Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Forward
Tropical Rhythms, a String Project in Jamaica, transpired from 1997 to 2001
under the leadership of JSOs Founder and Fulbright Scholar, Dr. Lisa Walker,
who later submitted the project as partial fulfillment of the requirements for her
Doctor of Musical Arts degree at Claremont Graduate University, California.
The string project was a life changing venture for many of the participants and
for Lisa in pedagogical development. Very early, Lisa recognized the need to
step outside of her American musical paradigm to be successful in the
Jamaican culture. According to her, the Jamaican musicians proved to be the
most vibrant group she had ever coached. Through the experience, she has
developed a more comprehensive approach to pedagogy and become a more
effective and exciting teacher.
While I was not a part of Lisas life until the last two months of the project, I
witnessed the end results and have been an integral part of all her subsequent
projects around the world, including the Jamaica Symphony Orchestra (JSO),
which was launched in Jamaica in September 2008.
Jamaica Symphony Orchestra (JSO) performing at the World Travel Award in Jamaica on October 22, 2010
Born in Los Angeles and trained in Chicago, Lisa is easily one of the best string
coaches worldwide. For nine years, I have seen her coach beginning students to
play like professionals in record time in North America, Central America,
Europe, and the Caribbean. In this book, she shares her experience with the
Jamaican music culture and her secrets for success.
Courtney Walker
JSO Executive Director
December 2010
Acknowledgements:
Administrators:
Gillian Lee and Cynthia Thompson
Jamaican Teacher-trainees:
Marc Gayle, Sadiki Thompson
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Pages
Introduction
Chapters:
1: Setting the stage
13
20
26
30
34
7: Practical Issues
39
8: Special Achievements
42
Conclusion
44
Citation
47
List of Participants
48
Photographs
51
Reading List/Bibliography
59
INTRODUCTION
Pamela OGorman, The First Twenty-one Years in the Life of the Jamaica School of Music, in
British Journal of Music Education, (United Kingdom Vol. I/1 1984), 80.
2
Ibid., 82.
1
included
teaching
General
Music
History,
My
Violin
The students
In spite of the
The
also became evident that music forms the basis of their connate form of
expression. The sing-song inflection of Jamaican Patois, the use of
music as an integral part of community life, and an inherent
understanding of musical concepts presented form the basis of this
opinion.
A Dictionary of Jamaican English, a particularly informative
book on Jamaican Patios published by the University of the West
Indies, gives vivid recitations of the song-like dialect.3 Visitors to the
island are introduced to a sample of the musical community by
serenading
groups
of
instrumentalists
and
singers
performing
F.B. Cassidy and R.B. LePage, eds., A Dictionary of Jamaican English, 2nd ed., (Kingston, Jamaica:
University Press of the West Indies, 2003).
4
OGorman, 64.
The
CHAPTER 1:
Setting the Stage
Jamaicas music
bass
guitar,
trombone
and
percussion
instruments.
Hope Alysia Davis, Trevor Alvin Beckford, School and Church Music Educator: An Examination of
His Contribution to Music Education in Jamaica (Doctoral Dissertation, University of Southern
Mississippi, 1997), 2.
5
Prior
Teachers
to
forming
Ensemble,
the
I
String
accepted
public
performances
After the
concert, the respective music teachers were less reluctant, yea even
congenial to forming a string ensemble. In addition, Moyah Gibson, a
Jamaican Suzuki violin instructor, recommended six of her advancing
students for study with me directly after the same aforementioned
concert.
The String Teachers Ensemble comprised four violins, two violas,
and one violoncello.
Consistent
12
CHAPTER 2:
Play something for me!
teaching the child the basics of the instrument before teaching her to
play. The parent replied that she was not sure she could afford to pay
me to teach her child the basics. For this parent, there was a direct
correlation between the payment of fees for each lesson and the
progress of the child. I soon discovered this particular mindset to be
widespread in the Jamaican culture. High value is placed on a visible
performance product with very little value placed on the actual process.
This peculiar cultural disposition compels a pedagogical approach
heavily based on performance.
Performance-based pedagogy accentuates the performing aspect
of pedagogy, including learning technique through graded repertoire,
weekly ensemble master classes and frequent public performances.
The Suzuki Method, begun by Shinichi Suzuki in Japan in 1947, is one
example of a performance-based system. It was through the Suzuki
13
Method that I developed an early and solid bond with the violin. The
late Mr. Joseph Williams, a Panamanian Suzuki instructor, introduced
me to the violin using the Suzuki Method. I studied with Mr. Williams
for three years before winning a scholarship to the Chicago College of
Performing Arts (pre-college division) at Roosevelt University.
Mr.
14
opportunity for the students to play for and with their peers. The group
classes proved to be highly motivational and exciting for the students
and were a vital ingredient in the success of the project.
