6WZZ 7ZSUU D]`b`sb SW\Sa GwQVbWUS\ OZa jc\US` AO\\

5ca RS[ 9\UZWaQVS\ d]\ AOZbS ?`cbhaQV

:w` OZZS$ RWS \]QV RO R`OcrS\ aW\R&

8S\YS\ eW` O\ ROa @WQVb x eWS eSWb Sa TsZZb$ PWa Sa PSW c\a Wab& n:OZZS\l aOUS\ eW` c\R PShSWQV\S\ RO[Wb SW\S U`c\RZSUS\RS 5`b c\R KSWaS$ hc` KSZb hc Y][[S\& K=@@=5A ?=HHF98;9$ 5 <]ZS W\ bVS GYg

?`ObhS`
=QV YO\\ \WQVb eSU$ c\R Sa Wab \WQVb US\cU RO& AO`Y Wab d]ZZ R`OcT c\R PZOTTb \WS USVv`bS KSWaVSWbS\ d]\ RS` ?O\bS aSW\Sa aQVeO`hS\ JW\gZa]TOa& 9` TcV`eS`Yb VS`c[ eWS SW\ R`SWTOQV PSaQVZSc\WUbS` ;SVv`Z]aS\R]Z[SbaQVS` x RWS <s\RS TZObbS`\$ RWS GQVcZbS`\ c\R RWS 5`[S hcQYS\& 8WS 6SW\S aW\R OcQV W\ 5YbW]\$ eS`RS\ c\bS` aSW\S[ ZO\US\$ Rw``S\ ;SabSZZ OPS` \c` W\ `SUSZ[srWUS\ 5Pabs\RS\ O\RS`a wPS`SW\O\RS`USaQVZOUS\& Bc` ROa 6SW\SY`SchS\ ZscTb PSW AO`Y SW\WUS`[OrS\ US]`R\Sb OP& 8S` FSab Wab SW\S C`UWS d]\ ^ZvbhZWQVS\ 6SeSUc\US\ c\R ?`s[^TS\$ eWS PSW SW\S` AO`W]\SbbS$ RWS SW\S[ P`cbOZS\ Dc^^S\a^WSZS` OcaUSZWSTS`b Wab& GSW\S 5cUS\ aW\R$ eWS [SW\S OcQV$ [ObbaQVeO`hS Ac`[SZ\& AO`Y ^OZOdS`b d]\ SW\S[ 7`OQYRSOZS`$ PSW RS[ S` T`wVS` USYOcTb VOb c\R RS` USaQV\O^^b e]`RS\ Wab x S` VObya \Obw`ZWQV Y][[S\ aSVS\$ eWS W[[S` x$ OPS` WQV Vv`S \WQVb VW\& AWQV W\bS`SaaWS`b \c`$ ROaa eW` [Wb c\aS`S` HwbS Rc`QV aW\R& 8Oa ROc[S\U`]rS NW^Z]Q%HwbQVS\$ ROa SW\[OZ ^`OZZ [Wb 7`OQYYv`\S`\ USTwZZb eO`$ Wab ZSS`& 9a eW`R HOU$ c\R RWS 8SOZS` VOPS\ WV`S HSZST]\S OPUSaQVOZbSb& ASW\S PSWRS\ 8SOZS` VSWrS\ FWQ] c\R <O^^g& AO`Y hcT]ZUS VSWrS\ OZZS 7`OQYRSOZS` FWQ] c\R <O^^g& FWQ] VOb aWQV OcT [SW\S ZSbhbS\ 5\`cTS VW\ \WQVb PZWQYS\ ZOaaS\& AO`Y$ RS` Sa aWQV hc` 5cTUOPS US[OQVb VOb$ wPS` <O\RSZ c\R KO\RSZ SW\S` <O\Rd]ZZ 8SOZS` OcT RS[ @OcTS\RS\ hc aSW\$ PSVOc^bSb$ ROaa FWQ] \OQVZsaab$ eSWZ S` eWSRS` OcT LO\Of Wab& J]`WUSa >OV` VOb S` aSW\S K]V\c\U W\ KOaVW\Ub]\ <SWUVba R`SW A]\ObS ZO\U \WQVb dS`ZOaaS\& 5Za] `cTS WQV jSbhb <O^^g O\$ c\R RS` S`aQVSW\b \OQV AWbbS`\OQVb$ OZa ROa )(((%8]ZZO`% HOUSaZW[Wb [SW\S` 6O\YYO`bS OcaZscTb c\R WQV eWSRS` ;SZR OPVSPS\ YO\\& <O^^g Wab RS` NcdS`ZsaaWUS`S RS` PSWRS\$ R]QV FWQ] ZWSTS`b ]Tb hc NSWbS\$ e] aWQV a]\ab YSW\ 8SOZS` `wV`b& 9` Y][[b [WbbS\ O[ HOU$ [Wb Gbc\RS\ JS`a^sbc\U heO`$ OPS` RWS O\RS`S\ aQVZOTS\ RO\\ OZZS c\R VOPS\ :SWS`OPS\R& 9` [SQYS`b c\R UWPb RW` SW\S ?\OcaS`bwbS$ OPS` S` Y][[b& AWb AO`Ya HSZST]\ `cTS WQV FWQ] O\$ R]QV RSaaS\ AOWZP]f Wab d]ZZ c\R hSWQV\Sb YSW\S BOQV`WQVbS\ [SV` OcT& =QV esVZS <O^^ga Bc[[S` c\R PSY][[S RW`SYb aSW\S AOWZP]f& <O^^g c\R FWQ] dS`YOcTS\ 7`OQY& GWS dS`YOcTS\ eSRS` :`SSPOaS \]QV D]b$ 9QabOag ]RS` a]\ab SbeOa& =QV YOcTS \c` d]`USY]QVbSa 7`OQY W\ HwbS\& AO\QVS @ScbS Y]QVS\ Sa aWQV ZWSPS` aSZPab x SW\ Y\WTTZWUSa JS`TOV`S\$ hc RS[ [O\ ?]YOW\$ 6OQY^cZdS`$ KOaaS` c\R SW\S ?]QV^ZObbS P`OcQVb x$ OPS` ROPSW VOPS WQV \c` jSeSWZa ROa 7]YS dS`aQVeS\RSb$ [W` RWS :W\US` dS`P`O\\b c\R SW\S\ \OaaS\ ?Zc[^ObaQV VS`OcaPSY][[S\$ RS` aWQV YOc[ `OcQVS\ ZWSr&

ZWSr& ;WP [W` RS\ ?`ObhS`$ PZOTTb AO`Y& GSW\ 7`OQY`vV`QVS\ x SW\ YZSW\Sa ;ZOa`]V` [Wb SW\USZSUbS[ 6`WZZ]R`OVb x Wab d]ZZS` ?\WSab& KS\\ S` RS\ `OcaY`Obhb$ P`W\Ub c\a ROa \]QV [W\RSabS\a heSW <Wba& 9` ZSUb RWS ZO\US\ 6SW\S wPS`SW\O\RS` eWS SW\ G^W\\S\bWS`$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U aQVSW\b Sa$ OZa ew`RS S` c[YW^^S\& 9` aWSVb Oca eWS wPS` aSQVhWU x U`OcSa ;SaWQVb$ Fc\hSZ\$ d]`abSVS\RS ?\]QVS\ x$ Wab O\USPZWQV OPS` 5\TO\U dWS`hWU& GSWb wPS` R`SW >OV`S\ Y][[S WQV [Wb hc\SV[S\RS` <scTWUYSWb hc WV[$ c[ hc `OcQVS\& =QV USPS WV[ ROa aQVO`bWUS ASbOZZbSWZ$ ROa PWa USabS`\ 5PS\R \]QV OZa GQVW`[a^SWQVS USRWS\b VOb& Nc[ ?`ObhS\ \W[[b [O\ OZZSa AvUZWQVS x [SWabS\a c\ZOQYWS`bS 8`OVbYZSWRS`PwUSZ$ OPS` GQVW`[S VOPS\ ZO\US$ Rw\\S$ [O\QV[OZ VOZPhgZW\R`WaQVS ASbOZZabsPS$ RWS aWQV hc[ 5caY`ObhS\ RS` FvV`QVS\ PSa]\RS`a Ucb SWU\S\ c\R$ eS\\ RWS HwbS ZSS` Wab$ [O\QV[OZ \]QV SW\$ heSW Kc\RS`VWba hcbOUS Tv`RS`\$ PSd]` [O\ RWS 7]cQV c\R RS\ 6]RS\ \OQV ?`w[SZ\ "eWS WQV aOUS# Phe& GbwQYQVS\ "eWS AO`Y aOUb# OPacQVS\ [caa$ OZa] \OQV RS[$ eOa Tw` OZZS 7`OQYawQVbWUS\ RWS ZSbhbS NcTZcQVb Wab$ PWa aWS O\ SW\S \ScS HwbS Y][[S\& =QV eWZZ AO`Y RS\ ?`ObhS` USPS\$ c\R S` hcQYb hc`wQY& 8Oa FvV`QVS\ TsZZb WV[ Oca RS\ <s\RS\$ TsZZb W\ NSWbZc^S heWaQVS\ c\a \WSRS` c\R hS`a^`W\Ub OcT RS[ OPUSab]rS\S\ DO`YSbbP]RS\& AO`Y aQV\O^^b SVS` \OQV @cTb$ OZa ROaa S` a^`WQVb& CV& CV \SW\& I[ ;]bbSa eWZZS\& GQV]\ Y\WSb S` O[ 6]RS\ c\R ab]QVS`b W\ RS\ GQVS`PS\& 9` YZOcPb SbZWQVS U`vrS`S ;ZOaabwQYS OcT$ ZSUb aWS SW\hSZ\ OcT RS\ 7]cQVbWaQV c\R Ts\Ub O\$ aWS [Wb RS[ ?`ObhS` hc PSO`PSWbS\& GQVOc\eS` [OZ& GQVOc\eS` [OZ$ [c`[SZb S` d]` aWQV VW\$ esV`S\R S` aWQV VSYbWaQV RWS SW\hSZ\S\ GQVS`PS\ d]`\W[[b& KWSRS` aQVSW\b Sa$ OZa es`S\ aSW\S ;SZS\YS$ <s\RS c\R ;ZWSR[OrS\ \WQVb d]\ @SPS\ S`TwZZb$ a]\RS`\ ew`RS\ [Wb U`W[[WUS` D`shWaW]\ d]\ GQV\w`S\ USTwV`b$ RWS O\ WV[ hS``S\ c\R hWSVS\ c\R WV\ hc` Dc^^S\a^WSZdS`aW]\ SW\Sa ;]ZRU`sPS`a [OQVS\$ RS` aSW\S KO\\S TWSPS`VOTb \OQV ;]ZRabscPQVS\ OPacQVb& AO`Y TW\RSb YSW\ ;]ZR& 9` ZSUb RS\ ?`ObhS`$ RWS ;ZOaa^ZWbbS` VW\$ c\R aSW\S 6SeSUc\US\ Y][[S\ hc[ GbWZZabO\R& 9` Zsaab aWQV OcT RWS 7]cQV hc`wQYaW\YS\$ c\R [O\ aWSVb Tv`[ZWQV$ eWS RWS GQV\w`S$ RWS WV\ OcT`SQVbUSVOZbS\ VOPS\$ c[ WV\ VS`c[ \WSRS`TOZZS\& 8WS HwbS Wab ZSS`$ c\R Sa Wab aSQVa IV` T`wV& KW` VOZbS\ c\a aSWb aSQVa HOUS\ c\R Tw\T BsQVbS\ R`O\$ c\R OZZS O\RS`S\ FvV`QVS\ aW\R YO^cbb& <W\bS` RS\ VS`c\bS`USZOaaS\S\ F]ZZ]a eW`R Sa VSZZ& AW\cbS\ dS`USVS\$ c\R \c` ROa ZSWaS 5cTVScZS\ RS` AwZZeOUS\ R`OcrS\ Rc`QVP`WQVb RWS GbWZZS& =QV VOPS SW\S\ ^]QVS\RS\ GQV[S`h W[ BOQYS\$ c\R [SW\S GQVcZbS`[caYSZ\ aW\R abSWT c\R dS`a^O\\b& 8S` ^]QVS\RS GQV[S`h VsZb GQV`Wbb [Wb [SW\S[ <S`hS\$ ROa USUS\ RWS 6`cab aQVZsUb eWS SW\S ewbS\RS :Ocab& =QV YO\\ \WQVb abWZZVOZbS\& 5Za AO`Y OcTabSVb$ c[ ROa ;ZOa OcThcTSUS\$ aSVS WQV$

:Ocab& =QV YO\\ \WQVb abWZZVOZbS\& 5Za AO`Y OcTabSVb$ c[ ROa ;ZOa OcThcTSUS\$ aSVS WQV$ ROaa aSW\ ?v`^S` W[ HOYb [Wb [SW\S[ eO\Yb$ ROaa c\aS`S 6SeSUc\US\ ag\QV`]\ aW\R eWS PSW KOaaS`^TZO\hS\$ RWS aWQV W\ RS`aSZPS\ Gb`v[c\U eWSUS\$ c\R Sa b`vabSb c\R S`aQV`SQYb [WQV hcUZSWQV$ eWS sV\ZWQV eW` c\a W\ RS[ V]TT\c\UaZ]aS\ 5Pabc`h aW\R$ RS` Y][[b$ eS\\ RWS 8`]US\ OcaUSVS\& 8S` aQVZSWQVS\RS <]``]` RS` ZSbhbS\ K]QVS\ x FwQYTOZZ3 eSU d]\ B]OV$ [SW\S[ :`Sc\R$ Y\O^^ OQVb HOUS d]` 9\RS RSa Gc\RO\QS :WZ[ :SabWdOZa3 9%AOWZ O\ [SW\S ;SaQVsTba^O`b\S`W\ ?ObS$ ROaa aWS [Wb c\aS`S` :W`[O [OQVS\ YO\\$ eOa aWS eWZZ$ eSWZ WQV \WQVb eWSRS`Y][[S3 5\% c\R 5P[SZRc\U W\ SW\S` 9\bhcUaYZW\WY W\ BSe 7O\OO\$ 7]\\SQbWQcb3 RWS qPS`\OQVbc\US\ W[ .( HV][^a]\ <]bSZ c\R ROa 5PbOcQVS\ W\ RWS Y\WSabWUS 7`OQYZO\RaQVOTb d]\ AO`Ya K]V\c\U [Wb RS\ GQV\]``S`\$ RWS W[[S` RO aW\R$ eS\\ Sa jS[O\R Y`OQVS\ Zsaab& 8WS aQV`SQYZWQVS\ GhS\S\ RS` jw\UabS\ JS`UO\US\VSWb$ RWS W[[S` VW\bS` [SW\S\ 5cUS\ OcTPZWbhS\$ eS\\ aWQV \WQVb$ YZO` eWS RS` \ScS HOU$ ROa 6WZR RS` \OVS\ NcYc\Tb d]`R`s\Ub$ W\ RS` Sa YSW\S\ GbSW\ [SV` UWPb c\R OcT Gbc\RS\ YSW\S\ USPS\ eW`R& =QV eSWr \]QV \WQVb$ eWS WQV RWS b`]abZ]aS\$ TZObbS`WUS\ Gbc\RS\ Rc`QVabSVS\ a]ZZ$ PWa <O^^g USUS\ 5PS\R aSW\ <O\Rg eWSRS` SW\aQVOZbSb c\R BOQVaQVcP ZWSTS`b& =QV eSWr \]QV \WQVb$ ROaa WQV x VWS` c\R O\ sV\ZWQVS\ C`bS\ x wPS` SW\S\ A]\Ob a] eSWbS`[OQVS\ eS`RS& 8Oaa WQV ROPSW TOab heO\hWU ?WZ] OP\SV[S\ eS`RS c\R [Wb +, RO\\ eS\WUS` eWSUS OZa W\ RS` OQVbS\ ?ZOaaS& J]\ RS[ \ScS\ GQVZ]aa O\ [SW\S` 6w`]bw` eSWr WQV OcQV \]QV \WQVba& ?ObS eW`R ROa OZbS OcaeSQVaSZ\$ eS\\ aWS [S`Yb$ ROaa WQV \OQVba ROUSeSaS\ PW\& 6Wa ROVW\ aW\R Sa OPS` \]QV K]QVS\& GWS PSTw`QVbSb$ WQV Yv\\bS W`US\RSbeOa abSVZS\$ c[ 8`]US\ ROd]\ hc YOcTS\$ ROPSW USVS WQV \c` VW\$ c[ \]QV SW\ ^OO`[OZ O\ [SW\S[ GQV`SWPbWaQV hc aWbhS\& 8S[ HSWZ d]\ [W`$ RS` eS\WUabS\a \OQV OcrS\ VW\ O[ PSabS\ Tc\YbW]\WS`b VOb$ ORWSc hc aOUS\& J]\ RS[ U`]rS\ ]TTS\S\ :S\abS` VW\bS` [SW\S[ GQV`SWPbWaQV PZWQYS WQV OcTa 9[^W`S GbObS 6cWZRW\U [Wb aSW\S` [wRS\ 5cb]`Wbsb c\R RS\ GQVcZbS`\ Oca TO`PWUS[ @WQVb& 8WS GbORb eW`R O\RS`a OcT [WQV eW`YS\$ eS\WUS` hc [W` USVv`WU$ eSWbS` eSU& I\R RS` 6`]OReOg$ hSV\ Gb]QYeS`YS c\bS` [W`$ eW`R dS`ZOaaS\ aSW\$ SW\S Rc\YZS GQVZcQVb W\ ;`Oc c\R GQVeO`h$ RWS aWQV d]\ RS` *.bV Gb`SSb \OQV B]`RS\ PWa hc[ HW[Sa G_cO`S S`ab`SQYb& =\ SW\S` RWSaS` BsQVbS aSbhS WQV [WQV W\ ROa :S\abS` c\R ZOaaS RWS 6SW\S POc[SZ\$ R`wQYS [WQV UO\h O\ RS\ FO\R c\R V]QYS RO dWSZZSWQVb abc\RS\ZO\U W\ RS` YOZbS\ :SP`cO`ZcTb& =QV USVS eWSRS` `SW\$ aSbhS [WQV O\ RS\ GQV`SWPbWaQV c\R `OcQVS SW\S\ GbSW\& =QV RS\YS RO`O\$ eWS OcTUS`SUb OZZS eO`S\$ OZa eW` d]` Tw\T >OV`S\ O\TW\US\& ?ObS$ RWS AWbO`PSWbS`$ c\aS`S :O[WZWS\& ASW\S ?ZWS\bS\ x 5cb]`S\ d]\ F][O\S\ c\R ?c`hUSaQVWQVbS\$ @g`WYS`$ 9aaOgWabS\ x eO`S\ [W` d]\ RS` OZbS\ 5US\bc` UST]ZUb$ PSW RS` WQV OZa 5aaWabS\b O\USTO\US\ VObbS$ OZa WQV \OQV BSe M]`Y USY][[S\ eO`& GWS T]ZUbS\ [W`$ c\R Sa ZOU a] dWSZ JS`b`OcS\

W\ RWS NcYc\Tb RO`W\$ a] dWSZ JS`b`OcS\ hc [W`& =QV aQVOcS OcT RWS dWSZS\ JS`b`sUS c\R AS[]a c\R :OV\S\ OcT [SW\S[ GQV`SWPbWaQV c\R ec\RS`S [WQV$ ROaa WQV [Wb RWSaS\ GOQVS\$ RWSaS\ @ScbS\ SW\[OZ SbeOa hc bc\ VObbS& 8Oaa [O\ OcT [WQV UShsVZb VObbS& 5cT AO`Ya 7]cQV aSVS WQV [SW\S\ 6SW\S\ PSW[ NWbbS`\ hc c\R T`OUS [WQV$ ]P S` LO\Of W[ 5`h\SWaQV`O\Y VOb& CP WQV USVS\ c\R [W` SW\ <]bSZ acQVS\ a]ZZbS& =QV VOPS [SW\S\ DOaa ROPSW$ RWS ?ZSWRS`$ RWS WQV O[ @SWP b`OUS$ SW\S 6O\YYO`bS c\R RWS aQVeO`hS AwbhS d][ BM7 DO`Ya 8S^O`b[S\b$ RWS WQV d]` Yc`hS[ OcT RS[ FwQYaWbh SW\Sa HOfWa USTc\RS\ VOPS$ [Wb SW\S[ OcTUS\sVbS\ U`w\S\ 5V]`\PZObb d]`\S& 5cT [SW\S[ ?]\b] Wab \]QV ;SZR& ?\O^^ dWS`hWUbOcaS\R& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ eWS WQV Sa PWa VWS`VS` USaQVOTTb VOPS$ Rc`QV eSZQVSa c\S`ew\aQVbS Kc\RS` [SW\ <S`h \WQVb abSVS\USPZWSPS\ Wab& AO`Y `cTb Oca RS` ?wQVS$ OPS` WQV dS`abSVS \WQVb$ eOa S` aOUb& ASW\ <O\Rg YZW\USZb$ R]QV Sa ZWSUb \SPS\O\ c\bS` SW\S[ Gb]r 8SQYS\ c\R @OYS\$ a] ROaa WQV Sa \WQVb Vv`S& 5Za WQV Sa a^sbS` TW\RS$ Wab RWS AOWZP]f d]ZZ PSc\`cVWUbS` BOQV`WQVbS\ d]\ :`Sc\RS\$ [SW\S` :O[WZWS c\R B]OV& =QV Vv`S W\ SW\S `SW\ c\R ZvaQVS aWS OZZS [WbSW\O\RS`& =QV Vv`S OcQV \WQVba 6Sa]\RS`Sa PSW RS[ \ScS\ GQVZ]aa O\ RS` Hw` RS` K]V\c\U$ RWS B]OV c\R WQV OQVb >OV`S ZO\U USbSWZb VOPS\ x ROaa Sa \WQVb [SV` ZOcb Y\OQYb$ a]\RS`\ ZSWaS YZWQYb$ OZa S` hc[ S`abS\ AOZ [Wb RS[ \ScS\ GQVZwaaSZ RWS Hw` vTT\Sb& J]\ OZZ RS[ Vv`S WQV \WQVba& =QV [S`YS \WQVba d]\ RS[$ eOa ^OaaWS`b Wab ]RS` \]QV ^OaaWS`S\ eW`R$ esV`S\R ROa ?]\ab`cYb$ ROa [SW\ @SPS\ eO`$ Oca RS\ :cUS\ USVb x GQVZ]aa Tw` GQVZ]aa$ ?ZWS\b Tw` ?ZWS\b$ 8]ZZO` Tw` 8]ZZO`$ JS`b`OcS\ Tw` JS`b`OcS\& 8Oa 9W\hWUS$ eOa WQV Vv`S$ esV`S\R AO`Y ewbS\R ROa ;ZOa OcTTSUb$ c\R ROa 9W\hWUS$ eOa WQV a^w`S$ esV`S\R RWS GbORb R`OcrS\ `OaQVSZ\R S`eOQVb$ aW\R RWS PO`aQVS\ :]`RS`c\US\$ RWS d]\ RS\ AO`W]\SbbS\aQV\w`S\ OcaUSVS\& 8S\ S\RZ]aS\ A]`US\$ RWS hsVS\ BOQV[WbbOUaabc\RS\ VW\Rc`QV c\R RO`wPS` VW\Oca eS`RS\ aWS ZOcbS`$ \OQVR`wQYZWQVS`$ eW`R WV` NcU TSabS`$ `c^^WUS`$ S\b`SWrS\ aWS [W` RWS 6O\YYO`bS$ hWSVS\ [W` RWS 8]ZZO`a Oca RS\ HOaQVS\$ ROa ?ZSW\USZR Oca RS` >OQYS$ ROa ZSbhbS PWaaQVS\ :O`PS Oca RS\ 5cUS\$ ROa @SPS\ Oca RS[ ?v`^S`&

6`Od]
9a Wab >O\cO` *(()$ c\R B]OVa 7]caW\S @Sbbg UWPb hc` :SWS` RS` 9`vTT\c\U RS` YZSW\S\ @WbS`Obc`OUS\bc`$ RWS [SW\S :`Sc\RW\ ?ObS c\R WQV USU`w\RSb VOPS\$ SW\ YZSW\Sa 5PS\RSaaS\ W\ WV`S[ 6`]e\ab]\S W\ 6`]]YZg\ <SWUVba& @Sbbg Wab SW\S e]VZS`h]US\S 8O[S Oca AS[^VWa$ SW\S KSZZSaZSg%5Pa]ZdS\bW\ c\R KWbeS$ RS` [O\ RWS wPS` aSQVhWU W\ YSW\S` KSWaS O\aWSVb ]RS` O\[S`Yb$ c\R VOb SbeOa d]\ RS` W[[S`T`Sc\RZWQVS\$ UcbVS`hWUS\ 6STZWaaS\VSWb SW\S` JS`ZWS`S`W\& =[ ;SUS\aObh hc WV`S` ac^S`SZSUO\bS\ GQVeSabS`$ RS` :`Oc SW\Sa 9f%6]baQVOTbS`a$ aQVSW\b @Sbbg [Wb WV`S` ^`WdWZSUWS`bS\ <S`Yc\Tb abSba SW\ eS\WU OcT ?`WSUaTcr hc abSVS\& GWS VOb \WS W[ @SPS\ O`PSWbS\ [waaS\$ `SRSb OPS` ]Tb d]\ WV`S\ >]Pa W\ RS\ ;`O^VWYOPbSWZc\US\ dS`aQVWSRS\S` 6cQVdS`ZOUS c\R WV`S` ZO\UjsV`WUS\ 5`PSWb Tw` GbWTbc\US\& GWS VOb heSW HvQVbS`$ FcbV c\R <O\\OV$ c\R VOcTS\eSWaS >cUS\RT`Sc\RW\\S\ [Wb BO[S\ eWS GWaag c\R 6OPa$ hc RS`S\ ;SPc`babOUS\ ]RS` >cPWZsS\ aWS ]Tb VSW[ \OQV AS[^VWa TZWSUb& 9a Wab 9\RS >O\cO`$ SW\S K]QVS d]` RS` ]TTWhWSZZS\ 9`vTT\c\U RS` 5US\bc`& KW` VOPS\ eSRS` HSZST]\ \]QV 6`WST^O^WS` \]QV 6O\YY]\bS\& AW` [OQVb 5\Uab$ ROaa eW` \]QV SW\S\ 5aaWabS\bS\ c\R SW\S\ 6cQVVOZbS` SW\abSZZS\ [waaS\$ d]` OZZS[ OPS`$ ROaa eW` Tw` PSWRS YSW\ ;SZR VOPS\& B]OV c\R WQV Y][[S\ hSV\ AW\cbS\ hc a^sb PSW @Sbbg O\$ ?ObS c\R WV` AO\\ aW\R aQV]\ RO& @Sbbg VOb jS[O\RS\ PSa]`Ub$ RS` RWS As\bSZ S\bUSUS\\W[[b$ ;Sb`s\YS OcaaQVS\Yb$ <s^^QVS\ `SWQVb c\R aWQV c[ RWS HOTSZ Yw[[S`b& 9` Wab AWbbS PWa 9\RS R`SWrWU$ 5aWOb$ Obb`OYbWd$ SW\RScbWU aQVecZ c\R SW\ PWaaQVS\ hc T`Sc\RZWQV& GbS^VS\ VSWrb S`$ c\R aSW\ OcTTsZZWUSa 6S\SV[S\ [OQVb [WQV dS`ZSUS\ USUS\wPS` ?ObS c\R WV`S[ AO\\$ RWS c\a OZa DOO` \WQVb a]\RS`ZWQV dS`b`Ocb aW\R c\R [W` hcaO[[S\ jSbhb R]QV aSV` Pw`US`ZWQV d]`Y][[S\& GbS^VS\ T`OUb B]OV c\R [WQV$ eOa eW` b`W\YS\ [vQVbS\$ c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb W\ RS` ?wQVS& 9` P`W\Ub c\a heSW ;ZsaS` KSWreSW\$ ]Pe]VZ WQV c[ SW\S\ K]RYO USPSbS\ VOPS c\R B]OV c[ SW\S\ GQ]bQV& 9` Wab UO\h Oca RS` :Oaac\U$ S\baQVcZRWUb aWQV c\R USVb hc`wQY W\ RWS ?wQVS$ Y][[b OPS` \WQVb eWSRS`& BOQV `c\R Tw\T AW\cbS\ abSVb @Sbbg OcT c\R aWSVb \OQV$ e] S` PZSWPb& KS\WU a^sbS` Y][[b S` [Wb RS\ 8`W\Ya& @Sbbg Wab aWQVbZWQV ^SW\ZWQV PS`wV`b& 9a Wab SW\ RSYORS\bS` 5PS\R& ?OdWO`$ GV`W[^a c\R ?saS OZa J]`a^SWaS$ RO\\ @O[[P`ObS\& =QV \SV[S d]\ OZZS[ hc dWSZ c\R PW\ ZO\US d]` RS[ BOQVbWaQV aObb& B]OV eWS OcQV @Sbbg P`W\US\ H]Oaba OcT c\a Oca x PSWRS VOPS\ ROPSW H`s\S\ W\ RS\ 5cUS\& =QV eW\RS [WQV c\PSVOUZWQV W[ ;ZO\h WV`S` KS`baQVsbhc\U c\R aQVs[S [WQV \WQVb hc[ S`abS\ AOZ ROTw`$ ROaa WQV SW\S` 7]caW\S d]\ B]OV a] \OVS abSVS c\R [SW\S SWUS\S\ JS`eO\RbS\ YOc[ YS\\S& 8Oaa B]OV c\R WQV OcT <]QVhSWbS\ c\R ;SPc`babOUS aSW\S` 7]caW\S\$ ;SaQVeWabS`

YS\\S& 8Oaa B]OV c\R WQV OcT <]QVhSWbS\ c\R ;SPc`babOUS aSW\S` 7]caW\S\$ ;SaQVeWabS` c\R BWQVbS\ USVS\$ WQV [SW\S :O[WZWS OPS` \c` SW\[OZ W[ >OV` PSacQVS x [SWabS\a O\ KSWV\OQVbS\ x$ c\R OcQV RO\\ \c` Tw` SW\S\ HOU c\R SW\S BOQVb& 5cT RS[ KSU hc[ 6OR PWbbS WQV GbS^VS\$ [W` \]QV SW\S\ K]RYO hc P`W\US\& 9` dS`UWaab Sa$ c\R WQV VOZbS [WQV O\ RS\ KSW\& 5Za WQV aQVZWSrZWQV ZSWQVb O\USascaSZb PW\$ aSVS WQV [WQV O[ HWaQV c[ c\R T`OUS [WQV$ eWS WQV PZ]r VWS` ZO\RS\ Y]\\bS& G]ZQVS 5PS\RS aW\R SbeOa Tw` O\RS`S @ScbS$ @ScbS eWS ?ObS c\R B]OV$ RWS [Wb WV`S\ 9ZWbS%I\W%5PaQVZwaaS\ c\R WV`S\ <OZb USPS\RS\ :O[WZWS\ eWS USaQVOTTS\ ROTw` aW\R$ ;ZwQY hc ew\aQVS\ c\R H`W\Ya^`wQVS OcahcP`W\US\& 6SW[ BOQVbWaQV \SV[S WQV \WQVb RS\ D]`beSW\$ RS\ @Sbbg d]\ GbS^VS\ vTT\S\ Zsaab$ a]\RS`\ abSVS OcT c\R [OQVS [W` \]QV SW\S\ K]RYO& 5Za GbS^VS\ ROa aWSVb$ TsZZb WV[ SW\$ ROaa S` [W` RS\ USew\aQVbS\ \WQVb USP`OQVb VOb$ c\R d]\ RO O\ aQVS\Yb S` [W` W[[S` UO\h aQV\SZZ \OQV& =[ HOfW \OQV <OcaS VOZbS\ B]OV c\R WQV c\a PSW RS` <O\R& =QV VOPS aWSPS\ ]RS` OQVb K]RYO USb`c\YS\$ [W\RSabS\a SPS\a] dWSZ ;ZsaS` KSW\$ c\R PW\ b`]bhRS[ \]QV \WQVb RO$ e] WQV US`\ es`S& =QV RS\YS RO`O\$ eOa W\ RS\ Y][[S\RS\ K]QVS\ \]QV OZZSa hc bc\ Wab$ c[ RWS 5US\bc` W\ ;O\U hc P`W\US\$ c\R O\ RWS PSWRS\ \]QV O\abSVS\RS\ 9`vTT\c\Ua^O`bga& NcS`ab SW\S 7]QYbOWZ^O`bg W\ RS` \ScS\ K]V\c\U SW\S` :`Sc\RW\ d]\ ?ObS$ RO\\ SW\ 8W\\S` Tw` `c\R Tw\ThWU ?ZWS\bS\ c\R ?]ZZSUS\ Oca RS` JS`ZOUaeSZb$ hc RS[ [SW\ :`Sc\R 8OdWR ZsRb$ SW\S` RS` S`abS\ 5cb]`S\$ [Wb RS\S\ WQV hcaO[[S\USO`PSWbSb VOPS& =QV PSTw`QVbS$ PSW PSWRS\ 5\ZsaaS\ SW\S FSRS VOZbS\ hc [waaS\ x eS\WUabS\a SW\ 8O\YSae]`b O\ RWS ;OabUSPS` `WQVbS\ hc [waaS\ x$ c\R wPS`ZSUS$ eWS WQV [WQV ROd]` R`wQYS\ YO\\& =QV aQVZWSrS RWS 5cUS\ c\R dS`acQVS OcahcPZS\RS\$ eWS aSV` [W` RO\OQV Wab$ FWQ] O\hc`cTS\ c\R SW\ ^OO` GbSW\S hc `OcQVS\& BOQV dWS` ]RS` Tw\T 8`W\Ya abSZZb aWQV RWSaS` ;SRO\YS [SWabS\a PSW [W` SW\ c\R PZSWPb$ PWa WQV S\beSRS` FWQ] ]RS` a]\ab SW\S\ 8SOZS` O\`cTS ]RS` SW\aQVZOTS& 9a Wab Yc`h d]` AWbbS`\OQVb$ c\R [W` USVS\ hWU AvUZWQVYSWbS\ Rc`QV RS\ ?]^T$ eWS WQV d]\ B]OV eSUY][[S\ c\R [W` eOa PSa]`US\ YO\\& AO\caY`W^b W[ 6w`] dS`USaaS\4 ;SZR Oca RS[ 5cb][ObS\4 BWQVba S`aQVSW\b [W` ^ZOcaWPSZ& 5cT RS` 6`]]YZg\ 6`WRUS FWQVbc\U AO\VObbO\ c[TOaab B]OV [SW\S <s\RS c\R aOUb [W`$ eWS ab]Zh S` Wab x OcT [WQV$ OcT RWS 5US\bc`& KsV`S\R S` a^`WQVb$ ab`SWTb RWS 6`wQYS\PSZScQVbc\U aSW\S\ ab`c^^WUS\ 6O`b$ RWS T`Sc\RZWQVS\ 5cUS\$ RWS ZO\US\ ?]bSZSbbS\ c\R ROa Yc`h USaQV\WbbS\S$ hc`wQYUSVS\RS <OO`& =QV R`wQYS [WQV O\ WV\$ aQVWSPS RWS O\RS`S\ ;SRO\YS\ eSU& 9` `WSQVb eWS W[[S` x \OQV G^SSR GbWQY 8S] c\R T`WaQVS` KsaQVS& =QV S\ba^O\\S [WQV SbeOa c\R RS\YS S`ab SW\[OZ$ ROaa OZZSa VOZP a] aQVZW[[ Wab$ ROaa aWQV OZZSa TW\RS\ eW`R& 5Za WQV O\ RWSaS[ 5PS\R W\a 6Sbb USVS$ [caa WQV O\ GbS^VS\ RS\YS\$ RS\ Hg^ PSW @Sbbg$ RS` G^SWaS\ OcT RS` KO`[VOZbS^ZObbS dS`USaaS\$ SW\ ;ZOa KSW\ dS`aQVwbbSb c\R [W` RS\ UO\hS\ 5PS\R aQVv\S 5cUS\ US[OQVb VOb& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ eWS @Sbbg O\ WV\ US`ObS\ Wab$ c\R RS\YS RO`O\$ ROaa S` aWQV hc ZO\US O[ HWaQV OcTUSVOZbS\ c\R hc dWSZS :`OUS\ USabSZZb

c\R RS\YS RO`O\$ ROaa S` aWQV hc ZO\US O[ HWaQV OcTUSVOZbS\ c\R hc dWSZS :`OUS\ USabSZZb VOb c\R aWQV aSW\S` :SVZS` O\aQVSW\S\R UO` \WQVb PSecaab eO`& 5PS` S` VOb SW\TZWSrS\ ZOaaS\$ ROaa S` W\ D`W\QSb]\ eO` c\R$ OZa S` [WbPSYO[$ ROaa B]OV :WZ[S[OQVS` Wab$ as[bZWQVS WV[ PSYO\\bS\ 6S`wV[bVSWbS\ OcTUShsVZb x 8`O[ObWYS`$ 5YbWdWabS\ c\R GQVOca^WSZS`& =QV [caa OcQV RO`O\ RS\YS\$ eWS S` aSW\S HSZST]\\c[[S` OcT RWS FwQYaSWbS SW\S` GS`dWSbbS USaQV`WSPS\ c\R aWS [W` W\ RWS <O\R USR`wQYb VOb$ OZa WQV [W` W\ RS` ?wQVS SW\ ;ZOa KOaaS` V]ZbS3 eWS S` [SW\S <O\R SW\S G^c` hc ZO\US USVOZbS\ c\R [W` USaOUb VOb$ ROaa S` OcT dWSZS\ JS`ZOUaTSabS\ RWS 6O` [OQVb c\R ROaa WQV WV\ R]QV [OZ O\`cTS\ a]ZZ& I\R ]Pe]VZ S` RS\ UO\hS\ 5PS\R hc \WQVba hc USP`OcQVS\ eO`$ eSWr WQV PSW[ 9W\aQVZOTS\$ ROaa WQV ROa bc\ eS`RS& qPS` SW\ >OV` a^sbS`$ OZa GbS^VS\ ;ZsaS` c\R 9Wa OcT SW\S\ YZSW\S\ HWaQV W\ c\aS`S[ :S`\aSVhW[[S` abSZZb x eWS S` Sa W\heWaQVS\ [W\RSabS\a SW\ VOZPSa 8cbhS\R [OZ USbO\ VOb x$ PS[S`YS WQV OcrS\ O\ aSW\S[ 8Oc[S\ SW\S ZO\US 6`O\R\O`PS& =QV T`OUS WV\$ eWS S` ROhc USY][[S\ Wab$ c\R S` c\bS`P`WQVb aWQV$ aWSVb [WQV O\$ OZa VsbbS S` aQV]\ ZO\US RO`OcT USeO`bSb$ ROaa WQV RWS :`OUS abSZZS$ c\R aOUb2 :`OU ZWSPS` \WQVb& 5PS` WQV YS\\S RWS 5\be]`b& GwQVbWUS VOPS\ 5\bS\\S\$ RWS Tw` RWS S\ba^`SQVS\RS :`S_cS\h PSW O\RS`S\ S[^Ts\UZWQV aW\R$ c\R jSbhb PW\ WQV US`ORS OcT GbS^VS\a KSZZS\Zs\US& KOV`aQVSW\ZWQV a^`SQVS WQV aQV]\ RO`OcT O\$ aSWb eW` c\a YS\\S\& 8]QV S`ab jSbhb$ OZa [W` a]T]`b YZO` Wab$ eWS S` aWQV dS`P`O\\b VOb$ PSU`SWTS WQV d]ZZ c\R UO\h$ eO`c[ WQV WV\ S\UOUWS`b VOPS$ eWSa] S` c\a eWSRS` PSW SW\S` DO`bg VSZTS\ YO\\$ ]Pe]VZ S` c\a aQV]\ heSW[OZ [Wb Y][^ZWhWS`bS\ 9\baQVcZRWUc\US\ d]\ eSUS\ ?`O\YVSWb c\R TO[WZWs`S\ ;`w\RS\ dS`aSbhb VOb& 5Za] aOUS WQV2 JWSZZSWQVb a]ZZbSab Rc PSaaS` OcT^OaaS\$ eOa Rc `OcQVab$ c\R OZa S` ZsQVSZ\R T`OUb2 DOaab Rc RS\\ OcT4$ eSWr WQV$ ROaa aWQV RO`Oca eOa S\beWQYSZ\ eW`R& 8Oaa RS` 6OZZ W[ G^WSZ Wab& G^sbS` ec\RS`S WQV [WQV RO`wPS`$ eOa WQV OZa BsQVabSa aOUS2 BWQVb a]$ eWS Sa \vbWU es`S& I\R RO\\2 =`US\ReO\\ a]ZZbS\ eW` ROa `SUSZ\& =QV aQV[SWrS W\ B]OVa 5PeSaS\VSWb SW\S DO`bg W\ RS` K]V\c\U& 9a Wab 8]\\S`abOUOPS\R$ c\R WQV VOPS aQV]\ ROTw` USa]`Ub$ ROaa WQV O[ \sQVabS\ HOU \WQVb O`PSWbS\ [caa& 8S\ UO\hS\ 5PS\R abSZZS WQV [WQV [wRS$ UsV\S$ `SQYS [WQV$ `SWPS [W` RWS 5cUS\ W\ RS` <]TT\c\U$ ROaa RWS @ScbS hSWbWU USVS\& =QV [OZS [W` RS\ S`abS\ <Wb Oca c\R RWS VS``ZWQVS FcVS$ RWS S` P`W\US\ eW`R$ c\R dS`OQVbS abWZZ c\R VSW[ZWQV OZZS$ RWS \]QV W\ RS` K]V\c\U aW\R& =QV a^OhWS`S [Wb [SW\S[ GSZbhS` c[VS` x ROa b`W\YS WQV W[[S` PSW U`vrS`S\ :SabS\ x$ c\R esV`S\R WQV `SRS c\R ZsQVZS c\R [Wb VS`hZWQVS\ I[O`[c\US\ ;ZwQY ew\aQVS c\R [WQV Tw`a ?][[S\ PSRO\YS$ USVS WQV W[ ?]^T Rc`QV$ eOa \]QV hc bc\ Wab& AWQV PSW B]OV [SZRS\ c\R WV[ eSWa[OQVS\$ ROaa RS` 5PS\R USZOcTS\ Wab$ WQV `SWT Tw`a 6Sbb PW\& 5[ ;SZROcb][ObS\ R`SW% ]RS` dWS`Vc\RS`b 8]ZZO` Tw` GbS^VS\ OPVSPS\$ RO[Wb S` Z]ahWSVS\ c\R GbSW\S YOcTS\ c\R FvV`QVS\ PSa]`US\ YO\\& 5crS`RS[ P`OcQVS WQV \]QV [W\RSabS\a R`SWVc\RS`b$ c[ WV\ Tw`a GS`dWS`S\ hc PShOVZS\$ RO S` \c` 6O`USZR \W[[b& =QV eS`RS WV[ aOUS\$ ROaa S` \WQVb OcThc`sc[S\ P`OcQVb x ROaa WQV ROa wPS`\SV[S$ RO[Wb S` aWQV OcT RS\ KSU [OQVS\ YO\\&

GbS^VS\ USVb USUS\ JWS`bSZ \OQV SZT c\R Y][[b \OQV SW\a hc`wQY& =QV VOPS US`ORS RWS 6O` aOcPS`US[OQVb$ RWS ;ZsaS` USa^wZb$ KOaaS` c\R GS`dWSbbS\ eSUUS`sc[b& "9` eW`R RWS NSWb [Wb OcT RWS FSQV\c\U aSbhS\&# 8WSaS BOQVb Wab eWQVbWU& BWQVb$ eSWZ WQV hc[ S`abS\ AOZ [Wb WV[ aQVZOTS& BWQVb$ eSWZ WQV eWSRS` /(( 8]ZZO` OcaUSPS$ RWS WQV YOc[ \]QV VOPS& G]\RS`\ eSWZ GbS^VS\ USUS\ dWS` IV` T`wV$ OZa eW` RWS HwbS TOab OcTUS`OcQVb VOPS\$ aSW\S\ :`Sc\R AO`Y O\`cTb$ RS` W\ AW\cbS\aQV\SZZS [Wb BOQVaQVcP OcT RS` AObbS abSVb& AO`Y Wab ;]c`[Sbj]c`\OZWab& ;`]r$ US^TZSUb$ YO\bWU& AW` TsZZb a]T]`b OcT$ eWS S` dWP`WS`b& 5Za ]P aSW\ ?v`^S` abs\RWU ZSWQVb c\bS` Gb`][ abSVb& I\R [W` TsZZb OcT$ eWS S` [Wb GbS^VS\ a^`WQVb& 9` aQVSW\b AOQVb wPS` WV\ hc VOPS\ eWS 8WQYS\ay :OUW\ wPS` RS\ GQVZOcTcQVa$ c\R ]Pe]VZ S` aWQV ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV d]\ aSW\S` PSabS\ GSWbS hSWUb$ [S`YS WQV$ ROaa SW\S AWaQVc\U Oca 6`cbOZWbsb c\R ZWSPS\RS` G]`US WV`S 6ShWSVc\U PSabW[[b& KsV`S\R AO`Y c\aS`S FvV`QVS\ V]QVVsZb c\R PS[s\USZb$ eWS TSbbWU c\R dS`aS\Ub aWS aW\R$ c[TZObbS`b WV\ GbS^VS\ eWS SW\S \S`dvaS ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`$ RWS SW\S[ 7VW`c`US\ OaaWabWS`b& AO`Y PSRS\Yb WV\ [Wb SW\S[ KWS%YO\\%[O\%\c`%6ZWQY c\R aQVwbbSZb RS\ ?]^T& GbS^VS\ aOUb WV[ \WQVb$ ROaa aWS [SW\SbeSUS\ a] dS`aS\Ub aW\R& 8Oaa WQV jSRSa AOZ hc ZO\US O\ RS` DTSWTS hWSVS c\R RWS :ZO[[S hc V]QV R`SVS& 8Oa PSO\abO\RSb jSRS`$ RS` [Wb [W` `OcQVb& =QV dS`acQVbS heO` [vUZWQVab aO\Tb hc W\VOZWS`S\$ OPS` Sa Y][[b [W` W[[S` d]`$ OZa ]P WQV \WQVb TSab US\cU hWSVS$ OZa ]P RWS :ZO[[S hc YZSW\ Wab$ OZa ]P WQV \WQVb US\cU OPY`WSUS& =`US\ReO\\ \OQV AO`Ya 5\Yc\Tb Vv`b GbS^VS\ OcT$ aWQV W[ ;Sa^`sQV O\ [WQV hc eS\RS\& CTTS\PO` UWZb SW\S \ScS FSUSZ$ \OQV RS` \c` AO`Y [WQV O\a^`SQVS\ RO`T$ c\R eS\\ S` ROa bcb$ Wab S` W[[S` Tc`QVbPO` VvTZWQV c\R aQVeSZUb W\ ?][^ZW[S\bS\ "[SW\S K]V\c\U$ [SW\ 5caaSVS\#& 9a Wab eWS ROa J]`a^WSZ hc SW\S` U`]rO\USZSUbS\ 5PhWSVS`SW$ c\R abObb aYS^bWaQV ]RS` OcT RS` <cb hc aSW\$ PW\ WQV O\USbO\& 8WS BOQVb aQVZS^^b aWQV PWa c\USTsV` hSV\ IV` T`wV VW\& 8O\\ a^OhWS`S\ GbS^VS\ c\R AO`Y VW\Oca W\ RS\ HOU$ c\R SVS Sa GO[abOUOPS\R Wab$ VOPS WQV aWS S`\Scb hc [W` SW\USZORS\& A]\bOU T`wV Wab [SW\ 6O\YY]\b] ZSS`$ c\R AO`Y VOb d]`USaQVZOUS\$ ROaa S` c\R WQV c\a W[ @OcT RS` K]QVS [OZ OZZSW\ b`STTS\& B]OV `cTb SbeO SW\ 8cbhS\R [OZ O\$ c\R WQV ZOaaS ROa HSZST]\ YZW\USZ\$ aQVOZbS ROa <O\Rg OP c\R `cTS WV\ \WQVb hc`wQY& A]\bOU\OQV[WbbOU Y][[b [SW\ 5aaWabS\b hc [W` W\a 6w`] c\R aOUb$ B]OV aSW O[ 5^^O`Ob$ S` aSW OcrS` aWQV c\R e]ZZS [WQV c\PSRW\Ub a^`SQVS\& =QV aQVZWSrS RWS Hw`$ c\R B]OV eSW\b O[ O\RS`S\ 9\RS c\R aOUb [W`$ WQV a]ZZS R]QV PWbbS OcTVv`S\& <v` R]QV PWbbS$ PWbbS RO[Wb OcT =QV TwVZS [WQV Tc`QVbPO` c\R aOUS$ jO YZO`$ Sa bcb [W` ZSWR$ c\R Sa Y][[b \WQVb eWSRS` d]`& 9` T`OUb \OQV 9W\hSZVSWbS\$ c\R WQV eS`RS ewbS\R& 9`abOc\ZWQVS`eSWaS S\baQVcZRWUb S` aWQV& =QV eS`TS GbS^VS\a HSZST]\\c[[S` eSU& KS`TS AO`Ya ?O`bS eSU& 5PS` Sa a^WSZb YSW\S F]ZZS& 6SWRS `cTS\ W\ RS\ Y][[S\RS\ K]QVS\ c\R A]\ObS\ O\$ c\R W`US\ReO\\$ WQV eSWr \WQVb US\Oc$ eO\\ c\R d]\ eS[$ aQV`SWPS WQV SW\S Bc[[S` OcT& I\R W`US\ReO\\ a^sbS` `cTS WQV O\&

I\R W`US\ReO\\ a^sbS` `cTS WQV O\&

9`abS Hw`
9a eW`R NSWb& 9` [caa aSWb Gbc\RS\ ^W\YSZ\$ OPS` ROa aQVWSPb S` W[[S` PWa hcZSbhb OcT& GSW\S 9ZbS`\ \S\\S\ Sa ROa D`]PZS[3 ROa D`]PZS[ Wab$ eS\\ S` USVb x OcTa ?Z] \s[ZWQV x$ RO\\ YO\\ S` \WQVb& 9a Wab \]QV \WQVb US\cU hcaO[[S\$ eWS S` ROa PSW aWQV aSZPS` \S\\b& Nc eS\WU 8`cQY& 8SaVOZP eO`bSb S` \]QV SbeOa& 6Wa ROa AWbbOUSaaS\ d]`PSW Wab$ RS\\ RO\OQV [S`Yb YSW\S`$ eS\\ S` hc ZO\US eSUPZSWPb& AO\QV[OZ ROcS`b Sa SW\S UO\hS Gbc\RS& AO\QV[OZ USVb Sa wPS`VOc^b \WQVb& I\R [O\QV[OZ ROcS`bya \c` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\& 8Oa abSZZb aWQV S`ab W\ RS` GWbcObW]\ VS`Oca& BOQV RS[ 9aaS\ abSVb S` d]` RS[ Od]QOR]U`w\S\ ?Z]PSQYS\& ;S`scaQVS R`W\US\ Rc`QV RWS USaQVZ]aaS\S Hw` x SW\S 9Waew`TSZaQVOZS TsZZb `c\bS`$ :ZcQVS\$ ;ZOa hS`P`WQVb$ ZOcbS`Sa :ZcQVS\$ SW\ HSZST]\ YZW\USZb& 8Oa <Oca Wab SW\ SW\hWUSa 8`s\US\& =`US\Re] Oca RS` ;S`scaQVYcZWaaS `cTb SW\S GbW[[S$ RWS WV\ W[[S` O\ SW\ KW\Ra^WSZ S`W\\S`b2 5ZZSa W\ C`R\c\U$ 6WZZg4 6WZZg z `cTb aSW\S AcbbS` \]QV SW\[OZ$ R]QV WV`S GbW[[S dS`YZW\Ub& 9W\ ^OO` 5cUS\PZWQYS \WQVba& Bc` ROa U`w\S ?Z]PSQYS\& 6SSWZ RWQV$ RS\Yb S`& 6SSWZ RWQV& AWb RS\ <s\RS\ PSO`PSWbSb S` VSTbWU RWS G^WbhS aSW\Sa DS\Wa& 9a YZ]^Tb O\ RWS Hw`& B]QV [OZ& 9W\S O\RS`S GbW[[S& GSW\ JObS`& <S``U]bb$ KWZZWS$ [OQV R]QV YSW\S @SPS\aOcTUOPS RO`Oca& 9W\S ?W\RS`Y]`RV]aS x [SWab Rc\YSZPZOc$ [O\QV[OZ U`w\ x Y\scSZb aWQV hc aSW\S\ :wrS\& 8WS I\bS`V]aS Vs\Ub WV[ c\bS` RS\ ?\WS\& 9` Wab aSWb wPS` SW\S` VOZPS\ Gbc\RS RO R`W\& AW\RSabS\a R`SW[OZ eO` S` \OV R`O\$ c\R RO\\ VOb Sa R]QV \WQVb USYZO^^b& 9a USVb \WQVb& 9` eSWr$ Sa eW`R P`S\\S\ x OZa ]P ;ZOaa^ZWbbS` `OcaYs[S\ x$ OPS` S` eWZZ Sa S\RZWQV VW\bS` aWQV P`W\US\& 9` bs\hSZb d]` RS[ 6SQYS\ x ZW\Ya$ `SQVba$ ZW\Ya$ `SQVba x c\R Y\SbSb aSW\S DS\Waa^WbhS& FSWPb aWS [Wb PSWRS\ <s\RS\& 8S` 8`cQY \W[[b hc$ c\R GQVeSWr b`Wbb WV[ OcT RWS GbW`\& 9` VOb ROa aQV`SQYZWQVS ;STwVZ$ ROaa S` `US` PSY][[b$ eS\\ aSW\S 9ZbS`\ VS`OcaTW\RS\$ eOa Z]a Wab& GSW\ JObS` VOb WV[ USaOUb$ S` a]ZZ aWQV USTsZZWUab \WQVb a] ZO\US OcT RS[ ?Z] OcTVOZbS\& KS\\ S` aSW\S\ G]V\ T`OUb$ eSaVOZP S` RO VS`c[Vw^Tb c\R a] SW\S U`]rS 5YbW]\ RO`Oca [OQVb$ VOb RS` >c\US YSW\S 5\be]`b& @Oaa ROa aSW\$ aOUb aSW\ JObS` WV[$ c\R S` ew\aQVbS$ S` Yv\\bS Sa& 9` R`SVb RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ OcT$ c[ aSW\ ;SVw^TS hc wPS`bv\S\& 5ca RS[ Hs\hSZ\ eW`R SW\ HO\h$ Oca RS[ ?\SbS\ SW\ TWSPS`VOTbSa ?\SWTS\& =\ SW\S[ eSWb S\bTS`\bS\ NW[[S` Vv`b S` aSW\S sZbS`S GQVeSabS` ?W[ eSW\S\& GSW\ JObS` P`wZZb WV`S\ BO[S\& 9W\S Hw` Y\OZZb& GSW\S

aSW\S sZbS`S GQVeSabS` ?W[ eSW\S\& GSW\ JObS` P`wZZb WV`S\ BO[S\& 9W\S Hw` Y\OZZb& GSW\S AcbbS` `cTb& =\ RS` ?wQVS ^TSWTb RS` KOaaS`YSaaSZ& 8Oa OZZSa VOb \WQVba [Wb WV[ hc bc\& 5PS` jSbhb YZ]^Tb jS[O\R x S` eSWr \WQVb$ eS` x O\ RWS Hw`& 9a YZ]^Tb \c`$ ]V\S K]`bS& 8S` >c\US Wab jSbhb SW\ d]\ DO\WY S`TOaabSa HWS`$ a] hcQYb c\R a^`W\Ub c\R Y\SWTb S` aWQV d]` RS[ 6SQYS\& 9` [OQVb aWQV OcT ROa \sQVabS ?Z]^TS\ USTOaab& <W\bS\ W[ :Zc` eW`R eWSRS` USaQV`WS\& 9beOa hS`P`WQVb& <s\RS$ 6SW\S x aSW\ UO\hS` ?v`^S` `]bWS`b c[ RS\ 8`cQY W\ RS` AWbbS& 9` Wab aWQVS`$ ROaa aSW\S 9ZbS`\ WV\ Vv`S\ Yv\\S\$ wPS`hScUb$ ROaa aWS jSRS\ 5cUS\PZWQY RWS dS``WSUSZbS Hw` SW\`S\\S\& 9` eWZZ [Wb RS[ G^`W\US\ OcTVv`S\$ YO\\ OPS` \WQVb& 9a Y][[b WV[ d]`$ OZa ]P ROa UO\hS <Oca x RWS 9ZbS`\$ RWS GQVeSabS`$ RWS ?ObhS\$ RS` ^TSWTS\RS ?SaaSZ x aWQV R`OcrS\ d]` RS` Hw` dS`aO[[SZb VOb& 6OZR x W\ RS[ 5cUS\PZWQY$ RS\ S` a] aSV` VS`PSWew\aQVb$ OPS` \WQVb VS`PSWTwV`S\ YO\\ x a^WSZb ROa OZZSa YSW\S F]ZZS [SV`& 8O\\ eW`R S` eSRS` ROa Hw`S\Y\OZZS\ \]QV ROa ?Z]^TS\ c\R GQV`SWS\ Vv`S\& KS\\ RS` P`S\\S\RS 8`cQY wPS`VO\R \W[[b c\R aSW\ ?v`^S` c\bS` WV[ eSUYZO^^b$ Vv`b S` \WQVba& =\ RWSaS[ A][S\b RSa qPS`aQVWSrS\a$ W\ RS[ S` jSRS ?]\b`]ZZS dS`ZWS`b c\R aWQV OZZSa W\ GQV[S`h c\R 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U OcTZvab$ PSa^`Wbhb S` RWS KO\R$ RS\ :crP]RS\$ RWS <SWhc\U c\R aWQV aSZPab& 9` aWSVb \WQVba d]\ RS` 6SaQVS`c\U$ PWa aSW\ YZSW\S` GW\\SaaQVec\R d]`PSW Wab c\R S` aWQV US`ORS VW\abSZZS\ c\R RS\ Gb`OVZ W\ ROa 6SQYS\ ZS\YS\ YO\\& 9` hWSZb \OQV VW\bS\$ c[ \WQVb ROa KOaaS` OcThc^SWbaQVS\3 Sa USVb S\RZ]a& 9` aWSVb$ ROaa dWSZ aOcPS`hc[OQVS\ Wab$ c\R T`OUb aWQV aQV]\ s\UabZWQV$ eOa S` aOUS\ a]ZZ$ eS\\ S` OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS RS` Hw` Wab& 5Za S` S\RZWQV TS`bWU US^W\YSZb VOb$ hWSVb S` [SbS`eSWaS H]WZSbbS\^O^WS` d]\ RS` F]ZZS$ eWQYSZb aWQV ROa 6O\R c[ RWS :wrS c\R Ts\Ub O\$ RWS I`W\^TwbhS O[ 6]RS\ OcThc[]^^S\& 9` eWaQVb ROa ?Z] c\R RWS KO\R ROVW\bS` c\R RO\SPS\ OP& 8O\\ Y\WSb S` aWQV VW\ c\R eWaQVb W\ U`]rS\ GQVew\US\ OZZSa b`]QYS\& 9` bc^Tb aWQV RWS <]aS [Wb RS[ DO^WS` OP$ PWa Sa WV[ c\bS` RS\ :W\US`\ hS`Y`w[SZb& 9` eW`Tb hc dWSZ ?Z]^O^WS` W\ RWS GQVwaaSZ$ a] ROaa RS` 5PTZcaa dS`ab]^Tb c\R ROa KOaaS` V]QVY][[b& 9` eSWr$ ROaa S` ROa DO^WS` VS`OcahWSVS\ [caa$ c[ SW\S \ScS GQVeSW\S`SW hc dS`[SWRS\& 9` U`SWTb W\ RS\ 5PTZcaa$ hS``b O\ RS[ DT`]^TS\$ c\R OZa es`S aSW\ Gb]rUSPSb S`Vv`b e]`RS\$ ZSS`b aWQV ROa 6SQYS\& ;S\Oc W\ RWSaS[ A][S\b USVb ROa ?Z]^TS\ eWSRS` Z]a$ c\R jSbhb abSVS\ PSWRS 9ZbS`\ d]` RS` Hw`& <]aS c\R I\bS`V]aS Y`c[^SZ\ aWQV \]QV c[ aSW\S :crUSZS\YS& 9` VOb aWS \]QV \WQVb V]QVUSh]US\$ eSWZ S` eSWr$ ROaa WV[ jSbhb SW\ eS\WU 6Zcb Oca RS` 9WQVSZ _cWZZb3 ROa [caa S` S`ab OPbc^TS\ c\R Yc`h b`]QY\S\ ZOaaS\& 8O Wab S` ]Tb hc VOabWU$ c\R RO\\ [caa S` RWS I\bS`V]aS eSUeS`TS\$ eSWZ aWQV YZSW\S P`Oc\S 6ZcbTZSQYS USPWZRSb VOPS\ c\R W\ RS\ eSWrS\ Gb]TT SW\USb`]QY\Sb aW\R& ?Z]^O^WS` RO VW\SW\hcab]^TS\ \wbhb \WQVba$ RO Sa [SWabS\a eSU`cbaQVb& AO\QV[OZ RS\Yb S` \WQVb R`O\$ eW`Tb RWS I\bS`V]aS W\ RS\ KsaQVSY]`P c\R TW\RSb aWS HOUS a^sbS` USb`]QY\Sb$ hcaO[[S\USTOZbSb c\R TZSQYWU W\ aSW\S` ?][[]RS\aQVcPZORS eWSRS`& GSW\S AcbbS` a^`WQVb WV\ \WS[OZa OcT RWS I\bS`V]aS\$ OcT ROa DW\YSZ\ O\ x OcT UO` \WQVba& 8OPSW USVb ROa aQV]\$ a] ZO\US S` RS\YS\ YO\\& 9` VOb YSW\S 9`W\\S`c\U RO`O\$ ROaa S` d]` SW\S[ ?Z] abSVb c\R SW\TOQV ^W\YSZb&

KOa b`SWPab Rc RS\\4$ R]\\S`b Sa d]\ R`OcrS\& GSW\ JObS` eWSRS`& 8S` >c\US `cTb VW\Oca$ ROaa S` UZSWQV TS`bWU Wab$ SW\S\ A][S\b \]QV$ c\R R`SVb RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ OcT$ c[ RWS ;S`scaQVS aSW\S` DcbhOYbW]\ hc wPS`bv\S\& 9` P`c[[SZb d]` aWQV VW\ x 6WbbS$ ;]bb$ PWbbS x3 SWUS\bZWQV P`c[[SZb S` ROa aQV]\$ aSWb S` aWQV d]` wPS` SW\S` 8`SWdWS`bSZabc\RS OcT RS[ ?Z] SW\USaQVZ]aaS\ VOb& ;S\OcS` T]`[cZWS`b S` aSW\S 6WbbS \WQVb& GSW\S <]aS c\R aSW\ <S[R aW\R Rc`QV\saab d]\ KOaaS`$ d]\ I`W\& B]QV SW\[OZ bc^Tb S` aWQV [Wb SW\S[ DOQYS\ H]WZSbbS\^O^WS` OP$ ROa S` W\ RS\ DO^WS`Y]`P dS`T`OQVbSb$ c\bS` SW\S Z]aS DO^^`]ZZS c\R SW\S ZSS`S ?ZSS\SfaQVOQVbSZ& B]QV SW\ ZSbhbSa AOZ eWaQVb S` OZZSa OP x RS\ <SWhYv^S`$ ROa ?Z]PSQYS\$ RWS 6`WZZS$ RS\ :crP]RS\& 8O\\ aQVOcb S` aWQV \OQV G^c`S\ aSW\Sa 5cTS\bVOZba c[& 9` eWaQVb aWQV [Wb RS` <O\R RS\ GQVeSWr d]\ RS` GbW`\ c\R ab`SWQVb aSW\S <OO`S UZObb& 9` V]Zb @cTb$ a^`WQVb \]QV SW\ ZSWaSa Gb]rUSPSb$ Y\W^ab ROa @WQVb Oca c\R V]TTb$ ROaa OcQV ROa @WQVb W[ :Zc` Oca Wab$ RO[Wb aSW\S \OaaS\ GOQVS\ \WQVb OcTTOZZS\& 9` Ob[Sb `cVWU Rc`QV$ S`U`SWTb RWS Hw`YZW\YS c\R eO^^\Sb aWQV Tw` ROa$ eOa WV\ R`OcrS\ S`eO`bSb& 9` Wab Tw\T >OV`S OZb&

:ZcU
9a aQV\SWb d]` RS[ <]ZZO\R Hc\\SZ& 8WS 5cb]a Y][[S\ \WQVb d]`es`ba& <c^S\ c\R ;SaQV`SW& ASW\ :ZcU \OQV 6S`ZW\ USVb W\ eS\WUS` OZa SW\S` Gbc\RS$ ROa YO\\ WQV c\[vUZWQV aQVOTTS\& B]OV Wab aQV]\ RO$ S` Wab d][ Gc\RO\QS RW`SYb hc RS\ 6S`ZW\S` :WZ[TSaba^WSZS\ USTZ]US\ c\R VOb d]` heSW HOUS\ R]`b aSW\S\ :WZ[ UShSWUb& =QV `cTS [SW\S\ 5aaWabS\bS\ O\$ RS` Tw` RS\ :ZcU c[ VOZP aSQVa SW\S\ KOUS\ c[ dWS` PSabSZZb VOb$ eOa aWQV PSa]\RS`a eSUS\ RSa GQV\SSa \c\ OZa hc Y\O^^ S`eSWab& 8OTw` YO\\ S` heO` \WQVba$ OPS` WQV VOZbS WV[ ROa d]` c\R aOUS WV[$ ROaa aWQV aSW\SbeSUS\ jSbhb [SW\ @SPS\ s\RS`b$ c\R heO` \WQVb hc[ 6SaaS`S\& =QV ZSUS OcT& 8Oa Wab ROa @SbhbS$ eOa WQV hc WV[ aOUS$ hc wPS`VOc^b jS[O\RS[ W\ [SW\S[ 6w`]& =QV VOPS SW\S TOab d]ZZS HwbS ROPSW x R`SW [WbbSZU`]rS GbSW\S c\R SbZWQVS ?`w[SZ& 9W\ aOcPS`Sa FvV`QVS\ c\R SW\ :ScS`hScU ZWSUS\$ W\ SW\ ;SaQVW``VO\RbcQV USeWQYSZb$ heWaQVS\ AO\caY`W^bS\$ >SO\a$ DcZZ]dS` c\R SW\S[ <OcTS\ ?WSVZya ?]a[SbWY W\ [SW\S` @& @& 6SO\%FSWaSbOaQVS& 8WS :OV`S`W\ Wab SW\S jc\US CabSc`]^sS`W\ [Wb bWSTS` GbW[[S$ c\R WQV VOPS WV` PS`SWba [SW\ nKS\\ GWS ewaabS\$ eWS eWQVbWU Sa Wab$ ROaa WQV `SQVbhSWbWU RO PW\l USac\US\$ RO[Wb aWS WV`S NOcPS`Y`sTbS OYbWdWS`b c\R c\a wPS` RS\ GbOc VW\eSUb`sUb& GWS abO``b [WQV PZ]r W[ FwQYa^WSUSZ O\& CP aWS [S`Yb$ eWS TS`bWU$ eWS Rc`QV RS\ KW\R WQV PW\4 9a Wab YZO`$ ROaa [W` ROa jSbhb RS\ FSab UWPb& GSZPab eS\\ B]OV [W` \]QV SW\[OZ dS`hSWVb$ ]Pe]VZ S` eSWr$ ROaa WQV R`OcT PW\$ aSWb WQV WV\ PSW[ Gc\RO\QS OZZSW\USZOaaS\ VOPS x ?ObS eW`R Sa \WQVb bc\& =QV eO` aQV]\ TOab heSW K]QVS\ \WQVb [SV` W\ RS` 5US\bc` c\R VOPS R`SW 6Sa^`SQVc\US\ OPUSaOUb$ PSW RS\S\ eW` S\RZWQV c\aS`S\ DO`b\S`aQVOTbadS`b`OU c\R RWS :W\O\hS\ Rc`QVUSVS\ e]ZZbS\& :`Sc\RS\$ ?ZWS\bS\$ 5\USabSZZbS\$ OZZS\ VOPS WQV S`hsVZb$ WQV VsbbS SW\S\ 6O\RaQVSWPS\d]`TOZZ c\R aSW ROcS`\R PSW[ 5`hb$ 5Yc^c\YbSc` c\R AOaaSc`& 8WS KOV`VSWb Wab$ ROaa WQV aSWb [SW\S` FwQYYSV` d][ Gc\RO\QS d]` Tw\T HOUS\ W\ SW\S` RWQYS\ 7`OQY%EcOZ[e]ZYS Rc`QV RWS K]V\c\U USbWUS`b PW\& ;S`ORS [OZ$ c[ wPS` RWS 0bV Gb`SSb hc[ ;SZROcb][ObS\ hc `S\\S\ ]RS` \SPS\O\ :ScS`hScUS c\R GbOVZe]ZZS hc YOcTS\$ VOPS WQV ROa <Oca dS`ZOaaS\& 8S` GQV\O^aZORS\ VOb [W` bsUZWQV ?SbSZ C\S USZWSTS`b$ c\R RS` DcbhT`Oc VOPS WQV USaOUb$ aWS a]ZZS \WQVb Y][[S\$ RO WQV Y`O\Y aSW& =`US\ReO\\ PSd]` WQV W\ RS\ KOUS\ USabWSUS\ PW\$ VOPS WQV ?ObS SW\S AOWZ USaQVWQYb$ aWS a]ZZS bc\$ eOa aWS Tw` `WQVbWU VOZbS$ WQV aSW `wQYTsZZWU USe]`RS\ c\R `ObS WV`$ aWQV W\ OZZS` \]beS\RWUS\ :]`[ OPhcaWQVS`\& 9VS WQV OcT GS\RS\ R`wQYS$ aQVOcS WQV OcT RWS RWQYS\ GQV\SSTZ]QYS\$ RWS W\ NSWbZc^S heWaQVS\ RS\ ;SPscRS\ VS`c\bS`Y][[S\$ c\R RS\YS$ WQV bcS WV` SW\S\ ;STOZZS\& GWS YO\\ OcaabSWUS\ c\R eSWbS`aSVS\& 5PS` WQV TW\RS a] Ucb eWS UO`

bcS WV` SW\S\ ;STOZZS\& GWS YO\\ OcaabSWUS\ c\R eSWbS`aSVS\& 5PS` WQV TW\RS a] Ucb eWS UO` \WQVba ROPSW$ c\aS`S DO`b\S`aQVOTb$ c\aS`S :W`[O$ [SW\S ?O``WS`S VW\hcaQV[SWrS\& =QV PSb`OQVbS ROa YSW\SaeSUa a]$ eWS [O\ aWQV SbeO OcT RS\ :W\US` aWSVb$ eS\\ [O\ aWQV US`ORS USaQV\WbbS\ VOb c\R eO`bSb$ ]P Sa PZcbSb& 9W\S\ A][S\b ZO\U Wab Sa SVS`$ OZa es`S Sa SW\ T`S[RS` :W\US`$ OZa es`S [O\ aSZPab c\dS`ZSbhb c\R ROa S`eO`bSbS 6Zcb \WQVb ROa SWUS\S& GQVZWSrZWQV Y][[S WQV hc[ :ZcUVOTS\ c\R ZOcTS hc[ 9`abS%?ZOaaS%GQVOZbS` d]`& 8WS :`Oc R]`b bSWZb [W` [Wb$ ROaa WQV [SW\S\ :ZcU dS`^Oaab VOPS& =QV T`OUS$ ]P \]QV SW\ O\RS`S` USVb$ c\R aWS aOUb [W`$ Sa UWPb SW\S\ wPS` 5[abS`RO[$ W\ R`SW Gbc\RS\& CV\S hc hvUS`\ YOcTS WQV SW\ 9`abS%?ZOaaS%HWQYSb hc[ d]ZZS\ D`SWa& Nc RS` NSWb VOPS WQV aWSPhWUbOcaS\R 8]ZZO` OcT RS[ ;W`]Y]\b] c\R RS\YS$ eS\\ wPS`VOc^b$ Tw\TbOcaS\R aW\R SW\ DO^^S\abWSZ& =QV T`OUS RWS :`Oc$ ]P Sa O[ :ZcUVOTS\ SW\ <]bSZ UWPb$ eSWZ WQV [WQV d]` RS[ :ZcU Yc`h VW\ZSUS\ c\R aQVZOTS\ [vQVbS& GWS aWSVb [WQV O\ c\R aOUb \OQV SW\S` DOcaS$ ROaa SW\ AO``W]bb [Wb RS[ HOfW ZSWQVb hc S``SWQVS\ Wab& =QV RO\YS WV`$ USPS [SW\ ;S^sQY Tw` RS\ GWSPS\%IV`%:ZcU OcT c\R \SV[S RS\ ;S^sQYaQVSW\ S\bUSUS\& J][ HOfW Oca `cTS WQV B]OV O\ c\R VW\bS`ZOaaS WV[ SW\S BOQV`WQVb$ ROaa WQV [SW\S\ :ZcU dS`^Oaab VOPS x I\[vUZWQVS` JS`YSV`$ aOUS WQV [Wb USa^WSZbS` 9\bbscaQVc\U x$ OPS` [Wb RS[ \sQVabS\ Y][[S& 8S` HOfWTOV`S` Wab SW\ Ucb OcaaSVS\RS` @ObW\] [Wb Rc\YZS\ 5cUS\$ c\R WQV TO\US a]T]`b SW\ ;Sa^`sQV O\& KWS WQV Sa O\abSZZS$ WV\ hc T`OUS\$ ]P S` R`vV\b$ eSWr WQV \WQVb$ OPS` RO\\ Wab Sa a] eSWb& 9` aOUb jO$ WQV T`OUS e][Wb$ c\R S` O\be]`bSb$ 6WS` c\R D]b& 8O\\ T`OUb S`$ eOa WQV \SV[S$ c\R WQV aOUS Sa WV[ `c\RVS`Oca& 9` Wab abWZZ$ T`OUb$ ]P WQV eSZQVSa ROPSWVOPS$ c\R WQV aOUS jO& 9` T`OUb$ ]P S` Sa aSVS\ YO\\$ c\R ]V\S hc hvUS`\ \SV[S WQV SW\S\ GbSW\ Oca RS` HOaQVS c\R VOZbS WV\ heWaQVS\ RS\ PSWRS\ J]`RS`aWbhS\ V]QV& 9` TsV`b ZO\UaO[S`$ PSb`OQVbSb ROa 7`OQY SW\USVS\R$ aOUb OPS` \WQVba& 5Za WQV Sa eSU\SV[S$ ZOQVb S` c\R aOUb$ S` VOb \]QV \WS eSZQVSa USaSVS\$ c\R WQV T`OUS WV\$ ]P S` @cab VOb$ Sa hc ^`]PWS`S\& ?ZO`$ aOUb S`$ a^sbS`$ \OQV aSW\S` GQVWQVb$ c\R UWPb [W` aSW\S <O\Rg\c[[S`& =QV abSQYS aWS SW\$ ]Pe]VZ WQV eSWr$ ROaa [SW\ :ZcU USVb$ PSd]` S` TS`bWU Wab& 8O S` [W` aSW\S\ BO[S\ \WQVb aOUb$ aQVOcS WQV OcT RS\ ^ZSfWUZOaUS`OV[bS\ :OV`S`OcaeSWa VW\bS` RS[ 6SWTOV`S`aWbh c\R aSVS$ ROaa S` Rc`QV SW\ GbwQY NSWbc\U dS`RSQYb Wab& =QV T`OUS WV\$ eWS S` VSWrb$ c\R S` P`c[[SZb SbeOa I\dS`abs\RZWQVSa& =QV T`OUS WV\ \]QV SW\[OZ$ c\R eS\\ WQV `SQVb dS`abSVS$ aOUb S` nFWQYl& =`US\RSbeOa O\ aSW\S[ 6S\SV[S\ s\RS`b aWQV$ OZa eW` d]` RS[ AO``W]bb O\VOZbS\& 9` eW`R ^ZvbhZWQV YwVZ$ c\R a^sbS` TsZZb [W` SW\$ ROaa S` SWUS\bZWQV UO` \WQVb aSW\ :OV`USZR dS`ZO\Ub$ ROaa Sa PSZO\UZ]a S`aQVSW\b$ OZa WQV Sa WV[ USPS& Bc` OQVbS WQV YOc[ RO`OcT$ a] T`]V PW\ WQV$ ROaa WQV RS\ :ZcU dS`^Oaab VOPS c\R jSbhb SW\ ^OO` Gbc\RS\ NSWb hc[ :ZOaVS\ VOPS& =QV USVS OcTa NW[[S` c\R aQVZWSrS RWS Hw` VW\bS` [W`$ OZa es`S Sa RS` J]`VO\U SW\S` U`]rS\$ O\UabS``SUS\RS\ 6wV\S$ OcT RS` WQV SW\S ab`O^OhWvaS F]ZZS hc a^WSZS\ VObbS$ RWS WQV \c\ S\RZWQV OPZSUS\ YO\\& =QV hWSVS [SW\S >OQYS Oca c\R POcS [W` SW\S\ RWQYS\ <Wb&

WQV \c\ S\RZWQV OPZSUS\ YO\\& =QV hWSVS [SW\S >OQYS Oca c\R POcS [W` SW\S\ RWQYS\ <Wb& 9a `SU\Sb ?`w[SZ OcT RWS 6SbbRSQYS$ OZa WQV ROa FvV`QVS\ O\a @WQVb VOZbS$ OPS` ROa Yw[[S`b [WQV \WQVb& =QV hWSVS Y`sTbWU c\R PSVOZbS RS\ FOcQV PSW [W`$ a] ZO\US WQV YO\\& 5Za WQV OcaOb[S$ dS`aQVeW\RSb RS` Gb`Saa RS` ZSbhbS\ Gbc\RS\$ c\R SW\ aQVW[[S`\RSa ;ZwQYaUSTwVZ b`Wbb O\ aSW\S GbSZZS& 6OZR eS`RS WQV [W` [SW\Sa ?v`^S`a PSecaab$ c\R [SW\S ?ZSWRS` abv`S\ [WQV& NeWaQVS\ RS[ S`abS\ c\R heSWbS\ <Wb hWSVS WQV >OQYS c\R DcZZ]dS` Oca& GWS S`aQVSW\S\ [W` OZa HSWZ SW\S` NeO\UaY]abw[WS`c\U Tw` RS\ 5cTb`Wbb R`OcrS\ c\R dvZZWU wPS`TZwaaWU& 6SW[ R`WbbS\ <Wb PW\ WQV \OQYb$ \SV[S [W` OPS` SW\ <O\RbcQV Oca RS[ 6OR c\R aQVZW\US Sa [W` c[ RWS <wTbS& 8Oa [OQVS WQV W[[S`$ eS\\ WQV R`vV\S& =QV TW\RS [SW\S\ CPS`Yv`^S` aQVZO\Y$ [caYcZva c\R aSfg& KS\\ WQV [WQV W[ G^WSUSZ PSb`OQVbS$ RS\YS WQV jSRSa AOZ$ \WQVb aQVZSQVb& 8O\\ TsZZb [W` SW\S JO`WO\bS RSa G^`cQVa Oca 6S\ BSWVO`ba F][O\ <Sg >]S SW\$ e] RS` 9`hsVZS` aWQV W[ G^WSUSZ [cabS`b c\R aSZPabhcT`WSRS\ RS\Yb$ ROaa S` eW`YZWQV Ucb PSWaO[[S\ Wab& 9V`ZWQV USaOUb$ ROa [OQVb [WQV O\& =QV aQVWSPS [W` ROa <O\RbcQV bWSTS` OcT RWS <wTbS$ hWSVS Sa SW\ eS\WU ab`OTTS`$ c\R VsbbS OcT SW\[OZ US`\ ;SaSZZaQVOTb& =QV `cTS RWS Bc[[S` RSa HOfWTOV`S`a O\$ OPS` \WS[O\R [SZRSb aWQV$ c\R RWS AOWZP]f USVb \WQVb O\& =\ RS` \sQVabS\ Gbc\RS ^`]PWS`S WQV ROa `c\R R`SWrWU AOZ& =QV ZSUS RS\ `SabZWQVS\ =\VOZb RS` HwbS W\ SW\S\ 5aQVS\PSQVS`$ c\R Sa aWSVb [W` \OQV eOV\aW\\WU dWSZ Oca& 6SW RS\ \sQVabS\ <Wba aQVZcRS`S WQV& 6OZR aW\R RWS 6SbbRSQYS c\R RS` :crP]RS\ d]ZZS` ?`w[SZ& =QV eSWr$ ROaa WQV aWS W`US\ReO\\ OcT OZZS\ JWS`S\ hcaO[[S\acQVS\ eS`RS c\R RO\\ RWS 7`OQYY`w[SZ Oca RS[ O\RS`S\ ?\WSab VS`Oca^WQYS\ [caa& 7`OQY`OcQVS\ heW\Ub [WQV W[[S` W\ RWS ?\WS$ a] ROaa WQV [O\QV[OZ abc\RS\ZO\U OcT HS^^WQVPvRS\$ @scTS`\$ @W\]ZSc[ ]RS` :ZWSaS\ VS`c[`cbaQVS$ ?ObhS\VOO`S$ :caaSZ\ c\R 8`SQY US\OcSabS\a Rc`QVaWSPS c\R eWS SW\ =``S` RS\ 6]RS\ \OQV 6`vaSZ\ OPbOabS& =QV eSWr$ ROaa Sa RO`OcT VW\OcaZscTb& 6SW RS\ \OQVZsaaWUS\$ eSWbab`ScS\RS\ <Wba O[ 5\TO\U PSb`OQVbS WQV RS\ 6]RS\ jSeSWZa OZa SW\S 5`b 5ZbS`adS`a]`Uc\U& 5cT RWS ?O\bS USZSUbS 6`vQYQVS\$ O\ RWS WQV [WQV a^sbS` VOZbS\ YO\\& 9a eW`R [W` SW\ H`]ab aSW\$ ROaa WQV \]QV eOa W\ ^Sbb] VOPS$ eS\\ aWQV RWS HwbS ZSS`b3 ROaa WQV SbeOa hc bc\ VOPS$ esV`S\R WQV OcT RWS \sQVabS @WSTS`c\U eO`bS& 5PS` O[ 5\TO\U$ eS\\ WQV Oca RS[ d]ZZS\ aQVv^TS$ Wab ROa W[[S` eSWb eSU& =\ RS[ NW[[S` W[ AO``W]bb O[ :ZcUVOTS\ BSeO`Y TZW[[S`\ eWS [SWabS\a$ eS\\ 7`OQY W[ G^WSZ Wab$ D]`\]a wPS` RS\ 6WZRaQVW`[& G]Tb c\R VSbS`] RWSa[OZ$ W[ 6ShOVZTS`\aSVS\& =QV hOVZS Tw` OZZS aSQVa Gb`SWTS\ c\R hO^^S VW\ c\R VS`$ eS\\ SW\S GhS\S aQVeOQV Wab ]RS` ZO\UeSWZWU eW`R& 9`ab$ OZa WQV RWS YZSW\S :ZOaQVS KSWreSW\$ RWS heSW 6WS` c\R RWS PSWRS\ YZSW\S\ K]RYOa Oca RS` AW\WPO` USb`c\YS\ VOPS$ TsZZb [W` SW\$ ROaa WQV hc`wQY hc[ :ZcUVOTS\ c\R hc [SW\S[ :ZWSUS` [caa& 8O WQV \]QV jSRS AS\US 7`OQY W[ 5aQVS\PSQVS` VOPS$ wPS`ZSUS WQV$ ]P WQV ROa eW`YZWQV [OQVS\ a]ZZ&

5PS` WQV [OQVya& =QV ZOaaS ROa FvV`QVS\ OPYwVZS\ c\R eWQYZS Sa RWQY W\ DO^WS`bwQVS`& =QV \SV[S RWS heSW GbSW\S c\R RWS dS`PZWSPS\S\ ?`w[SZ Oca RS[ 5aQVS\PSQVS` c\R abSQYS aWS eWSRS` W\ ROa NW^Z]Q%HwbQVS\$ W\ RS[ WQV aWS PSY][[S\ VOPS& 8O\\ eS`TS WQV ROa <O\RbcQV VW\$ hWSVS [WQV `OaQV O\ c\R abSQYS DTSWTS$ HwbS c\R :ScS`hScU d]`\ W\ [SW\S >SO\abOaQVS& 9W\ 8cbhS\R [OZ aSVS WQV [WQV ^`wTS\R W[ NW[[S` c[& KWaQVS as[bZWQVS 5PZOUS\ c\R VSPS jSRS\ S`YS\\PO`S\ ?`w[SZ d][ 6]RS\ OcT& AW\RSabS\a R`SW[OZ ^OQYS WQV HwbS$ DTSWTS c\R :ScS`hScU eWSRS` Oca$ c[ [W` \]QV SW\S\ ZSbhbS\ <Wb hc US\SV[WUS\$ PSd]` WQV USVS$ c\R Tw` RWS @]PPg c\R RS\ :ZcUVOTS\ US\Oc W\ RS` `WQVbWUS\ JS`TOaac\U hc aSW\& 5Za WQV RO\\ Z]aTOV`S$ PZSWPb [W` YSW\S Gbc\RS [SV` hc[ 9W\QVSQYS\& B]OV VOb R`SW% ]RS` dWS`[OZ O\US`cTS\$ R]QV WQV VOPS eSRS` OPUS\][[S\ \]QV [W` aSW\S BOQV`WQVbS\ O\USVv`b& =QV [SZRS [WQV W[ <]bSZ \WQVb S`ab OP& =QV USVS RW`SYb hc[ HOfWabO\R c\R \SV[S RS\ SW\hWUS\ KOUS\$ RS` RO abSVb& 8S` :OV`S` Wab SW\ Y`sTbWUS` GQVeO`hS` x RWQY$ OPS` ObVZSbWaQV$ Hg^ @W\SPOQYS`& JWS`hWU PWa Tw\ThWU& 8Oa d]` eS\WUS\ AW\cbS\ \]QV VSTbWU PSO\a^`cQVbS FvV`QVS\ P`S\\b eWS SW\ YZSW\S` CTS\ W\ [SW\S` >SO\abOaQVS& BObw`ZWQV T`OUS WQV WV\$ ]P S` R`vV\b& 9` aOUb jO$ c\R WQV T`OUS WV\$ ]P S` 7`OQY `OcQVb& BO YZO`$ aOUb S`$ c\R ]Pe]VZ WQV US`ORS S`ab SW\USabWSUS\ PW\$ eSWr WQV$ ROaa RS` :ZcU USUSaaS\ Wab& 8Oaa WQV eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV \WS[OZa \OQV 6S`ZW\ Y][[S& 8O\\ ZOaa c\a TSWS`\$ aOUS WQV hc RS[ @W\SPOQYS` VW\bS`[ GbScS`$ c\R S` aOUb$ \O YZO`& 5Za eW` c\a RS[ 8`]^%CTT Tw` =\ZO\RTZwUS \sVS`\$ aOUS WQV WV[$ S` a]ZZS hc`wQY hc[ <]bSZ TOV`S\$ WQV ew`RS SW\S\ a^sbS`S\ :ZcU \SV[S\& 9` T`OUb \WQVb$ hvUS`b \WQVb$ a]\RS`\ aOUb S`\Scb \O YZO` c\R eS\RSb& =QV `cTS RWS 0((S` Bc[[S` RS` 7]\bW\S\bOZ O\$ aOUS$ WQV Yv\\S eSUS\ ?`O\YVSWb \WQVb TZWSUS\$ c\R T`OUS$ ]P aWS [SW\ HWQYSb OcT RS\ \sQVabS\ 5PS\R c[PcQVS\ Yv\\S\& I\UZOcPZWQVS`eSWaS bc\ aWS ROa& =QV PSY][[S SW\S\ DZObh S`abS` ?ZOaaS O[ \sQVabS\ 5PS\R c[ OQVb& NSWb ]V\S 9\RS$ SW\S HwbS 7`OQY$ ;SaSZZaQVOTb ]`UO\WaWS`b$ c\R SW\ <]bSZ W\ \]QV \WQVb [OZ SW\S` AW\cbS 9\bTS`\c\U& =QV VOPS US`ORS heSW :ZwUS dS`^Oaab$ ?ObS US[OWZb$ ROaa WQV c\aS`S 5US\bc` UO\h WV` wPS`ZOaaS$ [SW\S ?O``WS`S wPS` 6]`R USe]`TS\ c\R [SW\S\ USZWSPbS\ c\R heSWTSZZ]a aQV`SQYZWQV PSc\`cVWUbS\ :`Sc\R dS`aSbhb& 5ZZ ROa VOPS WQV USbO\$ c\R WQV Yv\\bS \WQVb UZwQYZWQVS` aSW\& =QV VW\bS`ZOaaS BOQV`WQVb OcT B]OVa <O\Rg$ ROaa WQV RS\ heSWbS\ :ZcU ab]`\WS`b VOPS c\R []`US\ Y][[S& =QV a^`SQVS `cVWU c\R ZO\UaO[$ [Wb SW\S[ <OcQV d]\ `US` c\R ;S\S`dbVSWb$ c[ \]`[OZ hc eW`YS\ c\R \WQVb O\USR`vV\b& 5Za WQV RWS BOQV`WQVb USa^`]QVS\ VOPS$ aQVOZbS WQV ROa <O\Rg Oca$ RO[Wb WQV Sa \WQVb YZW\USZ\ Vv`S$ eS\\ S` hc`wQY`cTb& G^sbS` b`STTS WQV [WQV [Wb RS[ HOfWTOV`S`$ c\R eW` abSZZS\ c\a [Wb aSW\S[ KOUS\ W`US\Re] W\ BSeO`Y VW\bS` SW\ /%))& 9` VOb 5\Uab$ W[ <]bSZ USaSVS\ hc eS`RS\$ eSWZ S` RO jSRS\ HOU @ScbS VW\P`W\Ub c\R OPV]Zb& =QV ab]^TS WV[ RWS DTSWTS x a^O`aO[$ eSWZ VS`hZWQV

jSRS\ HOU @ScbS VW\P`W\Ub c\R OPV]Zb& =QV ab]^TS WV[ RWS DTSWTS x a^O`aO[$ eSWZ VS`hZWQV eS\WU wP`WU Wab x$ c\R OZa S` aWS O\hw\RSb$ aOUS WQV WV[$ eWS USWZ [WQV ROa FOcQVS\ [OQVb& 9` \WQYb hcabW[[S\R$ OZa S` RS\ FOcQV Ocaabvrb$ c\R aQV]\ USVS\ RWS FSWrdS`aQVZwaaS OcT x S`ab [SW\S`$ RO\\ aSW\S`& =QV \SV[S SW\S\ NcU$ c\R S` VsZb aWQV aSZPS` c\R `SRSb wPS` aSW\S :`Oc$ RWS WV\ heO` ZcbaQVb$ OPS` \WS TWQYS\ eWZZ& =QV W\VOZWS`S a] aQVO`T$ ROaa WQV [W` 8Oc[S\ c\R NSWUSTW\US` dS`P`S\\S& >Sbhb a]ZZbS WQV OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS RSa 5bZO\bWYa aSW\$ RS\YS WQV$ abObbRSaaS\ PW\ WQV VW\bS` SW\S[ /%))$ W[ GQVObbS\ SW\S` Gb`OrS\wPS`TwV`c\U heWaQVS\ BSeO`Y c\R BSe >S`aSg& =QV ew\aQVS [W` PSaW\\c\UaZ]aS\$ Y\]QVS\VO`bS\ GSf c\R S`ZSPS abObbRSaaS\ SW\S b`wPS KWQVa`c\RS ]V\S RS\ \vbWUS\ Gb]TT$ c[ c\a PSWRS `OcThcP`W\US\& 5Za aWQV RWS HwbS ZSS`b$ eS`RS WQV hWbb`WU c\R [caa RO`O\ RS\YS\$ ROaa WQV aSWb TOab SW\S` K]QVS \WQVb USaQVZOTS\ VOPS& 9a Wab VOZP SZT$ c\R [SW\ :ZcU USVb S`ab []`US\ 5PS\R c[ OQVb& =QV T`OUS RS\ HOfWTOV`S`$ ]P S` eSWr$ e] [O\ BOQVaQVcP PSY][[S\ YO\\$ c\R \Obw`ZWQV VOb S` YSW\S 5V\c\U& =QV dS`abSQYS SW\ ZSbhbSa GbSW\QVS\ W\ RS` GQVZwaaSZbOaQVS [SW\S` >SO\a$ RO[Wb \]QV eOa RO Wab$ eS\\ WQV W\ [SW\ <]bSZhW[[S` Y][[S& I\R WQV wPS`ZSUS$ ]P WQV hc`wQY W\ RWS GbORb TOV`S\ a]ZZ x hc AO`Y ]RS` hc SW\S[ <]bSZ W`US\Re] W\ AO\VObbO\$ d]\ e] Oca WQV <O^^g O\`cTS\ YO\\& 5PS` BSe M]`Y Y][[b [W` UO\hS NSWbh]\S\ S\bTS`\b d]`& I\R eS\\ WQV R]`bVW\ TOV`S$ Wab OZZSa hc a^sb$ RO\\ Y][[S WQV W[ @SPS\ \WQVb \OQV 6S`ZW\& 8S` HOfWTOV`S` aSbhb [WQV O[ AO``W]bb OP$ c\R WQV `cTS <O^^g O\$ a]eWS WQV W[ NW[[S` PW\& BOQV ZO\US[ <W\ c\R <S` S`YZs`b S` aWQV PS`SWb$ `Oca hc[ <]bSZ hc Y][[S\$ OPS` \c`$ eS\\ WQV Tw` [W\RSabS\a 0(( 8]ZZO` YOcTS$ RO[Wb Sa aWQV Tw` WV\ Z]V\b& ?SW\ D`]PZS[$ aOUS WQV& 9a Wab Yc`h \OQV SZT$ OZa WQV [Wb <O^^g a^`SQVS& I[ hSV\ d]` hevZT `cTb S` [WQV d][ DO`Y^ZObh O\$ ROaa S` RO Wab& =QV YO\\ [WQV \WQVb S`W\\S`\$ ROaa S` W\ AO\VObbO\ aQV]\ [OZ a] aQV\SZZ USZWSTS`b VsbbS& =QV \SV[S RS\ 5cThcU \OQV c\bS\$ V]ZS [W` W\ RS` ZSS`S\ <OZZS ;SZR Oca RS[ 5cb][ObS\$ USVS [vUZWQVab ZO\UaO[ c\R `cVWU O\ RS` FShS^bW]\ d]`PSW c\R aSVS aSW\S\ `]bS\ AW\WdO\ W[ @SS`ZOcT OcT RS[ DO`Y^ZObh abSVS\& AW` YZ]^Tb ROa <S`h$ c\R [SW\S ?SVZS Wab d]` 5\Uab a] hcUSaQV\w`b$ ROaa WQV YOc[ a^`SQVS\ YO\\$ OZa WQV \SPS\ WV[ SW\abSWUS& <O^^g b`sUb eWS wPZWQV eSWrS GeSOb^O\ba c\R SW\ aQVeO`hSa ?O^chS\aVW`b& Bc` RWS U`]rS\ ?]^TVv`S`$ RWS S` a]\ab c[Vs\US\ VOb$ TSVZS\& 9` Wab 5\TO\U R`SWrWU$ abO[[b Oca 8][W\WQO$ c\R OcrS` AS\US\$ 5R`SaaS\ c\R FvV`QVS\hOVZ VOPS\ eW` c\a eS\WU [WbhcbSWZS\& 5cQV VScbS Wab S` `cVWU eWS W[[S`$ ]Pe]VZ S` d]\ AO\VObbO\ Sfb`O hc[ :ZcUVOTS\V]bSZ `OcaY][[S\ [caabS& ;S[sQVZWQV c\R USRcZRWU hsVZb S` aSQVhSV\ HwbS\ OP c\R abSZZb YSW\S :`OUS\$ OZa S` [W` heSW aOcPS`S FvV`QVS\ UWPb& =QV abSQYS OZZSa d]`\ W\ [SW\S <]aS\bOaQVS\$ RO\YS WV[$ ROaa S` a] aQV\SZZ USY][[S\ Wab$ c\R YSV`S W\a <]bSZ hc`wQY& <sbbS W`US\RjS[O\R PS]POQVbSb$ eWS WQV x eSUS\ RSa *((%8]ZZO`%@W[Wba [SV`[OZa VW\bS`SW\O\RS` x RWS GQVSW\S Oca RS[ ;SZROcb][ObS\ USV]Zb VOPS$ RO[Wb hc SW\S[ JO\ [Wb ZOcTS\RS[ A]b]` c\R USbv\bS\ GQVSWPS\ a^OhWS`b c\R AW\cbS\ a^sbS` [Wb

