Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CollegeofLaw
Law101:ObligationsandContracts
CourseOutline
Prof.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
ContactInformation:
CourseSchedule:
maryrose.tan@gmail.com
+639178871555
TuesdaysandThursdays,6:30p.m.to9:00p.m.
Room311315
AttendanceRequirement: CollegeofLawrulesonattendanceshallbestrictlyapplied.
Studentsmayonlybeabsentforanycauseforamaximumof8
sessions.
Assessment:
(1)Classparticipation
25%
(2)Midtermexamination
25%
(3)FinalExam
50%
PrescribedTextbook:
Tolentino,CivilCodeofthePhilippines,Vol.IV
INTRODUCTION
A. CourseOverview
B. CommonLawTraditionandtheCivilLawTradition
Agabin,P.A.,Mestizo:TheStoryofthePhilippineLegalSystem(2011),
Chapter7,pp.169216
PARTONE:OBLIGATIONS
A. GeneralProvisions
1. Definition(Article1156,CivilCode)
2. Elements
a. ActiveSubject
b. PassiveSubject
c. ObjectorPrestation
d. EfficientCauseorJuridicalTie
BasedontheCourseOutlineofProf.EduardoLabitag.
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
3. NaturalObligations
a. Definition(Art.1423,CC)
b. Examples(Articles1424to1430)
c. DifferencebetweenNaturalandCivilObligation(Art.1423)
d. Distinguishedfrommoralobligations
Villaroelv.Estrada,71Phil.140(1940)
Fisherv.Robb,69Phil101(1939)
e. ConversiontoCivilObligation
bynovation
byratification
4. SourcesofObligations(Art.1157)
a. Law(Art.1158)
b. Contracts(Art.1159,1305)
c. Quasicontracts(Art.1160,2142)
Kinds:
i. Negotiorumgestio(Art.2144)
ii. Solutioindebiti(Art.2154)
iii. Others(Art.2164to2175)
d. DelictsorCrime(Art.1161)
e. Quasidelicts(Art.1162,2176)
Distinctionbetweencrimesandquasidelicts
Vicariousliability(Art.2180,Art.218219,FamilyCode)
Civilliabilityarisingfromcrime(Art.1161;Rule111,RevisedRulesof
CriminalProcedure)
Barredov.Garcia,73Phil607(1942)
Mendozav.Arrieta,91SCRA113(1975)
5. ClassificationofObligations
a. PureandConditionalObligations(Art.11791192)
b. WithaPeriodoraTerm(Art.11931198)
c. AlternativeandFacultative(Art.11991206)
d. JointandSolidary(Art.12071222)
e. DivisibleandIndivisible(Art.12231225)
f. WithaPenalClause(Art.12261230)
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
B. NatureandEffectsofObligations
1. KindsofPrestation
a. Togive
i. specificthing
topreservethething(Art.1163)
todelivertheaccessionsandaccessories(Art1166)
todeliverthefruits(Art.1164,par.1)
todeliverthethingitself(Art.1244)
ii. genericthing(Art.1246)
b. Todo(Art.1244)
c. Nottodo(Art.1244)
2. BreachofObligation
a. Concept
SongFov.HawaiianPhilippines,47Phil.821(1928)
Velardeetal.v.CourtofAppeals,361SCRA56(2001)
Angelesv.Calasanz,135SCRA323(1985)
DeltaMotorCorporationv.Genuino,170SCRA29(1989)
VermenRealtyv.CourtofAppeals,224SCRA549(1993)
b. ModesofBreach
Delayormora(Art.1169)
i.
morasolvendi
CetusDevelopmentv.CourtofAppeals,176SCRA72(1989)
AerospaceChemicalIndustriesv.CourtofAppeals,315SCRA92(1999)
SantosVenturaHocormaFoundationv.Santos,441SCRA472(2004)
Vazquezv.AyalaCorporation,443SCRA231(2004)
Abellav.Francisco,55SCRA447(1931)
delaCruzv.Legaspi,98SCRA43(1955)
ii.
moraaccipiendi(Seealso1268)
Villaroelv.ManilaMotorCo.,Inc.,104Phil.926(1958)
iii.
compensationmorae
CentralBankv.CourtofAppeals,139SCRA46(1985)
Fraudordolo(Art.1171)
doloincidenteanddolocausante
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Woodhousev.Halili,93Phil.526(1953)
Geraldezv.CourtofAppeals(1994)
Negligence(Art.1172,1173)
culpav.dolo
culpaaquilianov.culpacontractual
standardofcarerequired
Gutierrezv.Gutierrez,56Phil.177(1932)
Vasquezv.Borja,74Phil.560(1944)
deGuiav.ManilaElectricCorporation,40Phil706(1920)
USv.Barias,23Phil434(1912)
Sarmientov.SpousesCabrido,401SCRA122(2003)
Crisostomov.CourtofAppeals,409SCRA528(2003)
Contraventionofthetenor(Art.1172)
Chavesv.Gonzales,32SCRA547(1970)
Telefastv.Castro,158SCRA445(1988)
Arrietav.NARIC,10SCRA79(1964)
Magatv.Medialdea,206Phil341(1983)
c. Remediesincaseofbreach
i.
Performance
Specificperformance(Art.1165;Section10,Rule39,RulesofCourt)
Substitutedperformance
inanobligationtogivegenericthing(Art.1165,par.2)
undoingofpoorworkinanobligationtodo(Art.1167)
Chavesv.Gonzales,32SCRA547(1970)
Tanguiligv.CourtofAppeals,266SCRA78(1997)
undoinginanobligationnottodo(Art1168)
ii.
Rescission(Art.11911192)
iii.
Damages(Art.1170)
d. SubsidiaryRemediesofCreditor
i.
AccionSubrogatoria(Art.1177)
ii.
AccionPauliana(Art.1177;1381,par.3)
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
KheHongChengv.CourtofAppeals,355SCRA701(2001)
Siguanv.Lim,318SCRA725(1999)
iii.
OtherSpecificRemedies(Art.1652,1729,1608,1893)
e. FortuitousEvent(Art.1174)
i.
Effect:ExtinguishmentofLiability
ii.
