Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ImprovingTechnologyUseinanElementarySchool
InternshipWebsite:
http://flancbaumintern.weebly.com/
MarkFlancbaum
March31,2015
UniversityofColorado,Denver
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
IntroductionandProblemStatement
IamafifthgradeteacheratBrownInternationalAcademy,anurban,K5elementaryschool.I
amcolleagueswithapproximately40teachers,specialists,andinterventionists.Accessto
technologyvariesfromclassroomtoclassroom.AllteachershaveaccesstooneChromebook
labandoneMacdesktoplab.Teachershaveanassortmentoftechnologyintheirclassrooms
includingChromebooks,iMacs,iPads,PrometheanBoards,anddocumentcameras.85%of
BrownsstudentshaveaccesstotheInternetathome.
MydirectsupervisoratBrownismyprincipal,LynnHeintzman.Shewasalsomysupervisor
formyinternship.ThroughoutmyinternshipIworkedcollaborativelywithmysupervisor.I
alsoworkedwithourtechnologycommittee,thecurrenttechnologyspecialist,andnextyears
technologyspecialistwhenappropriate.Formyinternshipmysupervisoraskedmetoimprove
thetechnologyuseofourstaffandstudents.Ihadthetaskoffiguringoutwhatthatmeant.
Ourschoolrecentlyincreasedtheamountoftechnologyavailabletoteachersandstudents.One
problemisthetechnologyisnotbeingusedaseffectivelyaspossible.Themainusesof
technologyarecurrentlyresearch,typing,andtesting.Means(2001)said,Despitecountless
networkingandinteractivepossibilities,themostcommonlyassigneduseofclassroom
technologyduring199798waswordprocessing,followedbyInternetresearchandinformation
gathering(p.57).Iwassurprisedtofindourschoolin2015wasisinthesamesituationMeans
describedin199798.Manystaffmemberswanttousetechnologyeffectively,butdonotknow
how.Asaresult,studentsinourschoolaremissingoutonpowerfulwaystechnologycan
enhancetheirlearning.Inmyinternship,Iworkedtomoveourschooltowardmoreeffective
technologyuse.
PurposeandGoals
Thepurposeofmyinternshipwastoimprovethetechnologyuseinourschool.Althoughmany
ILTcompetencieswereaddressed,myfocuswasoncompetency6:Professionallearningand
leadership.Ibeganwithoneobjectiveinmind.AsIstartedmywork,thatobjectivebecame
threemajorobjectives.Thethreeobjectiveswere:
1. Teachclassroomteachersstudentstoimprovestudentandteachertechnologyuse.
2. Deliverprofessionaldevelopmentandprovideindividualizedsupporttoimproveteacher
technologyuse.
3. Assessteachertechnologyneedstoimproveschooltechnologyuse.
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
Phase1:Teachclassroomteachersstudents
Workingwithclassroomteachersandtheirstudentswasmyoriginalgoalforthisinternship.I
plannedtoteachclassessotheirteacherscouldseeeffectivetechnologyinstructioninaction.I
aimedtosupporteachteacherinawaythatwouldbemostbeneficialtowheretheycurrently
wereintheirtechnologyinstruction.
Intervention
Iworkedwiththreethirdgradeteachersandtheirstudents.IchosethirdgradebecauseIfound
theyhadopentimethatcoincidedwithmyplanningperiod.Thisallowedmetoteachclassesin
thelimitedopentimeIhadduringmyday.Inaddition,IchosethisgradelevelbasedonRogers
(1995)theoryofdiffusionofinnovations(seeimageA).Iknewallthreethirdgradeteachersfell
intotheearlyadoptersorearlymajoritycategories.Becauseofthis,Iwasconfidenttheywould
makestrongstartingcandidates.
ImageA:RogersDiffusionofInnovations
Constraints
ThemajorconstraintIhadwasavailabletime.Inordertoteachotherteachersstudents,ithad
tobedoneduringatimewhenIdidnothavestudents.Myplanningperiodwastheonlyperiod
longenoughwherethiswasthecase.Ialsohadtoconsidertheotherteachersschedules.Time
toteachtheirstudentswasalreadylimited.Itwasnotpossibleforthemtogiveuplargeamounts
oftimefortechnologylessons.Evenwiththeseconstraints,Iwasabletomoveforwardwith
thisgroupofmotivatedthirdgradeteachers.