[Wb ZOcTS\RS[ A]b]` c\R USbv\bS\ GQVSWPS\ a^OhWS`b c\R AW\cbS\ a^sbS` [Wb OcaUSPScZbS\ HOaQVS\ hc`wQYUSY][[S\ PW\$ Yv\\bS S` aWQV ]V\S OZZhc dWSZ DVO\bOaWS Oca[OZS\$ eOa RO d]`USUO\US\ Wab& 5PS` a] Rc`QVaWQVbWU c\R VOZPUO` RWS 5YbW]\ OcQV eO`$ eS\\ WQV S`ab eWSRS` OcT [SW\S[ NW[[S` PW\ c\R SW\S\ ZO\US\ NcU Oca SW\S[ RS` PZWbhPZO\YS\ \ScS\ FvV`QVS\ \SV[S$ eSWr WQV$ eW`R OZZSa ]YOg aSW\& 8O\\ eS`RS\ RWS U`W[[WUS\$ PSs\UabWUS\RS\ KOV`VSWbS\$ RWS [WQV d]\ OZZS\ GSWbS\ O\PZOTTS\$ aWQV W\ SW\S` FOcQVe]ZYS OcTZvaS\& =\ RS` HOb& 9a Wab SW\ IV`$ c\R WQV VOPS SW\S\ FWSaS\PObhS\ 7`OQY W\ RS[ YZSW\S\ 5aQVS\PSQVS` OcT RS[ BOQVbbWaQV& G] dWSZ VObbS WQV \]QV \WS Tw` [WQV OZZSW\$ c\R WQV eSWr$ ROaa WQV Sa Y][^ZSbb OcT`OcQVS\ eS`RS& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P W`US\Re] W\ RWSaS[ <OcTS\ RS` ?`w[SZ abSQYb$ RS` RS\ =\TO`Yb$ RS\ <W`\aQVZOU ]RS` RS\ <S`hO\TOZZ VS`PSWTwV`b& 8S\ 5\TOZZ$ RS` OZZ ROa hc SW\S[ jsVS\$ eWZZY][[S\S\ 9\RS P`W\Ub& 8S` 6`cabY]`P ec[[S`b$ RWS :W\US` aW\R dS`aS\Ub$ c\R WQV TwZZS [SW\S @c\US [Wb FOcQV&

G^cQYaQVZ]aa
9` Wab aSQVa& 9` [W\RS`b RS\ KS`b RSa <OcaSa$ aOUb [O\ WV[& AW\RS`b RS\ KS`b Rc`QV RWS PS^WaabS\$ [Wb F]ab wPS`h]US\S\ <SWhUWbbS` W[ 6OR& 9`aQVeS`b RS\ JS`YOcT$ eSWZ S` W[[S`$ eS\\ S` `c[aOcb c\R aOcPS`hc[OQVS\ dS`acQVb$ ROa AcabS` d]\ RS` HO^SbS VW\bS`[ 6SQYS\ OP`cPPSZb& GWS aW\R W\ RS[ U`w\S\ J]ZYaeOUS\$ c\R Sa Wab \WQVb ROa S`abS AOZ$ ROaa aSW\ JObS` WV[ ROa d]`USVOZbS\ VOb& 8Oaa aSW\S DW\YSZSW RWS :O[WZWS HOcaS\RS 8]ZZO`a Y]abSb$ abSVb aSWb AS\aQVS\USRS\YS\ TSab& 9` aQVeSWUb eWS W[[S`$ eS\\ aSW\ D`]PZS[ hc` G^`OQVS Y][[b& GSW\ JObS` scrS`b aWQV W\ aQVO`TS\$ ^`sU\O\bS\ 5caP`wQVS\$ RWS S` TOab W[[S` UZSWQV OPaQVZWSrb2 5Za] KWZZWS& FSWr RWQV O[ FWS[S\$ ]RS` <S``U]bb$ >c\US$ Y][[ hc RW`& K]`OcT Sa ZO\US abWZZ Wab& AO\ Vv`b \WQVba W[ KOUS\ OcrS` RS[ ZSWaS\ ;SP`c[[ d]\ )()( KW\a Oca RS[ FORW] c\R eWS aSW\S[ JObS` RWS DTSWTS USUS\ RWS NsV\S YZWQYb& GWS aW\R OcT SW\S[ <WUVeOg$ OcT RS` FwQYTOV`b d]\ 6]ab]\& GWS TOV`S\ c\O\US\SV[ aQV\SZZ$ PWa aWQV RS` JS`YSV` abOcb c\R ROa :ZcQVS\ c\R 5cTa%@S\Y`OR%GQVZOUS\ Z]aUSVb& 5Za aSW\ JObS` ROa FORW] ZSWaS` R`SVb c\R RWS <SWhc\U `SUcZWS`b$ abSZZb S` WV\ aWQV d]` RS\ dWSZS\ @s[^QVS\ c\R =\ab`c[S\bS\ W[ 7]QY^Wb RS` :ZcUhScUS d]`$ RWS S` TZWSUb& AOaQVW\S\ d]ZZS` DOaaOUWS`S$ RWS RO`OcT dS`b`OcS\$ ROaa S` aWS wPS`a ASS` P`W\Ub$ \OQV @]\R]\ ]RS` DO`Wa& AO\QV[OZ x a] eWS jSbhb x YO\\ S` aWQV \WQVb d]`abSZZS\$ ROaa Sa SbeOa UWPb$ eOa aSW\ JObS` \WQVb TS`bWUP`W\Ub& 8S` JS`YSV` eW`R aQVZW[[S`$ c\R aSW\ JObS` \v`USZb wPS` RWS 5cb]a d]` WV[& 8S` >c\US PZSWPb abWZZ& 9` Wab T`]V$ ROaa RWS 5cT[S`YaO[YSWb \WQVb [SV` WV[ UWZb c\R RS[ ;`c\R$ eSaVOZP aWS VScbS VWS` hcaO[[S\ W[ KOUS\ aWbhS\& GWS eO`S\ PSW SW\S[ 5`hb x RS[ 5`hb RS` 6]ab]\ FSR G]f$ VOb aSW\ JObS` USaOUb x$ c[ W\ 9`TOV`c\U hc P`W\US\$ eOa WV[ SWUS\bZWQV TSVZb& KOa aWQV US\Oc W[ G^`SQVhW[[S` RSa 5`hbSa OPa^WSZb$ eW`R S` dS`USaaS\& =[ 5cb] ecaabS S` Sa dWSZZSWQVb \]QV c\R VOb RO`wPS` \OQVUSROQVb$ dWSZZSWQVb eO` Sa WV[ OPS` OcQV RO aQV]\ \WQVb [SV` ^`saS\b& >SRS\TOZZa eW`R S` jOV`SZO\U dS`acQVS\$ Sa aWQV W\ 9`W\\S`c\U hc `cTS\$ OPS` ROa 9W\hWUS$ eOa RO\\ V]QVY][[b$ Wab RWS 5cb]TOV`b aSZPab& GW\R RWS OZbS\ G^`wQVS$ ROaa S` ROa <Oca `cW\WS`b$ c\R RWS [S`Yew`RWUS$ PSW\OV aSfcSZZ OcTUSZORS\S GbW[[c\U RSa HOUSa x UW\U Sa R]QV ROcS`\R c[ DS\WaaS c\R DW\YSZ\& 8WS UO\hS H]c` VObbS SbeOa JS`ab]VZS\Sa c\R JS`aQVs[bSa$ O\USTO\US\ [Wb RS` dS`Y\WTTS\S\ 5\Yw\RWUc\U aSW\S` AcbbS` PSW[ :`wVabwQY$ ROaa S` c\R aSW\ JObS` \OQV 6]ab]\ hc[ 5`hb TOV`S\ ew`RS\& 9` S`W\\S`b aWQV$ eWS PSa]`Ub c\R OPeSaS\R aWS OcaUSaSVS\ VOb& 9`

TOV`S\ ew`RS\& 9` S`W\\S`b aWQV$ eWS PSa]`Ub c\R OPeSaS\R aWS OcaUSaSVS\ VOb& 9` S`W\\S`b aWQV$ ROaa S` aWQV USew\aQVb VOb$ ROa 5cb] ew`RS W\ d]ZZS` :OV`b d]\ RS` Gb`OrS OPY][[S\ c\R Sf^Z]RWS`S\& Kw\aQVS RWSaS` 5`b eW`R S` \]QV jOV`SZO\U VSUS\ x W\ GQVcZPcaaS\$ :ZcUhScUS\$ H`O\a^]`bS`\$ NwUS\& 9` S`W\\S`b aWQV OcQV$ c\R heO` ZSPVOTb$ O\ RWS J]`VS`aOUS$ RWS aSW\ JObS` b`WTTb2 8Oaa aSW\S :`Sc\RS x HW[]bVg$ 8S`SY$ >S\\WTS` x c\R WV`S 9ZbS`\ WV\ aQV]\ aSV` POZR \WQVb [SV` hc[ G^WSZS\ ]RS` qPS`\OQVbS\ hc aWQV SW\ZORS\ eS`RS\& 8Oaa Sa \c` SW\S :`OUS RS` NSWb Wab$ PWa WV\S\ SW\ @WQVb OcTUSVb$ c\R eS\\ aWS S`ab 6SaQVSWR eWaaS\$ eS`RS\ aWS SW\S a]ZQVS GQVeSW\S`SW$ SW\ a]ZQVSa A]\ab`c[$ OcT YSW\S\ :OZZ [SV` PSW aWQV hc <OcaS RcZRS\& @SbhbS`Sa O`PSWbSb W\ WV[& 9a eSWbSb aWQV Oca hc RS` qPS`hScUc\U$ ROaa aWS PS`SWba 6SaQVSWR eWaaS\$ aWQV PSW aSW\S\ 9ZbS`\ PSaQVeS`b c\R WV`S ?W\RS`$ aSW\S :`Sc\RS$ d]` WV[ USeO`\b VOPS\& 6Wa aWS SW\ ^OO` >OV`S a^sbS` W\ SW\S YZSW\S`S GbORb eSWbS` \v`RZWQV c\R bWSTS` W\ RS\ KsZRS`\ hWSVS\$ a]`Ub S` aWQV$ ROaa aSW\S :`Sc\RS$ WV`S :O[WZWS\ c\R a]UO` aSW\S @SV`S` W\aUSVSW[ d]\ aSW\S[ D`]PZS[ eWaaS\ c\R ROaa RS` HOU Y][[S\ eW`R$ O\ RS[ aWS ROa [Wb dWSZ H`O`O Yc\Rbc\& AO\QV[OZ abSZZb S` aWQV ROa \WQVb \c` d]`$ a]\RS`\ [SW\b eW`YZWQV hc Vv`S\$ eWS aWS ZSWaS A]\abS` aOUS\& GWS TOV`S\ OZa]& GSW\ JObS` Zsaab aWQV eSWbS` wPS` <OcaeS`b[W\RS`c\U c\R PSd]`abSVS\RS <OcadS`P]bS Oca& 5ca RS[ FORW] P`c[[SZb eSWbS` RS` GS\RS`$ RS` \]QV >OV`S a^sbS` Tw` WV\ RWS b`WabSabS OZZS` b`]abZ]aS\ ;S`scaQVYcZWaaS\ aSW\ eW`R$ RS` GS\RS`$ RS` W\ jSRS[ OZbS\ c\R \ScS\ 5cb] aSW\Sa JObS`a S`bv\b& 5Za aWS RS\ <WUVeOg dS`ZOaaS\ c\R wPS` RWS USec\RS\S\ Gb`OrS\ 7]\\SQbWQcba VSW[es`ba TOV`S\$ Wab Sa abWZZ PWa OcT ROa USZSUS\bZWQVS ?ZWQYS\ RS` DTSWTS heWaQVS\ RS\ NsV\S\& 8WS 5crS\eSZb aQVSW\b SW\USeSWVb hc aSW\$ RS` 5`hbPSacQV c\R RWS O\aQVZWSrS\RS\ J]`VOZbc\US\ HSWZ SW\Sa ZO\UUSVSUbS\$ OZZaSWba PSTw`e]`bSbS\ GQVZOQVb^ZO\a& 8c PWab Yv`^S`ZWQV dvZZWU USac\R$ P`wZZb WV\ aSW\ JObS` aQVZWSrZWQV O\$ heSWTSZZ]a US`sRS`b d]\ RS[ UO\hS\ HOU& 8Oa Wab `SW\S KWZZS\aaOQVS& 8c [caab RWQV S\baQVSWRS\& KSWr ;]bb$ eOa Tw` SW\S\ PZSWPS\RS\ GQVORS\ Rc RO c\bS\ O\`WQVbSab& KOa Rc a^sbS` [OZ OZZSa \WQVb YO\\ab& 8WS ZSbhbS\ GsbhS [waaS\ USTOZZS\ aSW\$ OZa aWS aQV]\ OcT RS` NcTOV`b eO`S\ ]RS` d]` RS` ;O`OUS abO\RS\$ RS\\ S` YO\\ aWQV S`W\\S`\$ ROaa S` PSW RS[ K]`b GQVORS\ OcT ROa O\bV`OhWbTO`PS\S FO\QVUSPscRS USaQVOcb c\R USROQVb VOb$ SW\ \ScS` <SWhYv`^S` c\R SW\S \ScS HO^SbS aW\R \WQVba W[ JS`UZSWQV hc RS[$ eOa Sa Y]abS\ eW`R$ WV\ W\ C`R\c\U hc P`W\US\&

?][^ZWhWS`bSa HVSObS`
8Oa AO``W]bb O[ BSeO`Y 5W`^]`b VOb SW\S 6O`& ?c`h d]` AWbbS`\OQVb `cTS WQV W\ RS` FShS^bW]\ O\ c\R S`TOV`S$ ROaa aWS PWa c[ SW\a USvTT\Sb Wab& =QV RcaQVS$ `OaWS`S [WQV c\R `sc[S a] Ucb Sa USVb OcT$ SVS WQV \OQV c\bS\ TOV`S$ c[ eOa hc b`W\YS\ c\R \WQVb OZZSW\ hc aSW\& =QV aSbhS [W` \ScS ?]\bOYbZW\aS\ SW\$ RS\\ eS\\ WQV VWUV PW\$ YO\\ WQV \]QV a] dWSZ KOaaS` b`W\YS\ ]RS` H`]^TS\ W\ RWS 5cUS\ bc\$ RWS @W\aS\ eS`RS\ b`]QYS\ c\R TOZZS\ VS`Oca& =QV VOPS dWS` DOO` 9`aObhZW\aS\ Tw` RWS FSWaS SW\US^OQYb$ c\R aSWb WQV W[ <]bSZ PW\$ VOPS WQV RWS ZW\YS SW\[OZ c\R RWS `SQVbS aQV]\ heSW[OZ USeSQVaSZb& AW` Wab YZO`$ ROaa WQV d]`aWQVbWUS` aSW\ [caa$ OPS` \]QV aQVSW\b d]\ OZZS[ x ]P ?]\bOYbZW\aS\$ 8`]US\$ ;SZR ]RS` NSWb x [SV` OZa US\cU RO hc aSW\& =QV hWSVS [SW\S\ RWQYS\ Rc\YSZPZOcS\ ?OaQV[W``]ZZW [Wb RS[ N]^T[cabS` O\$ eSWZ WQV RO`W\ \WQVb a] Rw`` OcaaSVS3 OcrS`RS[ Wab S` bScS` c\R YOaQVWS`b$ [SW\S WQV$ eWS b]bOZ OPUSQ`OQYb WQV PW\& =QV abSWUS W\ [SW\S >SO\a$ c\R ]Pe]VZ WQV RS\ ;w`bSZ aQV]\ PWa hc[ ZSbhbS\ @]QV aQV\OZZS$ [caa WQV \]QV VOZP RS\ DcZZ]dS` `SW\abSQYS\$ RO[Wb RWS <]aS \WQVb `cbaQVb& =\ 6S`ZW\ eS`RS WQV W\ SW\ @SRS`eO`S\USaQVsTb USVS\ [waaS\& 5Za WQV O\USh]US\ PW\$ Wab S`ab[OZ eWSRS` SW\ <Wb TsZZWU$ ROhc SW\ ;ZOa K]RYO$ RO\\ ^`wTS WQV [SW\ 5caaSVS\ W[ G^WSUSZ$ ^ZOUS [WQV [Wb [SW\S\ <OO`S\$ PWa WQVya OcTUSPS c\R RWS AwbhS d][ DO`Ya 8S^O`b[S\b OcTaSbhS& AW` Wab eO`[$ c\R RO WQV SbeOa USWZ c\R c\`cVWU eS`RS W\ [SW\S\ GOQVS\$ hWSVS WQV RS\ DcZZ]dS` Oca$ ZSUS [WQV OcTa 6Sbb$ aQVOZbS SW\S\ D]`\] SW\ c\R eWQVaS& 9W\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ USPS WQV [WQV RS[ aQVec[[`WUS\ K]VZUSTwVZ VW\$ c\R OZa Sa \OQVZsaab$ aQVS\YS WQV [W` \]QV SW\S\ K]RYO SW\$ c[ [WQV hc P`S[aS\ c\R ROa <WUV OPhc[WZRS`\& 9W\S\ \]QV$ RS\YS WQV$ SW\S\ U`]rS\ hc[ Acb [OQVS\& 5Za] \]QV SW\S\& =QV hWSVS [SW\S\ DcZZ]dS` eWSRS` O\$ VO[^SZS d]` RS[ G^WSUSZ VS`c[$ dS`^OaaS [W` \]QV SW\ ^OO` 5cUS\b`]^TS\$ ab`SWQVS [W` RWS <OO`S UZObb$ aSbhS RWS AwbhS OcT$ aQVZs\UZS [WQV W\ [SW\S >SO\a$ c\R SVS WQV [WQVya dS`aSVS$ ZWSUS WQV eWSRS` OcT RS[ 6Sbb$ aQVW[[S`\R$ ]V\S <S[R$ c\R US\WSrS RS\ Yc`hS\ 5cUS\PZWQY$ PWa WQV eWSRS` [SW\S DTSWTS P`OcQVS$ SW\S\ 8`W\Y c\R SW\S eW\hWUYZSW\S 5bS[^OcaS d]` RS[ FOcaUSVS\& GQVZWSrZWQV Y][[S WQV VW\c\bS` W\ RWS 6O` c\R PW\ a]T]`b S\bbscaQVb$ ROaa RS` @ORS\ PSW\OV ZSS` Wab PWa OcT SW\hSZ\S Ds`QVS\ c\R hcaO[[S\ `SWaS\RS 5`PSWbaY]ZZSUS\& 8S\ `OabZ]aS\$ dS`ZSbhZWQVS\ 9W\hSZUs\US`$ RS\ WQV acQVS$ YO\\ WQV \WQVb S\bRSQYS\ x RS\ aSSZS\dS`eO\RbS\ ?][^ZWhS\$ RWS 7VO\QS OcT SW\S ZO\US BOQVb& =QV YW^^S R`SW ]RS` dWS` K]RYO c\R eS`RS ZO\UaO[ hWbb`WU& ASV` OZa heO\hWU AW\cbS\ ]V\S <Wb aW\R hc dWSZ$ c\R WQV PW\ aQV]\ [W\RSabS\a SW\S VOZPS Gbc\RS VWS` c\bS\& K]RYO ZW\RS`b \]`[OZS`eSWaS ROa NWbbS`\$ UZsbbSb RWS YZSW\S\ <]``]`eSZZS\$ RWS RS\ 5Pabc`h \OQV

ZW\RS`b \]`[OZS`eSWaS ROa NWbbS`\$ UZsbbSb RWS YZSW\S\ <]``]`eSZZS\$ RWS RS\ 5Pabc`h \OQV RS[ <WUV O\Yw\RWUS\$ OPS` jSbhb \wbhb S` \WQVb dWSZ& >SRS\TOZZa eO`bSb W\ [SW\S[ NW[[S` RS` U`vrbS 6ObhS\ 7`OQY OcT [WQV$ RS\ WQV jS USaSVS\ VOPS$ c\R Sa UWPb YSW\S\ dS`\w\TbWUS\ ;`c\R$ RWS :W\US` ROd]\ hc ZOaaS\& =QV eW\YS RS[ ?SZZ\S` a] `cVWU eWS [vUZWQV$ ZSUS heSW NeO\hWUS` c\R SW\S\ NSV\S` Tw` RWS FSQV\c\U wPS` +- 8]ZZO` VW\ c\R USVS hc[ 5cThcU& 8c`QV RWS BOQVb _cWZZb RWQVbS` FOcQV$ c\R PWa hc[ \sQVabS\ BOQV[WbbOU hWSVS WQV \Sc\ d]\ RS\ aSQVhSV\ HwbS\ eSU& B]QV \WS VOPS WQV W\ a] Yc`hS` NSWb a] dWSZ US`OcQVb x heSW HwbS\$ [Wb [W\RSabS\a SW\S` O\RS`S\ DS`a]\ USbSWZb$ es`S\ \]`[OZS`eSWaS aQV]\ SW\S `SWTS BOQVb& ASW\S <Ocb ^`WQYSZb d]` Ks`[S$ c\R WQV PW\ [W` jSRSa 5bS[hcUa c\R jSRSa <S`haQVZOUa PSecaab& ASW\S as[bZWQVS\ ?ZSWRS` c\R H]WZSbbS\aOQVS\ aW\R W[ <]bSZhW[[S` dS`ab`Scb$ c\R WQV VOPS W[[S` \]QV hc dWSZ hc[ FOcQVS\$ OZa ROaa WQV [WQV [Wb RS[ ;SRO\YS\$ ROa NW[[S` hc dS`ZOaaS\$ O\T`Sc\RS\ Yv\\bS& =QV `cTS RS\ HOfWTOV`S` d][ 5PS\R hcd]` O\ c\R VW\bS`ZOaaS SW\ 8cbhS\R BOQV`WQVbS\& 9` `cTb \WQVb hc`wQY& 8Oa DOQYS\ c\R 5cT`sc[S\ \W[[b Gbc\RS\ W\ 5\a^`cQV$ [Wb <c\RS`bS\ d]\ YZSW\S\ 6]fS\ab]^a$ c[ heWaQVS\Rc`QV hc `OcQVS\ c\R hc b`W\YS\& 8`SW Gbc\RS\ d]` RS[ :ZcU aQVOTTS WQV [WQV aQVZWSrZWQV \OQV c\bS\ W\ RWS <OZZS& 6SW[ 5P[SZRS\ TOZZS\ [W` W\ Hw`\sVS Tw\T ]RS` aSQVa As\\S` heWaQVS\ ,( c\R .( OcT& 5ZZS VOPS\ SbeOa c\PSabW[[b 6SabW[[bSa O\ aWQV x U`OcS <]aS\$ TSabSa GQVcVeS`Y$ KW\RjOQYS\& >7 DS\\Sg d]\ ?]^T PWa :cr& GWS `SRS\ ZSWaS [WbSW\O\RS`$ c\R Sa aQVSW\b x OcQV eS\\ WQV [W` \WQVb aWQVS` PW\ x$ ROaa aWS OZZSaO[b CV`Vv`S` [Wb RShS\b W[ <S[R dS`abSQYbS\ ?OPSZ\ b`OUS\& G]\ab Wab \WS[O\R W\ RS` <OZZS& 5[ HOfWabO\R abSVb SW\ SW\hWUS` KOUS\& 8Oa Wab S`$ Vv`S WQV SW\S\ RS` As\\S` aOUS\$ ]RS` [SW\S Sa hc[W\RSab$ OZa WQV Rc`QV RWS 5cb][ObWYbw` VW\Oca OcT RS\ :creSU b`SbS& I\R OZa WQV W\a HOfW abSWUS$ aSVS WQV$ eWS OZZS Tw\T ]RS` aSQVa ROa <]bSZ dS`ZOaaS\ c\R hc heSW$ R`SW d]` RS[ ;SPscRS ^O`YS\RS\ 5cb]a [O`aQVWS`S\& 8S` :OV`S` aWSVb [WQV eWaaS\R O\ c\R aOUb [SV` W[ H]\ SW\S` :SababSZZc\U OZa SW\S` :`OUS2 7]\bW\S\bOZ$ RS\ BO[S\ [SW\S` :ZcUZW\WS$ OPS` e]VS` eSWr S` ROa4 =QV T`OUS WV\$ c\R S` aOUb2 KW` aW\R W\ BSeO`Y$ RO TZWSUS\ OZZS 7]\bW\S\bOZ& =QV PZWQYS OcT ROa BO[S\aaQVWZR O\ RS` DZSfWUZOa%H`S\\aQVSWPS c\R aSVS$ ROaa Sa US\Oc eWS PSW RS[ HOfW USabS`\ d]\ SW\S[ GbwQY DO^^S dS`RSQYb Wab& DO\WY S`TOaab [WQV& 9` Zsaab RS\ KOUS\ O\$ TsV`b Z]a$ c\R OZa WQV aSVS$ ROaa aWQV RWS KOUS\ [Wb RS\ >7 DS\\Sg%Hg^S\ O\ c\a VSTbS\$ Wab [W` YZO`$ ROaa WQV US`ORS RWS ;`S\hS d]\ SW\S` KSZb hc SW\S` O\RS`S\ wPS`_cS`S& GQV]\ aSVS WQV d]` [W`$ eWS WQV O\ RWSaS HOfWTOV`b hc`wQYRS\YS\ eS`RS$ RWS ROa 9\RS [SW\Sa @SPS\a OZa T`SWS` AS\aQV [O`YWS`b& AO\ eW`R [WQV dS`VOTbS\& =QV VOPS SW\S HwbS 7`OQY c\R SW\S W\ DO^WS` USeWQYSZbS dWSZUS`OcQVbS DTSWTS W\ RS` HOaQVS [SW\S` >SO\a& =QV eSWr \WQVb$ e]VW\ RO[Wb& 5ca RS[ :S\abS` eS`TS\4 BSW\$ RWS Hg^S\$ eS` W[[S` aWS aW\R$ YZSPS\ O\ c\a& =\ RS\ DO^WS`Y]`P$ eS\\ eW` O\VOZbS\4 BSW\$ Oca RS[ UZSWQVS\ ;`c\R& NeWaQVS\ RWS GWbh^]ZabS` SW\Sa KOUS\a$ RS\ eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV SW\ dS`RSQYbS` 8`]US\TOV\RS` ZS\Yb4 BObw`ZWQV \WQVb&

KOUS\a$ RS\ eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV SW\ dS`RSQYbS` 8`]US\TOV\RS` ZS\Yb4 BObw`ZWQV \WQVb& Fc\bS`aQVZcQYS\4 JWSZZSWQVb& 5PS` RWS ;ZOa^TSWTS z eOa [OQVS WQV [Wb RS` ;ZOa^TSWTS4 8WS 5caeSUS PZWbhS\ OcT c\R dS`^cTTS\ SW\S` \OQV RS[ O\RS`S\$ esV`S\R eW` c\a W[ GQV\SQYS\bS[^] RS[ :ZcUVOTS\ \sVS`\& ?SW\S` Wab [OQVPO`& J]`[ JS`ZOaaS\ RSa <]bSZa ROQVbS WQV$ Sa es`S Ucb$ eOa [Wbhc\SV[S\$ RO[Wb WQV OcT RS` :ZcUVOTS\b]WZSbbS \]QV SW\[OZ R`vV\S\ Yv\\bS$ PSd]` WQV O\ 6]`R USVS& Nc a^sb eW`R [W` O\USaWQVba RSa HS`[W\OZa YZO`$ eOa Tw` SW\S VW`\dS`P`O\\bS =RSS ROa eO`& KW` VOZbS\ W[ 8`]^%CTT%6S`SWQV$ c\R WQV aSVS$ ROaa SW\S` RS` KOUS\ RW`SYb VW\bS` c\a Wab& =QV R`SVS RS\ ?]^T eSU$ OZa WQV OcaabSWUS c\R RS\ :OV`S` PShOVZS$ RS\ ROa ;SZR \WQVb hc W\bS`SaaWS`S\ aQVSW\b& ASW\ SW\hWUS` ;SRO\YS OcT RS[ KSU W\ ROa ;SPscRS Wab eO\\& KO\\ eS`RS\ aWS [W` OcT RWS GQVcZbS` bW^^S\ c\R [WQV OcTT]`RS`\$ [SW\S HOaQVS\ hc ZSS`S\ c\R [SW\ ;S^sQY hc vTT\S\4 6SW RS` 5PTS`bWUc\U4 8S` GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS4 5[ :ZcUabSWU4 9a aQVSW\b [W` c\[vUZWQV$ ROaa WQV PWa hc[ :ZcUabSWU Y][[S& DWZ]bS\ W\ I\WT]`[ USVS\ OcT RWS WV\S\ SWUS\S 5`b hc WV`S\ :ZwUS\& =QV abSZZS [W` WV`S c\PSaQVeS`bS\ :O[WZWS\ W\ RS\ VwPaQVS\$ OPS` \WQVb OZZhc e]VZVOPS\RS\ J]`]`bS\ d]\ 7]\\SQbWQcb$ BSe >S`aSg c\R BSe M]`Y d]`& =V`S GvV\S$ RWS YZSW\S A]RSZZTZcUhScUS POabSZ\ c\R RO[Wb O\USPS\$ ROaa aWS RWS UO\hS\ BO[S\ YS\\S\ x 7Saa\O$ DW^S` 7cP$ A]]\Sg$ /,/& =QV aSVS RWS HK5%I\WT]`[ c\R RWS AwbhS [SW\Sa JObS`a O\ RS[ OZb[]RWaQVS\ ?ZSWRS`abs\RS` W\ aSW\S[ NW[[S` Vs\US\ c\R eSWr \]QV$ eWS aQVv\ WQV RWS GOQVS\ TO\R$ OZa WQV jc\U eO`& 9` aOV eWS SW\ :WZ[abO` Oca W\ RS` USPwUSZbS\ Rc\YZS\ <]aS c\R RS\ USabs`YbS\ eSWrS\ <S[RS\& ASW\ JObS`& KWS Y]\\bS ROa ^OaaWS`S\$ Vv`S WQV WV\ T`OUS\$ eS\\ S` S`TOV`S\ e]ZZbS$ eOa VWS` OPUSVb& KWS Wab Sa ROhc USY][[S\$ KWZZWS4 J][ 5PTS`bWUc\UaaQVOZbS` hc` GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS Wab Sa \WQVb eSWb& =QV VOPS YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eOa WQV bc\ ]RS` e]VW\ WQV USVS\ a]ZZ& KS\\ aWS [WQV dS`VOTbS\ e]ZZS\$ eO`c[ VOPS\ aWS Sa \WQVb aQV]\ USbO\4 =QV a^WSZS [Wb RS[ ;SRO\YS\$ c[hcYSV`S\ c\R SW\ HOfW W\ RWS GbORb hc \SV[S\$ OPS` [W` Y][[S\ NeSWTSZ O\ [SW\S` KOV`\SV[c\U& 9a [caa O\ RS\ 8`]US\ ZWSUS\$ [caa DO`O\]WO aSW\& =QV PW\ SW\S hc YZSW\S Bc[[S` W[ U`]rS\ ;SaO[b^ZO\$ OZa ROaa [O\ [SW\SbeSUS\ SW\ <]bSZ wPS`eOQVS\ c\R SW\S\ H`c^^ >7 DS\\Sg%:WUc`S\ OcT [WQV O\aSbhS\ ew`RS& H`]bhRS[ [caa WQV ROa 7`OQY c\R RWS DTSWTS Z]aeS`RS\& =QV aSVS SW\S H]WZSbbS ZW\Ya d][ GWQVS`VSWbaPS`SWQV c\R USVS aQV\c`ab`OQYa VW\wPS`& 5Za WQV SW\b`SbS$ Wab aWS ZSS`& NeSW ?OPW\S\ c\R R`SW DWaaPSQYS\& =QV USVS hc SW\S` ?OPW\S W\ RS` 5PaWQVb$ RWS HwbS c\R RWS DTSWTS VW\c\bS`hca^wZS\$ OPS` OZa WQV R`W\ PW\ c\R RWS Hw` dS``WSUZS$ aSVS WQV$ ROaa ROa KOaaS` W[ ?Z] \c` `WSaSZb c\R O\aQVSW\S\R ]V\S I\bS`P`SQVc\U ZscTb& 8WS G^wZc\U Tc\YbW]\WS`b \WQVb& BSPS\O\ ROa ;ZSWQVS& =QV VOZbS Sa Tw` [vUZWQV$ ROaa aWS RWS G^wZc\US\

OcrS` 6Sb`WSP USaSbhb VOPS\$ RO[Wb WQV [SW\ NScU \WQVb dS`aQVeW\RS\ ZOaaS\ YO\\& =QV Y][[S [W` d]` eWS SW\ HWS` W\ RS` :OZZS& 8O\\ Vv`S WQV jS[O\RS\ SW\b`SbS\$ ZOaaS aQV\SZZ RWS <]aS `c\bS` c\R aSbhS [WQV OcTa 6SQYS\& AW\cbS\ dS`USVS\$ c\R WQV `wV`S [WQV YOc[& 9`ab dS`acQVS WQV$ YSW\S\ @Ocb d]\ [W` hc USPS\$ RO\\ eW`R [W` YZO`$ ROaa S` \Obw`ZWQV [SW\S :wrS aWSVb c\R Sa PSaaS` Wab$ eS\\ WQV [WQV \]`[OZ dS`VOZbS& 5Za [waabS WQV [OZ& 8S` RO `SW\USY][[S\ Wab$ USVb \WQVb$ c\R W\ [SW\S` DVO\bOaWS TwZZb aWQV RS` FOc[ ZOcbZ]a [Wb SW\S[ UO\hS\ 9W\aObhY][[O\R] Oca D]ZWhSW c\R :OV\RS`\ RS` FOcaQVUWTbPSVv`RS& 9a Wab [W` TOab c\[vUZWQV$ \WQVb c\bS` RS` ?Z]bw` Rc`QVhcUcQYS\$ ]P RO eW`YZWQV ROa PSTw`QVbSbS <SS` d]\ GQVcVS\ c\R GbWSTSZ\ ZOcS`b& 5PS` W`US\ReWS [vQVbS WQV R]QV ZWSPS` a] ZO\US Sa USVb W[ I\USeWaaS\ PZSWPS\& @W\Ya d]\ [W` Wab RS` H]WZSbbS\^O^WS`a^S\RS`$ c\R ZO\UaO[ `SWrS WQV SW\ ^OO` 6ZsbbS` d]\ RS` F]ZZS$ bcS a]$ OZa ]P WQV [WQV OPeWaQVS$ c\R USPS RWS ;S`scaQVS d]\ [W`$ RWS [O\ OcT RS[ ?Z] a] [OQVb& =`US\ReO\\ Y][[b [W` RO\\ W\ RS\ GW\\$ ROaa WQV \c` SW\S 7VO\QS VOPS2 =QV [caa RWS :W\US`OPR`wQYS d]\ RS` DTSWTS c\R RS` HwbS eWaQVS\$ H]WZSbbS\^O^WS` R`c[eWQYSZ\ c\R PSWRSa W[ ?c\abab]TTUSVscaS RSa G^S\RS`a dS`abSQYS\& :ZwQVbWU RS\YS WQV heO` RO`O\$ eS\WUabS\a ROa 7`OQY W\a ?Z] hc eS`TS\$ RO[Wb Sa aWQV W[ KOaaS` OcTZvab c\R RO\\ V]TTS\bZWQV `SabZ]a dS`aQVeW\RSb$ OPS` SbeOa W\ [W` VsZb [WQV ROd]\ OP3 WQV P`W\US Sa \WQVb wPS` [WQV$ [WbO\hcaSVS\$ eWS aWQV RS` Gb]TT W\ \WQVba OcTZvab& =QV [OZS [W` RWS c\bS`aQVWSRZWQVS\ Gb`OT[OrS Oca x [Wb 7`OQYPSaWbh hSV\ >OV`S <OTb$ \c` [Wb DTSWTS 6SesV`c\U4 H`]bhRS[ eWaQVS WQV a]e]VZ DTSWTS OZa OcQV HwbS OP$ eWQYZS a]`UTsZbWU PSWRSa W\ H]WZSbbS\^O^WS` c\R dS`abOcS Sa W[ G^S\RS`& 8Oa bcS WQV a] ZSWaS eWS [vUZWQV$ RO\\ hWSVS WQV [SW\S >SO\a V]QV$ aQV\OZZS RS\ ;w`bSZ hc c\R vTT\S RWS Hw` RS` ?OPW\S$ OZa es`S Sa Tw` [WQV RWS ZSbhbS GSYc\RS W\ :`SWVSWb& 5\ RS` KO\R \SPS\ RS[ 9W\UO\U abSVb SW\ :ZcUVOTS\%GWQVS`VSWbaPSO[bS`& 9` aWSVb [WQV RW`SYb O\$ OZa WQV hc[ KOaQVPSQYS\ USVS& I\R OZa WQV OcT RS[ KSU \OQV R`OcrS\ O\ WV[ d]`PSWY][[S$ b`Wbb S` OcT RWS ?OPW\S\ hc$ c\R c\aS`S 5`[S ab`SWTS\ aWQV ZSWQVb3 RO\\ PW\ WQV W\ RS` <OZZS$ ZOaaS RWS GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS ZW\Ya ZWSUS\ c\R USVS hc[ 5cThcU& =QV PS[wVS [WQV$ OcT RS` :OV`b \OQV c\bS\ hc` ;S^sQYOcTUOPS `cVWU hc PZSWPS\& :w` [WQV abSVb OcrS` :`OUS$ ROaa RS` GWQVS`VSWbaPSO[bS US`ORSeSUa hc RS[ H]WZSbbS\^O^WS`a^S\RS` USUO\US\ Wab& =QV R`SVS [WQV \WQVb c[$ R]QV WQV a^w`S RWS 6ZWQYS d]\ Vc\RS`b 7]^a c\R 8`]US\TOV\RS`\ OcT [W`$ OZa WQV O\ RS\ 8`SVY`SchS\ d]`PSW hc[ \sQVabS\ 5cThcU USVS& Fc\R heO\hWU AW\cbS\ ZOcTS WQV VS`c[$ SVS WQV hc` GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS hc`wQYYSV`S& =QV abSZZS [WQV O\ RWS H`S^^S$ RWS hc` heSWbS\ 9bOUS VW\OcTTwV`b$ c\R PS]POQVbS RWS ZO\US FSWVS d]\ H]c`WabS\$ ;SaQVsTbaZScbS\ c\R GbcRS\bS\$ RWS RO`OcT eO`bS\$ aWQV WV`S` ;w`bSZ c\R GQVcVS hc S\bZSRWUS\$ PSd]` aWS RWS ASbOZZRSbSYb]`S\ ^OaaWS`S\& =QV aSVS SW\S\ AO\\ [Wb U`OcS` <]aS$ 5Q`gZ^cZZ]dS` c\R SW\TOQVS\ GQVcVS\& 9a Wab SW\S` d]\ RS\ >7 DS\\Sg%Hg^S\ Oca RS` <]bSZZ]PPg$ c\R jSbhb abSVb S` VWS`$ SW\ ^OO` ASbS` S\bTS`\b$ c\R aWSVb [WQV d]ZZ O\& 8W`SYb VW\bS` WV[$ FWQVbc\U 5PTS`bWUc\UaaQVOZbS`$ Wab SW\S sZbS`S :`Oc$ RWS ZO\UaO[ SW\S\ F]ZZY]TTS` hWSVb c\R W\ SW\ <O\Rg a^`WQVb& AW` TsZZb OcT$ eWS \cZZ%OQVb%Tw\ThSV\ WV` ?]TTS`$ WV`S GQVcVS c\R WV`S >OQYS

<O\Rg a^`WQVb& AW` TsZZb OcT$ eWS \cZZ%OQVb%Tw\ThSV\ WV` ?]TTS`$ WV`S GQVcVS c\R WV`S >OQYS aW\R& =`US\ReWS S\ba^`WQVb ROa aSW\S[ 5cThcU& I\R eWS [O\ W\ RS` GYgZW\S SW\S` GbORb S`ab SW\S\ KOaaS`bc`[ Oca[OQVb c\R RO\\ aWS OZZS$ aSVS WQV W\ RS\ RO`OcTT]ZUS\RS\ AW\cbS\ hWU a]ZQVS` @ScbS& BWQVbaaOUS\R USYZSWRSbS$ Y]TTS`hWSVS\RS$ VO\RgPSeSV`bS N][PWSa [WbbZS`S\ 5ZbS`a$ RS`S\ c\a^]\bO\S 6SeSUc\US\ US\Oc OcT [SW\S OPUSabW[[b hc aSW\ aQVSW\S\& ;STwVZbS Gbc\RS\ ZOcTS WQV OcT RS[ :ZcUVOTS\ VS`c[$ SVS WQV [WQV Tw` RWS GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS O\abSZZS& Nc SW\WUS\ RS` @ScbS$ RWS WQV W\ JS`ROQVb VOPS$ VW\bS` [W` VS` hc aSW\$ eS`RS WQV T`SQV$ aSVS WV\S\ RW`SYb W\a ;SaWQVb c\R ZsQVZS$ aQVS`hS a]UO` USZSUS\bZWQV$ ROaa aWS RO SW\S c\RO\YPO`S 5cTUOPS VOPS\& BWS S`\bS WQV [SV` OZa SW\ PZvRSa ;`W\aS\ ]RS` SW\ 5cUS\`]ZZS\& =`US\ReO\\ Wab RWS 5\a^O\\c\U a] U`]r$ ROaa WQV [WQV \SPS\ RS[ 5cThcU W[ heSWbS\ Gb]QY aQV]\ d]\ RS` ;OZS`WS a^`W\US\ aSVS$ c[ RS` aWQVS`S\ JS`VOTbc\U hc S\bUSVS\& 5PS` ROa Wab YSW\S <vVS$ ROPSW YO\\ [O\ aWQV VvQVabS\a SW\ 6SW\ P`SQVS\ ]RS` heSW& G^sbS`$ Vc\RS[wRS d][ abc\RS\ZO\US\ DO\WYeO\RS`\ Rc`QV RS\ :ZcUVOTS\ c\R W[ T`SWS\ :OZZ \OQV PSW\OV SW\S` K]QVS 7`OQY$ eS\RS WQV [WQV aQVZWSrZWQV O\ SW\S\ RS` Hg^S\$ RS` SbeOa jw\US` Wab$ c\R T`OUS2 KO`c[ P`W\Ub WV` Sa \WQVb VW\bS` ScQV4$ e]`OcT S` ZSWaS ZOQVb c\R aOUb2 G^sbS`& KS\\ GWS S`ab e]O\RS`a aW\R$ [OQVbya dWSZ [SV` G^Or& KO`bS\ GWSya OP& =QV PW\ aWQVS`$ ROaa S` ROa aOUb& GSW\S K]`bS ZOaaS\ [WQV S`abO``S\$ RO\\ PSaQVZWSrS WQV$ [WQV S\RZWQV O\hcabSZZS\$ hWSVS GQVcVS c\R ;w`bSZ Oca c\R ^OaaWS`S RS\ ASbOZZRSbSYb]`& 5cT RWS O\RS`S GSWbS Y][[S WQV a] c\R a] \WQVb$ c\R W\heWaQVS\ PW\ WQV a] USPScbSZb$ ROaa WQVya SW\TOQV \c` \]QV VW\bS` [WQV P`W\US\ eWZZ& 5PS` WQV Y][[S Rc`QV& =QV Y][[S Rc`QV c\R S`ZSPS SW\ Yc`hhSWbWUSa$ d]`aWQVbWUSa <]QVUSTwVZ& JWSZZSWQVb Wab jO OZZSa \c` W\ [SW\S[ ?]^T& JWSZZSWQVb ZWSUb Sa \c` O\ RS\ 8`]US\$ RS`S\ UcbS KW`Yc\U UO\h dS`TZ]US\ Wab3 RWS SW\S\ YO^cbbS\ ?v`^S` c\R SW\S\ Tw` KOV\WRSS\ O\TsZZWUS\ ;SWab hc`wQYUSZOaaS\ VOPS\& =QV aQVOTTS Sa hc[ :ZcUabSWU$ c\R R]`b USVb [O\ aQV]\ O\ 6]`R& =QV hvUS`S [SV`[OZa$ OZa WQV W\ RS` KO`bSh]\S O[ ;ObS SW\ ^OO` d]\ RS\ >7 DS\\Sga VS`c[ZOcTS\ aSVS& 8WS K]`bS RSa jc\US\ DS\\Sga YZW\US\ [W` W[ ?]^T$ OPS` WQV P`OcQVS c\PSRW\Ub SW\S\ K]RYO c\R VOPS OcrS`RS[ T`SW S`VsZbZWQVS GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\ W\ [SW\S` FSWaSbOaQVS& KS\\ WQV [WQV S`ab[OZ W\ RWS RWQYS\ D]ZabS` TOZZS\ ZOaaS\ c\R [WQV OcaPZS\RS\ YO\\$ USVbya [W` eWSRS` Ucb& KS\\ WQV \c` O\ 6]`R Y][[S c\R eSU d]\ RWSaS\ 8c[^TPOQYS\$ USVbya [W` eWSRS` Ucb& 5Za] [O`aQVWS`S WQV hc[ 7VSQY% W\$ hSWUS [SW\S 6]`RYO`bS d]` c\R abSWUS SW\& ASW\ DZObh ZWSUb O[ ;O\U$ heSWbS FSWVS `SQVba& B]QV \WS VOb SbeOa a] SW\ZORS\R OcaUSaSVS\& =QV aSbhS [WQV VW\ c\R a^w`S POZR$ eWS RWS aQV`SQYZWQVS DO\WY RS` ZSbhbS\ heSWSW\VOZP Gbc\RS\ \OQVZsaab& =QV Ob[S Rc`QV c\R aSVS hc[ :S\abS` VW\Oca OcT RWS F]ZZPOV\ c\R ROa 6]RS\^S`a]\OZ$ ROa ;S^sQY dS`ZsRb& >Sbhb S`ab eW`R [W` YZO`$ ROaa RS` ?]TTS`$ RS\ WQV USabS`\ OcTUSUSPS\ VOPS$ [Wb RS` TOZaQVS\ AOaQVW\S OPUSUO\US\ Wab& 8WS

?]TTS`$ RS\ WQV USabS`\ OcTUSUSPS\ VOPS$ [Wb RS` TOZaQVS\ AOaQVW\S OPUSUO\US\ Wab& 8WS G]`US c[ dS`Z]`S\USUO\US\Sa ;S^sQY [cbSb [WQV OPS` eWS SW\ @cfca^`]PZS[ O\$ c\R WQV \SV[S [W` d]`$ [W` S`ab ;SRO\YS\ RO`wPS` hc [OQVS\$ eS\\ WQV W\ 6S`ZW\ PW\& =QV dS`abOcS [SW\S FSWaSbOaQVS c\bS` RS[ GWbh$ ZSV\S [WQV hc`wQY c\R aQVZWSrS Tw` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ RWS 5cUS\& 9\RZWQV OcrS` ;STOV`$ RS\YS WQV& I\R RO\\$ OZa WQV [WQV \OQV SW\S` GbSeO`RSaa c[aQVOcS$ dS`aQVZsUb Sa [W` RS\ 5bS[& =QV aSVS aWS x RWS DS\\Sga& 9W\a$ heSW$ R`SW$ dWS`$ [W\RSabS\a Tw\T d]\ WV\S\ aWbhS\ W\ RS` 9`abS\ ?ZOaaS dS`bSWZb& ;S\Oc W\ RWSaS[ 5cUS\PZWQY PScUb aWQV SW\S GbSeO`RSaa hc SW\S[ d]\ WV\S\ VW\c\bS` c\R aOUb WV[ ZSWaS SbeOa& NeSWTSZZ]a USVb Sa c[ [WQV& I[ [SW\S JS`VOTbc\U W\ 5[abS`RO[ ]RS` 6S`ZW\& KS\\ \WQVb UZSWQV VWS`& ;ZSWQV jSbhb& 8S` UO\hS DOaaOUWS``Oc[ Y][[b [W` ^ZvbhZWQV eWS SW\S ?cZWaaS d]`$ eWS SW\ OcaUSTSWZbSa 6wV\S\PWZR$ ROa RWS 9`abS ?ZOaaS SW\Sa :ZcUhScUa RO`abSZZS\ a]ZZ& 8WS Rw\\S\ GS`dWSbbS\ aW\R \OQVUS[OQVb$ RWS GbSeO`RSaaS\ GQVOca^WSZS`W\\S\ c\R RWS DS\\Sga 5\R`]WRS\ x VOZP AS\aQV$ VOZP F]P]bS`$ USTwVZZ]a c\R USTsV`ZWQV& 9W\S RS` GbSeO`RSaaS\ Wab ^ZvbhZWQV \SPS\ [W`& GWS T`OUb W\ SW\S[ H]\$ RS` [W` a^vbbWaQV c\R c\OcT`WQVbWU YZW\Ub$ ]P WQV SbeOa b`W\YS\ [vQVbS& 8WS DS\\Sga [OQVS\ [W` 5\Uab$ OPS` aWS `SUb [WQV OcT& `US`b [WQV& =QV T`OUS aWS$ ]P RWS AOaQVW\S eW`YZWQV W\ 5[abS`RO[ ZO\RSb& GWS UcQYb heO` dS`eW``b$ OPS` \WQVb a] dS`eW``b$ eWS aWS [SW\S` ASW\c\U \OQV a]ZZbS$ OZa] T`OUS WQV2 :W\RS\ GWS \WQVb$ ROaa ROa VWS` SW\ `SWQVZWQV Y][^ZWhWS`bSa HVSObS` Wab eSUS\ SW\S` SW\hWUS\ DS`a]\4 GWS aWSVb [WQV SW\ ^OO` GSYc\RS\ O\$ S\baQVcZRWUb aWQV c\R USVb ROd]\& KS\WU a^sbS` Y][[b aWS [Wb RS[ ?O^Wbs\ eWSRS`$ RS` [WQV VvTZWQV OcTT]`RS`b$ [SW\S GOQVS\ hc \SV[S\ c\R WV[ Oca RS[ :ZcUhScU hc T]ZUS\& =QV PW\ eWS USZsV[b& I\R ]Pe]VZ WQV eSWr$ ROaa RWSa RWS ZO\US`eO`bSbS :Sab\OV[S Wab$ RWS O\abSVb$ aSWb WQV O[ <]bSZ W\ ROa HOfW USabWSUS\ PW\$ PW\ WQV S`ZSWQVbS`b$ OZa [W` RS` ?O^Wbs\ RWS <O\R OcT RWS GQVcZbS` ZSUb c\R aOUb2 ;SVS\ eW`& KWS SW\ USaQV]ZbS\Sa ?W\R U`SWTS WQV c\bS` RS\ 5cUS\ as[bZWQVS` DOaaOUWS`S \OQV [SW\S` HOaQVS c\R T]ZUS WV[ Oca RS` AOaQVW\S& 5PS` dS`VOTbSb eS`RS WQV \WQVb& GbObbRSaaS\ S`YZs`b [W` RS` ?O^Wbs\$ ROaa aWS aSWb RS[ 5\aQVZOU OcT ROa K]`ZR H`ORS 7S\bS` d]`aWQVbWU aSW\ [waaS\ c\R ROaa WQV RWS GbSeO`RSaa [Wb [SW\S` crS`c\U a] PSc\`cVWUb VObbS$ ROaa WV\S\ PSW RS[ ;SRO\YS\$ [WQV O\ 6]`R hc VOPS\$ \WQVb UO\h e]VZ Wab& GSW\S >OQYS [Wb RS[ ^aScR][WZWbs`WaQVS\ ?ZW[PW[ x Gb`SWTS\$ GQVcZbS`YZO^^S\ x TsZZb [W` OcT& KWS OZZSa W\ RS` AOaQVW\S aWSVb aSW\S I\WT]`[ \OQV 5bb`O^^S Oca$ aQVsPWUS`$ OZa WQV RWS [SW\Sa JObS`a W\ 9`W\\S`c\U VOPS3 SW\ TORS\aQVSW\WUSa$ aQV\SZZ hcaO[[S\USYZObaQVbSa ?]abw[& 9` T`OUb [WQV$ ]P WQV USb`c\YS\ VOPS$ c\R WQV aOUS jO$ d]` RS[ :ZWSUS\ ew`RS WQV W[[S` \S`dva$ RSaVOZP VsbbS WQV hc` 6S`cVWUc\U SbeOa 5ZY]V]Z hc [W` US\][[S\& KWS WQV RWSaS ;SRO\YS\ c\R K]`bS O`bWYcZWS`S$ eSWr WQV aSZPS` \WQVb& =QV S\baQVcZRWUS [WQV ROTw`$ ROaa WQV RWS GbSeO`RSaa PSc\`cVWUb VOPS$ c\R OZa WQV US`ORS eWSRS` hc` GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS USVS\ eWZZ$ S`aQVSW\b

SW\ AO\\ W\ eSWrS[ <S[R [Wb SW\S[ C`R\S` d]ZZS` DO^WS`S& 9` abSZZb aWQV OZa 6Sb`WSPaZSWbS` d]\ 7]\bW\S\bOZ W\ BSeO`Y d]`$ S\baQVcZRWUb aWQV c[USVS\R PSW [W` Tw` ROa AWaadS`abs\R\Wa c\R PWbbSb RS\ ?O^Wbs\$ aSW\S 9\baQVSWRc\U hc wPS`RS\YS\& 5ca W`US\RSW\S[ ;`c\R eWZZ RS` AO\\ ]TTS\PO` eW`YZWQV$ ROaa WQV [WbTZWSUS& 8S` ?O^Wbs\ aOUb VvTZWQV \SW\ c\R eW`R aWQVbZWQV c\USVOZbS\$ OZa RS` 6Sb`WSPaZSWbS` eSWbS` W\ WV\ R`W\Ub& =QV PW\ UO\h abWZZ$ esV`S\R aWQV ROa OPa^WSZb& GQVZWSrZWQV UWPb RS` 6Sb`WSPaZSWbS` OcT$ c\R RS` ?O^Wbs\ ew\aQVb [W` OZZSa ;cbS c\R [OQVb aWQV eWSRS` OcT RS\ KSU hc[ 7]QY^Wb& =QV aSVS$ eWS S` W[ 8c`QVUO\U dS`aQVeW\RSb$ c\R [caa ^ZvbhZWQV O\ [WQV VOZbS\$ RO[Wb WQV \WQVb VW\bS` WV[ VS` `cTS& =QV VOPS heO` YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eOa WQV WV[ aOUS\ a]ZZbS$ OPS` a]POZR S` eSU Wab$ ew\aQVS WQV [W`$ S` Ys[S hc`wQY& 8S` 6Sb`WSPaZSWbS` PWbbSb c[ [SW\S 6]`RYO`bS c\R S\baQVcZRWUb aWQV W[[S` \]QV& =QV aOUS WV[$ Sa aSW \WQVb aQVZW[[$ WQV ew`RS SW\TOQV \OQV <OcaS TOV`S\ c\R []`US\ TZWSUS\& ?][[b \WQVb W\ :`OUS$ aOUb S`$ S` aSbhb [WQV VScbS 5PS\R \]QV W\ SW\S\ :ZWSUS`& 9` USVb SW\ ^OO` GQV`WbbS eSU$ [OQVb OcrS` <v`eSWbS SW\ ^OO` 5\`cTS OcT aSW\S[ <O\Rg$ Y][[b hc`wQY c\R aOUb$ S` VOb [WQV 9`abS` ?ZOaaS Tw` SW\S\ 5W`%:`O\QS%:ZcU USPcQVb$ RS` wPS` DO`Wa \OQV 6S`ZW\ USVb& 9a Wab OZZSa US`SUSZb$ RS` :ZcU USVb W\ SW\S` 8`SWdWS`bSZabc\RS d]\ SW\S[ \OVS\ :ZcUabSWU& B]QV SW\ AS\aQV [Wb C`R\S`\ S`aQVSW\b& 8WS PSWRS\ USZSWbS\ [WQV hc SW\S[ 5W`%:`O\QS%GQVOZbS`$ e] WQV SW\ HWQYSb S`VOZbS$ c\R RO\\ hc[ ;ObS& =QV PW\ \]QV YSW\S hSV\ AW\cbS\ R]`b$ aQV]\ YO\\ [O\ O\ 6]`R USVS\& 8Oa VOb aWQV jSbhb OZZSa a] aQV\SZZ S\beWQYSZb$ ROaa WQV YOc[ \]QV [WbY][[S& 5PS` ROa abO`YS ;STwVZ$ ROaa W`US\ReS` x \WQVb PZ]r RS` 6Sb`WSPaZSWbS` RS` 7]\bW\S\bOZ x$ RO`O\ W\bS`SaaWS`b Wab$ ROaa WQV VScbS 5PS\R TZWSUS$ PZSWPb& I\R RO\\ aSVS WQV aWS& 8`SW DS\\Sga abSVS\ \WQVb eSWb d][ ;ObS& HWQYSba W\ RS` <O\R$ abSQYS\ aWS RWS ?v^TS hcaO[[S\ c\R ZW\aS\ W\ [SW\S FWQVbc\U eWS RWS HV`SS Gb]]USa RS` G^W]\OUS W[ VsaaZWQVS\ ;SeO\R& NcS`ab PW\ WQV ewbS\R& 8O\\ R`vV\S\ [W` RWS ZSbhbS\ K]`bS RSa >c\U^S\\Sga Rc`QV RS\ ?]^T& KO`bS\ GWSya OP& =\ RS` \sQVabS\ JWS`bSZabc\RS USVS\ W[[S` [SV` @ScbS O\ 6]`R$ PWa RWS KO`bSh]\S O[ ;ObS \OVShc ZSS` Wab& 9W\ ^OO` BOQVhwUZS` Y][[S\ \]QV O\$ SbZWQVS ZOcTS\ [Wb WV`S` 6]`RYO`bS hc` HWQYSbY]\b`]ZZS$ T`]V$ ROaa aWS RS\ :ZcU \WQVb dS`^Oaab VOPS\& GQVZWSrZWQV aW\R \c` \]QV RWS R`SW DS\\Sga c\R WQV RO& 8WS ?]\b`]ZZSc`W\ a^`WQVb [Wb WV\S\& GWS PZSWPS\ O[ GQVOZbS`$ USVS\ OPS` \WQVb O\ 6]`R& 9W\S O\RS`S ?]\b`]ZZSc`W\ Y][[b hc [W`$ T`OUb$ ]P WQV SW\ HWQYSb Tw` RS\ :ZcU VOPS$ c\R aOUb [W`$ ROaa Sa RS` ZSbhbS 5cT`cT Tw` RS\ :ZcU Wab& =QV S`hsVZS WV`$ ROaa WQV hc DO\WYObbOQYS\ \SWUS c\R \]QV \WQVb eSWr$ ]P WQV VScbS 5PS\R TZWSUS& =QV T`OUS$ ]P OZZS O\ 6]`R aW\R$ c\R aWS RScbSb OcT RWS DS\\Sga c\R aOUb$ \WQVb OZZS$ OPS` RWS [SWabS\ DOaaOUWS`S aQV]\& KWS hcd]` VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ d]` SW\S` c\S`Vv`b eWQVbWUS\ 9\baQVSWRc\U hc abSVS\& :ZWSUS WQV$ eS`RS WQV dWSZZSWQVb W\ DO`Wa ]RS` 6S`ZW\

eWQVbWUS\ 9\baQVSWRc\U hc abSVS\& :ZWSUS WQV$ eS`RS WQV dWSZZSWQVb W\ DO`Wa ]RS` 6S`ZW\ dS`VOTbSb& 6ZSWPS WQV$ eS`RS WQV dWSZZSWQVb VWS` dS`VOTbSb& :ZWSUS WQV c\R eS`RS \WQVb dS`VOTbSb$ Y][[b \OQV SW\ ^OO` `c^^WUS\ HOUS\ [Wb B]OV dWSZZSWQVb OZZSa eWSRS` W\ C`R\c\U& 6ZSWPS WQV VWS` c\R eS`RS W`US\ReWS R]QV \WQVb dS`VOTbSb$ PZSWPS WQV OcT 8`]US& 8Oa Wab [W` YZO`& 5Za] abSVS WQV OcT$ USVS d][ ;ObS eSU c\R `SQV\S RO[Wb$ dS`VOTbSb hc eS`RS\& 5Za WQV [WQV Yc`h c[R`SVS$ ZOcTS\ heSW d]\ RS\ DS\\Sga US`ORS OcT RWS GSWbS$ c[ hc aSVS\$ ]P WQV hc`wQY hc` GWQVS`VSWbaY]\b`]ZZS USVS& CV\S [WQV \]QV SW\[OZ c[hcR`SVS\$ VOZbS WQV OcT RWS ;S^sQYOcaUOPS hc& =QV eSWr$ ROaa WQV \WQVb PWa hc[ HOfWabO\R Y][[S& DS\\Sga$ D]ZWhSW$ RWS :ZcUVOTS\aWQVS`VSWb c\R ;]bb eSWr eS` \]QV eS`RS\ wPS` [WQV VS`TOZZS\& 8WS ZSbhbS\ NSWZS\ SW\Sa F][O\a$ RS\ WQV d]` >OV`S\ dS`[WbbSZb VOPS$ Y][[S\ [WbbS\ W\ RS` DO\WY V]QV& 9a eO` a]eSWb$ ZOcbSbS\ aWS$ 9a eO` a]eSWb& =QV Y`O[S [SW\ <O\Rg VS`d]` c\R aSVS$ ROaa RWS 5YYcO\hSWUS \c` \]QV SW\S\ 6OZYS\ VOb c\R `]b PZW\Yb& =QV `cTS 8OdWR O\& 9a Wab \OQV SZT$ c\R aSW\S :`Oc GcaWS \W[[b OP& =QV PWbbS c[ 9\baQVcZRWUc\U c\R T`OUS aWS$ ]P 8OdWR RO Wab$ Sa aSW eWQVbWU& GWS aW\R ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV aQV]\ W[ 6Sbb& 9` [SZRSb aWQV c\R T`OUb$ eOa Z]a Wab& =QV aOUS WV[$ ROaa WQV OcT RS[ :ZcUVOTS\ BSeO`Y eSUS\ 8`]US\ dS`VOTbSb eS`RS\ a]ZZ c\R ROaa S` [W` SW\S\ UcbS\ 5\eOZb PSa]`US\ [caa& KOV`aQVSW\ZWQV aQV`SWS WQV$ OZa WQV WV[ aOUS$ S` a]ZZ aQV\SZZ [OQVS\$ RS\\ S` aOUb ^aQVb c\R [SW\b$ WQV a]ZZS [WQV PS`cVWUS\& 9` T`OUb$ e] WQV OcT RS[ :ZcUVOTS\ PW\$ c\R WQV aOUS$ OcT RS[ KSU d][ 5PTZcUaUObS hc` ;S^sQYOcaUOPS& 9` aOUb [W`$ WQV a]ZZS O[ 5^^O`Ob PZSWPS\$ [W` SW\ HOfW \SV[S\ c\R \OQV <OcaS Y][[S\& =QV S`YZs`S WV[$ ROaa WQV Sa \WQVb PWa hc RS\ HOfWa aQVOTTS\ eS`RS$ c\R RO\\ USVb RWS JS`PW\Rc\U eSU& 8S` 5YYc Wab ZSS`& =QV USVS eSWbS`& BWS[O\R VsZb [WQV OcT& =QV USVS Rc`QV RWS 5PTZcUVOZZS hc` ;S^sQYOcaUOPS& J]\ RS\ DS\\Sga Wab OcT SW\[OZ \WQVba [SV` hc aSVS\& =QV PW\ wPS`hScUb$ ROaa aWS ]PS\ Oca RS[ :ZcUVOTS\USPscRS `Oca aW\R c\R [WQV PSW RS\ HOfWa S`eO`bS\& =QV \SV[S RS\ 5caUO\U O\ RS` ;S^sQYOcaUOPS c\R USVS wPS` RWS Gb`OrS hc[ HOfWabO\R& 9W\ HOfW VsZb& =QV abSWUS SW\& 8S` :OV`S` T`OUb$ e]VW\& =QV aOUS$ C\S :WTbV 5dS\cS W\ AO\VObbO\3 eSWZ WQV OPS` RO[Wb `SQV\S$ ROaa [O\ c\a \]QV OcT RS[ :ZcUVOTS\USZs\RS O\VsZb$ TwUS WQV VW\hc$ Sa ew`RS SW\S Yc`hS :OV`b& 8S` :OV`S` P`c[[SZb SbeOa c\R TsV`b Z]a& =QV aQVOcS OcT aSW\S\ :OV`S`OcaeSWa$ c\R ROa c\dS`RSQYbS :]b] hSWUb eW`YZWQV RS\ U`OcVOO`WUS\$ Ps`bWUS\ =\RS`$ RS` O[ GbScS` aWbhb& =QV aQVeSPS W[ GQV]QYhcabO\R& >SRS GSYc\RS$ RWS dS`USVb$ jSRS` ASbS`$ RS\ ROa HOfW ]V\S GW`S\S\% c\R 6ZOcZWQVb%I\bS`[OZc\U hc`wQYZSUb$ S`aQVSW\b [W` eWS SW\ Kc\RS`& 8O\\ Y][[b [W` RS` ;SRO\YS$ ROaa RWS UO\hS H`c^^S eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV SW\TOQV d]` RS` K]V\c\U OcT [WQV eO`bSb& =QV T`OUS RS\ :OV`S`$ ]P WQV [OZ aSW\ <O\Rg PS\cbhS\ RO`T& 9` `SWQVb Sa [W` \OQV VW\bS\$ c\R WQV `cTS S`\Scb 8OdWR O\& =QV PW\ W[ HOfW$ aOUS WQV$ OPS` WQV eSWr \WQVb$ ]P eW` PWa hc[ <Oca Y][[S\& 9` aOUb$ S` eO`bSb W\ RS` @]PPg OcT [WQV c\R WQV a]ZZ [WQV PS`cVWUS\& 8Oa ew`RS WQV OcQV US`\S$ OZa eW` OcT RS\ Hc\\SZ FWQVbc\U GbORb hc`]ZZS\& =QV YO\\ UO` \WQVb UZOcPS\$ ROaa eW` a] eSWb USY][[S\ aW\R& =QV aSVS ROa

hc`]ZZS\& =QV YO\\ UO` \WQVb UZOcPS\$ ROaa eW` a] eSWb USY][[S\ aW\R& =QV aSVS ROa 5cTUSP]b O\ Gb`SWTS\eOUS\ c\R NWdWZTOV`hScUS\ RS` FOcaQVUWTbPSVv`RS d]` [W`$ eWS aWS C\S :WTbV c[abSZZS\$ hcQYS\RS @WQVbS` c\R RWS S`aQV`]QYS\S BScUWS` W\ RS\ ;SaWQVbS`\ RS` 6Se]V\S`& 8OPSW T`OUS WQV [WQV$ ]P H`Sd]`$ [SW\ @WSPZW\Ua^Tv`b\S`$ VScbS 5PS\R 8WS\ab VOb c\R eOa S` e]VZ RS\Yb$ eS\\ WQV W\ <O\RaQVSZZS\ OPUSTwV`b eS`RS& 5PS` Sa UWPb YSW\ 5cTUSP]b& Bc` 8OdWR eO`bSb [Wb hS`ewVZbS\ <OO`S\ W\ SW\S\ AO\bSZ USaQV\w`b W\ RS` @]PPg& 9` aWSVb S`aQVv^Tb c\R O\USascS`b Oca c\R aOUb$ S` PZSWPb wPS` BOQVb& 5[ A]`US\ USVS\ eW` T`wVabwQYS\$ c\R S` T`OUb$ W\ eSZQVS 9\bhWSVc\UaYZW\WY S` [WQV P`W\US\ a]ZZ$ OPS` b`]bh RS` U`W[[WUS\ 6Sa]`U\Wa W\ aSW\S[ ;SaWQVb O\be]`bS WQV2 =\ UO` YSW\S& KW` aWbhS\ OcT <]QYS`\ O[ d]`RS`S\ :S\abS` RSa AO`_cSb$ c\R RS` HOU c\R RWS @ScbS R`OcrS\ ab`OVZS\ c[ RWS KSbbS& KOa Tw` SW\S ;ZWbhS`eSZb$ RS\YS WQV$ US[OQVb Tw` RWS 8OdWRa c\R B]OVa$ Tw` @ScbS$ RS`S\ @SPS\ WQV \c` OZa [OYSZZ]a c\R UZwQYZWQV O\aSVS\ YO\\& 9W\ C`b$ RS\ WQV PSacQVS\ Rc`TbS$ O\ RS[ WQV OPS` \WQVb PZSWPS\ YO\\& 8S\ WQV PS`SWba dS`ZOaaS\ VOPS& 8OdWR a^OhWS`b Oca RS[ FSabOc`O\b c\R R`SVb aWQV \WQVb c[& 5\ aSW\S ZSbhbS\ K]`bS YO\\ WQV [WQV \WQVb S`W\\S`\$ OPS` aWS eO`S\ Yc`h$ YZO` c\R b`Oc`WU&

I\bS` ?]\b`]ZZS
9` Wab hSV\& 5PS\RSaaS\ahSWb& 9` Wab SbeOa OcTUS`SUbS` OZa a]\ab$ eSWZ S` aSW\S\ :`Sc\R ?S\\g RO VOb c\R aSW\ C\YSZ HSRRg Oca GO\ 8WSU] Tw` SW\ ^OO` HOUS hc 6SacQV Wab& C\YSZ HSRRg YO\\ S` Ucb ZSWRS\& 8S` VOb SW\S\ D]]Z$ T`OUb dWSZ \OQV RS` GQVcZS c\R USVv`b hc RS\ eS\WUS\ @ScbS\$ RWS aSW\S\ JObS` hc[ @OQVS\ P`W\US\$ WV\ OcTVSWbS`\ Yv\\S\& GSW\S AcbbS` [OQVb <O[Pc`US`aOcQS x [Wb 7VO[^WU\]\Q`S[Sac^^S c\R NeWSPSZac^^S USab`SQYbSa FW\RS`VOQY$ ROa hc ?SYaS\$ FSWa ]RS` ?O`b]TTSZ^w`SS USUSaaS\ eW`R& JWSZZSWQVb [OQVb aWS OcQV FOV[VsV\QVS\& ;ZSWQVSa D`W\hW^ eWS RWS <O[Pc`US`aOcQS$ \c` [Wb SW\S[ 6ScbSZ HWSTYwVZUS[waS x 9`PaS\$ AvV`S\$ DS`ZheWSPSZ\& 8Oa aW\R a] WV`S ;S`WQVbS$ RWS aWS hc <OcaS W\ M]c\Uab]e\$ CVW]$ Y]QVS\ USZS`\b VOb$ OZa \OQV RS[ H]R WV`Sa JObS`a ROa ;SZR Y\O^^ eO`$ c\R RWS aWS OcQV USY]QVb VOb$ OZa aWS GbSeO`RSaa eO` c\R [Wb dWS` NW[[S`US\]aaW\\S\ W\ EcSS\a e]V\bS& =V[ aQV[SQYS\ RWSaS GOQVS\3 S` Waab aWS$ OZa PSYs[S S` \WS US\cU ROd]\$ c\R \W[[b aWQV [SV` OZa SW\[OZ BOQVaQVZOU& :w` aSW\S\ JObS` Wab Sa GQVeSW\ST`Or& <ScbS 5PS\R aOUb S`$ S` TOaab Sa \WQVb$ ROaa aWS aSW\S[ 6`cRS` a] SW\S\ GQVSWr d]`aSbhS\ e]ZZbS& KS\\ S` heWaQVS\ aSW\S\ FSWaS\ hc <OcaS Wab$ Y]QVb S` [SWab SbeOa O\RS`Sa x :WaQV d][ ;`WZZ ]RS` USY]QVbS\ <c[[S` x$ c\R jSbhb bcb S` ROa OcQV& =\ RS` ?wQVS Wab 6Sb`WSP& GSW\S AcbbS` ecaSZb O[ <S`R VS`c[& GSW\S sZbS`S GQVeSabS` ?W[ RSQYb RS\ HWaQV$ c\R aSW\S jw\US`S\ ;SaQVeWabS` GSO\ c\R @WaO aSVS\ \SPS\O\ TS`\& 8Oa U`]rS ?`WabOZZUZOa aSW\Sa JObS`a Wab d]ZZ [Wb GQ]bQV$ c\R aSW\ C\YSZ HSRRg VOb SW\S :ZOaQVS 6WS` W\ RS` <O\R& 8WS >c\US\ [OQVS\ aWQV wPS` RWS <c[[S` W[ G^wZPSQYS\ ZcabWU$ S`TW\RS\ BO[S\ Tw` aWS c\R Y][[S\bWS`S\ WV`S ?`cabS\bWS`PSeSUc\US\ eWS G^]`b`S^]`bS` SW\S\ GV]e% FW\UYO[^T& ?S\\g \S\\b RS\ ?ZSW\abS\ AO[O%DSb$ ROa Wab WV` G^Wbh\O[S Tw` ?W[$ c\R aWS YWQVS`\ VSTbWU$ OZa RWS U`vrS`S\ <c[[S` wPS` RS\ YZSW\S\ VW\eSUYZSbbS`\& CV \SSSWWW\ z AO[O%DSb ?S\\g eS\RSb aWQV ?W[ hc$ RWS \ScSa 6SabSQY OcT RS\ 9aabWaQV ZSUb$ c\R aOUb2 @OcT$ AO[O%DSb 8WS hS`_cSbaQVS\ RWQV& @OcT 8WS PSWRS\ >c\US\ Yv\\S\ d]` @OQVS\ YOc[ `SRS\& 8Oa USVb a] eSWbS`$ PWa ?W[ aWQV SW\ 6cQV aQV\O^^b c\R [Wb SW\S[ []`RaewbS\RS\ =V` Yv\\b [WQV [OZ VW\Ocaabw`[b& 8O`wPS` ZOQVS\ aWS aWQV aQVeW\RZWU& C\YSZ HSRRg ZOQVb OcQV c\R aOUb WV\S\ ZSWaS$ aWS aSWS\ c\[vUZWQV$ VOb OPS` ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV G^Or RO`O\& 8Oa 9aaS\ eW`R aS`dWS`b$ c\R aSW\ JObS` aQVeSWUb& HSRRg Wab heO` jw\US`$ OPS` 5crS\abSVS\RS ew`RS\ WV\ Tw` ROa CPS`VOc^b RS` :O[WZWS VOZbS\$ RS\ ZbSabS\ RS` aWSPS\ ;SaQVeWabS`$ RS\ 5\TwV`S`& JWSZZSWQVb TsZZb Sa WV[ RSaVOZP ZSWQVbS`$ PSW[ 9aaS\ [OZ SbeOa hc aOUS\& 8Oa c\PSaQVeS`bS @OQVS\ W\ RS` ?wQVS c\R HSRRga Ucb[wbWUSa 9W\dS`abs\R\Wa

hc aOUS\& 8Oa c\PSaQVeS`bS @OQVS\ W\ RS` ?wQVS c\R HSRRga Ucb[wbWUSa 9W\dS`abs\R\Wa USPS\ WV[ US\Oc ROa GSZPabdS`b`OcS\$ ROa S` P`OcQVb$ c[ RS\ Ac\R OcThc[OQVS\& 9` S`hsVZb HSRRg d]\ aSW\S` :crPOZZ[O\\aQVOTb& 8Oaa aWS W\ RWS c[ZWSUS\RS\ GbsRbS TOV`S\$ ROaa S` VOZP`SQVba a^WSZb$ [O\QV[OZ OcQV AWbbSZabw`[S`& 9` S`hsVZb WV[ d]\ >]S$ RS[ aQVeS`abS\ >c\US\ W\ RS` ?ZOaaS$ RS` OcQV SW\S` RS` aQV\SZZabS\ Wab c\R$ ]Pe]VZ S` W\ RS` 8STS\aWdS a^WSZb$ RWS [SWabS\ H]`S aQVWSrb& GSW\ JObS` Vv`b aWQV ROa aQVeSWUS\R O\$ abSVb OPS` SW\ ^OO`[OZ OcT c\R USVb W\ RWS ?wQVS$ c[ aWQV \OQVhcaQVS\YS\& ?S\\g `SRSb wPS` WV`S\ ?ZOaaS\YO[S`ORS\ 8S\\Wa$ RS` WV[ hcT]ZUS \WS[OZa PORSb c\R W\ SW\S[ <Oca ]V\S TZWSrS\RSa KOaaS` ZSPb& 8S\\Wa VOb SW\ Vs\US\RSa 5cUS\ZWR$ ROa aSW\ ZW\YSa 5cUS VOZP dS`RSQYb$ OcQV eS\\ Sa ]TTS\ Wab$ c\R ?S\\g S`YZs`b$ ROa aSW RO`OcT hc`wQYhcTwV`S\$ ROaa S` OZa 6OPg c\bS`S`\sV`b eO`& GSW\S :O[WZWS aSW a] O`[$ ROaa aWS WV[ \WQVb VW\`SWQVS\R VOPS hc SaaS\ USPS\ Yv\\S\& GSW\S AcbbS` aOUb SbeOa BSbbSa wPS` ?S\\ga :O[WZWS& ?W[ aOUb ?S\\g$ S` a]ZZS RS\ GQV\OPSZ VOZbS\& 8WS >c\US\ ^ZO^^S`\ eSWbS` x wPS` RWS GQVcZS$ ?S\\ga GQVeSabS`\$ eS` eSWr eOa x c\R HSRRg Vv`b PSWRS\ USRcZRWU hc c\R ZOQVb aSW\ aQV\SZZSa$ OPUSVOQYbSa @OQVS\$ ROa aWS \c` eSWbS` O\abOQVSZb& @WaO a^WSZb [Wb WV`S[ 9aaS\$ c\R GSO\ aWbhb OcT RS[ ?W\RS`abcVZ& J]\ eSWbS[ aSVS\ aWS Oca eWS jSRS O\RS`S :O[WZWS& J]\ eSWbS[ aWSVb S` Oca eWS jSRS` O\RS`S >c\US& 8S` [Wb aSW\S[ :`Sc\R hcaO[[S\ ZOQVb& qPS` :crPOZZ `SRSb& ?]`RV]aS c\R F]ZZW b`sUb eWS OZZS >c\Ua W\ aSW\S[ 5ZbS`& 5cQV PSW US\OcS[ <W\aQVOcS\ ew`RS [O\ RS[ >c\US\ \WQVb O\aSVS\$ ROaa S` OPS\Ra PSbSb$ \WQVb [SV` OcThceOQVS\& 9` aOUb SbeOa$ SbeOa W\heWaQVS\ Zs\Uab JS`USaaS\Sa$ c\R RO S`U`SWTb RO\\ aSW\ JObS` ROa K]`b c\R aOUb2 5QV jO$ KWZZWS$ Wab ROa a]4 8O[Wb U`SWTb S` ROa ;SaOUbS O\$ ]P Sa \c\ c[ :crPOZZ$ 8S\\Wa ]RS` RWS GQVcZS UW\U ]RS` c[ RWS A]bbS\$ RWS eWS dS``wQYb USUS\ RWS @O[^S OcT RS` JS`O\RO TZObbS`\& 9a Vv`b aWQV UO` \WQVb U`]P O\$ OPS` S` eSWr$ ROaa aSW\ JObS` S`ab O\Ts\Ub& 8S\\]QV$ RWS Gbc\RS W\ RS` ?wQVS [Wb ?S\\g c\R C\YSZ HSRRg VOb WV[ Acb US[OQVb$ S` TwVZb aWQV [Wb WV\S\ W[ 6c\RS c\R ROVS` aWQVS`& 9` `SRSb wPS` SbeOa O\RS`Sa& K]`wPS`$ a^WSZb YSW\S F]ZZS& 8O aOUb aSW\ JObS` SbeOa$ ROa YSW\S` dS`abSVb OcrS` WV[& 6ZWQYab jO d]ZZ Rc`QV$ KWZZWS$ a^]bbSb S`& 5ZZSa W[ ;`WTT$ eWS Sa aQVSW\b& 6SW RS\ K]`bS\ aSW\Sa JObS`a eSWr S`$ ROaa S` hc eSWb USUO\US\ Wab c\R O[ PSabS\ RS\ Ac\R VsZb& ;O\h [Wb RW` W[ `SW\S\$ KWZZWS4 8WS GbW[[S Wab 6]ab]\ ^c`$ GQ]bQV ^c`& Gs[bZWQVS` D`]PZS[S <S`` USe]`RS\4 ;sPya SW\a$ wPS` ROa Rc `SRS\ [vQVbSab4 G]ZZ WQV dWSZZSWQVb4 KOa VsZbab Rc ROd]\4 =\heWaQVS\ aW\R OZZS abWZZ$ eSWZ YSW\S` PSU`SWTb$ c[ eOa Sa USVb& 5PS` S` eSWr Sa& I\R S` PSbSb$ ROaa aSW\ JObS` OcTVv`b$ ROaa S` \WQVb OcaUS`SQV\Sb jSbhb Oca^ZOcRS`b$ eOa S` eSWr$ \WQVb ROa VW\Oca^]aOc\b$ e][Wb S` WV\ W[[S` W\ RS` <O\R VOPS\ eW`R& CP S` Sa C\YSZ HSRRg aQV]\ S`hsVZb VOb4 HSRRg aWSVb WV\ jSbhb a] Y][WaQV O\& =ab ROa AWbZSWR ]RS`

C\YSZ HSRRg aQV]\ S`hsVZb VOb4 HSRRg aWSVb WV\ jSbhb a] Y][WaQV O\& =ab ROa AWbZSWR ]RS` 5PaQVSc4 9` eSWr Sa \WQVb& GSW\ ;SaWQVb eW`R VSWr W\ RS` O\USa^O\\bS\ 5b[]a^Vs`S$ c\R aQVZWSrZWQV Ts\Ub C\YSZ HSRRg O\$ d]\ aSW\S[ G]V\ 7V`Wa hc `SRS\$ RS` PSW SW\S` HVSObS`OcTTwV`c\U [Wba^WSZb ]RS` W\ SW\S` AO\\aQVOTb Wab ]RS` aWQV US`ORS SW\ 6Oc[VOca POcb& 8Oa 5PS\RSaaS\ USVb hc 9\RS$ c\R ROa ^SW\ZWQVS NeWaQVS\a^WSZ US`sb W\ JS`USaaS\VSWb& GSW\S AcbbS` [vQVbS$ ROaa [O\ WV` W\ RS` ?wQVS VWZTb$ c\R YZOUb$ WV` FwQYS\ aSW eWSRS` UO\h aQVZW[[& KS\\ ROa [OZ YSW\ 6O\RaQVSWPS\d]`TOZZ Wab$ aScThb aWS& GSW\ JObS` dS`R`SVb RWS 5cUS\$ ?W[ abSVb aQV]\ O\ RS` G^wZS c\R esaQVb OP$ S` c\R ?S\\g P`W\US\ SW\ ^OO` GQVwaaSZ\ W\ RWS ?wQVS c\R dS`aQVeW\RS\ \OQV ]PS\& =`US\ReO\\ d]` RS[ GQVZOTS\USVS\ Wab S` W[ 6OR$ c\R Sa ROcS`b Zs\US` OZa a]\ab& GSW\S AcbbS` YZ]^Tb SW\[OZ$ ?S\\g [SV`[OZa3 S` R`SVb RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ OcT$ d]ZZTwV`b aSW\S\ HO\h$ aOcb OZZSa d]ZZ c\R [OQVb aOcPS`& G] eSWb$ a] Ucb$ OPS` OZa S` eWSRS` W\ aSW\ NW[[S` Y][[b$ aWQV \SPS\ RS[ PS`SWba aQVZOTS\RS\ ?S\\g ZSWaS OcahWSVb$ aSW\S \OaaS\ GOQVS\ a]`UTsZbWU c\bS` RS\ <O\RbwQVS`\ W[ KsaQVSY]`P dS`abSQYb c\R c\bS` RWS 6SbbRSQYS Y`WSQVb$ VOb S` wPS`VOc^b \WQVb ROa ;STwVZ$ ROaa RWS GOQVS OcaUSabO\RS\ Wab&

