You are on page 1of 42

Results and Analysis of the Global Survey

of Improved Cookstove Programs


by
Jamuna Ramakrislina*
Project Main Report No. 1
15 November 1991

The survey itself was undertaken jointly with:


Stephen Karekezi and Catherine Gathoga
Foundation for Woodstove Dissemination
P.O. Box 3099, Nairobi, Kenya
Marie-Jo Demante
Association Bois De Feu
45 bis, avenue de la Belle-Gabrielle
94736 Nogant-sur-Mame Cedex, France
Edgardo Caceres
Center for Mesoamerican Studies on Appropriate Technology
Apartado Postal 1160, Guatemala, Guatemala

Risk and Development Program


Environment and Policy Institute
East-West Center
1777 East-West Road
Honolulu, Hawaii 96848 USA

Jamuna Ramakrishna was a Consultant with the Risk and Development Program.

The East-West Environment and Policy Institute publishes Occasional Papers, Working
Papers, and Project Papers.
Occasional Papers are monograph-length manuscripts, which are subject to internal and
external peer review, edited, and distributed at a modest cost.
Working Papers present results of completed and ongoing research and inform interested
colleagues about work in progress. T hey are reviewed internally, edited, and distributed in
limited numbers for comment and discussion.
Project Papers present research results with the least possible delay. T hey are approved for
publication by a research associate, are not always reviewed or edited, and are distributed by
the projects.

Covers printed on premium recycled paper

4s] i. 0
, -, 5..,L., )

U
0
._.)
a 0

8 '2 i a
,-.
, 2,.. -.-0-, -c, = 0
o2
.;
, -0 . > g 9 o
,a
,
,2
E
L r i 2 2 ', 1 27
s
5 8
1
n
C<S' 2 '. ' - , ' '

'
i, 2,, v ; 0. . . , -c
0
d m
.(
,ac(o a )
> o
4: t
<
2a)- - o - 0
:,,. .
.
7
1
ir
o
,'
.
_
v'
..0
,; H .. 5
g
Z
1
0
1
.3.a
2
3
o
r<. L0 e,2 z )
2
0 CJ ' . 2
,_
)5 . . , . a) .
:-r. L i a , . 0., -S A )
.,,. ! C. ,-.
<a a g
. 5
m
1
,.
.. .2, . '-f
g': c ' _ '1
2 v
Sa
3"
)a -2 .2.

- .
7.1
3 L - 52 , g
- cPo '
,0't .. .--,
2 v ,o t ) i )
'a
0H
..'
5',' a
),"'" am
,
.'a
, , ; ,,
'1,.,). 7
Z
)E,
, 5, E'6'. 'rYi
z
-' T
'7. ' 2 Et 2
2 -E
.t1' I
2
';k' .
,,
E
a
2
l.. '
gE
i
,Q
c. .
4.
E
'g
,..
- ' ,'
o .
..0 v- =

Surveya
n
d
AnalysiP
r

Introduction

onIm
provedC
P
kstverg
o
m
a
s
Resustla
n
d
Analysio
G
e
fth
S
a
b
lo
y
rve
u

E
,
z -0, -. '- 8 2 < 5t.
t
-,.,-, 8E_.0
1.4 .
,7 5. 5r . , _. .
)
rn
,-k -,z 20a
s, ). .z , f . . E
-5
= -- -.), ),..t ' - 2_-.) 2 '2
,
0
"
7
)
E 9 r- 2
n
Ca 7 _,.-': , a
-0
,0 . .F2. ' P , m.
o.
,
' v %c )r 2a e- 2
.uo I.5 .0P
-. 5
.7 ,2
T.).
; .
E

.>1 0
t
.
.
1)t,' V. ',Vf , - , , F., T .
t.., Va
4an
-
, , ,0 , , ,00.
r
t
0 c 7,..
)
.'1 0.
- r, 'E- 2 1- 8 2
2
.8 ,--.4,
12 4 .
-;-=:4- , 2
- - s-L P' '
L
.2
9 1. 2 L .r 5. -. . 0 5 :
, P _o >-..
2 85
,2
.0
85
'43
. v A -r )
0 T.- aa
E
v . 6. . . 25
i
,-..;7
. ,
.
0
2
;
E-n
n _ t 'V
,i.5a.)c,a)1
- , -.,)2 e' , ,iL' . ' 1 ' - 0 , t , r
9 -o
2
e
' n . .n- . t
,z
=5,,,. tg
. _ .:1
.,,.5
1.-- < . c4 0- n
5I5 T..
,- -.
R
,
x
,
., "
g .
,
P
ya
.., ,E
.
..0 ,-= . ' .

11 g a .
,
i

...
,..<,.
5l'''
7
F..
..=
-to
,rt)
0
a
8,
2
a
5
,..
.o6.
6 .,s
c.=
.z2-.
.2
;;'!', .,,3
8'
.E-zE
1' 72
4OD
Ta4.7'
'4F;
,
L__,
V,'
.,, 04
aE
' ) 4 a . ) 0. a )
Z0
,.7g>
:. 11'EE7' 418Ij , , ,0. , ,
1.)
4
-z =
26.6-;'1 728-i, r
. 2
7
'E 0
A.
,r , u ,ti. 8
1e
? ...2
1
.32
2
. .
i' E
v. .
._
,',-Y,'
L
-Ig
2
0-g
..-. 'ai' ' , '''

t0

.S
-;.
'
..
' c 3L
.
..2 gF ',=, 1..
,
-0 1 , ,
5
5
,, )
, r... o L E
ta,..9., o' 0cz - ,o -0 ! p
'
0.2
5
'P
'1
)
6
.7
=
Z5
,
05

:a
,E
, 'g'gC.-= d
,, I
-,
i ,
tL
,
,o
c- F
'. ,
.
al
- i
)
..

P
. .., . .
..
=
E ,
9
2 l .
; '
,
- ,
, 0.
.E,
C
.
,
4 '' a -,0
5
I
2E E. c)
2. .
g .- g cc .0 . ' . . '?= --c - .
,
5 -e ta, - 'I ' ' :-..' 3 ' 5 -:
8
'
f
.
.
7
2
E: -g. g ,T; 5
4
g ' i .
2
.)
r) 2 E
E
v
Li
2
,. c4.' '
>
- f , ,9, , , t -, .T, , 4 - ,, . , e
,; 1(yr.,
3? -22
3 E .
7
;
,
E
!
.
,-.
v>.
v y
7
1.o, . ,._,. -2. :9: ,i r,
.
5.
-5
Q
s ... 7 L
6
,
'lE.,-5 2 2. t'' 1 4 't
0,..,
E
'
,
.,
,

7
5
.
r .'?
??,2
.>
2
?
.
.
2
5
t
.
_-_
:
r
a
'
g
i -' 5.
4
_., .
)
.'2.' 1 .
8
'c
o
.
.
,F
t. ' P q
2 l
1 y
g..'a
. -' 7.., .
' a
a
.0L - ' , z 48 :, > .8 .S 'g a

, .y t
g. . I,0n t o Eo i . 9
- -0 . 2 2
g
-2-')l).8 1"a
4_ ., , 1 -g'
2
.
,,,,
0 ..
5
E
.
5, -a
0 i. 1
.
-3
,
,
p
8 4 ,
?

t
g
.

2
.
-.4
'
.
:
5
.g a- ,' 8 ' '''' t , ;' '' C . ,z1 ? , ., 2, - _. ,,,, . F
'0
2'1
' ')_- 4. . - 1, .. . .g
...
(-); . - - g
. -.-00
;0e
.

,
.
_
.
,
t

L
8
2
n'
4
8 2 1 E>
pg --:j w g, -',,2. * 2 .3
84
' t 4
0
.g
S
.
-2t.' -. . 5 2
r
a
0 a, ,
'3
,,F
2 ._
r ,. ) . c . 5 , ,94 E . g
A
5 .
5
,-'9_Si.2a,,I -,>;. .8'' 8a g:4_
'
,-.
0
13
c.;
"
i
6
(t
.q
t,E
= -' g

P
,- , ,2, 0
:'' 0 - t' 4- -04-) ,. -=2
,, 1,
& -E . i t . S; 9 2 ',77' A 5 "l0 c4
%'S
1
,
2,5
,ual2
9
,
;
;
9
S i
'
) : ; .
. .8, Et ,9. 8 g g . ' 4
, 5
- .
,a
-0,2
,7
,K
;
e ,,,,
- 2 - . E 2 .2 u
Z
-a-1,,'Y
7. . ,S
2 ; .5 . . ,
8
g,
4
-a
.
.,0
t
-,:1Z. 7 r,
,
,
0
.'e
-3
2 .-E
,$,.>., ,- s ' *5 _ g
2

)E
5
,
_
,
5 . ,. g
r,:

g, o
-1
5g
-; 2
2
,
,
.
!
8

-(E
,
t'A
'
2 ' k: ' ,,
-5:. -e, .5
, ,
,
,
t7,'5a8
1
2 ' ..
,1F'n
t
u

;
=
Tr)
?
,
-25; -5 ,,,,3 . Q 2 - ,2 = 4 2 R .75 -,,::,1 . g -'I aE ' .g, ' 7 - ', ,t.t a c._) , , L - 1 . . E-.
,
5
'rtK
,_ 1 L :
7
t..,-!' 2 .
g
c
e , ,
. E
's.f8
2
o
,
o
,
_
.
=
8c i
-T ' a '.
,7g': ,
,
z
'' '
g'-t1 9 - .2
0
,.-2 5 .
'j
.2
.o'52
.
1
.
''2 1. .
.
%
1
'

-'g5
ctt
1
,-. 4.
-2, _ .
.
y
9 ,
. , _ ,
5
2
2
,
n E d ?') r i
i
,
.
2
, . . .
1 .
2 2
E
,
.

a W ' '
- 0
," r ,
1
.
c
r

'

la.

'
I
'
6
-

:1
''7 '''''' 8 1c4 7 g t <
0 3 . : E
'i
1
= Ct ,
'
',
'
'
- r
1
t
-

t go
T t l \ . . ! - - , ) ,--,, - , ,
L t
a8
:
)
w
2
i
,
0
_
0
.

