, .

241
,
)

, ,
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,
(+

, .

)

,

,
.

.
,

as is to be

,

,

.
,

,

.

(
(
,
) Essence),
,
(

),
.
(
)

242
.

(views)
(viewpoints)

Agile-couching

(
.

, ,
)

Agile-couching

(
.

, ,
)

Agile-couching

(
.

, ,
)

.

Issue tracker

, ,

(

)

Issue tracker
.
, .

(views)
(viewpoints)

.
,

,

.
243

, ,

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

,

.

,
.

.

, ,

.

.

(views)
(viewpoints)

.

.
:

, ,
. , :
, ,
.
(
)
(checkpoints)
244
/process plant),
, .
,
. , :
, ,
245
( )
10.
: , , ,
, //. , organizational engineering
() ,
() .

:
.
Enterprise engineering ,
,
IT- , , .
business engineering,
- , ..
:
, ,
.
:
,
, , , (
).
, ,
, , , , ,
,
: , . ,
,
246

.
.
enterprise engineering,
.
,
( IT-,
,
).

( ), (
) ,
(leadership)
// .
( -
enterprise endeavour)
- .

( ), ,
( ).

- ( ),
( ,
,
,
,
),
(, /extended
enterprise
).

, (..
).
(endeavour, effort, enterprise)

(communities), (communities of
practice - ).
-

. , -
, ,
. (
) , .

247
,
. , ,
, - ,
. (
- ).
, ,
- : ,
( . ,
, ,
).
,
( ,

, ,
!).
,
, / .
, ,
, :
, (
), - ,
: - ,
, , (
) .
,
, ,
-
. ,

, -. (
, ).
:

( -
),
(
,
).
,
, , ,

,
.
(
, ):
Goals, (
, !)
248
Targets, (, ,
. ,
, , ,
).
:

,
, .
,
. , ,
,
(
, , ).

,
. ,
SpaceX,
(
SpaceX ,
.
, .
: ?
SpaceX ).
,
.
, -
, - :
, .
(
, , ),
, - ,
.

( user needs, ).

(corporate governance, governance
, ,
)
, ,
,
( -
,
).
,
.
,
( -
249
,
,
).
, ,

(
)
(motivational model). :
, .
(..
, : ,
).
( ,
5Ps perspective, plan, ploy, pattern, position.
, , , , ).
:
- (
,
, ).
, , ,
. ( , )
( )
( -)
( ).
: ,
, ,
. , .
, ,
,
, . - .
,
( ) ,
. ,
,
( ,
):
250
, .

(http://qame.ru/book/sale/strategiya_raboti_s_klientami_v_bolshih_prodazhah/%d0%a
1%d1%82%d1%80%d0%b0%d1%82%d0%b5%d0%b3%d0%b8%d1%8f%20%d1%
80%d0%b0%d0%b1%d0%be%d1%82%d1%8b%20%d1%81%20%d0%ba%d0%bb
%d0%b8%d0%b5%d0%bd%d1%82%d0%b0%d0%bc%d0%b8%20%d0%b2%20%d
0%b1%d0%be%d0%bb%d1%8c%d1%88%d0%b8%d1%85%20%d0%bf%d1%80%
d0%be%d0%b4%d0%b0%d0%b6%d0%b0%d1%85.djvu),
DjVu
(,
WinDjView
http://www.koob.ru/about/windjview-setup.exe).
( )
, , , ,
( , ).
( , ..
, , ,
),
//
.
-,
-
( , ,
), -
,
,
(/, ,

, ).
,
, ,
(.. ,
, ) .

(, ),
, .
251

/ ( ,
user needs
,
),
,
,
(measurements KPIs/Key Performance Indicators
),
(operation management
-), (leadership)
(change management)
(..
),
(-) .

: ,
, -
. ,
,
:
-- ,
,
.
-, ,
-
.

, , ,
() , -
:
,
.
:
, ,
, /
, (..
),
.

:
(
: -

252
. ,
. : -
, ).
,

(engineering and technology management, engineering,
technology and innovation management). ,
(, http://www.mines.edu/ETM_GS,
http://www.journals.elsevier.com/journal-of-engineering-and-technologymanagement/).
.
, .
( ),
, ,
, .

