Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dissertation submitted to
Dr. NTR UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
VIJAYAWADA (A.P.)
DOCTOR OF MEDICINE
IN
COMMUNITY MEDICINE
By
2010
CERTIFICATE
PROFESSOR OF COMMUNITY
MEDICINE,
NARAYANA MEDICAL COLLEGE,
NELLORE, (A.P.)
Dr. N.T.R. UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
VIJAYAWADA (A.P.)
Date : 24.11.2009
3
I am greatly indebted to my respected Professor and
4
thank the other members of social welfare hostels involved
Dr. K. MUNISUSMITHA
5
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS USED
6
CONTENTS
1) INTRODUCTION 01- 05
5) RESULTS 48 - 73
6) DISCUSSION 74 - 85
8) RECOMMENDATIONS 88 -89
9) LIMITATIONS 90
11) ANNEXURES
7
INTRODUCTION
8
INTRODUCTION
There are 1-2 billion adolescents in the world, 85% of them live in
population, policies and programs in India have focused very little on the
adolescent group.
having the lowest mortality and morbidity compared with other population
age groups. Adolescents are an “in between group”, with some nutrition
problem, some common with children and some with adults. In addition,
there are adolescent-specific issues that call for specific strategies and
9
go through adolescence with little or no knowledge of the body’s impending
marriages, high fertility rates, high rates of teenage pregnancy, high risk of
STI/RTI, and poor nutritional status are the main health problems among the
The newer focus on RCH also has been invigorated by the continuing
implementation.3
for education and employment. They are taken out of schools when they
reach menarche. From the very beginning of life, girls are groomed to
Both the 1992 ICMR study on Iron and Folic Acid supplementation and
UNICEF have reported low mean hemoglobin levels and low nutritional
10
girls and pregnant mothers. Poor physical growth and stunting are the
primary outcomes of poor nutrition. The 1998–99 NFHS-2 reported that the
Welfare at central level and the Department of Health and Family Welfare at
girl children. The major thrust to adolescent health, however, was given in
the National Population Policy 2000. The National Youth Policy, 1986 (New
the population. The importance of this target group lies in the fact that they
women in the State. Various base line surveys also revealed that the health,
level.4
The scheduled castes and scheduled tribes have been identified as two
11
As per 2001 census, Scheduled Castes constitute about 16.2% and
The school age children from poor Scheduled Castes families are not
being sent to school because of the tendency of some parents to utilize the
services of their children at their tender age, in order to augment their family
part of the programme for the welfare of the SCs and the STs.
with the changes and promote awareness of health, hygiene and nutrition so
development.4
and socio academic profile of the scheduled caste children, has been
homes away from homes at places where schooling facilities are available.
The girls stay more than 8 years in these hostels. Health care of the
girls in the hostels is of utmost importance because the children in the school
12
age (5-15years) are in a period of growth and development when optimum
nutritional and health care is essential. Good health and nutrition are
among these adolescents will have permanent benefit in their lives and also
the ideas and practices will influence their families and communities. As
these girls have come out of their environment and are living in groups, they
face special risks and need extra care for the maintenance and improvement
The data regarding the nutritional status, morbidity status and sanitary
conditions of the social welfare hostels for the scheduled castes are sparse,
In this context, the present study was taken up among adolescent girls
residing in the social welfare hostels for scheduled castes in Nellore city.
This study focuses on health and nutritional status of adolescent girls and the
13
AIMS
AND
OBJECTIVES
14
AIM
OBJECTIVES
hostel.
15
REVIEW OF
LITERATURE
16
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Adolescence definition
development when young people acquire new capacities and are faced with
for their material needs. And as they change, so do their needs change with
them.
Phases in adolescence
think abstractly.
and relates more strongly to his or her peer group, although families
17
3. Late adolescence (16-19yrs): The body fills out and takes its adult
form, while the individual now has a distinct identity and have more
Special characteristics
changes.1
cycle.
5. Experimentation.
7. Transition. 10
Numerical facts
18
There are about 1.2 billion adolescents, a fifth of the world’s
developing countries.9
new risks to young people. These conditions may directly jeopardize health.8
of family and culture, earlier puberty and late marriage - all these extend the
of the world. In some countries, early marriage and childbearing lead to high
now more readily available to adolescents and threaten their health in both
19
the short and long term. Violence inflicted by and on young people is a
young.8
girls is reflected in the high MMR, the incidence of low birth weight babies,
high perinatal mortality and foetal wastage and consequent high fertility
rates.
life, and also to prevent the onset of nutrition related chronic diseases in
20
Nutrition influences growth and development throughout infancy,
more requirements for growth spurt and increase in physical activity. They
need more of all nutrients particularly calcium, iron and iodine. The need for
adolescence and adulthood, and when pregnant, are more likely to deliver
21
In order to break the intergenerational cycle of malnutrition, a special
World
For a number of years, the health of adolescents has not been a major
concern and research has consequently been limited, as they are less
22
susceptible to disease and suffer from fewer life-threatening conditions than
period of relatively good health with low prevalence of infection and chronic
disease. Mortality and morbidity trends among adolescents are quite similar
women, with the consequence that health needs of adolescents may not be
adequately met.11
energy deficiency. Most often, the BMI of adolescent girls of 13years and
above is below 18.5. The girls are usually physically stunted, a manifestation
glaring nutritional deficiency, with not less than 25-40% of adolescent girls
India
economic status of the households to which they belong and their age and
23
kinship status within the households. India has traditionally been a male
determination.3
and boys. There is data to show that in a situation of extreme food and
scarcity, the adverse effect on the nutritional status is greater on girls than on
boys. Girls in the 13 to 16 years of age group consume less food than boys.