A]`US\
GSWb TOab heSW K]QVS\ PW\ WQV W[ ;O\aSd]]`b <]bSZ& 5\RS`S NW[[S` W\ O\RS`S\ <]bSZa UW\US\ d]`Oca& =\ [SW\S` ;SUS\R x G]<]$ KSab JWZZOUS$ 7VSZaSO x aW\R aWS OZZS$ RS[ ;STwVZ \OQV OPS` KSZbS\ S\bTS`\b$ W\ JWS`bSZ\$ e] WQV \]QV \WS eO`& =QV [SZRS [WQV c\bS` BO[S\ Oca RS` ?W\RVSWb O\ x ?S\\g GQVeSbS`$ AWQVOSZ @Z]gR$ 5RO[ ;`O\b%KSab x c\R S`YZs`S$ ROaa WQV ?`OQV [Wb [SW\S` :`Sc\RW\ VOPS c\R \WQVb USTc\RS\ eS`RS\ [vQVbS& BWS[O\R dS`hWSVb SW\S AWS\S& AO\ aWSVb aWQV ZSRWUZWQV [SW\S\ DOaa O\$ hWSVb RWS 6O\YYO`bS Rc`QV c\R UWPb [W` SW\S\ GQVZwaaSZ& G] ZO\US eWS W[ ;O\aSd]]`b eO` WQV a]\ab \W`US\Ra& =\ RS\ O\RS`S\ <]bSZa x .( HV][^a]\$ K$ AO`WbW[S$ KOaVW\Ub]\ G_cO`S x PW\ WQV \c` SW\S BOQVb ]RS` heSW$ VvQVabS\a dWS` BsQVbS USPZWSPS\& 8Oa eO` \OQV BSeO`Y$ \OQV RS\ qPS`\OQVbc\US\ PSW AO`Y c\R \OQV BSe 7O\OO\$ 7]\\SQbWQcb$ e] [SW\S :`Sc\RW\\S\ @WZW c\R 9ZWhO [WQV W\ GWZdS` <WZZ O\US[SZRSb VObbS\$ SW\S` 9\bhcUaYZW\WY$ Oca RS` WQV a]T]`b eWSRS` `Oca PW\& BOQVRS[ WQV [W` PSW RS[ :OV`S`$ RS` [WQV OPV]ZbS$ eOa PSa]`Ub VObbS$ aSbhbS S` [WQV O\ SW\S[ 7]c`bgO`R AO``W]bb A]bSZ W\ B]`eOZY OP$ e] WQV PZWSP$ PWa ROa 7`OQY hc` BSWUS UW\U$ c\R [WQV RS` `][O\bWaQVS\ J]`abSZZc\U VW\UOP$ eS\WUS ?WZ][SbS` S\bTS`\b d]\ RS[ ?`O\YS\VOca$ W\ RS[ WQV USP]`S\ eO`$ hc abS`PS\& =QV VOPS SW\WUS AOZS ROa NW[[S` USeSQVaSZb c\R PW\ jSbhb W\ SW\S` GcWbS$ RWS [W` RS` AO\OUS`$ RO WQV hc[W\RSab SW\ ^OO` K]QVS\ PZSWPS$ O\USPZWQV TOab hc[ VOZPS\ D`SWa Zsaab& 8O`OcT Wab S` \WQVb d]\ aSZPab USY][[S\3 PSW[ NW[[S`eSQVaSZ VObbS WQV RS\ AS\aQVS\ O[ 9[^TO\U UST`OUb$ eWS Sa PSW WV\S\ [Wb @O\UhSWb`OPObb OcaasVS& >SRS BOQVb Vv`S WQV OcT RS` Gb`OrS ;SaQV`SW x KSWbS` a]$ 6WZZg& ;S\WSr Sa$ a] ZO\US Rc YO\\ab& GQVeSW\ Tw` RWQV$ ROaa Rc wPS`VOc^b \]QV RO PWab$ 6WZZg& 9\bZO\U RS[ ;O\aSd]]`b ^O`YS\ @WSTS`eOUS\ [Wb ASbOZZYsabS\ OcT RS[ 8OQV$ RWS Tw` [WQV UO\h YZO` qPS`eOQVc\UaTOV`hScUS aW\R& qPS`OZZ aSVS WQV c\OcTTsZZWUS O[S`WYO\WaQVS DYea$ c\R WQV PW\ aWQVS`$ ROaa jSRS` SW\hSZ\S d]\ SW\S[ FOcaQVUWTbPcZZS\ ]RS` dS`RSQYbS\ 9`[WbbZS` USTOV`S\ eW`R& H`]bhRS[ hWSVS WQV jSRS\ 5PS\R \OQV AWbbS`\OQVb [SW\S aQVeO`hS 5`QbS`gf%>OQYS c\R RWS aQVeO`hS DO`Ya ! FSQ`SObW]\%AwbhS O\$ TOV`S `c\bS` W\ RWS @]PPg c\R aQVZc`TS hc[ ;SZROcb][ObS\ W\ RS` 6]RSUO 9QYS ),bV Gb`SSb& 8O abSVS\ heSW 5cb][ObS\ \SPS\SW\O\RS`$ c\R \c` SW\[OZ USZW\Ub Sa [W`$ a] aQV\SZZ [SW\S ?O`bS SW\hcaQVWSPS\ c\R RWS D=Ba c\R 6Sb`sUS SW\hcUSPS\$ ROaa WQV ROa )(((%8]ZZO`%@W[Wb Y\OQYS& =\ RS` FSUSZ [caa WQV eO`bS\ c\R Tw\T [OZ *(( 8]ZZO` OPVSPS\& 5PS\R Tw` 5PS\R [OQVS WQV ROa$ c\R RO\\ RSQYS WQV [WQV [Wb :ScS`hScUS\ SW\& KWS dWSZS d]\ [SW\S` G]`bS RWS @ScbS VW\bS` RS` HVSYS e]VZ hc ;SaWQVb PSY][[S\4 <c\RS`bS4 BcZZ4

RWS @ScbS VW\bS` RS` HVSYS e]VZ hc ;SaWQVb PSY][[S\4 <c\RS`bS4 BcZZ4 6S^OQYb [Wb [SW\S\ as[bZWQVS\ 8`]US\ c\R DTSWTS\$ Oca 5\Uab$ [O\ Yv\\bS [SW\ NW[[S` Rc`QVacQVS\$ esV`S\R WQV eSU PW\$ YSV`S WQV hc[ <]bSZ hc`wQY& NeSW[OZ VOPS WQV W\ RS` <OZZS HwbS\ [Wb 7`OQY TOZZS\ ZOaaS\& ASW\ ;w`bSZ VOb [WbbZS`eSWZS hSV\ @vQVS`& NcS`ab VObbS S` \c` aSQVa& 9W\ ^OO` VOPS WQV [Wb SW\S[ ASaaS` aSZPab `SW\US[OQVb$ RWS O\RS`S\ aW\R W\ @SRS`eO`S\USaQVsTbS\ heWaQVS\ <]bSZa c\R ;SZROcb][ObS\ USabO\hb e]`RS\& H`]bhRS[ `cbaQVb [W` RWS >SO\a \]QV d][ <W\bS`\& =QV PW\ \WQVb OZZSW\ W[ NW[[S`& AOZQ]Z[ Wab aSWb dWS` ]RS` Tw\T$ dWSZZSWQVb OcQV aSQVa HOUS\ PSW [W`& 9` bOcQVbS SW\Sa 5PS\Ra [Wb <O^^g OcT$ c\R aSWbRS[ aWbhb S` [Wb W[ 6]]b& D`W\QSb]\%5Pa]ZdS\b$ eWS S` aOUb& 9W\ GQVeO`hS` Oca <O`ZS[$ eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV S`ab R`SWrWU c\R aQVv\& GQVSW\b \WQVb aQVecZ hc aSW\ c\R YO\\ S\]`[ dWSZ 7`OQY dS`b`OUS\$ ]V\S hWbb`WU ]RS` \S`dva hc eS`RS\& 9W\Sa 5PS\Ra PW\ WQV wPS`hScUb$ ROaa jSRS\ 5cUS\PZWQY RWS 7]^a W\ c\aS` NW[[S` SW\TOZZS\$ c\R eW` abw`[S\ Oca RS[ <]bSZ$ OZa abw\RS Sa W\ :ZO[[S\& KW` ZOaaS\ OZZSa RO x OZZSa PWa OcT RWS 8`]US\ x c\R [SZRS\ c\a W[ K O[ I\W]\ G_cO`S O\& =QV abWSTSZS eWS SW\ =``S` Rc`QVa NW[[S`$ c\R AOZQ]Z[ wPb aWQV W\ ;SRcZR c\R [OQVb [W` K]RYOa [Wb 9Wa c\R @W[]\S\aQVSWPS\& Nc` 5PZS\Yc\U S`hsVZb S` [W`$ ROaa S` SW\ GbW^S\RWc[ Tw` D`W\QSb]\ VOb c\R :]]bPOZZ a^WSZb& J]` SW\S[ >OV` VOb S` ROa GbcRWc[ OPUSP`]QVS\$ eWZZ OPS` eSWbS`[OQVS\$ eS\\ S` US\cU ;SZR hcaO[[S\VOb ]RS` SW\S\ Uw\abWUS`S\ KSU TW\RSb$ Sa hc TW\O\hWS`S\& 9` S`eW`Pb US`ORS aSW\S AOYZS`hcZOaac\U& 5Za WQV WV\ T`OUS$ e]VS` S` <O^^g YS\\b$ aOUb S`$ Oca RS[ JWS`bSZ$ c\R OZa WQV SW\eS\RS$ ROaa <O^^g W\ KOaVW\Ub]\ <SWUVba e]V\b$ aOUb S`$ RO VOPS S` T`wVS` OcQV USe]V\b& 6Sa]\RS`a abWQVVOZbWU Wab aSW\S ;SaQVWQVbS \WQVb$ OPS` eOa a]ZZya4 9` Wab \Sbb c\R aSfg$ c\R Sa es`S [W` c\S`b`sUZWQV$ jSbhb OZZSW\ hc aSW\& 8Oaa S` PSW [W` Wab$ Zsaab RWS UO\hS\ d]`O\USUO\US\S\ BsQVbS c\R RWS W\ 5caaWQVb abSVS\RS\ c\aOUPO` SW\aO[ S`aQVSW\S\& =\ [O\QVS\ RWSaS` BsQVbS `cTS WQV SW\S\ 9aQ]`b GS`dWQS Oca RS[ 5\hSWUS\bSWZ RS` JWZZOUS J]WQS ]RS` RSa BSe M]`Y AOUOhW\S O\& ?SW\S` RWSaS` 9aQ]`ba \W[[b jS[OZa 8`]US\ [Wb [W`$ c\R RWS [SWabS\ PZSWPS\ \c` SfOYb SW\S Gbc\RS& =V`S <Ocb c\R WV` AWbUSTwVZ x RWS [SWabS\ [SW\S\ W`US\ReO\\$ WQV a]ZZS Yw`hS` b`SbS\$ a]\ab Yv\\S WQV [W` aQVORS\ x `SWQVS\ \WS Oca$ aW\R \WS[OZa UO\h ROa$ eOa [W` d]`aQVeSPb$ c\R eS\\ aWS USVS\$ PW\ WQV TOab W[[S` S`ZSWQVbS`b c\R S\bbscaQVb& 8Oa NW[[S` W[ K Wab YZSW\ W[ JS`UZSWQV hc RS[ W[ ;O\aSd]]`b& 9W\ ?OPcTT$ c\R RWS @wTbc\U bOcUb \WQVba x abObb OPhchWSVS\$ aQVeSPb RS` FOcQV$ RS\ eW` dS`O\abOZbS\$ SeWU c[ RWS @wTbc\UaYZO^^S\ VS`c[& =QV VOPS 5\Uab$ ROa Yv\\bS :ScS`OZO`[ OcaZvaS\ eWS W[ .( HV][^a]\ aQV]\ [OZ& 9`\Scb ROa <]bSZ hc eSQVaSZ\ es`S SW\S AvUZWQVYSWb$ OPS` OZZ[sVZWQV [OQVS WQV [W` G]`US\ c[a ;SZR x `c\R heO\hWUbOcaS\R aW\R \]QV RO$ c\R [SV` OZa dWS`hWUbOcaS\R VOPS WQV aQV]\ R`OcTUSVOcS\ x$ PZSWPb OZa] \c` ROa K ]RS` ROa ;O\aSd]]`b&

KW` `OTTS\ c\aS`S GWSPS\aOQVS\ hcaO[[S\ c\R USVS\& 8S` KSU hc`wQY hc[ ;O\aSd]]`b Wab aQV`SQYZWQV$ R]QV ]Pe]VZ WQV wPS`hScUb PW\$ ROaa c\aS`S :Sab\OV[S PSd]`abSVb$ [O`aQVWS`S WQV RW`SYb hc[ 5cThcU c\R Rc`QV RS\ ;O\U W\a NW[[S`& 9a Wab \]QV US\Oca]$ eWS eW` Sa d]` Gbc\RS\ hc`wQYUSZOaaS\ VOPS\& =QV USVS aQV\c`ab`OQYa hc[ :S\abS` c\R aSVS \OQV$ ]P c\bS\ D]ZWhSW d]`USTOV`S\ Wab& BWQVba& Bc` RS` D]`bWS` c\R SW\ ^OO` DOaaO\bS\& 8O\\ hc[ GQV`O\Y c\R W\a 6OR$ c[ hc aSVS\$ ]P c\a jS[O\R OcTZOcS`b& 5ZZSa YZO`$ c\R R]QV Zsaab RWS DO\WY S`ab \OQV SW\ ^OO` TSbbS\ <Wba$ SW\S` VOZPS\ :ZOaQVS K]RYO c\R 6SbbUSbw[[SZ [Wb AOZQ]Z[ \OQV& G^sbS`$ OZa RWS G]\\S OcTUSVb$ b`Wbb AOZQ]Z[ OcT RS\ YZSW\S\ 6OZY]\ VW\Oca& =QV [caa POZR eSU$ aOUb S`& GSW\ <O\Rg bcbya \WQVb [SV`$ c\R S` aOUb$ S` [caa hc`wQY W\ aSW\ \]`[OZSa @SPS\& =QV wPS``SRS WV\$ \]QV SW\S BOQVb hc PZSWPS\& KW` VOPS\ US\cU$ c[ wPS` RS\ BOQV[WbbOU hc Y][[S\$ PWa <O^^g eWSRS` S``SWQVPO` Wab$ c\R WQV dS`a^`SQVS$ RO\\ eW`YZWQV W\ RWS J]ZZS\ hc USVS\& 8S` HOU dS`ZscTb eWS wPZWQV$ GSf$ 5ZY]V]Z$ <Wba$ ROheWaQVS\ OcTa NW[[S` PSabSZZbSa 9aaS\$ ROa eW` YOc[ O\`wV`S\$ SW\S BScOcTZOUS d][ HOU hcd]`& AOZQ]Z[a ;S`SRS d]\ aSW\S[ @SPS\ R`OcrS\ W\ RS` KSZb Zsaab [WQV O\ [SW\Sa RS\YS\$ c\R WQV PSbS W[ GbWZZS\$ ROa SW\S` RWSaS` <Wba [W` RS\ ;O`Oca [OQVb& =QV POcS SW\S\ RWQYS` OZa RS\ O\RS`S\ c\R PSVOZbS RS\ FOcQV SW\ ]RS` heSW <S`haQVZsUS Zs\US` W\ RS` @c\US OZa WQV [SW\S$ OcaVOZbS\ hc Yv\\S\& 9a ^]QVb [W` W[ <OZa$ hWSVb RS\ 5`[ V]QV$ c\R WQV T`OUS [WQV$ eO\\ Sa ^OaaWS`b& KWSRS` RWS NSWZS\ Oca RS[ 6cQV& 9a eO` a]eSWb& 5[ \sQVabS\ A]`US\$ esV`S\R WQV \]QV RvaS$ ^OQYb AOZQ]Z[ aSW\S GOQVS\& =QV Vv`S RWS H]WZSbbS\a^wZc\U W[ 6OR c\R aSVS$ ROaa S` RS\ 5aQVS\PSQVS` OcT RS[ BOQVbbWaQV$ W\ RS[ WQV ROa 7`OQY OcTPSeOV`S$ PSW\OV ZSS`US[OQVb VOb& 9W\ ^OO` GbSW\S VOb S` R`W\USZOaaS\$ dWSZS YOaaWS`b& =QV R`wQYS SW\ 5cUS hc& BWQVb$ eSWZ Sa [W` SUOZ Wab$ a]\RS`\ eSWZ WQV ecaabS$ ROaa S` YZOcb$ c\R O[ 5PS\R$ OZa S` c\bS` RS` 8caQVS eO`$ heSW d]ZZS HwbS\ W\ [SW\S[ 6ZOhS` dS`abSQYb VObbS$ c[ VScbS PWa AWbbS`\OQVb x PWa WQV eWSRS` ;SZR OPVSPS\ YO\\ x wPS` RWS Fc\RS\ hc Y][[S\& I\aS` 5PaQVWSR Wab Yc`h& 8S` HOU aQVZS^^b aWQV ROVW\& =QV eWZZ [SW\S BOQV`WQVbS\ OP`cTS\ x SbeOa$ ROa WQV bOUSZO\U dS`[WSRS\ VOPS x$ R]QV [SW\ <O\Rg ^`saS\bWS`b SW\S \WS USaSVS\S 6]baQVOTb$ RWS [W` ^`]^VSbWaQV S`aQVSW\b2 G^SWQVS` d]ZZ& ?SW\S eSWbS`S 5cThSWQV\c\U [vUZWQV& 8WS ASZRc\U aQVeW``b W[[S` eWSRS` OcT RWS YZSW\S 5\hSWUS c\R dS`eSV`b [W` RS\ NcUO\U hc` AOWZP]f& BOQV SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ USPS WQV Sa OcT& ;SUS\ 5PS\R P`W\Ub [W` SW\ b`]bbSZWUS` >c\US d][ NW[[S`aS`dWQS SW\S\ HSZZS` BOQV]a$ RWS WQV \WQVb SaaS& 8WS KOV`VSWb Wab$ WQV ZOaaS [W` ROa 9aaS\ P`W\US\$ eSWZ WQV ?]\bOYb P`OcQVS& 9` Wab hc[ :ZW`bS\ OcTUSZSUb c\R S`hsVZb d]\ RS` BMI$ e] S` D]ZWbWaQVS KWaaS\aQVOTbS\ abcRWS`b$ d]\ RS\ Tw\T Hg^S\$ [Wb RS\S\ S` W\ KWZZWO[aPc`U hcaO[[S\e]V\b& KsV`S\R S` `SRSb$ PSaQVs[b [WQV aSW\S >cUS\R2 RWS `]aO

<Ocb$ RS` YZO`S 6ZWQY$ RWS GbW[[S$ RWS eSRS` W\ GO`YOa[ca \]QV 9`aQVv^Tc\U OPUZSWbSb& 6SW[ FSRS\ b`Wbb S` \sVS`$ c\R WQV YO\\ Tv`[ZWQV RWS =d]`g%GSWTS `WSQVS\$ RWS S` e]VZ VScbS T`wV W\ RS` S\US\ K]V\c\U W\ KWZZWO[aPc`U PSW[ 8caQVS\ PS\cbhb VOb$ SVS S` hc` 5`PSWb USTOV`S\ Wab& 9` Yv\\bS [W` jSbhb \WQVb \sVS` aSW\$ c\R WQV Yv\\bS [WQV \WQVb eSWbS` eSU TwVZS\& :w` RS\ >c\US\ Ts\Ub OZZSa S`ab O\$ S` eSWr \]QV \WQVb [OZ$ eWS `SWhS\R c\R c\dS`R]`PS\ S` Wab& =QV ROUSUS\ x [SW\S <s\RS aW\R PSRSQYb d]\ 6`O\R\O`PS\ c\R Fcr$ eSWZ WQV RWS UO\hS BOQVb VW\Rc`QV RWS 8`OVbaWSPS RS` 7`OQY^TSWTS\ OcaUSeSQVaSZb VOPS& 5\TO\Ua VObbS WQV RO`O\ USROQVb$ WV\ hc dS`TwV`S\$ OPS` OZa S` OcTVv`b hc `SRS\$ YO\\ WQV \c` \]QV [SW\S I\bS`aQV`WTb c\bS` RWS FSQV\c\U aSbhS\ c\R 5PabO\R VOZbS\& 5Za S` USVb$ PZOTTS\ RWS GbW[[S\ d]\ R`OcrS\ ZOcbS` OZa a]\ab& 9\RZWQV USZW\Ub Sa [W`$ SW\S BOQV`WQVb d]\ B]OV OPhc`cTS\$ RS` [W` aOUb$ ROaa S` [WQV ZWSPb c\R [W` \WQVb PvaS Wab$ a]\RS`\ 5\Uab VOb$ ROaa WQV b]b PW\& ?][[ R]QV \OQV <OcaS& =QV Y\OZZS [WQV O\ c\R b`W\YS$ c\R OZa RWS GbW[[S\ R`OcrS\ hc ZOcb eS`RS\ c\R SW\ AO\\ W[ <Oca USUS\wPS` OZZS[ 5\aQVSW\ \OQV SW\S JWRS]YO[S`O OcT [SW\ NW[[S` US`WQVbSb VsZb$ [OQVS WQV [W` SW\S RWQYS DTSWTS c\R S\baQVZWSrS [WQV$ \OQV <OcaS hc TOV`S\& 9a OcahcPORS\ c\R [WQV B]OV W\ RWS 5`[S hc eS`TS\& =QV `OTTS [SW\ 7`OQY c\R [SW\S FvV`QVS\ hcaO[[S\$ ZSaS RWS ?`w[SZ d]\ RWdS`aS\ HWaQVS\ c\R USVS hc` Hw` VW\Oca& 9W\ HOfW `]ZZb VS`O\$ OZa WQV OcT RWS ;O\aSd]]`b Gb`SSb b`SbS& 9a VsZb \SPS\ [W`$ c\R WQV abSWUS SW\& BOQV <OcaS4$ T`OUb RS` AO\\ [Wb RS\ YO\bWUS\ aZOeWaQVS\ NwUS\ c\R RS[ S\ba^`SQVS\RS\ 5YhS\b T`Sc\RZWQV& >O$ aOUS WQV& =[ FORW] ZscTb @]cWa 5`[ab`]\Ua nKVOb O K]\RS`TcZ K]`ZRl$ [OUWaQV c\R PS`cVWUS\R& 8WS @cTb W[ HOfW Tc\YSZb$ OZa es`S Sa dS`hOcPS`b& 8WS DO\WY$ RWS WQV AW\cbS\ hcd]` W\ [SW\S[ NW[[S` \]QV USa^w`b VOPS$ Wab dS`aQVec\RS\& GWS aW\R SW\S` d]\ RS\S\$ eOa4$ T`OUS WQV& 8WS :`OUS VOPS WQV HOfWTOV`S`\$ RWS O\aQVSW\S\R eWaaS\$ e] WQV VW\eWZZ$ aQV]\ SW\WUS AOZS USabSZZb c\R W[[S` \c` SW\ @sQVSZ\ OZa 5\be]`b PSY][[S\& =QV aQVOcS \OQV RS[ :OV`S`T]b]$ R]QV eWS PSW OZZS\ aSWb RS[ :ZcUVOTS\ Wab Sa d]\ DO^WS` ]RS` DO^^S dS`RSQYb& 5cT RS[ 6SWTOV`S`aWbh aSVS WQV$ eWS jSbhb aQV]\ [W\RSabS\a SW\ 8cbhS\R AOZ$ NW^Z]Q%HwbS\ [Wb ;SZR ascPS`ZWQV \SPS\SW\O\RS`ZWSUS\ x SW\S [Wb )%8]ZZO`%GQVSW\S\$ SW\S [Wb U`vrS`S\$ SW\S [Wb <O`bUSZR& 8S` KOUS\ Wab eWS OZZS HOfWa SW\USeSWVbS` :OV`S` PZWbhaOcPS`& =QV T`OUS WV\$ Tw` eS\ S` O`PSWbSb$ c\R S` [SW\b [Wb SW\S[ ZSWaS\ @OQVS\ \c`$ ROa Rw`TS S` \WQVb aOUS\& =QV VOYS \OQV$ c\R S` ZOQVb eWSRS`& 5PS` GWS O`PSWbS\ Tw` jS[O\RS\ c\R aW\R YSW\ HOfWTOV`S`$ abW[[bya4 9` ZOQVb S`\Scb c\R aOUb2 GWS aW\R RS` 9`abS$ RS` ROa aQV\OZZb& =QV YO\\ \WQVb TOaaS\$ ROaa S` bObasQVZWQV hcUSUSPS\ VOb$ YSW\ BSe M]`YS` HOfWTOV`S` hc aSW\& =QV VOPya USecaab $ aOUS WQV c\R PW\ S`ZSWQVbS`b$ ROaa RWSaS aSZbaO[S\ 6SUSU\c\US\ [Wb HOfWTOV`S`\ YSW\S R`]US\PSRW\UbS\ KOV\d]`abSZZc\US\$ YSW\S 5caUSPc`bS\ [SW\S` DO`O\]WO aW\R& 8S` :OV`S` eW`Yb T`Sc\RZWQV& 5Za S` aWQV c[R`SVb$ c[ [W` hc O\be]`bS\$ bO\hb @WQVb W\ aSW\S\ 5cUS\& =QV T`OUS eSWbS`2 KO`c[ dS`VOTbS\ aWS [WQV \WQVb SW\TOQV4 KSWZ aWS [WQV PS]POQVbS\ [vQVbS\$ S`eWRS`b S`& KSWZ aWS [WQV aQV]\ ZO\US PS]POQVbS\$ OcQV T`wVS`

PS]POQVbS\ [vQVbS\$ S`eWRS`b S`& KSWZ aWS [WQV aQV]\ ZO\US PS]POQVbS\$ OcQV T`wVS` aQV]\$ PSd]` WQV a] OcaUSbWQYb PW\$ \c` ROaa WQV Sa jSbhb S`ab PS[S`Yb VOPS& =ab ROa Ucb4$ T`OUS WQV$ c\R S` aOUb2 >O$ ROa Wab Ucb& =V\S\ ^OaaWS`b \WQVba& >S[O\R Yw[[S`b aWQV c[ GWS& =QV T`OUS WV\$ eS`$ c\R S` O\be]`bSb$ ROa Rw`TS S` [W` \WQVb aOUS\& >SRS\TOZZa aSW Sa SW\ ;ZwQY Tw` [WQV$ c\R WQV a]ZZS [W` YSW\S G]`US\ [OQVS\& 8WS :`OUS$ ]P WQV W[ <]bSZ OPUSVv`b eS`RS$ PSjOVb S`& 5Za WQV SW\S\ 6SeSWa dS`ZO\US$ aOUb S`2 BO jO$ GWS eS`RS\ [O\QV[OZ UO\h aQVv\ VSYbWaQV RO ]PS\& ;O\h aQVv\ VSYbWaQV c\R \S`dva& =QV T`OUS WV\$ ]P aWS [WQV OcQV PSW[ GSf PSZOcaQVS\ c\R PS]POQVbS\$ e]`OcT S` ZOQVb c\R [SW\b$ WQV Yv\\S UO\h PS`cVWUb aSW\$ Tw` aWS aSW ROa \WQVba BScSa& KW` VOZbS\ d]` C\S :WTbV$ c\R WQV S[^TW\RS bObasQVZWQV \WQVba OZa FcVS c\R SW\ SWUS\O`bWUSa ;ZwQYaUSTwVZ& ;`ObWaTOV`b$ ]RS`4$ T`OUS WQV$ c\R S` ZsQVSZb c\R eW\Yb [WQV eSU& FSUS\ GWS aWQV \WQVb a] OcT$ OZZSa eW`R Ucb$ aOUb S`$ OZa WQV OcaabSWUS& 9W\S KSZZS RS` 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U wPS`Y][[b [WQV$ c\R eWS WQV RO abSVS$ ZOcTS\ heSW As\\S` d]`PSW$ As\bSZ$ CV`Vv`S`$ `c\Rc[ >7 DS\\Sg3 aWS ZsQVSZ\$ OZa es`S WQV W\ W`US\RSW\ U`]rSa ;SVSW[\Wa SW\USeSWVb e]`RS\& AW` eW`R YZO`$ ROaa jSRS` 9W\hSZ\S RWSaS` KW\RjOQYS\b`sUS` [WQV d]\ 5\TO\U O\ W[ 5cUS USVOPb VOb& 6SaQVwbhb VOPS\ aWS [WQV $ aOUS WQV ZOcb& 8SaVOZP PW\ WQV OcQV \WQVb dS`VOTbSb e]`RS\& =QV PZWQYS [WQV OcT RS` Gb`OrS c[$ wPS` RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS VW\eSU hc` 9WUVbV Gb`SSb$ c\R aSVS [SV`S`S @ScbS W\ [SW\S FWQVbc\U aQVOcS\$ RWS aWQV aQV]\ Rc`QV WV` HS[^] dS``ObS\$ Rc`QV RS\ PSVS``aQVbS\$ SW\abcRWS`b \]`[OZS\ ;O\U& =\ RS` @]PPg aWbhb H`Sd]` O[ GQVOZbS` c\R Wab ]TTS\PO` \WQVb PSc\`cVWUb$ [WQV hc aSVS\& B]QV VOb B]OV RWS <OcadS`eOZbc\U \WQVb USPSbS\$ WV\ hc PS\OQV`WQVbWUS\$ eS\\ SW\S` RS` DTv`b\S` ]RS` D]`bWS`a [WQV aWSVb3 \]QV VOb S` RWS GQVZvaaS` \WQVb OcaUSeSQVaSZb& =QV ZOcTS O\ H`Sd]` d]`PSW$ RS` [W` SW\ <OZZ] hc`cTb& =\ RS` K]V\c\U Wab \WS[O\R& 5cT RWS =RSS$ ROaa B]OV \WQVb RO aSW\ Yv\\bS$ PW\ WQV UO` \WQVb USY][[S\& =QV [OQVS [W` SW\S\ 8`W\Y$ `OcQVS W[ 6OR SW\S DTSWTS c\R ZOcTS SW\S USTwVZbS 9eWUYSWb W[ K]V\hW[[S` VW\ c\R VS`& 9a Wab aSZbaO[$ \OQV RWSaS\ K]QVS\ eWSRS` hc <OcaS hc aSW\& 6S\\g$ [SW\S ?ObhS$ PSscUb [WQV O`UevV\WaQV c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb W\a GQVZOThW[[S`& 8WS K]V\c\U Y][[b [W` YZSW\S` d]`$ OZa WQV aWS W\ 9`W\\S`c\U VOPS$ Y]abPO`S`$ OZa es`S jSRSa ?WaaS\$ jSRSa 6cQV$ jSRSa :]b] HSWZ SW\S` a]`UTsZbWU W\ahS\WS`bS\ 5caabSZZc\U hc[ HVS[O n8Oa @SPS\ ROd]`&l KsV`S\R WQV eO`bS$ [OZS WQV [W` RWS GhS\S Oca$ RWS O\abSVb$ eS\\ S` \OQV <OcaS Y][[b& 9` eW`R dS`ZO\US\$ ROaa WQV OZZS 8`]US\ VS`OcaUSPS$ RWS WQV \]QV VOPS$ c\R SW\S` 9\bhWSVc\UaYc` hcabW[[S& =QV eWZZ WV\ S\RZWQV eWSRS`aSVS\& =V\ c[O`[S\$ d]\ WV[ c[O`[b eS`RS\$ RWS ZSbhbS\ K]QVS\ W`US\ReWS c\USaQVSVS\ [OQVS\ c\R eWSRS` [Wb WV[ hcaO[[S\ZSPS\& 5PS` jS Zs\US` WQV RO PW\$ RSab] c\[vUZWQVS` S`aQVSW\b [W` ROa& =QV eSWr \WQVb$ eWS ZO\US WQV O\ RWSaS[ 5PS\R R]`b PZSWPS$ OPS` Sa Wab S\beSRS` hc ZO\US ]RS` \WQVb ZO\US US\cU$ c\R WQV USVS eWSRS`& 8`OcrS\ OcT RS` Gb`OrS VsZb SW\ HOfW c\R P`W\Ub [WQV c\OcTUST]`RS`b hc[ <]bSZ hc`wQY& 5Za eW` O\VOZbS\$ aSVS WQV RS\ :OV`S` O\$ c\R S` hcQYb RWS 5QVaSZ\$ OZa e]ZZbS S` aOUS\$

5Za eW` O\VOZbS\$ aSVS WQV RS\ :OV`S` O\$ c\R S` hcQYb RWS 5QVaSZ\$ OZa e]ZZbS S` aOUS\$ aQV]\ Ucb& 9` VsZb RWS IV` hc$ eW\Yb [WQV eSU$ c\R eWSRS` SW\[OZ PW\ WQV Y]abS\Z]a HOfW USTOV`S\& 8WSaS BOQVb dS`USVb aQV\SZZ3 GSYc\RS c[ GSYc\RS PW\ WQV eOQV c\R OZZSW\& ?c`h \OQV AWbbS`\OQVb Y][[b <O^^g$ c\R WQV USPS a] dWSZ Oca$ eWS WQV YO\\$ )((( 8]ZZO`& 9` aOUb YSW\ K]`b$ OZa S` [W` RWS HwbS\ c\R RWS \ScS\ DTSWTS\ UWPb& ?SW\ K]`b RO`wPS`$ ROaa WQV W[[S` [SV` PSabSZZS$ bsUZWQV& 8Oaa S` aSWb TOab R`SW K]QVS\ jSRS\ 5PS\R d]`PSWY][[b& =QV ZOaaS [W` jS heSW @WbS` K]RYO OcT SW\[OZ P`W\US\$ [Wb ?wPSZ\ d]ZZ 9Wa$ c\R aQV]\ Wab eWSRS` \WQVba [SV` RO& =QV `OcQVS SW\S DTSWTS \OQV RS` O\RS`S\ c\R b`W\YS heWaQVS\Rc`QV VSTbWU& KSWZ WQV W[[S` eWSRS` hc TSab O\ RS\ FvV`QVS\ hWSVS$ dS`P`S\\S WQV [W` aQVeS` RWS :W\US`& =QV RcaQVS R`SW% ]RS` dWS`[OZ& GSWTS [WQV [Wb GVO[^]] SW\$ ROaa Sa \c` a] aQVsc[b$ eOaQVS [W` ROa ;SaWQVb [Wb RS` 9RSZaSWTS RSa <]bSZa$ P`OcaS [WQV OP c\R TwVZS [WQV SW\ KSWZQVS\ aOcPS`& DZvbhZWQV VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ ROaa [W` SW\S ?]\bOYbZW\aS VW\bS` RS\ 5cUO^TSZ US`cbaQVb Wab& =QV hWSVS [W` ROa @WR V]QV$ ab]QVS`S [Wb RS\ :W\US`\ RS` O\RS`S\ <O\R O[ 5cUS VS`c[ c\R bOabS \OQV RS[ Rw\\S\ FO\R RS` @W\aS OcT RS` UZWbaQVWUS\ <]`\VOcb& BOQVRS[ WQV ROa c\USTsV` SW\S Gbc\RS ZO\U US[OQVb VOPS$ P`S\\b [W` ROa 5cUS$ c\R RWS UO\hS 9QYS Wab `]b c\R USaQVe]ZZS\& 8Oaa ROa 6`S\\S\ W[[S` \]QV aQVZW[[S` eW`R$ TwV`S WQV RO`OcT hc`wQY$ ROaa WQV [W` RWS Q`OQYdS`aQV[cbhbS\ <s\RS \WQVb USeOaQVS\ VOPS& =QV V]ZS ROa \OQV$ c\R a]T]`b aSVS WQV RWS ?]\bOYbZW\aS OcT RS[ <SWreOaaS`Y\OcT YZSPS\& 6ZWQY W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ x [SW\ 5cUS aWSVb Oca$ OZa VsbbS [W` jS[O\R Gsc`S VW\SW\USa^`Wbhb& 8WS 5cT`SUc\U RS` ZSbhbS\ Gbc\RS\ Y]QVb wPS`3 WQV ab]rS SW\S\ ZOcbS\ GQV`SW Oca$ `S\\S Rc`QVa NW[[S` c\R eS`TS ?WaaS\$ ?ZSWRS` c\R eOa [W` a]\ab \]QV c\bS`Y][[b$ Rc`QV RWS ;SUS\R& 9W\ KOaaS`Y`cU hS`aQVSZZb O\ RS` ?][[]RS& 8Oa ?ZW``S\ P`S[ab [WQV& =QV VOPS 5\Uab$ ROaa WQV hc dWSZ ?`OQV US[OQVb VOPS c\R ROaa UZSWQV RWS <]bSZZSWbc\U S`aQVSW\b& =\ RS\ \sQVabS\ Gbc\RS\ aQVOcS WQV W[[S` [OZ eWSRS` Rc`QV RS\ G^W]\ c\R c\bS` RS` Hw` Rc`QV& 9W\ <Wb$ SW\ 8`W\Y$ 6ZWQY Rc`QV RS\ G^W]\$ 6ZWQY c\bS` RS` Hw` Rc`QV$ KOaaS`$ GVO[^]]$ GSWTS$ c\R ROa ;O\hS d]\ d]`\& ;SUS\ aSQVa IV` T`wV PS[S`YS WQV$ ROaa RWS G]\\S W[ CabS\$ OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS RS` GbORb$ O[ <W[[SZ wPS` RS[ <cRa]\ aQVSW\b& GWS ZSUb SW\ hO`bSa F]aO VW\bS` RWS \WSR`WUS\ ;SPscRS RSa =\Rcab`WSUSPWSba& KO\\ RWS FOaS`SW RS` BOQVb \OQVUSZOaaS\ VOb$ eSWr WQV \WQVb$ OPS` jSbhb Wab aWS d]`PSW& 5Za WQV OcT RS\ YZSW\S\ 6OZY]\ O[ GQVZOThW[[S` b`SbS c\R RWS abWZZS$ YwVZS @cTb SW\Ob[S$ TwVZS WQV [WQV S`ZSWQVbS`b$ S`aQVv^Tb$ eWS \OQV eWZRS[ GSf& 5ca RS[ 8c\YSZ RS` 9`W\\S`c\U bOcQVS\ RWS ZSbhbS\ NSWZS\ d]\ G]^VWSya 9\baQVSWRc\U OcT2 8Oa eO` \WQVb RS` >w\UabS HOU$ Sa eO` \c` A]`US\& 9W\ VS``ZWQVS`$ YZO`S` A]`US\& =QV a^`SQVS RWS K]`bS Oca c\R [caa ZOQVS\$ eSWZ RWSaSa nA]`US\l eWS ROa aQVv\abS c\R b`vabZWQVabS K]`b OcT 9`RS\ YZW\Ub$ ROPSW VOPS WQV aSZbS\ SbeOa a] USTw`QVbSb&

5caUS`SQV\Sb RS` A]`US\$ YZO` c\R VS``ZWQV JvUSZ Y`SWaS\ hc <c\RS`bS\ wPS` RS[ :Zcaa& HWST TZWSUS\ aWS O[ aQVeOQV S`VSZZbS\ <W[[SZ c\R ab]rS\ VS`OP& GW\R Sa AveS\4$ T`OUS WQV [WQV c\R aQVZWSrS RWS AvUZWQVYSWb a]T]`b Oca& 5PS` eOa Tw` JvUSZ a]ZZbS\ Sa a]\ab aSW\4 KsV`S\R aWQV ROa `]aO @WQVb OcaRSV\b c\R OZZ[sVZWQV W[ VSZZS` eS`RS\RS\ 6ZOc OcTUSVb$ eS`RS\ Sa W[[S` [SV`& BWQVb <c\RS`bS$ a]\RS`\ HOcaS\RS$ c\R RS` <W[[SZ Wab SW\ ^`sQVbWUSa GQVeW\US\USeW``& 5Za es`S SW\ GbwQY d]\ RS` KSZb S\bTS`\b e]`RS\$ c[ 9W\PZWQY W\a <W[[SZ`SWQV hc USPS\& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ T`OUS WQV [WQV$ ]P WQV \]QV O[ @SPS\ PW\& =QV b`SbS O\a ;SZs\RS` c\R aSVS heSW aQVeO`hS @W[]caW\S\ ZO\UaO[ d]` RS[ <]bSZ W[ ?`SWa TOV`S\& 8S` d]`RS`S KOUS\ Wab RW`SYb c\bS` [W`$ c\R WQV YO\\ RWS <s\RS RSa :OV`S`a O[ @S\Y`OR aSVS\& 5cT RS\ ;SVabSWUS\ VW\bS` WV[ a^OhWS`S\ @ScbS& J]`eWSUS\R hc heSWb$ [SV`S`S OcQV SW\hSZ\& 5ZZS VOPS\ \Obw`ZWQV RWS <]aS\ c\R GQVcVS c\R KW\RjOQYS\ O\$ RWS WQV Oca BSeO`Y YS\\S& =V`S GQV`WbbS c\R 6SeSUc\US\ aQVSW\S\ SW\S` SWUS\bw[ZWQVS\ 7V]`S]U`O^VWS abORbUS`SQVbS` qPS`eOQVc\U hc USV]`QVS\& GWS eW`YS\ a] eS\WU PSR`]VZWQV eWS RWS DS\\Sga USabS`\ 5PS\R& qPS` WV\S\ Y`SWaS\ RWS JvUSZ O[ <W[[SZ$ c\R WQV b`SbS hc`wQY$ c[ RWSaS ?cZWaaS$ RWSaS OcaUSYZwUSZbS =\ahS\WS`c\U hc ew`RWUS\& =QV [caa O\ RS\ :ZcUVOTS\ BSeO`Y c\R OZZ RWS HOfWa RS\YS\$ RWS eWS Rc`QV SW\ Kc\RS` OcTUSbOcQVb aW\R$ eS\\ WQV aWS P`OcQVbS& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ RS\ HOfWTOV`S` d][ 5PS\R c\R eOa S` USaOUb VOb$ OZa WQV Oca aSW\S[ NOcPS`bOfW USabWSUS\ PW\ x OZZSa eW`R Ucb& KWS aQV]\ USabS`\$ OZa WQV d]` C\S :WTbV abO\R$ RS\YS WQV$ ROaa WQV dWSZZSWQVb d]` SbeOa ROd]\USZOcTS\ PW\$ ROa RWS UO\hS NSWb OcT [SW\S` GSWbS eO`& 8Oaa SW\S Rc`QV]`UO\WaWS`bS qPS`eOQVc\U [vUZWQVS`eSWaS RS\ NeSQY dS`T]ZUbS$ [WQV hc aQVwbhS\$ abObb [WQV hc aQV\O^^S\& =QV eS`RS `]b PSW RS[ ;SRO\YS\$ ROaa VW\bS` SbeOa a] 5cTeS\RWUS[ c\R JS`ab]VZS\S[ e][vUZWQV G]`US$ eS\\ \WQVb @WSPS abO\R& AW\cbS\ZO\U ZSV\S WQV R]`b O[ ;SZs\RS`$ ROa ;SaWQVb W[ aO\TbS\ A]`US\eW\R& =`US\ReO\\ TsZZb [W` OcT$ ROaa RS` :OV`S` W\ RS[ KOUS\ c\bS` [W` [Wb SW\S` U`]rS\ eSWrS\ ?O`bS VO\bWS`b& 9` aQV`SWPb SbeOa [Wb aQVeO`hS[ :WZhabWTb RO`OcT& GSW\S 6SeSUc\US\ aW\R c\S`b`sUZWQV ZO\UaO[$ c\R W[[S` eWSRS` eWaQVb S` [Wb SW\S[ YZSW\S\ eSWrS\ HcQV ROa ;SaQV`WSPS\S eSU c\R Ts\Ub d]\ \ScS[ O\& =QV USVS VW\SW\$ hWSVS SW\S\ RWQYS\ GbSW\ eSU c\R UWSrS [W` \]QV SW\S\ K]RYO SW\& 5Za WQV eWSRS` OcT RS\ 6OZY]\ Y][[S$ aQV`SWPb S` W[[S` \]QV& =QV aSVS \c` aSW\S 5`[S$ RS\ CPS`Yv`^S` c\R RWS <s\RS& ?]^T c\R ;SaWQVb aW\R d]\ RS` G]\\S\PZS\RS dS`RSQYb& GQVZWSrZWQV abSZZb S` RWS ?O`bS VW\bS` RS` KW\RaQVcbhaQVSWPS OcTa 5`[Obc`S\P`Sbb& :F=G9IF abSVb RO`OcT& G]POZR S` [Wb RS` ?O`bS TS`bWU Wab$ Ts\Ub S` O\$ [Wb SW\S` YZSW\S\$ UZs\hS\R aQVeO`hS\ 8]aS hc VO\bWS`S\& 8OPSW PSeSUb S` RWS :W\US` a] aQV\SZZ$ ROaa aWS dS`eWaQVS\$ c\R RWSaS USVSW[\Wad]ZZS 6SaQVsTbWUc\U ROcS`b [SV`S`S AW\cbS\& 9a aWSVb [W` Oca$ OZa ]P S` SW\S 7`OQY^TSWTS ab]^Tb& 8O\\ \W[[b S` SW\ :ScS`hScU Oca aSW\S` 6ZOhS`bOaQVS c\R Y\W^ab Sa O\& 9` Y\W^ab Sa W[[S` eWSRS` O\$ OPS` \WQVb$ c[ SbeOa RO[Wb O\hchw\RS\$ \c` a]$ ROaa Sa OcTTZO[[b& 9`

W[[S` eWSRS` O\$ OPS` \WQVb$ c[ SbeOa RO[Wb O\hchw\RS\$ \c` a]$ ROaa Sa OcTTZO[[b& 9` Zsaab Sa Yc`h P`S\\S\ c\R Y\W^ab Sa \Sc O\& =QV PScUS [WQV jSbhb wPS` ROa 6OZY]\USZs\RS`$ a] eSWb WQV YO\\& =QV PW\ aWQVS`$ ROaa S` [W` W\ dS`aQVZwaaSZbS` G^`OQVS SbeOa [WbbSWZb$ ROa WQV dS`abSVS\ YO\\$ eS\\ WQV \c` eWZZ& DZvbhZWQV Vs\Ub Tw` [WQV OZZSa ROd]\ OP$ ROaa WQV WV\ dS`abSVS& KOa e]ZZS\ GWS [W` aOUS\4$ `cTS WQV ZOcb$ R]QV S` UWPb \WQVb hc S`YS\\S\$ ROaa S` [WQV USVv`b VOb& BOQV SW\S` KSWZS Vv`b S` OcT$ ROa :ScS`hScU O\hcY\W^aS\$ c\R \W[[b d]`aWQVbWU RWS eSWrS ?O`bS d][ 5`[Obc`S\P`Sbb& KWSRS` Ts\Ub S` O\$ hc eWaQVS\ c\R hc Y`WbhSZ\& BOQV SW\WUS` NSWb aQV`SWPb S` ZO\UaO[S` RS\\ jS SW\ \ScSa K]`b& 5Za S` RO[Wb TS`bWU Wab$ abSZZb S` RWS ?O`bS eWSRS` OcTa 5`[Obc`S\P`Sbb& NqB8@9F ZSaS WQV$ c\R [W` aQVeW``b RS` ?]^T d]\ RS\ JS`PW\Rc\US\ heWaQVS\ RWSaS[ K]`b c\R RS[ :ScS`hScUUSY\W^aS& KOa a]ZZ ROa VSWrS\4$ `cTS WQV d][ 6OZY]\ VW\c\bS`& 8S` :OV`S` abSQYb RS\ :WZhabWTb eSU c\R TOZbSb PSRsQVbWU RWS <s\RS OcT RS[ GQV]r& =QV PS]POQVbS WV\ \]QV ZO\US$ R]QV S` `wV`b aWQV \WQVb [SV`& 9W\S` \OQV RS[ O\RS`S\ c\R DOO` Tw` DOO` dS`aQVeW\RS\ RWS :ZO\Sc`S R`OcrS\& CV\S 9WZS PWSUS\ aWS c[ RWS 9QYS\ ]RS` dS`ZWS`S\ aWQV VW\bS` ;SPscRS\ c\R @OabeOUS\& 8S` :OV`S` Wab `SUZ]a eWS SW\S GbObcS$ c\R W\heWaQVS\ USVb Sa OcT aWSPS\ IV` hc& =QV PW\ eOQV c\R `cVWU$ T`SW d]\ G]`US c\R 9W\aO[YSWb& ASW\ ?v`^S` TwVZb aWQV Z]QYS` c\R S\ba^O\\b O\ c\R hWbbS`b ]RS` PWPPS`b Oca\OV[aeSWaS \WQVb& CPe]VZ WQV RWS UO\hS BOQVb OcT eO`$ TwVZS WQV [WQV OcaUS`cVb& 8S` <W[[SZ Wab W[[S` \]QV `]aO$ c\R Sa R`s\Ub [WQV c\S`Vv`b$ SW\S\ A]`US\a^OhWS`UO\U hc [OQVS\& GbObb eWS wPZWQV RWS HWaQV^ZObbS\ OPhceWaQVS\$ [WQV O\hcY\OZZS\ c\R [WQV O\% c\R eWSRS` OcahchWSVS\$ abSWUS WQV W\ >SO\a$ GQVcVS c\R DcZZ]dS` c\R USVS `Oca& 8WS PSWRS\ KOUS\ aW\R \WQVb [SV` d]` RS[ <]bSZ$ OZa WQV Sa dS`ZOaaS& 8WS Gb`OrS\ aW\R ZSS`$ c\R WQV ZOcTS RWS @WbbZS KSab )*bV Gb`SSb VW\c\bS` FWQVbc\U KOaVW\Ub]\& GQV]\ \OQV eS\WUS\ 6Z]QYa TO\US WQV O\$ \S`dva hc eS`RS\$ c\R RWS NOcPS`ZcTb$ RWS AW\cbS\ hcd]` \]QV heWaQVS\ RS\ ;SPscRS\ ZOU$ dS`aQVeW\RSb2 GWS eSWQVb RS[ ;SabO\Y \OQV :ZSWaQV$ RS[ Rc[^TS\ 6`c[[S\ RS` H`O\a^]`bS`& =QV aQVOTTS Sa PWa hc` ),bV Gb`SSb$ c\R OZa WQV RO\\ YSV`b [OQVS$ U`wrb [WQV SW\ Hg^ [SW\Sa 5ZbS`a W\ >]UUW\UaOQVS\ c\R H`cQYS`[wbhS& 9` Wab c\US^TZSUb$ TWb c\R awr c\R aQVSW\b [W` US\Oc RS` FWQVbWUS hc aSW\$ c[ RWS OcThWSVS\RS K]ZYS hc dS`b`SWPS\& 9` T`OUb$ ]P WQV US`OcQVb VOPS$ WQV aOUS jO$ c\R SVS [O\ aWQVya dS`aWSVb$ aW\R eW` W\ [SW\S[ NW[[S` c\R Y\OZZS\ c\a O\& KW` hWSVS\ RWS <S[RS\ Oca c\R YwaaS\ c\a SW\ PWaaQVS\& 9` Wab \]QV \WQVb ZO\US PSW [W`$ RO YZW\USZb ROa HSZST]\& =QV USVS SW\ ^OO` GQV`WbbS d][ 6Sbb eSU$ c\R \OQVRS[ WQV SbZWQVS Fc\RS\ [Wb G^SWQVS` d]ZZ& ?SW\S eSWbS`S 5cThSWQV\c\U [vUZWQV USYs[^Tb VOPS$ Vv`S WQV RWS BOQV`WQVb& GWS Y][[b d]\ AOZQ]Z[$ RS\ WQV dvZZWU dS`USaaS\ VOPS c\R [W` jSbhb O\Vv`S eWS SW\S\ :`Sc\R Oca RS[ G][[S`QO[^ d]` dWSZS\ >OV`S\& 9`\abS` H]\TOZZ$ c\R aSW\S BOQV`WQVb PSUW\\b [Wb RS\ K]`bS\2 <Sg$ 6WZZ$ WQV [caa

>OV`S\& 9`\abS` H]\TOZZ$ c\R aSW\S BOQV`WQVb PSUW\\b [Wb RS\ K]`bS\2 <Sg$ 6WZZ$ WQV [caa RW` eW`YZWQV [OZ eOa aOUS\ z =QV ZSUS OcT c\R Vv`S RWSaS BOQV`WQVb \WS hc 9\RS$ RS\\ W\ RWSaS[ 5cUS\PZWQY YZ]^Tb jS[O\R O\ RWS Hw`& 9a Wab SW\ ZOcbSa$ \OQVR`wQYZWQVSa ?Z]^TS\$ c\R OZa WQV hc` Hw` USVS c\R Rc`QV RS\ G^W]\ aQVOcS$ abSVb B]OV RO&

K]
;`c\RaQVcZS2 ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`YZ]& 8Oa ?Z] ZWSUb O[ 9\RS SW\Sa ;O\Ua$ VW\bS` RS[ G^`SQVhW[[S` RS` GQVcZaQVeSabS`$ c\R Wab OPaQVZWSrPO`& BOQVbSWZ2 5cT ROa ?Z] USVb RS` FSYb]`& J]`bSWZ2 =[ G^`SQVhW[[S` Wab \WS SW\S`& 5cQV \WQVb RWS ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`& <WUVaQV]]Z2 ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`YZ]& AWbbOUa VSWYSZ& 5ZbS`\ObWdS2 >c\US\YZ] \SPS\ :`O\hvaWaQV`Oc[ W[ 5ZbPOc$ S`abS` Gb]QY& :Oab W[[S` ZSS` OcrS` []`US\a d]` I\bS``WQVbaPSUW\\& Nc <OcaS2 5[ PSabS\ ROa ?Z] \SPS\ 8ORa NW[[S` VW\bS\ W[ <Oca$ UO\h eSU d][ K]V\% c\R 9aahW[[S` "\c` eS\\ 8OR \WQVb RO Wab#& =[ :`wVZW\U$ G][[S` c\R <S`Pab$ PSW aQVv\S[ KSbbS` c\R eS\\ 8OR hc <OcaS Wab2 RS` KOZR& =[ KW\bS` c\R PSW aQVZSQVbS[ KSbbS`$ eS\\ 8OR hc <OcaS Wab2 ROa ?W\RS`YZ] ]PS\$ OPS` 6SSWZc\U& 6SW :`Sc\RS\ 8S`SY2 ?Z] W[ G]cbS``OW\& >S\\g2 <W\bS`[ DTS`RSabOZZ ]RS` ?Z] W[ G]cbS``OW\& AWQVOSZ2 ?Z] W[ S`abS\ Gb]QY$ heWaQVS\ AWQVOSZa c\R @WaOa NW[[S`$ wPS` RS` ;O`OUS& KS\\ RWS 9ZbS`\ eSU aW\R ]RS` R`OcrS\ OcT RS[ <]T$ WV` ?Z] VW\bS\ W[ <Oca& 6SW d]ZZS[ <Oca VW\bS` RS` GQVSc\S& 5RO[2 8WS ?W`QVS aSW\Sa JObS`a OcT RS` O\RS`S\ Gb`OrS\aSWbS$ ?Z] W[ 9`RUSaQV]aa& DOb`WQY2 I\PS\cbhbSa ?Z] c\bS\ W[ <Oca$ e] aSWb >OV`S\ USPOcb eW`R& ?S\\g2 85G G7<K=9F=;GH9 <5IG& Bc` heSW H]WZSbbS\$ PSWRS RO$ e] RWS @ScbS W[[S` aW\R& GcQV RW` SW\S Oca c\R PSbS$ ROaa Sa aQV\SZZ USVb& AS`YS2 )& AvUZWQVab H]WZSbbS\ W[ 9`RUSaQV]aa "@ScbS c\bS` RW` Vv`S\ RWQV a^`W\US\#& *& @scTS`$ 6ORS[ObbS\ c\R <O\RbwQVS` d]`a ?Z] ZSUS\$ c[ RWS <w^TS` hc Rs[^TS\& +& KS\\ Rc UShec\US\ PWab$ ]PS\ OcTa ?Z] hc USVS\2 BWQVb wPS` NW[[S`\$ W\ RS\S\ @ScbS aW\R3 [SV` <O\RbwQVS`$ 6ORS[ObbS\ c\R @scTS`& ,& BWQVb [Wb hc dWSZ ?Z]^O^WS` aOcPS`[OQVS\& 9a dS`ab]^Tb ROa ?Z]&

,& BWQVb [Wb hc dWSZ ?Z]^O^WS` aOcPS`[OQVS\& 9a dS`ab]^Tb ROa ?Z]& -& KS\\ SW\S KO\R W\ 6SQYS\\sVS Wab$ [Wb RS[ FwQYS\ hc` KO\R ^W\YSZ\&

BScS Hw`
5Za S` aWSPS\ Wab$ hWSVb aSW\S :O[WZWS c[& 9a Wab RS` G][[S` heWaQVS\ RS[ heSWbS\ c\R R`WbbS\ GQVcZjOV`$ c\R ROa <Oca$ ROa aWS PShWSVS\$ ZWSUb O[ 9\RS SW\S` ZO\US\ NcTOV`b$ TOab O[ 9\RS SW\S` ZO\US\ Gb`OrS$ Tw\ThSV\ ZO\US AW\cbS\ S\bTS`\b d]\ SW\S[ C`b W\ RS\ 6S`US\ 7]\\SQbWQcba$ W\ RS[ Sa YSW\S 5[^SZ\ UWPb& 8Oa <Oca hc `S\]dWS`S\ ROcS`b >OV`S3 aSW\S 9ZbS`\ S`eSWbS`\ Sa c[ GQVZOThW[[S`$ JS`O\RS\ a]eWS SW\ K]V\% c\R SW\ 9aahW[[S` [Wb ec\RS`aQVv\S[ <]ZhP]RS\$ RWS \WS[OZa PS\cbhb eS`RS\& :w` ]PS\$ e] RWS GQVZOThW[[S` aW\R$ TSVZb RO\\ ROa ;SZR$ a] ROaa RWS Fsc[S \WS SW\S\ `WQVbWUS\ :crP]RS\ ]RS` HS^^WQVP]RS\ S`VOZbS\& Nc[ GQVcbh d]` G^ZWbbS`\ eS`RS\ HS^^WQV^`]PS\ c\R @scTS` OcT RS[ G^S``V]Zh dS`bSWZb& 5ca RS[ eSWbZscTWUS\ SW\USaQV]aaWUS\ :O`[VOca eW`R SW\ U`]rSa U`OcSa <S``S\VOca W[ V]ZZs\RWaQVS\ ?]Z]\WOZabWZ$ SW\Sa RS` U`vrbS\ d]\ 7]\\SQbWQcb$ aOUb aSW\ JObS`$ c\R d]\ RS` 5\VvVS$ OcT RS` Sa abSVb$ wPS`PZWQYb Sa aSQVhSV\ <SYbO` KOZR c\R KWSaS& 5cQV RWS Hw`S\ZO\RaQVOTb Wab \Sc x SW\ O\RS`Sa GQVeSabS`\YZ] W\ RS` GQVcZS$ SW\ O\RS`S` KOZR$ W\ RS\ [O\ dS`aQVeW\RS\$ O\RS`S GQVSc\S\$ VW\bS` RWS [O\ USVS\ YO\\$ RWS <scaS` O\RS`S` :`Sc\RS$ [Wb RWdS`aS\ :OZZS\ c\R OPUSZSUS\S\ p`bQVS\$ e] [O\ a^`W\US\$ W\ DO\WY US`ObS\ c\R aQVZWSrZWQV OcTOb[S\ YO\\& =[ R`WbbS\ GQVcZjOV` aW\R \WQVb dWSZS& Fc\R heO\hWU W\aUSaO[b$ `c\R hSV\ W\ aSW\S` ?ZOaaS& 9` Wab S`ab SW\ ^OO` A]\ObS R]`b$ OZa SW\ \ScSa ?W\R OcTbOcQVb$ SW\ AsRQVS\& GWS Wab YZSW\$ PZ]\R$ d]USZO`bWU c\R WV[ a]T]`b dS`b`Ocb x eWS SW\S GQVeSabS` ]RS` SW\S YZSW\S AcbbS`& J][ S`abS\ 5cUS\PZWQY O\ USPWSbSb aWS wPS` WV\$ OPS` aWS bcb Sa aO\Tb c\R c\OcTTsZZWU& 9` PSU`SWTb$ ROaa aWS d]`\SV[S` c\R YZwUS` Wab OZa S` c\R R]QV hc WV[ USVv`b& G]POZR aWS W\ RWS ?ZOaaS Y][[b$ PScUb S` aWQV WV`$ PZWQYb hc WV` OcT$ c\R aSZPab eS\\ S` aWS SW\[OZ \WQVb PSOQVbSb$ a]`Ub S` aWQV c[ WV`S 5\S`YS\\c\U& ?ObVS`W\S& GWS ZWSab& GWS ZWSab W[[S`& GWS T`OUb WV\$ eOa S` d]\ RS\ 6wQVS`\ VsZb$ RWS aWS Tw` RWS GQVcZS ZSaS\& =\ RS` dWS`bS\ ?ZOaaS Wab ROa SW\ 6cQV wPS` SW\S c\abS`PZWQVS :O[WZWS c\R SW\ AsRQVS\$ ROa aWQV W\ jS[O\RS\ Oca RWSaS` :O[WZWS dS`ZWSPb$ \OQVRS[ aWS WV[ W[ KOZR VW\bS` WV`S[ <Oca$ e] S` Oca SW\S` EcSZZS b`W\Yb$ hcTsZZWU PSUSU\Sb Wab& =\ RS` Tw\TbS\ T]ZUb SW\S FSWVS eSWbaQVeSWTWUS` 5ZZSU]`WS\ wPS` SW\S <O\Rd]ZZ S\UZWaQVS` ?W\RS`$ RWS ROa c[ aWQV U`SWTS\RS 6vaS W\ RS` KSZb PSYs[^TS\ [waaS\& G^sbS`$ hc T`wV$ Zsaab aWS 6`]\bu c\R 8WQYS\a W\ aSW\S` FscPS`VvVZS ZWSUS\& 9` dS`aQVZW\Ub OZZSa$ U`s[b aWQV eSUS\ RS` Kv`bS`$ RWS S` \WQVb dS`abSVb$ ZWSab RWS 6wQVS` OPS` US`\$ eSWZ aWS WV` USTOZZS\$ c\R eSW\b ]Tb O[ 9\RS$ eSWZ S` esV`S\R RS` @SYbw`S e]O\RS`a eO`$ OcrS`VOZP RS` NSWb$ e] WV\ \WQVba O\ aWQV S`W\\S`b$ c\R ROa Nc`wQYY][[S\ W[[S` SW\ GQV]QY$ W[[S` b`Oc`WU Wab& GWS a^`WQVb

aWQV S`W\\S`b$ c\R ROa Nc`wQYY][[S\ W[[S` SW\ GQV]QY$ W[[S` b`Oc`WU Wab& GWS a^`WQVb wPS` RWS 6wQVS`$ S\bRSQYb d]\ AOZ hc AOZ [SV` RO`W\$ dS`abSVb aWS W[[S` PSaaS` c\R PSaQV`SWPb WV`S 9\bRSQYc\US\ W\ K]`bS\$ RWS WV\ PSUSWabS`\& 9` abWSVZb WV` RWSaS Kv`bS` c\R PS\cbhb aWS aSZPab& :w` aWQV OZZSW\$ W\ RS\ GQVcZOcTasbhS\$ W[ ;Sa^`sQV [Wb 9`eOQVaS\S\ c\R @SV`S`\& AWb jSRS[ K]`b a^w`b S`$ eWS S` aWQV SW\ GbwQY eSWb SW\S[ TSW\S`S\ =QV O\\sVS`b$ eWS aWQV eWSRS` SW\S :OZbS UZsbbSb& =V`S K]`bS VOPS\ NOcPS`Y`OTb$ eWS RWS ?ZSWRc\UaabwQYS$ RWS As`QVS\TWUc`S\ Oca WV`S[ @SPS\ VW\Ocab`OUS\& 8Oa ?ZSWR$ ROa SW\ YO[W\^cbhS\RSa 6OZU W\ SW\S D`W\hSaaW\ dS`eO\RSZb$ RS` GQVcV$ RS` aWS hc[ GQVZ]aa hc`wQYP`W\Ub$ \OQVRS[ WV` OZZSa US`OcPb e]`RS\ Wab& =\ RS` OQVbS\ ?ZOaaS USP`OcQVb ?ObVS`W\S ROa K]`b c\hcaO[[S\Vs\US\R$ c\R PWa VScbS Zsaab S` ROa W\ ;Sa^`sQVS SW\TZWSrS\ eWS SW\ ASWabS`aQVeW[[S`$ RS` vTbS` [OZ aSW\S ASROWZZS\ S`esV\b& GWS TW\RS\ VS`Oca$ ROaa WV`S :O[WZWS\ Oca UO\h \OV PSWSW\O\RS`ZWSUS\RS\ C`baQVOTbS\ W\ RS\ C`b USh]US\ aW\R& GWS TW\RS\ VS`Oca$ ROaa aWS [Wb aWSPS\ HOUS\ 5PabO\R W[ aSZPS\ ?`O\YS\VOca USP]`S\ aW\R& 9` eO` hcS`ab RO$ R]QV S` VOb 9`P`]QVS\Sa W\ RWS @c\US PSY][[S\ c\R SW\S K]QVS Zs\US` OcT RS` GscUZW\UaabObW]\ dS`P`OQVb& =\ RWSaS` Y`WbWaQVS\ 5\TO\UahSWb Wab \OQV WV`S` J]`abSZZc\U SW\ 6O\R heWaQVS\ WV\S\ USaQV[WSRSb e]`RS\ x RO[OZa$ OZa Sa \]QV YSW\S 9ZbS`\ UOP$ \c` ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`\ c\R O\RS`S CYb]PS`aSSZS\$ RWS aWQV W\a @SPS\ aQV`WS\& =[ OQVbS\ GQVcZjOV` eWZZWUb aWS SW\$ WV\ hc YwaaS\& 9a Wab RS` HOU d]` aSW\S[ R`SWhSV\bS\ ;SPc`babOU$ c\R WV`S 7ZW_cS$ RWSaSZPS 7ZW_cS eWS W[[S` x ?S\\g$ ;eS\$ 5RO[$ AWQVOSZ$ >S\\WTS` x dS`P`W\Ub SW\ ^OO` Gbc\RS\ O[ H`O[^]ZW\ VW\bS` RS[ 6W]ZORS\& <W\bS` RS[ H`O[^]ZW\ Wab RS` KOZR c\R SW\ KSU$ RS\ aWS ZO\UUSVS\$ c[ hc Y\cbaQVS\ ]RS` RWS$ RWS Y\cbaQVS\$ VSW[ZWQV hc PS]POQVbS\& 5\ RWSaS[ HOU eWZZWUb aWS SW\$ WV\ hc YwaaS\$ [Wb WV[ W\ RS\ KOZR hc USVS\& AO\ VOb Sa c\bS` RS` K]QVS PSa^`]QVS\$ c\R \c\$ O[ G]\\bOU$ Wab Sa a]eSWb$ c\R OZZS aW\R ROPSW& GWS [OQVb 5caTZwQVbS& NOcRS`b& =`US\ReOa& 9` YO\\ aWQV \WQVb US\Oc S`W\\S`\& 9` Wab T`cab`WS`b c\R USVb [Wb ?S\\g c\R SW\ ^OO` O\RS`S\ hc[ 7OTt$ c[ KOaaS` c\R GwrY`O[ hc YOcTS\& GWS PZSWPb O[ H`O[^]ZW\$ c\R S` VOb 5\Uab$ ROaa aWS$ eS\\ S` eWSRS`Y][[b$ W[[S` \]QV \WQVb [Wb WV[ W\ RS\ KOZR USVb& 8WS 6O\RS hWSVb Z]a$ wPS` RS\ DO`Y^ZObh RSa 9W\YOcTahS\b`c[a c\R wPS` RWS F]cbS /& GWS YOcTS\ WV` NScU c\R ZOcTS\ hc`wQY& 9` hcQYSZb VW\bS`VS`$ PSTw`QVbSb$ ROaa aWS \WQVb [SV` eWZZ ]RS` aWQV Tw` jS[O\R O\RS`S\ S\baQVWSRS\ VOb& 8Oaa S` RS` 9W\hWUS Wab$ RS` VScbS \WQVb W\ RS\ KOZR USVb& 5ZZS wPS`_cS`S\ eWSRS` RWS :S`\ab`OrS$ c\R S` aQVZO^^b VW\bS`VS`& ?][[b R`wPS\ O\$ c\R ^ZvbhZWQV eW`R OZZSa eSWr& G^sbS` S`W\\S`b S` aWQV O\ SW\S\ ?`O\YS\eOUS\ c\R O\ PS`cVWUS\RSa Nc`SRS\& 5\ ROa ;STwVZ$ \W`US\Re] hc aSW\ x heWaQVS\ @O\R c\R ASS`$ @SPS\ c\R H]R$ GQVZOT c\R KOQVS\ x$ OZZSa dS`aQVeW[[b \OQV OcrS\$ c\R SW\ ;STwVZ U`]rS` 6ST`SWc\U S`TwZZb WV\$ ROa ;STwVZ$ hc TZWSUS\& <S`OcaUS`WaaS\$ T]`bUSb`OUS\ hc eS`RS\& Bc` Yc`h bOcQVb S` Oca RWSaS[ BW`US\Re] OcT c\R Wab S\bbscaQVb$ OZa S` O[ \sQVabS\ HOU W\ SW\S[

RWSaS[ BW`US\Re] OcT c\R Wab S\bbscaQVb$ OZa S` O[ \sQVabS\ HOU W\ SW\S[ ?`O\YS\VOcahW[[S` hc aWQV Y][[b$ c[`W\Ub d]\ aSW\S` :O[WZWS$ SW\USVwZZb W\ 7OabdS`Ps\RS& 9a eW`R US`SRSb& 9a VSWrb$ S` c\R ?S\\g VsbbS\ USa^WSZb$ eS` hcZSbhb RS\ 5cb]a OcaeSWQVb& 8Oa eW`R OZa HObaOQVS USVO\RSZb c\R Y][[b aSW\S` AcbbS` hc CV`S\$ RWS aWQV aSV` RO`wPS` OcT`SUb& 9` aSZPab S`TsV`b d]\ RS[ ;S`SRS S`ab a^sbS` c\R RS\Yb W\aUSVSW[$ ROaa OZZSa PWa W\a GQVZW[[abS abW[[b$ ]Pe]VZ [O\ WV[ aOUb$ ROaa \WQVba RO`O\ Wab& 9` S`W\\S`b aWQV \WQVb O\ RS\ I\TOZZ$ R]QV SW\ AO\\ Oca RS[ C`b eW`R TSabUS\][[S\$ eSWZ S` c\bS` <S`]W\% c\R 5ZY]V]ZSW\TZcaa USTOV`S\ Wab& KOa Oca RWSaS[ AO\\ USe]`RS\ Wab$ S`TsV`b S` \WS& ?ObVS`W\S Y][[b [Wb RS\ O\RS`S\ W\a ?`O\YS\VOca c\R P`W\Ub WV[ 6wQVS` [Wb& 9` ZWSab aWS x OZZS x$ W\ 9`W\\S`c\U PZSWPb WV[ OPS` \c` RWS ;SaQVWQVbS d]\ RS\ ?W\RS`\$ RWS Rc`QV SW\S\ KO\RaQV`O\Y W\ SW\S KSZb RSa c\O\TSQVbPO` ;cbS\ c\R RSa aQV`SQYZWQV 6vaS\ USZO\US\$ [Wb 9WaYv\WUW\\S\ c\R @veS\3 RWS dS`UWaab S` \WS& 5cQV W\ dWSZS\ O\RS`S\ 6wQVS`\$ RWS aWS WV[ aQVS\Yb$ UWPb Sa SW\S NOcPS`bw`$ Rc`QV RWS [O\ b`Wbb x SW\S a^`cRSZ\RS EcSZZS$ RS`S\ KOaaS` SW\S` :O[WZWS RWS I\abS`PZWQVYSWb dS`ZSWVb$ SW\S\ ;]ZR`W\U$ RS` SW\S\ USevV\ZWQVS\ <]PPWbjc\US\ hc` <]TT\c\U Tw` ROa ;cbS W\ aSW\S` KSZb eS`RS\ Zsaab$ SW\S\ GQV`O\Y$ Rc`QV RS\ ?W\RS` SW\S[ c\UZwQYZWQVS\ NcVOcaS S\bY][[S\ x$ W`US\RSW\S\ c\aQVSW\PO`S\ 5ZZbOUaUSUS\abO\R$ RS` OZa DT]`bS hc SW\S` KSZb RS` Kc\RS` RWS\b& KSWZ S` \]QV \WQVb O\ ?`wQYS\ USVS\ YO\\$ eW`R WV[ SW\ 6Sbb W\ RS[ NW[[S` VS`US`WQVbSb$ ROa aSW\S :O[WZWS nROa <W\bS`hW[[S`l \S\\b& 8S` FOc[ Wab heSW 9bOUS\ V]QV$ c\R hc RS\ 6wQVS`\ c\R G^WSZS\ ]PS\ Y][[b [O\ wPS` SW\S <]ZhZSWbS`& 5\ RS` FwQYeO\R RSa <W\bS`hW[[S`a Wab SW\ `WSaS\U`]rSa :S\abS` [Wb SW\S[ OZbS\ 5V]`\POc[ ROd]`$ RS` O\ RS` GQVSWPS c\R O\ RS` GSWbS\eO\R RSa <OcaSa Y`Obhb& 8OVW\bS` SW\ FOaS\& <W\bS` RS[ FOaS\ RS` KOZR& 8WS GQVZOThW[[S` RSa <OcaSa aW\R W[ S`abS\ Gb]QY c\R eSU d]\ WV[$ a] ROaa S` \OQVba aSV` OZZSW\ Wab& 8S` 6Oc[ aQV`O[[b O\a :S\abS`$ d][ KOZR VS` Y\OQYb c\R Y\OZZb Sa$ c\R ROa `]bS @WQVb O[ :ScS`[SZRS` PZW\Yb eWS SW\S dS`ec\aQVS\S DS`ZS& 9` ZWSab W[[S` [SV` W\ RWSaS` NSWb& NWSVb aWQV eSWbS` W\ aWQV aSZPab hc`wQY c\R TwVZb aWQV hS`P`SQVZWQV W\ RS[ YZSW\S\ 6Sbb O[ 6]RS\ RSa NW[[S`a [Wb RS[ U`]rS\ :S\abS`& :`Sc\RS Y][[S\ c\R PZSWPS\ wPS` BOQVb$ @SV`S` P`W\US\ <OcaO`PSWbS\& GSW\S AcbbS` a^WSZb ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS` c\R Yw[[S`b aWQV c[ aSW\S 7OabdS`Ps\RS c\R RWS ?`O\YS\Ug[\OabWY$ RWS S` bsUZWQV [OQVS\ a]ZZ& GWS P`W\Ub WV[ 9aaS\ c\R b`]QY\Sb WV[ ROa ;SaWQVb$ c\R bOUawPS`$ eS\\ aWS PSW WV[ Wab$ TwVZb S` aWQV aWQVS`& :Oab ew\aQVb S` aWQV$ RWS NSWb hc <OcaS ew`RS SeWU ROcS`\& 9beO SW\S\ A]\Ob a^sbS` USVb S` O\ ?`wQYS\ eWSRS` hc` GQVcZS c\R Wab heO` T`]V$ VS`c[ZOcTS\ hc Yv\\S\$ PSROcS`b OPS` R]QV$ ROaa WV\ YSW\S` [SV` PS[cbbS`b c\R c[a]`Ub&

6Sd]` S` OPS` \OQV <OcaS Y][[b$ PSd]` S` ROa ?`O\YS\VOca dS`Zsaab$ ]RS` dWSZ[SV` O[ S`abS\ HOU R]`b$ P`W\Ub WV[ RWS ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS` SW\S 6Sbb^TO\\S$ W\ RWS S` ^W\YSZ\ a]ZZ& 9` Wab PSeSUc\Uac\TsVWU$ YO\\ \WQVb W\a 6OR c\R aWSVb aQVZOUO`bWU W\ RS\ ?\]QVS\P`wQVS\ SbeOa ;cbSa$ SW\S\ ;ZwQYaTOZZ& 9W\S AvUZWQVYSWb$ ROa W[[S`UZSWQVS AcabS` Oca :c[[SZ\$ <S`c[a^`W\US\$ FOaS\ c\R 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U hc Rc`QVP`SQVS\& ;S`ORS R`SWhSV\ USe]`RS\$ c\R SW\ YZSW\S` FWaa bcb aWQV OcT W\ RS` PWaVS` eWS hcUS[OcS`bS\ Hw`& 9W\ ec\RS`PO`S` <]TT\c\UaaQVW[[S`& 9` ^W\YSZb W\ RWS 6Sbb^TO\\S$ c\R Sa Wab SW\ ;STwVZ$ OZa ]P S` bOcaS\R ;ZOaa^ZWbbS` OcaaQVSWRSb$ OPS` RWS <s\RS USVS\ \WQVb Ocb][ObWaQV hc[ DS\Wa& =[ ?`O\YS\VOca YO\\ S` jSRSa AOZ ^W\YSZ\$ ]V\S aWQV O\hcTOaaS\& 5\RS`bVOZP >OV`S a^sbS`$ ^c[[SZWU$ PO`bZ]a$ hc VwPaQV c\R ]Tb Tw` SW\ AsRQVS\ USVOZbS\$ USVb S` OZa 5cabOcaQVaQVwZS` \OQV 5cab`OZWS\& NeWaQVS\ RWSaS` NSWb c\R RS[ ?`O\YS\VOcaOcTS\bVOZb UWPb Sa dWSZS 5cUS\PZWQYS RSa H`Wc[^Va$ eS\\ S` d]` SW\S[ 6SQYS\ abSVb c\R ]V\S ROa OZbS FWbcOZ ^W\YSZb& CTb UWPb Sa OcQV FwQYaQVZsUS$ a] ROaa S` aWQV SW\aQVZWSrS\ c\R TOab SW\S Gbc\RS [Wb aWQV Ys[^TS\ [caa& 8Oa USVb a]$ PWa RWSaS DVOaS$ RWS WV[ W[[S` SW\ FsbaSZ PZSWPS\ eW`R$ OZZ[sVZWQV OcaYZW\Ub& 9` Wab \]QV W\ 5cab`OZWS\$ OZa WV[ S\RZWQV <OO`S c\bS` RS\ 5`[S\ c\R W[ GQV`Wbb eOQVaS\$ OZa aWQV AcaYSZ\ c\bS` RS[ 6OPga^SQY PWZRS\ c\R S` esQVab$ W\ RWS @s\US USVb& 8WSaS 9\beWQYZc\U d]ZZhWSVb aWQV a] ZSWaS c\R VO`[]\WaQV$ ROaa S` UO` \WQVba ROd]\ [WbPSY][[b c\R S`ab PSW aSW\S` <SW[YSV` [S`Yb$ ROaa aWQV ROa 9\S`UWSTSZR c[ WV\ VS` dS`s\RS`b VOb$ ROaa [O\ O\RS`a OcT WV\ `SOUWS`b& I\R OZa OZZ ROa$ e]Tw` S` USPSbSb VOb$ aWQV SW\abSZZb c\R USaQVWSVb$ aQVZSWQVb aWQV aSW\S OZbS BS[SaWa ROd]\& 9` YSV`b \OQV SW\S[ VOZPS\ >OV` 5cab`OZWS\ hc`wQY c\R US`sb \WS eWSRS`$ \WQVb SW\ SW\hWUSa AOZ$ d]` SW\S` H]WZSbbS W\ DO\WY& 5ZZSa eW`R dS`USaaS\2 jSRS dS``WSUSZbS Hw`$ jSRS Gbc\RS$ RWS S` aWQV OcT H]WZSbbS\ US^ZOUb VOb$ jSRS :ZcQVb W\ RS\ KOZR$ e] WV\ YSW\S` aSVS\ Y]\\bS& 9`ab [Wb aSQVac\RheO\hWU S`W\\S`b S` aWQV$ ROaa S` SW\[OZ GQVeWS`WUYSWbS\ VObbS& I\R RO TsZZb WV[ RO\\ OZZSa SW\& BWS eW`R Sa SW\S 9`YZs`c\U Tw` ROa @SWRS\ aSW\S` ?W\RVSWb USPS\& BWQVba OZa HVS]`WS\$ SW\S AWaQVc\U Oca DagQV]Z]UWS c\R YW\RS`s`hbZWQVS` 8WOU\]aS$ OPS` \WQVba ?]\Y`SbSa ]RS` 9W\RScbWUSa& ?ObVS`W\S c\R S` dS`OP`SRS\ c\R YwaaS\ aWQV c\R USVS\ [WbSW\O\RS` c\R [SWRS\ aWQV PWa hc` R`O[ObWaQVS\ JS`avV\c\U RWS UO\hS ;`c\RaQVcZS c\R <WUVaQV]]Z VW\Rc`QV PWa hc[ GbcRWc[ c\R RO`wPS` VW\Oca& GWS USVb \OQV GQV]bbZO\R$ OcT SW\S PS`wV[bS I\WdS`aWbsb W\ SW\S` OZbS\ GbORb O[ ASS`$ c\R ZWSab RWS H`WZ]UWS SW\Sa U`]rS\ aQV]bbWaQVS\ GQV`WTbabSZZS`a wPS` SW\ AsRQVS\ c\R WV`S :O[WZWS x wPS` OZZSa x$ Oca RS` aWS ]Tb hWbWS`b& GQVZWSrZWQV P`WQVb aWS ROa GbcRWc[ OP c\R ZO\RSb W\ A]\bO\O& 9W\ ^OO` >OV`S a^sbS` USVb OcQV S` hc[ GbcRWc[ \OQV GQV]bbZO\R x OcT SW\S \WQVb O\\sVS`\R a] PS`wV[bS I\WdS`aWbsb W\ SW\S` OZbS\ GbORb W\ RS\ 6S`US\ x$ ZWSab RWSaSZPS H`WZ]UWS c\R Vv`b aSW\ UO\hSa @SPS\ \WQVb [SV`

OZbS\ GbORb W\ RS\ 6S`US\ x$ ZWSab RWSaSZPS H`WZ]UWS c\R Vv`b aSW\ UO\hSa @SPS\ \WQVb [SV` OcT$ RO`Oca hc hWbWS`S\& =V`S :`Sc\RS c\R WV` AO\\ ZOaaS\ \WQVb hc$ ROaa aWS WV\ eWSRS`aWSVb& GSW\S :`Sc\RW\\S\ c\R :`Sc\RS PSb`OQVbS\ aWS [Wb 5`Ue]V\& 5Za 9`eOQVaS\S PZSWPS\ aWS OcT 8WabO\h& GWS aQV`SWPS\ aWQV ]Tb& 9` ZWSab OZZS 6wQVS`$ RWS aWS jS[OZa Ucb TO\R& 9` b`sUb WV`S 5\aWQVbS\ c\R =\bS`^`SbObW]\S\ [Wb aWQV VS`c[$ OZa es`S\ Sa aSW\S SWUS\S\$ PWa S` aQVZWSrZWQV W`US\ReO\\ \OQV GQV]bbZO\R O\Ts\Ub$ aWQV aSZPS` 6wQVS` OcahcacQVS\ c\R aWQV \OQV c\R \OQV SW\S SWUS\S ASW\c\U hc PWZRS\& 8Oa Wab aSW\S FSWTS^`wTc\U$ c\R aWS eWaaS\ Sa PSWRS$ aWS ZO\US d]` WV[& 8]QV SVS ROa USaQVWSVb$ W\ RS[ G][[S`$ PSd]` S` OcT SW\S YZSW\S I\WdS`aWbsb O\ RS` CabYwabS AO`gZO\Ra USVb$ b`W\YS\ aWS SW\S :ZOaQVS aSV` bSc`S\ KSW\ Oca SW\S` d]\ heSW ?WabS\$ RWS WV`S AcbbS` Tw` SW\S :`Sc\RW\ OcTPSeOV`b$ RWS W\ SW\S[ S`PWbbS`bS\ GQVSWRc\UaY`WSU abSQYb& 9`ab >OV`S \OQVRS[ aWS PSWRS ?WabS\ \WSRS`US[OQVb VOPS\$ S`TOV`S\ aWS$ ROaa Sa eW`YZWQV aw\RVOTb bSc`S` KSW\ eO`& 8WSaS S`abS S`ZSaS\S :ZOaQVS [Wb RS[ ;`SWT OcT RS[ 9bWYSbb b`W\YS\ aWS OcT SW\S[ 6S`U$ RS` aWQV RS` =\RWO\S` \S\\b& GWS eW`Tb WV[ GbSW\QVS\ W\ RWS GV]`ba$ PWa YZO` Wab$ ROaa aWS eWZZ$ ROaa S` RWS <]aS OcahWSVb& GWS hWSVb WV`S OcQV Oca$ c\R S` bcb ROa$ eOa S` \]QV \WS USbO\ VOb$ aWS OPS` aQV]\& :w` WV\ Wab Sa SW\ Kc\RS`$ ROaa Sa wPS`VOc^b USaQVWSVb3 [Wb WV` Wab Sa SbeOa <SWZWUSa$ WV\S\ 6SabW[[bSa$ OPS` Sa VOb OcQV SbeOa d]\ =\hSab& >OV`SZO\U eW`R S` aWQV S`W\\S`\$ ROaa Sa OcT SW\S` KWSaS WV`Sa JObS`a ^OaaWS`b Wab$ SW\Sa 5PS\Ra OcT RS[ KSU hc SW\S[ G^WSZ& 8]QV aWS SW\WUS\ aWQV aQVZWSrZWQV OcT WV`S 9`W\\S`c\U$ WV`S JS`aW]\&

I^b]e\
KOa4 KWS YO\\ ROa aSW\4 =[[S` eWSRS` aSVS WQV Rc`QV ROa ;cQYZ]QV$ c\R jSRSa AOZ V]TTS WQV$ ROaa RWS KOV\d]`abSZZc\U$ B]OV abw\RS R`OcrS\$ dS`aQVeW\RSb c\R \WS[O\R OcT RS[ :Zc` Wab& 5PS` S` Wab jSRSa AOZ eWSRS` RO& I\R \WQVb \c` S`& 9W\ RWQYS` AO\\ W\ SW\S[ aQVeS`S\ H`S\QVQ]Ob abSVb \SPS\ WV[& 9` bSZST]\WS`b wPS` SW\ <O\Rg$ c\R WQV PW\ aWQVS`$ S` Wab d]\ RS` ?`W^] ]RS` RS` 8`]US\PSYs[^Tc\U& ?][[$ ZOaa c\a `SW\$ `cTb B]OV& ?SW\ ;`c\R hc` 6Sc\`cVWUc\U$ eW` e]ZZS\ RW` VSZTS\& >SaaS$ RS` AO\\ OcT RS[ 6Sbb$ S`abO``b c\R T`OUb$ eOa Z]a Wab& =QV aOUS WV[ ZSWaS$ S` a]ZZS aWQV a] aQV\SZZ eWS [vUZWQV O\hWSVS\$ [SW\ :`Sc\R aSW R`OcrS\& KWS RS` 6ZWbh TsV`b S` W\ aSW\S ?ZSWRS` c\R abSVb W\\S`VOZP d]\ GSYc\RS\ W[ AO\bSZ RO& 5Za S` hc` Hw` eWZZ$ PWbbS WQV WV\ hc eO`bS\& BS`dva$ [Wb OcTUS`WaaS\S\ 5cUS\ hWaQVb S`2 AOQV VW\$ WQV PZSWP VWS` \WQVb& G] aQV\SZZ WQV YO\\$ \SV[S WQV RS\ 5aQVS\PSQVS` d][ BOQVbbWaQV c\R aQVwbbS ROa \]QV d]`VO\RS\S 7`OQY W\ SW\S DZOabWYbwbS$ RWS WQV hcaO[[S\ [Wb RS` ZSbhbS\ DTSWTS W\ RWS =\\S\bOaQVS [SW\S` W[ GQV`O\Y Vs\US\RS\ >OQYS abSQYS& AWb SW\S[ HcQV eWaQVS WQV TZwQVbWU RWS ?`w[SZ c\R FSabS d][ BOQVbbWaQV$ RO\\ UcQYS WQV$ ]P a]\ab \]QV SbeOa W[ NW[[S` dS``sb$ eOa VWS` USZOcTS\ Wab& >SaaS USVb hc` Hw`$ OZa WQV [SW\S >SO\a c\R [SW\S\ DcZZ]dS` d][ 6]RS\ OcT`OTTS& >SaaS [OQVb RWS Hw` OcT$ ]V\S aWQV \]QV [OZ c[hcR`SVS\ ]RS` baQVwa hc aOUS\$ c\R aQVWSPb aWQV O\ B]OV c\R RS[ AO\\ W[ H`S\QVQ]Ob d]`PSW& 5Za B]OV SW\b`Wbb$ aWbhS WQV OcT RS[ 6Sbb& ;SVS\ eW`$ aOUb S`$ ]V\S wPS` RS\ Hg^S\$ RS` US`ORS OPUSVOcS\ Wab$ OcQV \c` SW\ K]`b hc dS`ZWS`S\& 8S` AO\\ W[ H`S\QVQ]Ob VSWrb >]V\ c\R aOUb [W`$ S` VOPS OZa SVS[OZWUS` 8`]US\%7]^ aSW\S 6ShWSVc\US\ a^WSZS\ ZOaaS\ c\R Rc`QV SW\S\ 5\`cT PSW RS` 6SVv`RS VS`OcaUSTc\RS\$ ROaa Sa SW\S 5YbS wPS` [WQV UWPb& 8O\\ aOUb B]OV [W`$ ROaa RWS D]ZWhSW W\ C\S :WTbV eO`$ c[ [WQV hc PST`OUS\& =[ NcUS SW\S` 8`]US\`OhhWO aSW [SW\ BO[S OcTUSbOcQVb& AO`Y4$ wPS`ZSUS WQV& GbS^VS\4 ASW\ ]V\SVW\ aQV]\ VSTbWUSa <S`hYZ]^TS\ eW`R Oca \Sc USaQVw`bS` 5\Uab hc SW\S[ <s[[S`\& GWS e]ZZS\ [WQV dS`VOTbS\$ RS\YS WQV c\R PZWQYS hc >]V\$ RS` US\Oca] OcaaWSVb eWS RWS DS\\Sga& KWS PWab Rc RS\\ O\ RS\ US`ObS\4$ T`OUS WQV B]OV& =QV PW\ wPS`hScUb$ ROaa RS` ?S`Z B]OV O\USZ]US\ VOb c\R \WQVba ;cbSa W[ GQVWZRS TwV`b& B]OV aOUb$ SW\ 5\eOZb VOPS WV\ S[^T]VZS\$ c\R WQV eWZZ eWaaS\$ eSZQVS`& 8S` BO[S aOUb [W` \WQVba$ c\R jS Zs\US` WQV [W` >]V\ O\aSVS$ RSab] aWQVS`S` PW\ WQV$ ROaa S` B]OV \OQV OZZS\ FSUSZ\ RS` ?c\ab SW\USaSWTb