ExceptionstoExtinguishment(Art.1174,1165par.3,552,1942,
1979,2001,2147)
JuanNakpil&Sonsv.CourtofAppeals,144SCRA597(1986)
Republicv.LuzonStevedoringCo.,21SCRA279(1967)
Dioquinov.Laureano,33SCRA65(1970)
Austriav.CourtofAppeals,39SCRA527(1971)
NationalPowerCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,161SCRA334(1988)
Yobidov.CourtofAppeals,281SCRA1(1997)
BacolodMurciaMillingv.CourtofAppeals,182SCRA24
Philcomsatv.GlobeTelecom,430SCRA(2004)
f. UsuriousTransactions(Art.1175,1413,1961)
PD858;PD1685
CentralBankCircular416
MonetaryBoardCircularNo.905;No.2209
EasternShippingLinesv.CourtofAppeals,234SCRA781(1994)
CrisminaGarmentsv.CourtofAppeals,304SCRA356(1999)
KengHuaProductsv.CourtofAppeals,286SCRA257(1998)
SecurityBankv.RegionalTrialCourtMakati,263SCRA453(1996)
Almedav.CourtofAppeals,256SCRA292(1996)
AngelWarehousingv.Chelsea,23SCRA19(1968)
FirstMetroInvestmentv.EstedelSol,369SCRA(2001)
C. DifferentKindsofObligations
1. PureandConditionalObligations
PureObligations(Art.1179,par.1)
ConditionalObligations(Art.1181)
Concept
Conditionv.PeriodorTerm
Gaitev.Fonacier,2SCRA830(1961)
Gonzalesv.HeirsofTomasandPaulaCruz,314SCRA585(1999)
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
KindsofConditions
a. Astotheeffectontheobligation(Art1181)
Gonzalesv.HeirsofTomasandPaulaCruz,supra.
i.
SuspensiveConditionorConditionprecedent
Retroactiveeffectwhenconditionisfulfilled(Art.1187)
Coronelv.CourtofAppealsandAlcaraz,263SCRA15(1996)
Rightsofthecreditoranddebtorbeforefulfillmentofthe
condition(Art.1188)
ii. ResolutoryConditionorConditionsubsequent
Parksv.ProvinceofTarlac,49Phil.142(1927)
CentralPhilippineUniversityv.CourtofAppeals,245SCRA511(1995)
Quijadav.CourtofAppeals,299SCRA695(1998)
b. Astothecauseororigin(Art1182)
i. Potestative
Effectoffulfillmentofconditiondependssolelyonthewillofthe
debtor
Debtorspromisetopaywhenhecanisnotacondition(Art1180)
LaoLimv.CourtofAppeals,191SCRA150(1990)
ii. Causal
NagaTelephoneCo.v.CourtofAppeals,230SCRA351(1994)
iii. Mixed
Osmenav.Rama,14Phil.99(1909)
Hermosav.Longora,93Phil.971(1953)
Taylorv.UyTiengPiao,43Phil.873(1922)
SmithBellv.Matti,44Phil.875(1922)
RustanPulpandPaperMills,214SCRA665(1993)
Romerov.CourtofAppeals,250SCRA250SCRA223(1995)
c. Astopossibility(Art.1183)
RomanCatholicArchdioceseofManilav.CourtofAppeals,
198SCRA300(1991)
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
d. Astomode:positiveornegative(Art.11841185)
Rulesincaseofloss,deteriorationorimprovementpendingthehappeningof
thecondition(Art.11891190)
HeirsofTimoteoMorenov.MactanCebuInternationalAirportAuthority,
413SCRA502(2003)
a. Definitionofloss,deteriorationandimprovement
b. Effectoflossordeterioration
Withoutdebtorsfault
Withdebtorsfault
c. Effectofimprovement
Bynatureortime
Duetodebtorseffortandexpense
Effectofpreventionofthefulfillmentoftheconditionbytheobligor(Art
1186)
Taylorv.UyTiengPiao,supra.
Herrerav.Leviste,135SCRA129(1985)
2. ReciprocalObligations(Art.11911192)
a. Concept
b. Alternativeremediesofinjuredpartiesoncaseofbreach
i.
actionforspecificperformance
effectwhenfulfillmentnolongerpossible
ii.
actionforrescission
requisites
howmade
effects
SongFov.HawaiianPhilippines,47Phil.821(1925)
Boysawv.InterphilPromotions,148SCRA365(1987)
UniversityofthePhilippinesv.delosAngeles,35SCRA365(1989)
DeErquiagav.CourtofAppeals,178SCRA1(1989)
Angelesv.Calasanz,135SCRA323(1985)
JamesG.Ongv.CourtofAppeals,310SCRA1(1999)
Iringanv.CourtofAppeals,366SCRA41(2001)
VisayanSawMillv.CourtofAppealsandRJTrading,219SCRA378(1993)
Deiparinev.CourtofAppealsandTrinidad,221SCRA503(2003)
GraceParkEngineeringCo.Inc.v.Dimaporo,107SCRA266(1981)
Roquev.Lapuz,96SCRA741(1980)
Suriav.IntermediateAppellateCourt,151SCRA661(1987)
7
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Read:Art1786,1788,148486,RepublicActNo.6552
3. ObligationswithaPeriod(Art.1193,1180)
a. ComparePeriod/Termv.Condition
b. KindsofPeriod
i.
Astoeffect
Suspensive(Art1193,par.1)
Resolutory(Art1193,par.2)
ii.
Astoexpression
Express
Implied
iii.
Astodefiniteness
Definite
Indefinite
iv.
Astosource
Voluntary
Legal
Judicial
c. Rulesincaseofloss,deteriorationorimprovementbeforearrivalofthe
period(Art.1194and1189)
d. EffectofPaymentinAdvance(Art.1195;1197,par.3)
e. BenefitofPeriod(Art1196)
i.
Forwhosebenefit
Creditor
Debtor
Both
ii.
Effects
iii.
Presumption(Art.1196)
Lachicav.Araneta,47OfficialGazetteNo.11,5699(1949)
PoncedeLeonv.Syjuco,90Phil311(1951)
Bucev.CourtofAppeals,332SCRA151(2000)
iv.
Whendebtorlosesrighttomakeuseofperiod(Art.1198)
f. WhenCourtMayFixAPeriod
i.
Periodisimplied
ii.
Perioddependsonsolewillofthedebtor
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Aranetav.PhilippineSugarEstateDevelopmentCo.,20SCRA330(1967)
CentralPhilippineUniversityv.CourtofAppeals,supra.
