Citophon's Challenge and the Aporia of Socratic Protect “Terwo Mishima. Before tet in det, woul ie ry hatch he min ine of mpumens in the Clon which Um going ake up jt Grd sae of mn of een Inte opening sme Socrates paso Copan the hid person ad tel tim that be herd Fe somes ee thn Cio, in be convertion With aniseed Sortie dar (prs) eras he vy ped bis smo ascii) with Tasynuhs. Taking Sor” wor st xis icon ar compa, Cliopon ass it he ary was lta ie, sou alow edd on he ne hand ere Socrates be ah othr ad Diehy prised him. Then, e explains a Sorter why he must ke such bignuratitc tovat hi, nthe is nif his pec Fass on the pest of Sora teaching hich he adie nese. naly Sacre prep sch va vies ere ers la Soe dt wich ein of wl nown sages ‘heen digi ito ‘By coms. nthe fe al CHopbon explains whe is dep fstion ith testes Lee He syst, Being ately coveted by Sacate pte at resolved to prev, wt exes oh Soran wa comes eat hai deed aoc ofthe sence of vito be aie and piece af fonert ave Haw to acquite them. Bu a these = Ching compli = reir Sorte’ company no Soca ise gives ny convincing answer Sb Sy ing hms in ea pore, he vit Thay wlan tao ready to goto anyone el A the en ofthe logue Clon st Sos, To tne who ae mo yet convetal hy you to ek ues you ae of teen ae, bt a thse who are aed converte Youre ever aang Hecho actin the pet vine, becoming ay 2 ome posr of ance philosophy a Tokyo uve once wrote st ren Boh he [Strats] sproves nd ees common peopl’ ay fifeIASCA 22014) nd eto se ove nan ute wy, Oe ak tha eRe noo ely pas even al only eds he each of vis who or nvm fers to give ayo ing Thi rc wt the {Chop pots. The ecm dese a Socates by Clioghan bs carol deep ito my he! ‘Thi “snson seems ome ot oe ery an expression ofthat scalars si persia yer Ippo tilda ating share bya a es Seles ett some stags fcr rating Sere logue. Tne flowing, tan ote te conten of he tenets mde by Cinna te spony dg and 1 pinto me profound poblens seni in Sor prep el aman on he ing pins: in 1 sl shy what Cop actly deans fom Socrates the spony doe ‘Second sl hth ow Socrates i depict nit “Thi alexis the etimny of Cop's demands fom an ier viewpoint aking ine econ bah aprile and what el espns dali ie he Co adhe Goran Fh nd ly | sl ake pte vue olen of ass eiewing lhe eesti views ated! making ame evil seston. “i per a ved igloo avy pute ye ae uti mre npn, Te ae ey hn ‘S310 al se he Dep tlic re es Dea ‘SEicait a tensor ice ngewe cag pd be ay ‘Raith tl sel alten Pt ee ee See {nd Pt Chr we (Dt an Po rg son Ung he Pots Shasta ey epee ake ey ae ‘Seam ey te enc ote rcp ptf tee er Pe oe, Ket Sd, sh ah Be on eons up’ in Ch Cte i Pn in Pes at Dn 229.5 Hse ah ‘Sct me nmin lop one SIT ae stew Cpe sige sth caning ra Snot ot ‘vcr gone ety bot "fests pr rec thy hee ny ha ot ca Cn Chess Pc a0 Tero Main: Cop's Caloge [What dot Cltpon demand rm Serates? ‘lop expres demands in eis ms OWS: © °0 you wos digi stem, wha ae 6 atl Ho make of Scat eaoriag of ope vitie? Are we to Beles Hh all "here and that epitope mer thr nd gas it ly? Wil ie oe ifelong wor simply to omer oh psi vse tse ‘nave not yet Ben comer 0 tht hy I tr ty comet he (anna “Thi ically» question whi sts dep it ou ut eal a6 Pa, noe nr, What Cop requis ee 10 Bo Beyond me extn a Fognspic ll” te if we ge ha his wa aso sold we a a sk Sova