>]V\ O\aSVS$ RSab] aWQVS`S` PW\ WQV$ ROaa S` B]OV \OQV OZZS\ FSUSZ\ RS` ?c\ab SW\USaSWTb VOb$ c[ [WQV W\ RS\ ?\Oab hc P`W\US\& KW` [waaS\ Z]a$ aOUb >]V\& GWS [waaS\ `Oca VWS`& =QV P`OcQVS wPS` SW\S Gbc\RS$ c[ [WQV TS`bWUhc[OQVS\$ c\R b`]bhRS[ USVb [W` ROa OZZSa hc aQV\SZZ& =QV aOUS$ WQV [vQVbS Yc`h OZZSW\ aSW\$ c\R POcS c\R `OcQVS heSW TSbbS <Wba OcT RS` H]WZSbbS& 8O\OQV ZOaaS WQV RWS DTSWTS OPYwVZS\ c\R abSQYS ROa `SabZWQVS 7`OQY VW\SW\$ RO[Wb WQV aWS \WQVb S`ab ab]^TS\ [caa$ eS\\ WQV [WQV ROa \sQVabS AOZ ROd]\abSVZS\ YO\\$ c[ hc `OcQVS\& 8S` FOcaQV dS`b`SWPb SW\ eS\WU RWS OYcbS 5\Uab3 WQV eOaQVS [W` ;SaWQVb c\R <s\RS c\R TOV`S [W` [Wb RS\ :W\US`\ Rc`QV RWS <OO`S& =QV hWSVS [SW\S\ F]ZZY`OUS\^cZZ]dS` O\$ [S`YS$ ROaa FOcQV W[ 6OR abSVb$ c\R aQVOZbS RS\ JS\bWZOb]` SW\& B]OV YZ]^Tb O\ RWS 6ORShW[[S`bw`$ c\R WQV VOZbS WV\ VW\& 8WS 5\Uab YSV`b hc`wQY$ esV`S\R RS` FOcQV Rc`QV RWS @wTbc\UaYZO^^S OPhWSVb& =QV aSbhS [WQV OcTa ?Z]$ \SV[S SW\S\ bWSTS\ NcU Oca RS` DTSWTS c\R PSbS c[ SW\S\ <S`hO\TOZZ& KW` dS`ZOaaS\ ROa <]bSZ$ ]V\S [WQV OPhc[SZRS\$ c\R a^`W\US\ OcT RS` ;O\aSd]]`b Gb`SSb W\ SW\ HOfW& >]V\ [SW\b$ WQV YO\\ d]\ ;ZwQY aOUS\$ ROaa WQV \]QV \WQVb TSabUS\][[S\ e]`RS\ PW\& =QV PZWQYS hc[ :OV`S` c\R OcT ROa dS`RSQYbS :]b] VW\bS` WV[ O\ RS` H`S\\aQVSWPS& <S``U]bb$ RS\YS WQV$ eOa a]\ab4 =QV S`hsVZS B]OV$ ROaa W\ ^`OYbWaQV jSRS[ HOfW$ [Wb RS[ WQV RWS ZSbhbS\ dWS`hSV\ HOUS USTOV`S\ PW\$ ROa :OV`S`T]b] d]\ DO^^S ]RS` DO^WS` dS`RSQYb eO`& 8Oaa [W` RWS :OV`S` eWS :OV\RS` ]RS` 8`]US\%7]^a d]`Y][[S\& =QV dS`acQVS WV[ YZO`hc[OQVS\$ eOa Sa [Wb RS\ HOfWTOV`S`\ c\R RS\ DS\\Sga OcT aWQV VOb c\R ROaa >]V\ c\R RS` jSbhWUS :OV`S` OcQV ROhcUSVv`S\ c\R ROaa S` [WQV WV\S\ \WS[OZa VsbbS OcaZWSTS`\ Rw`TS\& 8c VOab jO YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eOa Rc [W` RO[Wb O\bcab$ TZwabS`S WQV dS`heSWTSZb$ esV`S\R S` [W` RWS <O\R bsbaQVSZb& =QV PSbOabS RWS DTSWTS W\ [SW\S` HOaQVS c\R eSWr$ ROaa \]QV [W\RSabS\a heSW UcbS <Wba R`W\ aW\R& 8O[Wb `SWQVb Sa OPS` OcQV$ c[ [W` PSOPaWQVbWUbS\ <O\RSZ O\hcVs\US\$ RS\YS WQV c\R wPS`ZSUS$ e] WQV aWS dS`abOcS\ Yv\\bS$ TOZZa [WQV RWS PSWRS\ hc SW\S` D]ZWhSWabObW]\ P`W\US\& 8O\\ TsZZb [W` SW\$ ROaa RS` HOfWTOV`S` SW\ JS`RSQYbS` Wab$ c\R esV`S\R RWS @WQVbS` RS` GbORb R`OcrS\ d]`PSWab`SWQVS\$ TO\US WQV O\$ d]` DO\WY hc hWbbS`\& B]OV ZSUb RS\ 5`[ c[ [WQV c\R aOUb$ eW` TOV`S\ W`US\Re]VW\$ e] [O\ aWQV c\USabv`b c\bS`VOZbS\ YO\\& =QV T`OUS$ e] ROa aSW\ a]ZZ$ c\R S` c\R >]V\ eS`TS\ aWQV 6ZWQYS hc& 8O aWS Sa O\aQVSW\S\R aSZPab \WQVb eWaaS\$ T`OUS WQV$ ]P eW` eOa SaaS\ USVS\ Yv\\S\$ c\R RO[Wb [SW\S WQV$ OcQV eS\\ WQV Sa \WQVb aOUS$ eOa b`W\YS\& =QV P`OcQVS 5ZY]V]Z hc` 6S`cVWUc\U& KW` ZO\RS\ W\ RS\ GSdS\bWSa VW\bS` RS` HVW`R 5dS\cS c\R TW\RS\ SW\ QVW\SaWaQVSa FSabOc`O\b [Wb SW\S[ TOab ZSS`S\ G^SWaS`Oc[ W[ G]cbS``OW\& G]T]`b S\baQVcZRWUS WQV [WQV c\R USVS hc` H]WZSbbS$ c[ \]QV [OZ ]`RS\bZWQV O\ RS` DTSWTS hc hWSVS\& ;ZSWQV RO`OcT

c\R USVS hc` H]WZSbbS$ c[ \]QV [OZ ]`RS\bZWQV O\ RS` DTSWTS hc hWSVS\& ;ZSWQV RO`OcT [SW\S WQV ZOcbabO`YSa ;S`SRS d]` RS` Hw` hc Vv`S\$ W\ RS[ Sa RO`c[ USVb$ eO\\ S` YOaaWS`b eW`R& =QV hWSVS eSWbS` O\ RS` DTSWTS& GWS UZwVb W\ [SW\S` <O\R$ c\R WQV PSbc^TS RWS Fs\RS` hc` 5PYwVZc\U [Wb YOZbS[ KOaaS`& KWSRS` O[ HWaQV$ PWbbS WQV RWS ?SZZ\S`W\ c[ SW\S\ K]RYO$ PSY][[S hc` 5\be]`b$ ROaa aWS \c` KSW\ c\R 6WS` VOPS\$ c\R PSabSZZS SW\S :ZOaQVS USYwVZbS\ KSWrS\& B]OV Wab RO[Wb \WQVb SW\dS`abO\RS\$ OPS` >]V\ eS\RSb aWQV O\ RWS ?SZZ\S`W\ c\R UWPb WV` U`w\Sa @WQVb& 8S` KSW\ Y][[b$ c\R WQV YW^^S WV\ `c\bS` eWS KOaaS`& KOa hc SaaS\ PSabSZZS WQV OcQV$ `wV`S Sa RO\\ OPS` \WQVb O\& >]V\ S`YZs`b$ c[ SW\S` :Sab\OV[S hc S\bUSVS\$ [waaS WQV [WQV a]T]`b W\ ^agQVWOb`WaQVS 6SVO\RZc\U PSUSPS\& B]OV \WQYb ROhc$ c\R WQV eSWr \WQVb$ eOa WQV ROd]\ VOZbS\ a]ZZ& >]V\ S`Us\hb$ ROaa S` [Wb SW\S[ 5`hb hcaO[[S\O`PSWbSb$ RS` W\ RS` ^agQVWOb`WaQVS\ GbObW]\ RSa BSe M]`YS` D`SaPgbS`WO\ <]a^WbOZ SW\ 6Sbb Tw` [WQV `SaS`dWS`b VOb& 6SW RWSaS\ K]`bS\ PZWbhb SW\ 6WZR d]\ eSWrS\ @OYS\$ T`Sc\RZWQVS\ GQVeSabS`\ c\R dS`aQVZ]aaS\S\ Hw`S\ VW\bS` [SW\S\ 5cUS\ OcT$ c\R hc[ S`abS\ AOZ$ aSWb B]OV c\R >]V\ W[ <]bSZ OcTUSbOcQVb aW\R$ dS`a^w`S WQV 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U& =QV abSZZS [W` ZO\US\ GQVZOT c\R 6S`cVWUc\Ua[WbbSZ d]` c\R S`YZs`S [WQV ]V\S eSWbS`Sa PS`SWb$ hc RWSaS[ DagQVWObS` hc USVS\& 9W\WUS 6Z]QYa S\bTS`\b PSb`SbS\ eW` SW\ ;SPscRS$ ROa eWS SW\S dS`ZOaaS\S ;`c\RaQVcZS OcaaWSVb& KW` USVS\ Rc`QV P`SWbS$ ZSS`S ?]``WR]`S c\R USZO\US\ hc SW\S` Hw`$ RWS US`ORSeSUa SW\S[ ?`W[W\OZTWZ[ Oca RS\ JWS`hWUS`jOV`S\ S\babO[[b x AWZQVUZOa c\R [Wb GQVOPZ]\S OcTUS[OZbS GQV`WTb& KWSRS` abSWUb W\ [W` eWS ;OZZS ROa ;STwVZ OcT$ ROaa >]V\ SW\ `OTTW\WS`bSa HscaQVc\Ua[O\vdS` OcTUSh]US\ VOb$ c[ [WQV TSabhc\SV[S\& 8S` KSW\ VObbS [SW\S \UabS PSaQVeWQVbWUb$ OPS` jSbhb aW\R aWS W\ d]ZZS[ 5ca[Or eWSRS` RO& 9W\S Y`OcaVOO`WUS :`Oc W\ >SO\a c\R DOWaZSgPZcaS Y][[b O\ RWS Hw` c\R PSU`wrb >]V\ [Wb SW\S[ P`SWbS\ @sQVSZ\& NWdWZTOV\RS`W\$ RS\YS WQV a]T]`b& GWS R`wQYb [W` aO\Tb RS\ 5`[ c\R PWbbSb c\a$ WV` hc T]ZUS\& 9` [OQVb US`ORS \]QV jS[O\RS\ TS`bWU$ `cTb aWS VW\bS` aWQV$ OZa aWS c\a O\ SW\S[ FOc[ [Wb ZSS`S\ GQV`SWPbWaQVS\ d]`PSW hc SW\S[ 9QYPw`] TwV`b& =QV T`OUS aWS \OQV SW\S` H]WZSbbS$ c\R SVS B]OV c\R >]V\ SbeOa aOUS\ Yv\\S\$ S`PWSbSb aWS aWQV$ [W` RS\ KSU hc hSWUS\& =QV USVS [Wb WV` hc`wQY \OQV d]`\$ hc SW\S` Hw` [Wb RS` 5cTaQV`WTb <9FF9B& 8WS H]WZSbbS Wab ZSS`& GQV\SZZ R`SVS WQV RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ O[ KOaQVPSQYS\ OcT c\R a^`W\US W\ SW\S ?OPW\S& 8WS DTSWTS Wab \]QV d]ZZUSab]^Tb [Wb 7`OQY3 a]POZR WQV [SW\ :ScS`hScU USTc\RS\ VOPS$ abSQYS WQV aWS O\$ hWSVS a] dWSZ FOcQV SW\$ eWS [SW\S @c\US TOaab$ PSVOZbS WV\ R`W\$ a] ZO\US WQV YO\\$ c\R PZOaS RWS RWQYS FOcQVe]ZYS Oca RS[ :S\abS` \SPS\ RS` ?OPW\S& 8Oa SW\TOZZS\RS @WQVb a^`S\YSZb RS\ aQVeO`heSWr USTZWSabS\ 6]RS\$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U dS`USaaS WQV RWS @ScbS$ RWS OcT [WQV eO`bS\& 9a YZ]^Tb O\ RWS aWQV vTT\S\RS H]WZSbbS\bw`$ c\R B]OV abSVb d]` [W`& 5ZZSa ]YOg4$ T`OUb S` c\R `SUWab`WS`b aWQVbZWQV RS\ FOcQVUS`cQV& <Oab Rc RWQV O\USY\OZZb4 x

BSW\$ aOUS WQV$ ZOaa c\a USVS\& 9` R`wQYb [WQV c\R aOUb [W`$ eWS S`ZSWQVbS`b S` Wab$ ROaa WQV \]QV O[ @SPS\ PW\$ c\R WQV [vQVbS O[ ZWSPabS\ W\ aSW\S 5`[S aW\YS\$ RS\ UO\hS\ dS`TOV`S\S\ AWab d]\ WV[ Oca RS` KSZb aQVOTTS\ ZOaaS\$ OPS` Sa Y][[b [W` d]`$ OZa ]P S` [WQV \c` O\ aWQV R`wQYb$ c[ [SW\S GOQVS\ \OQV DTSWTS c\R :ScS`hScU OPhcbOabS\& =QV eW\RS [WQV Z]a c\R USVS VW\Oca OcT RS\ :Zc`& 8S` DagQVWObS` aWSVb Oca eWS Oca RS\ OQVbhWUS` >OV`S\& F]beSWr USab`SWTbSa <S[R$ <]aS\b`sUS`$ RWQYS <]`\P`WZZS$ 6`SWbQ]`RV]aS$ USZPS G]QYS\ c\R PST`O\abS A]YOaaW\a& 9` VOb @]QYS\VOO`S c\R PSRS\Yb [WQV [Wb RS[ [wRS\ @sQVSZ\ d]\ jS[O\RS[$ RS` aSZPab SW\WUSa O\ 8`]US\ ^`]PWS`b VOb& =\ RS` ?ZW\WY aSW SW\ 6Sbb Tw` [WQV T`SW$ aOUb S`$ OPS` ROa PZWSPS \WQVb ZO\US a]& 9` aQVWQYb B]OV c\R >]V\ `Oca$ c\R eW` aWbhS\ c\a SW\ KSWZQVS\ aQVeSWUS\R USUS\wPS`& GW\R GWS VWUV4$ T`OUb S`$ c\R WQV PSjOVS& ;cb$ aOUb S`$ US\WSrS\ GWS ROa `cVWU& 9` T`OUb$ eOa WQV [OQVS$ Zsaab aWQV wPS` RWS 6wQVS` Oca$ RWS WV[ USTOZZS\$ RO\\ PSS\RSb S` Yc`hS`VO\R RWS GWbhc\U c\R aOUb2 9a Wab =V`S 9\baQVSWRc\U& 8O\\ ZOaa WQVya$ aOUS WQV W[ 5cTabSVS\& B]OV c\R >]V\ a^`W\US\ OcT$ OZa WQV VS`OcaY][[S$ T`OUS\$ eWS Sa USZOcTS\ Wab$ c\R WQV aOUS WV\S\$ ROaa Sa aWQV S`ZSRWUb VOb$ ROaa WQV USVS& >]V\ aOUb [W`$ ROaa WQV RO[Wb `SQV\S\ [caa$ TSabUS\][[S\ hc eS`RS\$ SVS RS` HOU d]`PSW Wab& 8Oa aOUb S` aSV` S`\ab$ S` aQVSW\b jSbhb eW`YZWQV PSc\`cVWUb hc aSW\& =QV aQVO``S [Wb RS\ :wrS\ c\R eSWr \WQVb$ eOa WQV bc\ a]ZZ& =QV PW\ heO` W\ DO\WY$ OPS` WQV VOPS \OQV eWS d]` ;SZR OcT RS[ ?]\b] c\R RS\YS$ eS\\ WQV [W` SW\S\ 6S`U GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\ c\R heSW @WbS` K]RYO PSa]`US\ YO\\$ VOZbS WQV \]QV SW\ ^OO` HOUS Rc`QV c\R YO\\ RS[ ;O\hS\ RO\\ SW\ 9\RS [OQVS\& =QV abSVS W[ KO`bShW[[S` RSa DagQVWObS`a$ ZOcbS` @ScbS$ RWS WQV \WQVb YS\\S$ c[ [WQV VS`c[$ c\R eO\YS d]\ RS\ dWSZS\ Rc`QVeOQVbS\ BsQVbS\$ RS[ US`ORS OcT RS` H]WZSbbS US`OcQVbS\ 7`OQY c\R RS[ KSW\ d]\ d]`VW\& 8WS 6cZZS\abW[[S\ d]` RS` K]V\c\U$ RWS 5YbS RS` FOcaQVUWTbPSVv`RS$ RWS R`]VS\RS :Sab\OV[S aQVeW``S\ [W` W[ ?]^T VS`c[& =QV S`abO``S& =QV abSVS RO c\R VOPS YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eOa bc\& =QV eWZZ eSUZOcTS\& AWQV TOZZS\ZOaaS\& Bc` TSabUS\][[S\ eS`RS\ eWZZ WQV \WQVb& =QV eWZZ$ ROaa B]OV [WQV TSabVsZb& =QV eWZZ [WQV O\Y\OZZS\ c\R ROa OZZSa eSUeWaQVS\& =QV eWZZ eSUUSeWaQVb eS`RS\& KO`bS\ eW` S`ab [OZ OP$ aOUb >]V\ aQVZWSrZWQV$ W[[S` [Wb RS` FcVS& =QV YS\\S jS[O\RS\ W[ 7O`ZgZS <]bSZ \WQVb eSWb d]\ VWS`$ RS` YO\\ =V\S\ SW\ aWQVS`Sa NW[[S` hc[ 5ca`cVS\ c\R BOQVRS\YS\ PSa]`US\& 6`W\US\ eW` GWS jSbhb S`ab [OZ W\ GWQVS`VSWb& =\ GWQVS`VSWb YZW\Ub Ucb$ c\R hc[ S`abS\ AOZ O\ RWSaS[ HOU dS`b`OcS WQV >]V\$ VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ ROaa S` RS` Wab$ RS` S` hc aSW\ PSVOc^bSb$ c\R [WQV \c` ROd]` PSeOV`S\ eWZZ$ ROaa WQV W\ RWS GbORb OPVOcS c\R YOaaWS`b eS`RS& =QV abW[[S WV[ hc& =\ eS\WUS` OZa SW\S` Gbc\RS PW\ WQV PSW >]V\a ?]ZZSUS 6`WO\ W\ SW\S[ OZb[]RWaQV O\[cbS\RS\ NW[[S` W[ HVS 7O`ZgZS SW\_cO`bWS`b& 6`WO\ Wab V]QVUSeOQVaS\$ abWZZ c\R AWbbS heO\hWU& >]V\ PWbbSb B]OV$ hc[ GQVZOTS\ \OQV <OcaS hc TOV`S\$ c\R aOUb$ OZZSa eSWbS`S

heO\hWU& >]V\ PWbbSb B]OV$ hc[ GQVZOTS\ \OQV <OcaS hc TOV`S\$ c\R aOUb$ OZZSa eSWbS`S PSa^`SQVS\ eW` []`US\ T`wV& B]OV$ RS` OcT RS[ 6Sbb USaSaaS\ VOb$ abSVb [Wb PSa]`UbS` AWS\S OcT& FcT [WQV O\$ eS\\ Rc eOa P`OcQVab$ aOUb S` c\R c[O`[b [WQV \]QV [OZ& =QV R`wQYS WV\ ZSWQVb$ R`SVS [WQV ROPSW OPS` a] eSU$ ROaa S` [Wb RS\ <s\RS\ \WQVb O\ RWS HOaQVS [Wb RS` DTSWTS c\R RS[ :ScS`hScU Y][[b& 5Za S` c\R >]V\ hc` Hw` `OcaUSVS\$ PW\ WQV a]T]`b S`ZSWQVbS`b& =QV USVS hc[ HSZST]\ c\R `cTS RS\ NW[[S`aS`dWQS O\$ c[ SW\S U`]rS :ZOaQVS ?SbSZ C\S c\R SW\S\ ?wPSZ 9Wa hc PSabSZZS\& =QV abw`hS OP$ RO eW`R Sa NSWb Tw` K]RYO& 6`WO\ aWbhb W\ SW\S[ GSaaSZ c\R aWSVb [W` e]`bZ]a hc& 8S` K]RYO Y][[b c[USVS\R$ c\R WQV aQVwbbS 9Wa W\ SW\ U`]rSa ;ZOa c\R TwZZS Sa PWa hc[ FO\R& 6`WO\ aQVwbbSZb OcT RWS :`OUS$ ]P S` OcQV eOa eWZZ$ RS\ ?]^T c\R aOUb$ BSW\$ RO\YS& =QV YW^^S heSW 8`W\Ya VW\bS`SW\O\RS` c\R aQVS\YS [W` SW\S\ R`WbbS\ SW\& 8O\\ T`OUS WQV 6`WO\$ ]P WQV RcaQVS\ YO\\$ c\R S` VOb \WQVba ROUSUS\& =QV \SV[S RS\ 8`W\Y [Wb W\a 6OR$ a^S``S RWS Hw` OP c\R R`SVS RWS 8caQVS OcT& 8Oa 6OR Wab YZSW\ c\R VOb YSW\S @wTbc\U& qPS` RS` 8caQVS PSTW\RSb aWQV jSR]QV SW\ YZSW\Sa _cOR`ObWaQVSa :S\abS`$ c\R aQV]\ abSVS WQV \OQYb W\ RS` 8caQVS c\R `OcQVS$ eWS WQV ROQVbS$ SW\S YZSW\S 8]aWa$ OPS` Sa abSZZb aWQV VS`Oca$ ROaa W[[S` \]QV heSW$ R`SW U`]rS <Wba RO aW\R& DZvbhZWQV ew\aQVS WQV [W`$ WQV VsbbS RWS :ZOaQVS K]RYO [WbUS\][[S\& =QV ab]^TS RWS DTSWTS$ PZOaS RS\ FOcQV Oca RS[ YZSW\S\ :S\abS` W\ SW\S\ @cTbaQVOQVb$ ZOaaS RS\ 8O[^T OcTabSWUS\$ c\R POZR PW\ WQV Z]QYS`& 9W\[OZ Y][[b 6`WO\ O\ RWS Hw` c\R T`OUb ]P OZZSa ]YOg Wab& 9\ba^O\\S [WQV \c` c\bS` RS` 8caQVS$ aOUS WQV& 9W\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ dS`USVS\$ RO\\ UWPb aWQV RWS DO\WY RSa HOUSa eWS OcT RS` H]WZSbbS PSW[ DagQVWObS`& =QV S\baQVZWSrS [WQV$ SW\S\ NcU Tw` a^sbS` OcThcVSPS\$ c\R b`]QY\S [WQV OP& =\heWaQVS\ PW\ WQV d]\ aQVv\abS` 9\S`UWS S`TwZZb3 RS` K]RYO VOb RS` TZObbS`WUS\ GSWbS RSa FOcaQVa S\bUSUS\USeW`Yb& GQVSWr R`OcT$ RS\YS WQV$ OZa WQV [Wb RS[ bWST c[ RWS <wTbS USaQVZc\US\S\ <O\RbcQV eWSRS` W\a NW[[S` a^OhWS`S& =QV ZSUS >OQYS c\R >SO\a \SPS\ ROa 6Sbb c\R abSZZS RS\ K]RYO c\R ROa 9Wa OcT RS\ BOQVbbWaQV& GQVS\YS [W` \OQV$ U`SWTS hc` :S`\PSRWS\c\U c\R ZSUS [WQV VW\& 6`WO\$ RS`$ eWS WQV jSbhb aSVS$ Y`OcaS <OO`S$ U`w\S 5cUS\ c\R SW\S\ abO`YS\ -%IV`% 6O`baQVObbS\ VOb$ RS` [WQV O\ B]OV S`W\\S`b$ aWSVb USZOaaS\ hc$ eWS WQV [WQV Rc`QV RWS ?O\sZS hO^^S c\R b`W\YS& =QV T`OUS WV\ SW\ eS\WU \OQV aSW\S[ >]P "VOc^basQVZWQV D`]TWa^]`bZS` c\R D`][Wa Oca <]bSZhW[[S`\ aQVZScaS\ c\R W\ RWS FSVO P`W\US\#$ eOa S` T`wVS` US[OQVb VOb "7]^#$ c\R TW\RS VS`Oca$ ROaa S` SW\S :`Sc\RW\ "\SbbS :`Oc$ ?`O\YS\aQVeSabS`# c\R SW\ <scaQVS\ OcT RS[ @O\R VOb$ e] S` RWS K]QVS\S\RS\ dS`P`W\Ub& =QV aQVWSPS [SW\ <O\RbcQV \]QV SbeOa eSWbS` `c\bS` c\R T`OUS$ ]P Sa WV\ abv`b$ eS\\ WQV [W` D]`\]a O\aSVS& 9` aOUb 6WbbS aSV`$ c\R WQV USVS OcT DOg DS` JWSe& 9` PZSWPb SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ aWbhS\ c\R ZOQVb wPS` [SW\S OPac`RS\ @]QYUSabS\$ RO\\ aOUb S`$ S` [caa bSZST]\WS`S\& 5Za S` Oca RS[ NW[[S` USVb$ Y][[b [W` RS` ;SRO\YS$ ROaa WQV <O^^g VS`PSabSZZS\ c\R SW\S ]RS` heSW HwbS\ PSW WV[ YOcTS\ YO\\& 8Ohc P`OcQVS WQV 6O`USZR$ OPS` RO`wPS` hS`P`SQVS WQV [W` \WQVb RS\ ?]^T$ OZa WQV [SW\ <O\Rg Oca RS` >OQYS TWaQVS c\R a] aQV\SZZ

hS`P`SQVS WQV [W` \WQVb RS\ ?]^T$ OZa WQV [SW\ <O\Rg Oca RS` >OQYS TWaQVS c\R a] aQV\SZZ WQV YO\\ <O^^ga Bc[[S` esVZS& 9` [SZRSb aWQV$ WQV aOUS2 8`SWVc\RS`b c\R heSW DTSWTS\$ BO[S c\R 5\aQV`WTb RSa <]bSZa c\R ROaa S` [WQV O\`cTS\ a]ZZ$ eS\\ S` c\bS\ Wab& <O^^g \W[[b ROa c\US`wV`b VW\$ c\R WQV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P S` VWS` aQV]\ [OZ USZWSTS`b VOb& BOQV RS[ ;Sa^`sQV ZOcTS WQV W[ NW[[S` VW\ c\R VS` c\R VOPS 5\Uab$ ROaa 6`WO\ eWSRS`Y][[b& >Sbhb ]RS` \WS$ RS\YS ]RS` aOUS WQV$ hWSVS [WQV `OaQV O\$ USVS hc[ 5cThcU c\R TOV`S VW\c\bS` W\ RWS @]PPg& =QV eSWr$ ROaa [W` \c` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ PZSWPS\$ c[ ROa ;SZR hc V]ZS\ c\R eWSRS` W[ NW[[S` hc aSW\$ SVS 6`WO\ hc`wQYYSV`b& KWS WQV RS\ 8SOZ [Wb <O^^g OPeWQYSZ\ a]ZZ$ YO\\ WQV [W` \]QV UO` \WQVb d]`abSZZS\& 5Za aWQV RWS 5cThcUbw` vTT\Sb$ abSWUb RWS DO\WY W\ [W` V]QV c\R aQV\w`b [W` RWS ?SVZS hc& GWQVS` Wab 6`WO\ W`US\Re] VWS` c\bS\ c\R aWSVb [WQV& =QV USVS W\ 6S[SZ[O\a 6O` c\R RWS H`S^^S VW\OcT hc` H]WZSbbS& 8O aWS ZSS` Wab$ dS`aQVeW\RS WQV W\ SW\S` ?OPW\S c\R abSQYS [W` `OaQV RWS DTSWTS O\$ RWS d][ dWSZS\ ;SP`OcQV UO\h dS`Y]VZb Wab c\R jSbhb OcQV \c` \]QV eS\WU 7`OQY S\bVsZb& 9W\S\ ]`RS\bZWQVS\ <Wb UWPb aWS b`]bhRS[ \]QV VS`$ SVS WQV [WQV S\baQVZWSrS$ ROa ;ZOa`vV`QVS\ W\ SW\S` <O\R d]ZZ ?Z]^O^WS` hc hS`R`wQYS\ c\R Sa W[ ?Z] `c\bS`hca^wZS\& 9W\ vZWUS`$ dS`P`O\\b aQV[SQYS\RS` bWSTS` NcU \]QV$ RO\\ hS`b`SbS WQV ROa 8W\U c\R eS`TS Sa W\a ?Z]& 8WS aQVc[[S`WUS\ 6O`a c\R RWdS`aS\ BSPS\Z]PPga RSa 7O`ZgZS aW\R SW\ dS`b`OQYbSa @OPg`W\bV$ c\R WQV ZOcTS W[ GWbhPS`SWQV d]` RS\ HSZST]\S\ [SV`[OZa VW\ c\R VS`$ ]V\S RS\ 5caUO\U hc TW\RS\& 8OPSW esQVab [SW\S DO\WY& GQVZWSrZWQV Y][[S WQV RO\\ OcT RS` AORWa]\ 5dS\cS `Oca c\R T`OUS SW\S VwPaQV O\USh]US\S :`Oc \OQV RS[ \sQVabS\ ;SZROcb][ObS\& =QV VOPS 5\Uab$ ROaa aWS RS\Yb$ WQV eWZZ aWS Oca`OcPS\$ ]RS` [W` O\[S`Yb$ ROaa WQV OcT 8`]US PW\$ OPS` aWS hSWUb [W` SW\TOQV SW\S 7VOaS 6O\Y OcT RS` O\RS`S\ Gb`OrS\aSWbS& =QV VSPS OQVbVc\RS`b 8]ZZO` OP c\R ZOcTS hc`wQY W\a <]bSZ c\R `OcT W\ [SW\ NW[[S`& 6`WO\ Wab \]QV c\bS`eSUa$ OZa <O^^g O\`cTb$ c\R RO WQV 5\Uab VOPS$ \]QV [OZ ROa NW[[S` hc dS`ZOaaS\$ c\R [W` \WQVba O\RS`Sa SW\TsZZb$ aOUS WQV WV[$ S` a]ZZS V]QVY][[S\$ OPS` Sa [waaS aQV\SZZ USVS\& KS\WU a^sbS` abSVb S` W\ RS[ YZSW\S\ J]``Oc[ x eSWrS GeSOb^O\ba$ FWSaS\Y]^TVv`S`$ abc[[ x$ c\R ]Pe]VZ WQV \c` Tw` R`SWVc\RS`b PSabSZZb VOPS$ T`OUS WQV WV\$ ]P S` Tw` aSQVa VOb$ c\R S` aOUb$ Tw` dWS`$ c\R UWPb [W` OQVb HwbS\ c\R heSW DTSWTS\& 8WS KSZZS RS` 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U$ RWS [WQV wPS`Y][[b$ Wab PSW\OV a] USeOZbWU eWS RS` GbSW\$ RS\ WQV W\ RWS Tc\YSZ\OUSZ\ScS DTSWTS ^OQYS& =QV abSQYS RWS O\RS`S DTSWTS W\ [SW\S >OQYS\bOaQVS$ hWSVS [WQV Oca$ aQVZW\US [W` ROa <O\RbcQV c[ RWS <wTbS$ a^`W\US eWSRS` W\a 6Sbb c\R [OQVS [W` SW\S\ K]RYO& 5Za 6`WO\ hc`wQYY][[b$ `OcQVS WQV c\dS`V]VZS\$ c\R SW\ D]`\] TZW[[S`b wPS` RS\ 6WZRaQVW`[& 8c VOab eOa USYOcTb$ ]RS`4$ T`OUb S`$ c\R WQV \WQYS [Wb SW\S[ PvaS\ ;`W\aS\ OcT RS[ ;SaWQVb& KSWrb Rc SWUS\bZWQV$ eWS \OV O[ ?\Oab Rc PWab4$ T`OUb S`$ c\R WQV aOUS WV[$ ROaa S` aWQV S\ba^O\\S\ a]ZZ& 8Oaa WQV \]QV SW\S\ 5PS\R [SW\S :`SWVSWb US\WSrS$ WV[ OPS` dS`a^`SQVS$ ROhcPZSWPS\$ eS\\ S` aWQV hc`wQYZSV\b c\R OcTVv`b$ d]\ 6cZZS\ c\R DagQV]YZW\WYS\ hc `SRS\& 9` eWZZWUb SW\ c\R aSbhb aWQV W\ RS\ GSaaSZ

\SPS\ RS` ?][[]RS& =QV dS`P`ObS heSW @WbS` K]RYO c\R TOab R`SW HwbS\ 7`OQY$ esV`S\R WQV RO OcT RS[ 6Sbb ZWSUS$ [Wb 6`WO\ `SRS c\R [W` D]`\]a O\aSVS& =QV ZS\YS ROa ;Sa^`sQV OcT aSW\S :`Sc\RW\$ GSf c\R D]`\]a$ c\R S` aQVOTTb Sa$ abc\RS\ZO\U [Wbhc`SRS\$ ]V\S jS[OZa ]`RW\s` hc eS`RS\& AO\QVS 9`W\\S`c\US\ aW\R PSaQVs[S\RS` OZa O\RS`S$ c\R RWSaS Wab PSa]\RS`a aQVZW[[& =`US\ReO\\ USUS\ A]`US\ aQVZsTb S` SW\& ;O\h$ UO\h ZSWaS abSVS WQV OcT$ hWSVS [WQV O\$ `OTTS [SW\S GOQVS\ x <O\Rg$ DTSWTS$ GbSW\S$ :ScS`hScU x hcaO[[S\$ abSVZS [WQV Oca RS[ NW[[S` c\R dS`aQVeW\RS&

=RW]bS\eW\R
9a Wab SW\ YZSW\Sa 7]ZZSUS O\ RS` CabYwabS AO`gZO\Ra$ c\R eW` VOPS\ hc dWS`b SW\ <Oca O\ RS` 7VSOaS^SOYS 6Og US[WSbSb$ heO\hWU AW\cbS\ d][ 7O[^ca S\bTS`\b2 SW\ S`VvVb USZSUS\Sa PZOcSa FO\QVVOca [Wb 5ZcdS`YZSWRc\U c\R SW\S[ <]ZhRSQY OcT RS` FwQYaSWbS$ c\aS` DO`ORWSa& =O\ Wab SW\ eWZR R`SW\aQVOcS\RS`$ Rc\YSZVOO`WUS` =\bS`\ObaaQV`SQY Oca AS[^VWa3 6`]]Ya$ [SW\ NW[[S`US\]aaS d][ GbcRS\bS\VSW[$ Wab SW\ 7O`g%;`O\b%Hg^ Oca AO`gZO\R$ PWSRS`$ aSZbaO[ OZb[]RWaQV$ jSRS`[O\\a :`Sc\R c\R \WS[O\RSa :SW\R3 Bc[[S` dWS` Wab >OYS$ SW\ PZ]\RUSZ]QYbS`$ PZOcscUWUS` :`WSRS\ajw\US`$ RS` W\ RS\ :S`WS\ VW\bS`[ H`SaS\ abSVb c\R W\ 6OZbW[]`S PSW RS\ A]]\aVW\S`a Ac\RVO`[]\WYO a^WSZb c\R aW\Ub& 5cT RS` VW\bS`S\ JS`O\RO abSVb W[[S` SW\ :Oaa 6WS`$ c\R RS` ?wVZaQV`O\Y Wab d]ZZ [Wb @O[[Y]bSZSbba c\R OcaUSacQVbS\ GbwQYS\ FW\RTZSWaQV$ RWS eW` W[ @SPS\a[WbbSZ[O`Yb W\ RS` \sQVabS\ GbORb [WbUSVS\ ZOaaS\& 8WS ?ZOcS`SW PSUW\\b SW\Sa BOQV[WbbOUa$ OZa =O\ c\R WQV Rc`QV RWS :ZSWaQVeO`S\OPbSWZc\U ZOcTS\& 9` PZSWPb abSVS\$ hSWUb OcT SW\ G]`bW[S\b OPUS^OQYbS` @O[[Y]bSZSbba c\R TZwabS`b2 ?][[$ 6WZZg$ [OQV RS\ FSWrdS`aQVZcaa VW\bS\ O\ [SW\S` >OQYS OcT c\R abSQY SW\ ^OO` d]\ RS\ D`OQVbSfS[^ZO`S\ RO `SW\& Nc` I\bS`ab`SWQVc\U Y\SWTb S` ROa ;SaWQVb hcaO[[S\$ ROaa WV[ RWS 5cUS\ `Oca_cSZZS\2 <S``U]bb$ 6WZZg$ e]`OcT eO`bSab Rc4$ c\R ]Pe]VZ WQV aWQVS` PW\$ ROaa WQV S`eWaQVb eS`RS$ [OQVS WQV RS\ FSWrdS`aQVZcaa OcT$ aQV\O^^S [W` ROa :ZSWaQV c\R abSQYS Sa `SW\& 9a VO\RSZb aWQV c[ SW\S bSc`S GYWjOQYS [Wb SW\S` P`SWbS\ FSWrdS`aQVZcaabOaQVS VW\bS\& 8Oa :ZSWaQV ZWSUb aS\Y`SQVb RO`W\$ c\R OZa eW` Rc`QV RS\ @ORS\ hc` ?OaaS USVS\$ RScbSb \WQVba RO`OcT VW\$ ROaa =O\ c\aS` 5PS\RSaaS\ W[ ?`Sch VOb& J]\ RO O\ PShOVZS\ eW` Tw`a :ZSWaQV \WQVb [SV`& =O\a >OQYS PSUZSWbSb c\a PSW jSRS[ 9W\YOcT& KS\\ WQV J]`ZSac\US\ aQVes\hS$ ZSaS WQV bOUawPS` x W\ jS\S[ >OV` VOc^basQVZWQV <O`Rg c\R :WbhUS`OZR$ >cRS bVS CPaQc`S SW\ ^OO`[OZ& 5\ RS\ K]QVS\S\RS\ ZSaS WQV W\ [SW\S[ NW[[S` O[ 9\RS RSa :Zc`a$ OPaSWba d][ H`cPSZ& KSRS` W[ <Oca \]QV W\ RS` GQVcZS c\bS`VOZbS WQV [WQV wPS` [SW\S @SYbw`S& =QV ZSaS GOZW\US` c\R ?\]eZSa \]QV [OZ c\R RWS 6wQVS` [SW\S` >cUS\R& 9W\WUS ROd]\ S\bVOZbS\ \]QV RWS FO\RPS[S`Yc\US\ d]\ ?ObVS`W\S3 WQV VwbS aWS eWS AcaSc[aabwQYS& <W\ c\R eWSRS` VOb jS[O\R ?]Ya ]RS` 5QWR$ OPS` [SWabS\a VOZbS\ eW` c\a `c\R c[ RWS IV` O\ ;`Oa& =O\ VOb SW\S `]bS 6]\U d]\ ;`O^VWQa$ RWS S` `SW\WUb c\R ^cbhb c\R ab`SWQVSZb eWS SW\ <OcabWS`& =QV VOPS SW\S\ abs\RWUS\ J]``Ob W\ [SW\S[ NW[[S` c\R `OcQVS Oca SW\S` Yc`hS\ DZOabWYP]\U c\R Vv`S FWQYg @SS >]\Sa c\R 6]P 8gZO\$ c\R eS\\ WQV \WQVb ZSaS$ abO``S WQV SW\TOQV OcT RS\ `]bP`Oc\ US[cabS`bS\ KO\RPSVO\U O\ RS` 8SQYS& KW` TOV`S\ RWS CabYwabS `OcT c\R `c\bS` x DVWZORSZ^VWO$ 6OZbW[]`S$ KOaVW\Ub]\$ F]O\]OYS$ 6]ab]\$

RWS CabYwabS `OcT c\R `c\bS` x DVWZORSZ^VWO$ 6OZbW[]`S$ KOaVW\Ub]\$ F]O\]OYS$ 6]ab]\$ BSe M]`Y x$ c[ RWS ;`ObSTcZ 8SOR$ 8gZO\$ BSWZ M]c\U hc aSVS\& J]` OZZS[ =O\ c\R WQV c\R d]` OZZS[ 8gZO\& 6`]]Ya Wab RS` 9W\hWUS$ RS` SW\S TSabS :`Sc\RW\ VOb$ GVW`ZSg$ RWS W\ JW`UW\WO hc` GQVcZS USVb& =QV aQVZOTS `SUSZ[srWU [Wb heSW ]RS` R`SW dS`aQVWSRS\S\ AsRQVS\ x c\R PSW OZZS\ dS`hWSVb =O\ \c` O\USeWRS`b ROa ;SaWQVb& <S``U]bb$ 6WZZg$ eOa [OQVab Rc RS\\4$ aOUb S` W[[S`$ eS\\ USUS\ 9\RS RSa 5PS\Ra TSababSVb$ eS\ WQV [Wb OcTa NW[[S` \SV[S& >OYS VOb AsRQVS\ W\ 6OZbW[]`S ]RS` W[ C`b$ RWS \WQVb abcRWS`S\& KW` ZS`\S\ aWS \WS YS\\S\& =O\ aQVZsTb$ a]eSWb WQV eSWr$ \c` SW\[OZ [Wb SW\S[ AsRQVS\$ c\R heO` SW\S`$ [Wb RS` WQV SW\ ^OO`[OZ USY\cbaQVb VOPS c\R W\ RWS WQV$ eWS S` eSWr$ dS`Y\OZZb PW\ x c\R S` [OQVb ROa OcT RS[ FwQYaWbh SW\Sa KOUS\a$ OcT RS` FwQYTOV`b d]\ 6]ab]\$ esV`S\R 6`]]Ya c\R WQV d]`\S aWbhS\& KW` PSY][[S\ OZZSa [Wb& =QV USVS W\ RWS @cTb$ c\R S` PSVOc^bSb$ S` VOb USaQVZOTS\ c\R \WQVb US[S`Yb$ ROaa aWS OcT WV[ hcUO\US eO`& 9W\Sa 5PS\Ra VSPb >OYS ;SZR O[ 5cb][ObS\ OP c\R PS[S`Yb SW\S :SVZPcQVc\U hc aSW\S\ ;c\abS\$ RWS WV\ OcT RWS =RSS P`W\Ub$ SW\ \ScSa :Oaa 6WS` hc YOcTS\ c\R SW\ ^OO` @ScbS hc c\a SW\hcZORS\& 8Oa bc\ eW`& qPS`[ H`W\YS\ eW`R Sa a^sb$ c\R W`US\ReS[ TsZZb OcT$ ROaa 6`]]Ya \WQVb PSW c\a Wab& 9` [caa OcT RS[ 7O[^ca aSW\$ c\R eW` PSaQVZWSrS\$ WV\ hc acQVS\& =O\ TsV`b$ WQV aWbhS \SPS\ WV[$ >OYS VW\bS\& KW` VOZbS\ O[ BSebya$ SW\S` RwabS`S\ ?OaQVS[[S$ RWS [Wb OZZS\ [vUZWQVS\ G^SQWOZa RWS GbcRS\bS\ O\Z]QYb& 6WS` Tw` SW\S\ VOZPS\ 8]ZZO`$ RO[Wb aWS `SW\Y][[S\$ aWQV PSbwbSZ\ c\R O\TO\US\$ GQV\s^aS hc PSabSZZS\& KW` PSabSZZS\ GQV\O^a& HS_cWZO& =O\ Wab c\a W[[S` SW\ ^OO` ;ZsaS` d]`Oca$ c\R >OYS c\R WQV PS[wVS\ c\a$ 5\aQVZcaa hc VOZbS\& 5Za aWS RWQVb[OQVS\$ abSZZS\ eW` RWS <]QYS` c\R GbwVZS V]QV c\R PSY][[S\ \]QV ;`ObWaR`W\Ya ROTw`& KW` aW\R OcT RS`aSZPS\ 5ZYeSZZS\Zs\US$ VOPS\ OZZS R`SW RS\aSZPS\ Z]RS`\RS\ ?][SbS\ W\ c\a c\R PSaQVZWSrS\$ ROaa eW` jSbhb RS[ AsRQVS\e]V\VSW[ SW\S\ 6SacQV OPabObbS\ a]ZZbS\& 6`]]Ya acQVS\& =V\ RO `OcaV]ZS\& 5Za] P`SbbS`\ eW` Z]a& =O\ Zsaab n=RW]b KW\Rl ZOcTS\ c\R U`vZb RS\ HSfb [Wb2 8c PWab SW\ =RW]]]b$ 6OPS$ Sa Wab SW\ Kc\RS`$ ROaa Rc wPS`VOc^b Ob[S\ YO\\ab& 6SW[ GW\US\ eW`Tb S` aWQV W[[S` eWSRS` \OQV d]`\ USUS\ ROa GbScS`$ c\R aSW\S aQVeO`hS\ <OO`S c\R `]bS\ 5cUS\ Tc\YSZ\ Rs[]\WaQV W[ U`w\S\ GQVSW\ RS` JK%5`[Obc`& 9a Wab [W\RSabS\a heSW$ OZa eW` O\Y][[S\& KW` aW\R abc`hPSa]TTS\ d][ HS_cWZO c\R abSVS\ USTsV`ZWQV c\bS` Gb`][& I\aS` 5bS[ evZYb c\R aQVW[[S`b W\ RS` SWaYOZbS\ As`hZcTb$ c\R eW` hWSVS\ d][ KOUS\ hc[ K]V\VSW[ eWS SW\ hc jSRS` I\bOb S\baQVZ]aaS\Sa R`SWYv^TWUSa A]\abS`& 5cT NSVS\a^WbhS\ ZOcTS\ eW` Rc`QV RWS ;s\US$ =O\ U`SWTb aWQV c\bS`eSUa SW\S\ :ScS`ZvaQVS`& 9` bcb$ OZa ]P S` c\a RO[Wb d]ZZa^`wVb$ c\R OcT SW\[OZ USVb S` eW`YZWQV Z]a& <S``ZWQVS eSWrS K]ZYS\ _cSZZS\ Oca RS[ `]bS\ 6SVsZbS` VS`d]`$ W\ RS[ A][S\b ROa 9`abOc\ZWQVabS$ eOa WQV jS[OZa USaSVS\ VOPS& =O\ VsZb aSW\S \ScS KOTTS W\ RWS S\bUSUS\USaSbhbS FWQVbc\U$ R`wQYb RS\ ;`WTT hcaO[[S\$ c\R eWSRS` a^`WSrb RWS Kc\RS`e]ZYS [OjSabsbWaQV ZO\UaO[ W\ RS\ ;O\U VW\SW\& >OYS c\R e]ZZS\ ROa OcQV VOPS\$ c\R eW` `S\\S\ RWS H`S^^S VW\OcT c\R aQVOcS\$ ]P ]PS\ \]QV heSW @vaQVS` aW\R& >OYS

c\R eW` `S\\S\ RWS H`S^^S VW\OcT c\R aQVOcS\$ ]P ]PS\ \]QV heSW @vaQVS` aW\R& >OYS TW\RSb SW\S\$ OPS` WQV W`US\ReWS \WQVb& 9` c\R =O\ PSa^`wVS\ aWQV USUS\aSWbWU$ PSa^`wVS\ RWS ;s\US$ RWS Hw`S\$ RS\ 6]RS\$ SW\ AsRQVS\$ ROa aQVZsTb& KW` dS`ZWS`S\ c\a$ PZSWPS\ RS[ ;STwVZ \OQV OPS` Rc`QV SW\ c\aWQVbPO`Sa SZSYb`WaQVSa 6O\R [WbSW\O\RS` dS`Pc\RS\ c\R W\ FcTeSWbS& =QV Y][[S W\ SW\S\ 5cTS\bVOZba`Oc[$ W\ RS[ jS[O\R SW\S TOab TS`bWUS DObQVe]`YRSQYS VOb ZWSUS\ ZOaaS\& 9W\ U`cTbWUSa A]aOWY Oca PZOcS\ c\R `]bS\ Gb]TTdWS`SQYS\& 9a S`W\\S`b [WQV O\ [SW\S AcbbS` c\R RWS :ZWQYS\RSQYS$ RWS aWS O\ RS` <WUVaQV]]Z US\sVb VOb& CV\S \OQVhcRS\YS\ VSPS WQV RWS 8SQYS OcT c\R \SV[S aWS [Wb OcT RS\ ;O\U& 8O Vv`S WQV OcQV aQV]\ =O\ \OQV [W` `cTS\& ?][[$ 6WZZWWWSSS$ Y][[& NeWaQVS\Rc`QV `cTb S` OcQV \OQV >OYS& >OYS& KW` [waaS\ OPVOcS\& ?][[$ >OYS& =QV ZOcTS RS\ ;O\U S\bZO\U& DZvbhZWQV aW\R eW` OZZS R`SW eWSRS` hcaO[[S\$ c\R W[ aSZPS\ A][S\b aSVS WQV AsRQVS\ aQV`SWS\R Oca WV`S\ NW[[S`\ Y][[S\& KW` `S\\S\ hc[ 5caUO\U& =`US\RjS[O\R x d]\ c\a$ d]\ RS\ AsRQVS\4 x Zvab RS\ :ScS`OZO`[ Oca$ c\R TOab a]T]`b S`bv\b SW\S GW`S\S& 8S` KOUS\ abSVb ]PS\ VW\bS` RS` 6O\Y$ c\R eW` ZOcTS\ wPS` RS\ DO`Y^ZObh RSa K]V\VSW[a c\R Rc`QV RS\ ;O`bS\ SW\Sa BOQVPO`VOcaSa& =O\ Wab d]ZZ OcT ?O[^T SW\USabSZZb$ abvrb c\a VW\bS` SW\S <SQYS c\R `Oc\b c\a hc2 ;O\h abWZZ jSbhb& I\R ROa aW\R eW`& D]ZWhSWaW`S\S\$ :ScS`eSV`aW`S\S\ c\R RS` :ScS`OZO`[ aQVOZZS\ Rc`QV RWS GbORb$ esV`S\R `W\Ua c[ c\a `]bS c\R PZOcS @WQVbS` OcTPZWbhS\& AWbbZS`eSWZS Wab Sa R`SW$ dWS` IV` T`wV$ c\R RS` 7O[^ca c\R RWS BOQVPO`aQVOTb aW\R eOQV& =[ K]V\VSW[ c\R RS\ \sQVabS\ <scaS`\ USVS\ RWS @WQVbS` O\$ J]`Vs\US eS`RS\ OcTUSh]US\$ c\R @ScbS abSQYS\ RWS ?v^TS Oca RS\ :S\abS`\$ c[ hc aSVS\$ eOa Z]a Wab& KW` PZSWPS\ [W\RSabS\a SW\S Gbc\RS RO$ c\R OZa aWQV RWS @OUS hc PS`cVWUS\ aQVSW\b$ aQVZSWQVS\ eW` c\a aQVZWSrZWQV hc =O\a KOUS\ c\R TOV`S\ \OQV <OcaS& 6`]]Ya Wab RO c\R aQV]\ d]\ OZZS\ O\US`cTS\ e]`RS\$ RWS c\a YS\\S\ c\R [WbUSY`WSUb VOPS\$ eWS =O\ c\aS`S BO[S\ US`cTS\ VOb& 5Za eW` hc` <Ocabw` Y][[S\$ aWSVb 6`]]Ya [WQV S\bUSWabS`b O\ c\R aOUb2 KOa VOab Rc RS\\ RO4 DSW\ZWQVS`eSWaS aSVS WQV$ ROaa WQV W[[S` \]QV RWS PSW\OV TS`bWUS DObQVe]`YRSQYS W\ RS\ <s\RS\ VOZbS& 5ca 5\Uab$ ROaa jSRS\ 5cUS\PZWQY RWS D]ZWhSW OcTbOcQVS\ Yv\\bS$ ab]^TS WQV aWS W\ SW\S\ aQVeO`hS\ AwZZaOQY c\R ZOaaS aWS c\bS` RS` JS`O\RO RSa ZSS`S\ BOQVPO`VOcaSa dS`aQVeW\RS\& KW` PZSWPS\ OcT$ YWTTS\$ [OQVS\ c\a G]`US\$ eO`bS\ OcT RS\ 5\`cT d][ 7]ZZSUS$ RS` aQVZWSrZWQV OcQV Y][[b$ c\R O[ HOU RO`OcT TZWSUS\ eW`& >OYS UWPb ROa GbcRWc[ OcT& =O\ c\R WQV e]ZZS\ W[ Y][[S\RS\ <S`Pab hcaO[[S\ \OQV 6]cZRS` USVS\& 6`]]Ya hWSVb hc :`Sc\RS\ W\ RS` GbORb c\R P`W\Ub ROa GS[SabS` hc 9\RS& =\ RWSaS[ :`wVjOV` PSacQVS WQV =O\ SW\ ^OO`[OZ W\ 6SRT]`R$ BSe M]`Y& GSW\S AcbbS` Wab d]\ BSe C`ZSO\a R]`bVW\ USh]US\$ \OQVRS[ aWS aWQV d]\ =O\a JObS` VOb aQVSWRS\ ZOaaS\&

=QV j]PPS [Wb SW\S[ :`Sc\R hc <OcaS OZa @O\RaQVOTbaUs`b\S`$ c\R S` O`PSWbSb W\ KVWbS DZOW\a W\ SW\S[ G^]`bUSaQVsTb& GSW\S AcbbS` Wab ]Tb c\bS`eSUa$ aSW\ 6`cRS` GO[ Wab W\ RS` OQVbS\ ?ZOaaS c\R USevV\ZWQV ROVSW[& =O\ YOcTb [SWabS\a ?]Ya PSW SW\S[ :`Sc\R W\ FgS$ c\R \OQV[WbbOUa `OcQVS\ eW` ;`Oa c\R a^WSZS\ :`WaPSS$ OPS\Ra hWSVS\ eW` ?]Ya$ b`W\YS\ UcbSa 6WS` c\R a^WSZS\ 7O^a x PSW RWSaS[ NSWbdS`b`SWP aWbhb [O\ aWQV OcT heSW GSWbS\ SW\Sa NW[[S`a USUS\wPS` c\R eW`Tb ?`]\Y]`YS\ W\ RS\ 6SQVS`$ RS\ RS` ;SUS\a^WSZS` heWaQVS\ RS\ 6SW\S\ VsZb$ PWa SW\S[ RS` 8Oc[S\ PZcbSb$ eSWZ [O\ RWS UShOQYbS\ 6ZSQVYO\bS\ hc TSab USR`wQYb VOb& 5\ SW\S[ K]QVS\S\RS b`W\YS\ eW` W\ ;`SS\eWQV a] dWSZ ;cW\\Saa c\R `OcQVS\ a] dWSZ ;`Oa$ ROaa WQV [WQV aQV]\ wPS`USPS\ [caa$ PSd]` Sa O\ RWS @W\Sa USVb& KW` [OQVS\ GO[abOU c\R G]\\bOU Rc`QV PWa eSWb W\ RWS BOQVb hc[ A]\bOU$ c\R O[ A]\bOU a]ZZ WQV W\ AO\VObbO\ AWV] OPV]ZS\$ SW\S SVS[OZWUS jO^O\WaQVS 5cabOcaQVaQVwZS`W\ [SW\S` :O[WZWS& GWS dS`P`W\Ub RS\ HOU W\ BSe M]`Y$ c\R WQV VOPS [WQV OcT Kc\aQV [SW\S` AcbbS` PS`SWbS`YZs`b$ WV` RWS GbORb hc hSWUS\& A]\bOU[WbbOU ZWSUb W\ aOUS\VOTbS` :S`\S$ esV`S\R eW` d]ZZ OcTUSR`SVb 8gZO\ Vv`S\ c\R O[ :`wVabwQYabWaQV W\ =O\a ?wQVS SW\S @W\S \OQV RS` O\RS`S\ hWSVS\& A]\bOUT`wV USUS\ Tw\T POcS\ eW` OP$ \SV[S\ GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\ [Wb \]QV SW\ ^OO` 8]aS\ 6WS` c\R USVS\ W\a 6Sbb& =QV PW\ W[ ;sabShW[[S` c\R eOQVS c[ OQVb [Wb RS[ ;STwVZ OcT$ ROaa SbeOa \WQVb abW[[b& 9a ROcS`b SW\S\ A][S\b$ PWa [W` YZO` eW`R$ ROaa WQV \WQVb \c` W\a 6Sbb US^W\YSZb c\R USaQVWaaS\$ a]\RS`\ [WQV OcQV \]QV d]ZZUSY]bhb VOPS& =O\a AcbbS` Y][[b O\ RWSaS[ HOU \OQV <OcaS& =QV VOPS BORSZ\ W[ ?]^T c\R ^O\WaQVS 5\Uab$ ROaa =O\ RWS 6SaQVS`c\U S\bRSQYb& =QV b]`YSZS Oca RS[ 6Sbb$ hWSVS [SW\S dS`R`SQYbS I\bS`esaQVS Oca c\R USVS W\a 6OR$ c[ ROa ;`vPabS `OcahceOaQVS\& 8O\\ RcaQVS WQV$ hWSVS @OYS\ Tw` @OYS\$ ?WaaS\ Tw` ?WaaS\ ROa 6Sbb OP c\R eS`TS [WQV W\ RWS GOQVS\ d][ J]`bOU$ RWS \OQV D]b `WSQVS\ c\R d]ZZS` 6WS`TZSQYS aW\R& =QV R`SVS RWS jSbhb TZSQYWUS AOb`ObhS c[$ `OTTS RWS dS`aQV[cbhbS I\bS`esaQVS c\R 6SbbesaQVS hcaO[[S\ c\R aQVZSWQVS a] ZSWaS eWS [vUZWQV Rc`QV RS\ :Zc` hc` ?SZZS`b`S^^S$ RS\\ W[ ?SZZS`$ ROa eSWr WQV hc[ ;ZwQY$ UWPbya SW\S KOaQV[OaQVW\S c\R SW\S\ H`]QY\S`& =QV V]ZS RWS GOQVS\$ RWS W\ RS` KOaQV[OaQVW\S aW\R$ `Oca$ abSQYS aWS W\ SW\S\ KsaQVSY]`P$ c\R ab]^TS [SW\S <]``]`T`OQVb VW\SW\& >SRS` HOabS\R`cQY$ jSRSa 5cT`SWrS\ RS` KOaQV[WbbSZ^OQYc\U$ jSRSa Hw`aQVZWSrS\ VOZZb eWS SW\ ;SeSV`aQVcaa$ c\R WQV PW\ aWQVS`$ UZSWQV Y][[b =O\ VS`c\bS`USabw`[b c\R P`wZZb aSW\S\ @WSPZW\UaaObh KOa [OQVab Rc RS\\4 =O\ YO\\ RWSaS` :`OUS SW\ C^bW[c[ O\ 5PaQVSc c\R JS`OQVbc\U [WbUSPS\& 8S` >c\US [OU 6]P 8gZO\$ VsZb OZZS O\RS`S\ AcaWYS` Tw` 6ZS\RS` c\R YO\\ RS\ GbOOb AO`gZO\R a] eS\WU OcaabSVS\ eWS RWQYS AsRQVS\ ]RS` :`OcS\ c\R wPS`VOc^b TOab OZZSa$ eOa \WQVb Oca AS[^VWa Y][[b& =QV PW\ aSW\ :`Sc\R$ OPS` Sa aQVSW\b [W` SW\S c\aWQVS`S :`Sc\RaQVOTb hc aSW\$ RWS eSUS\ SW\S` SW\hWUS\ TOZaQVS\ 6O\R ]RS` SW\Sa d]ZZUS[OQVbS\ 6Sbba jSRS`hSWb OcTUSYw\RWUb eS`RS\ YO\\&

I[ \WQVb \]QV [OZ ?`OQV OcT RS` H`S^^S hc [OQVS\$ aSbhS WQV [WQV VW\ c\R eO`bS$ PWa RWS KsaQVS Rc`QVUSZOcTS\ c\R USb`]QY\Sb Wab& 8O USVb Sa aQV]\ OcT SZT IV` hc& =QV [OQVS ROa 6Sbb$ `OTTS [SW\S GOQVS\ hcaO[[S\ c\R `cTS SW\ HOfW& =QV eSQYS =O\$ c[ baQVwa hc aOUS\$ c\R S` Y\SWTb ROa ;SaWQVb hcaO[[S\ c\R aOUb2 ;]bb$ 6WZZg$ aWSVab Rc aQVSWrS Oca& 8O aSVS WQV =O\ hc[ ZSbhbS\ AOZ& 9` USVb \WQVb \OQV 6]cZRS`& =QV aQV]\$ OPS` [SW\ JObS` PSabSVb RO`OcT$ ROaa WQV \OQV AO`gZO\R hc`wQYYSV`S c\R RWS Gc^^S RO OcaZvTTZS& 8Oa bcS WQV& 6`]]Ya c\R WQV aW\R PWa hc [SW\S[ 5PaQVZcaa RO\\ NW[[S`USTsV`bS\$ c\R >OQY USVb hc`wQY \OQV 6OZbW[]`S$ e] S` x dS`[cbZWQV PWa VScbS x Ac\RVO`[]\WYO a^WSZb c\R VW\bS`[ H`SaS\ abSVb& =QV Y][[S wPS` SW\S Gbc\RS hc a^sb hc [SW\S` JS`OP`SRc\U [Wb AWV] W[ F]QYSTSZZS` 7S\bS`& ASW\S GOQVS\ abW\YS\$ c\R RWS aQVeO`hS 5a^S\%?O^^S OcT [SW\S[ ?]^T x aWS USVv`b =O\$ WQV b`OUS aWS RO[OZa TOab bsUZWQV x Wab \OQV RS` ZO\US\ BOQVb [Wb :caaSZ\ c\R ?`w[SZ\ OZZS` 5`b wPS`asb& 8WS ;OZZS Y][[b [W` V]QV$ c\R WQV VOPS [WQV W[ NcU aQV]\ heSW[OZ wPS`USPS\& AWV] aWSVb dS`s`US`b c\R eWS Oca RS[ 9W US^SZZb Oca& GWS b`sUb SW\ USZPSa ?]abw[ eWS d]\ 7VO\SZ$ `]bS Dc[^a$ c\R WV`S 6ZcaS Wab a] eSWr$ ROaa WQV RWS 5cUS\ hcaO[[S\Y\SWTS\ [caa& AWV] Wab \Sc\hSV\$ aWSVb jSR]QV Oca eWS SW\S USabO\RS\S ;SaQVsTbaT`Oc ]RS` SW\S BOQV`WQVbS\a^`SQVS`W\ AWbbS RS` 8`SWrWU& GWS [cabS`b [WQV O`UevV\WaQV c\R T`OUb$ ]Pya [W` Ucb USVb& 9W\WUS`[OrS\$ aOUS WQV c\R T`OUS aWS$ e] aWS VW\ [vQVbS& =QV VsbbS Sa [W` RS\YS\ Yv\\S\2 GOYa :WTbV 5dS\cS$ HWTTO\g$ 7O`bWS`$ 6S`UR]`T$ 6]\eWb HSZZS`$ ;cQQW& KW` dS`P`W\US\ RS\ HOU O\ C`bS\$ e] [WQV ROa KOQV^S`a]\OZ Ucb W[ 5cUS PSVsZb& 9a eW`R SW\S` RS` Zs\UabS\ HOUS [SW\Sa @SPS\a$ c\R WQV ZOaaS [W` W\ [SV`S`S\ 8SZWa c\bS`eSUa 5a^W`W\ c\R KOaaS` USPS\& 8WS GbORb Y][[b [W` d]` eWS SW\ NSWQVS\b`WQYTWZ[$ W\ RS[ WQV Rc`QV SW\ aQVeS`Sa Y]a[WaQVSa JS`aSVS\ USZO\RSb PW\& 8WS KOQVZScbS aW\R RWS SW\hWUS\$ RWS [WQV eOV`\SV[S\3 Tw` OZZS O\RS`S\ PW\ WQV c\aWQVbPO`& 8WS hS`Zc[^bS\ GV]`ba$ RS` OhbSYWaQVS Gb]TTUw`bSZ$ ROa G\]ePW`R%H%GVW`b c\R RWS 5a^S\ 7O^ "OZZSa YSW\S FSWaSO\RS\YS\# USVv`S\ hc SW\S` UO\h O\RS`S\ KSZb$ c\R WQV TwVZS [WQV \]QV \WQVb [OZ e]VZ RO`W\& 8WS AS\aQVS\ eW`YS\ a] aSZPabPSecaab$ a] TSab W\ WV`S[ @SPS\ dS`O\YS`b$ eWS aWS RWS :WTbV c\R RWS AORWa]\ 5dS\cS `OcT c\R `c\bS` [O`aQVWS`S\& AO\QVS aSVS\ \WQVb dWSZ sZbS` Oca OZa WQV$ OPS` aWS aQVSW\S\ Oca SW\S[ AObS`WOZ USaQV\Wbhb c\R d]\ ?`sTbS\ UST]`[b hc aSW\$ RWS WQV [W` \WQVb [OZ d]`abSZZS\ YO\\& G^sbS` eS`RS WQV ]Tb O\ aWS RS\YS\$ c\R RO\\ S`aQVSW\S\ aWS [W` eWS RWS GbORb2 U]ZRS\$ hOcPS`VOTb$ wPS`esZbWUS\R& 9`ab R`SW >OV`S RO\OQV aSVS WQV BSe M]`Y eWSRS`& 8O VOPS WQV ROa GbcRWc[ VW\bS` [W` c\R PW\ PSW [SW\S` :`Sc\RW\ AO`WS$ RWS \Sc\ >OV`S sZbS` Wab OZa WQV& GWS O``O\UWS`b SW\ heO\UZ]aSa H`STTS\ [Wb SW\S[ 6SYO\\bS\ d]\ WV`$ RS` JS`ZOUaZSYb]` Wab x W\ SW\S[ JS`ZOU$ RS` [W` eWS a]\ab \c` eS\WUS SW\ 6SU`WTT Wab$ eSWZ aSW\ BO[S W\ RS\ 6wQVS`\ d]\ GOZW\US` c\R 8WQYW\a]\ abSVb$ RWS WQV W[[S` eWSRS` USZSaS\ VOPS& =QV a^S``S [WQV$ OPS` aWS PSabSVb

c\R 8WQYW\a]\ abSVb$ RWS WQV W[[S` eWSRS` USZSaS\ VOPS& =QV a^S``S [WQV$ OPS` aWS PSabSVb RO`OcT$ ROaa WQV eS\WUabS\a [OZ SW\S\ 6ZWQY W\ RWS JS`ZOUaeSZb eS`TS$ RS\\ WV`S` ASW\c\U \OQV USVv`S WQV ROVW\& =QV wPS`ZOaaS [WQV SW\ eS\WU WV`S` DVO\bOaWS$ R]QV Sa Wab$ OZa es`S WQV Tw\T ]RS` aSQVa c\R ew`RS [WQV W[ :`SWPOR [Wb RS\ U`]rS\ >c\Ua wPS`a ?]^Ta^`W\US\ d][ NSV\[SbS`P`Sbb c\bS`VOZbS\2 b]ZZSa HVS[O$ OPS` SW\ 8W\U RS` I\[vUZWQVYSWb& KW` b`STTS\ c\a SW\S\ 6Z]QY d][ F]QYSTSZZS` 7S\bS` S\bTS`\b& 8S` @SYb]` aWSVb aWQV [SW\S\ @SPS\aZOcT O\ x RS\ WQV [Wb AO`WSa <WZTS S`abSZZb VOPS x c\R `c\hSZb RWS GbW`\& 9` RScbSb OcT RWS 5aaWabS\bS\ R`OcrS\ d]` aSW\S[ 6w`] c\R bSWZb [W` [Wb$ ROaa RWS [SWabS\ d]\ WV\S\ O\ 9ZWbSc\WdS`aWbsbS\ abcRWS`b$ SW\WUS R]`b OcQV WV`S\ 8]Yb]` US[OQVb VOPS\$ c\R ROaa [SW\ OYORS[WaQVS` KS`RSUO\U c\R [SW\S 6S`cTaS`TOV`c\U \WQVb ROhc O\USbO\ aW\R$ [W` RWS Hw` hc SW\S[ JS`ZOUaVOca eWS RWSaS[ hc vTT\S\& ;S\Oc ROa VOPS WQV PSTw`QVbSb$ c\R WQV dS`USVS d]` GQVO[& AO`WS eO`bSb O\ RS` 9WaPOV\ OcT [WQV$ e] OZZS >OV`S RS` U`]rS 7V`WabPOc[ O\UShw\RSb eW`R& =QV ZwUS aWS O\ c\R aOUS$ RS` @SYb]` VOPS [WQV S`[cbWUb3 aSW\S` 5\aWQVb \OQV aSW RO aQV]\ SbeOa hc [OQVS\$ \c` W[ A][S\b \WQVb& GWS aOUb2 BO$ aWSVab Rc$ c\R WQV abW[[S WV` PSW& 5Za eW` a^sbS` SW\S\ ?OTTSS b`W\YS\ c\R PSW 6`]]Ya 6`]bVS`a SW\S 6Sa]`Uc\U Tw` WV`S AcbbS` [OQVS\$ TOZZS\ [W` eWSRS` RWS KOQVZScbS OcT$ eWS >OV`S hcd]` [Wb AWV]$ c\R WQV PW\ wPS`hScUb$ aWS Yv\\S\ [W` O\aSVS\$ eOa WQV aSZPS` eSWr$ OcQV eS\\ AO`WS RO SW\S\ PZW\RS\ :ZSQY hc VOPS\ aQVSW\b x ROaa WQV \WQVb VWS`VS` USVv`S& 8Oaa RWSaS` C`b SW\S[ SZSUO\bS`S\$ YZwUS`S\$ USPWZRSbS`S\ c\R W\aUSaO[b d]`\SV[S`S\ AS\aQVS\aQVZOU d]`PSVOZbS\ Wab& 5[ BOQV[WbbOU abSWUS WQV W\ RS` ;`O\R 7S\b`OZ GbObW]\ [Wb RS[ UZSWQVS\ ;SRO\YS\ W\ RS\ NcU eWS O\ jS\S[ ?ObS`bOU R`SW >OV`S hcd]`2 8Oa Wab ROa ZSbhbS AOZ& CRS` SbeO \WQVb4

5\TO\U d][ 9\RS

8S\ S`abS\ 5ZY]V]Z x GQ]bQV d]\ aSW\S[ JObS` x b`W\Yb S` W[ KOZR$ [Wb ?S\\g$ Oca RS` :ZOaQVS& GWS aW\R hevZT& 9a Wab <S`Pab$ `W\Uac[ Pc\bSa @OcP c\R wPS`OZZ RS` awrZWQVS ;S`cQV d]\ A]RS`$ d]\ NS`TOZZ& GWS abWPWbhS\ RWS :ZOaQVS Oca RS[ 6O`aQV`O\Y c\R ZOcTS\ [Wb SW\S` DOQYc\U NWUO`SbbS\ d]\ aSW\S` AcbbS` c\R SW\S[ DZOgP]gYOZS\RS`$ RS\ ?S\\g W\ RS` 5^]bVSYS RSa BOQVPO`]`ba USYZOcb VOb$ RS\ <]ZheSU V]QV& 8S` KVWaYg aQV[SQYb \WQVb$ OPS` ROa Y][WaQVS eO`[S ;STwVZ W\ RS` 6`cab c\R ROa 6`S\\S\ W[ <OZa USTOZZS\ WV[ aSV`& 9` aSbhb RWS :ZOaQVS \c` R`SW ]RS` dWS` AOZ O\$ R]QV ROa US\wUb$ RO[Wb WV[ aQVec[[`WU eW`R& 8O[Wb S` :cr TOaab O\ SW\S[ C`b$ e] OZZSa aSZWU dS`aQVeW[[b& K] S` aWQV \WQVb [Wb VW\aQVZS^^S\ [caa& 5crS`RS[ USTsZZb WV[ RWS Rc\YZS GSWbS RSa ;O\hS\& 8Oa JS`aQVeW\RS\ W[ KOZR& 8WS VSW[ZWQVS\ J]`VOPS\$ ROa dS`ab]VZS\S <O\RSZ\& 8Oa W\bW[S ;STwVZ RS` ?][^ZWhS\aQVOTb& GWS YWQVS`\$ eWS aWS Sa W[[S` bc\& ?S\\g dS`hWSVb ROa ;SaWQVb c\R Vv`b \OQV SW\S[ NcU OcT& GWS `OcQVS\ US`ORS [OZ SW\S NWUO`SbbS c\R eWSVS`\ [SV` wPS` RWS \OQYbS\ ?OZS\RS`UW`Za$ OZa ROaa aWS aWS PSscUS\& I\R aWS [OQVS\ a] SbeOa \c` \]QV eS\WUS AOZS& 8WS 8WSPSahwUS hc[ 6O`aQV`O\Y aSW\Sa JObS`a TO\US\ RO[Wb jSR]QV S`ab O\& Bc` USVb S` [Wb RS` 6ScbS Yw\TbWU \WQVb W\ RS\ KOZR$ a]\RS`\ V]QV W\ aSW\ NW[[S`$ b`W\Yb O[ :S\abS` aWbhS\R Oca SW\S` `]b c\R ]`O\US USab`SWTbS\ HVS`[]aTZOaQVS c\R ZOcaQVb RS\ ;`WZZS\ R`OcrS\ ]RS` Vv`b 6]P 8gZO\$ 7Ob GbSdS\a$ BSWZ M]c\U& J][ @s`[ c\bS\ W[ <Oca PSY][[b S` YOc[ SbeOa [Wb& G] USVb ROa$ PWa S` RSa GbcRWc[a VOZPS` OcahWSVb& 8WS S`abS 8`]US$ RWS S` \W[[b$ Wab SW\S BOaS 7`gabOZ ASbV& 8Oa USaQVWSVb W[ ?wVZ`Oc[ SW\Sa YZSW\S\ <OcaVOZba[O`Yba$ e] S` W\ RS` <WUVaQV]]ZhSWb c\R a^sbS` OcQV W\ RS\ GS[SabS`TS`WS\ j]PPb& 8S` AO`Yb VOb PWa c[ hSV\ IV` OPS\Ra USvTT\Sb$ [O\ YO\\ R]`b GO\ReWQVSa$ :`wVabwQYaTZ]QYS\$ NWUO`SbbS\$ 6S\hW\ c\R V\ZWQVSa YOcTS\& 9W\ Hg^ \O[S\a AOf$ RS` RO O`PSWbSb$ UWPb W[ ROa ASbV& AOf Wab sZbS`$ a] SbeOa eWS SW\ ;Oc\S`jc\US aO[b RSOZS\RS` :`Sc\RW\3 [Wb WV[ VOb S` aWQV wPS` 8`]US\ c\bS`VOZbS\ c\R Oca FSRRW%eW^% 8]aS\ W\VOZWS`b$ aSWb aWS OPS\Ra R]`b hcaO[[S\ O`PSWbS\& 9W\Sa 5PS\Ra PWSbSb AOf Sa WV[ O\ c\R [OQVb Sa W[ ?wVZ`Oc[ hc`SQVb x SW\S YZSW\S Rw\\S @W\S OcT SW\S` 8]aS A]hhO`SZZO% GbWQYa c\R SW\ hcaO[[S\US`]ZZbS` 8]ZZO`aQVSW\ VW\bS` ?WabS\ [Wb 9WS`\$ AW\S`OZeOaaS` c\R <OZP%c\R%VOZP& 9a abWQVb W\ RS` BOaS$ c\R hc\sQVab [S`Yb S` \WQVba& 8O\\ Y][[b RS` FcQY$ ROa a^SSRWUS <]QVUSTwVZ$ d]\ RS[ AOf USa^`]QVS\ VOb$ c\R POZR eWZZ S` \]QV [OZ& GWS [OQVS\ ROa [Wb I\bS`P`SQVc\US\ jOV`SZO\U& @W\Sa ZSUS\ W[ ?wVZ`Oc[$ ?c\RS\ O\`cTS\$ 6WS` b`W\YS\$ ROa S` c\bS` RS[ H`SaS\ ZOUS`b& AOZ Wab Sa ?]YOW\$ [OZ ASbV& 8S` I\bS`aQVWSR eW`R WV[ \WS UO\h YZO` c\R W\bS`SaaWS`b WV\ OcQV \WQVb& 9a VWZTb$ RWS NSWb

I\bS`aQVWSR eW`R WV[ \WS UO\h YZO` c\R W\bS`SaaWS`b WV\ OcQV \WQVb& 9a VWZTb$ RWS NSWb VS`c[hcP`W\US\$ c\R dS`ZSWVb RS[ >]P SW\S G^`WbhWUYSWb c\R SW\S\ ;ZO\h$ RWS WV\ S`b`sUZWQV [OQVS\& ;`Oa Y][[b SW\ eS\WU a^sbS`$ c\R RO\\ Wab Sa W[[S` RO$ PWa S` c[ RWS +( Wab& 5[ 7]ZZSUS `OcQVb S` Sa PSW\OV bsUZWQV$ a^sbS` [Wb I\bS`P`SQVc\US\$ PWa Sa SW\Sa 5PS\Ra Y][WaQV aQV[SQYb$ WV\ Y`WPPZWU [OQVb c\R WV[ OcT RS\ AOUS\ aQVZsUb$ c\R RO\OQV `SWhb Sa WV\ \WQVb [SV`& KWS S` ROa S`abS AOZ 7`OQY `OcQVb& 8WSaS ;SaQVWQVbS S`hsVZb S` \WS& ASWabS\a aOUb S`$ S` VOPS Sa OcT SW\S` DO`bg ^`]PWS`b$ SW\ 6SYO\\bS`$ SW\ PST`Sc\RSbSa Ds`QVS\$ SW\ :`Sc\R$ jS[O\R$ RS\ S` \WQVb YO\\bS$ VOPS WV\ W\ SW\ ZSS`Sa NW[[S` USaQVZScab& 9a Wab jSRSa AOZ jS[O\R O\RS`a& 8WS S`Tc\RS\S ;SaQVWQVbS Vv`b aWQV Tw` WV\ abSba eS\WUS` PSaQVs[S\R O\$ eS\WUS` aQV`sU$ \]`[OZS`$ c\R aWS [OQVb [SV` VS`& 5PS` a] Wab Sa \c\ [OZ \WQVb USeSaS\& =\ aSW\S[ <SW[Ob]`b UWPb Sa SW\S\ 5\eOZb$ \S\\S\ eW` WV\ :Wbh& 9` Wab SW\ RWQYS` :WaQV W[ YZSW\S\ HSWQV RSa GbsRbQVS\a& GSW\ <Oca Wab U`]r$ OZb c\R W\ RS\ 5cUS\ jS\S`$ RWS a] SbeOa Yw[[S`b$ eWQVbWU& 9` c\R aSW\S :`Oc aW\R USaSZZWU& GWS USVv`S\ RS[ 7]c\b`g 7ZcP O\$ TOV`S\ dS`PScZbS OZbS J]Zd]a c\R AS`QSRSa$ RWS 6SO\%HOaQVS\$ RWS aWS wPS`OZZVW\ PSUZSWbS\$ b`OUS\ WV` A]\]U`O[[& 5ZZS YS\\S\ :Wbh& 9W\Sa G^sb\OQV[WbbOUa aWSVb S` :Wbh W\ BSe M]`Y& :Wbh aWSVb WV\& GWS aW\R \WQVb eSWb d]\ RS` YZSW\S\ @WbS`Obc`OUS\bc`$ W\ RS` S` jSbhb O`PSWbSb$ W`US\Re] W\ RS\ 9Oab :WTbWSa& GSW\S` 9`W\\S`c\U \OQV Wab Sa W\ RS` 6cQVVO\RZc\U W[ 7WbgQ]`^%;SPscRS$ OPS` US\Oc eSWr S` Sa \WQVb& 9` Wab jSbhb *- ]RS` *.& :Wbh U`wrb WV\ hcS`ab& 9` Wab W\ RS\ GSQVhWUS`\$ eSWb wPS` SW\a OQVbhWU U`]r$ aWZPS`U`Oc c\R Ucb OcaaSVS\R W\ RS` 5`b$ eWS SW\ =\bS`\ObaRW`SYb]` Ucb OcaaWSVb& :Wbh b`sUb SW\ USab`SWTbSa CfT]`RVS[R [Wb V]QVUSY`S[^SZbS\ `[SZ\ c\R VOb @SPS`TZSQYS O\ RS\ <s\RS\ c\R I\bS`O`[S\& ;SVS\ eW` R]QV hc [W` eOa b`W\YS\$ aQVZsUb :Wbh d]`& I\R aWS USVS\& 6OZR aW\R aWS hSV\ 6Z]QYa S\bTS`\b$ W\ :Wbhy K]V\c\U& 6SWRS b`W\YS\ K]RYO x S` S`hsVZb d]\ aSW\S\ ?W\RS`\$ SW\a W[ AWbbSZeSabS\$ SW\a OcT RS\ 6S`[cROa$ c\R SW\a abcRWS`b W\ KOaVW\Ub]\ \]QV >c`O& 8WS K]V\c\U ZWSUb W\ RS` I^^S` 9Oab GWRS$ SW\ YZSW\Sa 9W\hW[[S`O^O`b[S\b W\ SW\S[ OZbS\ AWSbaVOca& GWS `WSQVb S\bTS`\b \OQV A]bbS\YcUSZ\ c\R Wab OcaabOTTWS`b eWS SW\S GbcRWS\PS`Obc\UaabSZZS ]RS` ROa KO`bShW[[S` SW\Sa NOV\O`hbSa& 8WS aQVZWQVbS GWbhUO`\Wbc` Wab c\`cVWU PZOc c\R eSW\`]b US[cabS`b$ RWS J]`Vs\US aW\R PSWUS$ c\R OcT RS[ Rc\YSZP`Oc\S\ 7]cQVbWaQV [Wb RS\ O\USZOcTS\S\ ASaaW\UaQVO`\WS`S\ abSVS\ ZOcbS` :O[WZWS\T]b]a& BOQV SW\ ^OO` 8`W\Ya c\bS`VOZbS\ aWS aWQV wPS` GbcRWc[$ GSf$ 5ZY]V]Z c\R 8`]US\$ c\R ^ZvbhZWQV eW`R WV[ [Wb `SWQVZWQV JS`a^sbc\U YZO`$ ROaa :Wbh WV\ c\USOQVbSb RSa eWQVbWUS\ <OcaSa$ aSW\S` ?W\RS`$ aSW\S` :`Oc c\R aSW\S` 6SO\ 6OUa O\[OQVb& 9` VOb WV[ OcT RS[

<OcaSa$ aSW\S` ?W\RS`$ aSW\S` :`Oc c\R aSW\S` 6SO\ 6OUa O\[OQVb& 9` VOb WV[ OcT RS[ KSU hc` ?wQVS$ c[ \ScS ;Sb`s\YS hc V]ZS\$ SW\ ^OO`[OZ wPS` RS\ BOQYS\ USab`WQVS\$ Wab d][ GSaaSZ USUS\wPS` hc WV[ OcT RWS 7]cQV USY][[S\ c\R VOb WV[ PSW[ DZOcRS`\ [SV`[OZa RS\ CPS`aQVS\YSZ USR`wQYb& >Sbhb S`hsVZb WV[ :Wbh US`ORS$ ROaa S` VW\ c\R eWSRS` US`\S [OZ eOa `OcQVb& ASWabS\a ;`Oa$ USZSUS\bZWQV OPS` OcQV SbeOa Gbs`YS`Sa& :Wbh T`OUb WV\$ ]P S` aQV]\ [OZ nUSPOabl VOb$ c\R S` aOUb ]V\S NvUS`\ jO& 9a abW[[b heO` \WQVb$ OPS` S` VOb aQV]\ RO`O\ USROQVb& GWQV UST`OUb$ eWS Sa es`S$ aWQV RWS KW`Yc\U OcaUS[OZb$ OPS` Sa aOV \WQVb a] Oca$ OZa ew`RS S` jS RO[Wb W\ 6S`wV`c\U Y][[S\& n6OaS\l VWSr 7`OQY `OcQVS\$ c\R 7`OQY eO` RS` Gb]TT Y\OZZVO`bS` 8`]US\`OhhWS\$ wPS` RWS W[ @]YOZbSWZ RS` BSe M]`Y HW[Sa PS`WQVbSb ec`RS$ SbeOa$ ROa S` [Wb G]hWOZaWSRZc\US\ c\R ?\sabS\ dS`PO\R& 8WS UO\hS\ OQVbhWUS` >OV`S VW\Rc`QV$ W\ aSW\S` <WUVaQV]]ZhSWb$ [OQVbS 7`OQY GQVZOUhSWZS\ OZa RWS 8`]US$ RWS GbORbdWS`bSZ dS`Y][[S\ Zsaab$ RWS ?`W[W\OZWbsb V]QVb`SWPb c\R c\`SbbPO` awQVbWU [OQVb& 9W\S []\ab`vaS$ VSW[bwQYWaQVS ;SWrSZ$ OPa]Zcb bOPc& 9beOa$ ROa WV\ aQV]\ W[[S` US`SWhb VOb$ ROa S` aQV]\ W[[S` [OZ ^`]PWS`S\ e]ZZbS& 6WaVS` VOb S` \c` SW\S\ AS\aQVS\ USYO\\b$ RS` 7`OQY US`OcQVb VOb2 7O\Rg 8W:W]`S& 9` c\R 7O\Rg aW\R hcaO[[S\ W\ RS[ C`b OcTUSeOQVaS\$ W\ RS[ OcQV :Wbh ZSPb c\R O`PSWbSb& GWS eO` dWS` >OV`S sZbS` c\R P`OQVbS aWQV abs\RWU W\ GQVeWS`WUYSWbS\& GQVZWSrZWQV UW\U aWS d]\ RS` <WUVaQV]]Z OP$ c\R O\USPZWQV h]U aWS \OQV 5ZPO\g$ BSe M]`Y$ ZSPbS [Wb SW\S[ GQVeO`hS\ hcaO[[S\ c\R ec`RS Q`OQYawQVbWU& 7O\Rga ;SaQVWQVbS h]US\ RWS 9ZbS`\ W\ c\aS`S` ;SUS\R W[[S` US`\ OZa eO`\S\RSa 6SWa^WSZ ROTw` VS`O\2 KOa DOaaWS`b$ KS\\ AO\ 8`]US\ BW[[b& JWSZS >OV`S \OQV RS[ 5PS\R [Wb :Wbh eW`R S` aWQV O\ A`a& DO`a]\a S`W\\S`\$ aSW\S ?ZOdWS`ZSV`S`W\$ OZa S` hevZT eO`& 9W\S c\bS`aSbhbS =`W\$ RWS [W\RSabS\a OQVb ?W\RS` VObbS$ RWS `OcQVbS$ b`O\Y c\R b`ObaQVbS c\R [WbaO[b RWSaS\ OQVb ?W\RS`\ W\ SW\S[ U`w\S\ <scaQVS\ O[ Gc[^T`O\R e]V\bS& 9a aOV Oca eWS SW\ <SfS\VOca c\R VW\U W`US\ReWS aQVWST W\ RS\ O\U`S\hS\RS\ 6S`U VW\SW\& 9W\Sa HOUSa YO[ S` hc aSW\S` Gbc\RS$ c\R Sa hSWUbS aWQV a]T]`b$ ROaa S` \WQVb USwPb VObbS& KWSRS` \WQVb& GWS ZWSr WV\ SW\ eS\WU O\ SW\S` aW[^ZS\ 9bcRS VS`c[P]aaSZ\$ RO\\ ^OQYbS aWS WV\ PSW RS\ <s\RS\ c\R aOUbS$ S` a]ZZS OcTVv`S\& =QV aSVS aQV]\$ b]PbS aWS$ Rc eW`ab SW\ 7`OQYVSOR$ eS\\ Rc S`eOQVaS\ PWab$ US\Oc eWS 7O\Rg 8W:W]`S& 8Oa abSVb Tw` [WQV TSab& =V` heSW aSWR Oca RS[ UZSWQVS\ <]Zh& :Wbh USVb W\a GQVZOThW[[S` c\R Y][[b [Wb SW\S[ :ZsaQVQVS\ d]ZZ [WZQVWUS` YZSW\S` ?`WabOZZP`]QYS\ eWSRS`& 9` hWSVb SW\ Rc`QVaWQVbWUSa ;ZOa`vV`QVS\ Oca RS` HOaQVS$ ROa S` OZa DTSWTS PShSWQV\Sb$ ZSUb O\ SW\S[ 9\RS SW\ YZSW\Sa 8`OVbaWSP SW\ c\R RO`OcT RO\\ SW\ ^OO` GbwQYQVS\ ]RS` ?`w[SZ$ eWS S` Sa \S\\b$ d]\ RS[ 7`OQY& J]`aWQVbWU `SWQVb :Wbh WV[ ROa FvV`QVS\$ aOUb WV[$ S` a]ZZS Sa O\ RWS @W^^S\ VOZbS\ c\R hWSVb SW\ :ScS`hScU VS`d]`& 8Oa ;ZOa`vV`QVS\ Wab Rw\\$ c\R aSW\S <s\RS hWbbS`\& 9` VOb 5\Uab$ ROaa WV[ ROa 7`OQY

`OcaTsZZb$ OPS` Sa ^OaaWS`b \WQVba& :Wbh Y\W^ab ROa :ScS`hScU O\ c\R VsZb RWS :ZO[[S O\ ROa DTSWTS\S\RS& 9` hWSVb ZO\UaO[$ OZa S` aWSVb$ eWS ROa eSWrS NScU W\ RS` :ZO[[S 6ZOaS\ eW`Tb c\R ^ZObhb& DS`ZS\TO`PWUS` FOcQV UZSWbSb Rc`QV ROa FvV`QVS\$ c\R S` hWSVb TSabS`$ c[ WV\ hc aWQV hc P`W\US\& :Wbh aOUb WV[$ S` a]ZZ ZO\UaO[ [OQVS\$ c\R S` Vv`b OcT WV\& 6OZR Wab aSW\S @c\US d]ZZ$ c\R S` VsZb RWS @cTb O\ eWS PSW[ ;`Oa`OcQVS\& 9` Ob[Sb Oca c\R [caa a]T]`b VcabS\& 9a aQV[SQYb \OQV ASRWhW\ ]RS` FSW\WUc\Ua[WbbSZ$ OPS` OcQV SbeOa awrZWQV$ \OQV @W[]\S& 8S` FOcQV eOPS`b O\ :Wbh d]`PSW W\a K]V\hW[[S` eWS SW\ U`]rS`$ aWQV S\b`]ZZS\RS` 8`OQVS& KsV`S\R S` hcaWSVb$ eWS RS` FOcQV aWQV Y`scaSZ\R OcaP`SWbSb$ a^w`b S` RS\ FOcaQV S`ab eWS SW\ :ZObbS`\$ RO\\ eWS SW\ 6`wZZS\& 9W\ GQVeOZZ \ScS` 9\S`UWS Rc`QVTsV`b WV\ PWa W\ RWS <OO`a^WbhS\$ c\R W\ SW\S[ 5cUS\PZWQY d]ZZY][[S\S\ JS`USaaS\a Wab hcUZSWQV \WQVba c\R OZZSa W\ aSW\S[ 6SecaabaSW\& <W\bS` aSW\S\ 5cUS\ YSV`b a] SbeOa eWS :`WSRS\ SW\& 8S` :`WSRS\ eO\RS`b d]\ aSW\S\ GQVZsTS\ VW\c\bS` hc` 6`cab$ W\ aSW\S <s\RS c\R wPS`OZZVW\& 9` Rc`QVb]ab WV\ x YW\SbWaQV$ aSfcSZZ$ Sc^V]`WaQV x eWS SW\ ec\RS`d]ZZS` <c``WYO\$ RS` [Wb @WQVbUSaQVeW\RWUYSWb b]Pb& 9a Wab RWS es`[abS$ hs`bZWQVabS @WSPY]ac\U$ RWS S` jS S`ZSPb VOb$ c\R OZa aWS \OQVZsaab$ RWS YsZbSabS <O\R& 8Oa ;STwVZ TSVZb WV[ aQV]\$ SVS Sa UO\h eSU Wab$ c\R S` [vQVbS Sa \WQVb \c` eWSRS`VOPS\$ a]\RS`\ S` P`OcQVb Sa& 8S`eSWZ VsZb WV\ SW\ aWZPS`VOO`WUS`$ Ucb OcaaSVS\RS` AO\\ d]\ hc <OcaS W[ 5`[$ ab`SWQVSZb aSW\ 6SW\ c\R aOUb WV[$ S` [OQVb \]QV SW\S DTSWTS$ [Wb [SV` 7`OQY$ RWS aWS RO\\ hcaO[[S\ `OcQVS\& 8WSa[OZ UWPb S` aWQV OZZS AwVS$ ZO\UaO[ hc hWSVS\$ R]QV :Wbh aOUb WV[$ ROaa S` W[[S` \]QV hc TSab hWSVb$ ROaa S` RWS DTSWTS O\P`S\\b& 9` hWSVb UO\h ZSWQVb$ c\R aSW\S @c\US TwZZb aWQV& KWSRS` [caa S` VcabS\$ c\R eWSRS` Y][[b RWS 9f^Z]aW]\ RSa :wVZS\a c\R BWQVbTwVZS\a$ ROa 6SecaabaSW\ d]\ OZZS[ c\R \WQVba$ RS` USeOZbWUS 9\S`UWSaQVcP$ RS` WV\ abWZZVOZbS\ Zsaab& :Wbh \W[[b RWS DTSWTS O\ aWQV$ Zsaab aWS OPYwVZS\ c\R ab]^Tb aWS Tw` aWQV& KsV`S\R :Wbh W\VOZWS`b$ PSRScbSb S` WV[$ aWQV aSW\S\ @W^^S\ hc \sVS`\ x Sa Wab YZO`$ ROaa S` WV[ RO[Wb O\PWSbSb$ WV[ FOcQV W\ RS\ Ac\R hc PZOaS\& I\R esV`S\R S` ROa bcb$ TO\US\ aWS O\$ aWQV hc YwaaS\& B]QV \WS eO` SbeOa a] S``SUS\R& 8WSaS` b]PS\RS Gbc`[$ RS` WV\ Rc`QVb]ab$ esV`S\R S` SW\S\ AO\\ Ywaab$ RS\ heSWbS\ ]RS` R`WbbS\ S`ab W\ aSW\S[ @SPS\ x SW\S\ AO\\$ RS` sZbS` OZa aSW\ JObS` Wab$ RS\ S` aQV]\ OZa ?W\R W[ @SPS\a[WbbSZZORS\ c\R W\ RS` 6wQVS`SW aSW\Sa <SW[Obv`bQVS\a USaSVS\ VOb& GWS Y\cbaQVS\$ hWSVS\ aWQV Oca c\R dS`ZOUS`\ ROa UO\hS DTSWTS`OcQVS\ c\R ?waaS\ W\a GQVZOThW[[S`& 9a eW`R SW\ aQVeW\RSZS``SUS\RS` BSPSZ Oca FOcQV c\R <Ocb$ c\R Sa Wab Tw` WV\ ROa SW\hWUS AOZ$ ROaa RS` 5Pabc`h \OQV RS[ ;ZwQYa`OcaQV \WQVb c[a] aQVZW[[S` Wab$ ROa SW\hWUS AOZ$ ROaa PSWRSa \WQVb VO`b OcTSW\O\RS`^`OZZb& 8S` 5Pabc`h Y][[b$ OZa S` SW\ ^OO` Gbc\RS\ a^sbS` USVb$ Yc`h d]` AWbbS`\OQVb$ c\R WV[ YZO` eW`R$ ROaa S` aSW\S` :`Sc\RW\ BSZZ a] \WQVb USUS\wPS`b`SbS\ YO\\ x RS` :`Oc$ [Wb RS` S` aSWb wPS` heSW >OV`S\ hcaO[[S\ZSPb$ ]Pe]VZ S` aWQV hc\SV[S\R hc As\\S`\ VW\USh]US\ TwVZb&

