The Poetry of Thomas Hardy: A Handbook and Commentary
()
About this ebook
Originally published in 1970.
A UNC Press Enduring Edition -- UNC Press Enduring Editions use the latest in digital technology to make available again books from our distinguished backlist that were previously out of print. These editions are published unaltered from the original, and are presented in affordable paperback formats, bringing readers both historical and cultural value.
Alexander Rocklin
Alexander Rocklin is assistant professor of religious studies at the Otterbein University.
Related to The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
Related ebooks
The Castle of Indolence: An Allegorical Poem Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsAgnes Gray Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Crock of Gold Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Tragedy of King Lear Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Complete Works of Richard Crashaw, Volume I Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsDelphi Complete Works of Matthew Lewis (Illustrated) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsWindsor Forest Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsSonnets from the Portuguese Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Study Guide for Ezra Pound's "Salutation" Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Story of the Odyssey Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Chaucer and Religious Controversies in the Medieval and Early Modern Eras Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTristan Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Yvain, The Knight of the Lion by Chrétien de Troyes (Book Analysis): Detailed Summary, Analysis and Reading Guide Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsJerusalem Delivered: An English Prose Version Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Amoretti, A Sonnet Cycle: Also includes EPITHALAMION & PROTHALAMION: or, A SPOUSALL VERSE Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsRereading Chaucer and Spenser: Dan Geffrey with the New Poete Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsJames Joyce: The Ultimate Collection Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Faerie Queene — Volume 01 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsYvain, or, The Knight with the Lion Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsFaust, Part 1 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPoet's Tomb, The: The Material Soul of Poetry Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTales of Angria by Charlotte Bronte (Illustrated) Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsStrange Words: Retelling and Reception in the Medieval Roland Textual Tradition Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Poetry of James Thomson - Volume I: The Seasons Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Giaour Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPiers Plowman and the Poetics of Enigma: Riddles, Rhetoric, and Theology Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Poetry For You
The Odyssey: (The Stephen Mitchell Translation) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Divine Comedy: Inferno, Purgatory, and Paradise Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Iliad: The Fitzgerald Translation Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dante's Inferno: The Divine Comedy, Book One Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5You Better Be Lightning Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Dante's Divine Comedy: Inferno Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Prophet Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Gilgamesh: A New English Version Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Canterbury Tales Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Tao Te Ching: A New English Version Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Inward Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Odyssey Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bedtime Stories for Grown-ups Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5For colored girls who have considered suicide/When the rainbow is enuf Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Beowulf Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Twenty love poems and a song of despair Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Iliad of Homer Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Tradition Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Daily Stoic: A Daily Journal On Meditation, Stoicism, Wisdom and Philosophy to Improve Your Life Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Selected Poems Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dream Work Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Complete Poems of John Keats (with an Introduction by Robert Bridges) Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Letters to a Young Poet (Rediscovered Books): With linked Table of Contents Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Edgar Allan Poe: The Complete Collection Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Way Forward Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Enough Rope: Poems Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Love Her Wild: Poems Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Beyond Thoughts: An Exploration Of Who We Are Beyond Our Minds Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5
Related categories
Reviews for The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
0 ratings0 reviews
Book preview
The Poetry of Thomas Hardy - Alexander Rocklin
The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
The Fleeting of Time—
The Hovering of the Soul—
The Coming of Death
Hardy’s drawing to illustrate Amabel
in Wessex Poems.
The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
A HANDBOOK AND COMMENTARY
by
J. O. Bailey
THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA PRESS • CHAPEL HILL
Copyright © 1970 by
The University of North Carolina Press
All Rights Reserved
Standard Book Number 978-0-8078-9611-2
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number 77-97015
To
My Wife Mary and My Daughter Nancy.
Preface
The Poetry of Thomas Hardy: A Handbook and Commentary is an attempt to provide readers, students, and critics with data they need to understand a body of poems often misinterpreted. The poems and the poet were misunderstood during Hardy’s lifetime in ways that both dismayed and amused him. He stated this fact in the poem So Various.
The new critics
of recent years have continued to misunderstand the poems through ignorance of the facts Hardy had in mind when he wrote.
He put himself intimately—his personal experiences and his observations—into his poetry, but (except briefly, now and then) he did not supply footnotes. The present Handbook and Commentary supplies factual notes and even, where facts are not available, surmises intended to throw light on meaning.
Professor Richard Purdy’s Thomas Hardy: A Bibliographical Study offers many hints of the relation between Hardy’s life and his poetry, but his book is devoted chiefly to manuscripts and publication facts. His notes are limited to citing, for a few poems, the persons or occasions treated or biographical parallels in The Early Life or The Later Years. The commentaries of the present book, recognizing Purdy’s first-hand source of information (his friendship with Mrs. Florence Hardy), tend to rely upon this information as authentic and then to fill in the gaps wherever factual data are available.
My method has been first-hand exploration. I visited the places Hardy names in his poems, talked with elderly citizens of Dorchester who knew Hardy personally, read what remains of Hardy’s notebooks and as many letters as possible, and considered almost everything in print.
In my search for elusive facts I have been aided by institutions and individuals who have heartened me with their faith in the value of this work. I am grateful to the Cooperative Program in the Humanities of Duke University and The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill for a grant that helped me spend the summer of 1965 exploring the Hardiana in the Colby College Library; I am grateful to The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill for a seven-months’ leave-of-absence in 1966, to live in Dorchester, read the documents in the Dorset County Museum, and explore Hardy’s Wessex, Cornwall, and London. I am grateful to the University Research Council of The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill for assistance in travel to distant libraries, for stenographic help, and for aid in the publication of this book.
Libraries and museums in both the United States and England have offered every friendly service within their power. I offer thanks to the staffs of the libraries listed here. In the United States: the Colby College Library, the Library of Congress, the New York Public Library (the Berg Collection), the Yale University Library, the Princeton University Library, the Lilly Library of the University of Indiana, and the Miriam Lutcher Stark Library of the University of Texas; and in Great Britain: the Dorset County Museum (custodian of the Max Gate papers, the Sanders Collection, etc.), the Dorset County Library in Dorchester, the Weymouth Public Library, the British Museum, the Bodleian Library in Oxford, the Fitzwilliam Museum and the University Library in Cambridge, the National Library of Scotland in Edinburgh, the County Archives for Wiltshire in Trowbridge, and the Public Records Office in London.
I wish to thank again, in this public statement, the many friendly people who have helped, often with information not to be found in libraries. Dr. George M. Harper, then Chairman of the English Department of The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, approved my leave-of-absence for the work in England. The late Professor Carl J. Weber of Colby College gave me, in many conversations and letters, the benefit of his career as a Hardy scholar. Curator Richard Cary, Albert Howard, and Mrs. Mary Wandersee of the Colby Library looked up for me every scrap of information in the Hardiana there. Professor Siegfried Wenzel of The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill gave me help with problems involving Latin and Greek.
In Dorchester, where I was a stranger, I asked questions of people who had known Hardy and found everyone glad to help. Curator Roger Peers and his assistants, Miss Maureen Samuel and A. T. Stangrom of the Dorset County Museum, found for me obscure documents collected there. Lieutenant-Colonel D. V. W. Wakely of the Military Museum ransacked files for information about the old soldiers of Hardy’s poems. Assistant Librarian Miss B. M. Betts and County Archivist Miss Margaret Holmes helped me find old deeds and records. Francis Dalton, retired Curator of the Dorset County Museum, pointed out personally known facts about Hardy’s poems. Good friends Ernest and Lillian Burt, living in Dorchester in 1966, took me to Hardy places
all through Wessex. Miss May O’Rourke, a secretary for Hardy in the 1920’s, provided personal data about a number of poems. Frank Southerington, Jr., Hardy scholar from nearby Abbotsbury, went with me to explore parish records in the villages where Hardy’s ancestors had lived. Mr. and Mrs. J. P. Skilling, caretakers of the Hardy Birthplace, led me to spots on Egdon
Heath mentioned in Hardy’s poems. Mr. Beauchamp of Damers Hospital (formerly the Union
of several Hardy poems) guided me through the Hospital and told me its history. Mrs. Vera Mardon, pianist for Hardy and the Hardy Players, showed me a number of letters and recalled her experiences of the 1920’s.