an each ter, Wh Ihe mest ep How shold we ph to | wht joie? What So wey? 08873) Wats dean heres wy hy shal ein aan virtue (@ “Dow jas ie me the me flay ey hs ny. Mies ‘ull a elt roe te tr in aon ose who ate ae cor al pods heh OF te the seco ret x ot a ail bt ahr he pot of kil he pra we all "fet he il ii wht teas a wh Lei carey assis els a house ae expenty sel he Ge he rd whe he second is wh's ght Ls sre th ene res of tie alo rej me, jis a inthe eas ofeach the sl lo prodice ten wth th si ~bat wha the, are eo el he ering, he pt ‘which be ist an produces Tell 407-1) Here Cophon, applying te caf analy which wee fii with ew Pa ‘ly dogs, die heeft (a epoeounon) of asin wo eaepre, wamey (oye poe (ron) by Ce ain, oJasea 2208) (©) wba ug ag, nd aks man the shapes i’ anon Soca si fr the pecaia Thowg Cltopon hinds ot mike it xpc how these demands ee twcach x, is could be rege stb detention wh as scqueed in. ("And hati why. supp. Lge Thayne a to ayone ee Ln "mat sapere Bat you'r ly rey to sto exbting ee with :peses 1 meu ith een bol sys that you were exon e, ssyng tht | must negle my ody, yo would have esate gee ‘at ones nest aller suka exertion natin explanation fhe ‘tre fm dyad of he pale Kn of tse his ne ues ‘hats the kind hing you shoul tow 4106645, Bus on he gy of pylons (oma nd jst, Chophon ees Sorts 10 giv him a pee of ener veo wh fo do which il corspnd to the nate of his ou Thie 9 more pata pis ard an ht made in Do, whi re epee in hrc, ad sens tobe elated wht sshd for in Bat he dvd aden var wae 1nd genera an it very cee whether Clio wan obs () 2 enc rthod for racing the en, tix know the xem of et, pay sitoiosy, and aegis 0) ise of mre pl ini aie plicable ily ce ony thin) Bath fee, Inany ese, it general er partic ot, what he demand is bs i ‘wht cbs ex" which eed not nesely ba ingle ep but could be sever So we could ummaie Clon dann (CD) ina gen er efolows CI: The epi eaplatin of the ene of sae tough sowing i ile, {cD2: apiece of eon avi so ht each ann dine wih posible modem scoring 1 lee iia és, it ‘acti pa a eet "Coe re "iene tid ‘oe Campa Catge 9 329398, Teo Mishima lho Challenge Jn thie conection th simile of Kyra migh help ou weaning of {Cliopowsiwo demand I thease ofthe tf seins ae wed te es KI: Knowledge ofthe destin, which prt thes shoul head or 2: Knows ose and cata he sp to each he enn 1 nang CDI, 2 is aan to CD? ‘iophon i age o kaw ot, bt he complains hal Soca pes him wo ‘nan ther Soe wanders why Sores sa ach i wh le to [ow an here hiss fo posi SI: "You [Sere] ot hw ate)” ‘S2:"Yau dot wish se with ne” (4165.6) He sys esl uspens the fia jail nse hes, al rs Sos ta ke his tiude er Bu eee we gn a examine the eine of Copy lands, would ke hihi the fears of Ste depicted by lp ths dog by compuring em withthe piste of Secrest ir P's ‘ey dogs 2 What features dae Sucrats haven the Capon Sosa shoul be deed oh allowing ree Rs: Serato (Sel: th Soca the opening ame dog nh icy ‘pesto Cltepon Sacre 2 (82th Secaes dey porayelby Cpt. Sher 38} he Seater we nd inthe no Plas Now mot fhe though pat in the ath of 2, excep Pleat? hess on sie pin Pin the lowing} can be eared tayo te sme charters tne the of $3. I. Repo feonmon peal’ wy oH and lee 407-6) cates ody 2867-304 2 Sacral te dei of ata 4072-2 caress Protas 489-4, 380443578 (Tina 843299 ere Ts peo Dil Sly gh ew me ep Sn on SkJAScA 2208) The pricy of ul ood (47-8) cept Api 387 ad rio 757A theese perce oF knowing how ose ings so sper ole (407-845) coeds athens 2087-2427. 