9VS S` :Wbhy K]V\c\U dS`Zsaab$ USVb S` W\a 6OR c\R esaQVb aWQV a]`UTsZbWU RWS <s\RS$ RWS `crWU c\R `]bdS`P`O\\b aW\R d]\ RS` VSWrS\ DTSWTS& 9` esaQVb aWQV ROa ;SaWQVb c\R Ys[[b aWQV RWS <OO`S$ RO[Wb [O\ WV[ RWS abc\RS\ZO\US FO[[SZSW \WQVb O\aWSVb& 9` ^`wTb aSW\S ?ZSWRc\U$ YZ]^Tb RS\ 6ZOhS` OP$ aQVOcb$ ROaa RWS ?\v^TS O[ <S[R hc aW\R$ RS` ?`OUS\ US`ORS aWbhb$ RS` FSWrdS`aQVZcaa aSW\S` <]aS \WQVb ]TTS\ Wab& <W\bS` RS` USaQVZ]aaS\ Hw` RSa eW\hWUS\ 6ORa \SPS\ RS[ 9W\UO\U [OQVb S` ROa OZZSa aQV\SZZ c\R [SQVO\WaQV [W\RSabS\a SW\ 8cbhS\R [OZ& 9a Wab$ OZa es`S S` OcT 5cb]^WZ]b ]RS` eSQVaSZbS W\abW\YbUSabScS`b d]\ SW\S[ NcabO\R W\ RS\ O\RS`S\& 9` hWSVb aSW\S G]QYS\ O\$ `SWPb RWS :ZSQYS d]\ aSW\S[ GQVcV c\R eWaQVb aWQV \]QV SW\[OZ RWS GbW`\& 5Za S` aSW\S <OO`S ^`wTb c\R [Wb RS[ Ac\ReOaaS` Uc`USZb$ ROa S` W[ 5`h\SWaQV`O\Y TW\RSb$ YZ]^Tb :Wbh eWSRS`V]Zb O\ RWS Hw`$ ]P OZZSa W\ C`R\c\U Wab& ?][[S UZSWQV$ `cTb S` [Wb SW\S[ ZSbhbS\ 6ZWQY W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ& 9` acQVb aWQV OcT RS` @SfW\Ub]\ SW\ HOfW c\R V]TTb$ ROaa BSZZ aQV]\ aQVZsTb& 9a dS`PZwTTb WV\$ eWS aWQV ROa NSWbS`ZSPS\ dS`s\RS`b VOb$ a] ROaa aSQVa Gbc\RS\ WV[ eWS AW\cbS\ d]`USY][[S\ aW\R& 9` VOb 5\Uab$ S` Yv\\bS SbeOa dS`USaaS\ VOPS\& KOa$ eSWr S` \WQVb US\Oc x 6`WSTbOaQVS c\R GQVZwaaSZ aW\R RO$ RWS ?`OeObbS abSQYb W\ aSW\S` 6ZOhS`bOaQVS x$ OPS` W`US\RSbeOa TSVZb$ RO Wab S` aWQVS`& 8Oa Wab Yc`h d]` ]RS` Yc`h \OQV RS[ 5PS\R$ O\ RS[ S` B]OV YS\\S\ZS`\b& AWb GWQVS`VSWb Wab Sa$ PSd]` S` BSZZ [WbbSWZb$ ROaa S` aWS dS`ZOaaS\ [caa3 PSd]` S` B]OV aSW\S` AcbbS` d]`abSZZb$ RWS WV[ aOUb$ ROaa S` ?W[ \WQVba ROd]\ aOUS\ RO`T c\R \WS[O\RS[ Oca RS` :O[WZWS$ RS` Sa WV` S`hsVZS\ Yv\\bS$ eSWZ aWS O[ 9\RS a]\ab RWS NeWZZW\US dS`ZWS`b$ [Wb RS\S\ aWS aSWb Yc`hS[ aQVeO\US` Wab& 6Sd]` S` B]OV aSW\S[ 7VST$ aSW\S\ :`Sc\RS\ c\R RS\ 5cb]`S\ d]`abSZZb$ [Wb RS\S\ S` O`PSWbSb& 9a Wab$ PSd]` B]OV W\ aSW\S\ ?`SWaS\ PSYO\\b eW`R$ OPS` eOa hcS`ab eO` x RS` 5PS\R$ O\ RS[ S` B]OV YS\\S\ZS`\bS$ ]RS` RS` 5PS\R [Wb :Wbh x$ Zsaab aWQV \WQVb YZs`S\& 9a eO` SW\S NSWb$ W\ RS` OZZSa \OQV SW\S[ 5\TO\U OcaaOV&

:O[WZWS\b`STTS\
B]OV Wab ROa 9`abS$ eOa WQV aSVS$ OZa WQV W[ AO`WbW[S%<]bSZ Oca RS[ 5cThcU abSWUS& <OZP YOcS`\R$ Ps`bWU$ hWbb`WU$ SW\ ?\WS O[ 6]RS\$ aQVSW\b S` Z]aa^`W\bS\ hc e]ZZS\ c\R VsZb UZSWQVhSWbWU aQVwbhS\R RWS <s\RS wPS` aWQV$ OZa Tw`QVbS S` SW\S\ 5\U`WTT& I\R RO Wab \]QV SbeOa x OZa TwVZbS S` aWQV S`bO^^b$ OZa es`S S` VWS` RS` GQVcZRWUS& =QV VOPS WV\ aSWb RS[ 5PS\R W[ 7O`ZgZS d]` R`SW HOUS\ \WQVb USaSVS\& =QV ZOcTS O\ WV[ d]`PSW hc[ 5caUO\U& 9` `cTb$ c\R WQV PZSWPS \WQVb abSVS\& J]\ e]O\RS`a VS` Vv`S WQV2 6WZZg 6WZZg4 BWS[O\R \S\\b [WQV 6WZZg x \c` [SW\S :O[WZWS$ GbcRWS\T`Sc\RS c\R @ScbS$ [Wb RS\S\ WQV OcTUSeOQVaS\ PW\ x c\R jSbhb Vv`S WQV RS\ BO[S\$ OZa ]P S` [W` wPS` SW\S\ ?wQVS\bWaQV Oca [SW\S` ?W\RVSWb hcUS`cTS\ eW`R& 6WZZg 9a Wab [SW\S YZSW\S GQVeSabS` @WaO& =QV aSVS aWS heO` \WQVb$ S`YS\\S jSR]QV WV`S GbW[[S& GWS Wab Tw\Tc\RheO\hWU$ VOb OPS` SW\S dS``OcQVbS$ d]\ H`Oc`WUYSWb hS``wbbSbS GbW[[S$ RWS hc PSY][[S\ \]QV [OZ heO\hWU >OV`S VsbbS ROcS`\ a]ZZS\& AO\QVS @ScbS [OQVb a] SW\S GbW[[S O\& =QV aSVS [WQV OcT RS[ KSU hc[ 5caUO\U W\ RS` @]PPg c[$ c\R RO aW\R aWS& ASW\ JObS`& ?W[& @WaO& ASW\S :O[WZWS& ASW\S :O[WZWS ]V\S [SW\S AcbbS` c\R [SW\S\ YZSW\S\ 6`cRS` GSO\& =QV YO\\ \WQVb UZOcPS\$ ROaa aWS RO aW\R& ASW\ JObS` [caa Sfb`O d]\ BSe <O[^aVW`S USY][[S\ aSW\$ e] S` OZZSW\ W\ RS\ 6S`US\ e]V\b$ [SW\S GQVeSabS` ?W[ Oca AOW\S$ e] aWS [Wb WV`S[ AO\\ c\R RS\ NeWZZW\US\ ZSPb3 @WaO Oca 6]ab]\& =QV USVS SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\UaO[S`$ c[ [WQV hc dS`USeWaaS`\$ ROaa RS` YZSW\S AO\\ W\ RS` ZScQVbS\R PZOcS\ KW\RjOQYS c\R RS\ U`OcS\ BSe%6OZO\QS%@OcTaQVcVS\$ RS` RO W\ RS` aQVWQYS\$ aQVc[[S`WUS\ @]PPg RSa AO`WbW[S abSVb$ eW`YZWQV [SW\ JObS` Wab& 9` VOb W\ RS\ hevZT >OV`S\$ RWS WQV W\ BSe M]`Y ZSPS$ \]QV \WS SW\S\ :cr OcT RWS =\aSZ AO\VObbO\ USaSbhb& B]QV YSW\ SW\hWUSa AOZ VOb S` USaSVS\$ e] WQV e]V\S ]RS` e] WQV O`PSWbS& I\R OcQV B]OV VOb S` PWa jSbhb \WQVb YS\\S\USZS`\b& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P WQV <OZZchW\ObW]\S\ VOPS&

VOPS& ?][[ aQV]\$ KWZZWS$ abO[[SZb RS` AO\\ [Wb abO`YS[ 6]ab]\S` 9W\aQVZOU& 9` Wab Sa& GWSVb Oca eWS SW\ P`cbOZ aSW\S` Zs\RZWQVS\ 5PUSaQVWSRS\VSWb S\b`WaaS\S` >& 8& GOZW\US`$ RS\ [O\ W\ RWS RS\YPO` c\eW`bZWQVabS ;`]rabORbahS\S`WS dS`T`OQVbSb VOb& =QV [OQVS$ ROaa WQV `OcaY][[S& 5Za WQV O\ RS` Hw` PW\$ ^OQYb [WQV @WaO O\ RS` >OQYS& =QV `WSQVS WV` DO`Tc[ c\R NWUO`SbbS\`OcQV$ aQVwbbZS aWS OP c\R `S\\S hc` BW\bV 5dS\cS& GWS aSbhb [W` \OQV c\R `cTb$ WQV a]ZZS hc`wQYY][[S\& 9W\ HOfW VsZb [Wb SW\S[ FcQY O[ Gb`OrS\`O\R& =QV abSWUS SW\$ `cTS2 :OV`S\ GWS Z]a $ c\R ;]bb aSW 8O\Y bc\ eW` ROa OcQV& 8WS G]\\S PZWbhb Oca RS[ 7V`][ c\R ;ZOa RSa S\bUSUS\Y][[S\RS\ JS`YSV`a$ c\R [Wb hcaO[[S\USY\WTTS\S\ 5cUS\ aSVS WQV$ eWS @WaO OcT RWS Gb`OrS Y][[b$ SW\S[ HOfW eW\Yb$ RWS Hw` OcT`SWrb$ YOc[ ROaa Sa O\USVOZbS\ VOb$ c\R `SW\a^`W\Ub& 9` a]ZZS ROa HOfW OPVs\US\$ `cTS WQV RS[ :OV`S` hc c\R aQVs[S [WQV Tw` ROa aQV`SQYZWQV H`WQYTWZ[VOTbS RS` GWbcObW]\& 8WS GhS\S aQVSW\b eWS a] dWSZS$ RWS WQV S`ZSPS$ SW\S[ BOQV[WbbOUa%G^SQWOZ d]\ 6`WUVb @WUVba$ 6WU 7Wbg S\bZSV\b hc aSW\& 8S` HOfWTOV`S` TwUb aWQV W\ aSW\S F]ZZS x dS`R`SVb RWS 5cUS\$ TsV`b eSWbS`& 8c`QVa FwQYTS\abS` aSVS WQV$ eWS aWQV [SW\S 5\USVv`WUS\ c\R B]OV OcT RS` Gb`OrS dS`bSWZS\& 9a Wab AWbbOU$ c\R c[ aWS VS`c[ `OcaQVb RWS KSZb eSWbS`& =QV abOc\S$ eWS YZSW\ aWS aW\R$ eWS YZSW\ ROa OZZSa Wab& KWS aQV\SZZ RWSaS c\aQVSW\PO`S\ YZSW\S\ ;`]rabORbR`O[S\ d]`PSW c\R dS`USaaS\ aW\R& Hw`S\ TOZZS\ W\a GQVZ]aa$ A]b]`S\ VScZS\ OcT$ HOfWa aOcaS\ _cWSbaQVS\R ROd]\$ AS\aQVS\ hS`ab`ScS\ aWQV& 8c`QVa :S\abS` aSVS WQV aWS hc Dw\YbQVS\ eS`RS\& 5ZZSa eW`Tb @WQVb hc`wQY c\R PZS\RSb [WQV&

5ca RS[ GQV\SWRS`

BOQV R`SW >OV`S\ FS[WaaW]\ Wab RS` 6`cabY`SPa [SW\S` AcbbS` hc`wQYUSY][[S\& 8WS @WbS`Obc`OUS\bc`$ RWS ?ObS c\R WQV USU`w\RSb VOPS\$ Wab aSWb SW\WUS\ A]\ObS\ USvTT\Sb$ c\R S\RZWQV VOPS\ eW` OcQV HSZST]\& =QV eWZZ c\PSRW\Ub RWS J]`eOVZ *)* c\R S\baQVSWRS [WQV USUS\ RS\ FOb [SV`S`S` :`Sc\RS Tw` 5HH$ eSWZ ROa RS` SW\hWUS 5\PWSbS` Wab$ RS` c\a YSW\S .,.S` ]RS` UO` +,/S` Bc[[S` OcTR`wQYb& 8Oa Wab [W` eWQVbWU& JWSZS JS`hvUS`c\US\ c\R DO\\S\ T]ZUS\$ c\R RO ROa BSbh W\ AO\VObbO\$ eWS WQV VS`OcaTW\RS$ JS`Wh]\ USVv`b c\R 5HH WV` ?c\RS Wab$ [caa RWS AOQYS W\ c\aS`S[ 5\aQVZcaa wPS` JS`Wh]\ PS`SW\WUb eS`RS\$ eS\\ OcQV d]\ SW\S[ Gbv`c\UaacQVS` RS` 5HH W\ :Z]`WRO& 8WSaS HSZST]\USa^`sQVS ROcS`\ jSRS\ HOU Gbc\RS\& =\ RS\ S`abS\ K]QVS\$ OZa eW` c\aS`S ;SaQVsTbS \]QV ^S` <O\Rg OPeWQYSZ\$ eW`R c\a [SV`TOQV YZO`US[OQVb$ ROaa eW` ]V\S eSWbS`Sa SW\S\ :SabO\aQVZcaa PSY][[S\$ eS\\ eW` YZSW\ PSWUSPS\ c\R hc JS`Wh]\ USVS\& 8Oa ZSV\S WQV W[[S` eWSRS` OP c\R PSabSVS OcT RS` *)*& =QV ZOaaS a]UO` c\aS` UO\hSa 6`WST^O^WS` R`cQYS\$ PSd]` TSababSVb$ ROaa eW` RWS aQVv\S\ *)*%Bc[[S`\$ RWS 5HH c\a d]` A]\ObS\ hcUSeWSaS\ VOb$ eW`YZWQV PSY][[S\& =\ RWSaS` NSWb dS`YOcTS WQV [SV` 6wQVS`$ OZa WQV S`eO`bSb VObbS$ abSZZS [Wb ?ObSa <WZTS 5aaWabS\bS\ c\R SW\S @WhS\hT`Oc SW\$ USVS [Wb JS`ZSUS`\ c\R 5cb]`S\ SaaS\ c\R `SRS [SV`[OZa O[ HOU [Wb [SW\S` GQVeSabS` c\R [SW\S` AcbbS`& ASW\S AcbbS` Zsaab aWQV W\ SW\S` 6`cabY`SPaYZW\WY W\ 6]ab]\ PSVO\RSZ\ c\R TsV`b d]\ 7]\\SQbWQcb jSRSa AOZ R`SW Gbc\RS\ VW\ c\R hc`wQY& BOQV SW\WUS\ K]QVS\ `sb RS` 5`hb$ RS` WV`S\ HVS`O^WS^ZO\ S`abSZZb VOb$ hc` 9\bTS`\c\U PSWRS` 6`wabS$ c\R \]QV O[ aSZPS\ HOU a]ZZ aWS aWQV SW\S` `SY]\ab`cYbWdS\ C^S`ObW]\ c\bS`hWSVS\& 8Oa PSRScbSb$ aWS eW`R OQVb ]RS` \Sc\ Gbc\RS\ W[ CD aSW\$ [caa OPS`$ eS\\ OZZSa Ucb USVb$ RO\OQV \WQVb [SV` c\bS`a ASaaS`& =QV VOPS SW\S DagQV]bVS`O^WS PSU]\\S\& 9a Wab \WQVb RWS S`abS& 8WS S`abS VObbS WQV d]` Tw\T >OV`S\$ PSW SW\S[ R`OVbWUS\$ O\USVS\R YOVZS\ 5`hb O[ ;`O[S`Qg DO`Y \O[S\a 8`& 8OdS& 6SW 8OdS eO` WQV [Wb Tw\Tc\RheO\hWU$ OZa WQV \]QV [Wb BSZZ hcaO[[S\ZSPbS c\R RWS SW\ab eS\WU OcaUS^`sUbS KOV`\SV[c\U [s\\ZWQVS` GQVv\VSWb O\TW\U$ aWQV [Wb AOQVb W\ RS\ J]`RS`U`c\R hc R`s\US\& 6Wa ROVW\ PSaQV`s\YbS aWQV [SW\S aSfcSZZS 9`TOV`c\U [Wb As\\S`\ OcT SW\ 6OV\V]TaYZ]US^Zs\YSZ esV`S\R RS` 7]ZZSUShSWb c\R SW\ ^OO` VSWrS Gbc\RS\ [Wb SW\S[ 5aaWabS\hO`hb Tw` C\Y]Z]UWS$ RS` W\ RS` BsVS [SW\S` S`abS\ BSe M]`YS` K]V\c\U ZSPbS& 8WSaS 9^Wa]RS\ aQV`WSP WQV RS` BScUWS` hc c\R aQV]P aWS eSU& 8]QV USUS\ 9\RS [SW\S` 6ShWSVc\U [Wb BSZZ$ PSd]` WQV B]OV YS\\S\ZS`\S$ PSaQVsTbWUS\ [WQV As\\S` aSV` x WV`S ?v`^S`$ WV`S GbW[[S\$ WV` ;S`cQV& =QV dS`acQVS [WQV hc S`W\\S`\$ eWS Sa eO`$ F]\$ RS\ C\Y]Z]US\$ hc YwaaS\$ eWS OcT`SUS\R WQV RS\ ?`ObhPO`b O\ [SW\S[ ;SaWQVb c\R RS\ 8cTb aSW\S` T`WaQV USPwUSZbS\ <S[RS\ TO\R& 9W\ ^OO`[OZ `cTS WQV

[SW\S[ ;SaWQVb c\R RS\ 8cTb aSW\S` T`WaQV USPwUSZbS\ <S[RS\ TO\R& 9W\ ^OO`[OZ `cTS WQV SW\S HSZST]\\c[[S` Oca HVS JWZZOUS J]WQS Tw` As\\S` OcT RS` GcQVS \OQV GSfY]\bOYbS\ O\$ c\R eS\\ BSZZ dS``SWab Wab$ b`STTS WQV [WQV [Wb SW\WUS\ RWSaS` >c\Ua& BWS Wab ROa a] OcT`SUS\R eWS RWS S`abS\ 5cUS\PZWQYS [Wb F]\ [W` W\ 9`W\\S`c\U aW\R$ c\R R]QV U`SWTS WQV OcT RWSaS HSZST]\\c[[S`\ hc`wQY c\R Vv`S aQVSW\PO` SW\aO[S\$ dS`heSWTSZbS\ As\\S`\ hc$ RWS \sQVbS\a OcT DO`b\S`TO\U aW\R& =QV RS\YS [W`$ eS\\ WQV hc SW\S[ DagQV]Z]US\ USVS c\R Sa [W` d]\ RS` GSSZS `SRS$ YO\\ WQV ROa a] R`W\US\R USe]`RS\S 6SRw`T\Wa Z]aeS`RS\ ]RS` Sa hc[W\RSab a] hc`SQVb`wQYS\$ ROaa WQV \WQVb RO\OQV hc VO\RSZ\ P`OcQVS& CV\S OcT RWS ;`w\RS SW\hcUSVS\$ T`OUS WQV [SW\S\ 7VST c\R [SV`S`S :`Sc\RS \OQV S[^TSVZS\aeS`bS\ HVS`O^ScbS\ c\R DagQVWObS`\& :w\T ]RS` aSQVa acQVS WQV OcT$ heSW ROd]\ heSW[OZ$ c\R S\baQVSWRS [WQV aQVZWSrZWQV Tw` 8`& 8OdS& 9` \W[[b )/- 8]ZZO` RWS Gbc\RS x \WQVb aSW\S wPZWQVS\ *-($ eSWZ WQV eS\WU dS`RWS\S x$ c\R S` eWZZ [WQV heSW[OZ RWS K]QVS aSVS\& 8`SW ]RS` dWS` GWbhc\US\ ZO\U eW`R [SW\ =\bS`SaaS O\ As\\S`\ S`v`bS`b$ SVS eW` OcT [SW\S ?W\RVSWbaT`Sc\RS x ?S\\g$ 5RO[$ AWQVOSZ x hc a^`SQVS\ Y][[S\ c\R RWS :`OUS$ ]P WQV [WQV aSfcSZZ hc WV\S\ VW\USh]US\ USTwVZb VOPS& =QV UZOcPS \WQVb$ c\R S` [vQVbS$ ROaa WQV [WQV hc`wQYS`W\\S`S$ ]P WQV WV`S DW[[SZ USaSVS\ VOPS c\R aWS [SW\S\& =`US\ReO\\ aOUS WQV aOQVZWQV$ ROaa [SW\S\ DW[[SZ e]VZ \WS[O\R USaSVS\ VOb& 5Za 8`& 8OdS [WQV RO`OcT VW\eSWab$ ROaa WQV \OQV SWUS\S` 5caaOUS PSW[ :ZWSUS\TWaQVS\ OcT RS[ <]caOb]\WQ FWdS` [SV`[OZa RS\ d]\ AWQVOSZ USaSVS\ VOPS$ O\be]`bS WQV eWSRS`c[ aOQVZWQV$ ROaa WQV \WS W\ RS\ :Zcaa US^W\YSZb VOPS$ a]\RS`\ ROhc W[[S` O\a ITS` c\R W\ RS\ KOZR USUO\US\ PW\& KO`c[4$ T`OUb S`& 8Oa eSWr WQV \WQVb$ O\be]`bS WQV& <OPS\ GWS aWQV eSUS\ =V`Sa DS\Wa USaQVs[b$ ]RS` eO` S` =V\S\ ^SW\ZWQV4$ TsV`b S` T]`b& BSW\$ WQV UZOcPS \WQVb& KO`c[ RO\\4 KO`c[4$ T`OUb S` \]QV SW\[OZ& I\R RO PW\ WQV& AWb SZT ]RS` hevZT& =[ KOZR$ VW\bS` SW\S[ ;SeW`` d]\ NeSWUS\ TcV`eS`YS c\R Vw^TS WQV VS`c[ c\R PSO`PSWbS [SW\S\ GQVeO\h$ OZa abs\RS S` W\ :ZO[[S\ c\R WQV [waabS ROa :ScS` ZvaQVS\& I\R [Wb RWSaS` SW\S\ 9`W\\S`c\U abSZZS\ aWQV hWUbOcaS\R O\RS`S SW\& NcS`ab UZOcPS WQV \WQVb RO`O\$ OPS` RO Wab SW\S Yv`^S`ZWQVS 9[^TW\Rc\U$ SW\ KWSRS`S`YS\\S\ W[ ?v`^S`USRsQVb\Wa$ ROa [WQV ROd]\ OPVsZb$ ROa ;O\hS OZa SW\S :SVZaQVOZbc\U W[ ?]^T OPhcbc\&

8`& 8OdS c\R WQV dS`P`W\US\ O\RS`bVOZP >OV`S RO[Wb$ OZZSa eWSRS` VS`OcThcV]ZS\ x RWS H]WZSbbS RS` GQVcZaQVeSabS`$ RWS PZcbPSTZSQYbS I\bS`esaQVS$ [SW\S\ JObS`& 5cT WV\ dS`eS\RS\ eW` dWSZ NSWb& KOa S` USaOUb VOb$ eWS S` Sa USaOUb VOb$ eWS [W` ROPSW hc[cbS eO`& =[ 8SbOWZ& I\R OZa WQV RO\\ B]OV YS\\S\ZS`\S c\R eW` SW\ VOZPSa >OV` a^sbS` hcaO[[S\hWSVS\$ eS`RS WQV Sa ZSWR$ [WQV [Wb [SW\S\ ?W\RVSWbaYs[^TS\ hc PSaQVsTbWUS\$ c\R ZOaaS 8`& 8OdS aOcaS\& 9W\Sa HOUSa USVS WQV SW\TOQV \WQVb [SV` VW\& 9` a^`WQVb [W` heSW[OZ OcT RS\ 5\`cTPSO\be]`bS`$ OPS` WQV PShOVZS aSW\S FSQV\c\U c\R `cTS WV\ \WQVb hc`wQY& =QV a^`SQVS [Wb \WS[O\RS[ wPS` [SW\S 9`W\\S`c\US\$ c\R \OQV SW\WUS` NSWb T`OUS WQV [WQV eWSRS`$ ]P \WQVb OZZSa R]QV \c` ^VO\bOaWS`b eO`& GQVZWSrZWQV dS`PZOaab Sa c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb eSWbUSVS\R Oca [SW\S\ ;SRO\YS\& >Sbhb$ R`SW >OV`S a^sbS`$ PW\ WQV R`SWrWU c\R VOPS RS\ >]P OcTUSUSPS\$ RS\ WQV aWSPS\ >OV`S ZO\U VObbS$ [SW\S\ S`abS\ c\R SW\hWUS\ W\ BSe M]`Y$ c[ [Wb SW\S` :`Sc\RW\ hcaO[[S\ SW\S 5US\bc` hc U`w\RS\& =\heWaQVS\ VOPS WQV B]OV YS\\S\USZS`\b x O\ SW\S[ 5PS\R$ OZa BSZZ \WQVb W\ RS` GbORb Wab c\R WQV SW\S RWSaS` ?]\bOYb\c[[S`\ O\`cTS& 9` a^OhWS`b W\ [SW\S K]V\c\U$ c\R e]`bZ]a YwaaS\ eW` c\a& KW` `SRS\ RWS UO\hS BOQVb& 9` Wab [OaYcZW\$ OPS` OcQV OZPS`\ c\R VS`hZWQV$ c\R WQV [OQVS [WQV SW\ >OV` jw\US`$ OZa WQV PW\$ aOUS WV[$ ROaa WQV W\ <O`dO`R eO` c\R ROaa [SW\ JObS` W\ RS` AO`ZP]`]cUV Gb`SSb W\ 6]ab]\ OcTUSeOQVaS\ Wab& 8WS S`abS\ PSWRS\ @wUS\ PS`WQVbWUS WQV$ \]QV PSd]` Sa A]`US\ eW`R$ R]QV RWS ZSbhbS ZOaaS WQV abSVS\& ASW\ JObS` aSZPab eW`R >OV`S a^sbS`$ OZa aWS aWQV hc[ S`abS\ c\R SW\hWUS\ AOZ PSUSU\S\$ B]OV aOUS\$ ROaa S` W\ 8SRVO[$ AOaaOQVcaSbba$ OcTUSeOQVaS\ Wab$ SW\S` AWbbSZabO\Ra%GQVZOTabORb d]` RS\ H]`S\ 6]ab]\a& KW` S`hsVZS\ OZZS\$ eW` VsbbS\ c\a W\ 6`]]YZg\ OcT RS` ;SPc`babOUaTSWS` SW\Sa [SW\S` ?ZWS\bS\ YS\\S\USZS`\b$ RS` SW\ GQVcZT`Sc\R d]\ B]OV aSW& 8Oa Wab c\aS` S`abSa US[SW\aO[Sa ;SVSW[\Wa& KW` Yv\\S\ Sa x c\R OcQV O\RS`S x ZO\US NSWb eOV`S\& =QV b`W\YS hc dWSZ$ c\R WQV YO\\ \WQVb OcTVv`S\$ 8SOZS` O\hc`cTS\ c\R PWa W\ RWS Dc^^S\ VS`c[hcab`Sc\S\& =QV PW\ Q`OQYawQVbWU c\R eSWr Sa$ OcQV B]OV eSWr Sa$ OPS` Tw` OZZS O\RS`S\ PW\ WQV SW\ hcdS`ZsaaWUS`$ O\abs\RWUS` ?S`Z [Wb SW\S` dWSZdS`a^`SQVS\RS\ jc\US\ :W`[O c\R SW\S[ b]ZZS\ :`Sc\R& KW` aW\R W\ SW\S` aQVv\S\ K]V\c\U$ RWS B]OVa ;`]r[cbbS` PO` PShOVZb VOb$ c\R eW` VOPS\ aWS [Wb OZbS\ :]b]a$ O\bWYS\ AvPSZ\ c\R bSc`S\ DS`aS`\ OcaUSabObbSb& 5ca RS` :S`\S USaSVS\ Wab Sa SW\ PS\SWRS\aeS`bSa @SPS\& J]\ BOVS[ PSb`OQVbSb Wab Sa ROa \c` hc[ HSWZ2 =QV ZWSPS B]OV$ R]QV OPUSaSVS\ d]\ RS\ R`]US\PSRW\UbS\ H`ScZ]aWUYSWbS\ VOPS WQV heSW 5TTs`S\ USVOPb x SW\S [Wb SW\S[ AO\\$ SW\S [Wb SW\S` :`Oc& =QV PW\ TSab wPS`hScUb$ ROaa B]OV [W` RWS UO\hS 6ShWSVc\U VW\Rc`QV b`Sc USeSaS\ Wab& KW` aW\R ab]Zh OcT RWS K]V\c\U$ RWS eW` [Wb a]ZQVS` G]`UTOZb SW\US`WQVbSb VOPS\$ OPS` eW` \S\\S\ aWS PSWRS \WQVb c\aS` NcVOcaS$ a]\RS`\ C\S :WTbV& I\R Sa Wab$ OZa UsPS Sa jSRS K]QVS SW\ AWbbOU% ]RS` 5PS\RSaaS\ ]RS` SW\S\ 5\`cT$ PSW RS[

[SW\S HO`\c\U OcTTZWSUS\ YO\\ c\R O\a @WQVb Y][[b$ ROaa WQV \WQVb O\\sVS`\R a] W\bSZZWUS\b c\R PSZSaS\ c\R USaQVsTbaUSeO\Rb PW\ c\R \WQVb O\\sVS`\R a] UcbS 6ShWSVc\US\ VOPS$ eWS RWS @ScbS O\hc\SV[S\ aQVSW\S\& ASW\ 6O\YY]\b] Wab W[[S` ZSS`$ c\R eS\\ WQV [W` RWS ;SaQVsTbaPwQVS` RS` 5US\bc` O\aSVS$ T`OUS WQV [WQV$ eWS eW` c\aS`S 5\USabSZZbS\$ RWS AWSbS$ RWS HSZST]\`SQV\c\U PShOVZS\ a]ZZS\$ ]V\S ROaa ?ObS c\a [Wb SW\S[ eSWbS`S\ GQVSQY wPS` KOaaS` VsZb& B]OV Y][[b Tw` [SW\S D`WdObOcaUOPS\ OcT$ OPS` eW` TwV`S\ 6cQV$ RO[Wb WQV WV[ ROa ;SZR hc`wQYhOVZS\ YO\\$ eS\\ S`ab RWS 5US\bc`SW\\OV[S\ TZWSrS\& AW` TOZZS\ RWS NSWZS\ Oca SW\S[ ;SRWQVb d]\ AS`eW\ SW\$ RWS WQV BSZZ W[[S` eWSRS` aQVcZRPSecaab hWbWS`b VOPS$ =QV eO` SW\ O`[S` AS\aQV W\ SW\Sa FSWQVS\ <Oca& CTb ew\aQVS WQV [W`$ OZZSa es`S a]$ eWS Sa aQVSW\b$ WQV Yv\\bS ROa @SPS\$ ROa OZZS d]` 5cUS\ hc VOPS\ [SW\S\$ eW`YZWQV TwV`S\& 5PS` Sa Y][[b [W` O`U ^`]dWa]`WaQV d]`$ SW\S GQV`OcPS\R`SVc\U d][ NcaO[[S\abc`h S\bTS`\b& B]OV `SWab \OQV @5 c\R AS[^VWa$ c[ D`]RchS\bS\$ 5YbSc`S c\R ;SZR Tw` RS\ :WZ[ hc ]`UO\WaWS`S\$ O\ RS[ S` aSWb >OV`S\ O`PSWbSb& =\ aSW\S` 5PeSaS\VSWb `cTS WQV FWQ] ]RS` <O^^g O\ ]RS` USVS hc >cZW]$ [Wb RS[ [WQV SW\ Hg^ PSYO\\b[OQVb$ RS\ WQV YS\\S\USZS`\b VOPS$ OZa WQV hc[ heSWbS\ c\R ZSbhbS\ AOZ PSW :Wbh eO`& 8WSaS` Hg^$ SW\ heO\hWUjsV`WUS` <Wa^O\]%5[S`WYO\S` [Wb U`OcS\ NsV\S\$ ZsRb [WQV hc >cZW] SW\$ c\R RO USVS WQV RO\\ jOV`SZO\U VW\& 8WS @ScbS Y][[S\ hc >cZW]$ c\R S` Zsaab aWS 8`]US\ \SV[S\ c\R [WbSW\O\RS` aQVZOTS\$ a]ZO\US aWS WV\ SW\PShWSVS\& 8WSaS BsQVbS eO`S\ SW\[OZ aSZbS\ x OZZS heSW ]RS` R`SW A]\ObS x$ OPS` jSbhb ZWSUS\ W[[S` \c` K]QVS\ ROheWaQVS\$ c\R esV`S\R aWS T`wVS` USUS\ SW\a hc 9\RS UW\US\$ hWSVS\ aWS aWQV jSbhb W[[S` [SV` PWa HOUSaO\P`cQV VW\& BOQVRS[ [WQV B]OV O\ SW\S[ eSWbS`S\ `OcS\ A]`US\ USPSbS\ VOb$ <WZTS W\ 5\a^`cQV hc \SV[S\$ S`YZs`S WQV [WQV PS`SWb$ hc SW\S[ OcT GcQVbT`OUS\ a^ShWOZWaWS`bS\ DagQVWObS` hc USVS\& 9W\ GbcRWS\T`Sc\R B]OVa \S\\b c\a SW\S\ BO[S\$ c\R WQV USVS VW\& 9` VOb aSW\S D`OfWa hc <OcaS$ W\ SW\S` `WSaWUS\$ V]QVSZSUO\bS\ K]V\c\U O[ FWdS`aWRS 8`WdS& 8WS 6Sa^`SQVc\U Wab Yc`h& 9` T`OUb$ eSaVOZP WQV RO PW\& =QV S`hsVZS d]\ [SW\S[ 8`]US\Y]\ac[$ RS\ WQV c\PSRW\Ub OPabSZZS\ [vQVbS$ eOa [W` OPS` \WQVb USZW\US\ eWZZ$ c\R S` T`OUb [WQV \OQV [SW\S\ H`W\YUSe]V\VSWbS\& ASW\S H`W\YUSe]V\VSWbS\4$ aOUS WQV$ OZa VsbbS S` ^ZvbhZWQV d][ KSbbS` W\ DS`c O\USTO\US\ ]RS` aWQV \OQV RS` =6A%5YbWS S`Yc\RWUb& 9` aOUb$ WQV [caa ROa H`W\YS\ SW\abSZZS\$ PSd]` S` [SW\S 6SVO\RZc\U wPS`\W[[b$ c\R WQV S\baQVcZRWUS [WQV VvTZWQV c\R USVS& 9W\ VOZPSa >OV` a^sbS`$ \OQV SW\S` eSWbS`S\ GS`WS PvaS` BsQVbS$ bOcQVb SW\ \ScS` BO[S$ SW\ \ScS` HVS`O^Scb OcT$ S[^T]VZS\ d]\ SW\S[ O\RS`S\ 6SYO\\bS\& 8WSaS` 5`hb Wab O\RS`a$ S` \S\\b aWQV GQVORS\aPSU`S\hc\UaPS`ObS`$ eWZZ aOUS\$ S` VWZTb PSW RS` DZO\c\U RSa 5ZY]V]Z% c\R 8`]US\Y]\ac[a$ RO[Wb [O\ WV\ c\bS` ?]\b`]ZZS PSY][[b& =QV USVS SW\ SW\hWUSa AOZ hc WV[& 9a Wab SW\ aSV` Obb`OYbWdS` AO\\ d]\ 5\TO\U dWS`hWU [Wb SW\S` aQVWQYS\$ O^O`b[S\bsV\ZWQVS\ D`OfWa W\ 7VSZaSO& KW` abSZZS\ SW\S\ RSbOWZZWS`bS\ DZO\ OcT x

aQVWQYS\$ O^O`b[S\bsV\ZWQVS\ D`OfWa W\ 7VSZaSO& KW` abSZZS\ SW\S\ RSbOWZZWS`bS\ DZO\ OcT x a]c\Ra]dWSZ 8`W\Ya O[ 5PS\R$ a]c\Ra]]Tb 7`OQY W[ A]\Ob x$ c\R WQV TW\RS Sa OcT`SUS\R$ ROaa [SW\ 5ZY]V]Z% c\R 8`]US\Y]\ac[ jSbhb s`hbZWQV OPUSaSU\Sb Wab& B]QV W\ RS`aSZPS\ K]QVS wPS`aQV`SWbS WQV RWS TSabUSZSUbS\ 8]aS\ c\R dS`^OaaS RO\\ RS\ heSWbS\ HS`[W\$ eSWZ WQV RWS BOQVb hcd]` Rc`QVUS[OQVb VOPS& =QV USVS \WS eWSRS` VW\& A]\ObS a^sbS`2 9W\ eSWbS`S` A]`US\$ O\ RS[ Sa [W` R`SQYWU USVb$ SW\ eSWbS`S` BO[S d]\ SW\S[ 6SYO\\bS\ B]OVa& ;O`g Wab \Sbb c\R PSVcbaO[$ c\R aSW\S D`OfWa Wab \c` SW\ ^OO` 6Z]QYa d]\ RS` 5US\bc` S\bTS`\b& 9` T`OUb$ eOa [WQV hc WV[ TwV`b$ c\R WQV aOUS Sa WV[& 9` ab]QVS`b SW\ eS\WU W\ RS\ GOQVS\ Oca RS` ?W\RVSWb3 eW` `SRS\ wPS` ROa DW\YSZ\$ RS\ ab`S\US\ JObS`$ RWS dS`s\UabWUbS AcbbS`& 8Oaa aWS aWQV YS\\S\USZS`\b VOPS\$ OZa S` HK5% DWZ]b eO` c\R aWS SW\S VwPaQVS jc\US GbSeO`RSaa& 5Za eW` OcT RWS F]ZZS [SW\Sa JObS`a Y][[S\$ T`OUb S`$ eOa [SW\S AcbbS` USaOUb VOb$ eS\\ Sa PSW HWaQV c\US[wbZWQV ec`RS& =QV aQVWZRS`S$ eWS U`OcaO[ S` hc WV` eO`$ RS` OZa ?W\R O`[S` @ScbS W\ M]c\Uab]e\ 5cTUSeOQVaS\S\3 eWS dWSZ jw\US` aWS eO` OZa [SW\ JObS`3 ROaa aWS RS\ SWUS\S\ JObS` OZa HSS\OUS` dS`Z]`S\ VOb& ;cb%Ucb%Ucb$ [SW\b S` ROhc$ OPS` eOa VOb aWS USaOUb4 K] eO` aWS4 9`abOc\ZWQV$ RWS AOQVb R`SWS` K]`bS& 8WSaS VWS` aQVZWSrS\ RS\ `SW\abS\ ;WTbaQV`O\Y OcT& =QV aWbhS RO c\R RS\YS O\ [SW\S GWbhc\US\ PSW 8`& 8OdS$ e] WQV GQVZOU Tw` GQVZOU Rc`QVUSUO\US\ PW\$ eWS [SW\ JObS` RO[OZa eO`$ eOa S` USaOUb VOb c\R eWS$ c\R [W` eW`R YZO`$ ROaa eW` \WS[OZa wPS` aWS USa^`]QVS\ VOPS\& BWQVb SW\ SW\hWUSa AOZ& GWS eO` SW\S d]\ c\a$ RS\YS WQV c\R a^`SQVS Sa dWSZZSWQVb OcQV Oca& 9` eO` aQV`SQYZWQV hc WV`& <Ob WV`S ?wQVS$ WV`S ?ZSWRS`$ WV`S =\bSZZWUS\h$ WV`S =\bS`SaaS\$ WV`S :`Sc\RW\\S\ PS[sYSZb& ;S\Oc eWS PSW [W` c\R ?W[ c\R SbeOa eS\WUS` PSW @WaO c\R GSO\& J]\ RWSaS` US[SW\aO[S\ 9`TOV`c\U OPUSaSVS\ PZSWPb [SW\S AcbbS` PZOaa& =QV YO\\ [WQV \WQVb S`W\\S`\$ ROaa aWS [Wb [W` wPS` ROa D`]PZS[ USa^`]QVS\ VOb& 9a wPS`VOc^b \c` O\USa^`]QVS\ VOb& ?SW\ K]`b RSa H`]aba ]RS` RS` G]`US& 6SW ?\]QVS\P`wQVS\$ jO& 6SW TWSaS\ @SV`S`\ a]eWSa]& 5PS` VWS` x :SVZO\hSWUS& =QV aSVS aWS \]QV \WQVb [OZ d]` [W` PSW RWSaS\ 5PS\RSaaS\$ eS\\ eW` 6SacQV VObbS\$ eS\\ [SW\ JObS` W[ O\USVSWbS`bS\ NcabO\R [Wb aSW\S\ GbWQVSZSWS\ c\R 8`]Vc\US\ O\TW\U& 9a Wab$ OZa VsbbS RWSaSa <Oca [SW\S` ?W\RVSWb \c` [SW\S[ JObS` c\R [W` USVv`b$ c\R d]\ RS\ O\RS`S\ VsbbS \WS[O\R [WbPSY][[S\$ eOa d]` aWQV UW\U$ ]Pe]VZ OZZS ROPSW eO`S\& AWb SW\S[ AOZ PW\ WQV aSV` [wRS& 9beO SW\ VOZPSa >OV` a^sbS` aOUb [SW\S AcbbS` [W` O[ HSZST]\$ ROaa RWS Fv\bUS\OcT\OV[S WV`S` 6`cab UO` \WQVb Ucb OcaaWSVb$ ROaa RS` ?`SPa hc`wQYUSY][[S\ Wab c\R aWS hc eSWbS`S\ I\bS`acQVc\US\ \OQV 6]ab]\ [caa& =\ RS\ A]\ObS\ hcd]` VOPS WQV aWS \c` aSZbS\ O\US`cTS\& 8WS GWbhc\US\ [Wb ;O`g aW\R a]$ OZa ew`RS\ OZZS :]b]a [SW\S` AcbbS` Oca RS[ :O[WZWS\OZPc[ S\bTS`\b c\R Rc`QV 6WZRS` d]\ jS[O\RS[ S`aSbhb$ RS` WV` heO` sV\ZWQV aWSVb$ OPS` SW\RScbWU jS[O\R O\RS`a Wab$ jS[O\R$ RS\ WQV jSbhb S`ab ZO\UaO[ eOV`\SV[S& 9a dS`ZSbhb c\R dS`eW``b aWS$ ROaa WQV aSZbS\ d]\ [W` Vv`S\ ZOaaS$ RO eW` T`wVS` [SV`[OZa RWS K]QVS [WbSW\O\RS` USa^`]QVS\ VOPS\& GWS PSaQVeS`b aWQV PSW ?W[$ c\R ?W[ T`OUb [WQV$ eOa Z]a Wab& =QV aOUS WV`$ WQV VsbbS c\UZOcPZWQV dWSZ 5`PSWb&

eOa Z]a Wab& =QV aOUS WV`$ WQV VsbbS c\UZOcPZWQV dWSZ 5`PSWb& BOQV RS[ 5\`cT eSUS\ RS` aQVZW[[S\ AO[[]U`O^VWS [SZRS WQV [WQV vTbS`& 9a ROcS`b SW\ ^OO` K]QVS\$ OPS` RO\\ USVb [W` OcT$ eWS S`\ab RWS GOQVS Wab& 6OZR a]ZZ aWS ]^S`WS`b eS`RS\$ c\R RWS `hbS aOUS\ c\a$ RS` ?`SPa aSW e]VZ YOc[ d]ZZabs\RWU hc S\bTS`\S\$ OPS` ROa FWaWY]$ ROaa S` eWSRS`Y][[S$ PSabw\RS aSZPab RO\\ \]QV$ OcQV \OQV SW\S` O\aQVZWSrS\RS\ OUU`SaaWdS\ 7VS[]bVS`O^WS& ?W[ c\R WQV USVS\ RWS :W\O\hS\ c\aS`S` AcbbS` Rc`QV& 8WS ?`SRWbYO`bS\`SQV\c\US\ abO^SZ\ aWQV$ c\R aWS O`PSWbSb \]QV RS\ 6S`U d]\ 5\eOZbaUSPwV`S\ Oca RS` SW\ ^OO` >OV`S hc`wQYZWSUS\RS\ GQVSWRc\U d]\ [SW\S[ JObS` OP& 9a Wab SW\S ZO\UeWS`WUS$ aQV[cbhWUS GQVSWRc\U USeSaS\$ c\R SW\[OZ PWbbSb aWS [WQV$ [Wb RS[ :ZcUhScU \OQV BSe <O[^aVW`S hc Y][[S\$ e] aWS e]V\S\$ c\R d]` ;S`WQVb OZa NScUS Tw` aWS OcahcaOUS\$ c[ SW\S SW\abeSWZWUS JS`TwUc\U USUS\ [SW\S\ JObS` OcT`SQVbhcS`VOZbS\& =QV TZWSUS V]QV$ ]Pe]VZ [W` RS` FWQVbS` d]`OP aOUb$ Sa aSW \WQVb \vbWU$ S` ew`RS RWS SW\abeSWZWUS JS`TwUc\U ]V\SVW\ OcT`SQVb VOZbS\& 8O`wPS` PW\ WQV S`ZSWQVbS`b$ aQVs[S [WQV OPS` b`]bhRS[$ OZa WQV W\ RS` @]PPg RSa ;S`WQVba Yc`h [SW\S\ JObS` aSVS c\R eW` YSW\ K]`b eSQVaSZ\& 8WS JS`aWQVS`c\U hOVZb eSWbUSVS\R RWS 6SVO\RZc\U [SW\S` AcbbS`$ R]QV RWS BSPS\Y]abS\ ac[[WS`S\ aWQV$ c\R aWS YO\\ RWS O\abSVS\RS\ 5cTb`sUS Tw` D]`b`sba c\R KO\RUS[sZRS$ d]\ RS\S\ aWS ZSPb$ \WQVb OcaTwV`S\3 S`ab ZO\US \OQV RS` C^S`ObW]\ eW`R aWS ROhc eWSRS` W\ RS` @OUS aSW\& KW` PSa^`SQVS\ S`\abZWQV$ eOa TW\O\hWSZZ OcT c\a hcY][[b$ c\R WQV bcS a]$ OZa ]P WQV RS[ USZOaaS\ S\bUSUS\aSVS$ eSWZ W\heWaQVS\ ;SZR W\ RWS 5US\bc` TZWSrb& ASW\S :O[WZWS PSb`OQVbSb [WQV OZa US[OQVbS\ AO\\$ c\R ROa 6WZR eWZZ WQV \WQVb b`wPS\& ?W[ aOUb [W`$ ROaa WQV \OQV RS[ KWZZS\ c\aS`S` AcbbS` WV` HSabO[S\bd]ZZab`SQYS` aSW\ a]ZZ c\R ROaa S\ba^`SQVS\RS DO^WS`S hc c\bS`aQV`SWPS\ aW\R& GWS Y][[b dWSZZSWQVb \WQVb Rc`QV$ aOUb ?W[$ c\R RWS K]`bS PZSWPS\ a] W[ FOc[ abSVS\& :`wVjOV` *(()& =[ AOW eW`R [SW\S AcbbS` ]^S`WS`b$ c\R WQV TZWSUS V]QV& ?W[ Wab aQV]\ RWS UO\hS K]QVS RO$ PSW [SW\S` YZSW\S\ GQVeSabS` @WaO$ RWS W\ RS` BsVS e]V\b& GSO\ Wab jSbhb \Sc\hSV\ c\R ab`SWTb [w``WaQV Rc`QV RWS ;s\US c\R Fsc[S RS` ?ZW\WY& 8WS C^S`ObW]\ USZW\Ub$ c\R OZa eW` hc c\aS`S` AcbbS` VW\SW\Rw`TS\$ aQVSW\b aWS \c` \]QV VOZP a] U`]r c\R VOZP a] aQVeS` hc aSW\ eWS a]\ab x Rw`` c\R USaQVesQVb dS`aW\Yb aWS W\ RS[ ?ZW\WYVS[R$ ROa WV` d]\ RS\ GQVcZbS`\ TsZZb& =QV VOPS aWS aSWb A]\ObS\ \WQVb USaSVS\& 6SW[ G^`SQVS\ b`s\S\ WV` RWS 5cUS\$ c\R Sa Wab$ OZa ]P Sa WV` hc aQVeS` TsZZb$ RWS K]`bS hc T]`[S\ c\R W\ RWS KSZb hc S\bZOaaS\& 5Za WQV VW\Oca OcT RS\ ;O\U USVS c\R B]OV O\`cTS$ YO\\ WQV \WQVb [SV`$ P`SQVS hcaO[[S\ c\R VScZS F]bh c\R KOaaS`& 8WS 5US\bc`$ RWS ZO\US\ BsQVbS$ RWS ;SZRa]`US\$ ROa ;STwVZ$ ROa @SPS\$ ROa WQV [W` OcTUSPOcb VOPS$ \WQVb VOZbS\ hc Yv\\S\ x c\R jSbhb ^ZvbhZWQV OcQV \]QV [SW\S AcbbS`$ [Wb RS` WQV W[ ZSbhbS\ VOZPS\ >OV` W[[S` \c` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ heWaQVS\Rc`QV US`SRSb VOPS c\R RWS OcaaWSVb$ OZa ]P aWS abW`Pb2 5ZZSa VOPS WQV dS`[OaaSZb$ c\R WQV eS`RS Sa \WQVb VW\PWSUS\ Yv\\S\& qPS` RWS aQVZSQVbS

HSZST]\dS`PW\Rc\U aOUb [W` B]OV$ WQV a]ZZS [W` YSW\S G]`US\ [OQVS\$ Sa eS`RS OZZSa eWSRS` Ucb& GQVZWSrZWQV Vv`S WQV OcT hc eSW\S\$ c\R OZa eW` c\a dS`OPaQVWSRS\$ VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ S` Wab aSV` eSWb eSU& KW` aWbhS\ W[ ?`O\YS\hW[[S` PSW [SW\S` aQVZOTS\RS\ AcbbS` c\R c\bS`VOZbS\ c\a ZSWaS$ esV`S\R RWS GQVeSabS`\ Y][[S\ c\R USVS\ c\R [Wb RS\ GQVZscQVS\ c\R =\ab`c[S\bS\ c[ aWS VS`c[ VO\bWS`S\& =V` 5`hb$ SW\ U`]rS`$ Rc\YSZVOO`WUS` AO\\ W\ RS\ JWS`hWUS`\ [Wb OcaUS^`sUbS[ 6O`baQVObbS\$ aOUb c\a$ PSW RS` FSY]\ab`cYbW]\ VOPS Sa ?][^ZWYObW]\S\ USUSPS\$ RO [waabS\ aWS W\ SW\ ^OO` HOUS\ \]QV SW\[OZ \OQVaQVOcS\$ OPS` RWS 9\bTS`\c\U RSa ?`SPaSa c\R RS` @g[^VY\]bS\ aSW aSV` Ucb USZOcTS\& =QV [OQVS [W` PSecaab$ ROaa RWSaS` AO\\ RS\ UO\hS\ HOU d]` [SW\S` AcbbS` USabO\RS\ c\R WV` @SPS\ W\ RS\ <s\RS\ USVOZbS\ VOb& ASW\ >]P$ RWS 5US\bc`$ OZZ [SW\S G]`US\ aQV[SZhS\ \SPS\ RWSaS[ Gc^S`VSZRS\ ROVW\$ c\R \WQVb hc[ S`abS\ AOZ O\ RWSaS[ HOU aQVs[S WQV [WQV& 8S` HOU W\ RS` ?ZW\WY dS`ab`SWQVb$ c\R W`US\ReO\\ `OaQVSZb Sa O\ RS` Hw` c\R eWS Rc`QV NOcPS`SW abSVb B]OV RO$ ZsQVSZ\R$ [Wb HOaQVS\ d]ZZS` @SPS\a[WbbSZ d]\ 8SO\ ! 8SZcQO& BOQV c\aS`S[ HSZST]\USa^`sQV VOb S` SW\S\ :ZcU USPcQVb c\R Wab a] aQV\SZZ S` Y]\\bS VS`USY][[S\& 9a Wab$ OZa es`S RS` 6]RS\ RS` KSZb$ RS` [W` PSW[ 6Sb`SbS\ RS` ?ZW\WY c\bS` RS\ :wrS\ eSUUS`cbaQVb Wab$ ^ZvbhZWQV eWSRS` RO& B]OV \W[[b [WQV W\ RWS 5`[S$ c\R WQV R`wQYS [WQV O\ WV\$ a] ZO\US Sa USVb& ASW\S AcbbS` YSV`b W\ WV` YZSW\Sa \ScSa <Oca W\ 7]\\SQbWQcb hc`wQY$ ROa aWS \OQV RS` GQVSWRc\U USYOcTb VOb c\R ROa W\ SW\S[ YZSW\S\ BOQVPO`]`b RSa p`bQVS\a$ W\ RS[ WQV OcTUSeOQVaS\ PW\$ OcT SW\S` KWSaS abSVb& =V`S hOVZ`SWQVS\ :`Sc\RS TOV`S\ aWS hc WV`S\ 7VS[]% c\R 6Sab`OVZc\UabS`[W\S\$ \OQV 6]ab]\ c\R hc`wQY$ eS\\ aWS R]`b hc WV`S\ `hbS\ [caa$ P`W\US\ WV` []\ObSZO\U 9aaS\ `c\R c[ RWS IV`$ TwbbS`\ WV`S\ <c\R$ c\R ZO\UaO[$ UO\h ZO\UaO[ dS`eO\RSZb aWQV ROa PZOaaS$ ec\RS KSaS\$ ROa eW` W[ ?ZW\WYPSbb USaSVS\ VOPS\$ eWSRS` W\ SW\S USac\RS$ ^OcaPsQYWUS :`Oc& =V`S <OO`S eOQVaS\ \OQV$ Rw\\S` OZa hcd]`$ OPS` OZa aWS \OQV Tw\T >OV`S\ RO\\$ eWS RWS `hbS aOUS\$ Oca RS[ GQV\SWRS` Wab$ aWSVb [O\ WV` \WQVb [SV` O\$ eWS Y\O^^ aWS RS[ H]R S\b`]\\S\ Wab& =[ S`abS\ >OV` WV`S` ;S\Sac\U aSVS\ c\R a^`SQVS\ eW` c\a ]Tb& AWb [SW\S` USZscbS`bS\$ dS`ZSbhZWQVS\ AcbbS` TwVZS WQV [WQV e]VZ$ c\R eW` USVS\ sV\ZWQV [WbSW\O\RS` c[ eWS W\ [SW\S` HSS\OUS`hSWb c\R \]QV RO\OQV x OcT[S`YaO[$ SW\TwVZaO[$ S`[cbWUS\R& 5Za aWS RO\\ USaw\RS` eW`R c\R WV` @SPS\ eWSRS` OcT\W[[b$ `cTS WQV W[[S` aSZbS\S` O\$ PSaQV`s\YS [SW\S 6SacQVS OcT KSWV\OQVbS\ c\R R`WTbS eWSRS` ROd]\&

K]
<S``S\b]WZSbbS W\ RS` ASb`]%B]`bV%GbObW]\ KVWbS DZOW\a "VOabWUS <s\RS$ RWS O[ DWaa]W` d]\ SW\S[ FSWrdS`aQVZcaa hc[ O\RS`S\ USVS\$ RO\\ RWS ?OPW\S$ SW\ VOabWUS` Ac\R OcT [W`$ PWa Sa ^ZvbhZWQV$ hc[ S`abS\ AOZ [Wb SW\S[ AO\\$ d]`PSW Wab#& F]\a NW[[S`$ R`SW 6Z]QYa S\bTS`\b d]\ [SW\S` S`abS\ BSe M]`YS` K]V\c\U$ heSW[OZ& 5[ HSZST]\$ W[ 8c\YSZ\& BSZZ c\bS`eSUa& G] dWSZS GbW[[S\$ a] dWSZ JS`ZO\US\& 5^O`b[S\b V]QV wPS`[ NS\b`c[$ \OQV SW\S` ZO\US\ Rc`QVhSQVbS\$ Rc`QVbO\hbS\$ Rc`QVYWTTbS\ BOQVb$ [Wb SW\S[ 5cb]`$ RS\ [SW\ 7VST dS`b`Wbb& I\R aSW\S[ :`Sc\R& ;SeW`` d]\ ?v`^S`\ c\R `OaQVSa JS`aQVeW\RS\$ PSd]` aWS OcTeOQVS\& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ W\ jS\S[ KW\bS` aQV\SWb Sa& 8O[^TPOR W[ :Wb\Saa%7S\bS` W\ RS` -/bV Gb`SSb& As\\S` [WbbZS`S\ 5ZbS`a& \UabZWQV$ S`\ab$ [Obb PSaQVZOUS\S 9VS`W\US O\ RS\ :W\US`\& H]WZSbbS W\ SW\S[ NcU RS` ASb`] B]`bV& 9W\ aQVv\S` jc\US` AO\\$ sZbS` OZa WQV$ OPS` \WQVb wPS` *-$ VOb OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS RSa ;O\Ua USaSaaS\ c\R eW\Yb [W`$ WV[ hc T]ZUS\$ OZa S` hc[ 9\RS RSa KOUS\a USVb& ?waaS& Bc` ?waaS c\R T`Sc\RZWQVS <s\RS$ RWS [W` wPS` RWS GQVZsTS\ c\R ROa ;SaWQVb ab`SWQVS\& 9a eW`R OZZSa Ucb$ TZwabS`b S`$ PSd]` S` RWS Hw` OcThWSVb c\R W\ SW\S[ O\RS`S\ KOUS\ dS`aQVeW\RSb& K]VS` ecaabS S`$ ROaa WQV RO [SW\S NeSWTSZ VObbS4

@WSPS
9W\S 9`W\\S`c\U OcrS` RS` FSWVS& 9a Wab [SW\S dWS`bS BOQVb W[ .( HV][^a]\& 8S` dWS`bS 5PS\R$ aSWb WQV \OQV RS[ ?c`hPSacQV W[ GWZdS` c\R RS` :ZcQVb W\a 7]c`bgO`R AO``W]bb W\ B]`eOZY$ 7]\\SQbWQcb$ eWSRS` W\ RS` GbORb PW\& =QV VOPS SW\S\ 9aQ]`b PSabSZZb$ \S\\S\ eW` WV\ 7O`Z]a& 7O`Z]a Wab SW\ Rc\YSZVscbWUS` 6`OaWZWO\S` c[ RWS JWS`hWU$ c\R S` eO` aQV]\ SW\[OZ VWS`$ O[ 5PS\R$ OZa WQV VS`USY][[S\ PW\& 9` Wab abWZZ$ ObVZSbWaQV c\R SW\ ^OO` NS\bW[SbS` U`vrS` OZa WQV& 9` Y]abSb dWS`Vc\RS`b 8]ZZO` RWS Gbc\RS& =QV eSWr$ ROaa S` bOUawPS` O`PSWbSb$ OcT RS` 5PS\RaQVcZS W`US\RSW\S\ YOcT[s\\WaQVS\ 5PaQVZcaa [OQVb c\R Oca GO] DOcZ] abO[[b& 9` Wab OcT RS[ KSU& 8O <O^^g US`ORS VWS` eO`$ VOPS WQV `SWQVZWQV 7`OQY& ASW\ HSZST]\ YZW\USZb$ c\R O\ RS` Bc[[S` OcT RS[ 8Wa^ZOg aSVS WQV$ ROaa Sa B]OV Wab& 9` [caa Oca 6S`ZW\ hc`wQY aSW\& CV\S \OQVhcRS\YS\$ wPS`esZbWUb d]\ RS[ ^ZvbhZWQVS\ 6SRw`T\Wa$ aSW\S GbW[[S hc Vv`S\$ \SV[S WQV OP& 9` a^`WQVb aO\Tb$ c\R hc UcbS` @Sbhb aOUS WQV WV[$ e] WQV PW\ c\R ROaa S` Tw` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ `OcTY][[S\ YO\\& =QV VOPS YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eOa RO`Oca eW`R$ OPS` [SW\ 6SRw`T\Wa$ WV\ hc aSVS\ Wab abs`YS` OZa RWS 5\Uab$ O[ ?`OUS\ US^OQYb c\R \OQV <OcaS USaQVZSWTb hc eS`RS\& =\\S`VOZP d]\ AW\cbS\ Wab S` O\ RS` Hw`& =QV aSVS WV\ [W` Rc`QVa ;cQYZ]QV O\$ OPS` aSW\ 6WZR Wab dS`hS``b$ c\R WQV S`YS\\S WV\ \c` O\ RS\ ?ZSWRS`\& 9`ab \OQVRS[ WQV WV\ SW\S KSWZS PS]POQVbSb VOPS$ [OQVS WQV OcT& 5Za WQV WV\ VS`SW\ZOaaS$ TsZZb [W` OcT$ ROaa S` \]QV \WS a] dWSZ 6O`b VObbS c\R ROaa S` Rw\\ OcaaWSVb& =QV [vQVbS [WQV WV[ O\ RS\ <OZa eS`TS\$ PW\ OPS` d]`aWQVbWU c\R VOZbS [WQV hc`wQY& 5cQV S` hvUS`b$ c\R eW` c[Y`SWaS\ c\a O`UevV\WaQV& 8WS 8`]US\$ [SW\S 6`WSTbOaQVS c\R [SW\S\ DOaa VOPS WQV W[ 6OR c\bS` SW\S[ GbO^SZ <O\RbwQVS` dS`abSQYb Tw` RS\ :OZZ$ ROaa S` aWS [W` OPhc\SV[S\ dS`acQVb& 9` abSQYb aWQV SW\S NWUO`SbbS O\$ c\R aSZPab VWS`$ aSZPab jSbhb hWSVS WQV SW\ ;SaWQVb c\R aOUS2 Acaa ROa aSW\4 9` WU\]`WS`b ROa c\R `SRSb d]\ 5P[SZRS\$ AWbY][[S\ c\R 9\bhcU [OQVS\& =QV eS`RS ewbS\R c\R aOUS WV[$ ROaa WQV heO` OP`SWaS\$ OPS` \WQVb [Wb WV[ [WbY][[S\ eS`RS& 8Oaa WQV e]O\RS`a c\bS`bOcQVS c\R$ eS\\ S` ROa \sQVabS AOZ O\`cTb$ \WQVb [SV` OP\SV[S& G] dS`USVS\ c\USTsV` heO\hWU AW\cbS\$ c\R [W` USVb heSWS`ZSW Rc`QV RS\ ?]^T2 )& =QV VOPS Yc`h d]` B]OVa 9`aQVSW\S\ RWS ZSbhbS DTSWTS US`OcQVb c\R P`OcQVS eWSRS` SW\S$ c\R *& 7O`Z]a eW`R jSRS\ 5cUS\PZWQY VWS` aSW\& =QV aOUS B]OV$ ROaa S` USVS\ [caa x S\beSRS` S`$ ]RS` WQV& 9` aOUb$ S` USVb \WQVb$ e]`OcT WQV [W` [Wb dWSZ H`O`O RWS GQVcVS O\hWSVS c\R RWS >OQYS aQV\O^^S$ OZa e]ZZbS WQV eW`YZWQV `Oca$ c\R S` [W` aOUb$ WQV a]ZZS OcTVv`S\& 8WS NSWb ZscTb$ [SW\ FOcaQV d]\ d]`VW\ Wab Zs\Uab d]`PSW$ c\R Sa hWSVb [WQV W\ SW\S\ Tc`QVbPO`S\ 5\UabhcabO\R& =QV aOUS B]OV$ S` YO\\ \]QV SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ PZSWPS\$ OPS` WQV [caa eOa `OcQVS\& KS\\ S` ROa \WQVb VOPS\ YO\\$ a]ZZ S` USVS\& 9` aOUb2 FOcQV Rc \c`& =QV USVS W\a 6OR$ aQVZWSrS RWS Hw` c\R hWSVS DTSWTS c\R 7`OQY c\bS` RS\ <O\RbwQVS`\ VS`d]`& =QV [OQVS RWS DTSWTS TS`bWU$ SVS WQV `OcaUSVS$ c\R abSQYS [W` ROa wP`WUS 7`OQY W\ RWS >SO\abOaQVS& KWSRS` R`OcrS\$ aSbhS WQV [WQV OcT RWS 6SbbYO\bS c\R aOUS2 ASW\ab Rc

>SO\abOaQVS& KWSRS` R`OcrS\$ aSbhS WQV [WQV OcT RWS 6SbbYO\bS c\R aOUS2 ASW\ab Rc eW`YZWQV$ Rc Y][[ab RO[Wb hc`SQVb4 9` aOUb jO& =QV aSVS B]OV W\a ;SaWQVb$ esV`S\R WQV RWS DTSWTS O\hw\RS c\R a] dWSZ FOcQV SW\hWSVS$ eWS WQV \c` YO\\& 6SW[ 5caOb[S\ aSVS WQV heO` aSW\S U`W[[WUS AWS\S$ eSWr OPS` \WQVb$ eOa W\ WV[ d]`USVb& 8S` FOcaQV$ RS` Rc`QV [WQV VW\Rc`QVTsV`b$ TSUb aSW\S ;STwVZS c\R jSRS \]`[OZS FSOYbW]\$ RWS aWS PSW [W` OcaZvaS\ Yv\\bS\$ PSWaSWbS& =QV PSb`OQVbS WV\$ eWS [O\ d]\ SW\S[ OPTOV`S\RS\ NcU Oca SW\S\ I\PSYO\\bS\ OcT RS[ 6OV\abSWU PSb`OQVbSb& BScUWS`WU$ Rc`QV 6ZWQYY]\bOYb TZwQVbWU dS`Pc\RS\$ W[ ;`c\RS OPS` UZSWQVUwZbWU& B]OV S\baQVeW\RSb [SW\S[ 6ZWQY$ c\R WQV aOUS WV[$ ROaa 7O`Z]a Y][[b& GbObb$ eWS WQV S`eO`bS$ W\ RWS @cTb hc USVS\$ aOUb S`2 ;cb& =QV PZSWPS& KS\\ Rc WV\ \WQVb O\`cTab c\R WV[ OPaOUab$ PZSWPS WQV& ?SW\S G]`US$ ROa [OQVb [W` \WQVba& =QV Vv`S aSW\S K]`bS eWS d][ O\RS`S\ 9\RS SW\S` @WQVbc\U ]RS` Rc`QV SW\S RWQYS ;ZOaaQVSWPS c\R aOUS$ eSWZ Sa aWQV a] O\TwVZb2 ;cb& 7O`Z]a b`WTTb SW\& 9` aWSVb B]OV O\$ eS\RSb aWQV O\ [WQV c\R T`OUb2 6ZSWPb S`4 =QV aOUS2 >O& 9`ab [OZ& GWS [cabS`\ SW\O\RS`$ c\R 7O`Z]a aSbhb aWQV OcTa 6Sbb& =QV `OcQVS SW\S\ NcU& B]OV aSbhb aWQV W\ SW\S\ GSaaSZ O[ dS`VO\US\S\ :S\abS`& =QV `OcQVS \]QV SW\S\ NcU& B]OV Wab abWZZ& 7O`Z]a PSRScbSb [W`$ [WQV hc WV[ OcTa 6Sbb hc aSbhS\$ c\R ROa bcS WQV [Wb DTSWTS$ HwbS c\R :ScS`hScU W\ RS` <O\R& =QV UWSrS [W` \]QV SW\S\ K]RYO SW\ c\R T`OUS 7O`Z]a$ ]P S` W`US\RSbeOa [vQVbS& 9` [vQVbS 6WS`$ OZa] V]ZS WQV SW\a Oca RS` AW\WPO`$ [OQVS Sa OcT c\R USPS Sa WV[& 9` b`W\Yb SW\S\ U`]rS\ GQVZcQY c\R hWSVb aSW\ <S[R Oca& GSW\S Rc\YZS <Ocb Wab [OYSZZ]a$ c\R WQV aSVS hc$ eWS S` aSW\S 5`[PO\RcV` OP\W[[b c\R O\Ts\Ub$ aWQV RWS GQVcVS OcThcaQV\w`S\& =QV ZORS RWS DTSWTS$ c\R OZa WQV RS\ FOcQV Ocaab]rS$ VOPS WQV aQV]\ PSW\OV dS`USaaS\$ ROaa B]OV \]QV YSW\S\ ASbS` d][ 6Sbb S\bTS`\b aWbhb& 7O`Z]a c\R WQV YwaaS\ c\a& 9` `WSQVb \OQV CZR G^WQS c\R HOPOY$ SW\S SWUS\bw[ZWQVS ;S`cQVa[WaQVc\U$ RWS WQV [Wb [SW\S[ JObS` dS`PW\RS& KW` esZhS\ c\a OcT RS[ 6Sbb$ c\R \WQVb ZO\US$ RO P`OcQVS WQV RS\ \sQVabS\ <Wb c\R eWSRS` SW\ ^OO` U`]rS GQVZcQYS K]RYO& =QV ZORS RWS DTSWTS$ \SV[S SW\S\ bWSTS\ NcU c\R R`SVS [WQV W[ 5caOb[S\ \OQV B]OV c[& =QV dS`acQVS W\ aSW\S[ ;SaWQVb hc ZSaS\ c\R S\bRSQYS eSRS` Kcb \]QV 5PaQVSc ]RS` ?c[[S`& KOa WQV aSVS ]RS` jSRS\TOZZa hc aSVS\ [SW\S$ Wab AWbUSTwVZ& 5Za WQV hc` 6O` USVS$ c[ [W` \]QV SW\S\ 8`W\Y hc [OQVS\$ T`OUS WQV WV\$ ]P S` US\cU VOb$ c\R S` aOUb2 BSW\$ aQV]\ Ucb& =QV [vQVbS hc WV[$ [vQVbS PSW WV[ aSW\$ c\R jSbhb s`US`b Sa [WQV$ ROaa 7O`Z]a RO Wab& =QV b`W\YS c\R `OcQVS S`\Scb$ PSd]` WQV eWSRS` W\a 6Sbb USVS$ [SW\ ?v`^S` Wab d]\ 6SUWS`RS S\bTZO[[b x SW\ b]aS\RS`$ OZZSa dS`hSV`S\RS` <c\US`& GQV]\ aW\R 7O`Z]a c\R WQV UO\h \OQYb$ c\R OZa S` OcT [W` Wab$ eS\RS WQV [WQV B]OV hc c\R PSRScbS WV[$ O\a 6Sbb hc Y][[S\& 9` Y][[b c\R ZSUb aWQV \SPS\ [WQV& 7O`Z]a c\R WQV [OQVS\ eSWbS`$ c\R W`US\ReO\\ [S`YS WQV$ ROaa B]OV [SW\S <O\R VsZb& =QV aSVS WV\ O\$ c\R S` VOb TScQVbS 5cUS\& 9` ab`SWQVSZb [SW\S <O\R$ [SW\S\ 5`[$ c\R aOUb2 9a Wab aQV]\ Ucb$ [OQV RW` YSW\S ;SRO\YS\$ Sa Wab Ucb& GSW\S K]`bS$ aSW\S Y]aS\RS <O\R$ 7O`Z]a OcT [W`$ ROa 7`OQY c\R RS` K]RYO$ RWS [WQV Rc`QVb]aS\ x GQVO[$ @cab$ G]`US c\R NcabW[[c\U ^`OZZS\ OcTSW\O\RS`$ c\R ROa RS\YPO` GQVZW[[abS S`aQVSW\b \WQVb [SV` a] aQVZW[[& AWb ROa GQV`SQYZWQVabS$ eOa WQV [W` d]`abSZZS\ YO\\ x GSf W[ 8`]US\`OcaQV d]` B]OVa 5cUS\ x Wab hc SbeOa AS\aQVZWQVS[ USe]`RS\$ SW\S[ GQV[S`h$ RS` aWQV ZW\RS`\ Zsaab$ SW\S`

Wab hc SbeOa AS\aQVZWQVS[ USe]`RS\$ SW\S[ GQV[S`h$ RS` aWQV ZW\RS`\ Zsaab$ SW\S` ;`saaZWQVYSWb$ RWS [O\ [WbO\aSVS\ c\R dS`USPS\ YO\\& 8c PWab ]YOg$ dS`aWQVS`b [W` B]OV [Wb aSW\S` aO\TbS\ GbW[[S c\R aSW\S[ hs`bZWQVS\ Gb`SWQVSZ\$ c\R SW\S UO\hS KSWZS PW\ WQV Sa RO\\ OcQV& GQVZWSrZWQV USVb 7O`Z]a$ c\R B]OV c\R WQV aSbhS\ c\a SW\O\RS` USUS\wPS` O\a :S\abS`& 9` aOUb [W`$ WQV a]ZZS [WQV Tw` ROa ;SaQVSVS\S \WQVb aQVs[S\$ \WQVb \c` WQV VsbbS W\ c\aS`S` 6ShWSVc\U AWab USPOcb$ a]\RS`\ OcQV S`& 9` aOUb [W` OcQV$ eWS$ OPS` WQV UZOcPS WV[ \WQVb& KOa S` RO`wPS` S`hsVZb$ bcS WQV OZa JS`acQV$ [WQV hc b`vabS\$ OP& =QV aOUS B]OV$ ROaa S` USVS\ [caa$ c\R dS`a^`SQVS$ WV\ a^sbS` O\hc`cTS\& 5PS` WQV `cTS \WQVb O\& =QV ^OQYS [SW\S GOQVS\$ [SZRS [WQV OP c\R USVS W\ SW\ O\RS`Sa <]bSZ& B]OVa 6SacQV eS`RS WQV ZO\US dS`USaaS\& 9` Wab Oca RS[ GW\\& I\R OZa [W` RO\\ R]QV eWSRS` SW\TsZZb$ eOa WQV WV[ RO hcUS[cbSb VOPS$ aQVs[S WQV [WQV PWa W\ RWS <OO`a^WbhS\& B]QV a^sbS` YO\\ WQV aQVZWSrZWQV RWS GQVO[ PSWaSWbS ZOaaS\ c\R aSVS d]` OZZS[$ ROaa S` W\ RWSaS\ ^OO` Gbc\RS\ PSW [W` USPZWSPS\ Wab$ ROaa S` [W` R]`b W[ <]bSZhW[[S` RWS <O\R USVOZbS\ c\R [W` USaOUb VOb$ WQV aSW ]YOg& 8Oaa S` [WQV ZWSPb& I\R WQV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS wPS`hScUb WQV W\ jS\S` BOQVb "c\R jSRS` d]`VS`USVS\RS\ BOQVb [Wb WV[# eO`$ ROaa \OQV OZZS[$ eOa S` ecaabS c\R [Wb [W` S`ZSPb c\R aWQV d]\ [W` VObbS USTOZZS\ ZOaaS\$ YSW\ AS\aQV jS[OZa a] hc [W` abSVS\ ew`RS eWS S`& =QV VOPS \WS UST`OUb$ eO`c[&

6ZOQY]cb
9a Wab RS` G][[S` *((+$ Rc`QV SW\S FSWVS OcrS`USevV\ZWQVS` :SVZPS`SQV\c\US\ c\R AWaaUSaQVWQYS OcT RS` JS`a]`US`aSWbS abSVb BSe M]`Y ]V\S Gb`][ RO& AO\VObbO\ Wab O\ SW\S[ RS` VSWrSabS\ HOUS RSa >OV`Sa RwabS` c\R b]b& =QV USVS W\ SW\S[ ASS` S\bUSWabS`bS` 6w`]O\USabSZZbS`$ GV]^^S` c\R GbcRS\bS\ RWS c\bS`S :WTbV 5dS\cS S\bZO\U& ASW\ GQVsRSZ P`c[[b$ c\R RWS G]\\S PZWbhb hc VSZZ Oca RS\ :S\abS`\ RS` GbORb c\R RS[ 7V`][ TSababSQYS\RS` 5cb]a& =QV VOPS W\ RS` BOQVb hcd]` \WQVb USaQVZOTS\& 6Wa hc[ A]`US\ VOPS WQV 7`OQY US`OcQVb$ c\R OZa WQV \OQV <OcaS YO[$ eO` wPS`OZZ W\ RS` K]V\c\U ROa @WQVb O\& I\bS`[ G^WSUSZ$ OcT RS` HVSYS W[ J]``Oc[$ TW\RS WQV SW\S OcT RWS FwQYaSWbS SW\Sa ?cdS`ba USY`WbhSZbS B]bWh2 + IV` ) x ROa VOZb WQV \WQVb Oca& B]OV wPS`\OQVbSb \ScS`RW\Ua W\ <]bSZa$ eS\\ WQV \WQVb \OQV <OcaS Y][[S& ASWabS\a ZO\RSb S` W[ GVS`Ob]\ O\ RS` DO`Y 5dS\cS G]cbV& BOQV SW\ ^OO` c\\wbhS\$ dS`YObS`bS\ Gbc\RS\ W\ RS` 5US\bc` USVb RS` Gb`][ eSU$ Sa eW`R Rc\YSZ$ c\R WQV [OQVS [WQV OcT RS\ <SW[eSU& 5Za WQV VW\Oca OcT RWS wPS`TwZZbS Gb`OrS Y][[S$ aOUS WQV [W`$ ROaa Sa a]ZQVS HOUS \WQVb [SV` USPS\ eW`R& ?SW\S Rc`QVeOQVbS\ BsQVbS [SV`$ YSW\S <]bSZwPS`\OQVbc\US\ [SV` Tw` B]OV& 8WS c\aQVv\S\ 9W\hSZVSWbS\ RS` dS`UO\US\S\ BOQVb TZW``S\ [W` eWS W[[S` Rc`QV RS\ ?]^T& 7`OQY aQVs`Tb hc[W\RSab PSW [W` ROa 9`W\\S`c\UadS`[vUS\$ abObb 9`W\\S`c\US\ OcahcZvaQVS\& BWS eOQVS WQV []`US\a OcT c\R dS`USaaS$ eOa WQV W\ RS` BOQVb USbO\ VOPS& J]\ RS` O\ :OV`b USeW\\S\RS\ Gb`][OcaTOZZY`WaS c[ [WQV VS`c[ PS[S`YS WQV YOc[ SbeOa x [WQV PSaQVsTbWUb SVS`$ eWS WQV [WQV OcaUS`cVb c\R hs`bZWQV USPS\ a]ZZ$ eS\\ WQV B]OV eWSRS`aSVS& KsV`S\R RWS <S`RS\ dS`abv`bS` :crUs\US` [WbbS\ Rc`QV RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS hWSVS\$ a]`US WQV [WQV$ eWS WQV WV[ YZO`[OQVS\ a]ZZ$ ROaa \c\ S\RZWQV GQVZcaa Wab [Wb RS\ dS`UScRSbS\ BsQVbS\$ d]\ RS\S\ Sa c\hsVZWU dWSZS USUSPS\ VOb& =QV UZOcPS RO`O\& 5cQV eS\\ RWS 9`W\\S`c\U O\ jSRS\ SW\hSZ\S\ A]`US\ RWSaS` 5`b W\ RS\ ZSbhbS\ R`SW >OV`S\ x c\R RWS 9`W\\S`c\U O\ RWS UZSWQVPZSWPS\RS qPS`hScUc\U$ \c\ aSW eW`YZWQV GQVZcaa RO[Wb x eWS SW\S ?`vbS OcT [SW\S[ UcbS\ J]`aObh V]QYb$ PW\ WQV eWSRS` wPS`hScUb$ ROaa Sa RWSa[OZ O\RS`a ZscTb& 8Oaa RS` hsVS OZbS H`]bb Rc`QVP`]QVS\ eW`R& KS\\ RS` Gb`][ PWa hc[ 5PS\R eWSRS` RO Wab$ USVS\ eW` W\a ?\WQYS`P]QYS`& =QV eS`RS \WQVba b`W\YS\& CRS` R]QV$ OPS` \c` KSW\& 9W\ ;ZsaQVS\& JWSZZSWQVb heSW& 8S` Gb`][OcaTOZZ c\R ROa RO`Oca T]ZUS\RS 7VO]a OZa ;Sa^`sQVabVS[O eS`RS\ c\a d][ 5ZPb`Oc[ RS` dS`UO\US\S\ BOQVb OPZS\YS\& G]ZZbS Sa Z]aUSVS\ [Wb KWS ^OQYS\ eW` ROa O\4 ]RS` 8c P`OcQVab <WZTS$ R`]VS WQV WV[$ hc USVS\& BOQV SW\ ^OO` HOYbS\ SWaWUS\ GQVeSWUS\a eS`RS\ eW` wPS` RWS Y`SPaY`O\YS ?SZZ\S`W\ `SRS\$ eWS bO^TS` aWS Wab$ eWS aWS aQVcTbSb$ eWS b]ZZ RWS

eW` wPS` RWS Y`SPaY`O\YS ?SZZ\S`W\ `SRS\$ eWS bO^TS` aWS Wab$ eWS aWS aQVcTbSb$ eWS b]ZZ RWS aSZPabUS\sVbS\ GOQVS\ aW\R$ RWS aWS OcT RS` 5`PSWb b`sUb& =QV PS]POQVbS$ eWS aWS aWQV [Wb HOPZSbba d]ZZS` GbSOYa c\R ;Sb`s\YS Rc`QV ROa ;SR`s\US aQVWSPb$ c\R wPS`ZSUS$ ]P aWQV B]OV e]VZ dS`O\ZOaab TwVZb$ eWSRS` d]\ 9\bhcU$ AvUZWQVYSWbS\ O[PcZO\bS` 6SVO\RZc\U c\R 55 hc TOaSZ\$ eS\\ WQV SW\ R`WbbSa ;ZOa PSabSZZS& 8WS ?SZZ\S`W\ P`W\Ub c\a RWS 6c`US` [Wb :`WbbS\$ c\R WQV T`OUS [WQV S`\abZWQV$ eWS dWSZ WQV jSbhb b`W\YS\ YO\\$ ]V\S ROaa Sa HVSObS` UWPb& Bc` ROa PSaQVsTbWUb [WQV x \]QV SW\S\ x$ esV`S\R aWS d]\ WV`S` 7VS[]bVS`O^WS$ RS` 9`aQVv^Tc\U$ RS[ G]RP`S\\S\ c\R WV`S[ <OO`OcaTOZZ S`hsVZb& GWS aW\R U`]rO`bWU$ aOUS WQV$ bW^^S O\ ROa ;ZOa$ PWbbS [Wb SW\S[ Yc`hS\ BWQYS\ c[ BOQVaQVcP c\R eSWQVS B]OVa PvaS[ 6ZWQY d]\ RS` O\RS`S\ HWaQVaSWbS Oca& 8O\\ ZOaaS WQV Sa RO`OcT O\Y][[S\ c\R aOUS$ 5QV \SW\$ P`W\US\ GWS [W` SW\S\ K]RYO& CV\S WV\ O\hcaSVS\$ a^`W\US WQV OcT c\R USVS hc` H]WZSbbS$ T`OUS [WQV OZZS`RW\Ua$ ]P S` \]QV RO Wab$ eS\\ WQV eWSRS`Y][[S& 5PS` S` PZSWPb W[[S`$ c\R RO\\ eSW\b S`& 9` PWbbSb [WQV eSWbS`VW\$ ROa H`W\YS\ OcThcUSPS\ c\R [WQV PSVO\RSZ\ hc ZOaaS\$ WQV R`]VS WV[ eSWbS`$ hc USVS\ x Oca RS[ FSabOc`O\b$ Oca aSW\S[ @SPS\ hc dS`aQVeW\RS\& GQVZWSrZWQV eW`R Sa abWZZ PWa OcT RS\ 8W\\S`PSb`WSP c[ c\a VS`c[$ W\ RS` 9QYS SW\ HJ%GbO` [Wb WV`S[ AO\\$ W[ BSPS\hW[[S` SW\ JS`ZOUa[S\aQV$ O\ RS` HVSYS SW\ ^OO` PSQVS`\RS GbO[[UsabS& 8Oa aW\R c\aS`S 5PS\RS W[ ?\WQYS`P]QYS`& NWU 5PS\RS& 5PS` O\ RWSaS[ 5PS\R$ RS[ 5PS\R RSa Gb`][OcaTOZZa$ a]ZZ Sa O\RS`a eS`RS\& =[ ASS` RS` Rc`QV RWS Gb`OrS\ e]US\RS\ @ScbS ^ZvbhZWQV B]OV& 9` ZscTb RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS V]QV c\R aWSVb [WQV W[ aSZPS\ 5cUS\PZWQY eWS WQV WV\& Nc[ ;ZwQY aW\R [SW\ 5aaWabS\b c\R c\aS`S @WhS\hT`Oc PSW [W`$ RS\\ WQV [vQVbS \WQVb [Wb WV[ OZZSW\ aSW\& =QV P`OcQVS WV[ \WQVb S`ab W\a ;SaWQVb hc aSVS\$ c[ hc eWaaS\$ ROaa S` ewbS\R Wab& 9` U`wrb RWS PSWRS\ US`ORS [OZ c\R aOUb hc [W`2 ?][[ [Wb& GSW\S ;`]r[cbbS` Wab W\ WV`S[ 5^O`b[S\b W[ aSQVhSV\bS\ Gb]QY RSa GVS``g BSbVS`ZO\R$ c\R eW` [waaS\ hc WV`& G]T]`b& =QV aOUS WV[$ ROaa WQV a^sbS` R]`bVW\ Y][[S$ c\R S` O\be]`bSb [W` d]` [SW\S\ ?]ZZSUS\2 BSW\$ Rc Y][[ab jSbhb [Wb& =QV aOUS2 6S`cVWUS RWQV$ c\R S` O\be]`bSb$ ROaa S` aWQV PS`cVWUb$ eS\\ WQV [Wb WV[ [WbY][[S& GbObb SW\S GhS\S hc [OQVS\$ dS`OPaQVWSRS WQV [WQV d]\ [SW\S\ ?]ZZSUS\$ [OQVS YSV`b c\R USVS RWS :WTbV eWSRS` VW\OcT W\ FWQVbc\U GVS``g& :Oab RS\ UO\hS\ KSU$ d]\ RS` ),bV Gb`SSb PWa hc` -/bV$ ZOcTS WQV d]` WV[ VS`& 8WS GbORb Wab SW\ 7VO]a$ c\R eSUS\ 1')) VS``aQVb RS` 9W\R`cQY$ ROaa SbeOa GQVZW[[S`Sa OZa PZ]r SW\ Gb`][OcaTOZZ W[ ;O\U Wab& ;S`wQVbS d]\ 5b][Y`OTbeS`YS a^`S\US\RS\ HS``]`WabS\ TZWbbS`\ Rc`QV RWS Gb`OrS\& 8WS @cTb Wab c\VSWZaQVeO\US`& BWQVb eSWb d][ GVS``g aSVS\ eW` SW\ :SW\Y]abUSaQVsTb& 9W\ UO\h GQVWQYSa Tw` RWS @ScbS$ RWS \v`RZWQV RS` -/bV c\R awRZWQV RS` .(bV Gb`SSb heWaQVS\ :WTbV c\R AORWa]\ e]V\S\& GWS VOPS\ KSW\ c\R a]UO` SW\ ;S`sb$ ROa WV\ a]T]`b YwVZb c\R OcQV \]QV Tc\YbW]\WS`b$ eSWZ Sa O\ SW\S\ ;S\S`Ob]` O\USaQVZ]aaS\ Wab& 8S` @ORS\ aSZPab Wab Rc\YSZ PWa OcT SW\ ^OO` ?S`hS\$ c\R RWS :`Oc RSa =\VOPS`a abSVb O\ RS` dS`aQVZ]aaS\S\ Hw` c\R ^Oaab OcT$ eS\ aWS VS`SW\Zsaab& B]OV abSZZb SW\S :ZOaQVS GO\QS``S OcT RWS HVSYS$ c\R WQV aQV\O^^S [W` \]QV