The students
Shinichi Suzuki, preface to songs in Suzuki Violin School, Vol. 1- 10 (Evanston, Illinois: Summy
Birchard Company, 1970), 4ff.
15
Beethoven Class (level one); Bach Class (levels two and three); and
Chamber Orchestra (levels four and up).
16
17
The String Project in performance at the Hilton Hotel in Kingston, Jamaica (2000)
Certain
One
year.
In
response
to
this
variety,
I created
syllabus
for
their
child
to
18
All
19
CHAPTER 3:
If you dont feel anything, neither will your audience
--- Emphasize Dramatic Content of Music --You motivate the students to play the violin, while making the
process fun and exciting even though it is hard work.7
During my sojourn in Jamaica, I quickly learned that high
drama might very well define the essence of the Jamaican culture.
Practically all of the traditional festivals include a fusion of music and
drama, including Jamaican Independence Day celebrations, Jamaica
Carnivals, Accompong Maroon Festival activities and Jonkonuu.8
would even dare say that the primary reason the Jamaican
participants of the project play their instruments is to realize the
drama in the music.
Elucidation
of
dramatic
content
encourages
effective
For the
20
and made the process of learning fun and exciting even though it was
indeed hard work.
The last two public concerts compelled standing ovations in
addition to increased registration.
See Classical Strings, April, 2001 and Strings at Christmas, Dec, 2001 in accompanying media.
See appendix 1.
10
21
22
11
Leopold Mozart, A Treatise on the Fundamental Principles of Violin Playing, 2nd ed, trans. by
Editha Knocker (Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press, 1985), 218.
12
Robin Stowell, Technique and performing practice, in The Cambridge Companion to the Violin
(Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 139.
13
Adrian Eales, The fundamentals of violin playing and teaching, in The Cambridge Companion to
the Violin (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1992), 115.
23
Rochelle
Haynes
represents
one
shown
by
the
Jamaican
her
solo
debut,
Rochelle
varying the dramatic content as the music dictated. Her obvious strong
involvement with the music and ability to effectively communicate
produced commanding and convincing performances.
of
the
advanced
24
orchestra.
The
There
is
an
abstract,
yet
distinct
emotions
expression.
truly
felt
in
music
14
Ivan Galamian, Principles of Violin Playing and Teaching, 2nd ed., (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1985), 7.
25
CHAPTER 4:
What is the difference between a perfect musician (one without
mistakes) and a professional musician?
15
Mozart.
Francesco Geminiani, The Art of Playing on the Violin (London, 1751; facsimile edition available
from Oxford University Press).
17
Leopold Auer, Violin Playing As I Teach It (New York: Frederick A. Stokes Company, 1921).
18
Galamian.
16
26
in
each of
the
areas
to
achieve efficacy in
performance.20
19
Timothy W. Gallwey, The Inner Game of Tennis (New York: Random House, 1974).
Don Greene, Performance Success: Performing Your Best Under Pressure (New York: Routledge,
2002).
20
27
28
strings and three different violins inspired the children to play through
erroneous notes, temporary lapses of memory and sundry mishaps
during performances.
Rachael Lodge concentrating more on the music than simply the technique
Jamaica Gleaner24
24
See Appendix 1.
29
CHAPTER 5:
What am I saying now?
See bibliographic entries for Phyllis Young, Shinichi Suzuki and Paul Rolland.
Phyllis Young, The String Play, (Austin, Texas: University of Texas Press, 1986), 6 31.
30
dexterity.27
bowing on ones shoulder through a little tube that guides the bow, to
promote correct bow technique.28
Participants of the string project were consistently encouraged
to focus on the bow, as 100% of the sound comes from the bow.
Frequently, in illustration of this principle, I challenged a pupil to
produce as much sound as they could from the left-hand only.
It
often took less than a second for the pupil to return a smile of
comprehension.
The
following
are
several
exercises
for
developing
bow
Tone Colors
For beginning exercise and warm-up, I employed long bows on
open strings, with attention on clear, solid tone production.
Additionally, a variance of tone color was encouraged. For the very
youngest students, we often played the color game. In this game,
the student thinks of a color and tries to reproduce that color with his
paint brush (bow) on an open string. Invariably, the pupil learned to
vary the bow speed according to the desired color: lighter colors
require less pressure and slower bow speed while darker colors
27
Dr. Shinichi Suzuki, Suzuki Violin School, Vol. 1, (Florida: Summy Birchard Inc., 1970), 9ff.
Paul Rolland, The Teaching of Action in String Playing: Violin and Viola (New York: Boosey and
Hawkes, 1986), 85.
28
31
This is substantiated by
29
Galamian, 101.
32
verbal aspect of music making. For example, if the performer uses too
little bow and produces a small tone, the performer may be saying, I
am nervous or I dont want you to hear what I am playing.