, 7

Z1

' - '

TS

'

0 ..
c,
0
3
P
,
=

t) =' 8 -',% o
E-. . 4 g, '
7;
t
1

"

I.) a -4. .
2
,--.7] . . _ i ... 5,' .10, 1 0
' z,,,-_,i.;,. 2
E TA
-S. 0r 2g L
a..
"
, - a2' 0
-0
, . 14
.
E
,
17: 2 wa ,-, " Z ' p
. 0p
4 ) o4
L.) 0 0 , *
H
,.. . , , , , 1 ) - , = L
g. ,
6
at.
, , 2
g 5 o
.
z
3 i2 .Z ,
2 '
' aF
,c)
.
L4 ..=
a
.-L. -.'.' , 4R >8 -. 0 0

A _,,.'. 0
-'1
2
f
!
=
o
E t.' F,'
=
:' ! .
bo4"; - -z o
5
rn
0o,2 5 1
--'
'
'
,
t
; . .
1'
..0' 7 1
: h'' 2
.2. 5
e
2-t
-o 7-. . ' . .'
t )--' ' 2, 7 ; - g 8 7 2 . ,,,- 2 ?-,,,
;
'
'
E
:
:
;-.!

,
"f )
:is
E
- .-2
. -.- . _
.. .=
,
-1
--.,,E3
- , .1 7 . ,_
6
->
'
8
A it 2
67 ,
--8
g.
t,.
n

3
5
- .
2a az 42 ' - , -- .8.'1 - c c0 , o
. ,,
7
'
r'
0
0
74
=
2 >, 2=
. '''' . ,-EA 92
' , ',-', > : 4
g ...
a
2';' 5 8 2
SuvreyR
esults ".
.
0

,2- oz . 7 cc
- E 5
.,
3
-C
2
.

a
t
.
8
8
1
a z'
1
u

r
.
.
7
g.
=
(
'
'''''
. , f
,

E
,
'
4
:
.
'3
,
_
=
,
.2
='
_.-., :c, , ,
'
7
' ,c .73
'E
_,u,,_2

_
.
4 q
Y
P ' : .'--'=
., '2. - E
I 1 1 , ,
5 ,E
. ' ; . '.
,.
.--2
2
,
?
,,c-,.
2
4
L
Y

;
,
9 3
'
,
0
,
)
E
- ,
i
i t 2
.2r
'
) .
-aI7
-,_. s,,. ' 2 i0_.009' - ., ' : :
.aE-,
V
,
E:'
.
2
L
-1
,
'
o
,,". . a. ,, ..o , , =
4
2 tao
. .
'.2 -.
t 73 4 ' ;
b m
0
,--,1
,) 51', . , .r k
1
i
.
2
2
5
.- c d
2 ,-,
-E
,.62
,
tI E i' -'-'
.
P
a

'
.9
t-T2
t .
c6
,...o" c.)
,. ,,..0,.,. g
'E
0
,.2
z a
.. 2
t,
, ad
.7',3.,, ,,7.?F" -E, ,7! a, 2' '3 2'. .
e
, 0.
O
b
e
l
e
v
i
t
e
s
o
f
C
I
P
s
0 z .
2
'
',8-i- - c ,
, 8
-- .- o . ,
4
-LIg'
5
,
r
'
't.-A 74
n
.'), 0, ' - ,3 , .
=
3
_
.
, .
E
'.-?
'
,'c,.4
,
.
.
.
' .
,
a
2. '
=
,c
.
t
-Z7--.,.. o-u 7 3
5
.1 .
.
g
4
)u10*2
., ,.
0
-. N ELc,-..',- .,- * .1 IE '
.
E
a
za z
3
.E
2
'
2

,
e,g
i
a
' ' 4'
-0 4.1l
'a4 e_., 0 2e -' , 1,; ? ' " ,._ ,. c 4-2 ,,,, 0 " .
To . 6 ' ' ' -5.
,Z
g '..l.2
-' ,

,. ,
"
3
= 5 7
. 'a
l=
' , g; .
'1'
,
'F -E
a
F'' --8 t . ' .
E
3
t.
.' ' 3 g
'
tan . _ ,_
-.
,
,
i
1
1

1 ue l l
. 2 "-.: .
r .,0
.
c . )'' g
0,
.
a
Ed ,i2 z. -)'22..1 n,2. 2 LI'v - - - k- 5
-F
0
4
E
o
e -4)
c3
; uF, "3, a- ,2- 2 ' 21 - : 4' -..c
--6 -8
' . , E ,:11'-2. 2- ,:,' - , 9 , z , ,, I ' d - ,,
5 ta, g_ , r9 22
n
s
,t4
.11
r
,
g
,
,

'
2
.
,
-27
_
-c
'
a
.-,).9
1
EE g4"; ',.8
0E
4
.
- ,,' ,5
i0i i 2 0
C 2
m
.
'
,- . : i
a
I
. eg
. ' d'_
.0i0 - ' : .
.0
L
,
Q
z
':c - - '8
'8 ,'
.
.0
,SE
.9
,
- = 80E
i
.z- 4
,
,':
0 2
N
4
H
,
=
-t. U
0 i .8 - -5 '
' ' 4
-6 < 22) 2 ' " 'L
,
I?,
.
a
_
r
4
,
c2
, , e,- -2 o "
ci ,7: 1 ) - 5 ' < "
,f-<
2
E
. , 2. i t
-g' ' ,?o- ) .1. . t i F',e
)5 7 . L ' ' ' '
1. 7 4
u
,f:' 2.3:_ . i , g
1
-1
li
. t , ,-_
,, ,4
'
, -,-,2 7 . '., .3
f .-8'- -5
.
2
. g7.
E
8
2
"4'7ncv5
_
' --R g 5 , 2 "V
-, ,_ E- . .2 .
,m
=
.
.
*
.
c'.
,.5. .'a
2 2 -. ' - r , 4 .
. . rd p
'-2
E : E,
a
.

E
,

,
,- .3
E , , : . t , .
.E
.
,'l1
., ,=
1 .74
.
1
-t
'.0
S ' ,b= 5
'2 0 5..5,
2
,=
.
2
'-IA
'- , E ''. ' 'r, ' 7- ' '
:3
7
.1
3
.-.,-2.,
,
8
E
'.
s
.
' ' -
,
E
i
g
,
'5-,m

.
.ea E
, 8 La -,- r
/ ,.,
R
3
E
:.,1
0
-,6'
g- - g= 5- ' 34 '- -. ?'L' ,E-- . 3 _. ;t,-:
,.
--
,..'0,.5t. E -'7.t ' - , ' " R.c 73,85E . '-r
d ) 73 2 5
- ' E - ' '
E
.
,
cr'1'..' 2
'
), 1 - ,. ' ' .2,6
E ;. - ,
0
*2 . P
,,'

,
,
5 2 . .
_ g ) "8 _c c
,
--to'
.-',aA
,.-, - 22 "c,i , ,- 01
' ' S'
8
4
.;'7,t,4 . .. . I . . 1t--1f , _,, . ,o0 -,,2c7 , - _- ' '1 't 3" l 7 c 1 , 273Qt,,,, nc 0 0 0 cmb4, =
11 0
; .
8
Egg . :
1,'4
)'2t3
d
. ,?:, , ,
. . -- . -,F_
= . 6 , . . '- ,'F
,
g
' r"
..-'
E
4
'" ' '
1
'
4
0
E
8
.. :.
.E
' 2
,'...t5
Et
w
'L'93
5 ' 1 ' ,0 a : ' s
1
)'i 2 4 5
0
.>
2
,
,'csr?
.
l,',0,a
0
g
'

,f,t 2 ,,, I '


. , ,
-o
i
t
'
"
5 5
c0k
t.;4
.
i
c
2
Q
a
8
ad
=
.
6
8
.
ad
r'.4
,-...''
2
2
-582
F
.,
3
z
Z

'
,
.
-2
2
E
4
r,
-'2
(..)
'e
.
"1
,, --'4
.

0
7,
PL.
.
'
d
E
-..)
1
'
.c1
2
:
.E
4
;
c
-.' ' 0, - =
z.'-.,.
- ,E
b i8
x7
g
i';'c.3.sA
e
,
.
'

'

4
5
.'-.t . Ee a
'=
-"
.22
1
,
r

=
."1
9i,,-,. .-z L -' .
, 3
,
1
7E
0c
'.'' =2 ' ,
'

,t,'.
'
_
,
0
8
i
1,=
''.S
,g E
, .

7
)
2'
L
.,5
7
,-,

>

0
.

444 I , ' 4 . )

, ,

- 0 , r;

0
1

0.
a
5
"
8
5
0
P

.
).
7
,
8
0
t
':
'.
-2
4
:
4
k
l
0
8
0
5

r)
3
,
.
_
n
*
t
;
o
0

.
:
_
-

4 )

T 4

4)

0
e
' - '

1'

"

,0 . ' '

0
3
.
> , -0
0 4
4 ' 3
>
,
.
1
'
8
r3 ' ' ' '
0

,I
g
.
L
,

'
'
,
'
i
t
l
7
,
,
'
'

-C , - ,

,_,.

?/

;-$

_ L

C '

'. : ; ;

' ' '

P.

6
.

5
0
0
'
0
L
'
P
.