Outside Dorchester, friends were equally generous. Frank Pinion of Sheffield University, then preparing A Hardy Companion, welcomed my company on several excursions and allowed me to read his manuscript. Mrs. Gertrude Bugler of Beaminster, who played Tess in the Hardy Players’ production of Tess of the D’Urbervilles, showed me letters from Hardy and Mrs. Florence Hardy and guided me to sites of poems near her home. Mr. and Mrs. J. Stevens Cox, now of Guernsey, publishers of the Hardy monographs, showed me their collections of material. Miss Lois Deacon let me read the documents upon which Providence and Mr Hardy rests and discussed her theories with me. Hugh G. Brasnett of Wimborne showed me photographs he had made to illustrate Hardy’s works and guided me to places of interest in Wimborne. The late Miss Verena Acland of West Stafford told me the facts underlying Hardy’s Timing Her.
Mr. Gell, living in Woodsford Castle, took me through the Castle and discussed the scenes of A Sound in the Night.
Mrs. Joan Cochrane of Milton Abbas told me the story of her niece Lorna, of Hardy’s Lorna the Second.
Mrs. Gwendolen Bax of the Old Rectory, St. Juliot, gave me information valuable in understanding the poems laid there. Reverend Allen G. Watling, vicar of Melbury Osmund, helped me discover facts in the parish records. Mrs. P. F. Chapman, archivist for Madame Tussaud’s in London, provided information for understanding At Madame Tussaud’s in Victorian Years.
Miss Joan Brocklebank of Affpuddle helped with problems of Hardy’s old folk tunes.
Dean S. Evans of Gloucester Cathedral gave me information concerning The Abbey Mason.
Monica Hutchings, author of Inside Dorset, helped with information about places. Bernard Jones of Sturminster Newton, editor of William Barnes’s Poems, translated
for me a number of Hardy’s words from Dorset dialect. Arthur Oswald of Country Life furnished facts for interpreting The Flirt’s Tragedy.
Mrs. Muir of Fawley made available the parish records there. To these and others of a list too long for citation, I am grateful for the help mentioned and many interesting suggestions.
I am grateful for permissions that I wish to acknowledge. Macmillan and Company of London has given me permission to quote portions of Hardy’s Collected Poems needed in commentary upon them. Professor Richard Purdy of Yale University, who holds the rights of publication of Hardy’s letters, has allowed me to quote from them whatever is needed in discussion of a poem. H. P. R. Hoare and the National Trust and Maurice P. Rathbone, County Archivist for Wiltshire, gave me permission to publish quotations from the letters of Mrs. Florence Hardy to Alda, Lady Hoare. Miss Irene Cooper Willis, representing the Trustees of the Hardy Estate, showed me her copies of letters in the Library of the University of Leeds and gave me permission to publish for the first time three of Hardy’s poems, hitherto withheld: the early poem, not titled, that begins When wearily we shrink away,
and two poems Hardy wrote (or dictated) on his death-bed: Epitaph
(for G. K. Chesterton) and Epitaph
(for George Moore). Mrs. Hardy evidently refrained from publishing the latter two poems because the men attacked were living. Surely Hardy meant the poems to be published at some time. The notes on these poems indicate their importance.
Contents
Preface
Introduction
Explanatory
A Chronology of Major Events in Hardy’s Life
A Key to Persons Prominent in Hardy’s Poems
William Barnes
Elizabeth (Lizbie
) Browne
Louisa Harding
Mrs. Emma Hardy
Mrs. Florence Hardy
Mary Hardy
Mrs. Arthur Henniker
Horace Mosley Moule
Lady Susan O’Brien
Tryphena Sparks
A Key to Places Prominent in Hardy’s Poems
Beeny Cliff
Black Down
Blackmoor (Blackmore) Vale
Bockhampton Lane
Boscastle
Bossiney
Budmouth
Casterbridge
Colliton House
Conquer Barrow
Dorchester
Durnover
Egdon Heath
Fordington
Frome (Froom) River, The
Grey’s Bridge
High Stoy
Higher Bockhampton
King’s Hintock
Kingston Maurward
Lewsdon Hill
Lower Bockhampton
Maiden (Mai Dun) Castle
Maumbury (Maembury) Ring(s)
Max Gate
Melbury Osmund
Mellstock
Pilsdon Pen
Poundbury Camp
Puddletown
Pummery (Pummerie)
Rainbarrow (s)
Ridgeway (Ridge-way)
Roman Road, The
Rushy Pond
St. Juliot Rectory
St. Peter’s Church
Stinsford Church
Union, The
Valency (Vallency) River, The
Weatherbury
West Stafford
Weymouth
Winyard’s (Wynyard’s) Gap
Yellowham (Yell’ham) Wood
PART ONE: NOTES ON HARDY’S COLLECTED POEMS
Wessex Poems
The Temporary the All
Amabel
Hap
In Vision I Roamed
At a Bridal
Postponement
A Confession to a Friend in Trouble
Neutral Tones
She at His Funeral
Her Initials
Her Dilemma
Revulsion
The She, to Him
Sonnets
She, to Him, I
She, to Him, II
She, to Him, III
She, to Him, IV
Ditty
The Sergeant’s Song
Valenciennes
San Sebastian
The Stranger’s Song
The Burghers
Leipzig
The Peasant’s Confession
The Alarm
Her Death and After
The Dance at the Phoenix
The Casterbridge Captains
A Sign-Seeker
My Cicely
Her Immortality
The Ivy-Wife
A Meeting with Despair
Unknowing
Friends Beyond
To Outer Nature
Thoughts of Phena
Middle-Age Enthusiasms
In a Wood
To a Lady
To a Motherless Child
Nature’s Questioning
The Impercipient
At an Inn
The Slow Nature
In a Eweleaze Near Weatherbury
The Bride-Night Fire
Heiress and Architect
The Two Men
Lines
I Look Into My Glass
Poems of the Past and the Present
V. R. 1819-1901
War Poems
Embarcation
Departure
The Colonel’s Soliloquy
The Going of the Battery
At the War Office, London
A Christmas Ghost-Story
Drummer Hodge
A Wife in London
The Souls of the Slain
Song of the Soldiers’ Wives and Sweethearts
The Sick Battle-God
Poems of Pilgrimage
Genoa and the Mediterranean
Shelley’s Skylark
In the Old Theatre, Fiesole
Rome: On the Palatine
Rome: Building a New Street in the Ancient Quarter
Rome: The Vatican: Sala Delle Muse
Rome: At the Pyramid of Cestius Near the Graves of Shelley and Keats
Lausanne: In Gibbon’s Old Garden: 11-12 P.M.
Zermatt: To the Matterhorn
The Bridge of Lodi
On an Invitation to the United States
Miscellaneous Poems
The Mother Mourns
I Said to Love
A Commonplace Day
At a Lunar Eclipse
The Lacking Sense
To Life
Doom and She
The Problem
The Subalterns
The Sleep-Worker
The Bullfinches
God-Forgotten
The Bedridden Peasant
By the Earth’s Corpse
Mute Opinion
To an Unborn Pauper Child
To Flowers from Italy in Winter
On a Fine Morning
To Lizbie Browne
Song of Hope
The Well-Beloved
Her Reproach
The Inconsistent
A Broken Appointment
Between Us Now
How Great My Grief
I Need Not Go
The Coquette, and After
A Spot
Long Plighted
The Widow Betrothed
At a Hasty Wedding
The Dream-Follower
His Immortality
The To-Be-Forgotten
Wives in the Sere
The Superseded
An August Midnight
The Caged Thrush Freed and Home Again
Birds at Winter Nightfall
The Puzzled Game-Birds
Winter in Durnover Field
The Last Chrysanthemum
The Darkling Thrush
The Comet at Yell’ham
Mad Judy
A Wasted Illness
A Man
The Dame of Athelhall
The Seasons of Her Year
The Milkmaid
The Levelled Churchyard
The Ruined Maid
The Respectable Burgher
Architectural Masks
The Tenant-for-Life
The King’s Experiment
The Tree
Her Late Husband
The Self-Unseeing
In Tenebris
In Tenebris I
In Tenebris II
In Tenebris III
The Church-Builder
The Lost Pyx
Tess’s Lament
The Supplanter
Imitations, etc.