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
Procedures
Tobegin,Iinformallycontactedeachthirdgradeteachertogaugeinterest.Aftergettingthe
greenlight,IsurveyedtheteachersusingGoogleFormstocheckschedulesandneeds.Fromthe
surveyandinformalconversationsIwasabletodeterminewhichteacherwasmostready.I
createdascheduletomeetwitheachclasstwiceoverseveralweekstime.Ialsodetermined
whatlessoneachteacherthoughtwouldbemostvaluable.Thishelpedmetoplanthecontentof
eachsession.
Inmyfirstsession,Iconsultedwiththeclassroomteacherandfoundshehadastrongdesireto
usePowToonwithherstudents.PowToonisawebbasedprogramusedtomakeanimated
videos.Theteacherwantedherstudentstolearnhowtousetheprogramsotheycoulduseitfor
futureprojects.
Becausethiswasagroupofthirdgradestudentswithlimitedtechnologyexperience,and
becauseIhadlimitedtimewiththem,IcreatedPowToonaccountsforeachstudent.Duringthe
twolessonsItaughtthethirdgradestudentsthebasicelementsofPowToon.Eachstudent
createdtheirownbasicPowToon.IusedteachingmovesIhavefoundtobeeffectiveinmyown
technologyinstruction.Thiswasforthebenefitoftheclassroomteacherwhowaswatchingthe
lesson.
Irepeatedasimilarprocesswiththeothertwoclasses.Inthesecondandthirdclassesweused
ourtimetosetupsharedGoogleDrivefolders.Thefolderswesetupweresharedbetweenthe
studentandtheclassroomteacher.Itaughtstudentshowtocreatedocumentsinsidethefolderto
sharewiththeirteacher.Ialsotaughttheteacherhowtoefficientlyaccessthesefoldersand
providemeaningfulfeedbackusingthecommentingfeatureinGoogleDocs.
Findings
Overall,Phase1ofmyinternshipwassuccessful.Teachersgavepositivefeedbackwhenasked
abouttheexperience.TableAhighlightssomefeedbackgivenbyteachers.
TableA:ClassroomTeacherFeedback
Teacher
Feedback
Carly
"ManyofmystudentsareusingPowToonsforourupcomingsummative
assessmentinourheroesunit.Theyfeelconfidenttocompletethis
independently.Also,thetimespentwithusernames,passwords,and
logginginhashelpedmakethemmorecomfortableonotherwebsites."
Amy
"SomeofmykidsdotheirreadingresponsesonGoogleandsharethem
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
withme.Also,Ihavekidsworkingonprojectsforendofunitassessments
inGoogle,andtheywillbesharingthatwithmeaswell.Iwouldlove
someadviceaboutthebestwaytosetupfoldersfornextyear."
DianeE.
"IhavebeenabletouseGoogleDriveinsmallgroupsinreading.Students
respondtoreadingandIamabletogivethemfeedback.Thanks!"
Teachingthreeroundshelpedmetorefinetheprocess.Inhindsight,Ibelievethesessionson
GoogleDriveweremorepowerfulthanthesessionsonPowToon.Inoticedthroughoutmy
internshipthatwhenteacherswereclearlyshownhowtouseGoogleDrivewiththeirstudents,it
hadthegreatestimpactoneffectivetechnologyuse.
Ialsobelievestartingwithasmallgroupofmotivatedteacherswasasmartdecision.Itmadethe
processmanageableformeandforthem.Iwouldliketocontinuewithothergradelevels,
howeveratthispointthatisnotafeasibleoption.Perhapsinthefuture,ifmytimeconstraints
weretochange,Icouldpursueexpandingthiswork.
Phase2:Deliverprofessionaldevelopmentforstaff
InPhase2ofmyinternshipIdesignedanddeliveredaprofessionaldevelopmenttoteachers
aboutdigitalfeedbackinGoogleDocs.Duringastaffmeeting,teachersweresharingmethods
offeedbacktheyusewiththeirstudents.IsharedhowIuserealtimecommentingwithmy
studentsinGoogleDocs.Thereseemedtobealotofinterestfromstaffmembers,andsomy
principalaskedmetoteachaprofessionaldevelopmentonthetopicforourstaff.Iconsidered
herrequest,butaskedforonemodification.Iaskedifwecouldmakeitpartofadifferentiated
professionaldevelopment.Klemmer(2013)said,
"Differentiatedinstructionissomething
practicedandlaudedwithinclassroomsacrossAmerica.Yet,wedontpracticeanytypeof
differentiationwhenitcomestodevelopingourbestteachers.