-
, ,
,

L
r

S.2

---s

C.-

i4l 2 .14

2. & - ;

_. . , . = 0 . ,

, ) . . 0"a , ='., q 0 E
L
)
. . - - t . C-) ' t
.,_, = 2t, ,. .i - .
-'F. - 0),
r=c'- - .
;
'
C
(-. ' ,
=
.
.
,a.,) 2 0 l ' = .
g ,- g -....) 70
:'t' E5 ..23 ' c
0
2
i
'
'
' Cw
0.-- -' '='
0 0 = . -, 0
'n > , ti
- ,; ?
)
i
E
2
g
o4 n 1
.' 7:, E
t
A
0 , c -0 "
A
' E
t
-'.r->>":) 7
'
S
j
L
=
' ' ' '
4
'l 0 a
o4
=4
,2
8 , 2 4 t
;9''- 2 ,
t..E. .. 0, _
,
m
. 2 a . g r, E - 8 7,
- ;-",c
; ! ' 1 ' t t l 7,
.g
I .)
:'' - I .
5
.t12
,
z
,:s Z
-;-,
,2

..',''T '5 z . '


3
.tP r. 1' 3 ,
4
c, _ . ,
.'--'i .
5
;
.
,
'_i-,.8 3b'
' E 3.
F
'
c_ _cg , 2 l - u ',,n p . ,
' "t " 4' , , , "
'
5
.'''.g
",. a
a
=
5
c'3 ,g., -- o .
r
' '2, 4
,.'4l3
i
,
,E
7
'
*
, 2w , E
.:';-' 0
Z
d 2
.) u m a u
0
2
.
_
'9
-9'5. ' ',' , _ . , 2 _ a , - : 0 t9 1 : 4 t
,1
2
,
,
e
9
7) 4 ). , ,
4

._
c
'
' F ' m
''' c 4 . '- 4 C C C D ' ' 0
0
=
0
=
=
'z-: ' ' ' V -.
.'.,,
'
a
g
1
1
l7
,, -c
-.t ': = c
l-7
t
,
2
a-'
g
V
=i
,
3c
,
'I
,
ig
'4'. . 7 , F,c9 t L . 0 7
' . _ , -'<t,
.
t,.
. , 5
%
''tvl b
:
'
'
'.
7
2. =- Z: E ' E c F , Z9
. . . . . ,
>
'A
0
2
, -t i
2
- 47.! c ,.. 8 ,--:: - . , ,
't'. 05r 0'- 0.2 0 ' m
,;1
-g
.
1
t
'
at
.
> .,
5 .
.e
-5 : ',
4
=
2
.1tci'
-. P' , --.'
t;
- -,40 . _ : , , '
74 ' .' , ,C1 7 . ,2 ,
, -m2 ,,_2
z, LE
E
'j;%
00
0
, . 2 ,... . 2
.
"g
-n ,
>.,
..Y-t! b
u- ,
'o
0
0 - 0c
0
,
. E
.

'
-) o
6
-2
,
-=
u
.
,
.
cL,
, -. ' ' , 7 - ,
:
i'.-.t1
S
L
. , 40 .
, =.).-o
.t
1
Z
7
.,' .7 5
g
E - t'5') '2 20 L3,
E 2 , ' i'-,2
',.
"tS ,.
01
l - 8i
t
-= Y
E
_;7
15
t1
oE .4 -=t -m
0 Jz,
o -_,_
2L
r - Co ' t ;
-, -, -- ,
-8n
rn ,ir:- t ' '
' E
. 7' =0 EQ L P'7*
8.' -8
T
.
,
.,'*=
,
i
,7 7-,34 ' , ,ga
o l z
.8,e.5)..-,-r- A E
8
.01
'
9
,c ' r
L
o
7
,=2
_=7' - ' .
g
-. 2'c
7
a4). 2E
' 6 2' , T , ! ,
2'
E
T
,
,
1
4
,Q
,
.
1
,
'V 1 ,
_
'Z,-. -1S
',
'
-'
'
t
'
,A,--.') -c
1
b
.
'
'
'
Z
2 a
,''9
c
t
,
8 .
'
*
.'-. 4.
,
',. )
1
' ,
E
'
.
,' 6
r

-7, 2 E m 2 ,.,.. b : 4 73E


-J
7
'"' 5 , ! ' i , ' 7 '
1 : E
E
, ,):.. 2 tr,
, ''
,) 0, 0 2 ..,._)= 2 s :.,-7,N g f ! , ,, -g Ef- :: t ',,, :, - -,. ,
2 .
_ .s. ,,- ,
li d'' C
' g-, , , . . . E . , -,
i _,-,-2 s 7 'ra - 8-6
8
s
..
4
i s:- t3 ,
E .2
,
c ti,i
' )
' '
' i
- -,
' ,u

, L
,

et?. 0

0
8 :E

2
1
)

2C.
-R. a
M

,
a

. 94
g
:s
E
t
:
fE
4.

<

1CPContext

4.
e8
.7)

:, Lt . ' -. r 8, l ' .8 . c4..-.,


e 4
0. . 4 e . i : ,'1-,

--7
E
t H
, .
2
,..
,P ' i f i

0."
g c-)
a

.>_a* 2 ' .
- 4
2
E a
, r ,4u 3- =2 8 0 --',5' 2 a
'E
)
O
a
S
e
:
c
.
,
,
,
:
.
2

0 L- 0, .2 id.c . . . t
t 2 0 8. a,
-;'.dE.. E
.
-. ,.6, - .= H 0
0
. -. 0, ,t -tr
. 0
.
' , _ ' , ' ,,;
4-'TT, ' ' A ' 54 2 c 6 c 3 - ' ; , ' 2 '
2 0
.=
0 t .. -N
H c. , d2
- - a , ? . . - .''s
A
,. 1
al :
-,-,)
,
.5 i.-,
5
'
1.4
.;3 rA 2g. a), 1_-s - . tg ,
_,, 8 . E
.-2-,T,
-c
c
cE
,
r1 ' , ' 4
= = ,
4
7 T - ) - . 1--. t t 4
7,
0
0 -.
'
'
'O..6;- b a
'
c
.
1,d
A
7
.
-0
-.
'a1,l . 2 -- -2,
3
e
,
8
z
-F,
0
.,
7-L-- -- 2
;4
7=., , - 2 '-' TA )g . 0
-8
,..,
1.,7!a. -F,
E . = c...) 0
0
.:."r'.T
2
2 E
- = , ' - ' ' - o 16 4 - L-c , c,. 1
U
-02
_
'
0 t Il
;
8,' Te,- . . 2 -z 48 F..
-P
. Y
,.2' r..: , - . . :,-- -5
- -- .,o ,' ' -''' 2
,2E ,
''
7f,'7 ; ,
a
i,.-'
-E
o..'.
t
,l.
z'r
ii
8 s:E
- 1i
. -

cr,

. 0 -5

A l '41 0
=
r
r
i
"
Q
w ) ) U.
0

==
.0wi ,,, ,t .,_.,
r
-g E ,
L,

,.,
.);
9
,

.u 0

s.4

- = E u =
J R , , ,.,., ', -, i

19,74, 8 ,,:,.. - (
r'.. V. 2 T t 0
5 4
= ,. , u
r d1 ' 5 ts
2
2=
k,1 u0 . 2 -4- - 0 " r
lLI -5
- '
'4)
..,, 7 -0 6
'_-' ' E it
:2
-E 3817,l ;,'i 8 ,.
8 g' '' 'o
,...- L- t 13
'- , '
&
_'.
'7.,' '
o c a 9 2 -'>
,r,
Ad7 . '8 '"2
c E
-g
2
.-- 0 2 - ,_ - . --= , . .
,,'a
- . . ,)
.', E2 ,t -E
71
0 ''' a
,IC
c t .. ' S'. a.1- ), . :
,.-5
,>
'p," y E
8= .
E
-1
c Ea F
:.:5.
E
o , ' L I -", F., z .; . . 0 .
F
,78.! l0_e) 2.
L
4
4 ), 1::I
2 E . ,.
3
5
t --,:
:22a.:2 -. . . . ., L
1
>-?)
r
4
4
,
.
2 . Y
:2"pt=
;*6 - . . ' ' 7,,'
- ' . 5 '
= - - ,, E
e
n
I ,.9
*4-'A
''. g'
,
i
r

e
Q
r_,
,,,-?
8

.
,,,-,
: 0 ',), --di ..,-. )--. - =
g '
(-)
- 0 ... C-,
_ -) ---- . 7 - 7 1 5
s-".,1.
5 .'. .
.el
1 r., 0 -c 0 ; ,
.2
c.:46 ,=
, . r-.5 .: 4
- 62-=
> ,12 - F.. - 6
<

_
"g..l- ' -5 2 a - ''; - 2 E 5
t
..i4- ). 0, . ' -,7, , 0 - - . : 4 b ' g F
ri4.) H t
9a1
- - , t 6,iF,
..00
,5
,,
H L' . ' 1-' > .
:E
.
T
,z
z
,)
,
4)
_=2
: 0' 2 - 2 ,70E4?= , , o
Chaa
rce
tsircitsfS
otve
s 'F-,g
! ' g '
. ,
2-=e-,"1 L
.,,7
4
.i .
- . '
..
_
4
E
0
E
rC=
4
,c
g
u
,)8
tVE
'. 3
I,
>.,_u ,.
,,,,,', r
-A
4
_ i

,,-,0,...,; .

'

7 ;

ts suplantedb
y"sa
vin
g

2
4

P
-0 5.
g
.5 1
7
E t
,

7,-

-7
-n
,3

;.=:

0
t -
0

,',1/2
)
-

to .4
t; --E
E

E'

E
0

c D; .
, . . .
= . ,
,x .- >
- , . 7 . -" z
-?.
,
5
.
-=
-, p. i4n .. ;
2-2 .2, '
,t
,n
'). u0 ,-.
,
o
, - 2 ;c
_
.
c o- a =t1.
'E
0 1.
c
0
E-. , -.
0 >-k c) . 0 -0 ' =
6 '
7 --,
.
.
L
5>
9
=
t%
r
'
Q
.
)

E
r
g>, ,E c 2 4.L
; ,..,
'c IS
'''''5
8: 5 ,
., , .
I
/
,-4) - o
2JE, 0 .. 0' ' 0t .1
,
g.5 !
.c)t ' 5 g' %. E. ::9: v . , ' A l
,
' t. ' z'
g
7 7
-, ' '
1-.91
.0
-s. F0_,,
'
2 =
; ,2, , , ,. ,c , . , t x
_ '')? , ' '' '
E
o
1
1 7
0
'=>
7
.a ,2 ,A
c3qcsi c t ' , , -0,c'E_.t -- , ** ,- !,),
. :12
t.,11, ,
'L
8
' E.0
. ; 1r''L
5o4,.,
- - A t. o7I t: j 6 N, T0
..:
). .>
,
g

0.0 2- t . .1.' r
..
,-..tgE. 22 ..?...,
o . ..0 11
,
.
72 ,
-'.
-.- w
02
P _
h13,'
,,,0..C0 0c2
E
,
-,
2
9
7(;'t FE' ;,0 , -E
E
16 .5- ;8
0
0 ,
.7
7 $i
,
.
.245.'5-.";;3
C'
S
W
g
c
.,
7 ' )- g ,
8
8
,
"
_
,
o
=
,
'-1g
).
,....
,
2
. ..., - 0
,'77g
6
't-02, 5-- 5
T
S'
o E
0
=
A

0
= a- 2, , E
- - --,,,'-- E- : -tl' E
o.
- .> >, - o or
--a-a
.
-,' E V ,, , ) ,
* ,5 - 0 t9 5 = 2 = ..1
-.-?.=i , ,2 m
2
0
,
a
2
)5-' ,-; g g t
'
'
'
'
13 E
' ,. - c .=.
- E5
- C .
.
4
.a4
a
,H
_
.78
ic, 1 L
E
.
2 8 .?-_. %), ,
2. ,..
>
t :
.t,
. _a.,
t '
,
2
.'7
,- 2, 2 ----.'
, .
il 0 g 0
0 t=
ci-L

E37
ID
>,
,.4 =1-. --0 ---7, , ' -, ,
.