.
-
, , .

.
, .
, .
: ,
, ,
.
,
, .
: (
),
( learning organization ,
vs ), (
).
, .
,
.
,
. , , -
. ,
.
, ,
, . ,
, . ,
. :
,
( )
,
.
253
, .
,
/, , .
,
, .
.
,
. ,
. ,
( )
.
.
- , . -
, .

"" . ,
, ,
, .
?
/
- ? .
,
(
:
, ,
!),
- , .
:
:
,
.
, ,
, , ,
. :
,
,
(
: ).
()
.
, , ,
. -
, ,
: ,
, .
(producing, production) , ,
, , ,
254
, ,
, , .. (
).
( !)
(
) (

).
.
ISO 15288 :
,
( )
, -- ..
( , ,
..).

( , )
( ///)
:
255
.
, .
( ,
, ).
, , . ,
Word ,
.
, -,
: , .
, ,
. (leadership): ,

()
.

.
.
(http://www.melconway.com/Home/Conways_Law.html) ,
///
/
. ,
,

.
. ,

: ,
,
256
.
:
,
. ,
,
,
, .
,
, ,

.

, .
.
Autodesk,
,
: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkJ-Uy5dt5g
1498
Autodesk ( 2007 2011), .
,
.
( ), ,
http://www.autodeskresearch.com/projects/orgorgchart).
, .
,
,
. Autodesk 54 Fortune 100 -
,
http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/bestcompanies/2013/snapshots/54.html
.
, ,
, ,
, , .
IBM ,
35 , ,
IBM .
, .
: , , :
,
, Autodesk?
?
, ?

-:
257
/ , , ,
,
).
, ,
( ,
). (
)
. , ,
.
(
: ,
:
:
/, ,
-
).
, (
),
.

.
-
, - ,
.
, . ,
,
, "
",

!
, ,
, !
, ,
( ,
, ). "
!" , . ,
cognitive frameworks ...
" "
(, !
, ,
!) .

. Harold Lawson
INCOSE LinkedIn "Building SE into an Organization", "...it is all about
understanding and communication. If you do not get people on the same page you are
simply talking in the air. That is why learning fundamental paradigms, concepts and
principles of systems is so important". ,
258
, , .
"fundamental paradigms, concepts and principles of systems"
, .
" ". :
,
, ,
" ".
" " ,
.. ,
. "", , (

).

,
,
/ .
(
" ",
). ,
,
, .
.
,

!
:
( :
http://rutracker.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=2403312
!) ,
: - ,
, , , ,
(
),

, .
( )
,
. ()
, ( )
,
(
. /Throughput
accounting).

:
259
1. (,
//). ,
: , -
, - ,
- . ,
- (

, Factory
physics ).
2. (
), .. 100%,
, ..
3. ,
( !
?). ,
: ,
!
4. ( :

,
).

- Plan,
Do, Check, Act (PDCA):
(Plan ),
(Do ),
(Check , ),
(Act :
),
.
( ),
( ),
.
. PDCA 1939 . "
". .
PDCA :
,
/ .
,
(
) - ,
.
, ,
(, ,
, ).
260
- ,
. ,
: ,
,
( ). ,
, , -
, ,
.

,

(six sigma, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Sigma).
, (
!) 1 3.6
.
,
DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve,
Control), (DFSS, Design for Six Sigma) DMDV (Define,
Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify).

( )
, , .
Lean Six Sigma ( lean
-,
agile - , lean ).
,
- .
:
(..
,
),
.
,
(,
, ..).

-
. - , , ,
261
, (
,
,
. , ). ,
-
,

!
,
. , ,
, , !
- ,
. ,
-,
. ,
( ,

,
, - ..).
, .
, ,
. ,

:
() (
) .

:
, , - (

)
(
)

.
()
, -
, (,
- , -
,
,
,
!).
:
, -
.
! ( ,
262
,
).
- ,
- ( , ,
/, ).
,
, . ,
ISO 42010
( ).

/
:
(: , , , , )
, (run time).
( -, ,
, : ).
,
.
( ):
( ) , ,
..
, ,
,
.