Ionlywantedpeopletocometo
mysessioniftheywerereadyandmotivatedtoimplementthisstrategy.Iaskedthisofher
becauseIhavedoneothertechnologyprofessionaldevelopmentswhereonlyahandfulof
teacherswerereadyfortheinstruction.Ididnotwanttowasteteacherstime,andIwantedto
focusonthosewhoweretrulymotivatedandready.
Intervention
Ihadeightmotivatedteachersattendmyprofessionaldevelopment.ThemajorgoalsforthePD
were:
1. Teacherswillexperiencefeedbackasastudent
2. Teacherswillseeonewaytostructurestudentsharedfolders
3. Teacherswillunderstandthreedifferenttypesofdigitalfeedback
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
Constraints
ThemajorconstraintinthisphasewastheexperienceoftheteachersattendingthePD.All
teachersweremotivatedtolearn,buttherewasawiderangeofreadinesstoreceivethe
instructionIwaspresenting.Duetothisconstraint,severalparticipantswerenotreadyto
implementwhatIwasteaching.However,theparticipantsdifferentcompetencylevelsledto
powerfulindividualizedsupportafterthePD.
Procedures
ThePDwasuniqueinthatIdidnotknowwhowouldbeattending.Toprepareforthis,Isetup
myclassroomtoaccommodate20teachers.Thisincludedsettingup20computersandprinting
20GoogleDrivelogins.
ThroughusingGoogleDrivewithmyownstudents,Ihaverefinedmymethodsofproviding
realtimedigitalfeedback.Iwantedmyparticipantstoexperiencefeedbackasiftheywerea
studentinmyclassroom.Iknewexperiencingtheprocesswouldbemoremeaningfulthan
hearingaboutit.
IhadeachteacherlogintoGoogleDriveasoneofmystudents.Inorderrecreatemyclassroom
environment,IwalkedateacherthroughtheprocessonthePrometheanBoardsothatother
teacherscouldseeandhearthesteps.Ithenhadeachteachercreateanewdocumentinthe
sharedfolderandtypeashortparagraph.JustasIwouldinmyclassroom,Iquicklypoppedinto
eachsharedfolderandprovidedformativefeedbackontheparticipantswritingastheywere
typing.
ThroughoutthisprocessIswitchedbackandforthbetweenteacherandpresentermode.This
allowedmetoshowmyparticipantshowIprovidefeedback,andalsowhyIusethemethodsI
do.
Afterprovidingteacherswiththestudentexperience,Ididaquicktutorialonthreedifferent
waysyoucanprovideformativefeedbackinGoogleDrive.
1. Commentonasectionoftext
2. Usesuggestingmodetomakeedits
3. BringupastudentsworkonthePrometheanBoardanduseitasatoolforproviding
formativefeedbacktothewholeclass.
AttheendofthesessionIaskedteacherstofilloutabriefsurvey.Fullerton(2013)said,I
wouldsuggestthatifwewanttoeffectsystemicchange,wewoulddowelltoinvolve
practitionersinthedecisionmakingprocessandtovalueandsupportthatprocess.My
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
objectiveingivingthesesurveyswastoinvolvemyparticipantsindecidingwhattheyneededto
learnnext.TwoexamplesofsurveyscanbefoundinAppendixB.Therestcanbefoundonmy
internshipwebsiteat:http://flancbaumintern.weebly.com/pdartifacts.html
Findings
IbelieveIhadasolidplantodeliverthecontentofthisprofessionaldevelopment.Theteachers
whowerereadytoreceivethislevelofinstructionhavestartedusingdigitalfeedback.TableB
highlightstwoteacherswhoareusingdigitalfeedbackintheirclassrooms.
TableB:ClassroomTeacherFeedbackDigitalCommenting
Teacher
Feedback
Julie
"Iamgivingabouthalfofmystudentsfeedbackduringguidedreading.I
havecreatedfolders,shareddocumentswiththem,andposedquestions
thattheyhavetoanswerusingevidencefromthetextweareworkingon.