,
,nrn,E- . E 2 . ,. ,---,. =, . . 4f . , 2 0 . 5 , q 0
V : ?.5
,
0= ,. g z . , . .= _ . la
-2

.i . 2 C 1,4 !1
-.6
4,
e l
J
4
0 z
-2
, ;.7o
?tE E _
i
t
.
0 7
rE_ 2- 2 - rr, -8 '-_-
t 1 ' -, '
=
::: 'e:T 1 .
z
j> g. =0 . .0) Ko3 , . E,
..f..12
.
.
5
5
I ) V

.
,

t
)
.
.

.
E 8
1
c41'4.,EcA
? t )

-12 t o
F
-E' - ;
5
-c
37
'g
;;'

5 3 -3

cg
5

F7E, -.8 =
,

M
,

)
e,

a- .
-0, - .
7
!'T7
5
-C
..
.; !
),; . '
7.
1
.1'.
,' '
1
'0,
iy)
4,
)t
,' '
.d:
'7
C
z

1
1

'

'
6

,
H
:
7
4
=
o

77
;

D-

c t

- 5

+
-2 " -': ' m
7 .
3
oe. . 2. t
,
... m ?
Q)o
;_'_J
t.7z. E
7_ . .E 5
a
ki
, .. i- f
_ . :2 2 g 7.,5 ,,.-.,
8
u
-:.
: , - , = .- - I v ,
.
6' e-1 = L. 8.41
-,,,
6..! 0
''2l C.)
zl.. 9 ,' za - ,.7 Q - - =
b
5 :' T, ,c ,
..E -25 ; ,
"
,
;:i
; ,,Ar.ra6 .
".. :
:
L
4 -_ u
-2
.=' zP - 7 5 ,
.
,7

p 2

a:
p u
t ,.t E :
g c
.rE
. 1 . * ' ' - ' 0 t'o > . - - . > , a
8
.t 2 . g 'r. i F . - : E - l o ' 7 ' L - L z . - - '
.C '
2
.
,.=
o 2' ,- v.1 -;
-. 2
8 ..2

-0
1
. s -' txi- _.
. v.,.,z!
. 22
'7
'
8, . R
K :', -8 ,7,7
.5
'
;
_
,-,
-= C ,,3
.2
,_
m!K,
4 _*)
: .,
J 0.I -E ; '
L2
;,., i "l, . T '
IF
=
.
'
2
'
0
4E ,- -' t
. 0; 02
7
.'-3.)
8;. c .) * > - =
.C-2
9
1
3
'
-,.c , :. .2 " . 2 , :'z,8
.
,
-',-E
4 ar7 7 42E
=
,1
00
.' a
-F,1.a' *')' , . 8 )' 5
,
-D"'.
'
=
-oE
2 -p' , . . E
't 3Z,, z. _ : a
8
'092 .2
rv
'19-.' 8 " L .
- '
2
E
3
0
;:.'' 1
. T- ,
,
72
.
=
g .
>.r'. . :
.8
r
-e,.'>- 2- ' , =
"o
=
. 3, .
t' A
)
L
',0
E
8
t
=
'a
".6,oe0 v. A E

n -. ) .
4ft,- .- . t- n. '. 1
2
-23'f- '
4
.I,s
.0
:
,=. ' '
,
r-c: .= 8
ai. :
.
,
E
.-2>

,
-,,i 3., =
_

--r ,.
5
a
.m ,
_
'- )0
.:', ,
2
4 0
0
1
s,- -,
%
...- l2
2

o
. i
:
2 :
, P
5
-a-,- '
-, ,
-.--1 =
'
0
2
,r1- ,
,
I
,005 .
7 ,
Y
(,:7
.
1 ,L
)t:_
4
*9
>
-,
2
'
,-,- .' -,
'
8

'
- .,
p
-',
,
0,
7
-0t
,
'c, 2

0 8.
2

0
g
, N
1
2 .
5
Z
!
a
.
0
_
.

.)

O 0 - _
F
,0 0 ;

a
- 7
2 4 ) 4-)
.
.
r3
5 ,,-=,419F-.4. -E
. . x ;
E
--.., i , T:
-zi
4 . E - 0 ',-,', ,F, o
, . 0. ' $2 0,
. . - . - ,. 9 , ;-,
, E
.
--': 0
> - u. ra l 9 2
4
) 0 -L.,. -z
, i ')
s L , _ I D d . ) d : , . -a,'
E
. 6 r.
7
..

.,L't.,-,'.,rt
_
-.2 .sl
, !
1
.
',-.) 0 !,..,
c - .1. ' ,,-. r. 5 --.
..t? F--- 2 -,t1
7
;
'
E
-FI 0a 1 : 25 . . L2 . 2 2 7; CD =
,t- .
6J 5
- ' a
>r .
, I
d .a
)
0 'Tr) > -,
' 0- .- . , 2_
'
r -

- o'
0 -2
t
0
0
=
Q
:
_
5
:
a
:
a
7:,
i
:
--;
i
7
t
'
1 ,
L

1
0
P
-

,.4 , .

,-0

0 3

t
,

.
0
>, ,-,
5
...--.. '
. 0

.2,-, .-- g R. . 2*5 '= 12


.
. 5
E '
2
e
6
- ,--,',
g ' ( '0' , E
L,Ec,(.3
a -A 1 r , - -,,L
2 F,0
40
0 , . - -Eu
1 .,0;1 0j, ' x- - ,
0
. -5,. . 2 a c-) -d -a , ,
-.Z :46.
,,,
,
A
04 -.o 0, E--, 5 , 4
,
('a
,. a C,..) , '-a'.' ,, t >_:-, - 0 c _= ,0
5
.
2
-4
y ,
'
'i,5
0. ' )7.cj ' ,0.0 4 65 9a
2,
'.
2. 4- a
t
, . , ;
,4-c,
-0
)
, .5 . z - = . -,
5
z'--.. , .22
; . T.; r
2sr
e
a
c,-,-'75 ,.2 u-, i - o

-0) - ' , 1 I.t , 10

Z -c -

t" :f
5
- ,u 0 ' , - 01 - 5 ' " l a 2
'' g
- ?
1 c -. E73 ,.?, 0 '''' 5,- LL.. '
) Z'.. - a
5

E
,
!....'' 7 , 4
0
1
. _.
--. ., ., . .
, - -E-_ N e, '''
,
5 .
4
t=
c
..
,c'A_' II'''ro -5. u -,. 0
,
E
.
.
2
4
5
-. ' ' 8
5
..,
4
ILI - 6 -,
, 0 7._, .34 . -c
a
J4 o- -), ' L
2
,
=
a
,

a
tm
o
t.g
t, -.2
4)., t, a . 0
,
.
'
)'
c
2 t ,, 3 -..4
i',-5)
.1
a
-',,- o7- , :.3
',5E :=.%. s, 4; - . '
?
5
i
'
,_
0
,3- 5-z 4 1 )
1

,g
,, .?
g
c
2
1
8 D
t
= , : i -= " " '
-e
'. ..q
_
= 'a' _ -1 5
-= .
=..-1
cg-P2r)
.-, 0,g
- , 2 0,E,
a
4 ) 4 ) -I. "r,0L 7
a,
a
'
1
4
--1,,.-, ,a1
=
' ,'t , , , .
0 0.1 .,). ;,.. , i e 3 4-40
n - ., , . . . -14'-,;= a
.
)- 5za-,,2 =5,- -=. , -- _a
,a
--3=.:.,=.-,t .
7=,f = . c 4-. -c) - ' - 4 . ,-, 'E.: 5 't S I) - . - >-, a 0 :,; a
,0
'
s, '1
.
=:- .., 9.
< , .
f
,
9
r,-5.0 A
,.m
zP
.,,. . ,4 , >., ,'2-.-,c4247,,7'74-3-,.e0-,'121-01,--.=r-, -c,,,,
,
,
)
. 1
,7,.., -0 1, 2
5
. . . , ...: 7--E, cqcE, st , ).4.-'.
. -7 E
0 -, , 0=
7 . .
,' i =
.
. F.,,
. . p, =
., , F,) -,r.' E
.-.; 1
0
=
1
y
,0.''.'a, 3).,-c ET
.*-3
=
1
. I 5 3 F -> ,
-=
,a
,a -o
3
,m
sr. :2,,,-,''. Ft, E
' ' ',,'
P . -;'. t' E 74 ,?,' 12 TA -,',-c-) ''' :: t
4
: -,,,
,
I>
'.t.'2>
-F '72 - ,.0 ,4' , , .
.
,.-
; E
0
7
,
l2L.Ia', ,'t' .t re) - . 5 '
d
,0 .g
)
.-0
I',.E
t
- .0
c
5 r
-o . .
,, s
,
'-;-7;E
=
4
L
0
L

,
.
.,
,
,
,
,
=
_
=
,,
,
...
,..
=

-i
'
i
2
,7 g s.
2
'-z -'8S_
.;p
i0c -- 0 = .-,
,
z
.
.
' '2F'
t
8,..1
,:
t
.0-F
,4
L 5
'E
'i,. . ,r ,E ,' 8,
o
c
-=
'-'.4J- 5
,H V. , '0=
.
'
7
6
2-.-,0_
'. 5= _,
F
'
cr ,,-'
_
.=.0I
.N:_)c r5 . ;'
.
3.2, ,, -= , .
1
-7,1g

L
E
9 '
=
,0.>'ia,". '00 -, '2, 2
,.'
.,4 ,. F5,
ba , S
.
P
2
>
0
0
'

t,
- r ,0 : ! ='
9
,
.:', ! - ) . ,-', ' t b
.
c
,
, Eg - i'3' : '
,c)
.,, , , _ -E , 5t := ,,,
E
.' - ' ' 0_ . '..E' -'
t - ' ' 73
.i , - . . . " ' a. :it2 ' ' &E ,''?.., , .
c ' P
5
'
,
'aF
, ' .: ,s! .: e2
2A ,.;-: -- 2
' '
E
'
_
2

E' E '

- ..

t
_
a

7 ; ? .,.