Alternatively, a production of a full, generous tone, varying the tone
color as the music dictates, sends the message that one is comfortable
with what they are saying.
33
CHAPTER 6:
The Mother-Tongue and Reggae Twinkle
Moreover, the
30
Ibid., 1.
Shinichi Suzuki, Nurtured by Love: The Classic Approach to Talent Education, trans. by Waltrud
Suzuki (Florida: Summy Birchard Inc., 1986), 5ff.
32
Pamela OGorman, The first 21 years in the life of the Jamaica School of Music, in British
Journal of Music Education, (United Kingdom Vol. I/1, 1984), 76.
31
34
Reggae Twinkle
natural,
respectively).
Further,
virtually
all
of
the
35
String Project in Performance: Michael Hewitt, congo drum soloist with Lisa
(Holness) Walker conducting.
36
of
addition,
co-concertmasters.
Jamaican
artists
37
All
three of the guest artists expressed their astonishment with the level
of artistry of the Jamaican artists-in-training in relation to their level.
Further, one of the highlights of the adventure, according to
Carsillo, was an impromptu jam session on Reggae Twinkle,
In
with
An
Evening
of
Elegant
33
See Appendix 3.
38
CHAPTER 7:
Practical Issues
--- Teacher Trainees --Due to the continuing increase in enrollment, it became necessary
to train additional teachers to expand the program. The string program
in Jamaica comprised more than 70 students at its highest point of
enrollment
and
approximately
120
participants
in
total.
To
accommodate the large volume of prospective participants, I teachertrained Sadiki Thompson and Marc Gayle, two senior members of the
string project that expressed their interest in teaching and earning
money.
early-level master classes. Being able to set their own fee structure
and collect their students full tuition served as a particularly influential
incentive for the trainees.
39
40
for different kinds of jobs they might be hired for. Joelle Lee, at 9ys.
old represents one of the youngest entrepreneurs of the string project.
Joelle Lee, 9 Ys
The contractors
41
CHAPTER 8:
--- Special Achievements --A few of the participants were recognized nationally and
internationally for their achievements on their respective instruments.
Sadiki Thompson, Marc Gayle and Stefan Kerr received partial
scholarships to study at Apple Hill Center for Chamber Music
Summer Music Festival in New Hampshire for the summers of 2000
and 2001:
Sadiki Thompson
Sadiki Thompson leading chamber group at Apple Hill Center for Chamber Music
Coach: Michael Dabroski
Marc Gayle
Marc Gayle in coaching session at Apple Hill Center for Chamber Music
Coach: Myriam Teie
42
Jessica Yap
Jamaican Gleaner, Sunday, May 28, 2000
Justin Whyte, Entertainment Editor
---In listening to seven-year-old Jessica Yap play the first movement of Antonio Vivaldi's
Concerto In A minor, it becomes clear that she is one of Jamaica's gifted young
people.The youngster's musical talents were spotted by her mother and at threeand-a-half years she began learning the violin.
I think she has a flair for the violin.[as] her music teacher, Lisa Holness, said there
are certain things about the violin which Jessica has no problem in committing to
memory," Mrs. Yap told Showbiz.After playing the violin for a year and a half, she
gained a distinction in Grade 2 examinations set by Associated Board, Royal School
of Music. This is an exceptional achievement. She now plays the violin at an
intermediate level - between Grades 5 and 6 - yet she is too young to sit the
Associated Board's examination for that level. Under Miss Holness' tuition Jessica
won two first prizes in last year's biennial music festival organised by The Music
Teachers' Association of Jamaica. She also won the award for The Most Outstanding
Junior Performer.
In addition to being
43
CONCLUSION:
34
Ivan Galamian, Principles of Violin Playing & Teaching, 2nd ed. (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1985), 1.
35
Ibid.
36
Whyte, Lisa Holness creating young violinists.
44
artists
who
assisted
in
the
string
music
project.
37
See Appendix 3.