5. Te uct of Sora spent haf avakning peopl am seep (Ret) carspls to dpogy 31-31 the crt malo a he eel importance oie 408-090) ores Republic 3321. rin (phil) 8th prose fuse 40D) cared Republi 38146 rh Yohanan en 0) oresnds to hic 19. psc uta eecton ring (41-) cropntneC et, ‘ag 40). Rye 91-13. Sy ping ni dos a 7 ae ey S28 eis tn Ay ry Sat re Sr “he max pba pc is 8 wh wi be pond by Sez ss Rpt Tt Pomc wo ae ht tl New of Jno we Se Ser rs Wari pt tp man nny a ig hn we ics He hope. Dy enn Se seams 0 mai in as hich oi ne snd nevi ital Slee yoo he Sceues peso Clee dss te og aS, Accoring 1 Socio Se oping es nh gas fon be theo cop ig malin ner ht oon the hehe ui eke she hs oem dann poe cpt sme Ce ok te Pee scala 3 ‘Eeriiye tc ma es nee ee iy rte ‘Weems etter oe nS) Wins ‘ipo el ings a, 7A tly Pars Boe age omen wit bee coe eatin lun 3; 188 (cence ee “era we ceo Restraint mnasinmos se with Gres asumpion of 2 aig Soa whic sem anders Src (Se) gun utplenannens as prone by Chop ‘Oe eer han, S's rape to Clopin'reton aks ofthe sms share aS. He sy" al ans tole shame ore ot sh ta you wen your eto lp early ence kaw goes a ad points, il ake itm pate prasad deep the omer while ing, nye of tart th extent at Ta ab” (47a-) ‘Tiss oespndso wha Se sys inthe Gols 481-1 an eu te soared bal Pitan Ak wes above Se dt es halo Sel billy coed $3, hs et seus to sugges any tha be mai yet fhe ators el i ‘deed 1 83, he Socrates of Pat's ely logue. This alo cas 1 be of since wh rept othe gusten of eon, 41s the demand made by Ciopon lena? (On bis there cetera ‘A Ctapon's demand (CD) i etme cane be igh se he Anson conse of Sorat roti eng merely pret and evi the yoga es without ging any ar pose pide 11: CD siete Dsus he uaersans te Scat” msec rol (tds explicit Theta, bt arpably aed payed the eno) he ing of pesos Socrates tat i, ‘cntming to eanine ee ted ates Hog conch Theres, ioc ey tat the sco alert Citas biel te (62) he an, tty ea oe selected ene ld ‘eto hy Sacre anything re tan ere pratt, even tha wee simply © be ota pitosphizing mt wting wry made ans from Sone be, bat he poss ees examination ie 12 CD iene ste Socrates atl des ane Clap, nel by ofring delinte pti principle, he able ret of hing injostice ae. 1 opps ote convincing, bul there two pints whch oul te counted 1 eoumterargantsFist in view of he sila deme ae by Giancon — Pan, Cn Pst 2193108JASCA 2201) famous “Gon hlens= in Rape highly sy at Mato sel Tene uneasiness o inalisiey Aout he apr cding ofthe rst book, ‘hich ane snd nse someon wth he Tiga. AS Nusa Poin nme ent ite sae wt ayo He Plemachas wold ve bas Thee Rep had ended sk Ges wiht ay Tolling Hooks, He igh have then sch couse a is deni in Boo VIC the one ta Sse young foal eho who lst ir fh i teadtioal values Coup the pace of Incite lene. In this rent I mos eight aso in the Clio Togas sae! by Clipe just ter Cito cones a Fe tnds biotin pois sin Repti Thrsymchs appears on ete [usar the tna ve oti rend by Peers se fed Ad bth Sosa an Plein tems in pov his strat sity ween the se shapes the psi the Soctie clechas and Thrash eae fomed a rel alesis, ‘ancl ode