Deudorv.J.M.Tuason,2SCRA129(1961)
4. AlternativeObligations
a. Concept(Art.1199)
b. RightofChoice(Art.1200)
c. EffectofNoticeofChoice
d. WhenNoticeProducesEffect(Art.1201)
e. Effectoflossorimpossibilityofoneorallprestations(Art.1202to1205)
f. FacultativeObligation(Art.1206)
i.
Concept
ii.
DistinguishedfromAlternativeObligations
iii.
EffectofSubstitution
5. JointandSolidaryObligations
a. JointObligations
i.
Concept
Requisites
Wordsusedtoindicatejointobligations
ii.
Presumption(Art.1207,1208)
iii.
Effects(Art.1207,1208)
Extentofliabilityofdebtor
Extentofrightofcreditor
Incaseofnovations,compensation,confusion(Art1277)or
remission
b. SolidaryObligations
i.
Concept
Requisites
Wordsusedtoindicatesolidaryobligations
ii.
Kinds
Astosource(Art.1208)
o Legal(Art.1915,1945,2194,Art119oftheRPC)
o Conventional
o Real
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Astopartiesbound
o Active
o Passive
o Mixed
Astouniformity
o Uniform
o Varied/nonuniform(Art.1211)
Ynchaustiv.Yulo,34Phil.978(1916)
Inciongv.CourtofAppeals,257SCRA578(1996)
RCBCv.CourtofAppeals,178SCRA739(1989)
LafargeCementPhil.V.ContinentalCement,443SCRA522(2004)
iii.
Effects
Solidarycreditorinrelationto:
o commondebtor
righttodemand(Art.12141216;1217,par.1)
incaseofnovation,compensation,confusion,
remissionbyacreditor(Art.1215,par.1)
o solidarycocreditors
incaseofnovation,compensation,confusion,
remissionbyacocreditor(Art1215,par.2)
prejudicialactsprohibited(Art.1212)
assignmentofrightsnotallowed(Art.1213)
Solidarydebtorinrelationto:
o commoncreditor
obligationtoperform(Art.1207)
incaseofnovation,compensation,confusion,
remissionbyacreditor(Art.1215,par.1)
o solidarycodebtor
incaseofpaymentbyacodebtor(Art.12171220)
incaseoffortuitousevent(Art.1221)
Jaucianv.Querol,38Phil.718(1918)
RehabilitationFinanceCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,
OfficialGazetteNo.6,p.2467
Quiombingv.CourtofAppeals,189SCRA325(1990)
Inciongv.CourtofAppeals,257SCRA578(1996)
iv.
DefensesAvailabletoaSolidaryDebtorAgainsttheCreditor(Art.
1222)
Types
o thosederivedfromthenatureoftheobligations
o personaldefenses
o defensespertainingtohisshares
o thosepersonallybelongingtotheothercodebtors
10
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Effects
Ynchaustiv.Yulo,supra.
Alipiov.CourtofAppeals,341SCRA441(2000)
c. JointIndivisibleObligations
i. Concept
Distinguishedfromjointobligations
Distinguishedfromsolidaryobligations
ii. Indivisibilitydistinguishedfromsolidarity(Art.1210)
iii. Effects(Art.1209,1224)
6. DivisibleandIndivisibleObligations
a. DivisibleObligations
i. Concept
ii. Effects(Art.1223,1233)
b. IndivisibleObligations
i. Concept:distinguishedfromsolidaryobligations
ii. Kinds
Natural(Art.1225,par.1)
Legal(Art.1225,par.3)
Conventional(Art.1225,par.3)
iii. Presumptionsofdivisibilityandindivisibility(Art.1225)
iv. Divisibilityandindivisibilityinobligationsnottodo(Art.1225,par.3)
v. Effects(Art.1223,1223,1224)
vi. CessationofIndivisibility
7. ObligationswithaPenalClause
a. Concept
Principalv.AccessoryObligation
Distinguishedfromconditionalobligations
Distinguishedfromalternativeobligations
Distinguishedfromfacultativeobligations
Distinguishedfromguaranty
11
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
b. KindsofPenalClause
Astoeffect
o Subsidiary
o Complimentary
Astosource
o Conventional
o Legal
Astopurpose
o Punitive
o Reparatory
c. DemandabilityofPenalty(Art.1226,par.2)
d. EffectsofPenalClause:GeneralRuleandExceptions
Substituteforindemnityfordamagesandpaymentofinterest(Art.1226)
MakatiDevelopmentCorp.v.EmpireInsuranceCo.20SCRA557(1967)
Tanv.CourtofAppeals,367SCRA571(2001)
CountryBankersInsurancev.CourtofAppeals,201SCRA458(1991)
Notexemptdebtorfromperformance(Art.1227)
Creditorcannotdemandbothperformanceandpenaltyatthesametime
(Art.1227)
Creditorcannotcollectotherdamagesinadditiontopenalty(Art.1226)
e. Whenpenaltyshallbeequitablyreduced(Art.1229)
f. NullityofPrincipalObligationofPenalClause(Art.1230)
D. ExtinguishmentofObligations(Art.1231)
1. PaymentorPerformance(Art.1232)
a. Concept(Art.1232)
b. Requisites
i. Whocanpay
GeneralRule
12
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Exceptions:
o thirdpersonwhoisaninterestedparty;effects(Art.1302[3])
o thirdpersonwhoisnotaninterestedpartybutwiththeconsentof
debtor(Art.1302[2],1236,par.1)
o thirdpersonwhoisnotaninterestedpartyandwithoutthe
consentofthedebtor,withouttheknowledgeoragainstthewillof
thedebtor(Art.1236,par.2;Art.1237,1236,par.1)
o thirdpersonwhodoesnotintendtobereimbursed(Art1238)
inanobligationtogive(Art.1239,1427)
incaseofactivesolidarity(Art.1214)
ii. Towhompaymentcanbemade
Generalrule(Art.1240)
Exceptions:
o incapacitatedperson(Art.1241,par.1)
o thirdperson(Art.1241,par.2)
o whenproofofbenefitnotrequired(Art.1241,par.3;Art.1242)
o incaseofactivesolidarity(Art.1214)
iii. Whatistobepaid(Identity)
GeneralRule
Specificcases:
o Togiveaspecificthing(Art.1244)
o Togiveagenericthing(Art.1246)
o Topaymoney(Art.1249,1250;R.A.529,R.A.4100,R.A.8183)
13
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Arrietav.NARIC,supra
Kalalov.Luz,34SCRA377(1970)
St.PaulFireandMarineInsurancev.Macondray,70SCRA122(1976)
Papav.A.V.Valencia,284SCRA643(1998)
PhilippineAirlinesv.CourtofAppeals,181SCRA557(1990)
PaymentofInterest(Art.1956)
iv. Howpaymentistobemade(Integrity)
GeneralRule(Art.1233)
o Partialpaymentisnotallowed;exceptions(Art.1248)
Substantialperformanceingoodfaith(Art.1234)
Estoppel(Art.1235)
Presumptionsinpaymentofinterestsandinstallments(Art.1176)
v. Whenispaymenttobemade
GeneralRule(Art1169)
Nodemand,nodelay;Exceptions
vi. Wherepaymentistomade
Placeexpresslydesignated(Art.1251,par.1)
Whenplaceofpaymentisnotexpresslydesignated(Art.1251,
paragraphs2to4)
vii. Whopaysforexpensesformakingpayment(Art.1247)
c. ApplicationofPayments
i.