socialization, girls tend to neglect their health. The lesser access to food
coupled with neglect invariably leads to a poor nutritional status and a state
About 30 % of the total births in the country constitute low birth weight and
this in turn leads to high infant and child mortality and morbidity. According
proportion of girls are at obstetric risk as they enter the 14th -15th year of life
with a height less than 145 cm and weight less than 38 Kg.13 However, not
in developing countries.1
of malnutrition, anaemia control will find a high place in the action plan for
Department declared the year 2003 as the “Year of the Adolescent Girl.”4
Madras showed that amongst girls between 6-14 years of age, the prevalence
of anaemia was 63.8%, 65.7%, and 98.7% respectively. A study in rural area
showed that 65.5% parents of adolescent girls never spoke about the
25
Unfortunately, the special needs of adolescents are rarely addressed
(ICPD) in 1994 has reshaped the family welfare program into a broad-based
Policymakers and planners have now realized that the adolescent population
adulthood.3
school. The corresponding figure for male adolescents was 80.2 %. Location
lack of education was ascribed to their responsibilities for caring for siblings
26
as 40–45% of adolescent girls report menstrual problems. These are mainly
girls - referred to as early marriage. The national average age at marriage for
women in India is 16.4 years, although there are vast regional variations.3
Madhya Pradesh, and Andhra Pradesh, girls are married at around age of
teenage girls under age 18 and they have a 2-5 times higher risk of maternal
death. Adolescent pregnant mothers, who are often already poorly nourished
before becoming pregnant, run a high obstetric risk for premature delivery,
giving birth to a low birth weight baby, prolonged and obstructed labour,
Government of India
27
Important relevant policies and plans that have been developed in
India over the past 25 years include, RCH Services Program, Integrated
State Plans of Action for the Girl Child, District Primary Education
Program, Balika Samriddhi Yojana, 1997, National Plan of Action for the
gender justice were recognized as the major thrust areas of the policy.3.
as the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956; the Child Marriage Restraint
Act, 1976; the Juvenile Justice Act, 1986; and the Child Labour (Prohibition
28
In view of the above it is felt necessary to bring in greater synergy
health sectors and evolve a strategy for the growth and development of the
society. While there are inter-state and inter-regional variations in the status
of the Adolescent girls, one common threat faced by the Adolescent girls is
the low levels of iron and folic acid, leading to nutritional anaemia and low
health status.4
29
approaches from the 1950s to the 1980s primarily focused on social and
less concerned with civil and political rights. In contrast, the human rights
state and the other ‘duty-bearers’ (eg. parents and teachers) have obligations
encourages one to take a broader, systemic and more holistic view of the
issue. Poverty is not merely a lack of income but rather a condition of living
issue, but is also a human rights issue and therefore requires a more
30
As per the Census 2001, the total population of the Scheduled Castes
India, with nearly 60% of all SC children of primary school-going age (6-10
years) residing in the following six states: Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Madhya
Pradesh, Orissa, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh. The latter five states are
among the most disadvantaged states in India across most social indicators.
15
In an average for India, 27.09% of the population live below the poverty
need to be fully utilised for the benefit of these weaker sections in our
society.14
However, the gap between upper and lower castes children with
across many social indicators. Estimates from the National Family Health
from multiple forms of disadvantages, example being SC, girls, poor, living
31
completed primary education compared to 70% of children belonging to
other castes.15
caste.14
preamble which states specifically, that state shall secure for all citizens,
principles of state policy in the Indian constitution became the basis of social
The Central Social Welfare Board came into existence in 1953 with a
Department of Social Welfare was setup for first time in 1966. In pursuit of
the goal, the government distinguished between the social service needs of
32
the general population and the special needs of the large groups who have
traditionally suffered social disabilities such as SCs and STs. The central
has also created organizational infrastructure for the welfare of the SCs and
STs in the ministry of home affairs. A commission for SCs and STs was also
set up. 7
school participation rates across the country since the early 1990s. Gender
and social disparities have also declined with an overall increase in school
1992, the following special provisions for SCs and STs have been
33
incorporated in the existing schemes of the Departments of Elementary
SSA aims to provide useful and quality elementary education to all children
in the 6-14 age groups by 2010.16 Some of the main features of the
programme are:
minority groups.
There are specific strategies for girls and SCs/STs; as well. According to a
34
In Andhrapradesh, the welfare programmes for the Scheduled Castes
are looked after by the Education and Social welfare department. On the
level a Deputy Director of social welfare will implement the programmes for
the SCs including the hostels. The District Collector as the administrative
head of the district looks after the welfare programmes. Assistant social
welfare officer will look after the management of the hostels in his region.