( , ,
)
(viewpoints), ,
:
(way of working) (
, ,
, , )

(), . ,
( ),
.
( OMG Essence,
SPEM 2.0 ..).
:

.
.
, ,
(, , ..). ,
263
,
(,
).
, , ,
http://www.ww.bptrends.com/publicationfiles/01-09-ART-%20Case%20Management-1DeMan.%20docfinal.pdf
:
Artifact-based (
- ),
activity-based
(-
),
communication- (or conversation-) based:

(, )
.
-, workflow
- , (cyborg = cybernetic organism)
: ,
. ,
: (
),
( ).
,
,
,

,
.
,
, (workflow , ,
, ,
,
).
http://www.personal.psu.edu/axk41/BPM05-jerry-reprint.pdf
(.. viewpoint), -:
- (information-based,
,
, ..),
- (process based),
- (organization-based).
, , (
, /case management)
, ,
,
( ,
)
).
264
(-
, ,
, , ,
,
,
. (,
) : ,
, . /speech
acts: , , . ,
, , -
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/speech-acts/).

DEMO ( http://www.demo.nl/,
.
http://www.techinvestlab.ru/files/504456/demo_praxos_1.doc). DEMO
(
) ( , ,
, ,
).
( actor, ,
!)
( ),
. DEMO
,
( :
): -
, ,
, ,
, ,
.
-
,
(
, ,
).
(, , )
(
, ).
, , ,

(/
),
: , ,
, , .
Jan Dietz , ,
, ,
265
, / . ,
( ) . (Jan
Dietz) ,
, Enterprise Ontology:

Jan Dietz ,
(enterprise ontology). ,
, . , ,
( )
, ?, ..
.
,
(enterprise, ,
),
(endeavour, ..
,
).
, .

:
, , ,
( ) -,
.
, .
() , .
- , . (,
) ,
. ,

( )
266
, .
, - ( , ) - (
, ) ,
- .

,
, .
,
, ,
( :
, ,
).
( )
.
( , ,
) , - ,
.
, , , , , , , ,
, , .
, ,
.
, , ..
:

- John
Zahman,
. .
The
Enterprise
Ontology
(tm),

,
( ) ,
,
- ( - ,
267
:
,
).
- ( )
reification transformation,
(
):
1. Scope context (identifications) executive (business scope planners)
2. Business concepts (definitions) business management (business concept owners)
3. System logic (representations) architect (business logic designers)
4. Technology physics (specifications) engineer (business logic builders)
5. Tool components (configurations) technician (business components implementers)
6. Operations instances (instantiations) users, The Enterprise ( ,
).
,
( ) (
) ,
,
, ,
.
( ),
, cognitive
framework/ ,
268
(-).
:
1. (inventory sets) .
2. (process flows) , /
. , , .
3. (distribution networks) ,
, .
4. /
.
(responsibility
assignments)
5. (Timing Cycles) , " "

" " ( -
case life cycle project life cycle - "
", , ).

(..
,
). ,
ISO 24744 ( OMG Essence)
: Stage-WithDuration/*Kind is, in turn, specialized into TimeCycle/*Kind
(having as objective the delivery of a final product or service), Phase/*Kind (having as
objective the transition between cognitive frameworks) and Build/*Kind (having as major
objective the delivery of an incremented version of an already existing set of work
products). TimeCycle/*Kind also holds a whole/part relationship to Stage/*Kind, allowing
for the recursive composition of time cycles and other stages. , timing cycles ISO
24744 .
6. (Motivation Intentions) ,
. ,
motivation
, .
correspondence rules
ISO 42010 ( rules . .
http://www.ronross.info/blog/2011/09/06/where-are-your-business-rules%E2%80%A6-in-a-big-p-process-dead-zone/ ,
business rules correspondence rules ,
-
).
-
,
-. :
-
.
- .
- -.
269
(value networks), ,
- (value chain, value-added):

( value
, .. -
, ) OMG VDML
(Value Delivery Modeling Language): http://www.omg.org/spec/VDML/
- OMG BMM (business
motivation model, http://www.omg.org/spec/BMM/) ,
motivation, - (goals)
(means):
270
, (mission, vision, goal, objective ..) ,