Sapphic Fragment
Catullus: XXXI
After Schiller
Song from Heine
From Victor Hugo
Cardinal Bembo’s Epitaph on Raphael
I Have Lived with Shades
Memory and I
‘AГNΩΣTΩι ⊖EΩι
Time’s Laughingstocks and Other Verses
Time’s Laughingstocks
The Revisitation
A Trampwoman’s Tragedy
The Two Rosalinds
A Sunday Morning Tragedy
The House of Hospitalities
Bereft
John and Jane
The Curate’s Kindness
The Flirt’s Tragedy
The Rejected Member’s Wife
The Farm-Woman’s Winter
Autumn in King’s Hintock Park
Shut Out That Moon
Reminiscences of a Dancing Man
The Dead Man Walking
More Love Lyrics
1967
Her Definition
The Division
On the Departure Platform
In a Cathedral City
I Say I’ll Seek Her
Her Father
At Waking
Four Footprints
In the Vaulted Way
In the Mind’s Eye
The End of the Episode
The Sigh
In the Night She Came
The Conformers
The Dawn After the Dance
The Sun on the Letter
The Night of the Dance
Misconception
The Voice of the Thorn
From Her in the Country
Her Confession
To an Impersonator of Rosalind
To an Actress
The Minute Before Meeting
He Abjures Love
A Set of Country Songs
Let Me Enjoy
At Casterbridge Fair
The Ballad-Singer
Former Beauties
After the Club Dance
The Market-Girl
The Inquiry
A Wife Waits
After the Fair
The Dark-Eyed Gentleman
To Carrey Clavel
The Orphaned Old Maid
The Spring Call
Julie-Jane
News for Her Mother
The Fiddler
The Husband’s View
Rose-Ann
The Homecoming
Pieces Occasional and Various
A Church Romance
The Rash Bride
The Dead Quire
The Christening
A Dream Question
By the Barrows
A Wife and Another
The Roman Road
The Vampirine Fair
The Reminder
The Rambler
Night in the Old Home
After the Last Breath
In Childbed
The Pine Planters
The Dear
One We Knew
She Hears the Storm
A Wet Night
Before Life and After
New Year’s Eve
God’s Education
To Sincerity
Panthera
The Unborn
The Man He Killed
Geographical Knowledge
One Ralph Blossom Soliloquizes
The Noble Lady’s Tale
Unrealized
Wagtail and Baby
Aberdeen
George Meredith
Yell’ham-Wood’s Story
A Young Man’s Epigram on Existence
Satires of Circumstance Lyrics and Reveries
Lyrics and Reveries
In Front of the Landscape
Channel Firing
The Convergence of the Twain
The Ghost of the Past
After the Visit
To Meet, or Otherwise
The Difference
The Sun on the Bookcase
When I Set Out for Lyonnesse
A Thunderstorm in Town
The Torn Letter
Beyond the Last Lamp
The Face at the Casement
Lost Love
My Spirit Will Not Haunt the Mound
Wessex Heights
In Death Divided
The Place on the Map
The Schreckhorn
A Singer Asleep
A Plaint to Man
God’s Funeral
Spectres that Grieve
Ah, Are You Digging on My Grave?
Self-Unconscious
The Discovery
Tolerance
Before and After Summer
At Day-Close in November
The Year’s Awakening
Under the Waterfall
Poems of 1912-13
The Going
Your Last Drive
The Walk
Rain on a Grave
I Found Her Out There
Without Ceremony
Lament
The Haunter
The Voice
His Visitor
A Circular
A Dream or No
After a Journey
A Death-Day Recalled
Beeny Cliff
At Castle Boterel
Places
The Phantom Horsewoman
The Spell of the Rose
St. Launce’s Revisited
Where the Picnic Was
Miscellaneous Pieces
The Wistful Lady
The Woman in the Rye
The Cheval-Glass
The Re-enactment
Her Secret
She Charged Me
The Newcomer’s Wife
A Conversation at Dawn
A King’s Soliloquy on the Night of His Funeral
The Coronation
Aquae Sulis
Seventy-Four and Twenty
The Elopement
I Rose Up As My Custom Is
A Week
Had You Wept
Bereft, She Thinks She Dreams
In the British Museum
In the Servants’ Quarters
The Obliterate Tomb
Regret Not Me
The Recalcitrants
Starlings on the Roof
The Moon Looks In
The Sweet Hussy
The Telegram
The Moth-Signal
Seen by the Waits
The Two Soldiers
The Death of Regret
In the Days of Crinoline
The Roman Gravemounds
The Workbox
The Sacrilege
The Abbey Mason
The Jubilee of a Magazine
The Satin Shoes
Exeunt Omnes
A Poet
Satires of Circumstance in Fifteen Glimpses
At Tea
In Church
By Her Aunt’s Grave
In the Room of the Bride-Elect
At a Watering-Place
In the Cemetery
Outside the Window
In the Study
At the Altar-Rail
In the Nuptial Chamber
In the Restaurant
At the Draper’s
On the Death-Bed
Over the Coffin
In the Moonlight
Moments of Vision
Moments of Vision
The Voice of Things
Why Be At Pains?
We Sat at the Window
Afternoon Service at Mellstock
At the Wicket-Gate
In a Museum
Apostrophe to an Old Psalm Tune
At the Word Farewell
First Sight of Her and After
The Rival
Heredity
You Were the Sort that Men Forget
She, I, and They
Near Lanivet, 1872
Joys of Memory
To the Moon
Copying Architecture in an Old Minster
To Shakespeare After Three Hundred Years
Quid Hic Agis?
On a Midsummer Eve
Timing Her
Before Knowledge
The Blinded Bird
The Wind Blew Words
The Faded Face
The Riddle
The Duel
At Mayfair Lodgings
To my Father’s Violin
The Statue of Liberty
The Background and the Figure
The Change
Sitting on the Bridge
The Young Churchwarden
I Travel as a Phantom Now
Lines to a Movement in Mozart’s E-Flat Symphony
In the Seventies
The Pedigree
His Heart A Woman’s Dream
Where They Lived
The Occultation
Life Laughs Onward
The Peace-Offering
Something Tapped
The Wound
A Merrymaking in Question
I Said and Sang Her Excellence
A January Night
A Kiss
The Announcement
The Oxen
The Tresses
The Photograph
On a Heath
An Anniversary
By the Runic Stone
The Pink Frock
Transformations
In Her Precincts
The Last Signal
The House of Silence
Great Things
The Chimes
The Figure in the Scene
Why Did I Sketch
Conjecture
The Blow
Love the Monopolist
At Middle-Field Gate in February
The Youth Who Carried a Light
The Head Above the Fog
Overlooking the River Stour
The Musical Box
On Sturminster Foot-Bridge
Royal Sponsors
Old Furniture
A Thought in Two Moods
The Last Performance
You on the Tower
The Interloper
Logs on the Hearth
The Sunshade
The Ageing House
The Caged Goldfinch
At Madame Tussaud’s in Victorian Years
The Ballet
The Five Students
The Wind’s Prophecy
During Wind and Rain
He Prefers Her Earthly
The Dolls
Molly Gone
A Backward Spring
Looking Across
At a Seaside Town in 1869
The Glimpse
The Pedestrian
Who’s in the Next Room?