Concept(Art.1252)
ReparationsCommissionv.UniversalDeepFishing,83SCRA764(1978)
Paculdov.Regalado,345SCRA134(2000)
ii.
iii.
Requisites
RulesinApplicationofPayments(Art.12521253)
Ifrulesarenotapplicableorcannotbeinferred(Art.1254)
Meaningofthemostonerousdebtor
14
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
d. PaymentbyCession
i.
Concept(Art.1255)
ii.
Requisites
iii.
Effects
iv.
ComparedtoAssignmentofReceivables
e. DationinPayment
i.
Concept(Art.1245)
DistinguishedfromPaymentbyCession
DevelopmentBankofthePhilippinesv.CourtofAppeals,284SCRA14
(1998)
ii.
Requisites
iii.
Effects
FilinvestCreditCorporationv.PhilippineAcetylene,111SCRA421(1982)
f. TenderofPaymentandConsignation
i.
TenderofPayment
Concept
Requisites
ii.
Consignation
ConceptandPurpose
Requisites
o Whentenderandrefusalnotrequired(Art.1256,par.2)
o Twonoticerequirement(Art.1257,par.1;Art.1258,par.
2);Effectsofnoncompliance
Effects(Art.1260,par1)
o Withdrawalbydebtorbeforeacceptancebycreditoror
approvalofcourt(Art.1260,par.2)
o Withdrawalbydebtorafterproperconsignation(Art.
1261)
Withcreditorapproval
Withoutcreditorapproval
ExpensesofConsignation
15
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
DeGuzmanv.CourtofAppeals,137SCRA730(1985)
TLGInternationalContinentalEnterprising,Inc.v.Flores,47SCRA437
(1972)
McLaughlinv.CourtofAppeals,144SCRA693(1986)
Socov.Militante,123SCRA160(1983)
Sottov.Mijares,28SCRA17(1969)
Reisenbeckv.CourtofAppeals,209SCRA657(1992)
RuralBankofCaloocanv.CourtofAppeals,104SCRA151(1981)
Licuananv.Diaz,175SCRA530(1989)
Chanv.CourtofAppeals,230SCRA685(1994)
MeatPackingCorp.v.Sandiganbayan,359SCRA409(2001)
2. LossorImpossibility
a. LossoftheThingDue
i.
Concept(Art.1189,par.2)
ii.
Kinds
Total
Partial
iii.
Requisites(Art.1262)
iv.
Presumption(Art.1266,1267)
v.
Effects
Inanobligationtogiveaspecificthing(Art.1262,1268)
Inanobligationtogiveagenericthing(Art.1263)
Incaseofpartialloss(Art1264)
Actionagainstthirdpersons(Art.1269)
b. ImpossibilityofPerformance
i.
Concept(Art.1266,1267)
ii.
Kinds
Total
Partial
iii.
Requisites(Art.1266)
iv.
Effects
Inobligationstodo(Art.12661267;Art.1262,par.2)
16
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Impossibilitydistinguishedfromdifficulty
Incaseofpartialimpossibility(art.1264)
Occeav.CourtofAppeals,73SCRA637(1976)
NagaTelephoneCompanyv.CourtofAppeals,230SCRA351(1994)
PNCCv.CourtofAppeals,272SCRA183(1997)
3. CondonationorRemission
a. Concept
b. Kinds
Totalorpartial
Expressorimplied(Art.1270,par.1)
c. Requisites(Art.1270,par.2)
Yamv.CourtofAppeals,303SCRA1(1999)
d. Presumptions(Art.12711271;1274)
e. Effects
Ingeneral
Incaseofjointorsolidaryobligations
f. GoverningRules(Art.1270)
g. RenunciationofPrincipalorAccessoryObligation(Art.1273)
4. ConfusionorMerger
a. Concept
b. Requisites
c. Effects
Ingeneral(Art.1275)
Incaseofjointorsolidaryobligations(Art.1277)
d. ConfusioninPrincipalorAccessoryObligations(Art.1276)
5. Compensation
a. Concept(Art.1278);distinguishedfromConfusion
17
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
b. Kinds
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
TotalorPartial
Legal
Conventional(Art.1279,Art.1282)
Judicial(Art.1283)
Facultative
LegalCompensation
i.Requisites(Art.12791280):Duedistinguishedfromdemandable
Gantionv.CourtofAppeals,28SCRA235(1969)
BankofthePhilippineIslandsv.Reyes,255SCRA571(1996)
PhilippineNationalBankv.SapphireShipping,259SCRA174(1996)
CKHIndustrialDevelopmentv.CourtofAppeals,272SCRA333(1997)
Mirasolv.CourtofAppeals,351SCRA44(2001)
AssociatedBankv.Tan,446SCRA282(2004)
Villanuevav.Tantuico,182SCRA263(1990)
Perezv.CourtofAppeals,127SCRA636(1984)
SilahisMarketingCorp.v.IntermediateAppellateCourt,180SCRA21
(1989)
BankofthePhilippineIslandsv.CourtofAppeals,255SCRA___(1996)
ii.Effects(Art.1290,1289)
WhenCompensationisnotallowed(Art.12871288)
CompensationofDebtsPayableinDifferentPlaces(Art.1286)
EffectofNullityofDebtstobeCompensated(Art.1284)
EffectsofAssignmentofCredit
i. withconsentofdebtor(Art.1285,par.1)
ii. withknowledgebutwithoutconsentofdebtor(Art.1285,par.2)
iii. withoutknowledgeofdebtor(Art.1285,par.3)
6. Novation
a. Concept(Art.1291)
Changeindebtor
Changeinobject
Changeinthirdpersonwhoissubrogated
Changeincreditorwithitsconsentoratitsinstanceisnotnovation
18
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
b. Kinds