E ;'3' .1-3 'FF


s P '5 2

F,
=
: ....,, 7 E 6 2 , 1 I '...?, Y ,2
.o5 E' ' ' I f 7?: t ; , ' 8 _ , , ,
Z
a
-8 . c . .' . - - :
g;- E 5 . . . :5 ) L
o
10'e ..T1g, 1 - s z , ,
i
I', -5, 1
t
. , 2 2 t . 2 : 8 >' 6- - .
a
,
24

g,, 2 E &
c )1 g 1
:4
1
.1.0' m-, . . "1' - =
--7
,,
.
- 2 ' a '6 2
i
')i0
r-.:1 0== ,=., , -, ', 8, )( , -- 4: , 0 .c.. ,,:_.. . 11 'E ,
W
e
- . -7- - 1
- ' . .4
, V-1
go=V
, = ,r , j, 0 .. .9. ,. i Ci= f 0 ,3 , , t 52 - to o 0, 4
.I'-,; .?,
6 .'I ,. 9 ' , '-, , . . .
P tt: - ., P ,'',%' 'is
z;,'
-1
r
igia r ',,-'3 ' " -.9 171-, , - , 5 . , , , - > , , , - - L I , ,1--
g
.-,-r ta ' k1 2
- o . . ,:. , 14
z 2
-
,... . .
0u
5
= '
c
18 . - 6 - a c r. . .
,;,> 54)
5 , 7 ,4 5L : '- , 12
,
.,C
-=
tc '-," , c , d -,,. : )' . . ) .',2 0 C. 9 5
E
Q C'''
L
-' F,; . ' .: ' a .E. -5-. .,., . ,_. F
cc2 3
,0
cl
.=
..o os:. r : ' .
v- "
,, .
'
5 ' '
11
L
o
.
.
C I . , '
, ,,,'6 , A
7
,2
* t ,,. .. L, .
12
) ' 7
4
.2i 1
.E
EZ
17'2
,
,5t7 z
,,2 ,, ,
,>,J t - -

,g7
'
' -'
L
E
-'
p,-'
,_
'
,-c
'00
'
=3t'
..O
'9
'
..8
oF
i
5ts
-,c
2.'
,,e
-_
..
.
2

,
'1
,
'
2
,
'

- 9
n co' ; n
- 7 3
5
, - , x
_ ,
P - *
0 2
1
'
.
2
1
4
)
c
)

a i'-

7z
3
e
S
,
'
'
'
'
'
:
'
o
_
a

a -= o e -

g
r.

ri

- 2

,q

Z e a
a
2
'
E 2 c

7,

0 . 0 s o'
- - o -- T

"

-E

2 5
o -E t i
6. - 5 4 '
, e )

'I 8 g
8. -8 0 0 =

=
1
"
-6. 5 a
o e8 4
g
;
L
'
1
'TC 1"
'g

I
)g- ,0
'
. &

, 0E 0

-E
,

0
;
cu .1
1
2

LessonsLearned

.=
,0 0 5 t
=
._43? ' _
a_
0 . =. 0
.2
, ,,
0 5 (r)
0
= li. ; i l : : : 1. , 0. ' 2
. C-J 7c )
E
I
=
g
Ifh ''
. .
'
r'-,
=

4.1
= 4.)
r
=
n
.

,E
5
-' g
' i' 1
t -i c, V, r :
.O
5
'- '
>--t
0
. ti,
o
c
,'
!c.
2
4
E
t
,E g
o . .
U
tc-, ) ;- 2771 6 , 'a%
E ,2, ,C, o
8
g
.
3
g?
5
2 L
.
g
_
2
0, t ; e t g ' y .6
A ?t'A
0 ;7
0A
4- 8
,'
,_> W
)7
'
,
8
.
9

i
...
,) E4,1 , o )-EE
.4
= .T .
g
.
i . .
:
.-0
E "
2 E: d c 1 '.' ' & .
3r-3 ' ,,=, , ., v" ,' z E ET,-
a
1 0 0 ;2
u
r a,02
e ,--, i' , .
u
5 35&) =i
.z 6
2
c-.a3- .. 0
,
. 17,, 1 , , '
t 0

Vd

r2

=
d.,

ll
_
0
-=
2
A

>

1 3

' 6

c
.
.
.
=
'
7
.
_

En 0

'
,
'

' ' '

:
c

I
.

, F,
'

r:

il
.
)

S
)

'

,.

'

' f l .

,,,,

- 9 a. , . . .

>

, n*

l c .

t
o

.=. . .

i
c

'

.IF 7.s'

h o

'

" E

d ,

, -,

'd

.E ,
-- E 7

od .

4
.6
.
;

,
,,,u 1

'E :,

.c

d C , , ,

72; = ,
.=
as =8- 0' .7j (.5 u .
0 E
.0 -
,,,,, _1
'' ,
0
:
4
r
2
,.=
7-, E' 7E . , wd
,
,.
=
a. 2
.1
o
1
i
7
,- T.,
'1
' 4
.) Q
;,'
-.9
84T . . E
S-.'.
? .4 , ! 0 ,
'5 0 '0
a
e
.0

,..,
.=
Z
=.
,,' :A
,.
-,,,,
E
0
c
.'L - S 2
z
-
D = -a- 0 0 a ,..= 0,' g 8k4.)
t-;
c 71Z t ) =d..1 :
c
. . )

'5
T
E

t
o
t
i
.
2
m
,' . d. *o' ,-.
- -o.,5 t K t S Sr '
.C
-E t t7-, 2_ o
- I 2 = .1
0
.,3 4- a ,.,.. t >
.);7
.2
'
R

w
0
'
- 2 ,
2
.
7
,0
2 >
t
.7
f :I 4-) : R 2 . .:44 ): 1: 2 A 2 , .L,8a -1c, atO'1, 3. . . t' 421
.
P
,
1
:.t3 c e .' - , . ' ,
. 9,
2
9
2
i
"
0; _
2
.
,'
._ a
' .
7
,
0
e
*
E
.: d . )
,
*
u
' 0o
T
.
-E -*
.
"
I
Q
.
81 0*.
g
5
. , 1
;0
' .

.c . _

'

0
.

. . . :

= -'

_ . 5
-e 2.
,ti) '.0 cm
=
,
.'-.=0 m= 1_,
2gc

l
a
- 7 2
.
Eo i ' ,
,
S
2
s .
. = .
d L lt
' . - '
0
6
g
2
o
7
.
,
1
-

W I

- ,

C ,

t 3

5174

..

<

. , -; '

'a

't 1

c-1
C.-I
76
,.
4
Q
0
V
6
,
;
_
2
0
.
4
2
.
=
=
,

.-1

r'i
3
.
7
,
8
E
7
S

=
, - 0

4.)

>6.t.'..
C
'.
,,'---2 t1c'1d r
,-x 3 -8
8 - ,9 .
,
.
_-'.
4 >=
1 ,
: '
.
2, 2
,,
9?,r
s:
-
'E

z
g,
2:
-

k, -c -E :
. .....,.., 2
, 4
, . . . 6,, j T . 4 , P
-5
,
. .17.
- '-7
>-, E 8 ---4
2 ,9 Z
.
. 5 . ,.
c
o
_,0
'C.
2
.6=
t
I
.
,
E,
'
L
6
.
' ' .
.
>
=
g, _, ,
.. - ,
2
5t4 -: . 4 , ' 7-3
. 0
2, .