-! ,
,
(, , -
, !).
- , ,
. - (
VDML).
- (business model generation
http://www.businessmodelgeneration.com) ,
- , ,
, , , ,
, ,
- (canvas,
http://www.businessmodelgeneration.com/downloads/businessmodelgeneration_previe
w.pdf, .pdf -- http://www.bimoga.com/):
271
- McKinsey & Co,

Bain & Co, Booz & Co, BCG, Palladium "
". MBA.
" " (, value), " " (capability,
), " " (, , ,
) .. , ""
( , )
"/", "", ""
,
( , ,
, ). ""
"", " " (
), " " (
- , ).
:
- http://www.businessarchitectureguild.org/
( Business Architecture Body of Knowledge, BIZBOK,
3.0). , ,
, " ".
http://www.businessarchitectsassociation.org/
(
-),
. , -
, (
William
Ulrich
http://www.linkedin.com/groups/When-Stars-Align-Business-Architecture4379346.S.130420677).
272
SIG OMG http://bawg.omg.org/ ( VDML ,

http://bawg.omg.org/12-06-01.pdf)
LinkedIn http://www.linkedin.com/groups/BusinessArchitecture-Perspectives-Transforming-Business-4379346
http://www.bainstitute.org/ (,
40. , BPMinstitute.org
SOAinstitute.org , ).
architecture/
, ,
.
http://paularthurbodine.com/the-chicago-school-of-business-
( ) ,
, ,
"-" ( , ""
- , ""
), . enterprise
engineering, systems engineering
. - /
, , .
, ,
. - :
- .
, ,
. ,
,
( , , , ,
) ,
.
(organizational chart) ,
(
,
!):
273
(Departments in advertising agencies,

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organizational_chart#mediaviewer/File:Deprtments_in_adv
ertising_agencies.jpg) system
( , ,
), ,
(vice president creative services)
(Research, Art/Copy).
.

-
,
,
(- -
).
,
( ,
, ,
,
4D extensinalism)
.

, , , ,
. ,
, , .
274
,
, !
,

, . , ,
.
, ,
.

,
, ,
/ .
, -,
:
,
-- ,
. (..
),
.

, . , ERP
( ) ,
,
. CRM-
,
- .
,
-
:
, ,
,
:
-
" " ,
,
(..
275
).

IT- IT- (

).
/: -,
, , ,

, ..
( SCORM)
. HR-,

.
, (BPM),
/ / (issue
tracker, adaptive case management),
.
,
,
: issue tracker
(case management)
-/

,
( ).

,
, / , , , ,
, ( ,
..) ,

,
.

(stakeholders)
(viewpoints) (views),

/
. ,
- ,
( ) .
: .
, ,
,
/.
,
276
. ()
.
ArchiMate
(frameworks),
viewpoints TOGAF, Zachmans, ArchiMate.
- ,
, (
OpenGroup ArchiMate 2.0
http://pubs.opengroup.org/architecture/archimate2-doc/,
: http://ailev.livejournal.com/988360.html).
-
:
()

( )
.
,
. ,
,
Archi ( Archimate):
( ,
), ,
277
, .
,
.
21
,
,
. (
)
,
(,
, IT-,
IT-, .
,
,
IT-. !).

.

( :
,

!).

,
- .

( ) , "".
- (
), - (
),
.
,
, . :
. "",
, . ,
( ) ,

. ,
, ( ,
, , , "
"). .
, ,
. ,
(
), (
)
, .
, - ,
278
""
(" "),
- ,
. : "
, ",
"" () .
,
.
" ?!", " ?", " ?".
. : ,
" ". ,
.
.
, , " " (
"" ).
" ",
. ,
" ". ? ,
? " ?"
, , - (? ?
"" ).
:
( " " ).
, :
, ,
. , " "
" ". , "
" " ". ,
,
, "" "" , ""
"" . , .
, , "": ,
() , ()
, . - ,
. -: ,
. .
: - ,
. .
. -
. .
: ,
.
(activity, ,
"" ),
, .
, .
, .
279
,

.
.
( , "
).
,
20%
( 20% 80% , 80%
"" 20% "
" ).
.
. ,
, .
, .
- , .
, , "".
, , :
,
. ,
, ,
IT-.
( - , " DEMO") .
,
: "
?!".