One hostel welfare officer (warden) and one care taker will look after the
state with sanctioned strength of 2.46 lakhs at the rate of 100 per each
hostel.17
The aim of these hostels is to give the triple dimension of the teacher,
the taught and the parent (Wardens, Matrons in place of the parents) and to
promote and level up the SC children’s education on par with other castes.18
35
Hostel Facilities for SC Students
• The hostels function for 10 1/2 months and even further in the
• There is uniform time schedule for all these hostels for the day to day
• Also, there is uniform menu for all the hostels at the rate of Rs. 270/-
per month for the classes I to VII and Rs. 330/- per month per boarder
• The boarders are also provided with facilities like soaps, hair oil, text
books, note books, bedding material, trunk boxes plates and glasses
etc. free of cost. Cosmetic charges are enhanced from Rs. 10/-per
month to Rs. 20/- per month for boys and from Rs. 12/- and Rs. 17/-
Hyderabad, 2000).
36
• There are 79 Ananda Nilayams functioning to accommodate the
in the ratio of 50:50. These institutions run on par with hostels and are
Health Status:
on 598 children aged 6-17 years, the common morbid conditions found were
aged 10-19 years. 233 (58.2%) girls had attained menarche and the mean age
at menarche was 13.3 years. The mean height and mean weight in all age
groups was less than ICMR standards. The mean hemoglobin was 10 gm%.
37
morbid conditions found among girls were inadequate oral hygiene (55.4%),
students of both sexes (462 boys and 314 girls), in the age group 5-16 years,
girls than in boys. The extent of malnutrition in this group was high, with the
children in nearly all ages, both boys and girls, being deficient in both
wasting and stunting in these children was high (52.2% wasted and 26.3%
stunted) with boys and girls suffering almost equally. The prevalence of
in girls (30.5%) than in boys (22.9%). Malnutrition and anaemia make the
Area of Nagpur, in the 10-20 years age group, 700 adolescents were studied.
38
401 (57.28%) from anaemia. 379 (54.14%) were having acne, 259 (37.0%)
were having dental caries, 240 (34.28%) were having nicotine stains on
(0.28%) were known cases of congenital heart diseases (CHD). Out of 700
was 16.62 % and 10.23% respectively. About 7.67% of the girls surveyed
had non-specific fever and another 8% had digestive problems. 12% of the
girls reported body pains and backache. The prevalence of general morbidity
increased with age and it was high among illiterate than literates. 46% had
39
the commonest health problems noted in these girls were related to hygiene
epilepsy (0.4%) and UTI (0.4%). Among the six cardiac lesions, two were
rheumatic in origin.23
Tamil Nadu, a total of 190 adolescents were studied. The five leading
seemed to suffer from joint pains, weight loss, poor appetite and recurrent
and dermatological problems were more common among those who had
years. The heights and weights were less than the 5th percentile of National
center for Health statistics. The body mass index varied from 16 to 19 and
40
generally depicts an undernourished population. One hundred and twenty
four of the girls had attained menarche, the mean age being 13.9 years.24
adolescents aged 10-19 years was studied; diseases of the eye, ear, nose,
throat and skin, and upper respiratory infections were found in 70%. Injuries
the second most important cause of death amongst the adolescent population
Orissa for B.C.G. immunization coverage; coverage was found as 69.5 per
children was more than the ICMR standard while weight was lower than the
ICMR standard. Chest circumference was more or less similar to the ICMR
41
A cross sectional study was undertaken on 640 Relli boys and 671
Visakhapatnam The study revealed that Relli girls attained maximum mean
annual increase between 10 and 12 years and boys between 14 and 16 years.
The Relli boys and girls were taller and heavier than ICMR (1984) National
standards.27
June 2002 to January 2003 among 870 adolescents of age 10-19 years (480
(77.4%) anaemic males and 33 (63.5%) anaemic females had poor personal
was also seen that, 30 (53.6%) anaemic females had menstrual problems like
Nutritional Status
42
thinness in boys was 59.49% and in girls 41.32%. Mean BMI values of both
boys and girls were far below the NCHS median. Over weight was present
in 0.33%.29
adolescents, 53.8% were thin, 44% were normal, and 2.2% were over
weight. The mean BMI for boys and girls was 16.88kg/m² and 15.44 kg/m²
respectively.30
state, overall prevalence of stunting (< median height-2 SD) was similar in
both the sexes, boys: 39.5% and girls: 39.1%. Under nutrition (< median-
2SD of NCHS weight for age) in males was more (53.1%) as compared to
females (39.5%) in case of body weight. The mean daily intake of different
foods according to sex were almost similar in both the sexes. The percentage
study subjects were undernourished (BMI < 18.5 kg/m2), nearly one-third
Bitot’s spots were seen in 3.33% subjects and 25.90%, 13.33% and 4.44 %
43
girls had anaemia, dental caries and Iodine Deficiency Disorders (IDDs)
respectively. Nearly one-third girls were anaemic (Hb < 12 g/dl). Anaemia
males and females, up to 22 years of age from eight states, showed the
1.3%. The prevalence of goitre reduced from 5.8% to 3.0% during 1998-99
the pooled data. Overall dietary intake of iron had declined in all age groups
(1-3, 4-6, 7-9, 10-12 and 13-15 years) as per 1998-99 surveys when
obesity in school children from Delhi, total of 21,485 children in the age
group 5 to 18 years were evaluated for height, weight and BMI. The
status school girls was 2.14% and 0.28% as compared to 19.01% and 5.73%
the upper and lower socioeconomic strata, with upper socio economic status
44
In a study conducted in adolescent girls between 10 and 15 years of
9.2%, 26.5% and 86% of girls respectively. Iron deficiency anaemia was
heights and weights of study subjects at any given point of age were far
Meerut (UP), 174 (34.5%) adolescent girls were anaemic. The prevalence of
mild, moderate and severe anaemia among adolescent girls was 19%, 14.1%
occupation, mother’s education and family size stressed the need to develop
45
In a study conducted in orphanages located in Udaipur city, the
average amount of cereals consumed by the boys of different age group was
76.2% - 91.5% of the requirements, whereas intake of pulses was only 30%
of the suggested quantities. The leafy vegetables were rarely supplied to the
children but intake of other vegetables was more than the recommended.