VS`SW\Zsaab& B]OV abSZZb SW\S :ZOaQVS GO\QS``S OcT RWS HVSYS$ c\R WQV aQV\O^^S [W` \]QV R`SW& 8Oa bcS WQV PSecaab d]` RS[ =\VOPS`$ RO[Wb B]OV \WQVba ROUSUS\ aOUS\ YO\\& 9` aQVwbbSZb \c` ZO\UaO[ RS\ ?]^T$ c\R OZa S` \OQV aSW\S` 6`WSTbOaQVS U`SWTb$ USPS WQV WV[ dWS` NeO\hWUS`& KW` PSZORS\ c\a [Wb 6`ObVsV\QVS\$ 7`OQYS`\ c\R ?saS c\R USVS\ c[ RWS 9QYS hc[ GVS``g& 9a Wab d]`eWSUS\R SW\ 5^O`b[S\bVOca$ VOb OPS` OcQV <]bSZhW[[S`& =\ RS` @]PPg eW[[SZb Sa d]\ <]bSZRWS\S`\$ AO\OUS`\$ DOUS\$ c\R eW` S`YZs`S\$ ROaa eW` hc B]OVa ;`]r[cbbS` Phe& BSS\g e]ZZS\$ eWS aWS d]\ OZZS\ US\O\\b eW`R& AO\ YS\\b c\a c\R USZSWbSb c\a hc` H`S^^S$ RWS O\ RS\ 5PasbhS\ [Wb ?S`hS\ PSZScQVbSb Wab& 6Sd]` WQV V]QVUSVS$ aQVOcS WQV W\ RS\ KO\Ra^WSUSZ W\ RS` @]PPg$ c[ [WQV ^`saS\bOPSZ hc [OQVS\$ RS\ ?ObS` c\R RWS GQVZOTZ]aWUYSWb hc YOaQVWS`S\& =QV ab`SWQVS [W` RWS <OO`S hc`SQVb$ eWaQVS [W` RS\ GQVeSWr d]\ ;SaWQVb c\R GbW`\$ abSQYS [SW\ <S[R W\ RWS <]aS& 8O WQV hc[ ;ZwQY JWaW\S ROPSWVOPS$ a^`WbhS WQV Sa [W` W\ PSWRS PZcbc\bS`ZOcTS\S\ 5cUS\ c\R V]TTS$ ROaa BSS\g aWS c\R RS\ FSab d]\ [W` W\ RS[ <OZPRc\YSZ \WQVb OZZhc RScbZWQV aWSVb& =[ H`S^^S\VOca Wab Sa abWQYWU c\R VSWr$ c\R ROa @WQVb bO\hb d]` RS` U`w\ c\R U]ZRS\S\ HO^SbS& 8WSaSa aQVW[[S`\RS 8c\YSZ Wab$ OZa PSeSUbS\ eW` c\a c\bS` KOaaS`$ W\ NSWbZc^S$ Sa UWPb GWQVS`VSWb& =QV PW\ S`aQVv^Tb$ OPS` RWS USRs[^TbS\ H`WbbS c\R RWS abWQYWUS @cTb aW\R PS`cVWUS\R& KW` aQVZS^^S\ GsQYS d]ZZ KSW\ c\R @SPS\a[WbbSZ\ Rc`QV SW\S\ dS`U]ZRSbS\ Hc\\SZ$ RSaaS\ @WQVb OcT c\aS`S` <Ocb bO\hb& 8WS 5\Uab d]\ d]`VW\ Zsaab \OQV$ c\R OZa B]OV aWQV OcT RS[ H`S^^S\OPaObh c[R`SVb$ c[ hc aSVS\$ ]P WQV \]QV VW\bS` WV[ PW\$ ZScQVbS\ aSW\S 5cUS\ d][ ?S`hS\aQVSW\ c\R eW`YS\ eWSRS` T`Sc\RZWQV& KW` b`W\YS\ c\R SaaS\ [Wb BSS\g$ PS`wV`S\ SW\O\RS` hs`bZWQV O[ 5`[$ esV`S\R eW` ;SaQVWQVbS\ d]\ c\aS`S[ I`ZOcP W\ DO`Wa$ d]\ B]OVa :WZ[ c\R [SW\S[ >]P hc[ 6SabS\ USPS\& =QV [OZS [W` Oca$ eOa BSS\g e]VZ RS\YS\ ew`RS$ eS\\ aWS ewaabS$ ROaa WQV RWS BOQVb wPS` W\ SW\S` G]hWOZaWSRZc\U OcT RS` @]eS` 9Oab 7`OQY US`OcQVb VOPS$ W\ SW\S` K]V\c\U [Wb dWS` FWSUSZ\ c\R SW\S` EcS`abO\US O\ RS` Hw`& KOa Tw` SW\ ZO\USa ;SaWQVb aWS [OQVS\ ew`RS$ eS\\ WV` ROa jS[O\R S`hsVZbS& =QV b`W\YS SW\ ;ZOa \OQV RS[ O\RS`S\ d]\ RS[ GO\QS``S c\R S`abWQYS RWS 9`aQVv^Tc\U c\R RWS aQVZSWQVS\RS GQVO[ [Wb KSW\& =QV aSVS hc$ eWS B]OV BSS\g c\bS`VsZb$ WV` aQV[SWQVSZb$ aWS \OQV RS[ 9aaS\ PSVcbaO[ hc WV`S[ GQVZOThW[[S` P`W\Ub c\R WV` ROPSW RS\ FwQYS\ ab`SWQVSZb& 8Oa USTsZZb [W` aSV` O\ WV[$ RWSaS hO`bS GSWbS$ eWS S` aSW\S 5\USVv`WUS\ ZWSPb c\R aWQV [Wb WV\S\ dS`abSVb& KW` aQVZOTS\ OcT G]TOa W[ K]V\hW[[S` c\R dS`OPaQVWSRS\ c\a O[ \sQVabS\ A]`US\& KW` USVS\ hc :cr \OQV <OcaS$ c\R RWS FSabOc`O\ba$ 6]RSUOa c\R @SPS\a[WbbSZZsRS\ aW\R RS\ UO\hS\ HOU hc& 8WS GbORb Y][[b hc[ GbWZZabO\R& qPS`OZZ aWSVb [O\ PSb`SbS\S ;SaWQVbS` d]` dS`a^S``bS\ Hw`S\ c\R W[^`]dWaWS`bS\ GQVWZRS`\$ OcT RS\S\ ;9G7<@CGG9B abSVb& G^sbS` O[ BOQV[WbbOU USVS\ RWS @WQVbS` ec\RS`PO`S`eSWaS eWSRS` O\& :Oab OcUS\PZWQYZWQV dS`UWaab [O\$ eWS VWZTZ]a [O\ eO`& 8Oa @SPS\ YSV`b hc`wQY$ c\R OZZSa Wab

eWS W[[S`& 5[ 5PS\R SaaS\ eW` W[ ?\WQYS`P]QYS`$ c\R Sa Wab eWSRS` ROa OZbS @WSR& 6WbbS\$ 8`]VS\$ GQVeSWUS\$ H`s\S\& 5Za WQV hc` H]WZSbbS USVS$ [caa WQV O\ RS\ 5PS\R hcd]` RS\YS\3 eWS WQV \OQV RS[ 9aaS\$ PS\SPSZb d]\ GO\QS``S c\R GQVZOT[O\USZ$ PSW BSS\g O[ :S\abS` USabO\RS\ c\R wPS` RWS GwR]abSQYS RSa 7S\b`OZ DO`Ya hc[ DZOhO <]bSZ USaQVOcb VOPS$ ROa W[ 8c\YSZ\ ZOU$ Rc\YZS` eO` OZa OZZS O\RS`S\ ;SPscRS& =QV [caa RO`O\ RS\YS\$ eWS abWZZ RWS GbORb eO` x YSW\ ZSWaSa Gc[[S\ d]\ ?ZW[OO\ZOUS\$ YSW\S dS`SW\hSZbS\ GbW[[S\ Oca :S`\aSVS`\ ]RS` FORW]a& KWS eS\WUS 5cb]a OcT RS\ Gb`OrS\ eO`S\& I\R eWS dS`ZOaaS\$ USRcQYb$ USRS[wbWUb ROa DZOhO OcaaOV& 8WS GbORb c[ Sa VS`c[ [wRS$ OcaUSZOcUb$ OZa VsbbS aWS WV`S SV`USWhWUS\ 6w`US` \c\ S\RZWQV OcTUSUSPS\ c\R RWS @cab O\ RS[ UO\hS\ H`cPSZ dS`Z]`S\&

NcTZcQVb
K]VW\4$ T`OUb [WQV RS` HOfWTOV`S`$ OZa eW` \OQV GwRS\ aOcaS\$ eSU d]\ 7VSZaSO$ eSU d][ AO`WbW[S$ eSU d]\ [SW\S` :O[WZWS& @WaOa HOfW Wab \W`US\Ra hc aSVS\$ c\R aQV]\ SW\ ^OO` Gb`OrS\ eSWbS` RS\YS WQV \WQVb [SV` O\ aWS ]RS` RWS O\RS`S\& =QV RS\YS O\ [SW\ \sQVabSa NWSZ& 9W\S VOZPS HwbS c\R SW\S dS`P`O\\bS DTSWTS VOPS WQV \]QV W\ RS` HOaQVS& =QV [caa W`US\Re]VW\$ e] WQV `OcQVS\ YO\\& KW` TSUS\ O[ ;O\aSd]]`b <]bSZ d]`PSW$ e] WQV [Wb GWQVS`VSWb \WS eWSRS` VW\ YO\\& BWQVb$ \OQVRS[ B]OV d]` R`SW HOUS\ [Wb SW\S[ D`WdObRSbSYbWd R]`b eO`& I\R \WQVb$ \OQVRS[ WQV x PW\ [W` \WQVb aWQVS`$ OPS` a] aQVSW\bya x Q`OQYdS`Y\WSabS`bS ?`ObhS` c\R 5aQVS\PSQVS` W[ NW[[S` hc`wQYUSZOaaS\ VOPS$ eS\\ \WQVb a]UO` SW\S DTSWTS& B]`[OZS`eSWaS PW\ WQV wPS`d]`aWQVbWU& =QV eWaQVS [SV`[OZa USeWaaS\VOTb OZZSa OP$ RO[Wb PSW[ GOcPS`[OQVS\ \WS[O\R [S`Yb$ eOa USZOcTS\ Wab& 5PS` eW` aW\R wPS`VOabSb eSU$ c\R WQV VObbS ^O\WaQVS 5\Uab$ \OQVRS[ aWS [W` S`hsVZb VObbS\$ ROaa RWS D]ZWhSW W\ C\S :WTbV eO` c\R ROaa RWS FOcaQVUWTbPSVv`RS S`[WbbSZb& =QV abSZZS [W` d]`$ eWS RWS <]bSZZSWbc\U W[ ;O\aSd]]`b c\R W[ AO`WbW[S [Wb ?`W^] c\R 8`]US\Q]^a RWS NW[[S` Rc`QVYs[[b x [SW\S :W\US`OPR`wQYS d]\ RS\ K]RYOUZsaS`\ c\R RS` :S`\PSRWS\c\U \W[[b$ 7`OQYY`w[SZ d][ HS^^WQVP]RS\ ZWSab$ c[ aWS W[ @OP]` c\bS`acQVS\ hc ZOaaS\$ ;SZROcb][ObS\PSZSUS Oca DO^WS`Yv`PS\ TWaQVb c\R PSW RS` 7VOaS [SW\S as[bZWQVS\ 8ObS\ OPT`OUb& BW`US\Ra aQVSW\b Sa aWQVS` hc aSW\& AWb RS` 5\]\g[Wbsb$ RWS WQV PWaVS` US\]aaS\ VOPS$ Wab Sa ]TTS\PO` d]`PSW& B]OV c\R RS` D`WdObRSbSYbWd Yv\\S\ [WQV wPS`OZZ TW\RS\& =QV aQVOZbS [SW\ <O\Rg Oca& <Ob 6`WO\ \WQVb USaOUb$ [O\ Yv\\S [WQV wPS` [SW\ <O\RgaWU\OZ OcTa^w`S\4 =QV eS`RS <O^^g ^S` Aw\hbSZST]\ O\`cTS\& =V[ aOUS\$ [SW\ <O\Rg aSW YO^cbb& =QV PSbOabS RWS YZSW\S DZOabWYbwbS W\ [SW\S` >SO\abOaQVS c\R hWSVS RWS ?]\bc`S\ RS` [WbbSZU`]rS\ GbSW\S \OQV$ RWS aWS S\bVsZb& K] YO\\ WQV VW\4 K]4 =QV P`OcQVS SW\S\ aWQVS`S\ C`b c\R eSWr YSW\S\& 8S` HOfWTOV`S` T`OUb [WQV S`\Scb$ e] WQV VW\ eWZZ$ c\R WQV aOUS WV[$ S` a]ZZ \OQV CabS\ TOV`S\& KW` aW\R vabZWQV RS` :WTbV$ BsVS <]cab]\& CabS\ Vv`b aWQV \OQV ;`S\hS O\& I\S`T]`aQVbSa @O\R$ KSZbS\ S\bTS`\b d][ KSab JWZZOUS c\R d]\ 7VSZaSO$ e] WQV RWS ZSbhbS\ K]QVS\ dS`P`OQVb VOPS& 5Za eW` OcT RWS <]cab]\ Y][[S\ c\R US\ CabS\ P`SbbS`\$ Wab [W`$ OZa ]P WQV Oca SW\S[ hS`abv`bS\ @O\R W\ SW\S c\dS`P`OcQVbS \ScS KSZb VW\wPS`TOV`S& =QV eO` VWS` aQV]\ hWUbOcaS\R AOZ$ c\R R]QV S`aQVSW\b [W` \WQVba dS`b`Ocb& 8WS ;SPscRS$ GQVWZRS`$ FSabOc`O\ba$ jO aSZPab RWS AS\aQVS\ aW\R c\PSabW[[b$ c\UZOcPew`RWU$ aWS wPS`hScUS\ \WQVb UO\h OZa BSe M]`YS`$ OZa BSe M]`Y& 9a Wab eWS SW\ W\ H]`]\b] USR`SVbS` :WZ[ wPS` AO\VObbO\& =QV PWbbS RS\ :OV`S`$ O\ RS` 9QYS <]cab]\ c\R @OTOgSbbS hc VOZbS\& 8O\\ aSVS WQV$ ROaa RWS IV` \WQVb ZscTb& I\R ROaa ROa :OV`S`T]b] d]\ SW\S[ DO^^ab`SWTS\ dS`RSQYb Wab$ RS`

RWS IV` \WQVb ZscTb& I\R ROaa ROa :OV`S`T]b] d]\ SW\S[ DO^^ab`SWTS\ dS`RSQYb Wab$ RS` BO[S OZZS`RW\Ua \WQVb$ GW\UV ]RS` a] sV\ZWQV$ SW\ W\RWaQVS` ]RS` ^OYWabO\WaQVS` BO[S& 8S` :OV`S` Wab aQVeO`h c\R RSTW\WbWd YSW\ =\RS`& =QV US`ObS W\ DO\WY$ \SV[S SW\S\ NSV\S` Oca RS` >OQYS c\R `SWQVS WV\ WV[ Rc`QV ROa YZSW\S DZSfWUZOaTS\abS`& 8S` ]V\S IV` bOfWTOV`S\RS aQVeO`hS BWQVbW\RS` ZOQVb$ OZa WQV <OZa wPS` ?]^T OcaabSWUS& K]VW\4 =QV VOPS \c` \]QV \Sc\bOcaS\Ra]c\Ra]dWSZ OcT RS[ ?]\b]$ ROa 9\RS Wab OPhcaSVS\& =QV USVS RWS <]bSZa Rc`QV$ W\ RS\S\ WQV aQV]\ eO` x ;O\aSd]]`b$ .( HV][^a]\$ KOaVW\Ub]\ G_cO`S$ AO`WbW[S& =QV P`OcQVS SbeOa BScSa c\R S\baQVZWSrS [WQV$ Sa [Wb RS[ AS`QS` <]bSZ hc dS`acQVS\& 9a Wab ROa BsQVabS3 WQV abSZZS [W` SW\ aOcPS`Sa$ VSZZSa NW[[S` [Wb OcaUSTOZZS\S\ GSWTS\ c\R SW\S` 8caQVS d]`$ c\bS` RS`S\ Y`sTbWUS[ Gb`OVZ WQV RWS ?s[^TS c\R ?`s[^TS RS` dS`UO\US\S\ HOUS Z]aeS`RS\ YO\\& Nc[ ZSbhbS\ AOZ dWSZZSWQVb& =QV PSb`SbS RWS aQVWQYS$ `cVWUS <]bSZVOZZS c\R USVS hc[ 9[^TO\U& =QV T`OUS SW\S jc\US :`Oc$ ]P aWS SW\ NW[[S` VOPS\$ c\R aWS PWbbSb [WQV$ SW\S\ 5cUS\PZWQY hc eO`bS\& BOQV SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ Y][[b aWS [Wb SW\S[ PSP`WZZbS\ AO\\ d]\ 9\RS R`SWrWU ]RS` 5\TO\U dWS`hWU eWSRS`& KW` VOPS\ ZSWRS` \WQVba Tw` GWS$ aOUb RS` AO\\ ]V\S I[aQVeSWTS& =QV T`OUS WV\$ ]P aWS \WQVba VOPS\$ ]RS` \c` Tw` [WQV \WQVb& GWS VOPS\ [WQV aQV]\ dS`abO\RS\$ aOUb S` [Wb SW\S[ TSW\RaSZWUS\ ;SaWQVbaOcaR`cQY& 8WS :`Oc Wab ^SW\ZWQV PS`wV`b c\R eSWQVb [SW\S[ 6ZWQY Oca& 9a ROcS`b SW\ ^OO` HOYbS$ PWa [W` YZO` eW`R$ eOa Z]a Wab& CTTS\aWQVbZWQV aWSVb [O\ [W` O\$ ROaa WQV OcT 8`]US PW\& GSWb RS[ AO`WbW[S VOPS WQV \WQVb [SV` W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ USaQVOcb& GW\R [SW\S 5cUS\ PZcbc\bS`ZOcTS\4 FWSQVS WQV \OQV FOcQV c\R 5ZY]V]Z4 =QV eSWr \WQVb [SV`$ ]P WQV O[ A]`US\ USRcaQVb VOPS& ASW\ ;SaWQVb UZwVb d]` GQVO[$ c\R WQV dS`aQVeW\RS e]`bZ]a& 5cT RS` AS`QS` Gb`SSb ^OQYb [WQV RWS 5\Uab& =`US\ReWS VOPS WQV$ ]V\S Sa hc [S`YS\$ SW\S ;`S\hS wPS`aQV`WbbS\ x d]\ RO$ e] [O\ [W` RS\ 7`OQYawQVbWUS\ \WQVb O\aWSVb$ \OQV RO$ e] Sa a] ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV Wab$ ROaa [O\ [WQV eSUaQVWQYb& =QV aQVOcS$ ]P [SW\S <s\RS hWbbS`\& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ ROaa O\ [SW\S[ 5caaSVS\$ [SW\S[ JS`VOZbS\$ [SW\S` 5`b hc `SRS\ dWSZZSWQVb SbeOa Wab$ ROa [W` aSZPab \WQVb OcTTsZZb& 9beOa O\ [SW\S\ 6SeSUc\US\ c\R [SW\S[ UO\hS\ 5cTb`SbS\$ ROa$ eWS ?v`^S`% ]RS` Ac\RUS`cQV$ \c` d]\ O\RS`S\ PS[S`Yb eW`R$ [W` aSZPab OPS` S\bUSVb& GbO``S\ RWS @ScbS [WQV O\4 AOQVS\ aWS W[ J]`PSWUSVS\ SW\ O\USeWRS`bSa ;SaWQVb4 ASW\S <]aS aWbhb aSV` eSWb& J]` wPS` SW\S` K]QVS VOPS WQV [W` hcZSbhb SW\ @]QV W\ RS\ ;w`bSZ abO\hS\ ZOaaS\$ c\R [SW\ Rc\YSZPZOcS` F]ZZY`OUS\^cZZ]dS`$ RS` eWS SW\ GOQY O\ [W` VS`c\bS`Vs\Ub$ [caa UO\h SW\TOQV abW\YS\& CPe]VZ WQV aSWb SW\S[ A]\Ob OcT 8`]US PW\$ bsUZWQV ZWbS`eSWaS K]RYO b`W\YS$ \WQVb aQVZOTS c\R d]\ SW\S[ <]bSZ hc[ O\RS`S\ `S\\S$ Wab RWS 9`YS\\b\Wa$ ROaa WQV bObasQVZWQV eWS SW\ >c\YWS OcaaSVS\ Yv\\bS$ SW\ SQVbS` GQV]QY Tw` [WQV& 9a Y][[b [W` d]`$ OZa ]P WQV \WQVb [SV` eWS PWaVS` c\S`YO\\b Rc`QVa @SPS\ USVS\ YO\\$ OZa ]P [W` 7F57?<958 W\ 5aQVS OcT RWS GbW`\ USaQV`WSPS\ abSVb c\R jSRS` Sa aSVS\ YO\\&

=QV PW\ \W`US\Ra c\R USVv`S \W`US\Ra VW\& KOa ^OaaWS`b$ abSVb [W` jSbhb YZO` d]` 5cUS\ x ROa ZO\UaO[S 5P`cbaQVS\$ ROa 9``SWQVS\ RSa jSeSWZa \sQVabS\ c\[vUZWQVS\ GbORWc[a x 7`OQYVvVZS$ 9\bhcU$ ?\Oab$ Gb`OrS$ CPROQVZ]aS\OagZ$ SW\ Yc`hS` GQV]QY$ RO\\ RWS 5\^Oaac\U O\ RWS \ScS FSOZWbsb& 6W\ WQV jSbhb W[ :SUSTScS` heWaQVS\ 6w`US` c\R BWS[O\R$ jc\US[ ;S\bZS[O\ c\R DS\\S`4 =QV USVS Z]a& 9a Wab a^sb []`US\a$ OcT RS\ Gb`OrS\ VS``aQVb 6Sb`WSP& <]QVPSb`WSP$ R]QV W`US\ReWS aQVSW\b Sa$ OZa ]P [O\ [W` DZObh [OQVb& Nc` GSWbS b`Wbb$ [W` OcaeSWQVb& BWQVb [Wb [W` W\ 6S`wV`c\U Y][[S\ eWZZ& GSVS\ Sa OZZS4 =ab Sa a] ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV4 <OPS WQV 6Zcb W[ ;SaWQVb4 =QV P`OcQVS SW\S\ G^WSUSZ& =QV aSVS SW\S aQV[cRRSZWUS 6O` W`US\Re] \v`RZWQV RS` <]cab]\& GWS VOb USvTT\Sb$ c\R WQV USVS US`ORSeSUa hc` H]WZSbbS& =QV dS``WSUZS RWS Hw`$ V]ZS eWS \WQVba HwbS$ DTSWTS c\R :ScS`hScU VS`d]` c\R [OQVS [W` aQVZSc\WUab SW\S\ <Wb& 8S\ G^WSUSZ WU\]`WS`S WQV$ RS\\ eS\\ WQV SbeOa GQVScrZWQVSa O\ [W` VOPS$ RO\\ [vQVbS WQV Sa \]QV \WQVb aSVS\ x S`ab$ eS\\ WQV O\USY\OZZb PW\& I[ ROa ?ZWQYS\ RSa :ScS`hScUa hc wPS`bv\S\$ R`SVS WQV RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ OcT& =QV ab]^TS TOab RS\ VOZPS\ HwbS\W\VOZb W\ RWS DTSWTS c\R \SV[S SW\S\ FWSaS\hcU& 8S\ G^W`OZ\SPSZ PSVOZbS WQV W\ RS` @c\US$ PWa [W` RWS @cTb OcaUSVb& 8S` FOc[ dS`eO\RSZb aWQV W\ SW\S e]US\RS eSWrS K]ZYS$ SW\S 7`OQY`OcQVaOc\O$ c\R hc[ ;ZwQY Wab wPS` RS[ KOaQVPSQYS\ SW\ YZSW\Sa :S\abS`$ ROa WQV a]T]`b OcT`SWrS& 8S` G^WSUSZ Wab RW`SYb O[ KOaQVPSQYS\$ c\R esV`S\R RS` RWQVbS EcOZ[ Oca RS[ :S\abS` eOPS`b$ aQVOcS WQV VW\SW\& ASW\S 5cUS\ aW\R U`w\ c\R `]b$ c\R RS` F]ZZY`OUS\ [SW\Sa DcZZ]dS`a Wab eSWr dS`YZSPb& 8S` F]ZZW c\R RWS >OQYS aSVS\ R`SW Bc[[S`\ hc U`]r Oca& I\bS` [SW\S[ ZW\YS\ BOaS\Z]QV YZSPb USb`]QY\SbS` GQV\]RRS`$ c\R RS` aSWb K]QVS\ a^`WSrS\RS aQVeO`hS 6O`b Wab PZ]\R$ aWZPS`\ c\R `]b USa^`S\YSZb& GWZPS`\4 9W\ OZbS` AO\\ PZWQYb [WQV Oca RS[ G^WSUSZ O\$ OPUSVs`[b$ YZO^^`WU c\R dS`s\UabWUb& 5caUSZOcUb& =QV hWSVS \]QV SW\[OZ O\ RS` DTSWTS c\R PZOaS RS\ FOcQV hc[ :S\abS` VW\Oca& B]QV SW\ NcU& I\R \]QV SW\S`& =QV aSbhS [WQV OcTa ?Z]PSQYS\ c\R ZOaaS ROa 7`OQY RS\ <]``]` RSa A]`US\a Rs[^TS\$ PWa aQVZWSrZWQV SW\ :Zs[[QVS\ FcVS W\ [W` OcTabSWUb& 8O\\ YZ]^Tb jS[O\R& GQV\SZZ \SV[S WQV \]QV SW\S\ NcU Oca RS` DTSWTS$ SVS WQV [SW\S\ DcZZ]dS` aOcPS`[OQVS$ [W` ROa ;SaWQVb OPeWaQVS c\R [W` SW\ eS\WU KOaaS` OcT RWS KO\US\ a^`WbhS& =[ G^WSUSZ aSVS WQV W[[S` \]QV hWS[ZWQV hS``c^Tb Oca& 5PS` jSbhb TW\RS WQV ROa PSW\OV ZcabWU$ \WQVb [SV` a] aQVZW[[& 9a YZ]^Tb eWSRS`$ c\R WQV `OTTS [SW\ NScU hcaO[[S\$ a^wZS RWS H]WZSbbS c\R USVS Rc`QV RWS 6O` hc` Gb`OrS$ ]V\S \OQV ZW\Ya ]RS` `SQVba hc aQVOcS\& =QV aSVS SW\ HOfW c\R VOZbS Sa O\& 8S` BO[S SW\Sa \ScS`S\ <]bSZa 9QYS DO`Y 5dS\cS G]cbV c\R *.bV TsZZb [W` SW\ x HVS ;W`OTTS x$ c\R WQV aOUS RS[ :OV`S`$ RO a]ZZ S` VW\TOV`S\& NWS[ZWQV eSWb$ PS[S`Yb S`& ASW\S WQV jSRS\TOZZa& KOa VOPS\ GWS USaOUb4$ T`OUS WQV$ c\R S` ZOQVb& =QV eWSRS`V]ZS RWS :`OUS$ c\R S` O\be]`bSb W`]\WaQV2 J]\ [W` Oca P`W\US WQV GWS wPS`OZZ VW\& 8WS O\UabZvaS\RS KW`Yc\U RS` DTSWTS\$ RWS WQV US`ORS US`OcQVb VOPS$ Zsaab OcT RS` :OV`b wPS` RWS HVW`R 5dS\cS `OaQV \OQV& =QV wPS`ZSUS$ ]P WQV RWS GbORb dS`ZOaaS\ a]ZZ$

c\R RS\YS O\ C`bS eWS :Z]`WRO ]RS` 6]ab]\$ OPS` WQV eSWr SW\TOQV \WQVb$ eWS [O\ R]`b O\ 8`]US\ Y][[b& 5crS`RS[ YO\\ WQV VWS` \W`US\Ra [SV` SW\S\ :ZcUVOTS\ PSb`SbS\$ O[ eS\WUabS\ RS\ W\ BSeO`Y& =QV abSZZS [W` d]`$ ROaa wPS`OZZ [SW\ :]b] OcaVs\Ub c\R DS\\Sgb`c^^a RWS HS`[W\OZa Rc`QVYs[[S\& 8Oa HOfW PZSWPb W[ JS`YSV` Vs\US\& =\ RS[ ;SVc^S TwVZS WQV [WQV SW\USa^S``b c\R OcaUSZWSTS`b& 5Za Yv\\bS ROa HOfW jSRS\ A][S\b c[abSZZb eS`RS\& =QV eS`TS SW\S\ NeO\hWUS` OcT RS\ J]`RS`aWbh c\R abSWUS Oca& HVS ;W`OTTS Wab hSV\ 6Z]QYa S\bTS`\b& =QV Y]\b`]ZZWS`S [SW\S 5b[c\U c\R dS`acQVS W[ KSWbS`USVS\ SbeOa Z]QYS`S` hc eS`RS\& FcVWU$ aOUS WQV [W` W[[S` eWSRS`& FcVWU& 8Oa <]bSZ Wab ZSS` c\R `WSQVb \OQV 5[[]\WOY& 5ZZSa Wab \OUSZ\Sc c\R dWSZ PcaW\Saa[srWUS`$ OZa WQV [W` d]`USabSZZb VObbS& BWQVb UO\h ROa FWQVbWUS& H`]bhRS[ USVS WQV hc RS[ Hg^S\ O[ 9[^TO\U c\R T`OUS \OQV SW\S[ NW[[S`& 9` Wab T`vVZWQV$ W\ RS\ NeO\hWUS`\$ c\R aOUb$ aSZPabdS`abs\RZWQV& 9` PWbbSb c[ [SW\S\ DOaa$ Ts\Ub O\$ OcT aSW\S` HOabObc` hc bW^^S\$ RO b`Wbb SW\S sZbS`S :`Oc hc WV[ VW\bS` RWS HVSYS c\R aOUb$ aWS [OQVb ROa aQV]\& 9` aWSVb aWS dS`ec\RS`b O\ c\R b`Wbb hc` GSWbS$ OZa aWS aWQV [SW\S\ DOaa d]`\W[[b c\R aQVOcb$ eOa S` SW\USbW^^b VOb& CV$ aOUb aWS$ eW` aW\R jO OcaUSPcQVb& 8S` jc\US AO\\ eWZZ SbeOa SW\eS\RS\$ P`S[ab aWQV RO\\ OPS`& KW`YZWQV4$ T`OUS WQV& >O$ O\be]`bSb aWS$ eW` aW\R PWa 9\RS RSa A]\Oba OcaUSPcQVb& =QV eWZZ SbeOa aOUS\$ aSVS OPS` SW\$ ROaa Sa \WQVba hc aOUS\ UWPb$ R`SVS [WQV c[ c\R USVS eWSRS` VW\Oca OcT RWS Gb`OrS$ RWS DO`Y 5dS\cS$ e] aWQV RS` JS`YSV` W\ PSWRS\ FWQVbc\US\ abOcb& KS\\ [W` G]<] eWS SW\S T`S[RS @O\RaQVOTb S`aQVWS\S\ eO`$ a] Wab RWSaSa d]\ GbOVZ c\R <SYbWY S`TwZZbS GbwQY BSe M]`Ya ROa :`S[RS aQVZSQVbVW\& ?SW\S `c\RS\ 9QYS\$ YSW\ aQVObbWUS` KW\YSZ$ W\ RS[ [O\ NcTZcQVb Ts\RS& 8WS YOZbS As`ha]\\S ab`OVZb wPS`OZZVW\$ eW`R d]\ RS\ TOV`S\RS\ 5cb]a$ RS\ ;ZOaes\RS\ [SV`abvQYWUS` FSabOc`O\ba SPS\a] hc`wQYUSe]`TS\ eWS d]\ RS\ AO\aQVSbbS\Y\v^TS\ c\R 5YbS\bOaQVS\PSaQVZsUS\ ^S`TSYb USYZSWRSbS` ;SaQVsTbaZScbS$ RWS [Wb ZSS`S\ ;SaWQVbS`\ hc[ \sQVabS\ HS`[W\ [O`aQVWS`S\& =QV YSV`S hc` HVW`R 5dS\cS hc`wQY c\R eS\RS [WQV \OQV GwRS\& KWSRS` aQVSW\b Sa$ OZa ]P RWS @ScbS [W` DZObh [OQVS\$ OcaeSWQVS\$ hc` GSWbS USVS\& AW` TsZZb SW\ H`Oc[ Oca [SW\S` >cUS\R SW\ x d]\ SW\S[ DWQY\WQY W[ KOZR c\R SW\S` c\aWQVbPO`S\ AOQVb$ RWS ROa UO\hS 9aaS\ d]\ RS\ 8SQYS\ OcTabSWUS\ Zsaab c\R Sa VW\bS` RWS 6sc[S b`sUb& 5ZZS x [SW\S 9ZbS`\$ [SW\S GQVeSabS`$ ?W\RVSWbaT`Sc\RS$ c\aS`S BOQVPO`\ x TW\RS\ aWQV RO[Wb OP$ ROaa ROa 9aaS\ dS`aQVeW\RSb$ OPS` WQV eWZZ [SW\S HwbS 7VSSb]a \WQVb Z]aZOaaS\& =QV PW\ S\baQVZ]aaS\$ RWS 7VW^a hc PSVOZbS\$ c\R esV`S\R WQV OZZSW\ USUS\ RWS c\aWQVbPO`S <O\R O\Ys[^TS$ RWS aWS [W` US\Oca] S\baQVZ]aaS\ hc S\b`SWrS\ dS`acQVb$ b`SbS\ OZZS O\RS`S\ eSU& 8S` FSWVS \OQV eSWQVS\ aWS O\ RS\ FO\R RS` @WQVbc\U hc`wQY c\R wPS`ZOaaS\ [WQV [W` aSZPab& AWb GQVOcRS`\ aSVS WQV jSbhb OcT RS` HVW`R$ eWS USa^S\abWaQV US\Oc RWS J]`OcaaOUS W\ RWSaS[ H`Oc[ USeSaS\ Wab& =QV TwVZS [WQV eW\hWUYZSW\ c\R wPS`U`]r hcUZSWQV& I\S`aSbhZWQV c\R c\PSRScbS\R& =[ NS\b`c[ RSa ;SaQVSVS\a c\R O[ scrS`abS\ FO\R& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ SW\ ;SPscRS$ SW\ <Oca [Wb G]hWOZe]V\c\US\ W\ RS` *+`R Gb`SSb$ e] WQV SW\[OZ ;SabOZbS\ USaSVS\ VObbS$ RWS WQV Tw` >c\YWSa VWSZb& 8WS 9`W\\S`c\U PZWbhb W\ [W`

WQV SW\[OZ ;SabOZbS\ USaSVS\ VObbS$ RWS WQV Tw` >c\YWSa VWSZb& 8WS 9`W\\S`c\U PZWbhb W\ [W` OcT eWS SW\ <]TT\c\Uaab`OVZ& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ ROaa ROa <Oca \SPS\ SW\S[ ;SaQVsTb Tw` ;SP`OcQVb[vPSZ abO\R$ W\ RS[ WQV >OV`S hcd]` \OQV SW\S[ HS^^WQV USacQVb VObbS& =QV ZSUS SW\S\ GQV`Wbb hc c\R eS\RS [WQV$ OZa WQV hc` *+`R Gb`SSb Y][[S$ ]abes`ba FWQVbc\U GSQ]\R& =QV aSVS RS\ ;SP`OcQVb[vPSZZORS\ c\R RO\\ ROa ;SPscRS& 5crS`RS[ aSVS WQV x eWS a]ZZ WQV [WQV OcaR`wQYS\ x @ScbS eWS [WQV$ wPS`OZZ& GWS aQVZc`TS\ VS`c[& @SV\S\ O\ <Ocaes\RS\& GQVW[^TS\ W\ Aw\hbSZST]\S& 5Za VsbbS\ aWS OZZSaO[b ]`O\USTO`PS\S CdS`OZZa O\$ a] YZO` S`YS\\S WQV aWS& =QV ab]rS RWS @cTb Oca c\R S\ba^O\\S [WQV SW\ eS\WU& @SV\S [WQV USUS\ ROa ;SPscRS c\R ZOaaS [W` RWS G]\\S W\a ;SaWQVb aQVSW\S\& 8WS Ks`[S bcb `WQVbWU Ucb$ c\R Sa Wab aQVv\$ \WQVb [SV` ZOcTS\ hc [waaS\& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ O\ RWSaS[ HOU TwVZS WQV [WQV aWQVS`& 9W\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ a^sbS` aSVS WQV SW\S\ AO\\$ RS` PSW RS[ dS`ab`ScbS\ <OcTS\ d]` RS[ ;SPscRS SbeOa hc USZbS\ aQVSW\b& 9W\S` PWbbSb WV\ c[ :ScS`$ SW\ O\RS`S` YZ]^Tb WV[ OcT RS\ FwQYS\& 9` ^TSWTb SW\S` :`Oc [WbbZS`S\ 5ZbS`a \OQV$ RWS ROa ;SPscRS PSb`Wbb& 5\ RS` 5`b$ eWS aWS ZOQVb$ [S`Yb [O\$ ROaa aWS aWQV YS\\S\& GSW\S 5cUS\ VOPS\ SbeOa :`Sc\RZWQVSa$ OPS` OcQV SW\S USeWaaS <s`bS& 9` V]QYb aWQV \WQVb eSWb d]\ [W` VW\$ c[ SW\S hc `OcQVS\$ c\R WQV USVS hc WV[ c\R aOUS VOZZ]& KW` c\bS`VOZbS\ c\a SW\S KSWZS& 9` aQVSW\b [WQV hc dS`abSVS\& Nc eWaaS\$ eOa GOQVS Wab$ ]V\S ROaa WQV Sa Ocaa^`SQVS& =QV TwVZS [WQV e]VZ& ;cb US\cU$ c[ WV\ hc T`OUS\$ ]P W[ <Oca SbeOa T`SW es`S Tw` [WQV& 9W\ NW[[S`$ e] WQV SW\S KSWZS OPbOcQVS\ c\R wPS`\OQVbS\ c\R [SW\S FcVS VOPS\ Yv\\bS& 9a ew`RS aWQV OcQV OcahOVZS\$ TwUS WQV VW\hc& KsV`S\R WQV `SRS$ ZsQVSZb S` SW\ eS\WU$ OZa VsbbS S` jSRSa K]`b d]`OcaUSaSVS\& BOQV SW\S` DOcaS aOUb S`2 8O eSWr WQV US\Oc RWS FWQVbWUS Tw` RWQV& I\R YSW\S G]`US$ RO eW`ab Rc \WQVb PSVSZZWUb& 9` aOUb$ S` `SUSZb ROa$ c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb W[ ;SPscRS& =QV USVS hc[ ;SZROcb][ObS\ O\ RS` 6]RSUO \SPS\O\& NeO\hWU AW\cbS\ a^sbS` Y][[b S` eWSRS` `Oca c\R aOUb2 5ZZSa ^OZSbbW$ Y][[ [Wb& =QV a^OhWS`S VW\SW\$ c\R eW` USVS\ hc SW\S[ GQVOZbS`& ASW\ DOaa eW`R dS`ZO\Ub$ c\R WQV PSY][[S SW\ 5\[SZRST]`[cZO`$ OcT RS[ WQV [SW\S\ BO[S\ c\R RWS IV`hSWb SW\b`OUS& ASW\ \ScS` :`Sc\R$ RSaaS\ BO[S WQV \WQVb YS\\S$ aOUb hc RS[ c`OZbS\ AO\\ O[ GQVOZbS`$ ROaa WQV hc WV[ USVv`S c\R \c` hc 6SacQV PW\& KW` TOV`S\ [Wb RS[ 5cThcU W\ RS\ ),& ]RS` )-& Gb]QY VW\OcT$ c\R S` T`OUb [WQV$ ]P aWQV ROa ;O\hS Tw` WV\ eW`YZWQV USZ]V\b VOb& =QV USPS WV[ heSWVc\RS`b 8]ZZO`$ c\R S` aOUb ZsQVSZ\R2 BO jO$ RO\\ aQV]\& KW` abSWUS\ Oca RS[ 5cThcU c\R USVS\ SW\S\ :Zc` S\bZO\U$ c\R W`US\ReWS eO` WQV \]QV \WQVb SW\S GSYc\RS \S`dva ]RS` aQV`SQYVOTb$ aSWb WQV W\ RS[ ;SPscRS PW\& GSZPab ROa 5\[SZRS\ c\R 5caeSWaS\ YO[ [W` UO\h c\PSRS\YZWQV d]`& KW` PZSWPS\ d]` SW\S` Hw` abSVS\$ c\R S` YZ]^Tb ZSWaS O\& J]\ R`W\\S\ Vv`S WQV RWS GbW[[S SW\S` :`Oc$ RO\\ eWS Rc[^T SbeOa OcT RS\ 6]RS\ TsZZb c\R SW\ _cWSbaQVWUSa ?WQVS`\& 8WS Hw` vTT\Sb aWQV$ c\R SW\S YZSW\S aQVeO`hS :`Oc ab`OVZb [WQV O\& C VOZZ]$ Rc PWab OZa] RS` jc\US AO\\$ d]\ RS[ AO`aVOZZ USa^`]QVS\ VOb& =[[S` `SW\& =V` 5YhS\b Wab aQVeS` hc PSabW[[S\ x 7Ojc\$ GwRS\

AO`aVOZZ USa^`]QVS\ VOb& =[[S` `SW\& =V` 5YhS\b Wab aQVeS` hc PSabW[[S\ x 7Ojc\$ GwRS\ W`US\ReWS& GWS abSZZb aWQV OZa F]aWS d]` c\R aOUb$ WQV a]ZZ DZObh \SV[S\& ASW\ \ScS` :`Sc\R$ d]\ RS[ WQV jSbhb eSWr$ ROaa S` AO`aVOZZ VSWrb$ S\baQVcZRWUb aWQV& 8WS Hw` TsZZb VW\bS` WV[ W\a GQVZ]aa$ c\R F]aWS c\R WQV aW\R ^ZvbhZWQV OZZSW\ W\ SW\S[ 5^O`b[S\b a] U`]r eWS R`SW ?wVZP]fS\& =QV aSbhS [WQV OcT SW\ ?]`Pa]TO Tw` heSW$ OcT RS[ aWQV ZW\Ya eWS `SQVba ?O`b]\a$ HOaQVS\ c\R d]` OZZS[ HwbS\ bw`[S\$ RWS d]\ GQV\c`$ Gbg`]^]` c\R <O\RbwQVS`\ wPS`_cSZZS\& 9W\ dS`b`OcbS` ;S`cQV Vs\Ub W[ FOc[& G] dS`b`Ocb$ ROaa WQV F]aWS T`OUS$ ]P WQV `OcQVS\ RO`T& GWS aOUb [Wb WV`S` V]VS\ GbW[[S c\R RS[ aQVeS` hc TOaaS\RS\ 5YhS\b2 BO YZO`$ a]ZO\U Rc [W` eOa OPUWPab& I\R a] T`OUS WQV [WQV W\ F]aWSa eW\hWUS` 6cRS$ e]VS` AO`aVOZZ e]VZ ecaabS$ eOa eW` US[SW\aO[ VOPS\& FSW\ scrS`ZWQV aW\R eW` SW\ c\[vUZWQVSa DOO`$ OPS` W\ SW\S` <W\aWQVb UZSWQVS\ eW` c\a& KW` aW\R <O`]ZR c\R AOcRS c\bS` RS\ 7`OQYawQVbWUS\$ RS\YS WQV$ OZa aWS SW\S U`w\S 6ZSQVR]aS VS`d]`V]Zb$ W\ RS` aWS WV`S DTSWTS\$ ?`ObhS` c\R :ScS`hScUS OcTPSeOV`b& =QV \SV[S [SW\S HwbS VS`Oca$ c\R OP USVbya [Wb F]aWS c\R [W`2 DTSWTS\ ascPS`\$ d]ZZ^OQYS\$ O\Y\OZZS\& ASW\S HwbS Wab POZR ZSS`$ c\R WQV T`OUS aWS$ ]P WQV SW\S\ [SW\S` 8SOZS` Y][[S\ ZOaaS\ YO\\$ OPS` aWS aOUb$ ZWSPS` \WQVb& KS\\ WQV \]QV `OcQVS\ e]ZZS$ Yv\\S WQV WV` ;SZR USPS\ c\R aWS ew`RS aQV\SZZ eOa PSa]`US\& 6SW WV` Vv`b aWQV ROa UO\h SW\TOQV c\R VO`[Z]a O\& 5Za UW\US Sa c[ 5a^W`W\ Oca RS` \sQVabS\ 8`]US`WS& 5Za] USPS WQV WV` dWS`Vc\RS`b 8]ZZO`$ c\R aWS aQVZc`Tb Oca RS[ NW[[S`& =\heWaQVS\ Wab RWS G]\\S c\bS`USUO\US\$ c\R OPUSaSVS\ d]\ RS` KSWV\OQVbaZWQVbS`YSbbS$ RWS F]aWS wPS` RS[ <S`R Vs\US\ VOb$ aWbhS WQV W[ 8c\YSZ\& GWS PZSWPb wPS` SW\S Gbc\RS eSU$ c\R \OQVRS[ WQV [SW\S DTSWTS "c\R WV`S# OcaUSY`Obhb c\R RWS OZZS`ZSbhbS\ FSabS US`OcQVb VOPS$ [OQVS WQV [W` hc[ S`abS\ AOZ aSWb 6Sb`SbS\ RSa ;SPscRSa ;SRO\YS\$ ROaa SbeOa \WQVb abW[[S\ Yv\\bS& AvUZWQVYSWbS\ bc\ aWQV W[ abWZZS\ 8c\YSZ d]\ F]aWSa GbcPS OcT& <Ob aWS [WQV PSYZOcb4$ wPS`ZSUS WQV$ OPS` RO\\ TsZZb [W` SW\$ ROaa WQV jO W\ WV`S` K]V\c\U PW\& K] a]ZZbS aWS VW\4 =`US\ReO\\ eW`R aWS aQV]\ eWSRS`Y][[S\& JWSZZSWQVb Wab aWS OPS` OcQV PSW[ ?OcTS\ S`eWaQVb e]`RS\ c\R eW`R d]\ SW\S[ YZSW\S\ <SS` D]ZWhWabS\ eWSRS` VWS`VS`USaQVZSWTb& =QV PSY][[S 5\Uab$ ROaa ROa ;O\hS SW\S :OZZS aSW\ Yv\\bS& 8Oaa AO`aVOZZ SW\ JS`RSQYbS` ]RS` SW\ G^WbhSZ Wab& KWS a]\ab Yv\\bS jS[O\R ^`][^b [Wb SW\S` \SbbS\ YZSW\S\ Q`OQYawQVbWUS\ C[O OcTeO`bS\$ eS\\ [SW\S KS\WUYSWb SW\S NcTZcQVb d]` RS` PvaS\ KSZb acQVb4 5PS` F]aWS Wab YSW\ G^WbhSZ& F]aWS VOb c\bS` RS` @WQVbS`YSbbS 7`OQY US`OcQVb c\R [W` WV`S VOZP TS`bWUS\ ?c\abeS`YS UShSWUb& 9W\[OZ PW\ WQV \OVS RO`O\$ hc USVS\$ OPS` RWS 5caaWQVb OcT SW\S TSbbS @ORc\U 7`OQY Wab RO\\ R]QV abs`YS`& 5Za] aQVZWSrS WQV RWS 5cUS\ c\R eO`bS& =QV aQVZOTS$ OZa F]aWS eWSRS`Y][[b& IcV$ VOb ZSWRS` SW\ PWaaQVS\ USROcS`b& KO` \WQVb UO\h

SW\TOQV$ a] dWSZ hc Y`WSUS\& <OPya OPS`& ?O\\ab RWQV T`ScS\& KS` Wab RWSaS` 9\USZ4$ T`OUS WQV [WQV W[ 5cTeOQVS\& F]aWS hw\RSb SW\S ?S`hS O\ c\R PWbbSb c[ [SW\S DTSWTS& GWS ZSUb [W` SW\ \ScSa GWSP SW\$ VO\bWS`b [Wb RS\ DTSWTS\ c\R HwbS\ eWS SW\ 5^]bVSYS` c\R UWPb [W` aQVZWSrZWQV [SW\S [Wb SW\S[ FWSaS\abSW\ d]`\SR`W\ hc`wQY& ?O\\ab Rc OZZSa \OQVV]ZS\$ [SW\b aWS YWQVS`\R$ OZa WQV SW\ ?v\WU`SWQV O\ FOcQV SW\hWSVS c\R RS\YS$ VWS`$ VWS` PSW F]aWS Yv\\bS WQV abS`PS\& F]aWS `SRSb d]\ BSe C`ZSO\a& GWS `SRSb d]\ WV`S` AcbbS`$ RWS AOZS`W\ eO`$ c\R d]\ RS\ UO\hS\ PS`wV[bS\ >Ohh[caWYS`\ c\R ?w\abZS`\$ RWS aWS YO\\bS& =V`S HvQVbS` eO`S\ OZa jc\US AsRQVS\ PSUOPb$ VOPS\ RO\\ OPS` OZZSa aOcaS\ ZOaaS\& GWS eW`R \WS OcTUSPS\$ \WS[OZa$ aOUb aWS c\R RScbSb OcT RWS HwbS\ d]ZZ AObS`WOZ$ ROa aWS W[ @OcT RS` >OV`S USaO[[SZb VOb& AO\ YO\\ \WS eWaaS\$ eOa [OZ USP`OcQVb eW`R$ YWQVS`b aWS& AO\ YO\\ \WS eWaaS\& F]aWS eWSUb VvQVabS\a dWS`hWU ?WZ]& GWS Wab US`ORS [OZ SW\aTw\ThWU U`]r$ c\R WV`S <OO`S$ TOZZa aWS \]QV eSZQVS VOb$ aW\R c\bS` SW\S[ dS`eOaQVS\S\ aWZPS`\S\ ?]^TbcQV dS`abSQYb& =V`S ?c\ab]PjSYbS aW\R OZZSaO[b VOZP PWa R`SWdWS`bSZ TS`bWU& <WS` YZSP WQV \]QV ^OO` DS`ZS\ R`O\$ RO\\ Wab Sa Ucb& 8O P`OcQV WQV \c` \]QV SW\ OZbSa <OO`\Sbh R`wPS`hca^O\\S\& I\R ROa <]Zh O\ RS[ RO [OZ WQV RS[\sQVab OcQV [OZ O\& BWQVba ROd]\ aWSVb \OQV eOa Oca$ OPS` [Wb SW\$ heSW <O\RU`WTTS\ eW`R OZZSa aQVv\& F]aWSa <s\RS hWbbS`\ VSTbWU$ esV`S\R aWS RWS SW\hSZ\S\ PSW\OVaQVv\S\ BWQVbaS O\a @WQVb VsZb& BOQV SW\ ^OO` Gbc\RS\ FOcQVS\ c\R NcVv`S\ "F]aWS T`OUb [WQV \WQVba# eS`RS WQV c\`cVWU& 8Oa NW[[S` Wab hc YZSW\& F]aWS Wab \WS[OZa abWZZ& I\R WQV VOPS SW\S\ YZSW\S\ 6S`U 8`]US\ W\ RS` HOaQVS$ RS` [W` ROa ;STwVZ UWPb$ Sa [Wb RS` KSZb OcT\SV[S\ hc Yv\\S\& =QV ZOaaS F]aWS SW\ ^OO` GbSW\S c\R Vc\RS`b 8]ZZO` RO$ c\R aWS ab`SWQVb [W` hc[ 5PaQVWSR wPS` RWS GbW`\ c\R aOUb2 ?][[ eWSRS`& JS`UWaa F]aWS \WQVb& ?][[ eWSRS`& =QV b`SbS OcT RS\ VSZZ S`ZScQVbSbS\ ;O\U VW\Oca$ TOV`S [Wb RS[ 5cThcU \OQV c\bS\ c\R [SZRS [WQV PSW[ DTv`b\S` OP& 6`c[[d]ZZ [Wb 8`]US\ c\R hWbb`WU$ eSWZ WQV aSWb wPS` SW\S[ HOU \WQVba USUSaaS\ VOPS$ PW\ WQV [W` PSecaab$ eWS YO^cbb WQV jSbhb OcaaSVS\ [caa& B]QV YO^cbbS` OZa O[ A]`US\& KWS a]ZZ WQV [WQV W\ RWSaS[ NcabO\R PZ]r W\ SW\S[ <]bSZ O\[SZRS\$ T`OUS WQV [WQV$ OZa WQV a] ZO\UaO[ c\R a] `cVWU eWS [vUZWQV VW\Oca OcT RWS *+`R Gb`SSb USVS& =\heWaQVS\ Wab Sa 5PS\R& 8WS @ScbS SWZS\ d][ 8W\\S` \OQV <OcaS$ hc`wQY W\a eO`[S @WQVb WV`S` K]V\c\US\$ c[ WV`S ?ObhS\ c\R <c\RS hc TwbbS`\ c\R RS\ 6OPgaWbbS` hc PShOVZS\& 6caaS jOUS\ RWS *+`R Gb`SSb S\bZO\U$ c\R ?O`ObSaQVwZS` a^OhWS`S\ W\ WV`S` ?ZcTb d]` [W` VS`$ RWS G^]`bbOaQVS\ wPS` RS` GQVcZbS`& ASW\ <S`h YZ]^Tb ZOcb$ c\R ROa 6Zcb aQVWSrb [W` eWS Gb`][ Rc`QV RWS 5RS`\& =QV TwVZS [WQV ZSWQVb eWS SW\S KOTTSZ$ c\R [SW\S <]aS PZSWPb \WQVb ]PS\& HSZST]\WS`S\ YO\\ WQV \WQVb$ eSWZ WQV 5\Uab VOPS$ ROaa [O\ [WQV RO\\ eWSRS` OcTa^w`b& =QV VOPS \c` \]QV SbeOa wPS` OQVbbOcaS\R OcT RS[ ?]\b] c\R YO\\ \W`US\Re]VW\ TZwQVbS\$

VOPS \c` \]QV SbeOa wPS` OQVbbOcaS\R OcT RS[ ?]\b] c\R YO\\ \W`US\Re]VW\ TZwQVbS\$ \W`US\Ra PZSWPS\$ \W`US\Ra OcTbOcQVS\$ e] [O\ [WQV YS\\b& 9W\TOQV W\ W`US\RSW\ <]bSZ USVS\ YO\\ WQV \WQVb$ \OQVRS[ heSW [WQV VScbS aQV]\ OPUSeWSaS\ VOPS\$ c\R ROa eO` [SV`S`S HwbS\ 7`OQY T`wVS`$ OZa WQV \]QV ^`saS\bOPZS` eO`& 5\ RS` 9QYS *+`R GbSSb c\R *\R 5dS\cS PW\ WQV VOZP S`T`]`S\& K] a]ZZ WQV VW\4 >SRS FWQVbc\U Wab dS`YSV`b& K]VW\4

;S\Oc VWS`
B]OV c\R WQV aW\R OcT RS[ G^`c\U hc SW\ ^OO` K]QVS\ I`ZOcP W\ 7O[P`WRUS$ AOaaOQVcaSbba& =QV `cTS [SW\S\ :`Sc\R F]PS`b O\$ RSaaS\ @g[^V][ d]` Yc`hS[ W\ FS[WaaW]\ USUO\US\ Wab$ c\R S`Yc\RWUS [WQV$ eWS Sa WV[ USVb& 9` Vv`b aWQV PSabS\a O\& GSW\S GbW[[S Wab SW\ AWf heWaQVS\ H`c[O\ 7O^]bS c\R 7VO`ZSa BSZa]\ FWZSg& 9` eO` a] hWS[ZWQV RS` S`abS @SYb]`$ RS` [WQV W\ [SW\S` 5\TO\UahSWb OZa 5US\b O\US`cTS\ c\R hc[ 9aaS\ SW\USZORS\ VOb& 9` Wab c[ RWS JWS`hWU$ ]TTS\aWQVbZWQV aQVecZ$ V]QVW\bSZZWUS\b c\R c\dS`aQVs[b eWbhWU& BOQV RWSaS[ 9aaS\ VOPS\ eW` c\a OZZS ^OO` HOUS [OZ wPS` RWS 5`PSWb$ US[SW\aO[S 5cb]`S\ c\R JS`ZOUaYZObaQV c\bS`VOZbS\& CTb PSh]U aWQV F]PS`b PS`cTZWQV c\R ZWbS`O`WaQV OcT GOQVS\$ d]\ RS\S\ WQV YSW\S 5V\c\U VObbS$ c\R RO\\ bOb WQV W[[S`$ OZa ewaabS WQV 6SaQVSWR& KS\\ S` ROa US[S`Yb VOb x c\R ROa VOb S` PSabW[[b x$ RO\\ VOb S` Sa Tw` aWQV PSVOZbS\& F]PS`b aOUb [W` O[ HSZST]\$ ROaa S` eSUS\ SbeOa [Wb aSW\S` @c\US \]QV [OZ W\a ?`O\YS\VOca [caa& BWQVba 6Sa]\RS`Sa$ [SW\b S`$ YSW\S G]`US& =QV abcbhS SW\S\ A][S\b$ c\R OZa WQV \OQVVOYS$ PSaQVeWQVbWUb S` [WQV eWSRS`$ Sa aSW \WQVba ROPSW$ `SW\S F]cbW\S& KW` TOV`S\ \OQV 7O[P`WRUS& B]OV c\R WQV ZSaS\$ aQVOcS\ :WZ[S W[ 6`ObbZS$ b`W\YS\ YO\\S\eSWaS ?OTTSS c\R aSVS\ c\a <O`dO`R [Wb RS\ b]ZZS\ <scaS`\ `W\Ua c[ RWS I\WdS`aWbsb O\& KWS eW` ROa W[[S` bc\& 9W\Sa A]`US\a `cTb RO\\ SW\ ?]ZZSUS d]\ F]PS`b O\ c\R aOUb$ F]PS`b aSW b]b$ W[ ?`O\YS\VOca VOPS aWQV VS`OcaUSabSZZb$ ROaa S` SW\S @c\US\S\bhw\Rc\U VObbS& =QV VObbS F]PS`b aSWb dWS` ]RS` Tw\T >OV`S\ USYO\\b$ WV\ OZZS heSW$ R`SW A]\ObS USaSVS\ c\R [WQV `SUSZ[srWU [Wb WV[ O[ HSZST]\ c\bS`VOZbS\$ OPS` WQV YO\\ \WQVb aOUS\$ eW` VsbbS\ c\a \OVSUSabO\RS\& 9` USVv`bS hc [SW\S` 5`PSWbaeSZb$ eO` S\baQVWSRS\ SW\ @WQVbPZWQY RO`W\& GSW\ ?O[^T [Wb RS[ @g[^V][ UW\U$ a] dWSZ WQV eSWr$ wPS` SW\WUS >OV`S& BsVS`Sa VOb S` hc[W\RSab [W` \WS RO`wPS` S`hsVZb& 9W\S NSWbZO\U \OV[ WV\ RWS 6SVO\RZc\U aSV` [Wb$ a] ROaa S` aWQV [SV`S`S A]\ObS Y`O\Y aQV`SWPS\ ZWSr$ R]QV RWS FS[WaaW]\ UOP <]TT\c\U& 9` TZ]U \OQV 9c`]^O$ c[ W\ RWS C^S` hc USVS\$ c\R abw`hbS aWQV eWSRS` W\ RWS JS`ZOUaO`PSWb& Nc`wQY W\a \]`[OZS @SPS\& =QV ZSUS OcT$ c\R \OQV SW\ ^OO` 5cUS\PZWQYS\ RS` G^`OQVZ]aWUYSWb TO\US WQV O\ hc aQVZcQVhS\& =QV eSW\S bOUSZO\U c\R YO\\ \WQVb OcTVv`S\& 6SW[ 9aaS\$ PSW G^OhWS`Us\US\ c[ 7O[P`WRUS$ c\bS` RS` 8caQVS$ W[ :Wb\Saa 7S\bS`& =QV eSW\S VS[[c\UaZ]a& G] VOPS WQV hcZSbhb d]` R`SW ]RS` dWS` A]\ObS\ W[ ?`O\YS\VOca PSW [SW\S` AcbbS` USeSW\b& GQVZWSrZWQV dS`aWSUS\ RWS H`s\S\$ OPS` ROa 6SecaabaSW\$ ROaa WQV F]PS`b \WS eWSRS` aSVS\ ]RS` Vv`S\

dS`aWSUS\ RWS H`s\S\$ OPS` ROa 6SecaabaSW\$ ROaa WQV F]PS`b \WS eWSRS` aSVS\ ]RS` Vv`S\ eS`RS$ aSbhb aWQV bWST W\ [W` TSab c\R USVb \WQVb eSU& KW` Y][[S\ O[ @OP]`%8Og%K]QVS\S\RS \OQV BSe M]`Y hc`wQY& 5[ )(& GS^bS[PS` a]ZZ W[ I\WdS`aWbg 7ZcP SW\ ;SRS\YU]bbSaRWS\ab Tw` F]PS`b abObbTW\RS\& 5[ 1& Y][[b SW\ 5cb]` Oca 7VWQOU]$ RS\ WQV dS`b`SbS$ RSaVOZP \OQV BSe M]`Y& F]PS`b VOb aSW\S\ F][O\ ZSYb]`WS`b c\R US^`WSaS\$ RS` RS[\sQVab S`aQVSW\S\ a]ZZ& KW` PSacQVS\ RS\ ;SRS\YU]bbSaRWS\ab$ c\R F]PS`ba 5cb]`S\ S`hsVZS\ c\a$ eWS VS`d]``OUS\R S` WV`S 5`PSWbS\ ZSYb]`WS`b VOb& KWS S` aWQV c[ aWS USYw[[S`b VOb& KWS ZcabWU Sa [Wb WV[ eO`& 6SW WV`S\ K]`bS\ TwVZS WQV [WQV SW\aO[$ OZZSW\& KW` USVS\ W\a @yOQOj]c$ c\R WQV TO\US a]T]`b O\ hc b`W\YS\& 9W\ ;ZOa \OQV RS[ O\RS`S\ aQVwbbS WQV eWS KOaaS` VW\c\bS`$ c\R [W` Y`WPPSZb ROa ;SaWQVb d]\ hc dWSZ 5ZY]V]Z W[ 6Zcb& =QV S\baQVcZRWUS [WQV$ USVS hc` H]WZSbbS c\R `cTS >cZW] O\$ S` a]ZZ aSW\S\ 8SOZS` O\`cTS\ c\R WV[ aOUS\$ ROaa WQV UZSWQV [Wb ?]VZS d]`PSWY][[S& BOQVRS[ WQV RO\\ RWS FSQV\c\U PShOVZb VOPS$ dS`OPaQVWSRS WQV [WQV$ \SV[S [W` SW\ HOfW$ `S\\S W\ >cZW]a 5^O`b[S\bVOca c\R `SUS [WQV RO`wPS` OcT$ eWS US[sQVZWQV aWQV RS` 5cThcU aSW\S[ Gb]QYeS`Y \sVS`b& 8WSaS BOQVb dS`USVb PZWbhaQV\SZZ& =QV Y][[S W`US\ReO\\ d]` OQVb \OQV <OcaS$ OPS` S`ab$ \OQVRS[ B]OV aQV]\ eSU Wab& 5cT RS[ H`SaS\ ZWSUb YSW\ NSbbSZ& 8c\YSZ S`W\\S`S WQV [WQV$ ROaa SW\ OcaZs\RWaQVS` JS`ZSUS` x 8ScbaQVZO\R4 <]ZZO\R4 =QV eSWr \WQVb [SV` x aWQV O\USYw\RWUb VOb& =QV RcaQVS$ hWSVS [WQV O\ c\R USVS RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS S\bZO\U hc` 5US\bc`& AW` P`c[[b RS` GQVsRSZ d][ dWSZS\ K]RYO W\ RS` BOQVb$ c\R RS` <W[[SZ S`ab`OVZb W\ RS[ c\USevV\ZWQVabS\ e]ZYS\Z]aS\ 6ZOc$ ROa WQV jS USaSVS\ VOPS& CPS`VOZP RS` ),bV Gb`SSb aSVS WQV SW\S\ jc\US\ @SYb]`$ RS\ WQV YS\\S$ W\ aQV\SSeSWrS[ <S[R wPS` RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS ZOcTS\& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ eO`c[ S` Sa a] SWZWU VOb& 5Za WQV W\ RWS 5US\bc` Y][[S$ aW\R OZZS RO& ;S\Oc W\ RS[ A][S\b `cTb SW\ :`Sc\R O\ c\R aOUb$ ROa K]`ZR H`ORS 7S\bS` aSW O\USU`WTTS\ e]`RS\& :Oab a]T]`b P`WQVb <gabS`WS Oca W[ 6w`]$ W\ RS\ O\RS`S\ 6w`]a OcT c\aS`S` 9bOUS$ HSZST]\S aQV`WZZS\$ c\R OcT SW\S[ 6WZR OcT 7BB&Q][ aWSVb [O\$ eWS FOcQV Oca SW\S[ RS` NeWZZW\Uabw`[S _cWZZb& 8WS AOZZ d]\ KOaVW\Ub]\ W\ :ZO[[S\$ ?O[^TTZWSUS` wPS` RS` GbORb$ ROa DS\bOU]\ W\ RWS @cTb USjOUb x RWS ;S`wQVbS SaYOZWS`S\$ 7VO]a c\R 5\Uab U`SWTS\ c[ aWQV& B]OV `cTb O\& 9` eSW\b& 9` T`OUb$ ]P Sa [W` Ucb USVb$ dS`ZWS`b YSW\ K]`b wPS` RWS BOQVb hcd]` c\R aOUb$ ROaa S` d][ :S\abS` aSW\Sa 6w`]a W\ G]<] OcT RWS NeWZZW\Uabw`[S aQVOcb& KW` dS`OP`SRS\ c\a Tw` a^sbS` W\ RS` K]V\c\U& DZvbhZWQV TsZZb [W` eWSRS` SW\$ ROaa WQV YSW\S\ JS`ZSUS` S`eO`bS$ a]\RS`\ SW\S\ HS`[W\ PSW GSbV$ [SW\S[ :`WaSc`$ VOPS& =QV `cTS O\$ c[ hc aSVS\$ ]P S` USvTT\Sb VOb& 9` aOUb$ WQV a]ZZ d]`PSWY][[S\& ASW\S <OO`S aW\R ab`c^^WU$ c\R WQV UZOcPS$ O\ [SW\S\ PZcbc\bS`ZOcTS\S\ 5cUS\ c\R RS` YsaWUS\ <Ocb aWSVb [O\ RScbZWQVS` OZa a]\ab$ ROaa WQV RWS BOQVb Rc`QVUS[OQVb VOPS& AW` RWS <OO`S eOaQVS\ c\R aQV\SWRS\ hc ZOaaS\ YO\\ \WQVb aQVORS\$ RS\YS WQV$ aQV\O^^S [W` [SW\S 6`WSTbOaQVS c\R USVS hc` Hw`& ASW\S 5aaWabS\bW\ T`OUb$ e]

RS\YS WQV$ aQV\O^^S [W` [SW\S 6`WSTbOaQVS c\R USVS hc` Hw`& ASW\S 5aaWabS\bW\ T`OUb$ e] WQV VW\ eWZZ$ c\R OZa WQV aOUS2 Nc[ :`WaSc`$ abO``b aWS [WQV a^`OQVZ]a O\& 5Za WQV wPS` RWS *-bV Gb`SSb \OQV KSabS\ USVS$ TZWSUb SW\ >Sb a] bWST wPS` RS` GbORb VW\$ ROaa RWS ;SPscRS c[ [WQV VS`c[ PSPS\ c\R WQV [WQV [Wb RS\ <s\RS\ wPS`[ ?]^T OcT RS[ ;SVabSWU RcQYS& 8Oa aW\R RWS SW\hWUS\ GSYc\RS\ RWSaSa HOUSa$ W\ RS\S\ WQV \WQVb eWS PSbscPb PW\& 5ZZSa O\RS`S Wab ac``SOZ c\R eSWb eSU$ OZa ]P WQV Sa OcT SW\S[ 6WZRaQVW`[ ]RS` Rc`QV SW\S RWQYS @W\aS aSVS& 6SWRS Hw`[S abSVS\ \]QV$ OZa WQV hc` GWfbV 5dS\cS Y][[S& =QV PZSWPS SW\S\ A][S\b RO$ SVS WQV wPS` RWS **\R Gb`SSb hc GSbV USVS& 8WS @ScbS aW\R abWZZ& 5ZZS PSeSUS\ aWQV ZO\UaO[ c\R d]`aWQVbWU& GWS USVS\ PSVcbaO[ [WbSW\O\RS` c[& 6SW GSbV Wab Sa ZSS`$ c\R eW` Vv`S\ FORW]$ esV`S\R S` [W` RWS <OO`S esaQVb c\R O\aQVZWSrS\R aQV\SWRSb& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P S` [S`Yb$ eWS `c\bS`USY][[S\ WQV PW\$ eWS TS`bWU d]\ RS` Rc`QVeOQVbS\ BOQVb& GbObb eWS a]\ab hc b`ObaQVS\ c\R hc ^ZOcRS`\$ c\bS`VOZbS\ eW` c\a YOc[ c\R aW\R abWZZ$ OZa RS` 6S`WQVb wPS` RS\ 9W\abc`h RSa S`abS\ Hc`[a Oca RS[ FORW] Y][[b& GSbVa HSZST]\ YZW\USZb$ OPS` S` Zsaab Sa ZscbS\$ PWa aWQV RS` 5\`cTPSO\be]`bS` SW\aQVOZbSb& qPS` SW\S Gbc\RS P`OcQVb S`$ c[ [W` RWS <OO`S hc aQV\SWRS\$ c\R WQV UZOcPS$ RWS NSWb \W[[b S` aWQV$ eSWZ S` \WQVb OZZSW\ aSW\ [vQVbS& =QV PW\ T`]V$ PSW WV[ hc aSW\$ W\ GWQVS`VSWb& =QV USVS d]\ GSbV hc`wQY hc` 9QYS GWfbV 5dS\cS$ e] Sa d]\ AS\aQVS\ eW[[SZb$ RWS OZZS \OQV GwRS\ aQVOcS\& =`US\RSbeOa Wab \WQVb$ eWS Sa aSW\ a]ZZ$ c\R [W` eW`R SW\S\ A][S\b aQVeW\RZWU$ OZa WQV WV`S\ 6ZWQYS\ T]ZUS c\R RWS jSbhb \WQVbaaOUS\RS 5\aO[[Zc\U d]\ ;SPscRS\ W[ NS\b`c[ aSVS& 8WS Hw`[S aW\R SW\USabw`hb& J]` SW\S` Gbc\RS abO\RS\ aWS \]QV RO$ W\ :ZO[[S\ c\R FOcQV USVwZZb$ jSbhb aW\R aWS eSU& ;S\Oc RO eO`S\ aWS$ aOUb jS[O\R$ OZa WQV wPS`ZSUS$ O\ eSZQVS` GbSZZS RS` GYgZW\S aWS OcTUS`OUb aW\R& 5PS` W\ RS` K]ZYS Oca Fcr c\R FOcQV wPS` RS[ ;SPscRS%9W\S`ZSW$ ROa hc jSRS` PSZWSPWUS\ ;`]rabORb USVv`S\ Yv\\bS$ YO\\ WQV \WQVb Oca[OQVS\$ e] aWS USabO\RS\ VOPS\$ eWS ROa OZZSa SW\[OZ OcaUSaSVS\ VOb& =QV VOPS Sa PS`SWba dS`USaaS\&

K]
KS\\ B]OV eSU Wab2 hc <OcaS& KS\\ B]OV hc <OcaS Wab2 6SW AO`Y ]RS` >cZW] ]RS` SW\S[ WV`S` GObSZZWbS\& <]bSZa& KS\\ c\bS`eSUa2 <W\bS\ W[ HOfW3 ?Z] W\ RS` @]PPg d]\ C\S :WTbV3 H`S^^S\OPaObh heWaQVS\ dWS`bS[ c\R Tw\TbS[ Gb]QY W\ C\S :WTbV3 JWRS]YOPW\S W[ D]`\]ZORS\ OcT RS` ),bV heWaQVS\ .bV c\R /bV 5dS\cS c\R W\ RS[ heWaQVS\ ,,bV c\R 0bV$ O[ C`a]3 ?Z] W[ @yOQOj]c3 ?Z] W[ JWaW]\7O`S O\ RS` -bV 5dS\cS3 ?Z] W[ AQ8]\OZRya O\ RS` /bV$ c\bS`VOZP ),bV Gb`SSb3 GQV`SWPbWaQV W\ [SW\S[ 6w`]3 ?Z] \SPS\ [SW\S[ 6w`]3 H`S^^S\VOca W[ 6w`]PZ]QY3 W[ 7S\b`OZ DO`Y VW\bS` 6sc[S\ c\R W\ RS` H]WZSbbS O[ 8SZOQ]`bS HVSOb`S3 ;SPwaQV O[ KSabaWRS <WUVeOg3 W\ ?SZZS`USaQV]aaS\ d]\ F]VPOcbS\3 VW\bS` AwZZQ]\bOW\S`\ ]RS` OcQV W[ 7]\bOW\S`$ eS\\ Sa \WQVb O\RS`a USVb& =\ @]\R]\2 7VO`Z]bbS Gb`SSb <]bSZ$ VW\bS\ W\ AWSbeOUS\ "YSW\S 6ZOQY 7OPa#$ VW\bS` RS\ <SQYS\ ]PS\ W\ <WUVPc`g :WSZRa& =\ DO`Wa2 5cT 6O\Y O[ DZOQS RSa J]aUSa$ 6Sbb W[ 6]`RSZZ3 VW\bS\ W\ SW\S[ HOfW$ RSaaS\ :OV`S` SW\ ;`ObWa^sQYQVS\ <OaQV `wPS``SWQVb3 W[ H`S^^S\VOca SW\Sa K]V\PZ]QYa3 OcT RS[ ?Z] SbZWQVS` 6O`a c\R 7OTta& AS`YS2 I\bS`eSUa RWS DTSWTS OPYwVZS\ ZOaaS\$ PSd]` Rc aWS W\ RWS HOaQVS abSQYab$ a]\ab UZwVb aWS RWS <]aS Rc`QV&

8Oa >SacajOV`
8WSa Wab ROa >OV` [Wb RS\ [SWabS\ OcrS` <Oca dS`P`OQVbS\ BsQVbS\& 8S\ [SWabS\ NSbbSZ\ OcT RS[ H`SaS\ W\ c\aS`S` K]V\c\U$ RS\ [SWabS\ hS``wbbSbS\ J]`[WbbOUS\$ RS\ [SWabS\ USP`]QVS\S\ JS`a^`SQVS\$ PSW[ 8W\\S` \c` heSW K]RYO hc b`W\YS\$ RS\ [SWabS\ wPS` 6]`R USe]`TS\S\ J]`asbhS\ eWS RS[$ FWQ]$ <O^^g$ AO`Q$ >cZW] ]RS` eS` a]\ab [W` ROa FOcQVS\ S`[vUZWQVb$ \WQVb [SV` O\hc`cTS\$ RS\ [SWabS\ 6W\%ZSWRS`%Y`O\Y%5\`cTS\ PSW [SW\S` 5aaWabS\bW\$ RS\ [SWabS\ @wUS\& 9a Wab ROa R`WbbS >OV` \OQV RS` C^S`ObW]\ [SW\S` AcbbS`$ ROa heSWbS$ \OQVRS[ aWS [Wb RS` 7VS[] OcTUSVv`b VOb$ ROa >OV`$ W\ RS[ B]OV aSW\S\ :WZ[ W\ AS[^VWa R`SVb& 8WS 5US\bc` ZscTb Ucb& KW` [OQVS\ ;SeW\\$ SW\S FSWVS 6wQVS`$ RWS WQV dS`YOcTS$ b`SWPS\ \WQVb \c` RWS JS`ZOUS W\ SW\S\ VSTbWUS\ 6WSbS`YO[^T$ a]\RS`\ eS`RS\ OcahcUaeSWaS W\ 6ZsbbS`\ eWS RS[ BSe M]`YS` OPUSR`cQYb$ wPS`OZZ Ucb PSa^`]QVS\$ SW\a a]UO` OcT RS` HWbSZaSWbS RS` BSe M]`Y HW[Sa 6]]Y FSdWSe& I\R SW\ HWbSZ$ RS` [W` PSa]\RS`a ZWSP Wab$ SW\ OcUS\heW\YS`\RSa Kc\RS` O\ 7VO`[S c\R 7Vch^S$ Y][[b W\ RWS 9\ROcaeOVZ Tw` RS\ BObW]\OZ 6]]Y 5eO`R& J]` RS` B][W\WS`c\U$ d]` RS[ 9`aQVSW\S\$ UWPb Sa SW\S\ @c\QV W[ @O ;`S\]cWZZS$ SW\S[ PS`wV[bS\ T`O\hvaWaQVS\ FSabOc`O\b W\ RS\ 9Oab -(a& =QV ZORS SW\S 6SYO\\bS$ SW\S 6SW\OVT`Sc\RW\ \O[S\a >SO\$ ROhc SW\& >SO\$ RWS \WS[OZa [WbbOUSaaS\ USVb& >SO\$ RWS WQV [Wb Tw\Tc\RheO\hWU W\ RS` @]PPg RSa <]bSZa :`O\YTc`bS` <]T YS\\S\USZS`\b VOPS c\R RWS [WQV aSWb >OV`S\ hc 6wQVS`^O`bga c\R O\RS`S\ H`STTS\ W\ WV`S[ DS\bV]caS [Wb 8OQVbS``OaaS c\R 6ZWQY OcT RS\ 9Oab FWdS` SW\ZsRb& >SO\a DO`bga aW\R W[[S` ZcabWU$ eSWZ aWQV R]`b aQVZOUS\RS` 9`T]ZU$ FcV[$ FSWQVbc[$ ^]ZWbWaQVSa 9\UOUS[S\b c\R OcaUS[OQVb GQV`sUSa RWS <O\R `SWQVS\& AOZ aW\R Sa 5PS\RSaaS\ W[ YZSW\S\ ?`SWa$ [OZ U`]rS 6S\STWhSaaS\& 5PS` OZZ RWS >OV`S Wab W[[S` DZObh Tw` [WQV& I\R W[[S` aQVSW\b Sa [W` ROa ZSbhbS AOZ hc aSW\& >SRSa AOZ VOPS WQV ROa ;STwVZ$ Sa Wab a]eSWb$ jSbhb eS`RS WQV SbeOa aOUS\$ ROa WV` jSRS =ZZcaW]\ wPS` [WQV \W[[b c\R WV` hSWUb$ eOa Tw` SW\ VW`\Z]aS` 6ZS\RS` WQV PW\& 5Za] ZORS WQV >SO\ hc RS[ @c\QV W[ @O ;`S\]cWZZS SW\& =QV ZORS aWS SW\$ eSWZ WV` 6cQV wPS` RS\ TOPSZVOTb abSW\WUS\ 5cTabWSU c\R :OZZ SW\S` K5GD%D`W\hSaaW\ SW\ @WSPZW\UaPcQV RS` 5cb]`W\ d][ 5cUS\heW\YS`\RS\ Kc\RS` Wab& =QV ZORS aWS eSUS\ WV`Sa ZWbS`O`WaQVS\ ;ZO[]c`a SW\$ eSWZ aWS RS` 5cb]`W\ eWQVbWU c\R OcrS`RS[ OcQV [Wb WV`S[ ZSUS\Rs`S\ @SYb]` PST`Sc\RSb Wab& 5ca OZZ RWSaS\ ;`w\RS\ c\R eSWZ aWS [WQV aQV]\ a] ]Tb SW\USZORS\ VOb c\R WQV [WQV$ eS\\ aWS RO Wab$ USZWSPb TwVZS$ a] aSZbaO[ c\R c\eOV`aQVSW\ZWQV aWQV ROa \c\ OcQV eWSRS` O\Vv`b$ PWbbS WQV aWS hc Y][[S\& I\UZOcPZWQVS`eSWaS aOUb aWS hc$ c\R WQV T`ScS [WQV OcT RS\ PSa]\RS`S\ 9\S`UWSaQVcP$ RS\ aWS RS` JS`O\abOZbc\U P`W\US\ eW`R$

T`ScS [WQV OcT RS\ PSa]\RS`S\ 9\S`UWSaQVcP$ RS\ aWS RS` JS`O\abOZbc\U P`W\US\ eW`R$ aQVZWSrZWQV USVb Sa PSW a]ZQVS\ 9aaS\ SW\hWU c\R OZZSW\ RO`c[$ \ScS @ScQVbS\ RS` @WbS`Obc` [vUZWQVab eSWb VW\Oca W\ RWS I[ZOcTPOV\ hc PSTv`RS`\& A]\ObSZO\U eW`R RWSaS` @c\QV US^ZO\b& 9W\ U`]rhwUWUS` :`Sc\R RS` 5cb]`W\ VOb aWQV PS`SWbS`YZs`b$ RWS ?]abS\ hc b`OUS\$ c\R RO\Y RS` d]`\SV[S\ 5R`SaaS$ RS` 6ShWSVc\US\ RSa ZSUS\Rs`S\ @SYb]`a c\R RS` S\UOUWS`bS\ 6S[wVc\US\ OcT OZZS\ GSWbS\ Y][[b SW\ c\US[SW\ S`ZSaS\Sa 5cTUSP]b O\ @WbS`Obc`U`vrS\ hcaO[[S\& KWSa] aQVW[[S`b [O\QVSa [s`QVS\VOTb O[ <]`Wh]\b OcT c\R O\RS`Sa \WQVb4 8WSaS` @c\QV$ aSWb A]\ObS\ W[ HS`[W\YOZS\RS`$ Tc\YSZb [WQV W\ PZOcS` HW\bS jSRSa AOZ O\$ eS\\ WQV RWS GSWbS OcTaQVZOUS$ c[ ZW\Ya ]RS` `SQVba \]QV SbeOa SW\hcb`OUS\& 8Oa 6Zcb abSWUb [W` W\ RS\ ?]^T$ eS\\ W`US\RSbeOa W[ NcaO[[S\VO\U RO[Wb [W` W\ RS\ GW\\ ]RS` OcT RS\ GQV`SWPbWaQV Y][[b$ RS\\ ROa 6cQV$ >SO\$ @O ;`S\]cWZZS c\R RS` ZSUS\Rs`S @SYb]` PWZRS\ hcaO[[S\US\][[S\ SW\S ZScQVbS\RS JS`VSWrc\U d]\ ;ZwQY& =QV P`OcQVS SW\S\ 5\hcU$ c\R W\ SW\S[ 5\TOZZ d]\ @SWQVbaW\\ USVS WQV hc GOYa c\R YOcTS [W` SW\S\ aQVZO\YS\$ ZSWQVb aQVeO`hPZOc USab`SWTbS\ 5\hcU d]\ ;cQQW Tw` wPS` + ((( 8]ZZO`& B]QV \WS VOPS WQV a] dWSZ ;SZR Tw` SW\ ?ZSWRc\UaabwQY OcaUSUSPS\& =\ RS` ?OPW\S aSVS WQV SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U RO`W\ Oca eWS SW\ :`S[RS`& >S[O\R$ RS` hWU 5\hwUS PSaWbhb$ hWU ROhc ^OaaS\RS DOO` GQVcVS c\R ;SZR US\cU$ c[ aWQV ROa OZZSa ZSWabS\ hc Yv\\S\& KS\\ [O\ aWQV W[ G^WSUSZ \WQVb S`YS\\b$ Wab ROa a]$ OZa ]P [O\ SW\ :]b] d]\ aWQV aWSVb$ ROa jS[O\R OcT SW\S` DO`bg OcTUS\][[S\ VOb$ c\R SWTS`awQVbWU OcT RWSaS\ c\USVS[[bS\$ Obb`OYbWdS\$ wPS`OZZ VW\^OaaS\RS\ AS\aQVS\ aQVWSZb$ RS` c\S``SWQVPO` eSWb d]\ SW\S[ aSZPab S\bTS`\b Wab3 [O\ aWSVb RWSaS\ <W[[SZVc\R$ RS\Yb aWQV$ ROaa S` W\ aSW\S[ @SPS\ \]QV \WQVb SW\S GSYc\RS dS`ZSUS\$ c\aWQVS`$ c\USZWSPb eO` c\R dS`OPaQVScb aSW\S @]QYS`VSWb d]\ <S`hS\& I\R RO\\ abSZZab Rc TSab$ Rc PWab Sa aSZPS`& I\[vUZWQV$ ROa YO\\ R]QV \WQVb aSW\& KS\\ Rc OPS` aWSVab$ ROaa S` RSW\S GOQVS\ O\VOb c\R ROaa S`$ <S``U]bb jO$ ROaaSZPS U`]rS OPabSVS\RS c\R ROaaSZPS YZSW\S O\ZWSUS\RS CV` VOb$ eS\\ Rc OZa] aWSVab$ ROaa Rc Sa PWab$ T`OUab Rc RWQV S`ab [OZ2 ?O\\ Sa aSW\$ ROaa O\RS`S US\Oca] OcT RWSaSa 8c$ ROa Rc \WQVb PWab$ VS`SW\TOZZS\4 8Oa S`aQVwbbS`b RWQV SW\S\ A][S\b$ c\R Rc Y][[ab hc RS[ GQVZcaa$ ROaa RS` AS\aQV OcT RS[ :]b] W[ ;`c\RS R]QV SW\ O\RS`S` Wab& CRS` dWSZ[SV`$ ROaa Sa WV\ \WQVb UWPb& 8WS :]b]O\aWQVb c\R RWS @wUS$ RWS aWS VS`d]`P`W\Ub$ aW\R eWS RS` 5\hcU& KS\\ Rc OZa] W\ SW\S` I[YZSWRSYOPW\S abSVab$ W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ aQVOcab c\R jS[O\RS\ S`PZWQYab$ RS` OcaaWSVb eWS RS` AS\aQV OcT RS[ :]b]$ YOcTab Rc RS\ 5\hcU$ RS\\ eS\\ Sa RWSaS\ AS\aQVS\ aQV]\ \WQVb eW`YZWQV UWPb$ Zsaab aWQV R]QV eS\WUabS\a a] bc\$ OZa UsPS Sa WV\& NeSW 5PS\RS d]` RS[ @c\QV PW\ WQV PSW SW\S[ 5PS\RSaaS\& =QV eSWr \WQVb [SV`$ Oca eSZQVS[ 5\ZOaa c\R [Wb eS[$ OPS` SW\WUSa Wab aWQVS`& =QV PW\ W[ @yOQOj]c& =QV b`W\YS K]RYO& 8WS ?SZZ\S` c\R ?SZZ\S`W\\S\ aQVS\YS\ [W` RS\ UO\hS\ 5PS\R \OQV& AWQV S`TwZZb SW\S O\US\SV[S FcVS$ RWS [Wb jSRS[ ;ZOa hc\W[[b$ c\R ROa ?]\hS`b RS` wPZWQVS\ G]`US\ dS`abc[[b OZZ[sVZWQV& BOQV SW\S` Yc`hS\ DVOaS RS` GbWZZS abSWUS\ RO\\ O\RS`S ?Zs\US Oca

dS`abc[[b OZZ[sVZWQV& BOQV SW\S` Yc`hS\ DVOaS RS` GbWZZS abSWUS\ RO\\ O\RS`S ?Zs\US Oca RS` HWSTS OcT& 6SeSUbS Gb`SWQVS`& @OcbS <v`\S`& 8WS SZS\RS$ \OUS\RS ;WS`$ RWS aWQV OZa 6SRw`T\Wa OcTTwV`b& KsV`S\R WQV `SRS$ hcVv`S$ SaaS c\R ZOQVS$ aQVeS\YS WQV RS\ HOYbab]QY$ PSTSVZS RS\ =\ab`c[S\bS\ hc aQVeSWUS\& 8O WQV ROPSW jSR]QV eSWbS`b`W\YS$ aQVeWZZb RWS AcaWY eWSRS` O\$ eW`R R`s\US\RS`$ c\R WQV S\baQVcZRWUS [WQV$ USVS hc` H]WZSbbS c\R esVZS SW\S Bc[[S`& 8WS d]\ AO`Y RWSa[OZ$ c\R WQV [OQVS [Wb WV[ Oca$ ROaa WQV \OQV RS[ 9aaS\ hc WV[ Y][[S& 9W\S\ A][S\b ZO\U VOPS WQV 6SRS\YS\$ eSWZ W\ heSW HOUS\ RS` @c\QV Tw` RWS 5cb]`W\ RSa 5cUS\heW\YS`\RS\ Kc\RS`a Wab c\R WQV ROTw` W\ H]^T]`[ aSW\ [caa& 5PS` Sa aW\R heSW d]ZZS HOUS$ aOUS WQV [W`& GSZPab eS\\ WQV RWS BOQVb U`vrbS\bSWZa Rc`QV[OQVS$ PZSWPS\ [W` \]QV dWS`c\RheO\hWU Gbc\RS\$ c[ eWSRS` :cr hc TOaaS\& =QV USVS hc AO`Y$ c\R Sa T]ZUb SW\ HO\h Oca FOcQV c\R <Ocb c\R O\RS`S\ @ScbS\$ c\R O[ A]`US\ eWZZ WQV RO\\ \WQVb$ ROaa Sa OcTVv`b& 8S` @c\QV TW\RSb heO` O[ \sQVabS\ HOU abObb$ OPS` ROa Y][[b [W` W[[S` \]QV eSWb eSU d]`& 9W\ UO\hS` HOU$ SW\S BOQVb c\R SW\ A]`US\ \]QV& 9a eW`R aQV]\ YZO^^S\& 9a YZO^^b R]QV W[[S`& Bc` ROaa RWSaS BOQVb RWS S`abS Wab$ RWS heSW aSW\ [vQVbS& KO`c[ aWS c\R \WQVb RWS O\RS`S\4 =QV aSVS [W` RS\ HS`[W\YOZS\RS` d]\ RO[OZa O\$ c\R S` Wab [Wb HW\bS\U`OTTWbW wPS`asb& H`STTS\ hc[ AWbbOUSaaS\$ hc[ ?OTTSS$ HSZST]\bS`[W\S$ H`W\YbS`[W\S$ H`W^a \OQV @]\R]\$ @5$ :`O\YTc`b& <]QVhSWbS\$ ;SPc`babOUS$ 6S\STWhS$ HVSObS`$ C^S`$ 6wQVS`^O`bga$ :WZ[d]`TwV`c\US\& G] dWSZSa$ e] [O\ VW\ [caabS$ aWQV bO`\S\ [caabS$ a] dWSZ Gb`Saa& BWS eS`RS WQV a] W\ 5\a^`cQV US\][[S\ eWS W\ jS\S[ >OV`$ heWaQVS\ [SW\S[ heSWc\RR`SWrWUabS\ c\R R`SWc\RR`SWrWUabS\ ;SPc`babOU& 8S[ a]\\S\abWQVWUS\ GbO`b W\a >SacajOV`& =`US\RjS[O\R x AO`WS4 x [SW\bS W[ GQVS`h W[[S`$ R`SWc\RR`SWrWU aSW ROa >SacajOV`$ [Wb RS[ SW\ @SPS\ S\RSb c\R SW\ \ScSa PSUW\\b$ [Wb RS[ RWS >cUS\R hc 9\RS USVb c\R [O\ c\PSab`SWbPO` W\a 9`eOQVaS\S\OZbS` SW\b`Wbb& 5PS` OZa aWS R`SWc\RR`SWrWU ec`RS$ eO` WQV dWS`c\RheO\hWU c\R ROa 9`eOQVaS\aSW\ SW\S O\RS`S KSZb& KO`c[ ec`RS\ OcaUS`SQV\Sb Oca RWSaS` BOQVb R`SW4 KO`c[ S[^TO\R WQV OZZSa$ eOa Tw` jSRS\ O\RS`S\ c\R OcQV [WQV aSZPab \OQV PS\SWRS\aeS`b UZwQYZWQVS` :wUc\U OcaaOV$ OZa @Oab4 9a eO` ROa >OV`$ W\ RS[ WQV [wRS ec`RS$ ROa >OV`$ W\ RS[ WQV O\TW\U$ OcThcUSPS\& =\ RS[ RS` HOYbab]QY hS`P`OQV c\R RWS Hv\S Oca RS[ C`QVSabS``Oc[ RS\ 8W`WUS\bS\ \WSRS`eO`TS\ c\R ROa <Oca wPS`TZcbSbS\& =QV USVS USUS\ AWbbOU PSW AO`Y eSU c\R \SV[S [W` SW\ NW[[S` W\ SW\S[ YZSW\S\ <]bSZ W\ RS` BsVS RS` 5US\bc`& 9a Wab SW\ PWZZWUSa H]c`WabS\V]bSZ$ SW\S PSaaS`S 5PabSWUS$ c\R WQV USVS ROVW\$ eSWZ Sa [W` PSW AO`Y hc R`SQYWU$ hc dS`_cOZ[b$ hc VSWYSZ Wab& 8WS TZObbS`WUS DO`O\]WO$ RWS WQV d]\ RS\ [SWabS\ [W` PSYO\\bS\ 7`OQY`OcQVS`\ YS\\S$ VOb [WQV O\ RS\ ZSbhbS\ R`SW ]RS` dWS` 7`OQYOPS\RS\ OcQV S`TOaab& 8WSa[OZ Wab Sa PSa]\RS`a aQVZW[[ c\R VsZb PSa]\RS`a ZO\US O\& 6SW AO`Y abSVS WQV O[ :S\abS` c[ [SW\S NWdWZTOV`hScUS RS` D]ZWhSW d]` aSW\S[ 5^O`b[S\bVOca hc aSVS\& 5[ A]`US\ [caa WQV RO `Oca& =QV VOP FWQ]a