At a Country Fair
The Memorial Brass: 186-
Her Love-Birds
Paying Calls
The Upper Birch-Leaves
It Never Looks Like Summer
Everything Comes
The Man with a Past
He Fears His Good Fortune
He Wonders About Himself
Jubilate
He Revisits His First School
I Thought, My Heart
Fragment
Midnight on the Great Western
Honeymoon Time at an Inn
The Robin
I Rose and Went to Rou’tor Town
The Nettles
In a Waiting-Room
The Clock-Winder
Old Excursions
The Masked Face
In a Whispering Gallery
The Something That Saved Him
The Enemy’s Portrait
Imaginings
On the Doorstep
Signs and Tokens
Paths of Former Time
The Clock of the Years
At the Piano
The Shadow on the Stone
In the Garden
The Tree and the Lady
An Upbraiding
The Young Glass-Stainer
Looking at a Picture on an Anniversary
The Choirmaster’s Burial
The Man Who Forgot
While Drawing in a Churchyard
For Life I Had Never Cared Greatly
Poems of War and Patriotism
Men Who March Away
His Country
England to Germany in 1914
On the Belgian Expatriation
An Appeal to America on Behalf of the Belgian Destitute
The Pity of It
In Time of Wars and Tumults
In Time of The Breaking of Nations
Cry of the Homeless
Before Marching and After
Often When Warring
Then and Now
A Call to National Service
The Dead and the Living One
A New Year’s Eve in War Time
I Met a Man
I Looked Up from My Writing
Finale
The Coming of the End
Afterwards
Late Lyrics and Earlier
Apology
Weathers
The Maid of Keinton Mandeville
Summer Schemes
Epeisodia
Faintheart in a Railway Train
At Moonrise and Onwards
The Garden Seat
Barthélémon at Vauxhall
I Sometimes Think
Jezreel
A Jog-Trot Pair
The Curtains Now Are Drawn
According to the Mighty Working
I Was Not He
The West-of-Wessex Girl
Welcome Home
Going and Staying
Read by Moonlight
At a House in Hampstead
A Woman’s Fancy
Her Song
A Wet August
The Dissemblers
To a Lady Playing and Singing in the Morning
A Man was Drawing Near to Me
The Strange House
As ‘Twere To-Night
The Contretemps
A Gentleman’s Epitaph on Himself and a Lady, Who Were Buried Together
The Old Gown
A Night in November
A Duettist to Her Pianoforte
Where Three Roads Joined
And There Was a Great Calm
Haunting Fingers
The Woman I Met
If It’s Ever Spring Again
The Two Houses
On Stinsford Hill at Midnight
The Fallow Deer at the Lonely House
The Selfsame Song
The Wanderer
A Wife Comes Back
A Young Man’s Exhortation
At Lulworth Cove a Century Back
A Bygone Occasion
Two Serenades
The Wedding Morning
End of the Year 1912
The Chimes Play Life’s a Bumper!
I Worked No Wile to Meet You
At the Railway Station, Upway
Side by Side
Dream of the City Shopwoman
A Maiden’s Pledge
The Child and the Sage
Mismet
An Autumn Rain-Scene
Meditations on a Holiday
An Experience
The Beauty
The Collector Cleans His Picture
The Wood Fire
Saying Good-Bye
On the Tune Called The Old-Hundred-and-Fourth
The Opportunity
Evelyn G. of Christminster
The Rift
Voices from Things Growing in a Churchyard
On the Way
She Did Not Turn
Growth in May
The Children and Sir Nameless
At the Royal Academy
Her Temple
A Two-Years’ Idyll
By Henstridge Cross at the Year’s End
Penance
I Look in Her Face
After the War
If You Had Known
The Chapel-Organist
Fetching Her
Could I But Will
She Revisits Alone the Church of Her Marriage
At the Entering of the New Year
They Would Not Come
After a Romantic Day
The Two Wives
I Knew a Lady
A House with a History
A Procession of Dead Days
He Follows Himself
The Singing Woman
Without, Not Within Her
O I Won’t Lead a Homely Life
In the Small Hours
The Little Old Table
Vagg Hollow
The Dream is—Which?
The Country Wedding
First Or Last
Lonely Days
What Did It Mean?
At the Dinner-Table
The Marble Tablet
The Master and the Leaves
Last Words to a Dumb Friend
A Drizzling Easter Morning
On One Who Lived and Died Where He Was Born
The Second Night
She Who Saw Not
The Old Workman
The Sailor’s Mother
Outside the Casement
The Passer-By
I Was the Midmost
A Sound in the Night
On a Discovered Curl of Hair
An Old Likeness
Her Apotheosis
Sacred to the Memory
To a Well-Named Dwelling
The Whipper-in
A Military Appointment
The Milestone by the Rabbit-Burrow
The Lament of the Looking-Glass
Cross-Currents
The Old Neighbour and the New
The Chosen
The Inscription
The Marble-Streeted Town
A Woman Driving
A Woman’s Trust
Best Times
The Casual Acquaintance
Intra Sepulchrum
The Whitewashed Wall
Just the Same
The Last Time
The Seven Times
The Sun’s Last Look on the Country Girl
In a London Flat
Drawing Details in an Old Church
Rake-Hell Muses
The Colour
Murmurs in the Gloom
Epitaph
An Ancient to Ancients
After Reading Psalms XXXIX., XL., Etc.
Surview
Human Shows
Waiting Both
A Bird-Scene at a Rural Dwelling
Any Little Old Song
In a Former Resort after Many Years
A Cathedral Façade at Midnight
The Turnip-Hoer
The Carrier
Lover to Mistress
The Monument-Maker
Circus-Rider to Ringmaster
Last Week in October
Come Not; Yet Come!
The Later Autumn
Let Me Believe
At a Fashionable Dinner
Green Slates
An East-End Curate
At Rushy-Pond
Four in the Morning
On the Esplanade
In St. Paul’s a While Ago
Coming Up Oxford Street: Evening
A Last Journey
Singing Lovers
The Month’s Calendar
A Spellbound Palace
When Dead
Sine Prole
Ten Years Since
Every Artemisia
The Best She Could
The Graveyard of Dead Creeds
There Seemed a Strangeness
A Night of Questionings
Xenophanes, the Monist of Colophon
Life and Death at Sunrise
Night-Time in Mid-Fall
A Sheep Fair
Snow in the Suburbs
A Light Snow-Fall After Frost
Winter Night in Woodland
Ice on the Highway
Music in a Snowy Street
The Frozen Greenhouse
Two Lips
No Buyers
One Who Married Above Him
The New Toy
Queen Caroline to Her Guests
Plena Timoris
The Weary Walker
Last Love-Word
Nobody Comes
In the Street
The Last Leaf
At Wynyard’s Gap
At Shag’s Heath
A Second Attempt
Freed the Fret of Thinking
The Absolute Explains
So, Time
An Inquiry
The Faithful Swallow
In Sherborne Abbey
The Pair He Saw Pass
The Mock Wife
The Fight on Durnover Moor
Last Look Round St. Martin’s Fair
The Caricature
A Leader of Fashion
Midnight on Beechen, 187-
The Aërolite
The Prospect
Genitrix Laesa
The Fading Rose
When Oats Were Reaped
Louie
She Opened the Door
What’s There To Tell?