MystudentshavealsousedGoogleDocstotypetheirfinalwritingprojects
andsharedthemwithme.Theyseemtobesoproficient."
Kathleen
"Mark,IimmediatelybeganusingtheGoogleDocsimultaneousteaching.
Thathasbeengreatformeandforthekids.Ialsobenefittedfrom
consultingwithyouaboutwhatIcanandcan'tdeleteIimmediately
becamemoreconfidentaboutcleaningupmyaccount.Thanksagainfor
thehelp."
ThesurveysinAppendixBprovedtobethemostpowerfulpartofmyinternship.Thesesurveys
askedhowIcouldsupporteachteacherintheirtechnologyuse.Ifoundeachteacherhadvery
uniquenextsteps.TableCshowsthewayinwhicheachteacherdesiredsupport.
TableB:ClassroomTeacherFeedbackDigitalCommenting
Teacher
SupportRequested
Julie
Iwanttogivemystudentsanopportunitytotypemoreintheclassroom
whenwehavealimitedamountoftime.
Jamie
PuttingPDUdocumentsonGoogleDrive.
Kate
Iwouldlovetocreatesomedocuments,sharethosedocumentsinsmall
groups,andthenhavethemworktogethertorevise/edit.Ialsoneed
supportwithfolders.
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
DianeS.
IfeellikeIhavesomegoodideasalready,butcouldusesomehelpwith
acquiringtechnology.Grants?
Shelley
Yes!IneedhelpwithlearningGoogleDrive.Brainstormingbestwayto
setthingsupformystudentsandcollaborationwithteachersalso.Ialso
needsupportsettingupmynewKindleFires.
Lindsey
Yes!IneedtoknowhowtoaccessthedrivesthestaffatBrownusessuch
ascomputerlabsignupandsharedfoldersofdifferentgradelevelteams.
Thanks.
Michelle
Wouldyourstudentsbeabletosharetheirfolderswithme?HowcanI
keepthemorganizedbyclass?
Kathleen
CanyouhelpmesetuptheGoogleDrivelike5thgrade?Orapagefor
me?Iwouldliketohavearesourcewherekidscouldaccesscontent.Ido
notunderstandhowweareallconnectedatthesametimeononepage.
Also,Ineedtocleanupmydrive.Canyouhelp?
ItwasclearIwasworkingwithadiversegroupoflearners.Idecidedtosetupaoneonone
meetingwitheachoftheeightteachers.Thesemeetingswerehighlysuccessful.Iwasableto
workwitheachteacherintheirzoneofproximaldevelopment(ZPD).Itriedtolistenwell,and
thenhelpeachteacherthebestwayIknewhow,followingupwhennecessary.Thefeedback
fromTableBalongwiththefeedbackinTableCshowsomeofthesuccesses.
TableC:ClassroomTeacherFeedbackIndividualMeetings
Teacher
Feedback
Shelley
Iamintheprocessofprogrammingthe10KindleswithAmazons
educationprogramWhispercast!OnceyougotthemallconnectedIhave
beenusingthemforresearchexclusively.Iamexcitedtogetsomesafe
readingandlanguagegames.Iamalsolearninghowtoputcertainbooks
andgamesonsometabletsandnotothers.
Lindsey
"IfeelsomuchmorecomfortableonGoogleDrivenow.Icanactually
participateinmeetingswithoutfeelinglost!
DianeS.
Iappliedforagrant.Crossyourfingers!
Overall,theindividualizedmeetingsallowedmetodifferentiatetotheneedsofmylearners.I
workedwiththeseeightteachersinresponsetotheirsurvey.However,throughoutmyinternship
Ilearnedofseveralothertechnologyneedsintheschool.Imetwithotherteacherstosupport
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
themwiththeirtechnologyneeds.Althoughtimeconsuming,theindividualmeetingswere
worththeinvestment.
Phase3:Collecttechnologydata
InPhase3ofmyinternshipIcollectedtechnologydata.Iconductedtwodifferent
surveys/inventoriestoinformdecisionsfornextyear.Thesesurveysweredoneincollaboration
withmyprincipalandnextyearstechnologyspecialist.
Intervention
Twodatacollectionneedsaroseduringmyinternship.
