“Adyton," "Opisthodomos,” and the Inner Room of the Greek Temple
Mary B. Hollinshead
Hesperia, Vol. 68, No. 2. (Apr. - Jun., 1999), pp. 189-218.
Stable URL
hittp/flinksjstor-org/sici%sici=0018-098X% 28 199904¢2106%2968% 3A2%3C 189%3A%22%22A TIRGSE2.0.CO%SB2T
Hesperia is currently published by American School of Classical Studies at Athens.
Your use of the ISTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR’s Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
bhupulwww.jstororg/about/terms.hunl. JSTOR’s Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you
have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of « journal or multiple copies of articles, and
you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial us.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use ofthis work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at
hutp:/www jstor.org/journals/asesa html
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or
printed page of such transmission,
JSTOR is an independent not-for-profit organization dedicated to ereating and preserving a digital archive of
scholarly journals. For more information regarding JSTOR, please contact support @jstor.org,
hupshvwwjstororg/
Wed Dec 13 09:44:18 2006HESPERIA 68.2, 1999
For Lucy Shoe Meritt
1. This article is dedicated to Lucy
Shoe Merit, with gratitude, for her
generosity in sharing her expertise in
and enthusiasm for Greek architecture
In the uncommonly long develop-
ment ofthis article, Ihave received
‘exceptional assistance from Susan
Kallemeyn Thalmann, who shared her
‘work on the adyton at several stages,
and from Naomi Norman, who offered
substantial help withthe opisthodomos.
Cinder Griffin Miller as also given me
access to her unpublished dissertation
‘on cult statue bases. Iam gratfal for
the generosity of these scholars, who
nevertheless bear no responsibility for
the conclusions presented here. A
Faculty Development Grant from the
‘Universiy of Rhode Island enabled me
to visi several sites in southern Italy
and Sicily Al igures were drawn by
Mary G. Winkes; the sale forall
drawings is ca. 1250.
2. Thalmann 1975
“ADYTON,”
“OPISTHODOMOS,”
AND THE INNER ROOM
OF THE GREEK TEMPLE
‘We know very little of what took place inside a Greek temple. Sacrifice,
the focal act of communal religious observance, was enacted outside, on an
‘open-air altar usually opposite the main, east, facade of the temple, while
the interior contained objects dedicated to the deity, including a cult statue,
In form most Greek temples had a single main interior room, or cella;
some had an additional small room behind it, accessible only from the
cella, Such a subdivision of interior space suggests that the inner chamber
served a special function. This study is designed to ascertain why some
temples had inner rooms and how these chambers were used, questions
that shed light on the nature of the temple itself Examination of termi-
nology used for temple interiors and of archaeological remains of temples
with inner rooms, together with literary and epigraphical references to
activities that occurred in temples, indicates a larger economic role for
‘many temples and less secret ritual than has been assumed.?
‘Nomenclature is a central issue here, as naming incorporates a set of|
assumptions and a specific interpretation. Since the 19th century, the in
ner room has been called &BvTov (adyton, “not to be entered”), a term
known from ancient sources. The usage of “adyton” in literary and
cpigraphical testimonia led scholars to consider the inner room a locus of
cult ritual of a chthonian or oracular nature, mysterious rites conducted
within the temple, However, the variety of places referred to as “adyton"
‘makes it clear that the term did not denote a particular architectural struc-
ture, and so is not appropriate as a standard designation for a part of the
Greek temple, a concept fist demonstrated by Susan Thalmann. In some
temples, the inner room may have been described spatially, in relation to
the cella, as émo868oy0¢ (opisthodomos, “place behind”; see p. 210 be-
ow). Opisthodomos,” too, brings its own set of associations, derived from
the structure of that name, widely known as a repository of valuables on
the Athenian Akropolis. Although ancient sources suggest that “opistho-
7 Ainside est end
Argos Pythian Apollo late ebay 6th - x is
Athens Zeus Olympion 515 8x20) x a2
Anemis seh : x - —ASOTB
Apollo? 625-400 x 2
Apollo Jace 5h 6x15 x 2
Actemis 2nd quarter 5th x De
Dodona Ze? Jase quarter 3d pose =~
His Aixonides Apollo Soo/mid ath added 5 x OTB, throne in cella
Hala Araphenides Artemis ahah oxi : ;
Tasion, Aten Pythion 4h x x AB
Kalapodi NI Artemis 457-426 ox1d * a
Kalapodi NII Artemis AQéetate ath x14 x >:
Kombothels Artemis oth ; x > finds ela inner room
Longa,Messenia (Building G) last quarter6th_ 6120) x >
Nemes Zeus Sed quarter 4th — 612 x x
Oropos Ampbiacsos th ; x x OTB inealla
Parlin, Boia? 700 : x >
Perachora Hera Akria Sad quater 6h - > x ——_Bininner rom
Symphalos Artemis? Hen? Hellenistic x > Batbackof ella
Teen Athena Alea late 7th 6x16 x >
Cycrapes
1a, Nawos Dionysos 570 - pomle ox 0 -
Nort Arnica
Cyrene Apolo rid 6h 6x11 (added) - xe
Cyrene Apolo sid 4th 6xil : xO
NaukratisT Aphrodite 7 : ; x
Naskraie Aphrodite late Sth ; : ss
Asia Mixon
Didyma Apollo 550 9x17 x x maisos ove spring
Didyma Apollo 331 wx x x naiskos over spring
Klsros Apollo Sd exit x x
Kyme Aphrodite? eh : x po:
Samos (om Building) mid 6tiae ch -/513 x > peristye added
Maona Grazcta
Crimisa (Ciro) Apollo Qdhalfoth 7150) > finds in inner room
Crimisa (Ciro) Apollo Isequarer3ad 8x19 : >
Foce del Sele Hlera 510-500 8x17 x x OT or Bin cellaTABLE 1, CONTINUED
“ADYTON,” “OPISTHODOMOS,” AND THE INNER ROOM 197
Site Deaiation Daten Promaos Altar —_Fetures*
Franesilla Building) nda - x
Marita,
Hipponion (Belvedere Temple) ca. 500 6x? x >
LLocriBpizephysii Athena carly Sth : x pF
Metapontum Hera (Temple B) 560/540 9x77 15? x Bincelh?