The Harbour Bridge
Vagrant’s Song
Farmer Dunman’s Funeral
The Sexton at Longpuddle
The Harvest-Supper
At a Pause in a Country Dance
On the Portrait of a Woman About To Be Hanged
The Church and the Wedding
The Shiver
Not Only I
She Saw Him, She Said
Once at Swanage
The Flower’s Tragedy
At the Aquatic Sports
A Watcher’s Regret
Horses Aboard
The History of an Hour
The Missed Train
Under High-Stoy Hill
At the Mill
Alike and Unlike
The Thing Unplanned
The Sheep-Boy
Retty’s Phases
A Poor Man and a Lady
An Expostulation
To a Sea-Cliff
The Echo-Elf Answers
Cynic’s Epitaph
A Beauty’s Soliloquy During Her Honeymoon
Donaghadee
He Inadvertently Cures His Love-Pains
The Peace Peal
Lady VI
A Popular Personage at Home
Inscriptions for a Peal of Eight Bells
A Refusal
Epitaph on a Pessimist
The Protean Maiden
A Watering-Place Lady Inventoried
The Sea Fight
Paradox
The Rover Come Home
Known Had I
The Pat of Butter
Bags of Meat
The Sundial on a Wet Day
Her Haunting-Ground
A Parting-Scene
Shortening Days at the Homestead
Days to Recollect
To C. F. H.
The High-School Lawn
The Forbidden Banns
The Paphian Ball
On Martock Moor
That Moment
Premonitions
This Summer and Last
Nothing Matters Much
In the Evening
The Six Boards
Before My Friend Arrived
Compassion
Why She Moved House
Tragedian to Tragedienne
The Lady of Forebodings
The Bird-Catcher’s Boy
A Hurried Meeting
Discouragement
A Leaving
Song to an Old Burden
Why Do I?
Winter Words
The New Dawn’s Business
Proud Songsters
Thoughts at Midnight
I Am the One
The Prophetess
A Wish for Unconsciousness
The Bad Example
To Louisa in the Lane
Love Watches a Window
The Love-Letters
An Unkindly May
Unkept Good Fridays
The Mound
Liddell and Scott
Christmastide
Reluctant Confession
Expectation and Experience
Aristodemus the Messenian
Evening Shadows
The Three Tall Men
The Lodging-House Fuchsias
The Whaler’s Wife
Throwing a Tree
The War-Wife of Catknoll
Concerning His Old Home
Her Second Husband Hears Her Story
Yuletide in a Younger World
After the Death of a Friend
The Son’s Portrait
Lying Awake
The Lady in the Furs
Childhood Among the Ferns
A Countenance
A Poet’s Thought
Silences
I Watched a Blackbird
A Nightmare, and the Next Thing
To a Tree in London
The Felled Elm and She
He Did Not Know Me
So Various
A Self-Glamourer
The Dead Bastard
The Clasped Skeletons
In the Marquee
After the Burial
The Mongrel
Concerning Agnes
Henley Regatta
An Evening in Galilee
The Brother
We Field-Women
A Practical Woman
Squire Hooper
A Gentleman’s Second-Hand Suit
We Say We Shall Not Meet
Seeing the Moon Rise
Song to Aurore
He Never Expected Much
Standing by the Mantelpiece
Boys Then and Now
That Kiss in the Dark
A Necessitarian’s Epitaph
Burning the Holly
Suspense
The Second Visit
Our Old Friend Dualism
Faithful Wilson
Gallant’s Song
A Philosophical Fantasy
A Question of Marriage
The Letter’s Triumph
A Forgotten Miniature
Whispered at the Church-Opening
In Weatherbury Stocks
A Placid Man’s Epitaph
The New Boots
The Musing Maiden
Lorna the Second
A Daughter Returns
The Third Kissing-Gate
Drinking Song
The Tarrying Bridegroom
The Destined Pair
A Musical Incident
June Leaves and Autumn
No Bell-Ringing
I Looked Back
The Aged Newspaper Soliloquizes
Christmas: 1924
The Single Witness
How She Went to Ireland
Dead Wessex
the Dog to the Household
The Woman Who Went East
Not Known
The Boy’s Dream
The Gap in the White
Family Portraits
The Catching Ballet of the Wedding Clothes
A Winsome Woman
The Ballad of Love’s Skeleton
A Private Man on Public Men
Christmas in the Elgin Room
We Are Getting to the End
He Resolves to Say No More
PART TWO: NOTES ON HARDY’S POEMS NOT PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED OR NOT COLLECTED, ALTERNATE TITLES, THE DYNASTS, AND THE QUEEN OF CORNWALL
Introduction
A. H., 1855-1912
Above the Youth’s
After the Battle
Agnostic (Evensong: Cathedral), The
Among the Roman Gravemounds
As if Not There
At a Rehearsal of One of J. M. B’s Plays
At an Evening Service [Sunday] August 14, 1870
At His Funeral
At Lodgings in London
At Madame Tussaud’s and Later
At Middle-Hill Gate in February
At Moonrise, or we used to go
At News of a Woman’s Death
At St. Launce’s
At the Cemetery Lodge
At the War Office after a Bloody Battle
Autumn [October] at the Homestead
Autumn Evening
Autumn in My Lord’s Park
Autumn in the Park
Autumn Night-time
Battue, The
Benighted Traveller, The
Break o’ the Day, The
Bridegroom, The
Budmouth Dears
By Mellstock Cross at the Year’s End
By the Century’s Deathbed
By the Roman Earthworks
Calf, The
Century’s End, The
Chance
Children versus Sir Nameless, The
Choirmaster’s Funeral, The
Chorus of the Pities
Clock of Time, The
Comet at Yalbury or Yell’ham, The
Complaint of the Common Man, The
Conversational Phantasy, A
Cornhill’s
Jubilee, The
Dairyman Dick
Dandy’s Song
Day of First Sight
De Profundis, I, II, and III
Dead Drummer, The
Dead Fingers, The
Dear my love
December Rain-Scene, A
Departure, The
Departure by Train, A
Discord, A
Domicilium
Down Wessex Way
Dream indeed?, A
Dynasts, The
Ejected Member’s Wife, The
Emleen
End of the Old Year
Epigram on Existence
Epilogue
Epilogue (of The Dynasts)
Epitaph (for G. K. Chesterton)
Epitaph (for George Moore)
Epitaph by Labourers on Jas.
Eunice
Evaders, The
Eve of Waterloo, The
Exhortation, An
Face in the Mind’s Eye, The
Fair Vampire, The
Fall of the Leaf, The
Famous Tragedy of the Queen of Cornwall, The
Far from the Madding Crowd
Felling a Tree
Fiddler’s Story, The
Fine Lady, The
Fire at Tranter Sweatley’s, The
Forebodings
Forsaking of the Nest, The
Funeral of Jahveh, The
G. M.
Glass in the Stream, The
Glass-Stainer, The
Glimpse from the Train, A
Great Adjustment, The
Hangman’s Song, The
Hatband, The
He Prefers the Earthly
He views himself as an automaton
His Education
His Love brings little Pleasure
Hope Song of the Soldiers’ Sweethearts and Wives
How He Looked in at the Draper’s
Humour in the Servants’ Quarters
Hundred Years Since, A
Hussar’s Song: Budmouth Dears
If I Had Known
If You Think
Imaginative Maiden, The
Impromptu to the Editor, An
In a Churchyard
In a Eweleaze
In an Old Place of Resort after Many Years
In a London Lodging
In Memoriam, F. T.
In Memory of Sergeant M——. Died 184-
In St. Paul’s: 1869
In the Crypted Way
In the Matter of an Intent, A Philosophic Fantasy
In the Time of War and Tumults
In Time of Slaughter
Inquiry, An
Jingle on the Times, A
Lady Clo
Lady in the Christmas Furs, The
Lady Revisits Alone the Church of Her Marriage, A
Lament, A
Last Chorus
Last Leaving, A
Latter-Day Chorus, A
Lavine
Let Me
Life’s Opportunity
Lizard, The
London Nights
Long-Ago Sunrise at Dogbury Gate, A
Looking Back
Many a one has loved as much as I
Marble Monument, The
Midnight Revel, The
Misery of That Moment, The
My Love’s Gone a-fighting
Newspaper Soliloquises, The
Night in a Suburb
Night of Trafalgar, The
1918
Nisi Dominus Frustra
No Girl in Wessex
Noble Lady’s Story, The
Not a line of her writing have I
Not Again
O Jan! O Jan! O Jan!