i. Astoform:expressorimplied
ii. Astoorigin:conventionalorlegal
iii. Astoobject
objectiveorreal
subjectiveorpersonal
mixed
c. Requisites(Art.1292)
Millarv.CourtofAppeals,38SCRA642(1971)
Dormitoriov.Fernandez,72SCRA388(1976)
MagdalenaEstatev.Rodriguez,18SCRA967(1966)
Reyesv.SecretaryofJustice,264SCRA35(1996)
Cochingyanv.RBSuretyandInsurance,151SCRA339(1987)
BroadwayCentrumCondominiumCorporationv.TropicalHut,224SCRA
302(1993)
Molinov.SecurityDinersInternational,363SCRA358(2001)
Garciav.Llamas,417SCRA292(2003)
CaliforniaBusLinesv.StateInvestment,418SCRA297(2003)
Babstv.CourtofAppeals,350SCRA341(2001)
d. Effects(Art.1296)
e. EffectsoftheStatusoftheOriginalandNewObligation
i. nullityorvoidabilityoforiginalobligation(Art.1298)
ii. nullityorvoidabilityofnewobligation(Art.1297)
iii. suspensiveorresolutoryconditionororiginalobligation(Art.1299)
f. ObjectiveNovation
g. SubjectiveNovation
i. Bychangeofdebtor
Expromision
o Requisites(Art.1293)
o Effects(Art.1294)
Delegacion
o Requisites(Art.1293)
o Effects(Art.1295)
Garciav.Llamas,417SCRA292(2003)
Quintov.People,305SCRA709(1999)
19
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
ii.
Bychangeofcreditorsubrogationofathirdpersonintherightsofthe
creditor(Art.1300)
Conventionalsubrogation
o Requisites(Art.1301)
o Distinguishedfromassignmentofcredit
o Effects(Art.13031304)
Licarosv.Gatmaitan,(2001)
LegalSubrogation
o Requisites
o Whenpresumed(Art.1302)
o Effects(Art.13031304)
AstroElectronicsCorp.v.PhilippineExportandForeignLoanGuarantee
Corporation(2003)
20
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
PARTTWO:CONTRACTS
I.
Introduction
A. ConceptandDefinition(Art.1305)
B. ClassificationofContracts
1. Accordingtosubjectmatter:thingsorservices
2. Accordingtoname:nominateandinnominatecontracts(Art.1307)
3. Accordingtoperfection:bymereconsent(Art.1315)orbydeliveryofobject
(Art.1316)
4. Accordingtoitsrelationtoothercontracts:preparatory;principal;oraccessory
5. Accordingtoform:informalorformal
6. Accordingtopurpose
7. Accordingtonatureoflegaltiecreated:unilateral,bilateralorreciprocal
8. Accordingtocause:onerousorgratuitous
9. Accordingtorisk:commutativeoraleatory
Dizonv.Gaborro,83SCRA688(1978)
C. Characteristics
1. ObligatoryForcebetweentheParties(Art.1308)
a. GeneralRule:FreedomtoContract(Art.1306)
Gabrielv.MontedePiedad,71Phil.497(1941)
PakistanInternationalAirlinesv.Ople,190SCRA90(1990)
b. Exceptions:
i. Whenitisinequitable(Art.1310)
ii. Specialdisqualifications:
Art.87,FamilyCode
Articles1490and1491
Article1782
iii. Whatmaynotbestipulated
ContrarytoLaw
(a) pactumcommisorium(Art.2088)
(b) pactumleonina(Art.1799)
(c) pactumdenonalienado(Art.2130)
(d) otherlimitations:LaborCode,CorporationCode
Contrarytomorals
Contrarytogoodcustoms
Contrarytopublicorder
Contrarytopublicpolicy
21
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Cuiv.Arellano,2SCRA205(1961)
Arroyov.Berwin,36Phil386(1917)
FilipinasCompaiadeSegurosv.Mandanas,17SCRA391(1966)
Bustamantev.Rosel,319SCRA413(1999)
c. Effectofcontractastothirdparties
i. Performancemaybedeterminedbythirdparties(Art.1309)
ii. Whenpossessionoftheobjectofthecontractiswithathirdperson(Art.1312)
iii. Creditorsofcontractingparties(Art1313,1177,1381)
iv. Interferencebythirdparties(Art.1314)
Daywaltv.LaCorporacindelosPadresAgustinosRecoletos,etal.,
39Phil.587(1919)
SoPingBunv.CourtofAppeals,314SCRA751(1999)
Lagonv.CourtofAppeals,453SCRA616(2005)
2. Mutuality(Art.1308to1310;1473)
GSISv.CourtofAppeals,228SCRA183(1993)
ProfessionalAcademicPlans,Inc.etal.v.Crisostomo,453SCRA342(2005)
3. RelativityorPrivityofContracts(Art.1311)
a. Contractstakeeffectonlybetweentheparties,theirassignsandheirs
ManilaRailroadCo.v.LaCompaniaTransatlantica,38Phil.875(1918)
DKCHoldingsCorp.CourtofAppeals,329SCRA666(2000)
b. Noonemaycontractinthenameofanother(Art.1317)
GutierrezHermanosv.Orense,28Phil.571(1914)
c. Stipulationsinfavorofthirdpersons(Art.1311,par.2)
Florentinov.Encarnacion,79SCRA192(1977)
Coquiav.FieldmenInsuranceCo.,26SCRA178(1968)
Constantinov.Espiritu,39SCRA178(1968)
Youngv.CourtofAppeals,169SCRA213(1989)
MarmontResortv.Guiang,168SCRA373(1988)
MandarinVillav.CourtofAppeals,257SCRA538(1996)
22
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
II.
EssentialRequisitesofContracts
A. Consent:Requisites(Art.1319)
1.
PerfectionofContract:OfferandAcceptance
a.
