Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DE PIERO Z K
Writ 2
April 15, 2015
or any aesthetic appeal. It is all written in black and white. It is a very scholarly,
informative article with neither personal anecdotes nor opinions.
WhenIWork.com is a website that helps employees schedule and communicate. A
page on this site: The Pros and Cons of Raising the Minimum Wage serves to inform the
audience of the issue on raising the minimum wage. The author starts with the title and
lists several pros and cons of the case. The audience of this article would be the public,
but mainly the people that use this site, employees. The tone of this writing is scholarly
but more relatable. This pros and cons list uses pictures and colors and is not too long and
detailed. The purpose of this article is however, not only to inform, but also to persuade!
This text has a conclusion in which the author uses the pros and cons list he just
portrayed to show that these Studies from both sides of the debate make it relatively
clear that increasing minimum wage will not make a significant impact on the poverty
level. By using a factual page of pros and cons on the subject, the author concludes that
raising the minimum wage would not be the solution to the poverty level. This pros and
cons list has a comments page in which other users of this website express their concerns
and critiques of this text. What good is this article? If you say, that raising minimum
wage will not solve the problem. What will? one user said. To which another replied,
Govt cant fix poverty. If it could, it would have. The war on poverty has not had any
effect in the 40+ years that it has been going on. Many other users add onto this pros and
cons list the author has originally written up, leaving the subject up for discussion.
Reddit.com is a website made up of everybody on the Internet. It is more of a
discussion page where one user would put up a question and other users would comment
their opinions on the matter. In this case, one user put up the question What would be
the pros and cons of raising the minimum wage? He/she would write a small overview
on the subject and leave it open for other users to list their ideas of pros and cons. The
returning comments would sometimes lead to very heated debates. An example would be
when one user says: That's not entirely true. A business can't just choose to raise the
prices on things. They'll lose customers. Most like their profits will take a hit before an
increase in price is considered to which other users reply to with their own beliefs. This
pros and cons list has a lot of opinions and self-made theories that are very questionable.
Nonetheless, it is still a pros and cons list.
These pros and cons lists from different sources show similarities and differences.
All pros and cons list from the three source list have a specific subject that they analyze.
They are usually all written in second order thinking. Then they have several bulletpointed or numbered statements showing what the beneficial or harmful effects that
statement would have, in this case, raising minimum wage. All three pros and cons list
share the same purpose, to weigh the benefit or harms and inform the audience of it.
However, there are also differences in these varying sources as well. In
BalancedPolitics.org, there is only one author and no comments section. This list does not
allow for any input or opinions to be made. In WhenIWork.com the author has a set pros
and cons list but there is a comments section for other users to put in their opinions.
WhenIWork.com also has a set audience it is aiming for. In Reddit, the subject is up for
discussion to all the users. The tone used in BalancePolitics is also much more scholarly
and unbiased. The tone used in Reddit is much more opinionated and defensive.
This genre study showed that there are certain conventions that make up a specific
genre. Although these three sources approach a pros and cons list in different ways, one
can see this text is a specific textual genre on its own. Genre is important because
different genres have a different purpose and audience. Recognizing genres help the
author go in a set direction, while it helps the audience ease into the subject. In navigating
genres, Dirk references to Devitt, genres have the power to help or hurt human
interaction, to ease communication or to deceive, to enable someone to speak or to
discourage someone from saying something different. Differing genres will have
differing purposes, audiences, tones and styles and understanding genre can help both the
author and audience stay relevant.