Intake of fats and oils was observed to be 30-45% less than what it is
suggested. The milk intake by children was insufficient. Food items like
fruits, meat, fish and eggs were never included in the diet provided in the
districts from 13 states of the country including rural and urban children
(< 12 years), adolescent girls (11-18 years) and pregnant women. Prevalence
the eight districts of northern India was 89.4 % and in the six districts of
In a study carried out among 1295 girls of school going age (6-18
46
81.8% of girls were anaemic, out of which 55.2 % were mildly anaemic,
0.6% severely anaemic and the rest were moderately anaemic No significant
higher among girls with a habit of post meal consumption of tea / coffee
urban slums in 69 Males and 69 Females of 10-19 years, 55% were anaemic,
girls of 10-19 years, prevalence of thinness was 14.7%, 37.8% were stunted,
44.8% were anaemic, dental caries in 25.9% and 15.4% with angular
higher among the late adolescent age group than in early adolescent age
group.41
47
In a study conducted in 360 school going adolescent girls of 13-18
years age group of Raipur city, the prevalence of anaemia was 82%. The
supplementation. The study revealed that role of Iron and Folic acid twice a
adolescent girls.42
was observed that 35.5% were under nourished, 3.1% were obese. Anaemia
48
MATERIAL
AND
METHODS
49
Municipal Corporation Map of Nellore Showing
Social Welfare Hostels
50
MATERIAL AND METHODS
famous for high paddy field, and so it got its name from the word (paddy)
"nelli".44 The population of the district was 2,668,564 of which 22.45% were
The study was conducted in five social welfare hostels and Ananda
Nilayam located near Madras bus stand within a radius of half a kilometer.
All the hostels except one are housed in Government buildings. Three
hostels are located in a single building but having kitchen and storage room
in separate blocks in the same compound. The other two girl’s hostels are
warden, one care taker and three kitchen staff in addition to one sweeper and
one watchman.
The girls in the hostels are attending three primary schools, one high
school and three colleges in the neighbourhood. The medical officer of the
school health clinic provides medical checkup and treatment for children
51
incurred for the purchase of medical aids like spectacles prescribed by the
Nellore city.
Study population: All the girls aged between 11-19 years residing in
hostel.
Exclusion criteria: Absentees and drop outs of the subjects from the hostel
Sample size: 562 adolescent girls were registered at the time of study in
social welfare hostels out of which 542 are recruited in this study.
stadiometer etc.
residing in six social welfare hostels for scheduled caste students in Nellore.
52
Among these six hostels four are for school children, one is Anandanilayam
(orphanage) and one for college girls. Written permission was obtained from
the Deputy Director of social welfare hostels of Nellore district. The study
Morbidity Status
head to toe and deviations from normal were recorded. Enquiry was made
about the education and occupation of the parents, duration of stay in the
Nutritional Status
• Diet survey.
Anthropometry45
53
Height- Stadiometer (measuring rod) capable of measuring to an
accuracy of 0.1 cm was used to assess height of the subjects. The subject
was made to stand without foot wear with the feet parallel and with heels,
buttocks, shoulders, and occiput touching the measuring rod, hands hanging
by the sides. The head was held comfortably upright with the top the head
was used to record the weight of the girls. Checking the scale with a known
weight was done frequently and adjustment to zero was done every time for
with light clothing and without footwear and with feet apart and looking
Body Mass Index (BMI) – BMI was calculated using the formula
Weight in kg/height in m²
The subjects were categorized into four groups based on BMI according to
54
> 25 kg/m2 - Obese
centile for age.47 In this study, 5th percentile of NCHS standards of BMI for
Wasting - Height for age less than 3rd percentile of NCHS/WHO standards.48
In this study, 5th percentile of NCHS standards of height for age were
survey was carried out for one dietary cycle of seven days in two hostels
randomly. Weighment of raw foods was done three times in a day (6.00AM,
10.00AM and 4.30 PM) preceding breakfast, lunch and dinner. The weights
of bulk items like rice, pulses etc.were recorded by an Avery weighing scale.
For any item below 1 kg, a small weighing scale was used. The number of
children who dined that day and their ages were recorded.
Environmental conditions:
55
All hostels were visited and information was collected regarding
Laboratory Tests:
WHO cut off levels were taken as standards to classify the haemoglobin
status.
56
Analysis:
Data collected was entered in Microsoft Office Excel and analysed by using
57
RESULTS
58
RESULTS
I. Socio-Demographic Profile
Table1: Demographic background of study subjects (n=542)
59
average family size of 4-6 (54.2%). There is no significant difference
between urban and rural areas for the above Socio-demographic factors.
urban areas majority were school educated (8.1%). On the other hand
illiterate and school educated were almost equal. When compared with
There is significant difference between urban and rural areas for father’s
education.