inline yous who wee ining Honesty a ae thy should tine oo de, it were oth case, bt ant od ows eon pclae hs work in it of tunes Snes would be Ian azo ch, 01 pth a6 wel Like the ise dese inte Pond (d-e) te ae serwsy he ake Somes’ rote as Ire cgay hey see fo ete vue, won Fg oa be to 80 0 Secs th espe wl ete applet an theme hy wil ecm incl o follow Tirnysha’ teaching For this renson, BE woul oo be ‘sing tom Cobos standin. ‘Seon for Cop's qieian i soak be ood cht inthe oly Stress he iy ie exci at he in he est selva ta thse with hom be sone om vse (Po, Apt 3025 and 138 the ult Wb he a sl yyy a he Exar al pt ah tng fo te Re hd, A Nem, SRA nl ey me ha sy Pa NY otras rl taped nat i Pa hc Peart ec ot ay oon Pu as Acie wu ns ade reo irl ue eee are eT aan yee) an te “eru Misinas Clon Cha tpt fhe Rape he mo signa met ile sng the fre has te elt In view ee opi sroma beat yeni th ay vw BY dass soa emit: Some des anv Cogn rat ying define pact oe, kts eon doing ice, tw at Inthe Ovo Sota (Sed) concn or seco fre malig ie rat en lls Majer premie: On sl ever dons, ir remit: Sees oe the il. die iji, Cenc: See el oar yang hilt es leo anne he ution ow be sl chen * passat ih he sede! in perigee, stotad teen caste perl Scns ope High be smeting he ie hat Chop tn dena om Sues Mae weeded Cr a CX Cina wo so ni Sc peso den awe Sl Hans tne ht Bam CD cr, 0 gn Sten (See no ion ihe Kleen he Coo me Gone Po pve tt aedy “cate (reeronmer) Clephon ages tthe mi penis, be boke cron cng nti, wl rece oi et wl eo ad a Cat mir ei nes at lta noe er at {deck pons we wo nel e ete feta. cal, {som nto! apes wth opin A Clips onan ia se open Pats work? a ace ann es at Sx es ae p's dead y Me pe twinge be emi” ay hee 0 yt tang Ka ane Chopin Sn ae ‘Stn ey Vu Stennis re a ‘Sherman ioc rete eS) do ‘Sy wgy cust meer oa of dec ques oi ran en {PA hte ster none fino Sie CW en cs Pe ON ap Rect ao Sef, Roe Th of te Rin Pls FT in. rude Cte Ca oa Sop CodeJasca 2201 Fly wold ie tke up te vexed problem oF asp king herpes ews gee Hy schosbfoe and afer Sing Cambie woud lif gin wy Gg Gee Grote ck up the Cpa in i ook on Pitan regarded as goin wok of Pi Sil he takes it 0 be ‘etch or pen ever worked ou, a wit song pet He sys “When 1 ‘ead he Kloot am ot uric tht Pst ever beget it sacs, foe eet povided Sorter wih an answer tthe respect, yet emai, fein of Kop, The eae api Sosa as er made ston, ht ‘oa whet Pia inf cot ave answered hs om asic”? The nent slr in Engsspeking wor wo het met sG.M. A Cue, Hiatile9 he Cop a8 ht ther pps an is lage tend to be but vy ilinive a lamising, dhaogh Teapot agree vith is enchants. Tete he ver fa revew fhe sy of seolahip tl debts on the nage se any cag utes wih any ‘cat conments He ins a the atu o be wien by Pn aes Rec Tan before hut he ats eames the poy Ut 9 wien somes ‘he Intiscoeton i stein th ees Wino’ ide, yng "To Sac Wilamowite dos tat ths Ceo ca td ast the Roi, ‘won up hn ha ot ke he Wulf hog that wrk ey ey nil, sich a pupil mould ve Been Inphingtock in a very denied cho, 4nd 1 Yo ae Haws handiwork cul ane cane be inclded ang the works of the master’ stead of thi “all ppl of Wim edinks of se righ pup who so peeve ere his nae fr rating the sept plist est ook of the Repeat hi Imari mes ays fever afer ‘Nest fom the German spiking world, 1 would Tike to