, (,
!), . ,
, , ..
:
,
(
),
. "
"
" ", "" ,
"" - ""
"". "" ""
. ,

. : ,
; ,
(, , ); .. ,
,
.

.
- , .
280
,
. ,

, ,
.
, ,
-
, : ,
. ,
. ,
.
.
.
, , -
.
, .
, , .
, -
.
.
, .
( ),
( ),
. ,
(
) ( ,
). .
, .
, ,
. ( ,
) ( ),
( ). ,
:
.
.
,
, . ,
,
, .
- , ,
,
.

(
), - (
).
281
,
16 ,
7 ,
9 ,
11 , ,
.
- (
?),
:
7
4
-
, .
. .
33 .
, .
, , - . -
(, ) .
, :
, .
, ( , ,
..) ( )
.
, , ,
.

.
, ,
. : ,
, . ,
: ,
(
) -
, ,
, .
: ,
,
. - :
( ) .
: ,
.
,
282
. ,
, , .
, ( , ..
" ") .
-
.
(" " ,
" ", )
. ,
/ ( ""
).
:
(17),
(7+9) .
.
, .
, .
"" ,
, (

), , -,
. , ,
. ,
.. , , , ,
"", ,
. , , :
,
, : .
, ,
"" ():
-. ,
, .
, ,
"". ,
, - .
, , ,
: , , .
, .
, ,
(leadership). ,
. )
"" "" , ,
, )
"" .
283
: , ,
, , " ", "",
, ..
,
, " ".
,
(: ,
1000
,
), ,
.
: ,
, , " ,
, ".
" ", " " "
" . ,
, . , -
( ) , (
) . , ,
.
, ) ) ,
, .
-:
" "
. , ,
( ).
, ,
, .
, ,
, .
,
( )
(, ), (, )
, "" , ..
. :
284
, ,
.
: ,
.

, .
,
( , ).
(
"" ),
, , , .
,
,
.
.
, ,
- -.
- (
),
.

:
.
: " ".
(" "),
(, , ),
(, , ,
, " ").
,
( ) .
"", "", "".
, ,
, -.
,
.
.
- ,
(,
-
) . ,
(
, ,
, , " "
" ", -
). ,
: " " .
285
- ,
. ,
, ,
. ,
, - , (, )
.
, - ,
( , ,
) , .
, ,
, - ,
.
, ,
: , .
IT-
( ,
, ,
..,
) IT- (IT-solution).
,
()
, : ,

, . -
,
( , )
( ). ,

,
,
(.. IT-),
(
,
).

, .
, , (
, , ,
! , ,
location, ).
: , ,
.
,
.
286

- ,
, ,
. , . "
", , , , ,
. " ",
, ,
, ,
"" ,
(leadership),
- .
(, ,
) ,
, .
, .
" ", ,
, ,
. ,
, , .
, ,
-.

, , .
, ,
.
,
, .
, )
[] )
,
[, ] )
" " [ ] ,
[
].
, ,
, (operations
, .
).
,
,
. ,
( , ),
,
,
. , ,
, , .
, . operation
management ,
287
(.
http://www.stedwards.edu/mba/draman/mgmt6305/pdf/Chapter1_p2.pdf).
,
, ,
.
,
, ,
. ,
: ,
, .
(, ,
) (
-
http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/Business+philosophies+and+popular+manag
ement+theories). ,
,
, ,

.
( , TQM, JIT, lean management).
,

. , ,
30
MBA-:
http://web.archive.org/web/20070504104830/http://www.poms.org/EducationCourses/
POMS_Syllabi.html. ,
20 .
MPA (master of public
administration) : , "
( , , , ) (
.
, , )".

(,
http://www.csus.edu/PPA/syllabi/undergraduate/spring2003/ppa140s.pdf,
How
Different are Private and Public Agencies Supposed to Be? Read: Paul Appleby,
Government is Different. Graham Allison, Public and Private Management: Are They
Fundamentally Alike in All Unimportant Respects?),
. . ,
operations management public
management . : new public
management, reinvent government, alternative service delivery e-government.

performance
(.,
,
http://www.performanceweb.org/ Lean Six Sigma For Government
Project Management for Government). " "
, .