60
Table3: Occupational background of parents of study subjects (n=542)
61
Table4: Educational status of study subjects (n=542)
On the whole 35.79% were in middle school, 56.08% were in high school,
8.11%were in college education.
The study shows that majority of girls stayed less than five years in
the hostel.
62
II. MORBIDITY STATUS
63
B&C- 1.46%), clinical anaemia 41.14% and defective vision 12.36% .On the
whole 88.93% of the girls were having one or more morbid conditions,
have significance across the age groups. High morbidity was found in 11-13
In 542 subjects, 17.7% did not report any illness in the past two
weeks, 446 (82.3%) reported illness in the past two weeks. 42.25% suffered
65
III. Menstrual Health
66
Table10: Menstrual pattern of study subjects (n=273)
This table shows the menstrual pattern in 273 girls who attained
menarche. 62.2% had regular menstrual cycle, 77.3% had an average of 3-5
9.5% always suffered from premenstrual tension. 3.7% always suffered from
67
Method of disposal Frequency Percentage
Cloth pieces reused 46 16.9
Pads / cloths disposed properly 200 73.3
Pads / cloths disposed 27 9.9
improperly
No. of pads used per day
<2 97 35.5
>2 176 64.5
64.5% used more than two pads per day during menstruation.
Majority of them (73.3%) were using sanitary pads or cloths which are
disposed properly.
68
III. NUTRITIONAL STATUS
Anthropometric Measurements
2.10 Kg. The median weight increased as the age increased. When compared
to 50th percentile of NCHS standards the mean weights of girls in the present
study were very low. This was significant with a t value of 0.002.
69
Figure1: Line chart showing Weight for Age
70
Table 13: Median Height compared with NCHS standards in study
Subjects (n=542)
The median height of the girls ranged from 131 ± 6.24 cm to 154.50 ±
girls in the present study were very low. This was significant with a t value
of 0.005.
71
Table14: Prevalence of Stunting in study subjects (n=542)
was highest in the age group of 14-15 year i.e., 46.7%, followed by 50.8 %
72
Table 16: Distribution of study subjects according to BMI staging
(n=542)
BMI staging Frequency Percentage
1 <18.5(under weight) 350 64.6
2 18.5-22.99(normal) 188 34. 7
3 23-24.99(pre-obese) 2 0.4
4 >25(obese) 2 0.4
Total 542 100
12.6±0.11 gm/dl. The mean haemoglobin level was highest in 18 year age
group.
73
Table 17: Grading of Haemoglobin of study subjects according to WHO
criteria (n=135)
74
Table 19: Duration of stay of study subjects in the hostel and Anaemia
(n=135)
Anaemia
Period of
stay Present Absent Total
(years) (%) (%) (%)
<5 40(52) 37(48) 77(100)
>5 27(46.55) 31(53.45) 58(100)
Total 67(49.63) 68(50.37) 135(100)
(χ ²=0.2,df = 1, p = 0.65)
Out of 77 girls who stayed less than five years in the hostel, anaemia
was present in 52% where as in those who stayed more than five years
75
IV. Diet Survey:
two girl’s hostels. The finding of the survey in terms of intake of nutrients
presented here. The requirements of nutrients and food items were computed
Vitamin-
Proteins Fats Calcium Iron A Vitamin- Vitamin- Nicotinic Vit
Calories
(gm) (gm) (mg) (mg) Carotene B1 (mg) B2 (mg) acid (mg) C
(µg)
Requirements 1,70,680 5,100 1,870 51,000 1,955 2,04,000 85 102 1,139 3,40
Actual 1,96,628 5,343 2,643 41,800 3,422 6,13,624 279 5,002 899 5,30
consumption
Excess 25,948 243 773 - - 4,09,624 - 654 240 1,90
Deficit - 9,200 1,467 - 194 4,900
with requirements (n=85)
adequate. The intake of other nutrients was below the actual requirement
76
Table 22: Daily intake of food items compared with requirements in
terms of recommended balanced diets
(n=85)
Cereals, pulses, fruits and egg intake was adequate whereas the
intake of all other food items were below the recommended levels.
The intake of all nutrients was adequate except the proteins which was less
than the recommended values.
77
Table 24: Daily intake of food items compared with requirements in
terms of recommended balanced diets.