45
The
this
experience,
have
developed
more
to
educators,
Jamaican
Suzuki
music
and
teachers,
Traditional
Caribbean
violin
string
music
pedagogues,
future
46
47
Christian, Lilieth
Gayle, Marc
Aiken, Arielle
Christie, Matthew
Green, Pia-Milan
Aiken, Naydene
Chung, Rory
Hardie, Milton
Bailey, Delpher
Cook, Luke
Harripaul, Kristen
Bernard, Kintu
Creary, Lauren
Haynes, Annabel
Blake, Randi
Cunningham, CarlMichael
Haynes, Rochelle
Bowie, Monique
Dacosta, Danielle
Henry, Matthew
Bromley, Helen
Dacosta, Shannon
Bowie, Jhulen
Brown, MarshaGaye
Doonquah,
Dominique
Brown, Rebekah
Edwards, Justin
Burke, Adrian
Burgess, Rhona
Byles-Lee, Gillian
Elliot, Emily
Falconer, Analee
Fox, Zoe
Fyffe, Courtney
Gayle, Krystal
48
Henry, Chiann
Henry, Mauleen
Ho, James
Ho, Peter
Ho, Philip
Holness, Micah
Holness, Moriah
Howard, Orlando
Issa, Debbie
Issa, Issabella
Jones, Javier
Reid, Kester
Webley, Stefanie
Jones, Heather
Reid, Shawn
Williams, Jordan
Kerr, Stefan
Reid, Rosalyn
Wray, Jodi-Ann
Lee, Adam
Reid, Jonathan
Yap, Joanna
Lee, Joelle
Reid, Julian
Yap, Jessica
Lee, Russell
Richards, Violet
Lee, Simon
Rookwood, Justine
Leslie, Nadje
Rookwood, Krysten
Levy, Adam
Rookwood, Ramon
Liang, Keanu
Russell, Gillian
Lim, Robyn
Shah, Sudha
Llewellyn, Leanna
Shields, Alexi
Llewellyn, Brittany
Smith, Jodi-Ann
Lodge, Rachael
Smith, Lowell
Lue-Yen, Laurian
Smith, Nicolette
Mair, Raisa
Smith, Stephanie
Mair, Rueben
Smith, Toni-Ann
Matthies, Camoy
Smith, Tress-Anne
MacDonald, Abigail
Stamp, Alana
McLaughlin,
Sapphire
Steele, Blair
Millen, Janelle
Stern, Jamie
Millen, Jodie-Ann
Moody, Natasha
Moss, Adam
Moss, Dominic
Palomino-Lue, Eve
Phinn, Abraham
Stern, Brittany
Thompson, Gina
Thompson, Jordan
Thompson, Karl
Thompson, Sadiki
Tucker, Shari
Phinn, Faith
Tyson-Young,
Maya
Prout, Brittany
Vassell, Giselle
Raynor, Chenelle
Watson, Reva-Mae
Reid, Brianna
Webb, Mario
49
Administrators:
*Lisa Darby Walker, 1998 2000; Cynthia Thompson, 2000; Gillian
Lee, 2000 2001
Teacher-trainees:
Sadiki Thompson, Marc Gayle
50
PHOTOGRAPHS:
51
Concertmasters:
Marc Gayle
Philip Ho
Peter Ho
Stefan Kerr
Joelle Lee
52
Performance Ensemble:
53
Chamber Ensemble:
54
Combined Groups:
55
56
57
Rehearsals/Classes (Miscellaneous):
Violin Sectional
Chamber Coaching
Emily Elliot, Cello; Sadiki Thompson, Violin
Coach: Angela Elliot
58
59
READING LIST/BIBLIOGRAPHY
Allen, Michael; Gillespie, Robert and Hayes, Pamela Tellejohn.
Essential Elements for Strings. Milwaukee, WI: Hal Leonard
Corporation, 1994.
Anderson, Gerald E. and Robert S. Frost. All for Strings. 3 vols. San
Diego: Kjos Music Co., 1985.
Applebaum, Samuel. String builder. Rockville Center, New York:
Belwin Mills, 1960.
Auer, Leopold. Violin Playing As I Teach It. New York: Frederick A.
Stokes Company, 1921.
Baillot, Pierre Marie Frances De Sales. The Art of the Violin. Trans. by
Louise Goldberg. Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 1991.
Borges-Scoggin. A Study of the Pedagogy and Performance of String
Instruments in Brazil and the Social, Cultural, and Economic Aspects
Affecting Their Development. Doctoral Thesis, University of Iowa,
1993.
Bornoff, George. Finger Patterns for Violin. New York: Carl Fischer,
1948.
Bosanquet, R.C. The Development Of Cello Teaching In The
Twentieth Century. In The Cambridge Companion to the Cello, ed. R.
Stowell, 195 - 210. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press,
1999.
Brandfonbrener, Alice G. Interview with Dorothy DeLay: Thoughts
on Pedagogy and More from the Famed Teacher of Violin Virtuosos.
Medical problems of performing artists, vol. 12, no.3, 1997, 63-66.
Britton, Allen P. A University Program For Preparing String
Teachers. In The Tanglewood String Symposia, 1963 and 1964: String
Problems, Players and paucity, ed. L. Krasner, 52-55. Boston
Symphony Orchestra, 1965.
Cassidy, F.G. and R.B. Le Page. A Dictionary of Jamaican English, 2nd
ed. Kingston, Jamaica: University Press of the West Indies, 2003.
Davis, Hope Alysia. Trevor Alvin Beckford, School and Church Music
60
61
62
63
64