(., ,
288
http://institute.uschamber.com/required-core-curriculum/,
).
,
(Production and Operations management

Society): http://www.poms.org/

: ,
[ ]
, ( :
" "). , ,
(, ,
, ),
,
, .
, , ,
,
(http://www.xprogramming.com/xpmag/kings_dinner.htm).
,

(, ,
, ,
).
(,
, - operations research :

).
operations research (-
)

.
,
. ,
( , ,
).
(Schreiber
et
al.,
2000
CommonKADS,
http://www.cs.vu.nl/~guus/papers/Speel01a.pdf):
289
( )

(planning)
(sheduling)
(assignment)

.

( MBA, ,
, MBA
,
: , ,
).

,
, ,
. ,
, , "",
,
, ,
,
.
, , .
, , (
, !) ,
, , .
:
management engineer operation engineer. "
" (
, -
, ,
).
operations research analyst, " "
. http://www.collegegrad.com/careers/proft47.shtml
, ,
management operations (,
Operations research and management science are terms that are
used interchangeably to describe the discipline of applying advanced analytical
techniques to help make better decisions and to solve problems). 1996
50000 , 2002
61700 operations research analyst, 2004. 58000.
management
analyst
( management
consultant):
http://www.ethics.state.pa.us/portal/server.pt/document/1280123/6_mgt_analyst
_pdf , 2004 605000 ,
management analysts .
computer systems analyst,
, ,
290
IT-. ,

, . 2004.
487000 ,
.
,
:
( Lingvo: operations management
[].
, ,
;
production management
operations management, .. ""
, , ,
. ., production
).
Operations Management is the process by which an organization converts inputs
(e.g. labor, material, knowledge, equipment) into outputs (goods and services).

" " " "
" ".
(supply chain management)
(project management)
(process management), (process reengineering)

management)
(planning
and
production
(logistics)
(operation strategy)
(management of service operations)
(performance improvement)
(enterprise
(resource management)
resource
planning)
get things done (GTD)

.
C ,

.
Operations managmenet
"",
. , ,
http://www.stedwards.edu/mba/draman/mgmt6305/pdf/Chapter1_p2.pdf:
business
environment, business processes, Business System Model, competitive edges, customer
functions, decision-making functions, design, dimensions of a business, functional silo
syndrome, goals, good, implementation, inputs, intangible service, inventory-intensive
291
businesses, management, manufacturing, measurements, operation, operations function,

organization, output, policies, process, product, profit, resource management, scheduleintensive businesses, service, service industry, strategy, system, systems thinking,
Throughput, transformation process, value-added. ,
. (
):
http://www.clamshellbeachpress.com/bookinfo.php?Id=1&Type=Learn+More 408
.
supply
chain
operations
management
http://www.lindo.com/library/glossary.pdf (69 ).
/
() / .
, (flow). -
"", "" ,
,
(

)
/ , "
" ( " "),
,
, .
, ,
. ,
. :
. ,
.
, ,
: , ,
, . ,
. ,
. , . ,
:
,
.
(build time)
(run time) ("
" ),

. ,
,
, ,
(: ).
,
( ,
, ) (
: ,
,
).
,
(BPM, business process management) workflow management
IT- ,
292
(http://www.bpminstitute.org/community/bpm-group/choreography-vs-orchestration).

,
, .
, ,
(, , ).
,
-
( ,
). ,
, , -
(up front) , ,
.
- ,
(, PRINCE2
, ),
(
,
,
), (
).
:
(
,

(
,
).
( PMI PMBoK, PRINCE2),

:
,
( P2M/Project&Program Management,
TOC/Theory of Constraints, LastPlanner/Lean Project management).

(..
,
) .. (
) .
,
.
,
(,
:
).
293

(
,
,
), .
.
( )
(
), ..
( )

( -
) (
).
, (..
,
) ,

, .