1. Aninventoryofexistingtechnologyinclassrooms
2. Analysisofteachershopesforourtechnologyspecialnextyear
Idecidedtotakeonthisprojecttosupportmyprincipalandnextyearstechnologyspecialistin
theirdecisionmakingprocess.
Procedures
Thetechnologyinventorywasrequestedbymyprincipal.Shewantedtohaveaclearerpicture
ofwhattechnologyteachershad.Shewouldusetheinformationtohelpinformpurchasing
decisionsinthefuture.Icollaboratedwithmyprincipaltobetterunderstandwhatinformation
sheneeded.Basedonourcollaboration,Idesignedaninventorytocollecttheinformation.The
completedinventorycanbefoundinAppendixC.
Ibegancollectingdatathroughemail.IknewIwouldnotgetinformationfromallteachers,but
abouthalftheteachersreturnedmyemaildetailingtheirtechnology.Ithenstartedvisiting
classroomsofteacherswhohadnotresponded.IwasabletogetallofthedataIneededthrough
thesetwomethods.
Thetechnologysurveywasacollaborativeeffortbetweennextyearstechnologyspecialistand
myself.Nextyearstechnologyspecialist,Michelle,doesnothavealotofexperienceinthe
technologyfield.Shewasmyfifthgradeteammatethisyear,andismovingintothetechnology
rolenextyear.Iofferedtocollectdatatohelpherplanforinstructionnextyear.Shewantedto
knowwhichtwotechnologyskillsteachersthoughtweremostcrucialtosuccessattheirgrade
level.Idesignedaformtocollectthisdata.ThecompletedformcanbefoundinAppendixD.
Findings
ThisdatacollectionphaseofmyinternshipproducedwhatIexpected.Attheendoftheprocess
IhaddatathatIwasabletopassalongtothepeoplewhoneededit.Icouldhaveanalyzedthe
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
10
data,butinthissituation,itwasnotmyrole.Instead,givingthedatatotheappropriatepeople
willallowthemtomakemoreinformeddecisions.Ibelievethiswillimprovethetechnologyuse
atourschool.
Conclusion
Mygoalduringmyinternshipwastoimprovetechnologyuseinmyschool.Ibeganwiththe
ideaofteachingotherteachersstudentstomodeleffectivetechnologyinstruction.Icompleted
thisobjective,butwasnotabletotakeitasfarasIhadplanned.Thisallowedmetobranchinto
otherobjectives.
Myinternshipincludedavarietyofdifferenttasks.Onthesurface,thesetasksdidnotseemto
havemuchincommon.However,Ibelieveeachtaskcamebacktomyinitialgoal:toimprove
technologyuseatmyschool.
IrecognizethestepsImadeduringthisinternshipweresmallones.Changehappensslowly.
However,eachsmallimprovementisastepforward.IhopethesmallgrowthImadewillbuild
momentumintolargergrowthatourschool.AsFullerton(2013)said,Ifwecanestablish
learningcommunitiesinourschoolsinwhichteachersfeelthattheyhavevoice,thattheir
concernsarebeingheardandaddressed,wheretheyfeelsafetotakerisks,wecanbuildaculture
oflearninginschools.IhopethecultureoflearningatBrownhasbeenstrengthenedthrough
mywork.
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
11
References
Fullerton,T.t.(2013).Areflectiononmyexperiencesengagingteachersinprofessional
developmentontheintegrationoftechnologyintotheirpractice.
McgillJournalof
Education,48
(2),443448.
Klemmer,T.(2013).Help'AList'teacherswithdifferentiatedPD.
EducationWeek
,
32
(28),27.
Means,B.(2001).Technologyuseintomorrow'sschool.
EducationalLeadership
,
58
(4),5761.
Retrievedfromhttp://www.researchgate.net/publication/234606681_Technology_Use_
in_Tomorrow%27s_Schools.
Rogers,E.M.(1995).
Diffusionofinnovations
.SimonandSchuster.
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
12
Appendices
Thefollowingappendicesareartifactsfrommyworkinthefield.Moreartifactsandinformation
canbefoundat:http://flancbaumintern.weebly.com/
AppendixA:GoogleFormsSurvey
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
13
AppendixB:ExamplesofTeacherSurveys
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
14
AppendixC:ExistingTechnologyInventory
IMPROVINGTECHNOLOGYUSEINANELEMENTARYSCHOOL
15
AppendixD:TeacherHopesforNextYearTechnologySpecial