Metapontim Hera 520-510 6x12 x A a
(Tale Palatine)
Paestum Hera Basilica”) ($60) 530 9x18 x x Be)atcella rea?
Stenuy
Acgigento (East ofGate5) Sed quarter 6h - -
‘Camaina Athena? early Sth ; :
Gela Bulking - - -
Himers A Athena? 025 ; ; Bin inner room
Himera B Herakdes? 575 - -
Monte Adranone Demeterand early dth - - round Bin cells A?
Persephone
‘Monte lato Aphrodite Sedquarer6h - 2 deposits in inner oom
Morgantina =? Snd quarter6th = > ps
Selinous, Acropolis (Meyaron) carly 6b Sch x >t
Salinows, Acropolis (Temple) ea. 550 6x17 x x aes for OT or Bin cell?
Salinous, Acropolis (Temple) 535 6x13 x x BE) cuttings inane oom
Salinous, Acropolis Temple A) rid Sth 6x14 x > Beutings in inner room
Selinous, Acropolis (Temple) last quarer Sth 6x14, x >
Selinous, East Hill Hera (Temple E) 2nd quarter Sth 615 x x
Selinous, East Hill (Temple GT) 2adhalf6th 8x17, x :
Selinous,Gaggara Demeter 580 ; x x
Matophoros
Selinous,TioloN Hera sequarer6th —- 2 As,Bin cela inner room
Syracuse Apollo ely 6th oxi7 x pe
Possinte INNER Rooms, Remains INsurFictENT,
Aigina l
Conf
Conf, Roda
Delphi
Ephesos
Kephallenia Skala
Longs
Plataca
Selinous, East Hill
Selinous, East Hill,
Silyon
“Tegea
Aphsia
Axtemis
Apollo
Artemis
Hera
Hera (Temple E')
(Temple F)
Artemis Knakeatis
"A «altar, OT = offering table, B = base198 MARY 8, HOLLINSHEAD
of specific goddesses, such as Demeter and Kore or Artemis, with the
presence of inner rooms in temples have been based on the assumption
that the dark, inaccessible cavelike nature of inner rooms suggests ties to
the underworld and chthonian deities, a premise supported by labeling
such rooms “adyta.” Presumably, private and mysterious rites took place in
this sanctum sanctorum of the temple. Such an interpretation may be ques
tioned on both general and specific grounds. Several scholars have chal-
lenged the strict categorization of gods as chthonian or Olympian. Van
‘Straten cites Rudhardt’s work demonstrating that “it is not possible to
single out one particular sort of sacrifice that is typical of chthonian dei-
ties." Scullion and Schlesier have explored the validity of these distine~
tions even farther.”
Nevertheless, scholars have considered sanctuaries dedicated to
Demeter and Persephone, or even just to Demeter, as potentially chthonian
in the character of ritual.” A statement by Cicero (Ver Il, 4.48.106), vetus
est hace opinio ... insulam Siciliam totam esse Cereri et Liberae conseeratam,
and Diodorus’ account locating Persephone’s abduction at Enna (5.3-5,
68-69) have suggested that worship of the mother-daughter pair was char-
acteristically Sicilian, Citing Cicero and Diodorus, Langlotz, Gruben, and
‘others have supposed that the frequent occurrence of inner rooms in Sicil-
ian temples reflects the chthonian nature of Demeter and Persephone, and
of their worship." In fact, Table 1 demonstrates that worship of Demeter
does not show significant association with temples with inner rooms in
Sicily or elsewhere. Only three temples dedicated to Demeter have inner
rooms, Sanctuaries (few of them with temples) dedicated to Demeter and
Persephone have been identified in Sicily at Agrigento, Camarina (Fig. 1),
Eloro, Enna, Gela, Megara Hyblaea, Morgantina, Selinous, Syracuse, and
Vassallaggi." However, only one Sicilian temple, dedicated to Malophoros
530, Van Straten 1974 176, “offtandes vegas, tantht des vietimes
refering to Rudhardt 1992, p. 251 animals, selon des modes dives
“Les sactifces destings aux diewx