,

(
,
), () .
business proccesses (
-, business
- ). (..
, ,
, ,
294
),
ISO 9000.
process (
, ). ISO 15288
life cycle processes,
- ISO 9000
process. , :
, ,
, , ,
ISO 15288 .

(
, ),
. ,
,
,
,
.
,
,
workflow,
OMG BPMN 2.0 (Business
process model and notation, http://www.bpmn.org/).
,
(),
-
( )
-.
/-
(case management adaptive case
management, dynamic case management, advanced case management case
, .
/ ,
) -
, ,
,
(Case management. A coordinative and goal-oriented discipline, to
handle cases from opening to closure, interactively between persons involved with the
subject of the case and a case manager or case team).
( )
( ), case file (case
folder) , ..
,
(
.. ) (
, , ..
295
) .
, ,
.
, (, ,
, ),
(Case. A situation, set of circumstances or initiative that requires a set of actions to
achieve an acceptable outcome or objective. A case focuses on a subject that is the focus
of the actions such as a person, a lawsuit or an insurance claim, and is driven by the
evolving circumstances of the subject).
(,
, )
, .
, -
( ),
-

( ).
, , ,
.
(
,
).
,
( ,
), - -
( ,
, ).
, , -
( ,

,
; ,
,
,
).
,
,
-design (3D- ) -project
( ),
.
issue tracking (
case management)
. // (issues)
,
,
,
, .
issue trackers
( ).
296

(PLM-, product life-cycle managmenet) issue
trackers, .
issue////
(Engineering Change Request). , ,
(Engineering Change Order),
, ,
(Engineering Change Notice).
issue tracker :
, ,
issue: Done, ,
( DEMO)
.

? , view .

.
(
)
( )
. ,
,
.

( ,
.., )
,
.
OMG Essence ,

. ,
, , " ".
297
,
(
).
, : " ",
" ". , ,
:
,
- (" ,
", " - ").
,
.
,
. ,
.
-design
(PLM-) ,

. (..
,
),
, .

()
.
, .. .

! ,
! ,
, ,
, ,
.
(issues/tasks/cases) , , .
, ,
.
(), (
, ).
" " ,
( , ) ,

. Essence

:
Essence ,
" " " ".

, .
(
298
) :
.
, -
.
,
, lean (
).

(
, ,

, ),

. !

,
!
,
.
,
PRINCE2 (
), WBS
,
Essence.
: , .

:
( ):
( ,
, , ..)
( )
:
( ,
). .

issue trackers,
Essence
(, up front)
.
, .
, /
, , , ..
( ) ( issue
tracker) . ,
299
,
,
, , (
, ).
, -
, -
. issue (
),
( ).
, :
.
? ,
(issue tracking) (),
: (" "

, )
, "
"
" ",
, , issue - issue
tracker. ,
, (
: ,
!).
( Go No Go
)
.
( ).
(,
).

(Event management is the co-ordination, running and
planning of all the people, teams and features that come together to create every kind
of
event,
http://www.eventbusinessacademy.com/why-events/what-is-eventmanagement, )
- :
, , , .
,

,
(enabling) .
,
,
.
,
,

, .
300
,
,
. , (
), :
,
.

,
( )
( , ).
,
(,
, ,
, ).
, ,
.
, , , ,
(, throughput
accounting, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Throughput_accounting) ,
,
. beyond
budgeting (http://www.bbrt.org/beyond-budgeting/bb-mental.html :
,

), (
, ),
.
, , ( , )
-.
(
, ),
.
, :
(, , , , ).

().
, ?
, ?
?
,
.
, , ,
.
, . , 2*2=4
301
( 4, 3 7),
(,
), .
.
( -
. , 2*2=4
). , ..
. ,
(, UNICODE
)
, ().
,
.
.

), .. , (
),
( ,
)
, .
/ (,
) (,
). ,
, .
. ,
, ,
.

,
.
,
( )
, ,
,
,
.
(http://www.aup.ru/docs/etks/etks-51/144.htm)
, Toyota production system

.
, "" "
",
"" "" ,
(.. -
- ).
,
( ) ,
" ". () (
,
302
, ) -
/, /
- .
, -
- ( ),
-,
- (
-) , , Toyota

. -
, - ,
-
,
, ..
.