-7
-04 ' . 0
)..,' ,g -,
E
' ' E , - -= 9 t;,,
a
z
0152E. ,,2:Fa .5
. " 2..
2 , -2
E '-'
.. ' ' ' ,. . ,',, .- 33, . , , . . 0 5 . - ,,,g 78, 13
,
_
5
_'_
,'
,
- - - ' ,
_1 '
.-_, --'' c 05 0-), R . -7
s,D , ;
-5, ' - ' ...'
, 5 2 r ,. -,
5
7
-i. .= i .
,
1.
'
.
,'.2' 5
'c
, E, C c ..,_. r .7.
- L;'c ' 7
-,42 ,". -_,">
.
=
1

.
:
,t , z f
c
7, ,.-'s' , ,._-: . 2 - E
,au
--_
:
--,5 -22 5
,
,
'
z
u2 , ,
2_-w
3
.
,
1tui 3 . .
2
.
0
'3, ' - ' P 7, , , ' v I L
,
8
>
.
i
,
.
,
- t
.',,, 5

a
F
E
,
"
--2s
-' E-3
','.7
' . 2, . , . .t _ - , ,__
-! c
'22- .
',
"
,P e E ,,L ]
7 >,-2
g' c 0
Z r - 3 ',ti,,,, ,
0
.L_ 4, ,,..,.> _.2;':2 I: ' . ,> - .. E E . , .'7- C- . E-, ,U ' . ' ' .' '
c ., t!
.
g
' 'r-_
. .
,
1 - .
- '
= . 3
.
-a
.a
:-,'
0
' ' 4 i! 27 E . I r - ,
E. . - tiP . ' .A ' - ' . t . - l i2T
.= .1.
-> 0.)
t
.5F
4
c1 . .E , . , 0 ". 4.
,
0
1
'
,.,O 777
3
- ' ' '
w
.
i
.
1A
b5.L- E, 02 2- . o o 2E
-> ->
,
l
' ' - T !
,'
-.
'
2
n
g
,
'
t

.
.
-0o', ; 5- . ;,
=, , _ , , - ' . 5e
i
g
a
N
- '0
.)i- . 0.)
, . i . .A
- .- _ " . , . ,0
1o
- ,
,
, ,
-',-2
. , 0 .2,
> ..- =o,,' 0.0
, . . , . 4. - .
0-0
, ,c )
. . -', '-'i . ._ 1 ) 2 t , i--,' , , - o 1
.2=0
-_ , 7 , t f . 17,
'.3'1 ,-7m.52 1 Z - 0=.
A '
0
,
?
.
d
,
. . -
'T
-o
.2 2t 5 - - - , . - . . ,
-A
0
-I-,0,a- '.. - . . s- = .. '
=
c
.
_ r
_
d
!
0,
r . = E0
,Z C .0 ,
.
37f l
0
-':- - " . . )
,5
.
.
,
:
.
0 2 C >,-,,,,,_,,,
-.2. - =- g : S ',,s'. 2 -7, , , , , - - : ' '. .._
2
_6C,: .6 , t."-E
E
5
,59
2.3 t ; . - '.- -...8 T' 4. 1, ,.7 '0. '' a ,4
,
, '
?.
-0
F,
:'-."Z'.!"2, r'-;-,.0' i gu ' .73
,
?
.
=
2
2' ' ,
-' ,rA
).
t ." t - ', o8: )
. . . _
'.:.
'
?.-..
26'
, s
5
0 .0
.
,
., c
E
-,-z0-.j120
,, 711cs ,17-:
f0 '.
ELi
7 Er ,4..
,
.-- o
0
,', - t,
,
ti
0 '
r'-E
E).
->
5 7,, & 5t - 4,
c---tu-:,.-=.:
, . _ .. , , j
F
'
7
3
T
,
5
!
E
.
5
F
.8
56' C
' ' ' 7
.=L

i-7.2
p,... , - <. J r . . , 0
4.- Z.
. .: ' , ' 6iii-- - . ' .
-. .7
-e
)
<4
00 : '',.. 2 2 - Lo
5
P
.-. . E
- g roz''' ,';--, ' r;
.
,t,L'-3772
'12'2,', _
' It' =. t: 6 ,
o .
:-L
2.alg -6 g lo ,,., 2. , , ,
C . ) , ! g; ..,.. 1
.- .,O....,
, - - 0
0
E
tV' ' _.
.0
0
8 . i l = =.' E_ E '22
5
:
.
,
I
,
5
.-.,
2
,
i
,
'
'4
-7o, ,
.2 r, - .t! t..). ' .
' ,
.
0 .
,
-4
:
'
vtg,Z -,.
;.0_g, ' C
'
' m
=

2
.
8
.
a',!-2 1
'
g
.

'
T- 1 =
o
g
1
.
r
j
-3 2
'. .
2 '
; .
f
e
,
=.''
E
2,6 ' 0 . , ,
';
'
7'
)-, 5
.'5'9F 1
. i
- .E
04E,. ,. .
5
.
t7
,
;
t:
.
E
4
Q
'
.6
-,,4
't4 .
>,
!t: 2 2
,
.
4e
,
.
..
,
;
-:- a
0
,
-.,u
.
'
-.
-t..c 1 2
?. _
,
3
.
1'
_' .
_.-4r. i ,

.
L
3
, .
2: d 2
0
2-.2F
,
,
)
2
4 Q 1
. ,, A. 2 I . '
. ,
e'
,
=
;
Ixd,-4
.

.0
f ;
0
2
,
. .,= ..,c
.
M
c
c
R
0
'
'= . F,C0
Y
,
.
.
2
.
r_
'?'- - g .,. , . g.2 , A L 0 ?.-.
,
7 1-- - . - 4 , 1 0 -".,
C
'5 1 a4
,
5 ,1 g ' ; . . Zt i 01 ?,
' g. _

:'
.
M
.
0
Z
1
=
,
.
E
t
2
6
,f
r
.
>
,

=
1
.
.
.
,."g

13 a-' 5 0 : - 3
. ,
'
6
.
,
.
..
,7
=
'E
0
'0 2 . . - c...1 i . . 7 12
4
.-" . r 3
0 5
.
7
ci
-.2t . j .47 ,2 5- ' L' . ' '-'," E 0., .' . ' -, ' E ' o
5
t o z _-4 - -"-0 - =
.
8
iu
L, . > . . :E
1
'.-o
.
4
.
.
.
.
7
F E
E c =, = 0 =
- 9 ' - ,' .1 E 2I )
t
.=
1
,4E .
2
0 ,
u
-. . a. . l. . U= =c - r
: '
d
6, 02.
c,..
.
=
i
i. .-... 6z
- '---.'
.
.:
c
rE 2 j l3
.
2 ,
E
:
2
1
u
?
7i' .
,
_
)p
.E
;
. - '''
,
:
r ' ,1
0
: "f ' ' l' ,- 4,Q
'.
:i2,. ! , 2
.8
.g
.
1
C
,
t
', z.
s
z .
]
,5' . g8
L '

g
2
1
i
'
.
4
M
,
t
5
,
_ -,E, Q.., -'.-6 '= 4 '- 6 2al g 0 15t2 :',' . .- 6, , ., 'c, !, , t.,"' 4 ,= 4 =,6 . 6 .C: 1
-.- 1
.
.=
', , . I 3 o
c. 1,;
. E. =- 2 ..e 7, . 25
Z
,_:
5
m
1
5
'
'
;
'
,to g i
i
I i ,g
r
. 1' ' t4,2 : . . , ,. '-;
2
. .2 M,
-D s0 -- =2c '
- ,
.,
u
.
.
1
. ,. C . 0
.
,
2
2
2
,
o
2
,
4
.?
'
0
,Z '4
.
%
.1-2
E
.= ,.=
g f. .4.8'.5: C E - - - ,-; -0 t4,
- > . . m, - )'->
0.12
.
7
7r ' .
1
'4-_-_,'1 ' i ! 1
'"- 2 2' .0>
2 -' c=, . = 0. = 3 _' ,o , 7'.4;_, = .
'.
'
8
0
6 7,,,
-.4..bil
5
0
:
. .
,
!
7
1
t
2E
E
0 . ''
,
9
E
.
=
") , g t
,s7- , 2 , . 0
.., _.-,.- ' AZ. a -= ' 8 . "1
2 .
!
z-'. 6;6
4, C' ..' = -'80 r - - 8 >
' 8
-0
2 p
0
d
43
,' ,5
.
7
.' - 1
6
4
:
,
C
'
d
'
0- >,g, , . :1 1-. - o Y= 2 2
- o o- - . 2 - ' ' , ,t;
g
.,t'-''
8J.tQ
-'- t . =
1 f , g 'a. 2 g. 0 ,2 .:
-1E0r. F, . j "7E
c -- a'1 t t 1.4 , ,
z:
, : , . . .
c
g
='.i q . _t1;
I
,r- ,:'
' E'
-aa . 0 =. t . . . r. g -,- .'.._-.?.
_', -2,
. s a= z
4 .- - '.1
.
.-'r',to4. 74
.'
E ,. , e
4
.
0 z
'.
.
"
,-' 9,ts 2 ..,. -8 v .: 2
. '- ' t 'a
;0'0UKM. ,,; 5 -'-I.re2, 0 2' 8 '2 I ' t.
g
A
- 5E :
2t " : t .
.'.2 t s, . ' 2
2
7
. 4 E'
0
5
, . . 5 . , i E., -.
.io
,..,
, 0 _70
0
..
=.
-. Ce
I . ,
1 ,
.0 o
= -.
E
3., 1.1 7
.7
2 - . 6- .-.. , ,..

-.E
,0
c- ,;. ..'01i.?,-_. ..6, .,''-'
,-5
1a
-E .
1
0.1,
2
.

t'+.. LI
;
'
Q
p
,
,,
g
,
4
LI ' :
I
rg
.
..
c
i' l ..7.' :25 , ,,
2 0'
=w:, c 4 r4
1
.
l
'
E
,
'
,- - c v ,_. la-3.1.
.,9
7
; g) t -'e : . t. - 4. . , c l . .
.,1. 38
M, ) c
- 5 . > .1
t 4= . , ' E .2
.5
' ',.
- 0- ,,, 2?
A
3 .- m '
0
,': .Q' 5 , Ea,r;C' . .'
..LF
.
.
5
-:- t.' 7
t
o
i
l
t
5
.I.' 2 .
4.'-2
c l ,-.'= :
.
c,. ' 9, , C
- I:
0 .
,
f'7
o'I 8 . . 64..
0
2,6,2
.
7
,. : ...
- 5
4
'.. E
g
c
'-_,..,
.
,
F
,
'
.
t
9
,,,
,'
7
P
t
4
'
'- ;-..2 a, . Cp
4
7
c
2
0
,..
E
,
L.
1
.
8
3
2
c
F
.
.
e'0 2 2 -o 12- 0 : . - . .2,' , u _
2
5 E
''S
' .., ' ' 0
,'t5.0 , 1. 1,_
.
,
,... = ,t.,-,
.
--0
2 ., ,F", . , ,1 . . ;
'
P
4
'
r
,
0
C
.
5. 4 55L'
= 0, t
- .- 6
"-. Eio1! E. .o2.:5 E, - -a,7-02 .4
t , , , , , ..... , . , 0
'7
I,u
.i
e
r&
8
,
',: :2 ,...a E. z ,:,
, E..5
E
.
_c,
.
"
.
,
.
S
8' L . - , to u u =
97
:1
2sm
7
2
.
.
,
g. , , =
_
'
5
l .-7F
8
..
,N
.- . ,-.E
>
,'-'_
'
.
= ,.:a2
.
.
t
,4
'
.
C
'
4
' , . r'-. .
. =
_
-,T
T . . - l; . .
,
7
5,
.
1
'g _
,
g
t'> 2
_
'
8
E
2
7
o,,- s
6
0-'0
'
;
a
, r
F
2 ?
F:
-'5Z
-- ;u l .c
2
'
.-5
.4
>
. .. 7 '
,
." .
,,2--'
,.
,
.i.2

e
u
_
t
,:
. E'
. t
,-.,.g
9
.
'
,
,:0
. ,
.0=
,
,
''4 ?
. . ,l , -.6
_

1
.
)
.
?
.
,
,
.
.
,.. g
5
.
2.t , ,
ac: .
_.
. .z
r..) E
', .
0, 0
'
T ,
. ,
,
- E
. 3 ,
0a1
,. t
., c
.,
2
,,
7,
C,
,
2,

_22 o 0 -_9 2 '


2 v ,
0
a

0
!
L
- 6
'
s
q
e
A
i
'
'

261

TE.,: i.)