Bc[[S` c\R USVS ROd]\ Oca$ ROaa S` O[ BOQV[WbbOU \Sc ZWSTS`\ YO\\& 8Oa bcb S` OcQV$ c\R WQV PZSWPS RWS UO\hS BOQVb OcT$ OZZSW\ [Wb RS[ ?OPSZTS`\aSVS\ c\R c`OZbS\ aQV[cRRSZWUS\ :]ZUS\ RS` F]PW\ 6g`R GV]e$ W\ RS\S\ c\USZS\YS ;]%U]%6]ga c\R %;W`Za ab`W^^S\ c\R aWQV d]\ F]PW\ ]`OZ PST`WSRWUS\ ZOaaS\& 8O\OQV PZSWPS WQV RWS UO\hS BOQVb PSW RS[ GS\RS`& GWS P`W\US\ 6WZZWUeS`Pc\U Tw` bSc`S 1((S`%Bc[[S`\$ W[[S` \ScS \OQYbS c\R VOZP\OQYbS As\\S` c\R :`OcS\$ RWS [Wb ;S`SRS d]\ eWZRS[ HSZST]\aSf RWS ?O[S`O PShW`hS\& 8Oa <]bSZhW[[S` PZWQYb OcT SW\S S\US ;OaaS$ c\R WQV PScUS [WQV VW\Oca c\R aSVS hc RS\ @WQVbdWS`SQYS\ RS` O\RS`S\ <]bSZhW[[S` V]QV& <W\ c\R eWSRS` VcaQVb RS` GQVObbS\ SW\Sa AO\\Sa ]RS` SW\S` :`Oc wPS` RWS KO\R$ c\R WQV abSZZS [W` bOcaS\R GhS\O`WS\ d]`& AO\QV[OZ VOZZb SW\ ;S`scaQV x SW\ ZSWaS` ?\OZZ$ SW\ USRs[^TbSa ?`ObhS\$ SW\ GQVZOU$ [Wb RS[ SW\ :S\abS` USaQVZ]aaS\ eW`R x Rc`QV RWS ;OaaS$ c\R SW\ ^OO`[OZ `cTS WQV <OZZ]& GQV\SZZ Wab Sa A]`US\$ c\R USUS\ hSV\ eW`R [W` YZO`$ ROaa WQV \OQV <OcaS [caa$ c[ Tw` RS\ @c\QV W[ @O ;`S\]cWZZS [SW\S\ 5\hcU hc V]ZS\& B]OV VOb [W` hWU BOQV`WQVbS\ VW\bS`ZOaaS\$ c\R PWa OcT SW\S\ 5\`cT d]` heSW HOUS\$ c[ WV[ hc aOUS\$ ROaa WQV \]QV ZSPS c\R Sa [W` Ucb USVb$ VOPS WQV [WQV \WQVb PSW WV[ US[SZRSb& J][ 5PS\R hcd]` VOPS WQV \]QV W[[S` SW\S RWQYS HwbS$ eOa [WQV SW\ eS\WU PS`cVWUb$ OZa WQV RS\ PSd]`abSVS\RS\ HOU O\USVS& =QV PcQVS ROa <]bSZhW[[S` \]QV SW\[OZ c\R \SV[S SW\ HOfW hc[ C\S :WTbV$ c[ RS\ 5\hcU hc V]ZS\& 8O B]OV hc[ ;ZwQY \WQVb R]`b Wab$ aQV\O^^S WQV [W` RS\ 5\hcU$ aQVeO`hS GQVcVS c\R G]QYS\$ aQVOTTS [WQV `Oca c\R TOV`S [Wb RS[ HOfW eWSRS` W\a <]bSZ& =\heWaQVS\ Wab Sa hevZT$ c\R ROa 9aaS\ Wab c[ SW\a& =QV YO\\ \WQVb UZOcPS\$ ROaa WQV heSW BsQVbS c\R SW\S\ UO\hS\ HOU R`OcTUSVOcS\ VOPS& B]OV [caa d]` 5\Uab OcrS` aWQV aSW\& 8]QV ]Pe]VZ [W` ROa YZO` Wab$ `cTS WQV WV\ \WQVb O\$ USPS WQV WV[ \WQVb 6SaQVSWR$ ROaa WQV e]VZOcT PW\& ASW\S` 5aaWabS\bW\ VOPS WQV c[ OQVb OcT RWS AOWZP]f USa^`]QVS\$ ROaa WQV RW`SYb hc RS[ @c\QV USVS3 RO[Wb es`S ROa hc[W\RSab S`ZSRWUb& 5PS` RS` @c\QV <S``jSaca$ eWS a]ZZ WQV W\ RWSaS` JS`TOaac\U RO VW\USVS\4 =QV V]QYS [WQV OcTa 6Sbb$ ab]^TS SW\S\ U`]rS\ GbSW\ W\ RWS a^SQYWUS$ dS`P`O\\bS DTSWTS d]\ dS`UO\US\S` BOQVb c\R W\VOZWS`S& ASW\S 5\Uab eSUS\ RSa 9aaS\a$ B]OV$ [SW\S` 5`PSWb c\R OZZS[ O\RS`\ dS`aQVeW\RSb eWS SW\S :ZO[[S$ RWS ^ZvbhZWQV YSW\S\ GOcS`ab]TT [SV` PSY][[b& =QV eWQYZS RWS 6SbbRSQYS c[ [WQV c\R ZOaaS RS\ eO`[S\$ eSWbS\ 6ZWbh Rc`QV [WQV VW\Rc`QVUSVS\& 8S[ ;STwVZ \OQV ZWSUS WQV \c` SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ OcT RS[ 6Sbb$ OPS` OZa WQV [WQV eWSRS` VW\aSbhS$ Wab Sa Tw\T \OQV SW\a& 8S` @c\QV& 8Oa abS`\S\Tc\YSZ\RS 9`SWU\Wa$ RSaaS\ GW`S\S\USaO\U aSWb A]\ObS\ hc Vv`S\ Wab$ VOb PS`SWba PSU]\\S\$ c\R WQV PW\ VW\wPS`$ c\USRcaQVb$ c\`OaWS`b$ Rw`` d][ 7`OQY`OcQVS\ c\R H`W\YS\$ eOa [W` W\ RWS :W\US` Y][[b$ abObb W`US\ReOa hc SaaS\& =QV `OcQVS \]QV SW\S DTSWTS c\R USVS aQV\SZZ c\bS` RWS 8caQVS& 9a Wab TOab heSW$ PWa WQV Oca RS[ <]bSZ c\R W\ SW\ HOfW Y][[S& FOaWS`b$ USRcaQVb$ W[ 5\hcU VOPS WQV W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ USaSVS\ c\R$ ] ;]bb$ [W` SW\US`SRSb$ ROaa WQV Ucb OcaaSVS& 9W\ PWaaQVS\ Rw\\ c\R YZO^^`WU heO`$ OPS` RS` 5\hcU$ \WQVb hc `SRS\ d]\ RS` HwbS$ RS` DTSWTS c\R RS[ :ScS`hScU W\ RS` 6`cabbOaQVS$ USPS\ [W` SW\ eS\WU <]TT\c\U$ ROaa WQV RWS \sQVabS\ Gbc\RS\ Ucb wPS` RWS 6wV\S P`W\US&

6wV\S P`W\US& =QV Y][[S VW\$ USVS aQV\c`ab`OQYa hc` 6O` c\R YW^^S SW\S\ U`]rS\ K]RYO& 8S` @c\QV TW\RSb W\ SW\S[ aS^O`ObS\ G^SWaS`Oc[ W[ S`abS\ Gb]QY abObb$ d]` RS[ SW\S YZSW\S H]WZSbbS Wab& =QV dS`aQVeW\RS W\ RS` dS`U]ZRSbS\ YZSW\S\ ?OPW\S c\R ZORS [W` aQVZSc\WUab RWS DTSWTS& ASW\S <s\RS hWbbS`\$ RO aSWb RS[ ZSbhbS\ <Wb W[ <]bSZ wPS` heO\hWU AW\cbS\ dS`UO\US\ aW\R$ c\R WQV YO\\ YOc[ RWS :ZO[[S `cVWU VOZbS\& =QV W\VOZWS`S c\R VcabS S`ab$ OZa [W` RWS @c\US P`S\\b$ RS\ FOcQV VS`Oca& =QV eOaQVS [W` RWS <s\RS$ a^wZS RS\ Ac\R [Wb GSWTS Oca$ c[ RS\ ;S`cQV hc dS`RSQYS\$ c\R PZOaS OcT RWS DTSWTS$ RO[Wb aWS OPYwVZb$ PSd]` WQV aWS W\ ?Z]^O^WS` eWQYZS c\R eWSRS` W\ RWS 5\hcUbOaQVS abSQYS& 8WS ZO\US HOTSZ W[ GOOZ Wab VwPaQV [Wb 6Zc[S\ c\R USPc\RS\S\ @SaSSfS[^ZO`S\ RSa 6cQVa RSY]`WS`b& CTTS\PO` VOb [O\ US`ORS S`ab DZObh US\][[S\& 8O Sa d]` RS[ 9aaS\ SW\S\ I[b`c\Y UOP$ Wab [SW\S 5PeSaS\VSWb hc[ ;ZwQY eS\WUS` OcTUSTOZZS\$ OZa eS\\ aWQV OZZS c[ Dc\Yb SW\a hc HWaQV USaSbhb VsbbS\& >SO\ abSVb OcT$ OZa aWS [WQV VS`SW\a^OhWS`S\ aWSVb& =QV PW\ US`ORS S`ab O\USY][[S\ 6WbbS S\baQVcZRWUS RWS JS`a^sbc\U $ TZvbSb aWS& >SO\ eSWr OZa] UO` \WQVb$ ROaa WQV [WQV aSZPab dS`a^sbSb VOPS& 5cQV ROa SW\ Kc\RS`& =`US\ReWS c\bS`VOZbS WQV [WQV [Wb RS` 5cb]`W\$ WV`S[ ZSUS\Rs`S\ @SYb]`$ SW\WUS\ O\RS`S\$ aSbhS [WQV \SPS\ >SO\ O\ RS\ HWaQV$ c\R ROa 9aaS\ \W[[b ]V\S [SW\ Ncbc\ aSW\S\ @OcT$ c\R OcQV [SW\S JS`a^sbc\U Zvab O\aQVSW\S\R YSW\S ?]\b`]dS`aS\ Oca& =QV aOUS$ WQV aSW S`YsZbSb$ SW\TOQV O\USaQVZOUS\& :w` >SO\ S`TW\RS WQV D`]PZS[S W\ RS` :O[WZWS$ c[ RWS WQV [WQV VsbbS Yw[[S`\ [waaS\$ c\R aWS hWbbS`b d]` OcT`WQVbWUS[ AWbUSTwVZ& NeSW[OZ S\baQVcZRWUS WQV [WQV esV`S\R RSa 9aaS\a$ c[ O\ RS` 6O` c\bS\ K]RYO hc YW^^S\ c\R OcT RS[ ?Z] hc `OcQVS\& ;SUS\ VOZP dWS` dS`OPaQVWSRS WQV [WQV OZZS`aSWba$ ZOcTS VW\Oca OcT RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS$ c\R OZa WQV SW\S\ AO\\ W\ RS\ 8`SWrWUS`\ aSVS$ RS` :ZcUPZsbbS` dS`bSWZb$ Y][[b [W` SbeOa O\ WV[ PSYO\\b d]`$ c\R WQV T`OUS WV\$ ]P S` 8`]US\ \W[[b& 5cT aSW\ >O VW\ T`OUS WQV2 7`OQY4 9` ab`OVZb [WQV O\ c\R aOUb$ ]RS` dWSZ[SV` ZOQVb2 AO\\][O\\& GSW\S\ BO[S\ dS`USaaS WQV eWSRS`$ OPS` eW` eS`RS\ aQV\SZZ :`Sc\RS& KW` e]ZZS\ [Wb RS[ HOfW hc RS[ <]bSZ W\ RS` *,bV TOV`S\$ TW\RS\ OPS` YSW\a& BSPS\ [W` VsZb SW\ H`O\a^]`bS` eSUS\ RS` 5[^SZ$ c\R WQV T`OUS RS\ Hg^S\ O[ GbScS`$ ]P S` c\a [Wb\SV[S\ YO\\$ e]`OcT S` dS`PZwTTS\RS`eSWaS jO aOUb& ASW\ \ScS` ?c[^SZ x RS` aSW\S :ZcUPZsbbS` W\ SW\S\ AwZZSW[S` USe]`TS\ VOb x$ YWQVS`b VW\bS\ W\ RS[ H`O\a^]`bS`$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U Wab S` ?S\\g W[ KOZR [Wb SW\S` :ZOaQVS GQ]bQV$ AOf$ eWS S` W[ ?wVZ`Oc[ @W\Sa ZSUb$ =O\$ eWS S` RS\ :ScS`ZvaQVS` aQVeS\Yb& =QV YWQVS`S [Wb$ a] T`ScS WQV [WQV$ d]\ RS[ @c\QV eSU hc aSW\$ jS\aSWba RS` @W\WS$ RWS [WQV c\R [SW\S\ \ScS\ :`Sc\R d][ FSab RS` KSZb b`S\\b& 8S` H`O\a^]`bS` `ObbS`b RWS :WTbV S\bZO\U& 8`]US\ W\ RS` HOaQVS$ ?][^ZWhS O\ RS` <O\R$ NW[[S`aQVZwaaSZ ROPSW$ RS\ UO\hS\ 5PS\R NSWb& BOQV[WbbOU c\R 5PS\R \SV[S\ WV`S\ @OcT& KW` aQVZOTS\ \WQVb [WbSW\O\RS`$ ]Pe]VZ WQV Sa [vQVbS& I[ hSV\ P`W\Ub FWQ] BOQVaQVcP$ c\R T`wV c[ dWS` Wab OZZSa eSU& ASW\ ?c[^SZ eW`R c\`cVWU c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb& 9` [vQVbS Tw\ThWU 8]ZZO` Tw` SW\ HOfW \OQV <O`ZS[$ c\R

eW`R c\`cVWU c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb& 9` [vQVbS Tw\ThWU 8]ZZO` Tw` SW\ HOfW \OQV <O`ZS[$ c\R WQV USPS WV[ dWS`hWU& KWSRS` OZZSW\$ `OcQVS WQV RWS ^OO` ?`w[SZ$ RWS WQV dS`abSQYb VObbS& ?`ObhS RWS ZSbhbS\ FwQYabs\RS Oca RS` YO^cbbS\ DTSWTS c\R dS`acQVS RS\ ZSbhbS\ H`]^TS\ ;WTb VS`OcahcaOcUS\$ PWa aWS aQVeO`h dS``crb Wab& GSVS Oca RS[ :S\abS` c\R T`OUS [WQV$ ]P Sa V]QV US\cU Wab$ ROaa WQV abS`PS$ eS\\ WQV `OcaYZSbbS`S c\R W\ RS\ @cTbaQVOQVb a^`W\US& 8`WbbS` Gb]QY& ?O\\ [O\ dS`USaaS\& I\R OZa RO\\ YSW\ DZO\S\$ YSW\ Hc\$ YSW\ :WbhSZ 7`OQY [SV` W[ KSU Wab$ Y][[b [W` SW\ ;SRO\YS2 B]OV& 8O WQV ROa \WQVb OcaVOZbS$ \SV[S WQV RWS dS``crbS DTSWTS Oca RS[ 5aQVS\PSQVS` c\R aSVS \OQV$ ]P aWS eW`YZWQV \WQVba [SV` VS`UWPb& =QV aSVS \OQV$ ]P \WQVb OcT RS[ 6]RS\ \]QV SW\ GbwQYQVS\ 7`OQY ZWSUb$ UO\h O[ FO\R RSa HS^^WQVP]RS\a dWSZZSWQVb$ c\R RO`OcT eO`bSb$ ROaa WQV Sa PS`US$ RO[Wb Sa [WQV `SbbS\ YO\\& 5PS` RO Wab \WQVba& BWQVba [SV` OcrS` [W` c\R RS[ 6SecaabaSW\$ ROaa WQV B]OV aSWb R`SW HOUS\ \WQVb O\US`cTS\ VOPS& 9a Wab aWSPS\ IV` T`wV$ WQV PW\ OZZSW\ W\ SW\S[ <]bSZhW[[S` \OQV R`SW HOUS\ 7`OQY c\R ]V\S C`WS\bWS`c\U& JS`s\UabWUb& =QV TwVZS [WQV$ OZa VsbbS [WQV SW\ H]`\OR] USaQVZcQYb c\R [WQV W\ :SbhS\ eWSRS` OcaUSa^WS\& KO`c[ VOPS WQV PSW jS\S[ 5PS\RSaaS\ a] dWSZ USb`c\YS\4 KO`c[$ <S``U]bb \]QV[OZ$ eO`c[4 8Oa VOPS WQV [WQV W[ U`SZZS\ @WQVb Vc\RS`bS` A]`US\a]\\S\ aQV]\ dWSZS Vc\RS`b AOZ UST`OUb$ c\R eWS W[[S` UWPb Sa YSW\S 5\be]`b& =QV `sc[S OcT$ `OTTS [SW\S <OPaSZWUYSWbS\ hcaO[[S\ c\R USVS Rc`QV RS\ b`wPS\$ abWZZS\ A]`US\ RWS :WTbV 5dS\cS S\bZO\U hc RS[ <Oca$ ROa V]TTS\bZWQV \]QV [SW\ NcVOcaS Wab& B]OV Wab \WQVb RO$ OZa WQV VW\Y][[S& =QV `cTS O\ c\R VW\bS`ZOaaS WV[ SW\S BOQV`WQVb$ ROaa WQV W\ RS` K]V\c\U PW\$ W[ 6Sbb ZWSUS c\R Sa [W` Ucb USVb& 8Oaa Sa [W` ZSWRbcb c\R \WQVb eWSRS` d]`Y][[b& 8Oaa WQV WV\ ZWSPS& =QV aQVZOTS Tw` USTwVZbS AW\cbS\ SW\$ OPS` eWS aWQV VS`OcaabSZZb$ aW\R Sa R`SW ]RS` dWS` Gbc\RS\& B]OV eSQYb [WQV USUS\ AWbbOU& 9` VOb H`s\S\ W\ RS\ 5cUS\ c\R a^`WQVb T`Sc\RZWQVS` [Wb [W`$ OZa WQV VsbbS S`V]TTS\ Yv\\S\& 9` c[O`[b [WQV$ eWS WQV RO W[ 6Sbb ZWSUS$ c\R bsbaQVSZb [W` RS\ FwQYS\ eWS SW\S[ b`]abPSRw`TbWUS\ ?W\R& 9` [OQVb SW\ PSa]`UbSa ;SaWQVb$ c\R WQV eSWr$ ROaa SbeOa W[ 6caQV Wab& 8c VOab 6SacQV$ aOUb S`$ c\R aQVZOUO`bWU PSU`SWTS WQV$ ROaa \c\ S\RZWQV$ \OQV a] ZO\US` NSWb$ a] dWSZS\ BsQVbS\ c\R A]`US\$ RS` HO\h d]`PSW Wab& KS`4$ T`OUS WQV$ c\R S` aOUb [W`$ ROaa [SW\S GQVeSabS` ?W[$ 8OdWR c\R ?ObS W[ K]V\hW[[S` aW\R& 8WS KSZb PZSWPb abSVS\& 8WS NSWb abSVb abWZZ& =QV YO\\ \WQVb UZOcPS\$ ROaa aWS 6SaQVSWR eWaaS\& 8Oaa aWS RO aW\R& B]OV VsZb [W` RWS <O\R$ c\R WQV PW\ RO\YPO` Tw` aSW\S Ns`bZWQVYSWb& :`]V$ ROaa S` [WQV \WQVb dS`Zsaab& 5PS` RS` <]``]` d]` RS[ 6Sd]`abSVS\RS\ USVb [W` Rc`QV c\R Rc`QV$ WQV PW\ eWS PSbscPb& ;SVS\ eW`$ R`s\Ub S`& I\R [Wb aSW\S` <WZTS abSWUS WQV W\ RS\ 6ORS[O\bSZ c\R aQVZc`TS hc RS` Hw` heWaQVS\ GQVZOT% c\R K]V\hW[[S`& B]OV VOb RWS <O\R OcT [SW\S` GQVcZbS`$ OZa WQV RWS Hw` vTT\S c\R aSVS$ eWS aWS RO OZZS c[ RS\ 7]cQVbWaQV W[ a]\\S\Rc`QVTZcbSbS\ K]V\hW[[S` aWbhS\ c\R hc [W` VS`aQVOcS\& =QV eSV`S [WQV \WQVb$ \]QV \WQVb& =QV PW\ abWZZ c\R Y]]^S`ObWd$ esV`S\R ?W[$ ?ObS$ B]OV

c\R 8OdWR [W` RS` FSWVS \OQV aOUS\$ ROaa aWS [WQV W[ ?O[^T USUS\ RWS GcQVb c\bS`abwbhS\ eS`RS\$ OPS` \WQVba [SV` [Wb [W` hc bc\ VOPS\ e]ZZS\$ eS\\ WQV eSWbS` 8`]US\ \SV[S& JWSZS H`s\S\ TZWSrS\$ c\R WQV Y][[S [W` d]` eWS c\bS` KOaaS`$ OZa [waabS\ WV`S K]`bS ZO\US Gb`SQYS\ hc`wQYZSUS\$ c[ hc [W` hc USZO\US\& I\bS\ abSVb SW\ KOUS\$ RWS HWQYSba Tw` SW\S\ :ZcU \OQV C`SU]\$ hc SW\S` 9\bhcUaYZW\WY$ aW\R USYOcTb$ OZZSa Wab US^OQYb c\R SW\ 6Sbb eO`bSb& 8S\ 9f%7]^ ]RS` 9f%@SRS`\OQYS\ ]RS` 9f%G^]`bZSV`S`$ RS` [caYSZPS^OQYb [Wb dS`aQV`s\YbS\ 5`[S\ \SPS\ [W` abSVb c\R [WQV W\ U`W[[S\ Hv\S\ O\PZOTTb$ `ORWS`S WQV W\abW\YbWd Oca& =QV aSVS WV\ \WQVb O\$ `SRS \WQVb [Wb WV[$ c\bS`ZOaaS jSRS ?][[c\WYObW]\ [Wb WV[ c\R S`YZs`S [WQV \c` c\bS` RS` 6SRW\Uc\U$ ROaa S` c\a \WQVb PSUZSWbSb$ PS`SWb$ [Wb hc[ :ZcUVOTS\ hc Y][[S\& 5PUS[OQVb& B]OV$ ?ObS c\R WQV abSWUS\ W\ RS\ KOUS\ c\R TOV`S\ hc[ @O ;cO`RWO& 9a Wab T`wVS` BOQV[WbbOU$ c\R OZa eW` hc[ HS`[W\OZ Y][[S\$ aOUS WQV$ WQV [caa eOa SaaS\$ PSabSZZS SW\S\ HSZZS` FwV`SW c\R SW\S :ZOaQVS KSWreSW\$ RWS WQV RO\\ ZSS`b`W\YS$ e]USUS\ WQV ROa 9aaS\ YOc[ O\`wV`S& 5cT RS[ :ZcU \OQV C`SU]\ b`W\YS WQV K]RYO$ esV`S\R B]OV c\R ?ObS abc[[ hcaSVS\ ]RS` aQVZOTS\& 8WS ?ZW\WY Wab SW\S Gbc\RS d]\ D]`bZO\R S\bTS`\b c\R aWSVb \OQV SW\S` YZSW\S\ ;`c\RaQVcZS Oca$ RWS [O\ [WbbS\ W\ VwUSZWUSa KSW\POcUSPWSb USabSZZb VOb& 9a `SU\Sb YSW\ SW\hWUSa AOZ$ esV`S\R WQV R]`b PW\$ RS` <W[[SZ Wab Rc\YSZ$ SW\ [OYSZZ]aSa 6ZOc$ ROa aWQV a^sbS` O[ HOU `]aO c\R PSW G]\\S\c\bS`UO\U aQVO`ZOQV`]b Ts`Pb& ASW\ NW[[S`US\]aaS Wab SW\ bOPZSbbS\awQVbWUS` <W`\QVW`c`U Oca @]a 5\USZSa$ RSaaS\ PWZRVwPaQVS aQVeSRWaQVS :`Sc\RW\ [SV`[OZa d]`PSWY][[b c\R [Wb c\a \OQV D]`bZO\R ]RS` O\ RWS ?wabS TsV`b& 5cQV O\RS`S aW\R RO \]QV x RS` ^S\aW]\WS`bS FSbbc\UaeOUS\TOV`S` Oca KOaVW\Ub]\ GbObS$ RS` aWQV jSRS\ 5PS\R PWa hc` 6SaW\\c\UaZ]aWUYSWb PSb`c\YS\ c\R e]QVS\ZO\U YSW\ K]`b [Wb O\RS`S\ AS\aQVS\ USeSQVaSZb VOb3 RS` _cOaaSZWUS `SWQVS >w\UZW\U Oca BSe M]`Y$ RS` W\ SW\S[ U]ZRS\S\ 5RWROa%H`OW\W\UaO\hcU VS`c[ZscTb c\R `SRSb eWS SW\ ;O\UabS`3 RS` ^O`O\]WRS ASbV%:`SOY Oca RS[ GO\ :S`\O\R] JOZZSg$ RS` aSW\S\ ?SZZS` [Wb 5ZcT]ZWS OcaUSZSUb VOb$ c[ RWS 7]^a c\R RWS 6c\RSa^]ZWhSW hc wPS`ZWabS\$ d]\ RS\S\ S` aWQV OcT GQV`Wbb c\R H`Wbb dS`T]ZUb ecaabS& AWb OZZS\ Y][[S WQV YZO`& 5[ heSWbS\ ]RS` R`WbbS\ HOU$ \OQV f TZSVS\bZWQVS\ 5\`cTS\ PSW B]OV$ ?ObS c\R [SW\S` GQVeSabS`$ aWS [vQVbS\ [WQV R]QV PWbbS hc`wQY \OQV BSe M]`Y V]ZS\$ TW\RS WQV [WQV RO[Wb OP$ ROaa WQV W[ 9\bhcU PW\$ ROaa WQV TSabaWbhS& 5Za WQV S`ab [OZ OcTVv`S$ \OQV <OcaS hc e]ZZS\$ abSZZS WQV [Wb 9`abOc\S\ TSab$ eWS Ucb WQV [WQV [Wb RS\ >c\Ua dS`abSVS$ eWS sV\ZWQV eW` c\a aW\R$ c\R eWS b]ZZ Sa Wab$ S\RZWQV SW\[OZ UO\h SV`ZWQV aSW\ hc Yv\\S\& >SRS\ 5PS\R USVS WQV OZZSW\ OcT SW\S` aQVv\S\ KWSaS a^OhWS`S\ c\R aQVOcS [W` O\$ eWS Sa Rc\YSZ eW`R c\R RS` <W[[SZ aWQV [Wb `]aO c\R `]bS\ Gb`SWTS\ wPS`hWSVb& =QV USVS R]`b a^OhWS`S\ c\R VOPS 5\Uab d]` RS` FwQYYSV` \OQV BSe M]`Y$ 5\Uab$ eOa RWS @ScbS RS\YS\$ OPS` \OQV SW\ ^OO` K]QVS\ aQVv^TS WQV <]TT\c\U& =QV S`YZs`S [WQV T`SWeWZZWU PS`SWb$ \]QV SW\S K]QVS Zs\US` hc PZSWPS\ x hc[ HSWZ$ eSWZ WQV B]OV c\R ?ObS hSWUS\ [vQVbS$ ROaa Sa [W` S`\ab Wab$ d]` OZZS[ OPS`$ eSWZ WQV \OQV dWS`

B]OV c\R ?ObS hSWUS\ [vQVbS$ ROaa Sa [W` S`\ab Wab$ d]` OZZS[ OPS`$ eSWZ WQV \OQV dWS` K]QVS\ UO\h W\ RS` ;S[SW\aQVOTb RS` DObWS\bS\ c\R 6S`ObS` OcTUSVS& =QV VOPS Sa \WQVb SWZWU RO[Wb$ RS\ FOV[S\ VWS` hc dS`ZOaaS\$ RS` Sa [W` S`ZOcPb$ RWS dWSZS\ ;SVSW[\WaaS ^`SWahcUSPS\$ RWS WQV SW\ @SPS\ ZO\U c\bS` RS\ HS^^WQV USYSV`b VOPS$ ]V\S ROaa WQV aWS RSaVOZP Z]aUSe]`RS\ es`S ]RS` aWS [WQV eS\WUS` US^ZOUb VsbbS\& 9W\Sa A]`US\a a^`SQVS WQV W\ RS` ;`c^^S hc[ S`abS\ AOZ aSWb RS\ GWbhc\US\ [Wb 8`& 8OdS wPS` [SW\S GQVeWS`WUYSWbS\ PSW[ DW\YSZ\& BOQV RS` ;`c^^S aOUb [W` SW\ O\RS`S` AO\\$ SW\ 6O\YS` Oca GO\ :`O\QWaQ] [Wb dWS` ?W\RS`\$ ROaa S` OZa ?W\R [Wb RS[aSZPS\ D`]PZS[ hc Ys[^TS\ VObbS& NeSW HOUS d]` RS[ 9\RS [SW\Sa 5cTS\bVOZba aQVZSWQVb S` aWQV d][ ?ZW\WYUSZs\RS$ dS`aOQYb W[ \sQVabS\ Gb`W^QZcP PSW[ HS_cWZO c\R eW`R \OQV <OcaS USaQVWQYb& 5Za WQV \OQV BSe M]`Y hc`wQYY][[S$ `cTb [SW\S AcbbS` O\$ ROaa aWS [WQV aSVS\ eWZZ& =QV aQVWSPS ROa TOab SW\S\ A]\Ob `Oca c\R eWZZWUS aQVZWSrZWQV SW\$ [Wb WV` SaaS\ hc USVS\& Nc RS[ @c\QV dS`a^sbSb aWS aWQV O\RS`bVOZP Gbc\RS\& 5Za aWS RO\\ S\RZWQV Y][[b c\R eW` PSabSZZS\$ S`hsVZb aWS d]\ RS\ ;S\S`ObW]\S\ d]\ H`W\YS`\ c\R 8`]US\OPVs\UWUS\ W\ WV`S` :O[WZWS c\R RS` [SW\Sa JObS`a c\R aOUb [W`$ ROaa WQV hc SW\S` ZO\US\ FSWVS USVv`S& 5\TO\Ua VOPS WQV [WQV heO` wPS` WV`S JS`a^sbc\U OcTUS`SUb$ OPS` RO\\ PW\ WQV R]QV S`abOc\ZWQV S\ba^O\\b c\R [S`YS$ ROaa eWSRS` SbeOa d]\ c\aS`S` T`wVS`S\ I\UShec\US\VSWb RO Wab& =QV T`OUS$ ]P WQV OcT SW\S GOQVS Oca [SW\S` ?W\RVSWb hc a^`SQVS\ Y][[S\ Yv\\S$ SbeOa$ wPS` ROa WQV \]QV [Wb YSW\S[ Oca RS` :O[WZWS US`SRSb VsbbS$ ROa [W` OPS` \ScZWQV SW\USTOZZS\ aSW& GWS aOUb jO$ R]QV SVS WQV ROa K]`b ^W\YSZ\ Ocaa^`SQVS\ YO\\$ VSPb aWS RWS <O\R c\R aQVwbbSZb RS\ ?]^T& =QV `SRS \]QV Yc`h eSWbS`$ OPS` jSbhb eSW\b aWS c\R T`OUb [WQV$ ]P WQV [WQV \c` hc[ 9aaS\ [Wb WV` b`STTS\ e]ZZbS$ c[ WV` hc aOUS\$ eOa Tw` SW\S aQV`SQYZWQVS AcbbS` aWS Wab& JS`PZwTTb wPS` WV`S\ ^ZvbhZWQVS\ 5caP`cQV O\be]`bS WQV$ ROaa aWS [W` R]QV \c` aOUS\ a]ZZ$ ]P aWS aWQV O\ a] SbeOa S`W\\S`b c\R [W` PSabsbWUS\ YO\\$ ROaa Sa eW`YZWQV ^OaaWS`b Wab$ eSWZ WQV \WQVba OZa SW\S\ <OcTS\ eW``S`$ d]\ SW\S[ GSSZS\YZS[^\S` OcTUSaQVwbbSZbS` 9`W\\S`c\US\ RO`O\ VOPS& I\bS` H`s\S\ aOUb aWS SbeOa$ ROa aWQV O\Vv`b eWS2 8O`wPS` `SRS WQV \WQVb$ RSW\ JObS` eO` RS`jS\WUS z ASW\S ZSbhbS 9`W\\S`c\U ROhc Wab$ ROaa aWS [WQV T`OUb$ ]P WQV SW\S 5V\c\U VOPS$ eWS aQVeS` aWS Sa RO[OZa VObbS$ eOa Tw` SW\ 5ZPb`Oc[ jS\S >OV`S Tw` aWS eO`S\& =QV aOUS jO$ aWS VsbbS Sa W[[S` aSV` Ucb dS`abO\RS\$ c\a YZO`hc[OQVS\$ eWS aQVeS` aWS Sa VOb$ c\R aWS dS`Zsaab ROa FSabOc`O\b& =QV ZOcTS WV` \OQV$ OPS` aWS dS`aQVeW\RSb e]`bZ]a W\ SW\S[ HOfW& =QV USVS eWSRS` W\a FSabOc`O\b$ hOVZS RWS FSQV\c\U c\R dS`ZWS`S OcT RS[ KSU hc` 5US\bc` R`SW Gb`OrS\ eSWbS` [SW\S 6`WSTbOaQVS$ [SW\S GQVZwaaSZ c\R [SW\S G]\\S\P`WZZS& =QV TO\US SW\S O[PcZO\bS HVS`O^WS O\$ RWS WQV \WQVb hc 9\RS [OQVS$ VOZbS [WQV \c` SW\S NSWbZO\U O\ RWS FObaQVZsUS hc` 5PabW\S\h$ RWS [O\ [W` W\ RS` ?ZW\WY USUSPS\ VOb$ bSZST]\WS`S SW\ ^OO`[OZ [Wb [SW\S[ NW[[S`US\]aaS\ c\R RS\ O\RS`S\ >c\Ua x RWS d]` K]QVS\ \]QV eWS SW\S :O[WZWS Tw` [WQV eO`S\ x c\R USPS$ PSd]` RS` A]\Ob c[ Wab$ RS\ ?]\bOYb [Wb WV\S\ OcT&

?]\bOYb [Wb WV\S\ OcT& =QV RS\YS$ WQV PW\ wPS` RS\ 6S`U& =QV abw`hS [WQV W\ RWS 5`PSWb$ Y]\hS\b`WS`S [WQV OcT RWS 5US\bc`$ RWS 5cb]`S\$ RWS WQV dS`b`SbS$ c\R Sa aWSVb Oca$ OZa Yv\\bS WQV [WQV VW\bS` RS` 5`PSWb dS`aQVO\hS\$ OZa aQVwbhbS aWS [WQV d]` RS` JS`acQVc\U& =QV aSVS$ eWS RWS @ScbS OcT 9[^Ts\US\ c\R DO`bga b`W\YS\$ c\R PW\ hc\sQVab S`ZSWQVbS`b$ ROaa WQV ROa \WQVb [SV` \vbWU VOPS& BOQV SW\ ^OO` A]\ObS\ Ts\Ub Sa RO\\ R]QV O\$ O\ [W` hc \OUS\& KWS ;SRO\YS\PZOaS\ W[ 7][WQ [SZRS\ aWQV YZSW\S FOcaQV^VO\bOaWS\$ d]` OZZS[$ eS\\ WQV OZZSW\ PW\$ \OQV ZO\US\ 5`PSWbabOUS\$ ]RS` eS\\ WQV SW\ AWbbOUSaaS\ OcaUSZOaaS\ VOPS c\R d][ <c\US` ZSWQVb PS\][[S\ PW\& =[ CYb]PS` TW\RS WQV SW\S OZbS 7`OQY^TSWTS W\ RS` HOaQVS SW\Sa 6ZOhS`a$ RS` W\ c\aS`S[ GQVZOThW[[S`aQV`O\Y Vs\Ub& =QV dS`abSQYS ROa 8W\U O\ eSQVaSZ\RS\ C`bS\$ c[Y`SWaS Sa e]QVS\ZO\U eWS SW\ :OZYS$ RO\\ Y`ObhS WQV aQVZWSrZWQV RWS OZbS\ FwQYabs\RS VS`Oca c\R hWSVS aWS Rc`QV& 9a UWPb \c` RS\ ZSWaSabS\ 5\TZcU SW\Sa FOcaQVa$ RS\ RWS ^O\WaQVS 5\Uab$ ROaa WQV `wQYTsZZWU USe]`RS\ PW\$ aQV\SZZ dS`b`SWPb& ?Oc[ VOb Sa O\USTO\US\$ Wab Sa eWSRS` d]`PSW$ c\R B]OV$ RS` UZSWQV RO`OcT VS`SW\Y][[b$ abW[[b [W` hc$ ROaa eW` Sa \WS[O\RS[ S`hsVZS\ a]ZZbS\& =QV dS`abSQYS RWS DTSWTS$ \SV[S aWS [Wb W\a 6w`] c\R dS`ZSUS aWS W`US\ReWS& K]QVS\ZO\U a]`US WQV [WQV$ ROaa W`US\RjS[O\R x [SW\S 5aaWabS\bW\$ ?ObS$ RWS DcbhT`Oc x aWS R]`b USTc\RS\ VOb c\R [WQV hc` FSRS abSZZS\ eW`R& BWQVba RS`UZSWQVS\ USaQVWSVb& I\R RO\\$ aWSPS\ A]\ObS a^sbS`$ c\[WbbSZPO` d]` RS[ Gc\RO\QS :WZ[ :SabWdOZ W\ DO`Y 7Wbg$ IbOV$ eWZZ WQV [WQV [Wb B]OV hc[ GcaVW%8W\\S` W[ >O^]\WQO b`STTS\& 5[ A]`US\ RSa HOUSa d]` RWSaS[ 8W\\S` Y][[b [W` RS` ;SRO\YS$ 7`OQY hc `OcQVS\$ R]QV O\abObb WV\ eSUhcaQV\W^^S\ eWS a]\ab VOZbS WQV [WQV ROPSW OcT& I\R Vs\US WV[ \OQV$ PWa WQV [W` aOUS2 KO`c[ \WQVb4 qPS`[]`US\ `SWab B]OV OP$ RO\\ PW\ WQV TOab heSW d]ZZS HOUS OZZSW\ W\ RS` GbORb& =QV VOPS aQVeS` USO`PSWbSb$ OZZSa ZscTb$ \WS[O\R eW`R JS`ROQVb aQVv^TS\& =\\S`VOZP d]\ GSYc\RS\ PW\ WQV O\ [SW\S[ <O\Rg c\R `cTS hc[ S`abS\ AOZ aSWb TOab SW\S[ >OV` GbS^VS\ O\& KW` V]ZS\ WV\ Zs\Uab \WQVb [SV` OZa 6O`bS\RS` Tw` c\aS`S DO`bga$ OPS` S\bUSUS\ RS[ FOb W\ RS` FSVO$ OZZS R`]US\PSh]US\S\S\ HSZST]\\c[[S`\ hc ZvaQVS\$ VOPS WQV aSW\S \]QV& 9` \W[[b PSW[ S`abS\ ?ZW\USZ\ OP$ c\R eW` dS`OP`SRS\ c\a Tw` a^sbS` O\ RS` 9QYS d]` [SW\S[ 6w`]USPscRS& I[ aSQVa TOV`S WQV \OQV c\bS\$ c\R S` ZSV\b R`OcrS\ O\ RS` KO\R& 9` Wab Rw\\S`$ OZa WQV WV\ W\ 9`W\\S`c\U VOPS$ sZbS`& =QV U`wrS WV\ \c` Yc`h$ ]Pe]VZ S` O\aQVSW\S\R ;SaSZZaQVOTb acQVb& =QV USPS WV[ ,(( 8]ZZO` hc[ ?OcTS\ c\R *(( Tw` RWS 8`SQYO`PSWb c\R dS`OP`SRS [WQV [Wb WV[ Tw` RS\ \sQVabS\ HOU& 5\TO\US\ eWZZ WQV heO` \WQVba [SV` [Wb WV[$ OPS` ROa ?OcTS\ wPS` WV\ TW\RS WQV VOZP a] aQVZW[[& G]ZO\US WQV [WQV \WQVb eWSRS` [Wb 8SOZS`\ SW\ZOaaS$ WV`S HSZST]\\c[[S`\ \WQVb eWSRS` OcaU`OPS$ Wab RS` YZSW\S H`W^ VWS` R]QV \c` SW\S SW\[OZWUS GOQVS$ SW\S 5ca\OV[S$ SW\S VO`[Z]aS$ OPS` \]beS\RWUS 5cahSWb& 5[ \sQVabS\ HOU b`STTS WQV [WQV Y`WPPZWU c\R USa^O\\b [Wb GbS^VS\ O\ RS`aSZPS\ 9QYS& 8WSa[OZ Wab S` UO\h USaQVsTba[srWU& 9` UWPb [W` SW\S YZSW\S P`Oc\S HwbS [Wb GbSW\S\ c\R

DTSWTS\& =QV RO\YS WV[$ USPS WV[ aSW\ ;SZR c\R [OQVS$ ROaa WQV eWSRS` `OcT W\ [SW\ 6w`] Y][[S& =QV VOPS d]`$ RWS GbSW\S O[ \sQVabS\ HOU hc `OcQVS\$ eS\\ B]OV eSU Wab$ O\RS`bVOZP HOUS PSd]` WQV hc` D`S[WS`S aSW\Sa :WZ[a hc WV[ \OQV IbOV TZWSUS& 8Oa USVb aQV]\$ RS\YS WQV$ ROa Wab \c` SW\ PWaaQVS\ 9\ba^O\\c\U$ \WQVb RS` FSRS eS`b$ SW\ VO`[Z]aSa 8O[^TOPZOaaS\& 6SW OZZS` TOcZS\ GSZPabPSaQVeWQVbWUc\U eSWr WQV$ ROaa ROa ;O\hS Pva S\RS\ eW`R$ eWS Sa ROa W[[S` bcb$ c\R ROaa WQV [W` VWS` SW\S\ USZORS\S\ FSd]ZdS` O\ RWS GQVZsTS VOZbS& 8]QV O\abObb [WQV OPhcaQV`SQYS\$ VWZTb RWSaS` 9W\eO\R \c`$ [WQV hc wPS``SRS\& 8WS HwbS P`W\Ub S\beSRS` SW\S\ YO^cbbS\ HOU$ \OQV RS[ WQV \]`[OZ eSWbS`ZSPS\ YO\\$ eSWZ \WQVba ^OaaWS`b Wab$ ]RS` aWS TwV`b hc SW\S` 5^]YOZg^aS& 5ZZSa ]RS` \WQVba& I\R OZZSa hc dS`ZWS`S\ YZW\Ub \OQV 9`Zvac\U& =[ 6w`] [OQVS WQV SW\ ^OO` 5\`cTS$ aOUS [SW\S\ AWbO`PSWbS`\ baQVwa$ OZa aWS USVS\$ c\R abSZZS TSab$ ROaa Sa PWa hc RS[ 5PS\RSaaS\ [Wb B]OV \]QV heSW Gbc\RS\ aW\R& NeSW Gbc\RS\& J]\ SW\S` DTSWTS PW\ WQV PWa ROVW\ eWSRS` `c\bS`& KO`c[ \WQVb4 =QV abSVS d][ GQV`SWPbWaQV OcT c\R aQVZWSrS RWS 6w`]bw` OP& =\ RS` GQVcPZORS [SW\S` 5aaWabS\bW\ TW\RS WQV SW\ :ScS`hScU& =QV aSbhS [WQV eWSRS`$ \SV[S ROa 7`OQY Oca RS` HOaQVS x heSW HwbQVS\ x$ eWSUS Sa W\ RS` <O\R c\R \SV[S RWS aOcPS`S ;ZOa^TSWTS VS`Oca$ RWS dWSZ ZSWQVbS` Wab$ OZa WQV Sa W\ 9`W\\S`c\U VOPS& 9a Y][[b [W` eWS SW\ H`Oc[ d]`$ OZa WQV SW\ YZSW\Sa aSWTWUSa GbwQY 7`OQY OPaQV\SWRS c\R Sa W\ RWS DTSWTS abSQYS& 9a ^OaaWS`b UO` \WQVb eW`YZWQV$ ROaa WQV ROa :ScS`hScU O\Y\W^aS c\R RWS :ZO[[S O\ RWS DTSWTS VOZbS& =\ RS\ S`abS\ GSYc\RS\ \OQV RS[ dS`b`OcbS\ 5caab]rS\ RSa FOcQVa VOPS WQV wPS`VOc^b \WQVb ROa ;STwVZ$ SbeOa JS`YSV`bSa hc bc\$ Sa Wab SW\ KWSRS`aSVS\ [Wb SW\S[ OZbS\ :`Sc\R$ eSWbS` \WQVba$ RWS KWSRS`OcT\OV[S RSa c\UZOcPZWQVabS\ ;Sa^`sQVa$ ROa WQV jS S`ZSPb VOPS$ SW\ ;Sa^`sQV$ ROa aWSPS\ A]\ObS hcd]` c\bS`P`]QVS\ ec`RS c\R ]V\S jSRS\ GQVec\R O\ US\Oc RS[ Dc\Yb jSbhb eSWbS`USVb& 5PS` Sa Wab [SV` OZa \c` SW\ ;Sa^`sQV$ Sa Wab RS` PSabS GSf$ RWS YvabZWQVabS AOVZhSWb$ ROa TSaaSZ\RabS 6cQV x Sa Wab$ OZa YSV`bS [O\ hc OZZ RWSaS\ 8W\US\ UZSWQVhSWbWU hc`wQY$ OZa Ys[S [O\ \OQV <OcaS x$ c\R [SV` OZa OZZSa O\RS`S T`OUS WQV [WQV$ OZa WQV [WQV W\ RS\ 8`SVaSaaSZ aW\YS\ ZOaaS c\R hcaSVS$ eWS RS` FOcQV Rc`QV [SW\ 6w`] eOPS`b2 KO`c[ PZ]r VOPS WQV jS[OZa OcTUSVv`b4 8`SW Gbc\RS\ aWbhS WQV O\ [SW\S[ GQV`SWPbWaQV$ `OcQVS SW\S HwbS OcT c\R `S\\S W\ ^ZvbhZWQVS` DO\WY RO\\ `Oca hc[ >O^]\WQO$ hc B]OV$ [Wb RS[ WQV d]` SW\S` Gbc\RS dS`OP`SRSb eO`& =QV abw`hS W\ ROa FSabOc`O\b$ aSVS WV\ [Wb RS[ FwQYS\ hc` KO\R O\ SW\S[ HWaQV aWbhS\$ aWQVbZWQV PSa]`Ub$ c\R OZa S` [WQV S`PZWQYb$ eW`R S` PZSWQV c\R Ts\Ub O\ hc eSW\S\& 5\ ROa KSW\S\ S`W\\S`S WQV [WQV& =QV ZwUS c\R aOUS WV[$ WQV aSW W[ 6w`] Rc`QV SW\S\ 5\`cT OcTUSVOZbS\ e]`RS\$ VsbbS eSRS` [SW\ <O\Rg \]QV ROa 5US\bc`%HSZST]\ YZW\USZ\ USVv`b$ OZZSa aSW W\ C`R\c\U$ S` a]ZZS R]QV OcTVv`S\ hc eSW\S\& Nc <OcaS aQVZsTb S` RO\\ OcT RS` 7]cQV$ c\R PSd]` S` O[ A]`US\ OP`SWab$ abSZZb S` \c` SW\S :`OUS2 ?][[ab Rc hc[ Gc\RO\QS4 I\R WQV aOUS$ OPS` jO$ \Obw`ZWQV& =QV dS`a^`SQVS Sa WV[&

Rc hc[ Gc\RO\QS4 I\R WQV aOUS$ OPS` jO$ \Obw`ZWQV& =QV dS`a^`SQVS Sa WV[& I\R WQV aQVOTTS Sa OcQV eW`YZWQV& 5PS` WQV PZSWPS \c` SW\S BOQVb$ hc aSW\S` D`S[WS`S c\R hc` O\aQVZWSrS\RS\ DO`bg [Wb aSW\S\ D`]RchS\bS\$ :`Sc\RS\ c\R 5\USVv`WUS\& =QV ZsQVZS c\R \WQYS$ PW\ dS`PW\RZWQV c\R USPS RS\ `wQYS\abs`YS\RS\ DO`b\S`& 5PS` [SW\S ;SRO\YS\ aW\R PSW RS` W\ DO^WS`bwQVS` SW\USaQVZOUS\S\ YZSW\S\ NW^Z]Q%HwbS W\ RS` HOaQVS [SW\Sa [O`W\SPZOcS\ 6ZOhS`a$ RS` W\ C\S :WTbV W[ GQVZOThW[[S`aQV`O\Y Vs\Ub& =QV aSVS RWS Rc`QVaWQVbWUS ;ZOa^TSWTS d]` [W`$ RWS \SPS\ RS` HwbS abSQYb$ c\R ROa :ScS`hScU OcT RS` ?][[]RS& >SRS GSYc\RS$ RWS WQV W\ IbOV PW\$ RS\YS WQV RO`O\& J][ 5cUS\PZWQY [SW\S` 5\Yc\Tb O\ eWZZ WQV \c` eSU& GQV]\ OZa WQV BSe M]`Y dS`ZOaaS$ eWZZ WQV \c` eWSRS` VW\$ hc`wQY hc jS\S` I\bS`VOZbc\U$ RWS US`ORS eWSRS` PSU]\\S\ VObbS c\R d]\ RS` [WQV jSbhb$ e] Sa a]eSWb Wab$ \c` RS` H]R \]QV OPVOZbS\ YO\\&

@SbhbS Hw`
=QV P`OcQVS SW\S\ \ScS\ DcZZ]dS`& =QV [caa aOcPS` aSW\$ eS\\ WQV [W` SW\ \ScSa <]bSZ acQVS& 9a Wab 5PS\R$ OPS` SW\WUS @sRS\ VOPS\ dWSZZSWQVb \]QV OcT& =QV abSWUS W\ SW\ HOfW c\R aOUS RS[ :OV`S`$ \OQV G]<]& 9` ac[[b PSW[ :OV`S\$ c\R WQV P`W\US Sa \WQVb wPS` [WQV$ \OQVhcaSVS\$ ]P aSW\ 5caeSWaT]b] d]\ DO^WS` ]RS` DO^^S dS`RSQYb Wab ]RS` UO\h TSVZb eWS W\ RS\ O\RS`S\ :sZZS\& <WS` ]YOg4$ T`OUb S`$ OZa eW` hc` 9QYS <]cab]\ c\R K]]abS` Y][[S\& =QV abSQYS hSV\ 8]ZZO` W\ RS\ ;SZRaQVZWbh c\R aSVS S`ab UO` \WQVb \OQV RS` IV`& 8WS ;SaQVsTbS awRZWQV RS` <]cab]\ aSVS\ eSWV\OQVbZWQV Oca& I\USevV\ZWQVS GQVOcTS\abS` x O\W[WS`b$ W\ahS\WS`b$ W\bSZZWUS\b OcaUSZScQVbSb x Z]QYS\ S\bZO\U RS` K]]abS` c\R aQVwQVbS`\ SW\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS WQV [Wb RS` dWS`bS\ ]RS` Tw\TbS\ ?ZOaaS \OQV BSe M]`Y USY][[S\ PW\$ c[ RWS KSWV\OQVbaaV]e W\ RS` FORW] 7Wbg AcaWQ <OZZ hc aSVS\& 8WS Gb`OrS\ W[ NS\b`c[ eO`S\ d]ZZUS^OQYb [Wb H]c`WabS\ c\R BSe M]`YS`\$ RWS hc <c\RS`bS\ GQVZO\US abO\RS\ d]` RS\ GQVOcTS\abS`\ d]\ GOYa :WTbV 5dS\cS c\R @]`R ! HOgZ]`& =QV eSWr \]QV$ ROaa [W` \WQVb OcTUW\U$ eOa O\ RS\ :S\abS`\ a] eWQVbWU eO`$ OPS` ROaa WQV Sa OcT`SUS\R TO\R$ SbeOa a] 6SRScbS\RSa c\R eSWbVW\ 6SYO\\bSa [WbhcS`ZSPS\& =\ RS` FORW] 7Wbg AcaWQ <OZZ eO` Sa US\Oca]& ASW\S AcbbS` VObbS [W` USaOUb$ Sa aSW ROa PSabS HVSObS` RS` KSZb c\R RWS F]QYSbbSa RWS aQVv\abS c\R bOZS\bWS`bSabS H`c^^S$ RWS Sa UOP$ SW\ AOU\Sb Tw` AS\aQVS\ Oca OZZS` KSZb& 5Za [SW\S ?ZOaaS S\RZWQV Rc`QV ROa ;SewVZ \OQV FORW] 7Wbg d]`R`O\U$ PZWSP [W` TOab RWS @cTb eSU& <WS` eO`S\ eW`$ O\ RS[ C`b$ hc RS[ AS\aQVS\ d]\ wPS`OZZVS` YO[S\$ c[ RWS F]QYSbbSa hc aSVS\ "eOa RWS SWUS\bZWQV [OQVbS\$ OV\bS WQV W[[S` \]QV \WQVb#& 8Oa ;]ZRRSY]` c\R RS` `]bS HS^^WQV ZWSrS\ ROa nKSWV\OQVbS\ W\ BSe M]`Yl%5R`S\OZW\ \]QV aQV\SZZS` W\ [W` Y`SWaS\$ a] ROaa WQV d]` 5cT`SUc\U PcQVabsPZWQV hWbbS`bS& CPS\ O[ S`abS\ H`S^^S\OcTUO\U UOP Sa Aw\hbSZST]\S& =QV UW\U aQV\c`ab`OQYa hc[ \sQVabS\ 5^^O`Ob c\R esVZbS RWS BcZZ& 8S` JS`[WbbZc\U aOUbS WQV$ WQV e]ZZS ^S` F%;Sa^`sQV hc <OcaS O\`cTS\& 9a YZW\USZbS$ OPS` \WS[O\R V]P OP& 5\`cTPSO\be]`bS` UOP Sa RO[OZa \]QV \WQVb& AOWZP]f OcQV \WQVb& 5Za] ZSUbS WQV OcT& 5PS` WQV ^ZObhbS Tv`[ZWQV c\R [caabS [Wb jS[O\RS[ RO`wPS` `SRS\$ [caabS RWS 5cT`SUc\U W`US\ReWS Z]aeS`RS\& =QV esVZbS S`\Scb RWS JS`[WbbZc\U$ US`WSb O\ SW\S O\RS`S HSZST]\WabW\ c\R aQVWZRS`bS WV` W\ UZwVS\RS\ :O`PS\$ e] WQV eO`$ eOa Sa RO hc aSVS\ UOP c\R eOa WQV PSW RWSaS[ 6SacQV W\ RS` GbORb$ SW\S[ [SW\S` S`abS\$ aQV]\ OZZSa USaSVS\ VObbS& J]\ RS` JS`O\abOZbc\U O\ RWSaS[ 5PS\R eSWr WQV \WQVba [SV`$ OPS` O\ RS\ 5\`cT S`W\\S`S WQV [WQV US\Oc x RWS \SbbS HSZST]\WabW\$ RWS T`Sc\RZWQVS GbW[[S c\R ROaa aWS [W` aOUbS$ WQV a]ZZS hc [SW\S[ @SV`S` USVS\ c\R OcT^OaaS\$ ROaa WQV [WQV \WQVb dS`ZOcTS& =QV eO\RS`S O\ RS\ Rc`QVRSaWU\bS\ Pc\bS\ GQVOcTS\abS`\ RS` K]]abS` d]`PSW c\R wPS`ZSUS$ eOa Tw` SW\S >OV`SahSWb Sa Wab& 9a aWSVb heO` \OQV KSWV\OQVbS\ Oca$ OPS` ROa

wPS`ZSUS$ eOa Tw` SW\S >OV`SahSWb Sa Wab& 9a aWSVb heO` \OQV KSWV\OQVbS\ Oca$ OPS` ROa YO\\ e]VZ \WQVb aSW\& 9`ab \OQV SW\S` KSWZS eSWr WQV eWSRS`$ ROaa Sa As`h Wab& =QV PSb`SbS SW\S\ U`]rS\$ VSZZS\ @ORS\ [Wb \WSR`WUS\ HWaQVS\ c\R SZSUO\bS\ ?ZSWRS`abs\RS`\$ O\ RS\S\ ]TTS\PO` a]`UTsZbWU a]`bWS`bS KO`S Vs\Ub& =QV T`OUS RWS Rc\YSZVOO`WUS JS`YscTS`W\$ RS`S\ PZOcS 5cUS\ U]ZRS\ c\R `]b aQVWZZS`\ eWS C^OZS$ ]P aWS F]ZZY`OUS\^cZZ]dS` Tw` <S``S\ VOPS\& =QV aSW hc 6SacQV$ aOUS WQV$ c\R RS`$ RS\ WQV O\VsbbS$ aSW \WQVb [SV` hc USP`OcQVS\& GWS aQVOcb O\ [W` `c\bS`$ c\R WV` 6ZWQY c\R WV` GbW`\`c\hSZ\ USPS\ [W` `SQVb& GWS aQVWQYb [WQV hc` H`S^^S W\a G]cbS``OW\& I\bS\ \SPS\ RS` H`S^^S abSVb SW\ ?]`P [Wb hcaO[[S\USTOZbSbS\ ?OaQV[W`%F]ZZY`OUS\^cZZ]dS`\$ c\R RS\ YZSW\abS\$ RS` RO Wab$ eSW\`]b [Wb N]^T[cabS`$ \SV[S WQV [Wb W\ RWS I[YZSWRSYOPW\S& G]POZR RWS Hw` W\a GQVZ]aa TsZZb$ [OQVS WQV [W` SW\S RWQYS @ORc\U$ VcabS ZOcb$ c[ ROa ?ZWQYS\ RSa :ScS`hScUa hc wPS`bv\S\$ c\R hWSVS UWS`WU O\ RS` DTSWTS& =QV PZOaS RS\ FOcQV d]\ [W` c\R aQVZWSrS SW\ ^OO` AW\cbS\ RWS 5cUS\& =QV VOPS YSW\S 5V\c\U$ eWS Sa eSWbS`USVS\ a]ZZ$ ZSV\S [WQV USUS\ RWS KO\R c\R ZOaaS [WQV d]\ RS` 8`]US eO`[ SW\VwZZS\$ c[ \WQVb RO`O\ hc RS\YS\& 8WSaS YZSW\S ?OPW\S$ \WQVba OZa SW\ Kw`TSZ Oca @WQVb$ G^WSUSZUZOa c\R eSWrS` :O`PS$ UWPb GWQVS`VSWb$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U PW\ WQV `cVWU& =QV ZOaaS [WQV O\ RS` KO\R VS`c\bS`UZSWbS\$ RO[Wb aWQV RWS O\USa^O\\bS\$ dS`Y`O[^TbS\ AcaYSZ\ Z]QYS`\& 9a Wab SW\ ;STwVZ$ OZa Yv\\bS\ [W` RWS ;ZWSR[OrS\ PWa OcT RS\ ZSbhbS\ :W\US` OPTOZZS\& 5Za UW\US [SW\ OZZhc TZwQVbWU hcaO[[S\USaSbhbS` ?v`^S` Oca RS[ @SW[& DZvbhZWQV aSVS WQV eWSRS` B]OV d]` [W`$ eWS S` W[ >O^]\WQO eSW\b& 8S\ ?]^T aQVwbbSZb c\R aQVZcQVhb& AW` aOUb$ WQV a]ZZS \WQVb `SRS\$ WV[ \WQVba S`YZs`S\$ S` eWaaS US\Oc$ ROaa WQV VWUV aSW$ [O\ aSVS Sa [W` PWa W\ RWS <OO`a^WbhS\ O\& G] aQV\SZZ eWS [vUZWQV ZSUS WQV \OQV& 9a ROcS`b SW\ ^OO` NwUS$ PWa ROa GQV`SQYS\aPWZR d]\ B]OV dS`PZOaab$ c\R \OQV SW\ ^OO` eSWbS`S\ <Wba Wab Sa RO\\ S\RUwZbWU OcaUSb`WSPS\& =\ RS` YZSW\S\ ?OPW\S abSVb RS` EcOZ[$ c\R WQV eSWr$ ROaa WQV eSU [caa& BOQV RS` \sQVabS\ RWQYS\ DTSWTS TsZZb [W` ^ZvbhZWQV ROa G]<] ;`O\R <]bSZ SW\$ ROa W\ RS` BsVS aSW\ [caa c\R W\ RS[ WQV hc[ ;ZwQY \WQVb PSYO\\b PW\& =QV aSbhS [WQV OcT`SQVb c\R eWSUS [WQV W[ ;SRO\YS\ O\ SW\ aOcPS`Sa$ T`WaQVSa <]bSZhW[[S`$ esV`S\R aWQV W[[S` [SV` FOcQV c\bS` RS` 8SQYS RS` ?OPW\S Y`scaSZb& J]\ HObS\R`O\U S`TwZZb Rc`QV [SW\S\ DZO\$ RWS 5caaWQVb OcT SW\S 6ZSWPS$ ZOaaS WQV ROa :ScS`hScU OPYwVZS\ c\R YSV`S W\ RS\ @ORS\ hc`wQY& =[ ;SVS\ [S`YS WQV$ ROaa [SW\S >SO\a \WQVb [SV` ]PS\ PZSWPb& CPe]VZ WQV aQV]\ [SW\S\ OZbS\ PZOcS\ ?OaQV[W`^cZZ]dS` VW\SW\USabSQYb VOPS$ `cbaQVb RWS dS`aWTTbS$ OPUSeSbhbS @SdWa ROcS`\R `c\bS`& 6Sd]` WQV W\ ROa <]bSZ USVS$ [caa WQV [W` SW\ \ScSa @]QV W\ RS\ ;w`bSZ abO\hS\ ZOaaS\& 8Oa G]cbS``OW\ RSa @ORS\a Wab jSbhb VSZZS`$ OZa WQV Sa W\ 9`W\\S`c\U VObbS$ c\R YZSW\S`& =QV PSTw`QVbS$ ROaa [O\ [WQV `OcQVS\ USVv`b VOb c\R jSbhb RS\ EcOZ[ `WSQVb$ RS` Oca RS` ]TTS\S\ ?OPW\S\bw` R`W\Ub& CV\S RS\ DcZZ]dS` O\hc^`]PWS`S\$ ZOcTS WQV hc RS` :`Oc [Wb RS\ ]^OZPZOcS\ 5cUS\ V]QV c\R aOUS WV`$ WQV [vQVbS WV\ [Wb\SV[S\& GWS hWSVb [SW\S

RS\ ]^OZPZOcS\ 5cUS\ V]QV c\R aOUS WV`$ WQV [vQVbS WV\ [Wb\SV[S\& GWS hWSVb [SW\S ?`SRWbYO`bS Rc`QV$ c\R OZa aWS SW\S HOaQVS VS`d]`V]Zb$ OcT RS` c\bS\ _cS` 7V`Wab]^VS` :WaQVS` abSVb$ aSVS WQV [WQV W\ RS[ @ORS\ c[& 8S` US^TZSUbS$ c\S`U`w\RZWQVS 7VWQ d]\ d]`VW\ Wab dS`aQVec\RS\$ jSbhb eW`Yb OZZSa hcaO[[S\USab]^^SZb c\R Rw\\& 8WS HOaQVS aWSVb Y][WaQV Oca$ hc aQVeS`$ hc Pc\b$ hc ^`]bhWU$ eWS SW\ FS_cWaWb Oca SW\S[ ?SZZS`bVSObS`abwQY wPS`a 9W\YOcTS\& 8WS C^OZscUWUS aQVZsUb RS\ DcZZ]dS` W\ GSWRS\^O^WS` SW\$ abSQYb WV\ W\ RWS D`]bhbOaQVS$ UWPb [W` [SW\S\ 6]\ c\R ew\aQVb [W` SW\S\ aQVv\S\ 5PS\R& =QV [S`YS$ eWS [W` RWS FSOZWbsb S\bUZSWbSb$ OZa WQV RWS HOaQVS \SV[S& =ab ROa ;O\hS SW\S :OZZS4 5PS` eWS VsbbS\ aWS eWaaS\ a]ZZS\$ ROaa WQV VS`Y][[S4 =QV VOabS Oca RS[ @ORS\ VW\Oca OcT RWS K]]abS` Gb`SSb& 9W\ ^OO` HOYbS a^sbS` Vv`S WQV$ eWS jS[O\R aQV`WZZ$ \S`dva$ [Wb GwRabOObS\OYhS\b [SW\S\ BO[S\ `cTb& 6WZZ$ ]V$ VOZZ]$ 6WZZ& =QV S`abO``S& FCG=94 4 8WS Q`OQY`OcQVS\RS OZbS ?]\hS^bYw\abZS`W\ Oca RS` *+`R Gb`SSb4 KOa [OQVb aWS VWS`4 <S``U]bb$ abSQYb aWS RO SbeO [Wb R`W\4 =QV PZWQYS [WQV c[ c\R aSVS YSW\ PSYO\\bSa ;SaWQVb& =QV VOPS <S`hYZ]^TS\$ c\R SW\ jsVS` 6ZcbO\R`O\U W[ ?]^T aQV\w`b [W` RWS ?SVZS hc& 8O\\ Wab aWS RO2 6O`PO`O& 9W\S `SWhS\RS$ W[[S` bORSZZ]a USYZSWRSbS :`Oc$ RWS OcaZs\RWaQVS JS`ZOUS PS`sb$ SW\ a]US\O\\bS` GQ]cb& =QV YS\\S aWS$ eS\\ OcQV \WQVb Ucb$ aSWb >OV`S\& GWS [cabS`b [WQV PSa]`Ub$ OPS` \WQVb c\T`Sc\RZWQV$ c\R WQV aOUS Yc`h VOZZ] c\R USVS eSWbS`$ PSd]` aWQV SW\ ;Sa^`sQV S\ba^W\\S\ YO\\& GWS hc aSVS\ ZS\Yb [SW\S ;SRO\YS\ ^`][^b OcTa 6wQVS`[OQVS\$ OcT RWS 5US\bc`$ ?ObS$ c\aS`S 5\USabSZZbS\$ [SW\S 5cb]`S\ x <S``U]bb$ a] dWSZS 5cb]`S\& I\R RO[Wb S`eOQVS\ RWS BO[S\$ ;SaWQVbS` c\R GbW[[S\ as[bZWQVS` JS`ZSUS`$ @SYb]`S\$ 5US\bS\$ GQ]cba$ KS`PSZScbS c\R 5aaWabS\bS\ RS` FSWVS \OQV hc[ @SPS\ eWS SW\ U`]rSa ZOcTS\RSa KO\RPWZR x c\R OZZS aW\R S[^v`b c\R aQVW[^TS\& 8O\\ abSZZS\ aWQV RWS 9`W\\S`c\US\ O\ B]OV c\R O\ RS\ 9\bhcU eWSRS` SW\& 8WS D`]bhbOaQVS W\ RS` SW\S\ <O\R c\R [SW\S ?`SRWbYO`bS W\ RS` O\RS`S\$ VOabS WQV eSabes`ba hc[ G]<] ;`O\R& =QV aSVS x RO\YS$ ZWSPS` ;]bb$ RO\YS x SW\ @SRS`eO`S\USaQVsTb$ USVS a]T]`b VW\SW\$ \SV[S [SW\S\ ;w`bSZ OP c\R PWbbS RO`c[$ [W` SW\ ^OO` \ScS @vQVS` SW\hcabO\hS\& 8Oa Wab jSbhb ROa R`WbbS AOZ W\ RS\ ZSbhbS\ Tw\T K]QVS\& 9W\[OZ VOPS WQV [W` W`US\Re] W\ SW\S[ <]bSZhW[[S` [Wb RS[ ASaaS` aSZPab heSW OZZS`RW\Ua eS\WUS` TSW\S @vQVS` VW\SW\USab]QVS\& 8S` OZbS ?\OPS VW\bS` RS` KO\R Oca <O\R% c\R 6`WSTbOaQVS\ PSscUb RS\ OPUSeSbhbS\ ;w`bSZ c\R [WQV d]`aWQVbWU c\R aOUb2 GWS P`OcQVS\ [SV` OZa \c` SW\ ^OO`& 9` [OQVb dWS`$ c\R OZa WQV RS\ ;w`bSZ c[PW\RS$ ^Oaab S` [wVSZ]a W\a ZSbhbS @]QV& =QV wPS`ZSUS$ ]P WQV [W` \]QV SW\a [OQVS\ ZOaaS\ a]ZZ$ OPS` RS` AO\\ VOb a] aQV\SZZ USZ]QVb c\R OPUS`SQV\Sb$ ROaa WQV UZOcPS$ S` [vQVbS [WQV Z]aeS`RS\& =QV USVS SW\ ^OO` Gb`OrS\ eSWbS` W\ FWQVbc\U <]bSZ$ eSWr OPS`$ ROaa WQV [SW\S\ aWTTWUS\ DcZZ]dS` OcahWSVS\ [caa$ PSd]` WQV VW\Y][[S& =QV b`OUS WV\ aSWb wPS` SW\S[ A]\Ob& 9` Wab dvZZWU OcaUSZSWS`b$ c\R aWQVS` PW\ WQV [W` heO` \WQVb$ OPS` WQV PSTw`QVbS$ RWS c\RSTW\WS`PO`S ab`SWTWUS ?`cabS d]`\ c\R O[ ?`OUS\ Ts\Ub O\ hc abW\YS\&

9W\ ^OO` 9QYS\ eSWbS` aSVS WQV SW\S\ YZSW\S\ QVW\SaWaQVS\ =[PWaa& 9a Wab a] SW\S` [Wb US`ORS [OZ R`SW ]RS` dWS` HWaQVS\$ VOc^basQVZWQV Gb`OrS\dS`YOcT& 5Za WQV SW\b`SbS$ aW\R YSW\S ;sabS RO& =QV USVS hc` HVSYS c\R T`OUS$ ]P WQV RWS H]WZSbbS PS\cbhS\ RO`T$ c\R RS` >c\US$ S` Wab VvQVabS\a aSQVhSV\$ aOUb$ RWS aSW \c` Tw` ;sabS PSabW[[b& 9W\S :`Oc$ dS`[cbZWQV aSW\S AcbbS`$ Y][[b VW\hc c\R PSY`sTbWUb$ Sa aSW YSW\ vTTS\bZWQVSa K7& =QV [caa [WQV c[hWSVS\$ c\R RO WQV ZO\UaO[ OcQV eWSRS` SW\S\ NcU P`OcQVS$ PSabSZZS WQV R`SW ;S`WQVbS c\R SW\ ^OO` 6`vbQVS\ [Wb 9W hc[ AWb\SV[S\ c\R T`OUS ZSWQVb US`SWhb$ ]P WQV jSbhb hc` H]WZSbbS USVS\ RO`T& 8WS :`Oc aOUb jO$ eS\\ WQV d]`VS` PShOVZS& 8Oa bcS WQV& =QV USVS O\ RS` HVSYS c\R O\ RS` ?wQVS d]`PSW hc SW\S[ eW\hWUS\ ?Z]& Nc[ ;ZwQY VOb Sa SW\ :S\abS` c\R SW\S\ G^WSUSZ& =QV R`SVS RS\ KOaaS`VOV\ OcT c\R PSbsbWUS RWS G^wZc\U$ RO[Wb [O\ ROa ?ZWQYS\ RSa :ScS`hScUa c\R ROa ?\OQYS\ RS` 8`]US PSW[ 5\hw\RS\ \WQVb Vv`b& =QV ZORS RWS DTSWTS c\R P`S\\S aWS O\& 8O\\ ab]^TS WQV aWS S`\Scb$ eSWZ WQV \OQV RS` S`abS\ @ORc\U \]QV Zs\Uab \WQVb S\ba^O\\b PW\& 5Za WQV hWSVS$ a^`W\Ub RS` GbSW\ Oca RS[ FvV`QVS\$ c\R ROa ;ZOa a^ZWbbS`b& 8Oa ^OaaWS`b [Wbc\bS`$ eS\\ [O\ SW\ U`]rSa$ YOZbSa GbwQY 7`OQY W\ RWS \]QV VSWrS DTSWTS abSQYb c\R aWS hc aQV\SZZ O\hw\RSb& G] ZSWaS eWS [vUZWQV ZSaS WQV RWS G^ZWbbS` OcT$ TW\RS RS\ hc[ ;ZwQY \]QV UO\hS\ GbSW\ c\R abSQYS WV\ eWSRS` W\ RWS O\USY\OQYabS DTSWTS& =\heWaQVS\ PW\ WQV a] S``SUb$ ROaa WQV \]QV [SV` VW\SW\^OQYS& 8Oa Wab SW\S USPOZZbS @ORc\U3 WQV PZOaS RS\ FOcQV Oca RS[ :S\abS` c\R a^w`S RO\YPO`$ eWS ROa ;STwVZ RS` 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U wPS` [WQV Y][[b& =QV aQVsZS [WQV Oca RS[ DcZZ]dS` c\R PSb`OQVbS [SW\S\ CPS`Yv`^S` W\ RS[ YZSW\S\ G^WSUSZ& qPS`OZZ abSVS\ RWS FW^^S\ c\R ?\]QVS\ VS`d]`$ c\R [SW\S <Ocb Wab VSZZU`Oc& ?ZSW\S ?`ObhS` c\R 6`O\R[OZS aW\R OcT 5`[S\$ 6`cab c\R 6OcQV dS`ab`Scb& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ VOPS WQV YSW\S @cab OcT GSf$ OZa es`S WQV W\ SW\S\ FOcaQVhcabO\R O\RS`S` 5`b USZO\Ub$ W\ RS[ GSf YSW\S F]ZZS [SV` a^WSZb& 8Oa PS`cVWUb [WQV$ RS\\ RS\ ?v`^S` RO W[ G^WSUSZ [vQVbS WQV \WS[O\RS[ hSWUS\& =QV aSVS [W` RWS aQVZW[[abS\ 6`O\R[OZS c\R ?`ObhS`$ RWS O\ RS\ <s\RS\ c\R I\bS`O`[S\ aW\R$ US\OcS` O\$ c\R Sa T`vabSZb [WQV& B]QV SW\[OZ aQVOcS WQV W\ RS\ G^WSUSZ c\R aSVS$ eWS eS\WU <Ocb WQV VOPS x SW\ VOcQVRw\\S`$ ab`OTT USa^O\\bS` ?\]QVS\PShcU& 9a aWSVb Oca$ OZa es`S WQV VOZPdS`Vc\US`b SW\S[ :ScS` S\babWSUS\& B]QV \WS VOPS WQV [SW\S 6SQYS\Y\]QVS\ a] d][ 6OcQV OPabSVS\ USaSVS\ eWS jSbhb$ c\R OZa WQV RS\ DcZZ]dS` wPS`hWSVS$ PW\ WQV T`]V$ ROaa RWSaSa VS``ZWQVS$ RWQYS Kc\RS`eS`Y Oca K]ZZS ROa OZZSa dS`VwZZb& =QV eOaQVS [W` ;SaWQVb c\R <s\RS$ S\bTS`\S RWdS`aS :ZSQYS d]\ [SW\S\ >SO\a c\R eWaQVS <OO`S$ GbOcP c\R :caaSZ\ d][ GQVW`[ [SW\S` b`ScS\ AwbhS& :W\RS JWaW\S W\ [SW\S` >OQYS c\R b`s\YS [W` RWS 5cUS\ RO[Wb& G^wZS RS\ Ac\R [Wb :ZwaaWUaSWTS Oca c\R `SWPS [W` OcQV eSZQVS c\bS` RWS 5QVaSZ\$ c[ SbeOWUS 5caRw\abc\US\ d]\ R]`b hc dS`RSQYS\& =QV hw\RS [W` \]QV SW\S DTSWTS O\$ PZOaS R`OcT$ RO[Wb aWS OPYwVZb$ eWQYZS aWS SW\$ abSQYS RS\ OZbS\ DcZZ]dS` W\ RWS H`OUSbOaQVS c\R vTT\S RWS Hw`$ RWS hc` ?wQVS c\R \OQV d]`\ hc[ =[PWaa TwV`b& 8]`b aW\R heSW As\\S` W\ RWQYS\ >OQYS\$ Rc\YZS\ <]aS\ c\R U`OcS\ GQVcVS\$ OcaUS[OQVbS DS\\Sga$ c\R aWS aSVS\ [WQV RW`SYb O\$ OZa WQV hc` HVSYS USVS& 8Oa 9aaS\ Wab SW\USbwbSb$ WQV aQV\O^^S Sa [W`$ RO\YS RS` :`Oc c\R RS[ >c\US\ c\R dS`aQVeW\RS& =QV USVS \OQV KSabS\$ c\R OZa WQV [WQV c[R`SVS$ aSVS WQV$ eWS RWS PSWRS\

dS`aQVeW\RS& =QV USVS \OQV KSabS\$ c\R OZa WQV [WQV c[R`SVS$ aSVS WQV$ eWS RWS PSWRS\ DS\\Sga Oca RS[ =[PWaa Y][[S\ c\R VW\bS` [W` VS` [O`aQVWS`S\& =QV eSQVaZS [SV`[OZa RWS FWQVbc\U$ c\R \OQV SbeO heO\hWU AW\cbS\ [SW\S WQV aWS OPUSaQVwbbSZb hc VOPS\& =QV eS`TS ROa QVW\SaWaQVS 9aaS\ c\R RWS H`OUSbOaQVS [Wb [SW\S[ OZbS\ DcZZ]dS` W\ SW\S\ AwZZSW[S`& ASW\ <S`h aQVZsUb VSTbWU$ c\R WQV VOPS 5\Uab$ d]` ZOcbS` DO\WY RWS 5\[SZRc\U W[ G]<] ;`O\R hc dS`[OaaSZ\& 8O WQV OPS` hc \S`dva PW\$ c[ S`ab \]QV W\ SW\S` 6O` SbeOa hc b`W\YS\$ RS\YS WQV$ 5cUS\ hc c\R Rc`QV& =QV P`OcQVS \c` ROa NW[[S`& KS\\ WQV S`ab RO PW\$ eW`R OZZSa Ucb& 6W\ WQV S`ab RO$ YO\\ WQV RS\ NW[[S`aS`dWQS `cTS\$ <O^^g O\`cTS\$ c\R SW\ ^OO` :ZOaQVS\ K]RYO b`W\YS\$ c[ RS` 5\Uab RWS G^WbhS hc \SV[S\& =QV Y]\hS\b`WS`S [WQV USRO\YZWQV OcT RWS JS`aQV\OcT^OcaS W[ <]bSZhW[[S`$ OPS` W\aUSVSW[ Wab [W` aQV]\ YZO`$ ROaa \WQVba [SV` USVb$ RO WQV \c` \]QV eS\WU ;SZR VOPS$ YSW\ ?WZ] [SV` hc dWSZ c\R YOc[ \]QV SW\S AvUZWQVYSWb$ [WQV hc dS`abSQYS\& =`US\ReWS \OVb ROa 9\RS& =QV USVS W\ SW\ 8SZW O\ RS` 9QYS d]`[ <]bSZ$ YOcTS hSV\ :ScS`hScUS$ aSQVa GQVOQVbSZ\ GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\ c\R SW\ GSQVaS`^OQY 6WS`$ RO[Wb WQV UZSWQV$ eS\\ WQV W[ NW[[S` PW\$ SbeOa hc b`W\YS\ VOPS& Nc US`\ [vQVbS WQV SW\S DTSWTS `OcQVS\$ PSd]` WQV ROa <]bSZ PSb`SbS$ OPS` Sa VSWrb$ jSbhb ]RS` \WS& =QV USVS W\ RS\ BScPOc Oca 6OQYabSW\ c\R ;ZOa$ c\R esV`S\R WQV a] ZO\UaO[ c\R `cVWU eWS [vUZWQV RWS GbcTS\ VW\OcTabSWUS$ RS\YS WQV O\ ROa aOcPS`S 6SbbhScU$ RWS a^`cRSZ\RS 8caQVS$ RS\ NW[[S`aS`dWQS$ RWS a^WSUSZPZO\YS\ AvPSZ$ RWS GWQVS`VSWb& =\ RS` <OZZS eW[[SZb Sa d]\ Hg^S\$ RWS \OQV D`]RcYbW]\aOaaWabS\bS\ d][ :WZ[ OcaaSVS\ x AwbhS\$ >SO\a c\R GQV[cRRSZ& ;]bb aSW 8O\Y& ;]bb aSW 8O\Y TOZZS WQV \WQVb OcT& G]T]`b abSZZS WQV [W` d]`$ ROaa WQV Oca @5 USY][[S\ PW\$ c[ VWS` hc R`SVS\$ c\R ROaa jSRS` [SW\S <c\US`USabOZb$ RWS FW\US c\bS` RS\ `]bS\ 5cUS\ c\R RWS TSbbWUS\ <OO`S$ RWS c\bS` RS` AwbhS VS`d]`aQVOcS\$ OcT Y\O^^S D`]RcYbW]\abS`[W\S c\R ZO\US 5PS\RS W[ GQV\SWRS`Oc[ PSW[ GWQVbS\ RS` 8OWZWSa hc`wQYTwV`S\ eW`R& AWb RWSaS[ Kc\aQVUSTZW[[S` W[ ?]^T USVS WQV hc[ 9[^TO\U c\R T`OUS \OQV SW\S[ NW[[S`& KWS ZO\US4$ T`OUb RWS :`Oc$ c\R WQV `SQV\S Yc`h RWS -(( 8]ZZO` ^`] BOQVb c\R ROa 7`OQY Rc`QV$ ROa WQV PSW <O^^g PSabSZZS\ eWZZ& :w` dWS` HOUS$ aOUS WQV WV`$ c\R WQV [waaS [WQV c\bS` SW\S[ 8SQY\O[S\ O\[SZRS\ c\R P`scQVbS SW\ FOcQVS`hW[[S`& GWS hcQYb [Wb YSW\S` KW[^S`& ;S`\$ aOUb aWS$ hWSVb [SW\S ?`SRWbYO`bS Rc`QV$ eW`Tb SW\S\ 6ZWQY W\ [SW\S\ DOaa$ UWPb [W` SW\S GQVZwaaSZYO`bS$ c\R eSU PW\ WQV& =[ 5cThcU c\bS`eSUa hc[ R`Wbb]PS`abS\ Gb]QY YWQVS`S WQV Tv`[ZWQV d]` 5cT`SUc\U c\R 9`ZSWQVbS`c\U& 8O ]PS\ Rw`TbS Sa V]QV US\cU aSW\$ c[ hc a^`W\US\& KS\\ OZZS Gb`WQYS `SWrS\$ PZSWPb ROa \]QV& 8Oa NW[[S` Wab YZSW\$ aQVeOQV PSZScQVbSb c\R USVb \OQV GwReSabS\& 8WS @WQVbS` d]\ G]<]$ H`WPSQO c\R KOZZ Gb`SSb bO\hS\ c\R PZW\YS\ USUS\wPS` RS\ U`]rS\ :S\abS`\$ c\R OZa WQV RS\ FOc[ PSb`SbS$ Y][[S WQV [W` d]` eWS W[ =\\S`\ SW\S` V]QV wPS` RS` GbORb aQVeSPS\RS\ GQV\SSYcUSZ& =QV abSZZS [WQV O\a :S\abS` c\R `cTS hc[ ZSbhbS\ AOZ <O^^g O\& 9` Y][[b USUS\ SW\a& J]` SW\S` Gbc\RS VOPS WQV OcTUS`OcQVb$ eOa \]QV d]\ RS` HwbS PSW F]aWS wP`WU eO`$ c\R [SW\S DTSWTS Wab jSbhb \]QV UO\hS Tw\T NS\bW[SbS` ZO\U$ dS`Y`cabSb [Wb

F]aWS wP`WU eO`$ c\R [SW\S DTSWTS Wab jSbhb \]QV UO\hS Tw\T NS\bW[SbS` ZO\U$ dS`Y`cabSb [Wb c\`OcQVPO` dS`P`O\\bS\ FSabS\& 6SW [SW\S[ 5\`cT Gbc\RS\ hcd]` VOPS WQV 7`OQY Tw` heSWbOcaS\R 8]ZZO` PSabSZZb& G] dWSZ eWS \]QV \WS& =QV YO\\ WV[ \c` )-(( W\ PO` USPS\ x ROa$ eOa WQV d]` AWbbS`\OQVb \]QV Oca RS[ 5cb][ObS\ hWSVS\ Y]\\bS$ c\R bOcaS\R RO\OQV& =QV PWbbS WV\$ [W` RS\ FSab Oca\OV[aeSWaS hc S`ZOaaS\& BOQV SW\S[ Yc`hS\ NvUS`\ ZSUb S` [W` RWS HwbS\ c\R RWS \ScS\ DTSWTS\ VW\& BSbbSa <]bSZ$ [SW\b S`$ aSW\S S`abS 6S[S`Yc\U wPS`VOc^b hc [SW\S\ 5cTS\bVOZba]`bS\$ \SbbSa NW[[S`& I\R RO[Wb USVb S`& 6SW[ 5\PZWQY RS` dWS`hWU HwbS\ 7`OQY OcT [SW\S` 6SbbRSQYS$ [SV` OZa WQV jS OcT SW\S[ <OcTS\ USaSVS\ VOPS$ TwVZS WQV [WQV a] aWQVS` eWS RS\ UO\hS\ HOU \]QV \WQVb& 8WS HwbS\ aSVS\ d]ZZS`$ d]ZZUS^OQYbS` Oca OZa a]\ab$ c\R RWS :wZZS$ ROa bO\hS\RS @WQVb d]` RS[ :S\abS` c\R ROa 6SecaabaSW\$ ROaa WQV RWSaS\ FOc[ \WQVb [SV` dS`ZOaaS\ eS`RS$ dS`aSbhS\ [WQV aQV]\ d]` RS[ S`abS\ NcU W\ <]QVabW[[c\U& =QV ZSUS [WQV OcTa 6Sbb c\R ZOaaS [W` RWS HwbS\ OcTa ;SaWQVb c\R OcT RWS 6`cab TOZZS\$ S`ab SW\hSZ\$ RO\\ OZZS OcT SW\[OZ& 9a Wab SW\ ;STwVZ RSa 5\USY][[S\aSW\a& 8Oa 9\RS SW\S` FSWaS& BWQVb \c` RS` Y]^TZ]aS\ HOUS c\R BsQVbS c\R K]QVS\ aSWb RS[ FwQYTOZZ$ a]\RS`\ RS` UO\hS\ ZO\US\ FSWaS$ RSa UO\hS\ c\\wbhS\ ?O[^Ta& 8S` GObh Oca jS\S[ 6cQV abSZZb aWQV eWSRS` SW\$ PSY][[b jSbhb OPS` SW\S\ \ScS\ GW\\& 9a eO` a]eSWb& =QV hWSVS RWS J]`Vs\US hc$ ab]^TS [W` SW\S RS` \ScS\ DTSWTS\ c\R ZOaaS RWS ?`w[SZ TZWSUS\ eWS \]QV \WS& 9a a^WSZb YSW\S F]ZZS& 8WSaS\ 6S`U PSY][[S WQV \WQVb eSU& 8Oa YO\\ WQV c\[vUZWQV ZSPS\R wPS`abSVS\& =QV [OQVS [W` RWS \sQVabS DTSWTS& I\R \]QV SW\S& I\R \]QV SW\S& <O^^g VOb [W` OQVb DTSWTS\ USUSPS\$ c\R WQV ZORS \]QV heSW$ RO[Wb WQV \WQVb S`ab SW\S OPYwVZS\ ZOaaS\ [caa$ PSd]` WQV RWS \sQVabS `OcQVS& :Oab SW\S Gbc\RS ZO\U W\VOZWS`S WQV c\c\bS`P`]QVS\$ \OQYb$ c\R Ob[S ROPSW [SV` FOcQV OZa @cTb SW\& FOcQV S`TwZZb [WQV x eO`[$ Y\WabS`\R$ U`]r& =QV TwVZS [WQV aQVeS`SZ]a W\ RS[ aQVc[[`WUS\ FOc[& =QV PW\ PSW\OV \WQVba& 6OZR eS`RS WQV S\RUwZbWU \WQVba aSW\& =QV ZOaaS [W` d][ NW[[S`aS`dWQS TZOaQVS\eSWaS K]RYO P`W\US\$ OPS` \WQVba hc SaaS\& =QV `OcQVS c\R b`W\YS RWS UO\hS BOQVb$ c\R PWa hc[ A]`US\ VOPS WQV SW\ 8`WbbSZ d]\ <O^^ga HwbS\ US`OcQVb c\R PSTw`QVbS$ ROaa RS` J]``Ob \WQVb `SWQVb& BOQV AWbbS`\OQVb V]ZS WQV [W` bOcaS\R Oca RS[ 5cb][ObS\$ `cTS FWQ] O\ c\R PWbbS WV\$ [W` Tw` heSWbOcaS\R hc ZWSTS`\$ RWS heSWbS\ HOcaS\R PSYs[S S` O[ \sQVabS\ HOU& =QV VOPS FWQ] \]QV \WS c[ SW\S\ J]`aQVcaa USPSbS\$ R]QV S` hvUS`b \WQVb& 5Za S` USUS\ heSW IV` T`wV S`aQVSW\b$ PcZZWU$ aQV`sU$ W\ SW\S[ eSWbS\ `]bS\ H%GVW`b x UWPb S` [W` RWS <sZTbS OcT Dc[^ c\R ZSUb a]UO` \]QV Tw` heSWVc\RS`b R`OcT& 5cTa <Oca$ aOUb S`& =aa eOa$ AO\\$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U aWSVb S` PSa]`Ub Oca& 5PS` \c` SW\S\ A][S\b$ c\R RO\\ Wab S` eSU& =QV `OTTS RWS HwbQVS\ hcaO[[S\& 9a aW\R \]QV [SV` OZa O[ 5PS\R hcd]`$ OPS` RO WQV \c` \]QV dWS`bOcaS\R OcT RS[ ?]\b] VOPS c\R RWS <]bSZ`SQV\c\U ZscTb$ [OQVS WQV [W` b`]bhRS[ eWSRS` ;SRO\YS\$ ]P Sa `SWQVb& 8S` H]R c\R ROa ZSS`S 6O\YY]\b] ZWSUS\ ?]^T O\ ?]^T$ c\R WQV aSbhS OZZSa OcT RS\ GWSU RSa 9`abS`S\& =QV \SV[S RWS GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\ Oca WV`S` JS`^OQYc\U$ R`wQYS aWS SW\hSZ\ Oca RS\ RWQYS\ 6ZWabS`YO`bS\& =QV eS`TS RWS HOPZSbbS\ W\ SW\ KOaaS`UZOa Oca RS[