/, .
/ /,
/,
, / .
, / :
( , " ",
.
, ""
).
- (
/,
, , ,
..)
(
, ,
-, -
,
)
- ( ,
)
/
( ),
303
(""
/ ,
,
).
:
( ):
// /-
. " "

/
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_engineering).
( explicit, tacit)
(), ( "")
,
. //,
.
,
,
. ,
,
, .
, ( )

, ,
, ,
.
, .. (
, /
-):
, (generative
design: , ..
, )
/ , ""
.
.
" ", -
(
, ,
" " ..),

- .
" "
304
"".
(), ( ) ,
(http://ailev.livejournal.com/631926.html, 2008):
( tacit knowledge
). , ,
( , explicit).
( , ,
" ", " ", "
" .). ,
" " (, ""
"",
!).
/ ,
( , ..
, , .). -,
, -
.
" " , "
": ,
( ),
(
:
/
//
, ). ,
, .
() ( ).
, : -, - .
,
,
, . , ( ) " "
tacit
knowledge , ,
.
""
: ,
. , " ", "
", " ". "
", , ,
-
. , ,
.
/
(!),
-""-.
,
/
305
, " " (
, ).
, ,

. ,
, ,

. , , ""
/:
,
(

, ).
,
( :
,
,

).
, (
" ", " ", " -")
,
PLM ( PLM-
, . , Dassault Systemes
Exalead, - ).
, " "
" ", "
", ,
. " " (
) / ,

,
. /
.
, ( )
. , (http://www.asem.org/)

( " " " "
, " " - ,
" "
, ..).

, (
http://www.acdm.org/),
" " .
***

Системноинженерное мышление - 2015

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Системноинженерное мышление - 2015

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

TechInvestLab, 2 2015

interdisciplinary approach and means to enable the realization of successful systems

understanding stakeholder needs; exploring opportunities; documenting requirements;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail), 2008 "Wuhan

Masters Project or the two-semester Systems Engineering Masters Thesis.

(systems engineering management)

Engineering management (designing),

ASEM, American Society for Engieering Management

(BS/BE, Bachelor of Science/Bachelor of Engineering),

Market Research, Assessment, and Forecasting

Strategic Planning and Change Management

Product, Service and Process Development

Engineering Projects and Process Management

Financial Resource Management

Marketing, Sales and Communications Management

Leadership and Organizational Management

Professional Responsibility, Ethics and Legal Issues

engineering management technology

1: Innovative Ideas and Concept Development

Ethics in Technology Management

(Temporal Whole Part) ,

mind and cognitive science ( cognitive psychology, cognitive linguistics!):

Language OMG Essence, OMG

Billy Koen (http://www.me.utexas.edu/directory/faculty/koen/billy/41/)

Donald Firesmith , 80- , . -

( Lingvo: operations management

(supply chain management)

(management of service operations)

get things done (GTD) ,

feedback systems, feedback control, control loops).

/ (system in operational environment)

("He has taken on his Aspect and raised up

multiple-track minded simultaneously.

(functional breakdown structure),

(work breakdown structure)

(plant breakdown structure)

(document breakdown structure)

advancing manufacturing, cyber-physical production systems, etc.

(hardware test engineer):

TDD, test driven development ( , agile

Model-based testing ( test automation):

Test of Cyber-physical systems (control system engineering):

Paul Clements, et al. Documenting Software Architectures

(life cycle model)

: Nikon D3300, Sony SLT-A77 II, Olympus OM-D E-M10).

(Use Single NDI),

(Hardware with embedded

(Hybrid agile/plan-driven system),

(Multi-owner system of systems),

1. Fly the aircraft!.

(endeavour, effort, enterprise)

communication- (or conversation-) based:

5. (Timing Cycles) , " "

, (mission, vision, goal, objective ..) ,

- McKinsey & Co,

SIG OMG http://bawg.omg.org/ ( VDML ,

(Departments in advertising agencies,

(Production and Operations management

get things done (GTD)

businesses, management, manufacturing, measurements, operation, operations function,

( PMI PMBoK, PRINCE2),

You might also like