Offer
mustbecertain(Art.1319)
whatmaybefixedbytheofferor(At.1321)
whenmadethroughanagent(Art.1322)
whenofferbecomesineffective(Art.1323)
businessadvertisementsofthingsforsale(Art.1325)
advertisementsforbidders(Art.1326)
b.
Acceptance
mustbeabsolute(Art.1319)
kinds:
o express(Art.1320)
o implied(Art.1320)
o qualified(Art.1319)
periodofacceptance(Art.1324)
optioncontract(Art.1324)
Sanchezv.Rigos,45SCRA368(1972)
c.
TerminationofOffer
d.
PerfectionofContract
Fourtheorieswhencontractisperfected:
o Manifestationtheory
o Expeditiontheory
o Receptiontheory
o Cognitiontheory(Art.1319[2])
Rosenstockv.Burke,46Phil.217(1924)
Malbarosav.CourtofAppeals,402SCRA168(2003)
SanLorenzoDevelopmentCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,449SCRA99(2005)
MMDAv.Jancom,G.R.No.147465,January30,2002
2.
LegalCapacityoftheParties
a. Minors,insaneordementedpersons,anddeafmuteswhodonotknow
howtowrite(Art.1327)
b. Whenofferoracceptanceismadeduringalucidinterval,intoxication,
duringhypnoticspell(Art.1328)
c. Corporations(Sections23and36,CorporationCode)
23
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
3.
VicesofConsent:ConsentmustbeIntelligent,Free,SpontaneousandReal
(Art.1330to1346)
a. MistakeorError
i. MistakeofFact
Astosubstanceoftheobject
Astoprincipalconditions
Astoidentityorqualificationsoftheparties
Astoquantity,asdistinguishedfromsimplemistakeofaccount
Asiainv.Jalandoni,45Phil296(1923)
HeirsofWilliamSevillav.Sevilla,402SCRA501(2003)
Andresv.ManufacturersHanoverandTrust,177SCRA618
SpousesTheisv.CourtofAppeals,268SCRA167(1997)
ii. MistakeorErrorofLaw
GeneralRule:Ignoranceofthelawexcusesnoone(Art.3)
Exception:MutualErrorofLaw(Art.1334)
iii. Mistakewhenonepartyisunabletoread(Art.1332)
Dumasugv.Modelo,34Phil252(1916)
Hemedesv.CourtofAppeals,316SCRA347(1990)
Lustanv.CourtofAppeals,266SCRA663(1997)
Katipunanv.Katipunan,375SCRA199(2002)
Leonardov.CourtofAppeals,438SCRA201(2004)
iv. Inexcusablemistake(Art.1333)
b. ViolenceorIntimidation(Art.1335)
Martinezv.HSBC,15Phil.252(1910)
Leev.CourtofAppeals,201SCRA405(1991)
c. UndueInfluence(Art.1337)
d. FraudorDolo(Art.1338)
Kinds:
i. Dolocausante(Art.1338)
ii. Doloincidente(Art.1344[2])
Hillv.Veloso,31Phil.161(1915)
Woodhousev.Halili,supra.
Geraldezv.CourtofAppeals,230SCRA320(1994)
Sierrav.CourtofAppeals,211SCRA785(1992)
24
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
FailuretoDiscloseFactswhenthereisadutytorevealthem(Art.1339)
Tuasonv.Marquez,45Phil381(1923)
RuralBankofSta.Mariav.CourtofAppeals,314SCRA255(1999)
Usualexaggerationsintrade:opportunitytoknowthefacts(Art.1340)
Azarragav.Gay,52Phil.599(1928)
Trinidadv.IntermediateAppellateCourt,204SCRA524(1991)
Mereexpressionofopinion(Art.1341);Effects(Art.1344)
Songcov.Sellner,37Phil.254(1917)
e. Misrepresentation
i. byathirdperson(Art.1342)
ii. madeingoodfaith(Art.1343)
iii. activeorpassive
4.
Mercadov.Espiritu,37Phil.215(1917)
Braganzav.VillaAbrille,105Phil.456(1959)
SimulationofContracts
Rodriguezv.Rodriguez,28SCRA229(1914)
Suntayv.CourtofAppeals,251SCRA430(1995)
Pangadiletal.v.CourtofFirstInstance,G.R.No.L32437,August31,1982
Umaliv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.89561,September13,1990
a. Kinds:AbsoluteandRelative(Art.1345)
b. Effects(Art.1346)
B. Object
Mustbedeterminateastoitskind(Art.1379)
WhatmayNOTbeobjectsofcontracts(Art.1347)
a. Allthingsoutsidethecommerceofman
b. Allintransmissiblerights
c. Thoseserviceswhicharecontrarytolaw,morals,goodcustoms,public
order,orpublicpolicy
d. Futureinheritance,exceptwhenauthorizedbylaw
e. Impossiblethingsorservices(Art.1348)
Blasv.Santos,1SCRA899(1961)
JLTAgro,Inc.v.Balansag,453SCRA211,G.R.No.141882,March11,2005
25
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
C. Cause
1. MeaningofCause(Art.1350)
a. inonerouscontracts
b. inremuneratorycontracts
c. incontractsofpurebeneficence
2. DistinguishedfromMotive(Art.1351)
3. Presumption:ExistenceandLawfulnessofCause(Art.1354)
4. DefectiveCausesandEffects:
a. AbsenceofCauseorUnlawfulCause(Art.1352)
b. StatementofFalseCause(Art.1355)
c. InadequacyofCauseorLesion(Art.1355)
Liguezv.CourtofAppeals,102Phil.577(1957)
Carantesv.CourtofAppeals,76SCRA514(1977)
SpousesBuenaventurav.CourtofAppeals,416SCRA263
III.
FormofContracts
A. GeneralRule:Contractsareobligatoryinwhateverform,providedallessential
requisitesarepresent(Art.1356)
B. Exception:Whenthelawrequiresthecontracttobeinaspecificforminorderforit
tobevalidorenforceable(Art.1356)
Kindofformalitiesrequiredbylaw:
1. Forvalidity(Articles748,749,1874,2134,1771,1773)
2. Tomakeiteffectiveastothirdparties(Articles1357and1358)
3. Forpurposesofprovingexistenceofcontract(StatuteofFraudsinArt.1403)
Hernandezv.JudgedelosAngeles,27SCRA1276(1969)
Resuenav.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.128338,March28,2005
InterpretationofContracts
IV.