6OR c\R aQVwbbS ROa UO\hS 7`OQY W\ SW\ O\RS`Sa& 8OPSW hWbbS`\ [W` RWS <s\RS$ c\R [SW\ UO\hS` ?v`^S` aQVZ]bbS`b W[ HOYb [SW\Sa <S`haQVZOUa& =QV b`W\YS RS\ K]RYO eWS KOaaS` c\R VOPS jSRSa AOZ$ eS\\ WQV heSW \ScS :ZOaQVS\ PSabSZZS$ 5\Uab$ RWS >c\Ua d][ NW[[S`aS`dWQS Yv\\bS\ O[ 9[^TO\U [SZRS\$ ROaa VWS` ]PS\ SbeOa AS`Yew`RWUSa OPUSVb& 8S` heSWbS A]`US\ Wab RO$ c\R ROa NW[[S` eW`Yb YZSW\S`& 8S` HOU R`OcrS\ Wab U`Oc$ c\R ]Pe]VZ WQV d][ :S\abS` OcT JWS`bSZ PZWQYS$ W\ RS\S\ WQV aSWb >OV`S\ SaaS\ USVS$ SW\YOcTS c\R VS`c[ZOcTS$ Y][[b Sa [W` d]`$ OZa asVS WQV SW\S GbORb$ W\ RS` WQV \]QV \WS eO`& BWQVba Y][[b [W` PSYO\\b d]`$ c\R Sa aQVSW\b eS\WUS` SW\ C`b hc aSW\$ RS\ WQV S`Yc\RS\ YO\\$ eS\\ WQV [Wb RS[ 5cThcU \OQV c\bS\ TOV`S$ OZa SW\ :]b] ]RS` SW\ KO\RUS[sZRS hc[ 5\aQVOcS\& =QV `OcQVS eSWbS` c\R PW\ T`]V$ ROaa ROa @wTbc\UaagabS[ RWS FOcQVe]ZYS\$ RWS WQV Ocaab]rS$ UZSWQV OPaOcUb& 5crS`RS[ VOPS WQV ROa :S\abS` SW\S\ G^OZb eSWb USvTT\Sb$ RO[Wb T`WaQVS @cTb VS`SW\Y][[b$ c\R [OQVS [W` RWSa[OZ OcQV YSW\S ;SRO\YS\$ ROaa O\RS`S\ ;sabS\ ]RS` RS[ DS`a]\OZ RS` ;S`cQV OcT RS[ ;O\U OcTTOZZS\ Yv\\bS& AWb SW\S[ <O\RbcQV c[ RWS <wTbS b`SbS WQV O\a :S\abS` c\R aSVS OcT RS[ DO`Y^ZObh VW\bS` RS[ <]bSZ SW\S FSWVS aQVeO`hS` GIJa c\R [SV`S`S Rc\YZS @W[]caW\S\ \SPS\SW\O\RS` abSVS\& 9a [waaS\ \Sc\ KOUS\ aSW\$ c\R WQV YO\\ Sa \WQVb US\Oc S`YS\\S\$ [SW\S OPS`$ ROaa W\ jSRS[ d]`\S heSW DS`a]\S\ aWbhS\& AW` ab]QYb RS` 5bS[& 9W\S` VOb ]TTS\PO` SW\ :S`\UZOa W\ RS` <O\R& ASW\ <S`h Ts\Ub O\ hc Vs[[S`\& 9a aWSVb Oca$ OZa VsbbS\ aWS OZZS SW\ :S`\UZOa& 5QVbhSV\ :S`\UZsaS`$ RW`SYb OcT RWSaSa :S\abS`$ RWSaSa NW[[S`$ [WQV US`WQVbSb& 8Oa <O\RbcQV `cbaQVb [W` `c\bS`$ c\R WQV Y\WS [WQV VW\ c\R aSVS OcT ?\WS\ Oca RS[ :S\abS`& 9W\S` d]\ WV\S\ eW\Yb& 9a Wab aQVeS` hc aOUS\$ OPS` WQV PW\ [W` aWQVS`$ S` eW\Yb VW\bS` RS` GQVSWPS& 8Oa ;ZOa a^WSUSZb$ OPS` R]QV$ jO$ RS` 5`[ eW\Yb& JS`RO[[b$ RWS eW\YS\ OZZS& AWb RS` SW\S\ <O\R eW\YS\ aWS$ W\ RS` O\RS`S\ VOZbS\ aWS ROa :S`\UZOa& 9a Wab$ OZa VsbbS WQV SW\S\ Gb`][aQVZOU PSY][[S\& 8WS 5`[S c\R RS` <OZa bc\ [W` eSV$ c\R WQV PW\ Yc`h d]` RS[ <S`hO\TOZZ& JS`RO[[b$ dS`RO[[b$ J9F85AAH$ `cTS WQV d]` [WQV VW\& =QV `S\\S Rc`QVa NW[[S`$ TwZZS SW\ ;ZOa PWa hc[ FO\R [Wb K]RYO c\R ZSS`S Sa OcT SW\S\ NcU& J9F85AAH& GQV]\ aQV\O^^S WQV [W` SW\S \ScS DTSWTS c\R ^OQYS aWS d]ZZ& G7<9=GG9 $ aQV`SWS WQV$ OZa WQV aWS O\hw\RS\ eWZZ& 6SW ]TTS\S\ J]`Vs\US\ YO\\ WQV \WQVb `OcQVS\& BWQVb$ eS\\ RWS OZZS hcaSVS\& 5PS` eS\\ WQV aWS hchWSVS$ abw`[S\ aWS ROa NW[[S`& =QV ZOcTS W\a 6OR c\R R`SVS RWS 8caQVS OcT$ c[ ROa ?ZWQYS\ RSa :ScS`hScUa hc wPS`bv\S\ c\R ROa ZOcbS ?\OQYS\$ eS\\ RWS :ZO[[S ROa wPS`U`]rS GbwQY 7`OQY O[ 9\RS RSa FvV`QVS\a O\P`S\\b& 9`ab \OQV R`SW bWSTS\ NwUS\ Wab Sa OcTUS`OcQVb$ c\R WQV aQV\O^^S [W` SW\ <O\RbcQV c\R ZSUS Sa c\bS\ d]` RWS 6ORShW[[S`bw`& DZvbhZWQV TsZZb [W` OcT$ ROaa RWS @wTbc\U W[ 6OR \WQVb OZZhc dWSZ bOcUb& 8S` FOcQV Vs\Ub aQVeS` c\R RWQVb c\bS` RS` 8SQYS& =QV USVS W\a NW[[S` hc`wQY& CV\S Oca RS[ :S\abS` hc aSVS\$ aQVZWSrS WQV RWS J]`Vs\US$ aSbhS [WQV OcTa 6Sbb$ ZORS RWS DTSWTS c\R `OcQVS& I\R \]QV [OZ& I\R \]QV [OZ& AW` USVb RS` K]RYO Oca$ c\R ]V\S K]RYO hWbbS`S

`OcQVS& I\R \]QV [OZ& I\R \]QV [OZ& AW` USVb RS` K]RYO Oca$ c\R ]V\S K]RYO hWbbS`S WQV c\Y]\b`]ZZWS`b& =QV VOPS heO` 5\Uab$ jSbhb \]QV [SV` hc PSabSZZS\$ bcS Sa OPS`& =QV PSa^`WbhS RWS Ks\RS O\ RS` 6ORShW[[S`bw` c\R RWS @wTbc\UaYZO^^S\ [Wb GVO[^]] W\ RS` <]TT\c\U$ ROaa RS` T`WaQVS 8cTb Rc`QVaQVZsUb& =QV b`W\YS RS\ ZSbhbS\ FSab K]RYO$ ab]^TS [W` \]QV SW\ ^OO` DTSWTS\ c\R aSVS [Wb SW\S[ 6ZWQY OcT RWS IV`$ ROaa Sa aQV]\ \OQV SW\a Wab& 9W\S BOQVb VOPS WQV \]QV W[ <]bSZ$ Tw` [SV` `SWQVb [SW\ ;SZR \WQVb& 8S` K]RYO Y][[b$ c\R RS` 6]g$ RS` WV\ P`W\Ub$ Wab YSW\ 6]g$ a]\RS`\ SW\ AO\\ c\R hc UZObb$ TW\RS WQV$ hc aSZPabPSecaab c\R$ \O jO$ hc aSV` AO\\$ c[ SW\ NW[[S`YSZZ\S` hc aSW\& AWab$ RS\YS WQV& I\RS`Q]dS`& =QV RO\YS WV[$ c\bS`aQV`SWPS RWS FSQV\c\U$ c\R OZa S` T`OUb$ ]P WQV a]\ab \]QV SW\S\ Kc\aQV VOPS$ RS\YS WQV2 J9FD=GG 8=7<$ aOUS OPS` `cVWU2 BSW\$ RO\YS$ c\R dS`abSQYS [SW\S GQVZ]bbS`Vs\RS VW\bS`[ FwQYS\& 9` USVb$ c\R WQV [SW\S wPS` [W` SbeOa hc Vv`S\& =ab wPS` [W` \]QV SW\ NW[[S` ]RS` ROa 8OQV4 =QV YO\\ [WQV \WQVb S`W\\S`\& =QV ZOcTS Rc`QVa NW[[S`$ abSQYS [W` SW\S DTSWTS O\ c\R wPS`ZSUS$ ]P WQV RWS J]`Vs\US OcThWSVS\ c\R \OQVaSVS\ a]ZZ& 9W\S 8`SWdWS`bSZabc\RS c\R TOab SW\S VOZPS :ZOaQVS K]RYO ROcS`b Sa$ PWa WQV RWS J]`Vs\US hc`wQYhWSVS$ [WQV VW\OcaZSV\S c\R aSVS$ ROaa wPS` [W` SW\ ]TTS\Sa 8OQV c\R \WQVb \]QV SW\ NW[[S` Wab& 8S` ]PS`abS Gb]QY Wab hc`wQYUSaSbhb$ c\R [SW\S 9bOUS Wab RWS @SbhbS d]` RS` JS`jw\Uc\U& =QV aQVOcS VW\c\bS` OcT RS\ DO`Y^ZObh$ aSVS RWS aQVeO`hS\ GIJa c\R @W[]caW\S\ c\R [SW\S hc aSVS\$ ROaa W\ SW\S[ RS` KOUS\ SW\ :ScS`hScU O\USY\W^ab eW`R& I\R W[ \sQVabS\& K]ZZS\ aWS [WQV c[ RS\ JS`abO\R P`W\US\4 KO`c[ PS]POQVbS\ aWS [WQV4 KO`c[ \SV[S\ aWS [WQV \WQVb SW\TOQV TSab4 J9F85AAH$ K9F G=B8 8=9 @9IH94 DZvbhZWQV Y][[S WQV [W` hc[ I[^cabS\ ZSWQVb d]`& KSV`Z]a& =QV eWZZ [WQV OcT`WQVbS\$ PZSWPS OPS` d]` 5\Uab USY`w[[b eWS SW\ VOZP USaQVZ]aaS\Sa ?ZO^^[SaaS`& =QV hWSVS RWS J]`Vs\US hc c\R USVS USRcQYb OcT NSVS\a^WbhS\ hc[ 6Sbb hc`wQY& 8WS ;S`scaQVS wPS` [W` x GQV`WbbS4 GQVZSWTb RO eOa4 K]ZZS\ aWS aWQV d][ 8OQV `c\bS`ZOaaS\ c\R hc[ :S\abS` `SW\Y][[S\4 AW` eW`R PSecaab$ eWS YZSW\ ROa NW[[S` Wab$ c\R WQV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P aWS Sa SWUS\a Tw` [WQV a] VS`US`WQVbSb VOPS\& ;SVv`b Sa hc SW\S` U`vrS`S\ GcWbS c\R VOPS\ aWS$ OZa WQV W[ 5\[O`aQV eO`$ RWSaS\ d][ 8OQV Oca hcUs\UZWQVS\ FOc[ dS`eO\hb$ [Wb ?O[S`Oa dS`aSVS\ c\R OPUSbSWZb$ c[ [WQV hc Y`WSUS\4 J]\ W`US\Re] Vv`S WQV SW\ FORW]& =QV `S\\S d][ 6Sbb hc[ ?ZSWRS`aQV`O\Y& 8Oa <O\RbcQV Zvab aWQV eWSRS`$ c\R WQV S`PZWQYS W[ G^WSUSZ SW\ YZO^^`WUSa ;S`W^^S x RWS 9ZZP]US\$ ?\WS c\R :W\US`Y\vQVSZ abSVS\ d]` eWS O\ :sRS\ PSTSabWUbS VvZhS`\S GQVO`\WS`S& =QV PW\ RWS AO`W]\SbbS$ RWS WQV aQV]\ bOcaS\R AOZ USaSVS\ VOPS$ ]V\S hc OV\S\$ ROaa WQV Sa eO`& =QV PSabSVS \c` \]QV Oca GbSQYS\$ GQV\w`S\ c\R NcQYc\US\& ;SZR eSU& @WSPS eSU& ?O``WS`S eSU& FcT eSU& :`Sc\RS eSU& <]TT\c\U eSU& Gg[^ObVWS\ eSU& BcbhS\ eSU& NeSWbS 7VO\QS\ eSU& I\R eS\\ Sa W`US\ReSZQVS J]`PSVOZbS USUS\ ROa GbS`PS\ UOP$ RO\\ aW\R RWS jSbhb OcQV eSU& =QV `OcQVS SW\S\ TSbbS\ <Wb& =\ RS[ ;ZOaPSQVS` [caa \]QV Tw` TOab heSWbOcaS\R 8]ZZO` 7`OQY aSW\& =QV VOPS Y\O^^ heSW :ZOaQVS\ K]RYO$ aSQVa GQVOQVbSZ\ GQVZOTbOPZSbbS\$ heSW \ScS c\R R`SW O\USaQV[OcQVbS$ OPS` \]QV P`OcQVPO`S DTSWTS\ wP`WU& 8Oa [caa OZZSa a] aQV\SZZ eWS [vUZWQV W\ [WQV `SW\$ RO[Wb Sa [WQV eSUVOcb$ PSd]` ROa NW[[S` USabw`[b eW`R& =QV VOPS W\ RS\ ZSbhbS\ K]QVS\ \c` Tw\T$ aSQVa Gbc\RS\ USaQVZOTS\& G]eSWb WQV eSWr$ \WQVba USUSaaS\& =QV PW\ [W` aWQVS`$ ROaa [SW\ YO^cbbS` ?v`^S` Sa \WQVb wPS`abSVb$ eS\\ WQV WV[

USUSaaS\& =QV PW\ [W` aWQVS`$ ROaa [SW\ YO^cbbS` ?v`^S` Sa \WQVb wPS`abSVb$ eS\\ WQV WV[ OZZSa `SW\R`wQYS$ eOa WQV VWS` VOPS& 8WS TS`\UZOa% c\R TScS`hScUPSeSV`bS\$ eW\YS\RS\ GIJ%:OV`S` R`OcrS\$ RWS jSbhb O\aQVSW\S\R OcT RS[ 8OQV aW\R$ Yv\\S\ jSRS\ 5cUS\PZWQY Rc`QV Hw` c\R :S\abS` ^ZObhS\& GQV\SZZ hWSVS WQV [SW\S 6]fS`aV]`ba O\& DZvbhZWQV Wab Sa S\]`[ eWQVbWU$ ROaa WQV I\bS`esaQVS O\VOPS c\R ROaa OZZSa aOcPS` Wab& KS\\ aWS ROa NW[[S` abw`[S\$ eWZZ WQV \WQVb$ ROaa Sa dS`R`SQYb c\R d]ZZUSY`w[SZb Wab$ c\R WQV eWZZ \WQVb \OQYb aSW\& =QV eWaQVS RWS 5PZOUS\ W[ 6OR c\R W[ NW[[S` OP c\R abSZZS [W` RWS ;ZsaS` [Wb RS\ HOPZSbbS\ c\R RS[ 7`OQY O\a 6Sbb& 8WS PSWRS\ :ZOaQVS\ K]RYO abSZZS WQV OcT RS\ 6]RS\ c\R V]ZS [W` \]QV SW\S ZSS`S hc[ DW\YSZ\& =`US\ReO\\ PSW[ 5cT`sc[S\ TOaaS WQV RS\ 9\baQVZcaa$ \WQVb [SV` OcThcabSVS\$ eS\\ WQV S`ab [OZ W[ 6Sbb ZWSUS& =QV V]QYS [WQV OcT RWS 6SbbYO\bS c\R ZORS RWS DTSWTS& =QV `OcQVS SW\S DTSWTS \OQV RS` O\RS`S\$ OPS` RS` 7`OQYd]``Ob W\ RS[ ;ZOa \W[[b \WQVb OP& =QV TO\US O\$ RWS HOPZSbbS\ hc \SV[S\& 9W\S \OQV RS` O\RS`S\$ [Wb U`]rS\ GQVZcQYS\ K]RYO& =QV Vv`S GQV`WbbS OcT RS[ 8OQV& 8Oa ;S`scaQV d]\ GSWZS\$ aQVeS`S\ GbWSTSZ\$ 8`OVbaSWZS\& ?WabS\ [Wb ;SeSV`S\ eS`RS\ wPS` RS\ 6Sb]\ USaQV]PS\& qPS`eOQVc\UaUS`sbS VS`O\USVWSdb& KWSRS` GQV`WbbS& KWSRS` 7`OQY& KWSRS` HOPZSbbS\ c\R \]QV U`vrS`S GQVZcQYS K]RYO& G] USVb ROa W[[S` eSWbS` W\ RS[ VOZPRc\YZS\ NW[[S`$ W\ ROa RWS J]`[WbbOUaa]\\S Rc`QV RWS USaQVZ]aaS\S\ J]`Vs\US R`W\Ub& 8WS PZO\YS\ AvPSZ [Wb WV`S[ aQVSW\PO` a] SZSUO\bS\$ SW\ZORS\RS\ ;`]rabORbTZOW` aSVS\ jSbhb PWZZWU$ YOZb c\R USevV\ZWQV Oca& =QV Vv`S SW\S\ <cPaQV`OcPS` c\R [OZS [W` Oca$ eWS RWS @ScbS wPS` [W` ROa 8OQV [Wb 8`OVbaSWZS\ O\ RS[ <SZW TSab[OQVS\ c\R RWS AOaQVW\S jSRS\ A][S\b [Wb RS[ NW[[S`QVS\ Z]aTZWSUb$ T]`b d]\ BSe M]`Y$ c\R Sa VW\bS` RS\ AOcS`\ SW\Sa 6c\RSaUSTs\U\WaaSa OPaSbhb& 8Oa 6Sbb aQVSW\b hc eOQYSZ\$ c\R WQV eSWr \WQVb$ ]P \c` WQV RO eOQYZS$ \c` ROa 6Sbb ]RS` ROa UO\hS NW[[S`& =QV aQVZcQYS eSWbS` HOPZSbbS\& FOcQVS eSWbS`& H`W\YS eSWbS`& BSV[S [W` SW\ GbwQY DO^WS`$ RS\YS O\ RWS dWSZS\ BOQV`WQVbS\$ RWS B]OV OcT RWS FwQYaSWbS d]\ 6`WSTc[aQVZsUS\ USaQV`WSPS\ c\R [W` OcT RS\ H`SaS\ W\ c\aS`S[ J]``Oc[ USZSUb VOb$ aQV`SWPS =QV YO\\ \WQVb [SV` c\R ZSUS RS\ NSbbSZ \SPS\ ROa 6Sbb& =QV YO\\ YOc[ \]QV RWS 5`[S PSeSUS\$ c\R [SW\S 6SW\S TO\US\ O\ hc aQV[S`hS\& ASW\ <S`h Y][[b [W` d]` eWS SW\S FOYSbS W\ RS` 6`cab$ RWS W[ 6SU`WTT Wab OPhcVSPS\$ c\R UZSWQVhSWbWU P`SWbSb aWQV SW\S aQVeS`S$ Rc[^TS KSZZS b`sUS` 9\S`UWS d][ BOQYS\ VS` W\ [SW\S[ ?]^T Oca& 8WS HOPZSbbS\ aW\R PSW\OV OZZS& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ T`OUS WQV [WQV$ ]P WQV eW`YZWQV 9`\ab [OQVS\ eWZZ& JWSZZSWQVb PSabSVb R]QV W[[S` \]QV RWS AvUZWQVYSWb$ Oca RWSaS[ bWSTS\ @]QV VS`OcahcY][[S\4 KWZZ WQV eW`YZWQV abS`PS\4 =QV VOZbS SW\$ c\R OcQV RWS ;S`scaQVS OcT RS[ 8OQV Vv`S\ OcT& 5ZZSa Wab abWZZ PWa OcT ROa FOcaQVS\ [SW\Sa 6ZcbSa VW\bS` 5cUS\$ CV`S\ c\R 6`cab& =QV Vv`S \c`$ eWS ROa @SPS\ Rc`QV [SW\S\ [wRS\$ aQV[S`hS\RS\ ?v`^S` aQVeO^^b& KWZZ WQV ROa eW`YZWQV PSS\RS\4 >Sbhb4 9W\ aQV\OZhS\RSa ;S`scaQV Y][[b d][ 8OQV$ c\R WQV S`abO``S&

>O$ RS\YS WQV$ OZa WQV [WQV d]`PScUS$ hc[ ;ZOa [Wb RS\ HOPZSbbS\ U`SWTS c\R [W` RWS ZSbhbS\ hSV\ ]RS` hevZT W\ RS\ Ac\R aQVwbbS& >O$ aOUS WQV ZOcb hc RS\ As\\S`\ OcT RS[ 8OQV c\R RS\ GIJ%@ScbS\$ RWS dS`[cbZWQV OZZSa [WbVv`S\& >5$ `cTS WQV$ PSd]` WQV RS\ K]RYO Y][^ZSbb Ocab`W\YS& >O$ [c`[SZS WQV ewbS\R c\R ^OQYS RWS ZSbhbS aOcPS`S DTSWTS d]ZZ$ PWa aWS Oca RS` :]`[ USVb& >O$ jO c\R \]QV [OZ jO$ esV`S\R WQV ROa OZZSa W\ [WQV `SW\hWSVS c\R ZO\UaO[ eS`RS c\R RWS U`]rS$ b`sUS$ ZO\US`eO`bSbS KSZZS O\`]ZZb$ aWQV wPS` [W` evZPb c\R OcT [WQV \WSRS`Y`OQVb& >O& @O\US eO` [SW\S \sQVabS 9`W\\S`c\U$ ROaa WQV W\ RS` @]PPg d]\ C\S :WTbV abSVS$ [WQV O[ 9[^TO\UaaQVOZbS` TSabVOZbS c\R @cWa aOUS$ ROaa WQV RS\ \ScS\ GQVZwaaSZ P`OcQVS& AWb RS` NSWb Y][[b OPS` RWS 9`W\\S`c\U VW\hc$ eWS WQV O\ RS` B]`R]abSQYS :WTbV 5dS\cS c\R KOaVW\Ub]\ G_cO`S DO`Y abSVS& <Ob [WQV SW\ HOfW R]`b OPUSaSbhb4 6W\ WQV d][ <]bSZ Oca hc :cr USUO\US\4 =QV ecaabS Sa RO[OZa \WQVb c\R eSWr Sa OcQV jSbhb \]QV \WQVb& 8]QV WQV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS WQV O\ RS` 9QYS abSVS c\R \WQVb eSWr$ eOa WQV bc\ a]ZZ& CP WQV \OQV <OcaS USVS\ a]ZZ ]RS` \WQVb& =QV VOPS YSW\ ;SZR& BWQVba& I\R WQV YO\\ [WQV YOc[ eOQVVOZbS\& =QV Yv\\bS [WQV a] OcT RS\ ;SVabSWU ZSUS\ c\R SW\aQVZOTS\& KS\\ WQV \c` SW\S `cVWUS 9QYS Ts\RS$ e] WQV \WQVb PSVSZZWUb ]RS` TSabUS\][[S\ ew`RS& 8S` GQVZOT ZWSUb OcT [W` eWS SW\S 6ZSWRSQYS$ c\R WQV YO\\ \WQVb abSVS\PZSWPS\ ]V\S hc bOc[SZ\& =QV USVS RWS :WTbV FWQVbc\U B]`RS\$ VSW[es`ba& I\R \c\ aOUb [W` @cWa x <Wa^O\]%5[S`WYO\S` c[ RWS 8`SWrWU$ wPS`Oca VvTZWQV$ RS`aSZPS DTv`b\S`$ RS[ WQV aSWb >OV`S\ W[ ?][[S\ c\R W[ ;SVS\ hceW\YS x$ ROaa B]OV \WQVb RO Wab c\R WQV VWS` YSW\S\ Ncb`Wbb VOPS& 9` aOUb Sa T`Sc\RZWQV$ OPS` S` aOUb Sa& =QV PWbbS WV\$ [W` c[ <W[[SZa eWZZS\ RS\ \ScS\ GQVZwaaSZ hc USPS\& 9a UW\US aQV]\ W\ C`R\c\U$ B]OV VsbbS \WQVba ROUSUS\& 9` aOUb [W`$ S` VOb 5\eSWac\U$ [W` RS\ GQVZwaaSZ \WQVb hc USPS\$ c\R WQV O\be]`bS WV[$ WQV [caa [WQV VW\ZSUS\$ a]\ab abS`PS WQV& =QV YO\\ [WQV YOc[ \]QV OcT RS\ 6SW\S\ VOZbS\& 9` `cTb >]V\$ RS\ <OcadS`eOZbS`& >]V\ Y][[b VS`c\bS` c\R PWbbSb [WQV$ WV[ hc T]ZUS\& KW` TOV`S\ W\ RS\ S`abS\ Gb]QY$ e] S` SW\ YZSW\Sa 6w`] VOb$ c\R S` aQVZsUb [W` d]`$ PSW WV[ hc eO`bS\$ PWa B]OV \OQV <OcaS Y][[b& =QV aOUS WV[$ S` a]ZZ B]OV O\`cTS\& ASW\ <O\Rg bcbya \WQVb [SV`& 9` esVZb RWS Bc[[S` c\R UWPb [W` RS\ <v`S`& B]OVa AOWZP]f [SZRSb aWQV$ c\R WQV aOUS$ ROaa WQV hc <OcaS PW\ c\R [O\ [WQV \WQVb `SW\Zsaab& 8OPSW TOZZS WQV c[& ASW\S 6SW\S Y\WQYS\ eSU$ c\R WQV ZWSUS d]` >]V\a GQV`SWPbWaQV OcT RS[ 6]RS\& 9` VWZTb [W` V]QV$ OPS` Sa Wab YSW\ GbcVZ RO& =QV ZSV\S [WQV USUS\ RS\ Hw``OV[S\& =QV aQVZOTS c\R eOQVS$ PW\ ZSPS\RWU c\R b]b c\R eSWr \WQVb$ eWS WQV VWS`VS` USY][[S\ PW\& >]V\ `SRSb$ OPS` WQV dS`abSVS \WQVb [SV`$ eOa S` aOUb& 8Oa HSZST]\ YZW\USZb$ c\R S` VsZb [W` RS\ <v`S` O\a CV`& 9a Wab B]OV& <OZZ]$ aOUS WQV& =QV PW\ hc <OcaS& <WZT [W` PWbbS& =QV USPS >]V\ RS\ <v`S`$ c\R aWS `SRS\ eSWbS`$ RO\\ PSUZSWbSb >]V\ [WQV VW\c\bS` hc @cWa& ;SPS\ GWS WV[ RS\ GQVZwaaSZ$ aOUb >]V\$ c\R @cWa vTT\Sb RS\ GQV`O\Y VW\bS`[ GQVOZbS`& BOQV SW\WUS` JS`eW``c\U eSUS\ OZbS` c\R \ScS` GQVZwaaSZ VOZbS WQV S\RZWQV RS\ GQVZwaaSZ W\ RS` <O\R c\R USVS eWSRS` hc[ 5cThcU& 5Za WQV SW\abSWUS$ eSWr WQV \WQVb [SV`$ W\ eSZQVS[ Gb]QY eW` e]V\S\& 8`WbbS`4 =QV R`wQYS RWS 8`SW c\R eSWr$ Sa abW[[b \WQVb& :w\T4

eSZQVS[ Gb]QY eW` e]V\S\& 8`WbbS`4 =QV R`wQYS RWS 8`SW c\R eSWr$ Sa abW[[b \WQVb& :w\T4 GSQVa4 GSQVa& GSQVa& GSQVa K& 5Za] R`wQYS WQV RWS GSQVa& 8WS Hw` vTT\Sb c\R aQVZWSrb aWQV OcT 8`SW$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U dS`USaaS WQV$ ROaa Sa \WQVb [SW\S 9bOUS Wab c\R USVS hc` Hw`& 8O\\ TsZZbya [W` SW\$ R]QV OZa WQV abSVS\ PZSWPS$ USPS\ [SW\S 6SW\S eWSRS` \OQV$ c\R WQV TOZZS VW\& 8WS Hw` aQVZWSrb aWQV$ c\R OZa aWS aWQV OcT GSQVa eWSRS` vTT\Sb$ YO\\ WQV [WQV V]QV`O^^SZ\& 8WS K]V\c\U ZWSUb `SQVba d][ 5cThcU$ RWS ZSbhbS Hw` ZW\Ya& =QV USVS RO`OcT hc c\R VOZbS [WQV RWS UO\hS NSWb O\ RS` KO\R TSab& GQVZWSrZWQV Y][[S WQV O\ c\R aSVS ROa UZs\hS\RS \ScS GbOVZaQVZ]aa O\ RS` GbSZZS RSa OZbS\ Yc^TS`TO`PS\S\& =QV eSWr \WQVb$ e] RS` GQVZwaaSZ USPZWSPS\ Wab$ c\R [S`YS S`ab$ OZa WQV W\ [SW\S\ HOaQVS\ Y`O[S$ ROaa WQV WV\ \]QV W\ RS` `SQVbS\ <O\R VOZbS& >Sbhb P`OcQVS WQV \c` \]QV OcThcaQVZWSrS\& 5PS` W`US\ReWS PSY][[S WQV RS\ GQVZwaaSZ \WQVb W\a GQVZ]aa& 9a [caa RS` TOZaQVS aSW\& CRS` eW` e]V\S\ W[ aWSPbS\ Gb]QY& CRS` W[ dWS`bS\& =QV hWSZS \OQV RS[ GQVZ]aa$ OPS` [SW\S <O\R hWbbS`b$ c\R S` USVb \WQVb `SW\& >Sbhb e] WQV \WQVb [SV` W\ 6SeSUc\U PW\$ wPS`Y][[b [WQV RWS GQVZsT`WUYSWb eWS SW\S :ZcbeSZZS& =QV ZSV\S [WQV \SPS\ RS` Hw` O\ RWS KO\R$ YO\\ [WQV OPS` \WQVb OcT`SQVb VOZbS\& =QV `cbaQVS OP c\R VOZbS [WQV O[ Hw`U`WTT TSab$ c[ \WQVb VW\bS\wPS` hc TOZZS\& 9W\S NSWbZO\U Vs\US WQV aQVeO\YS\R RO$ c\R OZa [W` aQVeO`h d]` 5cUS\ eW`R$ a^w`S WQV W[ FwQYS\ c\R OcT [SW\S\ 5`[S\ <s\RS$ RWS [W` RS\ GQVZwaaSZ OP\SV[S\& AWQV V]QVhWSVS\& =QV aSVS aWS O\ [SW\S\ I\bS`O`[S\$ c\R aWS aW\R RS` aQVv\abS 5\PZWQY wPS`VOc^b& <s\RS Oca @WQVb$ \WQVb Oca :ZSWaQV$ RWS [WQV Tw`a]`UZWQV c\R O\[cbWU c[TOaaS\& B]OV& 9` hWSVb [WQV O\ aWQV x SW\ 8cTb \OQV FSW\WUc\U c\R NWUO`SbbS\ x$ abwbhb [WQV [Wb SW\S` <O\R c\R aQVZWSrb [Wb RS` O\RS`S\ RWS Hw` OcT& 8OPSW aOUb S` SbeOa$ OPS` RWS K]`bS aW\R hc eSWb eSU& 9` eWZZ [WQV OcT`SQVb VOZbS\$ OZa aWQV RWS Hw` vTT\Sb$ OPS` WQV YW^^S aQV]\& 8Oa @WQVb Oca RS` K]V\c\U ab`OVZb c\a S\bUSUS\& =QV TOZZS VW\SW\&

KVWbS DZOW\a
9W\ ?`O\YS\eOUS\$ RS` O[ @WSTS`O\bS\SW\UO\U d]\ C\S :WTbV eO`bSb$ P`W\Ub [WQV hc[ @S\]f <WZZ <]a^WbOZ& =[ ;SUS\aObh hc [SW\S` ?`O\YS\eOUS\TOV`b OZa NevZTjsV`WUS` PSVOZbS WQV d]\ RWSaS` \WQVba W\ 9`W\\S`c\U x YSW\S\ GQVeSPShcabO\R heWaQVS\ KOQVaSW\ c\R KSUaSW\$ YSW\ PS`cVWUS\RSa Nc`SRS\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV \WQVb O\ RWS B]bOcT\OV[S$ \WQVb O\ RS\ 5cThcU hc` ^agQVWOb`WaQVS\ GbObW]\$ \c` O\ RS\ Gbc`h W\ RS` K]V\c\Uabw`$ B]OV VW\bS` [W`$ ROa @WQVb& =QV S`eOQVS OZZSW\ W\ SW\S[ NW[[S`$ TSabUSaQV\OZZb W\ SW\S[ 6Sbb$ ]V\S hc eWaaS\$ e] WQV PW\& 9`ab \OQV [SV`S`S\ AW\cbS\ PSU`SWTS WQV$ ROaa WQV ZSPS$ c\R RO\\ [OQVb [WQV ROa ewbS\R& GQVeSabS`\ Y][[S\& 9W\ 5`hb& @ScbS eO`bS\ d]` RS` Hw` x [SW\S :O[WZWS$ B]OV x$ OPS` WQV aOUS RS\ GQVeSabS`\$ aWS a]ZZS\ \WS[O\RS\ VS`SW\ZOaaS\& KWS S`abO``b ZWSUS WQV W\ RS[ NW[[S` c\R RS\YS \c` SW\a2 KOa \c\4 >cZWO$ SW\S :`Sc\RW\ Oca @]a 5\USZSa$ `cTb W[[S` eWSRS` O\& 8OcS`\R aOUS\ [W` RWS GQVeSabS`\$ ROaa aWS O[ HSZST]\ eO`bSb$ ]RS` `WQVbS\ [W` Oca$ ROaa WQV aWS hc`wQY`cTS\ a]ZZ& G] USVb ROa bOUSZO\U$ c\R PSd]` WQV W`US\RjS[O\R O\RS`S\ USaSVS\ ]RS` USa^`]QVS\ VOPS$ `SRS WQV aQVZWSrZWQV [Wb WV`& Nc[ S`abS\ AOZ abSVS WQV OcT$ dS`ZOaaS ROa NW[[S` c\R USVS hc RS[ Aw\hbSZST]\ O[ GQVeSabS`\hW[[S`& <OZZ]$ aOUS WQV$ c\R aWS aQVeOZZb [W` RWS CV`S\ d]ZZ& 9W\S NSWbZO\U aW\R WV`S K]`bS RWS SW\hWUS\$ RWS WQV Vv`S$ c\R aWS eWSRS`V]Zb aWS SW\ c[a O\RS`S AOZ$ wPS` K]QVS\$ wPS` A]\ObS& =QV PSY][[S SW\ O\RS`Sa NW[[S`& 9a Wab YZSW\$ [Wb heSW 6SbbS\$ c\R PZWQYb OcT SW\S ?W`QVS W\ RS` //bV Gb`SSb VW\Oca& 5Za WQV VW\Y][[S$ Wab Sa ZSS`$ YSW\ NW[[S`USTsV`bS W\ GWQVb& 5cT RS` ?][[]RS abSVb SW\S `WSaWUS eSWrS C`QVWRSS& NeSW ZO\US 6O[PcaabsPS [Wb hcUSa^WbhbS\ 9\RS\ abwbhS\ RWS DTZO\hS& GWS Wab d]\ >SO\$ c\R OcT RS` PSWUSTwUbS\ ?O`bS T`OUb aWS$ ]P WQV \WQVb RS` FSROYbW]\ WV`S` @WbS`Obc`hSWbaQV`WTb PSWb`SbS\ [vQVbS x Sa Wab [W` W[[S` \]QV S`\ab$ abSVb RO$ OZa es`S \WQVba d]`USTOZZS\$ c\R aWS aQVZWSrb =\ OZZS` @WSPS& =QV abO``S OcT RWS C`QVWRSS$ RWS Q`S[SeSWrS ?O`bS$ c\R T`OUS [WQV$ eS\ aWS RO hc YS\\S\ c\R hc ZWSPS\ [SW\b& =QV \SV[S SW\S\ RS` 6O[PcaabsPS$ P`SQVS WV\ Rc`QV$ USVS W\ ROa VSZZS$ PZOc USYOQVSZbS 6OR c\R TO\US O\$ WV\ [W` W\a <O\RUSZS\Y hc ab]rS\& =[[S` TSabS` ab]rS WQV hc$ PWa RWS <Ocb OcTP`WQVb c\R 6Zcb Y][[b$ c\R RO\\ aSVS WQV OcT SW\[OZ$ eOa [SW\S :Ocab [Wb RS[ YZSW\S\ G^WSr RO O\`WQVbSb$ c\R W[ aSZPS\ 5cUS\PZWQY eW`R [W` YZO`$ ROaa WQV \WQVb abS`PS\ eWZZ& GbS`PS\ aQVSW\b [W` a]UO` ROa hc aSW\$ eOa WQV O[ OZZS`eS\WUabS\ eWZZ& =QV Vv`S OcT$ PW\ T`]V$ ROaa \WQVba OZZhc GQVZW[[Sa ^OaaWS`b Wab$ VOZbS RS\ 5`[ c\bS` YOZbSa KOaaS`$ eWQYZS DO^WS`bwQVS` R`c[ c\R aSbhS [WQV OcT ROa aQV[OZS 6Sbb O[ :S\abS`& @O\US PZSWPS WQV RO aWbhS\& =QV aQVOcS OcT RS\ ?W`QVbc`[ c\R eO`bS&

@O\US PZSWPS WQV RO aWbhS\& =QV aQVOcS OcT RS\ ?W`QVbc`[ c\R eO`bS& 6Sd]` WQV [Wb jS[O\RS[ a^`SQVS$ `SWaS\ RWS [SWabS\ Oca [SW\S` :O[WZWS eWSRS` \OQV BSe 9\UZO\R OP& ASW\S AcbbS` PZSWPb PSW SW\S` :`Sc\RW\ OcT RS` I^^S` KSab GWRS$ OPS` WQV ZOaaS aWS \WQVb hc [W`& B]OV Y][[b SW\ ^OO`[OZ c\R aWSVb PSaaS` Oca RS\\ jS& 5\ SW\S[ HWaQV W\ RS` 7OTSbS`WO aWbhb S` [W` USUS\wPS` c\R PSaQVs[b c\R PZS\RSb [WQV& =QV eWSUS \]QV Y\O^^ .( YU$ TOab heO\hWU c\bS` [SW\S[ B]`[OZUSeWQVb$ RWS DgjO[OV]aS c\R ROa GeSObaVW`b aW\R [W` dWSZ hc eSWb$ c\R S` ab`]bhb d]` ;Sac\RVSWb W\ aSW\S[ <S[R d]\ 5U\Sa 6&$ RS[ S\UZWaQVS\ ?`OUS\^cZZ]dS` c\R RS[ aQVWQYS\ U`OcS\ 7Wbg[O\bSZ& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS S` aWQV RWS SW\hSZ\S\ GOQVS\ USYOcTb VOb& KW` a^`SQVS\ Sa \WQVb Oca$ OPS` Sa Wab YZO`$ ROaa OZZSa d]`PSW Wab$ ROaa eW`$ \OQVRS[ eW` a] ZO\US hcaO[[S\USZSPb VOPS\$ jSbhb USb`S\\bS KSUS USVS\& 5ZZSa$ eOa eW` USeSaS\ aW\R$ RWS UO\hS hOcPS`VOTbS$ U`OcaWUS C^S`$ Wab d]`PSW& Bc` SW\ HWaQV Wab heWaQVS\ c\a$ OPS` eW` aW\R W\ dS`aQVWSRS\S\ KSZbS\& 9` Y][[b [W` UO` \WQVb eWS SW\ `WQVbWUS` AS\aQV d]`$ SVS` eWS SW\S ;SabOZb Oca SW\S[ H`Oc[$ SW\ \sQVbZWQVSa Kc\RS`$ ROa \OQV RS[ 5cTeOQVS\ \c` OZa 9`W\\S`c\U eSWbS`PSabSVb& I\R RO\\ bOcQVb ?ObVS`W\S OcT& =\ SW\S[ 5ZPb`Oc[ VOb aWS [WQV Rc`QV RS\ 7WbgdS`YSV` ZOcTS\ aSVS\$ heWaQVS\ 6caaS\ c\R HOfWa bOc[SZ\R$ c\R WV`S\ JObS` O\US`cTS\$ RS` US`ORS d]\ jS[O\RS[ Oca c\aS`S` YZSW\S\ GbORb S`TOV`S\ VOb$ ROaa Sa D`]PZS[S UWPb& ?ObVS`W\S VOb OcTUSZSUb$ Wab hc[ :ZcUVOTS\ d]\ @cPP]QY W\ HSfOa USTOV`S\$ e] aWS e]V\b$ VOb RWS \sQVabS AOaQVW\S \OQV BSe M]`Y US\][[S\ c\R Wab O[ HOU$ PSd]` WQV \OQV <OcaS USeO\Yb PW\ c\R RS` ?`O\YS\eOUS\ [WQV OPUSV]Zb VOb$ \OQV BSe M]`Y USY][[S\& NeSW K]QVS\ ZO\U VO``b aWS esV`S\R RS` 6SacQVahSWbS\ PSW [W` Oca$ [SWabS\a OZZSW\$ W[[S` [Wb SW\S[ 6cQV& KS\\ WQV 6SacQV PSY][[S$ USVb aWS OcT RS\ ;O\U c\R ZWSab$ Wab RS` 6SacQV eSU c\R WQV PW\ OZZSW\$ Y][[b aWS eWSRS`& 9W\Sa BOQV[WbbOUa S`hsVZb aWS [W` d]\ RS` :ZcUhScUS\bTwV`c\U$ RWS eW` W\ RS\ G][[S`TS`WS\ heWaQVS\ RS[ ZSbhbS\ ;`c\RaQVcZjOV` c\R RS` <WUVaQV]]Z US^ZO\b VObbS\& 8Oa :ZcUhScU \O\\bS aWQV HVS 5ZOaYO\ 9f^`Saa$ c\R eW` VObbS\ [Wb <WZTS d]\ ?O`bS\$ NSWQV\c\US\ c\R ?]abS\`SQV\c\US\ US\Oc OcaUSbwTbSZb$ eWS eW` RO[Wb hc SW\S` SW\aO[S\ =\aSZ W\ RS` ?O`WPWY TZWSUS\ e]ZZbS\& I\aS` :`Sc\R AWQVOSZ$ RS` SW\ :ZcUhScU abScS`\ Y]\\bS x aSW\ JObS`$ SW\ DWZ]b$ VObbS Sa WV[ PSWUSP`OQVb x$ eO` [Wb d]\ RS` DO`bWS& 5ZZSa `cTb ?ObVS`W\S [W` W\ 9`W\\S`c\U x ROaa eW` GO[S\ [Wb\SV[S\ e]ZZbS\$ c[ Yc\abd]ZZS ;s`bS\ O\hcZSUS\$ c\R \OQV ;S`sbS\ hc` I[eO\RZc\U d]\ GOZh% W\ GwreOaaS` USacQVb VObbS\3 ROaa eW` c\a a]UO` SW\S ASbV]RS wPS`ZSUb VObbS\$ RWS Sa c\a S`ZOcPS\ ew`RS$ W[[S` hcaO[[S\hcPZSWPS\$ abObb SWUS\S KSUS hc USVS\& =QV VObbS ROa :ZcUhScU dS`USaaS\$ OZZSa$ eOa RO[Wb hcaO[[S\VW\U c\R eWS [OQVPO` Sa c\a RO[OZa S`aQVWS\& =QV Vv`S WV` hc c\R TwVZS [WQV eWS RO[OZa [Wb hSV\ x PSSW\R`cQYb d]\ WV`S[ KWaaS\ c\R RO\YPO` Tw` WV`S 5cT[S`YaO[YSWb& 5PS` [SWabS\a `SRS\ eW` \WQVb& GWS VsZb [SW\S <O\R c\R eW` aWbhS\ US\Oc eWS RO[OZa$ OZa Sa [Wb c\a O\TW\U$ W\ SW\S[ ?`O\YS\VOca$ abWZZ PSWSW\O\RS`& BOQV heSW K]QVS\ W\ @S\]f <WZZ b`STTS\ B]OV$ ?ObVS`W\S c\R WQV c\a [Wb RS[ [W`

BOQV heSW K]QVS\ W\ @S\]f <WZZ b`STTS\ B]OV$ ?ObVS`W\S c\R WQV c\a [Wb RS[ [W` hcUSeWSaS\S\ DagQVWObS` c\R a^`SQVS\ wPS` 9\bhcUaYZW\WYS\& KW` S\baQVSWRS\ c\a Tw` SW\S& ?ObVS`W\S TsV`b \OQV C\S :WTbV c\R acQVb SW\ ^OO` ?ZSWRS` c\R 6wQVS` Tw` [WQV hcaO[[S\& GWS VWZTb [W` [Wb RS[ ;S^sQY VW\Oca OcT RWS Gb`OrS$ c[O`[b [WQV hc[ 5PaQVWSR c\R YSV`b \OQV HSfOa hc`wQY& KW` dS`ZWS`S\ c\a eWSRS` Oca RS\ 5cUS\$ aWS USVb \OQV 6SZWhS$ c\R SW\S NSWbZO\U Vv`S WQV \WQVba d]\ WV`$ PWa aWS aWQV RO\\ R]QV eWSRS` [SZRSb$ ^S` AOWZ ]RS` ^S` HSZST]\$ c\R aWQV RS` ?`SWa Tw` SW\S KSWZS aQVZWSrb& 8OdWR$ RS\ WQV aSWb c\aS`S[ :`wVabwQY W[ AO`_cSb \WQVb [SV` USaSVS\ VOPS$ eO`bSb d]` @S\]f <WZZ O\ RS` 9QYS //bV c\R DO`Y 5dS\cS [Wb aSW\S[ >SS^& 9` Wab a]e]VZ VS`hZWQV eWS d]`aWQVbWU$ c\R a] TOV`S\ eW` eSWbUSVS\R aQVeSWUS\R hc RS` OZbS\ =``S\O\abOZb W\ KVWbS DZOW\a$ BM$ RWS jSbhb SW\ ^agQVWOb`WaQVSa ?`O\YS\VOca [Wb ROhcUSVv`WUS` YZSW\S` 9\bhWSVc\UaYZW\WY Wab& KW` VOZbS\ O\ SW\S[ 8`cUab]`S W\ RS` BsVS RS` ?ZW\WY$ c\R WQV PS]POQVbS RWS @ScbS W\ RS\ ;s\US\ c\R T`OUS [WQV$ eWS aWS WV` @SPS\ [SWabS`\$ eWS W`US\ReS` ROa VW\Y`WSUb& 8OdWR USVb [Wb [W` Rc`QV RS\ @ORS\ eWS SW\ JObS`$ RS` aSW\S\ G^`]aa W\a :S`WS\ZOUS` P`W\Ub$ c\R T`OUb [WQV$ ]P WQV NOV\^OabO$ 6]\P]\a$ B]bWhPwQVS` P`OcQVS& 9` YOcTb [W` heSW ?ZORRS\& 8WS eS`RS WQV d]ZZaQV`SWPS\& =\ RS\ S`abS\ HOUS\ W\ KVWbS DZOW\a [OQVS WQV [W` wPS` RS\ >c\US\ ;SRO\YS\$ RS` W\ ROa NW[[S` OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS RSa ;O\Ua Y][[b x c\R wPS` aSW\S AcbbS`$ RWS WV\$ OZa aWS aSW\S GOQVS\ OPabSZZb$ O\aWSVb$ OZa Yv\\bS S` ROd]\ZOcTS\ ]RS` aWQV W\ @cTb OcTZvaS\$ a]POZR aWS WV[ RS\ FwQYS\ YSV`b& GWS S`W\\S`b [WQV O\ B]OV& I\R OZa RS` >c\US [WQV Yc`h O\PZWQYb$ [Wb 5cUS\ eWS heSW aQVeO`hS Ac`[SZ\$ ]V\S <]TT\c\U$ ]V\S :O`PS$ ]V\S @SPS\$ aSVS WQV [WQV aSZPab& ;SUS\ 5PS\R USVS WQV OcT SW\S` aO\Tb OPTOZZS\RS\ KWSaS a^OhWS`S\$ sV\ZWQV RS` W\ C`SU]\$ c\R T`OUS [WQV$ eWS Sa eSWbS`USVb& 9W\Sa G^sb\OQV[WbbOUa$ eS\WUS HOUS d]` [SW\S` FwQYYSV` \OQV BSe M]`Y$ eSWr WQV d]` 5\Uab c\R JS`heSWTZc\U \WQVb e]VW\ c\R TOZZS O[ ]PS`S\ 9\RS RS` KWSaS OcT RWS ?\WS& 8Oa ;`Oa Wab \Oaa$ eSWZ Sa US`SU\Sb VOb$ c\R RS` <W[[SZ Wab ZWQVbZ]a c\R U`Oc dS`\SPSZb& =QV ZSUS [WQV OcT ROa TScQVbS$ aQVZO[[WUS ;`Oa c\R PWbbS RWS 9`RS ZSWaS c[ <WZTS& @O\US PZSWPS WQV a]$ RO\\ abSVS WQV aQVZWSrZWQV OcT$ [SW\S <]aS Wab O\ ?\WS\ c\R CPS`aQVS\YSZ\ Rc`QV\saab$ O\ [SW\S\ <s\RS\ c\R 9ZZP]US\ YZSPb AObaQV& 5Za WQV eWSRS` abSVS$ aSVS WQV SW\S\ FWaa W\ RS` K]ZYS\eO\R$ c\R W\ RWSaS[ FWaa SW\S\ TS`\S\ @WQVbab`OVZ& 9` Wab VSZZ`]aO c\R ROa GQVv\abS$ eOa WQV jS USaSVS\ VOPS& 8WS K]ZYS\ vTT\S\ aWQV eSWbS`$ ROa @WQVb \W[[b hc$ c\R ROPSW eW`R [W` ZSWQVbS`& =QV eSWr$ c\R aSW Sa \c` Tw` RWSaS\ 5cUS\PZWQY$ ROaa [SW\S G]`US \WQVba s\RS`\ eW`R c\R ROaa OZZSa a] Wab$ eWS Sa aSW\ a]ZZ& 8Oaa WQV hc`SQVbY][[S& 6SW 9W\P`cQV RS` 8c\YSZVSWb USVS WQV RWS KWSaS VW\c\bS`& 5Za WQV c\bS\ O\Y][[S$ aQVOZZb [W` Oca RS[ U`]rS\ 5V]`\POc[$ RS` RS\ 9QY^c\Yb RS` KWSaS PWZRSb$ J]USZZs`[ S\bUSUS\& 8S` UO\hS 6Oc[ Wab d]ZZ d]\ JvUSZ\$ c\R aWS Y`SWaQVS\$ Y`sQVhS\ c\R TZObbS`\$ ROaa Sa aWQV

O\Vv`b eWS GbORW]\USbvaS& ;SPO\\b d]\ RS` 6SeSUc\U c\R RS[ @s`[$ aQVOcS WQV WV\S\ ZO\US hc& 8O\\ ^ZvbhZWQV U`]rSa :ZwUSZ`OcaQVS\ W[ ;SheSWU$ c\R RS` GQVeO`[ TZWSUb OcT$ ab`SWQVb wPS` RWS KWSaS$ Yc`db S`ab \OQV ZW\Ya$ RO\\ \OQV `SQVba c\R dS`aQVeW\RSb VW\bS` RS` ?W`QVS& 5Za WQV hc`wQY W\ [SW\ NW[[S` Y][[S$ YZW\USZb ROa HSZST]\& 9a Wab >cZWO$ RWS [WQV PWbbSb$ RWS DObS\aQVOTb Tw` WV` S`abSa ?W\R hc wPS`\SV[S\$ WV`S H]QVbS` ?ObS$ RWS Yc`h \OQV [SW\S` FwQYYSV` \OQV BSe M]`Y USP]`S\ eW`R& BOQVba Vv`S WQV RS\ KW\R VW\bS` RS\ ;SPscRS\ VScZS\ c\R O\ RS\ :S\abS`\ `wbbSZ\& =QV Vv`S ;SaQV`SW OcT RS[ ;O\U c\R T`OUS [WQV$ ]P UZSWQV jS[O\R VS`SW\^ZObhb eWS O[ S`abS\ 5PS\R ROa Rc\YSZVOO`WUS AsRQVS\$ ROa O\ RS` Hw` OcT RWS ?\WS TWSZ c\R [WQV T`OUbS$ ]P WQV ;]bb aSW& =[ G^OZb c\bS` RS` Hw` aSVS WQV @WQVb& AOZ Wab Sa b`wP$ RO\\ eWSRS` VSZZ$ RO\\ eSU& HOUawPS` aWbhS WQV W\ RWSaS[ NW[[S` W\ SW\S[ GSaaSZ$ c\R [W` Wab ZSWQVb eWS \]QV \WS x OZa es`S SW\S c\UZOcPZWQVS @Oab d]\ [W` US\][[S\ x$ PWa ;SaWQVbS` d]` [W` OcTbOcQVS\ eWS :ScS`eS`YS& 9a Y][[S\ W[[S` [SV`$ SW\a \OQV RS[ O\RS`S\$ ;SaWQVbS` Oca [SW\S[ @SPS\$ UZOcPS WQV$ c\R RScbZWQV a^w`S WQV RS\ N]`\$ RS\ ?c[[S`$ RWS 9\bbscaQVc\U c\R JS`OQVbc\U$ RWS d]\ WV\S\ OcaUSVb& 8O eW`R Sa [W` W\ RS[ GSaaSZ eWSRS` aQVeS`$ c\R [O\QV[OZ aWbhS WQV R]`b Gbc\RS\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ [SW\ KSW\S\ c\R V]TTS$ RWS H`s\S\ Y][[S\ eWSRS`& =QV ZOcTS W[ NW[[S` VW\ c\R VS` c\R VW\bS`ZOaaS BOQV`WQVbS\ OcT <O\Rga c\R AOWZP]fS\& 9W\WUS `cTS\ hc`wQY$ O\RS`S \WQVb& =QV Y\WS [WQV VW\ c\R PSbS& I[ <WZTS& I[ SW\S\ 5caeSU& I[ JS`USPc\U& =QV RS\YS O\ SW\a [SW\S` @WSPZW\UaUSRWQVbS c\R S`YS\\S$ eWS ^`]^VSbWaQV Sa USeSaS\ Wab& =QV RS\YS O\ [SW\ @SPS\ hc`wQY$ eWS eWQVbWU Sa [W` SW\[OZ eO` c\R RO\\ OcT SW\[OZ \WQVb [SV`& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ RWS ZSbhbS\ NSWZS\ SW\Sa 6cQVa$ RWS WQV SW\[OZ hc dS`abSVS\ [SW\bS& KS\\ Sa aWQV O\TwVZb eWS ROa 9\RS RS` KSZb$ Wab Sa \WQVb ROa 9\RS& KWS SW\S\ F]aS\Y`O\h PSbS WQV RWSaS K]`bS c\R TZSQVbS aWS W\ 6`WSTS SW\ c\R aOUS aWS O[ HSZST]\ c\R a^`SQVS aWS OcT RS` KWSaS W\ RS\ KW\R& =QV Vv`S OcT$ O\ aWS hc UZOcPS\$ PSbS OPS`$ ROaa aWS eOV` aW\R& GWS aW\R Sa& =QV RS\YS O\ OZZ RWS HOfWTOV`S` c\R <]bSZO\USabSZZbS\$ RWS 8SOZS`$ RWS GwQVbWUS\& 8WSjS\WUS\$ RWS d]` 5PaQVSc$ 5\Uab ]RS` 9YabOaS hWbbS`bS\$ c\R RWSjS\WUS\$ RWS PSas\TbWUS\R [SW\bS\$ OZZSa eS`RS UcbUSVS\$ OZZSa eS`RS Ucb& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ eS\ aWS d]` aWQV hc VOPS\ [SW\bS\$ T`OUS [WQV$ eS` aWS aSZPS` eO`S\& 9W\WUSa eW`R [W` W[[S` SW\ FsbaSZ PZSWPS\ x RWS ;Sa^`sQVS$ ROa U`]rS 6OZZSbb RS` HOfWa c\R O\RS`S\ KOUS\$ RS` 8`]US\jsUS` c\R 7]^a$ RS` >7 DS\\Sga x c\R \WS eS`RS WQV ROa a] YZO` Rc`QVaQVOcS\$ ROaa WQV KOV`VSWb c\R H`cU c\bS`aQVSWRS\ YO\\& J]\ RWSaS\ 8W\US\$ RWSaS\ 9`W\\S`c\US\ PSVOZbS WQV \c` 9W\R`wQYS x eWS aWS OcaaOVS\$ aWQV O\Vv`bS\$ aWQV O\TwVZbS\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS WQV O\ jS\S[ A]`US\ OcT RS[ 6OZY]\ W[ ;O\aSd]]`b USabO\RS\ VOPS& 8WS dWSZS\ @ScbS$ RWS c[ aSQVa IV` T`wV R]`b VS`c[a^OhWS`b aW\R3 RWS H]e\ 7O`a c\R RWS OcT ?O`bS\ USaQV`WSPS\S\ Kv`bS`$ RS`S\ GW\\ [W` \WQVb OcTUSVb c\R RWS WQV RSaVOZP aQV]\ ]Tb \OQVaQVZOUS\ e]ZZbS$ ]V\S Sa jS[OZa hc bc\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ RWS AveS\$ RWS W\

\OQVaQVZOUS\ e]ZZbS$ ]V\S Sa jS[OZa hc bc\& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV O\ RWS AveS\$ RWS W\ eSWbS\ 6vUS\ wPS` RS[ :Zcaa Y`SWabS\& 9a eO`S\ a] dWSZS& JWSZ a^sbS` Y][[b SW\S NSWb$ W\ RS` WQV [W` d]`abSZZS$ eWS Sa Tw` RWS O\RS`S\ 6SbSWZWUbS\ eO`$ RWSjS\WUS\$ RWS Rc`QV JS`eO\RbaQVOTb$ NcTOZZ ]RS` BSWUc\U [Wb [W` hc bc\ VObbS\& 8WS JS`ZSbhbS\ c\R JS`ZSbhS\RS\& 9`abS`S P`W\US\ aWQV PSa]\RS`a VSTbWU W\ 9`W\\S`c\U2 RWS 5US\bc`O\USabSZZbS\$ RWS WV`S >]Pa dS`Z]`S\ VOPS\$ RWS d]\ [W` dS`b`SbS\S\ 5cb]`S\$ RWS OcT [WQV O\USeWSaS\ eO`S\ c\R aWQV \ScS 5US\bS\ acQVS\ [caabS\$ 5\USVv`WUS$ :`Sc\RS$ ?ObS& B]OV& 5\TO\Ua dS`USVS WQV d]` GQVO[$ GQVcZRUSTwVZS\ c\R 6SROcS`\$ R]QV [Wb RS` I\bS`abwbhc\U dS`eO\RbS` ;SWabS` S\beWQYSZb aWQV RO`Oca SbeOa eS\WUS` GSZPabPSh]US\Sa& 8WSaSa eS\WUS` GSZPabPSh]US\S eW`R [Wb <WZTS RS`aSZPS\ dS`eO\RbS\ ;SWabS` bsUZWQV eSWbS` S`Yc\RSb& JWSZSa Wab \OQV eWS d]` ;`S\hUSPWSb& =QV T`OUS [WQV$ eWS Sa Tw` [SW\S\ JObS` eO`& KWS RWS Gbc\RS\ Oca [SW\S` ?W\RVSWb$ O\ RWS WQV [WQV S`W\\S`S$ Tw` WV\ eO`S\& CP S` PSa]`Ub eO`& KWS S` RWS FwQYTOV`b d]\ RS[ 5`hb W\ 6]ab]\ S`ZSPb VOb& I\R eOa RO\\ YO[& KOa UW\U WV[ Rc`QV RS\ ?]^T$ \OQVRS[ RWS 5cb]bw`S\ hcUSY\OZZb eO`S\ c\R WQV W[ <Oca dS`aQVec\RS\ eO`4 K] Wab S` VW\4 =\ aSW\ NW[[S`$ c[ aWQV SW\S\ GQ]bQV SW\hcUWSrS\4 I[a <Oca$ c[ OcT RS\ MaO\RS` hc ^W\YSZ\4 CRS` Wab S` W\ RS` ;O`OUS USPZWSPS\ c\R VOb RS\ ;S`scaQVS\ RSa OPYwVZS\RS\ A]b]`a USZOcaQVb$ RS\ GQV`WbbS\ wPS` WV[ W\ RS` ?wQVS4 KWS ZO\US [OU S` RO USPZWSPS\ aSW\4 8OQVbS S`$ S` Yv\\bS SbeOa dS`YSV`b US[OQVb VOPS\4 Nc VO`b USeSaS\ aSW\4 Nc ab`S\U4 KWS VsbbS aSW\ SWUS\S` JObS` ROa O\US^OQYb4 KOa ecaabS S` d]\ RS[ wPS`VOc^b \]QV4 9` eO` \Sc\hSV\ USeSaS\$ OZa aSW\ JObS` abO`P$ ROa ZOU ZO\US hc`wQY& 8O[OZa VObbS S` abcRWS`b$ e]ZZbS hc` BOdg c\R e]ZZbS TZWSUS\& KSU d]\ 6]ab]\& 8waS\jsUS`$ :`OQVbTZcUhScUS$ UO\h SUOZ x <Oc^baOQVS$ eSU& KWS ZO\US ZOUS\ RWS )1 RO[OZa Tw` WV\ hc`wQY4 KWS ZO\US RWS .4 GSQVa >OV`S& KOa ecaabS S` d]\ aSQVajsV`WUS\ >c\US\4 <ObbS S` 5\Uab4 KOa VOb S` O\ jS\S[ HOU eSUTOZZS\ ZOaaS\$ c[ aSW\S\ G]V\ d]\ :OW`TWSZR 7]c\bg$ 7]\\SQbWQcb$ \OQV 6]ab]\ hc P`W\US\4 KOa Tw` FSQV\c\US\ ec`RS\ \WQVb PShOVZb4 KSZQVS` FOaS\ \WQVb US[sVb4 KSZQVSa YZSW\S :ZcUhScU PZWSP c\USeO`bSb ]RS` c\USTZ]US\$ RO[Wb S` SbeOa bc\ Y]\\bS$ c[ aSW\S[ G]V\ hc VSZTS\$ RS[ >c\US\$ RS` PSW[ DW\YSZ\ jSRSa AOZ VS`c[bO\hbS$ OZa VsbbS [O\ WV\ W\ 6`O\R USabSQYb4 8S[ >c\US\$ RS[ \OQV ASW\c\U RSa 5`hbSa \WQVba TSVZbS& KOa a]ZZbS S` RO PZ]r [OQVS\4 KO` RO \WQVb Gb`S\US O\USaOUb4 KWS ZS`\bS\ ?W\RS` RS\\ a]\ab4 G] UW\US\ JsbS` R]QV [Wb WV`S\ GvV\S\ c[$ ]RS` \WQVb4 =QV T`OUS [WQV$ ]P S` W\ RWSaS` 5`b PSa]`Ub eO`& CRS` ]P S` SW\TOQV ROQVbS$ eOa YO^cbb Wab$ YO\\ [O\ eWSRS` hcaO[[S\aQVcabS`\$ c\R eOa dS`P]US\ Wab$ eW`R US`ORSUSVs[[S`b& =QV YSV`S \OQV BSe M]`Y hc`wQY c\R acQVS [W` SW\ YZSW\Sa$ VSZZSa GbcRW]$ e] WQV d]\ jSRS` 9QYS Oca ROa 9[^W`S GbObS 6cWZRW\U aSVS\ YO\\& 5[ ,& >cZW YwaaS WQV jS[O\RS\$ SW\S\ :`Sc\R$ RS` [SV` OZa SW\ :`Sc\R eW`R c\R [W` ;SZR ZSWVb$ RO[Wb WQV [W` ROa GbcRW] ZSWabS\ YO\\& =QV dS`YOcTS SW\S :]b]U`OTWS$ RWS WQV >OV`S hcd]` W\ SW\S[ 5\TOZZ d]\ C^bW[Wa[ca S`abO\RS\ VObbS$ c\R d]\ RS[ 9`Zva c\R RS[ USP]`UbS\ ;SZR YO\\ WQV W\ BSe M]`Y ZSPS\$

S`abO\RS\ VObbS$ c\R d]\ RS[ 9`Zva c\R RS[ USP]`UbS\ ;SZR YO\\ WQV W\ BSe M]`Y ZSPS\$ P`OcQVS hc[ S`abS\ AOZ aSWb [SW\S` >cUS\R \WQVb hc O`PSWbS\ c\R TW\RS [Wb RS` \vbWUS\ I\bS`abwbhc\U SW\S\ KSU$ RWS HOUS c\R BsQVbS Rc`QVhcabSVS\$ ]V\S WV\S\ hc S\bTZWSVS\& AWb RS` NSWb Wab SW\ A]`US\ RO\\ SW\TOQV SW\ A]`US\$ YSW\ Y]^TZ]aSa ;SecaSZ [SV`$ c[ RWS :]ZUS\ SW\S` Rc`QVeOQVbS\ BOQVb hc PSesZbWUS\$ c\R RS` 5PS\R eW`R \WQVb [SV` RO`OcT dS`eS\RSb$ 5caTZwQVbS c\R H`WQYaS`SWS\ Tw` RS\ \sQVabS\ HOU hc S`aW\\S\& HOUS aW\R eWSRS` HOUS abObb 6wV\S\ Tw` RWS =\ahS\WS`c\U SW\Sa Y][^ZWhWS`bS\ HVSObS`abwQYa$ RSaaS\ HSfb$ 6SZScQVbc\U c\R AOaYS RO`OcT OcaUS`WQVbSb aW\R$ GQVsRS\ hc PSU`S\hS\$ [WQV hc aQVwbhS\ c\R [W` hc dS`aQVOTTS\$ eOa WQV hc P`OcQVS\ [SW\S& 8WS FwQYYSV` W\a JS`ZOUaeSaS\ aQVSW\b OcaUSaQVZ]aaS\& 8Oa Y][[b [W` eWS dS`P`O\\bS 9`RS d]`$ RWS YSW\ @SPS\ [SV` PW`Ub& 5PS` WQV W``S [WQV& 9W\S :`Oc$ RWS WQV >OV`S hcd]` SW\[OZ OcT SW\S` DO`bg USb`]TTS\ VObbS$ dS`OP`SRSb aWQV [Wb [W` hc[ AWbbOUSaaS\$ c\R PSW RWSaS[ AWbbOUSaaS\ PWSbSb aWS [W` SW\S\ >]P O\& GWS `SRSb d]\ Acb c\R U`]rS\ ?`sTbS\ c\R YSW\S\ eSWbS`S\ GQVsRS\$ c\R aQV]\ esV`S\R eW` SaaS\ c\R ?OTTSS b`W\YS\$ USevV\S WQV [WQV O\ RS\ ;SRO\YS\& 8WS S`abS\ HOUS RSa BScO\TO\Ua aW\R PSs\UabWUS\R$ OPS` \WQVb [Wb T`wVS` hc dS`UZSWQVS\& 8WS jOV`SZO\US G]`US$ [O\ Yv\\bS [WQV OZa 6ZS\RS` S\bZO`dS\$ Wab \WQVb [SV` RO& =\ [SW\S[ \ScS\ 6w`] dS`b`SbS WQV \c` SW\S SW\hWUS 5cb]`W\ x >SO\$ RWS$ OZa WQV WV` aOUbS$ WQV e]ZZS eWSRS` O`PSWbS\$ WV`S[ `S\][[WS`bS\ 5US\bS\ aQV`WSP$ aWS [vQVbS aWQV d]\ jS[O\R O\RS`S[ dS`b`SbS\ ZOaaS\& 5Za WQV O\ jS\S[ HOU Rc`QV RWS PZWbhS\RS Hw` RS` 5US\bc` b`SbS$ RS\YS WQV PSW [W`$ TOZZa RWSa RSW\ ZSbhbS` HOU Wab c\R >SO\ RSW\S ZSbhbS ?ZWS\bW\$ b`OU Sa [Wb :Oaac\U x RS` <W[[SZ abw`hb ROd]\ \WQVb SW\$ Sa a]ZZ RO\\ SPS\ \WQVb aSW\& Nc[ ;ZwQY Wab Sa OPS` \WQVb [SW\ ZSbhbS` HOU& =QV PW\ W[[S` \]QV W[ aSZPS\ 6w`] c\R VOPS O\RS`S ?ZWS\bS\ hc >SO\ VW\hcUSe]\\S\& @O\US \]QV Vv`S WQV B]OV dS`heSWTSZb [Wb [W` `SRS\$ eWS a] ]Tb x Rc`QV dS`aQVZ]aaS\S Hw`S\$ d]\ RS` O\RS`S\ HWaQVaSWbS$ O[ HSZST]\& >SRS` 5PS\R W[ ?\WQYS`P]QYS` PZSWPb [W` W\ 9`W\\S`c\U$ jSRSa ;ZOa Sfb`O$ ROa WQV VW\c\bS`USaQVwbbSb VOPS$ eS\\ S` hc` H]WZSbbS UW\U& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS S` hc` :O[WZWS\e]QVS `Oca \OQV C`SU]\ YO[3 eWS S` [Wb aSW\S[ 6O`b c\R aSW\S` U`OcS\ 8`cQYY\]^TjOQYS OcT RS[ DO`Y^ZObh abO\R$ a] aOcPS`$ dS`b`OcS\S`eSQYS\R c\R d]ZZ @WSPS& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS T`]V WQV W[[S` eO`$ ROaa S` [WQV \WQVb dS`ZWSr& =QV S`W\\S`S [WQV$ eWS S` [WQV ROa ZSbhbS AOZ [Wb aSW\S\ aQVv\S\ <s\RS\ V]QVUSh]US\ VOb c\R eWS WQV \OQV d]`\ USTOZZS\ PW\$ eSWZ WQV aQVZWSrZWQV R]QV OZZSW\ Rc`QV RWS Hw` [caabS& =\ RS[ >OV`$ PSd]` WQV eWSRS` O\TO\US hc O`PSWbS\$ `cTS WQV [W\RSabS\a SW\ ^OO`[OZ RWS K]QVS [SW\S\ JObS` O\$ ]Tb []`US\a$ eS\\ WQV O[ <cRa]\ FWdS` W\ SW\S[ ^`sQVbWUS\ DO`Y a^OhWS`S\ USVS$ d]\ RS[ WQV UO` \WQVb USecaab VObbS$ ROaa Sa WV\ UOP& KW` `SRS\ hc[ S`abS\ AOZ aSWb >OV`S\ [WbSW\O\RS`$ c\R WQV YO\\ W[[S` \c` abOc\S\& 6SW c\aS`S[ S`abS\ ;Sa^`sQV PW\ WQV \]QV W\ KVWbS DZOW\a& 8Oa HSZST]\ YZW\USZb$ WQV \SV[S OP$ c\R S` Wab R`O\& KWZZWS$ aOUb S` \OQV SW\S` KSWZS c\R c\bS` H`s\S\$ Sa bcb [W` ZSWR& 9` aOUb [W` OZZSa$ O\ eOa

S` aWQV S`W\\S`b$ c\R WQV Vv`S abWZZ hc c\R PW\ T`]V$ ROaa WQV [W` \WQVb OZZSa \c` OcaUSROQVb VObbS& =QV aOUS WV[$ ROaa S` Tw` [SW\S\ 5cTS\bVOZb W\ RS` 9\bhWSVc\UaYZW\WY \WQVba YO\\$ ROaa RWS D`]PZS[S [SW\S` ?W\RVSWb \WQVb RWS I`aOQVS ROTw` aW\R$ a]\RS`\ \c` ROhc PSWUSb`OUS\ VOPS\& 6SW RWSaS[ HSZST]\Ob PZSWPb RWS NSWb abSVS\3 WQV [vQVbS Sa VW\bS` [W` VOPS\$ c\R WQV [vQVbS$ ROaa Sa \WS OcTVv`b& =[ CYb]PS` jS\Sa >OV`Sa ZsRb S` [WQV SW\$ W\ aSW\S` 7Saa\O [Wb WV[ d]\ 7]\\SQbWQcb \OQV AOW\S hc TZWSUS\& 8S` YZSW\S :ZcU^ZObh Wab \WQVb eSWb d]\ R]`b$ e] eW` USe]V\b VOPS\$ eS\WUS AW\cbS\ d]\ [SW\S` <WUVaQV]]Z S\bTS`\b& =QV VObbS dS`USaaS\$ eWS ZOcb$ eWS ZSWQVb YZSW\S :ZcUhScUS aW\R$ c\R eWS [SW\ JObS` aWQV [Wb WV\S\ OcaYS\\b& GSW\S <s\RS UZSWbS\ hWSZPSecaab wPS` RWS UZSWQVS\ =\ab`c[S\bS$ GQVOZbS`$ @WQVbS` c\R ?ZO^^S\$ [Wb RS\S\ S` VO\bWS`b VOb$ OZa WQV YZSW\ eO`$ c\R RWS [W` \]QV US\Oca] SW\ FsbaSZ c\R US\Oca] c\S`U`w\RZWQV eWS RO[OZa aW\R& KW` TZWSUS\ d]\ SW\S` KWSaS OP$ RWS OZa F]ZZPOV\ RWS\b& KW` aQVwbbS`\ ROVW\$ eWS YZSW\S :ZcUhScUS ROa SPS\ bc\$ c\R W\ RS[ 6`cQVbSWZ SW\S` GSYc\RS$ RS` SW\S[ W[[S` eWS dS`hOcPS`b d]`Y][[b$ VSPS\ eW` d][ 6]RS\ OP c\R abSWUS\ `OaQV VvVS` c\R VvVS`$ wPS` RWS C`baQVOTbS\ c\R GQVcZS\ c\R RS\ Pc\bS\ A]RS` RSa <S`PabSa VW\Oca& 8Oa 8`vV\S\ RSa A]b]`a c\R RS` KW\R ZOaaS\ YSW\ ;Sa^`sQV hc& 5cT [SW\S\ ?\WS\ ZWSUb SW\ Gb]r ?O`bS\& I[VS`USe]`TS\ W\ RS` @cTb wPS` RS\ :SZRS`\ c\R 6S`US\ c\R Gb`OrS\$ e] OZZSa USaQVOV$ aQVeSWUS\ eW` PSWRS&

8WS AcZRS
9` Wab Y\O^^ heSW& ?O\\ ZOcTS\& DOcaPsQYWU$ T`vVZWQV$ Waab OZZSa$ eOa [O\ WV[ d]`aSbhb$ c\R eWZZ W[[S` \]QV [SV`& JS`aW\Yb W\ H`sc[S`SWS\ c\R \SWUb hc 5\TsZZS\ c\Ps\RWUS\ ;SZsQVbS`a& GSW\S GQVeSabS` Wab Rw\\ c\R PZ]\R$ aSW\ JObS` Rc\YSZVOO`WU c\R `WSQVb \OQV HOPOY$ aSW\S AcbbS` Wab OZZSa$ eOa O\ :O`PS$ ;SabOZb c\R 8cTb ROheWaQVS\ZWSUb& GWS VOb bWSTPZOcS 5cUS\& GWS ^TZO\hb 6Zc[S\$ ^TZO\hb aWS wPS`OZZ x W\ GbSW\Us`bS\$ RWS d][ FOaS\ PWa VW\OcT hc[ KOZR `SWQVS\$ S\bZO\U ;SVeSUS\$ W\ Hv^TS\$ RWS OcT :S\abS`Ps\YS\ abSVS\$ OcT H`S^^S\abcTS\& >Sbhb ^TZO\hb aWS US`ORS eWSRS`$ c\R S` aWbhb \WQVb eSWb d]\ WV` OcT SW\S` [Wb G^WSZaOQVS\ wPS`asbS\ 8SQYS& GWS aW\R OcT RS[ FOaS\ VW\bS`[ <Oca$ UO\h O[ FO\R$ e] S` O\abSWUb c\R hc` a]US\O\\bS\ AcZRS VW\ OPTsZZb$ SW\S[ bWSTS\$ TScQVbS\ FOaS\PSQYS\$ ROa d]\ ;`O\WbTSZaS\ Rc`QVP`]QVS\ eW`R& 5cT RS[ <wUSZYO[[ c\R W\ RS` AcZRS abSVb RWQVbSa 6ZOcPSS`USab`w^^$ ROVW\bS` Wab RS` KOZR& GSW\S AcbbS`$ c\bS` SW\S[ `WSaWUS\ Gb`]VVcb$ `cTb ascaSZ\R aSW\S\ BO[S\& 8WS PSWRS\ ?ObhS\ aWbhS\ O[ FO\R RS` 8SQYS c\R PS]POQVbS\ WV\& 9` Vv`b aWS aQV\c``S\ c\R [vQVbS aWS TSabVOZbS\ c\R WV`S KSWQVVSWb c\R WV` ;SaQV\c`` O\ aWQV P`W\US\$ W\ aWQV VW\SW\& 9` U`SWTb \OQV WV\S\$ c\R aWS [WOcS\$ hWSVS\ aWQV T`WSRZWQV hc`wQY c\R ZSUS\ aWQV eSWb US\cU eSU eWSRS` W\a ;`Oa& <W\bS` RS\ ?ObhS\ S`ab`SQYb aWQV RS` bWSTU`w\S FOaS\ hc[ KOZR VW\& 8WSaS 8W\US$ RWSaS p`bZWQVYSWbS\$ RWS UO\hS KSZb jS\aSWba RSa c\[WbbSZPO`S\ 6S`SWQVa aSW\S` 8SQYS c\R aSW\S` AcbbS`$ aW\R WV[ S`ab aSWb Yc`hS[ PSecaab& >SRSa \ScS Kc\RS` Y][[b Oca RS[ BWQVba$ eW\Yb c\R Z]QYb& 9W\S 6WS\S$ SW\ O[ <W[[SZ aQVeSPS\RSa :ZcUhScU$ SW\ 5[SWaS\VOcTS\ \SPS\ RS` 8SQYS$ ROa FOcaQVS\ RSa KW\Ra W\ RS\ 6sc[S\& 9` eWZZ OZZSa OcT SW\[OZ aSVS\$ c\R heO` a]T]`b& 9a Wab RS` S`abS G][[S`$ W\ RS[ S` ZOcTS\ YO\\& 8S` S`abS G][[S`$ W\ RS[ S` aWQV \sVS` hc RS[ VW\PSeSUS\ YO\\$ eOa S` eWZZ& KSU d]\ RS[$ eOa S` \WQVb eWZZ& 9` b`sUb \]QV KW\RSZ\$ OPS` ROa eW`R POZR d]`PSW aSW\& 9` aQVOcb wPS` RWS 5\VvVS$ RWS AcZRS VW\eSU c\R aWSVb RWS aQVW[[S`\RS D`OQVb RS` 6ZsbbS` c\R NeSWUS wPS` SW\S[ <SS` d]\ 6Oc[abs[[S\& 9W\ KW\Rab]r dS`aSbhb ROa @OcP W\ 5cT`cV`$ c\R Sa Wab SW\ ;S`scaQV eWS ROa FOcaQVS\ RSa KOaaS`a Oca RS[ <OV\$ eS\\ aSW\S AcbbS` WV[ SW\ 6OR SW\Zsaab& 8]QV RWSaSa \ScS FOcaQVS\ Wab ZOcbS`$ eWZRS`$ OcT`SUS\RS` OZa OZZSa$ eOa S` jS USVv`b VOb& GSW\S AcbbS` ac[[b W\ RS\ 6Zc[S\ SW\ @WSR c\R dS`aQVScQVb :ZWSUS\ d]\ WV`S[ ;SaWQVb&

GSW\S AcbbS` ac[[b W\ RS\ 6Zc[S\ SW\ @WSR c\R dS`aQVScQVb :ZWSUS\ d]\ WV`S[ ;SaWQVb& 9` abSVb d]\ RS` 8SQYS OcT c\R eOQYSZb OcT RS\ ;`wPQVS\PSW\S\& 9W\ \ScS` KW\Rab]r a]`Ub Tw` 7VO]a W\ RS\ 6sc[S\& GSW\ <S`h YZ]^T VSTbWU$ c\R S` ^SWZb RWS 6Oc[`SWVS O\ c\R aSbhb aWQV W\ 6SeSUc\U& 8WS VS`OPab]rS\RS\ JvUSZ$ RS` eSZZWUS U`w\S FOaS\$ RWS P`c[[S\RS\ =\aSYbS\$ RWS GO[S\PwaQVSZ c\R G][[S`abscPQVS\$ RWS W\ NSWbZc^S Rc`QV RWS @cTb aQVeSPS\$ RWS 6ZOcPSS`ab`scQVS` O[ KOZR`O\R x ROa OZZSa bO\hb d]` WV[& >SRS` \ScS VS``ZWQVS NS\bW[SbS` Z]QYb WV\$ a] ROaa S` aQV\SZZS`$ hWSZab`SPWUS`$ \]QV aQV\SZZS` USVb$ PWa WV[ ROa aQVZWSrZWQV \WQVb [SV` Oca`SWQVb c\R S` hc ZOcTS\ PSUW\\b& 9` ZscTb OcT ROa ]PS`S 9\RS RSa FOaS\a$ RWS Y\O``S\RS\ abS$ RWS PZWbhS\RS\ 6ZsbbS`$ RWS ;S`scaQVZOeW\S hc& 9` Y][[b wPS` RS\ <wUSZYO[[$ c\R RS` <O\U OcT RS` O\RS`S\ GSWbS Wab OcT SW\[OZ c\S`eO`bSb abSWZ& 8WS 6SW\S eW`PSZ\ c\bS` WV[$ c\R S` [caa OcT^OaaS\$ ROaa S` \WQVb VW\TsZZb& G] aQV\SZZ Wab S` \]QV \WS USZOcTS\$ c\R SW\S\ A][S\b ZO\U a^w`b S` SW\S\ 5PabO\R heWaQVS\ aWQV c\R aSW\S[ ?v`^S` x OZa ]P aWQV ROa SW\S d][ O\RS`S\ S\bTS`\b VOb c\R RWS \ScS ;SaQVeW\RWUYSWb jSbhb [WbS`ZSPb$ OPS` \WQVba Tw` aWS YO\\& 8S` FOaS\$ aSW\S 6SW\S$ aSW\ ?v`^S`$ OZZSa dS`aQVeW[[b c\bS` WV[$ c\R S` UWPb Sa OcT$ Zsaab aWQV d]\ RS` ;SaQVeW\RWUYSWb b`OUS\& 9W\ [sQVbWUS` KW\R TsV`b Rc`QV RWS AcZRS$ c\R WV[ Wab$ OZa ew`RS S` UZSWQV Z]aTZWSUS\$ OZa ew`RS RWS 9`RS WV\ T`SWUSPS\ c\R S` wPS` RS\ FOaS\ VW\OcaaSUSZ\$ wPS` RS\ ;S[waSUO`bS\ c\R RWS GQVOcYSZ VW\ hc RS\ 6Oc[Y`]\S\& J]\ W`US\Re] `cTb aSW\S AcbbS`& GWS `cTb aSW\S\ BO[S\$ R]QV WV`S GbW[[S Wab TS`\ c\R PSYO\\b c\R ZWSUb jSbhb VW\bS` WV[& 5ZZSa$ eOa SW\[OZ aSW\S 5cT[S`YaO[YSWb W\ 5\a^`cQV US\][[S\ VOb$ RWS U`]rS\ c\R YZSW\S\ 8W\US W\ aSW\S[ ?]^T$ OZZSa dS`aQVeW\RSb PSW aSW\S[ J]`es`baZOcT$ RWS 6SW\S `cRS`\ c\bS` WV[$ RWS @cTb `OcaQVb WV[ W\a ;SaWQVb$ 5\Uab c\R GbOc\S\ P`SQVS\ Oca aSW\S[ YZSW\S\ <S`hS\ VS`d]`& 5Za S` RS\ <O\U VW\c\bS` aQVZWbbS`b x eWSRS` SbeOa BScSa$ SW\ \ScS` NOcPS` x$ Rc`QVPZWbhb FcVS eWS SW\ T`WSRZWQVSa ;SeWbbS` aSW\S W\ 5cT`cV` US`ObS\S\ ;ZWSR[OrS\$ S`TwZZb jSRS\ NS\bW[SbS` RSa 8OVW\aOcaS\RS\$ ZWSPY]ab WV\ W\ RS\ GSYc\RS\$ PSd]` S` ab]Z^S`b$ PSd]` S` aWQV 9ZZP]US\$ ?\WS c\R ;SaWQVb O\ RS` ;`O\WbPO\Y OcTaQV`O[[b& 6Sd]` S` d]` GQV`SQY OcTVScZb c\R aSW\S AcbbS` aWQV [Wb TZObbS`\RS[ <cb c\R H`s\S\ wPS` WV\ eW`Tb& 6Sd]` aWS WV\ O\ aWQV hWSVb c\R S` aSW\S 5\Uab dS`UWaab$ eSWZ dS`b`OcbS 5`[S WV\ c[TO\US\$ RWS \OQV DTZO\hS`RS c\R 6Zc[S\ RcTbS\& 5ZZ RS[ d]`Oca USVb SW\S U]bbUSYwaabS$ U]bbdS`TZcQVbS FcVS$ RWS O[ Dc\Yb RS` VvQVabS\ ;SaQVeW\RWUYSWb$ OcT RS[ <vVS^c\Yb aSW\Sa K]ZZS\a SW\aSbhb$ SW\ 5cUS\PZWQY$ RS` d]`PSW Wab$ SVS S` OcQV \c` hc[ 5cUS\PZWQY eS`RS\ YO\\ c\R RS\ S` dWSZS Vc\RS`b AOZ [Wb OcTUSaQV`O[[bS` <Ocb eWSRS`hcS`ZSPS\ dS`acQVS\ eW`R& >Sbhb$ b`]bh c\R eSUS\ OZZS[$ eOa WV\ aSW\S[ ;STwVZ \OQV S`eO`bSb$ PScUb S` aWQV W\ RS\ KW\R d]` c\R a^`W\Ub&

8O\YaOUc\U

?O[ c\R aWSUbS2 >S\\WTS` FcR]Z^V KOZaV3 ^S`TSYbS @SYb]`W\2 DOb Gb`OQVO\3 P`WZZO\bS` JS`ZSUS`2 AWQVOSZ DWSbaQV3 YZcUS` ;STsV`bS2 F]PW\ F]PS`ba]\3 `SQVbS <O\R2 AObb <cRa]\3 USZWSPbSa HSO[2 >]\ObVO\ ;OZOaaW$ BWQY :Zg\\$ >]V\ 6]eS$ >WZZ 6WOZ]aYg$ 7V`Wab]^VS` D]bbS`3 dS`eO\RbS ;SWabS`$ ]V\S RWS \WQVba USVb2 @Oc`O ;&$ 5RO[$ A&$ F]US` A&$ 7V`Wa D&$ 5ZZg K&$ F]PS`b 5&3 FOb c\R 6SWabO\R2 7g CyBSOZ$ 8OdWR ;WZPS`b$ @WZW HOgZ]`$ >cZWS 9WaS\[O\$ >O[Sa @SQSa\S$ 7]c`b\Sg <]RSZZ$ 9ZWhO ;`Wae]ZR$ @WaO Gb]`g$ GcaO\\OV ASOR]ea$ @SS 6`OQYab]\S$ A]\WQO AO`bW\3 @WSPS2 >SO\ GbSW\3 <SZRW\2 ?W[ BWQV]Za3 [SW\S abO`YS :O[WZWS2 A][$ 8OR$ ?W[$ @WaO$ GSO\$ AObb$ 6S\$ 6`WO\&

qPS` 6WZZ 7ZSUU

6WZZ 7ZSUU O`PSWbSb OZa @WbS`Obc`OUS\b W\ BSe M]`Y& |D]`b`sb SW\Sa GwQVbWUS\ OZa jc\US` AO\\{ Wab aSW\S SWUS\S ;SaQVWQVbS& KSWbS`S =\T]`[ObW]\S\$ OcQV hc 9%6]]Y%5caUOPS\$ TW\RS\ GWS PSW eee&TWaQVS`dS`ZOUS&RS

=[^`Saac[

8WS C`WUW\OZOcaUOPS S`aQVWS\ *()( c\bS` RS[ HWbSZ nD]`b`OWb ]T O\ 5RRWQb Oa O M]c\U AO\l PSW @WbbZS$ 6`]e\ O\R 7][^O\g$ O RWdWaW]\ ]T <OQVSbbS 6]]Y ;`]c^$ BSe M]`Y k *()( Pg 6WZZ 7ZSUU :w` RWS RScbaQVS 5caUOPS2 k G& :WaQVS` JS`ZOU ;[P<$ :`O\YTc`b O[ AOW\ *()) 7]dS`USabOZbc\U2 VWr[O\\$ VSWZ[O\\$ VO[Pc`U ' 5\\O @S\O KWbbS$ \OQV SW\S` =RSS d]\ ?O^] BU 8WSaSa 9%6]]Y Wab c`VSPS``SQVbZWQV USaQVwbhb& =G6B 1/0%+%)(%,().1,%0