mon Siac, eaneske an eter. ‘As we hive sea ee, Ssmacher read he dog in ton a pero nd sappeees hatthe sogu, coming fom ane of he bes rhea hos deed sins Sooates and he Soca in gna, ot ex spit ia wi ine ash mils soe ec lene es cg ep tb o* Ter Mihi Citpn'sChalenge By coms Beans aes he loge 1 be eine, its ta te Scrat eid the ist Plo’ Soca, bat Anisho' " whee ‘Geshe inks the Soest by Cliophen i "er Paes Skrte Pino's Sorts, and eps iris a casing fom «bas Aran ‘tandoitwhick not only regres the impatnce of pec Bt ln ‘phases pai” By surveying these inept ean ny tong how dive thei pags aod the diy of ding ny dive neve tthe queso. ‘As is wel ko, ee Sigs cane bison bo i hat om ‘ein the works puis is serine esting het in ie Cambvige don Hat we ca inane bow res hesitation was he allowing word which ecnmpare bi cans of mil i ht Pl Shey from wt Shay ea ay cones a ab ee Chapin a tn Onc eyes my pfs tone eat Cone res wih ves he scan ceo tht Contra tat am oni crn Shey ed hte Acsodng fo Bowes nat oly Sings who eng ht nid The cas te yh a ving doe he wt ae in nd AE. Tylor swell She, ‘whi ited fortis by Sings as we S80 Howe msl nd Baily gid the lalogu as oie, wheres Cvs Rowe aks he pote nee” Tn sh station I hase to yer yon vey, Bt apr Fa her Sac Sy eh rr ed BE aye pie ere tomentose ‘tn hg sar onc Beg a ses aes ide ea, SEETRE neamepe m cee Beers eaten aa lecaa alter ———————————————— EO ———Asc 22014 pons for do, tet he role went weit he Haring ene tn being end’ pencil o Sores (Se) seat etl the ital sting ck to clans for authenity. Kis te ht Clephen also tears tat Strats {Se2) ec pipe othe cd, thi ert seem enought wipe out the poceing msrp. {fH very ie oe me 1 agin that Par Shoe te Copon ner ams ft te = ning the Cri, whee be ‘thi very, we tov iis th his isatsbton could sggst ow advent the a of the dale mas wee he would hoe doe neta, hs sens 1 ‘nina a the pus of asaning “one igh pap auor as Gre ‘Or ne gh ague 8 wore apie ay ht his istreton cok! te doused al wad ot only fr easing th natetie view, ut alo pia asin thal heath wold have doe enon nore show we inact Citpon sth og, not the ath afte dab an Sivas te cde oa at wht he ay abut Sacae protein this enneton one might eal Ca an Nia who pve he deiitons of messy {Gp} a ese (en) ne Cha in te Laces spect} ‘oh pri fe pert be very Soca (3). They cant however, de ‘hi dino ne they ae ronal by Soces hime. ‘Sich an argent sees 4 fave suse plas, bul then we do oot rand why th ar (Pat?) et i Sete in th opening me dae (Gel) ny someting which sands “gmewploisc” Moone the etton of the metal felch in Ree VU (S37 ‘3947 ipl iter tof henderson Dy 83 in the torte dnlops a Rew. Tere, having expe “wha et vl aes, fom dct as it cael paste, Socrates say to Glaseon a Fos: And isn't tone lang pean ato the ate agents whi ey? Fe youne? Ido’ suppose ht hs sped your nace i when youn ol st th rt tate of aunt, hey meth ting a kink ih ya ii Chit Rie at tn vie ‘ets yee npn dla ent pee ay eed sere 2S ae et ne he {Shs an Te fn en y Sse a gh se a Ue pis st ty ee the on on os ee v0 ‘Tero Misti: Clpans Chatenge of gme of contadtn Tey ime thse woe refed te by ing hers theses, nd ike pups thy exo gang, a tein hae ou han ih hare They ences a ft [Caco ‘Then when thee fied ny ad erm ef by hin a, thy Fceflly an qu al mt bev wt they el ie