A. ComparewithRulesofStatutoryConstruction
B. PrimacyofIntention(Articles1370,1372)
Borromeov.CourtofAppeals,47SCRA65(1972)
Kasilagv.Rodriguez,69Phil.217(1939)
Santiv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.93625,227SCRA541(1993)
C. DeterminingIntention(Art.1371)
Rapanutv.CourtofAppeals,246SCRA323(1995)
26
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
D. RulesofContractInterpretation
1. UndertheCivilCode
a. Whenitcontainsstipulationswhichadmitofseveralmeanings(Art.1373)
OilandNaturalGasCommissionv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.114323,
July23,1998
b. Whenitcontainsvariousstipulations,someofwhicharedoubtful(Art.1374)
SpousesRigorv.ConsolidatedOrixLeasingandFinanceCorporation,G.R.
136423,August20,2002
c. Whenitcontainswordswithdifferentmeanings(Art.1375)
V.
d. Whenitcontainsambiguitiesandomissionofstipulations(Art.1376)
Chuav.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.119255,April9,2003
e. Withrespecttothepartywhocausedtheobscurity(Art.1377)
RizalCommercialBankingCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.
133107,March25,1999
f. Whenitisimpossibletosettledoubtsusingtheabovecitedrules(Art.1378)
Ingratuitouscontracts
Gacosv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.Nos.8596263,August3,1992
Inonerouscontracts
g. Whendoubtsarecastupontheprincipalobjectsothatthetrueintention
cannotbeknown(Art.1378)
2. UndertheRulesofCourt(Rule130,Sections10to19)
ReformationofInstruments
A. Requisites(Art.1359)
1. Meetingoftheminds
2. Trueintentionofthepartiesarenotexpressedintheinstrument
3. Failuretoexpresstrueintentionduetomistake,fraud,inequitableconduct,or
accident
27
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
B.
C.
D.
E.
VI.
A.
Garciav.Bisaya,97Phil.609(1955)
Bentirv.Leande,330SCRA591(2000)
Quirosv.Arjona,G.R.No.158901,March9,2004
WhenReformationisnotallowed(Art.1366)
ImpliedRatification(Art.1367)
Whomayaskforreformation(Art.1368)
Procedureforreformation(Art.1369)
Atilanov.Atilano,28SCRA2232(1969)
Carantesv.CourtofAppeals,76SCRA514(514)
Sarmingv.Dy,383SCRA131(2002)
DefectiveContracts
RescissibleContracts
1. Kinds(Art.1381)
2. Characteristics
a. Thedefectconsistsininjuryordamageeithertooneofthecontracting
partiesoftoathirdperson
b. Contractisvalidbeforerescission
c. Attackmayonlybedirecton,notcollaterally
d. Attackmaybedonebycontractingpartyorbyathirdpersonwhoisinjured
ordefrauded
e. Validatedonlybyprescriptionandnotbyratification
3. Definition(Art.1380):DistinguishedfromRescissioninArt.1191(Resolution)
UniversalFoodCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,33SCRA1(1970)
SpousesCannuv.SpousesGalang,G.R.No.139523,May26,2005
Iringanv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.129107,September26,2001
Riverav.delRosario,G.R.No.144934,January15,2004
EquatorialRealtyv.MayfairTheatre,G.R.No.133879,November21,2001
4. Requisites
a. Contractisrescissible
b. Partyaskingforrescissionhasnootherlegalmeanstoobtainreparation
(Art.1383)
UnionInsuranceSocietyofCantonv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.100319,
August8,1996
28
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
c. Heisabletoreturnwhathemaybeobligedtorestoreifrescissionisgranted
(Art.1385)
Riverav.delRosario,G.R.No.144934,January15,2004
5. EffectofRescission(Art.1385)
a. Astothirdpersonswhoacquiredthingingoodfaith(Art.1385[2]and[3]
b. Astothirdpersonswhoacquiredthingsinbadfaith,whenalienationwasin
fraudofcreditors(Art.1388)
6. ExtentofRescission(Art.1384)
Siguanv.Lim,318SCRA725(1999)
7. BadgesofFraud(Art.1387)
Oriav.McMicking,21Phil,243(1912)
Siguanv.Lim,318SCRA725(1999)
Suntayv.CourtofAppeals,251SCRA430(1995)
ChinaBankingCorporationv.CourtofAppeals,G.R.No.129644,March7,2000
MRHoldingsLimitedv.Carlos,G.R.No.138104,April11,2002
B. VoidableorAnnullableContracts
1. Kinds(Art1390)
2. Characteristics
a. Thereisadefectinconsentofoneofthecontractingparties
b. Bindinguntilannulledbyacompetentcourt
c. Maybevalidatedbyratificationorprescription
Felipev.HeirsofAldon,120SCRA628(1983)
3. Annulment
a. DistinguishedfromRescission
b. Grounds(Art.1390)
c. WhoMayorMayNotInstituteActionforAnnulment(Art.1397)
Singsongv.IsabelaSawmill,88SCRA623(1979)
SamahanngMagsasakasaSanJosepv.Valisno,430SCRA629(2004)
Malabananv.GawChing,181SCRA84(1990)
Armentiav.Patriarca,18SCRA1253(1966)
29
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
d. Prescription(Art.1391)
Carantesv.CourtofAppeals,76SCRA514(514)
e. Effect:MutualRestitution(Art.1398and1402)
Cadwallader&Co.v.Smith,Bell&Co.,7Phil.461(1907)
Velardeetal.v.CourtofAppeals,361SCRA56(2001)
Inesv.CourtofAppeals,247SCRA312(1995)
ArraRealtyCorporationv.GuaranteeDevelopmentCorporation,438
SCRA441(2004)
i. Whenonthepartiesisincapacitated(Art1399)
Katipunanv.Katipunan,375SCRA199(2002)
ii. Whenthethingislostthroughthefaultofthepartyobligedtoreturnthe
sam(Art.1400)
f. ExtinguishmentofActionforAnnulment
i. byratification(Art.1392)
ii. Whenthethingislostthroughthefaultofthepersonwhohastherightto
filetheaction(Art.1401)
4. Ratification
a. Requisites
i. Contractisvoidable
ii. Ratificationismadewithknowledgethatcontractisvoidable
iii. Atthetimeofratification,thecausefornullityhasalreadyceasedtoexist
b. Forms
i. Expressortacit(Art.1393)
ii. Bythepartiesthemselvesorbytheguardianinbehalfofanincapacitated
party(Art.1394)
c. Effects
i. actiontoannulisextinguished(Art.1392)
UySooLimv.TanUnchuan,38Phil.552(1918)
ii. contractiscleansedretroactivelyfromallitsdefects(Art.1396)
30
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
C. UnenforceableContracts
1. Characteristics
a. Validbutcannotbeenforcesbyaproperactionincourt
b. Canberatified
c. Cannotbeassailedbythirdpersons
2. Kinds(Art.1403)
a. Unauthorizedcontracts(Art.1404)
b. ContractscoveredbyStatuteofFrauds
i. PurposeofStatuteofFrauds
AsiaProductionCo.Inc.v.JudgePano,205SCRA458(1992)
WesternMindanaoCo.v.Medalle,79SCRA703(1977)
Limketkai&Sonsv.CourtofAppeals,250SCRA523(1995)
Babaov.Perez,102Phil.756(1957)
Reissv.Memije,15Phil.350(1910)
Villanuevav.CourtofAppeals,267SCRA89(1997)
ii. HowRatified(Art.1405)
PhilippineNationalBankv.PhilippineVegetableOilCo.49Phil.857(1927)
Carbonnellv.Poncioetal,103Phil.655(1958)
FirstPhilippineInternationalBankv.CourtofAppeals,252SCRA259
(196)
iii. RightofthePartieswhenaContractisenforceablebutapublicdocument
isnecessaryforitsregistration(Art.1406)
c. Contractsexecutedbypartieswhoarebothincapableofgivingconsent
i. Effectofratificationbytheparentsorguardianofoneoftheparties(Art.