,,,

97
,
1

-L-7
w.

U
.
;

Ch v l
,

.2
ce

,, 1 E 5
C4 A Mf t c t1
,2

vD

..r :tl ...5.!zdl - tn


(-)

1:4 cn

1 ;-,'7;

_52 a
.

gl

e
a
,

un T r r n

.2

ch

c
,
*

,
,

7.1,

<I C

;6 4:1

,
-'

N r--

g,

_
,

EE
' 1 74
1
-

8
"
8

ri
7;
r)
tz
.
4
LE 0 ',-; .
E
=i
1
V
7- :, ';t4
: ':
,
-z
F:'-'" 4,-,
, t t
2 ,E
E
,- E
- - i l'l 4
..2
Z
i-- - E 7
2
je oo
g ,
- E
e
m

H
E
'- ;7 4.
i
,,_ L -

=-. -5 .
.
.,11.1 2 ?.-:
,

i g',-4;.1 _.___,_..

'S :.Z ,7

r,

-o

Cl

---:

-!
<

- - - - z

A.'
,4,
-141

.7-

rTo

-;

r-, -

.
=2
2
n

.7
44, F

<

'
.
.
4 .-..:-

:a
3

- -tr

I'
7

t o

Ci

- t
-, '

-E

2
F->

.= z
..

,
.

- --,

1.

= 2

Cl

r 4

t
Fi ' - - " "

4
4' C 4

, - -

E g g
<

to
4
9
1

-Y
. ,
o,T
E'' d ,-1)
-2.
.2' 5 . = :
c<
-1
,=,
'7
.1
-2
', - . . .
),
'$,'
,k.<. r .
e..A
..-' -. - :
,e- . .
:c
.
=L
c4
-
-,
.,
-E
-l
,i
.
P
.
,
2
;

-5

.
1
2

7 ,-.4 , , 9 v.

E,s.

r 4 SC

2E4

C O

.F. l ' 1
g
,

::, , I

C C S C

f r-

''''5

t 9
I
.
'
o ' '
.
.
'
g
e

o.
,.
.
Ip
Iz
-

T, e
-

,
9

t
E

EF .
3r

C '

'

o
,
7.
.'
,
E
1:'
-1 <
F-. .
'd'
t
y7
7,

( . . ,

-2
1
5
0
.
,
< 4. C l 1 3
,

t1Et, C
.,5
.
4

. 7 , '4 4 4

,1 ; 1 = _9, ,. LI-,7, to I 1
,

O
E

ei3 .....>
.=
-

--,
s

"

''' "
,g
tg
0l
R
-' ,
441
; .
E
41.
4I

,-' ,

. )

- ,.

.
'

' "

'

.
-:
i

:1

P
4

t h

<

,-,

r.A
P
-T.
CC?

--I
-,
a
'
'
'
,
r

'
'
2
a

u s , 0 ....
-;
m
,..L ' .. e q
El 4
,
4
8
c
t
,
C
:

'
.1
= o n e' n
.
r
r
e
;
r

,
.
rq C I, CD tr ) . ,
Z u ,
E
N
E
N
T
.
4
E
N

q
o
r
C
I
,
H o" n ' e n EN ,
E ; )
j
g
H
4
.?
Q . )
.oa
E
o

l o
2

Characteristics

_ .

o r 7

r"
--

, . . 4 ; - , .0., ,
=
1
_L=
t, , T
e
N

L
5

, n

o r
- -

r o

en

-e
,,
= r qT r
s
,
E
A
T
,
,
r
, T
T
N
.
.
r
4
,
'
0 -e n- , ,
a
'
T
i
I
I
.
I
4
"
c
Tr
l
0, 0 4
,
,
r

= E
,
' ,
C
: '
'

t:

.5
d
' = 4 )
2 ;E
t
. = = = ,
:
. -z , I '
2 co 5 z t,
=E
Z
'
z15 ; i.
,
1
e

-= _.

oo

Le) ,,e)
L=
c
,

.,

0 E.E-. S
=
E
1E

, ,.." 8 1
-

r-

cr e q;

a
-

C-)

"-

4 0 )
"

n
"

'
a

(
4

eq r n , [
1
.
e
n

2
.->

rA
N r

,
C

,r Nc oc

t . 0 = .
E 0 2 az ti
rv .
,
> ,
z:cH
t
.
C
0
0
0
5
0
Z
'
0
=
2
c
;
:
g

E
f
g
.

6
> o r rn L e n 4,
- t-

Cn4

2 c, 7 :

2 2 6 s
5
,, 8 ,

=
: :"
z

'F, E
.
P
_. . : t - ,
.
1
.
9
z
E
,
,
.
"
'
.

r-1

. .

-,:, .
7 r

71

-45:.)

anualabour

Meandailyw
e
g
a
r
fo

priceofIC/me
n
a
d
ilyw
.4
5
):
e
g
a

Meanratio(me
n
a

g1

e e,
(-4

e-

INNEMIENO

0_
0

sumpuodsal dComns Jo amugaigd

'A rIffilflarlffliffi
F
A
Flil/A
V
rlf f /7/0/
A
T
INFAI
A
417 VCC4k:CECC*74.7.4
.
VA r / 0 / 42 0 rli 70/711;
I vavA vavA va
I
v
A
A
707/4./Ariff/APYffleiff/AP1ArtelA
P
T
v
,
A
A
V
felA P;
v
!I P
A
ea
r a
i'
!
I v a v

C7,

K
7
v 4E l M O KA M E C : *
W Y M I KCCC40:1 : e4 &KC*:
W
7
I
/
7 fKf
0
17411vA'
/ V
1
7 / A7
0
Wff/A FlA v a r/O/A
/ AM
7
v
r 1
0
A
1
0
/
v
Fla rlaPrlAFlair/OhOVAFlA
0 ;&.I.MPAPAPMPAP,MAPAPitilV
4
A
/ .
5
v
0/ 0 17 4 rIff1170/17fflA
fteld174
F
0
FlillA F/7/I 70/A
A
W EIF: CNECCCONW
O: C.CCCC4KCOTCA
/
P
7
v
. ;
0
A
07010/7/07.10,2 FlOtiflArlff/0/0/07illi
VAN riff/Air/if/7/4E
7 P
/
v
rAWAv e
4
A
7
A
n li
F
/
v
Yf f /0/0/1/ille/A
v A rla riff/0/011F/4
/
7
,
vAvAv,
vA
Z
/
,
vdivir
7
r ri
VAWA
oAPA.1PA.2
/
A l rAl
1
A
v
Ar/
dAF l i l / 7 / 0 1 0 / 7 / f f / 1P7 A A
0/01
P
1vY
S I M
.7
fA
f i f f i e l f:f i
P .
1 /f 1f 7 Vill.,
E f 101f f a07,0 YffifflA1VAriff/A flff/A
l
N
r
4
1
1
7
4
1
v
i
e
v
ed r d ir 6v4i
0 // 1
rA /f l i l lv7 4/ 4
il A
I
il
lAY
K
v
F l, 0
0
C.)
cei
CA
tr)
e .
A rL
4
v
sunpuodsoN
i f wICALItis
f
e g0eJo
i r earvloond
A
i fAf
:
l Av
4
A
Y A
V
v
A
A
K
v

I
K
E
C
O
N

OI
*i

f'\)

Ez
--(I
t
,

(...) 12
4
,,s A ,
cl)
1[
/
/.- e
'

7
(1) 5
,

s
/

,
;

0
U

/
/
/
/
;
.
7

/
,
'
"
;
/
4
/
7
"
A

S3SUOdSON i f 0 A I I I
S J O
O 1 3 1 . 1 " 0 0 .
1
0
, 1

g,

Q)
.
O

1
Y
i
1

a
.
z
r
,

>Lu
0

LU

stuuA aid Jo 1 uo olo d

a_
0

IN gD lIgd

-4

SzieofImprovedC
kstve
o
P
ro
je
cts

(N

sloocald Jo ogultfoond

LT-1

*V*
.40-011
1
.00
, AO,
0
4

_4
5
t.r)
9

!.t4

2-1

CC,

q n o l o n j f u p p o o Jo 0 2
cluoand

0
*4
1
, 0 4
,
0
0
.40
0
40. . 1
P
0
4
1
/A
0 A
, - 01
00 ,
1 A I
1
VeW
0
04 0 40 + * * * * 1

v
1 , I 1

v
1

e W
1

*
1
e 0e 0e 1

e l + 0404
-0
i V
r
e
A i / /A 4
1 1 , +
*
'S
.
,
r
1

I
'
I
A
M
A
I
I
o
.
.

V
A

A
W
A
S
,

r own
,.
/
40
104%
.
*;

A s
e*V
.