Oh the old old clock
Old Clock, The
Old Mason, The
Old Paths, The
Old Portrait, The
On Durnover Moor
On J. M. B.
On Stourcastle Foot-Bridge (1877)
On the Doorstep
One Who Ought Not to be There
Orphaned, A Point of View
Pale was the day
Pathetic Fallacy, The
Peace upon Earth
Peasant’s Philosophy, A
Pedestrian, The
Phantom, The
Plaint of a Puppet, The
Plaint of Certain Spectres, The
Play of St. George, The
Poem on the War, A
Poems Imaginative and Incidental
Poems of Feeling, Dream, and Deed
Point du Jour, Le
Portraits, The
Pretty pink frock
Prologue (of The Dynasts)
Protean Lady, The
Queen of Cornwall, The
Questions
Quiet Tragedy, A
Rain on Her Grave
Rejected One’s Wife, The
Remembrance
Rencounter, A
Return from First Beholding Her, The
Return to Athels-hall, The
Seducer Muses, The
She
She Thinks She Dreams
She Would Welcome Old Tribulations
Sick God, The
Sleeping Palace, A
Snow at Upper Tooting
Song
Song of the Soldiers
Song of the Soldiers’ Wives
Sonnet on the Belgian Expatriation
Sound of Her, The
Staying and Going
T———a. At news of her death. (Died 1890)
They Are Great Trees
Thoughts from Sophocles
Thoughts of Ph———a
Three Burghers, The
Thrown Elm, The
Time’s Laughingstocks, A Summer Romance
To a Bridegroom
To an Orphan Child
To External Nature
To Him
To His Scornful Love
To J. M. B.
To Lady ———. Offended by something the Author had written
To my Father’s Fiddle
To the Unknown God
Tramp’s Tragedy, The
Two Red Lips
Two Roses
Two Tall Men, The
Unplanted Primrose, The
Upper Leaves, The
Vicar’s Young Wife, The
Victorian Rehearsal, A
Voices from Things Growing
Waiting
War-Shadow
Wasted Illness (Overheard), A
Wet Easter Morning, A
When I Weekly Knew
When wearily we shrink away
While Drawing Architecture in a Churchyard
White and Blue
Widow, The
Widow’s Thought, The
Wind at the Door, The
Woman of the West
Words on the Brass, The
World’s Verdict. A Morality-rime
Yellow-Hammer, The
Young Hope (Song)
Bibliography
Index
The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
Introduction
A professor teaching a course in the interpretation of poetry had adopted an anthology without footnotes, and assigned Hardy’s The Phantom Horsewoman.
Then he studied the poem himself by examining the point of view, the diction, the expected ironies, the rhythms, the figures of speech, and the supposed symbolism, but the ghost-girl rider
baffled him. What does she symbolize?
he asked me. Death, riding the pale horse of Revelation? Is she luring the man into the sea?
He thought of every possibility except a fact he did not know because he was unfamiliar with Hardy’s life-story. I told him that the ghost is Hardy’s memory in 1913 of Emma Gifford as she was when he had courted her in Cornwall in 1870. With this fact he was able to march to his classroom beaming.
I. A. Richards, to discover whether students can judge poetry without some hint, at least, of facts the poet had in mind, conducted an experiment among his undergraduates reading English for an Honors Degree at Cambridge University. He distributed on printed sheets poems without title, author’s name, or other facts external to the poem itself. One of the poems was Hardy’s George Meredith.
Richards asked the students to write critical evaluations. The responses exhibited complete confusion about what the poem said, and the evaluations ranged from condemnation of the poem as worthless to extravagant praise. Students said: It arouses no emotions in me. I understand what it says, but feel no interest in it.
I feel there is something wrong with this poem. Perhaps it is that the poet plunges too quickly into his subject; he does not pause to create an atmosphere.
The second verse is nonsense. The second line of verse four is particularly poor, only excelled perhaps by the second line of the last verse. Who ever heard of anything so strained, so artificial as ‘The world’s vaporous vitiate air’? The effort was not worth the ink it used.
¹ If the students had known even the title and the author their judgments would have been different. If they had known of Hardy’s long friendship with Meredith some who supposed the poem ludicrous might have found it an interesting critical estimate and tribute.
Except when Hardy was presenting matters so personal that he felt concealment necessary, he had no intention of being obscure. He said in 1918: It is unfortunate for the cause of present day poetry that a fashion for obscurity rages among young poets, so that much good verse is lost by the simple inability of readers to rack their brains to solve conundrums.
² He said again in 1920: I am very anxious not to be obscure. It is not fair to one’s readers. . . . Some of the younger poets are too obscure.
³ Hardy’s poetry is obscure only when he wrote of persons, places, events, or philosophical views that he could not explain except in a long footnote or did not care to explain because of the intimate material.
Since he did not state backgrounds, poems that some reviewers, critics, and scholars have called masterpieces of structure, music, or philosophic statement, were called by others trivial, trite, rough, or melodramatic. In my observation, the more a critic has known of the backgrounds of the poems, the more just his judgments. For example, a recent book on Hardy’s poetry assumes that My Cicely
is fiction and dismisses it as one of Hardy’s canned melodramas.
Examination of the poem as possibly a reflection of Hardy’s journey to Topsham when he heard a false rumor of the death of Mrs. Tryphena Gale at least removes it from the category of canned melodrama. Knowledge of the places mentioned along the route illuminates Hardy’s interest in history and geography.
An understanding of backgrounds is especially important in reading Hardy’s poems. Florence Emily Hardy’s The Later Years says: Speaking generally, there is more autobiography in a hundred lines of Mr. Hardy’s poetry than in all the novels.
⁴ He wrote to Clive Holland in August, 1923: If you read the . . . ‘Collected Poems’ you will gather more personal particulars than I could give you in an interview, circumstances not being so veiled in the verse as in the novels.
⁵
These statements are all the more impressive in view of the fact that Hardy’s novels contain a good deal of his experience and observation. Doris Arthur Jones records that Hardy told my father that he had never put an incident or a character in one of his books that he had not warranty for in real life.
⁶ Weber, analyzing Jude the Obscure, traces in some detail the extent to which Hardy put himself into his fiction.⁷ Thus we may suspect that a poem may be related to Hardy’s life and that the key to its meaning may lie in knowledge of the facts, besides the light that seeing this connection may throw on details only hinted at in Hardy’s biography.
The personal story underlying a poem may be psychological rather than physically factual. For example, when a boy, Hardy had a brief, sentimental affection for a neighborhood girl, Louisa Harding. During most of his life, he more or less forgot her; though she never married, but lived her long life in Dorchester, it is recorded that Hardy never spoke to her. After her death Hardy, in his old age, wrote two poems about her, Louie
and To Louisa in the Lane,
which must be considered love-poems. He took guests to Stinsford Churchyard to visit her grave. In the sense that a vivid daydream is a biographical fact, the poems to Louisa are autobiographical.
On the other hand, Hardy did mingle fiction with fact. In his poems more than in his novels, he used actual place-names but sometimes used a fictional name for an actual place (as Durnover
for Fordington) and sometimes so concealed a place that not even his friend Hermann Lea could identify it. He sometimes used actual persons’ names but sometimes disguised persons with fictional names. He assumed fictional personalities. We have Hardy’s insistent warning not to assume that all his poems with ‘I’ as their apparent speaker are in any way autobiographical.
⁸
Some poems may deal with personal matters even when there is no external evidence of the fact. It seems that Hardy felt some compulsion to express himself in poetry about matters he did not wish known. The poems that deal with Tryphena Sparks illustrate this tendency. He deliberately destroyed many records. He cut pages from his notebooks; he wrote instructions on them in red ink to his wife and his executor, Sir Sydney Cockerell, that they go through his papers and destroy certain documents. After Hardy’s death, Cockerell was much at Max Gate, sorting and burning papers,
for he had promised to prevent the publication of any of Hardy’s early letters that might come to light after his death.