1407)
ii. Effectofratificationbytheparentsorguardianofbothparties(Art.1407)
D. VoidorInexistentContracts
1. Characteristics
Voidfromthebeginning
Producesnoeffectwhatsoever
Cannotberatified(Art.1409)
31
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
Tongoyv.CourtofAppeals,123SCRA99(1983)
Cuiv.Arellano,2SCRA205(1961)
Chavezv.PresidentialCommissiononGoodGovernment,307SCRA372(1999)
Guiangv.CourtofAppeals,291SCRA372(1998)
Castillov.Galvan,85SCRA526(1978)
2. Kinds
a. VoidContracts
i. Thosewhosecause,objectorpurposeiscontrarytolaw,morals,good
customs,publicorderorpublicpolicy
Whentheactconstitutesacriminaloffense(Art.1411)
Whentheactisunlawfulbutdoesnotconstituteacriminaloffense
(Art.1412)
o Inparidelictorule
Menchavezv.Teves,449SCRA380(2005)
Angelv.AledoandModales,420SCRA645(2004)
Whenthepurposeisillegalandmoneyispaidorproperty
deliveredtherefore(Art.1414)
Whenthecontractisillegalandoneofthepartiesisincapableof
givingconsent(Art.1415)
Liguezv.CourtofAppeals,102Phil.577(1957)
Rellosav.GawCheenHum,93Phil827(1953)
Whentheagreementisnotperseillegalbutprohibited(Art.
1416)
PhilippineBankingCorporationv.LuiShe,21SCRA52(1967)
Frenzelv.Catito,406SCRA55(2003)
AcabalandNicolasv.Acabal,454SCRA555(2005)
Whentheamountpaidexceedthemaximumfixedbylaw9Art.
1417)
Whenbyvirtueofacontractalabourerundertakestoworklonger
thanthemaximumnumberofhoursofworkfixedbylaw(Art.
1418)
Whenthecontractisdivisible(Art.1420)
Whenthecontractisthedirectresultofapreviouslillegalcontract
(Art.1422)
32
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
ii. Thosewhoseobjectisoutsidethecommerceofman
iii. Thosewhichcontemplateanimpossibleservice
iv. Thosewheretheintentionofthepartiesrelativetotheprincipal
objectofthecontractcannotbeascertained
v. Thoseexpresslyprohibitedbylaw
b. InexistentContracts
i. thosewhichareabsolutelysimulatedorfictitious(Articles1345to
1346)
ii. thosewhosecauseorobjectdidnotexistatthetimeofthetransaction
3. NoWaiverofDefenseofIllegality(Art.1409)
4. ActionorDefensefortheDeclarationoftheInexistenceofaContract
Noprescriptionperiod(Art.1410)
Notavailabletothirdpersonsnotdirectlyaffected(At.1421)
33
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
PARTTHREE:SPECIFICEXAMPLESOFOBLIGATIONS
ObligationsCreatedbyLaw
A. Estoppel
1. Definition(Art.1431)
Kalalov.Luz,34SCRA337(1970)
2. Kinds
a. Technicalestoppel
i. byrecord
ii. bydeed(Art.1433)
b. Equitableestoppelorestoppelinpais(Art.1433)
3. PersonsBound(Art.1439)
ManilaLodgeNo.761BenevolentandProtectiveOrderoftheElksv.Court
ofAppeals,73SCRA168(1976)
4. Application(Art.1434to1438)
Miguelv.Catalino,26SCRA234(1969)
Read:Annotation32SCRA542
Mendozav.ReyesandCourtofAppeals,G.R.No.L31618,August17,1983
B. Trusts
1. Definition(Art.1442)
2. Parties(Art.1440)
a. Trustor
b. Trustee
c. Beneficiaryorcestuiquetrust
Salaov.Salao,70SCRA168(1976)
3. Kinds(Art.1441)
a. Expresstrusts
i. Proofrequired(Art.1443)
ii. Form(Art.1444)
iii. Wantoftrustee(Art.1445)
iv. Acceptancebythebeneficiary(Art.1441)
34
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
b. ImpliedTrusts
i. Howestablished(Art1441)
ii. Howproved(Art.1457)
iii. Specificcases(Art.1448to1456)
Fabianv.Fabian,22SCRA231(1968)
Buenov.Reyes,27SCRA1179(1969)
Tamayov.Callejo,46SCRA27(1972)
HeirsofSanjorjov.Quijano,G.R.No.140457,January19,2005)
AznarBrothersRealtyCompanyv.Aying,G.R.No.144773,May16,2005.
35
Law101:ObligationsandContractsProf.MaryRoseS.Tan
Semester2,AY20122013
36