A "esl hey themes andthe woe psp re dei nthe fpesof othe (SI961-<3)" Thisricsm eats wat Sse sys toh on allover dota Futhenou, the yng men vo follow me aun Ofte ove He wil hoe who ate st esi he ano he ery eae ere oe ‘eple quetne hey themselves an ate ea ty 1 estono "ink they ind m abundance of en Wh ive ey fave ome lee ‘abo itl or thing, 236-6) Inanoter usge of he dol where Soc asin eis een of the un allover eho ic epee theme of mgeance clad by ‘Wty then do sae pe ena spending conibl tine in my emg? You have head hy, eaten the jis hve tld yo the whl ah, “Tey enjoy arn thse being guess ho hk thy ae wi, tare Ad hiss no amples. 33.0) Heri sid ht tee young people esque ach hr bt from Sorte deseripion wich even mets he Sehaofedenjyed by th youn it woul be ey to imagine wh wou flo ae et ag, wee someting ein he stove gute passage of Repu VIE could hae. this ‘nesion the fas eis i Newphen's Meare Ui4D-46 de sof sini, There eps ht yung Altines re eis Te ie ty relating is ies of mono in a preily Saree of chu As wes ove, Falemarhi’ view of sie refed by Snes wit ay Psite eave within Robi, Ts fst ss omg tht lt hinsl es SEER ion io he la Cte by Re ine aeJASCA 2 204) wong ts mich a he would don Aeple Vl, abut he pose epi oslo effect the pon refed by Sertich. 1s sly posible tat Pt sot eae oe ava ofthe dangerous ‘seacoast afer ving writen Bok bu a are Pls to asume, x uy ley have dns tnt set ~ whet Be my fe bp doth Plt wot the Clio aer a Rep oF ‘moe peinly and eur pking fer edi pt 3543 nt Plo, avin found opens dem be justified, then wie the rst of the Tayubte™? Wat any dss eter eich view tus so eain specie eu Tam a ne 0 exeely specie” a His sei Aoyama Gain Diversity invinoeranahts babe np SSS eegenn fein en tt meat Svea as oe ere SA areca arma t Se ta atta Sema hs Ee See ee ‘tera ad ar cari mm oC Sate end tna Tsetse fs en needed OSS be lowe ERR SA er earch amare Scorer nnuicmas te econ at Socata eae dian tas ‘ovine eo ie ni crn a acon at SLi omer ‘Reconsidering the Final Scene ofthe Aeneid? Hivoyuki Takahashi ‘Questions toe aed thou the Fina cone ‘hoe bs Seen ch contoney aoa he False of he Aen! ut somes fappers tht the mere fated soe dnsion ge the me ‘ersadowed ters bane. This per anys a pooch om den gle ted toa ta ot Bonk Toe hein ith Tare sing i een adversity nding 1 the casino be Becomes sare ht is ene thing in (24, eas the eof his dea whe i eyes ae rahe teh of ie cope selon ine 98, i gt wan 952), “Te ity of death hs exes ugestte ssa uncertain he are, Incing that of Rowe healt Fortis appeac and arse he lowing questions ree {Ith ny signe inthe extatons om bth Tar etc 916, ata 919) and Acne pr encat 940) Trt ket aii ‘2h ‘ely orn ait 5, wae they inked the pvt me of mae Inthe second a fhe on? As wl fe ee ine etl ar, ms one instating he wa to wn (he ke she cn), ut olay ed oe tnt he Tons and the Runs shed uch of hei la a Beh peoples come ent (731319) Wha mesnig Jos the death of Targa athe st Hood dpicted ol i hs ed? (2 Why dd othe pet thown by Acne Sith off Tums despite being sid 10 be fre ei (19) snd extant fons (0243?? With ‘monet and sock wave suing any wal etl oa ra meta gua ome ae fee fle fm cn reas ‘ie naar lo Sr 31 ON), ee Cpe a1), ‘Pati ith 1 ¥en a, eatin dau ei atin hn They htt ce utd pent tc Tr oly er ep iin ya er Sh te St of