⁹ There were bonfires of papers at Max Gate. Mrs. Hardy stood by the whole time and watched, presumably to ensure that nothing escaped the flames. . . . Mrs. Hardy herself burnt, on another bonfire, baskets full of the letters and private papers that I [the gardener] had carried down from the study to the garden under her supervision and watchful eye. She would not let me burn these, but insisted upon doing it herself, and after all the papers had been destroyed, she raked the ashes to be sure that not a single scrap or word remained.
¹⁰ These facts make documented explanation of the backgrounds for many poems impossible.
Therefore, in the present Handbook and Commentary, I have thought it reasonable, when a poem seems related to known facts in Hardy’s life, to surmise the missing facts. (Every surmise is stated to be so.) I have tried to make sense of each poem but also to avoid any unwarranted inference that a statement is biographical because it occurs in a poem. Hardy did write fiction.
It may be of interest to glance at some features of his temperament as revealed in his poems. He seems to have lived as vividly in his memory as in the present, perhaps even more vividly. He tended to idealize and romanticize the images of memory. J. C. Squire wrote: It is characteristic of Mr. Hardy that only the landscapes of his past are ever sunny; when he is writing in the present tense the chances are a hundred to one that it will be raining hard, on window-pane and bereaved tree, and there is quite a strong probability that he will actually find himself in a churchyard where the natural inclemency of the weather is re-inforced by the rain-worn cherubs on the tombstones, the half-effaced names, the dripping moss and the direct reminders of the dead.
Hardy clipped this statement from a review, pasted it in his scrapbook, and opposite it wrote in pencil: good!
¹¹ This tendency is portrayed in The Old Neighbour and the New,
where Hardy, calling on William Barnes’s successor, scarcely sees the new rector to whom he is talking because he sees sitting in the rector’s chair a vivid mental image of his old, dead friend. The tendency is allowed free rein in his Poems of 1912-13
concerned with his memories of his first wife Emma, after her death. The mental process suggests an analogy with photography: the actual exposure is vivified, enriched, and colored when it is developed
in the memory. Such idealizations may be mingled with remorse, where Hardy’s actions, as in his married life with Emma, had brought pain not realized at the time.
An aspect of his memory is that it included much he did not himself experience. The poem One We Knew
presents Hardy’s grandmother, Mary Hardy, who, until her death in 1857, would sit by the fire with Tommy at her knees, talking of the experiences and observations of a long and eventful life. The poem says that she spoke not as one who remembers, / But rather as one who sees.
Tommy apparently saw all she told him so vividly that it seemed his own experience. The tales, legends, and facts of history poured into the ears of the eager boy are reproduced in dozens of poems of country folk who lived in Wessex villages before Hardy’s birth. Ballad-like in structure, often tragic in outcome, permeated with folk-lore, such tales appear vividly in poems like The Dark-Eyed Gentleman
and The Bride-Night Fire.
Hardy was careful to make his country people authentic in person, place, and lore. Writing in 1903 to John Pascoe, who had asked whether the legendary matter and folk-lore of his books was traditionary and not invented,
he said that this was a point on which I was careful not to falsify local beliefs & customs.
¹²
Seeming to think of the past as present and of the dead in their graves as somehow alive, Hardy not only wrote Friends Beyond
to tell stories of the dead, but also spent much time visiting churchyards, Paying Calls
(as a poem is titled) on dead friends. He saw nothing lugubrious in this interest but said: I used to spend much time in such places sketching, with another pupil, and we had many pleasant times at the work. Probably this explains why churchyards and churches never seem gloomy to me.
¹³ There is another explanation. A broken stone skull in Stinsford Church fascinated Hardy when he was a boy. In June, 1926, when Sir Sydney Cockerell visited Max Gate, Cockerell wrote in his diary: We went after breakfast for a motor drive, first to Stinsford Church where T. H. pointed out the place where he sat in a pew as a boy under the skull at the base of the monument to Audley Grey. The skull used to frighten him on dark days.
¹⁴ The feeling of fright disappeared when Hardy, reading the scientists (Huxley’s On the Physical Basis of Life,
for instance), came to see that death is a process going on all through life and that from the corrupted body new life grows, as in Voices from Things Growing in a Churchyard.
Thus, in Hardy’s poems, death haunts life in a friendly way.
Hardy described places in a double vision of their present and their past, often giving them names suggesting their past: he wrote of Puddletown but called it Weatherbury
for the nearby ancient British hillfort of Weatherby; he called the village of Yetminster by its medieval name of Estminster. Perhaps to suggest more of the Roman castra,
he renamed Dorchester Casterbridge
and emphasized that it announced old Rome in every street, alley, and precinct. It looked Roman, bespoke the art of Rome, concealed dead men of Rome.
¹⁵ The places are real, described with the accuracy of an architectural draftsman, and identifiable, in spite of the changes of the present century, for he pictured their permanent aspects. The past in Hardy’s poems and novels haunts the present.
His reading in the scientists during the 1860’s caused him to abandon the religious faith of his boyhood and hence the concept of God as a manlike Father. Yet he could not abandon his wonder at the riddle of life and a strong feeling for religion. He expressed his wonder in a series of fantasies that personify the unknowable Power underlying existence and his feeling of compassion for all living and suffering things. The personifications of the powers of nature took various forms which by 1900, under the influence of Schopenhauer, Von Hartmann, and other philosophers, had merged into the Immanent Will of The Dynasts. Essentially the Will is a symbol for the mysterious, underlying, motivating forces and processes of the universe. These processes seem to have no consciousness, feeling, or morality. They are the processes of J. S. Mill’s Nature.
Hardy spoke of the varying aspects of this symbol in the last sentence of the Preface of his last volume of poetry, Winter Words: I also repeat what I have often stated on such occasions, that no harmonious philosophy is attempted in these pages—or in any bygone pages of mine, for that matter.
Hardy’s religious feeling, deeply implanted in his youth and supported by his extreme sensitivity, was broadened by his reading The Origin of Species and related works. Christian teaching suggested loving-kindness and compassion as the basic virtues, and the facts of evolution indicated that all sentient life is akin. Therefore men owe loving-kindness to birds, beasts, and even trees and flowers (often personified in Hardy’s poetry).
In this thinking, natural processes will forever be what they are, but men may ameliorate the conditions of life through compassion that, difficult in the present state of the world, may through the ages become instinctive and replace the self-regarding impulses of human nature. Hardy saw the process as a long one: he called it evolutionary meliorism.
Now and then, at least, he expressed belief in it, as in A Plaint to Man
and the conclusion of The Dynasts.
Thus, though many of Hardy’s poems are light, his subjects often trivial incidents and observations, he did have a message.
He considered his poetry as a whole to be, in Matthew Arnold’s term, a criticism of life.
He spoke scornfully of the arty poetry popular in the 1890’s (as in The Yellow Book) as the art of saying nothing with mellifluous preciosity.
¹⁶ Depressed by the irremediable ills
of indifferent natural law, he would look straight at remediable ills; he would take a full look at the Worst,
and set about reform. Besides his emphasis upon loving-kindness and compassion, he attacked a variety of evils. He wrote with pity of the farm boys—the expendable drummer Hodge and the mouldering soldier
dead in Durban-sacrificed for English prestige in the South African war. Though he supported England in World War I, for the Germans were the aggressors, he expressed The Pity of It
that kin folk kin tongued
should be led to war by dynasts, gangs whose glory threats and slaughters are.
Beyond the slaughters he deplored the psychological consequences of violence: the dark madness of the late war
and the barbarizing of taste in the younger minds, the unabashed cultivation of selfishness in all classes.
¹⁷ These post-war phenomena nearly stifled his hope for meliorism. He nearly became (what he was too often called) a pessimist. By no means active in politics, he expressed some basic principles of democracy in many poems, as in A Man
and his sympathetic treatment of ordinary village folk. He bitterly satirized social snobbery and the pretentious idle rich, as in A Leader of Fashion.