(n=140)
adequate, whereas the intake of all other food items were below the
recommended levels
78
Table26: Environmental Conditions of Social Welfare Hostels
Girls hostel Girls hostel Girls hostel Girls hostel College Ananda
Sl. Environmental conditions I II III IV hostel nilayam
No (n=165) (n=140) (n=104) (n=165) (n=65) (n=77)
1 Distance from road (mts) 50 50 134 64 64 50
2 Source of noise and dust Present Present Absent Absent Absent Present
3 Floor area per girl (sq.ft) 9.8 11 6 6.4 12 9.7
4 Ventilation (window area) Inadequate Adequate Inadequate Adequate Adequate Adequate
(18%) (21%) (15%) (21%) 42% 45%
5 Indoor lighting Insufficient Sufficient Insufficient Sufficient sufficient sufficient
6 Furniture Not provided Not Not provided Not Not provided Not provided
provided provided
7 Reading facilities Inadequate Inadequate Inadequate Inadequate Inadequate Inadequate
8 a. Water supply Inadequate Inadequate Adequate Inadequate Inadequate Inadequate
b. Storage of drinking water Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Not Satisfactory Satisfactory
Satisfactory
c. Drawal of drinking water Satisfactory Satisfactory Satisfactory Not Satisfactory Satisfactory
Satisfactory
a. No. of toilets 6 6 8 7 2 6
9 b. Toilet : pupil ratio 1:27 1:23 1:13 1:23 1:32 1:13
c. Maintenance Bad Bad Good Bad Good Bad
79
a. No. of bathrooms 6 6 6 7 2 6
10 b. Bathroom : pupil ratio 1:27 1:23 1:17 1:23 1:32 1:13
c. Maintenance Bad Bad Good Bad Good Bad
Facilities for collection and
11 disposal of refuse and Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate
garbage
a. Physical condition of the Bad Bad Good Good Bad Bad
kitchen
b. Fuel LPG LPG LPG LPG Firewood LPG
12 c. Storage of raw food Separate room Separate Separate Separate Separate Separate
room room room room room
d. Rodent infestation Absent Absent Absent Present Present Absent
80
The per capita floor area for the hostel children ranged from 6 sq.ft -
12 sq.ft in girls’ hostels which was well below the prescribed norm of
20sq.ft per child. The number of toilets provided was inadequate which
ranged from 1 for 32 girls in one hostel and 1 for13 in another hostel. Water
supply and storage of drinking water are not satisfactory. The inmates of all
facility for 10 children. The condition of the kitchen was bad in college
hostel and two hostels have rodent infestation. Dining hall provision is
absent in all hostels and indoor lighting was found to be inadequate in two
hostels.
81
DISCUSSION
82
Discussion
The results of the study done at Social welfare hostels, Nellore among
Morbidity profile:-
The health problems of adolescent girls vary from place to place and
several studies conducted in India and abroad revealed that the main
aged 6-17 years, the common morbid conditions found were skin disorders
conditions are of similar pattern but the study included boys also.
83
conditions found were inadequate oral hygiene (55.4%), pediculosis
Block of North Arcot district of Tamil Nadu, the leading general complaints
were general fatigue, palpitations, backache and abdominal pain. The study
was conducted in rural community; girls were not educated and are more
Prevalence of general morbidity increased with age and it was high among
1,144 girls of 5–15 years age group common health problems were hygiene
girls; pediculosis was most frequently seen in older girls, 6.6% asthma, 0.5%
cardiac diseases.
84
In the present study, the morbidity due to skin diseases is 24.4%. In
present study can be attributed to the over crowding, poor personal hygiene.
85
the present study were low as they are in social welfare hostels and are
stomatitis in study conducted by Dilip kumar Das et al. in West Bengal was
15.4%.41
Menstrual Pattern
In the present study, the mean age at menarche is 13 years. The age of
menarche among Indian girls, ranges from 11.5–14.5 years, with the current
average age being 13.5 years3.Singh et al..19, in his study found the age of
menarche to be 13.7 years. The results of two studies are comparable to each
Nutritional status
86
In the present study, the median weight of subjects ranged from 30 ±
4.69kg to 45.5 ± 2.1kg and the median height ranged from 131 ± 6.24cm to
154.5 ± 4.06cm. These are very low when compared to NCHS standards.53
both boys and girls were below NCHS standards, reason being both the
children, the heights and weights were below NCHS (50th percentile) and
Indian (50th percentile) standards, 31.7% were under weight and 7.02% were
of short stature when compared to 5th and 3rd percentiles of NCHS. In the
present study 46.7% are having thinness and 13.3% are stunted. This high
malnutrition was 78.4%.This high value may be due to lower age group.
Delhi.
87
(50.8%). This may be due to growth spurt. In a study conducted by Dilip
kumar das41 in West Bengal were 37.8% stunted and 14.7% were thin.
In another study by Medhi et al.29 52% of girls were stunted and 41%
whereas Singh et al.19 in Lucknow in his study reported less than ICMR
standards.
88
Table: Comparative frequency of under nutrition among Adolescents of
different countries57
89
In study by Patil58 in Maharashtra according to WHO Asian Pacific BMI
In the present study according to WHO BMI staging 64.6% were having
chronic energy deficiency (CED), 34.7% were normal, 0.4% obese and 0.4%
preobese. In a study by Kapil et al.59 8.1% were CED grade I, 6.65 were CED
BMI was far below NCHS median and over weight was detected in only 2
prevalence of CED in other studies when compared to present study may be due to
fact that they are conducted in communities and most of them have included both
In the present study 49% of girls suffered from anaemia, 16.3% from mild,
29% from moderate, 4.4% from severe anaemia. The mean haemoglobin ranges
Dilip kumar et al.41 (44.8%), Varsha Zanvar54 (46.6%), Aneja et al.43 (47%), Singh
90
High prevalence of anaemia was found in studies by Srinivasan7 (80.4%),
This high prevalence when compared to present study may be due to inadequate
1.59 gm/dl) is more than that of non-menstruating girls (10.69 ± 2.20 gm/dl), this
menstruating girls (12.65 ± 1.3 g/dl) more than that of non-menstruating girls
subjects had history of worm infestation, similar to the present study where
91
subjects / Mild Modera Severe Total
settings te
SWACH India 218/206 2001 SGAG*- SGAG- SGAG- SGAG-
Foundation (Haryana) SGAG/ 21.9 56.1 7.3 85.3
NSGAG NSGA NSGAG- NSGAG NSGA
rural G-17.0 61.6 -11.7 G-90.3
Kotech et al. India 2860, 12- 2000 58.0 15.1 1.6 74.7
baseline (Vadodara 19 years
survey; district) old girls
adolescent tribal, rural
girls and urban
areas
*
SGAG: School Going Adolescent Girls
NSAG: Non- School Going Adolescent Girls
Diet survey
A study of the consumption of the food items revealed that among the 13-15
years age group the intake of all nutrients was adequate except the proteins, green
leafy vegetables, other vegetables, milk, fats and eggs which were below the
recommended levels. In the 10-12 years age group, the intake of all nutrients was
adequate except milk, fats, iron, green leafy vegetables and other vegetables which
The diet survey results are comparable to the studies among children in
social welfare hostels of Tirupati town by Srinivasan which revealed deficit intake
92
of pulses, green leafy vegetables, milk, fats and oils, sugar, and jaggery in boys and
cereal based diet. The intake of legumes, animal foods, green leafy vegetables and
proteins, green leafy vegetables, other vegetables and iron in a sub sample. In the
Environmental conditions:
The per capita floor area for the hostel children ranged from
6-12sq.ft in girls’ hostels which was well below the prescribed norm of
20sq.ft per child.60 Thus there was over crowding present in all the six hostels
which might be responsible for the high prevalence of skin disorders, pediculosis.