;%

;;
0
4

8 c o '
SOSTIOdSgU i c
0
A111S
J O
O
a
e
l
l - 1 0 0 n
d

\0

r24

P
A
RTS
S
O
L

VV.
1
1
M
, O*
,1 0

MMME ME MME MME MME MM


M M MMM MM MMM
MOM MM MM
IM M E M M M E M M O M M M E M
I MMMMOMMM M
L
MM
MM
OM
MMMOMM M
M JE
0 1 M M IM M E M B E M M M M M
1 1 0
T
.
I II I M M A R E r a
1 r a
a l I M M
.M
M
1 M mnE: M
MM M M M : m m
IM
M
M
M
MMMMMMMMM MMM
M
M U
M
t l
r il e
E L M
E S

.rummatm...

=1
ollealmorean

LL4

' M
E M M E N

I EL M U M M E = M
/M
MM M M M M M M M M M
MMMMMMM MMB MMM MM
-M
M M M E M M O M M IM M M E M M
MMM MME MMM MME MM
MM
EMMM M
MMMMM MM M
MMM MMMMMMMMMM MM
D

11111
11111
691M
Ini l
l

F
IGU
R
E1
0

, n nsurner-tramm
noti
tei m m i a l u r
l111112A1mr
.tu. n
. .r- . . . . . . . .. e s u n i n a n . . " . I LI I I I I I I N I I I I I
0
r n u m o
MMMiiiirinlimputtn-----n
Eun E M
n
mM
aai1:111111:22
i i L m u m
11111:111111
n.1:11::111121
s11111111112
o
M I M I = 1111:111:100.0
-tmEmono
n
mmmmm
..... 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
4
I. l l i ggl
u
H
i gn
i1 1 1 B 1 1 1 1 1
u
1
i1 : 1 : 1 1
t
Fumilumuninirannunrun
n
u
i i h
.................
:ImiunraraurLsrmaniarambrum.....
n i i
mum=
lE1ut
i 1
F
1 1
t1r r
1 1
a
a
2
1n
m
"t
9
-o 1
,- .
E
a
1
rn 1
.a
S3A0 IS JO 11.130
: n
1
.e
1
u
-n
0
4:
-u
1
-t
su
MM MMMMMM MM MM

I N L I M I U M I Z I C I P

I : r M e n n i

MMMMMM MMMM MMMMMM M M M M M M M M M M IM M IE M O M mm IM IM M

0
.1M
0010
. .
0 0 m n 0 0 No 0 0

MM MMM MM MM MMMMMM MM MM

M 0 0MM 0100000m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

i n a

n g l
i r
r

r . . . 1 . 4 . . . .

M E MME ME MME MMM MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM


MMMMEEMMEMM
M E M M E M M M M M E M M E M M IM M M I L I I I : 1 1 1 : : : : :
MMME MM

MME MMO MM

mm0 0 0 mommomm0 0 0

M E E
m U a M WO EM ME I M pi lo ZpU MpMp M
p nEoM0 M
. 0M, 0E0M, 0M0E 0M0M0
0000;0 . . . :0 . mm MMEMMEMMEMMEMEMMEMM 0 0 1 0
Mm M
mommom=0 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
I M
,
M M
0 0 0 1 M 0 0 0 M 0 0 PPPPM P0
I M
M
M

F
IGU
R
E1

F
G
IU
R
E1
2

SJOSII
.
J O
I t I
O D
M d

a)

CO
- 11
CD

13)

Ci-

4
0
C

7
0
1

L9)

1-1 8
-s
CIS
(/) e
0
e:7'
0) 4
)
C
4

F
IGU
R
E1
3

z
[S]
I

soi 2u ppomJo uonomd

El

C4,

F
IGU
R
E1
4

4)
-0
-

SDI upti om jo uo g d

F
IGU
R
E1
5

OSII U1 S D I JO 110pO nl d

"TC

El

F
IGU
R
E1
6

CD

fl

2uppom jo uopomid


0 tc
0E 4
> ._,
2 .
0
A-:

bi
c)
-
0.. E . . =u
,,
0 , 2 6 1z1
0

cn
Q

r .>

c t

,C
I- 0
,2 '0c
,,
0,0 CI

= , Z 4 4 - '
el)
0
- . 4
-o -3
, c u 0
.u, ti, E -=
1,t ;8
,C t
0
44 - < C

.,
r
t .
9

:-.
-*
*
). +

.
)
"
t
=
1
;

CU -. 1

,= t
=

. = pL

s-1-1

, ..,
.
,,
p, 0 c) u , .- . Jo
7--, E 6, ---4 0 0 . , ,
Ez1 o
88
: > . T'4
.) Z
-4 :4 ' _c dt
a c* * *
*t
*
c 2 .
X
r 2) ,
0
4-4 , ,
C I
;CD L -t
( 4
1 . )
_= t c) /
i E
.9.
) ,u
E
a A2P 0
0
. > uP
'5

0 ,
* ,
"C$
- ,t
0L )
( 4 e>
F0
i.,
. -= .c,
'
)= 0
C,
. !,61t E 0
L
'1 I
,
.,-
cPA
u=:,..,,
' " 8
.1
,
.t_C
dE
-c 4 . > 4
c0;-,
Le:" r4
0
, (
01.
*t,Q
-1
,=A
-Tk1cc -- .
T0.0
i ,,'-' = 0 x
I)
.d
-.,) ) L.
) ,,Q
b,
.
>=
= -*
*Cj *
,5 6:
))t
0
x

Eu
1
,,
- u
,,0
,0
, )
,= i
P
t'
11
-
) c
1

c l

= ca tq E, - - ,
1
C
4 C A 0 ,-,
0
a
4
.C C
,...,
- .-1).2 ,,, =
2

173

Vr0

- 1 1) c0n
,
u
bi) - -=- , u0
c1.-
, 4 -4
=
, e=lt) ')
0
'
0 -rjel.)
s(c.., .,,
t +.
= =
0 0

L) ' , . - - ,

c,1
- = F,
0 cl,)

1-I - =

tcl
* ,0
,
0

.
=

C i)

eL)

F
G
IU
R
E1
7

:S
u
ple
m
e
n
ta
ryQ
nAppendxiD
stio
e
u
:Particularso
S
e
fth
vyM
u
y
lg
d
o
th
e
AppendxiA
:OriginalQ
u
e
stio
na
A
ireppendxiB
S
:h
o
rtQ
uestionaireAppendixC

,.

IMPROVED BIOMASS COOKSTOVE PROGRAMS


A GLOBAL REVIEW
A Project of the East-West Center, the
Energy Sector Management Assistance Program (World Bank), and the
United Nations Development Program
Principal Investigator: Kir k R. Smith, East-West Center
Summary
"An Evaluation of Improved Biomass Cookstove Programs: Prospects for Success or Failure."
Available from ESMAP, World Bank, 1818 H Street, N.W., Washington, D.C., 20433.
Main Reports

1. "Results and Analysis of the Global Survey of Improved Cookstove Programs," J.


Ramakrishna. (Survey done in collaboration with the Foundation for Woodstove
- Dissemination, Nairobi; Association Bois de Feu, Paris; and the Center for Mesoamerican
Studies on Appropriate Technology, Guatemala.)
"Improved Stove Programs: Wher e are We Now?" K.R. Smith & J. Ramakrishna.
3. " T h e Hearth as System Central," K.R. Smith.
Country Studies (All final)
1. "100- million Improved Cookstoves in China: H o w was it Done?" S. Gu, K. Huang, D. a u ,
8, K.R. Smith.
"The Indian National Improved Stoves Program," J. Ramakrishna.
"Improved Cookstove Programs in Sri Lanka: A n Evaluation," J. Bialy.
"The Status of Improved Cookstove Programs in Nepal," G.S. Shrestha, H 0 Gorkhall, &
K.R. Smith.
"Improved Cookstove Programs in East and Central Africa: A Review,"
Wickramagamage.
Background Report
"The Economics of Improved Cookstove Programs," F. Hitzhusen.
"Evaluation Criteria for Imp oved Cookstove Programs: Assessment of Fuel Savings,"
Bialy.
"Social and Organizational Aspects of Improved Cookstove Programs," S. Pandey.
"Health Effects of Biomass Smoke: A Brief Survey of Current Knowledge," KR. Smith.

THE EAST-WEST 'CENTER was established in Hawaii in 1960 by the United States Congress
"to promote better relations and understanding between the United States and the nations
of Asia and the Pacific through
: c Some
o o p2,000
e r research
a t i v efellows, graduate students, and professionals in business and government
s t each
u year
d ywork
, with the Center's international staff on major Asia Pacific issues relating
to
population,
economic
t r a i n i n g and trade policies, resources and the environment, Culture and
communication,
and international relations. Since 1960, more than 27,000 men and women
,
from
the region
have
a
n
d participated in the Center's cooperative programs
Officially known as the Center for Cultural and Technical Interchange Between East and
r
e
s
e
a
r
West, InL, the Center is a public, non-profit institution with an international board of goverc
h
?
'
nors Principal funding comes from the United States Congress. Support also comes from
more than twenty Asian and Pacific governments, as well as private agencies and corporations.

T H E EAST-WEST ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY INSTITUTE(EAPI) was established in October


1977 Through interdisciplinary and multinational programs of research and training, the Institute seeks to develop concepts and methods for sustainable environmental management
and to address major environmental issues of the Asia-Pacific region.. Program plans and
projects are developed and carried out in collaboration with colleagues from the region and
others throughout the world. Results of Institute programs are disseminated through books,
journal articles, occasional papers, working papers, newsletters, and other educational and
informational materials.
Reconciling development with the environment by bringing social and natural systems
into harmony with one another is EAPI's overall objective. Achievement of this Objective involves both m a i n t
'help
attain these i n t e r
a
-social
i n i n gsciences to develop and disseminate new tools for policymaking, management, edul'cation,
ei n nk evdand
i r oresearch.
n m Work of the Institute is organized within four programs that interact
substantially
with
each other and with other institutes and programs of the East-West Center.
ge on at al sl ,
Eq A
u aP l I i
dt yr , a
w
s
oa
nn
td
h
ei
m
p
kr
n
o
w
o
v
li
en
dg
g
et
bh
a
se
e
oq
u
fa
l
ti
t
hy
eo
nf
a
th
u
ru
a

You might also like