Among lesser objects of scorn, he attacked social conventions and pruderies that stifle self-expression and self-development.
Comments on other aspects of his poetry as an expression of his temperament are more the task of the critic than of a Handbook: his variety of poetic forms, often ballad-like, dramatic, or purely lyric; his humor, often overlooked by those who persist in regarding him as a hopelessly sad man; his fresh and indeed eccentric diction, with frequent disregard for the pretty, conventional phrase in favor of the word (a coined word where needed) that states precisely what he meant; and his use of irony in word and structure because he habitually observed the contrast between the romantic and the factual, the ideal and the real.
This Handbook and Commentary will by no means replace criticism in these and other fields but may supply critics with a basis for just criticism of Hardy’s poems: an understanding of the facts upon which they rest.
NOTES
1. Richards, Practical Criticism, pp. 146-53.
2. Meynell, ed., Friends of a Lifetime, p. 299.
3. Collins, Talks with Thomas Hardy at Max Gate, p. 21.
4. P. 196; Life, p. 392.
5. In the Dorset County Museum.
6. The Life and Letters of Henry Arthur Jones, p. 360.
7. Hardy of Wessex, 2nd ed., Chapter XVI.
8. Blunden, Thomas Hardy, p. 96.
9. Blunt, Cockerell, pp. 213-14.
10. Stephens, Thomas Hardy in His Garden, pp. 15-16.
11. Thomas Hardy’s Verse
pasted in Reviews of T. H.’s Books (Poetry),
in the Dorset County Museum.
12. In the Weymouth Public Library.
13. Meynell, ed., Friends of a Lifetime, p. 291.
14. Blunt, Cockerell, p. 213.
15. The Mayor of Casterbridge, Chapter XI.
16. Letter to Edmund Gosse, Dec. 12, 1898; copy in the Colby College Library.
17. Apology
for Late Lyrics and Earlier.
Explanatory
This Handbook and Commentary presents those facts in Hardy’s life needed to understand his poems. As some facts underlie many poems, full presentation with each poem of the facts upon which it rests would require continual repetition. To avoid this, I am presenting below three keys for ready reference: a chronology of major events in Hardy’s life, a key to persons prominent in several poems, and a key to places frequently mentioned. These keys attempt to tell, of such persons as Mrs. Emma Hardy or such places as Higher Bockhampton, only what is needed for understanding the poems.
The basic biography is Mrs. Florence Hardy’s The Early Life of Thomas Hardy and The Later Years of Thomas Hardy. Because of frequent reference to these volumes, I am calling them The Early Life and The Later Years (without The in footnotes). Recent republication in one volume as The Life of Thomas Hardy necessitates in the footnotes a double reference, as "Early Life, p. 35; Life, p. 27."
As Hardy’s novels are published in numerous editions, quotations from them are cited by chapter. Since the same source of information is cited in various footnotes, citations are abbreviated to author’s last name, title of the book or article, and the page numbers. Full data appear in the Bibliography. Information concerning dates and other facts of publication is taken from Professor Richard Purdy’s Thomas Hardy: A Bibliographical Study. Where the published poem is followed by a date or a place, I have omitted repetition of these facts. Much of the same information appears in many places. I have thought it sufficient to cite one source. In reading the scholarship, I have found some studies helpful in pointing to material I then looked up. For example, Copps’s The Poetry of Thomas Hardy
points to dozens of passages of the Bible quoted or echoed in Hardy’s poetry. I have cited only the Bible.
Hardy’s letters are scattered all over the world. I have examined as many as I could. Also the collection of letters to Hardy in the Dorset County Museum includes many of Hardy’s replies in the form of his pencil-draft on the back of a letter. I have assumed that the pencil-draft in Hardy’s handwriting is essentially the reply that was typed and mailed. To save space, I have referred to Hardy’s letters that I have seen only in draft as In the Dorset County Museum.
Hardy’s habit of close revision suggests that the letter may exist elsewhere with some differences in wording.
In Part One, the comments on Hardy’s Collected Poems are arranged in the order of the poems as published in the 1962 edition by Macmillan and Company, Ltd., of London, which contains the poems of Winter Words. (The arrangement in the American edition, published by the Macmillan Company of New York, is essentially the same, but the volume does not include Winter Words.) Part Two treats poems not published in the Collected Poems, alternate titles of poems, etc. It includes several poems here published for the first time. The arrangement is alphabetical by title.
A CHRONOLOGY OF MAJOR EVENTS IN HARDY’S LIFE
This chronology is designed to show the relationships among major facts in Hardy’s life and thus among biographical items in the poems. The chronology omits many of Hardy’s movements—for instance, his frequent illnessess, short trips to London (often several times a year), and brief visits to persons and places in Wessex.
1840: June 2, Thomas Hardy was born at Higher Bockhampton.
November 24, Emma Lavinia Gifford was born in Plymouth.
1841: December 23, Hardy’s sister Mary was born.
1844: Hardy’s father gave Tommy an accordion and taught him to play the fiddle; through boyhood, Hardy played at country dances.
1845: April, Julia Augusta Martin, wife of Francis Pitney Martin, moved to Kingston Maurward as lady of the manor.
1847: The railroad from London was extended to Dorchester.
1848: Hardy, as the first pupil, entered the village school established by Mrs. Martin at Lower Bockhampton.
1849: He was transferred to a school in Dorchester.
1851: March 20, Tryphena Sparks was born in Puddletown.
July 1, Hardy’s brother Henry was born.
1852: Hardy began the study of Latin.
1853: October, Mrs. Martin and her husband left Dorset for London.
1855: Hardy’s schoolmaster, Isaac Last, gave him Beza’s Latin Testament as a reward for diligence in studies.
He began to teach in the Stinsford Sunday School.
1856: July 11, he was apprenticed to the architect John Hicks of 39 South Street, Dorchester, next door to the school kept by William Barnes. He continued to live in Higher Bockhampton and in the early morning hours to study Latin; he took up Greek.
August 9, he witnessed in Dorchester the execution of Martha Brown for the murder of her husband.
September 2, his sister Katharine was born.
1857: January 9, Hardy’s paternal grandmother, Mary Head Hardy, died.
He came under the friendly tutelage of Horace Moule of Queen’s College, Cambridge. (Moule was born May 30, 1832, a son of the Vicar of Fordington.)
1859: Hardy purchased Griesbach’s Greek New Testament, which he read regularly throughout his life.
1860: Horace Moule introduced him to Essays and Reviews and other religious, philosophic, and scientific writings.
1862: Hardy proposed to Mary Waight of Dorchester, but was rejected.
April 17, he went to London to continue architecture on more advanced lines.
He took up residence at Clarence House, Kilburn, but in 1863 moved to 16 Westbourne Park Villas.
May 5, he began work as assistant architect in the office of Arthur Blomfield.
He called on Julia Augusta Martin in London.
1863: March 16, his essay The Application of Coloured Bricks and Terra Cotta to Modern Architecture
won a medal offered by the Royal Institute.
He spent much time in this and following years in reading the poets: the Elizabethans, Shelley, Keats, Browning, Tennyson, et al.
1864: He read the works of Darwin, Spencer, Huxley, and Mill, as well as the poets.
1865: March, Hardy’s How I Built Myself a House
appeared in Chambers’s Journal, his first published fiction.
Autumn, he enrolled in an evening course in French at King’s College and continued this study until March, 1866.
Autumn and early winter, he supervised the removal of coffins and bones from Old St. Pancras Churchyard for a railway cutting.
He inquired about matriculation at Cambridge University to prepare to become a country curate but gave up the plan because of uncertainty in his religious views.
He began writing verses.
1866: Hardy sent poems to editors of magazines, but none were accepted.
He read with enthusiasm Swinburne’s Poems and Ballads.
1867: He thought of going