The number of toilets provided was inadequate which ranged from 1 for 32 girls in
one hostel and 1 for13 in another hostel. Dubey and Murdia61 (1976) in a study on
was over crowding in the hostels and the sanitary facilities were grossly
inadequate.
The bad environmental conditions may also account for the high prevalence
93
et al.62 (1994) in Kerala which revealed that owing to the environmental
deprivation, the rural coastal children exhibited poorer nutritional status in spite of
94
SUMMARY
&
CONCLUSIONS
95
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
education. Majority of girls stayed less than five years in the hostel.
significance across the age groups. High morbidity was found in 11-13 year
girls.
5. The median weight of the girls ranged from 30 ± 4.69 Kg to 45.5 ± 2.10 Kg
and it was very low when compared to 50th percentile of NCHS standards.
96
The median height of the girls ranged from 131 ± 6.24 cm to 154.50 ±
4.06cm.
6. Stunting was highest (14.7%) in 14-15 year age group. The prevalence of
underweight.
found to be anaemic, among them 84.38% had the history of passing worms.
8. A study of the consumption of the food items revealed that among 13-15
years age group and 10-12 years age group, green leafy vegetables, other
vegetables, milk, fats and eggs were below the recommended levels.
9. There was over crowding in all the six hostels which might be responsible
97
RECOMMENDATIONS
98
RECOMMENDATIONS
In view of the high prevalence and incidence of morbidity among adolescent
estimation of inmates and facilities for treatment on the spot at school health clinic
diseases like skin diseases, anaemia, worm infestation and menstrual problems etc.
which are recurring in nature. In view of the high prevalence of anaemia, Iron and
materials like sanitary napkins, soaps and oils etc. in kind and regular supervision
out regularly both at school and in hostels in consultation with health authorities.
99
The hostel menus need to be modified suitably to provide balanced diet for
wash proof tiles and daily cleaning. Proper storage facilities are to be improved to
prevent infestation by rodents and other vermin. Separate furnished dining hall to
to be created to satisfy the norms of 20 sq.ft. for each student. Sufficient facilities
for reading and writing have to be provided in terms of space, lighting and sitting
100
LIMITATIONS
101
LIMITATIONS
girls and stool examination for worm infestation could not be carried out due
to logistic reasons.
2. In the present study, NCHS standards were used for comparison of mean
heights and weights as IAP standards were not available for 18 and 19 year
age groups.
3. Diet survey was conducted in only two girl’s hostels, due to constraint of
4. Since the hostel authorities were informed about the study, the conditions
observed with regard to the diet and environment may not reflect the true
picture.
102
BIBLIOGRAPHY
103
Bibliography
1. WHO. Adolescent Nutrition: A Review of the Situation in Selected
104
8. WHO. Action for Adolescent Health: Towards a Common Agenda,
UNICEF1997.
2002.
162.
toBihar.TheBihartimes;www.bihartimes.com/Poverty/anant_
105
16. National portal of India: Education of scheduled caste and
scheduledtribes:http://india.gov.in/sectors/transport/index.php. (Accessed on
24-12-08).
welfare,Hyderabad.http://apsocialwelfare.apgov.in/sc_st
Welfare:G:\downloads\APonlineorganisation_schostels.2.mht.
(Accessed on 25-12-08).
Medicine.2006, 31(2):11-15.
106
23. Agrawal.M, Ghildyal.R, Khopkar.S. Health status of school girls from
75-78
206.
2007, 32(1).
74:343-347.
107
30. Deshmukh.P.R.Guptha.S.S.Bharambe.M.S.Dongre.A.R. Maliye.C.
31. Diet and nutritional status of adolescent: NNMB, 20th Report, NIN
33. Diet and nutritional status of tribal population. Report on first repeat
2006: 43(11):943-952.
108
37. Shahnaz Khan, Aarti Sankhla.P.K. Dashora. Nutritional Adequacy of
228.
41. Dilp kumar Das, Ranadeb Biswas. Nutritional status of adolescent girls
42. Pooja Trivedi , Aruna Palta . Prevalence of anemia and impact of Iron
109
45. Bodysizemeasurementprocedures.www.cardia.dopm.uab.edu/pdf D
47. Tim J Col, Katherine M Flegal, Dasha Nicholis, Alan A Jacson. BMI
51. Behera T.R., Satapathy, D.M. Sahani, N.C. and Sahu.T. Nutritional
2009:46:106-111.
110
53. National Centre for Health Statistics: CDC growth charts. United
Promotion; 2000.
111
belonging to poor socioeconomic group of rural area of Rajasthan.
60. http://164.100.24.208/ls/committeeR/EMPOWERMENT/10rep.pdf
(Accessed on 10-1-2009).
53, 204-215.
112
ANNEXURES
113
ANNEXURE – I
II.PHYSICAL EXAMINATION :
15. Anthropometry : Ht(cms): Wt(kgs): BMI(kg/m²):
16. pulse rate : 18. BP:
III.GENERAL EXAMINATION :
19. Built – Thin /normal
20. Pallor,Icterus,Clubbing,Kyphosis,Lymphadenopathy,Edema -
21. Eye vision – refractive errors – present / absent
22. Signs of vitamin deficiency:
23. ENT disorders:
24.Congenital abnormalities: present/absent
25.BCG scar : present/absent
26. Habits and Behavioural problems if any :
114
27.CVS:
28.RESPIRATORY SYSTEM:
29.PER ABDOMEN:
30.CNS:
V.INVESTIGATIONS:
31. Haemoglobin (gm/dl):
32. H/O Passing worms in the stools: present /absent
115
Menstrual hygiene:
51. Material used during menstruation: sanitary pads / new cloth / old cloth /
all
52. No. of pads used per day:
53. Method of disposal: cloth pieces reused / sanitary pads or clothes
disposed properly
116
ANNEXURE – II
117
25. Maintenance of bathrooms - Good / Bad
26. Disposal of refuse
(Description of methods of collection and disposal)
a) Pits with in the premises
b) Thrown outside the hostel
c) Collected and burnt
d) Municipal services to collect
e) Others specify
27. Disposal of garbage ______________
28. Disposal of waste water _______________
29. Mosquito / fly breeding if any - Yes / No
30. White washing of the walls _____________________
31. Kitchen
a) Structural condition Good / Bad
b) Kept clean Yes / No
c) Rodent infestation of kitchen Present / Absent
d) Dimensions of Kitchen _________________
e) Ventilators Provided / Not Provided
f) Lighting Sufficient / Not Sufficient
g) Smoke outlet facility provided / not provided
32. Storage of food grains – separate room - Present / Absent
33. Dining Hall – provided/not provided .
34. Utensils - Steel / Brass / German Silver / Aluminium.
35. Washing method of vessels ____________________
36. If brass vessel present - Tinned / Not Tinned
37. No. of chairs and tablets in dining hall ___________________
38. Food handler’s hygiene
a) Personal hygiene - Good / Bad
b) History of passing of worms in stools -Yes / No
c) Soap and Towel provided separately- Yes / No
118
ANNEXURE-III
OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS USED IN THIS STUDY
Socio Demographic Factors
Illiterate - Who cannot read and write in any language were labelled as illiterate.
School educated –Subject’s education from 1st to 10th class.
College educated- Subject’s education above 10th class including post graduation,
professional.
Middle school - Subjects studying class 6-7.
High school - Subjects studying class 8-10.
Type of Family
a) Nuclear: A married couple and their children while they are still regarded as
dependent.
b) Joint family: Number of married couples and their children who live
together in the same household.
c) Three generation: This tends to be a household with representatives of
three generations.
Menstrual pattern
Menstrual cycle – Regular- subject’s having 28-30 day cycle.
Irregular - subject’s having any deviation from 28-30 day cycle.
Dysmenorrhea - the occurrence of painful cramps during menstruation.
Frequently - >5 times in one year.
Occasionally -<5 times in one year.
Always - on every menstrual cycle.
Morbidity profile
Current Morbidity status- Any morbidity present at the time of examination by
the investigator.
119
Fever-A body temperature (oral) that is higher than normal (98.4ºF) recorded by
mercury thermometer.
Exanthematous fever – Fever accompanied by different types of rash.
Scabies- A contagious skin disease caused by a parasitic mite (Sarcoptes scabiei)
and characterized by intense itching.
Hygiene- Refers to practices associated with ensuring good health and cleanliness.
Poor personal hygiene- Refers to practices associated with: hair with lost luster,
nails not trimmed and filled with dirt, brushing teeth only once daily, teeth with
caries/mottling, swollen, inflamed / bleeding gums, skin with diseases, clothes not
changed after bath, not bathing daily, not wearing foot wear etc.
Vitamin deficiency- Is any disease caused by chronic or long-term vitamin
deficiency or caused by a defect in metabolic conversion with clinical features of
angular stomatitis, cheilosis, bitots spots, bleeding gums etc.
Defective vision - WHO criteria of visual acuity ≤6/18 in better eye detected by
Snellen chart is taken as defective vision,
Pallor - Paleness of mucosal membranes, conjunctiva, palms.
Method of haemoglobin estimation-Sahli’s haemoglobinometer
Principle- Amount of Hb can be estimated by conversion of known volume of
blood in to acid haematin by addition of dilute Hcl and subsequent calorimetric
comparison with a suitable standard.
120